Marketing Paper 2
Marketing Paper 2
Marketing Paper 2
Newspapers have become products like any other consumer, industrial or service
products. They have unique features which other products do not have. The newspaper
industry in India is witnessing intense competition from within and from outside like
electronic and internet media. This has tremendous bearing on circulation and
advertisement revenues.
The industry has responded proactively to these challenges. There is more and more
focus on marketing and innovations in marketing strategies. Reviews of some of these
strategies are focused in the paper.
The authors have presented a case study of TIMES OF INDIA GROUP for innovations
in marketing strategies, which are product, price, promotion and distribution related. A
survey has been conducted by the authors on a recent innovation in marketing strategy
of TRIMMING and SLIMMING the size of the newspaper. The data collected from 357
readers of Bangalore are analysed. The readers in general are not only positive to these
changes but also have observed them keenly. Such understanding of sensitivity of
readers is crucial for the success of marketing strategies.
Newspapers play a critical role in informing the positive developments, achievements and
general public about news and events. Their experiments. Journalism has been the core of
views on these would mould the opinions and newspaper in India. Of late, they are emerging
attitudes of the people. The print media, in more as product rather than instruments of
particular the newspapers have not only exposed journalism. They have emerged like any other
the evils of the society but also have highlighted consumer, industrial or service products.
consumers of the product. Only literate sections various trends over the years. It has become
of the society can consume this product. As it capital intensive requiring crores of rupees of
constitutes the habit of the reader’s it exercises investment on materials and machines. The
immense influence on them. It even moulds advertisement revenue has increased to more
their attitudes, thinking and actions. Because of than 60% of the total revenue. Feature articles,
huge advertisement revenue, it is low priced fortnightly features, continuation stories have
even though the actual cost is number of times become a common feature. Layout is playing a
more. It enjoys high degree of brand loyalty and very important role in appearance and
frequency and the extent of shift of readers from presentation. Modular layout is now being
one newspaper to another is very limited. They adopted which is based on building block
need to be highly dynamic, as they have to cater concept. Technological upgradation has become
to the changing needs and expectations of their the order of the day. Satellite transmission is
readers. used for sending texts and photographs.
Satellite editions are becoming popular. The
NEWSPAPER INDUSTRY IN INDIA industry is becoming more and more reader’s
Indian press has completed more than two oriented which is in tune with the modern
centuries of fruitful existence. It was James marketing concept.
Augustus Hicky who started the first newspaper These trends have brought about paradigm shift
‘Bengal Gazette’ in 1780. Later on, John Burton
in the philosophy and practice of the
and James Mackenzie started Guardian in 1818.
contemporary newspaper industry in India.
Girish Chandra Ghosh established ‘The
Bengalee’ in 1868. Some of the leading
newspapers during early 19th century were the CHANGES IN ENVIRONMENT
‘Bengal Harkaru’, ‘Morning post’, ‘Telegraph’, The macro and micro environment of the
‘Calcutta Courier’, ‘Oriental Star’, ‘India Gazatte’ newspaper industry in India has undergone
and ‘Asiantic Mirror’. significant changes in the last decade. The
The newspapers have played an effective and mass media is witnessing tremendous
constructive role in Indian struggle for transformation towards electronic and Internet
independence. Mahatma Gandhi, media. The number of viewers and surfers is
Balagangadhar Tilak, Gopal Krishna Gokhale, increasing day by day. The reading habits of
Bipin Chandrapal, Dadabai Navroji, started people are‘also undergoing revolutionary
newspapers in order to spread and disseminate changes. They have become more of viewers
the message of freedom struggle. Many and seers rather than readers. The average
revolutionaries extensively used this media for time devoted for reading has significantly come
creating awareness among people. Even after down.
independence, the role of newspapers
continued. The competition within the industry and outside
is becoming more and more intense. The total
TRENDS IN NEWSPAPER INDUSTRY time available for a person to read, write, etc.,
has not increased but the mediums have
Newspaper industry in India has witnessed increased. This is resulting in more media
competition for the share in the mind and heart Product mix : There is creative mix of
of the readers. The number of newspapers in hard and soft news in addition to providing
English and other vernacular languages has global perspective with a local flavour.
increased over the years. Their circulation, Aspects of packaging like colour, layout,
readership and editions have also increased. etc. have become more relevant.
Hence, the competition within the industry has Supplements have increased role to play
become very intense for increasing the slice of in the designing of the product features.
the cake. Reader interest innovations are also
playing important role.
On the other hand, the competition from
electronic and other media has also increased. Price mix: Affordability has become a
Such competition from within and outside is not motivating factor for purchasing the
only in terms of circulation but also in case of newspapers. The reduction in price and
advertisement revenue. The advertisers of the differential pricing, have become very
present day have alternative medias for common in the industry. The price wars
promoting their goods and services. These have become order of the day.
changes have created serious constraints on the Promotion mix: High visibility has
survival and growth of newspaper industry in become the order of the game. Need for
India because of the pressure on their circulation Brand awareness and recall have
and profitability. This scenario has thrown up compelled the newspapers to resort to
many opportunities and threats to the industry. massive promotion through different
medias. Innovative promotions have
RESPONSE OF THE INDUSTRY increased the curiosity of the readers.
The newspaper industry in India has responded Distribution mix: Effective distribution at
proactively to these opportunities and threats. the right time' and at the right place, has
The newspapers, individually and collectively, become important. The selection,
are designing short, medium and long term appointment and terms and conditions of
plans and strategies for their survival and the agents are very crucial. The role of
growth. These are in terms of product, price, hawkers is increasing .
promotion and distribution.
Segmentation, targeting and
FOCUS ON MARKETING positioning : The basis for segmentation
of markets of newspapers has undergone
The response of the newspaper industry in India sea change. New segments like youth,
has been one of focusing more and more on women, sports lovers, business minded
marketing, which was not only neglected but ones have been identified and targeted by
also ignored all these years. Such a focus on many newspapers. Further, the
marketing is resulting in the designing of a positioning of newspapers is given
different kind of marketing programme. importance by projecting the distinct
features.
Classifides, Men and Women, Education prices. This opened a new era in the
Times, Ascent and Financial Times. It marketing strategies of newspapers in
brought out a special supplement called IT India. Times of India resorted to an
Ascent in order to cope up with the IT invitation price of Rs 1.50 and Rs 1 in
boom. Many booklet presentations were important locations of India like New Delhi
brought out from time to time keeping and Bangalore. This strategy took the
pace with certain events and rivals by surprise and compelled them to
developments. follow the suit. The circulation of Times of
India not only increased but also
Giving importance to local news and surpassed that of the main rivals like
events is another strategy followed by this Hindustan Times in New Delhi and
group. Hapennings in the respective Deccan Herald in Bangalore.
cities, weather conditions, entertainment,
grievances, sports and other events are The Economic Times also followed a
covered prominently. A supplement similar strategy. Few years back, it
exclusively catering to local hapennings is substantially increased the size of the
also brought out. For example Bangalore market category through its promotion
Times is brought on six days of the week price of one-rupee-per -copy edition in
and this supplement caters only to Mumbai. This made a large number of
hapennings in Bangalore. readers ordering their own copies. An
invitation price of two rupees on weekdays
The product strategies of Economic Times was also introduced in many cities. The
are also similar to but with variance and price of the paper during weekends like
distinction. Layout and appearance are Saturday and Sunday has been increased
given primary importance. Lot of visuals to seven rupees. This prompted many
and caricatures are used to make the readers to buy the newspapers only for
presentation more effective. Three five days in a week. This strategy also
supplements namely Investors Guide, brought into its fold many readers who
Brand Equity and Corporate Dossier are would not have purchased the paper in
brought out every week to cater to the the normal course .
needs of the target segments of readers.
Occassionally, Economic Times also c. Promotion Related Strategies: The
brings out, booklet presentations like group resorted to various promotion
Brand Equity Quiz book and Strategic strategies, which are innovative in nature.
Marketing which has now become a In fact, these strategies were eye openers
periodic priced publication. to many as people thought that
newspapers are to promote others
b. Price Related Strategies: Price paid by products but not their own. Times of India
the readers of newspaper was considered group distributed free samples in select
insignificant in Indian conditions until areas, offered special discounts for the
Times of India group brought down the tickets of select programmes, organized
various contests and events like public TRIMMED AND SLIMMED PAPER - AN
speaking etc.,and started ‘Newspaper in EMPIRICAL STUDY
Education’ programme in various schools.
Times of India Group introduced a slimmer but
Regular advertisements are given on
not lighter, livelier but not frivolous newspaper in
hoardings. It launched a massive
the recent months. This slimmer, easy to
campaign to build its brand image which
handle, sleeker and contemporary newspaper
they want to be synonymous with the term
started a new trend in newspaper industry of
‘India’. India. Some newspapers introduced this
As far as Economic Times is concerned, strategy little earlier or later in order to match
some innovative strategies introduced with the strategy of Times of India Group. As this
include ET Club, ET awards for corporate is a new precedent in India, the authors
excellence and special pull outs on various undertook a survey of 357 readers of Times of
occasions. ET Club is mainly meant for India and Economic Times in Bangalore. The
students who will get the paper in bulk at objective was to ascertain the immediate
their institutions. Panel discussions, response and reaction of the readers towards
workshops and seminars are organized for this latest strategy of a newspaper in general
members at frequent intervals. As part of and Times of India Group in particular. This was
carried out during June, 2002.
ET Club activities, the senior executives of
the paper visit the institutions and deliver
lectures on corporate matters and also The Methodology:
conduct ET awareness tests. This A structured questionnaire was distributed to 400
strategy introduces the Economic Times to readers selected on random basis. The MBA
the students who would make it a habit as students of Canara Bank School of Management
and when they grow up in the corporate Studies, Bangalore University collected the
ladder. primary data from the readers. The questionnaire
consisted of certain background details of the
All these strategies of Times of India
readers like age, gender, occupation, annual
group over a period of time have made household income and the length of the habit of
marketing very important in increasing not reading Times of India Group newspapers. It
only the circulation but also the ad also found out the observations of the readers
revenue. They became innovators in the towards the recent changes in size, layout,
sense that they are the pioneers of these content and supplements. Their response to
strategies, which other picked up later on. these changes was also ascertained by giving
One such recent innovative strategy of five scales of agreement or disagreement
this group is the slimmer and livelier paper regarding the positive and negative dimensions
by pruning the size. This is introduced with of the recent changes. The data collected were
effect from 16th of May 2002 for Times of analysed with the help of percentages, frequency
India and Ecnomic Tmes. tables and mean scores.
TABLE 1
DISTRIBUTION OF RESPONDENTS BASED ON THEIR EXTENT OF
OBSERVATION OF CHANGES
The above table reveals that 60.47% of readers The above table was further analysed to arrive
of Times of India have treated the recent at meanscores. These scores were ascertained
changes as major ones whereas 53.24% of after giving weightage of 1,2 and 3 to answers
readers have treated as major changes in case like no change, minor changes and major
of size. Another important finding is that more changes. The summary is given below.
than 50% of readers of both the newspapers
have observed minor changes in case of layout,
content and supplements.
TABLE 2
MEAN SCORES OF THE EXTENT OF CHANGES OBSERVED BY
READERS OF TIMES OF INDIA
Extent of change
TABLE 3
MEAN SCORES OF THE EXTENT OF CHANGES OBSERVED BY
READERS OF ECONOMIC TIMES
Extent of change
From the above tables, it can be inferred that than that of 1.98 of Economic Times. This
the mean scores of the readers of Times of analysis brings out the fact that the recent
India are more than that of Economic Tmes in changes in the newspapers were more visible to
case of all the dimentions like size, layout, readers of Times of India than that of Economic
content and supplements. Even the average Times.
mean score of 2.09 of Times of India is more
TABLE 4
DISTRIBUTION OF READERS OF TIMES OF INDIA BASED ON RESPONSE TO CHANGES
Strongly
disagree
33(9.59)
17(4.94)
1O( 2.91)
29(8.43)
22(6.39)
b. Not improved 56( 16.28) 97( 28.20) 71(20.64) 94(27.32) 26(7.56)
4. Change in
supplements is
The above table reveals that more than 75% of disagree or strongly disagree that it is easy to
the readers agree or strongly agree that the handle and 17Y0disagree or strongly disagree to
change in size is easy to handle whereas 64% the means to cut cost. More percentage of
agree or strongly agree that it is a means to cut readers agree or strongly agree to the change in
cost. It can also be observed that more layout, content and supplement than the
percentage of readers (19.19%)are undecided percentage of readers who disagree or strongly
in case of means to cut cost than 3.78% in case disagree
of easy to handle. Nearly 20% of the readers
TABLE 5
DISTRIBUTION OF READERS OF ECONOMIC TIMES
BASEDONRESPONSETOCHANGES
~~
1. Change in size is
a. Improved
b. Not improved
23( 14.94)
19( 12.34)
78(50.65)
28( 18.1 8)
1 26(16.88)
40(25.97)
1 13(8.44)
51(33.12)
1 14(9.09)
16( 10.39)
4. Change in
supplements is
The above table brings out that 74% of readers cut cost. With regard to change in layout, 66%
agree or strongly agree that the change in size agree or strongly agree that it is impressive but
is easy to handle whereas 56% agree or strongly 31% feel that it is difficult to read. 53% of
agree that it is a means to cut cost. The readers disagree or strongly disagree that it is
percentage of readers (20.13%) who are difficult to read. In case of improvement of
undecided in case of means to cut cost is more content, 65% agree or strongly agree whereas
than that of readers who opine that it is easy to 30% agree that there is no improvement. A
handle. 19% of readers either disagree or similar trend is observable in case of change in
strongly disagree that it is easy to handle and supplements also.
24% disagree or strongly disagree for means to
a. Easy to handle
I l l than that of difficult to read, no improvement in
content and irrelevant supplements.
I
~
Sources