Human Sexuality Nodrm
Human Sexuality Nodrm
Human Sexuality Nodrm
“This collaborative volume updates the team’s popular textbook covering top-
ics from A-frame orgasm to zygote transplantation. Most sexuality textbooks
focus primarily on biological or psychological aspects. In contrast, this book
truly presents a holistic overview of human sexuality in its social contexts and
cross-cultural variability, attending as well to variations in sexual orientation
and gender diversity, while clearly explaining the physiology and psychology.
Ideal for anthropology of sexuality courses, the clear descriptions of anthro-
pological and sociological concepts also suit this book for a general sexuality
course or as a general reference.”
— Timothy M. Hall, MD PhD, Assistant Clinical
Professor, UCLA Dept. of Family Medicine
Taylor & Francis
Taylor & Francis Group
http://taylorandfrancis.com
Human Sexuality
Utilizing viewpoints across cultural and national boundaries and taking into
account the evolution of human anatomy, sexual behavior, attitudes, and
beliefs across the globe, Human Sexuality, Second Edition, remains an essential
text for educators and students who wish to understand human sexuality in all
of its richness and complexity.
Anne Bolin, PhD, is a Professor Emerita from Elon University, diplomate with
the American Board of Sexology, a certified sex researcher, and former co-chair/
co-founder of the Human Sexuality and Anthropology Interest Group.
Katja Antoine, PhD, is Program and Research Developer at the UCLA Center
for the Study of Women.
Human Sexuality
Biological, Psychological, and
Cultural Perspectives
Second Edition
1 Introduction 1
Chapter Overview 1
The Anthropological Perspective 1
Summary 18
Thought-Provoking Questions 19
Suggested Resources 19
Chapter Overview 20
Anthropological Perspectives in Contrast 20
Definitions of Human Sexuality 30
Biological Definitions and Dimensions 33
Sexual Violence 41
Summary 45
Thought-Provoking Questions 45
Suggested Resources 45
Chapter Overview 47
Arboreal and Terrestrial Adaptations 51
viii Contents
Evolution of the Brain 54
Evolution of the Human Family 55
Evolution of Intimacy 60
Female Sexuality 61
Human Evolution: A Synthesis 65
Summary 66
Thought-Provoking Questions 66
Suggested Resources 67
12 Sexuality through the Life Stages, Part III: Adult Sexuality 279
Chapter Overview 279
Experiencing Sexuality and Human Sexual Response (HSR) 279
The Cross-Cultural Spectrum: Indigenous and NonIndustrialized
Sexuality 280
Theories of Sexology in Industrialized Society 286
Overview of US Sexual Attitudes 299
Problems in Sexual Response: Diagnosis and Disagreements 300
Hookup Culture 312
Sex and Social Media 315
Parenting Styles 316
Summary 319
Thought-Provoking Questions 320
Suggested Resources 320
Notes 445
Glossary 449
References 480
Index 555
Illustrations
Chapter Overview
1 Introduces human sexuality from a biological, psychological, and cultural
perspective.
2 Discusses how the social control of human sexuality forms the fundamen-
tal basis for the functioning of human groups and group life.
3 Discusses ethnographic and comparative approaches to the cultural
patterning of human sexuality. Highlights anthropologists such as
Malinowski, Benedict, Mead, Ford and Beach, Martin and Voorhies, and
Frayser.
Psychological
Attributes
It was simple—a very simple point—to which our materials were orga-
nized in the 1920s, merely the documentation over and over of the fact
that human nature is not rigid and unyielding, not an unadaptable plant
which insists on flowering or becoming stunted after its own fashion,
responding only quantitatively to the social environment, but that it
is extraordinarily adaptable, that cultural rhythms are strong and more
compelling than the physiological rhythms which, they overlay and
distort. . . . We had to present evidence that human character is built
upon a biological base which is capable of enormous diversification in
terms of social standards.
(in Singer, 1961: 16)
Samoan society was one in which extremes in emotion were culturally dis-
couraged. It was characterized by casualness in a number of spheres, in-
cluding sexuality, parenting, and responsibility. In contrast to industrialized
culture, a young Samoan woman’s sexuality was experienced without guilt.
8 Introduction
She concluded that the foundation of this nonchalant approach to sex and
conflict-free adolescence could be explained by the following:
In this work, she established the importance of the study of women when little
information was available (Howard, 1993: 69). She also challenged notions of
biological reductionism that, even today, are too often used to support status
quo politics.
Despite the magnitude of Margaret Mead’s contribution to anthropology,
and her recognition as a public figure who brought anthropology out of the
halls of academia into the mainstream United States, she was not without her
detractors. Since her death in 1978, Coming of Age in Samoa has been at the
center of a heated debate in anthropology launched by Australian anthropol-
ogist Derek Freeman in his book Margaret Mead and Samoa: The Making and
Unmaking of an Anthropological Myth in 1983 and his subsequent 1999 book
The Fateful Hoaxing of Margaret Mead: A Historical Analysis of Her Samoan Re-
search. Derek Freeman argued strongly for a very different Samoa from the one
studied by Mead. Based on his own research in Samoa from 1940–1943 and ex-
tensive subsequent research in the 1960s, Freeman took issue with the picture
of the easygoing family life, low affect, and positively sanctioned premarital
sex, citing punitive family relationships, competition and aggression, sexual
jealousy, and a stormy puberty. His explanations are in direct opposition to
those of Mead; he weighed in on the “biology is destiny” spectrum arguing
for instinctive and innate interpretations of his findings. Freeman, however,
did not disagree with Mead’s depiction of adolescent casual attitudes toward
adolescent sex (in Barnouw, 1985: 98–99). In his second attack, he argued
that Mead’s two key informants deliberately lied to her. Just as Freeman has
critiqued Mead, other anthropologists have found much lacking in Freeman’s
evidence (Cote, 2000; Ember, 1985; Holmes, 1987), yet others have argued that
they were both partially correct (Abramson, 1987; Shankman, 1996; Ember
and Ember, 1994).
The different conclusions can be attributed to several factors, including
the gender of the fieldworker, which can have a decided effect on developing
rapport and on the kind of data collected (Holmes, 1987). There was also a
fourteen-year gap in time between when Mead finished her research in 1926
and Freeman started his in 1940. Samoan culture had changed a great deal
since the 1920s with the impact of missionization, colonialism, increasing
Euro-American contact, globalization, and the expansion of capitalism, which
undoubtedly affected Freeman’s interpretation of Samoan adolescent behavior
(Ember, 1985: 88; Ember and Ember, 1994; Shankman, 1996). Mead worked
primarily with adolescent girls while Freeman’s main sources were senior men
Introduction 9
whose knowledge of what teenage girls were experiencing was undoubtedly
limited. Abramson’s research supports the view that adults opposed premarital
sex, but in spite of this, Samoan adolescents had frequent premarital sex (in
Bates and Fratkin, 2003: 65–66). Not only did Mead and Freeman rely on dif-
ferent populations for research, but they also studied on different islands whose
history of colonization varied as well. Mead studied in American Samoa while
Freeman worked mostly in the Independent State of Samoa (Ember, 1985: 87).
Shankman has argued that the disagreement may lie in the vantage point
of comparison. Thus, compared with the United States at the time, Samoan
premarital sexuality may have indeed been more common and open (Ember
and Ember, 1994). In addition, Freeman has criticized Mead for too heavy a
reliance on her two key informants and not collecting enough divergent views.
However, Cote (2000) and Shankman (1996: 564) have critiqued Freeman’s re-
search on the same grounds: that he has selectively used information that sup-
ports his stance while ignoring evidence which substantiated Mead’s claims.
The general consensus by anthropologists is that Mead may have over-
stressed the homogeneity of Samoan culture and adolescent experiences, but
her general stance, that culture is a tour de force in shaping the expression
of gender and influencing biological differences in the sexes to a very strong
degree, is supported by the huge range of variation in the expression of gender
found cross-culturally. Finally, Freeman claims to “Unmake… an Anthropo-
logical Myth” by focusing his critique on one of her earliest works undertaken
when she was just twenty-four-years old and by ignoring an entire lifetime of
research publications. As such, this is a rather extreme claim. Indeed, this on-
going debate confirms one of our favorite quotes by Margaret Mead: “Sooner or
later I am going to die, but I’m not going to retire” (Brainy Quotes).
Ford and Beach’s pioneering Patterns of Sexual Behavior (1951) proposed that
sexual partnerships consist of two types: mateships defined in the same way as
marriages; and liaisons, “less stable partnerships in which the relationship is
more exclusively sexual” (1951: 106). Sexologists and anthropologists generally
subdivide human liaisons on the basis of their premarital or extramarital char-
acter (Ford and Beach, 1951: 106).
The regulation of sexual partnerships makes it possible to define groups of
people by relationships based on offspring and kinship. These kin relationships
Introduction 13
are formalized through marriage systems. Sexual prohibitions function to
“minimize competition among relations and to increase the bonds of cooper-
ation and friendship between neighboring groups” (Crapo, 1987: 61). Because
descent is important for a number of reasons such as inheritance, obligations,
and affiliations, we can regard sexual unions as having the potential to shape
kin group formation; sexual access therefore defines kin groups. The impor-
tance of sexuality is socially recognized through marriage as an institution
with sexual rights and obligations. But it should be kept in mind that there
is a great deal of sexual activity that occurs prior to and outside marriage, in-
cluding sexual activities between people of the same sex, ritual and ceremonial
sex, as well as a host of other encounters including affairs, “one-night stands,”
and “hooking up.”
Societies differ as to their tolerance of premarital and extramarital activities
and the conditions under which they are acceptable and/or prohibited. Ac-
cording to Broude and Greene’s (1976) survey of the cross-cultural record, in
69 percent of the societies studied, men commonly participated in extramar-
ital sex, and in 57 percent of the societies women did so as well. This leads us
to another thorny issue for sex researchers, the contrast between ideal and real
culture. The ideal culture or normative expectation is that 54 percent of the
societies surveyed allow only men to have extramarital sex, while 11 percent
allow it for women. But the data suggest that many more people worldwide
actually violate this ideal, particularly in the case of women.
In summary, human sexuality is a central force in the origin of kin groups.
In Murdock’s words: “All societies have faced the problem of reconciling the
need of controlling sex with that of giving it adequate expression” (1949: 261).
The regulation of sexual relations is the basis for descent and inheritance,
critical factors for human societies in the maintenance of social groups. Yet sex
and marriage do not necessarily “go together” like a horse and carriage. Sex is
not the central factor in the bonding of two individuals through marriage. To
think so is to engage in a bias shaped by recent modern US views of marriage.
Sex is indeed critical for kin groups and their perpetuation; although sex is a
right and an obligation in marriage, it is not necessarily the basis upon which
marriages are made. Economic cooperation emerges as an important factor
in marriage both in evolutionary terms and in the cross-cultural record. This
will become more evident in our discussion of “The Patterning of Human
Sexuality.”
Social systems
THE FRAME
Human biology—
BASEMENT
evolutionary adaptation
Summary
1 Human sexuality is a biological, psychological, and cultural experience
and phenomenon.
2 Human sexuality is a means used by human groups to achieve socio-
cultural goals, such as the creation of kin groups.
3 A variety of anthropological perspectives and their proponents were in-
troduced, including Malinowski, Benedict, Mead, Ford and Beach, Martin
and Voorhies, and Frayser.
4 We concluded that human sexuality has several components, one in
human biology, which provides us with certain potentials and limitations,
and the other in culture, wherein our sexuality is learned and integrated
in the broader cultural context.
5 Emphasis was placed on the importance of the individual in society through
her/his relationship to the cultural context including motives, personality,
attitudes, values, perceptions, and emotions. It is because of these individ-
ual differences that cultures are so dynamic and ever-changing.
6 We discussed the value of a biological, psychological, and cultural per-
spective for understanding human sexuality.
7 We offered discussion of the culture concept, including discussion of the
dynamic elements of culture and introduced the importance of culture
change for understanding human sexuality.
Introduction 19
Thought-Provoking Questions
1 After reading this chapter, reflect on how your views about human sexu-
ality have been affirmed, challenged, or expanded?
2 What did you learn about human sexuality in this chapter that was
unexpected?
3 What makes anthropological perspectives on human sexuality unique?
4 What are some of the ways in which human sexuality is shaped by culture?
Can you think of any sexual or related behavior that is completely nat-
ural? Would you regard breastfeeding as completely natural without any
cultural influences?
Suggested Resources
Books
Holmes, Lowell Don. 1987. The Quest for the Real Samoa: The Mead/Freeman Contro-
versy and Beyond. South Hadley, MA: Bergin and Garvey.
LaFont, Suzanne, (ed.). 2003. Constructing Sexualities: Readings in Sexuality, Gender
and Culture. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.
Websites
American Anthropological Association. http://www.aaanet.org.
International Academy of Sex Research. http://www.iasr.org/.
National Sexuality Resource Center. http://www.cregs.sfsu.edu.
Center for a Public Anthropology. http://www.publicanthropology.org/index.htm.
2 Biological, Psychological, and
Cultural Approaches
Georgina S. Hammock
Chapter Overview
1 Compares and contrasts psychological, sociological, and biological per-
spectives of human sexuality.
2 Presents anthropological concepts, terms, and definitions. Specific exam-
ples from the fields of physical anthropology and cultural anthropology
that are relevant to our understanding of sexology are offered.
3 Provides a definition of and discusses the scope of human sexuality.
4 Offers the importance of a relativistic perspective of human sexual
expression.
5 Discusses sexual violence from various socio-cultural and legal perspectives.
Biological
The biological perspective focuses on the physiological basis of sexual behav-
ior. Biological perspectives on human sexuality stress what are referred to as
essentialist views of human sexuality. Essentialist views look at instinct as an
“essential” attribute of sexuality and regard reproduction as the core of that in-
stinct. Katchadourian and Lunde (1975: 2–3) have challenged this perspective
of human sexuality and counter that:
The incentive is in the act itself, rather than in its possible consequences
[reproduction]. Sexual behavior in this sense arises from a psychological
“drive,” associated with sensory pleasure, and its reproductive conse-
quences are a by-product (though a vital one)… [O]ur sexual behavior in-
volves certain physical “givens,” including sex organs, hormones, intricate
networks of nerves, and brain centers.
Sociological
The sociological tradition in sexual science is characterized by research that
focuses on contemporary sexuality in Europe and the United States and/or
usually emphasizes industrialized nations. It looks at the importance of “social
learning, social rules and role playing” in the expression of human sexual-
ity (Musaph, 1978: 84), and stresses patterns of social interaction. The survey
method remains the most popular sociological research technique used for
collecting sexological data (Katchadourian, 1985: 11). Sociological research
has provided a valuable contribution to sexology through its attention to the
intersection of class, status group, and the sexual experience. This approach is
evident in such classic works as Komarovsky’s Blue Collar Marriage (1962) and
Rubin’s Worlds of Pain (1976).
Anthropology and sociology are very compatible perspectives. There are,
in fact, a number of anthropologists whose sexological interests are primarily
in studying US culture. The anthropologist, in contrast to the sociologist, is
trained to maintain a comparative and bio-cultural view with reference to
the cross-cultural record regardless of the research topic; whether it is study-
ing childbirth or middle-aged women (Brown and Kerns, 1985; Jordan, 1993;
Trevathan, 1987). Although the sociological perspective tends to focus on the
importance of social structure and patterns of interaction, the anthropological
one additionally integrates the significance of beliefs in understanding human
behavior. This is essential in overcoming our own industrial society’s cultural
biases about sex that can creep into research. It is therefore useful in the study
of sexology in the United States to sustain a broader frame of reference includ-
ing structure, meaning, and cultural variation internally and cross-culturally.
For the anthropologist, this may also include an evolutionary understanding as
well. Generally speaking, however, anthropology and sociology are very closely
related disciplines and it is often impossible to distinguish between the works
of anthropologists and sociologists.
Psychological
Psychology addresses sexuality from the perspective of the individual and the
individual’s environment. In general, psychology’s approach to sexuality fo-
cuses on the motives behind sexual behavior and factors that influence that
motivation. To understand this process, psychologists study many different
facets of the human experience. Indeed, there is perhaps no one psychological
perspective, but several different thrusts within a general concern with cog-
nitive, emotional, behavioral, and some physiological components of human
sexuality.
Bio-Psycho-Cultural Approaches 23
On the theoretical level, psychologists have approached human sexuality
from many different angles. Some rather infamous theories within psychology
have focused on the critical role of sexuality in the development of personal-
ity. Freud’s rather complex theory proposes that the sex instinct (eros) along
with the death instinct (thanatos) were driving forces in the development of
an individual’s personality (Hyde, 1982: 6). Thus, Freud places biology at the
root of the individual’s psychosexuality. Developmental aspects of sexuality are
considered part of our physiological inheritance. As individuals develop, they
encounter various stages in which sexuality and conflict are characteristic and
shape the personality that individuals will have as adults.
Other theories, such as social learning theory (Bandura, 1986), emphasize
the role of observational learning in the acquisition of behavior. From this per-
spective, other people serve as models (e.g., a parent, friend, or a person in the
media) that help us to learn what behaviors are acceptable and unacceptable
in our society. When we see these models rewarded for their behaviors, we are
more likely to behave like the model and when we see the models punished for
their behavior, we are less likely to behave like the model. For example, social
learning has a powerful role in shaping our gender roles. In US culture, females
and males learn to present themselves in specific ways to be accepted and val-
ued. These lessons are learned from many different sources from an early age
onward. These models include parents, teachers, the media, and peers. Even
Halloween costumes serve to reinforce these roles. Boys are traditionally dressed
in action-oriented outfits that emphasize violence and death. Girls, on the other
hand, are dressed as brides and princesses and when they are presented as vil-
lains, they are eroticized—even at the ages of six and seven (Nelson, 2000).
In addition to theories important to human sexual behavior, psychology
researchers are also interested in the impact of individuals and their envi-
ronments on other aspects of sexual functioning. For example, research on
the male sex hormone testosterone is an interesting case. Research in this
area has found that numerous situational factors are related to changes in the
levels of testosterone in males. Males who have lost a competition, whether
physical or mental, (Mazur, Booth, and Dabbs, 1992), whose sports teams
have lost (Fielden, Lutter, and Dabbs as cited in Mazur and Booth, 1998), and
who have been degraded in the context of a military officer training program
(Thompson, Dabbs, and Friday, 1990) show decreases in their testosterone
levels. These relationships suggest a reciprocal relationship between societal
or cultural events and biological responses and highlight the importance of
socio-cultural variables to physiological functions.
Developmental psychologists are interested in the relationship of aging and hu-
man sexuality. The number of processes involved in the development of an indi-
vidual’s sexuality across childhood, adolescence, early and late adulthood is quite
large. For example, researchers have studied the influence of parents and peers
on adolescents’ sexual activity. Others have looked at the effectiveness of school
sex education courses on the initiation of sexual activity and the use of safer sex
behaviors. Still others investigate the motivation behind sexual infidelity.
24 Bio-Psycho-Cultural Approaches
Social and personality psychologists are interested in the significance of
variables associated with the person (e.g., religious attitudes, self-esteem, mood,
love for one’s partner) and the environment (e.g., the media, perceived friends’
behavior, attractiveness of the partner) in understanding sexual motivation
and behavior. One major area of study for these psychologists is intimate rela-
tionships. For example, research on the initiation of relationships shows that
some of the most important variables in attraction are physical attractiveness,
similarity, and physical proximity. Other research focuses on the dynamics of
relationships and factors that influence whether individuals will stay or leave a
relationship. Another area of relationship research deals with the darker side
of relationships—violence and jealousy. Finally, other researchers in this area
study the impact of erotica and pornography on perceptions of partners and
violence against women.
Another area of psychology deals with the study and treatment of sexual
dysfunction and “pathologies.” Research in this area is devoted to uncovering
the various explanations for sexual difficulties and finding effective means of
treating those difficulties. The goal of these treatments is to help those with
difficulties to function more effectively. For those whose behavior is consid-
ered undesirable or unwanted or detrimental to society, such as rapists and
pedophiles, the goal is to shape the behavior so that it no longer harms other
members of society.
As you can see, the scope of psychological studies covers extensive areas,
including sexual motivation, familial and peer influence, self-esteem issues,
and a number of other subject areas as far ranging as gender identity and
gender differences in sexual response. Although the topics may vary, the
approach is usually focused on the psychology of the individual and his/
her environment in the development of sexuality. The predominant trend
in psychology is to focus on a far smaller or micro-level analysis than that
undertaken by anthropologists. Though psychological anthropologists may
be interested in the mental and emotional structures behind the expression
of human sexuality in individuals, the cultural context remains an import-
ant feature for their analysis. Psychological anthropologists specifically, and
anthropologists generally, are more likely to be interested in the impact of
culture on family dynamics, childrearing practices, or in the cultural pat-
terning of sexual dysfunction within society. For example, the psychological
perspective locates dysfunction within the individual and the family milieu,
in contrast to an anthropological perspective which locates its source in soci-
ety. Like anthropology, psychology emphasizes the role of learning; however,
unlike anthropology it does not usually consider it within a cross-cultural
framework. Nor does it emphasize a culture’s childrearing practices, which
can influence adult personality (Katchadourian, 1985: 11; Kottak, 2002: 21).
A relatively recent point of connection between psychology and anthropol-
ogy has been the increasing popularity of evolutionary perspectives in psy-
chology, a major theoretical perspective often taken in anthropology (see
Chapter 3 for further discussion).
Bio-Psycho-Cultural Approaches 25
Interdisciplinary Approaches
Hopefully, by this point, it is clear that while each discipline views and inves-
tigates sexuality with a different focus, each contributes to a more complete
understanding of the behavior. The case of studying the issues associated with
sexuality and aging is illustrative of this point. A biologist might address the
developmental process of aging by studying the impact of elevated or reduced
levels of hormonal changes on the different sexual organs at adolescence and
old age. A sociologist might look at different types of sexual behaviors that
are expressed at different ages—childhood, adolescence, adulthood and late
adulthood—and how these differ as a function of race and class. A psychol-
ogist might study the impact of aging on the individual’s perception of their
sexual attractiveness to others and an anthropologist might question the evo-
lutionary advantage of sexuality at the various stages of the life cycle and how
different cultures might respond to these behaviors. All of these points are
important aspects of the relationship between aging and sexuality.
Not only do the different perspectives provide different pieces to the puzzle
that is human behavior, they also often enjoy a certain amount of “cross-
pollination.” There are scientists who are trained as physical anthropologists,
social psychologists, and psychological anthropologists. In other words, often
scientists are interested in the crossover of information from one discipline
to another. The physical anthropologist must be knowledgeable about both
anatomy and anthropology, the social psychologist looks at the intersection
of sociology and psychology, and the psychological anthropologist studies
the influence of culture on psychological phenomena. Therefore, it is often
difficult at times to determine what the perspective of the researcher might
be. Imagine that you have read about research that was conducted on the
occurrence of violence in dating relationships. In this study, the research
looked at variables such as the impact of personality (e.g., self-esteem, neurot-
icism, the willingness to trust others) and the environment (e.g., your part-
ner’s level of aggression) on the use of aggression. In addition, they report on
the prevalence of the behavior and how males and females differ in its use.
What would the perspective of that researcher be? What if you also find out
that his/her colleagues have looked at whether the rates of aggression differ
across regions of this country? Would you assume that the researcher was a
sociologist, a psychologist, or an anthropologist? Actually, the research men-
tioned here was done by social psychologists (Hammock, 2003; White and
Koss, 1991).
As you can see, it is often difficult to imagine what the perspective of
the researcher might be. Is the person who studies the influence of social
class, cultural norms, and beliefs about women on the incidence of date rape
a psychologist, a sociologist, or an anthropologist? Is the researcher study-
ing safer sex behavior in sex workers a sociologist or an anthropologist? Is
the researcher investigating the impact of the family on the use of violence
in intimate relationships a psychologist or sociologist? Is the work on the
26 Bio-Psycho-Cultural Approaches
supportive function of transgender support groups on transgender commu-
nities conducted by an anthropologist, sociologist, or psychologist? In other
words, the borders between the different disciplines and their perspectives
are often fuzzy and allow for a great deal of sharing of interdisciplinary re-
search to be conducted.
Similarly, you often find that teams of researchers representing different per-
spectives often come together to conduct research on sexual behavior. A classic
article on romantic love provides an excellent case in point. In this study, the
researchers studied different regions of the brain to determine whether areas of
the brain associated with reward and motivation systems are related to reports
of being intensely in love with a romantic partner. The study used MRI images
taken while the participants were looking at a picture of the beloved and of a
familiar individual. Their results support the relationship of love with certain
regions of the brain. Further, their research argues that romantic love is quite
complex and might actually be a motivational state that leads to specific types
of emotions and a focusing on the beloved (Aron et al., 2005). This fascinating
research was accomplished by a team of individuals trained as psychologists,
anthropologists, and neurologists.
The bottom line is that all of the different disciplines are critical to obtain-
ing a complete understanding of human sexuality. Though the primary focus
of this book is on the anthropological perspective, in the following chapters
you will see how each of these perspectives has contributed to the topics stud-
ied. This will result in a biological, psychological, and cultural approach that
examines how biological, psychological, and cultural variables influence sex-
ual behavior. But before we can look at individual behaviors, several critical
terms and theories must be understood.
Anthropological Concepts
Having compared and contrasted the anthropological perspective with
biological, sociological, and psychological ones, specific concepts from an-
thropology must be introduced to help further the understanding of the
anthropological approach to human sexuality. We have selected four key
terms and related concepts that will be useful. These are evolution, the cul-
ture concept, ethnocentrism, and cultural relativism. We have been very
selective in our choice of these four terms; there are numerous others that
are important in anthropological approaches to human sexuality. These are
introduced in subsequent chapters and may be found in the glossary at the
end of the text. Anthropological terms and concepts are discussed in greater
depth than other terms because of their importance. Other anthropological
terms of particular relevance for understanding the perspective of this text-
book are society, primates, bonding, ethnological, ethnographic, compara-
tive, cross-cultural, and genetic fitness. These are presented in the glossary at
the end of the text and/or are interspersed throughout the various chapters
of this book.
Bio-Psycho-Cultural Approaches 27
Evolution
The modern theory of evolution challenged the prevailing view of the sev-
enteenth and eighteenth centuries that all species were separate and divine
creations. Through his famous travels on the HMS Beagle, Charles Darwin
formulated his theory of natural selection. Naturalist Alfred Russell Wallace,
during this same period, independently arrived at a similar conclusion: spe-
cies are not separate creations but have evolved through a process of natural
selection. In 1858 Darwin and Wallace together rocked the meetings of the
Linnaean Society of London, and in 1859 Darwin published The Origin of
Species, documenting and detailing the theory of natural selection (Ember,
Ember, and Peregrine, 2005).
The central tenets of natural selection are straightforward. Natural selec-
tion is a mechanism of evolution that involves long periods of time. Those
individuals who are better adapted to their environments will be more likely
to reproduce surviving offspring than those who are not. Those individuals
who reproduce themselves are more likely to pass on the traits they possess
than those who are not so well adapted to their environments. This has been
referred to as survival of the fit and is calculated in terms of reproduction,
not life span of the individual. Since environments do not remain stable over
time, different characteristics may emerge as more adaptive so that what was
adaptive in one environment at one time is no longer adaptive at another
time. Adaptation is defined as “a process by which organisms achieve a bene-
ficial adjustment to an available environment, and the results of that process”
(Haviland, 1989: 59).
Though Darwin knew that traits were inherited, he could not explain how
new variation in populations occurred. It was Gregor Mendel, an Austrian
monk, who pioneered the study of genetics. His findings were incorporated
into the theories of the scientific community in the early 1900s. Studies of
genetics are now an essential component in the study of evolution (Ember,
Ember, and Peregrine, 2005).
Related to the issue of cultural meanings are two additional concepts incor-
porated by anthropologists in their research on culture and sexuality; these
are emic and etic perspectives. Emic approaches take the perspective of the
participant’s point of view, seeing the world from the standpoint of the in-
sider. Ethnographers are dedicated to acquiring this emic perspective, before
they can undertake an etic analysis. Etic perspectives are those based on a
scientific outsider’s ways of knowing and understanding the world. This in-
cludes a “set of epistemological and theoretical principles and methodologies
acquired during a more or less rigorous and lengthy training period” (Harris,
1999: 33).
Bio-Psycho-Cultural Approaches 29
Ethnocentrism
According to Bernstein (1983: 183), ethnocentrism is “unreflectively imposing
alien standards of judgment and thereby missing the point of the meaning of
a practice.” It is “the attitude that other societies’ customs and ideas can be
judged in the context of one’s own culture” (Ember and Ember, 1990: 510)
and “that one’s own culture is superior in every way to all others” (Haviland,
1989: 296). As a discipline, anthropology has rejected this view as a result
of the method of participant-observation; early on anthropologists came to
know that “savages” were as human as those peoples living in industrialized
societies and that their behavior could only be understood as part of their cul-
ture (Haviland, 1989: 296). To fully comprehend the meaning and danger of
ethnocentrism, it is important to adopt the anthropological stance of cultural
relativism.
Cultural Relativism
According to Ember and Ember (1990: 510), relativism is “the attitude that a
society’s customs and ideas should be viewed within the context of that society’s
problems and opportunities.” Thus, “there is no single scale of values applicable
to all societies” (Winick, 1970: 454). Anthropologists find it crucial to remain
relativistic in order to describe, explain, and to discover meaning without the
biases of their home society. For example, it is obvious that US cultural biases
against homosexuality could impact scientific understanding of the subject.
Herdt (1981, 1987, 1988, 2006) and Williams (1986) have written about tribal
people’s homosexual practices and Blackwood (1984a, b, 2005a, b) on indige-
nous lesbian behavior. They offer a relativistic and nonjudgmental view of the
subject. It is evident from their writings that even terminology such as “homo-
sexual” and “lesbian” are so loaded and culturally specific that they cannot be
directly translated into the meaning given to, for example, boy-inseminating
rites among Sambia of Highland New Guinea (Herdt, 1987, 2006 among oth-
ers). The “homosexual” behavior of these peoples is simply not commensurable
with our Euro-American concept of homosexuality or gay (Herdt, 2006).
At some point in adopting a culturally relativistic perspective, you might
be faced with a clash of values. How far to take cultural relativism and where
to draw the line are questions often asked by students; however, it is one that
concerns anthropologists as well. In fact, Ethos, the journal of the Society for
Psychological Anthropology, devoted an entire issue to the question of moral
relativism (1990: 131–223). The introduction begins with:
To the sensitive young woman who has had benefits of proper upbringing,
the wedding day is ironically, both the happiest and most terrifying day of
her life… On the negative side, there is the wedding night, during which
the bride must pay the piper, so to speak, by facing for the first time the expe-
rience of sex. At this point, dear reader, let me concede one shocking truth.
Some young women actually anticipate the wedding night with curiosity
and pleasure! Beware of such an attitude. A selfish and sensual husband can
easily take advantage of such a bride. One cardinal rule of marriage should
never be forgotten: GIVE LITTLE, GIVE SELDOM, AND ABOVE
ALL, GIVE GRUDGINGY… while sex is at best revolting and at worst
rather painful, it has to be endured, and has been by women since the be-
ginning of time, and is compensated for by the monogamous home and the
children produced through it.
(1989 [1894]: 5–7, emphasis author’s)
This historical view represents a fundamental change over time in how sex is
regarded for women. In the United States today the model of sex is one of “sex
as pleasure” rather than sex as duty.
Despite this new model, there still exists a double standard in US society
wherein a woman’s sexuality is bounded by a model of sexuality that empha-
sizes monogamous, committed heterosexual and potentially reproductive sex.
Such changes in attitude influence how human sexuality is experienced and
integrated within culture.
Species-Wide Behavior
Human sexuality, or more accurately the capacity for sexuality, is a species-wide
behavior. The term species is defined as “a population or group of populations
that is capable of interbreeding, but that is reproductively isolated from other
such populations” (Haviland, 1989: 66). Although all humans may mate with
Bio-Psycho-Cultural Approaches 33
one another, it is characteristic of cultures to restrict sexual and reproductive
activities between people. Sometimes the cultural meaning assigned to cer-
tain gene pools and/or physical attributes prohibits groups of humans from
interbreeding with one another even though they are perfectly able to do so
(Haviland, 1989: 66). Thus, all humans are capable of interbreeding and pro-
ducing viable offspring, but cultural barriers may prevent people from marry-
ing and reproducing.
Kessler and McKenna’s (1978: 7–16) definitions also serve us well. Though it
is conventional to define sex as the biological aspects of male or female, and
to define gender as the “psychological, social, and cultural aspects of maleness
and femaleness,” Kessler and McKenna argue that even the concept of two
biological sexes is a social construction (1978: 7).
For purposes of clarity, sex will be used in this context to refer to activi-
ties related to sexual pleasure, arousal, and intercourse whether recreational
or for reproduction (Jacobs and Roberts, 1989: 440). Gender will refer more
broadly to the cultural aspects of being male or female. Elsewhere, specific us-
ages such as chromosomal, hormonal, or morphological sex will be presented,
even though these biological characteristics are always interpreted through a
cultural lens (cf. Kessler and McKenna, 1978: 7).
Through an understanding of the “attribution process,” how people as-
sign gender to others, insight can be gained into the social construction of
38 Bio-Psycho-Cultural Approaches
femininity and masculinity. Euro-American femininity and masculinity are
integrated in a binary gender scheme whose central tenants are that there are
only two sexes, male and female, and that these are appropriately associated
with the two social statuses of gender: men and women, boys and girls. “What-
ever a woman does will somehow have the stamp of femininity on it, while
whatever a man does will likewise bear the imprint of masculinity” (Devor,
1989: vii). Therefore, masculinity and femininity are associated with gender
roles. The Euro-American gender schema is a shared belief system about sex
and gender. It regards biological sex as the basis for gender status, which is the
basis for gender role. The actual process whereby people attribute gender to an-
other actually occurs in the reverse to our gender schema; a person’s display of
masculinity or femininity (gender role) indicates gender, which is followed by
the presumption of appropriate genitalia which are not readily visible (Devor,
1989: 149; Kessler and McKenna, 1978: 1–7, 112–141). Without our portable
gene scanners and x-ray vision, daily life consists of encounters in which the
biological is clearly mediated by cultural expectation in the attribution pro-
cess. We do not really see genitals and sex, but gender presentations of femi-
nine and masculine beings.
In summary, masculinity and femininity may be defined as components of
gender roles that include cultural expectations about behaviors and appear-
ances associated with the status of man or woman in the industrial binary
model of the sexes. For the purposes of our discussion, the following definition
for gender role will be used:
Because of the attribution process, gender roles are often confused with sex
and biology. Gender role stereotypes include ideas that differences in gender
are the result of biology. For example, women are more nurturing, men are
more aggressive, and women are emotional while men are rational. These dif-
ferences are rather the result of learned behaviors. Stereotypes such as these
are classified by sociologists as expressive and instrumental gender roles. Boys
are socialized into instrumental roles that are associated with acting or achiev-
ing while girls are socialized into relationship-oriented or expressive roles
(Renzetti and Curran, 2003: 167). That these roles are cultural and are not
natural is amply demonstrated in the cross-cultural record in which a diver-
sity of behaviors and expectations are recorded. Mead’s study of the Arapesh,
Bio-Psycho-Cultural Approaches 39
the Mundugumor, and the Tchambuli (they call themselves the Chambri) in
Sex and Temperament in Three Primitive Societies (1963 [1935]) offers a clas-
sical account of gender role variation in counterpoint to our industrialized
society’s conceptions. Among the Mundugumor, both men and women were
aggressive and non-emotional, while among the Arapesh, both sexes were co-
operative and nurturant. The Tchambuli (Chambri) expressed the reverse of
our Euro-American gender roles with cooperative caring men and assertive
women as the behavioral norm.
Deborah Gewertz’s research on the Chambri complicates Mead’s perspec-
tive with a regional and historical approach. During Mead’s research the
Chambri had only recently returned to their home site after a twenty-year
exile. Consequently, the men were focused on refurbishing their ritual equip-
ment and seemed to be highly involved in artistic and expressive endeavors.
The women appeared dominant to Mead because they had already estab-
lished their economic system of barter. Nonetheless, Gewertz argues that
Mead was essentially correct in her view that gender roles are flexible and
responsive to changing environments (Gewertz, 1981; Ward and Edelstein,
2006: 60–61).
Sexual Violence
Sexual violence—sexual activity that takes place without consent—is a long-
standing and ubiquitous part of human societies. The term refers to words
and actions of a sexual nature expressed against a person’s will and without
their consent, using force, threats, manipulation, or coercion (“About Sexual
Assault,” 2018, National Sexual Violence Resource Center, NSVRC). Consent
means saying “yes” to sexual activity; not saying “no” is not consent (wom-
enshealth.gov). Saying “yes” when you are legally unable to do so (e.g., under
threat, when you are physically or mentally unable to, or when you are under-
age) is also not consent (womenshealth.gov). Sexual violence is an umbrella
term that includes acts such as rape, sexual assault, sexual harassment, sexual
trafficking, masturbating in public, non-consensual image sharing, and watch-
ing someone engage in private acts without their knowledge or permission
(“About Sexual Assault,” 2018, National Sexual Violence Resource Center,
NSVRC). While some of these terms are used interchangeably in everyday
speech, the distinctions can illuminate the many forms of sexual violence that
take place on a daily basis. Familiarity with the definitions of these terms can
also help victims of sexual violence identify that a sexually violent act has
taken place. Here we will define two commonly used terms, sexual assault
and sexual harassment. We recognize that sexual violence is a global problem;
in our discussion, we use the conditions in the United States as an example.
We would also like to note that this section provides an overview, not an
in-depth analysis, of the meaning and prevalence of sexual violence in the
United States.
42 Bio-Psycho-Cultural Approaches
According to the US Department of Justice Office on Violence Against
Women (OVW), sexual assault “means any nonconsensual sexual act pro-
scribed by Federal, tribal, or State law, including when the victim lacks capac-
ity to consent” (justice.gov/ovw/sexual-assault). Sexual assault, then, includes
any type of sexual contact with someone who cannot or does not consent
(womenshealth.gov). While rape is commonly understood as a form of sexual
assault, many are unaware that acts like unwanted touching above or under
clothes, voyeurism, and unwanted “sexting” are also included (womenshealth.
gov). While legal definitions differ between states, sexual assault, by defini-
tion, is a crime. Sexual harassment is both a specific legal term that applies
to conduct in the workplace and at educational institutions, and a term with
a broader meaning in public discourse. In legal terms, sexual harassment is
a violation of Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 (EEOC). Title VII
states that:
Unwelcome sexual advances, requests for sexual favors, and other verbal
or physical conduct of a sexual nature constitutes sexual harassment when
submission to or rejection of this conduct explicitly or implicitly affects
an individual’s employment, unreasonably interferes with an individual’s
work performance or creates an intimidating, hostile or offensive work
environment.
Sexual harassment is also a violation of Title IX, a broad statute against sex-
based discrimination that applies to all educational institutions in the United
States that receive federal assistance (US Department of Education, Office for
Civil Rights). While these forms of sexual harassment are civil violations, they
are not criminal violations (Rape, Abuse & Incest National Network, RAINN).
So while sexually harassing a coworker by making unwelcome sexual advances
could lead to the harasser being fired, it could not, on its own merit, lead to
incarceration or a criminal record. Outside of the workplace and educational
settings, many forms of what is commonly referred to as sexual harassment are
not subjected to any form of regulation (e.g., unwanted catcalls, sexual jokes,
and sharing of sexual fantasies). Sexual harassment and sexual assault, then,
cover a broad range of offenses, all of which are a form of sexual violence.
Statistics from various studies show the extent to which sexual violence is a
problem in US society:
Staggering as these numbers are, the rate of rape and sexual assault has fallen
by more than half since 1993, from a rate of 4.3 assaults per 1,000 people in
1993 to 1.2 per 1,000 in 2016 (“Scope of the Problem: Statistics,” 2018, Rape,
Abuse & Incest National Network, RAINN). Considering the number of
sexual assaults that go unreported, these numbers are unlikely entirely ac-
curate. Even so, they do suggest a decline over time (Finkelhor and Jones,
2012; Lankford, 2016: 44). Possible reasons to explain the decline include
increased awareness of and public support for civil rights, women’s rights,
gay rights, and children’s rights; the adoption of affirmative consent poli-
cies at institutions of higher education; less tolerance for sexual violence
and victim-blaming in popular culture; and improved technology that assists
law enforcement in catching offenders and helps prosecutors convict them
(Lankford, 2016: 45).
Although this trend is encouraging, the rates of sexual violence remains
high for many sections of the US population. Among undergraduates, for
instance, 22 percent report experiencing at least one instance of sexual
assault since starting college (Mellins et al., 2017). Among these, women
report a rate of 28 percent, gender non-conforming students a rate of 38
percent, and men a rate of 12.5 percent (Mellins et al., 2017). While women
in general are at risk for sexual assault, the risk is higher for multiracial
women (32 percent), Native American and Alaskan Native women (28
percent), and non-Hispanic African-American women (21 percent) (Black
et al., 2010).
In recent years, the ubiquity of sexual violence against women in partic-
ular has prompted a massive global protest under the banner of #MeToo.
Founded in 2006 by civil rights activist Tarana Burke, the MeToo movement
initially sought to provide resources and advocate for survivors of sexual
violence, particularly young women of color from low-wealth communities
(www.metoomvmt.org, 2018). The hashtag (#MeToo) went viral on social
media in October 2017, after film producer Harvey Weinstein was accused
of sexual violence by over eighty women in the entertainment industry
(Moniuszko and Kelly, 2017). The movement has since prompted women
(and some men) in a wide range of industries to publicly expose instances
of sexual violence. These include abuses that have taken place in politics
44 Bio-Psycho-Cultural Approaches
(Godfrey et al., 2018), sports (Reel and Crouch, 2019; Zeegers, 2019), reli-
gious institutions (Griswold, 2018), education (Anderson, 2018), medicine
(Smith, 2018), and the military (Cohen, 2018). While the movement started
in the United States, it has also had a global reach. Some of the countries
that have had their own #MeToo conversations include Pakistan, South
Korea, Sweden, Egypt, Japan, Israel, and France (Adam and Booth, 2018;
Stone and Vogelstein, 2019).
While it is too early to tell what the long-term impact of the #MeToo move-
ment will be, many analysts speak of it as a catalyst for a cultural shift (Be-
itsch, 2018; Fileborn and Loney-Howes, 2019; MacKinnon, 2019). Since the
movement went viral, it has met with some backlash (Bower, 2019; Kottasová,
2019), but has nonetheless persisted as a powerful influence and support for
people exposing and prosecuting sexual violence. Organizations that work to
prevent sexual violence and assist victims have existed long before #MeToo,
and have presented a range of interventions that may help to decrease rates of
sexual violence. Some of these include:
• To promote social norms that protect against violence (e.g., bystander ap-
proaches, mobilizing men and boys as allies).
• To teach skills to prevent sexual violence (e.g., teaching healthy, safe
dating and intimate relationship skills to teens; promoting healthy
sexuality).
• To provide opportunities to empower and support girls and women
(strengthening economic supports for women and families, strengthening
leadership and opportunities for girls).
• To create protective environments (improving safety and monitoring in
schools, establishing and consistently applying workplace policies).
• To support victims/survivors to lessen harms (victim-centered services,
treatment for at-risk children and families to prevent problem behavior
including sex offending) (“Preventing Sexual Violence,” 2020, Centers for
Disease Control and Prevention, CDC).
This is not an exclusive list of tools for preventing sexual violence, but it high-
lights that prevention strategies need to address both broader socio-cultural
dynamics and local structural implementation. Such strategies also need to
assume an intersectional approach and take the needs of the most highly vic-
timized groups (e.g., people of color, LGBTQ communities, people who are
economically disadvantaged, seniors, and people with disabilities) into ac-
count. With increased awareness about sexual violence and its prevalence,
and with greater allocation of resources for prevention and victim support, the
rate of sexual violence may decrease further.
In conclusion, this chapter has presented terms and concepts necessary for
understanding human sexuality from an anthropological perspective. We have
elaborated on the importance of culture in shaping our human sexuality, and
Bio-Psycho-Cultural Approaches 45
have offered an examination of key concepts and points related to biological
and psychological dimensions of sexuality.
Summary
1 Psychology, sociology, and biology offer useful perspectives for the under-
standing of human sexuality. These viewpoints are incorporated to vari-
ous degrees by anthropological approaches.
2 To understand the bio-cultural perspective, it is necessary to define our
terms. These include concepts and constructs such as evolution, the cul-
ture concept, ethnocentrism, and cultural relativism.
3 Definitions of human sexuality have varied temporally and spatially.
4 Definitions of human sexuality include areas such as anatomy and physi-
ology, the sexual life cycle, and human sexual response.
5 Sex has many components. These include behavioral, cognitive, affective,
and symbolic dimensions.
6 Sex and gender are compared and contrasted.
7 Sex has been used to serve larger cultural ends in societies. We examine
sex in the context of power and politics.
8 Sexual violence is found across many different cultural contexts and re-
mains a complex human social problem.
Thought-Provoking Questions
1 What is the relationship of the individual to culture and psychology?
Provide an example of how sexuality represents this intersection.
2 How has the information in this chapter challenged you to think differently
about your beliefs about what is “naturally” feminine or masculine?
3 Think of a specific behavior related to sexuality (e.g., sexual dysfunctions, at-
titudes about sexuality, the use of safer sex techniques) and identify potential
behavioral, cognitive, and affective factors that might influence the behavior.
4 What have you learned in this chapter that you would choose to share
with a partner or friend? Why did you choose this piece of information?
How do you think it will influence your own thoughts and behaviors or
those of the person you are sharing the information with?
Suggested Resources
Books
Altman, Dennis. 2002. Global Sex. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
Lancaster, Roger N. 2003. The Trouble with Nature: Sex in Science and Popular Culture.
Berkeley: University of California Press.
Lyons, Andrew P., and Harriet Lyons. 2004. Irregular Connections: A History of Anthro-
pology and Sexuality. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press.
46 Bio-Psycho-Cultural Approaches
Websites
Alan Guttmacher Institute. www.guttmacher.org.
Association for Feminist Anthropology. http://sscl.berkeley.edu/~afaweb/index.html.
Gender Inn. http://www.uni-koeln.de/phil-fak/englisch/datenbank/e_index.htm.
Kinsey Institute for Research in Sex, Gender and Reproduction. www.indiana.
edu/~kinsey.
National Sexual Assault Telephone Hotline (available 24/7) 1–800–656–HOPE
(4673). Online live chat is also available. www.rainn.org.
National Domestic Violence Hotline (available 24/7) 1–800–799–SAFE (7233) or
1–800–787–3224 (TTY).
Online live chat is also available.www.thehotline.org National Sexual Violence Re-
source Center 1–877–739–3895. www.nsvrc.org.
3 The Evolutionary History of
Human Sexuality
Wenda R. Trevathan
Chapter Overview
1 Presents an overview of non-human primate evolution and ancestral
relations.
2 Discusses the consequences of human arboreal and terrestrial adaptations.
3 Focuses on the development of the grasping hand, stereoscopic vision,
and grooming.
4 Considers the consequences of these adaptations for modern sexual be-
havior including the importance of touch, feeling, and vision as import-
ant components in sexual attraction.
5 Presents discussion of the importance of bipedalism, loss of estrus, the de-
velopment of brain complexity, infant dependency, and reliance on learn-
ing and examines the profound consequences this has had on hominid
evolution and human sexuality as well as reproduction.
6 Explains the importance of the social group for human survival.
7 Introduces the concept of bonding in human and non-human primates.
8 Relates how the human brain is actively involved in human maturation,
reproduction, and sexuality.
9 Addresses estrus and loss of estrus and its implications for human
evolution.
10 Offers discussion of several controversial views on the role of orgasm for
female evolution.
Kingdom Animalia
Phytum Chordata
Subphylum Vertebrata
Infra class Eutheria
Order Primates
Suborder Anthropoidea/Haplorhini (dry nose)
Super family Hominidae
Genus Homo
Species Erectus (archaic)/sapiens (present day)
Figure 3.1 The place of humans in the biological taxonomy of living organisms.
Source: Jurmain, Kilgore, and Trevathan, 2005: 109, 150.
50 The Evolution of Human Sexuality
success, they survived in subsequent generations (see Figure 3.2). In this chap-
ter, we are going to discuss aspects of our primate heritage that some research-
ers believe serve as models for early hominid1 sexuality and that affect our
modern human sexual behavior.
Non-human primate models are valuable in several ways. They help to show
the continuities with other species of our order, and illustrate the high intelli-
gence and sociability of primates. The models can serve as a reality marker to
check our own biases and perspectives regarding dominance, division of labor,
and sexuality. They provide evidence of the relationship of ecological variables
such as food, shelter, and predators to social behavior and indicate the variety
and flexibility of primate behavior and patterns of intra- and intergender and
group cooperation and competition that may be evolutionarily deep-seated.
Primate analogies may serve as models for reconstructing early hominid be-
havior. We need to be careful, however, not to take these analogies with our
close primate relatives too far or they will defeat the purpose. We must re-
member that we have had our own line of evolution for 5–8 million years and
have adapted to almost every econiche on the planet. The development of
our cerebral cortex allows for qualitatively different kinds of communications
and social relations than other primates. These variables have worked to our
advantage and disadvantage relative to the expression of our sexuality. Our
complete dependence on language, sophisticated social systems, and complex
technology make us very different animals from any others that live or have
lived on our planet.
Because of their close immunological, genetic, and behavioral similarities
to humans, the common chimpanzee (Pan troglodytes) and pygmy chimpan-
zee or bonobo (Pan paniscus) are frequently used as the most appropriate pri-
mate models for reconstructing the human past. We will follow that common
practice by examining ways in which chimpanzee and human sexuality differ
and are similar, and we will posit the evolutionary significance of the differ-
ences. But we need to start at the beginning. The fundamental aspects of
The Evolution of Human Sexuality 51
our evolutionary history that affect our sexuality can be discussed under four
topics:
While we have the primate propensity for touch; rules, attitudes, and
behaviors about touching and body space are culture-specific. For exam-
ple, our culture has been described by some sexologists and sex therapists
such as Domeena Renshaw, MD, as “touch deprived” (Renshaw, 1976).
We have rather rigid rules about touching and body space and tend to
confuse affection with sexual touching. Most dramatically, this can be
illustrated by a middle-class value on newborns, infants, and children
“having their own room” and sleeping separately from their parents and
siblings from birth. In contrast, in many traditional societies, women
carry their infants with them while engaging in their daily activities and
parents and children share a common sleeping space.
The Evolution of Human Sexuality 53
Vision and Olfaction
In addition to the development of the grasping hand, our primate ancestors
acquired highly developed visual cortices from their arboreal adaptation that
remain with us today. Primate eyes are large, binocular, and stereoscopic and
allow diurnal and color vision (Jurmain, Kilgore, and Trevathan, 2005). This
represents a shift to vision from reliance on smell as a vehicle for information
processing. Although smell (or olfaction) may still be important in sexual in-
teraction (Pawlowski, 1999; Stoddard, 1990), visual cues provide much initial
information about potential sexual partners for humans. Females in several
primate species, including chimpanzees, have clear visual signals that they are
in estrus (to be discussed later), that is, they are receptive to sexual advances
from males. Their genital areas exhibit brightly hued purple swellings at the
time of maximum likelihood of ovulation and this is when males are most
interested in copulating with them.
Evolution of Bipedalism
There is much debate among scholars of human evolution (known as paleo-
anthropologists) about the reasons that bipedalism evolved in our species,
but, like most other evolutionary changes, there is little doubt that it was
related to climate change. About 7 million years ago, a drying trend in
Africa resulted in a decrease in forested areas and an increase in woodlands
and savannahs. At some point, human ancestors began spending more time
in the savannahs and less time in the forests, although, like other terrestrial
primates, they probably returned to the trees at night to sleep more safely.
It was formerly hypothesized that movement into the savannahs preceded
evolution of bipedalism, but recent evidence suggests that our ancestors be-
came bipedal before they moved into the savannahs (Jurmain, Kilgore, and
Trevathan, 2005). It is beyond the scope of this book to resolve the question
of why humans became bipedal, but some hypotheses conclude that selec-
tion favored this form of locomotion because it enhanced the ability to see
over tall grass, gather food, lower the costs of movement through greater
energy efficiency, avoid predators, free the hands for carrying objects and
babies, and for males to provision females and infants (Jurmain, Kilgore,
and Trevathan, 2005). Suffice it to say that all of these behaviors are com-
mon in humans today because we are bipedal, and this mode of locomotion
is the hallmark of our species in the fossil record. In other words, if the fossil
primate is bipedal, it is, by definition, hominid (Jurmain, Kilgore, and Trev-
athan, 2005). As we shall see, the subsequent evolution of the human brain
is intimately linked with bipedalism, embellishing characteristics already
developed in ancestral primates such as a large ratio of brain to body size.
Bipedalism had a consequence for the evolution of the hand and manipu-
lation of tools, the elaboration of the motor areas of the brain, as well as
memory and thinking.
54 The Evolution of Human Sexuality
Bipedalism also had a profound impact on the evolution of human sexuality
and reproduction. A number of skeletal and muscular changes accompanied
upright posture. One of the major changes in anatomy that had an impact on
hominid sexuality included a tilting forward of the pelvis; it became shortened
and flared as well. The genitalia were moved forward and the female genitals
became less exposed and more hidden than those of the male. Although we
don’t know if our human ancestors exhibited bright genital swelling when they
were in estrus, these sexual swellings would have been difficult to see during
bipedal walking and standing, so other ways of communicating sexual recep-
tivity were developed. These were probably related to the expansion of com-
munication skills in general, an essential component of culture.
With the shifting forward of the hominid female genitalia, face-to-face sex
was a possibility and perhaps a probability. We are not necessarily referring
here to the “missionary position” where males are on top, since this is not even
the most preferred position cross-culturally. Face-to-face sex includes positions
in which the female is on top of the male or side by side. The position of the fe-
male genitalia in a more forward location certainly contributed to the human
potential for a wide array of sexual positions.
Changes in the pelvis also affected childbirth by placing upper limits on
the size of the birth canal (Trevathan, 1987). These limits, associated with
increase in adult brain size in the last 2 million years of human evolution,
have meant that the human infant is much less developed at birth than our
closest primate relatives. In order for a species with such large heads to be
born through a rather narrow birth passage, natural selection favored birth at
an earlier stage of development before the brain had reached the size of most
primate newborns. This meant that the human newborn was more helpless at
birth and required much greater care from the parents, especially the mother.
This also meant a longer period in which the infant was dependent on paren-
tal care, a period that became very important for learning.
Evolution of Intimacy
The concepts of psychological masculinity and femininity have been widely
discussed in the United States since the 1970s by writers such as Hite (1976,
1981, 1987), Cassell (1984), Farrell (1974, 1986, 1993), Zilbergeld (1978, 1992,
1999), Goldberg (1976, 1980, 1984), and Tanner (1995, 2001). Relative to rela-
tionships, this research generally explores what men and women need and want
from each other and in their romantic and love relationships. In essence, this
research states that men and women have very similar needs and wants in rela-
tionships. However, their means of expressing and getting their needs met are
different, and are not necessarily well communicated to or well understood by
the other gender. For example, both men and women state they want emotional
bonding and depth in their relationships and that trust, being able to be one’s
self, and honesty are important. They also state they value these needs over
genital sexuality, per se. However, according to the work by the researchers cited
above, culturally defined ways of communicating and meeting these needs and
perceptions of the other gender may either impede or enhance need fulfillment.
In general, men and women attitudinally and culturally still fulfill their scripts,
those socially defined roles of masculinity and femininity (Gagnon and Parker,
1995; Gagnon and Simon, 1973). People’s deep sense of who and what they are,
regardless of their overt behavior, rests on fairly well-ingrained pre-1960s ideas
of masculinity and femininity. This is expressed in women when they value
relationships, communication, and being physically attractive over sexuality per
se and when they assume primary responsibility for the relationship (Cassell,
1984; Hite, 1976, 1981, 1987; Tanner, 1995). Men express this by using sex as an
example of emotional caring by defining the quality of a relationship sexually
rather than through verbal or affective means, or choosing partners primarily
on physical characteristics (Farrell, 1974, 1986; Fisher, 2004; Goldberg, 1976,
1980; Hite, 1981; Zilbergeld, 1978, 1992).
The result is that while needs for closeness, trust, and bonding exist, the
means people use to express and meet these needs may not achieve this pur-
pose. In addition, pre-1960s rules about male–female interaction have changed.
New ones have not been culturally recognized and accepted socially on a wide
scale. While some individuals have achieved relationship satisfaction, there
is much confusion, anxiety, and miscommunication on a cultural level about
male–female relationships (Tanner, 1995, 2001). There is also a wider variety
of relationships more openly and visibly present in this society today (Blum-
stein and Schwartz, 1983; Lippa, 2006; McWhirter and Mattison, 1984).
One aspect of this phenomenon is the relatively recent focus on inti-
macy. Intimacy, a late-twentieth-century, middle-class term, essentially is a
relabeling of the anthropological concept of bonding, a primate and human
The Evolution of Human Sexuality 61
primate behavior. As human primates, we need to interact with others of our
own kind and establish close social and emotional or affective ties with each
other. Development of intimacy or bonding rests on bio-behavorial interac-
tion (Fisher, 2004; Perper, 1985). Intimacy develops in stages that include ver-
bal and non-verbal cueing, kinesics, and interaction (Perper, 1985). Perper, an
anthropologist and biologist, suggests that the most elementary steps toward
intimacy may rest in forms of cueing that are universal. Intimacy draws on
our social evolution as primates in relation to our need for continuous social
interaction and recognition from members of our own kind, species, and group.
Paths to intimacy are culture-specific and culturally defined. For example, in
many nonindustrialized societies, adult social intimacy is found with members
of one’s own gender through men’s and women’s groups, initiation ceremonies,
voluntary associations, or extended kin-group participation (Frayser, 1985; Gre-
gersen, 1983; Murphy and Murphy, 1974; Turnbull, 1961, 1972; Ward, 2006).
In the United States, intimacy is an elusive goal. There are a variety of
books, talk shows, and self-help groups to help us achieve intimacy (e.g.,
Goldberg, 1976, 1980, 1984; Hite, 1987). Both men and women in this culture
express a strong desire for intimacy in their social relationships and interac-
tions with one another but seem to have a difficult time achieving it (Farrell,
1986, 1993; Hite, 1987; Kaschak and Tiefer, 2001; Lippa, 2006; McGill, 1987;
Tiefer, 2004). In part, this is due to the changes in socio-sexual rules and
the lack of new, culture-wide rules to guide male-female interaction. Clear,
well-defined roles for male and female behavior and affect no longer exist in
this society. At the same time culture lag exists. Culture lag occurs when
behavior changes faster than the belief systems that support it. There is a lag
or gap between how people behave and the consonant belief system that un-
derlies the behavior. So, people behave one way and may hold beliefs or values
that do not fit comfortably with the behavior. This may be exemplified by
the number of people in counseling for sexual and relationship problems, and
the discrepancy between people’s sexual behavior and the comfort level and
attitudes that accompany one’s behavior (Allgeier and Allgeier, 1991; Kaplan,
1974; Kaschak and Tiefer, 2001; Lieblum and Rosen, 2000; Lieblum and Sachs,
2002; Whelehan and Moynihan, 1984). Intimacy necessitates an acceptance
of interdependency. US values on independence and individuality can work
against intimacy. At this point, we are ambivalent about issues of intimacy
and independence; masculinity/femininity as defined before the “Sexual Rev-
olution” of the 1960s; androgyny, commitment, and autonomy. Concerns with
AIDS and other STDs that impact on fertility and the quality of life intensify
this ambivalence and confusion.
Female Sexuality
Anthropologists are often interested in finding characteristics that are unique
for humans or at least clearly differentiate humans from other animals. Ha-
bitual bipedalism is a characteristic that is commonly cited as distinguishing
62 The Evolution of Human Sexuality
humans from all other mammals, as is the dependence on language and cul-
ture. Additionally, aspects of sexuality, particularly female sexuality, are of-
ten presented as “uniquenesses” for humans. These include non-reproductive
and nonovulatory sexual activity (sometimes referred to as “loss of estrus”),
concealed ovulation, the common occurrence of orgasm in women, and, as
previously discussed, pair bonding and paternal care. There is much debate
about whether or not these characteristics are truly unique, but we can at least
say that most are more common in humans than in any other primate species.
We begin with a discussion of the fact that human females engage in a
great deal of sexual behavior that is unrelated to reproduction. As noted, most
other mammalian females seek or allow copulation only when they are likely
to conceive (i.e., when they are in estrus). At the time of maximal likelihood
of conception, female mammals exhibit physical signs (e.g., the red swol-
len perineal area of baboons and chimpanzees); chemical signals known as
pheromones; and behaviors indicative of willingness to be inseminated, so it is
clear to potential partners (and probably to themselves) that they are capable
of becoming pregnant. Beach (1976) proposed three terms to describe aspects
of female sexual behavior: receptivity (willingness to be mated); attractivity
(males are interested in mating with them); and proceptivity (actively seeking
a mating opportunity). For most primates, these three behaviors coincide at
the time of ovulation and are rarely exhibited at other times. For humans,
however, receptivity, attractivity, and proceptivity are largely independent of
the ovarian cycle, although there is some evidence that women may be slightly
more attractive to men when they are ovulating (Tarín and Gómez-Piquer,
2002) and female libido (proceptivity) may rise slightly at the time of ovulation
(Burleson et al., 2002). Furthermore, women well past the time in which they
can reproduce (i.e., postmenopause) often show no sign of diminished interest
in sex or diminished attractiveness, and indeed, their interest in sex may rise
in the first few years after menopause when the likelihood of becoming preg-
nant is no longer a risk.
Concealed Ovulation
Related to the loss of estrus is a phenomenon known as “concealed ovulation,”
meaning that most women and their partners are unaware when they ovulate,
unless they are taking extraordinary measures to track their basal body tem-
perature (BBT) or cervical mucus. When we consider how obvious it is when
a female baboon or chimpanzee is in estrus, it is surprising that humans are
so unaware of when they are likely to conceive. Thus, we have another “why”
question to pursue from an evolutionary perspective. Not surprisingly, there
are dozens of ideas for why human females lost estrus and concealed ovulation.
One scenario that has been around for a long time and fit former stereo-
types about gender roles exemplifies exchange theory in which ancestral
males traded meat for sex with females (Fisher, 1983; Symons, 1979). This has
been observed in some chimpanzee groups (Goodall, 1986), but it is usually
The Evolution of Human Sexuality 63
associated with females in estrus, that is, those who are sexually receptive to
the males. If females exhibit signs of sexual receptivity and are willing to en-
gage in sexual activity at times other than when they are ovulating, they may
receive more meat from the males. Eventually, according to this “meat for sex”
scenario, sexual receptivity would become “decoupled” from ovulation and es-
trus behavior (sexual receptivity) would be “continuous.” Females and their
offspring would benefit from additional protein by this economic exchange for
sex. But because males would be more likely to provide food for offspring that
they have some confidence are theirs (“paternity certainty”), they would need
to remain in proximity to the female they are provisioning to ensure that they
are not cuckolded. Accordingly, marriage and the family developed from the
situation of exchange (Symons, 1979).
Another scenario proposes that by concealing ovulation, an ancestral fe-
male could solicit sex from several males so that no one, not even the female
herself, could be sure who the father of her offspring was (Hrdy, 1981). As
noted, this confusion over paternity (“paternity uncertainty”) enabled females
to secure resources from a number of males, and, perhaps more importantly,
minimized the likelihood of infanticide inflicted by males on young that they
were certain were not their biological offspring. According to Symons (1979:
141), “By hiding ovulation, females may have minimized their husbands’ abil-
ities to monitor and to sequester them, and maximized their own abilities to
be fertilized by males other than their husbands” (modified from Burley, 1979).
Yet another scenario for concealed ovulation relates it to population in-
crease in the human species. In this view, ovulation was concealed not only
from males, but from the females themselves, so that they were not able to
control their fertility to the same extent that they could if ovulation were
associated with obvious physical signs. Burley (1979) argues that the fear of
childbirth would have led ancestral females to avoid copulation at times they
were most likely to conceive so they would have had fewer offspring in their
lifetimes. Females who were not aware of when they were ovulating could not
exercise this degree of control over their fertility and would have had more
offspring to pass along the characteristic of concealed ovulation so that today,
it is true for all humans. This scenario invites a play on the paraphrase from
the Bible: “Blessed are those who don’t know when they are ovulating for their
daughters shall inherit the earth.”
Summary
1 The grasping hand, stereoscopic vision, and grooming are adaptations re-
lated to primate arboreal and subsequent terrestrial environments.
2 These adaptations have consequences for modern sexual behavior includ-
ing the importance of touch, feeling, and vision as important components
in sexual attraction.
3 Bipedalism played a critical role in enhancing trajectories begun in asso-
ciation with adaptation to an arboreal niche. With bipedalism, probably,
began trends for the loss of estrus and escalated reliance on communi-
cation and learning. Bipedalism and the consequent enlargement and
development of complexity in the hominid brain were involved in the
evolutionary tradeoff that selected for infant dependency.
4 Human reliance on learning is a significant aspect of our sexuality associ-
ated with the expansion of the neocortex.
5 For humans the social group is vital for survival.
6 As a continuation of non-human primate behavior, humans form a variety
of socio-emotional ties with one another known as bonds; one of the most
basic is adult female–child. Male–male, male–female, and female–female
bonds can be both cooperative and competitive. Both social and biologi-
cal fatherhood, and intimacy are important in most human societies.
7 The human brain is actively involved in human maturation, reproduc-
tion, and sexuality.
8 The loss of estrus for humans enhanced their reproductive success in com-
parison with other primates, in part through its effect on paternity.
9 There are several controversial views on the role of orgasm for female
evolution. Orgasm is important as a reinforcing mechanism because it is
pleasurable. This is critical in a species without estrus. Human females
are unusual in being able to be sexually receptive throughout their cycle.
With humans, because ovulation was concealed, the sheer amount of cop-
ulation would enhance the chance for impregnation. Orgasm is important
in facilitating this.
Thought-Provoking Questions
1 Some people have suggested that the “touch-deprived” nature of contem-
porary American society may explain some inabilities to form healthy
social bonds (e.g., parent–child, male–female). Do you agree? If you agree,
what do you think can be done about it?
The Evolution of Human Sexuality 67
2 In what ways would a strong and healthy young woman with a nursing
infant and a four-year-old child compromise her own reproductive success
by engaging in hunting large game? Would the compromises be the same
for her mate and father of her children to engage in this same type of
hunting?
3 Why would males in dozens of societies rank female attractiveness higher
than wealth and women rank the two qualities in reverse order? What do
these preferences have to do with reproductive success?
Suggested Resources
Books
Buss, David M. 1994. The Evolution of Desire: Strategies of Human Mating. New York:
Basic Books.
Ellison, Peter T. 2001. On Fertile Ground: A Natural History of Human Reproduction.
Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Hrdy, Sarah Blaffer. 1999. Mother Nature: A History of Mothers, Infants, and Natural
Selection. New York: Pantheon Books.
Small, Meredith. 1998. Our Babies, Ourselves. How Biology and Culture Shape the Way
We Parent. New York: Anchor Books.
Websites
American Association of Physical Anthropologists. http://www.physanth.org/.
American Society of Primatologists. http://www.asp.org/.
Human Behavior and Evolution Society. http://www.hbes.com/.
Human Biology Association. http://www.humbio.org/.
4 Introduction to the
Hormonal Basis of Modern
Human Sexuality
Chapter Overview
1 Introduces the hormonal basis of human sexuality.
2 Describes the H-P-G axis.
3 Defines and compares analogous and homologous structures.
4 Distinguishes the sexual and reproductive cycles.
On June 1, 1994, New York State passed legislation that allowed women
to breastfeed their babies legally in public places such as malls, restau-
rants, and stores. Women may also appear bare-breasted on public
beaches in New York. However, the legality of breastfeeding in public or
appearing topless on public beaches if you are a woman is state-specific.
FIMBRIAE ENDOMETRIUM
OVARY
MYOMETRIUM
VAGINA CERVIX
Sexual Reproductive
cycle cycle
Although the cerebral cortex can dominate the functioning of the H-P-G axis
(e.g., perceived unresolved stress can affect the menstrual cycle), for this dis-
cussion we are going to examine the H-P-G axis as it usually works. The H-P-G
axis operates as a negative feedback cycle, similar to a thermostat, where fluc-
tuations in one part of the axis induce hormone releases in other parts of the
axis. Although the hypothalamus and pituitary monitor a number of body
functions, we will focus on their role in sexual and reproductive processes (see
Figures 4.3 and 4.4).
The hypothalamus, located in the parietal or side area of the brain, releases a
hormone called GnRH (gonadotropic releasing hormone), which triggers the
functioning of the pituitary. In humans, the hypothalamus monitors the onset
of puberty in both genders (puberty is also related to cultural, nutritional, and
exercise practices as will be discussed in later chapters). The hypothalamus
also controls the release of pheromones (i.e., sexual scent cues); the release
The Hormonal Basis of Human Sexuality 73
Table 4.1 Comparative anatomy
Hypothalamus
LHRH
Pituitary
LH FSH
Ovaries
Progesterone Estrogen
Hypothalamus
+
LTH
Anterior
pituitary
–
– +
LH FSH
Testes
Testosterone
period by noting that testosterone levels in males generally are highest in the
morning. These data do not, however, contradict the general belief that men,
relative to women, experience tonic patterns of testosterone release. These male
patterns are ongoing and continuous from puberty until death, although there is
a gradual decrease in testosterone production in aging men.
Hormone Comparative function: male Primary Comparative function: female Primary Source
release: male release:
female
Follicular stimulating Stimulates spermatogenesis Pituitary Egg maturation, includes Pituitary GnRH
hormone (FSH) estradiol (an estrogen) stimulation
from
hypothalamus
Luteinizing hormone Maintains interstitial cells of Pituitary Stops egg maturation, Pituitary GnRH
(LH)—interstitial cell testes releases mature egg from stimulation
stimulating hormone ovary, induces release of from
(ICSH) in male androgens at ovulation hypothalamus
Luteotropic hormone Unknown at present; may Pituitary Uterine tone, stimulates Pituitary GnRH
(LTH) (prolactin) be involved in sperm and lactation, promotes stimulation
testosterone production production of progesterone from
hypothalamus
Testosterone Primary and secondary sex Testes Libido, complement to female Adrenal LH stimulation
characteristics, libido primary and secondary sex glands and in pituitary
characteristics ovaries
Estrogen Skin tone, reduces osteoporosis Adrenal Primary and secondary Ovaries FSH stimulation
risk, complement to glands sex characteristics (e.g., in pituitary
primary and secondary sex menstrual cycle)
characteristics
Progesterone Possibly anti-aggressor agent Adrenal Primary sex characteristics Ovaries LH stimulation
glands in pituitary
The Hormonal Basis of Human Sexuality 77
78 The Hormonal Basis of Human Sexuality
LH stands for luteinizing hormone. It is the same hormone as ICSH, the
interstitial cell stimulating hormone. LH functions in both the follicular and
luteal phases of the menstrual cycle as will be discussed in depth in Chapter 6.
In the follicular phase, LH serves to stop egg maturation and helps to release
the mature egg from the ovary through triggering androsterone, a male sex
hormone. In the luteal phase, LH stimulates the release of progesterone from
the follicle or sac that released the mature egg.
In men, LH is also referred to as ICSH. ICSH maintains the cells of the
testes, which produce testosterone, the primary male sex hormone. These in-
terstitial or leydig cells are necessary for testosterone production, which is re-
sponsible for primary and secondary sex characteristic development in males
as discussed in Chapter 5.
LTH or luteotropic hormone (prolactin) is another pituitary hormone in-
volved in the H-P-G axis. It is involved in lactation (breastfeeding), in the
maintenance of uterine tone, and in the production of progesterone. The func-
tion of LTH in the human male is currently unknown.
This chapter is a brief overview of the hormonal basis of human sexuality.
The specific hormones introduced here will be discussed in more detail in the
next two chapters. Those chapters will integrate these hormones into male
and female sexual reproductive anatomy and physiology.
When the limbic system, which is the center of our emotions and includes
the hypothalamus, is added to the CC + H-P-G axis formula, we have a com-
plete bio-chemical basis for human sexuality. These brain functions interact
to comprise the cognitive, affective, and biochemical foundation of human
sexuality. This basis is expressed through the physiological maturation and
development process. It includes attainment of puberty, and the learned, cul-
turally specific behaviors, values, norms, and beliefs we as a species believe
and act on verbally, nonverbally, and symbolically. The latter include each
culture’s shared definitions of masculinity and femininity, appropriate gender
role behavior, speech, demeanor, and affect, as well as rules concerning what
constitutes “normal” sexual, and reproductive behaviors. Hormones and be-
havior affect each other (this interaction will be illustrated in the next few
chapters). The manifestations of hormones and of the physical characteristics
they influence occur within a cultural context. The next three chapters dis-
cuss biological traits such as the onset of puberty, regular menstrual cycles,
and the sexual and reproductive structures as they are expressed within the
context of culture.
Summary
1 The cerebral cortex plus the H-P-G axis comprise the bio-chemical and
behavioral bases of our sexuality.
2 The hypothalamus, an evolutionarily old structure, and the pituitary
gland make up the bio-chemical regulators of our sexuality.
The Hormonal Basis of Human Sexuality 79
3 The H-P-G axis comprises a negative feedback system that influences the
onset of puberty, the release of gonadotropins, the release of pheromones,
and erogenous zone sensitivity.
4 Many of our sexual and reproductive structures are both analogous and
homologous. Men and women share a hormonal system. This means that
bio-chemically, men and women are more similar than they are different.
5 The sexual and reproductive cycles are distinct but overlapping systems.
6 Male hormonal functioning is frequently described as tonic, female as
cyclic.
7 The major sex hormones are androgens, specifically testosterone; estro-
gen, which refers to a group of hormones; and progesterone.
8 Culture and biology interact in the expression of our sexuality.
Thought-Provoking Questions
1 How do biology and culture affect each other?
2 If men and women share a hormonal system, what accounts for the differ-
ences between men and women?
Suggested Resources
Journal
Aitken, R. John, Peter Koopman, and Sheena E. M. Lewis. 2004. “Public Health:
Environmental Pollution and Male Fertility.” Nature, 432: 48.
Website
Endocrine Society. https://www.endocrine.org/about-us. Last accessed 10/2019.
5 Modern Human Male
Anatomy and Physiology
Chapter Overview
1 Applies the formula CC + (H-P-G axis) = bio-chemical behavioral aspect
of human sexuality to males.
2 Discusses the role of FSH (follicular stimulating hormone) and LH
(luteinizing hormone)/ICSH (interstitial cell stimulating hormone) as a
tonic process in males.
3 Discusses the external and internal anatomy and physiology of the male
sexual and reproductive systems.
4 Discusses male primary and secondary sex characteristics.
5 Introduces the concept of the libido and relates it to testosterone levels.
6 Discusses the effect of alcohol and marijuana use on testosterone levels.
7 Introduces HIV infection and AIDS in men.
8 Introduces male sexual response.
In this chapter (and in Chapter 6), physical normalcy is assumed unless specif-
ically stated otherwise. A discussion of male anatomy incorporates the CC +
(H-P-G axis) formula presented in the previous chapter.
Applying the CC + (H-P-G axis) formula to males involves a hormonal
exploration of FSH (follicular stimulating hormone); LH (luteinizing
hormone)/ICSH (interstitial cell stimulating hormone), which are the
same hormones; and the gonadotropins, particularly the androgens. As
introduced in Chapter 4, men tend to have a more continuous (tonic) re-
lease of H-P-G axis hormones in their bodies than do women, whose more
rhythmic release is described as cyclic. Men’s hormonal patterns continue
from puberty until death. In men, the hypothalamic release of GnRH (go-
nadatropic releasing hormone) triggers pituitarian FSH and LH (ICSH)
activity. FSH and LH activate testicular functioning and the production
of androgens, male sex hormones. FSH aids in spermatogenesis, or sperm
production, which occurs in the seminiferous tubules of the testicles. LH
(ICSH) maintains and promotes the integrity of the interstitial cells of the
testes, the major source of testosterone production. Testosterone, consid-
ered a “male” sex hormone, is the primary androgen and the focus of our
discussion.
Modern Human Male Anatomy and Physiology 81
Testosterone is produced in the interstitial cells of the testicles in men. An-
other name for the interstitial cells is the leydig cells. In women, much of the
testosterone is produced in the adrenal glands with some of it also produced
in their ovaries. Testosterone is a crucial sexual cycle hormone in both genders
and a reproductive cycle hormone in males. On a hormonal basis, testosterone
is responsible for the libido or sex drive in both men and women. The amount
of testosterone required to maintain the libido in men and women is referred
to as the threshold level, and it exists in roughly the same amounts in both
men and women. As long as this threshold level is maintained, the hormonal
aspects of the libido are present in men and women. Men and women pro-
duce testosterone from puberty until death. Thus, both men and women can
maintain a hormonal basis for the libido from sexual adulthood (i.e., puberty)
through sexual and reproductive aging (e.g., post-menopause in women).
Testosterone, as a major sex hormone, is actively involved in the expres-
sion of primary and secondary male sex characteristics. For this to occur, men
continuously produce, from puberty until death, about ten times as much tes-
tosterone on a tonic basis as do women (Greenberg, Bruess, and Mullen, 1993).
Generally, the tonic release of free circulating testosterone in the male sup-
presses or binds the release of estrogen and progesterone, the “female” sex hor-
mones, in the male. The primary sex characteristics are those directly related
to sexual and reproductive functioning. In the male, they include the growth
and development of the internal and external penis, the testes and scrotal sac,
as well as the auxiliary reproductive structures such as the vas deferens, semi-
nal vesicles, and epididymis.
Eunuchs, also castrated and often after puberty, reflect feminized fat
distribution. They were found in the harems in the Middle East and
ancient China to prevent wives and concubines from having affairs with
other men or from other men having access to these women. Their lack
of testicles was culturally believed to sufficiently decrease their libido so
that they would have no sexual interest in the women they were guard-
ing. Depending on the situation, however, they may have formed deep
personal and emotional attachments to the women they guarded.
Men generally also have more muscle mass,3 are leaner, and have a lower body
fat to overall body mass ratio than women. This contributes to men’s overall
greater physical strength. In current US standards of aesthetic leanness for men,
the range of body fat is from about 8 percent for athletes to about 19 percent for
the “average” male (“Defining Overweight and Obesity,” 2005). Males need a
minimum of 4–6 percent body fat to reach puberty. Athletes in training, football
players for example, may try to achieve a 4–6 percent body fat content during the
playing season. They may be muscularly “bulky,” but they are not soft-tissue fat.
Men tend to have upper-body fat (i.e., their body fat is distributed around
their waists and chests). Some physical aspects of men’s comparative leanness
and body fat distribution are that men tend to carry “spare tires,” “love han-
dles,” or “pot bellies” of excess body fat around their midsections; they may
be more prone to coronary heart disease; and they may float less easily than
women. In general, both men and women have become fatter since the 1980s;
both have greater amounts of subcutaneous body fat than previously (“Defin-
ing Overweight and Obesity,” 2005).
For some types of prostate cancer, female sex hormones are given to slow
or stop tumor growth. Depending on the type, amount, and duration of
this form of chemotherapy and the individual man’s hormonal system,
he may develop some female secondary sex characteristics during treat-
ment. This could include changes in body fat amount and distribution
and breast enlargement.
Testosterone has an effect on men’s skin. Men’s skin tends to age more slowly,
has fewer wrinkles, and is more prone to acne than women’s. Men tend to have
more severe acne than do women because testosterone can stimulate sebaceous
(oil) gland secretions which contribute to acne. Skin smoothness and aging are
also related to the estrogen levels that men retain from puberty until death, as
well as cultural practices such as shaving, which removes dead skin cells.
84 Modern Human Male Anatomy and Physiology
Libidinous functioning or having an interest in sex has attributes of both
primary and secondary sex characteristics. As stated previously, a compara-
ble amount of testosterone known as the threshold level is required in both
males and females in order to generate an interest in sex. Again, this baseline
physiological level integrates with cultural values and beliefs about how, when,
where, with whom, and how often the sex drive is expressed.
Estrogen and progesterone in men are primarily produced in the adrenal
glands and generally are suppressed or bound by the testosterone. Unbound
estrogen can produce secondary feminizing sex characteristics such as gyneco-
mastia or breast development, loss of facial and body hair, or reduced sex drive.
Progesterone, which does not produce feminizing secondary sex characteris-
tics in men, may be given in various forms to some convicted sex offenders. It
is part of their rehabilitation and therapy, as it acts as an antilibido hormone. It
not only diminishes libido in both males and females, but may mitigate aggres-
sive feelings as well. Silber (1981), a researcher in this area, has administered
progestin-based drugs to some convicted sex offenders who have chronically
elevated testosterone levels.
Silber (1981) investigated male sexuality and has developed a theory about
certain kinds of sexual behavior related to hyper-testosterone levels. The nor-
mal level of free-circulating testosterone found in men allows for primary and
secondary sex characteristic development and a sex drive. A few men, however,
have chronically elevated levels of testosterone well outside the normal range.
These chronically elevated levels of testosterone, coupled with strongly inter-
nalized and culturally supported values on aggression and violence as a means of
expressing anger and frustration or resolving conflict, may be involved in some
of the more dramatic sex crimes. Silber hormonally tested and interviewed a
number of men convicted of sex crimes, which also involved extreme forms of
violence (e.g., rape and body mutilation or dismemberment). In this sample, he
found chronically elevated levels of testosterone, a psychological connection
between thoughts of sexual violence and heightened arousal, and acceptance
of physical violence as a means of expressing anger or frustration and resolv-
ing conflict. When these men in his prison sample were given progestin-based
drugs, their testosterone levels lowered to within normal limits. The testoster-
one levels remained within normal limits as long as the progestin-based drug
was taken. If the drug regimen stopped, the testosterone levels increased to
their previously elevated levels. On the drug, the prisoners reported less of a
connection between sexual arousal and violence (Silber, 1981).
This is fascinating and potentially powerful research that has controver-
sial and potential social and legal implications. Although some Scandinavian
countries physically castrate convicted male sex offenders, this is seen as cruel
and unusual punishment in the United States. More likely, convicted male sex
offenders in the United States will be given progestin-based drugs (Gis and
Gooren, 1999; Grossman, Martis, and Fichtner, 1966).
Drug usage can affect male sex hormones, particularly testosterone. Two
commonly used drugs that affect testosterone levels are alcohol and marijuana.
Modern Human Male Anatomy and Physiology 85
Extensive chronic alcohol and marijuana abuse can suppress testosterone lev-
els below the threshold level. This can result in loss of libido and the ap-
pearance of feminizing secondary sex characteristics such as gynecomastia, or
breast enlargement, increase in overall amount and redistribution of body fat,
body hair loss, and beard softening. These effects are reversible if the alcohol
or marijuana drug abuse stop. Some recent research suggests that chronic drug
use or abuse by men can negatively affect both their fertility and the quality
of their sperm as well as contribute to problems in fetal development (Daniels,
1997; Emanuele and Emanuele, 1998).
Steroids also affect secondary sex characteristics, particularly muscle size
and the lean muscle mass to body fat ratio. Steroids contain androgens that
can rapidly increase muscle mass. Their use for this purpose is illegal in most
formal athletic situations. The 2004 Summer Olympic Games and the Amer-
ican Baseball Association have both had to address scandals involving steroid
use by their players (Anon., 2005). Steroids are stored in the body for at least
six weeks and excess amounts are secreted in the urine. This phenomenon
explains the mandatory urine tests for steroids in competition-based athletes
and for some employees. Steroids also can cause general metabolic problems.
They are powerful and potentially dangerous drugs. If abused they may damage
the kidneys, liver, and heart, or even result in the user’s death. Injection of
them through shared needles also puts the user at risk for hepatitis B, for HIV
infection, the virus which causes AIDS, and for other infections.
Foreskin
From the seminiferous tubules, the newly produced immature sperm cross the
testes to the epididymis. The epididymis are two, crescent-shaped, grayish struc-
tures that curve around the side of each testicle. They house the immature
sperm for approximately seventy-two days until they are sufficiently mature
to be released into the vas deferens (Daniels, 1997; Emanuele and Emanuele,
1998). It is important to remember that the manufacture and maturation pro-
cess of sperm is continuous. Millions of sperm are produced and matured daily.
Modern Human Male Anatomy and Physiology 89
The spermatic cords, located on the side of each testicle and extending to
the pubis, contain several structures such as the cremasteric muscle, vas def-
erens, blood vessels, and nerves. The spermatic cord itself functions to raise
and lower each testicle in the scrotal sac. The difference in the length of the
spermatic cords is the reason that one testicle may hang lower in the scrotal
sac than the other testicle. The elevation and lowering of the testicle in re-
sponse to changes in temperature, fright, stress, or sexual arousal is a function
of the cremasteric muscle. The actual response of the cremasteric muscle is
called the cremasteric reflex. This reflex can be triggered spontaneously by
running the side of one’s thumb quickly along the inner thigh of an unsuspect-
ing male. The testicles will spontaneously contract. Triggering this response is
not recommended unless you know the male well.
Another structure located in each spermatic cord is the vas deferens. The
vas deferens, analogous and homologous to the fallopian tubes, transport the
mature sperm from the epididymis out of the pelvis to the seminal vesicles
and ejaculatory tracts or ducts. Release of mature sperm by the epididymis
into the vas deferens is continuous. However, during times of intense sexual
arousal, an average of 200–400 million sperm are released into the vas defer-
ens. The vas deferens begin as external structures in the spermatic cord and
then proceed internally to loop around behind the bladder until they join with
ejaculatory tract on each side of the man’s body. The vas deferens are the site
of a vasectomy, the most common form of voluntary male sterilization (see
Chapter 8 for a description of this procedure).
After looping around behind the bladder, the vas deferens connect with the
seminal vesicles. There are two of these structures as well, on each side of the
man’s body, adjacent to the bladder. The seminal vesicles produce the majority
of semen.
After the vas deferens loop around the bladder joining the seminal vesicles,
the vas deferens become the ejaculatory tract. The sperm carried by the vas
deferens now becomes part of the ejaculate when the seminal vesicles release
semen into the ejaculatory tract and the semen mixes with the sperm to form
ejaculate.
The tract contains ejaculate from the point where the vas deferens becomes
the ejaculatory duct. By volume, ejaculate is about 98 percent semen and
2 percent sperm. Semen is a pearly-colored, sticky, viscous fluid that leaves a
white stain on material such as clothing or bedding when dried. It will, however,
wash out of clothing or bedding. Semen is essential to sperm for transport and
survival. Semen is an alkaline or basic substance with a pH range from 7.5 to 9.5.
Sperm needs an alkaline environment in order to survive (Guylaya et al., 2001).
Semen is composed of a number of ingredients including albumen, the same
substance found in egg whites, which gives semen its slippery texture; it also
has sugars—glucose and fructose; bases, which give it its salty taste; and pro-
teins (Guylaya et al., 2001). Semen has several functions. Its composition nour-
ishes the sperm. Semen also is a transport medium for the sperm, aids in sperm
motility, and lubricates the urethra. The amount of ejaculate per expulsion
90 Modern Human Male Anatomy and Physiology
averages about two teaspoons, although it may feel and appear to the male and
his partner(s) to be a great deal more.
Currently, with the very real concern and problem with HIV transmis-
sion through semen and vaginal fluids, oral sex on either a man (fellatio) or
woman (cunnilingus) is only a safer sex activity when using a condom on
the penis or vaginal dam barrier over the vulva, the external genitalia, of
the female. The HIV virus is found in semen, not sperm (IXth International
AIDS Conference, 1993; Griffin, 2005; Menstuff, 2005; Padian, 1987). On
the risky sex continuum, HIV exists in sufficient quantities in semen to in-
fect a partner through unprotected penile-anal, penile-vaginal, or oral sex
(IXth International AIDS Conference, 1993; “Advancing HIV Prevention,”
2003). Therefore, properly used latex barriers such as condoms and vaginal
(dental) dams need to be consistently used to reduce the risk of infection
(see also Chapter 16).
Semen also has socio-cultural dimensions. In many cultures it is recognized
as a vital life substance. There are a variety of beliefs about its functions,
quality, and quantity. Barker-Benfield (1975) has coined the term “spermatic
economy” to connote the attitudes of some Mediterranean groups and the
nineteenth-century British toward “semen” (sic) (i.e., ejaculate). In these cul-
tures, ejaculate is seen to exist in finite supply and judicious caution against
“spending” (i.e., ejaculating “frequently,” as with masturbation) is advised.
Until the present generation, among the Sambia, a patrilineal, horticultural
group in New Guinea, prepubescent and adolescent boys ritually engaged in
fellatio (oral sex) in order to build strength and physical reserves of ejaculate
so that they do not run out of it in adult heterosexual relations (Herdt, 1982;
Knauft, 2003). Among the Sambia, women are seen as sexually powerful and
voracious. Ejaculatory contact with women is carefully regulated so as not to
use up all of a man’s vital life essence (see also Chapter 11).
We have mixed views on the wisdom of frequent ejaculation or “spending”
in our culture. One philosophy promotes a “use it or lose it” approach; the
more orgasmic (ejaculatory) one is, the more one will continue to be (Masters
and Johnson, 1974). The other approach, exemplified by some college ath-
letic coaches from the late-nineteenth century to the present, encouraged a
“spermatic economy” perspective. Male athletes were advised not to engage in
ejaculatory sex before an event so that they would “save” their strength and
energy. Although many college coaches in the United States recognize this as
a piece of folklore, and most do not pass it on as serious advice to their players
(Gordon, 1988), athletes in a human sexuality class state that they are told by
their coaches to avoid having “sex” before a game to avoid “being tired.”
The ejaculatory tract is essentially an extension of the vas deferens. The
ejaculatory tract transports the ejaculate (i.e., sperm and semen) to the ure-
thra. The urethra is surrounded by the prostate, which produces the balance
of the semen to deposit a full ejaculation in the urethra.
The prostate is a walnut-shaped, spongy organ that lies below the bladder.
The urethra runs through it. The prostate can be felt through the perineum
Modern Human Male Anatomy and Physiology 91
and by finger insertion into the rectum. Perineal and rectal stimulation of the
prostate can produce intense levels of sexual arousal. The prostate produces
semen that contributes to the ejaculate carried in the ejaculatory tract. The
prostate is a common site of both minor irritation and major problems. In
younger men, prostate trouble can be due to either localized or systemic in-
fection or irritation and is known as prostatitis. This can generally be easily
remedied through antibiotics. In older men, enlargement of the prostate due
to either atrophy as part of the natural aging process or due to prostate cancer
commonly occurs. Prostate cancer currently is most reliably diagnosed by a
combination of a PSA blood test and digital rectal exam (Oesterling, 1991:
24). It occurs in a geometric proportion relative to age: in fifty-year-old men,
there’s a 40 percent chance of enlargement; in sixty-year-old men, a 50 percent
chance and so forth. It’s pretty much a given that the longer a man lives, the
greater are the chances that he will have problems with his prostate. One of
the more serious immediate concerns of an enlarged prostate, either due to
irritation, atrophy, or cancer, is that the enlargement constricts the urethra.
Constriction of the urethra makes urination painful, difficult, or impossible.
In fact, painful, slow, or incomplete urination is frequently a sign that prostate
problems exist. Treatments include antibiotics, or in the case of enlargement
or cancer, surgical removal of the prostate often happens. For benign, non-
cancerous prostate enlargement, drug treatments, laser therapy, or a TURP is
performed. TURP stands for transurethral resection of the prostate. A man
does not ejaculate after a TURP, but should retain erectile and orgasmic abil-
ity. For prostate cancer, a number of treatments are available. These include
more radical surgery, radiation, hormone therapy, chemotherapy, or “watchful
waiting,” depending on the location, size, and type of the tumor (Carroll and
Nelson, 2004). An orchidectomy, or removal of the testicles, may be performed
in some cases of prostatic cancer to avoid testosterone feeding the cancer.4
The male’s urethra runs from the base of the bladder through the corpus
spongiosum, the underside cylinder of the internal penis, ending in the uri-
nary meatus at the glans of the penis. The male urethra has two functions. It
transports urine from the bladder to outside the body, and it transports the
ejaculate, which is deposited in the urethra during the emission phase of male
ejaculation, from the ejaculatory tract and prostate to outside the body. Both
urine and ejaculate leave the body through the urinary meatus.
As stated previously, sperm survive in an alkaline or basic environment.
Urine is acidic and the urethra can be acidic from transporting urine. To coun-
teract the acidity of the urethra so that sperm can survive, two phenomena
occur. There is a sphincter or small closure between the bladder and urethra.
This sphincter closes during arousal and ejaculation so that urine does not
leak into the urethra and damage sperm. The common belief in the United
States that one may swallow urine when swallowing ejaculate, “cum,” during
oral sex is therefore erroneous. Again, it is important to remember in this age
of AIDS, that oral sex is risky without using a condom from beginning to end;
with a condom oral sex becomes safer.
92 Modern Human Male Anatomy and Physiology
To further counteract the acidity of the urethra, secretions from the Cowper’s
glands neutralize acid levels and lubricate the urethra for the passage of ejacu-
late. Cowper’s glands and ducts are located just beneath the prostate on either
side of the urethra. They are homologous to Bartholin’s glands in the female.
They release a clear, slippery fluid known as pre-ejaculatory fluid or “precum”
into the urethra. This fluid flows through the urinary meatus immediately prior
to ejaculation and may be used to lubricate the glans and increase stimulation.
This fluid may contain sperm, semen, or HIV if the man is infected. It is im-
portant, therefore, not to swallow precum, or to have it come in contact with
either the women’s genitals or the anus of either gender in order to avoid pos-
sible HIV infection or conception in the case of heterosexual genital contact.
The internal penis is composed of three cylindrical or corpus bodies: two of
which are the corpora cavernosa, Latin for cavernous bodies, and the corpus
spongiosum, Latin for spongy body (see Figure 5.2).
The corpora cavernosa are the top two cylindrical bodies of the penis. They
are composed of spongy tissue and a rich vascular or blood supply. During sexual
arousal, it is primarily these two structures that engorge with blood to create
an erection. In addition to neural responses, an erection is achieved and main-
tained vascularly as long as the blood flow into the corpora cavernosa occurs
faster than the blood flow from it; this process is helped by sphincters which
close to keep the blood in the cavernous bodies. Human males do not have a
penis bone or other structure to maintain an erection. One drug known to have
an effect on the vascular structure of the corpora cavernosa is nicotine. Nicotine
constricts blood vessels. Since free-circulating blood is physiologically import-
ant in achieving and maintaining an erection, smokers and chewers may have
impaired full erectile ability. People who have stopped smoking or chewing to-
bacco and whose bodies are nicotine-free report quicker, fuller, firmer erections
(Buffum, 1982). Lack of nicotine allows the blood vessels of the penis to open
more completely. Chapter 12 discusses other drugs that can affect erectile ability.
The third cavernous body of the internal penis is the corpus spongiosum.
The corpus spongiosum forms the glans penis and is the structure through
Modern Human Male Anatomy and Physiology 93
which the urethra runs ending in the urinary meatus at the tip of the glans.
Men who have been subincised (i.e., who have had the underside of their pe-
nes slit open vertically as part of initiation; see Chapter 11) do not urinate
through the urinary meatus in the glans. Urine is released farther back along
the urethra.
Male internal and external genitalia comprise the sexual and reproductive
structures. The male external genitalia, in contrast to the female’s, are highly
visible. Both internal and external structures operate dramatically during
male sexual response. The distinctions between conscious and unconscious
(out-of-awareness) responses and erection-ejaculation-orgasm are introduced
here and will be discussed in more detail in Chapter 12.
Sexual response, in general, is an interaction of conscious and unconscious
mechanisms. The conscious awareness involves the cerebral cortex, the lim-
bic system (feelings), and to some extent the hypothalamus. It includes the
perceived, learned triggers of arousal, and awareness of excitement or eroge-
nous zone activity. The unconscious dimensions of the hypothalamus, neural
responses such as triggering the reflex arc on the spinal column, hormonal
release (H-P-G axis functioning), and vascular responses. Of these two mech-
anisms, the conscious may dominate, defining pleasure, sensuality, sexuality,
and the perception of the intensity of arousal and orgasm. In the male, this
relates specifically to perceptions of erectile firmness, “staying power” (ability
to maintain an erection), ejaculatory force, sensation, and amount. These are
learned, culturally patterned responses. For example, male Tantrics in India
exert conscious control over ejaculatory release. These learned responses can
override physiological response and ability, as evidenced in the sensual-sexual
arousability and pleasure experienced by people with spinal cord injuries.
Erection, ejaculation, and orgasm are physiologically distinct processes, al-
though they may be perceived as being the same, particularly male orgasm
and ejaculation. The fact that post-pubertal males often achieve orgasm and
the expulsion phase of ejaculation concurrently reinforces this belief and the
sensation that orgasm and ejaculation are the same in males.
Summary
1 The CC + (H-P-G axis) discussed in Chapter 4 was applied to males.
2 FSH and LH are involved in the tonic process of spermatogenesis.
3 Androgens, particularly testosterone, are involved in male primary and
secondary sex characteristic development. The role of estrogen and pro-
gesterone in men was presented.
4 Male internal and external sexual and reproductive anatomy and phys-
iology were discussed relative to normal functioning, the libido, and ef-
fects of alcohol, nicotine, and marijuana use on male libido and sexual
response.
5 It is possible for men to contract HIV infection and other STIs through un-
protected penile-anal intercourse; unprotected penile-vaginal intercourse
94 Modern Human Male Anatomy and Physiology
(particularly if the women is menstruating); and either unprotected fella-
tio (oral sex on a male) or unprotected cunnilingus (oral sex on a female),
particularly if she is menstruating.
6 Cultural responses to male sexual and reproductive functioning include
such practices as circumcision, subincision, and superincision, as well as
cultural beliefs about sexuality.
7 Common problems of the prostate such as prostatitis and enlargement of
the prostate can occur in men across the life cycle and increase as they
age.
8 Erection, ejaculation, and orgasm are physiologically distinct processes.
Thought-Provoking Questions
1 How does the structure of culture influence how we think about male
sexual and reproductive anatomy and physiology?
Suggested Resources
Book
Joannides, Paul. 2004. Guide to Getting It on. 4th ed. Berkeley, CA: Publishers Group
West.
Journal
International Journal of Men’s Health. Men’s Studies Press.
6 Modern Human Female
Anatomy and Physiology
Chapter Overview
1 Applies the formula CC + (H-P-G axis) to female sexual and reproductive
anatomy and physiology.
2 Describes the cyclic, negative feedback aspects of the female’s H-P-G axis.
3 Compares and contrasts the menstrual cycle and spermatogenesis.
4 Discusses the female’s primary and secondary sex characteristics, includ-
ing those that are homologous and analogous with the male.
5 Describes the four phases of the menstrual cycle as well as cultural
responses to it.
6 Discusses menstrual cramps, menstrual synchrony, and LLPD/PMS.
7 Introduces cultural responses to female anatomy and physiology.
8 Introduces models of female sexual response.
9 Introduces conception and recent western technologies that increase the
chances of conception and gender selection.
10 Summarizes the importance of knowing basic sexual and reproductive
hormones, anatomy, and physiology.
The discussion of female anatomy and physiology parallels that for the male.
On a hormonal basis, the formula and systems are analogous for both gen-
ders: the cerebral cortex (CC) + (H-P-G axis) is involved. On a relative scale,
women’s hormonal systems are described as cyclic. Over a period of time, fre-
quently measured in monthly or lunar cycles, a woman completes one round
of hormone release through the H-P-G axis. By comparison, the male’s relative
tonicity means his pattern of hormone release occurs over twenty-four hours.
To introduce the H-P-G axis in women is to discuss it as a negative feed-
back system. The release of LTH (particularly during lactation), FSH, and
LH from the anterior lobe of the pituitary is related to fluctuating ovarian hor-
mones (i.e., estrogen and progesterone). Analogous to the male H-P-G axis,
gonadotropin releasing hormone (GnRH) is released from the hypothalamus
which stimulates the production of pituitary hormones. Follicular stimulating
hormone (FSH) helps eggs mature in the ovary during the follicular phase of
the menstrual cycle. Luteotropic hormone (LTH) not only helps to maintain
uterine tone and promotes progesterone production but is directly involved in
96 Modern Human Female Anatomy and Physiology
the lactation process. Luteinizing hormone (LH), which is synonymous with
interstitial cell stimulating hormone (ICSH) in the male, helps to release the
mature egg from the ovary, induces androgens at ovulation, and induces proges-
terone production and release in the luteal phase of the menstrual cycle. The
cyclic release of these hormones in the female creates a system of balance and
regularity. Contrary to popular lore in the United States, female hormone pat-
terning is not “raging,” “erratic,” or “uncontrolled.” It is interesting to note the
level of cultural concern regarding women’s hormone release compared to the
relative lack of concern toward that of males. For example, Martin notes that
even medical texts refer to menstruation, menopause, and female hormonal
patterns in negative or injured terms—“degenerative, deteriorated, weakened,
repaired.” Analogous processes for spermatogenesis or other body functions are
labeled more neutrally or even positively—“shedding of the stomach lining,
phenomenon of spermatogenesis” (1987: 47–50). This will be discussed in more
detail when the menstrual cycle and the bio-behavioral dimensions of men-
strual cramps, menstrual synchrony, and late luteal phase disorder (LLPD),
popularly known as premenstrual syndrome (PMS), are presented.
As with males, females produce their own gonadotropins (sex hormones),
as well as those of the other sex (e.g., testosterone). In females, androgens,
or the male sex hormones, are produced by both the adrenal glands and the
ovaries (Emanuele, Wezeman, and Emanuele, 1999). Androgens, particularly
testosterone, are produced from puberty until death in the female. Androgens
are released at the end of the follicular phase of the menstrual cycle in order
to help expel the mature egg from the ovary. The libido hormone, testoster-
one, is produced in roughly the same amounts in men and women to ensure
the threshold level necessary for the sex drive. Women continue to produce
testosterone post-menopausally. Thus, on a hormonal basis, women retain
their libido and capacity for sexual response after menopause. The expression
of post-menopausal women’s sexuality varies cross-culturally. In the United
States, it appears to be less dependent on hormones and more dependent on
the responsibilities and stress women have in their lives and the quality of the
relationships they have with their partners (Kaschak and Tiefer, 2001; Tiefer,
2004). Outside the United States, particularly in foraging and matricentered
societies, for example, as well as in Thailand, post-menopausal women’s sexual-
ity tends to be accepted and the women are sexually active (Brown and Kerns,
1985; Im-em et al., 2002).
Specific female sex ovarian hormones, estrogen (actually a group of
hormones) and progesterone, are primary ovarian hormones produced from
puberty until menopause. Their production and release follow an H-P-G axis
pattern analogous to that of the male. FSH induces estrogen; LH induces pro-
gesterone. As with the male, the use of recreational drugs (such as alcohol,
marijuana, cocaine) and some prescription drugs can affect this release pat-
tern, influencing not only the libido and sexual response cycle, but the men-
strual cycle as well (Buffum, 1982; Emanuele, Wezeman, and Emanuele, 1999;
Gill, 2000).
Modern Human Female Anatomy and Physiology 97
Estrogen and progesterone are responsible for the development of primary
and secondary sex characteristics. As with the male, these characteristics
cover a wide spectrum of individual variation, are relative when comparing
men and women, and are expressed through cultural variables of custom, nu-
trition, and health. Estrogen appears to be more operative than progesterone
in the development of many of the female’s secondary sex characteristics.
(CDC), women who have less than 18.5 percent body fat are underfat/under-
weight (“Defining Overweight and Obesity,” 2005). This also means that in
many nonindustrialized societies, girls have greater muscle mass and aerobic
fitness due to their mobility patterns. Because they eat less dietary fat, they
may reach puberty later than girls do in industrialized societies where sed-
entism is more common and the diet is higher in fat and overall calories. In
a few African societies, for example, prepubescent girls undergo a period of
fattening which accomplishes several goals. It increases their body fat to the
point they achieve puberty and fattens them so they are culturally defined as
attractive and eligible for marriage and pregnancy. The common occurrence
100 Modern Human Female Anatomy and Physiology
in nonindustrialized societies of adolescent sterility may actually be a function
of insufficient body fat for puberty and regular menstrual cycles to occur. See
Chapter 11 for further discussion.
In the United States, current standards for a lean female are about 21 percent
body fat; the average is about 24 percent (“Defining Overweight and Obesity,”
2005). Given our current interest in female thinness, many younger women, in
particular, diet and exercise themselves into fashionable leanness and irregular
menstrual cycles. One clear sign of anorexia nervosa, a severe and dangerous
eating disorder that primarily is found in middle-class adolescent females, is
cessation of menstruation. Women athletes whose body fat is less than 17 per-
cent also can experience menstrual and ovulatory irregularities depending on
the quality of their diet. These irregularities are reversible upon increasing the
body fat ratio beyond 17 percent. Our present standards of female beauty in
essence would have women look like lean males with breasts, and reinforce a
cultural pattern of potentially serious eating disorders for a sizable number of
our population. It is also interesting that a female athlete’s price for competi-
tive leanness may be altered menstrual cycles. Similarly, extremely lean males
who have less than 6 percent body fat may have reduced production of sperm
(Wheeler et al., 1984).
These secondary sex characteristics can be culturally interpreted not only as
indicators of sexual adulthood, but also as visual sexual cues exemplified by fea-
tures such as breast development, appearance of pubic hair, or widening of the
hips. In contrast to males where spermatogenesis is hidden, menstruation is a
visible and clear marker that primary sex and reproductive characteristics have
been achieved. The development of the primary sex characteristics is related to
the H-P-G axis and release of estrogen and progesterone from the ovary.
Labia minora
Corpus cavernosum
Bulb of vestibule
Urethral opening
Labia majora
Vaginal opening
Opening of right
Bartholin’s glands
Anus
Bartholin’s glands
Figure 6.2 Vulva: exter nal anterior and inter nal anteriolateral view.
Source: Illustration from Anatomy and Physiolog y Connexions website http://cnx.org/content/col11496/. June 19, 2013. Reproduced in Wikipedia. https://en.
wikipedia.org/wiki/Clitoris
Modern Human Female Anatomy and Physiology 101
102 Modern Human Female Anatomy and Physiology
have more words to describe the aesthetics of the vulva and clitoris than do
industrialized societies, where many of the terms carry negative connotations
(Marshall and Suggs, 1971).
In other societies such as in the Sudan, the labia minora are ritually surgi-
cally removed in order to preserve a woman’s modesty, virginity, and chastity.
Currently, this female genital surgical procedure known as excision is gener-
ating tremendous controversy. It and other forms of female genital surgery will
be discussed separately.
The clitoral hood or prepuce, formed by the juncture of the labia minora,
loosely covers the clitoris. The prepuce is analogous and homologous to the
foreskin, particularly where it covers the glans of the clitoris. Smegma also
collects under the clitoral hood as it does under the foreskin and functions as
a lubricant in both instances. The friction of the prepuce over the clitoris can
produce intense sexual stimulation.
The clitoris, composed of a glans, shaft, crura or legs, and urethral sponge,
is supported by a dense pelvic musculature and has more nerve endings in
its glans than does the glans of the penis. Despite its depiction in a number
of medical and physiology texts as a “small, pea-like structure, the clitoris is
actually about four to six inches in length, most of which is located inter-
nally” (Chalker, 2000). While homologous to the penis, it is not analogous to
it (Freud aside!). The only known function of the clitoris is sexual pleasure. It
is the only organ in the human body whose sole function is sexual pleasure.
This characteristic functionally distinguishes it from the penis which has four
functions: sexual pleasure, a transport mechanism for ejaculate, an organ of re-
production in penile-vaginal intercourse, and a transport mechanism for urine
(see Figures 6.3).
Among the Sambia and some groups in sub-Saharan Africa, regular in-
tercourse with ejaculation and orgasm in the women is seen as helping
the development of the fetus. During the Renaissance, in Italy, people
believed that a child would be healthy, attractive, and intelligent if
both partners had an orgasm during conception. “Folklore” may have
more basis in science than is commonly believed in some situations
(Herdt, 2006).
110 Modern Human Female Anatomy and Physiology
The uterus is composed of several layers: the myometrium, parametrium, and
endometrium. The parts of the uterus to be discussed include the fundus, the
corpus, the cervix, the os, and the endometrium. The fundus is the rounded
top part of the uterus. As the uterus enlarges during pregnancy, the fundus can
be felt externally through the lower abdomen as it rises above the pelvic bone.
The corpus or body of the uterus is composed of several layers of which only
the endometrium will be discussed. The fallopian tubes enter the uterus at the
bottom of the fundus and beginning of the corpus. The corpus extends into
the vagina from its lower section, the cervix.
The cervix extends into the vagina and can be felt by deep insertion of the
fingers into the vagina, and can be seen by the use of a mirror and speculum. A
speculum is the instrument used during a pelvic exam to separate the walls of
the vagina. The cervix receives a lot of medical and lay attention. The cervix
is the site of the PAP smear (Papanicolaou smear). The PAP test is part of a
gynecological exam. Cells are gently scraped from the cervix and analyzed to
detect cervical normalcy and abnormalities, including cancer. Cervical cancer
is one of the more common cancers to affect women. Regular PAP smears every
one to three years help to ensure early detection and treatment (see Figure 6.4).
The cervix changes in color and texture depending on whether or not a
woman is pregnant. In non-pregnant women, the cervix is pinkish and carti-
laginous in texture, similar in texture to the tip of your nose. In response to
Figure 6.4 Female reproductive system: drawing of the internal sexual anatomy.
Source: GFDL Issue resolved in 2003. GNU Free Documentation License https://en.wikipedia.
org/wiki/Human_reproductive_system#/media/File:Female_reproductive_system_lateral.png
Modern Human Female Anatomy and Physiology 111
hormones released during pregnancy, the cervix softens to a state more similar
in texture to your lips, and changes color to a bluish-purplish hue. During sex-
ual arousal and orgasm, the uterus, including the cervix, responds in various
ways by retracting, contracting, and lowering into the vagina.
The cervix is the site of the os, an opening in the tip of the cervix generally
about the size of a thin pencil lead. It also changes in color and shape depending
on whether or not a woman is pregnant. A non-pregnant woman’s os is pinkish
and donut-hole shaped; a pregnant woman’s os is purplish or bluish and more like a
slit. This change in shape is irreversible after a woman has a child. These changes
in the cervix and os appear in the first trimester and are used as signs of pregnancy
during a prenatal pelvic exam. The os is the passageway for menses (menstrual
blood), the fetus, and sperm. During menstruation the os dilates slightly to allow
the shedding endometrium to pass through. The os is the structure that dilates or
opens during the first stage of labor to allow the baby to pass through.
Most of the month, the os is covered with a thickish, sticky substance called
cervical mucous. Cervical mucous is a protective barrier to keep foreign ob-
jects such as sperm, douches, contraceptive foams, or bacteria out of the sterile
uterine cavity. Just prior to and during ovulation, however, the cervical mu-
cous thins and becomes more permeable in order to allow the sperm entry to
the fallopian tubes where the egg may be fertilized. If the egg is fertilized and
implants in the endometrium, another mucoid substance, the cervical plug,
forms over the os as a protective seal for the fetus against foreign substances
entering the uterine cavity. The cervical plug usually is expelled during the
first stage of labor and is used as a sign that labor is imminent or has begun.
The endometrium is the innermost lining of the uterus. In response to
H-P-G axis hormones, estrogen builds up the endometrium, and progesterone
maintains it in the uterus. The endometrium serves as the anchor for the em-
bryo and fetus. The endometrium is a thick, cushiony layer of blood, tissue,
and mucous that accumulates each month in preparation for a fertilized egg.
The fertilized egg implants in the endometrium where it remains attached
for nine months by the placenta as it develops into an embryo and fetus. The
endometrium is shed as the menses or menstrual blood if fertilization and im-
plantation do not occur.
There is a clinical condition called endometriosis which is primarily found
among middle-class, college-educated, career women in the United States who
are in their late twenties and thirties. Many of them are nulliparous (they
have never borne a child). Endometriosis involves patches of endometrial
tissue found on the ovaries, external uterus, or other pelvic and abdominal
organs, and in the fallopian tubes. Endometriosis in the fallopian tubes can
cause tubal blockage and scarring, interfering with conception. Although the
exact cause of endometriosis is unknown, it is theorized that it may be due to
a variety of factors including prenatal disposition, hormone fluctuations, and
delayed pregnancy among some career women (Berek, Adashi, and Hillard,
1996; Stewart et al., 1979).
112 Modern Human Female Anatomy and Physiology
Symptoms of endometriosis include fertility and menstrual problems, pain
during both intercourse, known as dyspareunia, well as menstruation, known
as dysmenorrhea. Definitive diagnosis of endometriosis is through laparoscopy,
a surgical procedure that involves an incision in the abdomen where organs are
viewed through a lighted tube or laparoscope. Treatment can be hormonal or
surgical depending on the severity of the situation. In a number of cases fertility
may be restored (Berek, Adashi, and Hillard, 1996; Wade and Cirese, 1991).
The uterus, composed of several structures, is a marvelous organ. Its capac-
ity to change in size and function, depending on pregnancy, is phenomenal.
As a reproductive and sexual organ, it is imbued with a range of cultural con-
notations and definitions. For example, the sexual function of the uterus is
only recently being accepted and understood, making its already controversial
ritual removal (hysterectomy) post-menopausally in the United States an even
more debatable issue (Berman, Berman, and Bumiller, 2001; Boston Women’s
Health Collective, 2005; Klee, 1988). In general, in industrialized societies for
the past several hundred years, women’s mental health has been defined as a
function of her reproductive organs (Barker-Benfield, 1975; Klee, 1988). Freud
used a psychiatric classification known as hysteria from the Greek word for
womb, another term for the uterus. According to Freud, hysteria is primarily
an affliction of women, characterized by over-emotionality, denial, and depres-
sion (Freud, 1920a, b).
In both industrialized and nonindustrialized societies the function of the
uterus and ovaries are subject to cultural scrutiny. For example, in the Tiwi
society, an Australian foraging group, the essence of sexuality is female. Female
totems, religious, and animistic guardian spirits, which are inanimate sym-
bolic structures that are given lifelike characteristics, play a role in concep-
tion. Although the Tiwi realize that heterosexual contact and penile-vaginal
intercourse is necessary for conception, they need to explain why only certain
incidences of p-v intercourse results in conception. Their causal explanation
for heterosexual contact, which results in conception, is that a female totem
breathes life into the woman’s body. Part of Tiwi contraception then includes
appeasement of the female totems to avoid pregnancy (Goodall, 1971). Cultural
concern over this aspect of human behavior is matched by the degree of con-
cern human groups have with another bio-behavioral phenomenon, menstrua-
tion. Key concepts related to menstruation (the shedding of the endometrium)
are menarche, a girl’s first menstruation or period, and the menstrual cycle.
Menstrual Cycle
The menstrual cycle, a primary sex characteristic, has both sexual and re-
productive functions and is reproductively analogous to spermatogenesis dis-
cussed in Chapter 5. Both the menstrual cycle and spermatogenesis produce
the gametes (the egg or ovum) and sperm, respectively, which are necessary
for conception to occur. The menstrual cycle and spermatogenesis function
in response to the H-P-G axis. Other similarities include the involvement of
Modern Human Female Anatomy and Physiology 113
homologous structures such as the ovaries and testes, the fallopian tubes and
vas deferens. The menstrual cycle and spermatogenesis are physiological pro-
cesses culturally defined as signals of sexual and reproductive adulthood.
These are also sharp contrasts between the menstrual cycle and sper-
matogenesis. The menstrual cycle is just that, cyclic, roughly taking a lunar,
twenty-eight-day month, to follow through a round of H-P-G axis hormone re-
lease. The menstrual cycle is rhythmic as opposed to the tonicity of spermato-
genesis and male H-P-G axis functioning. The ovaries do not produce eggs as
the testes produce sperm; rather, several immature eggs start developing each
month in their follicles or sacs in the ovaries. Generally, only one egg reaches
maturity and is released at one point in the cycle, ovulation, as opposed to the
continuous, numerous—several-million-daily—production of sperm. The men-
strual cycle is highly visible in the menstrual phase when the endometrium is
shed through the os and out of the body vaginally. In contrast, spermatogenesis
is unmarked. There are no clear primary markers of this process other than the
irregularity of nocturnal emissions (i.e., wet dreams). Indicators of spermato-
genesis often are culturally defined through secondary sex characteristics such
as beard growth, voice changes, the growth spurt in height and limb length, or
through the imposition of initiation ceremonies or rites de passage, rituals that
socially take a person from one stage in the life cycle to another.
Another contrast between the menstrual cycle and spermatogenesis is the
arbitrary, finite nature of the menstrual cycle. Menstruation begins at puberty,
occurs roughly once a month for an average of four to seven days, and ends at
menopause. It is bleeding without injury, illness, or provocation. In contrast,
spermatogenesis is invisible. Sperm do not appear in other situations such as
illness or injury as blood may, and spermatogenesis is continuous from puberty
to death. The attributes of the menstrual cycle allow for a range of cultural
interpretation and action.
The discussion of the physiology of the menstrual cycle is adapted from
Speroff, Glass, and Kase (1978). The menstrual cycle is discussed in four
phases: follicular, ovulation, luteal, and menstrual or menstruation. Born with
all the eggs she’ll ever have, about 700,000, a woman will mature and release
a range of 200–400 eggs during her reproductive life cycle, barring illness,
injury, pregnancy, or surgery on her reproductive organs (Berek, Adashi, and
Hillard, 1996). Based on a lunar, twenty-eight-day calendar cycle, she will ma-
ture and release about thirteen eggs a year. These are averages for healthy
industrialized women. In reality, there can be considerable variation relative to
the length and regularity of the cycle and egg release, depending on variables
such as nutrition, amount of body fat, stress, illness, or pregnancy.
The follicular phase is the longest and most irregular of the four phases of the
menstrual cycle. Its length determines the overall length of the cycle and the
regularity from one cycle to the next. The follicular phase ranges between
eleven and sixteen days in length. Egg maturation occurs during the follicular
phase. Based on hypothalamic release of GnRH, the pituitary releases FSH
stimulating multiple egg maturation in the follicles of the ovary. About mid-
point in the follicular phase, FSH starts to falter which induces the release of
ovarian estrogen, specifically estradiol. Estradiol helps to stabilize the FSH
level and induces the release of LH. At this point, the end of the follicular
phase is approaching and LH performs several functions. It stops multiple egg
maturation, and helps to release the most mature egg from the follicle, which
is also aided by the release of androgens, specifically androstriol. During this
time estrogen regulates the levels of FSH and LH, maintaining a delicate bal-
ance between them since a surge of FSH would stimulate egg maturation again
and a drop in LH could impede the most mature egg’s release from the ovary.
For this reason, estrogen or estradiol is called the key regulating hormone in
the menstrual cycle. At the end of the follicular phase, the egg is ready to be
released, FSH is stabilized, and LH and estrogen levels are high (see Figure 6.5).
Data are inconsistent as to whether or not women experience an increased
interest in genital, heterosexual contact at ovulation. From reports some
women are “horniest” at ovulation, others are just prior to or during their
periods, others are throughout their cycle, and some not at all (Hite, 1976;
Masters and Johnson, 1966; Masters, Johnson, and Kolodny, 1985). While bi-
ologically it would “make sense” to be most interested in sex during ovulation
(consistently assumed to be p-v intercourse in much of the literature), human
sexuality is a complicated interaction of biology and learned behavior, includ-
ing perception and emotions. Human sexual behavior is culturally filtered and
expressed, which can explain the variation in research findings.
Ovulation is the briefest phase of the cycle. It is the release of the egg from
the follicle into the lower pelvis where it is generally drawn into its correspond-
ing fallopian tube. Ovulation occurs at mid-cycle. Generally a woman ovulates
once a month, but there can be variations due to stress, intense orgasms, or
irregular follicular and ovulatory patterns (Speroff et al., 1978). Thus, since a
woman can, though rarely does, ovulate more than once a month, it is untrue
that she cannot get pregnant during her period—that she’s totally “safe” then
as some US folk beliefs assert. In addition, some women’s cycles are sufficiently
irregular such that ovulation may occur during menstruation. A woman may
be aware of ovulation through a cramping or pinching sensation in her lower
abdomen from the ovary which just released its egg. This sensation is similar
Modern Human Female Anatomy and Physiology 115
FSH
Estrogen
Progesterone
Day 1-4 14 21 28
LH
FSH
Progesterone
Estradiol
Day 1: Day 4:
Day 2: Diestrus Day 3: Proestrus
Day Metestrus Estrus
Reproductive Technology
Reproductive technology, developed and in use since the mid-1970s, has had an
impact on our physical evolution as hominids. Currently, artificial insemination
by husband (AI-H) or donor (AI-D), in vitro fertilization (IVF), chromosomal
filtration for gender selection, embryo transplants, amniocentesis, and
chorionic villi sampling (CVS) are all available as alternative means of direct
heterosexual contact for reproduction.
Sperm banks for AI-D and AI-H are found in most major cities in the United
States. Over 1,000,000 artificial inseminations are performed each year. A gen-
eration of artificially inseminated babies has reached adulthood, some of whom
are trying to locate their biological fathers. Minimally, artificial insemination
means that men are no longer directly needed for impregnation, only their
healthy ejaculate is. AI-D is used by some lesbians who want to be both bio-
logical and sociological mothers without having p-v intercourse. A very simple
process is involved. All one needs is a fresh, healthy ejaculate sample, a syringe,
and an ovulating female.3 What are the potential consequences of AI-D and
AI-H for partnering, parenting, and for men? This is not a balanced situation.
Men still need women to carry the fetus and to give birth. Surrogate mothers
are not as accepted as are sperm banks and artificial insemination, although
increasingly, women are egg donors for infertile couples (see Chapter 7).
In vitro fertilization, “test tube babies,” is now rather common in industrial-
ized societies for couples for whom the woman has irreparably damaged fallo-
pian tubes (Nyboe, Gianaroli, and Nygren, 2004; Reynolds et al., 2003; Wright
et al., 2003). This procedure involves surgically extracting a mature egg from
the woman’s ovary, combining it with a fresh ejaculate sample from her hus-
band, and then implanting the conceptus (the fertilized egg) into her uterus.
Available since 1978, thousands of babies have been conceived and born by
this method, and are apparently physically and developmentally healthy. As
of 2002, the national average success rate for a live birth in the United States
is 40.7 percent. The procedure is expensive—several thousand dollars per at-
tempt (Andersen, Nyboe, and Nygren, 2004).
Modern Human Female Anatomy and Physiology 121
Chromosomal filtration of X and Y chromosomes to preselect a female or
male fetus is gaining in success and popularity. Developed in the late 1970s to
early 1980s by a reproductive embryologist in San Diego, this method report-
edly has an 85 percent success rate for Y chromosome filtration. From a spun
ejaculate sample, the lighter Y chromosomes filter to the top and the heavier
X chromosomes settle to the bottom of the tube. Chromosomes and semen for
the preferred sex are filtrated out and artificially inseminated into the woman.
Given that there persists in our own and other societies a widespread cultural
preference for sons, what are the implications of this procedure for future gen-
erations? What will happen with the “natural” gender ratio balance, if there
ever was one, which was relatively untampered with except by cultural ma-
nipulations such as female infanticide (Benagiano and Bianchi, 1999; Mal-
pani, 2002; “Towards Ending Violence against Women in South Asia,” 2004)?
We know that in both India and China currently, the preference for male
children has changed the gender ratio balance sufficiently to be reflected in
the adult population, affecting the number of women available as potential
spouses (Malpani, 2002; “Towards Ending Violence Against Women in South
Asia,” 2004).
Embryo transplants from one uterus to another are also being done. In
this situation a woman is artificially inseminated with another woman’s part-
ner’s ejaculate. The man’s wife usually has blocked fallopian tubes or prob-
lems with implantation. After fertilization occurs in the “donor” woman, the
conceptus or fertilized egg is carefully evacuated from her uterus after several
days and implanted in the wife’s uterus. In one case, the receiving parents
were killed in a plane crash and the state of the floating embryo was of legal
and social concern. In 1989, there was a court case in the United States in
which a divorcing couple contested ownership of their fertilized eggs. The
court decided in favor of the wife. She could have them implanted. Ques-
tions of paternity and future child support remain unanswered at this time.
We do not have legal, social, cross-cultural, or evolutionary models or prec-
edents that easily incorporate these phenomena into our sexual and repro-
ductive behavior and belief systems. These technological options force us to
rethink our attitudes about life, abortion, parenting, and “normalcy.” The use
of unused embryos for stem cell and other medical research comprises one of
the current ethical debates in assisted reproductive technology (ART) (see
Chapter 7).
Amniocentesis and chorionic villi sampling, CVS, detect chromosomal
normalcy, abnormalities, and gender in embryos and fetuses. By either with-
drawing amniotic fluid from the amnion during the end of the first trimester
(amniocentesis), or sampling chorionic tissue early in the first trimester (CVS),
much chromosomal data can be obtained and used to make a decision about
whether to continue or terminate a pregnancy. In either situation there is a
small chance of spontaneous abortion (miscarriage). In the case of amniocen-
tesis, a second trimester abortion would be performed, while with CVS, a first
trimester abortion, if selected, would terminate the pregnancy.
122 Modern Human Female Anatomy and Physiology
Fetal reduction is one of the more recent reproductive choices. It is in-
tended for use in a large multiple fetus pregnancy or where a twin or triplet
is seriously chromosomally or developmentally impaired. Fetal reduction is
highly controversial. Fetal reduction involves the induced abortion of the fe-
tus which has serious problems to help increase the chances of survival of the
other fetuses (Berek, Adashi, and Hillard, 1996; Kelly, 1990). The impact of
these technologies could change our reproductive practices and future. There
are clear implications for altered sex ratio balances, the number of adult men
needed in a population, concepts of sexuality and sexual relations, definitions
of gender and gender roles, as well as of parenting and families. These are not
Orwellian (1950) or Brave New World (Huxley, 1946) fantasies, but realities of
early twenty-first-century life. Sexual and reproductive choices and decision
making now are qualitatively different than in previous generations or in other
cultures including our own.
Summary
1 Female sexual and reproductive anatomy and physiology are an expression
of the CC + (H-P-G axis) formula.
2 Female hormonal functioning is generally described as cyclic, in contrast
to the male’s depiction as tonic.
3 The menstrual cycle is a function of a negative feedback interaction of the
H-P-G axis.
4 Many of the primary and secondary female sex characteristics discussed
are analogues and/or homologues of the male’s.
5 Differences in male and female body fat and muscle mass are culturally inter-
preted. Female primary and secondary sex characteristics are often dramati-
cally responded to culturally. Much cultural interest is shown toward female
sexual and reproductive functioning. This can include controversial genital
surgery such as circumcision, clitoridectomy, hysterectomy, and infibulation.
6 There are several models developed in industrialized societies to explain
the variety of female sexual response.
7 Various diseases and cultural management of female sexual and reproduc-
tive structures affect a woman’s fertility.
8 The menstrual cycle is a bio-behavioral phenomenon.
9 The menstrual cycle is culturally regulated and associated with taboos in
many societies, including the United States.
10 Menstrual synchrony, menstrual cramps, and premenstrual syndrome
(PMS) may be culture-specific, industrialized phenomena.
11 Anatomically, physiologically, and hormonally, men and women are much
more similar than they are different.
12 Numerous technologies such as AI-D and AI-H, in vitro fertilization,
and chromosomal filtration developed in industrialized societies over the
past fifteen to twenty years have the potential to radically change human
reproduction.
Modern Human Female Anatomy and Physiology 123
Thought-Provoking Questions
1 If virginity is defined as not having p-v intercourse, does that mean that
self-identified, behaviorally consistent gays and lesbians are always virgins
since they do not engage in this behavior?
2 Why do societies manipulate and pay more and different kinds of atten-
tion to female reproductive and sexual structures than they do male?
3 What kinds of immediate (proximal) and long-term (distal) evolutionary
changes could occur from ART?
Suggested Resources
Books
Boston Women’s Health Collective. 2005. Our Bodies, Ourselves: A New Edition for a
New Era. New York: Touchstone Publishers, Ltd.
Chalker, Rebecca. 2000. The Clitoral Truth: The Secret World at Your Fingertips. New
York: Seven Stories Press.
Diamant, Anita. 1997. The Red Tent. New York: St. Martin’s Press. Federation of Fem-
inist Women’s Health Centers. 1995.
Website
Museum of Menstruation. http://www.mum.org/.
7 Fertility, Conception, and
Sexual Differentiation
Chapter Overview
1 Defines fertility, sterility, infertility, and conception.
2 Delineates criteria for male and female fertility and infertility, and
discusses the causes of infertility in the United States.
3 Discusses cross-cultural and US reactions to fertility and infertility.
4 Discusses biological, cultural, and technological aspects of conception.
5 Defines genetic, gonadal or hormonal, and phenotypic sex, gender iden-
tity, and gender role.
6 Discusses the sexual differentiation process in utero.
7 Discusses intersexed persons including those with Turner’s Syndrome,
Klinefelter’s Syndrome, and XYY Syndrome.
assumed, its importance is not taken for granted. Fertility is important in all
societies; it is probably one of the few universal concerns in human sexuality.
This can be seen in art forms, myths, folklore, and people’s value on fertility
and kinship through time and space. Penis sheaths common among groups liv-
ing in New Guinea, Michelangelo’s sculpture of “David,” and the Washington
Monument in Washington, DC, are all examples of various cultures’ appreci-
ation of phallic forms. The Venus de Willendorf, a 25,000–year-old statuette
of a woman with pendulous breasts, a rounded stomach, and large hips and
thighs, is a commonly cited example of a female fertility symbol.
Beliefs about fertility and conception are widespread and culture-specific.
Though all human groups know that it requires penile-vaginal intercourse to
conceive, various fertility enhancers are found cross-culturally. To enhance
conception, potions are consumed, rituals are performed, seduction techniques
are encouraged, and spirits are appeased. For example, the Mayan women
of Mexico may consult a curandera, midwife, or traditional birth attendant
(TBA) relative to fertility concerns (Faust, 1988). Among the Brunei Malay,
the dukun, a healer, may be consulted for advice as well as potions to ingest
Fertility, Conception, and Differentiation 127
(Kimball and Craig, 1988). Among the Tiwi, which were discussed earlier,
certain female totems are believed to be responsible for conception. They can
be sought out or avoided depending on whether a woman wishes “to have life
breathed into her body” or to avoid conception (Goodall, 1971). Among the
Sambia, a horticultural group in New Guinea, fellatio (oral sex) performed on
the husband is believed to “prepare a wife’s body for childbearing by ‘strength-
ening’ her” (Herdt, 1993: 306). See Chapter 11 for a discussion of Sambian
“growing a boy.” Semen in this culture is thought of as a vital life essence
which makes and keeps men strong and healthy while ensuring female fertility
and embryonic development. Their sexual beliefs are representative of what
Barker-Benfield (1975) refers to as the “spermatic economy.” The spermatic
economy is a belief system that is widespread cross-culturally, including the
United States. It focuses on semen (i.e., ejaculate) as a precious, essential life
substance that exists in finite supply and can be “used up” in a man’s lifetime if
he is not careful about where, how, and with whom he “spends” it (ejaculates).
Sambian sexual beliefs existed in a culture in which endemic or ongoing war-
fare over scarce resources, including women, was common. Resources for food,
shelter, and water exist in limited supply due to natural boundaries, sometimes
referred to as impacted habitats. Women do most of the food procurement,
processing, and distribution. They are frequently seen as the enemy since mar-
riages are often political alliances among warring factions. Women can also
be perceived by the men as sexually voracious and potential depletors of trea-
sured ejaculate. The idea that men form the baby and women “grow it” is not
that different than European thinking of several hundred years ago when the
uterus was perceived as the receptacle of the homonucleus (little baby) “given”
by the man.
Much of the effort to ensure and protect fertility, both within and outside
the United States, rests with women. Until recently, the dominant fertility
patterns among women were extended periods of lactation followed by preg-
nancy. Continuously uninterrupted menstrual cycles, varied by one or two live
births and short or non-existent periods of lactation, are largely a middle-class,
industrial, twentieth- and twenty-first-century phenomenon (Beyene, 1989;
Frayser, 1985). Since fertility is critical to the continuation of any group, it
is a topic that is taken seriously by most of the world’s peoples. This includes
means of enhancing conception, avoiding conception as discussed in Chapter
8, and means of dealing with infertility.
Infertility is seen as a tragedy societally and individually, regardless of an
individual culture’s positions about population pressures. Infertility, or the in-
ability to conceive and bear a child, is a cause of societal and cultural concern.
When it occurs, it is almost universally grounds for divorce and individual
grief (Cohen and Eames, 1982; Ward and Edelstein, 2006: 82–83). There is
much cross-cultural variation in response to infertility. However, a fairly wide-
spread constant is that the woman is seen as being responsible for the fertility
problem (Frayser, 1985). For example, among the herding Nuer in Africa, an
infertile wife becomes a “husband” to another, assumably, fertile woman. The
128 Fertility, Conception, and Differentiation
female “husband” becomes the sociological father to her wife’s offspring by a
male. This practice allows the continuation of the infertile woman’s patrilin-
eage, the descent system where you trace your family through your male kin
(Cohen and Eames, 1982). As with many other cultures, the Sambia believe it
is only the woman who can be infertile. When infertility occurs in their cul-
ture, the Sambian male takes another wife, but does not divorce the allegedly
infertile wife (Herdt, 1993).
In both industrialized and nonindustrialized societies, infertility is managed
by cultural means. Common solutions can include divorce and remarriage, po-
lygyny, adopting a child, and fostering, the latter being primarily a nineteenth-
to twentieth-century, industrialized alternative. “Aunting” and “uncling” also
occur. In these situations, the infertile couple involve themselves intensively
with the children in their extended kin group. This may include financial, so-
cial, psychological, and ritual activities, similar to what occurs in the unilineal
descent groups in nonindustrialized societies. Single-parent adoptions are also
increasing for both men and women in industrialized societies. This extends
to international adoptions for singles and couples. The economic and social
flexibility that has occurred for some people in our culture since the latter part
of the twentieth century makes this option more feasible. Some international
babies are seen as easier to adopt—girls, for example, may be easier to adopt in
societies that strongly value boys (“Towards Ending Violence against Women
in South Asia,” 2004). Since most cultures have either bilateral or patrilineal
descent, boy children perpetuate the lineage and are less likely to be put up for
adoption. See Chapter 10 for definitions and discussion. Boy babies may also
be preferred because they are seen as “brighter, stronger, and healthier” than
girls (Whelehan’s counseling file).
Overpopulation may be a global concern and an issue for mainstream
groups. However, much of the nonindustrialized world as well as some eth-
nic groups in the United States such as the Amish, Hutterites, and African
Americans may perceive these concerns and attempts to impose birth control
on them as a threat of genocide by the larger society. Regardless of generalized
concerns about population pressures, for the infertile couple who wants a bio-
logical child, it is a very remote, abstract argument. Given the universal value
on fertility, the anguish an infertile couple experiences in not being able to
conceive is understandable.
In some societies, infertility is cause for divorce, grief, and loss of status,
particularly for the female. Many societies actively try to treat infertility indig-
enously either through biomedicine, potions, behavioral changes, consultation
with specialists, or gender selection (Becker, 1990; Faust, 1988; Kimball and
Craig, 1988; Malpani, 2002; Marmor, 1988).
Since much of the biomedical work on infertility has occurred in industri-
alized societies in the last decades of this century, the focus of this discussion
will be on the industrialized countries. In the United States, fertility problems
have stabilized with about 10–15 percent of the couples who are trying to
conceive and bear a child unable to do so (“Optimal evaluation of the infertile
Fertility, Conception, and Differentiation 129
male,” 2010: 3; “Optimizing natural fertility,” 2012; Sharlip et al., 2002). In the
United States, a couple is defined as infertile after they have been trying for a
year to have a child without success (Esteves et al., 2015: 3; “How is Infertility
Diagnosed?” n.d.; “Infertility and Fertility,” 2017; “Multiple definitions of in-
fertility,” 2016).
Physiologically, infertility may rest with the man, the woman, or the couple.
Although the statistics on causal attribution vary, roughly 35–40 percent of
the time the problem is with the male; 35–40 percent of the time the problem
is with the female; and the remaining percentage is either couple incompati-
bility, behavioral, or unknown (Berek, Adashi, and Hillard, 1996: 915; Hatcher
et al., 1986; Ragone, 1994; Stewart et al., 1979). Physiological causes for both
male and female infertility relate to the established criteria for fertility.
Male infertility can be due to low sperm count, motility problems, or de-
formed sperm. STIs (sexually transmitted infections), abusive-addictive drug
usage, and congenital problems can cause infertility in males (Aitken, Koop-
man, and Lewis, 2004; Kenkel, Claus, and Eberhard, 2001; Thacker, 2004;
Thomas, 2000). Relative to numbers, a subfertile or infertile male is one whose
sperm count is below 20–40 million sperm per ejaculate (Berek, Adashi, and
Hillard, 1996: 920; Kelly, 1988; Stewart et al., 1979). This is the most common
cause of infertility in men.
Sperm motility is another factor in infertility. As stated, sperm need to
move quickly and continuously in order to reach a fallopian tube and be able
to fertilize an egg. Slow-moving, sluggish sperm probably will not survive the
trip or be taken in by the egg. Problems with sperm motility are the second
most common cause of male infertility in the United States. Finally, a man
may produce misshaped sperm, or sperm missing one or more of its necessary
parts. A semen analysis, which notes sperm count, size, shape, and motility, is
a key diagnostic tool in a male fertility workup.
Female infertility can be caused by endogenous hormonal imbalance, ill-
nesses, or stress, as well as by STIs, endometriosis, pelvic inflammatory disease
(PID), and drug abuse or addiction. The most common form of female infertil-
ity is caused by problems with ovulation. The second most common problem is
some form of tubal blockage, followed by a combination of the two. Diagnostic
tests for female fertility problems are usually more complicated, extensive, in-
vasive, and costly than for males. These tests include hormonal assays, mea-
surements of tubal patency, and studies of cervical mucous.
The causes of couple or male-female infertility may be behavioral or phys-
iological. Behavioral problems include either too frequent ejaculatory-penile
vaginal intercourse that depletes the sperm supply,1 too infrequent ejaculatory
intercourse, or ejaculatory intercourse at times when the woman is not ovu-
lating. Physiological problems include pH imbalances between the woman’s
vagina and the man’s semen; incompatibility between the cervical mucous
and sperm, often referred to clinically as “hostile”2; and occasionally, an aller-
gic reaction by the woman to her partner’s sperm (Aitken and Graves, 2002;
Guylaya et al., 2001; Stewart et al., 1979).
130 Fertility, Conception, and Differentiation
Fertility may be decreased in “spermatic economies.” Infrequent p-v inter-
course reduces the chances of conception. Among some groups such as the
Sambia, Mae Enga, and other horticultural groups in Melanesia, specifically
New Guinea, p-v intercourse occurs relatively infrequently, resulting in a low
birth rate. As discussed, women in these societies are also seen as sexually
voracious, powerful, and dangerous—eager to “swallow” a man’s precious and
limited life essence (Gregersen, 1983; Herdt, 1982, 1993; Williams, 1986).
Currently, there are a wide range of treatments having variable degrees
of success available to infertile couples in the United States. Male infertil-
ity problems may be treated by isolating and concentrating his viable sperm
and then artificially inseminating his partner with them (AI-H), by artificial
insemination donor (AI-D), or combining donor-husband sperm in artificial
insemination. Generally, vitamin or drug therapies do not alleviate the con-
dition. If the vas deferens is blocked, or a varicocele, a varicose vein of the
scrotal sac, exists, surgery may be helpful.
AI-H may be more successful if the man makes love with his partner
using a condom to catch the ejaculate, rather than masturbating into
a specimen jar in a doctor’s bathroom. The greater eroticism of partner
lovemaking is believed to cause a more forceful ejaculation of younger,
fresher, healthier sperm (McCarthy, 1990; Medical Aspects of Human
Sexuality, 1991: 16).
Legal and social questions arise in our culture as to whether AI-D donor
files should be open to AI-D children, and as to whose rights take prece-
dent—the donor’s right to anonymity or the child’s right to know biolog-
ical paternity. It is noted that AI-D donors are medically and genetically
screened prior to being accepted as participants, that phenotype and
socio-cultural matching occurs between the donor and child’s family,
and that the donor’s medical and social history data are available to the
AI-D child’s family.
Fertility, Conception, and Differentiation 131
Couples’ treatments range across the behavioral-physiological spectrum. For
those infertility problems caused by intercourse-related behaviors, education
about ovulation, the timing of fertilization, and sperm supply can help to alle-
viate the situation. While this may appear to be a relatively “simple” solution,
sensitivity to the couple’s psycho-emotional state is important. Making love by
the calendar in order to conceive a child can produce anxiety, tension, specta-
toring (i.e., observing how well you are doing), and can be less than a sponta-
neous, passionate, sensuous experience for both people. Couple infertility due
to sperm-cervical mucous pH incompatibility may be treated with drugs, with
AI-H as a bypass mechanism, or with the use of condoms for a while to see if
the problem may self-correct (Stewart et al., 1979; Wright et al., 2003).
American lay and folk remedies for infertile couples abound. They include
increasing the frequency of p-v intercourse and ejaculation, which can ac-
tually decrease the sperm count; using different positions in intercourse; or
ingesting vitamins or aphrodisiacs, which enhance neither fertility nor virility.
There is anecdotal reporting of infertile couples who have conceived a child
after adopting a baby.
The inconsistent use of safer sex and the increase in sexually transmitted
infections (STIs) since the late twentieth century have resulted in a rise in fer-
tility problems that are occurring at a younger age (Coste et al., 2004; “Cur-
rent Trends Ectopic Pregnancy,” 1995; Kamwendo et al., 2000; Lipscomb et al.,
2000). The financial expense and psychological and emotional costs are great for
those affected by infertility. It is interesting that even with all the sophisticated
technology to treat problems and knowledge about infertility that we have in
this country, the responsibility for a fertility problem is still largely seen as the
woman’s. In a study of middle-class, professional couples in the San Francisco
Bay Area it was found that regardless of the physiological “cause” of the problem,
the woman was expected to somehow “fix it.” If the physiological problem was
not the male’s, he offered support to his partner, but did not assume responsi-
bility for its resolution (Becker, 1990). This is not that far from the generalized
industrial and nonindustrial response of seeing the woman as responsible for fer-
tility. About half of the infertile couples in the United States can be successfully
treated so that conception and a live birth can occur; this number can be as high
as 80 percent for women under 35 and as low as 26 percent for women age 40
and over (Malchau et al., 2017; Zieve et al., 2018). These numbers do not include
live births resulting from advanced reproductive techniques (Zieve et al., 2018).
Conception
As the preceding discussion indicates, fertility is a necessary condition for con-
ception. Biomedically, conception is the union of the sperm and egg, which is
dependent upon regular spermatogenesis and ovulation. Conception is not the
same as viability, or the ability to create and bear offspring. Viability necessitates
implantation of the fertilized egg into the endometrium and the development
and birth of a full-term fetus (Allgeier and Allgeier, 1991; Reynolds et al., 2003).
132 Fertility, Conception, and Differentiation
In terms of reproductive success, there is a great deal of waste. Relative to an
individual who may or may not wish to impregnate or be pregnant, conception
and viability may be akin to playing roulette.
Conception is regulated and interpreted through culture. In most cultures,
there are explanations given as to why and when intercourse results in con-
ception (Frayser, 1985; Gregersen, 1983). It is a myth in industrialized societies
that nonindustrialized groups do not know that heterosexual genital contact is
necessary for conception. That members of these societies do not openly discuss
this, particularly with researchers from industrialized societies, is not surpris-
ing. Specifics of sexual behavior and conception, particularly across gender lines
(most researchers have been and are male), are not topics of everyday conversa-
tion. Explanations for conception are embedded in people’s views of sexuality,
reproduction, and male-female relations. For example, the Tiwi, whom we dis-
cussed previously, believe that the essence of sexuality is female. Male totems,
animistic spirit beings, are important in their patrilineal kinship system; one’s
spiritual totems are inherited matrilineally through females.
A woman conceives through a given act of intercourse when her spirit totem
breathes life into her body (Goodall, 1971). Given that much of the embryonic
process is still unknown from an industrialized, technological perspective (e.g.,
Muecke, 1979; Sizonenko, 2003; Wilson, 1979) and that new knowledge about
sexuality continually unfolds, a measure of humility is needed in understand-
ing these explanations. It was only a generation ago (when your authors were
children) that we were often told that the “stork brought babies,” or that they
were picked from the “cabbage patch.” Conception occurred by a “seed being im-
planted in a woman’s tummy,”—leading a number of girls to swallow watermelon
seeds. Students in one human sexuality class reported they “knew people who be-
lieved if you had ‘sex’ standing up, you wouldn’t get pregnant because it ‘would all
fall out.’” These were (are?) common US folk beliefs about conception and birth.
Due to current and future assisted reproductive technology (ART), hetero-
sexual genital contact is no longer necessary for fertilization to occur. The full
impact of these industrialized developments on conception in both industrial-
ized and nonindustrialized societies remains to be seen (Benagiano and Bianchi,
1999; Malpani, 2002; Todosijevic, Ljubinkovic, and Arandc, 2003). Some poten-
tial consequences of these developments were presented in Chapters 5 and 6.
From an industrialized bio-behavioral perspective, there are several aspects
of prenatal sexual differentiation and post-natal phenotypic expression that
culturally define sexual physiological “normalcy.” Although there are a variety
of ways to biologically define one’s sex, as discussed in Chapter 2, from a bio-
medical perspective, four criteria need to be met. Prenatally, the establishment
of genetic or chromosomal sex and appropriate differentiation in utero need to
occur. Post-natally, appropriate gender identity, or the knowledge that you are
male or female, and gender role development and puberty (i.e., sexual adult-
hood) need to occur.
Genetic or chromosomal sex is determined at conception. Genetic or chro-
mosomal sex is the arrangement of either the XX pairing for a girl, or the XY
Fertility, Conception, and Differentiation 133
pairing for a boy. Although a range of chromosomal X and Y combinations is
possible and may occur, only XX or XY are genetically normal. Based on ge-
netic sex, sexual differentiation or gonadal sex develops in the fetus (Muecke,
1979; Sizonenko, 2003; “Syndromes of Abnormal Sex Differentiation,” 2005;
Wilson, 1979). Gonadal sex gives rise to phenotypic sex, or the external and
internal physical characteristics that allow a culture to label a child a boy or
girl. These characteristics include, but are not limited to, such structures as
the penis, testicles, vas deferens, or prostate in the boy, and the clitoris, ova-
ries, fallopian tubes, or vagina in a girl. At birth, a child is labeled as a boy or
girl based on visual inspection of the genitalia; the child’s sense of itself as a
boy or girl is referred to as gender identity. It is believed that children know
their gender identity by the time they are eighteen to twenty-four-months old
(Money and Ehrhard, 1972). Based on gender identity, gender role develops.
Gender role, sometimes referred to as script or scripting (Gagnon, 1979), is the
internalization and acting out of culturally defined male or female behavior, af-
fect, and attitudes. The ideal, at least in US culture, is to have genetic, gonadal,
and phenotypic sex, gender identity, and gender role synchronized so that one
looks, acts, thinks, and feels like a culturally defined boy or girl, man or woman.
The process of sexual differentiation in utero and attainment of gender iden-
tity and gender role has received a great deal of attention from the Middle Ages
through Freud to the present (e.g., Bullough, 1976; Freud, 1929 [1929]; Gagnon,
1979). Sexual differentiation, the most physiological aspect in this continuum,
has also received a great deal of scrutiny (Jost, 1972; Muecke, 1979; Sherfey, 1972;
Sizonenko, 2003; “Syndromes of Abnormal Sex Differentiation,” 2005; Wilson,
1979). These theories range from postulations that as humans we are all embryo-
logically female in our composition (Sherfey, 1972 based on Jost, 1961), to a very
complex interpretation of the hormonal-anatomical differentiation process (“Ex-
ploring the Biological Contributions to Human Health,” 2001; Wilson, 1979).
A simplified interpretation of sexual differentiation follows based on more
than sixty years of research (McCarthy and Arnold, 2011; Phoenix et al., 1959).
Genetic or chromosomal sex is determined at conception by the pairing of
either XX or XY chromosomes for a girl or boy, respectively. As part of embry-
onic development regardless of genetic sex, the following schema occurs:
• The embryo is sexually undifferentiated for the first six weeks of life. Phe-
notypic sex cannot be determined by visual observation.
• Both male and female embryos contain both the Mullerian ducts, which
will develop some female sexual and reproductive structures, and Wolffian
ducts, which will develop some male sexual and reproductive structures.
• The Wolffian ducts develop part of the urinary tract system in both males
and females, specifically the ureters, the collecting tubules of the kidneys,
and part of the bladder.
• The presence of Wolffian ducts is a necessary condition for Mullerian duct
development in the female (“Exploring the Biological Contributions to
Human Health,” 2001b; Muecke, 1979; Sizonenko, 2003).
134 Fertility, Conception, and Differentiation
In the male, the following process occurs. At about six weeks of embryonic de-
velopment, the male begins to sexually differentiate. Several hormones are re-
leased by the embryo to expedite this process. They are testosterone, the H-Y
antigen,4 both of which facilitate male anatomic development, and Mullerian
inhibiting substance (MIS), which closes the Mullerian ducts and causes them
to atrophy (“Exploring the Biological Contributions to Human Health,” 2001;
Sizonenko, 2003; Wilson, 1979). Based on the hormone release and the XY
chromosomal arrangement, the penis, testes, and scrotum develop. The Wolf-
fian ducts develop into the rete testes (a rudimentary structure) the epididymis
and vas deferens. During the course of fetal development and with the help
of testosterone, the other accessory organs appear (e.g., prostate, seminal ves-
icles). The testicles descend into the scrotal sac during the third trimester. If
all goes well, approximately nine calendar months after conception an infant
is born. The infant is then typically given the gender identity of a boy, and his
formal gender role socialization begins.
A girl’s differentiation process begins later, around ten to twelve weeks of
fetal development.5 Although estrogen may be involved in later prenatal de-
velopment, its role, if any, in the differentiation process is not as clear as is
testosterone in the male’s (“Exploring the Biological Contributions to Human
Health,” 2001; Hyde, 1994; Wilson, 1979). The Wolffian ducts spontaneously
close in the female. A Wolffian inhibiting substance, analogous to MIS, does
not exist. The genital tubercle, homologous and analogous with the males, de-
velops into the clitoris. The Mullerian ducts develop into the uterus, fallopian
tubes, broad ligament, and upper third of the vagina with the other accessory
organs (e.g., labia minora) following. The presence of an X chromosome in
both males and females, the need for MIS and testosterone release in the male
and lack of comparable hormone release in the female, the live birth of an X or
XO “female” and not of a Y or YO male, all lead some researchers (e.g., Sherfey,
1972) to take a strong stand that human embryos are innately female.
Intersexuality
As stated, only XX or XY arrangements are considered to be normative genetic
sex in this culture. There are, however, a number of other X and Y combi-
nations that can occur. Three of the most common are Turner’s Syndrome,
Klinefelter’s Syndrome, and the XYY Syndrome. Turner’s Syndrome, repre-
sented by an X or XO combination, occurs in about 1:2,500 to 1:4,000 live
births (Cui et al., 2018; Davenport, 2010; Oktay et al., 2016; Sybert and Mc-
Cauley, 2004). Klinefelter’s Syndrome, represented chromosomally as XXY,
occurs in about 1/500 to 1/900 live births (Dahl et al., 2018: 79; Davis et al.,
2016: 15; Salemi et al., 2016: 408). The XYY Syndrome, formerly known as the
“Supermale Syndrome,” occurs in about 1/1,000 live births (Kim et al., 2013;
Liao et al., 2011; Linden et al., 2002). See Table 7.1 for a description of these
and additional forms of intersexuality.
It is estimated that only 1 percent of fetuses with Turner’s Syndrome are likely
to survive long enough to be born (Morgan, 2007; Papp et al., 2006). Turner’s
Fertility, Conception, and Differentiation 135
Syndrome individuals often have a number of severe physiological problems and
frequently die in their twenties. They are sterile, have incomplete or rudimen-
tary ovaries, uterus, and fallopian tubes, a blind vagina that may be corrected
surgically, immature post-pubertal external genitalia, are often short, and have
webbed neck or fingers (Money and Ehrhardt, 1972). Webbing is a fold of skin
between the neck and shoulder or digits. Turner’s Syndrome individuals may
have cognitive development problems (Mange and Mange, 1980; Stine, 1977).
Although they have some female phenotypic sex characteristics, they do not
meet the criteria of normative genetic and physiological development presented
earlier in this chapter. Turner’s Syndrome individuals chromosomally represent
the single X chromosome that some writers have used to postulate the innate fe-
maleness of the human embryo. Single X chromosome individuals are not physi-
cally normative females either. This position is believed by Bolin and Whelehan
to be a feminist bias, since an X or XO female is not a physiologically normative
female. This politicization of the embryo (i.e., that males are “incomplete” since
they need hormonal release during differentiation to become a phenotypic male
and without it would develop female characteristics) may be a backlash reaction
by some feminist researchers. The backlash could be a reaction against Freudian
interpretations of the clitoris as a “half-formed” penis and the vaginal orgasm
myth (1959 [1929]), as well as a general industrialized tendency to present male
culture as total culture in which women are defined in terms of their relation-
ships to men. Perhaps bias needs to be recognized more openly whenever it is
found to avoid politicizing the differentiation process.
Klinefelter’s Syndrome (XXY) individuals have an essentially male pheno-
type. They are sterile and tend to have underdeveloped primary and second-
ary sex characteristics. Atrophied testicles6 produce low levels of testosterone,
frequently resulting in gynecomastia, or breast enlargement, low libido, prob-
lems with erectile ability, and more fat than muscle mass per overall body
composition. In essence, both male and female secondary sex characteristics
appear. Some XXY individuals’ psychological development has been labeled
schizophrenic, which may be more perceived than real (Mange and Mange,
1980; Money and Ehrhardt, 1972).
The XYY Syndrome receives attention because of the alleged aggressive and
physically violent tendencies of these individuals. According to some theorists
(Allgeier and Allgeier, 1991), the extra Y chromosome produces men who are
not only taller and more muscular than XY males, but who also have a greater
propensity for acting out violently. Many of these studies are methodologically
flawed (Allgeier and Allgeier, 1991). About 50 percent of the XYY males are
sterile. See Table 7.1 for a description of behavioral characteristics.
All three of these syndromes (Turner’s, Klinefelter’s, and XYY) are believed
to occur randomly. Since both Turner’s and Klinefelter’s Syndrome individuals
are sterile, they are self-limiting. They do not reproduce. Fertile XYY males do
not appear to be more likely to produce XYY sons than XY males. Causes of
these chromosomal variations are unknown (Mange and Mange, 1980).
The essence of being male or female is important as a defining characteristic
and is culturally valuable. It can include substances such as semen or menstrual
Table 7.1 Summary of anomalies of prenatal differentiation
Congenital Adrenal Genetically inherited malfunction In XX children, can cause mild to severe masculinization of genitalia at One in 15,000
Hyperplasia (CAH) of one or more of six enzymes birth or later; if untreated, can cause masculinization at puberty and
involved in making steroid early puberty. Some forms drastically disrupt salt metabolism and are life-
hormones threatening if not treated with cortisone.
Androgen Insensitivity Genetically inherited change in XY children born with highly feminized genitalia. The body is “blind” One in 50,000 to
Syndrome (AIS) the cell surface receptor for to the presence of testosterone, since cells cannot capture it and use it one in 20,000
testosterone to move development in a male direction. At puberty these children
develop breasts and a feminine body shape.
Turner’s Syndrome Females lacking a second X A form of gonadal dysgenesis in females. Ovaries do not develop; stature is One in 2,500 to
chromosome (XO) short; lack of secondary sex characteristics; treatment includes estrogen one in 4,000
and growth hormone. births
Klinefelter’s Syndrome Males with an extra X chromosome A form of gonadal dysgenesis causing infertility; after puberty there is often One in 500 to one
(XXY) breast enlargement; treatments include testosterone therapy. in 900
Ovotesticular Disorder Usually XX chromosome, more More commonly born with both testicular and ovarian tissue; combination One in 100,000
of Sex Development rarely XY or mosaic. Some of ovaries and testes. Sometimes has a male side and female side; or grow births
136 Fertility, Conception, and Differentiation
(ovotesticular DSD; evidence of family history together in one organ. Appearance of external genitals varies considerably
true gonadal intersex; Cause in XX unknown, possible in terms of intermediate states.
true hermaphroditism gene translocation from Y
XYY Syndrome The extra Y is not an inherited This condition was called SuperMale Syndrome because some early flawed Frequency: one in
(formerly called condition but due to an error studies found a high number of prison inmates with XYY; they were 1,000. However
Supermale in cell division in the fertilizing also thought to be overly aggressive. Subsequent research has disproved this number is
Syndrome) sperm or in developing embryo this stereotype. XYY males typically have no distinctive characteristics conservative,
although they may be slightly taller than average and about 50% have since many men
learning disabilities although mild. with XYY are
unidentified
Source: Adapted from: Auchus, 2010; van der Kamp and Wit, 2004; Gottlieb and Trifiro, 2017; Genetics Home Reference National Institutes of Health: “Androgen
Insensitivity Syndrome” (https://ghr.nlm.nih.gov/condition/androgen-insensitivity-syndrome#statistics); Oktay et al., 2016; Cui et al., 2018; Davenport, 2010; Sybert and
McCauley, 2004; Dahl et al., 2018; Davis et al., 2016; Salemi et al., 2016; Nistal et al., 2015; Kim et al., 2013; Liao et al., 2011; Linden et al, 2002; Sax, 2002.
Note: Total number of people whose bodies differ from the normative male or female is one in 1,500–2,000 (ISNA: “How Common is Intersex?”).
Fertility, Conception, and Differentiation 137
blood as well as spiritual, aesthetic, kinesics, or occupational attributes. There-
fore, cross-culturally a man can be phenotypically and genetically male, but be
labeled female or something else (i.e., “not man” or “near man”) by his affect,
demeanor, or special talents as exemplified above. Similarly, a phenotypic and
genotypic female may succeed in being a warrior woman (Williams, 1986).
With the Sambia, oral intercourse among adolescent males is seen as a way of
preserving and recirculating semen—a vital, life-sustaining fluid believed to
exist in finite quantities. Male-male fellatio during adolescence builds up male
energy (jergunda). Accumulating jergunda allows him to fulfill his sexual obli-
gations as a husband and semen-nurturer to his unborn children. By definition,
then, p-v intercourse is a potential drain of this energy and therefore must be
carefully controlled (Herdt, 1982). These male gender role expectations are
valued and fulfilling them grants status and respect to men.
Summary
1 Fertility, infertility, and conception are bio-behavioral phenomena.
2 There are a number of technological procedures in industrialized cultures
to deal with infertility problems.
3 There are a number of theories used to explain sexual differentiation in
utero. Some theories used to explain transgender identity and homosexu-
ality rely on interpretations of the differentiation process.
4 Genetic or chromosomal sex, hormonal, or gonadal sex, phenotypic sex,
gender identity, and gender role are cultural terms used to explain the pre-
natal differentiation process and post-natal development of identity and
roles in the United States.
5 Turner’s Syndrome, Klinefelter’s Syndrome, and the Supermale Syndrome
are variations of XX or XY chromosomal arrangements.
Thought-Provoking Questions
1 How are phenomena such as fertility, conception, and gender culturally
influenced and expressed?
2 What are the controversies around ART and what are the potential
changes in human reproduction as a result of ART?
Suggested Resources
Websites
ISNA Intersex Society of North America (http://www.isna.org). Last accessed 11/09/07.
Sizionenko, P. C. 2003. “Human Sexual Differentiation.” Geneva Foundation for Med-
ical Education and Research. http://www.gfmer.ch/Books/Reproductive_health/Hu-
man_sexual_differentiation.ht.
8 Birth Control, Abortion, and
Methods of Birth Control in
Cross-Cultural Contexts
Chapter Overview
1 Defines key terms and concepts related to birth control including contra-
ception, population, fertility, mortality, migration, theoretical effective-
ness rate, actual/use effectiveness rate, and woman years.
2 Compares and contrasts population trends between industrialized and
nonindustrialized nations.
3 Examines industrialized, nonindustrialized, and indigenous approaches to
birth control.
4 Explains various birth control and contraceptive methods.
5 Discusses prevalence and availability of various kinds of contraceptive
techniques globally with reference to policy and unmet needs in industri-
alizing nations.
6 Provides an overview of abortion trends and practices in the United States
including the historical and political context.
7 Explores abortion trends in industrializing/nonindustrialized nations.
8 Summarizes preindustrial and traditional methods of birth control in a
cross-cultural and historical context.
• Between 2019 and 2050, it is predicted that the population of the more
industrialized countries as a whole will decline slowly by about 1 percent a
year. Out of the 2 billion expected to be added to the global population in
that timeframe, the least industrialized countries are projected to account
for 1.5 billion (an annual increase of 48 million).
• The number of low-fertility (below 2.1 live births per woman) countries
continues to grow, and now includes all of Europe and North America,
China, Brazil, Bangladesh, Russia, Japan, and Vietnam. Notably, this is
not exclusively a trend among the most industrialized countries.
140 Birth Control, Abortion, and Culture
• Between 2010 and 2020, international migration has become a major fac-
tor in the population changes of some countries. This migration is pri-
marily driven by either economic opportunities or by flight from areas of
conflict.
• The population of the least industrialized forty-seven countries is pro-
jected to almost double, going from 1 billion in 2019 to 1.9 billion in 2050.
• Predictions of overall worldwide fertility declines are contingent on access
to family planning, especially in industrialized countries (World Popula-
tion Prospects, 2019).
• Although three fourths of men and women rely on condoms for their
first experience, this declines with age (“Contraceptive Use in the United
States: Fact Sheet,” 2018; “National Survey of Family Growth,” 2017).
• Only 18 percent of women and 25 percent of men aged 15–44 had used a
condom in the past month (Copen, 2017: 1).
• The majority of sexually active people still favors female contraceptive
methods: approximately 20 percent of women get sterilized, compared to
10 percent of men. For women ages 40–44 the rate more than doubles to
47 percent (“Contraceptive Use in the United States: Fact Sheet,” 2018;
“National Survey of Family Growth,” 2017; “Trends in Contraceptive Use
Worldwide,” 2015).
• As people age, consistent use of condoms decreases for both women and
men. For instance, among youth ages 15–19, 36 percent of women and 53
percent of men reported having used a condom on each sexual encoun-
ter over the past year. For adults ages 35–44, these numbers decreased to
9 percent of women and 11 percent of men (Copen, 2017: 3). As noted
previously, there is a corresponding increase in female sterilization among
women in the latter half of this age group.
Researchers in Brazil have found that women who had three or more children
were more likely to choose sterilization as a method of birth control and were
less knowledgeable about other methods of birth control. Having children was
also found to be initiated earlier among Brazilian women with more than three
children and they also had a lower income than women with fewer children
(Leone and Hinde, 2005; Tamkins, 2004). These findings may help explain
Brazil’s high sterilization rate for women; 50 percent of women aged thirty-five
and older had been sterilized according to 1966 data offering historical depth
to this practice. Subsequently, sterilization has continued as a popular method
and may account for the declining fertility of Brazil recorded for the second
half of the 1970s. Researchers suggest that education about contraception
should be provided for adolescent women since this is the age they are making
reproductive choices and need to be informed about effective reversible meth-
ods (Leone and Hinde, 2005; Tamkins, 2004).
142 Birth Control, Abortion, and Culture
Source: Data compiled from information from “Trends in Contraceptive Use Worldwide 2015,”
United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs Population Division, 2015.
1) Male Condoms
FDA approval: Latex: before approval required/Polyurethane: 1989,
cleared; 1995, marketed.
Side effects and health risks: May develop an allergic reaction
especially to people with latex. If either partner is allergic to latex use
polyurethane condom.
Protection from STIs: Best protection against STIs except for ab-
stinence. Very effective in preventing HIV when used consistently and
correctly.
Failure rate (births per one hundred women)a: Eleven1,2
Convenience: Placed in position before intercourse and worn during
intercourse then immediately discarded.
Availability: No doctor’s visit. Free or low cost from health depart-
ment or drugstore.
2) Female Condoms
FDA approval: 1993
Side effects and health risks: Irritation or may develop allergic reac-
tion to material (usually not serious).
Protection from STIs: Protection from STIs and HIV transmission;
not as safe as a male latex condom.
Failure rate (births per one hundred women)a: Twenty-one
Convenience: Used immediately before and worn during intercourse.
Availability: No doctor’s visit.
7) Spermicide Alone
FDA approval: Before approval required. Since November 2002, only
one active ingredient has been allowed.
Side effects and health risks: May cause allergic reactions and gen-
ital irritation or rash. May develop urinary tract infection. Skin rash.
Protection from STIs: While the spermicide kills the sperm, there
is no evidence it protects against STIs or HIV. Spermicide may irritate
vaginal tissue and can increase the risk for HIV.
Failure rate (births per one hundred women)a: twenty to fifty
Convenience: Time differential for applying depending on type cho-
sen. Can be used as part of sex play. Can be messy.
Availability: No doctor’s visit required.
breast tenderness. In extreme cases, the drug can lead to blood clots,
heart attacks, strokes, gallbladder disease, or liver tumors.
Protection from STIs: None
Failure rate (births per one hundred women)a: Less than one
Convenience: Extremely effective. One injection every month. A woman
can attempt a pregnancy after being off the injections for three months.
Availability: Must visit the doctor for the injection.
Failure rate (births per one hundred women)a: Less than one
Convenience: Device is inserted by minor surgery into the vagina
by catheter. Scar tissue forms in fallopian tubes preventing conception.
Another birth control method must be used for three months or until
confirmation of placement.
Availability: Doctor’s visit and surgery.
22) Abstinence
FDA approval: NA
Side effects and health risks: None
Protection from STIs: Yes, as long as all forms of sex are abstained from.
Failure rate (births per one hundred women)a: None
Convenience: May be difficult to maintain long term.
Availability: Free. Does not require doctors or devices.
23) Withdrawal
FDA approval: NA
Side effects and health risks: May not withdraw in time. Pre-
ejaculate may contain viable sperm. Most practice withdrawal at each
sexual encounter.
Protection from STIs: None
Failure rate (births per one hundred women)a: Twenty-two
Convenience: Ineffective as birth control.
Availability: Free. Does not require doctors or devices.
24) Breastfeeding
FDA approval: NA
Side effects and health risks: Takes time and energy. May lower vag-
inal lubrication during sex, which can cause pain.
152 Birth Control, Abortion, and Culture
Notes
a These statistics do not note the distinction between theoreti-
cal effectiveness rate and actual/use effectiveness rate. In se-
lecting a method of birth control, these distinctions should be
explored.
1 Projected from six-month study and adjusted for use of emergency
contraception.
2 If spermicides are used with barrier methods, be sure that the sper-
micide is compatible with the condom or diaphragm (will not cause
it to weaken or break). Oil-based lubricants (such as petroleum jelly
or baby oil) will cause latex to weaken and should not be used with
these methods.
3 Spermicides used alone, with barrier devices, or with condoms
can cause irritation to the skin lining of the vagina, especially
when the spermicide is used frequently. There is a possibility that
spermicide might increase the risk of acquiring some sexually
transmitted diseases because of rupture of the vaginal skin. Sper-
micide has not been proven to be effective against bacteria and
viruses in people. Therefore, there is no reason to use spermicide
during pregnancy.
4 Medications for vaginal yeast infections may decrease effectiveness
of spermicides.
5 Less effective for women who have had a baby because the birth
process stretches the vagina and cervix, making it more difficult to
achieve a proper fit.
Birth Control, Abortion, and Culture 153
In nonindustrialized societies availability of the methods described in Box
8.1 is expanding as a result of international family planning programs, govern-
ment programs, NGOs, and other organizational efforts. However, “traditional”
methods for birth control are still utilized in nonindustrialized societies among
ethnic, indigenous, and migrant populations and may coexist and/or be cultur-
ally fused with more traditional methods. For the sake of convenience and sim-
plicity we use the term “traditional” to refer to indigenous, ethnic, and cultural
practices prior to and coexistent with industrialized methods of birth control.
There are significant differences in the availability of industrialized methods
of birth control between rich and poor countries (Potts, 2003: 93). For instance:
• More than 200 million people throughout the world lack access to a full
range of family planning services (Planned Parenthood Global, 2019).
• More than 10 percent of married women around the world actively want
to use family planning but lack access to the contraceptives, information,
and services that would make that possible (World Family Planning High-
lights, 2017).
• Due to an increase in the number of women in their reproductive years,
the absolute number of women in need of family planning has increased
by 20 million between 2000 and 2020, (“World Family Planning High-
lights 2020,” 2020).
• The number of married or in-union women using contraception is pro-
jected to rise by 15 million globally, from 778 million in 2017 to 793 mil-
lion in 2030. The growth in the number of contraceptive users is projected
to be especially fast in Africa and Southern Asia. Globally, the number
of married or in-union women with an unmet need for family planning
is projected to decline slightly, from 142 million in 2017 to 130 million in
2030 (World Family Planning Highlights, 2017).
The United Nations reported on world contraceptive use in 2015 and has iden-
tified some distinct differences between industrialized and nonindustrialized na-
tions (note many agencies, organizations, and scholars use the term “developed”
and “developing nations”). Refer to Table 8.1. This information was collected
on contraceptive use by women between the ages of fifteen and forty-nine who
are married or in consensual unions. Selected trends from this research found:
Country Gross national Maternal deaths Adult HIV Unmet need for
income per 100,000 live prevalence rate family planning (%);
per capita births in 2017 (%) in 2018 women ages 15–49
2018 (US$) (2005–2014)
Sources: Compiled from “GNI per Capita” and “Prevalence of HIV,” World Bank, 2018; “UNICEF
Maternal Mortality Rates,” 2017; Sedgh et al., 2016, Guttmacher Institute.
• The pill and female sterilization have remained the most prevalent meth-
ods since 1982.
• The pill is most preferred in younger women, never-married, and
college-educated women.
Birth Control, Abortion, and Culture 155
• Sterilization is most common among women over thirty-five, married, or
previously married, living below 150 percent of the federal poverty level,
and those without a college education.
• Sterilization is the leading method among black and Hispanic women,
while the pill is the leading method for white women.
• Fifty percent of all women aged forty to forty-four who practice contra-
ception have been sterilized (“National Survey of Family Growth,” 2017).
• Women in their teens and twenties are more likely to rely on the inject-
able method than are older women.
• Women aged twenty-five to twenty-nine are more likely than women in
other age groups to rely on the implant or IUD.
• Women who have used the injectable increased from 5 percent in 1995 to
23 percent in 2006–2010; the patch increased from less than 1 percent in
2002 to 10 percent in 2006–2010, and 6 percent had used the contracep-
tive ring in 2006–2010 (the first time it was included in surveys).
• 5.5 million women use barrier contraceptives, such as the male condom.
• Condom use is most prevalent among teenagers, twenty to twenty-four-
year-olds, childless women, and never-married women (“Fact Sheet: Con-
traceptive Use in the United States,” 2018).
There is no scientific or medical reason for the eighteen and older age re-
striction that the FDA has imposed on obtaining non-prescription Plan B.
Studies show that increased access to EC does not cause teen promiscuity or
other health risk behaviors. And top FDA officials have privately acknowl-
edged that the age restriction is a political concession to conservative activ-
ists who have been fighting to keep barriers to contraception access in place.
(“Plan B: One Step Forward, Two Steps Back,” 2006)
Abortion
Contemporary methods of abortion include surgical abortions and medical
abortions. Generally, medical problems arising from abortions are few if con-
ducted by trained professionals in hygienic environments; less than 1 percent
of all abortions in United States incur complications. The risk of death due
to abortion is less than one-tenth as large as the risk of childbirth; roughly
less than 0.6 per 100,000 procedures. Furthermore, abortions do not increase
a woman’s future health risk for other pregnancies and there is no increased
incidence of infertility, miscarriages, tubal, or cervical pregnancies or breast
cancer (“Abortion,” 2006; Waxman, 2004). In countries where abortions are
illegal, 47,000 women a year die from complications, and many more have
their health compromised by unsafe conditions (“Safe and Unsafe Induced
Abortion: Global and Regional Levels in 2008, and Trends During 1995–
2008,” 2012).
The majority of abortions, about 90 percent, occur during the first trimester,
with 56 percent prior to the eighth week (“Abortion,” 2006; “Get in the Know:
20 Questions about Pregnancy, Contraception and Abortion,” 2006; “Who
Gets Abortions” 1990: G1). The vacuum aspiration method is the most com-
mon first trimester technique. This method involves the insertion of a tube
into the cervix. The tube is attached to a hand-held device or a suction ma-
chine that withdraws the endometrial tissues from the uterus. In the manual
vacuum aspiration method (MVA), the tissues from the uterus are gently suc-
tioned through a hand-held device. This method may be used as early as three
weeks and up to approximately seven weeks after the last menstrual period.
Between six and twelve weeks, the machine suction procedure is preferred.
For these first trimester pregnancies later than six weeks, local anesthetic and
dilation of the cervix is performed along with suction. Dilation of the cervix
may include insertion of an absorbent material the evening before which en-
hances the stretching of the cervix. As with the dilation and evacuation (D
Birth Control, Abortion, and Culture 165
and E) procedure (discussed as follows), medication and/or the use of dilation
rods may also be incorporated. In addition to either the MVA or machine
suction, the use of a curette to further evacuate the uterine walls may also be
used if suction alone was not enough (referred to as dilation and curettage or
D and C); although this approach is seldom used during the first trimester but
somewhat later (weeks twelve to fifteen). The benefit of the vacuum aspiration
method is that it takes only ten minutes and is done on an outpatient basis
under a local anesthetic requiring only a few hours of recuperation in a clinic
(“Abortion,” 2006; Goldberg et al., 2004; Hyde, 1985: 266).
Second trimester abortion rates drop dramatically with only 10 percent oc-
curring during this period with the most prevalent method that of dilation and
evacuation (D and E) (“D&E Abortion Bans: The Implications of Banning
the Most Common Second-Trimester Procedure,” 2017; “Second-Trimester
Abortions Concentrated Among Certain Groups of Women,” 2011). Dila-
tion and evacuation combines the vacuum aspiration method with elements
of dilation and curettage (D and C). D and E may include the insertion of
an absorbent material that dilates the cervix. The dilation material is usually
inserted the night before the procedure is performed to facilitate the absor-
bent material in gradually stretching open the cervix. Medications used either
alone or in conjunction with dilators (rodlike devices) may also be incorpo-
rated. During the D and E, the patient is sedated or given IV medication as
well as numbed locally; the dilator material is removed followed by evacuation
of the uterus using suction and medical instruments (such as the curette) to
clean the uterine walls further. The procedure takes between ten and twenty
minutes. Dilation and evacuation is the preferred method for second trimester
abortions (weeks thirteen to twenty-four) and even third trimester abortions
because of the safety, efficacy, and time efficiency involved in this procedure.
Only about 1 percent of late-term abortions occur after the twentieth week
with less than one-tenth of 1 percent occurring at the twenty-fourth week and
then only if the mother’s health is at risk (“Abortion,” 2006; Westheimer and
Lopater, 2005).
Another but infrequently used option for late-term pregnancy termination
is the induction method. This method is seldom used and only when there
is a severe medical problem in the mother or fetus during the latter part of
the second trimester or into the third trimester. Medications are injected into
the amniotic sac and the vagina to cause contractions and the expulsion of the
nonliving embryonic tissues; these medications include prostglandin, saline
and/or other substances (“Abortion,” 2006; “Planned Parenthood,” 2006).
Hormonal methods of abortion, also referred to as medication abortions,
are another choice for women but currently are limited to the first trimester of
pregnancy. One type of medication uses the drug mifepristone (Mifeprex) as
an abortificant. It is known more popularly in the United States as RU 486.
This method is effective in the first two months of pregnancy and is 95–97
percent successful if used with misoprostol, a prostglandin. This protocol was
tested on 2,000 women in the United States in the fall of 1994 (American
166 Birth Control, Abortion, and Culture
Health, 1994: 8). Mifepristone works by inducing menstruation and prevent-
ing implantation in women who suspect fertilization by interfering with the
production of progesterone and causing the lining of the uterus to slough. A
second medication, misoprostol, is taken three days following mifepristone
causing the cervix to soften and the uterus to contract thereby prompting a
miscarriage in the early stages of gestation (“Abortion,” 2006; Dowie, 1991:
137–140; Hall, 1989: 44; “Historical Information on Mifepristone,” 2006; King,
2005; Klugman, 1993: 59).
Mifepristone was originally produced by a French company and accepted
for use in 1988. It was not approved in the United States until 2000 amidst
substantial controversy. It is authorized by the federal Food and Drug Admin-
istration to terminate pregnancy up to forty-nine days after the last menstrual
cycle. Other countries have adopted it although not without controversy; the
United Kingdom and Sweden approved it in 1991, Germany in 1992 and other
European countries by 1999. Currently it is available in approximately sixty
countries and it has been proven safe with few adverse reactions and compli-
cations (“Questions and Answers on Mifeprex,” US Food and Drug Adminis-
tration, 2019). However, some research indicates it has more side effects than a
surgical abortion, although 90 percent of the women in one study stated they
would opt for it again (Jones and Henshaw, 2002; “RU 486 Non-Surgical/Med-
ical Abortion,” 2006). In France it is used in about one-third of the abortions.
Figures for the United States indicate it is increasingly used, from 5 percent
of the abortions in 2001 to 24 percent in 2004 (“Get in the Know: Medi-
cation Abortion, 2006). Anti-abortion advocates are against the legal use of
mifepristone (“Historical Information on Mifepristone,” 2006). Mifepristone is
relatively fast acting and produces a medical abortion within a week in 92 per-
cent of the cases with 95–97 percent effectiveness within two weeks. The side
effects include cramping, bleeding, and clotting (“Abortion,” 2006; “Abortion
Information,” 2006).
Methotrexate is another drug commonly used in the United States that pro-
duces the same effect as mifepristone; it is followed by misoprostol about five
days later. Methotrexate is an injection that inhibits reproductive growth and
can be used up to the ninth week of gestation. It is FDA approved but is used
off label as an abortificant and is effective 90–97 percent of the time (“Abor-
tion,” 2006; Westheimer and Lopater, 2005). With methotrexate/misoprostol,
approximately 75 percent of the abortions are completed within a week, but in
15–20 percent of the women it can take up to four weeks (“Abortion,” 2006;
“Abortion Information,” 2006).
In the United States abortion is a hotly debated issue framed in diverse terms
such as choice, life, personhood, and reproductive rights reflecting heteroge-
neous scholarly, religious, political, biological, and philosophical perspectives.
The cultural meaning surrounding birth control methods such as abortion
have varied considerably through time and across cultures. Worldwide and
throughout history women everywhere have always been interested in hav-
ing some control over their reproductive lives, whether it was to ensure and
Birth Control, Abortion, and Culture 167
manage fertility, space births, or control the number of births and offspring.
A cultural constructionist perspective will allow us to better understand this
current controversy. Cross-culturally and historically there is considerable
variation regarding when a blastocyst, embryo, fetus, neonate, or infant has
been socially recognized as human and achieved personhood (Morgan, 1996).
The anti-abortion camps in the United States have focused on creating “fetal
personhood” and hence fetal rights (i.e., to life). Those sectors that support
a woman’s right to choose whether to terminate a pregnancy focus on wom-
en’s reproductive rights, and their sexual and reproductive autonomy. Cross-
culturally the possible approaches to defining humanity and personhood are
much further-reaching than the perspectives currently taken in the United
States (Morgan, 1996). Notions of abortions and fetal personhood are related
to wider socio-cultural patterns including the status of women, social stratifica-
tion, gender ideologies, beliefs about the life cycle and bodies, mythology, the
sacred world, and other features of social life including the family and kinship
(Morgan, 1996; Ward and Edelstein, 2006).
For an example of how abortion is embedded in the socio-cultural matrix,
we need look no further than our own history. Before the nineteenth century,
it was a woman’s decision regarding termination of a pregnancy that was made
up to the time of the quickening, when she first felt fetal movements, at about
four months of pregnancy. Abortificants (drugs for abortions) were widely ad-
vertised and available; reflecting the pre-nineteenth-century belief that life
began when the child moved, not at conception (Crandon, 1986: 471). “In
1800 there was not, so far as is known, a single statute in the United States
concerning abortion” (“Abortion in American History,” 1990: 8). However,
over the next one hundred years abortion became illegal in every state, with
the only exception allowed if the woman’s life was endangered. This may be
partially attributed to the efforts of the newly formed American Medical As-
sociation’s desire to legitimize and co-opt the maternal/female body as territory
that had previously been under the control of women and midwives. Accord-
ing to the medical view, only physicians were sufficiently informed to know
when abortions were necessary and justified (Crandon, 1986: 471). Until the
1960s, women were excluded from equal entry into medical schools, thereby
ensuring that women had no voice in this issue until Roe v. Wade (“Abortion
in American History,” 1990: 8).
The controversy surrounding abortion in the United States is represented
by two dominant perspectives: Pro Choice and Pro Life. The Right-to-Life
(Pro-Life) position argues that the blastocyst/embryo/fetus is a human life
from the moment of conception and has the right to life regardless of the
health risk, societal bias, and personal cost to the woman. The Pro-Choice
position believes that the woman has the right to autonomy over her repro-
duction and that women’s reproductive rights should prevail. In 1973 in the
landmark case of Roe v. Wade, the US Supreme Court, ruled seven to two that
a woman could decide (with her physician) to terminate a pregnancy in the first
trimester and that the state could not interfere with that right. The judgment
168 Birth Control, Abortion, and Culture
also allowed for second trimester abortions (Renzetti and Curran, 2003). Ironi-
cally, the Roe v. Wade decision set a standard for future government interest in
the rights of the fetus during the third trimester (Lacayo, 1990: 23). Although
Roe v. Wade has been held up by the Supreme Court in various challenges,
anti-choice supporters have been successful in putting limits on access to abor-
tion for some women, especially teenage, poor, and rural women at the state
level. For example, in July 1989, the Supreme Court ruled in favor of Webster
v. Reproductive Health Services. A Missouri law allowed states to deny Med-
icaid funds for abortions as well as facilities for abortion and required doctors
to test for fetal viability at twenty weeks (potential of fetus to survive outside
the women’s body). The decision paved the way for states to pass laws limiting
and restricting abortions in a variety of other ways (Carlson, 1990: 16; March
E-News, 2006; Renzetti and Curran, 2003).
The election of President Bill Clinton and a Democratic pro-choice plat-
form subsequently resulted in greater government support of the Roe v. Wade
decision. However, Clinton’s successor, George W. Bush, voiced his opposition
to abortion and passed legislation to undermine Roe v. Wade in several ways.
This included a global gag rule that denied funding to any international agen-
cies that provided information on abortion or abortion services. This presi-
dential mandate was first implemented by Ronald Reagan (1984), endorsed
by George Bush (I), subsequently overturned by Clinton (1993), and then re-
instated by the George W. Bush administration in 2001 on the anniversary of
Roe v. Wade. Since George W. Bush, other legislation has followed whose goal
is to undermine Roe v. Wade and to create a culture supporting fetal person-
hood over the reproductive rights of the woman. This legislation is backed by
far-right fundamentalist Christian leaders, their followers, and conservative
legislators who seek the support of this constituency. Anti-choice legislation in
some states has sought to limit women’s access to abortion by requiring coun-
seling, waiting periods prior to abortion, parental permission, and parental no-
tification before abortion can be performed. These laws are regarded as part of
a political strategy to lay the groundwork for restricting women’s reproductive
freedom and eventually overturning Roe v. Wade. While these tactics do limit
the number of abortions in a given state, the abortion rates of adjacent states
increase (“An Overview of Abortion in the United States,” 2003). In 2003,
George W. Bush proposed the “Partial Birth Abortion Ban” to outlaw proce-
dures as early as twelve to fifteen weeks of pregnancy. Federal judges ruled the
law unconstitutional (Harrison, 2004).
At the end of the Obama presidency (2009–2017), CNN reported that the
abortion rate in the United States had reached its lowest level since the Roe v.
Wade decision in 1973 (Siemaszko, 2017). This decline was at least in part due
to fewer unintended pregnancies (“Abortion Incidence and Service Availabil-
ity in the United States, 2014,” Guttmacher Institute, 2017). President Barack
Obama supported the Roe v. Wade decision and women’s right and freedom to
make decisions about their own bodies and health (The White House Office
of the Press Secretary, 2016). As a result, he ended the ban on federal funds
for international groups that perform or provide information about abortions
Birth Control, Abortion, and Culture 169
Table 8.3 Laws and abortion policies by statea as of November 2019
• Support for abortion per trimester is equal for men and women, but dif-
fers by age, education, and party affiliation, with young adults, college-
educated adults, and Democrats being more supportive.
Birth Control, Abortion, and Culture 171
• Eighty-three percent think abortion should be legal in the first trimester
if the mother’s life is at risk, and 77 percent approve if the pregnancy was
caused by rape or incest.
• Twenty-five percent are against abortion in the third trimester even if the
mother’s life is at risk.
• Sixty-seven percent support abortion in the first trimester if the child’s life
is at risk (48 percent in the third trimester).
• Fifty-six percent support abortion in the first trimester if the child would
be born mentally disabled (35 percent in the third trimester).
• Forty-five percent support abortion in the first trimester when the woman
does not want the child for any reason (20 percent in the third trimester).
(“Trimesters Still Key to U.S. Abortion Views,” 2018)
A 2019 Pew Research Center report corroborates the Gallup poll numbers. It
notes that 61 percent of US adults support legal abortion in all or most cases,
and 31 percent say it should be illegal in all or most cases (“Public Opinion
on Abortion” 2019). Considerable research substantiates that most Americans
do not want Roe v. Wade overturned (“About seven-in-ten Americans oppose
overturning Roe v. Wade,” 2017; de Pinto, 2019).
Race/Ethnicitya,c
White 82,889 67.7 29,683 24.2 3,056 2.5 1,880 1.5
Black 70,937 59.1 36,360 30.3 3,982 3.3 2,350 2.0
Other 20,448 70.3 6,252 21.5 742 2.6 462 1.6
Hispanic 42,110 67.5 14,970 24.0 1,704 2.8 944 1.5
Total 216,384 64.8 87,265 26.1 9,484 2.8 5,635 1.7
women have an abortion rate of 27.1 per 1,000 women, followed by Hispanic
women at 18.1, non-Hispanic Others at 16.3, and non-Hispanic whites at 10.0
(Jones and Jerman, 2017). See Table 8.4. How do women feel about having an
abortion? Research has found that the majority of women feel a huge sense of
relief, and are not, in fact, traumatized by the experience. Although many may
experience ambivalence, sadness, and guilt in their decision making, research
shows that 95 percent of women who have had an abortion felt it was the right
decision when asked three years later (Rocca et al., 2013). Women who did ex-
perience psychological problems afterward were likely to have had emotional
problems prior to the abortion (“Abortion and Mental Health,” American
Psychological Association, 2019; Steinberg et al., 2014). There is no scientific
Birth Control, Abortion, and Culture 173
evidence that having an abortion leads to psychological/emotional disorders.
In fact, Gilligan (1982) argues:
Abortion rates are higher in countries where it is illegal. See Table 8.5. Ward and
Edelstein propose that women “will do anything” to have control over fertility
and childbearing—even pursue an illegal abortion (2006). That they will pursue
abortions under unsafe and illegal conditions testifies to the anguish women feel
in having an unintended pregnancy. In fact, science shows that women who are
denied abortion are more likely to experience psychological distress than women
who receive an abortion (“Abortion and Mental Health,” 2019; Rocca et al., 2014).
Source: Boonstra et al., 2006, “Abortion in the United States Today”, “Global Illegal Abortion:
Where There Is No ‘Roe’,” Planned Parenthood; “The World’s Abortion Laws,” Center for Re-
productive Rights.
a Although abortion law reform may expand or reduce access to abortion, this may not impact
the classification of the country’s status as liberal or restricted.
174 Birth Control, Abortion, and Culture
Aside from Eastern Europe, Ireland is also a special case in our discussion of
illegal abortion in industrialized nations. Up until 2018, Ireland banned abor-
tion except when the mother’s life was endangered. Abortion was first made
Birth Control, Abortion, and Culture 175
illegal in 1861, and in 1983 a constitutional amendment was passed granting
the fetus the right to life, meaning it had equal right to life as the mother.
The consequences of this were that between 1980 and 2004 at least 117,673
(Irish) women traveled to Great Britain to have abortions, with estimates of
approximately 6,000 a year. Other findings suggest that Irish women may have
traveled to other European Union countries where abortions were less expen-
sive than in England (“Abortion Law in Ireland: A Brief History,” 2006; “Irish
Abortion Statistics,” 2006; “Submissions of the Irish Family Planning Asso-
ciation to the UN Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination Against
Women,” 2005). In 2018, the Irish repealed the eighth Amendment to the
Irish Constitution (the right-to-life amendment) in a referendum, with a land-
slide 66 percent of voters rejecting the amendment. As of January 1, 2019,
abortion is legal in Ireland up to twelve weeks of pregnancy (after a three-day
waiting period), as well as in cases where the mother’s life or health are at risk,
and in cases of fatal fetal anomalies (“History of Abortion in Ireland,” Irish
Family Planning Association, 2018).
Several trends emerge from this discussion of abortion. High rates of abor-
tion are found in countries where women lack information and access to
controlling reproduction; in many countries, women lack the personal and
political power to implement family planning strategies as well. Low abortion
rates, such as occur in the Netherlands, are correlated with widespread acces-
sibility to comprehensive sexuality education. Although it is important for the
world’s women to have the option of abortion as one strategy to limit unin-
tended pregnancies and provide them with autonomy over their reproductive
choices, it would be preferable for women to have affordable and effective birth
control rather than the more medically intrusive abortion.
Grimes et al. (2006) refer to the international scope of unsafe abortion as “the
preventable pandemic,” which can be mitigated by legal, safe, and accessible
abortion. They attribute “[t]he underlying causes of this global pandemic [to]
apathy and disdain for women; they suffer and die because they are not valued”
(2006: 1).
Sex does not guarantee conception; conception does not lead relentlessly
to birth; and birth does not compel the mother to nurse and protect the
newborn. Cultures have evolved learned techniques and practices that
can prevent each step in this process from occurring.
In our discussion of the cross-cultural context for birth control, we will empha-
size ethnographic research both classic and contemporary. This spans a wide
timeframe including research on indigenous societies prior to contact with
colonizing countries, post contact, and contemporary indigenous and ethnic
communities within a global context, at various points in time. Methods of
birth control have a long history and tremendous variety since people have
been interfering with reproduction prior to the invention of twentieth/twenty-
first-century methods like the pill, although methods like IUDs certainly have
their antecedents. Earlier we discussed birth control in industrializing nations.
Here we focus on preindustrial and indigenous peoples. It is important that we
approach this subject with the lens of cultural relativism because some of the
methods used to control fertility and births, manage birth spacing and popula-
tion include methods that challenge industrial ideologies, beliefs, and values,
such as infanticide and abortion.
In this regard, the terminology “traditional methods” needs explication.
Various industrialized national and international organizations such as the
United Nations and researchers who study fertility, birth, and population con-
trol define traditional methods as “non-technological and less effective than
more recently invented methods such as the oral contraceptive pill” (Hirsch
and Nathanson, 2001: 413). This dichotomy represents an etic approach and
not one necessarily used emically (Hirsch and Nathanson, 2001). Moreover,
the notion that some of the traditional methods are “ineffective” has been
challenged by research on various contraceptive herbs, as well as the predeces-
sors to modern methods such as IUDs and abortificants. With this caveat in
mind, we use the term “traditional” method for convenience and to emphasize
preindustrial practices to avoid impregnation, control birth spacing, births,
and offspring. However, this does not mean that women have not engaged in
practices that were not only ineffective; for example, Plains Indians wore a
contraceptive charm known as a “snake-girdle” made of beaded leather over
the navel (Gregersen, 1983: 291), but some were also dangerous. In this regard,
Ward and Edelstein (2006: 77) note: “It is clear from all the ethnographic and
historic accounts we have that human desire for controlling the life stream is
universal; it transcends time and space.” Much of the knowledge and practices
for controlling fertility, number of births, and birth spacing is women’s secret
and sacred knowledge, shared by networks of women and passed on through
generations. The lengths women will go to control their fertility have been
178 Birth Control, Abortion, and Culture
and are extraordinary; prior to Roe v. Wade, US women exposed themselves to
infection and even death in order to have illegal abortions, as many do today
in countries where abortion is illegal. As noted earlier, Ward and Edelstein
(2006: 81) refer to this as the “women will do anything” principle in order to
have control of their reproductive lives.
Worldwide traditional methods are still practiced in industrialized, indus-
trializing and nonindustrialized countries. The United Nations defines tradi-
tional methods as including prolonged abstinence, breast feeding (lactational
amenorrhea), douching, and various other folk methods. The data aggregated
by country/region for use of traditional methods are as follows: Africa (2
percent); Asia (less than 1 percent); Europe (1 percent); Latin America and
the Caribbean (1 percent); North America (1 percent); Australia and New
Zealand (0 percent); and Oceania (Melanesia, Micronesia, and Polynesia) (3
percent) (figures rounded to nearest percentage point, data from “UN Trends
in Contraceptive Use Worldwide 2015,” 2015).
However, indigenous and pre-industrial methods include a far wider array
than that defined by the United Nations as “traditional” or “folk” methods.
For example, coitus interruptus is the predominant method found cross-
culturally (Gregersen, 1994; Harris, 1989), but it is not defined by the UN as
an indigenous or folk method since it is also used by modern industrialized
and industrializing people, including US teenagers. (See earlier discussion for
worldwide statistics on this usage in more industrialized and less industrialized
countries.) As noted earlier, this method’s effectiveness is limited, with 25 out
of 100 women using this technique conceiving within a year (King, 2005).
Cross-cultural examples illustrate how cultural meanings define and permeate
this practice. For example, in East Bay, a Southwest Pacific people studied by
William Davenport, abstinence from marital coitus was the preferred method
for controlling birth spacing, while coitus interruptus was the technique used
in extramarital relationships (Davenport, 1977).
The cross-cultural and historical records reveal numerous other ethno-
theories and practices. Various indigenous peoples use techniques to expel
the semen after intercourse with ejaculation; for example, the Kavirondo
and Zande rely on body movement such as standing and shaking after inter-
course (Gregersen, 1994: 83, 290–291). This is not unlike the sexual folklore
among some college students that standing up immediately after sex reduces
the chance of conception. Other approaches have emphasized the avoidance
of intercourse and timing of intercourse through the use of postpartum sex
taboos that last from two to five years. Alternatives to intercourse with ejac-
ulation have included mutual masturbation and “outercourse” methods that
avoid vaginal penetration (Ward and Edelstein, 2006).
Historical and cross-cultural research reports an abundance of contraceptive
and abortificant recipes of herbs, medicines, and potions used by the ancient
Greeks, Romans, Egyptians, and other preindustrial and indigenous peoples,
past and present (Kroeber, 1953: 248; Riddle, Estes, and Russell, 1994: 29–35;
Schneider, 1968: 365; Ward and Edelstein, 2006). For example, the demand for
Birth Control, Abortion, and Culture 179
Silphium, a plant in the parsley family, which was widely used by the Greeks
as a contraceptive and abortificant from the seventh century BC to the fourth
century AD, contributed to its extinction. The ancient and cross-cultural
record reveals a variety of herbs that inhibited conception and terminated
pregnancy including Queen Anne’s Lace, pennyroyal, willow, date palm,
pomegranate, and acacia gum. The effectiveness of the chemical properties
of these herbs in affecting fertility has been clinically demonstrated (Riddle,
Estes, and Russell, 1994: 29–35). According to Ward and Edelstein (2006: 78):
Recipes over the last seven thousand years recommend a wide variety of
oily, astringent, acidic, gummy or fibrous substances, alone or in combi-
nation. The bark and nuts of many kinds of trees provide tannic acid,
an astringent vegetable compound that is a remarkably effective spermi-
cide. Vinegar or ascetic acid, yogurt, honey, salt, butter and buttermilk
are also reported from China, India or the Middle East. The [women] of
history made tampons or contraceptive suppositories out of lint, cotton,
wool, silk, seaweed, or other common household fibers and absorbent sub-
stances. Any household spermicide could be used with a tampon or as a
douche for washing out the vagina. These were relatively effective and
easily available.
Modern sponges, barrier methods, and IUDs have their antecedents as well.
Women have placed various barriers against the cervix including beeswax, lard,
and tissues made of bamboo. IUDs were made of buttons, stone, and gems placed
in a woman’s uterus. Sponges soaked in spermicides such as lemon juice and
then placed against the cervix are one of the oldest and most effective methods.
As mentioned earlier, a diverse array of oral abortificants, recipes for contra-
ception and sterility were part of women’s culture (Ward and Edelstein, 2006).
In addition to these methods, women’s desire to control their reproduction
included other approaches and interventions such as abortion and infanticide.
In a cross-cultural study of preindustrial societies, George Devereux found that
464 groups practiced abortion (1967: 92–152). A variety of techniques was used
for abortion. Oral recipes for abortificants and emmenagogues challenge in-
dustrial emic and etic distinctions between encouraging a menstrual cycle to
occur and an abortion. An emmenagogue is a recipe that causes menstruation,
and in the process, it may include the termination of an early pregnancy by
inducing a miscarriage (Ward and Edelstein, 2006: 271). In this regard, Ward
and Edelstein assert: “Historic and ethnographic accounts make no sharp
distinction between contraception and abortion” (2006: 79). Cultures may
openly condone or condemn such forms of managing reproduction. Women
are placed in conflicted situations in those societies that simultaneously pre-
vent contraception and abortion.
Infanticide in which a neonate is allowed to die or is purposely killed has
primarily occurred in situations where survival of parents or the group is at
stake as in cases with overpopulation, or in times of scarce resources such
180 Birth Control, Abortion, and Culture
as famine. It also is found in indigenous cultures with strong gender prefer-
ences for males (see Chagnon, 1983; Divale and Harris, 1976; Harris, 1993;
Yanomamo discussed in greater depth). Morgan’s (1996) research has found
that it is also distinctly tied to cultural notions of humanness and personhood.
For example, on Truk, abnormal or deformed newborns were not defined as
human but rather as ghosts; they were burned or thrown into the sea. To the
Trukese a ghost was not a human and was not a person, therefore it could not
be actually killed. In such societies, neonates are not presumed to be born hu-
man, but must be conferred with humanity based on certain physical charac-
teristics. Once humanity is designated, then cultural ideologies of personhood
can come into play. For many societies, personhood is a process and an attri-
bute that is acquired and socially recognized. In the United States personhood
is not just ascribed at birth but has become part of a political and religious
philosophy that is accorded to fertilized eggs, blastocysts, embryos, and fetuses
(Morgan, 1996).
Preindustrial and indigenous women have employed a number of tech-
niques to engage in the control of births and reproduction. As discussed ear-
lier in this chapter, attitudes, beliefs, and birth control practices including
abortion are related to subsistence, economic, political, social, historical,
and religious factors among others. These are also linked to the gender sys-
tem including women’s status and power. We shall discuss several examples
highlighting the interrelationship of culture including ideologies, features of
social organization, and culture change to methods used for controlling re-
production. For example, how people make a living and methods of fertility/
birth control are interrelated. With plant cultivation, horticulture, and agri-
culture, population growth has occurred over the last 10,000 years. This has
resulted in an escalating system of sedentism; surplus; complexity of social
organization (ranking and hierarchy); centralization of authority; unequal
access to prestige, power, and resources; and the loss of status for women.
These features are related to issues of birth spacing, beliefs about family size,
the value of children to the household economy, and gender preferences for
children. There is a complex relationship between culture and the social sys-
tem that impacts birth control beliefs and practices. We shall offer three case
studies illustrating the biocultural basis for understanding the complex rela-
tionship of culture, reproduction, population, and social organization. Three
case studies – the Ju/wasi, the Yapese, and the Yanomamo – are used to illus-
trate these intersections.
Ju/wasi
Foragers (gatherers and hunters) are excellent examples of how culture shapes
biology in relation to population. One widely accepted anthropological theory
correlates sedentism (i.e., permanent residence due to plant cultivation) with
population expansion. This line of reasoning is supported by data from across
the ethnographic spectrum and includes evidence from the Ju/wasi (formerly
Birth Control, Abortion, and Culture 181
known as !Kung, or San, also known as Ju/’hoansi) peoples of the Kalahari
Desert (Robbins, 2006). The settlement of Ju/wasi into permanent villages
has provided evidence of the effects of sedentism on a previously foraging
population and, together with other lines of evidence, contributes to under-
standing the impact of sedentism on populations prehistorically/historically,
offering insight into environmental adaptation and demographics (Bates and
Fratkin, 2003).
The Ju/wasi, like tropical foragers in general, are known for small popula-
tions. A number of interacting factors are believed to contribute to this situ-
ation. Foragers have diets low in fat and high in protein, and, consequently,
they have less body fat than food cultivators. The critical fat theory (Frisch,
1978: 22–30) argues that fertility can be reduced in several ways by the low
body fat levels; most notably through adolescent sterility (introduced in Chap-
ter 11) and through the practice of extended lactation without supplemental
food sources. In order to ovulate, women need a certain amount of body fat,
minimally estimated at 15 percent. Body fat levels are influenced by extended
lactation which requires a great deal of caloric energy, and this combined with
a foraging lifestyle, keeps fertility and reproduction low among gatherers and
hunters. In contrast, plant cultivators, especially agriculturalists, can gener-
ate a large surplus of calories. Sedentism along with the increased calories
encourages higher body fat levels in women, counteracts trends for adoles-
cent sterility seen among foragers, and results in increased fertility and repro-
duction (i.e., population expansion associated with food producers especially
agriculturalists).
The critical level of fat storage necessary for menstruation and ovulation to
occur is about 150,000 stored calories of energy, enough “to permit a woman to
lactate for one year or more without having to increase her prepregnancy ca-
loric intake” (Lancaster, 1985:18). A period of subfertility for several years after
menarche exists among some foragers, but this declines in settled populations.
According to Lancaster (1985: 18): “Sedentism combined with high levels of
caloric intake leads to early deposition of body fat in young girls and ‘fools’ the
body into early biological maturation long before cognitive and social maturity
are reached.”
Foragers typically have other cultural practices that contribute to smaller
populations. One method is birth spacing (Ember, Ember, and Peregrine,
2005). Foragers who may roam over vast territory cannot afford to nurse and
carry more than one child who has not yet achieved the ability to walk compe-
tently. The Ju/wasi for example, have solved this dilemma by spacing children
about four years apart. Several cultural practices contribute to Ju/wasi birth
spacing. One of these is a long postpartum sex taboo that requires abstinence
from coitus for a minimum of a year. Foragers are well-known for long post-
partum sex taboos for women as a way to space and indirectly control births.
A correlation exists between societies that have long postpartum sex taboos
and those with low fertility rates (Ember, Ember, and Peregrine, 2005; Nag,
1962: 79).
182 Birth Control, Abortion, and Culture
Foragers with low body fat ratios can interrupt ovulation by prolonged nurs-
ing, which in turn contributes to keeping body fat levels low. “It is now well
established that the longer a mother nurses her baby without supplementary
foods, the longer the mother is unlikely to start ovulating again” (Ember, Em-
ber, and Peregrine, 2005: 168). Ju/wasi mothers nurse for two or three years
without the additional sources of food available to settled agriculturalists and
industrialists such as milk from domesticated animals or harvested grain. Lac-
tating females, in populations where body fat is low, are less likely to become
pregnant because ovulation is depressed (Ember, Ember, and Peregrine, 2005;
Kottak, 1991: 203).
Two other techniques that are used by foragers to control births are infanti-
cide and abortion. Hunters and gatherers practice abortion and are known for
their knowledge of pharmacology in which animal and plant poisons are used
to cause the fetus to miscarry (Gregersen, 1983: 291). Procedures include the
use of herbal treatments and toxic substances from animals, vigorously hitting
or manipulating the stomach through massage or squeezing, and having some-
one jump on the abdomen (Devereux, 1955; Gregersen, 1983: 290–291; Riddle
et al., 1994: 29–35; Sarvis and Rodman, 1974; Ward and Edelstein, 2006). In
addition, Devereux (1955) and Sarvis and Rodman (1974) report attempts to
abort the fetus through strenuous activity or through the use of devices or sub-
stances that are inserted into the uterus. These techniques may cause harm to
the mother and are dangerous but show the lengths that women will go to for
control of their reproductive lives (Ward and Edelstein, 2006).
Yapese
With regard to methods of abortion, David M. Schneider’s (1968: 383–406)
report and analysis of abortion on Yap, a Caroline Island in Micronesia, is a
classic ethnographic example of how beliefs, political economy, gender rela-
tions, and demographics intersect. Yap is an island that once supported 50,000
people. Yet, by 1945, the population had fallen dramatically to only 2,500. The
culture was one that was geared to a much larger population; consequently,
the population decline affected socio-political organization in that there were
no longer enough people to fill positions and perform necessary political func-
tions and services. This resulted in a generalized Yapese concern and desire for
more children. In spite of this, women continued the practice of self-abortions.
Self-induced abortions on Yap have, in fact, exacerbated the depopulation
problem since these also tended to occur “during the maximum years of fe-
cundity” (Schneider, 1968: 384). However, abortion may not have been the
sole cause of the continued depopulation of Yap as gonorrhea or possibly some
other diseases have undoubtedly contributed to the low fertility rate.
Given this situation, it is not surprising that self-induced abortion on Yap
was negatively sanctioned and kept secret, especially from the men. Because
abortions were objected to on moral grounds, Yapese women were under pres-
sure to remain secretive, lest they become known as aborters, which could
Birth Control, Abortion, and Culture 183
jeopardize their marriages or chances for marriage since men want and desire
children. To understand the perpetuation of abortion practices by women in
spite of depopulation, it is necessary to engage in a holistic analysis of Yapese
culture (i.e., one that considers all aspects of Yapese life). There were three
methods of self-induced abortions on Yap. According to Schneider (1968: 385):
The latter method can lead to infection and associated reproductive problems,
although medical reports suggest that the resulting infection is mild and not
life threatening.
Historically, Yapese population decline may be traced back to a period when
population had peaked. What is remarkable about this situation is that, de-
spite the serious depopulation that followed, Yap culture in its traditional form
has continued as an adaptation to a dense population; this is an example of
culture lag. Abortion was a part of this earlier adaptation and represented an
effective solution to an overpopulation problem at the time. However, the per-
sistence of abortion in the face of decline in population must be understood
in the context of the totality of the culture, including gender relations and
expectations. Abortion was tied directly to gender role expectations for Yapese
women over the life course.
Women up to the age of thirty do not want children because they would
no longer be free to fall in and out of love, to attract lovers, to have and
break off affairs at will, to practice the elaborate games of love and socia-
bility that appeal to young Yap men and women. They do not want to be
tied to a child and to a husband when they are in the best position to gain
and enjoy the rewards of being unattached … On Yap the standard and
available means of avoiding children is to induce abortion when preg-
nancy occurs.
(Schneider, 1968: 393)
After the age of thirty, however, women’s attitudes began to change and
the desire for children was accelerated. This coincides with the transition
from youth to adult status. In summary, abortion persisted on Yap in spite of
184 Birth Control, Abortion, and Culture
population decline because the period of youth was regarded as a time when
women have access to the rewards and pleasures of love affairs in a system in
which they will never achieve the prestige positions and rankings available
to men.
Infanticide cross-culturally also illustrates the complexity and necessity
for a holistic perspective in understanding birth control. This should not be
construed to mean that infanticide has not been practiced in industrialized
societies as a method of regulating unwanted births. It has! Historically, Eu-
ropeans favored indirect methods of infanticide such as overlaying (where a
mother “accidentally” suffocated her child by rolling over on it when in bed);
wet nurses whose reputations for infant care literally guaranteed that the child
would die; or foundling homes such as those in France between 1824 and 1833
where 336,297 children were abandoned. “Between 80 percent and 90 percent
of the children in these institutions died during their first year of life” (Harris,
1989: 214).
Infanticide as a method to control birth is found in a variety of forms around
the globe. It includes the indirect methods just discussed that are favored by
the Europeans and others such as the northeast Brazilians (Scheper-Hughes,
1992), or may include conscious systematic neglect, starvation, and/or environ-
mental exposure as more direct approaches. In many contexts and for many
reasons both personal and cultural (e.g., poverty, the desire to limit family size,
and gender preferences, among others), surreptitious infanticide may be the
only solution for the mother with an unwanted pregnancy (Harris, 1989: 211).
Reports of direct infanticide in non-technologically complex societies suggest
that between 53 percent and 76 percent of these societies allow for the practice
of this method. In such situations, the cultural conception of being a person,
a member of the family and the group is not given to newborns (Harris, 1989:
212, 214).
Yanomamo
Marvin Harris’s (1974, 1993) re-analysis of Napoleon Chagnon’s study of the
Yanomamo of Venezuela and Brazil is a classic work that illustrates how in-
fanticide relates to warfare and a male supremacy complex among tribal cul-
tivators. The Yanomamo represent a case study supporting a broader theory
by Divale and Harris (1976) whose cross-cultural correlational study of the
HRAF files proposes that warfare is the most common way for tribal culti-
vators to regulate populations. This happens in an indirect way through the
practice of female infanticide, rather than directly by male deaths due to war.
The thesis behind their argument is that in order for population size to be
controlled, the limiting factor must be females and not males. The idea behind
this is that one male can impregnate a number of females; therefore, societies
can afford to lose adult males without affecting their population. Warfare and
conflict encourage a strong preference for male children because they can be
raised into strong and aggressive warriors (Robbins, 2006).
Birth Control, Abortion, and Culture 185
At the time of Chagnon’s original research, the Yanomamo were a tribal
society of 15,000 living in 125 villages (Chagnon, 1983). They were originally
riverine Indians whose ancestors were pushed into a forest adaptation due to
population pressure and colonization. These Yanomamo became skilled hunt-
ers and engaged in shifting cultivation in the forest. About 400 years ago they
began cultivating plantains and as a result of this semi-sedentary existence
combined with additional calories supplied by the plantains, they experienced
a rapid population growth spurt. Eighty-five percent of the Yanomamo diet
was from the plantains and the bananas that they cultivated. This feature is
a central part of Harris’s (1993; and Divale and Harris, 1976) argument. In-
creased calories and sedentism offset natural mechanisms for birth spacing and
low population that we have seen operating in gatherers and hunters such as
the Ju/wasi. Plant cultivation, which provides more carbohydrates and higher
caloric intake than foraging, allows for earlier puberty, increased conception,
and generally a longer childbearing period.
According to Harris’s (1993) argument, shifting cultivation did not meet
Yanomamo needs for protein. As they became semi-settled cultivators, their
high carbohydrate diet and increased population led them to put increasing
pressure on the local game resources for protein. Anthropologist Brian Fer-
guson’s (2001) study of Yanomamo warfare adds some nuances to Harris’s the-
ory although they are generally on the same page in terms of the Yanomamo
preferences for males and the development of a male supremacy complex and
its role in female infanticide. Ferguson (2001) argues that the real impetus for
the Yanomamo warfare and aggression was the availability of Euro-American
manufactured goods in the 1950s and 1960s. For Ferguson, this is what led to
the creation of permanent settlements as Yanomamo founded anchor villages
near trading outposts. The establishment of these more permanent villages is
what Ferguson believes led to the depletion of game.
Both Harris and Ferguson agree that the development of a male supremacy
complex occurred in order to help create fiercer hunters and warriors in re-
sponse to the dwindling game. In addition, the growing populations who set-
tled in villages came into conflict over protein as a scarce resource which also
contributed to and escalated warfare. According to Ferguson, fierce aggressive
males were needed to protect and acquire manufactured goods as well. This
complex of warfare, hunting, and competition for manufactured goods placed
a premium on males, rather than females. In the history of the world, it is rare
for women to participate in warfare since this would make poor evolutionary
sense. The premium on males ultimately led to female infanticide as a method
for parents to select for sons over daughters. The Yanomamo preferred that
the firstborn was a son and practiced infanticide if a girl was the firstborn. Be-
cause Yanomamo females did not fight, hunt, and bring home the protein, they
were valued less than males. Female infanticide contributed to a population
inequity in the ratio of male to females; there were 449 males to 391 females
in seven villages studied by Chagnon (1983). This gender inequity perpetu-
ated fighting and raiding to acquire women from other villages which, in turn
186 Birth Control, Abortion, and Culture
escalated the warfare even further. The Yanomamo practiced polygyny so that
the best fighters and hunters could acquire several wives through the lure of
protein, rank, and prestige. Twenty-five percent of the men were polygynous.
This added fuel to the fire by creating an even greater shortage of women. In
this situation warfare operated as a way to disperse populations and relocate
them in the environment in order to temporarily relieve population pressure
on resources. Among tribal cultivators, warfare and the female infanticide
it engendered served as the primary mechanism to limit population (Harris,
1974; Kottak, 1991; Robbins, 2006).
As we have illustrated in this discussion of birth control in cross-cultural
context, sexual practices as well as fertility control are intricately tied to the
broader cultural system and articulate clearly with a number of cultural vari-
ables as well as ecological ones relating to demography, types of subsistence,
and adaptations. This chapter has covered much territory related to birth con-
trol and contraception. Contemporary birth control methods in industrialized
nations and nonindustrialized nations were discussed as well as methods used
throughout the ethnographic spectrum, illustrating the importance of a cul-
turally relativistic stance in understanding sex and reproduction.
Summary
1 Definitions for concepts related to birth control were offered including
contraception, population control, fertility, mortality, theoretical effec-
tiveness, and actual/use effectiveness rate and woman years.
2 Differences in population trends among industrialized and non-
industrialized nations were discussed.
3 Currently available methods of birth control in the United States were
presented.
4 Comparison of the prevalence, availability, and policy implications for
contraceptives in industrialized and nonindustrialized/industrializing na-
tions were provided.
5 The abortion controversy was discussed in the United States, other indus-
trialized nations, and nonindustrialized/industrializing nations.
6 Birth control was placed in cultural context: selected examples of indige-
nous contraceptive and birth control practices were provided.
7 Preindustrial examples of birth control including coitus interruptus, lac-
tation, abortion, and female infanticide were discussed, with an emphasis
on the Ju/wasi, Yapese, and Yanomamo.
Thought-Provoking Questions
1 Why is the birth control method of extended breastfeeding/lactational
amenorrhea not a reliable method for US women? Can you explain this?
2 What are your perspectives on the issue of abortion? Where did your
views on this issue come from? Is there any way that the Pro-Choice and
Anti-Choice perspectives can be reconciled?
Birth Control, Abortion, and Culture 187
Suggested Resources
Books
Carpenter, Laura M. 2005. Virginity Lost: An Intimate Portrait of First Sexual Experi-
ences. New York: New York University Press.
Boyer, Jesseca. 2018. “New Name, Same Harm: Rebranding of Federal Abstinence-Only
Programs.” Guttmacher Institute, Volume 21. https://www.guttmacher.org/
gpr/2018/02/new-name-same-harm-rebranding-federal-abstinence-only-programs.
Last accessed 9/4/19.
Riddle, John M. 1997. Eve’s Herbs: A History of Contraception and Abortion in the West.
Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Russell, Andrew, Elisa J. Sobo, and Mary S. Thompson, eds. 2000. Contraception across
Cultures: Technologies, Choices. Constraints. New York: Berg Press.
Sobo, Elisa Janine and Sandra Bell. 2001. Celibacy, Culture and Society: The Anthropol-
ogy of Sexual Abstinence. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.
Scherper-Hughs, N. 1992. Death Without Weeping: The Violence of Everyday Life in
Brazil. Berkeley: University of California Press. 1992.
World Family Planning 2017 Highlights.” United Nations Department of Economic and
Social Affairs. https://www.un.org/en/development/desa/population/publications/
pdf/family/WFP2017_Highlights.pdf. Last accessed 12/30/20.
World Family Planning 2020 Highlights.” United Nations Department of Economic
and Social Affairs. https://www.un.org/development/desa/pd/sites/www.un.org.devel-
opment.desa.pd/files/files/documents/2020/Sep/unpd_2020_worldfamilyplanning_
highlights.pdf. Last accessed 1/2/21.
Websites
“Abstinence-Only-Until-Marriage Programs are Ineffective and Harmful to Young Peo-
ple, Expert Review Confirms.” Guttmacher Institute, 2017. https://www.guttmacher.
org/news-release/2017/abstinence-only-until-marriage-programs-are-ineffective-and-
harmful-young-people.
“New Name, Same Harm: Rebranding of Federal Abstinence-Only Programs,” Gut-
tmacher Institute, 2018. https://www.guttmacher.org/gpr/2018/02/new-name-same-
harm-rebranding-federal-abstinence-only-programs.
Ott, Mary A. and John S. Santelli. 2007. “Abstinence and Abstinence-Only Educa-
tion.” Current Opinion in Obstetrics and Gynecology, 19(5): 446–452. https://www.
ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5913747/.
Planned Parenthood of America. http://www.plannedparenthood.org/. Last accessed
12/18/06.
9 Pregnancy and Childbirth
Chapter Overview
1 Examines pregnancy and childbirth as biological, psychological, and cul-
tural phenomena.
2 Views pregnancy and childbirth as a physiologically normal, healthy pro-
cess in which complications may occur.
3 Examines childbirth as the means to culturally create and extend kinship.
4 Examines male participation in the female experience of pregnancy and
childbirth.
5 Examines cultural responses to pregnancy, childbirth, and the postpar-
tum period.
6 Explains the stages of labor.
7 Explains the non-interventionist/interventionist birth continuum and
places US cultural birth practices along the continuum.
8 Discusses postpartum depression biologically, psychologically, and
culturally.
The Fetus
The humanness of the fetus is culturally defined. Currently, industrialized
countries’ interpretations of when the fetus becomes human are controversial,
and are the topics of intense debate relative to abortion and certain forms of
birth control. For example, since the 1980s, conservative religious groups in
the United States believe that human life begins at conception and take strong
Birthing Models
There are two general models developed as the cultural response to preg-
nancy: the interventionist and non-interventionist. These models exist on
a continuum, since all cultures intervene in the pregnancies and births of
their members. Those societies toward the non-interventionist end tend to
view pregnancy and birth as a natural phenomenon and emphasize the socio-
psychological dimensions over the physiological. In these societies, the well-
being of the mother and fetus is a primary concern with the expectation that
the woman needs support. The physical birth process, while long and “labori-
ous,” is generally believed to occur on its own timetable. This model is char-
acteristic of many societies outside the United States and the United States
prior to the late nineteenth century (Davis-Floyd, 2001; Fisher, Bowman, and
Thomas, 2003; “Midwives and Modernization,” 1981).
The interventionist model is characteristic of current US society, even
with the range of birthing alternatives available such as birthing centers,
family-centered childbirth, water births, and the increased use of midwives and
doulas. Adopted from the Greeks, doulas are women who provide support for
pregnant women throughout the pregnancy and early postpartum period. In
2017, over 98 percent of the births in the United States occurred in hospitals
(MacDorman and Declercq, 2019). Birth is primarily viewed as a biomedical
Pregnancy and Childbirth 195
phenomenon with a best-case and worst-case scenario (Davis-Floyd, 1988, 2001;
Janssen et al., 2002; Reibel, 2004). The interventionist view perceives childbirth
as inherently dangerous and prepares for the crisis situation as a general rule.
Thus, there is much medical and technological intervention in normal as well
as complicated births (Davis-Floyd, 1992, 2001; Reibel, 2004). This includes
routine use of internal and external fetal monitors to chart the fetal heartbeat,
episiotomies, and the use of IVs and drugs in the vast majority of births (Davis-
Floyd 2001; Jordan, 1983, 1993; Michaelson, 1988b; Reibel, 2004; Sargent and
Stark, 1989; Williams, 1989). It also reflects a rising caesarean rate of 31.9 per-
cent of the hospital births in this country in 2018 (Martin et al., 2019).
Cultures address pregnancy through the postpartum (post-birth) period in
a variety of ways. These include the role of the couvade, birth attendants,
birth practices, and breastfeeding customs. The couvade is a culturally created
bio-behavioral phenomenon in which the father can simulate the pregnancy
and birth of the woman who is bearing his child. Fathers may participate in
the rituals and ceremonies accompanying the birth. Birth attendants are
those people who take care of the woman during her labor, the birth of the
baby, and immediately after. Who these people are varies widely. Outside the
United States, they usually are female; they usually are known to the preg-
nant woman; and they may be midwives, women who are trained in pre- and
post-natal care and indigenous birthing practices. These women attend to the
socio-psychological and physical needs of the woman and her baby before,
during, and after birth (Faust, 1988; “Midwives and Modernization,” 1981;
“Quality of Midwifery Care Given Throughout the World,” 2000; Raphael,
1988; Semenic, Callister, and Feldman, 2004).
The following passage is a description of a birth in a Mayan community in
Latin America. It provides an interesting contrast to our biomedical approach.
Since the mid-nineteenth century in the United States, the entire birth pro-
cess has been increasingly medicalized, removed from the home and familiar
settings, and has become a mostly male-physician specialty.1 Hospitalization for
childbirth usually means the woman is in an unfamiliar, socially sterile, medical
environment, attended by a series of strangers. Although women may have a
number of friends or family with them during labor and birth in the United
States currently, the physiological aspects of pregnancy are emphasized over the
socio-psychological. Women are delivered in the United States; they do not give
birth. In nonindustrialized societies, the locus of control rests with the pregnant
woman; in the United States, control rests with her medical birth attendants
(Davis-Floyd, 1992, 2001; Martin, 1987). In many nonindustrialized societies,
birth attendants are integrated into the fabric of the woman’s life; in the United
States, they are distinct, discrete entities who act on her.
Examples of birth attendant-parturient woman relationships from Greece,
Latin America, and Egypt illustrate the importance of this role. The following
examples illustrate the shared characteristics of the birth attendants. These
older, experienced females may be involved in non-obstetric health care as
well. The birth attendants are known to the pregnant woman and are part of
her social support system. They provide her with care, advice, and guidance
from pregnancy through the postpartum period.
In Greece, this woman is called the doula. She is particularly helpful in
establishing a breastfeeding pattern and assisting the postpartum woman. She
gives advice, helps with the daily routine, and provides socio-emotional sup-
port in teaching the new mother how to breastfeed. She temporarily becomes
part of the new extended kin household (Raphael, 1988).
In Latin America, midwives are often called doña, a title of respect (Faust,
1988; Godziehen-Shedlin, 1981; Sukkary, 1981). These women take seriously
the overall health of their patients or clients, and frequently care for both
their gynecologic and obstetric needs. These midwives monitor diet, social
activity, and if government-trained, may record maternal blood pressure, fetal
heart rate, and other physical signs during pregnancy (Faust, 1988). In much
of Indian Latin America, pre- and postpartum massage and binding, in which
the woman’s abdomen is tightly wrapped, are part of prenatal and perinatal
care. This necessitates the midwife’s presence and her support of the pregnant
woman (Fuller and Jordan, 1981).
Egyptian midwives or dayas, also provide known, continuous pre- and post-
natal care. They stay with the new mother for seven days after birth, taking
Pregnancy and Childbirth 197
care of both her and the baby. As with the doula, dayas become part of the
extended kin household, more like a family member than an outsider (Suk-
kary, 1981).
Fathers have various degrees of involvement in the pregnancy. In some soci-
eties, the sociological role of the prebirth father is highly ritualized through the
couvade. He may “experience” morning sickness and labor, and undergo compa-
rable forms of food, activity, sexual taboos, and modifications of his daily routine
that the mother of his child incurs. The father may take to his hammock and ex-
perience simulated labor contractions during his partner’s birthing process. The
couvade is a cultural means of acknowledging and enjoining men to participate
actively in the pregnancy and birth phenomenon (Kottak, 1991; Raphael, 1988).
For most of the twentieth century in the United States, fathers were not al-
lowed to participate actively in pregnancy and birth. They were forbidden to be
with women during labor and birth. They were seen as economic contributors,
but not as interested, involved participants during the pregnancy. Since the mid-
to-late 1960s, childbirth advocates have actively encouraged greater participation
by fathers, extended kin, and friends. This has resulted in the involvement of a
greater number of fathers and others in women’s pregnancy, birth, and postpar-
tum care (Leavitt, 2003; Raphael, 1988). The father-involved childbirth move-
ment in the United States may serve some of the same functions as the couvade.
In the United States, some heterosexual couples talk about “our preg-
nancy,” and men wear a strap-on “pregnant-stomach” to simulate later
stages of pregnancy.
1 We have more girls under fifteen years of age giving birth than in other
industrialized societies. Younger adolescents have immature reproductive
tracts, tend to smoke more, and have poorer nutrition than older adoles-
cents and adults. These behaviors can result in more complicated preg-
nancies and births.
2 We have differential access to health care in this country; poorer people
get less health care and it is of poorer quality than found among mid-
dle-class, insured people.
3 Reproductive technology allows women to become pregnant who would
not otherwise, and older women (those in their forties getting pregnant
for the first time) who are pregnant have more complications.
4 Our interventionist approach to almost all births, not just those with
complications, results in more procedures such as C-sections that increase
the risk of complications.
Outside the United States, pain may be relieved with herbal remedies or talked
through. Childbirth pain is seen as normal and tolerable, part of a process to get
the baby born (Godziehen-Shedlin, 1981; Jordan, 1983, 1993; Newton, 1981).
Traditionally, episiotomies were unknown. The perineum stretches through
the upright birthing position, spontaneous rupture of the bag of water, mas-
sage, and hot compresses (Jordan, 1983, 1993). “Preps” are unknown and the
woman’s own clothing is usually worn. Babies and mothers are kept together
after birth; babies usually are nursed immediately and whenever they cry. It is
interesting that the counterpart of high-technology childbirth in the United
States, “family-centered childbirth,” advocates procedures and behaviors that
are common and widespread practices in cultures outside the United States.
These include recent “advances” such as birthing rooms and birthing chairs,
having women move around during labor, or having a childbirth coach present
to help the woman.2 Most recently, they include shorter hospital stays. Post-
partum infant-mother contact, a given in societies outside the United States, is
beginning to be re-established here through the practice of “rooming in,” where
for most of a twenty-four-hour period, the newborn and mother share a room.
Postpartum
The postpartum period, a bio-social event, extends from the birth of the baby
until the woman resumes her full pre-pregnancy roles and new status in the
society as a mother and adult. This may take several weeks, as in the United
Pregnancy and Childbirth 199
States, or longer in other societies such as the Ju/wasi where postpartum sexual
taboos last two to three years (Frayser, 1985; Murdock et al., 1965). Biologi-
cally, the woman’s body returns to a non-pregnant state: the uterus involutes,
and her menstrual cycle resumes, irregularly at first depending on whether she
nurses. Nursing is common outside the United States and engaged in sporad-
ically and for shorter periods of time in the United States. Nursing may in-
hibit ovulation when it lasts for greater than eighteen months, when it occurs
regularly and without interruption, and when it is correlated with relatively
low body fat in the lactating female (Ember and Ember, 1990; Frayser, 1985).
Breastfeeding then serves as a means of birth control under these conditions.
For most US women, nursing is not a reliable means of birth control for several
reasons. First, most US women do not breastfeed long enough for the hormonal
suppression of ovulation to occur on a regular basis. Second, most US women
do not nurse regularly enough and give “supplemental” feedings—bottles of
juice, formula, or solids—and thus interrupt the rhythm that is established by
frequent, regular nursing. Third, most US women’s body fat is too high to sup-
press the H-P-G axis regulation of ovulation. To reiterate, nursing as a means
of birth control is not recommended for most women in the United States.
Breastfeeding itself is nutritionally complete for younger infants, and helps
to protect them from disease by supplying them with their mother’s antibodies.
HIV-infected breast milk can be passed from the lactating woman to the nurs-
ing infant. There is international debate and controversy regarding whether
women with either unknown HIV status or who are HIV infected should
breastfeed (Altman, 1998) (see Chapter 16).
Postpartum depression, well documented in the United States, and less
so in other industrialized and traditional societies, is both physiological and
cultural. The elevated levels of estrogen and progesterone during pregnancy
drop dramatically after birth. In addition to this internal hormone withdrawal,
many women in the United States do not have extended kin and non-kin
social networks and models for child rearing and social support. They are ex-
pected to read about child rearing and turn to the experts, health care, and
social service people for help with parenting. Frequently, they do not know
what they are doing and are alone at home. They may be isolated from other
adults and have one or more infants, toddlers, and other young children to
care for. The response to this situation may be “postpartum depression” (Bos-
ton Women’s Health Collective, 1992, 2005; Fisher, Bowman, and Thomas,
2003; Semenic, Callister, and Feldman, 2004).
In nonindustrialized societies, an individual exists as part of the larger
social group, generally the extended family. A postpartum woman is part of
that group as a continuous aspect of her life. Her midwife, as discussed, may
also join this group briefly in the first few days or weeks after birth. Although
the confinement period may extend through part of this time, it also offers
benefits: rest from the daily routine, regular food, and relaxation from overall
social and familial obligations. At the same time, mother-infant bonding
occurs.
200 Pregnancy and Childbirth
The relative separation of woman and baby from hour-to-hour social obliga-
tions may also provide some immunity from infection for the baby.
The pregnancy-through-postpartum continuum is an example of a physio-
logically widespread phenomenon that receives cultural attention wherever it
occurs. The variability and forms of interpretation are culture-specific. They
range from highly technological to highly psycho-sociological.
Summary
1 Pregnancy and childbirth are bio-cultural phenomena. Cultures intervene
in the management of pregnancy and birth in a variety of ways.
2 While this chapter treats pregnancy and birth as a physiologically normal
process, the dominant view in US culture for over 150 years has been
that they are dangerous processes requiring medical management and
intervention.
3 Birth creates and extends kin groups.
4 Pregnancy generally is discussed in terms of trimesters relative to fetal
development and changes in the woman’s body.
5 Cultures involve the father of the child in the woman’s pregnancy and
birth in a variety of ways.
6 Labor and birth are a four-stage process that is managed culturally with a
wide range of interventions.
7 The postpartum period is culturally defined and involves biological and
social dimensions.
Thought-Provoking Questions
1 What are some of the cultural values in the United States that support
the notion of pregnancy and childbirth as dangerous phenomena that
need to be medically controlled and managed?
2 What can we learn from cross-cultural childbirth practices and what can
industrialized societies contribute to childbirth practices cross-culturally?
Suggested Resources
Book
Jordan, Brigitte. 1992. Birth in Four Cultures: A Cross-Cultural Investigation of Childbirth
in Yucatan, Holland, Sweden and the United States. 4th ed. Long Grove, IL: Waveland
Press.
Websites
La Leche League USA. https://lllusa.org. Last accessed 11/04/19.
Cesarean Delivery Rates by State. https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/pressroom/sosmap/cesar-
ean_births/cesareans.htm.
10 Sexuality through the Life
Stages, Part I
Early Childhood Sexuality
Chapter Overview
1 Introduces definitions of childhood and parenting.
2 Outlines the various functions of the family.
3 Discusses kin groups and family forms including the nuclear and extended
family.
4 Presents the importance of marriage rules and patterns.
5 Provides an overview of kinship and its various forms and structure.
6 Reviews the major theories of the incest taboo, including issues of uni-
versality and the interrelationship of kinship structures with the incest
taboo.
7 Discusses incest in the United States.
8 Traces historically the changing perspectives of children’s sexuality in in-
dustrialized societies.
9 Introduces major theories of childhood sexuality including the psycho-
analytic views of Freud and Horney as well as those of pediatrician Dr.
Spock.
10 Presents evidence of the development of children’s early capacity for sex-
ual responses as well as masturbation and child-child sexual experimenta-
tion in the United States.
11 Presents an overview of nonindustrialized society’s childhood sexuality to
emphasize its diversity and the cultural shaping of children’s development.
Definitions
Early childhood sexuality is a highly charged issue, which is made more com-
plex by news stories of child molestation, incest, and the violation of a child’s
innocence. To comprehend fully the issue of childhood sexuality, researchers
focus on the way culture interprets childhood as a specific time with a begin-
ning and end with its own social and physiological changes. This necessitates
that one must first understand the bio-cultural aspects of childhood from a
physiological view, as well as the role that one’s culture assigns to the phys-
ical body, in particular the genitals. An understanding of childhood relates
202 Early Childhood Sexuality
to cultural conceptions of parenting, cultural notions of the family as well as
kinship and descent.
It is important to remember that one of the unique aspects of human evo-
lution is cooperation. Individuals who are not necessarily biologically related
have, in our evolutionary past and under various cultural conditions, made a
valuable contribution to survival of the group through parenting and nurtur-
ing the young. It is part of our deep human capacity to bond. Many children
today have godparents who act in the place of the family in medical emergen-
cies, death, or other situations necessitating help. In the South, the “courtesy
aunt/uncle” is a family friend who acts as the parents if the necessity arises.
This may include nothing more than picking up a child from playschool, but
it is a bond that is forged through time and respect (“Fictive Kin,” 2006; Kot-
tak, 2004). Godparenting is also referred to as compadrazgo in Latin American
cultures. The godparents may agree to raise the child Catholic if the parents
are unable to, or if they die.
It has been posited by physical anthropologists that one of several factors
accounting for female hominids’ long postmenopausal lifespan is their contri-
bution to survival of infants and children through caregiving. Human females
are unique in their long post-reproductive lives. What information is available
from our closest relatives confirms that reproduction and the lifespan converge
in non-human primates. It is only in human females that longevity far exceeds
the period of reproductive fertility. As grandmothers and socio-partners, we
can imagine the enormous contribution of human females to the survival of
the group in evolutionary terms. Hominid females, in the past and today, act
as role models, caregivers of the young, parent substitutes, providers of the vast
reservoir of knowledge in regard to the socialization of the young, and as edu-
cators of new parents. Like most human behavior, human parenting is a biolog-
ically adaptive behavior that interacts with the socio-cultural dimension. This
is also true of kin groups in which biological relations are culturally shaped.
It is easy to forget, given the truncated nuclear families found in industrial-
ized societies, that kin and family are the core units of culture. Children are
born into a kin group in which descent is reckoned. For the majority of the
world’s cultures, descent is unilineal (Holmes and Schneider, 1987: 387). This
refers to tracing descent through only one side of the family, either the mother
or the father; unlike Euro-Americans who reckon descent through both the
mother and father (note indigenous groups in North and South America were
largely unilineal in descent). Kin groups and descent are important for our
discussion because they relate to the social positioning and cultural meaning
of children in a society; to issues of parenting and parenting roles; to rules of
incest, marriage; and reproduction boundaries; and why paternity certainty is
important under some conditions and not others.
The industrialized worldview of parenting often emphasizes its connection
to biological paternity or “paternity certainty.” This is in reference to the bio-
logical principle that an individual is usually aware of whom his/her mother is,
but without the use of technology to determine genetic heritage, the biological
Early Childhood Sexuality 203
father is not readily apparent. Even in a minority of cases such as adoption,
this quest is documented by people’s desire to find their “biological parents,”
often at great cost and expense. We suggest, however, that family is socially
constructed through the meaning we give to biology.
In understanding how family is a bio-cultural phenomenon, let us explore
briefly the cultural emphasis on the importance of paternity certainty and the
conditions that are correlated with its emphasis (see Chapter 3). These vari-
ables include male-centered descent rules (tracing descent through the father’s
side of the family) and/or residence patterns. Concern with paternity certainty
is also associated with certain kinds of subsistence strategies, specifically those
found in horticultural societies that are under resource pressure and in agricul-
tural societies. These kinds of societies are also associated with male-centered
descent systems (patrilineal systems are discussed in a later section). Thus, cer-
tain kinds of horticulture (farming characterized by slash-and-burn techniques
and fallow periods between plantings) are associated with male-oriented de-
scent patterns. And agricultural societies (using irrigation, ploughing, draft
animals, and fertilizer) generally are associated with this pattern. Finally,
concern with paternity certainty is found in societies in which males hold
privileged positions, such as the majority of agricultural societies, some hor-
ticultural societies, and industrialized nations generally. It is hypothesized
and supported by a good deal of evidence that these conditions are correlated
and historically related to one another (Brettell and Sargent, 2005b: 135–141
among numerous others; Martin and Voorhies, 1975).
For example, male-centered descent systems wherein individuals trace their
ancestry through the father’s kin play a role in the sex and gender system of a
society. In some types of horticultural and generally in agricultural societies,
the male line of descent establishes the continuation of the family property
and business. Thus, in the Sudan, according to the legal system dominated by
Islamic law, women cannot inherit property. Nor are they positioned to sup-
port themselves due to lack of educational and employment opportunities as
well as cultural customs related to the separation of the genders and ideologies
of gender and work. This places them in a position where they must marry, or
risk becoming a social and economic liability to their families (Gruenbaum,
2005: 481–494). Women must be virgins or they bring shame on their family.
Virginity is therefore a mechanism that functions to support the certainty
of paternity and is linked to ideas of kinship and the family (Gruenbaum,
2005). Descent and kinship rules around inheritance can have profound con-
sequences on the lives of people, especially with regard to women and their
status. Concern over biological paternity is clearly not a random cultural con-
cern but must be understood in relationship to the broader cultural context,
especially kinship rules.
Kinship is important for ordering human social relations and creating
groups and boundaries. Throughout the course of evolution and in most non-
technologically complex societies, the family is the primary unit for production
and consumption. Kin groups are formed through marriages and reproduction.
204 Early Childhood Sexuality
Marriages should not be confused with mating, which is defined in terms of
premarital and extramarital sex. A definition of heterosexual marriage then
can be stated as follows: Marriage is the “socially approved relationship be-
tween a socially recognized male (the husband) and a socially recognized fe-
male (the wife) such that the children born to the wife are accepted as the
offspring of both husband and wife” (Kottak, 2004: 8). Note that these spouses
need not always belong to the other sex nor are they necessarily limited to a
single spouse at a time (Blackwood, 2005a; Bolin, 1996b; Kottak, 2004: 281).
Marriage partners will share economic, reproductive, and sexual obligations.
The functions of marriage are numerous and relate to these obligations. Mar-
riage provides a setting that facilitates infant survival as well as a stable setting
for children’s socialization. Group survival is enhanced by extending social
relations and providing sexual outlets and economic advantages to the par-
ticipants (Ferraro, 2004: 195; Holmes and Schneider, 1987: 388). As will be
discussed, all groups have incest taboos, which prohibit sex and marriage with
various kin and hence structure kin groups.
Just as there are socio-cultural rules regarding whom one may have sex with
in the family (incest rules), there are also marriage rules. There are two forms
of marriage rules: exogamy and endogamy. Exogamy prohibits marriage within
one’s own group. The definition of group will vary from that of a particular
group of kin, to village, or groups of villages (Ember, Ember, and Peregrine,
2005: 360). According to alliance theory, exogamy creates economic and
political relationships between groups, some of which might otherwise be in
conflict, and/or forges broader social networks and economic ties providing
greater integration. For example, the Indian village of Rani Kera with 150
households was linked to 400 other nearby villages through the practice of vil-
lage exogamy (Ember, Ember, and Peregrine, 2005: 361). Endogamy is marriage
that must take place within the group. This may include groups of relatives,
the tribe, or even a caste or class. Hindu castes, although illegal but still prac-
ticed, endorse caste endogamy, marrying within the same caste, but not below
in order to avoid the risk of ritual pollution (Ferraro, 2004: 201). Endogamy
does not refer to marriage within nuclear families, but may include marriages
between cousins or other related individuals. Descent theory regards endog-
amy as a vehicle for families to contribute to cohesion and solidarity by keep-
ing wealth, power, and prestige within the group (Cohen and Eames, 1982:
121–122; Kottak, 2002: 406–407).
There are primarily two types of families: the nuclear family and the ex-
tended family. Nuclear families consist of the parents and their progeny. While
blended families, single-parent-headed households, and extended families exist
in the United States, the nuclear family is regarded as the cultural ideal rep-
resented in a variety of discourses including the media and political rhetoric.
Other forms of marriage are also prevalent such as the blended family, which
represents children from previous marriages, single female- or male-headed
households, extended families, and childless couples. Extended families in-
clude consanguineal (blood) and affinal (marriage) relatives in addition to the
Early Childhood Sexuality 205
nuclear ones. In nonindustrialized societies, the extended family usually in-
cludes relatives from either the male or female lineage and is the most common
family form (Ember, Ember, and Peregrine, 2005: 366–368).
There are several types of marriage represented in the cross-cultural spec-
trum. These include single mateships, which are composed of two spouses.
According to Ford and Beach’s (1951) classic study using ethnographic sam-
ples, 16 percent of the world’s societies required this form, while in 84 percent
of them, men could practice polygyny if they could arrange it. Polygamy is
legally practiced or societally accepted in 33 countries and accepted by part of
the population in 41 countries (United Nations, 2011: 4). The Demographic
and Health Survey (DHS) carried out from 2000 to 2010 indicates that 10–53
percent of women aged 14 to 49 had co-wives.
It has previously been suggested that only a few of the men in societies that
prefer polygyny are actually able to practice this highly priced endeavor—it
takes a multitude of wealth to sustain multiple wives (Broude, 1994; Ponzetti,
2003; Saxton, 1993). A recent model suggests that the practice of polygyny
is limited by two factors: wealth inequality that decreases the availability of
wealth for men to pursue polygyny and low fitness returns for wives (Ross et al.,
2018: 1).
The generic term for multiple spouses is polygamy, while polygyny refers
to multiple wives. However, in 49 percent of the polygynous societies single
mateships are actually the rule, since a man must have a certain amount of
economic wherewithal to acquire additional wives. As is illustrated by the
Tiwi of Australia, once a man has demonstrated that he is a good prospective
husband in terms of his status and economic condition, having several wives
enhances his economic standing considerably (Hart and Pilling, 1960). In 14
percent of the polygynous societies, the only acceptable additional wife is her
sister. This is known as sororal polygyny.
Another form of marriage is polyandry in which a woman may have more
than one husband. Although the percentage is small, less than 1 percent, this
pattern has been common in Tibet, India, and Sri Lanka and has also been re-
ported historically among the Marquesans of the Pacific (Levine, 1988; Suggs,
1966). However, polyandry is currently no longer practiced in some areas and is
under pressure to change in others (Cohen and Eames, 1982: 126–127; Ember,
Ember, and Peregrine, 2005: 365). It is believed that less than a dozen such
cultures are currently in existence, and the cause for this marriage pattern
is unknown. The most common polyandry is known as fraternal polyandry,
which occurs when the multiple husbands of one woman are brothers. Possible
advantages stemming from polyandry include keeping scarce resources, such as
land, within the patrilocal family (Ponzetti, 2003: 1096). Fraternal polyandry
occurs in Nepal and India where brothers may marry one woman and live
patrilocally. All the brothers are recognized as the wife’s husbands, and all
take on the parenting role of father to her children. The wife has equal sexual
access to all the brothers. In fraternal polyandrous societies, sororal polygyny
may also be practiced (Schultz and Lavenda, 2001: 476–477).
206 Early Childhood Sexuality
Associated polyandry occurs among the Sinhalese of Sri Lanka (Levine and
Sangree, 1980), and is reported in the Pacific and among indigenous peoples of
North and South America (Schultz and Lavenda, 2001: 407–408). Associated
polyandry refers to a marriage in which a woman may have multiple husbands,
but these husbands are unrelated. The Nayar represent one of the most famous
anthropological reports of this kind of polyandry. The Nayar woman engages
in a ritual marriage to a man from a linked lineage. After three days of seclu-
sion where sex might occur if the wife is old enough, the couple parts and they
go their separate ways with no further obligations or relations. The woman is
then free to marry and have sexual relations with men of her own choosing as
long as they are of the same caste or higher (endogamy). The only restriction
is that these husbands cannot be brothers. This system is referred to as one
of visiting husbands. The men and women in these relationships have more
than one spouse. The households are consanguineal ones in that a woman
lives with her children, her sisters, and her sisters’ children. The marriages
are valuable for their alliance functions, not economic ones. Men take on fi-
nancial responsibility for their sisters and sisters’ children (Kottak, 2004: 257;
Schultz and Lavenda, 1990: 301–302).
Like polygynous marriages, polyandrous ones reflect adaptations to subsis-
tence conditions. In Tibetan fraternal polyandry, polyandrous marriages help
maintain family landholding units against possible subdivision through indi-
vidual inheritance and partition of lands. The ecological conditions are such
that households must pursue both agriculture as well as animal husbandry in
order to survive. In such a situation, a division of labor among cohusbands is
advantageous (Goldstein, 1987: 39–48; Ponzetti, 2003: 1096).
Other forms of marriage exist but are not widespread. These include a form
of group marriage practiced by the Oneida utopian Christian community in
New York. All members regarded one another as spouses. As a result of local
hostility, this system was discontinued in 1879 (Gregersen, 1994: 310). Out of a
study of over one hundred of these “multilateral marriages,” only 7 percent ex-
ceeded five years (Constantine and Constantine, 1973; Ponzetti, 2003: 1096).
Other forms include woman marriage, as among the Nuer, in which two women
are married. One woman takes on the role of a social male and arranges for
“her” wife to become pregnant by “another” man. The woman-husband then
becomes the social father of the child (Blackwood, 1984a: 56–63; Brockman,
2004: 688; Cohen and Eames, 1982: 128–129). The levirate and sororate rep-
resent marriage systems related to the death of spouses. In the levirate the
wife will marry her dead husband’s brother. Seventy percent of a sample of 159
societies reported on in Murdock’s (1965) classic cross-cultural correlational
study of traditional societies preferred this form, while 60 percent preferred
the sororate in which a man marries his dead wife’s sister. One explanation
of these practices suggests that remarriage between relatives is important for
maintaining the stability of the familial group, which may be threatened by the
death of the parent. Alliance theory argues that these marriage forms main-
tain alliances originally established by the dead sibling (Scupin, 2003: 75–76).
Early Childhood Sexuality 207
Marriage creates kinship relationships between individuals and groups. We
shall begin our discussion of kinship by focusing on descent groups. Descent
groups are characterized by a permanent set of relations that are not changed
by residence or death. These groups are formed through various principles
of descent and represent ways in which human groups organize themselves.
Descent is defined as “the cultural principle based on culturally recognized
parent-child connections that define the social categories to which people
belong” (Schultz and Lavenda, 1990: 261). Descent groups comprise people
who recognize shared ancestry. It is the primary way people are organized in
nonindustrial and prestate societies. Though nuclear families are defined by
common residence and are therefore impermanent, the descent group is per-
manent (Ferraro, 2004: 228) (Figure 10.1).
Descent systems are either unilineal, tracing one’s ancestors through one side
of the family and not the other, or are non-unilineal. Non-unilineal descent
is also referred to as bilateral or cognatic descent and is based on the princi-
ple of tracing descent through both parents equally (Ferraro, 2004: 235–236).
Approximately 40 percent of the world’s societies are non-unilineal. These
include bilateral, ambilineal, and bilineal descent. The US descent system is
called the bilateral kindred.
Matrilineal descent traces membership through the female line only, while
patrilineal descent traces group membership through the male line only. In
these systems, an individual will trace ancestry through either their matrilin-
eage or patrilineage. Unlike the clan, the lineage has demonstrated descent in
that members can trace their kinship and exact relationships to one another
and a founding ancestor. In contrast, stipulated descent occurs among people
who claim to be related to a common ancestor but are unable to document the
exact relationship because the ancestor is either hypothetical or very remote.
Stipulated descent is associated with clans.
208 Early Childhood Sexuality
Hawaiian Kinship
Sister Brother Sister Brother Sister Ego Brother Sister Brother Sister Brother
Sudanese Kinship
Mother’s Brother Mother’s Sister Mother Father Father’s Brother Father’s Sister
Inuit Kinship
Cousin Cousin Cousin Cousin Sister Ego Brother Cousin Cousin Cousin Cousin
Iroquois Kinship
Cousin Cousin Sister Brother Sister Ego Brother Sister Brother Cousin Cousin
Crow Kinship
Cousin Cousin Sister Brother Sister Ego Brother Sister Brother Aunt Father
Omaha Kinship
Mother Uncle Sister Brother Sister Ego Brother Sister Brother Cousin Cousin
Incest Taboos
Childhood sexuality, like adult sexual expression, is managed by culture. One
of the ways in which it is managed is through proscriptions against incest. The
incest taboo is cited as an example of a cultural universal, although there are
exceptions to the taboo. The incest taboo is defined as a “[u]niversal prohibi-
tion against marrying or mating with a close relative” (Kottak, 2002: 700). The
incest taboo refers to those family members that we in the United States call
the immediate family. In virtually every society, sex is prohibited between an
individual and her/his siblings, parents, and children. These people are termed
“primary relatives.” Anthropologists continue to debate the origin of the in-
cest taboo, since it is such a widely shared institution. As a consequence of this
debate a number of theories have emerged. We shall review several of the more
prominent perspectives. These perspectives span a long timeframe and cross
disciplines including biological, psychological, anthropological, and integra-
tive approaches. Meigs and Barlow argue that “[t]he incest taboo is to anthro-
pology what Shakespeare is to English literature—fundamental and classic”
(2002: 38). The study of the incest taboo emphasizes prohibitions rather than
the consequences of actual incest taboo violations (Patterson, 2005). In those
societies where sex was allowed within families such as the ancient Egyptians,
Hawaiians, and Incans, it was restricted to nobility who were considered gods
and above human laws (Ember, Ember, and Peregrine, 2005).
Psychoanalytic theories represent one kind of explanation about incest.
Perhaps the most famous psychoanalytic view of the incest taboo is Sigmund
Freud’s theory of the Oedipus complex. The Oedipal complex has had an im-
portant impact on early- to mid-twentieth-century anthropological reflection
on the subject, particularly in the anthropological school of thought known as
culture and personality. This subfield regarded personality as causal in shaping
culture’s more expressive aspects such as art, religion, and mythology. Not all
anthropologists agreed with Freud’s formulation. In fact, the anthropologist
Bronislaw Malinowski in 1927 challenged the view that the incest taboo was a
result of the existence of the Oedipus complex.
Freud’s theory of the Oedipus complex was derived from his work with
specifically western European clients. The Oedipus complex is represented as
one stage in the psychosexual development of a child. The first phase a child
experiences lasts from birth through one year of age and is the oral stage in
212 Early Childhood Sexuality
which the infant’s interests center on the mouth as a source of pleasure. Freud
regarded pleasure seeking in the human as a given, as instinctual. The anal
stage occurred at approximately two years of age. It is the period in which the
child achieves control of his/her bladder and anal sphincter and finds pleasure
in this sensation. However, toilet training can cause conflicts as the child’s
wishes may be controlled by external pressures such as toilet-training prac-
tices. The Oedipal phase, or phallic stage, is characterized by love, hate, envy,
and guilt, and occurs from about three to five years old. This is followed by a
period of latency, from about six to twelve years of age, when the sexuality of
the Oedipal phase is repressed. At puberty, interest in sexuality is reasserted.
Libido, or the desire for sex which Freud considered panhuman and natural,
underwent various expressions and repressions through these developmental
stages. Freud felt these stages were embedded in our human biology and were
universal. Freud’s theory of development is linked to his view that sexuality is
both a conscious and unconscious force throughout the life course. This was
an astonishing view in light of his Victorian milieu.
The Victorian era is named for the reign of Queen Victoria who ruled from
1837 to 1901. The Romantic period, which began around the 1800s, fed the
Victorian era. The Romantic era celebrated nature and the unspoiled. These
notions filtered into the Victorian period. At this time the concept of the
noble savage flourished, derived from anthropological reports of “exotic na-
tives” communing with nature in its unspoiled and pristine state. Middle-class
English children were also seen as having a nobility derived from purity. They
were viewed as yet unspoiled by civilization. As the industrial revolution gained
momentum, children “became the last symbols of purity in a world which was
seen as increasingly ugly” (Sommerville, 1990: 198). Children were glorified
during the Victorian era. In short, they were next to the angels in virtue.
While middle-class adult Victorians had to suppress their impulses in an era
where sexuality and sexual symbolism were not publicly expressed, children
represented innocence of desire. They were in a state of natural privilege as-
sociated with “childhood goodness” (Sommerville, 1990: 204). Sommerville
(1990: 209) has suggested that this view of children did not extend to the
United States during this same time period. Middle-class US perspectives of
children demanded competence and performance in contrast to British views
of children who “symbolize[d] the innocence which a severely repressed society
felt it had lost.”
Sigmund Freud’s work on childhood sexuality followed closely on the heels
of the Victorian period. In 1905 Freud published his Three Essays on the Theory
of Sexuality. Freud felt that human sexual energy, which he called libido, was
present at birth and that through the course of children’s development; this
energy became focused in different body zones during the different stages of
psycho-sexual maturation. This embodied a very different interpretation of
the child from the Victorian notions of innocence. For Freud, the infant was
charged with an undifferentiated sexual energy; that is, he or she could find
sexual pleasure in the entire body in the erotogenic zones. This is what Freud
Early Childhood Sexuality 213
meant when he referred to the infant as “polymorphously perverse.” Libido is
an energy rewarded by the “aim” of pleasure. The erotogenic zones were areas
of the body through which libido could be discharged. Freud emphasized these
in his stages of childhood.
The oral stage of development focused on the mouth area as the first zone
for pleasure. This is the pleasure the child derives from sucking and nursing.
The second zone emphasized the anus and was termed the anal stage of de-
velopment. This was the period where the child has learned to control her or
his bowels and finds pleasure in the process of evacuation. The third or phallic
stage actually refers to the phase when children, between three or four years of
age, explore their genital areas and find self-stimulation to be pleasurable. This
stage, which accented the genitals, also included the Oedipus complex, which
occurs around the ages of five or six. For boys, as will be discussed shortly,
the Oedipus complex is resolved out of fear of the father and identification
with him. The little girl conversely desires her father and resents her mother
(Appignanesi, 1979: 76–88; Gleitman, 1987: 352–353; Lindsey, 2005: 26–27).
The latency stage follows the Oedipal phase. This was the period from about
six years old to puberty when children, according to Freud, lost interest in sex.
This phase initiated the end of the four stages of infantile sexuality. It should
be remembered that sexual interests were seen as repressed, but not eliminated
from the psyches of children (Appignanesi, 1979: 92; Westheimer and Lopater,
2005: 424–425).
The Oedipal phase is the cornerstone of Freud’s theory of psychosexual de-
velopment. Freud named this after Oedipus, the tragic hero in a mythical story
of a man who married his mother unknowingly and, upon finding this out,
blinded himself as punishment. According to Freud, the young boy covets his
mother and regards his father as a rival for his mother’s affections. In contrast,
the young female desires her father and regards her mother as a competitor. Her
complex is called the Electra complex. In the Electra complex, the little girl
subconsciously desires sex with her father, which comes about as a consequence
of penis envy and a concomitant sense of inadequacy. These wishes of both
boys and girls cause the child to feel fear and guilt toward the same-sex parent.
The Oedipus and Electra complexes are resolved through renunciation of the
love object and identification with the same-sex parent (Gleitman, 1987: 351;
Lindsey, 2005: 26). The gender bias in Freud’s theory was clearly expressed when
he wrote: “It does little harm to a woman if she remains in her feminine Oedipus
attitude… She will in that case choose her husband for his paternal characteris-
tics and will be ready to recognize his authority” (in Sayers, 1986: 101).
To account for the Oedipus complex as universal, Freud turned to an evolu-
tionary explanation. From Freud’s perspective, the almost worldwide appear-
ance of the incest taboo could be viewed as a mechanism to prohibit that
which we desire. But from where did this taboo and desire arise? Freud ad-
dressed this in Totem and Tabu (1950 [1913]). At some early and unspecified
point in time, there existed a “primal horde” in which a father kept a harem
of women but expelled his male children. The expelled brothers colluded and
214 Early Childhood Sexuality
murdered their father and ate him so they could have sexual access to their
sisters and mothers. However, after their dastardly deed, they felt a great deal
of remorse. Out of respect for their slain father’s wishes, they renounced their
mothers and sisters. This was the beginning of the incest taboo, which prohib-
its sex and marriage between immediate blood relatives. Freud cited evidence
cross-culturally of the ritual totemic meal, which he interpreted as a symbolic
re-enactment of this original crime. To Freud, the totem animal represents
the father who is ritually eaten in commemoration of this event. According to
Freud, the consequences of this primal scene have been transmitted to all of
us through the collective unconscious, presumably somehow inherited (Freud,
1950 [1913]: 34; in Bock, 1988: 32–36; Lyons and Lyons, 2004: 107).
In response to Freud, Malinowski argued that the Oedipus complex was not
a cultural universal but was relative to the particular family structures found
in a given culture. Since Freud’s theory was based on middle-class western
European values with family constellations in which the father was the dom-
inant figure, Malinowski tested this theory in a situation in which the family
constellation was quite different, that of the Trobriand Islanders. He addressed
this in his book Sex and Repression in Savage Society (1961 [1927]). He reasoned
that different family structures would likely lead to different kinds of conscious
and unconscious conflicts in individuals (Brown, 1991: 32). As we have seen,
the Oedipus complex proposes that a young male child will desire his mother
and want to get rid of his father. As the child matures, this complex is then
outgrown.
But the Trobriand Islanders had a very different family structure. They were
a matrilineal society in which kinship was traced through the mother. In fact,
the Trobrianders believed that the procreator of a child was a dead kinswoman
of the mother. Although the mother was the primary authority figure, she had
a warm relationship with her children. In contrast to the European system
in which the father was the authority figure, the mother’s brother among the
Trobriand Islanders assumed the role of disciplinarian. He was also the person
from whom the child would inherit. In contrast, the father (like the Trobriand
mother) had a warm and affectionate relationship with his children.
In the Trobriand Islands, it was the mother’s brother who earned the boy’s
hostility; and it was his sister, not his mother, whom the boy desired. Trobri-
and children were subjected to a rigorous brother/sister incest avoidance rule
(taboo) at puberty (Bock, 1988; Brown, 1991). Unfortunately, the comparable
complex for women—the Electra complex—has been relatively unexplored.
The Electra complex “received much less attention from Freud and almost
none from Malinowski…” (Brown, 1991: 32). This is typical of the “unmark-
ing” and silence around women that occurs in patriarchal societies and which
is reflected in scientific theorizing. Despite this shortcoming,
Some anthropologists believe the incest taboo arose as a vehicle for estab-
lishing alliances outside the family. In fact, Edward Tylor’s adage “marry out
or die out” is one explanation for the origin of the taboo. According to Tylor,
the “hatreds and fears” associated with closed families forced people to extend
alliances to other families and therefore to build societies (Patterson, 2005;
Scupin, 2003: 75; Shapiro, 1958: 278). This explanation is typical of the func-
tionalist approach in anthropology which maintains that institutions exist to
fulfill needs. Other notable anthropologists such as Leslie White, George Peter
Murdock, and Levi-Strauss have explained the incest taboo along these same
lines with various refinements and additions, yet maintaining the theme of
alliance building. Such hypotheses have been critiqued as explaining rules for
marrying outside one’s group, but not necessarily incest taboos, a subtle but
important distinction (Scupin, 2003: 75).
Early Childhood Sexuality 217
In 1922, Edward Westermarck offered an explanation for the incest taboo
which argued that the taboo reflects an absence of sexual desire expressed in
people’s intrinsic “horror” of incest. Incest rules therefore exist for those who
have gone “awry” or deviated (Brown, 1991: 119). Westermarck felt that the
lack of erotic desire that people raised in proximity feel toward one another
was an evolved sentiment ingrained in the psyche through biology. This the-
ory is often summarized as “proximity breeds contempt.”
The Westermarck effect has garnered substantial support particularly as it
relates to sibling incest. Spiro (1965) and Fox’s (1962) analysis of Israeli kibbut-
zim marriage and Wolf’s study of marriage in China (1966, 1968, 1970) pro-
vide provocative evidence for this theory. Spiro found that children who were
raised together as cohorts on kibbutzim as part of social planning to reduce the
role of the nuclear family practiced sex and marriage avoidance of one another
as adults (in Brown, 1991: 120). Fox interpreted this as support of the Wester-
marck effect. He concluded that in societies in which children are raised with
close physical intimacy, they will not have sexual desires for one another; and
the incest taboo will be more like an afterthought since siblings will not desire
one another anyway. However, societies where siblings are raised in the absence
of physical intimacy are more likely to have strict taboos since desire will need
curbing. Fox’s hypothesis integrates a Freudian thrust not incorporated by Wes-
termarck (Brown, 1991: 120). Shepher’s 1971 and 1983 research on kibbutizm
marriages supports the finding of lessened sexual attraction to partners raised in
proximity. In a study of 211 kibbutzim, there were only 14 marriages of peers out
of 2,769 married couples (Meigs and Barlow, 2002: 39; Scupin, 2003).
Arthur Wolf’s investigation of marriage in China has intriguing implica-
tions for the Westermarck effect. Wolf studied two forms of marriage practiced
in a Chinese village in Taiwan (1966, 1968, 1970). The minor form of marriage
was one in which a girl was adopted into her future husband’s family at an
early age and raised as a member of the family. In the major form, marriage
took place in adulthood without any previous familial association between
the partners. Wolf (1970) suggested that wife adoption would lead to a sexual
aversion in the couple who was reared together. In comparing major and mi-
nor forms of marriage, he found that in the minor form there were 30 percent
fewer offspring, the divorce rate was 24.2 percent and extramarital relation-
ships were found in 33.1 percent of the marriages. In contrast, major marriages
had a 1.2 percent divorce rate and 11.3 percent rate of extramarital sex (Wolf,
1970: 503–515). This evidence strongly supports the contention that familiar-
ity leads to disinterest and even aversion.
This is by no means an exhaustive review of anthropological theories of the
origin of the incest taboo, but only highlights some of the more prominent
ones. The more recent theories on incest and its taboo integrate the work of
some of these earlier theorists. For example, bio-social approaches argue that
close attachment of father and daughters reduces the likelihood of incest oc-
curring later as a result of some biological process activated through the social
218 Early Childhood Sexuality
process of active father involvement in childrearing (Meigs and Barlow, 2002:
42; Parker and Parker, 1986; Roscoe, 1994). Meigs and Barlow (2002) argue
that a fruitful direction for research lies in the psychoanalytic direction. They
suggest exploring the possible relationship reported in the anthropological lit-
erature between trance/dance behaviors that are linked with spiritualist ec-
static religious experiences and the dissociative experiences of incest survivors.
The incest taboo may be explained by a convergence of several theoretical
positions discussed in this chapter.1 The incest taboo
These theories are not necessarily mutually exclusive but could be regarded as
interactive. For example, “cultural learning and genetic transmission are not
mutually exclusive alternatives and may interact to produce incest avoidance
in ways that are complex and flexible” (Meigs and Barlow, 2002: 40). We would
add that the Westermarck effect of childhood proximity leading to lack of de-
sire could be added to this list as a vehicle of psychological conditioning. Thus,
the incest taboo is a consequence of what people would not want to do anyway
under certain conditions. Walter argues that in societies where children are
exposed to prohibitions that prevent the familiarity of the Westermarck effect,
then desire for the forbidden could arise. In such a case, the incest taboo would
operate as a mechanism to prevent incest (1990: 440).
Despite the universality of the incest taboo, the particular form, focus,
meaning, and response to it is extremely variable cross-culturally. This diver-
sity is especially apparent in the case of exogamy, in which the incest taboo is
extended. In spite of the near universality of the incest taboo, incest does oc-
cur. We have discussed the special situations of exceptions for elites. We want
to turn now to incest in the United States, which is primarily non-consensual
and involves victimization. This is because children and adolescents are not in
a position vis-á-vis their parents and older siblings to give informed consent.
It is difficult to get an accurate estimate of the incidence of incest. One of
the problems with assessing the incest statistics is that these are clouded by the
“false memory” controversy. Over the last twenty years a recovered-memory
movement in psychotherapy has flourished. Therapists report that victims of
incest/child abuse experienced amnesia about these events and only through
therapy was this sexual abuse “recovered” and discovered. Detractors argue
that therapists were leading or suggesting this to their clients, and that there
is little evidence that actual incest or sexual abuse occurred (Patterson, 2005:
note 1; Tyroler, 1996).
One report suggested that 250,000 children are victims of incest, with half
of these cases involving fathers and stepfathers (Kelly, 1990 [citing Russel,
Early Childhood Sexuality 219
1983]). Another suggests that as many as one in twenty women may be vic-
tims of father-daughter incest (Scupin, 2003: 77). Depending on the report
and the time period of the study, statistics for incest range from 4 percent in
Gebhard’s (1965) study to 27 percent in Hunt’s (1974) survey (in Francoeur,
2004c: 613) and 15 percent in the work of Becker and Coleman (1988, in
King et al., 1991: 380). Recent figures by the Bureau of Justice note that 27
percent of all child sexual assaults were by a family member (“Sexual Assault
of Young Children,” 2000). The Child Maltreatment Survey in 2017 found
that 91.6 percent of all child sexual assault victims were maltreated by one or
both parents: 40.8 percent were maltreated by the mother alone, and 21.5 per-
cent by the father (Child Maltreatment Survey, 2017: 25). Almost 30 percent
of the father-daughter incest cases in the United States include an alcoholic
father (Berger, 1993). It must be remembered that although a stepfather or step-
mother is not a biological parent, but a social parent, the severity in terms of
trauma may be the same for the victim. The victim has had a trusted parental
figure violate her or him.
The survivors of incest suffer a host of psychological problems and malad-
justments throughout the life course as a result of their experiences. These
include sexual acting out, sexual dysfunctions as adults, low self-esteem, self-
blame, and self-destructive behaviors. They may experience psychological
problems not unlike the Vietnam veterans who suffered post-traumatic stress
syndrome. In addition, Newman and Peterson report that women experience
anger that is specific, toward mothers and fathers (1996: 463–474).
Incest should not be confused with children’s curiosity about their own gen-
italia and that of their siblings that occurs around two to three years of age.
Sexual violence between siblings is much more prevalent than child abuse
by both parents; suggestively, it is the most common form of abuse within
families (Kiselica and Morril-Richards, 2007: 1). Incest as reported between a
brother and sister is five times more likely than between a father and daughter
in the United States (Westheimer, 2000: 154; Westheimer and Lopater, 2005).
220 Early Childhood Sexuality
Despite these findings, father-daughter incest is more heavily researched and
sibling incest and assault is underreported (Caffaro and Conn-Caffaro, 2005:
609). Thirteen percent of all college-aged students had experienced some type
of sexual activity with a brother or sister. Four percent of these cases involved
full coitus, while most reports involved looking at and touching sibling geni-
tals (Westheimer, 2000: 154; Westheimer and Lopater, 2005). In terms of gen-
der differences between experiences of sibling sexual abuse, one study found
that out of a sample of 49 female and 24 male survivors of sibling incest and
assault, a sister was most likely to be abused by their brother (Caffaro and
Conn-Caffaro, 2005: 608). In one study by Finkelhor (1980), 15 percent of
the women and 10 percent of the men in a college population reported this
behavior with 75 percent brother-sister exploration and 25 percent same-sex
behavior. But even in such a benign sibling context, there is still the possibil-
ity for coercion and possible incestuous sexual abuse. Twenty-five percent of
this population, mostly women, were uncomfortable because force was used
(in Francoeur, 1991a: 111). Incest survivors are invariably the less powerful
person in such interactions. Generally, the survivor is not in a consensual
position because of differences in authority or because of actual or threatened
physical force.
The double standard of the industrialized society’s gender system is reflected
in the incest statistics in the United States. Boys’ sexual abuse tends to be per-
petrated by a stranger, while girls’ is much more likely to be by a relative (Baker
and King, 2004: 1235). According to Stark (1984), 85 percent of the incest vic-
tims are female with “only 20 percent of the sexual abuse of boys and 5 percent
of the sexual abuse of girls perpetrated by adult females” (in Kelly, 1990: 356).
Recent figures suggest that between 20 percent and 30 percent of girls are
abused by a relative with 4 percent involving father-daughter incest, but only
about 10 percent of boys are abused by a relative (Baker and King, 2004: 1234;
Herman and Hirschman, 1981). Of those children sexually abused, the Bureau
of Justice Statistics (2000) reports that nearly one-third of all male sexual as-
saults were by family members, whereas only 25.7 percent of female assaults
were by a relative. Remember that sexual assaults on females far exceed those
on men (Pereda et al., 2009: 333; Stoltenborgh et al., 2011: 11). The National
Violence Against Women survey found that women are 6.5 times more likely
to be raped by non-spouse relatives, 3.4 times more likely to be raped by ac-
quaintances, and 4.8 times more likely to be raped by strangers (Tjaden and
Thoennes, 2006: 23). The frequency of stepfathers engaging in sexual activity
with family members is unclear in current research. Baker and King (2004)
indicate that stepfathers are more likely than biological fathers to engage in
incest, but several studies have shown this is not the case (Greenberg et al.,
2005: 55; Langevin and Watson, 1988: 149). Stereotypes from the media and
folklore can play into negative expectations of stepparents (Claxton-Oldfield,
2008: 53; Claxton-Oldfield and Whitt, 2004: 32).
Statistically speaking, family members were more likely to abuse younger
children with about half the incest victims under age six (“Sexual Assault on
Early Childhood Sexuality 221
Young Children,” 2000). A 1994 national survey revealed that 12 percent of
men and 17 percent of women reported that they had been sexually touched
by an older person when they were children. The offender was reported as
typically being a family friend or relative as opposed to a stranger (Laumann
et al., 1994).
Children who are survivors of incest are in a disadvantaged position in re-
lationship to the abuser. One common response is “accommodation” in that
they may feel they have no other alternative. They may be conflicted by the
love and trust they feel for the biological or social parent. Or they may not
want to cause family problems by telling; very often they have been manip-
ulated or threatened with consequences if they do tell. Thus, the accommo-
dation strategy is one of serious denial. Researchers note that some survivors
have no direct memory of the incest as adults. Only through psychotherapy do
they become aware of the memories so long denied and hidden.
One aspect of father or stepfather incest is the purported acceptance of the
situation by the mother. In such cases, the mother is reported to default in her
role as spouse, and the daughter or stepdaughter takes the mother’s role in re-
lation to her father or stepfather. In such situations, the young female is doubly
injured in terms of betrayal of trust, both by her father/stepfather and by her
mother who tacitly allows the relationship. The mother, not usually overtly,
may permit it to go on because it is part of the family denial system. How-
ever, this is a very controversial theory and some researchers such as Chandler
(1982), Ward (1985), and Myer (1985) deny that the mother has any role at all
(in Francoeur, 1991a: 615; in Kelly, 1994: 356). Certainly, the degree of the
mother’s tacit involvement varies depending on the family dynamics.
The father’s role as perpetrator is more clearly identified. In fact, the sexu-
ally abusive father or stepfather follows a pattern in which gender inequality
is an important factor. The father is typically hypermasculine in his disregard
and respect for women and children. We may view him as oversubscribing to
his gender role. Another contributing cultural factor, which may also play a
part, includes the perpetrator’s valuing (sexual attraction to) women for their
youthfulness. Finkelhor (1984) has identified four cultural and psychological
factors that converge to place children at risk for sexual abuse by fathers or
stepfathers. These factors are embedded in a patriarchal system of masculinity
and include the following ideologies and values:
Flores and Mattos’ (1998) study in Brazil identified several predisposing factors
for incest that bear further scrutiny in other settings. These are identified as
222 Early Childhood Sexuality
Given these three variables, an incestuous relationship may not always result
in long-term emotional scarring and damage for the child.
Pat Whelehan has dealt with a small number of adult male and female in-
cest “survivors” over the past three years. Some of these individuals did ex-
perience extreme emotional damage with long-lasting negative consequences
relative to their self-esteem and romantic relationships with others. Three of
these individuals came through the experience intact. The difference is that
the three individuals who viewed their incest/adult-child sexual experience
positively were males who were not coerced and who had a positive non-sexual
relationship with their older sexual partners. (They “checked in” with the
author because they wondered if “something was wrong with them” because
they felt “okay” about their experiences and who they are currently as sexual
adults.) The other survivors fit the model of incest “survivor.” They are women
who were coerced and had hostile or non-bonded sexual relations with males
who were not only older, but in a position of authority over them. They ex-
perienced much emotional and psychological trauma from their earlier sexual
contact (Whelehan’s counseling files).
Although it is difficult to remain objective about this issue given our culture’s
view on adult-child and incestuous sexuality, it is important to do so in order to
help those individuals who have been traumatized to regain a positive sense of
self and sexuality. We need to know when such contact may or may not be harm-
ful and then consider the individual’s unique experience across this continuum.
Early Childhood Sexuality 223
Theories of Childhood Sexuality
Freud’s theories of childhood sexuality present a conflict model of develop-
ment. Each stage has its unique set of conflicts centered around the erotogenic
zones. Neo-Freudians such as Karen Horney (1885–1952) and Erich Fromm
(1900–1980) among others challenged the Freudian view that erotogenic
zones and stages of development are the key to understanding human behav-
ior. Rather than focusing on the zones, some neo-Freudians felt that the rela-
tionships people had with one another were primary. This represents a shift
from biology, libidinal energy, and erotogenic zones to social relations in un-
derstanding childhood development (Gleitman, 1987: 355–356).
Horney took issue with Freud on several specific points in his theory of
childhood sexuality. She contested Freud’s position that children did not rec-
ognize gender differences at birth by asserting that children knew “intuitively”
the differences because each gender had sensations of being penetrated and
penetrating. Horney brings a less male-biased view to the psychoanalytic sce-
nario of child development. She argues that both genders envy one another’s
genitalia. This is in contrast to the Freudian perspective which proposed that
women have penis envy, but men have no comparable womb envy. Later in
her career, she challenged the Freudian notion of the Oedipus complex. She
regarded the Oedipus complex as situationally derived from a particular kind
of family dynamics where emotional dependency of the child was combined
with self-centered and unresponsive parents (Sayers, 1986: 40).
Dr. Spock’s Baby and Child Care book has had a tremendous impact on
childrearing worldwide, spanning over fifty years and continuing past Dr.
Benjamin Spock’s death in 1998. His book has sold over 50 million cop-
ies (making it second in sales only to the Bible) and has been published
in thirty-nine languages (Spock and Needlman, 2004; The Doctor Spock
Company, 2004). Since 1945, Spock’s book has been revised to accommodate
changes in gender roles and family structure in the United States. As he
neared his eightieth birthday, Spock added a co-author in anticipation of the
need for a successor to carry on the tradition (1985). The most recent edition
of Dr. Spock’s Baby and Childcare, the tenth edition, was updated and revised
by Robert Needlman, MD, the vice president of Development and Behav-
ioral Pediatrics at The Dr. Spock Company. Some relevant areas of revision
include “cultural diversity and nontraditional family structures, children’s
learning and brain development, and coping with family stress” (The Doctor
Spock Company, 2019).
Dr. Spock passed away March 15, 1998, at the age of ninety-four. Spock’s
model of childhood development, like Freud’s whom he admired, was also
based on stages of development. For example, he notes that “[b]oys become ro-
mantic toward their mothers, girls toward their fathers” (Spock and Needlman,
2004: 165). For Spock, these feelings about wanting to marry the other gender
parent happen as between the ages of three and six years old. He regarded
224 Early Childhood Sexuality
such feelings as important for preparing the child for adult sexual attraction
and relations: stating “[w]e realize now that there is a childish kind of sexual
feeling at this period which is an essential part of normal development” (1985:
447). Later, he notes “these strong romantic attachments help children to grow
spiritually and to acquire wholesome feelings toward the opposite sex that
will later guide them into good marriages” (Spock and Needlman, 2004: 166).
Again, like Freud, Spock perceived that this attraction brought up sentiments
of rivalry, jealousy, and fear toward the same-sex parent. For Spock, the res-
olution follows as a natural process. “Nature expects that children by 6 or 7
will become quite discouraged about the possibility of having the parent all to
themselves” (Spock and Needlman, 2004: 167). This marks the end of this phase
of attachment which will be “repressed and outgrown” and which is succeeded
by an interest in other activities such as athletics, education, and same-sex peer
involvement (Spock and Needlman, 2004: 177; Spock and Rothenberg, 1985:
437). Spock is rather Freudian in that he regards these interests as caused by the
sublimation of sex that takes place from ages six until about twelve years of age.
Spock advises parents not to give in to their children’s feelings of rivalry by
refraining from overt affection with one another. It is important for children
to be confronted with the fact that they cannot ever marry the parent. Spock’s
account is obviously influenced by Freudian theory of the Oedipus complex
(1985: 437; Spock and Needlman, 2004: 167–168). However, Spock’s represen-
tation of Freud is much less sexually oriented around the pleasure principle.
For example, Spock regards the interest in sex that occurs between two-and-
one-half and three-and-one-half years of age as part of a much broader pattern
associated with the “why” stage of curiosity (1985: 451; Spock and Needlman,
2004: 169, 174–175). He regards this as part of children’s natural curiosity about
why the genders are different and where babies come from.
Summary
1 Childhood and parenting were discussed.
2 The functions of marriage and the family were presented.
3 The subject of kinship was introduced along with kin terms, including
residence and descent.
4 Some of the major theories of incest were offered along with the conse-
quences of incest.
5 Theories of childhood sexuality were reviewed including the psychoana-
lytic perspective and Dr. Spock’s perspective on childhood sexuality.
6 Attention was given to childhood sexual expression in the United States
and cross-culturally.
230 Early Childhood Sexuality
Thought-Provoking Questions
1 How could cultural definitions of incest shape the way individuals actu-
ally experience and interpret sexual encounters with a culturally defined
family member?
2 As a child, do you recall participating in childhood sex play? If so, what
type of parental response did this invoke? Do you recall what messages you
received from society about this behavior? Did your behavior continue,
or did it become covert due to negative responses from parents and/or
society?
Suggested Resources
Books
Francoeur, Robert T. and Raymond J. Noonan. 2004. The Continuum Complete Inter-
national Encyclopedia of Sexuality. New York: Continuum.
Namu, Yang Erche and Christine Mathieu. 2003. Leaving Mother Lake: A Girlhood at
the Edge of the World. Boston, MA: Little, Brown and Company.
Website
US Department of Health and Human Services, Administration for Children and
Families, Administration on Children, Youth and Families, Children’s Bureau.
(2011). Child Maltreatment 2010. Available from http://www.acf.hhs.gov/programs/
cb/stats_research/index.htm#can.
11 Sexuality through the Life
Stages, Part II
Puberty and Adolescence
Chapter Overview
1 Defines and constructs puberty and adolescence.
2 Discusses rites of passage as initiation ceremonies that facilitate the tran-
sition to adulthood.
3 Presents the three phases of rites of passage.
4 Presents female genital cutting as a controversial issue in rites of passage.
5 Uses the Sambia as a case study of rites of passage in which older boys
orally inseminate younger boys.
6 Outlines adolescent sexual behavior in nonindustrialized as well as indus-
trialized societies.
7 Addresses the issue of adolescent sterility.
8 Reviews the topic of sex education in the United States.
9 Compares and contrasts adolescence in the United States with nonindus-
trialized transitions to adulthood.
Having entered upon their calling, children were playing parts in the
adult world and had a recognized status there, even though they were not
yet considered adults. Rights and responsibilities came gradually, with a
number of milestones on the way to maturity. In some respects they were
still considered children for years afterward. But the adult world was not a
foreign and unknown territory to them.
(Sommerville, 1990: 213)
Other options varied by class for girls and boys. Upper- and middle-class boys
were also involved with training for their profession by the latter part of their
teenage years. During this period, the age of marriage was around fifteen years
old, and puberty did not happen until much later—around eighteen or twenty
years old (Francoeur, 1991a, b).
The Industrial Revolution changed the nature of work and, consequently,
the apprenticeship as a mechanism to integrate youth into society was lost. As
the population grew so did employment opportunities for the middle and up-
per classes. Male aristocrats sought positions in the military and government
which, in turn, had to be expanded to accommodate their need for employ-
ment. At the same time, education for the upper and middle classes also kept
youngsters in the home under their parents’ guidance. The results of these
Puberty and Adolescence 235
trends were the creation of adolescence as a separate phase in industrialized
youths’ lives characterized by their separation from the world of work and
adults (Sommerville, 1990: 216). Along with this trend, the age of puberty also
gradually dropped from the late teens and early twenties to what it is today
(Aries, 1962). This historical overview points to the importance of cultural
molding and varying context of adolescence as a life stage. Therefore, when
researchers such as DeLameter and Friedrich (2005) define pre-adolescence
as the years from eight to twelve and adolescence as spanning ages thirteen
through nineteen, this must be placed within the current context of early
twenty-first-century middle-class US perspectives, remembering that adoles-
cence is a social construction.
Turning to the cross-cultural data, we find that the most elemental ways
that peoples categorize and define themselves are based on two criteria: age
and gender. Adolescence is an example of an age grade. Age grades are a
social classification of people whose ages lie within a culturally distinguished
age range. As individuals progress through different age grades they acquire
different rights and obligations as their status changes (Cohen and Eames,
1982: 411; Scupin, 2003: 158). In many societies one’s age grade is a significant
part of one’s life and place in society. This is particularly true in non-stratified
societies in which other ways of identifying and categorizing individuals such
as on the basis of power, wealth, and status are absent.
The magnitude of age grading in people’s lives is related to age sets. An age
set is “[a] non-kin association in which individuals of the same age group inter-
act throughout their lives” (Oswalt, 1986: 432). This means a group of people
of the same gender and similar age will move together though the various life
stages of a particular society together. For example, among the Shavante of
Mato Grasso area of Brazil, boys of seven to twelve years of age are inducted
into the bachelor hut together where they begin a rite of passage wherein they
learn hunting, weapons making, and ceremonial skills, ultimately culminating
in adulthood and elder status. At the end of five years, the boys enter the age
stage of young men together where more learning occurs. After another five
years, the boys marry (in a group age set ceremony) their wives who have been
selected for them by their parents. After this ceremony they may sit on the vil-
lage council and are regarded as young warriors. The final stage for the age set
is a progressive one occurring at five-year intervals as each age set matures with
the eldest age set consisting of the senior men with the most authority. Al-
though Shavante women also have age sets, their participation is much more
limited and doesn’t include the initiation ceremonies, life in bachelor huts, or
elaborate ceremonials. In fact, their age set doesn’t really function as a same-
sex association for women as it does for the men. This may be because the
Shavante society is gender stratified to a certain degree; for example, women
are not allowed to sit on the council where community business is transacted.
Such a set of initiations and stages of increasing authority of Shavante men
provides them the opportunity to strengthen and validate cultural concep-
tions of masculine superiority and privilege in societies in which women have
236 Puberty and Adolescence
less prestige and power (Ember, Ember, and Peregrine, 2005: 393–394). One of
the consequences of initiation ceremonies is to foster age sets among initiates.
Transitions from group to group and from one social situation to the
next are looked on as implicit in the very fact of existence, as that a
man’s [and a woman’s] life comes to be made up of a succession of stages
with similar ends and beginnings: birth, social puberty, marriage, fa-
therhood and motherhood, advancement to higher class, occupational
Puberty and Adolescence 237
specialization, and death. For every one of these events there are cere-
monies whose essential purpose is to enable the individual to pass from
one defined position to another which is equally well defined.
Rites of passage have three distinct phases: separation, transition, and incor-
poration (Van Gennep, 1960: 12). In separation, an individual is removed
from his/her previous world or place in society. Transition or liminality in-
volves “threshold” rites that prepare an individual “for his or her reunion with
society.” This is the phase in which the initiates undergo training for their
anticipated status. As part of this, they are likely to experience some sort of
ordeal or testing. Incorporation rites integrate the initiates back into their
society/social group. This includes a return to the community after the initiate
has been socially and perhaps even spatially removed. It is the public recogni-
tion of the person’s new status in society (Van Gennep, 1960: 21, 46, 67).
In the case of the pubescent, rites of passage function to ease the journey
from the status of child to that of adult. According to Chappel and Coon
(1942), changes of status are disturbing for personal and social relations within
the group. Initiation ceremonies, like other rites of passage, help ease and fa-
cilitate the transition to adulthood. They do this for the novice who must
experience an identity shift as he/she takes on a new position, as well as for
the broader social group who must now accept the youth as an adult. Initia-
tion rites are often stressful and include rigorous tests, hazing, isolation from
previous associates, and/or painful ordeals. These attributes provide symbolic
referents for learning about what the new status as adults includes. Adolescent
rites of passage provide an opportunity to practice and gain knowledge about
adulthood. Chappel and Coon (1942: 484–485) maintain that these ceremo-
nies restore equilibrium to the individual as well as the community. In addi-
tion, the dramatic, painful, and stressful elements may help prepare the youth
for the “stresses” of adulthood as well as function to enhance group solidarity
(Oswalt, 1986: 106). The rites of transition are particularly important as a pe-
riod in which the novice is liminal, or “betwixt and between statuses,” accord-
ing to Victor Turner (1969). By occupying this liminal status, the pubescent
individual will be in a unique position to unlearn her/his position as a child
and take on new responsibilities as an adult.
In summary, many societies provide rites of passage for adolescents to help
facilitate the transformation from the status of child to that of adult. As we
have seen, the transition to a new position in society may be marked by new
sets of rights and obligations as well as relations with people, including kin and
non-kin. It may include new expectations and changes in the individual’s iden-
tity as well. In preparation for this transformation, rites of passage participants
undergo a journey through three characteristic phases: separation, transition
or liminality, and integration. The phases of transition facilitate new learning
and the development of identity components necessary for the new status.
238 Puberty and Adolescence
Ritual activities demarcate and actually facilitate the transformation of the
individual’s identity. They impress upon the novice the importance of the new
status and what it means to be an adult man or woman (or perhaps some other
option) in that society. By being separated socially and/or even geographically
from their families, novitiates are given an opportunity to develop themselves
as future adults. In addition, their families and others who have previously
related to them as children may now regard them in their new status as they
are reintegrated into society as adults. In such a way it is clear to the neo-adult
what their position and place in society will be.
There are, however, gender differences in rites of passage that may be re-
lated to variation in socialization. Chodorow (1974, 1989, 1995) has argued
that female and male socialization may be contrasted in terms of continu-
ity and discontinuity. She believes that this is based on the universality of
women as caregivers of children (i.e., the majority of children experience an
intimate relationship with a female, usually their mothers, during their early
years). However, there is a gender difference in the mother-child relationship.
Male socialization is discontinuous, in that boys must eventually experience
a separation from the domestic worlds of their mothers, while girls do not.
Young females learn to identify with their mothers and other women as associ-
ational role models and need not learn a new role as they mature. In contrast,
boys’ association with women during childhood prevents them from making
an easy transition into masculine role identification (Chodorow, 1974, 1989,
1995). Boys’ initial role model is a cross-sex one in contrast to the associational
one of little girls. This model has been critiqued as ethnocentric because it is
based on notions of the traditional nuclear family in which father is the bread-
winner and mother works in the home. Although it may apply to some white
middle-class Euro-American families, it does not necessarily apply to all; for
example, African American and Mexican-American families. Despite these
shortcomings, Chodorow’s work remains as a major contribution in feminist
psychoanalytic identification theory and psychological anthropology, and has
continued to promote debate (Renzetti and Curran, 2003).
Theories about why initiation ceremonies are often much more elaborate
and at times more severe for males than females, although female ceremonies
are more prevalent, may be related to Chodorow’s thesis. There are a number
of ideas on this subject. Burton and Whiting’s (1961) cross-sex identity hy-
pothesis suggests that young men in polygynous and patrilineal households
are more likely, for a variety of reasons, to acquire a cross-sex feminine gender
identity. In order to switch their cross-sex identification with their mothers to
that of men, a severe initiation ceremony is mandated. It is designed to impress
upon the boys that the world of men is more important and valued than that
of women. According to this theory, severe practices such as circumcision or
genital surgeries are guaranteed to catch the young man’s attention and to re-
verse the feminine cross-sex identity. An important facet of these ceremonies
is a mockery or “put down” of women which contributes to masculine self-
definition as “not feminine.” This argument has been criticized because the
Puberty and Adolescence 239
alleged cross-sex identity is not demonstrated or verified by the researchers but
only speculated upon. Other less psychodynamically focused theories include
Young’s socio-cultural interpretation of initiation ceremonies.
Young’s (1965) research emphasized that the functions of rites of passage
varied by gender; male initiation ceremonies were designed to incorporate
men into the entire community, while female initiations integrated women
into domestic groups. Young postulated that this was related to the differential
roles and tasks that each sex was assigned in society: women were assigned
domestic roles and men public roles. For Young, male solidarity was an import-
ant feature overlooked by the psychoanalytic approaches of researchers such
as Burton and Whiting (Bock, 1988: 117). Solidarity was also a salient feature
for the female household as well. Young explained that female initiations were
less elaborate because the domestic sphere is more private and less extensive
as opposed to the public world of males (1965: 106). The domestic arena is also
a continuous and familiar one in that females are born into it and exposed
to information about their role as they are growing up. This was suggested in
Chodorow’s (1974, 1989, 1995) approach as well.
Female initiation ceremonies will often ritually mark menarche, when a girl
begins to menstruate. The timeframe in a girl’s life between menarche and
full adulthood is referred to as maidenhood. Maidenhood, a period in girl’s
life where she is prepared for adulthood, is co-terminously a phase when there
is also great deal of cultural interest in her behavior. Maidenhood is a social
construction (not a biological period) and the length of time it encompasses
varies (Ward and Edelstein, 2006: 72).
Menarche is an event that is regarded as a very important in many cultures,
signaling a girl’s sexual and/or reproductive maturity (Ward and Edelstein,
2006: 273). How a society responds to menarche is related to the broader cul-
tural context such as attitudes toward women in general, women’s positioning
in society compared to men, forms of social organization, and beliefs about
menstrual blood. For example, New Guinea highland groups are well known
for their view of menstrual blood as polluting. Menarche rituals are as varied
as there are cultures. In some groups, like the Gussii, a clitoridectomy, removal
of the clitoris, may be part of the ceremony acknowledging menarche (see
discussion of female genital cutting). In other societies such as the Tlingit, a
girl was confined for at least a year with a series of proscriptions around her be-
havior (she must not gaze at the sky or must scratch an itch only with a stone)
(Oswalt, 1986: 108–109). Among Andaman Islanders, according to Service
(1978: 60–61):
The meanings of menstrual blood vary from “power” to “pollution” and may
be related to specific menstrual taboos. Menstrual taboos are cultural rules
defining contact with menstruating women. According to Ward and Edelstein
(2006: 71), “[t]here is no cross-cultural evidence that menstruation is every-
where considered unclean, that women uniformly feel shame or pain, or that
menstrual blood repulses men.” They argue that if early anthropologists and
others would have labeled the seclusion of women in menstrual “sanctuaries”
rather than “huts” we would have a very different prism for regarding this prac-
tice. Currently it is difficult to evaluate whether menstrual seclusion practices
suppressed women or invigorated them with rest and recreation in a woman-
only domain (Ward and Edelstein, 2006).
Schlegel and Barry’s (1980: 696–715) classic study of 186 societies found
that societies that emphasized female initiation ceremonies were more likely
to be gatherers and hunters. They suggested this was because reproduction
is important for foraging groups whose population density is low. Such cere-
monies among foragers emphasize the importance of the life-giving attributes
of women. In contrast, initiation rites in small-scale plant cultivators (like
non-intensive horticulturalists) emphasize equally both girls and boys. How-
ever, when rigid separation of the sexes is enforced during the rites of passage,
this accents the cultural importance of gender differentiation in such societies
(Schlegel and Barry, 1980: 712). In fact, this characteristic is not uncommon
in puberty rites in general. Despite variance in social organization, a general
feature of female initiations is that they are centered on fertility while male’s
initiations are focused on responsibility. In horticultural societies with both
male and female initiation ceremonies, same-sex bonding is an important
function of the initiation ceremonies where homosocial relations (same-sex)
are an integral part of such cultures (Schlegel and Barry, 1980: 712). Before
turning our attention to an extreme form of ritualized masculinity in which
boy-insemination rituals flourish among the Sambia (Herdt, 1981, 1984a, b,
1987, 2006, among others), we will turn our attention to the topic of female
genital cutting to highlight issues in rites of passage for women.
The politics of naming are closely articulated with the consequences of these
practices for girls and women and penetrate Euro-American and other indus-
trialized national discourses about human rights and cultural relativism. The
psychological, reproductive, sexual, and health consequences of this surgery on
women, their families and partners are part of heated debates (Lightfoot-Klein,
1989, 1990). As we stated earlier, female genital cutting is a highly charged
issue that is influenced by acculturation, immigration, emigration, and global-
ization. Issues of ethnocentrism, cultural relativism, and indigenous cultural
integrity are involved.
As of 2013, at least 200 million girls and women had undergone FGM and an es-
timated 3 million girls are at risk for undergoing FGM every year (UNICEF, 2013).
There are well-established negative health consequences of female genital cutting
including infertility, shock, hemorrhage, septicemia, retention of menstrual blood
Puberty and Adolescence 243
and urine (hematocolpos) resulting in urinary tract infections and chronic pelvic
infections, and serious complications in childbirth. Sexual functioning may be
interfered with resulting in painful intercourse and loss of sexual response. In the
situation of infibulation, first intercourse may not only be painful but virtually
impossible (Gruenbaum, 2005; Klapper, 2006; Kopelman, 2002). Lightfoot-Klein
(1989) and Gruenbaum offer some opposing evidence regarding sexual function-
ing, arguing that many women maintain their capacity for sexual responsiveness
and are orgasmic even with infibulation. This may be related to the degree and
type of cutting, expertise of the midwife, barber, “surgeon,” as well as the nature
of the relationship with the partner (Gruenbaum, 2005: 483).
Women with type III FGM have a 31 percent increased risk of delivering
via cesarean section and a 69 percent increased risk of developing postpartum
hemorrhage. Risk of infant deaths born from mothers who have undergone
type III FGM increased by 55 percent (WHO, 2019: 3).
Note the use of terminology of “FGM” in this statement. The emic and etic
explanations for this practice sometimes converge and sometimes don’t. Female
genital surgeries cross diverse religions and therefore are not ethically the result
of religious dictums, although people who support or denounce the practice may
offer religious reference. For example, the Qur’an does not require it, but various
interpretations of Islam and the Prophet Mohammed may be cited as justification
for acceptance or rejection of the practice (Gruenbaum, 2005). The emic reasons
given for female genital cutting can be summarized as falling into five categories:
This said, understanding the practice of genital surgery requires a context that
can complicate a discussion of the practice. For some, such as the Maasai of
Kenya, it is a rite of passage and occurs usually at marriage when a girl is
244 Puberty and Adolescence
excised. After she is healed she is allowed to join her husband as a woman, no
longer a girl. Yet for others, genital surgery may be resisted as part of ethnic
identity or adopted as part of acculturation for an immigrant group such as
among the Zabarma and Hausa minorities in the Sudan (Gruenbaum, 2005).
For some peoples, the genital cutting is part of an aesthetic for smoothness
that is regarded as part of an ideology of beauty held by both men and women
(Gruenbaum, 2006; Ward and Edelstein, 2006). It is also articulated with be-
liefs that female genital cutting enhances male sexual response (Gruenbaum,
2006; Ward and Edelstein, 2006).
From an etic perspective, Boddy refers to such practices as well as the con-
comitant rules for women’s modesty and chastity as the “overdetermination
of women’s selfhood” (1989: 252). These are rules of conduct that are more
restrictive for women than for men. Such rules and the practice of genital cut-
ting are associated with patricentric and patriarchal societies in which males
are dominant. This is not to say that women may not have power in the do-
mestic sphere, but that men hold the power in the formal spheres of society
including the public, economic, and the political arenas. Genital surgery is
therefore embedded in women’s subordination and ideologies that support that
subordination. These may include notions that women are “essentially” sexu-
ally voracious and the genital cutting “tames” those tendencies along with the
belief that women are unclean and hence are purified by the practice (Badri,
2000; Gruenbaum, 2005; Kopelman, 2002: 52).
These are extremely difficult, emotionally charged behaviors not only
within cultures, but across cultures as well. Resolution will take a long time
to achieve because female genital surgery is a complicated issue. Reference to
female genital cutting as mutilation and torture are culturally insensitive ways
to approach this issue. The international reaction of industrialized nations to
“eliminate” the practice is not always welcomed. There is a growing response
of African and other international/indigenous women who wish to eliminate
genital surgeries or who wish to introduce less invasive and more symbolic
forms of the surgery (Mutisya, 2002; Ward and Edelstein, 2006). Such ap-
proaches recognize how complex this issue is and include respecting the sym-
bolic aspect of genital surgery as a rite of passage signaling a young woman’s
readiness for marriage (Gruenbaum, 2005; Mutisya, 2002; Ward and Edelstein,
2006). As we have seen there are agencies such as the World Health Organiza-
tion that are completely against the practice and/or individuals, such as Alice
Walker in her film Warrior Marks, who asserts an unequivocal anticultural
relativistic stance toward this issue (Ward and Edelstein, 2006). However, as
Ellen Gruenbaum cautions: “[T]he first step in changing anything is to under-
stand what it means to the people who do it. With more insight, we can better
understand why people have resisted widespread change and why some are
now pursuing change” (2005: 488). Those wishing to introduce change in this
practice such as grassroots and local women leaders as well as their supporters
argue that increasing women’s educational and economic opportunities is an
important part of the solution for change. In addition, young men must also
Puberty and Adolescence 245
take a stance that resists the practice by not marrying women who are geni-
tally cut (Gruenbaum, 2005).
Others have suggested surrogate rites of passage that don’t involve cutting
(e.g., a Kenyan rural group created “Circumcision through Words,” an alter-
native rite for girls that involves seclusion and learning women’s specialized
knowledge [Reaves in Gruenbaum, 2005]). More controversial and illegal in
many industrialized nations, are alternatives that involve medical professionals
in the nicking/pricking of the clitoris (Mutisya, 2002). This is clearly a difficult
subject traversing human rights, justice, fairness, respect for difference, emic
and etic approaches, and avoidance of harm among others (Salmon, 2006).
Lest we take a position of moral superiority as industrialized women and
men, it is important to understand how our own societies intervene in girls’
and women’s bodies through diet, exercise regimes, and other techniques
that make women beautiful and sexually desirable, such as shaving the pu-
bic area, bikini waxing, labial piercing, and plastic surgeries including breast
implants and “vaginal rejuvenation surgeries.” Vaginal rejuvenation surgery,
also referred to as vaginoplasty, includes specific procedures to tighten a “loose
vagina” and to reduce the appearance of enlarged labia. These have been mar-
keted as enhancing sexual satisfaction and beautifying the appearance of the
genitals (CosmeticSurgery.com, 2006; Navarro, 2004: 8; “Vaginal Rejuvena-
tion Surgery,” 2003).
The Sambia
Gilbert Herdt’s study, The Sambia: Ritual, Sexuality, and Change in Papua New
Guinea (2006, first edition, 1987), describes the rites of passage of the Sambia
male children/adolescents as they pursue adulthood. What makes the Sambia
of particular interest is that their initiation into manhood involves an ex-
tended period of masculine insemination rites in which older boys orally in-
seminate younger boys. All males among the Sambia will have experienced the
roles of inseminatee/fellator and inseminator/fellatee with other men during
the course of their initiation and journey into manhood (see also Herdt, 1981,
1984a, b, 1988). Herdt notes that boy inseminating rites were once practiced
among fifty or sixty traditional (precontact) cultures in Melanesia (2006). Ac-
cording to Herdt this ritual is part of “culture specific initiation rites, secret
male cults, and small-scale patrilineal societies involved in rampant warfare
among men and sexual antagonism between men and women” (Herdt, 2006:
xvi). Herdt’s research began in 1974 and spanned more than thirty years and
involved over twelve research trips. Since beginning his research, the Sambia
have undergone tremendous change including the ending of warfare (six years
before Herdt’s arrival), the increasing influence of Christianity through mis-
sionization, the growing impact of the wage labor economy, and a concomitant
escalation in women’s status (Herdt, 2006). Although the following discussion
246 Puberty and Adolescence
situates the Sambia in the ethnographic present of 1974, Herdt (2006: 154)
comments on some of the more recent and dramatic changes that have
occurred:
A sexual revolution has overtaken the Sambia. In the past decade or so, they
have undergone huge life-changing, culture-breaking, and culture-making
alterations in their sexuality—greater than anything we have experienced
in our civilization in such a short period of time—and much greater than
the so-called sexual revolution of the 1960s in the United States. To go
from absolute gender segregation and arranged marriages, with universal
ritual initiation that controlled sexual and gender development and im-
posed the radical practice of boy-insemination, to abandoning initiation,
seeing adolescent boys and girls kiss and hold hands in public, arranging
their own marriages, and building square houses with one bed for the
newlyweds, as the Sambia have done, is revolutionary.
The Sambia are a highland Papua, New Guinea, group characterized by war-
fare and male privilege. As is typical in groups like this, there is great disparity
in the status of men and women, with men being privileged and dominant.
At a prepubescent age, boys will leave their mothers and live in all-male club-
houses, where for the next seven years they will fellate the older males (teenag-
ers and men in their early twenties) who share the clubhouse with them. It is
only by swallowing the ejaculate of the older boys that a young boy can hope
to grow into manhood. Manhood is defined by semen, which is regarded as a
very powerful substance. Boys are believed to be born without semen so it is
important that a boy consume as much as possible in order to have an ample
supply. The obvious way to get this is by fellatio, or oral insemination. Semen
has a power known as jerungdu (Herdt, 1987: 101, 2006: 57). Jerungdu is de-
fined as “the principle of male strength, virility, and manliness associated with
semen and warrior prowess in Sambia culture” (Herdt, 2006: 167).
Like sexuality in general, there are rules and practices regulating homo-erotic
behavior. When a young man reaches about twenty-five years old, he is mar-
ried. However, he must remain attentive to preserving his supply of sacred
fluids, lest his spouse, who is regarded as potentially dangerous and polluting,
sap him of his strength and use up his semen during intercourse. Societies
like the Sambia are noted for female pollution avoidance rituals, which dra-
matize women’s social inequality to men. Female pollution avoidance rituals
may restrict menstruating women by confining them to a special structure (a
menstrual house). These rituals are based on beliefs that females are impure.
Avoidance of women and concepts of female impurity associated with the fe-
male menstrual cycle contribute to status inequalities and disparities between
the sexes (Herdt, 1987, 2006). Such rituals do not occur in societies in which
women share power with men but tend to be found in patrilineal societies and
societies in which women have lower prestige (Zelman, 1977: 714–733). Note
that this does not necessarily contradict Ward and Edelstein’s perspective that
Puberty and Adolescence 247
such seclusion may indeed be a sanctuary for women and while it may be per-
sonally empowering, such practices according to cross-cultural research, do
reproduce the relations of inequality and apparently do not augment women’s
overall status. The critical variable in whether seclusion is oppressive or en-
hancing to women may be the patrilineal kinship system. Clearly more re-
search is needed on this subject.
The purpose of initiation among the Sambia is to make men out of boys.
Little boys inhabit the world of women and are dangerously contaminated by
it. As a result of this, they are regarded as not quite masculine. Masculinity
is not something that is seen as “naturally” occurring for Sambian boys and
men; jerungdu must be acquired as the source of masculinity. Consequently,
males have two major barriers in becoming masculine: in addition to the femi-
nization of young boys that is believed to occur through their close ties with
their mothers, there is also the problem that males cannot manufacture their
own semen. To make matters worse they can lose jerungdu through ejacula-
tion. The Sambia ritualized insemination initiation resolves this dilemma
of manhood. Fellatio is the means of acquiring an initial supply of semen.
The proof of the power of the initiation among the Sambia is that young
boys provide evidence that it works by becoming bigger, physically strong,
and assertive. In the end, the pre-initiated and feminized boy (polluted by
contact with his mother) has been remade into a fierce warrior (Herdt, 1987,
2006). Through the course of initiation the boys have learned the cultural
values associated with masculinity and with it the secrets of manhood hid-
den from Sambian women. For example, heterosexual coitus is particularly
dangerous for men since through it they can lose their power. Once the
initiates are past the stage of ingesting semen through fellatio, they must
learn secret lore on how to replenish their jerungdu by drinking a white tree
sap that can restore their power (Herdt, 1987, 2006).
The Sambia are a provocative example to contrast with our own industrial-
ized society’s concepts of manhood and sexuality. During most of the initiation
cycle the initiate is not permitted any heterosexual activity. In the early stages,
the boys act as the fellators and ingestors of semen which contains the power
to make them grow into manhood. The initiates are prohibited from mastur-
bation or anal sex as well. In other words, they have no sexual outlets other
than wet dreams. However, from about fifteen years of age through eighteen,
the boys enter the third stage of initiation when they become bachelors and
inserters rather than fellators. Their ability in the “inseminator” role proves:
that they are strong and have jerungdu, because their bodies are sexually
mature and have semen to “feed” to younger boys. They feel more mascu-
line than at any previous time in their lives. So the bachelors go through
a phase of intense sexual activity, a period of vigorous homoerotic activ-
ity and contacts, having one relationship after another with boys. Their
sexual behavior is primarily promiscuous, for the initiates are concerned
mostly with taking in semen, while the bachelors mainly desire sexual
248 Puberty and Adolescence
release through domination of younger boys… Eventually Sambia adoles-
cent boys become more interested in females.
(Herdt, 1987: 162, 2006: 115)
The purpose of the boy insemination is to acquire semen so that the youths
may ultimately marry and achieve fatherhood. Around the age of seventeen,
the bachelors enter the fourth stage of initiation in which they are permitted
interaction with women. From the beginning of the initiation until the fourth
stage, they have not been in contact with women. In their late teens and early
twenties, the initiates go through a fifth stage of bisexuality as married men,
which is followed by a sixth stage of adulthood in which heterosexuality is
practiced (Herdt, 1987, 2006). This stage is associated with the birth of the
man’s first child. Thus, the birth of a child is the marker for full adulthood.
Of these measures the first is the most successful, while the third has not
proven to be a deterrent to the highly motivated youngster (Ford and Beach,
1951: 183–184). One of the means restrictive societies use to ensure control of
youngsters’ sexuality is by placing a value on female virginity. Some may even
have tests of this virginity through demonstrations of bloodied cloth or deflo-
ration ceremonies (Ford and Beach, 1951: 186, also Delaney, 1991).
• 4.5 percent of females under eighteen and 5.5 percent of males under eigh-
teen acknowledge same-sex attraction only.
• Five percent of girls under eighteen and 2.3 percent of males under eigh-
teen reported equal attraction to both sexes.
• 44.7 percent of the girls and 56.8 percent of boys report other sex attraction
with the remainder either uncertain, or not understanding the question.
According to the Youth Risk Behavior Survey in 2017, 39.5 percent of high
school students in the United States had ever had sex: 41.4 percent were male
and 37.7 percent were female. The number of students who ever had sex has for
the most part steadily declined over the years (CDC, 2017: 10, see Figure 11.1).
72
64
56
PERCENTAGE
48
40
32
24
16
8
TOTAL MALE FEMALE
0
Figure 11.1 Percentage of high school students who ever had sex from 2007–2017.
Source: Youth Risk Behavior Survey 2007–2017, CDC.
94
Condom 96
97
55
Withdrawal 57
60
61
Pill 56
56
8
Emergency 14
Contraception 123
21
Depo-Provera 20
17
11
Fertility awareness 15
12
2
Patch 2
10
2
5
Ring
5
3
Intrauterine device
3
3
Implant 1
3
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Percent
1
The Percentage of female teenagers who ever used emergency contraception increased significantly from 2002 to
2011-2015 (0<0.06).
2
The percentage of female teenagers who ever used the patch increased significantly from 2002 to 2005-2010 and
decreased significantly from 2006−2010 to 2011−2015 (ρ<0.05).
3
The percentage of female teenagers who ever used the implant inceased significantly from 2006-2010 to 2011-2015 (ρ<0.05).
NOTES: CI is confidence interval Neither the contraception ring nor the implant were available in 2002. The number of
teenagers who had ever used the intrauterine device in 2002 was too small to be statistically reliable.
Figure 11.2 Methods of contraception ever used among females aged 15–19 who had
ever had sexual intercourse.
Source: NCHS, National Survey of Family Growth, 2002, 2006–2010, 2011–2015.
Trends in the Prevalence of Sexual Behaviors and HIV Testing
National YRBS: 1991—2017
The national Youth Risk Behavior Survey (YRBS) monitors health behaviors that contribute to the leading
causes of death, disability, and social problems among youth and adults in the United States. The national
YRBS is conducted every two years during the spring semester and provides data representative of 9th
through 12th grade students in public and private schools throughout the United States.
54.1 53.0 53.1 48.4 49.9 45.6 46.7 46.8 47.8 46.0 47.4 46.8 41.2 39.5 Decreased 1991—2017 No change
262 Puberty and Adolescence
Decreased 1991—2017
37.5 37.5 37.9 34.8 36.3 33.4 34.3 33.9 35.0 34.2 33.7 34.0 30.1 28.7 Decreased 1991—2013 No change
Decreased 2013—2017
Used a condom
(during last sexual intercourse, among students who were currently sexually active)
Increased 1991—2017
46.2 52.8 54.4 56.8 58.0 57.9 63.0 62.8 61.5 61.1 60.2 59.1 56.9 53.8 Increased 1991—2005 No change
Decreased 2005—2017
Used an IUD or implant
(before last sexual intercourse to prevent pregnancy, among students who were currently sexually active)
—3 — — — — — — — — — — 1.6 3.3 4.1 Increased 2013—2017 No change
Figure 11.3 Trends in the prevalence of sexual behaviors and HIV testing, CDC.
Trend from Change from
Percentages
1991–2017 1 2015–20172
1991 1993 1995 1997 1999 2001 2003 2005 2007 2009 2011 2013 2015 2017
Used birth control pills
(before last sexual intercourse to prevent pregnancy, among students who were currently sexually active)
Increased 1991—2017
20.8 18.4 17.4 16.6 16.2 18.2 17.0 17.6 16.0 19.8 18.0 19.0 18.2 20.7 Decreased 1991—1995 No change
Increased 1995—2017
Did not use any method to prevent pregnancy
(during last sexual intercourse, among students who were currently sexually active)
Decreased 1991—2017
16.5 15.3 15.8 15.2 14.9 13.3 11.3 12.7 12.2 11.9 12.9 13.7 13.8 13.8 Decreased 1991—2007 No change
No change 2007—2017
Drank alcohol or used drugs
(before last sexual intercourse, among students who were currently sexually active)
Decreased 1991—2017
21.6 21.3 24.8 24.7 24.8 25.6 25.4 23.3 22.5 21.6 22.1 22.4 20.6 18.8 Increased 1991—1999 No change
Decreased 1999—2017
Ever been tested for HIV
(not counting tests done if they donated blood)
Decreased 2005—2017
—3 — — — — — — 11.9 12.9 12.7 12.9 12.9 10.2 9.3 No change 2005—2013 No change
Decreased 2013—2017
1 Based on linear and quadratic trend analyses using logistic regression models controlling for sex, race/ethnicity, and grade, p < 0.05. Significant linear trends (if
present) across all available years are described first followed by linear changes in each segment of significant quadratic trends (if present).
2 Based on t-test analysis, p < 0.05.
3
Not available.
Puberty and Adolescence
recommendation by the U.S. Government, Department of Health and Human Services, or Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
264 Puberty and Adolescence
The evidence suggests that comprehensive sex education (which includes
AIDS education, discussion of various STI/HIV, and pregnancy prevention
options in addition to abstinence) delays initiation of sex and increases con-
traceptive use in youth (Haberland and Rogow, 2015: 19; Kirby, 2008: 24;
Starkman and Rajani, 2002: 317). In fact, abstinence-only sexual education is
positively correlated with teen pregnancy even after controlling for confound-
ing factors such as income, education, and ethnic diversity (Stanger-Hall and
Hall, 2011: 6). According to data from the National Survey of Adolescent Males
(NSAM), between 1988 and 1995, the rate of condom use at last intercourse
among fifteen- to nineteen-year-old males increased from 56 percent to 69 per-
cent (Murphy and Boggess, 1998), although data from the Centers for Disease
Control and Prevention indicates that in 2005, 34 percent of currently sexually
active high school students did not use a condom during last sexual intercourse
(“Youth Risk Behavior Surveillance-United States, 2005”), [2006, see Figure 11.3].
It is possible to become pregnant during first intercourse and it is also pos-
sible to contract HIV as well. We cannot assume that US adolescents are
using contraceptives regularly. The rate of contraceptive use with first sex
has increased substantially among adolescents. For females (ages fifteen to
nineteen) in 2002, 75 percent used some form of contraception at first inter-
course, while 82 percent of males (ages fifteen to nineteen) did so. Despite this
90
80
70
PERCENTAGE
60
61.5 61.1 60.2 59.1
56.9
50 53.8
40
30
20
10
Figure 11.4 Percentage of high school students who used a condom the last time they
had sex.
Source: Youth Risk Behavior Survey 2017, CDC.
Disclaimer: Reference to specific commercial products, manufacturers, companies, or trademarks
does not constitute its endorsement or recommendation by the U.S. Government, Department
of Health and Human Services, or Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
Puberty and Adolescence 265
positive trend, teens are inconsistent in contraceptive use. For example, only
28 percent of females and 47 percent of males reported use of a condom every
time they had penile-vaginal sex in the previous twelve months (Franzetta
et al., 2006). Condom use has decreased significantly in high school students
since 2007; from 2015 to 2017, the percentage of teens who used a condom
the last time they had sex decreased from 56.9 percent to 53.8 percent (see
Figure 11.4).
Using contraception is difficult for adolescents since it is loaded with sym-
bolic meaning about oneself as a sexual being. By using contraception ado-
lescents must acknowledge that they are engaging in preplanned sex. This
may lead to conflicting feelings regarding values and sense of self as a “moral”
being. Concerns about privacy and parent approval of sexual behaviors can
deter adolescents from using contraceptives as well, particularly in families
and communities with strong cultural values related to sexuality (Caal et al.,
2013: 620; Gilliam et al., 2009: 100) With adolescence in industrialized soci-
ety comes a number of questions for the individual concerning sexuality and
contraception.
120
116.2
100
Birth rates per 1,000 females ages 15-19
100.3
Hispanic
80
Black
60
59.9
Total
40
42.5
28.9
White
27.6
20
18.8
13.4
0
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
00
01
02
03
04
05
06
07
08
09
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
Year
Figure 11.5 Birth rates per 1,000 females ages 15–19, by race and Hispanic origin of
mother, 1990–2017.
Source: “Trends in Teen Pregnancy and Childbearing” HHS.gov.
Unfortunately, the statistics for the United States, and the other countries
for that matter, do not distinguish differences among ethnic groups and other
minorities. Nevertheless, these differences between the United States and
other industrialized nations have been largely attributed to the absence of:
If we in the United States are to reduce pregnancy and STI rates effectively, we
must desensitize the issue of condom use and remove taboos associated with this
method (Sinding, 2005). It is also important that we not only provide condoms
but make available information on how to use condoms correctly in a culturally
sensitive manner to enhance their effectiveness (Sinding, 2005). In summary,
lessons from industrialized countries with low levels of teenage pregnancy/birth
and STIs correlate social acceptance of adolescent sexual relations with com-
prehensive sexuality education that emphasizes the avoidance of STIs/HIV and
pregnancy prevention, and provides easy access to contraceptive and reproduc-
tive health sources (“Teenagers’ Sexual and Reproductive Health,” 2004).
268 Puberty and Adolescence
What is the price of adolescent pregnancy and childbirth?
• Teen mothers are more likely to drop out of school than their peers and
are significantly less likely to earn a high school degree or to earn a college
degree.
• Teen motherhood costs the United States approximately $16,000 per teen
birth (NCSL, “Teen Pregnancy Prevention” 2019).
• The children of teen mothers are often more inclined to have health prob-
lems which are a result of birth weight and premature births. Low birth
weights lead to problems in childhood development and extended health
risks (Weiss, 2000, 2006).
Growing evidence suggests that teen mothers’ prior backgrounds, with the ma-
jority of them being non-white and economically disadvantaged, plays a larger
role in negative consequences than the teen pregnancy itself (Patel and Sen,
2012: 1070; SmithBattle, 2006: 131), although more long-term research needs
to be done. Other problems prevail among teenage mothers. Adding to their
economic vulnerability is an increased likelihood of a repeat birth to teenaged
mothers; approximately one in five give birth each year (CDC “Vital Signs”,
2013). Children of teenaged mothers are at a higher risk of having educational
difficulties and disabilities that are related to their mother’s socio-economic
positioning (Weiss, 2006; “Young Mothers Disadvantage, Not Their Age It-
self,” 2001).
• Many teens wait until after they have had sex to talk to their parents
about sex (i.e., if they ever do). One in four teen girls and nearly one in
two teen boys who have had sexual intercourse say their parents don’t
know about it.
• Among parents in the know, many are finding out about their teens’ sex
lives later than they might like to, or at least too late to have an influ-
ence on the choices their children make, or to encourage them to protect
themselves.
• Of all the teens surveyed—including both those who have had sex as well
as those who have not—half have never had a conversation with a parent
about how to know when you are ready to have sex.
• Even fewer have talked with a parent about how to bring up topics like
birth control, condoms or sexually transmitted disease (STD) testing with
someone they are dating.
• Most teens aren’t talking about their sexual health with a doctor either.
Less than a third report having talked with a health care provider about
HIV/AIDS, other STDs, or condoms (“Sex Smarts: A Public Information
Partnership,” 2002).
• Low income, minority parents reported more discussion with their teens
about the negative consequences of sex and where to obtain birth control
than high income, white parents.
• Politically conservative, religious parents reported more discussion with
their teens about the negative consequences of sex than their liberal and
non-religious counterparts.
• In general, non-religious parents reported more discussion about where to
obtain birth control than religious parents.
• Parents were less likely to talk with males, younger teens, and teens not
believed to be romantically involved.
The CDC also reports that female teens are more likely to talk to their parents
about sex: two out of three teenage girls talked to their parents about saying
270 Puberty and Adolescence
no to sex compared to only two our of five males who did the same (Martinez,
Abma, and Copen, 2010: 1). Two thirds of sons in another study reported that
they had not talked with their parents about how to use a condom (Beckett
et al., 2009: 39). Forty percent of girls from the same study had not talked to
their parents before starting birth control (Beckett et al., 2009: 40) Salience
of gender in parent and teen discussions (see last bulleted point) has been
recorded by other researchers as well. Wilson and Koo (2010: 7) found that
daughters are more likely to talk to their mothers about sex but prefer to talk to
fathers about topics relating to dating and relationships. Mothers of daughters
are also more likely to recommend that they wait to have sex more than moth-
ers of sons. Both daughters and sons are more likely to talk to their mother
about sex over their father.
The mass media should not be underestimated as a source of sex education
(Kunkel et al., 2003, 2005). In fact, media, specifically television viewing, takes
precedence over the peer group according to some researchers (Kunkel et al.,
2003, 2005). In fact, Brown, Halpern, and L’Engle (2005) refer to the media
as the “sexual super peer.” Research indicates that children and adolescents
watch on the average three hours of television a day. Television can have both
a positive as well as negative outcome on young people’s sexual decision mak-
ing, including use of safer sex and pregnancy prevention strategies. Donner-
stein and Smith (2001) and Gunter (2002) regard television as an important
vehicle for sexual socialization of adolescents influencing knowledge, values,
beliefs, attitudes and behavior (in Kunkel et al., 2005). Although television
programming, which may offer sexuality education information (e.g., STI/HIV
information, safer sex and pregnancy prevention has increased since 1998), it
has subsequently leveled off since 2002.
The Internet is a substantial resource for sexual education. Adolescents
commonly search for topics related to HIV/AIDs, pregnancy, contraception,
sexual anatomy and sexual orientation. With 73 percent of the teenage pop-
ulation using social media, web-based interventions could have a significant
impact on adolescent sexual health (Simon and Daneback, 2013: 308). Gold
et al. (2011: 5) identified the amount of social networking sites (SNS) used to
educate people about sexual health and involve health promotion. The study
found that out of 178 online health promotion activities, 58 percent used at
least one SNS. Future research should work to identify how much SNS are
utilized by adolescents to learn about sexual health.
Other significant sources of information on sexuality and influences on
adolescent sexuality besides parents and the mass media include schools,
political policy, and religious institutions (Halpern et al., 2000). Virginity
pledges are abundant in church programming, although not all churches sup-
port abstinence-only approaches. For example, a survey of African American
churches found church leaders were open to including sexuality as a topic
for their health education programs, including information on contraceptive
education (Coyne-Beasley and Schoenbach, 2000). The “virginity pledge”
approach was begun by the Southern Baptist Church with their “True Love
Puberty and Adolescence 271
Waits” program. Virginity pledges burgeoned in the mid-1990s especially
among evangelical Christian organizations. However, research has found that
teens making a private pledge to wait until they are more mature to have sex
is more effective in reducing the likelihood that they will engage in sexual in-
tercourse and oral sex. This is contrasted with those who made formal pledges
such as a virginity pledge, which had no effect on teens’ sexual behavior (Ber-
samin et al., 2005: 428). There is no significant difference in age of first sex or
sexual activity between those that take virginity pledges and those that do not
(Rosenbaum, 2009: 7). Virginity pledgers are less likely to use contraceptives
than non-pledgers. This is in part due to a mistrust of contraceptives in pop-
ulations that practice abstinence only, and through virginity pledging (Paik
Sanchagrin, and Heimer, 2016: 4).
In contrast to this research, which showed no effect on teenage sex, Han-
nah Brückner of Yale University and Peter Bearman of Columbia University
conducted a study of virginity pledging teens and reported virginity-pledging
teens were actually more likely to engage in riskier sexual behavior; they were
less likely to use condoms, and more likely to engage in oral and anal sex. In
addition, intercourse was only delayed (but not prevented) by twelve to eigh-
teen months among the virginity pledgers and they were less likely to know
their STI status (Brückner and Bearman, 2005: 271–278; Wind, 2005).
The public and private school systems in the United States that offer sex
education curriculums are also an important institution in teen sexuality edu-
cation. Nationwide, schools are not uniform in terms of content and coverage.
Socio-economic variables influence teen sexual expression and can impact the
influence of variables such as religion, the schools, and the mass media. Ac-
cording to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, students attending
schools in rural or high poverty regions are more likely to engage in adolescent
risky sexual behavior and unprotected sex (Underwood, 2019: 38). Further-
more, students in sexual minorities (lesbian, gay and bisexual students) are less
likely to use contraceptives such as birth control or condoms. Data regarding
the use of other protective barriers, such as dental dams, was not collected
(CDC, 2017: 60). Inequalities in sexual behavior are further stratified in this
group by socio-economic status (SES): young men who have sex with men that
are foreign-born or have low SES engage in riskier sexual behavior (Halkitis
and Figueroa, 2013: 187).
Concerns over sex education gained prominence in the 1960s as a result of
SIECUS (The Sex Information and Education Council of the United States)
and AASECT (the American Association of Sexuality Educators, Counselors
and Therapists). Research indicates that the question of sex education is not “if”
such programs should occur but rather “what kind of approach.” Surveys indi-
cate that that the majority of Americans favor more comprehensive sexuality
education; that is, education that includes information on a variety of options,
over abstinence-only education (“Facts in Brief: Sexuality Education: Sex and
Pregnancy among Teenagers,” 2002). Keep in mind that comprehensive sexu-
ality education programs in schools are still fairly rare. Currently, 24 states and
272 Puberty and Adolescence
the District of Columbia require sex education. In regards to content of sex ed-
ucation, 18 states mandate that contraception must be included in curriculum,
and 37 states require that abstinence is included in curriculum (Guttmacher
Institute, 2016).
Sex education programs vary a great deal in their success rates. Though
a number of stances may be taken, we have an excellent example of what
doesn’t work. This has historical precedence: the “Reaganesque” “Just Say No”
approach of the 1980s. This slogan was the result of a 1981 effort to reduce
teenage pregnacies without advocating birth control through the Adolescent
Family Life Act (ALFA), a congressional act that funded programs promoting
premarital abstinence. One study even found that “participants [in one ALFA
project] engaged in more sexual activity than controls” (Troiano, 1990: 101).
While funding for AOUM programs through the AFLA Act ceased in 2010,
Congress created the Sexual Risk Avoidance Education program to continue
support for abstinence-focused sex education (Santelli et al., 2017: 275). This
program exists in conjunction with the Teen Pregnancy Prevention (TPP)
program that was created by President Barack Obama in 2010. This program
sought to shift funding from AOUM policies towards more comprehensive,
risk reduction programs to prevent teen pregnancy. These programs include
the promotion of contraceptives in adolescent populations and culturally sen-
sitive sex education (HHS, 2017). Despite the TPP program, congress increased
federal funding for AOUM by $85 million dollars in 2016 (Hall et al., 2016: 1).
Since scare tactics have proven ineffectual, sex education curriculums
whose goals are to reduce adolescent pregnancy (and STI/HIV) through the
use of contraception can be very successful. Such programs must take a mul-
tidimensional and comprehensive approach (Troiano, 1990: 101). By that, we
mean that not only should the mechanics of reproduction be addressed, but
the psychological and social aspects as well, including lesbian, gay, bisexual,
and transgender issues. Concern over the threat of HIV/AIDS has recently
given a new impetus to sex education. Other societal trends are also reflected
in new approaches to sex education development. For example, sexuality is in
a historical niche where it is now regarded as an important and very natural
component of one’s life. This view is also related to trends in which sex and
procreation were separated resulting in a greater emphasis on sex for pleasure.
These patterns are in their incipient stages and are just beginning to be felt in
sex education which is still suffering from conservative paradigms of fear and
abstinence only.
The evidence in regard to abstinence models is intriguing. Apparently, sex
education programs do not impact the likelihood of sexual activity one way
or another, but rather may actually increase the likelihood of contraception
and hence affect pregnancy and STI transmission including HIV infection
(Kirby, 1984; in Kelly, 1990; Kirby, 2001: 337–340). This is expressed in the
contrast between European sex education programs and those in the United
States. European programs take for granted that adolescents are having sex
and their approach consequently focuses on the issues of how to combat STIs/
Puberty and Adolescence 273
HIV and pregnancy (Francoeur, 1991a: 125; Boonstra, 2002): “Americans are
mainly concerned with keeping teenagers from being sexually active and en-
joying it” (Francoeur, 1991a: 125); and US adults are less accepting than their
European counterparts about teens having sex. European adults and their sex-
uality education programs carry a message that sex is a natural part of commit-
ted relationships and that teenagers have a responsibility to practice safer sex
strategies and prevention of pregnancy (Boonstra, 2002).
Extensive yet ineffective programming is abundant in the United States.
This has arisen from the explicit assumption that teens do not posses enough
information on sexuality in general and its consequences (Francoeur and
Noonan, 2004: 1192). The truth, however, is that teenagers are receiving
plenty of sexual information from peers and the media, yet our prevalent
abstinence-only approaches are severely ineffective in their assumption that
teens will discontinue sex as a recreational activity (Koch, 2004: 1174–1175).
Adolescent birth rates declined from 2007 to 2014 despite a paradoxical de-
crease in sex education from 2006 to 2013 (Lindberg et al., 2016; Hall et al.,
2016). In 2017, condom use among high school students actually decreased
from 62 percent in 2007 to 54 percent (CDC, 2017: 9). Additionally, the use
of contraceptives, particularly the “pill,” by sexually active teenage women is
lower in the United States than in other industrialized countries. This con-
tributes to the high pregnancy rates in the United States as compared with
other industrialized countries (Guttmacher Institute, 2017: 2); on a global
scale, the United States has a significantly greater use of contraceptives than
industrialized countries (United Nations, 2019 1) Until very recently, all fifty
states had taken advantage of federally sanctioned abstinence-only sex educa-
tion funding available for use in high schools. Several states, however, includ-
ing Maine, Pennsylvania, and California, turned down this federal subsidy for
sex education specifically because it did not include a comprehensive approach
(Kehrl, 2005).
Summary
1 Puberty is a physiological phenomenon, while adolescence is a cultural
one that may or may not be coterminous with puberty.
2 Rites of passage were introduced as rituals that facilitate the transition
from childhood to adulthood.
3 Rites of passage have three phases and distinct functions in nonindustrial
societies.
4 Theories of rites of passage were addressed. Female ceremonies are more
common, but male ceremonies are more elaborate and severe.
5 Female genital cutting was discussed including prevalence, practices, and
controversial issues.
Puberty and Adolescence 277
278 Puberty and Adolescence
ash/oah/adolescent-development/reproductive-health-and-teen-pregnancy/teen-
pregnancy-and-childbearing/trends/index.html.
Darroch, Jacqueline, Jennifer J. Frost, Susheela Singh, and Study Team. 2001. “Teen-
age Sexual and Reproductive Behavior in Developed Countries: Can More Progress
Be Made?” Occasional Report Number 3. The Alan Guttmacher Institute, Novem-
ber 1–120. http://www.guttmacher.org. Last accessed 11/09/07.
Ashcraft, Amie M, and Pamela J Murray. “Talking to Parents about Adolescent Sex-
uality.” Pediatric Clinics of North America, U.S. National Library of Medicine, April
2017, www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5517036/.
12 Sexuality through the Life
Stages, Part III
Adult Sexuality
Chapter Overview
1 Discusses the importance of culture in shaping beliefs and practices and
introduces erotocentricty.
2 Focuses on the ethnographic and cross-cultural record and human sexual
response, including Mangaian and Tantric perspectives.
3 Presents classic and contemporary industrialized theories of sexuality.
4 Outlines major topics in problems of desire and sexual response.
5 Emphasizes the importance of context and culture in understanding con-
cerns with sexuality, including industrialized approaches.
6 Examines nonindustrialized and indigenous emic perspectives regarding
issues in sexual functioning.
7 Explores the phenomenon of hookup culture and social media.
8 Discusses parenting styles.
These are just some of the cultural influences shaping human sexuality.1
Anthropologists and others have recently turned their attention to scru-
tinizing even further the “variations in meanings and narratives between
280 Adult Sexuality
individuals, across cultures, moving research, education and policy closer to the
voices and experiences of local cultures and their moral worlds” (Herdt, 2004:
48). How humans experience their sexuality in terms of desire, arousal, and ex-
pression is a biological, psychological, and cultural phenomenon. The biology/
physiology of sexuality is encountered through the lens of culture which in-
forms our psycho-emotive worlds. According to Herdt (1999: 101), there is also
a great deal of individual variation among us in our sexual subjectivity (i.e.,
how we experience and express sexuality), including individual attributes like
personalities, histories, and sense of self. Each of us brings subjectivity into our
interpretation of our society’s sexual system, to include both internal meanings
as well as those derived from the wider social system. An interest in how indi-
vidual variation intersects with the cultural in understanding sexuality is part
of a broader revolution in anthropology that has challenged notions of homo-
geneity and stability (Herdt, 1999; Manderson, Bennett, and Sheldrake, 1999;
Suggs and Miracle, 1999). Culture must therefore be understood as dynamic,
containing elements of contradiction and negotiation as well as historicity and
must be inclusive of individuals and events (Bolin and Granskog, 2003).
By presenting human sexuality in its widest possible scope, incorporating
biological, psychological, and cultural perspectives, with attention to the sub-
jectivity and agency of individuals within their cultural matrix, our intent is to
avoid Euro-American erotocentricity—that is, using our own values in judging
the erotic lives and sexual cultures of other people.
The sexual values of the industrialized world are not the only standard
for sex, nor are these always the best or “right way.” Nonindustrialized
societies and indigenous cultures are not exotic, strange, bad, or wrong—
in short, “other.” Approaching sexuality through cultural relativism will
facilitate an appreciation of other cultures and lead us to a critical anal-
ysis of our own industrial worldviews. Industrial society did not create
sex, nor are its citizens the only ones with theories of human sexual re-
sponse. Ethnocentrism operates like blinders, shaping our view of what
is normal and abnormal and good and bad. Ethnocentrism prohibits us
from accepting variation for what it is, the expression of our biological,
psychological, and cultural diversity.
The importance of culture in the patterning of sexuality has been the cor-
nerstone of anthropological research on this subject. (For anthropological re-
search emphasizing evolutionary and more biologically framed approaches to
sex see Chapter 3.) The now classic ethnographic studies that emphasized or
included data on sexual practices such as the work of Malinowski (1961 [1927]),
Benedict (1934), and Mead (1961 [1928]), among numerous others, provided
the fodder for the HRAF files and ethnology, furthering the comparative study
of cultures (discussed in Chapter 1). The HRAF allowed for cross-cultural
comparisons for hypothesis testing, identifying trends, patterns, and themes
in sexual behaviors. As noted earlier, Ford and Beach (1951) offered the first
and most provocative work on sexuality at the time, providing a compendium
of information on the details and specifics of sexual practices and beliefs. The
ethnographic and the comparative perspectives represent two approaches that
are still current in the cross-cultural study of sexuality. However, as definitions
of sexuality have changed over time, so has the discipline of anthropology and
the interests of anthropologists.2
Herdt (1999: 102–103) and others have commented on the changes that have
occurred in anthropological research since the early days of ethnography: “an-
thropologists from the 30s to the 70s, largely ignored erotics and sexuality, the
body, the emotions of the individual actor, and the passions pertaining to them”
(e.g., Lewin and Leap, 1996). Sexual excitement and orgasm were completely
unstudied until recently. Differences in meanings of social practices, such as
the difference between the genders and their experience of sexual relations,
were largely ignored in the paradigm (Vance, 1991). Even more fundamental is
the thesis that nonindustrialized communities differ substantially in sexual and
social desires; hence, different individuals within the same social strata or class
or age group might feel contrasting or even aberrant desires compared with their
peers or contemporaries in the society (Herdt and Stoller, 1990). Consequently,
it is not so curious that the cross-cultural study of sexuality advanced so little
until the recent work of a small number of heterosexual scholars, followed by
feminist and gay and lesbian scholars after the 1970s (Gagnon and Parker, 1995).
Until relatively recently the ethnographic research was far richer on the
subject of heterosexual erotic preferences rather than homoerotic and bisexual
behaviors with a few exceptions, such as the earlier work of Westermark (1956
[1906]), Stewart (1960), and Ford and Beach (1951), to name a few. Over the
282 Adult Sexuality
past thirty-five years this situation has been in the process of being remedied
through the work of anthropologists such as Gilbert Herdt, Walter Williams,
Evelyn Blackwood, Ester Newton, Kath Weston, and Richard Parker, among
numerous others (Manderson, Bennet, and Sheldrake, 1999). While efforts
have been made to expand discourse into homosexual populations (Higgins
and Hynes, 2018: 3), most of this research focuses on addressing disparities in
LGBT youth rather than sexual experiences and preferences of adult popula-
tions (Fredriksen-Goldsen and Muraco, 2012: 407; Harding et al., 2012: 68;
Knochel et al., 2011: 371). Chapter 14 addresses sexual orientation in greater
depth. The recent anthropological approaches offer nuanced explorations of
emic constructions of sex.
Included among the sexual behaviors reported for heterosexuals, regard-
less of marital status, are vaginal, anal, and interfemoral intercourse (the
penis is placed between the partner’s thighs); cunnilingus (oral stimulation
of the vulva); fellatio (oral stimulation of the penis); masturbation (sexual
self-stimulation); and mutual masturbation (stimulating one’s partner’s gen-
itals usually manually) (Davis and Whitten, 1987: 73; Herdt, 2006). Cross-
culturally, erotic practices between men who have sex with men include oral
and anal sexual practices, mutual masturbation, interfemoral intercourse; and
for women who have sex with women this also includes oral, manual stim-
ulation, “dry humping,” and the use of an artificial penis made of various
materials. Ethnographic information on what women actually do in terms
of behavior and pleasure, particularly with regard to masturbation (Fahs and
Frank, 2014), has been lacking in previous years. However, research in this
field is growing (Goldey et al., 2016; Herbenick et al., 2011 McLelland, 2013).
The meanings of the same-gender sexual behaviors vary widely. For example,
as the Sambia illustrate, although oral insemination occurs as a rite of pas-
sage among young men, it is not equivalent to industrialized “homosexual”
behavior/identity; nor is the Lesotho “mummy-baby” ritualized friendship of
an older and younger woman a lesbian one, although it incorporates erotic el-
ements (Blackwood, 2005a, b). The terms homosexual/lesbian/bisexual/queer
are loaded with Euro-American sentiment. Given the evidence of third and
more genders in many societies, the exportation of industrialized transgender
and LGBTQ identities through globalization and the variety of extant emic
interpretations of sexuality, the appropriateness of the term “homosexual”
just because two bodies have the same genitals must be seriously questioned
(Lancaster, 2003; Nanda, 2000).
What is regarded as erotic in one culture may not be in another. There is
tremendous heterogeneity in virtually every aspect of sexual arousal encom-
passing what is regarded as foreplay, whether it is emphasized in the sexual
repertoires, the sexual positions that are preferred, and what positions are
considered “natural” and unnatural, as well as the embodiment of erotics. For
example, in some societies, breasts are not erotic but the source of food for an
infant. Although the missionary position with the man on top is the most
common position for Euro-Americans, this too is not universal. Other positions
Adult Sexuality 283
for heterosexual intercourse include the Oceanic position, which involves the
man squatting between the thighs of his partner with her legs straddling his
thighs; another position preferred in some African and Native American so-
cieties is lying side by side, face-to face (Gregersen, 1994). Gregersen (1994:
62–70) summarizes a number of additional positions described in the ethno-
graphic record. These include:
The power of the universe is expressed through two oppositional forces: the
static inertia of the female and the dynamic inertia of the male. Spiritual power
is created through the union of these opposite cosmic forces. This creates a
286 Adult Sexuality
primal energy that can lead to spiritual perfection resulting in a sacred unity
called prana (Garrison, 1983: 7).
In contrast to industrialized concepts of heterosexual sexual expression as
having only two phases, foreplay and intercourse, the Tantric texts view sex as
occurring in multiple phases. These include (Devi, 1977):
These phases illustrate the central principle of Tantrism as a form of sacred “wor-
ship [that] is through the flesh, with body and mind” (Devi, 1977: 16). Conse-
quently, coitus is regarded as a vehicle for creating a sexual energy that leads to
religious ecstasy. Tantric philosophies of sexuality differ considerably from prom-
inent perspectives in Christianity. St. Augustine of Hippo is credited with infus-
ing Christianity with negative sentiments about sexuality. In his interpretation,
the Garden of Eden is the locus of original sin. Because Adam and Eve defied
the authority of the creator god by discovering sex, that sin was passed on to all
of humankind. Although sex was regarded as necessary for procreation, sexual
desire and arousal were thought to be sinful. The story of Adam and Eve provides
the framework for establishing a rationale for regulating sexual behavior, gender
relations, and marriage. As opposed to the Tantric perspective of sex as sacred,
in Christianity celibacy became the exalted state because the original sin of sex
meant a fall from grace. In industrialized worldviews, heavily influenced by
Judeo-Christianity, sex is located in the body, distinct from spirit and mind
(Tiefer, 2004: 24). According to Francoeur (1992: 7): “Christianity, for the most
part, has not been able to integrate sexuality into a holistic philosophy or see sex-
ual relations, pleasure, and passion as avenues for spiritual meaning and growth.”3
Put briefly, men changed their sexual behavior very little in the decades
from the fifties to the eighties. They “fooled around,” got married, and
288 Adult Sexuality
often fooled around some more, much as their fathers and perhaps their
grandfathers had before them. Women, however, have gone from a pat-
tern of virginity before marriage and monogamy thereafter to a pattern
that much more resembles men’s…
(Ehrenreich, Hess, and Jacobs, 1986: 2)
Since the 1980s and continuing into the new millennium, the United
States has witnessed a tremendous backlash to the gains women have
made regarding their reproductive rights to control their fertility (Faludi,
1991; Herdt, 2004; Kimmel, 2000). This backlash was extended more
widely under the Donald Trump administration through promotion of
“abstinence-only” approaches to sex education domestically and inter-
nationally as well as federal policies aimed at banning abortions and
defunding Planned Parenthood. We encourage the reader to be alert to
changes in policy over time and with different administrations and to
pursue reputable government and scholarly sources for updates subse-
quent to the publication of this textbook.
The meaning of sex was also reformulated as a consequence of the social up-
heavals heralded by the 1960s. Masters and Johnson (1966) demonstrated that
women’s sexuality was more extensive than previously thought, so that sex
came to include more than just penile-vaginal intercourse for heterosexual co-
itus. The importance of the clitoris in female sexual response was one factor in
this new view. The definition of sexuality was expanded to include additional
Adult Sexuality 289
behaviors such as cunnilingus, which was only whispered about in the 1950s.
Populist currents for the democratization of sex were felt as Freudian theory
began to lose some of its foothold and popular sex books appeared. Sex experts
sprang up everywhere during the 1960s and 1970s including: J’s The Sensu-
ous Woman (1969), Comfort’s The Joy of Sex (1972), Friday’s My Secret Garden
(1974), and Hite’s The Hite Report (1976).
With these books, a more humanistic trend evolved that offered sexual
advice as the changing meanings of female sexuality were being felt in the
bedroom (Ehrenreich, Hess, and Jacobs, 1986). These popular accounts were
not scientific and were not based on the principles of sound research method-
ologies, but, in all fairness, this was not their purpose. Rather they represented
a trajectory in the “democratization” of sex, which was a popular genre that
would coexist with current proclivities for scientific and empirical research
initiated by Kinsey and coupled with newly emerging medical and scientific
perspectives of the 1960s such as that of Masters and Johnson (1966).
Sexological research is not only a product of history and culture (i.e., re-
produces culture); it also contributes to the wider sexual culture of our times
and place (produces culture) defined as the “intrinsic or internal meaning, as
well as extrinsic or environmental sources of sexual behavior” (Herdt, 1999:
100). Though the media plays an ever-increasing role in sexuality nationally
and globally, the scientific literature is also part of the diverse ways that sex
is framed and “spun” (Gagnon, 2004). In the following sections we review the
contributions of selected researchers in the field of sexology. By no means is
this meant to be an exhaustive review; rather it highlights several of the most
prominent theorists and their significant influences on sexology in the twenti-
eth century and the new millennium.
Freud
Freud had a tremendous impact on sexological thinking up through the 1950s.
As discussed in Chapters 2 and 10, Freud’s theory of psychosexual development
emphasized phases in childhood and adolescence and the importance of the Oe-
dipus complex. For Freud sexuality was the cornerstone of his psychoanalytic
approach (i.e., adult sexuality is determined by childhood psychosexual develop-
ment). Freud regarded male sexuality as the norm against which he judged wom-
en’s sexuality as more timid and passive, as well as inherently more problematic.
In his 1905 book, Three Essays on the Theory of Sexuality, he identified two types
of female orgasms. The clitoral orgasm was regarded by Freud as an immature one
centered on the erogenous zone of the clitoris, and related to girls’ experiences
with masturbation. In contrast, the vaginal orgasm was considered the mature
form of orgasm, associated with reproduction. This shift from clitoral to vaginal
orgasm occurred after puberty as the vagina became the central foci of women’s
sexuality. In Freud’s view, women who experienced sexual pleasure in ways other
than through penile penetration were immature and fixated in an earlier phase of
development (Bullough, 1994; Byer and Shainberg, 1991: 186; Freud, 1975 [1922]).
290 Adult Sexuality
Critiques of the Freudian approach are numerous, but the most often cited
charges address the issue that the psychoanalytic approach is not subject to sci-
entific methods of verification since Freud’s theories emerged from his practice,
and he offered no systematic data per se. He only treated 130 patients, none
of whom were children. In addition, his perspective on women’s sexuality has
been denounced as androcentric (Westheimer and Lopater, 2005).
Kinsey
In 1948 Alfred Kinsey and his colleagues published the Kinsey Reports on
male sexuality (Sexual Behavior in the Human Male) followed by 1953’s Sexual
Behavior in the Human Female. Their work had a profound impact on the sci-
entific community as well as on US conceptions of sexuality. Although Kinsey
and his collaborators’ contributions are many, we shall highlight a few of the
most significant findings about American sexuality. In contrast to Freud’s psy-
choanalytic perspective that stressed the differences between female and male
sexuality, Kinsey concluded male and female sexuality were much more alike
(Ehrenreich, Hess, and Jacobs, 1986), which is a surprising view of sexual-
ity given that their research occurred in the context of the post-WWII baby
boom. Thus, their position, that there were few differences in male and female
orgasm and human sexual response, contradicted not only the legacy of Freud
but the popular gender culture of the times that was in the midst of celebrating
gender difference as essentialistic.
The Kinsey approach to human sexuality was dedicated to scientific rigor
that emphasized the behavioral, although critics have argued that it left the
affective and experiential component of sex unrecognized. Despite back-
ground training as a zoologist, Kinsey emphasized a sociological approach to
measurement, analyzing data using gender, age, education, and marital status
as variables in understanding sex as a “natural” and essential drive (Giami,
2005). Kinsey’s passion and mission were devoted to ending sexual ignorance
by using the scientific method to collect data on people’s sexual experiences
that could subsequently be quantified into behavioral terms. Sexual Behavior
in the Human Male was based on 12,000 case histories and Sexual Behavior in
the Human Female was based on 8,000. Although detractors have focused on
Kinsey and his colleagues’ lack of attention to sexual meanings and culture,
this was not indeed the objective of their research. Kinsey was a dedicated pro-
ponent of sexuality education, hoping to end sexual ignorance and mythology;
he brought to the United States a much needed culturally relativistic approach
to sexual behavior (Lyons and Lyons, 2004).
Betty Friedan, an early feminist and author of The Feminine Mystique (1963)
(Ehrenreich, Hess, and Jacobs, 1986: 43), criticized the Kinsey reports for pre-
senting sexuality “as a status-seeking game in which the goal was the greatest
number of ‘outlets,’ [or] orgasms.” Ehrenreich and colleagues (1986) suggest
that Kinsey’s dedication to an evidence-based scientific sexology that could be
quantified had a profound influence on America’s conceptions of sexuality by
Adult Sexuality 291
shifting the focus to the number of orgasms. He has been accused of bias in his
statistics due the number of male prisoners in the first book and for reliance on
volunteers in both volumes (Lyons and Lyons, 2004).
Despite these critiques of his/and his colleagues’ work, Kinsey made a huge
contribution to creating the emergent discipline of sexology and influenced so-
ciety at large by confronting traditional attitudes toward sexuality (Bullough,
1994, 2004). Kinsey and his colleagues offered a new sexual paradigm for main-
stream US culture that normalized and familiarized homosexuality, masturba-
tion, premarital sex for men and women, heterosexual coitus, and extramarital
affairs by making them topics of conversation in popular culture (Bullough,
2004; Giami, 2005). Kinsey may be credited with establishing the survey as a
method for understanding US sexual practices that has continued today, al-
beit with more rigor. See the discussion of Laumann and colleagues’ research,
which follows.
The Kinsey Institute at the University of Indiana persists today as Kinsey’s
legacy. This institute continues to promote and fund sexuality research, creat-
ing new opportunities for interdisciplinary sex research and education as well
as housing a massive archive of print, film and video, fine art, artifacts, and
photography.
Masters and Johnson are also known for their study of problems in human
sexual functioning. In 1970 they published Human Sexual Inadequacy.
Their therapeutic approach was distinctive; they treated couples rather than
the individuals; utilized a behaviorist model rather than a psychoanalytic one;
and boasted high success rates through short-term psychotherapy.
the “uterine orgasm” does not involve any contractions of the orgasmic
platform… this kind of orgasm occurs in coitus alone, and it largely de-
pends upon the pleasurable effects of uterine displacement. Subjectively
the orgasm is felt to be deep, i.e., dependent on repeated penile-cervix
contact.
This orgasm is characterized by interrupted breathing with the orgasm and the
expulsion of breath occurring simultaneously (Singer and Singer, 1972: 260).
The blended orgasm combines characteristics of both the vulval and the
uterine orgasm. It incorporates contractions of the orgasmic platform but is
experienced as deeper than a vulval orgasm and more akin to the uterine in
that breathing is interrupted (Singer and Singer, 1972: 260). The same cri-
tique of Masters and Johnson has been applied to this research. While Singer
and Singer expanded Masters and Johnson’s perspective on women’s orgasms,
similarly their research suggests a “biological uniformity” that underrates the
complexity of how meanings and symbols, culture and context can influence
the individual’s experience of sexuality (Tiefer, 2004).
Kaplan
Helen Singer Kaplan wrote extensively on the subject of human sexuality
(1974, 1979, 1983, 1989) and was known for her modification of Masters and
Johnson’s four-stage human sexual response cycle. Kaplan (1979) remodeled
Adult Sexuality 295
the human sexual response cycle into three phases. She added “desire” as a
precursor stage to arousal defining it as the specific “sensations” that lead to
an interest in having sex. The addition of “desire” has earned her the most ac-
claim in contributing to an understanding of human sexual response. She cat-
egorized the second phase in human sexual response as the “arousal” phase
in which she collapsed Masters and Johnson’s excitement and plateau phases,
followed by orgasm. For Kaplan sexual desire was considered an appetite or
drive motivating sexual behavior. Other researchers more recently have em-
phasized the socio-cultural and relational parameters of desire (DeLameter and
Sill, 2005). The stage of desire has been integrated into the human sexual
response cycle in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders,
a compendium of the Euro-American nosology of mental distress and is re-
garded as one of the categories of sexual disorders. (See section “Problems in
sexual response” for further discussion.)
Unlike Kinsey and Masters and Johnson, Kaplan proposed that female and
male sexuality were distinctive. Subscribing to theories of the biological basis
of sex differences, Kaplan believed that these different sexualities are due to
testosterone, which she argued accounted for a much stronger sexual drive in
males than in females. In contrast to men, the female sex drive was shaped
to a greater degree by lived experience in Kaplan’s view. Kaplan felt that cli-
toral stimulation was essential to female orgasm and that vaginal intercourse
alone would not necessarily result in an orgasm without additional clitoral
stimulation (King, 2005). According to Klein (1981: 73–75, 77, 92), Kaplan
also regarded humans as monogamous pair bonders, although she left open the
possibility that it may be serial. While offering a more complex view of human
sexual response, this model has been subject to the same appraisal as that of
Masters and Johnson—that of reducing human sexual response to physiologi-
cal indicators at the expense of the personal, cultural, and contextual. Though
contributing to knowledge of the physiology of sexuality, the HSR cycle as
conceived by Masters and Johnson, Singer and Singer, and Kaplan does not
consider the tremendous variety in individuals’ sexual arousal (McAnulty and
Burnette, 2003; Tiefer, 2004). Kaplan also made an important contribution to
sexology through her earlier work on sexual dysfunction. In The New Sex Ther-
apy: Active Treatment of Sexual Dysfunction (1974), she synthesized Masters
and Johnson’s behaviorist approach to sexual dysfunction with psychoanalysis.
Unlike Masters and Johnson’s therapeutic model based on symptoms, Kaplan’s
integrated concern for interpersonal interaction with an emphasis on the un-
conscious (Fischer and Eisenstein, 1984: 143; Kaplan, 1979, 1974).
• Delayed ejaculation
• Erectile disorder
• Female orgasmic disorder
• Female sexual interest/arousal disorder
302 Adult Sexuality
• Genito-pelvic pain/penetration disorder
• Male hypoactive sexual desire disorder
• Other specified sexual dysfunction
• Unspecified sexual dysfunction
Female arousal disorder was removed from the DSM-V because it is most often
identified in the context of hypoestrogenism, disqualifying it from a psychi-
atric diagnosis. The DSM-V is no longer premised on the assumption that
the human response cycle is primarily the same across the genders as it has
been in previous editions (Tiefer, 2004). Instead, diagnostic criteria is based on
the duration and severity of associated symptoms; dysfunctions are specified as
lifelong, or generalized in regard to duration. Severity is ranked as mild, mod-
erate, or severe and refers to the degree of distress over symptoms (McCabe
et al., 2016: 137). The DSM-V-TR classification affirms a perspective that sex-
ual dysfunctions are largely psychogenic in origin, although sexual disorders
are embodied in very real physiological problems in sexual functioning. Sexual
dysfunctions in the DSM-V-TR also include those caused by general medical
conditions such as male hypoactive sexual desire disorder; male erectile dis-
order; other female or male sexual dysfunction; and substance-induced sexual
problems in functioning.
According to some studies, diverse sexual problems are widespread in
the United States. Laumann, Paik, and Rosen (1999) using the National
Health and Social Life Survey has found figures as high as 40 percent of
women and 30 percent of men surveyed recounted problems with sexual
functioning. Selvin Burnett, and Platz suggest that 18.4 percent of the male
population in the United States over the age of twenty will be affected by
erectile dysfunction (2007: 152).The Florey Adelaide Male Ageing Study
(FAMAS) in Australia found that 31.7 percent of participants aged thir-
ty-five to eighty years old developed erectile dysfunction at the end of a
five-year period (Martin et al., 2017). While there are several large-scale
studies on male sexual disorders, equivalent research on women is lacking
(McCabe et al. 2016). One significant study of sexual experiences of Austra-
lian mid-life women found that 69 percent of participants experienced low
sexual desire and 40 percent experienced sexually-related distress (Worsley
et al., 2017: 680).
Disorders of Desire
The sexual disorders of desire include aversion and hypoactive forms that
affect both men and women, and are generally described as a disinterest in
sexual gratification. Aversion is defined in the DSM-V-TR as a “[p]ersistent
or recurrent extreme aversion to, and avoidance of, all (or almost all) genital
sexual contact with a sexual partner.” And hypoactive disorder is defined as
“Persistently or recurrently deficient (or absent) sexual/erotic thoughts or fan-
tasies and desire for sexual activity,” (2013: 302.71 (F52.0)).
Adult Sexuality 303
Hyposexual desire disorder was first identified in 1970 (King, 2005). In the
1980s, Harold Lief, a therapist, suggested that hyposexual desire occurred in “20
percent of all adult Americans” (in Leo, 1984: 83). More recent research for males
by Laumann, Paik, and Rosen (1999) reports that 16 percent of men under sixty
reported low sexual desire; Rosen’s (2000) figures suggest a range of zero to 15
percent and Simons and Carey’s (2001) data suggest it is even lower in the zero-3
percent range. Meuleman and Van Lankveld (2005) regard hyposexual desire dis-
order as a particularly difficult problem to diagnose and treat in men, due to its
biological and psychological causes. However, a review of literature by Basson
(2005) found that as many as 30–35 percent of women ages eighteen to seventy
have had problems with sexual desire in the previous year. Research on difficulties
in desire has been attributed to biological influences such as low levels of testoster-
one in both men and women and to the role of dopamine. It must be pointed out,
however, that reports of treatments with testosterone and dopaminergic drugs im-
proved arousal and intensity of orgasm, but desire was not increased. In guidelines
issued by the Endocrine Society, Wierman et al. (2006: 17) note that
Davis et al. (2005: 96) have concluded that “[t]he measurement of serum tes-
tosterone, free testosterone, or DHEAS in individuals presenting with low
sexual function is not informative and levels of these hormones should not
be used for the purpose of diagnosing androgen insufficiency.” In addition,
psychological factors alone or in combination with biological factors also in-
fluence both men and women’s desire. For example, depression and the use of
antidepressants can inhibit sexual desire, as can low self-esteem, anxiety, and
past negative experiences with sex (Bancroft, Loftus, and Long, 2003; Basson,
2005). Like other sexual problems, disorders of desire for both women and men
may increase with age. We shall discuss this aspect in Chapter 13.
Arousal Disorders
In the DSM-V-TR female arousal disorder is defined as the
Prevalence of this disorder includes statistics that 2 percent of men under forty
experience frequent problems with erections (Prins et al., 2002). Approximately
5–20 percent of men have moderate erectile dysfunction (Kubin et al., 2003:
66). The term impotence has been widely used in popular culture to describe
a man’s inability to obtain an erection. The concept of male potency does not
have a counterpart in terminology for women and is an obvious example of
the dual and sexist symbolization of male sexuality (Richardson, 1988: 129).
Erectile problems can occur for a variety of reasons. Most men have at some
time experienced the inability to have an erection due to “excessive fatigue,
heavy drinking, and/or over anxiousness about sexual performance—all of
which are characteristically associated with masculine activities” (Richardson,
1988: 129). Some, but not a complete list of, additional factors identified as
306 Adult Sexuality
causing or contributing to erectile disorder include prescription medications
(especially those for high blood pressure); diseases like atherosclerosis and di-
abetes; damage to nerve fibers due to surgery or trauma; and low testosterone
levels (Joannides, 2004).
Before the advent of the “sexopharmaceutical revolution” in the 1990s, re-
search on men’s erectile problems emphasized psychogenic and socio-cultural
factors, although harbingers of medicalization had begun earlier in the 1970s
followed by an initial expansion in the 1980s as the fields of urology and
pharmacology carved out a treatment niche. Industrialized masculinity in the
late twentieth and early twenty-first centuries continued to emphasize a penis-
centered model of performance and orgasm. The loss or decline of erectile
and orgasmic functioning is a serious threat to masculine identity shaped by
an ideology of phallocentrism—the ideal of producing erections at will and as
well as having staying power or sexual stamina (Kilmartin, 2007). Performance
not pleasure is emphasized in this industrial ideal of masculinity. Medicaliza-
tion of erectile dysfunction emerged as a sociological theory to critique the use
of medicine to dictate phallocentric norms of the male sexuality (Rosen, 1996;
Tiefer, 1994).
A psycho-cultural perspective toward male erectile problems was developed
out of the convergence of men’s studies and various social scientific approaches.
Generally speaking, before 1970, young men’s erectile problems were attributed
to psychological causes (related to the stresses of masculinity and other contex-
tual factors), and erectile disorders in midlife and older men were considered
part of the aging process, not necessarily a disorder. After 1970, however a shift
in emphasis occurred and male dysfunction came to be socio-culturally defined
incrementally over the last thirty-five years as a biomedical phenomenon (Tiefer,
2006a). At one time Masters and Johnson stated that as much as 80 percent of
erectile disorders were due to psychological factors; currently it is estimated by
doctors that perhaps 80 percent have a physical basis (King, 2005).
Viagra was born (approved by the FDA) March 27, 1998. With its invention
and that of its cohorts, it has become a major player in the ideologies of “nor-
mative” masculine sexuality. Treatments for erectile disorders were revolution-
ized by Pfizer, the creators of sildenafil (Viagra), whose clinical studies found
sildenafil produced erections in 70 percent of a test population of men with
erectile problems (Ault, 1988: 1037; Handy, 1998: 54). Tiefer suggests Viagra’s
timely success was due to “cultural shifts in gender role spotlighting genital ap-
titude as proof of masculinity, a tale examined repeatedly in men’s studies over
the last quarter-century,” (2006: 279). Other additional treatments for erec-
tile dysfunction currently available include psychological therapy, hormone
replacement therapy, vacuum devices, urethral suppositories, penile injections,
vascular surgery, and penile implants (King, 2005; “Putting the Pill (for Men)
in Perspective,” 1998: 4; Tiefer, 2006). All testify to the lengths that men will
go in the quest for phallic performance and living up to an industrialized (and
sometimes nonindustrialized) ideal of masculinity. New oral medications for
increasing blood flow to the penis are on the horizon. In the “New View of
Adult Sexuality 307
Men’s Sexual Problems,” Tiefer (2006a) offer a multidimensional approach
to masculine sexual difficulties, one that underscores the integration of bio-
psychogenic and cultural variables, including context and the nature of the
partner relationship. Tiefer (2004: 233) asserts:
Orgasmic Disorders
Orgasmic disorders include both female and male, as well as premature ejacu-
lation in men. Female Orgasmic Disorder is defined by the DSM-V-TR (2013:
302.73 (F52.31)) as the:
The clinician must take into account factors that affect duration of the ex-
citement phase, such as age, novelty of the sexual partner or situation, and
recent frequency of sexual activity. Premature ejaculation is a problem of con-
trol and is the most prevalent sexual dysfunction reported for men up until age
fifty-nine. It may be due to biological factors, but this is rarer; it is more likely
related to performance anxiety and other psychocultural factors. Debates as to
rates of occurrence include figures from 20 percent to 30 percent of men expe-
riencing premature ejaculation, with disagreement on how it is defined (King,
2005; Saitz, 2016; Serefoglu and Saitz, 2012).
The most recent edition of the DSM (DSM-V) does not indicate vaginismus as
its own disorder, but rather includes it in with dyspareunia under the category
of genito-pelvic pain/penetration disorder. Concerns about this change regard
the fear that vulvodynia, vulvar pain or a burning sensation with or without
penetration, will be misdiagnosed as a genito-pelvic penetration disorder and
will primarily be treated through psychological interventions (Vieira-Baptista
and Lima-Silva, 2016: 1). Etiology of what was previously known as vaginismus
is usually attributed to psychological and/or biological factors, but vulvodynia
can have a variety of causes. Treatments include psychotherapy, antidepres-
sants, topical and injected steroids, and estrogen, among other interventions
(National Vulvodynia Association (NVA) (Research Update Newsletter,
2005). The National Vulvodynia Association is a patient advocacy group dedi-
cated to improving the sexual lives of women who have vaginal pain.
Hookup Culture
In line with the approach to human sexuality in this book, Garcia et al. (2012)
note that the phenomenon of modern hookup culture “provides a case of hu-
man social behavior through which to explore the relationship and possible
interaction between evolved mating psychology and cultural context “(162)
and that it is “best understood from a biopsychosocial perspective that in-
corporates recent research trends in human biology, reproductive and mental
health, and sexuality studies” (172). As “hooking up” has evidently become the
dominant and normative sexual script for men and women in the twenty-first
century, its ubiquity both reinforces and challenges many traditional ideas
about gender and sexuality (Bogle, 2008). “Hooking up—brief uncommitted
sexual encounters among individuals who are not romantic partners or dating
each other—has taken root within the sociocultural milieu of adolescents,
emerging adults, and men and women throughout the Western world” (Garcia
et al., 2012: 161).
How does “hooking up” differ from other forms of casual, non-committal
sex? This question has been perhaps the most challenging for scholars to define
because its very ambiguity is what apparently makes it preferable to saying that
two people “had sex.” Hooking up can include any behaviors that participants
construct as intimate or sexual in nature. From kissing to intercourse, hook-
ing up can refer to any sexual activity or behavior that can be interpreted as
such in specific situational or cultural contexts. However, hooking up has not
Adult Sexuality 313
necessarily replaced, nor is it necessarily incompatible with human desires for
committed long-term relationships, pair bonding, or classic notions of finding
romance (Fielder, Carey, and Carey, 2013). In fact, successful relationships can
evolve from casual hookups. On the other hand, especially for adolescents and
young adults, hookups often involve alcohol or drug consumption and in some
cases lead to sexual coercion and unwanted sexual encounters. Sexual consent
in particular has emerged as a contentious issue scholars have struggled with in
deciding whether or not hookup culture is liberating or oppressive, especially
for young college-aged women (Muehlenhard et al., 2016).
In American Hook Up: The New Culture of Sex on Campus (2017) Lisa Wade
provides a deeply insightful sociological case study of why hookup culture goes
far beyond college students having casual sex. Whereas students have consis-
tently taken advantage of sexual permissiveness or exploration during their
college years, hookup culture is a novel phenomenon. Hookup culture, Wade
argues, permeates and is supported by various social organizational norms as
well as institutional structures of colleges past and present. Hookup culture
is deeply embedded in campus life and Greek organizations in particular.
Students, especially freshmen cohorts, become absorbed in what she describes
as a “fog” which initially disorients them but inevitably re-orients them to
conform to the social pressures to hook up. Greek organization membership,
fraternity parties, alcohol consumption, and strong peer pressure to raise one’s
social status via the number and status rank of sexual partners are key factors
in why hookup culture thrives in four-year residential colleges. Students who
do not or cannot conform to what is essentially a white, male, heterosexual
party culture environment are systematically excluded. In a sense, students’
sexual status that depends on participation in hookup culture determines stu-
dent’s social status on campus. This applies more or less to both female and
male students.
How did hookup culture become such an all-encompassing, dominating culture
on residential college campuses nationwide? Wade traces modern hookup culture
back to nearly a century ago when unprecedented numbers of young people were
able to attend college. Being on their own, away from parental supervision, and
able to organize social life around mixed company, fraternity men clashed with
administrative officials who tried to cultivate the college experience as a serious,
dedicated pursuit of education devoid of leisure and pleasure. However, fraternities
gradually succeeded in framing college and campus life as a period of carefree in-
dulgence and independence. By the 1960s, women, too, had begun to rebel against
retaining sexual purity and aspiring to normative monogamous marriage ideals.
Female college students flocked to fraternity parties designed to create a sexually
permissive atmosphere controlled by men, characterized by the transactional na-
ture of providing entertainment and alcohol in exchange for implicit sexual com-
pliance. This kind of formulaic social interaction persists to this day across many
residential campuses with strong Greek affiliations.
Wade shares the claim of many other scholars who argue that hookup cul-
ture reproduces rigid, heteronormative gender norms and sexual scripts that
314 Adult Sexuality
devalue and harm women while reinforcing men’s sexual dominance and
sexual privilege. And although many college women willingly participate in
hookup culture as they see casual sex as liberating them from oppressive so-
cial expectations of commitment and monogamy, most experience at least one
non-consensual, coerced, or forced sexual encounter. In fact, sexual consent
becomes a highly contentious issue in situational contexts designed precisely
to obscure or negate its necessity.
But do college students who participate in hookup culture really enjoy and
thus have more sex than those who opt out? Wade’s findings show that a quar-
ter of students who participate seemed to enjoy their carefree casual sexual
encounters, while one third opted out entirely, and the rest “dabbled” in it but
felt ambiguous about it. The most interesting finding Wade reveals, however, is
that in general, even those most deeply entrenched in hookup culture do not
have as much sex as we would expect: on average, graduating seniors in her
sample hooked up about eight times in four years, and many not at all. None-
theless, she maintains that even if students opt out of hooking up, they cannot
escape becoming absorbed in hookup culture.
Wade repeatedly cautions readers not to problematize casual sex among col-
lege students, but rather to be mindful of hookup culture’s compulsory nature
and its negative consequences such as social exclusion, sexual exploitation,
and maintaining gender hierarchies that clearly privilege the social status and
sexual needs of men. The barriers to changing the negative aspects of hookup
culture, Wade suggests, need be addressed by focusing on structural, institu-
tional changes that begin with buffering powerful fraternity organizations who
singlehandedly shape the social life on campus, and must include alternative
social and sexual opportunities not based the dominance of white, male, het-
erosexual privilege.
There are numerous other problematic aspects and social variables asso-
ciated with hookup culture’s contentious stronghold within and beyond the
college context. Vrangalova (2015) notes that the problem of defining what
exactly constitutes a hookup makes cross-study comparisons rather compli-
cated. Emotional connections, intimacy, and seeking long-term romantic rela-
tionships are seen as so antithetical to college hookup culture, that individuals
who express these more traditional values are punitively excluded from it. At-
tachment styles and motives of sexually active college student populations also
inform hookup decision-making and satisfaction outcomes (Snapp et al., 2014).
Helm et al. (2015) found that religious backgrounds or religious involvement of
college students lessens participation in the sexual permissiveness of hookup
culture by about 40 percent. Although both men and women seek out casual,
non-committal sexual hookups, women tend to be more emotionally motivated
to engage in hookups, and are more affected by male non-investment than
men (Townsend and Wasserman, 2011). Race, ethnicity, and socio-economic
markers similarly shape student population involvements in hookup culture in
that non-white, immigrant, or low-income students tend to be less involved
or de facto excluded (Allison and Risman, 2014; Brimeyer and Smith, 2012).
Adult Sexuality 315
Residential proximity, compared to two-year community or commuter col-
leges, also sets the stage for hookup culture to emerge (Wade, 2017).
Parenting Styles
Regardless of group structure and sexual orientation, the socialization of chil-
dren is an ongoing concern in all societies. Parenting within mainstream US
culture is undergoing rapid behavioral and attitudinal changes. The average
marriage in this culture lasts seven years, comparable to medieval Western
European marriages. However, our marriages usually end through separation
or divorce in contrast to the death of a spouse as occurred in medieval times
(Stone, 1977). At the same time, American longevity continues to increase,
with an average life expectancy of about seventy-six years for a middle-class
white male and about eighty-one years for a middle-class white female (World
Bank, 2017). In addition, nuclear family size is decreasing largely due to eco-
nomic and subsistence reasons—it’s expensive to raise children to adulthood
in a highly technical, post-industrial society. The demography of parenting is
also shifting. At one end are young (under fifteen years old) female teenaged
parents who encounter socio-economic problems since teenagers are not rec-
ognized as legal, social, or economic adults. At the other end are “older” adult
parents, women older than thirty-five experiencing their first pregnancy. The
overall average age of first pregnancy in this culture is about twenty-four years
(US Census Bureau, 2000).
The ideal post-WWII nuclear family is the least common family structure;
approximately 23 percent of households are headed by single parents. Although
over one million men are full-time single parents, the majority of single parents
are women, either by circumstance—divorce, separation, or desertion—or by
choice (US Census Bureau, 2016).
Currently, in two-parent households, generally both parents work outside
the home full-time. This creates a need for childcare—largely in the form of
Adult Sexuality 317
paid, nonkin-based arrangements such as daycare centers based on class, not
ethnicity. In-home division of labor and time spent parenting are highly vari-
able in these situations. Frequently, the presence of a child restructures the
adult relationship along more “traditional” lines, where the female assumes
primary responsibility for housework and childcare responsibilities in addition
to full-time paid involvement. Although fathers are emotionally and socially
bonded to their children, their in-home responsibilities usually are not equally
shared with their female partners (Hochschild, 1989). Hochschild’s research
(The Second Shift) indicates that women in two-income families work an
equivalent of an extra month a year with their additional household respon-
sibilities (1989).
Parenting and gender role options are becoming more flexible as indicated
by the greater availability of assisted reproductive technology (ART) (see
Chapters 6 and 7), more educational and career opportunities for women,
a rise in divorce rates, and greater numbers of single heads-of-households
(AAUW, 1989: 5; US Bureau of Labor, 1985; US Census Bureau, 2000). With
increased tolerance and visibility of alternative lifestyles, more gays and les-
bians are more openly involved in parenting. Although increasing numbers
of gays or lesbians are adopting children or having their own through ART,
it is still difficult for them to obtain custody or reasonable visiting rights of
children from their marriages (Boston Women’s Health Collective, 1976, 1984,
1992, 2005; Douglas, 1990; Whelehan, 1987). However, a few legal decisions
have allowed gay and lesbian parents to maintain contact with their minor
children. In Virginia, a lesbian mother was awarded custody (Morning Edition:
Lesbian Mother in Custody, 1994; SOLGAN, 1992; “The Courts Are Again
Asked to Redefine Families,” 1990). Lesbians also have the legal option of
AI-D, which is available to them through clinics in urban areas or more infor-
mally through arrangements made with male friends. Lesbians stand a greater
chance of parenting their biological children than do gays. For gays to do so,
they must either “pass” in a heterosexual marriage, hope to receive visitation
rights if they divorce, or find a woman willing to bear their child and let them
raise the child. This latter option, known as surrogate mothering, is a difficult
situation for gays or straights, married, or single men. Genetic parenthood is
more preferred by gay men, however it’s an expensive process and states that
are particularly lacking in LGBT-friendly reproductive clinics leave gay men
with a limited surrogacy market (Jacobson, 2018: 19). While there is significant
ethnographic research regarding gay men’s parenthood through gestational
surrogacy (Bergman et al., 2010; Blake et al., 2017; Dempsey, 2013; Smietana,
2019), male perspectives of infertility are particularly lacking in national data
(Culley et al., 2013; Jacobson, 2018: 19).
From research conducted in the 1970s (e.g., Green, 1978, 1979a, b), children
of homosexual parents are as likely to be homosexual as are children of het-
erosexual parents. More recent research, which surely needs more follow-up,
suggests possibly a familial tendency toward male homosexuality (Bailey and
Pillard, 1991; Hamer and Copeland, 1994). Lesbians do not create man-hating
318 Adult Sexuality
daughters and sexually confused sons any more than gays create misogynist sons
and sexually confused daughters. One gay man says of his daughter and son,
“They’re so normal,” a statement many of us who are parents would like to make
about our children. His children are proud and accepting of who their father is.
Their conflicts, shared closeness, and confidences are what many parents in the
United States hope to achieve with their children (Whelehan’s files).
Single-parent households, which are primarily headed by women, frequently
function under severe economic restrictions unless the woman is a middle-class
career person who chose single parenting (Crooks and Baur, 1987; Hochschild,
1989). In female-headed single-parent households, there are a variety of par-
ent-child interactions and male role models available to the children in the
form of extended kin relations such as the mother’s brothers or the mother’s
father, non-sexual male friends, and sexual partners (Dugan, 1988). This is a
well-established, adaptive pattern in many lower income African American
and Latino households (Dugan, 1988; Stack, 1974).
In single-parent, male-headed households, the economic situation is usually
more stable, more secure, and more comfortable (AAUW, 1989: 5). Men earn
approximately 28–34 percent more than women in comparable positions, and
after divorce experience about a 43 percent increase in disposable, or available,
income; however, women often experience a drop in disposable income of al-
most 33 percent (Boston Women’s Health Collective, 2005; Faludi, 1991: 22).4
It is also more socially acceptable for a male as a single person and parent in
US society to seek a relationship with a woman than for a female single parent
to seek a relationship with a man. As with women, men rely on paid childcare,
extended kin, and non-sexual friends of both genders for support and to be
female role models for their children. Use of extended kin and non-kin as a
means of socioeconomic support and socialization of children is a continu-
ation of our hominid behavior of alloparenting, where non-human primate
“sisters” and “aunts” care for the young as well as the biological parents.
Since a significant proportion (23 percent) of families in the United States
comprise single-parent households, this involves qualitative shifts in parenting
and childcare similar to those mentioned for dual-income families (US Cen-
sus Bureau, 2019). In nonindustrialized societies and for some ethnic groups in
industrialized societies, childcare can be managed within extended kin and
clan relationships. For the middle class in the United States, extended kin re-
lationships have been attenuated since the beginning of the twentieth century.
Increasingly, middle-class parents, both single and dual, turn to paid, non-kin–
based childcare, professional childcare “experts”—counselors, educators, pedia-
tricians, how-to advisors—and literature for information, support, and help in
raising children. Blue-collar and lower-class kin groups tend to tie into social
service agencies and extended kin for help in childrearing (Rubin, 1975).
Teenaged Parents
A parenting situation defined in this culture as highly problematic is teen-
aged parenting, particularly for those teens younger than fifteen. We (in the
United States) have the highest rate of teenaged pregnancy of any industri-
alized society (The Alan Guttmacher Institute; Wattleton, 1990; World Health
Statistics Annual, 1988). Approximately 18.8 babies are born per 1,000 teenage
women aged fifteen to nineteen years old in the United States (Martin et al.,
2017: 1). Yet, teenagers in the United States are not culturally recognized
adults physically, socio-psychologically, economically, legally, or politically.
Most of these teenagers give birth to their children and many decide to keep
and raise them. It is a cultural situation of “children having children.” These
teenagers have a high rate of complications during pregnancy and child-
birth including premature births, low birth-weight babies, or spontaneous
abortions. Often, the fathers of the babies, many of whom are men in their
twenties, not teens, cannot and do not economically and socially support the
nuclear families they have created (Males, 1992: 525). There was a decrease
in the overall number of teenaged pregnancies during the 1990s with both
sides of the sex education controversy claiming success for this decline (The
Alan Guttmacher Institute). This trend has continued through the twen-
ty-first century.
Younger teenaged parents often become dependent on the social service sys-
tem, which varies greatly by state relative to how much economic, social, and
emotional support is available. These teens can have a difficult time gaining
the culturally appropriate skills such as job training, high school, or college
education. Survival mechanisms include support from extended kin networks,
particularly in economically poorer, white, African American, and Latino
families, and reliance on Aid for Families with Dependent Children, referred
to as TANF (Temporary Assistance to Needy Families). Larger societal in-
stitutions perceive teenaged pregnancy and parenting as an unresolved crisis
situation (The Alan Guttmacher Institute; Wattleton, 1990).
Summary
1 Sex is defined as a biological, psychological, and cultural phenomenon
with attention to the importance of culture in shaping its meaning and
expression.
320 Adult Sexuality
2 Cross-cultural evidence was introduced including Mangaian and Tantric
models of sexuality; these were contrasted with industrialized models.
3 Industrialized models of sexuality were introduced in a critical and histor-
ical framework.
4 Prominent researchers of sexology were discussed including Freud, Kinsey,
Masters and Johnson, Kaplan, Singer and Singer, Whipple and Perry, Lau-
mann and colleagues, and Tiefer and colleagues.
5 Problems in sexual response were addressed including sexual dysfunction
and sex therapy. These were placed in a biological, psychological, and
cultural framework.
6 The clinical perspective of sexual dysfunction is compared to the “New
View of Women’s and Men’s Sexual Problems.”
7 Hookup culture and social media have significantly reshaped modern dat-
ing culture.
8 Parenting styles vary, and blended families and teenage parents are be-
coming more frequent.
Thought-Provoking Questions
1 How do college students define “hooking up”? Describe how sexuality is
negotiated by women and men in the encounter. What expectations do
you think are involved?
2 What is your response to the “New View of Women’s and Men’s Sexual
Problems”?
Suggested Resources
Books
Gagnon, John H. 2004. An Interpretation of Desire: Essays in the Study of Sexuality.
Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
Tiefer, Leonore. 2004. Sex Is Not a Natural Act. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
Article
Noonan, Raymond J. 2001. “Web Resources for Sex Researchers: The State of the Art,
Now and in the Future.” The Journal of Sex Research, 38(4): 348–351.
Websites
The Kinsey Institute for Sex, Gender, and Reproduction. See sections: Research
Program, Current Research Projects, Research Publications, Selections from the
“Kinsey Reports” 1948–1953 and Kinsey Institute Data and Codebooks. http://www.
kinseyinstitute.org/research/surveylinks.html. Last accessed 12/12/06.
Shiva Shakti Mandalam. This Is a Comprehensive Tantric Resource Site on the Inter-
net. http://www.religiousworlds.com/mandalam/index.html. Last accessed 12/12/06.
13 Sexuality through the Life
Stages, Part IV
Sexuality and Aging
Chapter Overview
1 Introduces biological, psychological, and social factors of sexuality and
aging.
2 Discusses aging men and andropause in the United States.
3 Discusses aging women and menopause in the United States.
4 Examines hormone replacement therapy (HRT/MHT) to address menopause.
5 Discusses sexuality during women’s menopause years.
6 Explores cultural ideologies of aging and sexuality in cross-cultural
contexts.
• Biological factors: health, physical fitness, and illness in both the indi-
vidual and/or partner, including local or systemic conditions such as the
endocrine system, the vascular system, arthritis, cancer, disability, the side
effects of medications and medical treatment, and substance abuse.
• Psychological factors: past sexual experiences, emotional well-being, per-
sonality characteristics, and beliefs/feelings/attitudes about sex and aging.
• Partner factors: quality and length of the relationship, opportunity for sex
with a partner. The sex ratio for single women to single men over sixty
makes it more difficult for heterosexual women and gay men to find a
partner since women outnumber men significantly in aging populations
(women outlive men by around five years).
• Socio-cultural factors: cultural beliefs about aging and sex, including the
influence of ethnicity, religion, sexual cultures, gendered norms, sexual
norms, ideologies of the body including the aging body, income level, etc.
324 Sexuality and Aging
Only more recently have cross-cultural and international comparative data of
aging men and women become available. The Global Study of Sexual Attitudes
and Behaviors funded by Pfizer includes in-person and telephone interviews
with 27,500 men and women aged forty to eighty years old from twenty-nine
countries (Laumann et al., 1994, 2006). This research will be discussed. Several
other large surveys have been conducted in the United States. The American
Association of Retired Persons (AARP) has undertaken two major studies on
midlife and aging, both for AARP’s Modern Maturity Magazine, which in-
cludes representative samples. One was reported in l999 (see Jacoby, 1999) and
the other in 2009, “Sex, Romance and Relationships: AARP Survey of Midlife
and Older Adults.” This 2009 sexuality research surveyed 1,670 adults aged
forty-five years and older. As a consequence of this survey, comparative data
with the AARP 2004 representative sample was provided; however, different
methodologies make these comparisons limited. Yet another study was con-
ducted by the National Council on Aging (Dunn and Cutler, 2015). Clearly
sexuality and aging is an expanding field for research since the number of US
elderly has grown exponentially as the baby boomers have aged.
Highlights of the AARP’s “Sex, Romance and Relationships: AARP Sur-
vey of Midlife and Older Adults” are presented along with data comparing the
2009 research with the 2004 AARP sex survey where applicable. This infor-
mation targets the ages of forty-five through seventy-plus years. Additional in-
formation on sexual desire compared by gender and age follow these findings.
• It usually takes a longer time and more direct stimulation for the penis to
become erect.
• The erection is less firm, less full, and less vertical.
• The amount of semen is reduced, and the intensity of ejaculation is lessened.
• There is usually less physical need to ejaculate.
• The refractory period—the time interval after ejaculation when the male
is unable to ejaculate again—becomes longer.
Viagra and its cohorts can be life-threatening for men with low blood
pressure taking nitrate medications. Other side effects include head-
aches, upset stomach, and visual problems. Prior to Viagra, men’s choices
for erectile problems included vaccum devices (pumps), injections, and
penile implants of various sorts.
We recognize that for many men and their partners, these drugs and/or the
various technologies to facilitate erection have reinvigorated their sexual
relationships. While there is literature that debates how female partners re-
spond to sildenafil, vadenafil, and tadalafil (the literature is relatively silent on
same-sex partners), the 2004 AARP survey indicated that women of all ages
reported their own satisfaction was enhanced with the partner’s use of silde-
nafil and its cohorts, with some increase in amount of sexual activity as well.
Montorsi et al. (2004) indicate partners of men who use sildenafil are equally
as pleased with treatment outcomes; however, partner perspectives are not
widely included in the current literature, nor are discussions about the emo-
tional and relational impacts of using sexo-pharmaceuticals (Potts et al., 2003:
698). It must be remembered that desire and sexual interest are not impacted
by these drugs. There may be indirect psycho-social expectations that impact
the effect of these drugs, which according to Jacoby (2005: 1–3) is probably
why 42 percent of the men discontinued using sildenafil and its cohorts.
At this point, we should recall a few points about the history of “impo-
tence,” or erectile problems and its relations to men’s norms. Generally speak-
ing, before the invention of Viagra and its successors, Tiefer (2004, 2006a) and
Marshall and Katz (2002), among others, have argued that a gradual decline
in desire and erectile capability was regarded as a normal part of the aging
process. Couples in intimate relationships adjusted their sexuality in various
ways, focusing more on the total body experience. However, the last twenty
years have witnessed an escalation of the notion of “an ageless sexual vitality”
embedded in trends in medicalization of both age and sex, including the in-
vention of sildenafil and its cohorts, contributing to a continued emphasis on
sexual performance for men (Tiefer, 2004, 2006a: 7).
Sexuality and Aging 327
The latter part of the twentieth century and the new millennium have wit-
nessed the growing hegemony of masculine gender norms that equate sex with
performance and an unrelenting and unfailing sexual desire. Viagra and its
cohorts have had a tremendous impact on aging men who have experienced
changes in erectile functioning. And these changes have more recently been
interpreted as sexual dysfunctions rather than as part of the process of sexual
aging in which libido and erectile functioning decrease (Marshall and Katz,
2002). This should not be interpreted to mean that sexual dysfunctions are not
real to men. Rather, it is suggested that a more multidimensional approach is
required to understand men who experience serious problems with sexuality
and erection related to lifestyle, health, disease, disability, and medications such
as antidepressants. Suffice it to say that there are psychological, relational, and
cultural factors in sexual problems throughout the life course, not just among
aging men (Tiefer, 2006a, in particular refer to the section, “A New View Classi-
fication of Sexual Problems”). In addition to issues related to aging erectile func-
tioning, a separate but related matter is sexual desire throughout the life course.
Changes in sexual desire are also part of the aging process for men as well as
women that are best viewed from the holistic stance of a biological, psycholog-
ical, and cultural perspective (DeLamater and Sill, 2005). Desire has also been
medicalized as we discussed in Chapter 12 (hypoactive sexual desire disorder)
(Meuleman and Van Lankveld, 2005). In contrast to men, the aging process
for women’s sexual and reproductive life is marked by a clear physiological
change that culminates in the cessation of menses (menopause). However, a
male counterpart to menopause has recently been identified and “named” in
late twentieth-century Euro-American scholarly and media discourses. This
has been variously designated as the male climacteric, male menopause, and/
or andropause. Sperm production gradually declines through the male life
course so that by age seventy-five a man may be producing only 10 percent of
the sperm he produced before age thirty (Kelly, 1990: 58). Although women
lose significant amounts of estrogen and progesterone as they age, and men’s
levels of testosterone do decline, how much and with what impact does the
decline in testosterone have on sexual desire and interest? In addition, there
is a great deal of variation among men that may include genetic as well con-
text-specific factors such as medications (Angier, 1992; Marino, 1993; Vermeu-
len, 2000). With the FDA approval of a testosterone gel (Androgel) in 2002,
there has been a substantial increase in men being treated with testosterone
therapy for low sexual desire/interest, and for other related reasons including
328 Sexuality and Aging
mood, energy levels, etc. Provision of testosterone therapy has increased five-
fold since 2011 (McBride et al., 2016: 47). Testosterone “therapy” has been
escalating in the United States since the introduction of user-friendly gels and
patches, as opposed to injections, and has led the National Institute of Aging
to register concerns about the risks and benefits of testosterone treatments
(“NIA Statement on IOM,” 2003). The variability of testosterone therapy in
aging men makes the prescription of testosterone difficult, and more research
needs to be done before its widespread use (Ahern and Wu, 2016: 193).
Studies offer conflicting views on testosterone production in aging men.
After thirty years of age, testosterone levels can decrease by 0.4–2 percent an-
nually (McBride et al., 2016: 47). Vermeulen (2000) notes that by seventy-five
years old, average testosterone levels are only 65 percent of those of young
adults; while 25 percent of the men over seventy-five still have testosterone
levels in the upper range for young men. Tan and Culbertson (2003) assert
that between the ages of twenty and eighty men’s testosterone levels decline
by about 35 percent. The Baltimore Longitudinal Study of Aging (Harman
et al., 2001) on 890 older men found age-related reduction in testosterone lev-
els but these lower levels were not universal, affecting about 20 percent of men
aged sixty, 30 percent of men over seventy years old, and 50 percent of the
men over eighty years old. Evidence suggests that low testosterone is not that
common; Sartorius et al. suggest that decrease in testosterone levels may be
attributed to co-morbidities associated with aging, and not the process of aging
itself (2012: 760). Furthermore, The National Institute on Aging (“Frequently
Asked Questions about Testosterone,” 2003) states:
Changes in men’s sexual desire as they age may be highly variable and inter-
connected to a number of factors which may include physiological influences
related to the endocrine system, health and illness, medications and medical
treatments. DeLamater and Sill’s (2005) research using data from the AARP
Sexuality and Aging 329
1999 survey of people over age forty-five found that the chief influences on
sexual desire for men were age, education, and the importance of sex to the in-
dividual. For both men and women, DeLamater and Sill conclude “attitudes are
more significant influences on sexual desire than biomedical factors” (2005: 138).
Though there may be no profound and documented major changes in hor-
mone levels before eighty years old, this does not mean that the masculine
climacteric in the United States is a myth. A male climacteric or midlife crisis
is a culturally acknowledged period in the industrialized man’s cycle where
he may experience a variety of symptoms including anxiety and depression
(Henker, 1977 in Kelly, 1990: 58; Masters, Johnson, and Kolodny, 1982: 170;
Moss, 1978; Vermeulen, 2000). The “male menopause” may in fact be a re-
sponse to the cultural conception of aging dominant in the United States.
This is a period where the male, whose patriarchal culture has encouraged,
advantaged, and celebrated him, confronts a mitigating cultural feature: the
youth orientation of US society. The aging man must face the inevitability of
aging and the profound changes in status and prestige that may accompany it.
The “male menopause” may well be a response to this male dilemma, for ours
is not a society that venerates the elderly.
Whether a man experiences a social phase like “andropause” will vary
cross-culturally, depending on the cultural meanings embedded in the partic-
ular society’s ideology of aging, and the definitions and expectations regarding
masculinity (Winn and Newton, 1982).
Societal attitudes about “dirty old men” may do much harm to the aging
man’s self-esteem. Industrialized society’s ideal cultural standards set a very
narrow age range for socially approved periods of sexual behavior. Sexuality is
denied to the young as well as the very old in the United States in the ideal
cultural norm. This reflects the traditional value on sex for procreation. If our
model of sexuality was purely recreational, and not so phallocentric, elderly
sexuality would probably be championed for the changes it produces. The el-
derly man as well as woman who wishes to continue to experience his or her
sexuality may be the brunt of jokes and other sanctions among industrialized
Anglos. Ageist attitudes regard sex as if it is something that should be out-
grown among the elderly. That this damage may be first expressed through the
ideologies of a male climacteric in anticipation of these cultural attitudes also
reflects the reproductive success model of sexuality.
• Headaches.
• Difficulty concentrating/changes in memory.
• Joint pain.
• Palpitations.
• Frequent urination.
• Night sweats.
• Insomnia/disrupted sleep.
• Vaginal dryness (lubrication is significantly reduced).
• Thinning of the vaginal walls and loss of vaginal elasticity.
• Lack of energy.
• Decline in sexual desire.
• Changes in sexual response with fewer orgasmic contractions.
• Increased risk for osteoporosis.
Keep in mind as you view this list that there is compelling research to suggest
that many of the physical changes and “symptoms” of menopause as well as
Sexuality and Aging 331
how women experience menopause, are in fact influenced by socio-cultural
variables linked to women’s status, the meaning of aging, sex, and reproduc-
tion (Avis et al., 2001; Richters, 1997; Ward, 2006). For example, the Inis Beag-
eans, an Irish community noted for their repressive sexual attitudes, believed
that one of the consequences of menopause is mental illness, so that some
of the physiological symptoms reported among industrialized women such as
hot flashes and mood swings were regarded as signs of insanity. According to
Messenger who studied this community some women have “retired from life
in their mid-forties and, in a few cases, have confined themselves to bed until
death, years later” (1971: 15). Psychological and physical changes associated
with menopause are not experienced uniformly across cultures (Ward, 2006).
We shall return to this topic shortly.
It is sometimes difficult to assess whether some of the uncomfortable sen-
sations older women experience are related to the cessation of fertility and
decline in estrogens, progesterone or with aging generally. Nevertheless, med-
icalization of menopause has been escalating since the first “treatments” for
menopause with estrogen and progesterone, referred to initially as estrogen
replacement therapy (ERT) and later coming to be known as HRT, hormone
replacement therapy. HRT has more recently been called menopausal hor-
mone treatment (MHT) by the National Center for Complementary and
Alternative Medicine, the National Institutes of Health.
Robert Wilson’s (1962) research on prescribing estrogen and progesterone
for menopausal women jump-started the US and industrialized use of MHT
(King, 2005). Wilson claimed MHT was a miracle drug and pronounced “Step-
ford Wife” results, claiming MHT would preserve women’s youth and sexual vi-
tality: “[e]strogen makes women adaptable, even-tempered, and generally easy
to live with” (in King, 2005: 320). The widespread use of MHT contributed
to the medicalization of menopause as a syndrome with symptoms that can
be “fixed” with medication. One of the consequences is that these symptoms
contribute to a negative view of women’s aging, one that is exacerbated by US
and industrialized emphasis on youth culture and women’s lower status com-
pared to men. In addition, according to Tiefer (2004), the medicalization of
menopause has been escalated by the growth of capitalism and the expansion
of pharmaceutical companies and health care nationwide and internationally
(Tiefer, 2004). This is certainly not the “menopausal zest” that Margaret Mead
associated with women’s renewed sense of energy that occurred in some soci-
eties as women experienced freedom from fulltime duty as mothers/spouses (in
Ward, 2006: 75). We shall return to the topic of the influence of culture on the
menopausal experience.
• Eight more cases of breast cancer than in women not using MHT.
• Seven more cases of heart disease.
• Eight more cases of stroke.
• Eight more cases of blood clots in the lungs (“The Age Page Hormones
after Menopause,” 2005).
However, current research critiques the response to the WHI study, stating
that the absolute risk of CVD in younger women who start HRT at the onset
of menopause is not significant enough to discontinue its use in managing
Sexuality and Aging 333
menopausal symptoms (Chester et al., 2018: 251), and that the early closure
of the 2002 trial resulted in a loss of valuable research that could have been
useful in dispelling displaced fears about using HRT (Cumming et al., 2015:
57). An Internet survey of post-menopausal women from the UK found that
43.8 percent of respondents did not feel that they knew enough about HRT to
make a decision regarding its use. While this improved from 2004, where 73
percent of surveyed women indicated the same, the benefits and risks in using
HRT remains a poorly discussed topic between clinicians and their patients
(Cumming et al., 2015: 60).
As a result of the WHI studies, medical practitioners became alerted to
possible health risks and consequently carefully began to monitor MHT for
clients. FDA guidelines recommend that the lowest dose for the shortest pe-
riod of time is the best way to proceed. Even with low dosages the health risks
are not known. Some women have switched to what are called bio-identical
hormones, chemically tweaked estrogens and progestins that are akin to the
naturally occurring ones (Northrup, 2001); however, the health risks of using
bio-identical hormones have not been established and remain a contentious
debate in the medical community (Boothby et al., 2008: 406; Mukkamala,
2016: 5). In addition, the health effects of “natural” supplements derived from
plant estrogens that are not under FDA control have not been studied scien-
tifically. Women are advised to consult with their healthcare providers and
to weigh the risks and benefits of MHT. If they do decide to use MHT, then
it should be regarded as a short-term and temporary treatment (Barcaly and
Vega, 2005).
As a result of the WHI findings, US/industrialized women and their medical
practitioners have gone in quest of alternative and “natural” treatments, as
well as lifestyle changes, including diet, exercise, and the use of vitamins and
supplements to reduce some of the more uncomfortable effects of menopause.
However, a cache of other pharmaceuticals is also currently prescribed in place
of MHT to counteract menopausal effects including antidepressants used off
label to reduce hot flashes and anti-inflammatory drugs for joint pain, among
others. These drugs also have detrimental side effects that must be consid-
ered when weighing the decision regarding menopausal effects and treatments
(Parker-Pope, 2006). The natural and alternative approaches including vita-
min therapy suggest that to reduce the risk of osteoporosis, menopausal women
should take calcium and vitamin D. Regular weight-bearing exercise is also
advocated for strengthening bones. In addition, women and their healthcare
providers are pursuing CAM: complementary and alternative medicine. The
following points regarding menopause and treatments to alleviate symptoms
are made by the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Med-
icine of the National Institutes of Health (“Do CAM Therapies Help Meno-
pausal Symptoms?” 2005).
Since the Women’s Health Initiative results were first reported in 2002, closer
scientific scrutiny of the research findings has offered challenges to the study
for its flawed design (Klaiber, Vogel, and Rako, 2005). For example, the health
risks of MHT were primarily associated with the much older women (ages fifty
to seventy-nine years old) who began taking hormones with little or no prior
history of MHT. This biased the results of MHT because the older population
was more at risk for coronary and cerebral atherosclerosis due to their age.
The younger women who began MHT at menopause had far less risk, with
some evidence that MHT may actually offer some safeguards for heart health
(Klaiber, Vogel, and Rako, 2005; Parker-Pope, 2006). Current clinical guide-
lines suggest that MHT is safe for women younger than age sixty or within
ten years of menopause with no history of cardiovascular disease, embolisms
or breast cancer (Stuenkel et al., 2015: 3976). Despite this, the use of MHT
to treat menopausal symptoms has decreased by 80 percent since its initial
publication in 2002. This is partly due to a failure to adequately train medical
students to identify and treat menopause in female patients (Santen et al.,
2014: 281). Menopausal women are encouraged to weigh their options carefully
and to consider the risks and benefits of not only MHT, but also the use of sup-
plements that are not scrutinized by the FDA for safety. No relevant medical
society in the United States currently endorses the use of alternative hormone
therapies (Gass et al., 2015: 1277).
[t]he lack of a single set of menopausal symptoms and the findings that the
type and number of symptoms vary with race/ethnicity attest to the need
to continue to explore the complex relationship between the physiological
changes occurring during menopause and the symptoms experienced by
women.
More recently, the Sexual Well Being Global Survey (SWGS) was distributed
in 2006 to 26,032 participants in twenty-six different countries. Participants
ranged in age from 16 to 65. This survey identified patterns in sexual behavior
across men and women of different geocultural backgrounds, as well as across
heterosexual and homosexual participants. However, it should be noted that
90 percent of participants were heterosexual (Wylie, 2009: 41). This study was
also funded by SSL/ Durex, aimed at identifying the sexual behaviors and needs
of a population of potential consumers (2009: 45). Key points are summarized:
Turning now to the cross-cultural record, we will examine some of the evi-
dence around the issue of aging and sexuality from the middle years through
later years of the life cycle. Cross-culturally the period of the middle years
is defined as the period in which one is not yet old and defined functionally
as a period when one’s children have reached adulthood (Brown and Kerns,
1985). Although cross-cultural research is limited on this period, Judith K.
Brown and Virginia Kerns’ In Her Prime: A New View of Middle-Aged Women
offers an excellent overview of this subject. Brown and Kerns’ work contains
articles focusing primarily on women. There are unfortunately no “systematic
cross-cultural studies of men in their middle years” (Oswalt, 1986: 161). How-
ever, Stanley Brandes’ Forty: The Age and the Symbol (1987), mentioned earlier,
344 Sexuality and Aging
offers an important cultural analysis of the meaning of forty in industrialized
society. According to Brandes (1987: 85), one of the weaknesses in the adult
lifepsan literature is its focus on universals to the detriment of class, cross-
cultural (author’s addition), and ethnic differences. The perceptions of when
one is aging and at what point transitions and stages are demarcated are largely
cultural constructs overlying a biological continuum of changes. A person’s ap-
pearance, position, stage in rites of passage, and reproductive roles demarcate
one’s “age” in society (Winn and Newton, 1982). Thus, Glascock and Feinman
(1981 in Oswalt, 1986: 165) note that maturity and aging are not clearly iden-
tified by physiological changes, but rather by other transitions in the life course
including changes in occupation and work effort, status of children, passing on
of inheritance, etc.
Preindustrial societies do not show the expected variation in what we
conceive of as the midlife experiences of women. In fact, “[t]he changes in
a woman’s life brought about by the onset of middle age” appear to be some-
what positive in nonindustrialized societies (Brown and Kerns, 1985: 2). Three
changes accompany transition into the middle years: restrictions may be lifted,
authority over certain younger relatives may be expected, and women may
become eligible for special non-domestic status (Brown and Kerns, 1985: 2–3).
When women undergo menopause in societies in which menstruation is re-
garded as polluting or taboo, the post-menopausal woman may gain a great
deal more freedom of movement and flexibility in interaction. For example,
they may be free to talk with non-kin males and act in more indelicate and
indecorous ways in societies in which propriety in young women is demanded
(Brown and Kerns, 1985: 3).
Richard Lee (1985: 23–35) reports that Ju/wasi (formerly known as the
!Kung) women between the ages of twenty to forty years old were required to
project a non-sexual image of “shy sweetness.” After age forty, Ju/wasi women
are given much more sexual freedom. An older woman may have an affair with
a young man that may be common knowledge among her cohorts or she may
engage in open sexual joking with men (if over about fifty years old). Women’s
status among the Ju/wasi, which is high to begin with, becomes increasingly
higher as they age so they have greater influence in arranging marriages, par-
ticipating in gift exchanges, and acting in the role of kinship expert.
Cross-culturally, older women may be given the opportunity to be more
influential and exert more authority, including increased access to the labor of
children and their spouses, as well as a more managerial role in food getting
and distribution activities. Control over the distribution of food is one way
that informal power of older women is expressed. Finally, aging may provide
women access to extra domestic positions such as that of shaman, holy or
sacred roles, ceremonial planner, and midwife, among others. The obligations
and taboos around fertility are no longer in effect with menopausal status and
women can command respect, and exert more influence and power. For ex-
ample, by becoming a mother-in-law she can gain status she never had with
maidenhood (Brown and Kerns, 1985: 4–5; Ward, 2006).
Sexuality and Aging 345
The cross-cultural spectrum is broad concerning the issue of sexuality
among older women and men. For example, Vatuk (1985: 147–148) notes in
her research in Western Uttar Parades and Delhi that men and women are
expected to give up sexual relations upon the marriage of the son. In contrast,
for the Ju/wasi, a healthy sexuality is accorded even more leeway for the ag-
ing woman. Lee notes an interesting marriage pattern of older Ju/wasi women
and younger men, a pattern sanctioned negatively in US society (except for
Hollywood movie stars). Approximately 20 percent of all marriages at /Xai/xai
waterhole were between older women and young men. Following divorce or
widowhood it is not uncommon for an older woman to take a younger man as
a spouse (Lee, 1985: 30). It would be interesting to explore further the beliefs
about older women as sexual partners in these kinds of relationships.
Information on sexuality among the elderly cross-culturally is not exten-
sive and it is subject to the same methodological dilemmas of sex research in
general. For example, while human sexuality textbooks may include a cross-
cultural discussion of sexuality in childhood and adolescence, like the subject
of “middle age,” there is little available on the transition to older age. This
is true for the anthropological literature as well, although there is a growing
body of research on this subject, including some cross-cultural correlational
approaches, some comparative approaches, and ethnographic perspectives. In
contrast to the ageism found in the United States regarding sex among older
people, the cross-cultural record shows more acceptance of sex as an activity
and desire that continues throughout the life course as demonstrated in Winn
and Newton’s (1982) cross-cultural correlational study of sexuality and aging
among 106 traditional cultures using the HRAF files. This research identified
common themes and patterns related to aging and sex.
• In 70 percent of the societies (in which data were available) older males
continue to engage in sexual behavior.
• A common ideology in these societies was the expectation that men’s
sexual capabilities were not influenced by age.
• In 84 percent of the societies (in which data were available) older females
continued to have an interest and engage in sexual activities.
• In these societies reports of strong sexual interest by older women were
common.
• In 50 percent of these societies, older women’s sexual expression was re-
lated to their change in reproductive status.
• In 22 percent of the 106 societies older females were permitted to engage
in sexual conversation, sexual humor, and sexual gestures.
• The lessoning of prohibitions in sexual conversation was associated with
older women in 74 percent of the societies.
• Only at very old ages do expectations decrease concerning sexual interest/
activity.
• In only three societies (Taiwan, Northern Greece, and the Philippines)
was disapproval of elderly sex a cultural norm held by young people.
346 Sexuality and Aging
In a study of Greek and Mayan peasant women, Beyene (1989) found none
of the symptoms associated with menopause in industrialized societies. Both
Greek and Mayan women looked forward to it as an end to fertility and re-
ported more interest in sex and improved sexual relations with their husbands.
We can see how biology and gender interact through the cultural system, as
loss of reproductive roles for women often offers them more opportunities.
In this regard Davenport (1977: 115–163) cites some intriguing evidence
from the peasants of Abkhasia who live in the Caucasus region. These peoples
are known for their longevity and continued sexual functioning “long after
70, and even after 100” (1977: 118). The indigenous Abkhasians illustrate the
nexus of biology and culture in the aging process, including reproduction and
sexual expression. The Abkhasians represent an enclaved genetic population,
so there are obviously genetic factors involved in their longevity. Notably, 13
percent of the women continue menstruating after age fifty-five. According
to Davenport (1977: 118), “[o]ldsters continue to work, enjoy their food and
have heterosexual relations in diminishing amounts well beyond ages at which
Western Europeans and North Americans consider such activities to be al-
most impossible.” However, the cultural factors are very important in under-
standing the Abkhasian sexual vigor at advanced ages. These peasants have
no concept of retirement and change at old age. People continue through life
doing everything they have always done, including having sex, but to a lesser
extent. There are no specific negative sanctions concerning sex among the
elderly in contrast to the industrialized societies. The variety of perspectives
regarding sexual interest and activity among middle- to older-aged people con-
tinues to illustrate the richness and diversity of human sexuality throughout
the life cycle and the importance of understanding the influence of culture
upon bio-psychological dimensions of being human.
Summary
1 Sexuality at advanced ages is shaped by numerous biological, psychologi-
cal, and cultural factors.
2 Both men and women experience a physical change that affects sexual
desire, behavior, and expressions to varying degrees.
3 Hormone replacement therapies can regulate changes to women’s bodies
in a number of ways.
4 Cultural ideologies of aging and sexuality vary across cultures.
Thought-Provoking Questions
1 Why is there a social stigma attached to being sexually active at an ad-
vanced age?
2 Why are the physical effects of menopause experienced differently across
cultures?
Sexuality and Aging 347
Suggested Resources
Books
Mattern, S. P. 2019. The Slow Moon Climbs: The Science, History, and Meaning of Meno-
pause. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Steinke, D. 2018. Flash Count Diary: Menopause and the Vindication of Natural Life.
S.l.: Picador.
Gross, Z. H. 2000. Seasons of the Heart: Men and Women Talk about Love, Sex, and
Romance after 60. New York: New World Library.
Website
Sexuality in Later Life. ewa. https://www.nia.nih.gov/health/sexuality-later-life.
14 Sexual Identities, Preferences,
and Behaviors
Chapter Overview
1 Defines and describes various sexual identities.
2 Distinguishes between sexual identities and sexual behavior.
3 Defines heterosexism and homophobia.
4 Discusses known sexual behaviors as a continuation of what is found in
the mammalian and primate world.
5 Argues for a greater awareness of all forms of culturally defined sexual
identities.
6 Presents various theories which attempt to explain non-heterosexual
orientation.
7 Discusses sexual identities cross-culturally.
8 Discusses the range of gender role behavior.
Sexual Identities
A discussion of sexual identities and relationships confronts biases and as-
sumptions about sexuality. In many societies presently, including the United
States, heterosexuality is assumed and perceived as a “given.” For those people
who are heterosexual, this seems “normal and natural.” For people who iden-
tify as gay, bisexual, lesbian, or queer, this assumption of heterosexual “nor-
malcy” appears to be biased and based in heterosexist ethnocentrism. As part
of our exploration of human sexuality, we must seriously examine the range of
sexual identities, their possible expressions, and relationship forms.
Some basic definitions are needed. Sexual identity is often conflated with
sexual orientation, which refers to one’s attraction to sexual and romantic
love partners. However, we differentiate between sexual identity and orienta-
tion because sexual identity now refers to one’s own perception of one’s sexual
self, which can differ from one’s sexual orientation. Currently, this identity is
structured in the United States as being most commonly homosexual, bisex-
ual, heterosexual, or queer. However, sexual identities and orientations are
ever-expanding and an increasing number of people are identifying as asexual
or pansexual. A homosexual identity denotes sexual and romantic attraction
toward individuals of one’s own sex or gender. A bisexual identity denotes
Sexual Identities, Preferences, and Behaviors 349
sexual and romantic attraction toward both one’s own and the other sex or
gender, sometimes referred to as ambisexual. A heterosexual identity is sexual
and romantic attraction toward individuals of the other sex or gender. An
asexual identity refers to not being sexually attracted to other people at all,
and a pansexual identity refers to attraction to people regardless of their sex or
gender. A queer identity rejects rigid sexual attraction binaries based on sex-
uality, gender, or both. Relatively non-judgmental terms used to describe each
of these identities include “straight” for male and female heterosexuals, “gay”
for male, and “lesbian” for female homosexuals, particularly for those who are
open or “out” about their identities, and “bisexual” for male and female bi-
sexuals. Similarly, “same-sex” sexual behavior refers to two biological or natal
males or females having sex, but it can also refer to same-gender sexual behav-
ior where sexual partners may share a gender identity (i.e., both identifying as
men or women) but may not share a biological sex (i.e., being physically male
or female). For the sake of eliminating redundancy, we note that same-sex
sexual behavior includes same-gender sexual behavior.
Sexual identity is not synonymous with sexual behavior; these are dis-
crete entities. As with sexual identity, sexual behavior may be homosexual,
bisexual, or heterosexual. Given our culture’s assumptions about heterosexu-
ality, lesbians, gays, and bis may experience confusion and rejection in estab-
lishing their identity. Since the late twentieth century a number of groups
and events have helped people become more comfortable with and accepting
of sexual orientations. These include the Gay Rights Movement and Gay,
Lesbian, Bisexual, Transgender, and Queer Pride Parades (Blackwood and
Wieringa, 1999b).
The mayor of Moscow, Russia, Yuri Luzhkov, tried to ban the first-ever
Gay Pride Day in the city in February 2006. Human Rights Watch, among
other international groups, called on the mayor to allow the parade as
an example of tolerance and acceptance of “universal” human rights
(Human Rights Watch, 2006).
A person’s sexual identity and behavior may or may not be consonant. This
can occur for example, when one’s sexual partner of choice is not available,
as in sex-segregated institutionalized populations such as prisons or all-boys’
or all-girls’ schools, or where one’s choice is culturally proscribed. This latter
situation frequently occurs in the United States, which is overtly homophobic.
Homophobia is the fear, prejudice, and negative acting-out behavior toward
people who self-identify or are believed to have a homosexual orientation. Re-
searchers such as Boswell (1980), Greenberg (1988), and Johansson, Dynes,
and Lauritsense (1981/1985) believe that the presence of homophobia in most
twentieth- and twenty-first-century societies is a continuation of practices and
350 Sexual Identities, Preferences, and Behaviors
beliefs derived from Judaism and the Old and New Testaments. These beliefs
have been perpetuated by Christianity and the Catholic Church since the
Middle Ages.
In part, these homophobic positions are a reaction to the non-reproductive
aspects of same-sex sexual relations and their accompanying sex-for-pleasure
aspects. The repercussions of this prejudice have been felt politically, econom-
ically, socially, and religiously to the present. In a homophobic society such as
ours, for example, a same-sex sexual orientation may be hidden. The behav-
ior may be heterosexual and those involved pass (i.e., appear to be straight
in public). Alternatively, a same-sex orientation may be expressed openly in
communities where it can find support and relative degrees of acceptance and
safety. For example, “gay communities” such as Key West in Florida, West
Hollywood in Los Angeles, the Castro in San Francisco, or the Village in New
York (Blumenfeld and Raymond, 1989; Kelly, 1988; Kirk and Madsen, 1989).
Discussions about the origins of sexual orientation and the sex of one’s
sexual and romantic love partners are emotionally and legally charged
in the United States. The Supreme Court decided in 2003 that adult,
consensual, same-sex behavior in the privacy of one’s home was not a
crime. It overturned a case of two men who were arrested for engaging
in sex at home.
Bisexuality
There is increasing research on bisexuality, but less than exists for gays and
straights (Klein, 1978; Paul, 1984; Rust, 1999; Tielman, Carballo, and Hen-
driks, 1991). A bisexual orientation is a romantic and sexual attraction toward
both men and women. Both men and women can self-identify as bisexual.
Bisexuals may choose only same-sex partners, partners of the other sex only,
or of both sexes and genders. (Bisexuality is not synonymous with group sex
354 Sexual Identities, Preferences, and Behaviors
where people have multiple partners concurrently.) The following statements
come from one of your author’s files (Whelehan):
Of all the sexual orientations discussed, bisexuality appears to receive the least
acceptance, even though bisexual behavior has been estimated to be the high-
est. However, estimates of bisexuality are contradictory in current research.
As of 2011, one study indicates that among adults who identify as lesbian, gay,
or bisexual, there are slightly more bisexual-identifying people (1.8 percent)
than lesbian or gay individuals (1.7 percent) (Gates, 2011: 3). The National
Health Interview Survey performed by the CDC in 2013 indicated 96.6 per-
cent of American adults identified as heterosexual, 1.6 percent identified as
lesbian or gay, and 0.7 percent identified as bisexual. The remaining 1.1 per-
cent said they identified as something else, didn’t know, or refused to answer
(Ward et al., 2014: 5).
Bisexuals, on average, tend to be closeted, and are often most comfortable
with other bisexuals since both the straight and homosexual communities have
difficulty understanding and accepting them (Mclean, 2007: 164; Maliepaard,
2018: 154). Compared to heterosexual populations, as well as other LGBTQ
groups, bisexual people have higher rates of suicidal behavior and substance
abuse (Pompili, 2014: 1909). Gays, lesbians, and straight people often pressure
bisexuals to choose a straight, or gay, or lesbian behavior and identity, possi-
bly so that the non-bisexuals are more comfortable. Straight people can see
bisexuals as “playing a game,” “going through a stage,” as being indecisive, or
as being homosexual; this exclusive, discriminatory behavior toward bisexual
people (by heterosexual or homosexual groups) is known as “biphobia” (Barker
et al., 2012: 21). Since some closeted gay men and lesbians do engage in hetero-
sexual relations, this behavior further reinforces misperceptions about bisexu-
als. In addition, since this culture only accepts a heterosexual orientation and
behavior as “normal,” people can be confused, trying to sort out their feelings
and behavior. They may experiment sexually with members of their own and
the other sex as part of psychosexual growth (Klein, 1978; Rust, 1999). One
of the more unfortunate aspects of bisexuality, which is also shared with ho-
mosexuality, is the hiding and passing some bisexuals engage in because of
non-acceptance by the larger society. As Paul posits, bisexuality is part of the
range of human sexual behavior (1984). It is probably the most inclusive of the
orientations and one that can directly contribute to reproductive success.
Sexual Identities, Preferences, and Behaviors 355
Homosexuality
A homosexual orientation is the romantic and sexual attraction to mem-
bers of one’s own sex or gender, frequently called gay, when the attraction
is openly acknowledged between men, and lesbian when it occurs between
women. Kinsey et al. estimated that at least 10 percent of the US population
is exclusively homosexual (1948). On Kinsey’s scale, which is a measure of
behavior, not orientation, bisexuals are a two to five clustering in the three
to four range (Kinsey et al., 1948, 1953; see Table 14.1). In the United States,
Gates (2011: 1) found that 8.2 percent of Americans reported same-sex sexual
behavior and 11 percent acknowledge same-sex sexual attraction. Current re-
search in the United States indicates that the number of US adults identifying
as LGBTQIA has increased from 3.5 percent in 2012 to 4.5 percent in 2017;
this increase has been driven almost entirely by millennials, Hispanics, and
Asian groups have seen the largest increase in reported homosexuality. Re-
ported homosexuality in these groups increased from 5.8 percent in 2012 to
8.1 percent in 2017 (Newport, 2018). Gates (2011: 1) estimates that roughly 19
million American adults have engaged in same sex sexual activity, and around
25.6 million Americans acknowledge some level of same-sex sexual attraction.
Kinsey’s figure may be under-reported since the scale does not clearly distin-
guish between orientation and behavior; research from other sources includ-
ing cross-cultural material would support at least that percentage (Bell and
Weinberg, 1978; Ford and Beach, 1951; Kirk and Madsen, 1989; Walter, 1990).
Current research supports this claim: a recent survey of US high school stu-
dents found that of those who engaged in same-sex behavior, most identified as
heterosexual. Defining sexual orientation in research practice is difficult, and
future studies should include various dimensions of sexual identity, including
behavior, sexual and romantic attractions, to accurately assess homosexuality
(Mustanski et al., 2014: 241). In terms of gender differences, gay men tend
to reach milestones of coming out to family members or friends earlier than
women (Pew Research Center, 2013). About 5.1 percent of women identified
as lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer, intersex, or asexual in 2017, as
opposed to 3.9 percent of men (Newport, 2018).
Research published in 1994 stating that homosexuals comprise only 2 per-
cent of the population is questionable since orientation and behavior were
confused, and criteria by one of the researchers included that his subjects were
out to their family, friends, and the researcher (Michael et al., 1994).
As part of sexual culture change since the 1960s, many gays and lesbians
have become more open and more desirous of formal social recognition for
themselves and their relationships (Bell and Weinberg, 1978; Kirk and Madsen,
1989). According to a 2017 study, 10.2 percent of LGBT adults in the United
States were married to a same-sex spouse, and 13.1 percent of LGBT individu-
als were married to an opposite-sex spouse (Jones, 2019). Nearly two-thirds of
married same-sex couples are lesbians and only about one-third are gay men.
Gays and lesbians want to live and work openly with their partners, be part
of extended kin groups as couples, and receive comparable economic and so-
cial recognition and acceptance as do straight couples. Nowhere is this more
356 Sexual Identities, Preferences, and Behaviors
obvious than in the controversies surrounding gay marriages. Massachusetts
was the first state to legalize same-sex marriages in 2003, followed by Con-
necticut in 2008 and Iowa, Vermont, New Hampshire, and Washington, D.C.
in 2009. San Francisco married same-sex couples in 2004, but those marriages
were contested by the governor and the state (Marshall, 2004; “Opinion: US
Requirement that AIDS Group Sign Pledge against Sex Work,” 2005). Sev-
eral states passed legislation either banning same-sex marriages or refusing to
recognize those marriages performed in Massachusetts. This issue is so conten-
tious that President George W. Bush proposed a constitutional amendment to
ban same-sex marriages. That the federal government would seek to formally
and legally deny entire groups of people rights that are granted to others is
further evidence of our discomfort with sexual orientations and with sexuality
that is not potentially reproductive (Buchanan, 2005a).
Following President Bush’s administration, former President Barack Obama
announced in 2011 the Department of Justice would no longer recognize the
Defense of Marriage Act, in which marriages were only recognized if they were
between a man and woman (Office of the Press Secretary, 2016). In a landmark
ruling on June 26th, 2015, the Supreme Court voted to legalize gay marriage in
all fifty states. Groups of same-sex couples sued state agencies in Ohio, Michigan,
Kentucky, and Tennessee to challenge the rights of states to ban same-sex mar-
riage and to recognize legal same-sex marriages that occurred elsewhere (Oyez,
2015). The following excerpt from the decision embodies a momentous moment
in long political battle for LGBTQ rights in the United States:
Lesbianism
Research on lesbian, gay, and transgender individuals’ health has increased
compared to research about bisexual individuals. However, much of LGBT
research is focused on sexually transmitted diseases, which typically recruits
participants who are gay men (Boehmer, 2002: 1128). The HIV/AIDs crisis of
the 1980s in particular excluded women who have sex with women from most
research (Logie et al., 2012: 1; Dworkin, 2005: 6). Although there is a growing
awareness and increasing body of literature in this culture on lesbianism (cf.
Blumenfeld and Raymond, 1989) and cross-cultural documentation of lesbian
relationships (Blackwood, 1986; Blackwood and Wieringa, 1999a), lesbian re-
lationships and life-styles, like bisexual relationships, are historically discussed
less than those for gay men (SOLGAN, 1992). There may be several reasons
for this bias. Lesbian relationships tend to be less formalized and ritualized.
Females in general have greater flexibility to form female-female bonds and be
demonstrative than do males. Thus, lesbians may “pass” intentionally or un-
intentionally more readily than gays or bisexual men. Third, female sexuality
is structured differently from male sexuality. Unless it threatens known pater-
nity, female sexuality is not seen as having the same kind of force, power, vis-
ibility and possible threat as does male sexuality, particularly in industrialized
societies, which generate most of the researchers and research (Blackwood,
1986; Blumenfeld and Raymond, 1989; Kelly, 1988). Evelyn Blackwood and
Saskia E. Wieringa’s edited work on lesbian sexuality cross-culturally chal-
lenges European models of lesbians and research on women who identify as
Sexual Identities, Preferences, and Behaviors 359
lesbian. They see the lack of data on lesbians as due to: “problems in collection
and interpretation as well as to the silence of Western observers and scholars
on the topic of female sexuality” (Blackwood and Wieringa, 1999a: 39).
Cross-culturally and in the United States, lesbian relationships manifest a
great deal of flexibility and tend to emphasize the interpersonal dimensions of
the interactions (Blumenfeld and Raymond, 1989; Blumstein and Schwartz,
1983; Bryant and Demian, 1990; Herdt, 1984b; Weil, 1990). As with gays,
lesbians are parents who have well-adjusted children, friends, colleagues, and
neighbors. Lesbians overall show no greater psychological problems than do
straight women. In fact, research indicates that homosexuals who accept and
are comfortable with each other have high levels of self-esteem and may have
more stable relationships than the average heterosexual (Blumenfeld and
Raymond, 1989; Blumstein and Schwartz, 1983; Bryant and Demian, 1990;
Herdt, 1984b; Kirk and Madsen, 1989; Weil, 1990). Lesbians and gays may
have had to learn to be psychologically strong to confront the discrimination
they experience from the larger culture in a healthy way.
Heterosexuality
The degree of heterosexual bias in our culture is illustrated by the number of
heterosexual inventories that exist and the assumption that people are hetero-
sexual in both orientation and behavior. Although there have been some in-
roads made in the area of popular culture with television shows such as Queer
Eye for the Straight Guy, Will and Grace, Queer as Folk, and Transparent, as
well as movies such as Priscilla, Queen of the Desert, The Birdcage, Brokeback
Mountain, Carol, and Moonlight, we continue to have trouble recognizing dif-
ferent lifestyles in our own and other cultures. As Vance has stated, our con-
cept of homosexuality is “only found in modern, Western societies” (SOLGAN,
1992: 9). For example, in some books on orientations, behaviors, and genders
cross-culturally, it is difficult to find vocabulary to label and describe the man-
ly-hearted women among Plains Indians, the nadle among the Navaho, and
other forms of identity and behavior that is common, accepted, and valued
elsewhere (Roscoe, 1998; Williams, 1986).
In the post-WWII era in the United States, the ideal adult sexual standard
was that of a heterosexual, middle-class, monogamously married couple with
a minimum of two children—a boy and girl, in that order of preference. The
couple owned their own home where the woman worked full time without
monetary compensation and the man worked outside the home with paid full-
time employment (Blumstein and Schwarz, 1983; Frayser, 1985; Kinsey et al.,
1948, 1953). This ideal persisted until the Sexual Revolution of the mid-1960s
(discussed in Chapter 15) when these values and behaviors that were labeled
“traditional” were behaviorally challenged and questioned. During the Sex-
ual Revolution many people’s behaviors, but not necessarily their attitudes
changed. The changes in behavior but not attitudes led some researchers to
question whether there was a sexual revolution (Kelly, 1988; Weil, 1990).
360 Sexual Identities, Preferences, and Behaviors
Behavioral changes include more open sexuality outside of marriage, cohab-
itation, open marriage (O’Neill and O’Neill, 1972), and higher divorce rates as
well as the continuation of the traditional marriage (Blumstein and Schwartz,
1983). In the twenty-first century, there are numerous relationship patterns:
There was a slight drop in the divorce rate in the 1980s. This was attributed to:
the fear of AIDS and other sexually transmitted diseases; the economic ben-
efits of staying married contrasted with the economic hardship of separation,
divorce, single parenting, and child support; and the realization that being an
older single adult can lead to socio-sexual isolation (Weil, 1990). Ironically, the
decrease in divorce is not attributable presently to couples’ love for each other
or their desire to be together as a socio-psychological unit.
Although heterosexual marriage continues as a statistical norm, 45.2
percent of all US residents age eighteen and older choose to be single (US
Census Bureau, 2017). People are marrying slightly older—the median age of
women when they marry is twenty-eight, and men when they’re thirty years
old (US Census Bureau, 2019). These variations can be attributed to a variety
of factors. They include greater educational, career, and economic opportunity
and flexibility for both men and women; behavioral changes in gender-role ex-
pression and expectations, and greater materialism. There is also a generation
of children of divorced parents who are now adults, and who may be postpon-
ing marital commitment based on their experiences as children in custodial
situations.
Interestingly, when men and women in this culture are asked how sexuality
fits into their life and relationships, there tends to be both consistency and
diversity through time between them regardless of their sexual orientation.
Women, both lesbian and straight, tend to see sexuality as part of and an
expression of the relationship. Men, both gay and straight, tend to see sex-
uality as a physical pleasure, and a release of sexual tension (Blumstein and
Schwartz, 1983; Critchlow-Leigh, 1990; Hite, 1976, 1981, 1987; Kinsey et al.,
1948, 1953; Shilts, 1987). Both men and women are orgasmic, enjoy sexual
Sexual Identities, Preferences, and Behaviors 361
release, and enjoy sex in the context of a love relationship regardless of orien-
tation (Blumenfeld and Raymond, 1989; Blumstein and Schwartz, 1983; Bry-
ant and Demian, 1990; Critchlow-Leigh, 1990; Farrell, 1986; Goldberg, 1984;
Hite, 1976, 1981, 1987).
Summary
1 There are several forms of sexual identities and sexual orientation—
homosexual (gay or lesbian), bisexual, and heterosexual.
2 Sexual orientation is not synonymous with sexual behavior.
3 We do not know what causes anyone’s sexual orientation. However, het-
erosexuality is assumed to be normative in the United States, and thus is
unexplained. In contrast, homosexuality and bisexuality often are seen as
stigmatized or variant orientations and have been explained by a number
of theories.
4 There is a wide continuum of sexual behaviors in the animal and human
worlds.
5 Heterosexism and homophobia are widespread in the United States; defi-
nitions and expressions of sexual orientations vary by society and are in-
fluenced by culture change.
Thought-Provoking Questions
1 How does an ongoing value of sex for reproduction affect our attitudes
toward relationships and sexual behavior that are not heterosexual?
2 How are sexual orientation and gender culturally constructed and expressed,
and how do sexual identities or orientations differ from sexual behaviors?
Sexual Identities, Preferences, and Behaviors 363
Suggested Resources
Books
Blackwood, Evelyn, and Saskia Wieringa, eds. 1999. Female Desires: Same-Sex Relations
and Transgender Practices across Cultures. New York: Columbia University Press.
Rust, Paula C., ed. 1999. Bisexuality in the United States: A Social Science Reader. New
York: Columbia University Press.
Eisner, Shiri. 2013. Bi: Notes for a Bisexual Revolution. Berkeley: Seal Press.
Websites
“LGBT Rights.” American Civil Liberties Union. https://www.aclu.org/issues/lgbt-
rights.
“Know Your Rights.” Lambda Legal. https://www.lambdalegal.org/know-your-rights?g-
clid=EAIaIQobChMIrd7N47ym5gIV24FaBR2iLQ7dEAAYASAAEgLpsvD_BwE.
15 Sex, Sexuality, and Gender
Chapter Overview
1 Examines gender roles relative to concepts of psychological masculinity
and femininity.
2 Incorporates an anthropological discussion of gender variance including
the transgender community in the United States and other industrialized
societies and cross-cultural gender variance.
Transgender People
Before we begin our discussion of both clinical and cultural definitions and
explorations of transgender people’s identities, expressions, and experiences,
we would like to share our positions on the following:
• Since this is the second edition of the book, many aspects about trans-
gender people’s lives have changed. Yet, we feel that including earlier lit-
erature on the subject provides an important historical context that is
relevant to understanding it more broadly.
• Specifically nomenclature and identity labels pertaining to transgender
people change and expand frequently, which means that by the time of
publication, the language used here may be outdated. However, we chose
to keep potentially offensive terms such as “transsexual” or “transvestite”
in the original text to stay true to the evolution of scholarship.
366 Sex, Sexuality, and Gender
• The authors, especially those of us who have worked with transgender
individuals and organizations over many years, wish to emphasize that
we do not share the perspective of gender dysphoria being a mental
health pathology of any kind, although as of 2020, it remains listed in the
DSM-V-TR.
• Lastly, we emphasize that although this is a book on human sexuality, and
transgender people are commonly grouped under the LGBTQIA label, we
do not wish to conflate gender identity issues with sexual identity issues.
This has been a point of contention in the transgender community for
many years and we want to be clear that we separate these issues categor-
ically and ontologically.
Gender Dysphoria
Gender dysphoria1 is a clinical term that refers to distress felt by those who
are uncomfortable identifying with or behaving according to their culturally
assigned and defined gender (Harry Benjamin International Gender Dyspho-
ria Association, 2001; Money and Wiedeking, 1980). This clinical perspective
is codified in the various versions of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of
Mental Disorders (DSM). The DSM is published by the American Psychiat-
ric Association and is the handbook used in diagnosing mental disorders in
the United States (i.e., “DSM-V-TR”). It is currently in its 5th edition, pub-
lished in 2013. In 1980, the diagnosis of Transsexualism was introduced in
the DSM-III, and in 1994, the DSM-IV committee replaced the term with
gender identity disorder (GID) (The Harry Benjamin International Gender
Dysphoria Association, 2001). In the 2013 edition of the DSM-V, the terminol-
ogy changed again to replace GID with Gender Dysphoria (GD) (302.85). The
definitions and age-related specifications (i.e., GD in adulthood, adolescence,
and childhood) remain similar but reflect growing awareness of the diversity
and breadth of gender identities and expressions. According to the DSM-V-TR
(2013), Gender dysphoria refers to
the distress that may accompany the incongruence between one’s expe-
rienced or expressed gender and one’s assigned gender. Although not all
individuals will experience distress as a result of such incongruence, many
are distressed if the desired physical interventions by means of hormones/
surgery are not available. The current term is more descriptive than the
previous DSM-IV term gender identity disorder and focuses on dysphoria as
a clinical problem, and not identity per se
(451)
Socialization Variables
Over nearly fifty years ago, Money and Ehrhardt (1972) and Stoller (1968)
regarded socialization variables as taking precedence over prenatal sex hor-
mones in the formation of cross-gender identity, although these researchers
acknowledged that there may be some unknown biological (hormonal meta-
bolic) factor in the prenatal environment that may play a role. Stoller’s model
points to maternal overprotection and paternal distance—either emotional or
geographical—in transsexual etiology. According to Stoller, the child fails to
identify with the father and becomes effeminate. Other researchers sharing
Sex, Sexuality, and Gender 371
this view support the notion of a non-normative socialization, father absence
or prenatal dynamics such as a mother’s wish for a daughter (Cohen-Kettenis
and Gooren, 1999: 317). However, subsequent studies of these hypotheses were
not supported (Zucker and Bradley, 1995). Green (1974a, b) supports the view
that transsexuals share effeminate childhoods and then are subsequently chan-
neled into transsexualism as their options for normative gender identity devel-
opment have become closed off. Some support from the literature shows that
parental influences may be a contributing factor (Cohen-Kettenis and Arrindell,
1990; Garden and Rothery, 1992), but not necessarily a sufficient condition for
gender identity disorder (in Cohen-Kettenis and Gooren, 1999: 318).
She concludes that the brain and its interacting endocrine system “learn” be-
haviors just as humans acquire behavior through cognitive processes. Thus:
“Not only is the human mind in dynamic interaction with its environment…
so too is the human body changing, learning and growing through its experi-
ence within its environment” (Devor, 1989: 22).
In 1998, Dr. Jacob Hale wrote about a “borderland” between butch les-
bian identity and FTM masculinity, suggesting a “demilitarized zone.”
While the intervening years have brought no “demilitarized zone,” the
border may not have a long future. Converging trends in identity among
the younger generation in their teens and twenties suggest this, such as
changing meanings of “lesbian” and “FTM,” blending of sexuality and
gender, and understanding these as personal, rather than identity, differ-
ences. The socio-historical circumstances that gave power to anti-trans
feminist attitudes and trans rejection of lesbian identity are disappearing.
This is not to say that we are “post-lesbian” or “post-transsexual” but the
tension between identities, the need to distinguish clearly between them,
and the arguments about who is “really” lesbian or “really” FTM may be of
supreme unimportance to the next generation. Time will tell.
However, other societies have gender schemas that incorporate gendered ho-
mosexuality. In this situation the insertee or recipient of anal intercourse takes
on characteristics and behaviors associated with the feminine gender role and
feminine social identity. Unlike the United States gender schema, in Brazil,
one’s position as a recipient of homosexual anal intercourse defines one as
gender variant; the inserter is not considered homosexual or gender variant
(Kulick, 1998; Nanda, 2000). In some nonindustrialized countries, the sex/
gender system has created a place for various gender variant peoples through
the social construction of multiple genders, outside, inside and in between.
Although gender variance is legitimized and valued in some nonindustrial-
ized/industrializing societies, in others it is not. There is a tremendous amount
of diversity in the way gender variant peoples and cultures define, experience
and practice gender variant identities, statuses and roles; for some peoples such
as Plains Native Americans and some Hindus, it may be part of a sacred or reli-
gious experience and for others it is secular (Nanda, 1999, 2000). For example,
Thayer’s (1980) analysis argues that gender variance among Northern Plains
Indians represents an interstitial positioning of gender between the secular
and the sacred (in Bolin, 1987a, b) and in contrast Besnier (1996) notes that
Polynesian gender variance has no historical or current association with the
religious.
378 Sex, Sexuality, and Gender
From its early days through today, anthropologists have been document-
ing and analyzing this panoply of genders; for example Bogoras reported on
the Chuckchee “softman” in 1907. The cross-cultural study of gender vari-
ance reveals the limitations of our own Euro-American perspective of gender.
Scholars and researchers are not immune to the power of the industrial gender
schema to frame their analysis of the expression and meaning of gender vari-
ance, even when trying not to. Consequently it is far preferable in a discussion
of cross-cultural gender variance to use the indigenous or local name for the
gender variant identity, for example alyha for the Mohave male gender variant
status and mahu for the Polynesian “liminal” gender. It may be acceptable to
use the generic “two spirit” as a generic reference to Native American male
and female gender diversity (Lang, 1998). One major caveat relates to our
modern terminology that differentiates gender status/identity from gender role
and gender of erotic/sexual interest. The anthropological literature offers dis-
tinctions between these four insignias of gender in interpreting, for example,
whether a woman who behaves like a man is a cross-gendered or gender trans-
formed status, or whether such behavior is just part of gender role variability
for women (Bolin, 1996b, 2004b; Lang, 1998).
This is a subtle distinction that may be more evident through example than
explanation. Among the Northern Piegan, a highly sex-disparate culture stud-
ied by Lewis (1941), women could assume attributes associated with masculin-
ity through participation in economic venues. Among the Piegan, to acquire
wealth and display generosity had even higher prestige than war. Women who
pursued this career were known as manly hearts. The manly hearts were asser-
tive women characterized by aggression, independence, boldness, and sexual-
ity, all traits associated with Piegan masculinity (Lewis, 1941: 181f). But to be a
manly heart also required that one be wealthy and married. In this regard they
were highly valued as spouses because of their economic contributions. The
manly hearts gender was not a transformed status, although they “acted like
men.” Manly hearted women cursed like men, excelled in men’s and women’s
work, and generally behaved in ways associated with the masculine role but,
were essentially gendered as feminine in that they did not use their skills to
escape the gender constraints of being a wife and mother. The Piegan manly
hearts role inscribed the privileging of masculinity for both males and females,
while women’s pursuits were valued in women only (Lang, 1998: 305–306).
We must keep in mind that the distinction between gender statuses and gen-
der role may not be an emic one. A related point in the consideration of gen-
der diversity is that when gender varies, then Euro-American paradigms that
gender and sexual orientations are oppositional are dismantled rather rapidly.
When gender is destabilized then so is sexual orientation. Gender variance
also disrupts Euro-American notions of sexual orientation. US polarization of
homosexual and heterosexual does not translate well into the ethnographic
record as we saw in the case of Latin America wherein only the receptor in
anal sex is regarded as homosexual (Kulick, 1998). This polarization has also
been under cultural assault in the United States in the new millennium by
Sex, Sexuality, and Gender 379
youth (queering and questioning), and the recognition of a category of “men
who have sex with men” (MSM) (Hess et al., 2017).
A final point in the cross-cultural study of gender variance is that the
ethnographic record is decidedly thin on female supernumerary/transformed
statuses and female same-sex relations as well. In spite of the considerable con-
tributions of a cadre of women anthropologists including the valiant efforts of
Evelyn Blackwood who has dedicated her research to this subject area since
1984—including Blackwood and Wieringa (1999b), Blackwood (1999), Elliston
(1999), Lang (1998), and Whitehead (1981) among others—the study of female
gender variance and same-gender sexual behaviors is still in its infancy and
much work remains to be done. The classic anthropological literature on ad-
ditional/transformed genders is biased heavily toward examples of presumed
genetic/genital males and male gender variance is reported among many more
societies than for females (Lang, 1998). Unfortunately, since we offer discus-
sion of the classic ethnographic literature, our examples will necessarily reflect
this emphasis in the literature. However, women also occupied these positions.
Whether female two-spirit genders and other expressions are similar to male
gender variance is unclear (Lang, 1998). It may be argued convincingly that,
because gender statuses are structured differently for women and men globally,
gender variant statuses for women may not be expected to be mirror images
of men’s gender variance. In fact, Nanda (2000: 7) asserts: “[F]emale gender
diversity has its own cultural dynamic and is not simply a derivative, a parallel,
or the reverse of male gender diversity” (Nanda, 2000: 7). The bias in the liter-
ature has been speculated upon and may be explained as follows:
A final caution: although many cultures have gender variant positions for men
and women to transgress their gender by acting like or being identified with
the other gender, these must be understood within the context of the specific
culture at a specific point in time, since social identities are dynamic, situa-
tional, and contextual (Nanda, 2000: 4). Towle and Morgan (2006) offer a
cautionary voice to the use of the term “third gender” warning that in spite of
the acceptance of diversity implied by this term, it paradoxically signifies an
industrialized classification and appropriation of indigenous gender variance,
380 Sex, Sexuality, and Gender
obscures the heterogeneity and complexity of gendered social identities. As a
consequence, we have relegated the term “third gender” to those examples in
which the author uses the term.
Summary
1 Gender role is an expression of gender identity.
2 Gender role is culturally defined and expressed.
The cross-cultural expression of gender variance is explored.
3 US transgender identity is presented from a historical and cultural
perspective.
4 The concepts of androgyny and gender were developed in the 1970s to
explain gender role expression in US culture.
388 Sex, Sexuality, and Gender
Thought-Provoking Questions
1 To what extent are fundamentalist social and religious movements within
the United States and cross-culturally a backlash to the changes in sex-
uality, gender roles, and relationships that have been occurring since the
late twentieth century in industrialized societies, particularly the United
States?
2 Based on what you have read about the US transgender identity and
cross-cultural gender variance, how do you weigh in on the issue of biol-
ogy and gender in gender variance?
Suggested Resources
Books
Blackwood, Evelyn and Saskia Wieringa, eds. 1999. Female Desires: Same-Sex Relations
and Transgender Practices across Cultures. New York: Columbia University Press.
Cromwell, Jason. 1999. Transmen and FTMs: Identities, Bodies, Genders and Sexualities.
Urbana: University of Illinois Press.
Green, Jamison. 2004. Becoming a Visible Man. Nashville, TN: Vanderbuilt University.
Herdt, Gilbert, ed. 1996. Third Sex/Third Gender: Beyond Sexual Dimorphism in Culture
and History. New York: Zone Publishing.
Website
World Professional Association for Transgender Health. www.wpath.org.
16 Sexual Health
HIV, AIDS, and Sexually
Transmitted Diseases
Chapter Overview
1 Defines HIV infection and AIDS, placing it in the context of other
sexually transmitted infections (STIs) and sexually transmitted diseases
(STDs).
2 Discusses the epidemiology of HIV/AIDS globally.
3 Presents the biomedical aspects of HIV and AIDS.
4 Discusses HIV testing.
5 Discusses the sexual transmission of HIV and the controversies surround-
ing safer sex.
6 Explores the impact of HIV/AIDS on women in the United States and
elsewhere.
7 Discusses the political, economic, and socio-psychological factors in HIV
transmission, risk, prevention, and treatment in the United States and
cross-culturally.
8 Places the HIV/AIDS epidemic in a global context.
9 Presents the controversies surrounding drug and needle transmission of
HIV.
Introduction
Sexuality is one of the more complex dimensions of our humanity. One
place where this complexity is more obvious is when we explore the topic
of sexually transmitted infections (STIs) and sexually transmitted diseases
(STDs), specifically Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV) and Acquired
Immune Deficiency Syndrome (AIDS). This chapter highlights HIV/AIDS
as one of the most significant challenges currently confronting human
societies.
STIs/STDs can be acquired through the transmission of bodily fluids from
an infected individual to another person. STIs can be viral, bacterial, fungal,
or parasitic. STDs are the physical effects that happen to one’s body once
infected with an STI. These can include fevers, sores, fertility problems (par-
ticularly for females), and for those untreated STIs such as HIV and syphilis,
390 Sexual Health
death at their end stages. Common STIs include syphilis, chlamydia, and hu-
man papilloma virus (HPV). Syphilis and chlamydia are both treatable and
curable, as are genital warts. Even though chlamydia is not fatal, if left un-
treated it can cause infertility in women. HPV and herpes simplex 2 (HS2)
are both viruses, as is HIV. But HPV and HS2, while incurable, are not fatal,
and are easily treatable. A vaccine has been created to prevent HPV. Treat-
ments for these other STIs generally involve a short course of antibiotics or
other therapies, not a daily, lifelong regimen of treatment, as there is for HIV/
AIDS. This is important because STIs such as syphilis and gonorrhea can act
as risk factors and increase the likelihood of contracting an HIV infection.
This means that having one of these other STIs increases one’s risk for HIV
either by impairing one’s immune system or causing sores that make HIV more
readily transmissible.
Diseases such as the bubonic plague during the Middle Ages, syphilis,
and leprosy have played an important role in the physical, social, economic,
political, and psychological responses of societies over the past several hun-
dred years. In today’s society, HIV is the disease confronting us with global
and culture-specific significance and it affects industrialized, industrializ-
ing, and nonindustrialized countries. This disease, first identified by the
media in the United States in 1981 as GRID (Gay-Related Immune-defi-
ciency Disease), a misnomer, is now identified as HIV, which is a worldwide
phenomenon1.
There is neither a cure nor a vaccine for HIV/AIDS, and it is fatal if left
untreated. HIV infection can be treated with anti-retroviral medications
(ARVs), sometimes referred to as HAART (Highly Active Anti-retroviral
Therapy) with dramatic improvement in people’s health and their lives. How-
ever, these drugs are expensive, are not widely available outside of developed
societies, and can have serious side effects. People who take the drugs must
adhere to a strict daily schedule of dosage in order for the treatment to be
effective. Also, Pre-Exposure-Prophylactics (PrEP) that can be taken before
exposure to HIV and Post-Exposure Prophylactics (PEP) that can be taken
after exposure to HIV are available. These medications can stop HIV from
taking hold in the body.
Aside from the biological differences between HIV and other STIs, there
are socio-cultural, political, and economic factors that impact the course
of HIV/AIDS. As will be discussed, HIV/AIDS is global (pandemic) and is
found on all inhabited continents with devastating consequences for the
individuals, groups, and societies. Poverty, local and international political
decisions, and practices that are based more on “morality” and ideology
than science affect risks for infection and the course of the disease once
infected. The stigma that accompanies the HIV/AIDS pandemic shapes so-
cietal response to it to a greater degree than other STIs. For these reasons,
this chapter focuses on the HIV/AIDS pandemic. Table 16.1 compares HIV
to other STIs.
Table 16.1 Common sexually transmitted infections (STIs) and sexually transmitted diseases (STDs): mode of transmission, symptoms, and treatment
Diseases characterized by vaginal discharge
STD Transmissions Symptoms Treatment
Bacterial vaginosis Caused by a build up of Women will experience a fishy or musty smelling, pasty Metronidazole (Flagyl),
Gardnerella vaginalis discharge, which is usually gray, along with pain itching or Clindamycin cream,
bacterium, usually transmitted burning in or out of the vagina, and burning when urinating. Clindamycin oral pills, or
from sexual interaction Most men are asymptomatic. Tinidazole
Vulvovaginal The Candida albicans fungus Women could experience a white, “cheesy” discharge, vulvar Vaginal suppositories
Candidiasis may accelerate growth when edema, fissures, excoriations. Men are unaffected. or cream, such as
(yeast infection) the chemical balance of the clotrimazole, nystatin,
vagina is disturbed; it may also miconazole, terconazole,
be transmitted through sexual and butoconazole. Men
interaction. receive similar topical
treatments.
Trichomoniasis The protozoan parasite Most infected persons are asymptomatic (70%–85%) Metronidazole and
Trichomoniasis vaginalis Women may experience white or yellow vaginal discharge Tinidazole are used to
is transmitted through with an unpleasant odor, and an irritated vulva. Men treat both sexes.
genital sexual contact. Less may experience symptoms of urethritis, epididymitis, or
frequently, it has been found prostatitis.
to be transmitted by towels,
toilet seats, or bathtubs used
by an infected person.
Chlamydial The Chlamydia trachomatis Asymptomatic infection is common among men and women. Azithromycin,
Infection bacterium is transmitted In men, chlamydial infection of the urethra may cause a Erythromycin,
primarily through sexual discharge and burning during urination. Chlamydia-caused Lexvofloxacin, or Ofloxacin.
contact. It may also be spread epididymitis may produce a sense of heaviness in the affected
by fingers from one body site testicle(s), inflammation of the scrotal skin, and painful
to another. swelling at the bottom of the testicle. In women, chlamydial
infection may cause PID, ectopic pregnancy, disrupted
menstrual periods, abdominal pain, infertility, elevated
Sexual Health 391
Gonococcal The Neisseria gonorrhoeae Most common symptoms in men are a cloudy discharge Ceftriaxone or
Infection bacterium (“gonococcus”) from the penis and burning sensations during urination. Azithromycin are
(Gonorrhea or is spread through genital, If the infection is untreated, complications may include usually effective
“clap”) oral-genital, or genital-anal inflammation of scrotal skin and swelling at the base of in uncomplicated
contact. the testicles. In women, some green or yellowish discharge infections of the cervix,
392 Sexual Health
(Continued)
STD Transmissions Symptoms Treatment
Acquired Immuno- Blood and semen are the major Varies with the type of opportunistic infections (OIs) that At present, therapy focuses
Deficiency vehicles for transmitting affects someone with HIV. Common systems include: on specific treatments of
Syndrome the AIDS virus, HIV, which fevers, night sweats, weight loss, loss of appetite, fatigue, opportunistic infections
(AIDS) attacks the immune system. It swollen lymph nodes, diarrhea and/or bloody stools, and tumors. Since 1996,
appears to be passed primarily atypical bruising or bleeding, skin rashes, headache, combination therapy
394 Sexual Health
through sexual contact chronic cough, a whitish coating on the tongue or throat. has increased survival
or needle sharing among rates and decreased
injection drug abusers. Can progression to AIDS and
be passed perinatally from susceptibility to OIs in
mother to fetus or during those people who have
breastfeeding. access to the drugs and
can tolerate their side
effects.
Pelvic This often occurs when you This is an infection of a woman’s reproductive organs. Cefotetan, Doxycycline,
Inflammatory have an STD and do not get Symptoms include pain in the lower abdomen, fever, Cefoxitin, Gentamicin
Diseases (PID) treated; have more than one unusual discharge, pain or bleeding during intercourse,
sex partner; have had PID burning sensation during urination, or bleeding between
before; and are sexually active menstrual cycles.
and are twenty-five or younger.
Lymphogranuloma Caused by three strains (L1, L2, Most commonly found in men. In the first stage, small Doxycycline, Erythromycin
Venereum and L3) of the C. trachomatis lesions at the site of entry will occur. In the second stage,
(LGV) bacteria. inguinal lymph nodes become tender and the skin around
the pubic becomes inflamed. Discharge pus and blood may
also be found. In the third stage, lesions will heal with
scarring, but persistent inflammation may be observable.
Chancroid The Haemophilus ducreyi Symptoms are commonly found in both men and women. Azithromycin, Ceftriazone,
bacteria is transferred during Symptoms include anogenital ulcers and swollen lymph Ciprofloxacin,
sexual intercourse. nodes. Erythromycin
Epidemiology of HIV/AIDS
A basic knowledge of epidemiology, which is the study of the patterns of dis-
ease, helps us understand HIV/AIDS anthropologically. Knowing how many
people and who are infected with or at risk for HIV can help to develop in-
tervention programs from prevention and testing to treatment and care. In
addition to being a pandemic, HIV/AIDS is also endemic, meaning that it is
well-established in the populations where it is found. For example, about 27.2
percent of Swazilanders in South Africa have AIDS (“World Health Organi-
zation: AIDS Country Statistics, 2019). HIV/AIDS seems to have appeared
rather suddenly among men who have sex with men (MSM) in Los Angeles,
New York, and San Francisco during the summer of 1981 (Shilts, 1987). The
sudden appearance of a disease that spreads relatively quickly through a popu-
lation is referred to as an epidemic. The number of new cases of HIV/AIDS is
referred to as the incidence rate. In 2017, 38,739 people received an HIV diag-
nosis in the United States, and the rate of infected peoples has been declining
9 percent since 2010 (CDC Fact Sheet, 2019. HIV/AIDS is an epidemic, a
pandemic, and endemic in societies where it occurs.
HIV/AIDS also takes on acute, chronic, and terminal aspects of disease
and illness. Acute diseases have a sudden onset and a relatively rapid course
of infection. Colds and the flu are examples of acute diseases. The acute aspect
396 Sexual Health
of the disease occurs in the beginning months of being infected. About two
thirds of people with HIV experience flulike symptoms within the first two to
three weeks of being infected (HIV.Gov “Symptoms of HIV”). Chronic diseases
that are incurable can affect people’s functioning but may be treatable. Arthri-
tis and diabetes are examples of chronic diseases. HIV/AIDS is incurable, but
those people who have access to and can afford anti-retroviral therapy (ARVs/
HAART) live longer and function reasonably well. Terminal diseases are those
that kill you. Some cancers and some forms of heart disease are terminal. HIV/
AIDS is terminal for those who do not have access to HAART/ARVs. This in-
cludes most of the people outside industrialized countries who have the disease.
Disease refers to the clinical and physical manifestations of being sick: fevers,
night sweats, and weight loss are all the other physical aspects of HIV/AIDS.
Illness refers to the socioeconomic, psychological, and political aspects and con-
sequences of having a disease. For people with HIV/AIDS, these aspects can
include stigma and isolation from kin groups and friends, inability to work, with
resulting economic problems, as well as the effects that grief and the loss of pro-
ductive members of society have on the rest of the group. HIV/AIDS exemplifies
the core of epidemiological work (see Tables 16.1 and 16.2).
Source: “Regional HIV and AIDS statistics and features in 2017 by UNAIDS research fund.”
https://www.unaids.org/sites/default/files/media_asset/unaids-data-2018_en.pdf.
Demographics of HIV/AIDS
Age
Demographic variables of age, gender, socioeconomic status, ethnicity, and lo-
cation are also important in understanding the risks for and the manifestations
Sexual Health 397
of HIV/AIDS in a population. HIV/AIDS is classified as either pediatric when
it is found in people younger than twelve years old, or adult when it is found
in people older than fifteen. Currently, most pediatric HIV/AIDS cases are
a result of mother-to-child-transmission. A mother can transmit HIV to her
child during pregnancy, childbirth, or breastfeeding if her HIV-positive status
is unknown and/or she does not or cannot receive drugs to prevent transmis-
sion (see Tables 16.2 and 16.3).
US HIV/AIDS statistics
1 Opt-Out| Pregnant Women, Infants, and Children | Gender | HIV by Group | HIV/AIDS |
CDC https://www.cdc.gov/hiv/group/gender/pregnantwomen/opt-out.html (2019).
a Includes persons with a diagnosis of AIDS from the beginning of the epidemic through 2017.
Source: From CDC, http://www.cdc.gov.
Gender
Gender is a major risk factor for HIV/AIDS. HIV is primarily transmitted
through unprotected penile and anal intercourse. (See specifically the section
on Women and HIV/AIDs later in this chapter.) While initially HIV/AIDS
was seen as a disease of “middle-class gay identified men” in Euro-American
industrialized societies (and thus the early misnomer of GRID), and the elite
in both Brazil and some sub-Saharan African societies in the 1980s, it has
become a gendered epidemic in the twenty-first century. In 2017 adult and
adolescent women made up 19 percent of the new HIV diagnoses for that year
(CDC: HIV among women). Sub-Saharan Africa accounts for 70 percent of
the global burden for the HIV/AIDS infection, which women and adolescent
girls bearing a disproportionate infection rate (Kharsany and Karim, 2016).
Women in this region are eight times more likely than their male counterparts
to become infected with HIV (Kharsany and Karim, 2016).
Socioeconomic Status
HIV/AIDS rapidly moved in the 1980s from an epidemic of the middle class
in various parts of the world to a disease of the poor and disenfranchised by
the 1990s and early twenty-first century. In the United States, it is increasingly
a disease found among poor, urban, ethnic minorities. Cross-culturally, from
sub-Saharan Africa to India and Southeast Asia, most of the people infected
and affected by HIV/AIDS are poor. Most of the people in sub-Saharan Africa
earn less than US $2 per day, with women, on average, earning less than that.
The cheapest ARVs available cost US $1 per day, making them unaffordable to
most of the people who need them (Farmer, 2000; Farmer, Walton, and Furin,
2000). This aspect of HIV/AIDS has led activist anthropologist/physician Paul
Farmer and others to call AIDS a disease of poverty.
Male 77a
Female 23
Cultural Disparities
Since people’s behavior occurs and is expressed through their cultures’ norms,
values, and structures, the disparate socioeconomic and political situations
that exist within and between societies all influence the risk for HIV. These
disparities have been created and maintained through colonialism, global
markets and culture change. Socially, we have seen throughout this book
that sexual behavior is influenced by patterns of descent and residence and
the degree to which patricentricity (degree of centering around male father
figures) or importance of extended kin groups plays in people’s lives. Eu-
ro-American colonial practices changed sexual norms by generally lowering
women’s status in society and making them dependent on males, as well as
creating economic and political practices that benefitted colonial powers to
the detriment of indigenous groups (Flint and Hewitt, 2015; Jolivette, 2018;
Maju et al., 2019). In the grand mix of culture contact and change with vast
discrepancies in access to goods and services, sexual behavior has become the
major conduit for HIV worldwide. Specific examples from subcultures in the
United States and from certain Global South countries can highlight what
has happened.
The demographic profile of people living with HIV/AIDS (PLWH/A) in
the United States has changed drastically over the past four decades of the
epidemic. Currently, HIV/AIDS increasingly occurs among poor, ethnic and
female populations. African Americans, Latinx and Native Americans com-
prise a disproportionate percentage of HIV/AIDS cases in the United States.
Socially, preventative programs that work for men who have sex with men are
not appropriate for other groups, as they do not reflect these groups’ norms and
values. Economically and politically, African Americans, Latinx, and Native
Americans experience discrimination relative to employment, health services
400 Sexual Health
and self-determination. There also exist fewer preventative and treatment re-
sources for these communities than for the white middle-class (Centers for
Disease Control and Prevention, 2017b; Verissimo et al., 2018).
In 2017 (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 2017b):
• 41.1 percent of all reported HIV cases in the United States were among
African Americans.
• Sixteen percent of all reported HIV cases in the United States were
among the Latina.
• 9.9 percent of all reported HIV cases in the United States were among the
American Indian/Alaska Natives community.
• 5.1 percent of all reported HIV cases in the United States were among the
white and Asian community combined.
The most likely reason that ethnic minorities are at a higher risk of HIV is
due to a long history of systemic racism, which often leads to limited access
to quality health care, lower income and educational levels, and higher rates
of unemployment (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 2017b). These
realities leave little capacity for sexual health to be a priority or topic of knowl-
edge. If there is lack of knowledge about STIs among a community, it is not
rare for individuals to be unaware that they have them, and thus can lead
to further transmission. Another possible reason for higher rates of HIV and
STIs among these communities may be due to stigma, fear, discrimination,
and homophobia, both from their own community and others. The cultural
beliefs within a community may result in less safe sex practices. For example,
in many Latinx families there is a machismo value, which expects women to
be monogamous and for family and tradition to be greatly respected. This may
mean that a woman who insists on using condoms raises questions about her
behavior and the integrity of her male partner (Brooks et al., 2005; Centers
for Disease Control and Prevention, 2017a). Preventing the conception of chil-
dren may be seen as disrespectful. In certain communities, individuals who are
HIV positive are discriminated against and thus they are afraid to get tested
or discuss it, for fear of rejection. Getting tested may also mean an individual
has to disclose their sexual orientation when they are not ready or do not feel
comfortable (Reif, Wilson, and McAllaster, 2018).
Many of these communities are othered by the majority white population
and had long-standing culture and traditions infiltrated by early European
contact and long-standing white supremacy. Not only are Native American
populations among some of the poorest in the community, but they also re-
ceive some of the worst health care (Baugher et al., 2019; Urban Indian Health
Institute, 2019). Some Native American traditions include two spirits, or third-
or-fourth gender people; however, European powers stigmatized and penalized
these practices, therefore making them far less common or accepted among
the Native Americans themselves. This can lead to risky sexual behavior due
to denial and shame (Lee, Thompson-Robinson, and Dodge-Francis, 2018).
Sexual Health 401
Location
Location plays a role in HIV/AIDS. As stated, 70 percent of the AIDS cases
occurs in Sub-Saharan Africa, but this region only accounts for 12 percent of
the global population (Kharsany and Karim, 2016). The reasons for this are
largely socio-economic and political and are discussed in other sections.
Epicenters of HIV/AIDS in the United States refer to those cities that are
AIDS “dense” (i.e., have high incidence and prevalence rates of HIV/AIDS).
Washington DC is the city with the highest number of cases of HIV/ AIDS
on record. The majority of people who receive an HIV diagnosis live in urban
areas (CDC, 2019c). Cities tend to have higher incidence and prevalence rates
than rural areas in the United States for reasons of population density, greater
access to HIV testing and treatment that provide the basis for reporting and sta-
tistics, more population diversity, and a greater overall tolerance for a variety of
lifestyles and behaviors than occur in more rural areas. United States epicenters
tend to cluster on the coasts and in major industrial areas (see Table 16.4).
In both the United States and in nonindustrialized societies the incidence
and prevalence rates for HIV/AIDS are probably under-reported. There are
several reason for this. One, reporting is based on HIV test results and AIDS
diagnoses. As a highly stigmatized disease and illness, not everyone who is at
risk for infection or who is infected gets tested and diagnosed. It is estimated
that about 15 percent of the people with HIV in the United States do not
know they are infected (HIV.gov., 2019). Two, testing and diagnosis depend
on having an infrastructure and resources available within a group to carry
out the tests and diagnosis. That is expensive and unavailable to most people
at risk and with HIV/AIDS worldwide. Last, since HIV/AIDS is stigmatized,
there are political reasons for individuals, groups, and societies to neither know
their HIV status nor to keep records. Active discrimination against people
with HIV, moral condemnation from some fundamentalist religious groups,
and loss of employment and health insurance can contribute to inaccurate
epidemiological data.
Table 16.6 HIV tests: amount of time needed for accuracy, detection of HIV/AIDS
Nucleic Acid Test After 10–33 days Detects actual virus in the blood. Will give
(NAT) of exposure a positive or negative result based on the
amount of virus present in the blood.
Antigen/Antibody 18–45 days of Detects p24 HIV protein or HIV viral
Test exposure antigens.
Antibody Test 23–90 days of Detects antibodies to HIV in blood or oral
exposure fluid.
These concerns are not isolated to pregnant women in the United States. HIV
testing in nonindustrialized societies raises a number of ethical concerns for
women and for men. One concern is confidentiality. United States culture val-
ues privacy, the individual, and confidentiality (i.e., who knows and controls
the release of data).
Cross-culturally, confidentiality may rest with the kin group, or minimally
the women’s male relatives—their husbands and fathers or their brothers—
and not with the women themselves. Women are the focus of testing because
they are the ones who receive prenatal care, have most of the healthcare visits,
and receive most of the contraceptive services in many societies. Research has
found that women are willing to have an HIV test if they can be assured they
will receive the results in a private area, and decide when, how and to whom
results are given (Blankenship, 1999; Coodvadia, 2000; “Women’s Experience
with HIV Serodisclosure in Africa,” 2003). In some sub-Saharan African
groups married couples get tested, but it is usually the husband who makes the
Sexual Health 409
decision about getting tested for both himself and his wife. Decisions about
having an HIV test are serious given that women bear the brunt of HIV care
giving, are usually the ones blamed if they, their partners, or their children are
infected, and are the ones who are most often more severely stigmatized and
ostracized for being HIV positive.
When considering HIV testing outside industrialized countries, there are a
number of factors to consider:
• What does confidentiality mean in this society? Who controls and has
access to information? Who will receive HIV test results and who else
will know?
• Where and how are HIV tests administered? If travel is required to a
health clinic, is the clinic accessible and affordable? OraQuick or other
rapid HIV tests could be helpful in situations where people may only be
able to travel to a clinic once to have a test and need to get tested and
their results in the same visit.
• What are the psychological, social, financial, and political costs of hav-
ing an HIV test? If there are no treatments for those who test positive, if
people lose their employment, are ostracized from family and community,
beaten, killed, or have their children taken from them, is testing appropri-
ate in these situations with the resources available?
• What kinds of community involvement, participation, and education are
there about HIV/AIDS in general, safer sex, and testing? Are local leaders
involved (de la Gorgendière, 2005; Mariano, 2005)?
Safer Sex
It is known that some sexual behaviors result in a higher risk of HIV than oth-
ers. Risky sex entails any sexual behavior where people may come into contact
with infected blood, semen or vaginal fluids. To make this type of behavior
safer (i.e., to reduce the risk of transmitting HIV), safer sex can be practiced.
Safer sex includes the proper, consistent use of lubricated, non-spermicidal
internal or external condoms. A female condom (also known as an internal
condom) is a contraceptive device that is inserted into a vagina to help pre-
vent pregnancy, STIs and HIV. External condoms are placed on penises and
also help prevent pregnancy, STIs and HIV. The use of vaginal dams during
oral sex or rimming, as well as the use of finger cots or gloves during anal
and vaginal fingering/fisting also reduces risk for contraction of HIV. This in-
formation can be especially important among sero-discordant couples (one
person is HIV positive, the other HIV negative). Research on these couples
have found that HIV-negative consistent condom users were 71–77 percent
less likely than those who never or sometimes used condoms to acquire HIV
following repeated sexual encounters with an HIV-positive partner (Giannou,
Tsiara, and Nikolopoulos, 2015). In contrast to safer sex, safe sex means there
is no chance of transmitting or contracting HIV between partners. There are a
variety of safe sex behaviors that people can engage in. These include but, are
not limited abstinence, masturbation, fantasy, use of erotica or pornography,
and any sexual behavior that does not potentially expose people to others’
semen, vaginal fluid, or blood are safe sex techniques.
Thought-Provoking Questions
1 Why do researchers and activists believe that HIV/AIDS could be the
worst human health problem ever?
2 How do socio-economic, sexual, and political factors affect risk for infec-
tion, HIV testing decisions, and treatment?
Suggested Resources
Books
Shilts, Randy. 1987. And the Band Played On: Politics, People, and the AIDS Epidemic.
New York: St. Martin’s Press.
Vernon, Irene, S. 2001. Killing Us Quietly. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press.
Sexual Health 419
Videos/Movies
A Closer Walk
And the Band Played On
It’s My Party
Longtime Companion
Philadelphia
Yesterday (HBO)
Websites
CDC. http://www.cdc.gov/. Last accessed 12/30/2019.
HIV GOV. https://www.hiv.gov/ Last accessed 12/30/2019.
Planned Parenthoods. https://www.plannedparenthood.org/. Last accessed 12/30/2019.
UNAIDS. http://www.unaids.org/en/default.asp. Last accessed 12/30/2019.
WHO. http://www.who.int/en/. Last accessed 12/30/2019.
17 Global Aspects of Sex and
Sexuality
Chapter Overview
1 Places globalization in a cultural-historical context.
2 Discusses the globalization of sexuality relative to social, political, and
economic factors.
3 Discusses globalization and sex work/prostitution.
4 Examines the relationship between globalization, sexuality, and HIV.
Globalization
Since the late twentieth century, we have heard a lot about “globalization”
and the “global village.” What do these terms mean and how do they apply to
sexuality? This chapter addresses the globalization of sexuality.
Globalization is a new term for an old phenomenon. It is actually a contin-
uum of centuries of intergroup contact, trade, and change that has occurred
among indigenous groups worldwide as well as between European societies and
traditional peoples since the fifteenth century, including those in the Americas
(Dalby, 2000). For example, precolonial Southeast Asians such as the Macas-
sans from Sulawesi traded with aboriginal people of Northern Australia when
fishing for trepang that they then traded to China (Reid, 1999).
Currently, globalization includes bidirectional contact between indus-
trialized and nonindustrialized societies. Since the late twentieth century,
however, wealthy industrial nations such as the United States, Great Brit-
ain, and Japan have significantly impacted the kinds of social, political,
and economic changes that have occurred. These changes reflect capital-
ism’s influence on the economies of nonindustrialized societies. The ef-
fects industrialized countries have on other countries and groups cannot be
overemphasized.
These effects are global, can be irreversible, and are a definite shift from pre-
vious culture contact and change. Although changing the econiche is part of
human exploitation of resources, there are qualitative differences between how
and what nonindustrialized societies and industrialized societies have done
to and with the environment and one another. For example, the precontact
Mayans overworked the land which resulted in soil depletion. These effects,
however, were local and not global. Industrialized societies have irreversibly
Global Aspects of Sex and Sexuality 421
changed the econiche of rainforests around the world, and have transformed
local economies into sources of production that primarily benefit industrial-
ized societies, not their own (Robbins and Dowty, 2019).
The changes from industrialization are extensive. They range from pollu-
tion that has led to global warming to the destruction of the rainforests in
South America, to control over the production and distribution of drugs by
pharmaceutical conglomerates such as PhRMA (an international drug car-
tel). Changes also include the consequences economic decisions made by the
World Bank have had on small-scale farming. Anthropologists do not see
globalization as a process that creates a uniform middle-class Euro-American
value system worldwide, but instead see it as a phenomenon that engenders
qualitative change. Although these changes primarily benefit those living in
industrialized societies, they do not totally eliminate other societies’ core cul-
tural values. For example, a core value in Latino culture is la familia. La familia
places the nuclear family and extended kin group at the center of daily life.
This value can take on different manifestations depending on location and
degree of assimilation, but it persists.
From the beginnings of the Industrial Revolution in the 1700s to the pres-
ent, globalization has involved the colonization of the people in Southeast
Asia, India, sub-Saharan Africa, and the Pacific. The subsequent indepen-
dence of these groups from colonial rule during the twentieth century does
not isolate them from current international trade and communication or the
effects of capitalism on their local economies. The often-irreversible changes
resulting from colonialism and twentieth-century economic, political, and so-
cial policies extend to sexuality as well. Globalization and the global village
refer to the interconnectedness and expanse of industry, travel, and sexuality
that belie the existence of “purely” traditional behaviors and beliefs almost
anywhere in the world. These concepts are embedded in culture contact and
change, which form the heart of globalization.
Since the late twentieth century, however, the rapidity and nature of culture
contact and change have increased exponentially. This is largely due to the
growth of technology such as computers and the Internet, airline travel with
destinations around the world, the end of European colonial rule, and the
worldwide impact of US foreign policies. The general effects of globalization,
aside from their impact on sexuality, appear in a number of ways:
• A dramatic increase in the variety of food, clothing, art, and cars avail-
able all over the world.
• Outsourcing of work from the United States to nonindustrialized societies
and sweatshop industries in places such as Thailand and India that pro-
vide much of our clothing and other products. Sweatshops exist in both
industrialized and nonindustrialized societies and are characterized by low
wages, unsafe working conditions, long workdays without breaks, and lack
of benefits for the employees (check the labels of your clothes and other
goods to see where they were made!).
• International student exchange programs.
422 Global Aspects of Sex and Sexuality
• The development of generic drugs in Brazil, Thailand, and India, which
are available both in these countries and in sub-Saharan Africa.
• The prominence and influence of the World Trade Organization (WTO),
the World Bank, and PhRMA, which affect world markets.
• “Brain drain,” which occurs when industrialized countries hire profes-
sionals from nonindustrialized countries in fields such as medicine and
engineering. These people leave their homelands, thereby reducing the
number of available professionals in their fields there. The professionals
who leave their home countries may receive lower salaries and benefit
packages compared with the residents and citizens of the hiring compa-
nies (Gender-AIDS e-Forum, 2004/2005; “Global Challenges: Shortage of
Health Workers,” 2006).
• A worldwide increase in tourism, including sex tourism.
These examples reflect both positive and negative effects of globalization and
contribute to it.
Sex Work
Sex work is a broad category that encompasses prostitution, pornography,
phone sex operators, exotic dancers (strippers), massage parlor workers, and
424 Global Aspects of Sex and Sexuality
dominatrix workers. It includes those services offered over the Internet, those
that occur in brothels, on the street, and through “call work” (Delacoste and
Alexander, 1987; Whelehan, 2001a). Sex work involves males, females, and
transgendered persons, but is primarily engaged in by females. In industrialized
societies, sex work is usually an adult activity; in nonindustrialized societies,
there are more children involved (Farr, 2005; Kempadoo and Doezema, 1998).
The legality and types of sex work found vary widely within and between soci-
eties. For example, pornography by and for adults is legal in the United States.
Prostitution is illegal everywhere in the United States except for counties in
Nevada with fewer than 100,000 people. Prostitution is legal in Canada while
solicitation is not. The “red light” district of Amsterdam, Holland, is well-
known worldwide. Regardless of the legal status of sex work, those who work
in the industry are almost universally stigmatized for doing so, although their
(male) clients experience less stigma (Whelehan, 2001a).
Prostitution is the most common and well-known form of sex work. In the
United States, prostitution is the exchange of sex (left undefined) for money,
goods, or services (goods and services are unspecified) (Whelehan, 2001a).
Since prostitution is the most common form of sex work globally, and 80 per-
cent of sex workers are female, this discussion will focus on female prostitution.
“Prostitution” evokes strong legal, social (moral), and emotional responses from
people. The structure and expression of prostitution are deeply embedded in
larger cultural constructions of sexuality, particularly female sexuality. The cul-
tural construction of prostitution rests on several assumptions about sexuality:
When these assumptions are integrated with patrilineal and bilateral descent
(paternity certainty), in rigidly socio-economically hierarchical societies, they
lay a foundation for the existence of double standards of sexual behavior and
female prostitution.
Despite the public noise about sexuality (i.e., its high visibility in the me-
dia, in advertising, in the availability of human sexuality classes), we still
have a very deeply held view that sex is primarily for reproduction. At var-
ious times and in many cultures same-sex sexual behavior, masturbation,
oral sex, and anal sex have all been seen as immoral, deviant, perverse, un-
natural, sinful, or dirty. These behaviors all have two things in common.
Global Aspects of Sex and Sexuality 425
Sex workers’ rights groups also work to change attitudes about prostitution.
Even in Holland and Australia where prostitution is legal, workers are stig-
matized. Decriminalizing prostitution, advocating for decent and safe working
conditions, and educating the public about sex work are attempts to reduce the
stigma associated with it, address beliefs supporting sexual double standards,
and challenge the negativity which surrounds women’s sexuality in general.
Patricia Whelehan published an ethnographic study about sex workers who
live and work in urban areas of the United States. The biological men, women,
and transgender individuals in this book made several points about themselves
and their work. First, most of them wanted sex work decriminalized to make it
safer, to promote education about the industry, and to create a legal venue where
abuses can be addressed. Second, most of them found the stigmatization to be
one of the most difficult things for them to deal with as sex workers. The stigma
associated with sex work is what Goffman (1963) refers to as a “master status.” Sex
work defines who and what you are and it also carries over to other areas of your
life. For example, if you are a sex worker, then you must be dishonest, a bad neigh-
bor, wife, and mother. Every aspect of your life is suspect and questioned. Third,
sex workers want to be seen as people for whom their work is one part of their
life, but which does not define them. This is similar to statements made by people
in the lesbian-gay-bisexual-transgender-queer-intersex (LGBTQI) communities.
Fourth, sex workers want their profession seen as a means of legitimate work. The
majority do not see themselves as victims or deviants. Universally perpetuating
the view that they are only adds to the problems they face and reinforces the
sexual double standard (Kempadoo and Doezema, 1998; Whelehan, 2001a).
Finally, sex workers in industrialized societies recognize that they have a
privileged position relative to many prostitutes in nonindustrialized societies.
As such, a number of them work to improve the conditions existing elsewhere,
including changing larger socio-economic situations and advocating for an end
to the exploitation of sex workers globally (Kempadoo and Doezema, 1998).
Australia Bangladesh
Canada Brazil
China Cambodia
France Costa Rica
Germany Dominican Republic
Great Britain Hungary
Japan India
Kuwait Indonesia
Norway Kenya
Saudi Arabia Morocco
Singapore The Philippines
Sweden Thailand
United States Vietnam
Source: Adapted from Joni Seager, The Penguin Atlas of Women in the World. London: Penguin
Books, 2003; Martha Ward and Monica Edelstein, A World Full of Women. Pearson Education,
2014.
Global Aspects of Sex and Sexuality 431
In Eastern Europe, the dissolution of the USSR and the fall of the Berlin
Wall dramatically affected prostitution in this area. Rapid economic and po-
litical changes accompanied these events; most notable has been the change
of the infrastructure from a communist state where much of the requirements
of daily living such as housing, transportation, food, and medical care are pro-
vided for, to a capitalist market. There has been much political and economic
unrest as a consequence, including the development of an extensive sex trade.
The sex trade in Eastern Europe involves both coercive and non-coercive traf-
ficking within and across European borders as people grapple for economic
survival (Human Rights Watch, 2004; “Sex Workers,” 2005).
Sex work can comprise a specialized form of tourism, sex tourism, where
people travel to specific areas of the world to engage in paid sex. Although
sex tourism exists in various parts of the world, one of the most well-known sex
tourism areas is in Southeast Asia, specifically Thailand.2 Thai attitudes toward
gender, sexual orientation, and age of consent are radically different from in
many Euro-American societies. Coupled with a struggling economy and a strate-
gic geographic location for R&R (rest and relaxation) for United States and East
Asian military personnel stationed in places such as the Philippines, the area is
ripe for a thriving sex industry. Thailand’s sex trade provides incomes for indi-
viduals and their families as well as for the overall economy (Seabrook, 2001).
Sex junkets to Thailand by Euro-American and Japanese businessmen are
popular. Rules about same-sex sex, sex with minors, and “kinky” sex (i.e.,
non-missionary position p-v intercourse or oral sex) are looser than in people’s
home countries or are non-existent. If these sex contacts were truly consen-
sual, were under the control of the sex worker, did not involve minors, and
were protected from HIV and other STIs, there might be less concern about
people’s behavior. However, since market conditions and disposable income
tend to set the working conditions—place, worker age and gender, and be-
havior—there are considerable concerns raised about sexual and economic
exploitation. Since the 1980s, sex workers’ rights groups have consistently ad-
vocated for safe working conditions including enforced safer sex practices and
sex worker input concerning venues and salaries (Farr, 2005; ICPR, 1985; “IXth
International Conference on AIDS in Affiliation with the IVth STD World
Congress,” 1993; “XVth International AIDS Conference (IAC),” 2004b).
A critical review of trafficking argues that prostitution is not the only form of
trafficking in which exploitation occurs. In addition, such a view implies that
all sex work is coercive and overlooks other forms of sex work in industrial-
ized nations where prostitution may be a choice selected from other forms of
work, particularly when viewed from an emic perspective (Whelehan, 2001a).
The current construction of trafficking and the conflation of trafficking with
prostitution perpetuates a double standard, and overlooks the larger socio-eco-
nomic and political conditions that create and sustain sex work as it currently
exists.
Globalization, sex work, and HIV are linked both epidemiologically and
perceptually in a number of ways. Discussion exploded several myths about
HIV, women, and sex work. First, women are more often infected by male
partners than the reverse. Second, sex workers will practice safer sex if they are
given the option or the choice. This comes down to whether women are given
the ability to choose by male kin groups or employers. Data from the United
States indicate that only 0.04 percent of HIV in the United States is trans-
mitted by female prostitutes to male clients. It is important to remember that
clarification of emic and etic categories of sex work is important for statistics
related to prostitution, disease, and HIV transmission.
The evidence of HIV and sex work in nonindustrialized nations suggests
that support for safer sex practices results in the reduction of HIV risk and
infection rates as occurred in Thailand during the 1980s and 1990s. This kind
of support, however, is rare globally and undermined, for example, by the PEP-
FAR plan and its lack of support for condom availability. The gag rule on
438 Global Aspects of Sex and Sexuality
international aid agencies that work with sex workers further undermines safer
sex practices.
In order to reduce the risk of HIV for sex workers, a variety of recommenda-
tions are suggested. These include:
Summary
1 Globalization is an expansion of centuries of intercultural contact and
change.
2 Globalization of the twentieth and twenty-first centuries is primarily di-
rected by the political and economic policies of the wealthiest nations.
3 Globalization impacts sexuality in a variety of ways from changes in dress
and marriage practices to sex tourism.
4 The current HIV epidemic reflects global sexual, economic, polit
ical, and social policies.
Thought-Provoking Questions
1 What changes have occurred in sexuality as a result of globalization over
the past century?
2 How do the economic, political, and social policies of industrialized na-
tions impact sex work in their own and nonindustrialized societies?
Suggested Resources
Books
Farr, Kathryn. 2004. Sex Trafficking: The Global Market in Women and Children. New
York: Worth Publishers.
Kempadoo, Kamala and Jo Doezema, eds. 1998. Global Sex Workers: Rights, Resistance,
and Redefinition. New York: Routledge Publishers.
Robbins, Richard. 2005. Global Problems and the Culture of Capitalism. 3rd ed. Boston,
MA: Allyn and Bacon.
Global Aspects of Sex and Sexuality 439
Seabrook, Jeremy. 2001. Travels in the Skin Trade: Tourism and the Sex Industry. 2nd ed.
Sterling, VA: Pluto Press.
Whelehan, Patricia. 2001. An Anthropological Perspective on Prostitution: Mellen Studies
in Anthropology. Vol. 4. Lewiston, ID: Edwin Mellen Press.
Websites
ICPR. International Committee on Prostitutes Rights. https://www.walnet.org/csis/
groups/icpr_charter.html
Child Trafficking. theirworld.org/explainers/child-trafficking.
18 Summary and Conclusion
Chapter Overview
1 Restates the biological, psychological, and cultural perspective, its em-
beddedness in anthropological understandings and how this applies to an
exploration of human sexual behavior.
2 Reiterates the distinction between universal human sexuality and that
which is culture specific.
3 Puts sexual behavior in a socio-cultural context and emphasizes the ef-
fects of culture change on traditional sexual behavior and values.
4 Makes a concluding statement about the potential for changes in homi-
nid sexuality based on late twentieth and twenty-first-century sexual and
reproductive technology.
5 Places AIDS in a global context relative to its threat and the potential for
responding to it in a human way.
6 Places sex work currently in the context of globalization.
Chapter 1
1 We would like to thank Dr. Jane Granskog, Department of Anthropology,
California State University at Bakersfield, for conceptualizing this model. Al-
though it has been modified to meet the needs of our text and been given a new
metaphor, Dr. Granskog was instrumental in providing the foundation for this
approach.
Chapter 2
1 Sue-Ellen Jacobs states in “Native American Two Spirits”: The term “berdache”
[sic] as used by anthropologists is outdated, anachronistic, and does not reflect
contemporary Native American conversations about gender diversity and sexual-
ities. To use this term is to participate in and perpetuate colonial discourse, label-
ing Native American people by a term that has its origins in Western thought and
languages. The preferred term of Native Americans who are involved in refining
understanding about gender diversity and sexualities among Native American
peoples is “two spirit”... or terms specific to tribes (1994: 7). We have adopted
this usage where it seems appropriate to refer to gender-transformed/alternative
genders throughout the Native American ethnographic record and to use the
appropriate indigenous term or the more generic usages such as gender variance
elsewhere.
Chapter 3
1 Some scholars prefer to use the term “hominin” to refer to humans and their ances-
tors (Homo and Australopithecus species) as a reflection of the close evolutionary
similarity of humans, chimpanzees, and gorillas. In this text, however, we will use
the more common and historically older term “hominid” to refer to the group that
includes humans and their ancestors.
2 There are several classical and contemporary theories as to the conditions that
may have led to the development of the visual center of the brain as well as the
grasping hand. Collins (1921) has proposed that binocular vision would be favored
in species that have to leap from branch to branch as in the conditions encoun-
tered by the earliest tree dwellers. Cartmill’s (1974) visual predation theory suggests
that diet may have selected for the grasping hand in tandem with binocular vision
in situations where prey, such as insects, were found on slender vines. Sussman
(1978) is of the opinion that grasping hands would be adaptive for an arboreal
niche where early primates traveled on small branches. In this theory, reliance on
446 Notes
vision occurred because these early primates were probably nocturnal and they had
to be able to locate plant foods in the dark (Ember and Ember, 2005: 77–78).
3 Evidence for large game hunting appears relatively late in human history and may
represent one of several possible strategies for hunting and survival. In fact, mi-
croscopic analysis of the earliest tools dated between two and two-and-a-half mil-
lion years ago reveals that these were not used in actual hunting. Wear patterns
indicate use in modifying plant materials, scraping, and cutting up animal skins
(Zihlman, 1989).
Chapter 5
1 Baldness tendencies are a genetic trait in men carried by females.
2 This does not include taking steroids by some male and female athletes in order to
increase muscle size.
3 Muscle mass and standards of leanness are culturally defined. Men need a mini-
mum of 4 to 6 percent body fat to reach puberty.
4 Sex hormones can stimulate certain cancers.
5 This is not recommended as a means of contraception.
Chapter 6
1 Aspirin dissipates prostglandins. It also is an anti-clotting agent. If a woman has
blood clotting disorders or is to undergo surgery, she should limit her aspirin intake
and inform medical personnel as to how much and when she last took aspirin.
2 The craving for chocolate may be related to phenylethylamine. One of its chemical
compounds is related to phenylalanine, an amino acid. These compounds may
serve as mood elevators in humans.
3 Currently, regulated sperm banks test donations for HIV, since the virus is carried
in semen.
Chapter 7
1 It takes about twenty-four to thirty hours to replenish the supply of sperm after
ejaculation (Stewart et al., 1979).
2 Medical terminology for various sexual and reproductive conditions frequently has
pejorative connotations. These connotations, while not consciously intended to
hurt clients, may inflict psychological and emotional discomfort or harm a client.
A distraught, infertile couple does not need to hear about “hostile” cervical mu-
cous or “incompetent” cervices in their attempt to remedy their situation.
3 As of 2005, the FDA (Food and Drug Administration) requires that AI-D dona-
tions are screened for HIV, since the virus is carried in the semen of an infected
person.
4 The role of H-Y antigen in male sexual differentiation is controversial.
5 Later differentiation may occur in the female so that Wolffian duct development of
the urinary tract can take place.
6 They have been referred to as “degenerate testicles.” See note 2.
Chapter 9
1 This is incorrect/outdated. In fact, approximately 60 percent of practicing obste-
trician-gynecologists in the US and Canada are female and about 80 percent of
residents in OB/Gyn are female.
Notes 447
https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2019/04/190401115815.htm
ht t p s://w w w.npr.or g /s e ct ion s/ he a lt h-shot s/2018/0 4/12/596396698/
male-ob-gyns-are-rare-but-is-that-a-problem
2 Even the term “coach” implies some form of external management akin to an ath-
letic event.
Chapter 10
1 The interested reader is encouraged to explore the works of Cohen (1978), Fox
(1980), Levi-Strauss (1969), Livingstone (1969), Murdock (1949), Phelan (1986),
and White (1948), among others too numerous to mention. Recent reviews of the
incest taboo include Meigs and Barlow (2002: 38–49), and Patterson (2005: 1–18).
Chapter 12
1 The meanings that sex is given in a society are embedded and expressed in com-
plex ways through the social structure and the ideological system. For example,
how people experience their sexuality is linked to the ideological system such as
beliefs about reproduction, menstruation, and pollution. All are part of shaping
sexuality at the personal and cultural level. Indeed human sexuality “is embedded
in a complex web of shared ideas, moral rules, jural regulations, obvious associa-
tions and obscure symbols” (Davenport, 1977: 117). Our sexuality is ultimately part
of “worldwide economic, social, political and cultural systems” (Ross and Rapp,
1983: 57) which have diverse histories, trajectories and encounters (Herdt, 1999,
2004). The ethnographic spectrum offers an array of sexual practices and beliefs
that are testimony to the flexibility of humans in their ability to adapt to different
cultural milieus and environments.
2 Anthropologists have also devoted considerable time and increasing attention to
studying sex in industrialized societies.
3 This may be contrasted with Judaic traditions that have a generally positive view
of sex regarding it as a gift from God if practiced in the appropriate moral context
(Stein, 2005).
4 Faludi’s (1991) research challenges an earlier statistic that women’s disposable in-
come after divorce drops almost 73 percent (AAUW, 1989: 5).
Chapter 14
1 Additional information on homosexual support groups and referral sources for
gays, lesbians, their friends, and loved ones can be obtained from the Lambda
Legal Defense Group, Lambda Rising and PFLAG. These groups have chapters
around the country.
Chapter 15
1 Transgender has several meanings within (emic) and outside (etic) the gender
variant communities. Your authors recognize the different connotations associated
with the transgender identity and transpeople.
Chapter 16
1 GRID (Gay-Related Immune-deficiency Disease) was a misnomer that reflected the
homophobia and sex phobia of the media, researchers, and the Centers for Disease
448 Notes
Control and Prevention in 1981. That misnomer created the perception and belief
that HIV/AIDS was a “gay” disease, something that has persisted among a number of
groups to the present and which also contributed to the stigma associated with it.
2 The Centers for Disease Control (CDC) have been renamed the Centers for Dis-
ease Control and Prevention. As of July 1993, the commonly used acronym for this
organization remained the “CDC” and will be used here. Statistics are updated
biannually by the CDC.
3 Mandatory testing is required to enter and stay in the military, to be in the Job
Corps, and can be court-ordered in the United States. Mandatory testing was pro-
posed by some members of Congress in the 1980s with quarantine recommended
for those testing positive. That did not occur.
Chapter 17
1 As controversial as discussions of trafficking are, it is important to remember that
what constitutes childhood and adolescence are culturally defined.
2 One of the major concerns with sex tourism is the coerced and exploitative nature
of it particularly for women and children. Here are URLs for two groups that specif-
ically address sex tourism, trafficking, and children: http://www.childrentrafficking.
com and http://www.ecpat.net/eng/index.asp.
Glossary