Effect of Extrem Conditions On Polyurea Coatings
Effect of Extrem Conditions On Polyurea Coatings
Effect of Extrem Conditions On Polyurea Coatings
com
Technical
Effect of extreme conditions on polyurea coatings
By Jay A. Johnston and Primeaux first reported the effects of
Samantha Smith 2,4’-isomer MDI on spray polyurea coat-
Huntsman Polyurethanes Executive summary ings. Increasing the level of the 2,4’-iso-
The use of spray polyurea coatings in Spray polyurea elastomer systems are rapid curing coatings that can be ap- mer MDI extended the gel times of aro-
large commercial projects has continued plied over broad temperature and humidity ranges where other coating types matic polyurea systems and provided
to increase in volume and scale over the immediately fail. Due to the productivity gains of a rapid curing coating, improvements in the performance of the
past five years. The coatings’ fast cure polyurea coatings now are being used in more aggressive environments. These cured polyurea elastomers.1 Broekaert
rate, excellent physical properties and environments include higher temperatures and contact with reactive and non- and Pille-Wolf reported similar observa-
ability to be applied under adverse con- reactive liquids. Coating failures are possible if an inappropriate polyurea coat- tions upon investigation of the influence
ditions have led to the increased use of ing is selected for an application. Unfortunately, very little reference informa- of isocyanate isomer composition. An-
spray polyurea coatings in industrial ap- tion is available on the ability of polyurea coatings to resist temperature and other aspect of their paper reported the
plications. Large commercial and gov- solvents. This paper reports on the fuel resistance, chemical resistance, water influence of isocyanate functionality on
ernmental projects such as the San Ma- resistance and temperature resistance of polyurea coatings prepared with dif- gel time and performance of polyurea
teo Bridge, the Boston Tunnel, the ferent levels of urea groups in the backbone of the polymer. Prepolymers with spray systems.2 Their work examined
NCO contents from 9 to 20 percent were evaluated. The effects of hard block the performance of polyurea elastomers
TECHNICAL NOTEBOOK content on the standard physical properties and the resistance properties were after typical laboratory cure schedules.
Edited by Harold Herzlichh determined. Long-term cure schedules of systems
utilizing both high and low 2,4’-isomer
Dallas-Fort Worth Airport and the Pen- MDI products previously were examined
tagon have specified polyurea spray which gelled quickly, typically within 2 proved physical properties vs. the previ- by Perez and Johnston.3
elastomers as the preferred coating. The to 3 seconds. The fast gelation caused ous generation of polyurea technology. The use of hindered amines to slow the
unique performance and processing coating defects, lowered the coatings’ ad- The new commercial products contain reactivity of polyurea coatings also has
characteristics of spray polyurea coat- hesion to the substrate and caused pro- several levels of 2,4’-isomer MDI. The been reported. Secondary amines, such
ings have made it a technology that can cessing difficulties. Progress has been 2,4’-isomer MDI introduces sterically as Unilink 4200 amine and Clearlink
compete and win in applications once made on both the isocyanate chemistry hindered reaction sites into the prepoly- 1000 amine, have been shown to slow
exclusively held by more mature coating and the amine chemistry to slow the re- mer. The sterically hindered 2,4’-isomer the reactivity of polyurea coatings and
systems. activity of polyurea coatings. Huntsman MDI reduces the reactivity of the iso- caulks. Several groups have demonstrat-
Several recent accomplishments in Polyurethanes has introduced a series of cyanate with the amine. Varying the ed the use of secondary amines to slow
polyurea technology have increased the isocyanate terminated prepolymers that 2,4’-isomer MDI content of a prepolymer the reactivity of polyurea systems.4, 5, 6
versatility and simplified the application decrease the reactivity of polyurea sys- allows the systems reactivity to be opti- Spray polyurea coatings increasingly
of polyurea coatings. The first spray tems. The prepolymers also were devel- mized for each application. See Polyurea, page 14
polyurea systems produced coatings oped to provide elastomers with im-
Table II. Huntsman Polyurethanes isocyanate terminated prepolymers.
Table I. List of chemicals and suppliers.
Fig. 14. Acid and base resistance of polyurea coatings made with Rubinate 9480
MDI.
Products
Two Cognex systems nizes wheel-spoke patterns, wheel finish
and other features to ensure the pres-
or e-mail [email protected]. A new thermoplastic elastomer grade
from Star Thermoplastic Alloys and
identify tires, wheels ence of correct wheels, the firm said.
Uses include identifying wheels prior to
The Multiflow valve from Guill Tool
and Engineering Co. allows extruders
Rubbers Inc. allows overmolders to make
urethane products with less material, a
Machine vision system supplier balancing to trigger proper balance rou- to make three-layer or up to five-layer benefit to applications that require holes
Cognex Corp. unveiled two high-perfor- tine and guaranteeing the correct tubing products with fewer machines. In for bristles. Marketed under the name
mance systems for automatically identi- wheels are paired with the correct tires the three-layer Overflex, the TPE is available in Shore A
fying tires and wheels: the TIS-8000 for a specific vehicle. design, material hardness 40 to 65 and offers full colorabili-
Tire Identification System and the WIS- For more information, call 508-650- is fed into the ex- ty and ease of processing, the firm said.
8000 Wheel Identification System. 3000. truder and divid- Some popular applications of the TPE in-
Both use the company’s PatMax geo- ed inside the clude toothbrushes, levels, disposable ra-
metric pattern matching technology and
each are equipped with a PC-based ma-
In brief manifold to form
both the inner
zors, brushes and animal brushes. For
more information, call 312-225-7800; fax
chine vision frame grabber, a Sony XC- Elastoskin, a polyurethane elastomer and outer layers 312-225-7810; visit www.starthermoplas-
55 camera kit and identification and skin for automotive interiors from BASF of the product, re- tics.com; or e-mail [email protected].
verification application software, the Corp., offers good durability and tough- ducing costs, the
firm said. ness with a soft, luxurious feel and firm said. The CDS Analytical Inc.’s AS2500plus
The TIS-8000 provides high-accuracy, leather-like grain definition, the company valve can change Guill Tool and Engi- Pyrolysis Autosampler can perform ther-
in-process verification and identification said. The firm claims the elastomer, de- layer-wall thick- neering Co. Inc.’s mal desorption and pyrolysis on the same
of tires using machine vision software veloped by the BASF Polyurethanes Re- ness without Multiflow valve solid, powder or viscous liquid sample.
for recognizing tire treads and side- gional Business unit in Wyandotte, Mich., shutting down the extruder and elimi- The unit can be programmed through a
walls, Cognex said. Applications include outperforms polyvinyl chloride and other nates dead areas in the manifold that handheld controller or Windows-based
tracking and sorting tires during manu- traditional skin materials and is used on may lead to degradation of the material software for unattended operation, saving
facturing, verifying correct models prior instrument panels and inside door panels and contamination of the tubing, the the user money in operational expenses,
to mounting and guaranteeing the cor- of top-of-the-line cars like the Buick Park company said. For more information, the firm said. For more information, call
rect sequence of tires prior to shipping. Avenue and Cadillac CTS. For more infor- call 401-828-7600; fax 401-823-5310; or 610-932-3636; fax 610-932-4158; or visit
The WIS-8000 automatically recog- mation, call Andy Ladak at 248-948-2088 e-mail [email protected]. www.cdsanalytical.com.
Polyurea prepolymers gave coatings with the fast application time, fast return to ser- 2,4’-MDI,” presented at Polyurethanes Conference
greatest amount of “orange peel.” vice time, insensitivity to moisture and 2000, Oct. 8-11, 2000.
4. Perez, A., Hillman, K.M., House, D.W., Scott Jr.,
Standard physical properties barrier properties are the major reasons R.V., Ilijevski, D., “Secondary Aliphatic Diamine
The standard physical properties of for the application of polyurea coatings Chain Extenders in Aliphatic Polyurea Spray Appli-
Continued from page 18 the coatings were determined and en- on concrete. This research clearly cations,” UTECH 2000 conference paper, The
The effects of hard block content on tered into Table VIII. demonstrates that some solvents and Hague, Netherlands.
5. House, D.W., Scott Jr., R.V., Wetherall, J., “The
solvent resistance were examined in a Chemical resistance some chemicals negatively affect the Versatility of UOP Unilink and Clearlink Diamines
series of polyurea coatings. The hard The chemical resistances of the five physical properties of polyurea coatings. in Polyurethane and Polyurea Systems,” UOP
block contents of the coatings were ad- coatings were determined in three Care must be taken in selecting a suit- L.L.C. technical publication.
justed by spraying prepolymers with chemicals. These chemicals were select- able polyurea coating for a particular 6. Primeaux II, D.J., “Spray Polyurea Elastomers
Offer Performance Advantages,” Modern Paint and
NCO contents from 9 to 20 percent. ed because of their aggressive tendency application. These results were not un- Coatings, June 1991.
B-side formulations to attack polyurea coatings. The chemi- expected. Polyurea coatings are used 7. Texaco bulletin on Polyurea Solvent Resistance.
Each prepolymer in Phase III re- cals were acetone, sulfuric acid and ni- most often in secondary containment ap- 8. Darden, W., Loomis, R., Roehm, F.T., “Spray
quired a different B-side formulation. tric acid. The results are entered into plications, not primary containment ap- Polyurea Coatings for Primary and Secondary Con-
tainment,” presented at the Geosynthetics ’97 Con-
The B-side formulations were adjusted Figs. 15, 16 and 17. plications. Secondary containment ap- ference, March 11, 1997.
to compensate for each prepolymer’s The polyurea coatings were attacked plications require that a coating resist a 9. Smith, S., Johnston, J.A. “Chemical and Tempera-
NCO content. The B-side formulations rapidly by acetone. The softer coatings chemical for a predetermined period of ture Resistance of Standard Aromatic Polyurea Elas-
are described in Table VII. Due to the had low tensile strength before and after time. tomer Coatings,” presented at Fourth Pan-American
Coatings Expo, Mexico City, July 17-19, 2002.
fast gel time of the highest NCO content exposure to acetone. The coatings pre- Only a small percentage of all the 10. Primeaux II, D.J., “Study of Polyurea Spray
prepolymer, Unilink 4200 amine was pared from Rubinate 9480 MDI had the commercial polyurea coatings are used Elastomer Systems,” High Solids Coatings, Volume
added to the formulation. in above ambient temperature applica- 15, 1994.
Prepolymers
Prepolymers with a wide range of
NCO contents were sprayed in this
Technical tions. Specification of polyurea coatings
in higher temperature applications is
difficult without background informa-
11. Primeaux II, D.J., Anglin, K.C., “The Processing
of Spray Polyurea Elastomer Systems,” Polyure-
thanes 92, proceedings of the SPI 34th Annual
Technical/Marketing Conference, 1992.
phase of the paper. The lowest NCO con- best initial resistance to acetone. In- tion on the heat resistance of polyurea
tent prepolymer had a high viscosity. creasing the hard block content of the coatings. This research demonstrates Rubinate and Suprasec are registered
High viscosity resins are difficult to coating further did not improve the ace- that polyurea coatings maintain their trademarks of Huntsman International
spray. Rubinate 9524 MDI, was diluted tone resistance of the coating. physical properties at 150°C for several L.L.C. in one or more, but not all coun-
with Jeffsol PC to reduce the viscosity of The acid resistance of the coating was weeks. The coatings maintained their tries.
the prepolymer. tested in 25-percent sulfuric acid and physical properties at higher tempera- Jeffamine, Jeffsol and Tioxide are reg-
Processing performance 25-percent nitric acid. The softer coat- tures for only a short period of time. istered trademarks of Huntsman Corp.
The five prepolymers were sprayed ings had poor acid resistance in both With this information now available, or an affiliate thereof in one or more, but
with the five B-side formulations in sulfuric and nitric acid. The 16-percent polyurea coatings now can be specified not all countries.
Table VII. The gel and tack free times NCO prepolymers gave coatings with into higher temperature applications. Clearlink is a registered trademark of
decreased as the NCO content of the the best sulfuric acid resistance. The UOP L.L.C.
prepolymer increased. The data are pre- coatings made from Rubinate 9009 MDI References Ethacure is a registered trademark of
sented in Table VIII. The highest NCO and Suprasec 9549 MDI displayed the 1. Primeaux II, D.J, “Polyurea Spray Technology in
Albemarle Corp.
content prepolymers produced rapid best nitric acid resistances. Commercial Applications,” presented at 60 Years of Silquest is a registered trademark of
curing coatings. Low NCO content pre- Polyurethanes: International Symposium and Exhi- Crompton OSI Specialties.
bition, 1998. Unilink is a registered trademark of
polymers produced slow curing coatings. Conclusions 2. Broekaert, M., Pille-Wolf, W., “The Influence of
UOP.
The morphologies of the coatings also Isomer Composition and Functionality on the Final
were dependent on the NCO contents of Commercial projects utilizing poly- Properties of Aromatic Polyurea Spray Coatings,”
the prepolymers. The low NCO prepoly- urea coatings’ unique application speed UTECH 2000 conference paper, The Hague, Nether- Presented at a meeting of the Alliance
lands.
mers gave very smooth surfaces. No “or- and physical properties continue to in- 3. Perez Jr., A., Reddinger, J., Johnston, J.A., “Per-
for the Polyurethanes Industry, held Oct.
ange peel” was detected on the surface crease in terms of scale and complexity. formance and Processing Enhancements of Aromat- 13-16 in Salt Lake City, where it was
of the coatings. As the NCO content in- Protective coatings on concrete continue ic Polyurea Elastomer Systems Prepared form High honored with a best paper award.
creased, the surface morphologies be- to be the major application area for
came worse. The highest NCO content polyurea coatings. Polyurea coatings’
The authors
Fig. 17. Nitric acid resistance of polyurea coatings. Jay A. Johnston graduated with a doctorate in polymer chemistry from the Univer-
sity of Akron in 1991. He is a technical associate in the Adhesives, Coatings and Elas-
tomers Group at Huntsman Polyurethanes in Auburn Hills, Mich.
Johnston joined ICI Polyurethanes (now Huntsman Polyurethanes) in 1994. Previ-
ously, he completed postdoctoral fellowships at General Electric Co.’s corporate re-
search and development center and at the University of Akron’s Institute of Polymer
Science. Johnston currently is responsible for development of isocyanates and pre-
polymers for the ACE markets in North and South America.
Samantha A. Smith received her bachelor’s degree in chemical engineering from
Wayne State University in Detroit in 1999. She began working for Huntsman
Polyurethanes in November 1999 in the Automotive Group. In June 2000, Smith
transferred to the ACE group where she works on the development of isocyanates and
prepolymers.