Renegotiating Gender Through Dress in Bollywood: The New Indian Woman
Renegotiating Gender Through Dress in Bollywood: The New Indian Woman
Renegotiating Gender Through Dress in Bollywood: The New Indian Woman
net/publication/305278918
CITATIONS READS
2 2,001
2 authors:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Bharath M Josiam on 27 November 2017.
Renegotiating gender
through dress in Bollywood:
The new Indian woman
ABSTRACT KEYWORDS
Drawing upon the components of the social role theory and postcolonial theory, diasporic identity
this study examined the role of Bollywood diaspora films on the formation or rene- Bollywood
gotiation of identity among non-resident Indian women as manifested in their dress. dress
We were specifically interested in the creation of a new hybrid Indian identity for gender roles
young women of the diaspora, the women who are able to move seamlessly between postcolonialism
their two worlds, and in looking at the role of Bollywood as it reconciles traditional NRI
Indian values with the progress of postcolonial India.
INTRODUCTION
Bollywood is a thriving Indian movie industry based in Bombay (now
Mumbai). Bollywood films generally last for two and a half hours with formu-
laic storylines that embody Indian values, family drama, music and complex
choreography (Gooptu 2011; Matusitz and Payano 2011). Bollywood repre-
sents the essence of India but also provides temporal escapism for its view-
ers. Bollywood films with their extravagance and spectacle present a fantasy
lifestyle for India’s wide audience to escape from the realities of poverty
and political disorder (Hirji 2005). Everything and everyone in the films are
beautiful and melodramatic, presenting India as it ‘should be’ in modernity,
313
Jessica Strubel | Bharath M. Josiam
especially for the rising (and globalized) middle class that is largely responsi-
ble for the production of Bollywood films (Dwyer 2010: 381).
Since the mid-1990s, Bollywood has entered pop culture vernacular
across the world. In fact, the international popularity of Bollywood has helped
entertainment to become India’s second largest growth sector (Matusitz and
Payano 2011). Most of these films are situated outside of India and target a
market of non-resident Indians (NRI) who are willing to pay a premium to
view films that connect them to India.
Dress in India has always served as a channel of meaningful communica-
tion. Because of westernization, Hindi films, including those of Bollywood,
help to maintain and reposition the Indian identity through costuming. This is
especially true of NRI women as they renegotiate their roles in modern, west-
ern society while preserving their tradition.
For much of Bollywood’s history, the heroine wore traditional Indian
costume (which was associated with womanhood and nationalism), while the
less virtuous vamp (e.g., villainess) was able to wear her choice of westernized
and glamorous outfits (Rao 2010). The vamp and her clothing embodied excess
and became a cultural symbol of modernity. According to Clare Wilkinson-
Weber (2005), the vamp was exceptionally charismatic, but she was not meant
to be a model for emulation by decent female moviegoers. The vamp became
synonymous with the concept of ‘anti-Indianness’ that was imposed by colo-
nialism (Rao 2010: 7; Wilkinson-Weber 2005). Western attire, anything which
was too revealing and risqué, also personified modern conventions and the
temptations of the West. Hence, a western dress was commonplace for vamps,
because to identify with the West was to deny the virtues of Indian tradition.
314
Renegotiating gender through dress in Bollywood
Figure 1: Florence (Farhat) Ezekiel in Shree 420. Copyright 1955, V.I.P. Films.
immigrated to Bombay in the 1930s. For several decades Nadira played the
sultry temptress opposite many chaste Hindi heroines (see Figure 1).
The antithesis of the virtuous wife, the vamp, was a modern woman who
engaged in the improprieties of the westernized society (e.g., drinking, smok-
ing, seducing men). In classic Bollywood, the vamp is portrayed as the proto-
typical villainess who is not only malicious but also morally corrupt. The vamp
is an entity that has become associated with everything that is ‘unwhole-
some about the west’, including dressing in western attire (Gokulsing and
Dissanayake 1998: 77). Popular heroines of the 1970s and 1980s, such as
Hema Malini and Mala Sinha, openly refused to wear westernized attire or
other clothes they considered revealing or risqué (Rao 2010).
315
Jessica Strubel | Bharath M. Josiam
316
Renegotiating gender through dress in Bollywood
317
Jessica Strubel | Bharath M. Josiam
Much like the heroine in Purab Aur Paschhim, Simran (played by Kajol) in
Dilwale Dulhania le Jayenge is an NRI living in London with her family. She
dresses in the typical attire of the 1990s (the film was released in 1995), but
once she returns to Punjab with her family she is promised to a Punjabi boy
and inevitably adopts the traditional Indian sari (see Figures 3 and 4).
Figure 3: Kajol, as Simran, in western attire. Copyright 1995, Yash Raj Films.
318
Renegotiating gender through dress in Bollywood
Figure 4: Kajol, as Simran, in traditional Indian attire. Copyright 1995, Yash Raj
Films.
Namastey London was released in 2007 and demonstrates that the first
behavioural model for women is not reserved only for older titles. Heroine
Jasmeet (Katrina Kaif) is the epitome of the British NRI, a modern young
woman who is completely assimilated to British culture. On a family trip
to India, young Jasmeet is forced to marry a boy in India. The plot thickens
when Jasmeet refuses to recognize her marriage to Arjun, and instead she
announces her plan to marry her Anglo boyfriend who is also part of the inner
Figure 5: Katrina Kaif (as Jasmeet) and Akshay Kumar (as Arjun) in western
attire. Copyright 2007, Blockbuster Movie Entertainers.
319
Jessica Strubel | Bharath M. Josiam
Figure 6: Scene in India with Katrina Kaif in traditional Indian dress. Copyright
2007, Blockbuster Movie Entertainers.
circle of the British elite. Being Indian though, Jasmeet does not quite fit in.
She is subjected to racist comments and other forms of denigration. All the
while, Arjun is a touchstone for Jasmeet, drawing the two emotionally closer.
In the end, Jasmeet realizes her love for Arjun, abandons her British boyfriend
and returns to India with Arjun where she assumes her role as the conven-
tional Indian woman. Throughout the movie, Jasmeet is dressed in trendy
western attire while in London (see Figure 5). However, in India, she does
adopt traditional clothing (see Figure 6).
320
Renegotiating gender through dress in Bollywood
ensued (ironically during the service of female Prime Minister Indira Gandhi).
The renewal of strict tradition underscored women’s reproductive role above
all else, as evidenced in the steady rise of violence against women and the
media portrayal of women as ‘consumers rather than producers’ (Agnihotri
and Mazumdar 1995: 1870).
The portrayal of western society in Bollywood can also be surreal, and
has received a lot of criticism for the incorporation of extra martial affairs,
divorce and promiscuity of women (Hall 2007). Despite the restoration of
tradition that took place in the mid-1980s, the lifestyle of the urban woman
has changed drastically and Bollywood is now portraying the modern woman
as ‘brash and bold’ (Anon 2011). Unconventional behaviours are acceptable,
at least with the purpose of reflecting the cultural struggles of non-resident
Indian women.
Female leads, including the heroine, now impact the dress habits of
both middle class and upper class women. The dress of the contemporary
Bollywood heroine is still stylistically Indian, but tailored closer to the body
and less conventional by combining it with the elements of western fash-
ion. The dress is also symbolic of their identification with the women they
see in the films and their embracement of the western glamour that defined
1970s Bollywood heroines (Wilkinson-Weber 2005). More and more styles
from Bollywood films are appearing on the racks in India where consumer-
ism is lauded, thereby influencing a trendy youth market. There is also a rise
in the popularity of fusion clothes (Indian styles are adapted and westernized)
(Wilkinson-Weber 2005: 152). Bollywood demonstrates the shift in mental-
ity from formality, and the expression of Indianness, to a modernized Indian
identity marked by consumerism and a renegotiation of women’s traditional
gender role expectations.
Again, the second model of Indian woman is a modern woman who is
comfortable on the global stage, mixing modernity with tradition. Bollywood
has created a modern woman with a distinct identity who is capable of having
friendships with men without threatening her virtue. Modern women of India,
and abroad, place an emphasis on individualism and liberalism and are using
their dress to reflect this change in gender roles.
This movement is reflected in the costuming of the female leads in
contemporary Bollywood films. The contextual dress of the Indian woman is
no longer postcolonial (1947), and nor does she view herself, in traditional
dress, as inferior. At the same time, there are changing views of the vamp; the
heroine is shown as vampy, but it is not contemptible.
A woman can have it all, especially those of the diasporic audience. She
can be connected to the modern conventions of the western world while
maintaining her Indian tradition, as demonstrated in women’s acceptance of
(and comfort with) both styles of clothing.
A classic example of Bollywood’s new woman is depicted in We Are Family
(2010), a movie about a divorced mother of three in Australia who wears
western clothing throughout the film, and yet there are elements of tradi-
tional Indian design in many of her clothes. Nonetheless, during traditional
Indian events, such as Dilwali and her daughter’s wedding, the entire family is
dressed exclusively in traditional Indian attire.
In the film, Dostana (Mansukhani 2008), the heroine, Neha, lives with
two straight men who pretend to be a gay couple in order to secure a styl-
ish Miami apartment. Both of the male characters, Kunal and Sameer, fall for
their female roommate. In the end, when Kunal and Sameer reveal that they
321
Jessica Strubel | Bharath M. Josiam
Figure 7: Neha with Kunal and Sameer drinking beer. Copyright 2008, Dharma
Productions.
are indeed straight, Neha still remains friends with both men and maintains
her respectability. Neha’s dress throughout the movie is obviously western-
ized and quite sparse being that many scenes are filmed in South Beach. Her
dress also reflects her role as the powerful female executive at a popular fash-
ion magazine, the NRI woman who can ‘hang with the boys’ (see Figure 7).
However, during the song and dance scenes, she wears a cover-up with her
bikini while the foreign background dancers leave nothing to the imagination.
Some films have a purely western costume aesthetic and are much more
audacious in the portrayal of the heroine. In Dhoom 3 (the Indian version of
Ocean’s Eleven; Acharya 2013), the heroine does not even bother with Indian
costume for the song and dance sequences. In fact, in the second dance
sequence, she is essentially performing a striptease. Layer by layer, Katrina Kaif
(the heroine) removes her clothing (dingy overalls and trench coat) until she’s
left wearing nothing but a sports bra and very form-fitting shorts (see Figure 8).
Similarly, the female characters in Ek Main Aur Ekk Tu (set in Las Vegas;
Batra 2012) not only wear western clothing but clothing that is the quintessence
of licentiousness (e.g., revealing bathing suits, mini-skirts and tight dresses).
The plot of the movie is very suggestive even for contemporary Indian cinema.
Heroine Riana (played by Karina Kapoor) is shown walking out of bars carrying
an open bottle of beer, and after a night of binge drinking, the two lead charac-
ters wind up in a shotgun wedding that inevitably ends in a quick annulment.
322
Renegotiating gender through dress in Bollywood
Figure 9: Katrina Kaif and Hrithik Roshan. Copyright 2011, Eros International.
The rest of the film addresses Rahul’s (the hero played by Imran Khan) rocky
relationship with his overpowering parents. Even when the main characters
find themselves in India, they maintain their westernized dress aesthetic.
The popular 2011 coming-of-age Bollywood sensation Zindagi Na Milegi
Dobara (Akhtar 2011), follows Kabir (played by Abhay Deol) and his college
friends to Spain to celebrate his bachelor party. This movie also embodies all
that is the antithesis of the sacred Indian culture. Women are forward, every-
one is dressed in revealing western attire and there is even an explicating
open kiss between two characters (see Figure 9). The movie culminates in two
song and dance marriages between four of the main characters, where every-
one, with the exception of a few older women, are wearing western clothing
(including the brides and grooms).
Bollywood heroines (including the ubiquitous vamps) serve as models for
contemporary Indian and NRI women, reaffirming the idea that the Indian
woman can be modernized without compromising her Indian identity and
with no shame as revealed in her dress. As we have discussed, there are two
models women can follow that preserve their Indian identity. Regardless of
the path they choose, each allows women to unapologetically and visible
assert their ethnic identity without compromising their acceptance of moder-
nity and shifting roles in Indian society (in and outside of India), albeit the
second framework allows for more fluidity of modern expression.
Nevertheless, the modern Indian woman embraces global modernity and
confidently pairs traditional saris with western designs and is unashamed about
her sexual assertiveness. Bollywood and its leading ladies have compelled
women to question and renegotiate their social roles, thereby allowing them
participation in a more liberalized society without marginalization.
REFERENCES
Acharya, Wijay Krishna (2013), Dhoom 3, India: Yash Raj Films.
Akhtar, Zoya (2011), Zindagi Na Milegi Dobara, India: Excel Entertainment.
Agnihotri, I. and Mazumdar, V. (1995), ‘Changing terms of political discourse:
Women’s movement in India, 1970s–1990s’, Economic and Political Weekly,
22 July, pp. 1869–78.
323
Jessica Strubel | Bharath M. Josiam
324
Renegotiating gender through dress in Bollywood
SUGGESTED CITATION
Strubel, J. and Josiam, B. M. (2016), ‘Renegotiating gender through dress in
Bollywood: The new Indian woman’, Fashion, Style & Popular Culture, 3: 3,
pp. 313–325, doi: 10.1386/fspc.3.3.313_1
CONTRIBUTOR DETAILS
Jessica Strubel is an assistant professor in Merchandising at the University of
North Texas. Her research interests include, but are not limited to, American
popular culture, youth cultures and music subcultures as consumer groups,
and the popular media as a tool for cultural/fashion diffusion. She is also the
Reviews Editor for Fashion, Style, & Popular Culture.
Contact: College of Merchandising, Hospitality & Tourism, University of
North Texas, 342H Chilton Hall, 1155 Union Circle #311100, Denton, TX
76203-5017, USA.
E-mail: [email protected]
Jessica Strubel and Bharath M. Josiam have asserted their right under the
Copyright, Designs and Patents Act, 1988, to be identified as the authors of
this work in the format that was submitted to Intellect Ltd.
325
Cotton
Companies, Fashion and the Fabric of Our Lives
Edited by Joseph H. Hancock II, Nioka Wyatt and Tasha L. Lewis
ISBN: 9781783206858 This book brings together contributors from a wide range of
70 Illustrations disciplines to explore the importance of cotton as a major resource
108 pp | £27/$38
for US fashion businesses. It is rooted in a lengthy investigative
Paperback | Autumn 2016
220 x 220mm research project that deployed undergraduate and graduate
eBook available students and faculty researchers to US fashion businesses that
rely on cotton to make their garments – with the goal of bet
Joseph H. Hancock II teaches and ter understanding how such a key resource is sourced, priced,
conducts research at Drexel University
in Philadelphia and is the editor of the transported, manipulated, and, ultimately, sold on to the consumer
journal Fashion, Style and Popular as a stylish garment.
Culture. Nioka Wyatt is assistant
professor in the fashion merchandising & The contributors focus in particular on the role of brands in the
management programme at Philadelphia marketing of cotton goods, and the way that brand marketing
University. Tasha L. Lewis is assistant creates distinctions, valuable in the marketplace, between vari
professor in the Department of Fiber
ous versions of what are at base similar items of clothing, like
Science & Apparel Design at Cornell
University. tshirts and underclothes. The book also explores the importance
of the ‘Made in the USA’ campaign, with its appeal to consum
ers concerned about local manufacturing employment, reduced
resource use, and social responsibility.