Extract From Fred Botting
Extract From Fred Botting
Extract From Fred Botting
understanding…
“The Enlightenment, which produced the maxims and models of modern culture,
also invented the Gothic. Moreover, the Enlightenment can itself be considered a
reinvention, in the sense that the neoclassical values dominating British society in
the eighteenth century constituted a conscious recovery and redeployment of ideas
gleaned from Greek and Roman writers. After the Renaissance, the classical tradition
was associated with civilised, humane and polite civic culture, its moral and aesthetic
values privileged as the basis of virtuous behaviour, harmonious social relations and
mature artistic practices. Eighteenth-century writers liked to refer to their present as
‘modern’ and thus distinct from both a classical antiquity appreciated in its historical
continuity and a feudal past regarded as a barbaric and primitive stage, the
dominance of which had been discontinued. Such an overarching remodelling of
cultural values required an extensive rewriting of history.
Here, the word ‘Gothic’ assumes its powerful, if negative, significance: it condenses a
variety of historical elements and meanings opposed to the categories valued in the
eighteenth century. In this respect, ‘the real history of “Gothic” begins with the
eighteenth century’, when it signified a ‘barbarous', ‘medieval’ and ‘supernatural’ past
(Longueil, 1923, 453–4). Used derogatively about art, architecture and writing that
failed to conform to the standards of neoclassical taste, ‘Gothic’ signified the lack of
reason, morality and beauty of feudal beliefs, customs and works. The projection of
the present onto a Gothic past occurred, however, as part of the wider processes of
political, economic and social upheaval: emerging at a time of bourgeois and
industrial revolution, a time of Enlightenment philosophy and increasingly secular
views, the eighteenth century Gothic fascination with a past of chivalry, violence,
magical beings and malevolent aristocrats is bound up with the shifts from feudal to
commercial practices in which notions of property, government and society were
undergoing massive transformations. Along with these shifts, ideas about nature, art
and subjectivity were also reassessed. ‘Gothic’ thus resonates as much with anxieties
and fears concerning the crises and changes in the present as with any terrors of the
past.”
Fred Botting, ‘In Gothic Darkly: Heterotopia, History, Culture’, A Companion to the
Gothic, ed David Punter, Blackwell: Oxford & London, p. 13.