Problemas Del Desarrollo en Pacientes Con Ae
Problemas Del Desarrollo en Pacientes Con Ae
Problemas Del Desarrollo en Pacientes Con Ae
1136/archdischild-2015-309976
Original article
laid down in the Dutch Medical Research Involving Human test for differences in neurodevelopmental outcome across SES
Subjects Act do not apply for the present study. All parents were categories. To compare data with reference values, paired
informed that data were used for research purposes. samples t-tests were used for continuous data and χ2 tests for
categorical data. To test for differences between 5 and 8 years,
Procedures linear mixed models were used for continuous data and
The present study is part of a structured follow-up programme McNemar’s tests for categorical data. Only the data of children
for children born with OA with nine standardised assessments tested at both ages were used in the McNemar’s tests.
from the age of 6 months until the age of 17 years.3 5 7–9 The To combine the outcome scores of the M-ABC-I and
following data were collected: gender, gestational age, birth M-ABC-II, percentile scores were transformed into z-scores
weight, ethnicity, type of OA, the presence and type of asso- using probit transformations (ie, an inverse normal transform-
ciated congenital anomalies, genetic syndromes, sepsis, duration ation). Motor performance changes over time were investigated
of ventilatory support, duration of initial hospitalisation, dur- in longitudinal analyses using linear mixed models with z-score
ation of parenteral nutrition, antireflux surgery, number of pro- M-ABC as dependent variable (with mean=0 and SD=1, refer-
cedures under general anaesthesia within the first 24 months of ence population). In each model, the independent variables
life, total duration of anaesthetic exposure within the first were age and one of the following predictors: birth weight, the
24 months of life, and hospital admissions with duration of hos- presence of associated congenital anomalies, ventilatory
pitalisation within the first 5 years. Longitudinal follow-up data support, sepsis, duration of parenteral nutrition, duration of
are prospectively collected at 5 and 8 years of age. Motor devel- general anaesthetic events and duration of hospitalisation.
opment was evaluated by an experienced paediatric physiother- A random intercept was included to account for the within-
apist. Information about education, sports participation (yes/no) subject correlations. Linear mixed models allow subjects for
and physical therapeutic support (yes/no) was recorded. who some data are missing to be included in the analyses, pro-
Psychological assessment at 8 years was performed by an experi- vided that the data are missing at random, as explained previ-
enced paediatric psychologist. We classified socio-economic ously.7 Correlation of motor performance between ages 5 and
status (SES) as low, middle or high based on the highest degree 8 years was calculated using the intraclass correlation coefficient.
of maternal education.10 With the exception of the attention fluctuations score, intelli-
gence and sustained attention scores were converted into
PRIMARY OUTCOME z-scores using normative data. The raw score for attention fluc-
Motor development tuations was compared with the mean raw score (ie, 2.3).
Motor skills were examined with the Movement Assessment A higher raw score means more attentional fluctuations. A
Battery for Children (M-ABC).11 12 The M-ABC consists of sep- paired samples t-test was used to determine whether the data of
arate age-related item bands with increasing difficulty as children the intelligence tests had the same mean score and could be
get older. Each band contains eight items, which evaluate three pooled.
domains: manual dexterity (3 items), ball (2 items) and balance Correlation coefficients between z-score M-ABC at the age of
skills (3 items). Until October 2012, we used the first edition of 8 years and sports participation and sustained attention were
the M-ABC, but in November 2012, we switched to the second calculated. Furthermore, correlation coefficients between partici-
edition. Both editions contain similar content and are assumed pants’ characteristics and sustained attention were calculated.
to be comparable.13 M-ABC percentile scores are divided Pearson’s correlation coefficients were calculated for continuous
into three categories, namely normal, borderline and motor data and Spearman’s for dichotomous data. All statistical tests
problem. were two sided; significance level was p<0.05. Statistical ana-
lyses were performed using IBM-SPSS-Statistics-21 (SPSS,
SECONDARY OUTCOMES Chicago, Illinois, USA).
Intelligence
For children born after December 2001, the Dutch version of RESULTS
the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children (WISC-III-NL) was Of the 78 newborns with OA admitted between February 1999
used to assess full-scale IQ (FSIQ), total verbal IQ (TVIQ) and and August 2006, seven died (9.0%). The parents of seven chil-
total performance IQ (TPIQ).13 For children born earlier, the dren refused to participate (9.0%) and three children were lost
short version of the Revised Amsterdam Intelligence Test to follow-up (3.8%). One child had been operated elsewhere
(RAKIT)14 15 and the short version of the TVIQ scale of the and was first seen at 8 years. Four children with intellectual dis-
WISC-III-NL were used. For both tests, the IQ has a mean (SD) ability ((genetic syndrome (n=3) and unknown cause (n=1))
of 100 (15) in the normative population. could not be tested. Thus, 58 children were included in the ana-
lysis (figure 1).
Sustained attention Perinatal characteristics are shown in table 1. Surgical proce-
Attention was assessed with the Dot cancellation test (Bourdon- dures included thoracotomy for oesophageal correction (all
Vos test). This test is a continuous performance paper and patients), cardiac surgery (n=3) and Nissen fundoplication
pencil test that measures sustained attention in terms of speed (n=14).
and attentional fluctuations. Speed and attentional fluctuations More children received physiotherapeutic support at the age
are continuous variables, respectively, expressed in z-score and of 5 than at the age of 8 years (25% vs 10%, respectively;
raw score (higher score indicating more fluctuations).16 p<0.001). Participation in sports activities did no differ
between 5-year-olds and 8-year-olds (55% vs 73%, respectively;
Statistical analysis p=0.117).
Data are presented as mean (SD) unless otherwise indicated. Five 8-year-olds (10.2%) followed special education, 10
To compare data of participants and non-participants, regular education with remedial teaching (20.4%) and 34
Mann-Whitney U tests were used for continuous data and χ2 regular education without remedial teaching (69.4%) (χ2=2.86,
tests for categorical data. The Kruskal-Wallis test was used to p=0.239 compared with age peers in the general Dutch
F2 Harmsen WJ, et al. Arch Dis Child Fetal Neonatal Ed 2016;0:F1–F6. doi:10.1136/archdischild-2015-309976
Original article
Figure 1 Flow chart follow-up programme. OA, oesophagus atresia; ICU, intensive care unit; M-ABC, Movement Assessment Battery for Children.
population) special education: 5%; regular education with extra Motor development
support: 20%; and regular education: 75%).17 Forty-five children (78%) were tested with the M-ABC at both
SES was determined for the parents of 56 participants (97%) ages (figure 1).
and classified as low in 12.5% (n=7), middle in 50% (n=28) At 5 years, mean z-score M-ABC was lower than normative
and high in 37.5% (n=21). Neurodevelopmental outcome was values (z-score M-ABC=−0.75, n=54, p<0.001). Sixty-five per
not different across the SES categories for: motor performance cent had an M-ABC score within the normal range, which per-
at 5 years (χ2=1.201, p=0.549) and 8 years (χ2=0.393, centage is lower than that in the reference population (85%)
p=0.822), IQ (χ2=3.215, p=0.200) and sustained attention (figure 2). Problems were observed mainly for the gross motor
(speed: χ2=0.021, p=0.990; fluctuations χ2=0.694, p=0.707). abilities, such as ball skills (48% normal) and balance skills
Harmsen WJ, et al. Arch Dis Child Fetal Neonatal Ed 2016;0:F1–F6. doi:10.1136/archdischild-2015-309976 F3
Original article
Table 2 Associations with motor developmental outcome Table 3 Associations with motor developmental outcome at the
Z-score M-ABC age of 8 years
Birth weight (kilogram) 0.155 0.268 −0.123 to 0.432 Sports participation (yes/no) 0.440 0.002
The presence of other associated −0.388 0.153 −0.924 to 0.149 Sustained attention fluctuations† −0.360 0.021
CA (yes/no)
Sustained attention speed (z-score) 0.318 0.043
Ventilatory support, in days −0.002 0.849 −0.028 to 0.023
Pearson’s correlation coefficients were calculated for continuous data and Spearman’s
Duration of anaesthetic exposure −0.029 0.018 −0.054 to −0.005
correlation coefficients for dichotomous data.
within the first 24 months of life †Individual SD (raw score).
CA, congenital anomaly; Presence of other associated CA (yes=1, no=0), Sports M-ABC, Movement Assessment Battery for Children.
participation (yes=1, no=0); M-ABC, Movement Assessment Battery for Children. Each
predictor was included in a separate linear mixed model with adjustment for age.
FSIQ was 102 (14), mean (SD) TVIQ was 103 (14) and mean
(61% normal), but not for fine motor skills. One child with (SD) TPIQ was 98 (14); the distributions of all scales were con-
Opitz syndrome was included and completed the M-ABC satis- sistent with Dutch normative data.
factorily at 5 years. Although the result suggested delayed motor
development overall results did not change after exclusion of
this child (data not shown). Sustained attention
At the age of 8, mean z-score M-ABC was lower than norma- Sustained attention was assessed in 41/49 children; two missed
tive values (z-score M-ABC=−0.53, n=49, p<0.001). the appointment; two had been tested elsewhere; reasons for
Sixty-nine per cent had an overall M-ABC score within the four were unknown. Sustained attention was weaker compared
normal range. Considering the different domains, 53% scored with norms: mean (SD) z-score for Dot cancellation test speed
within the normal range for ball skills, 82% for balance skills −1.50(1.73); p<0.001 and mean (SD) raw score for Dot cancel-
and 82% for manual dexterity. lation test fluctuations +3.99 (1.90); p<0.001.
Motor performance did not improve from 5 to 8 years of age
(z-score M-ABC=+0.24, 95% CI −0.03 to +0.49, p=0.074). Determinants of developmental outcome
There was a significant correlation between z-score M-ABC at Longitudinal linear mixed model analyses revealed that the dur-
5 and 8 years (r=0.346, p=0.007). ation of anaesthetic exposure within the first 24 months was
negatively associated with z-score M-ABC ( p=0.018) (table 2).
Intelligence At 8 years, sustained attention was negatively associated with
Intelligence was assessed in 46/49 children (full-scale z-score M-ABC in terms of speed and attentional fluctuations,
WISC-III-NL, n=37; RAKIT and TVIQ of the WISC-III-NL, whereas sports participation was positively associated with
n=9). Data of three children who had recently been tested else- z-score M-ABC (table 3). Other potential risk factors, such as
where were not included. The data on total intelligence were sepsis, prolonged parenteral nutrition or prolonged hospitalisa-
pooled, because there was no difference between the RAKIT and tion, did not influence developmental outcome (data not
WISC-III-NL full-scale intelligence scores ( p=0.26). Mean (SD) shown).
F4 Harmsen WJ, et al. Arch Dis Child Fetal Neonatal Ed 2016;0:F1–F6. doi:10.1136/archdischild-2015-309976
Original article
DISCUSSION systems were not yet in use. Second, sustained attention could
The present study is—to our knowledge—the first that longitu- not be assessed in eight children which might have led to some
dinally evaluated developmental outcome and associated factors selection bias. Third, assessment lasted a whole day. Although
in children operated on for OA. Assessments showed impaired we schedule sufficient breaks, the children’s performance might
motor performance up until 8 years without improvement over have been influenced by fatigue. However, the strength of this
time. Intelligence was normal, indicating that these children do study is the highly structured follow-up with a considerable
not suffer from general developmental delay. Sustained attention study population in view of the rare diagnosis.3 5 7–9 Lastly, we
and duration of anaesthetic exposure within the first 24 months did not enrol healthy controls as this is hardly feasible for a lon-
of life were negatively associated with motor performance. gitudinal study in school-age children. However, within the
Most of the comparable studies reported normal motor per- infrastructure of routine patient care, we exclusively used stan-
formance within the first 3 years of life in comparison with dardised assessments with population norms obtained in healthy
population norms3 4 or with healthy controls.18 In line with Dutch children.
previous studies of our research group, the present study found
impaired gross motor performance at 5 years. Further, motor
development at 5 years was predictive of motor performance at CONCLUSIONS
8 years, which suggests sustained risk of impairment. Similarly, Children operated on for OA may be at risk of long-term
in children with non-cardiac anatomical congenital malforma- developmental difficulties—especially in the area of gross motor
tions, motor development at 6, 12 and 24 months was predic- performance. Sports participation should be encouraged as it
tive of motor performance at 5 years.8 can improve motor development. The duration of anaesthetic
In our cohort, we observed normal intelligence but impair- exposure within the first 24 months of life was associated with
ments in sustained attention at 8 years. Little is known about gross motor problems. The same was true for impaired
long-term cognition of patients with OA; most studies found sustained attention at 8 years. Future studies should focus on
normal mental development within the first years of life.3 4 18 neurocognitive evaluation and the effects of anaesthetics, neuro-
Two studies reported impaired intelligence at school age.19 20 toxic drugs and perioperative management during the critical
However, these findings should be interpreted with caution neonatal phase.
because both studies were retrospective and selection bias might Acknowledgements The authors thank the paediatric surgical long-term
have occurred. Moreover, Kubota and colleagues did not report follow-up team, consisting of paediatricians, paediatric surgeons, psychologists,
on selection procedures.20 In the present study, we found speech–language pathologists and paediatric physiotherapists and especially Saskia
impaired sustained attention at the age of 8 years. Attention pro- J. Gischler and Marjolein Spoel (medical staff ) and Anne Zirar-Vroegindeweij and
Annabel van Gils-Frijters ( psychologists). Ko Hagoort provided editorial advice.
blems have also been reported in children with congenital dia-
phragmatic hernia and in neonatal ECMO survivors.9 Contributors WJH collected data, performed data analysis and drafted the first
version of the manuscript. FJA collected data, performed data analysis, drafted the
Despite a normal intelligence, 10% of the children needed
manuscript and critically reviewed the manuscript. MHMvdC-vZ designed the study,
special education, which is twice as high as in the normal Dutch collected data, performed data analysis, drafted the manuscript and critically
population.17 In previous literature, 11% to 53% of patients reviewed the manuscript. JMvR performed data analysis and critically reviewed the
with OA had special educational needs in relation to learning dis- manuscript. RMHW critically reviewed the manuscript. DT designed the study and
abilities, speech–language problems or intellectual disability.19 21 critically reviewed the manuscript. HI designed the study, collected data, critically
reviewed the manuscript and is responsible for the overall content as guarantor.
Previously identified risk factors for developmental problems,
such as sepsis, prolonged parenteral nutrition or hospitalisation, Funding Financially support: Stichting Swart van Essen, Rotterdam.
were not found risk factors in the present study. In previous Competing interests None declared.
studies, motor performance was negatively associated with the Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
longer duration of hospitalisation, more surgical interventions
and additional congenital anomalies.3 5 The impact of general
anaesthesia on developmental outcome is still speculative;22 REFERENCES
1 Spitz L. Oesophageal atresia. Orphanet J Rare Dis 2007;2:24.
studies reported associations with learning disabilities,23 behav- 2 Walker K, Badawi N, Holland AJ, et al. Developmental outcomes following major
ioural problems24 25 and developmental disorders.25 We found surgery: what does the literature say? J Paediatr Child Health 2011;47:766–70.
a negative association of anaesthetic exposure with motor devel- 3 Gischler SJ, Mazer P, Duivenvoorden HJ, et al. Interdisciplinary structural follow-up
opmental outcome. This finding cannot be ignored but should of surgical newborns: a prospective evaluation. J Pediatr Surg 2009;44:1382–9.
4 Aite L, Bevilacqua F, Zaccara A, et al. Short-term neurodevelopmental outcome of
be interpreted with caution because we do not know what
babies operated on for low-risk esophageal atresia: a pilot study. Dis Esophagus
anaesthetics were used. Still, the question is whether develop- 2014;27:330–4.
mental problems can be explained by neurotoxic effects of 5 van der Cammen-van Zijp MH, Gischler SJ, Mazer P, et al. Motor-function and
anaesthetics. Frequent or prolonged anaesthesia may also be exercise capacity in children with major anatomical congenital anomalies: an
indicative of the presence of comorbidities that may independ- evaluation at 5 years of age. Early Hum Dev 2010;86:523–8.
6 Kovesi T, Rubin S. Long-term complications of congenital esophageal atresia and/or
ently affect developmental outcome.26 tracheoesophageal fistula. Chest 2004;126:915–25.
Approximately half of the children had impaired ball and 7 van der Cammen-van Zijp MH, Janssen AJ, Raets MM, et al. Motor performance
balance skills at 5 years. Interestingly, balance skills improved after neonatal extracorporeal membrane oxygenation: a longitudinal evaluation.
afterwards as a result of more exercise. Sports participation was Pediatrics 2014;134:e427–35.
8 Mazer P, Gischler SJ, VAN DER Cammen-VAN Zijp MH, et al. Early developmental
indeed positively associated with improved motor abilities.
assessment of children with major non-cardiac congenital anomalies predicts
Although children with poor motor performance may refrain development at the age of 5 years. Dev Med Child Neurol 2010;52:1154–9.
from sports activities, we believe that sports participation should 9 Madderom MJ, Toussaint L, van der Cammen-van Zijp MH, et al. Congenital
be encouraged. It helps develop motor skills, increases diaphragmatic hernia with(out) ECMO: Impaired development at 8 years. Arch Dis
health-related physical activity and improves quality of life.27 28 Child Fetal Neonatal Ed 2013;98:F316–322.
10 Centraal Bureau voor de Statistiek (Statistics Netherlands). Standaard
Some limitations should be discussed. First, data on pre- onderwijsindeling 2006 (The Dutch Standard Classification od Education). http://
scribed anaesthetics were not available. All patients were oper- www.cbs.nl/nl-NL/menu/methoden/classificaties/overzicht/soi/2003/default.htm
ated on more than 8 years ago, when electronic patient data (accessed 22 Feb 2016).
Harmsen WJ, et al. Arch Dis Child Fetal Neonatal Ed 2016;0:F1–F6. doi:10.1136/archdischild-2015-309976 F5
Original article
11 Henderson FA. SDA. The movement assessment battery for children: Manual. The 21 Faugli A, Bjornland K, Emblem R, et al. Mental health and psychosocial functioning
psychological corporation. 1992. in adolescents with esophageal atresia. J Pediatr Surg 2009;44:729–37.
12 Smits Engelsman BC. Movement abc-2-nl. Dutch manual. Amsterdam: Pearson, 22 Mann GE, Kahana M. The uncomfortable reality…We simply do not know if
2010. general anesthesia negatively impacts the neurocognitive development of our small
13 Smits-Engelsman B, Hill EL. The relationship between motor coordination and children. Int J Pediatr Otorhinolaryngol 2015;79:1379–81.
intelligence across the iq range. Pediatrics 2012;130:e950–956. 23 Wilder RT, Flick RP, Sprung J, et al. Early exposure to anesthesia and learning
14 Kort WSM, Bosmans EL. Wechsler intelligence scale for children-iii manual: disabilities in a population-based birth cohort. Anesthesiology 2009;110:796–804.
Wisc-iii-nl. Amsterdam: Pearson, 2005. 24 Kalkman CJ, Peelen L, Moons KG, et al. Behavior and development in children and
15 Bleichrodt NDP, Zaal JM, Resing WCM. Revision Amsterdam child intelligence test: age at the time of first anesthetic exposure. Anesthesiology 2009;110:805–12.
Manual. Amsterdam: Pearson, 1984. 25 DiMaggio C, Sun LS, Li G. Early childhood exposure to anesthesia and risk of
16 Vos P B-V. Handleiding (manual bourdon-vos). Lisse: Swets & Zeitlinger, 1992. developmental and behavioral disorders in a sibling birth cohort. Anesth Analg
17 Onderwijsinspectie TDIo. The state of education in the netherlands: Education report 2011;113:1143–51.
2009/2010. http://www.onderwijsinspectie.nl/publicaties (accessed 22 Feb 2016). 26 Beers SR, Rofey DL, McIntyre KA. Neurodevelopmental assessment after anesthesia
18 Walker K, Loughran-Fowlds A, Halliday R, et al. Developmental outcomes at three in childhood: review of the literature and recommendations. Anesth Analg
years of age of infants with esophageal atresia. J Pediatr Surg 2016;51:249–51. 2014;119:661–9.
19 Bouman NH, Koot HM, Hazebroek FW. Long-term physical, psychological, and 27 Vella SA, Magee CA, Cliff DP. Trajectories and predictors of health-related quality of
social functioning of children with esophageal atresia. J Pediatr Surg life during childhood. J Pediatr 2015;167:422–7.
1999;34:399–404. 28 Hebert JJ, Moller NC, Andersen LB, et al. Organized sport participation is associated
20 Kubota A, Nose K, Yamamoto E, et al. Psychosocial and cognitive consequences of with higher levels of overall health-related physical activity in children (champs
major neonatal surgery. J Pediatr Surg 2011;46:2250–3. study-dk). PLoS ONE 2015;10:e0134621.
F6 Harmsen WJ, et al. Arch Dis Child Fetal Neonatal Ed 2016;0:F1–F6. doi:10.1136/archdischild-2015-309976