Arbys Brand Consultation Project-1
Arbys Brand Consultation Project-1
Arbys Brand Consultation Project-1
Team 9:
Ben Lynch, Caroline Wharry, Elisabeth Hovis,
Ethan Scribano, Nick Bjacek, Nicole Nealon
MKTG 385: Consumer Behavior
Dr. Atav
April 28, 2021
1. Market Analysis
Promotion:
Arby’s doesn’t have a huge budget for advertising, so they resort to more niche audiences
in their promotions, as evidenced in their sponsorship with Andrew Johnston (“Arby’s and
Andrew,’ n.d.). Arby’s targeted “self-identified nerds and web-savvy gamers” in 2017 (G, 2017).
They hoped to get exposure with these niche audiences and get their attention, allowing them to
truly interact with and increase brand sentiment in these groups. It appears that Arby’s was trying
to appeal to these niche consumers’ belongingness need in Maslow’s hierarchy by trying to
create a relationship with them. Customers create art using Arby’s products and Arby’s reposts
or interacts with their posts. In their promotions, Arby’s focuses on the quality of their meats.
After their rebrand, they’ve used their new slogan, “We have the meats” to really push that to
consumers through iconic rote learning (Moyers, n.d.). They don’t appear to be targeting any
specific emotion but do want their audience to recognize the benefits of the qualities of their
sandwiches and other foods.
Product: Arby’s has lots of heavy and meat-filled sandwiches. Being that it’s a fast-food
restaurant, the typical healthy eater wouldn’t be the target consumer. People that would probably
come here would also eat at McDonald’s or Dairy Queen. They have introduced a Market Fresh
line which includes wraps and lighter sandwiches to combat growing health concerns and low
carb menu options (Dougal et. al, 2011). In addition, they transitioned to French fries with no
trans fats. Arby’s expanded their menus through co-branding with T.J. Cinnamons’ cinnamon
rolls and Ghirardelli cookies among others.
Place: Arby’s tends to be located near other fast-food restaurants as well as off of interstate exits
and high traffic areas. It’s possible they are trying to target the everyday traveler or vacationer
looking for something to eat (this is just speculation). By having their restaurants right off of
major travel points, Arby’s could be appealing to consumers’ physiological needs just by being a
place to eat when one is hungry.
Price: Arby’s has received backlash for their high prices, but they continue to keep prices higher
due to the quality of their food (Taylor, 2014).
How might the marketing mix be influencing attitudes?
Arby’s relies heavily on word-of mouth and peer recommendations. People believed their
menu offers were undiverse and weren't aware of all the menu options. With the movement of
vegetarianism, the advertising for their meat-centric menu became unappealing to the general
population (Moyers, n.d.)
Are they appealing to reference groups? How?
They are trying to capture the younger generations (millennial and gen-z) that may not
have considered going to Arby’s before (Twitter, n.d.).
Are they influencing any steps of the decision-making process?
With the memeification of their slogan and use of their twitter they are trying to influence
the decision stage.
Customer’s tastes are constantly evolving so Arby’s often changes their menu to appeal
to different generations (Kelso, 2014).
3. Research Objectives
Part A: Objective: determine how we can get Arby’s to appeal to a younger group than its
current consumers: Millennials and Gen Z. Our segment will be JMU students between the ages
of 18 and 23 since college students have a strong selective choice when it comes to fast food.
They can afford most brands and have high accessibility due to their proximity to public (bus)
and private (own car, uber) transportation. This group falls into the Gen Z generational category.
Part B: While there are parts of Arby’s recent campaigns on Twitter and TikTok that are
appealing to the younger generations, many potential customers still consider the brand a lower
choice in their fast-food consideration set. There is a lack of information and understanding of
what Arby’s really sells. They have successfully integrated their slogan as a recognizable part of
who they are and what they sell. However, the target market we feel they should capture to
remain successful as a brand has more than double the percentage of vegetarians and vegans
(Coppola, 2020). Relating to their current marketing strategy, we want to see how exactly what
they are doing is impacting the behaviors and thoughts of those within potential consumers. Do
customers think of Arby’s meat as superior or are they turned away by thinking about it? Is the
attention they are receiving helpful or hurtful attention in the eye of the consumer? In addition, it
is important to consider how their current marketing efforts which are primarily targeted at niche
segments are going to trend in the future. Are they going to grow in numbers and if so is that
something the marketing budget can support? It has been found that with lower budgets, niche
marketing can be extremely successful but is this really translating into an increase in sales,
awareness, or interest? (Wilson, 2019)
Part C: One potential area we were concerned about was the slogan for Arby’s because their
current slogan, “We have the meats”, first off could have a negative tone with some people, and
secondly, could be misleading considering new meatless menu options. Additionally, there have
been recent concerns with the health standards of Arby’s, which without a doubt has negative
effects on the already unsettling feelings about the restaurant chain. (Beach, 2021)
In our focus groups, one of the things that we could gather information on is how to improve
Arby’s slogan, and obtain suggestions on new ones to implement. Also, we would like to gain
insight on how many people are actually aware of the health inconsistencies, and what people
think is the correct way to address them if it is a common objection among consumers.
4. Research Summary
The participants of the focus groups were all in their early twenties and JMU students.
Out of the six participants for each, two were female and the other four were male. Both focus
groups conducted were about thirty minutes each, where the first one emphasized perceptions
and thoughts of the fast-food industry as a whole, and the second one was specific to Arby’s. The
participation level significantly increased from the first to the second group but never got in the
way of the overall flow of the meeting. The environment mirrored that of a discussion rather than
of an interrogation which allowed the participants to share their honest views on the topics
discussed. The participants seemed relaxed and engaged in the conversation providing the
opportunity for seamless transitions between topics. There were certainly points in both focus
groups where the participants had lengthy interactions, in which we gained most of our
information.
The focus groups provided insights into how participants viewed fast food, Arby’s, and
what they learned from the discussion. In regard to eating fast food in general, people seemed to
be split evenly. The people who did not eat fast food at all did so for health or monetary reasons,
while those who did eat fast food said they either enjoyed it, it was easy, or convenient. Gaining
an understanding of the fast-food industry in general was important to gauge the viewpoint
everyone was basing their answers off of for the questions referencing Arby’s. Additionally, it is
worth mentioning that when the participants were tested using aided recall of various fast food
chain logos and slogans, almost every single person knew all of them. A second aided recall test
was used to see if participants could match pictures of food to the fast-food restaurant it came
from. Many of the participants could match the food to the restaurant immediately. However,
this shocked others who did not realize how recognizable a picture could be. This shows the
reach and awareness fast food restaurants have in the minds of people who may not be
consumers of their particular brand.
Negative brand image and more specifically scandals are extremely memorable for
consumers, often more than any positive attention a company has received. Throughout the focus
group scandals involving companies such as Chick-fil-A and Subway were brought up and
answered as reasons as to why someone chooses to avoid those specific companies. Social media
is used as an advertising tool but is also a way for people to share their experiences, thoughts, or
viewpoints. It can be concluded that it is much harder for a company to recover from negative
publicity especially when that company is in the fast-food industry and there are many
alternatives to choose from.
The social media and meme presence of Arby’s was well known by the participants
without following any of their accounts. It was discovered through a series of follow up
questions the real reason why Arby’s has gained so much attention on these platforms. It is
because people do not take Arby’s seriously due to the different types of content they post.
Furthermore, many participants are put off by their perceived brand image, slogan, and actual
food. The prices were a point of concern for many participants as they are more expensive than
expected. This aligns with the discussion of quality being a basis for perceiving the value a
person places on a particular brand. The participants did not perceive the food at Arby’s to be of
high quality.
Overall, while Arby’s is known as a fast-food company in the industry their place is not
promoting growth or interest in the younger markets. They would not be chosen specifically
based on any of the criteria’s discussed in the focus group including price, convenience, quality,
or value. Many holes in their menu and overall brand image were uncovered supporting the
research and conclusions drawn surrounding Arby’s.
5. Strategic Strengths and Weaknesses (Criticism of the brand)
Despite the general public opinion about Arby’s being overwhelmingly negative, their
internet presence is incredibly strong. Currently, Arby’s has over 845,000 followers on Twitter.
This number pales in comparison to their larger competitors, but it is a testament to the
difference between their internet popularity and their purchase popularity. Arby’s internet
strategy is on par with their competitors who have millions more followers than they do. From
funny tweets describing their emoji usage, to following meme trends as quickly as they appear,
Arby’s has solidified itself as a known brand on the internet. This “memeification” of the brand
has gone as far as to become a trend on TikTok, a platform that Arby’s does not have as strong
of a presence on, where they are constantly mentioned and memed due to their humorous image.
However, this humorous image can only do so much for Arby’s consumption. Currently
Arby’s exists in the public schema as a meme, not as a viable restaurant choice. One of our focus
group participants mentioned how she and her friends see Arby’s as a joke and not somewhere
they would ever choose to eat at, believing the slogan was “asking for” ridicule. Another
participant went as far to say, “who the [heck] eats at Arby’s?!” when prompted who they think
visits their locations. This shows that though Arby’s internet presence is profitable, they are not
taking full advantage of its potential.
Arby’s pricing strategy is detrimental to its success. When asked in the focus group how
much a sandwich cost, everyone was collectively shocked at the price saying it was insanely
expensive for the quality of the food. The food products themselves were seen as unappealing by
the focus group, stating that they looked “dry” and contained “too much meat”. This is further
enforced in their promotional activities, where Arby’s only talks about the red meat products
available on their menu. When the focus group was asked about the other products available on
Arby’s menu, which include salads, chicken sandwiches, and milkshakes, the participants were
wholly unaware of their existence. Arby’s promotion of an undiverse menu is restricting their
potential customers, a tactic which is only reinforced by their memeification of their meat
selection.
Arby’s use of a humorous social media presence has the potential to be highly valuable,
but it is currently being misused. Their lack of utilization of their public platform to inform
potential customers of their menu diversity is a main point of difficulty for this company.
Another point of difficulty is their pricing strategy and their selective promotion strategy.
Potential customers are being led to believe Arby’s only sells overpriced, unappealing
sandwiches. This combination is driving potential customers away at a dangerous rate. Finally,
Arby’s is currently only effectively selling itself as a popular meme account, not a fast-food
chain. The general social consensus of the brand is that though they are funny, they are not an
option to purchase from. This is the type of internet popularity companies need to avoid, because
after all, someone cannot eat a tweet.
6. Recommendations
We believe that Arby’s is missing a key segment of customers, which is Gen Z and
Millennials. These people know of Arby’s and make plenty of jokes about Arby’s, but many
have never stepped foot into one of their restaurants. There are many ways to help attract this
segment.
Arby’s menu is full of meat and not very many alternatives. They have a “Market Fresh”
menu with lighter, healthier items which should be more prevalent and advertised across their
platforms. Our focus group only knew of their meat sandwiches, such as the roast beef and
reuben. This provides an opportunity to capture the portion of Gen Z and Millennials who are
health conscious because, as proven in the focus groups, people are simply unaware of the
healthier options.
Arby’s sandwiches tend to be generally bland, specifically with their roast beef. Our
focus group touched on that a lot, saying that a barrier to them eating there was the lack of
flavor. Introducing a line of sauces to customize Arby’s sandwiches would attract those
customers who are looking for the customization aspect and those who want more than simply
meat and a bun for a sandwich.
While Arby’s most likely does not have a way to just decrease their prices, there are a
few menu items on the cheaper side that they could increase customer awareness of. For
example, their sliders are only around $1 each. Getting customers to know about their cheaper
menu items will help get them in the door.
As seen in Appendix 1, our focus group mentioned that collaborations with influencers
are a great way for brands to increase product awareness and even get consumers to buy a
product. The same could be said with Arby’s. There are plenty of memes going around about
Arby’s, so if they were to come out with a collaboration with an influencer with the same
audience as them, it could be incredibly successful. This could help separate them from the
“meme” image and make them appear to the consumer as a more “serious” food company like
Dunkin’ or McDonalds. Platforms such as TikTok and Twitter are great places to spread
products for brands. Arby’s is successfully interacting with and marketing to their customers on
these platforms but can go even a step further with a large collaboration. The Travis Scott-
McDonald’s collaboration that took place in late 2020 increased McDonald’s quarterly sales by
4.6 percent (Fickenscher, 2020). In addition, this collaboration was widely talked about on many
social media platforms such as Tiktok and Instagram.
7. Appendix 1: Transcript of Focus Group
Focus Group 1)
Welcome
Introduce Moderator & assistant moderator
Introduce Focus Group
Introduce Topic
Explain Topic
Explain what the results will be used for
Explain why they were chosen to participate
Guidelines
No right or wrong answers, only differing points of view
We're tape recording, one person speaking at a time
We're on a first name basis
You don't need to agree with others, but you must listen respectfully as others share their
views
No phones, unless it’s an emergency
Talk to each other
As the Moderator, we’re here to guide the discussion
Opening Questions:
Please describe on a typical day how you eat
How do you feel about eating out?
How often do you eat out?
How much money do you think you spend per week eating out?
When you eat out is it mostly fast food or casual dining?
What brands come to mind when you think of fast food?
Body Questions:
What fast food brands do you eat at and why?
When you eat fast food, what attributes do you look for? Like location, price, variety of
menu, mood?
Aided Recall - which brand do you recognize (logos)
● Hardees
● McDonalds
● Burger King
● Bojangles
● Wendy’s
● Chick-fil-A
● Subway
● Panera
Aided Recall - Which food is from what fast-food place?
For logos we can ask if they know which place it is and their slogans
For the picture of the actual food, we can ask does this look good, would you eat it, What
do you think the price is for that item? Ask for feedback about price of item
How many of you have social media i.e., Twitter, Instagram, Facebook, & TikTok?
How often do you use social media? How many hours per day?
Do you follow any fast-food chains on your social media accounts?
Can you remember the last ad you saw for a fast-food chain on social media? Do you
recall what it was about?
If you saw a fast-food chain ad on your social media would it motivate you to go get it?
What do you think/feel about fast-food chains being on social media?
Ending Questions:
What stood out to you most in this session?
Do you have anything else you would like to say about fast food chains and their
marketing?
If you do not eat fast food frequently or at all, would you now?
Have we changed your views on fast food and their marketing via social media?
Is there anything else anyone would like to add before we end the session?
Focus Group 2)
Welcome
Introduce Moderator & assistant moderator
Introduce Focus Group
Introduce Topic
Explain Topic
Explain what the results will be used for
Explain why they were chosen to participate
Guidelines
No right or wrong answers, only differing points of view
We're tape recording, one person speaking at a time
We're on a first name basis
You don't need to agree with others, but you must listen respectfully as others share their
views
No phones, unless it’s an emergency
Talk to each other
As the Moderator, we’re here to guide the discussion
Opening Questions:
Please describe on a typical day how you eat
How do you feel about eating out?
How often do you eat out?
How much money do you think you spend per week eating out?
What brands come to mind when you think of fast food?
Body Questions
What are important qualities you look for when purchasing fast food?
What do you think of when you think of Arby’s?
If someone asked you to go to Arby’s with them, what would you say?
Have you ever eaten at Arby’s? If so, do you remember what you got?
If you don’t eat at Arby’s, where do you eat? And why?
If you have ever eaten at Arby’s, do you have a positive experience?
Or negative?
People who eat at Arby’s are…. (give background from class)
What would Arby’s look like if it were a person?
What do you think they have on their menu?
What on their menu sounds good or bad? *show menu*
How expensive do you think Arby’s is?
Show images of Arby’s food - Ask them what they think the price is for that item
Then show actual price and ask about their feedback from what they thought it
would be to what it actually is
How do you feel about Arby’s slogan - “We have the meats”
Have you ever seen any of Arby's ads? What platform were they on and were they
memorable?
Do you follow Arby’s on social media?
*Show Arby’s ads* What do you think about these ads? Ask for reflection.
What do you think Arby’s should do differently? In their advertising? In their
menu/experience?
Does Arby’s have the important qualities you look for when purchasing fast food?
What are the positives and negatives of Arby’s?
Ending Questions
What stood out to you the most in this session?
Do you have anything else you want to say about Arby’s and your feelings towards the
company?
If you have not eaten at Arby’s before, would you now?
Have we changed your views on the company?
9. Appendix 3: Additional Material
https://www.tiktok.com/@h1t1/video/6886594556977089798?
_d=secCgYIASAHKAESMgow
%2B8jX3zhdiFrlz3h4wjHzFgkC6oLS52Vcr6%2FwRKMsisAB
%2ByxNQRqFnak2%2B%2BJ9KAhxGgA
%3D&language=en&preview_pb=0&sec_user_id=MS4wLjABAAAA5xZwQ9jYH-
vAWCxaQNGcrob3ZahqDm_7Rv2RZ74fTLP4ivhQXLywQVoUBe9jlRcI&share_ap
p_id=1233&share_item_id=6886594556977089798&share_link_id=8C2EBF9D-
FF53-4785-9462-
08B055980975&source=h5_m×tamp=1619487952&tt_from=more&u_code=d8
518j7m33aeab&user_id=6732611100171879430&utm_campaign=client_share&utm_
medium=ios&utm_source=more&_r=1
https://www.tiktok.com/@h1t1/video/6897653233397845254?
_d=secCgYIASAHKAESMgowgx
%2BiwxkbsxfshJBwFSNEJDtLzqgZxXuSfQPYbQ6hKpwpUDfgDkguPBOrIVox5Zz
5GgA
%3D&language=en&preview_pb=0&sec_user_id=MS4wLjABAAAA5xZwQ9jYH-
vAWCxaQNGcrob3ZahqDm_7Rv2RZ74fTLP4ivhQXLywQVoUBe9jlRcI&share_ap
p_id=1233&share_item_id=6897653233397845254&share_link_id=E3086BE6-
033F-4797-AD1A-
C634413D630F&source=h5_m×tamp=1619488121&tt_from=more&u_code=d
8518j7m33aeab&user_id=6732611100171879430&utm_campaign=client_share&utm
_medium=ios&utm_source=more&_r=1
Arby’s Tweets and Bio:
References
Arby's and Andrew 'Beef' Johnston: WARC. WARC An Ascential Company. (n.d.).
https://www.warc.com/content/article/arbys-and-andrew-beef-johnston/118123.
BAC Reports. (2021, April). Wendy's/Arby's Group, Inc. Fundamental Company Report
Including Financial, SWOT, Competitors and Industry Analysis. marketpublishers.
https://marketpublishers.com/report/services/restaurants/wendysarbys_group_inc_swot_an
alysis_bac.html.
Beach, C. (2021, February 26). Dozens report illnesses after eating at Arby’s restaurant.
https://www.foodsafetynews.com/2021/02/dozens-in- report-illnesses-after-eating-at-
arbys-restaurant/.
Booth, B. (2019, April 16). How humor saved Arby's and propelled it to the forefront of pop
culture. CNBC. https://www.cnbc.com/2019/04/16/how-humor-saved-arbys-and-bolstered-
its-brand.html.
Breschi, A. (2021, February 23). 16 Types of Customer Needs (and How to Solve for Them).
HubSpot Blog. https://blog.hubspot.com/service/customer-needs.
Coppola, D. (2020, November 30). Consumers who are vegan or vegetarian by age U.S. 2018.
Statista. https://www.statista.com/statistics/738851/vegan-vegetarian-consumers-us/.
Dougal, A. S., Simley, J., Mote, D., Windisch Brown, S., Salamie, D. E., & Covell, J. L. (2011).
Wendy's/Arby's Group, Inc. https://go.gale.com/ps/i.do?
p=GVRL&u=viva_jmu&id=GALE|
CX1722000102&v=2.1&it=r&sid=GVRL&asid=c33df968.
Echo-Factory. (2019, March 28). How Arby's Marketing Wins Over Vegetarians & Millennials.
Echo-Factory. https://echo-factory.com/blog/meats-heart-arbys-marketing-wins-
vegetarians-millennials/.
Fickenscher, L. (2020, October 8). McDonald's sales soar on Travis Scott meals. New York
Post. https://nypost.com/2020/10/08/travis-scott-meals-help-mcdonalds-sales-soar/.
G, B. (2017, March 7). BLOG: Arby's Marketing and "Nerds" - An Analysis. Intelligent Design
Collaborative. http://www.idesigncollaborative.com/arbys-marketing-nerds-analysis/#S3.
Kelso, A. (2014, August 15). Arby's redefines target audience after year-long review.
www.qsrweb.com. https://www.qsrweb.com/articles/arbys-redefines-target-audience-after-
year-long-review/.
Kimberlin, J. (2019, August 8). Secret Menu Challenge: Attack of Arby's Meat Mountain.
pilotonline. https://www.pilotonline.com/food-drink/article_566e5e15-3054-5e96-8f60-
4573ad5de00f.html.
Kunst, A. (2019, June 20). Visitors of Arby's in the U.S. by age 2018. Statista.
https://www.statista.com/statistics/230959/people-who-visited-arbys-usa/.
LaMarco, N. (2018, December 10). Types of Economic Factors That Can Affect the Fast Food
Industry. Chron. https://smallbusiness.chron.com/types-economic-factors-can-affect-fast-
food-industry-36923.html.
Lucas, A. (2020, October 22). Arby's enters Mexico, and pandemic pushes new U.S. customers
to try its sandwiches. CNBC. https://www.cnbc.com/2020/10/22/arbys-enters-mexico-and-
pandemic-boosts-new-customers-in-us.html.
MBA Skool Team. (2020, April 29). Arbys SWOT Analysis: Competitors, STP & USP.
MBASkool. https://www.mbaskool.com/brandguide/food-and-beverages/3066-arbys.html.
McCoy, R. (2018, February 21). Arby's to expand to Brandon in new retail center.
SiouxFalls.Business. https://www.siouxfalls.business/arbys-to-expand-to-brandon-in-new-
retail-center/.
Rahkovsky, I., Jo, Y., & Carlson, A. (2018, July 24). What Drives Consumers to Purchase
Convenience Foods? USDA. https://www.usda.gov/media/blog/2018/07/24/what-drives-
consumers-purchase-convenience-foods.
Ryan, T. (2018, July 12). Does Fast Food Really Cost Less? Mindful.
https://www.mindful.org/does-fast-food-really-cost-less/.
Rötzsch Thomas, S. (2021, February 11). 4 Types of Market Segmentation With Real-World
Examples. Yieldify. https://www.yieldify.com/blog/types-of-market-segmentation/.
Stuckrath, T. (2020, February 5). Religious Dietary Restrictions: Essential Quick Reference
Guide: Thrive! Thrive Meetings and Events. https://thrivemeetings.com/2018/01/religious-
dietary-restrictions-guide/.
Taylor, K. (2014, November 9). Forget Rising Beef Prices: Why Arby's Is Placing All Bets on
Meat. Entrepreneur. https://www.entrepreneur.com/article/239455.
Tucker, J. (2021, January 26). The Inspirational Story of the Brothers Who Created Arby's. Nav.
https://www.nav.com/blog/inspirational-story-brothers-behind-arbys-26195.
Wilson, M. (2019, July 24). Arby's is betting $3.9 billion that its customers don't want fake meat.
Fast Company. https://www.fastcompany.com/90370906/arbys-is-betting-customers-dont-
want-fake-meat.