Engaging Youth and Adults As Partners in Social Change: A Discussion Guide
Engaging Youth and Adults As Partners in Social Change: A Discussion Guide
Engaging Youth and Adults As Partners in Social Change: A Discussion Guide
A Discussion Guide
On October 17, 2005, 115 young people, adults and elders More information about this seminar can be found in
from across the country came together to celebrate and explore the following two papers:
75 years of the W.K. Kellogg Foundation’s grant-making. The
group shared diverse, creative and courageous strategies for • Youth Engagement: A Celebration Across Time and Culture
youth and adults to achieve positive social change. Framing the Issue and
This discussion guide captures the energy and excitement from • Youth Engagement: A Celebration Across Time and Culture
that event so that it can be shared with more people and more Proceedings Summary.
communities. Its purpose is to inspire the development of youth-
adult partnerships for community change by helping people sit Both are available from the Innovation Center for Community
down and talk about the power of this approach. Additional tools and Youth Development at www.theinnovationcenter.org and
in this series will help harness that energy and excitement for both were used in the creation of this discussion guide. More
deeper discussions and action. information about the seminar can also be found on the
W.K. Kellogg Foundation’s website at www.wkkf.org.
The decision to begin this series with a discussion guide is an
intentional one. In our work with community-based organizations
from across the country and around the world, people cite the
power of sitting down together and talking about history, about
current work, and about their goals and dreams for the future.
They say that these discussions really strengthen community
change. Cross-generational dialogues that build upon lessons
from the past, consider realities from the present, and dream of
the future result in two things:
Like the event that inspired them, this guide and video are Each of the three sections is designed to be used on its own.
divided into three sections: Each includes an opening and a closing. If you choose to use
the activities at the same time, you may decide to eliminate
1. Rhythms of the Past some of these opening and closing sections.
2. Relationships of the Present
3. Results of the Future Participants
Participants should be of different ages and should be
representative of the diverse groups that make up the
community. Facilitators should also reflect this diversity.
Definitions of Terms
A glossary is included at the end of this guide. These terms and
definitions are not exhaustive—it may be useful to have your
group use these definitions as the starting point for a discussion
about what each means in your community.
• Review the discussion guides in advance and rephrase For all of these discussions, it is important to establish and
questions to meet the needs of your group. discuss group norms for conversation that ensure everyone
• Review the FOOD FOR THOUGHT section for stories, ideas, feels comfortable, respected, and valued. This is especially
and examples to share with the group. (These may be shared important if your group of youth and adults has never worked
by reading aloud, sharing printed copies, writing on large together before. To help establish group norms, you might
sheets hung on the wall, or in another way that makes sense explore available resources, such as the CIRCLES guide listed in
for the group.) the ACTIVITIES section on page 22, or materials on establishing
• Explore some of the tools in the RESOURCES section for Gracious Space from the Center for Ethical Leadership
additional stories and strategies that would resonate with your (http://www.ethicalleadership.org). At the event, participants
group. (These might include longer stories, online video, or established a safe space for discussions through a variety of
links to the websites of organizations doing similar work.) If activities, including a pledge to one another in which all agreed
time allows, select a few resources or sections to share with to:
your group as part of the discussion.
• Preview the video and share with the group, if appropriate. • Be open-minded and welcome diverse opinions, recognizing
the important contributions of our diverse backgrounds.
• Commit to learning from one another in an atmosphere of
During Each Discussion mutual respect and tolerance.
• Encourage one another to speak from the heart.
• Document what comes out of the discussion. (These might • Respect one another’s unique voice and commit to giving
be exciting ideas, items for future discussion, and lessons each other an equal opportunity to share.
learned. You may choose to document through art, notes
written on large sheets of paper, or video taping.) Other resources on working with youth and adults as partners,
including Creating Youth-Adult Partnerships and Youth-Adult
Partnerships: A Training Manual, available at
After Each Discussion www.theinnovationcenter.org, may be helpful.
• Young people organized “Bacon’s Rebellion” in 1676 well • In 1976, the Department of Education of South Africa
before the war for independence. Aaron Burr and Alexander decreed that Afrikaans would be the official language of
Hamilton were student leaders. Thomas Paine, great instruction at schools. Students objected to being forced to
propagandist of the revolution, was a young person. Even use the language of their oppressors under the apartheid
Thomas Jefferson, as the movement for independence began, system, and they unified to protest. Their actions fueled
was a very young man. the movement that eventually overturned the system of
oppression.
• The Civil Rights movement of the late 1950s and 1960s was
powered by young people who organized the Student • In 1989, students in Prague commemorated the 20th
Nonviolent Coordinating Committee (SNCC).1 anniversary of the death of Jan Palach, the student who
burned himself to death in protest at the Soviet occupation of
• In 1968, about 40,000 students on nearly 100 campuses Czechoslovakia. Their collective memorial helped spark the
across the country demonstrated against the Vietnam War overturn of the communist regime.
and against racism.
• Other examples from your community, experience, or
• Chicano youth were a forceful voice for equality and civil knowledge.
rights; for example, on March 27, 1968 some 40,000 high
school students in Southern California walked out to protest
anti-immigration legislation.
1
See History of the Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee at Davis, Dernoral, “When Youth Protest: The Mississippi Civil Rights Movement,
http://www.ncsu.edu/chass/mds/sncchist.html. 1955-1970,” Mississippi History Now, 2001.
http://mshistory.k12.ms.us/features/feature21/civilrights.html (13 July 2005).
Cozzens, Lisa, “Sit-ins,” Civil Rights Movement 1955-1965, 1997.
http://www.watson.org (13 July 2005)
Additional stories and voices of youth engagement from the civil • Duke University's Center for Documentary Studies:
rights and other social justice movements, including oral history Behind the Veil Oral History
transcripts, audio clips, and video can be found on some of the (http://cds.aas.duke.edu/btv/index.html)
following websites: According to the VOICES OF THE CIVIL RIGHTS webpage,
“Behind the Veil: Documenting African American Life in the Jim
Voices of the Civil Rights Crow South” includes more than 1,000 audio-taped interviews
(http://www.voicesofcivilrights.org/index.html) with African Americans who experienced segregation in the
South from 1890 through the 1950s. More than 300
AARP, the Leadership Conference on Civil Rights (LCCR), and the narratives are available in transcript form. The project
Library of Congress have created this website, which aims to materials were used for the book/CD set and PBS radio
“preserve personal accounts of America’s struggle to fulfill the series “Remembering Jim Crow.”
promise of equality for all” through the collection and sharing of
“extraordinary stories of hope and courage by ordinary people” • Civil Rights Documentation Project
from the Civil Rights movement. From this website, you can link (http://www.usm.edu/crdp/)
to stories, online movies, and video and oral histories from civil
rights activists, including: According to the VOICES OF THE CIVIL RIGHTS webpage “The
University of Southern Mississippi's Center for Oral History
• Civil Rights in Mississippi Digital Archive and Cultural Heritage showcases Tougaloo College’s collection
(http://www.lib.usm.edu/~spcol/crda/oh/) of approximately 40 oral histories. The site also includes a
timeline with audio.”
According to the VOICES OF THE CIVIL RIGHTS webpage,
“The University of Southern Mississippi's (USM) Center for • Birmingham Civil Rights Institute
Oral History and Cultural Heritage is arguably the repository (http://www.bcri.org/archives/collections_guide/index.htm)
for material relating to this subject. USM’s digital collection
features the largest database of oral history transcripts— According to the VOICES OF THE CIVIL RIGHTS webpage
complete with brief biographies of each subject—as well as “The museum’s Complete Collections Guide is a treasure
manuscripts and photographs that document this turbulent trove of letters, photos, press clippings, and pamphlets—a
time in the state's history.” literal scrapbook of the Civil Rights Movement of the 1950s
and ‘60s. The museum houses the 56 Alabamian oral
histories recorded by Duke University’s ‘Behind the Veil’
researchers, as well as 300 interviews from its own oral
history project that are available in audio, video, and
transcript form.”
Video:
If you’re using this discussion guide with the Kellogg 75th
Anniversary video, start at RHYTHMS OF THE PAST.
Materials:
• Equipment to show video
(TV and DVD player or computer and LCD projector)
• Food for Thought items as handout,
written on large sheets, or available for reference
• Markers and large sheets of paper
to document discussion items
Time Needed:
45 minutes to one hour
Step I: Inform the group that this discussion is inspired by 10 minutes Find a way to share stories that makes sense for
Set the Stage the Kellogg 75th event. your group. This might include asking individuals to
read sections aloud, having small groups read and
Read them this description: share their understanding of what they’ve read, or
through another method.
On October 17, 2005, 115 young people, adults and
elders from across the country came together to If participants from the group also participated
celebrate and explore 75 years of the W.K. Kellogg at the 75th celebration, encourage them to explain
Foundation’s grant-making. The group shared the event to the group, including what was most
diverse, creative and courageous strategies for interesting to them and what they were most
youth and adults to achieve positive social change. interested in sharing from the event.
Step 2: Guide the group in a facilitated discussion, using 30 minutes So that everyone feels comfortable speaking,
Group Participation some of the following suggested questions and tips: encourage everyone to respond with one image,
word or phrase, emphasizing that there is no
“From this first section of the video or from the incorrect answer.
examples on page 7, what images, words, or
phrases stand out to you?”
“In addition to the examples discussed in the video Some examples to explore with the group might be
on page 7, what are other examples of young people labor movements of the early 20th century or the
leading positive social change?” Native American rights, women’s rights, and
environmental movements.
“Of these examples or others surfaced by the group, Encourage these individuals to briefly share their
are there any that adults or elders in the group had story.
experience with as a young person?”
“As an elder involved in one of these movements as Depending on the stories shared and the reactions,
a young person, how did it feel to share your story?” you might prompt further discussions by asking the
group questions such as:
“As a young person, what did it feel like to hear
these stories?” “From the examples above or those shared by the
group, were you surprised to hear any of the stories
“Was there anything surprising about sharing these where young people were involved or leaders in
stories?” creating change? Were you surprised that other
people didn’t know any of these stories?”
Step 2: “Looking at all of the examples where young people To help the group consider various examples of
Group Participation have been leaders in creating positive change, what young people as leaders in creating positive change,
(continued) are some of the common themes of each of these you might list different movements on a large sheet
movements?” of paper, using examples from FOOD FOR THOUGHT
and examples from the group’s discussion.
“What are some of the qualities that individuals
leading these change demonstrated?”
“What are some of the gifts that youth leaders from Ask for a volunteer to document some of these gifts
the past contribute to our positive community and qualities on a large sheet of paper so that
change efforts?” everyone can see them.*
Step 3: “How can we apply the lessons of the past to our 5 minutes Ask for a volunteer to document some of these
Next Steps work today?” lessons on a large sheet of paper so that everyone
can see them.
Step 4: Thank everyone for their participation. 10 minutes Review the ACTIVITIES section for ideas on how you
Wrap Up and the group might build on some of the lessons
Talk about next steps, including other activities you learned or discussion items raised.
might undertake with the group to build on the
discussion.
*One adaptation of this section asks participants to list each individual’s gift
on small paper cutouts created by the facilitator in advance.
Innovation Center for Community and Youth Development www.theinnovationcenter.org 13
Rhythms of the Past—Activities
To document other examples of youth and adults creating To access other resources on guiding a facilitated conversation,
change in your community or to lead a similar discussion with a you might explore:
larger group, you might consider the following activity:
Young people are engaged in their communities today through • Led by youth and young adults, Roca, Inc. of Chelsea, MA
a variety of strategies. Young people are leading change offers numerous programs and services to local youth, their
around social and economic justice, civil and political rights, families and communities. These range from after-school
peace activism, environmental protection, cultural sensitivity programs and teen pregnancy prevention, to adult education,
and preservation, and other issues that affect them on an community peacemaking, leadership development and more.
individual, community, national and international level. Roca’s approach to service delivery emphasizes relentless
Some examples include: street work and community outreach.
• OUTRIGHT in Portland, ME creates a safe space for GLBTQ
• Young people from organizations such as Asian Immigrant youth and promotes a safer world on their behalf by running a
Women Advocates have organized, mobilized and raised hotline and hosting educational and social events. For
awareness of the health concerns of immigrant laborers in example, youth members of OUTRIGHT have counseled a
San Francisco area garment factories, resulting in better local school official through the handling of an anti-gay
working conditions for their mothers, sisters, aunts and other harassment incident and advised specific changes to the
family members. climate of the school; organized a prom for GLBTQ young
• Young people from Tohono O’odham Community Action people in Portland attended by 190 young people; brought
in Arizona have worked with elders in their community to three young people—a transgender man, a lesbian, and a
resurrect traditional farming methods and tools. They straight ally—to the stage of a high school auditorium to tell
engage diverse members of their community to share their their stories to 300 teachers and students.
knowledge, energy, and strength in a sustainable agricultural • Other examples from your community or experience.
project that contributes to the health and financial well-being
of the community.
• In Hampton, VA, young people from UTH: Achieving Change
Together worked with adult partners to create a strong
coalition to expand the voice, visibility and empowerment of
all young people in Hampton. They developed and support a
youth-led coalition to create change by increasing the role of
youth involvement within school decision and policy making,
changing the perception of young people in the media, and
increasing the use of service-learning throughout Hampton
City Schools.
Video:
If you’re using this discussion guide with the Kellogg 75th
Anniversary video, begin the video at the RELATIONSHIPS OF
THE PRESENT section.
Materials:
• Equipment to show video
(TV and DVD player or computer and LCD projector)
• Food for Thought items as handout,
written on large sheets, or available for reference
• Markers and large sheets of paper to document
discussion items
Time Needed:
One hour to 1.5 hours.
Step 3: Play portions of the Kellogg 75th video or share 5-10 minutes Find a way to share these that makes sense for your
Sharing Other some of the stories from the resources section on group. This might include asking individuals to read
Community Stories page 17. sections aloud, having small groups read and share
their understanding of what they’ve read, or through
another method.
Step 4: Remind participants that: 20-30 minutes If the group is large, break into smaller groups to
Sharing Our Stories • the story of youth engagement is still being written allow for more dialogue. If the group is already fairly
• everyone’s story is a powerful addition to the small, encourage members to share their stories
collective movement for change through a brief discussion.
Ask participants to share their stories. If your group is familiar and comfortable with the
CIRCLES method (see the ACTIVITIES section), you
You might find it useful to start the group’s might find this a useful strategy for creating a
discussion by sharing your own story. positive, respectful space for discussion. Otherwise,
please feel free to use a style that works for
Ask questions similar to: your group.
“What has been your experience in working to create If you want to spend more time on this section, you
change?” might want to explore the CIRCLES activity or spend
more time developing group norms.
“What was exciting or interesting, what was difficult,
what was the result and what did you learn?”
Step 5: Request that the participants, in a larger group, 10 minutes Have a volunteer document these ideas on a large
Wrap Up share the results of their conversation by asking: sheet of paper so everyone can read them.
If you’re looking for an activity to better understand and World Café: A Guide from the World Café Community
document where young people and adults are creating change in (http://www.theworldcafe.com/index.html)
your community, you might explore:
This guide provides an overview of the principles used in
designing World Café conversations similar to conversations at
Charting Youth Involvement
the gathering in which participants shared their “secret spice”
(http://www.theinnovationcenter.org/event/ChartingYouthInvolve
and the ingredients of their organization’s success. This online
ment.pdf)
resource contains tips for creating powerful questions, outlines
From the Innovation Center’s Building Community tool kit, this the World Café assumptions and etiquette, and covers how to
activity “maps” the existence and nature of youth participation. set up your meeting space, as well as identifies all the supplies
you will need on hand to support your gathering.
In order to effectively recognize and unleash the power of young Discussions at the event revealed the following themes as
people engaged in creating change, it’s important to have the lessons for others looking to successfully engage youth and
right tools. adults in creating positive community change:
At Youth Engagement: A Celebration Across Time and Culture, • There is rich potential for learning and action in connections
participants worked on a “call to action” that built on the gifts of and dialogue between current youth leaders of social change
the past, best practices and reflections from current work and and the elders that led movements and efforts before them.
stories from individual and organizational experiences. They also • Young people from marginalized communities leading social
shared their passions, cultures, backgrounds, individual values change isn’t new, but part of a long and powerful history.
and the “secret ingredient” of their organization’s success. Current leadership and youth development programs have
much to learn from the past.
• Being an “elder” has nothing to do with age and
everything to do with having lessons, experiences
and a willingness to share.
• Changing the world begins with the individual.
• More than simply a way to creatively express oneself,
art can be a catalyst for change.
• “Families” of choice or by birth support individuals
to lead change.
• Effective social change requires the ability to work
within and across culture.
These themes and the stories that inspired them can be found in
the Youth Engagement: A Celebration Across Time and Culture
Proceedings Summary paper (see next page).
Youth Engagement:
A Celebration Across Time and Culture
Proceedings Summary
By Innovation Center Vice President Hartley Hobson
A Call to Action
A large, colorful community “call to action” drawing was
created by participants at the Youth Engagement: A Celebration
Across Time and Culture event. It can be found at the end of
this document, or online at
http://www.wkkf.org/DesktopModules/WKF_DmaItem/ViewDoc.a
spx?CID=297&ListID=28&ItemID=2970055&fld=PDFFile .
Video:
If you’re using this discussion guide with the
Kellogg 75th Anniversary video, begin this at the
RESULTS OF THE FUTURE section.
Materials:
• Equipment to show video
(TV and DVD player or computer and LCD projector)
• Food for Thought items as handout,
written on large sheets, or available for reference
• Markers and large sheets of paper to
document discussion items
Time Needed:
45 minutes to one hour
Step 3: Write the 7 themes from FOOD FOR THOUGHTS on 15 minutes Allow enough time for participants to read each and
Lessons for the Future large sheets of paper and hang around the room. discuss what these themes mean to them. The
themes are meant to inspire reflection, discussion
Encourage everyone to walk around the room with and personal interpretations. Encourage people to
a marker or pen and read each statement, think about what these phrases might mean to them
reflecting on what each means to them personally. in their work.
Participants should mark each poster with:
You might want to have music playing for this
• ! if the ideas is fresh or exciting process.
• ? if the participant didn’t quite understand it
• if you found yourself agreeing or
strongly agreeing
• if you disagree or strongly disagree.
Step 4: Ask everyone to gather in a group again to process 20 minutes Ask a volunteer to document some of the responses.
Sharing Our Stories the activity. Review the following questions:
Step 5: Discuss next steps with the group, including ways 10 minutes
Wrap Up to share this process with others, ways to build
upon this process for the future, ways to engage
others in this process, etc.
Visioning Exercise
(http://www.theinnovationcenter.org/event/VisioningExercise.pdf)
This exercise, from the Innovation Center for Community and
Youth Development’s Building Community: A Tool Kit for Youth
and Adults as Partners in Charting Assets and Creating Change,
helps groups plan, facilitate, and create a shared vision.
GLBTQ—An acronym commonly used for “Gay, lesbian, Youth-Adult Partnership—Young people and adults working
bi-sexual, transgender, or questioning” individuals. together, contributing their individual gifts and strengths as full
and equal partners for a shared venture.
Youth, Adult, Elder—The Innovation Center believes that
“youth,” “elder” and “adult” are terms best defined by each Youth Organizing—The union of grassroots community
community. For many communities, these terms may be organizing and positive youth development, with an explicit
assigned to individuals based on age, culture, achievement of commitment to social change and political action. Youth
specific milestones, and other factors. Through the Innovation organizing is based on the premise that young people are
Center’s work within the United States, we have found that many capable of taking leadership to transform their communities.
people use the term “youth” to apply to people ranging in age
from approximately 13-22. Elder often refers to adults over the
age of 60. It may be useful to explore your community’s
definitions for these terms and what these definitions mean to
your work through activities such as Youth-Adult Partnership: A
Training Guide and Creating Youth-Adult Partnerships, both
available from www.theinnovationcenter.org.
Youth Engagement: A Celebration Across Time and Culture was one in a series of special
seminars funded by the W.K. Kellogg Foundation during 2005 to mark 75 years of grantmaking.
The seminars, along with a variety of other special events and activities, highlighted some of the
important issues being addressed by Foundation programs, and honored the diverse individuals,
organizations and communities that are partners in finding innovative solutions to the myriad
challenges of our world. The Foundation was established in 1930 by cereal industry pioneer
W.K. Kellogg “to help people help themselves.”