DISH Treatment
DISH Treatment
DISH Treatment
1. Introduction
racic spine with preserved intervertebral height is characteristic symptoms, but some on the beneficial effects of light exercise,
for DISH, but not for OA; ii) clinical manifestations similar to, heat, use of analgesics and non-steroidal anti-inflammatory
or identical to, those of OA are prominent features of DISH in agents (NSAIDs) [5,17,19]. Recently, the use of locally acting
the peripheral joints. However, the peripheral joints affected by NSAIDs for the treatment of OA was demonstrated to be as
DISH have features that distinguish them from primary OA. effective as the same product administered orally, suggesting
One is the more frequent involvement of joints that are not usu- that it might also be successfully employed for the sympto-
ally affected in OA, such as metacarpophalangeal joints, elbows matic relief of pain and stiffness in the peripheral joints of
and shoulders [7-10]. Another feature is a more severe hypertropic patients with DISH [21,22]. Overall, it seems reasonable to
disease in the joints affected by DISH [11]; iii) whereas OA invar- assume that most of the treatments employed for the treat-
iably occurs with advanced age, DISH is not as common as OA ment of OA may be useful for the symptomatic relief of both
and more commonly affects males than females [12,13]; iv) the spinal and peripheral manifestations of DISH.
For personal use only.
primary event in DISH is thickening, calcification and/or ossifi- The early changes in spinal DISH, and probably in the
cation of ligaments and entheses. This is evident at the level of peripheral joints, are entheseal new bone formation [23]. Non-
the spine as well as in the peripheral joints [14,15]. Knowledge inflammatory enthesopathy is likely to be the hallmark of
about therapeutic options in DISH is scarce. DISH, not only in the spine, but also in many extraspinal
sites, which may become targets for therapy aiming to avoid,
2. Therapeutic goals and limitations arrest or retard its progress. The most common sites are the
tibial spines, posterior heal, superior patella, olecranon and
Treatment of DISH should address several issues. It is shoulder [14,20]. The enthesopathies are not necessarily symp-
expected to alleviate pain and stiffness; prevent, retard or tomatic, but may contribute to the more severe osteoarthritic
arrest progression; correct the associated metabolic disorders; changes due to stiffening of the joint capsule. Treatment
and prevent spontaneous or induced complications (Box 1). might be necessary in order to alleviate local pain and swell-
Specific therapeutic interventions in DISH have not been sys- ing. This can be achieved by local soft applications, such as
tematically explored. This is probably related to the inclusion of insoles for plantar spurs or protective bandages at other sites.
DISH in the spectrum of OA, and the assumption that the same Local infiltration of local anaesthetic and long-acting corticos-
therapeutic interventions for OA are suitable for DISH. Yet, it teroids might offer, at least temporary, relief in severely
was estimated that a period of at least 10 years is needed for the symptomatic cases. When multiple sites are involved, the
pathological process to evolve completely [16]; this notion implies same therapeutic modalities mentioned for the arthropathy
that a long observation period is required in longitudinal studies may be used.
in order to demonstrate that any therapeutic intervention might Several metabolic and constitutional factors, such as obes-
prevent the development of the disease, or hopefully reverse the ity, high waist circumference ratio, hypertension, diabetes
pathological changes. This review focuses on the therapeutic mellitus, hyperinsulinaemia, dyslipidaemia, elevated growth
options for the treatment of DISH based on the clinical manifes- hormone levels, insulin like growth factor-1 and hyperuricae-
tations, associated comorbidities, the possible pathogenetic mia, have all been reported to be associated with DISH [24-27].
mechanisms that lead to the development of the disease, and Some of these abnormalities are inter-related and may coexist
prevention of complications. in the same patient. Generally speaking, there is no doubt that
the coexistence of many cardiovascular risk factors pose
3. Therapeutic interventions patients with DISH at a higher risk for cardiovascular events.
It seems appropriate to screen these patients for known cardi-
The clinical manifestations of DISH may be related to spinal, ovascular risk factors, and as necessary, to correct them. Gen-
peripheral joint and soft tissue involvement. Spinal eral measures, such as weight reduction, adequate physical
involvement is often associated with pain and decreased range activity, low saturated fat and reduced carbohydrate intake,
Local heat
Physical activity
Protection of enthesopathic sites (insoles, bandages)
Weight loss
Analgesics
Low carbohydrate and saturated fat diet
NSAIDs
Avoid falls
Locally acting NSAIDs
Avoid aspiration
Local anaesthetic/corticosteroid injections
Expert Opin. Pharmacother. Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by University of Otago on 01/13/15
might all be important in preventing or arresting the progres- advantage over the use of sulfanylureas that increase insulin
sion of DISH. Some of these factors may have pathogenetic secretion. When coexisting hypertension is treated, the choice
implications and may, therefore, become therapeutic targets. of medications that might improve insulin resistance, such as
Hyperinsulinaemia has a profound effect on ligaments and angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitors, Ca2+ channel
entheses, which is independent of age and obesity. The differ- blockers and α-blockers, should be preferred to medications
entiation of mesenchymal cells in ligaments into chondrocytes that might worsen insulin resistance, such as thiazide diuretics
and the subsequent enchondral ossification is promoted by and β-blockers [30].
insulin [28]. The enthesis provides the growth plate for tendons The enthesis may be under the influence of other growth
and ligaments in children and persists into adulthood. This promoting peptides. Elevated growth hormone (GH) levels
particular structure is composed of collagen fibres, fibroblasts, were reported in DISH. This hormone is capable of inducing
chondrocytes and calcified matrix, which is probably a target osteoblast cell proliferation, and may promote local produc-
for the ossification process promoted by insulin [29]. tion of insulin-like growth factor-1 (IGF-1), which in turn
Therapeutic interventions should aim at a reduction of can stimulate alkaline phosphatase activity in osteoblasts
insulin secretion and insulin resistance. In patients with non- [25,31,32]. There is no explanation, as yet, to why the new bone
insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (NIDDM), the use of formation is mainly localised at the ligamentous and
biguanides that induce a better usage of insulin may offer an entheseal sites. However, it was suggested that, at least in the
spine, vertebral blood supply could be a factor in the onset DISH can avoid or minimise damage to the cervical spine or
or progression of DISH [33]. Intra-erythrocyte GH levels to soft tissues in patients who might need certain diagnostic
may exceed serum GH levels and could, therefore, be trans- or therapeutic interventions, such as upper gastrointestinal
ported to the vertebral site by the mechanism described ear- endoscopy or endotracheal intubation. Another preventable
lier [34]. While a therapeutic approach aiming at suppression complication, which might involve all spinal segments, is frac-
of GH secretion is unlikely, a targeted approach at the tures of the spine after minor trauma [43,44]. These fractures
vascular level might be feasible. tend to be unrecognised, unstable and associated with treat-
In recent years, a great interest in the molecular basis for ment delays and permanent neurological deficits. It is, there-
ossification of ligaments has emerged. Nuclear factor-κB fore, important to recognise these complications in order to
(NF-κB) is capable of regulating the differentiation of multi- offer a prompt therapeutic intervention, as well as adopting
potential cells, including the osteoblastic differentiation of the common measures to prevent falls and trauma, especially
undifferentiated ligamentous mesenchymal cells. It was in the elderly population. Heterotropic ossification following
shown that in patients with DISH, NF-κB is activated by orthopaedic surgeries, in particular hip arthroplasty, is com-
Expert Opin. Pharmacother. Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by University of Otago on 01/13/15
environmental stimuli that are partly promoted by the plate- mon among patients with DISH [45]. Several therapeutic
let-derived growth factor-BB and transforming growth interventions aiming to abolish the heterotropic ossification,
factor-β1 [35]. Other factors that may stimulate differentia- such as administration of NSAIDs, antivitamin K and irradia-
tion of ligamentous mesenchymal stem cells into osteoblasts, tion, have all been reported with variable success [46-49].
such as bone morphogenetic protein-2 and prostaglandin I2, Therefore, those with a high risk of developing this complica-
were described in ossified ligaments [36,37]. Therefore, in the tion, such as patients with DISH, should be considered candi-
future, these factors may become targets for specific thera- dates for one of these regimens. The therapeutic options are
peutic interventions. It is of note that some of these osteob- summarised in Figure 1.
lastic promoting factors were reported to be increased in
NIDDM and, therefore, may represent the molecular link 4. Expert opinion and conclusions
between the previously described associations between
For personal use only.
NIDDM and DISH [38,39]. Although DISH might contribute to the generation of OA,
The role played by administration of retinoid in the patho- or worsen primary OA, it should be regarded as a separate
genesis of DISH is controversial [40]. However, it was suggested, clinical entity with different prevalence, joint distribution,
that spinal hyperostotic changes, indistinguishable from those gender distribution and pathogenetic mechanisms. Its
seen in DISH, might emerge during treatment with retinoids. recognition as a distinct clinical entity will stimulate a
These changes usually affect patients < 45 years of age, and are more targeted research and, hopefully, better solutions
likely to be more common in patients treated with larger doses based on a true understanding of the pathogenetic mecha-
and for prolonged periods of time. Therefore, it is prudent to nisms underlying this common, yet under-recognised,
monitor musculoskeletal manifestations carefully in patients disease. At present, our knowledge enables us to offer
treated with retinoids and, whenever possible, reduce the doses empirical therapies based on the commonly employed
and the duration of therapy [41]. practices for the treatment of degenerative and metabolic
Reference should also be made to preventable or treatable joint diseases, rather than on a profound understanding of
complications of DISH. The manifestations and complica- the pathogenetic processes in DISH. In recent years,
tions of DISH of the cervical spine have been recently important steps toward better understanding of the
reviewed [42]. Although some of the manifestations constitute molecular processes that lead to calcification and
an integral part of the condition, some complications can be ossification of entheses and ligaments have emerged. These
avoided if taken into consideration. Aspiration pneumonia early, and still scarce, investigations will hopefully pave the
can be partially avoided if instructions for correct deglutition way to more targeted therapies, that will be able, not only
and preservation of an upright position after meals are to treat the signs and symptoms of this condition, but also
carefully explained to the patient. Physicians familiar with to change its course.
Bibliography spinal involvement in diffuse idiopathic (DISH) and calcification and ossification of
Papers of special note have been highlighted as skeletal hyperostosis (DISH). Radiology the posterior longitudinal ligament. Am. J.
either of interest (•) or of considerable interest (1976) 119:559-568. Roentgenol. (1978) 131:1049-1053.
(••) to readers. 3. UTSINGER PD: Diffuse idiopathic skeletal 5. RESNICK D, NIWAYAMA G: Diagnosis of
1. FORESTIER J, ROTES-QUEROL J: hyperostosis. Clin. Rheum. Dis. (1985) bone and joint disorders (2nd edn)
Senile ankylosing hyperostosis of the spine. 11:325-351. WB Saunders, Philadelphia
Ann. Rheum. Dis. (1950) 9:321-330. 4. RESNICK D, GUERRA J Jr., (1988):1563-1615.
6. MADER R: Diffuse idiopathic skeletal study of diffuse idiopathic skeletal skeletal hyperostosis: a controlled study.
hyperostosis: a distinct clinical entity. hyperostosis. Clinical features and J. Rheumatol. (1996) 23:672-676.
Isr. Med. Assoc. J. (2003) 5:506-508. functional status. Medicine (1997) 27. KISS C, SZILAGYI M, PAKSY A,
• A review that highlights the distinctive 76:104-117. POOR G: Risk factors for diffuse idiopathic
features of DISH. •• A comprehensive study that evaluated skeletal hyperostosis: a case control study.
7. LITTLEJOHN JO, UROWITZ MB, clinical and functional parameters in Rheumatology (2002) 41:27-30.
SMYTHE HA, KEYSTONE EC: patients with DISH compared with • A controlled study that highlights some of
Radiographic features of the hand in diffuse non-DISH patients. the comorbidities associated with DISH.
idiopathic skeletal hyperostosis (DISH). 18. ROTES-QUEROL J: Clinical 28. AKUNE T, OGATA N, SEICHI A,
Diagn. Radiol. (1981) 140:623-629. manifestations of diffuse idiopathic skeletal OHNISHI I, NAKAMURA K,
8. BEYELER C, SCHLAPBACH P, hyperostosis. Br. J. Rheumatol. (1996) KAWAGUCHI H: Insulin secretory
GERBER NJ et al.: Diffuse idiopathic 35:1193-1194. response is positively associated with the
skeletal hyperostosis (DISH) of the 19. EL GARF A, KHATER R: Diffuse extent of ossification of the posterior
Expert Opin. Pharmacother. Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by University of Otago on 01/13/15
shoulder. A cause of shoulder pain? idiopathic skeletal hyperostosis (DISH). longitudinal ligament of the spine. J. Bone
Br. J. Rheumatol. (1990) 29:349-353. A clinicopathological study of the disease Joint Surg. (2001) 83A:1537-1544.
9. UTSINGER PD, RESNICK D, pattern in Middle Eastern populations. • A study that strengthens the associations
SHAPIRO R: Diffuse skeletal abnormalities J. Rheumatol. (1984) 11:804-807. between DISH and hyperinsulinaemia,
in Forestier's disease. Arch. Intern. Med. 20. MAZIERES B, ROVENSKY J: and suggests insulin as a treatment target.
(1976) 136:763-768. Non-inflammatory enthesopathies of the 29. LITTLEJOHN GO: Insulin and new bone
10. RESNICK D, SHAPIRO RF, spine: a diagnostic approach. Baill. Clin. formation in diffuse idiopathic skeletal
WEISNER KB, NIWAYAMA G, Rheumatol. (2000) 14:201-217. hyperostosis. Clin. Rheumatol. (1985)
UTSINGER PD, SHAUL SR: Diffuse 21. TUGWELL PS, WELLS GA, 4:294-300.
idiopathic skeletal hyperostosis (DISH). SHAINHOUSE JZ: Equivalence study of a 30. LITHELL HOL: Effect of antihypertensive
Ankylosing hyperostosis of Forestier and topical diclofenac solution (pennsaid) drugs on insulin, glucose, and lipid
Rotes-Querol. Semin. Arthritis. Rheum. compared with oral diclofenac in metabolism. Diabetes Care (1991)
For personal use only.
protein-2 (BMP-2) in the pathological abnormalities. Br. J. Dermatol. (1996) 47. KNELLES D, BARTHEL T, KARRER A,
ossification process of the spinal ligament. 134:71-76. KRAUS U, EULERT J, KOLBL O:
Rheumatology (2001) 40:1163-1168. 41. NESHER G, ZUCKNER J: Prevention of heterotopic ossification after
• A novel pathogenetic aspect. Rheumatologic complications of vitamin A total hip replacement. A prospective,
37. OHISHI H, FURUKAWA KI, and Retinoids. Semin. Arthritis. Rheum. randomized study using acetylsalicylic acid,
IWASAKI K et al.: Role of prostaglandin I2 (1995) 24:291-296. indomethacin and fractional or single-dose
in the gene expression induced by irradiation. J. Bone Joint Surg. Br. (1997)
42. MADER R: Clinical manifestations of
mechanical stress in spinal ligament cells 79:596-602.
diffuse idiopathic skeletal hyperostosis of
derived from patients with ossification of the cervical spine. Semin. Arthritis Rheum. 48. LO TCM, HEALY WL: Re-irradiation for
the posterior longitudinal ligament. (2002) 32:130-135. prophylaxis of heterotropic ossification after
J. Pharmacol. Exp. Ther. (2003) hip surgery. Br. J. Radiol. (2001)
43. HENDRIX RW, MELANY M, MILLER F,
305:818-824. 74:503-506.
ROGERS LF: Fracture of the spine in
• A novel pathogenetic aspect. 49. GUILLEMIN F, MAINARD D,
patients with ankylosis due to diffuse
Expert Opin. Pharmacother. Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by University of Otago on 01/13/15
38. PFEIFFER A, skeletal hyperostosis: clinical and imaging ROLLAND H, DELAGOUTTE JP:
MIDDELBERG-BISPING K, findings. Am. J. Roentgenol. (1994) Antivitamin K prevents heterotropic
DREWES C, SCHATZ H: Elevated plasma 162:899-904. ossification after hip arthroplasty in diffuse
levels of transforming growth factor-beta 1 idiopathic skeletal hyperostosis. A
44. BURKUS JK, DENIS F: Hyperextension
in NIDDM. Diabetes Care (1996) retrospective study in 67 patients.
injuries of the thoracic spine in diffuse
19:1113-1117. Acta. Orthop. Scand. (1995) 66:123-126.
idiopathic skeletal hyperostosis. Report of
39. INABA T, ISHIBASHI S, GOTODA T four cases. J. Bone Joint Surg. Am. (1994)
et al.: Enhanced expression of platelet- 76:237-243.
Affiliation
derived growth factor-beta receptor by high Reuven Mader1,2
45. BELANGER TA, ROWE DE: Diffuse 1Ha’Emek Medical Center, Rheumatic Diseases
glucose. Involvement of platelet-derived
idiopathic skeletal hyperostosis: Unit, Afula 18101, Israel
growth factor in diabetic angiopathy.
musculoskeletal manifestations. J. Am. Tel: + 972 46 49 43 54;
Diabetes (1996) 45:507-512.
Acad. Orthop. Surg. (2001) 9:258-267. Fax: + 972 46 49 44 53;
For personal use only.