Hydropolitics of Pakistan
Hydropolitics of Pakistan
Hydropolitics of Pakistan
Introduction
o
Pakistan is one of those states which is blessed with abundance of surface and ground water.
o
Abdul Sattar writes in his book: "As Egypt is the gift of Nile, Pakistan is the gift of Indus" o
Unfortunately, Pakistan despite having all the abundance of water has not properly utilized its
resource.
o
The negotiations and treaties done in the past prove to be of some help to Pakistan's shaky
Hydropolitics.
o
Pakistan needs to focus on its water management policies both inter and intrastate. o It must
also develop a mechanism to resolve water related issues at local levels instead of taking it to
higher offices.
o
But with the increased developments in the region, Hydropolitics has become a political
debate between states and between provinces
o
The only solution to this issue lies in fixing existing minor problems (from infrastructures to
domestic use).
o
It is proved by many international bodies that if Pakistan does not start working on its water
policy and water management, it will become a water stressed country in near future - a
situation that Pakistan can ill afford. The incumbent and future administrations also need to
realize the hardship Pakistan could face due to mismanaged water policy.
Geography
Total Area: 881,913 sq. km
Population: 220,892,340 people
The Rivers
The River Indus and its tributaries are the main source of water supply in Pakistan. Dams and
barrages have been built on the Indus and its tributaries to store water. o Large dams at Tarbela
and Mangla are multipurpose projects storing water, irrigating lands and also generating hydro
electricity.
o
Small dams like those at Khanpur, Rawal and Hub supply water for agriculture, industrial and
domestic use and act as a reservoir as well.
o
Barrages also supply water for irrigation as well as industrial and domestic use.
The Indus
o
The ultimate source of Indus in Tibet, where it emerges from a Tibetan Plateau near a Lake
called "Manasarovar" or "Manas Sarovar".
o
Then it runs through Ladakh region of Indian Occupied Kashmir.
o
And then it moves towards Gilgit-Baltistan, Pakistan Administered Region. o
Then it runs South, along the entire length of Pakistan.
General Terminology
What is a Reservoir?
A reservoir is an enlarged natural or artificial lake or pond, or impoundment created using a dam
to store water.
What is a Hydropower?
Hydropower (or water power) is energy derived from falling-water or fast-running water, which is
harnessed for useful purposes.
OR
Hydroelectric power is produced with moving water. At hydropower plants water flows through a
pipe, or penstock, then pushes against and turns blades in a turbine to spin a generator to
produce electricity.
What is a Dam?
A dam is a barrier that stops or restricts the flow of water. Reservoirs created by dams not only
suppress floods but also provide water for activities such as irrigation, human consumption,
industrial use, aquaculture, and navigability.
What is a Headwork?
Headwork is a civil engineering term for any structure at the head or diversion point of a
waterway. It is smaller than a barrage and is used to divert water from a river into a canal or from
a large canal into a smaller canal.
What is a Barrage?
A barrage is a type of low-head, diversion dam which consists of a number of large gates that can
be opened or closed to control the amount of water passing through. This allows the structure to
regulate and stabilize river water elevation upstream for use in irrigation and other systems.
What is a Canal?
A canal is a manmade waterway that allows boats and ships to pass from one body of water to
another. Canals are also used to transport water for irrigation and other human uses.
What is a Floodgate?
Floodgate, gate for shutting out or releasing the flow of water over spillways, in connection with
the operation of a dam. Vertical lift, or radial, gates rise to permit flow under the gate.
What is a Karez?
A karez is an under ground irrigation tunnel. It has a gentle slope that conveys groundwater using
gravity to the land surface.
Standstill Agreement
Due absence of any arrangement for the sharing of water in those canal commands, the two
countries concluded a standstill agreement until 31 March, 1948, to allow time to reach a longer-
term settlement.
BRBD
This brief episode of the suspension of water supplies alarmed the Pakistani water bureaucracy
into initiating the Bombanwala-Ravi-Bedian-Dipalpur (BRBD) link canal project It allowed flows
from the Ravi River to be diverted to the Sutlej.
2. The Governments
If the commission fails to settle on a common decision the matter can be taken up to the
government level.
Responsibility: Same as above
3. The Neutral Expert
If the government cannot resolve the differences the matter can be taken up to a neutral
expert provided that the neutral expert is appointed and approved by both parties.
Responsibility: Same as mentioned previously
5. Court of Arbitration
If the Neutral expert or WB rules that the decision does not fall under its decision or the
issue is actually a Dispute then the issue must be submitted to the "Court of Arbitration"
whose award is final and binding.
Criticism
o
Nationalist engineers negotiated the IWT, and the treaty did not concern itself with more
contemporary principles of equitable sharing of water between riparians. o The treaty mirrored
the political landscape of that time by simply dividing the basin between the two countries
instead of providing for meaningful cooperative management or sharing.
o
Infrastructure developed under IWT served strategic purposes only (canals for military and
defense) (Indra Gandhi Canal and BRBD)
2. Barrage construction on Jhelum River at the mouth of Wullar Lake (1980s) This water storage
was way above its limit (33 time extra water storage than prescribed limit)
1985: Pakistan raised the issue but no progress was made
1987: Matter was taken to the Governments where India decided to suspend the
construction of the dam.
Later, India argued that Barrage can provide mutual benefit to the states but Pakistan took
no part in this argument.
1989: Pakistan asked India to acknowledge the inconsistency of its project but India refused.
However, India proposed a design change to eliminate any harmful effects on Pakistan.
Compromise drafts were exchanged but no final decision was made. India then unilaterally
suspended implementation of projects due to an uprising in Kashmir.
3. Hydroelectric Power Plant along with a Dam on Chenab River at Baglihar (1999) The reservoir
was far out from the limit and would easily manipulate India to obstruct water flow to
Pakistan.
This was an alarming situation for Pakistan as this project would compel India to completely
stop water supply for "up to 28 days"
And flood Pakistan during "critical wheat growing period of December to February."
Pakistan raised its wishes to visit the site but India delayed the visit.
2001 - 04: Negotiations at Indus Commission were fruitless as India did not agree that it
violated the design agreement under IWT.
2005: Matter was taken up to the Governments. But the stalemate remained unbroken. 12
Feb, 2007: the matter was taken to a neutral expert (WB). As a result, Height of the dam was
reduced by 1.5 meters and pond size reduced by 14%.
4. Hydroelectric Power Plant along with a Dam on Kishanganga Tributary of Jhelum River (2005)
Pakistan raised objection with this project's initial reveal, claiming that diversion of streams
would violate IWT.
The Court of Arbitration allowed India to divert a part of the stream and leave the rest of it to
flow downstream.
Pakistan's Internal Hydropolitics (Intrastate Hydropolitics/ Interprovince
Hydropolitics)
The conflict over water distribution between the dominant Punjab province and remaining smaller
provinces in the federation, particularly Sindh province, has remained peaceful and limited to the
political arena.
Kalabagh Question
o
The Kalabagh Dam controversy—an argument between the dominant Punjab province and
the remaining smaller provinces in Pakistan, especially Sindh, over a proposed storage dam
on the main-stem Indus River in Punjab—is perceived by Sindh as yet another insult that has
been directed at them by the Punjabis in the form of further appropriation of Sindh’s rightful
share of water.
o
Moreover, it is also claimed that Punjab messes up the figures to show water scarcity and
water wastage in order to build the Dam for additional water storage.
o
The Pakistani Water Managers View Kalabagh as an element of misgovernance in both
provinces and a pure engineering issue that can be resolved by changing the design and also
the reluctance of its stake-holders.
o
Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa is concerned about the potential flooding of rich farmland and Pashtun
cultural heartland by the lake that will be created behind the dam. The province is also
reluctant to lend its support to the project because of suspicions based on the poor record of
the Pakistani government in providing for the rehabilitation of those affected by earlier large-
dam projects.
o
The environmentalists argue that instead of coming up with new mega-projects, Pakistan
should focus on existing ones and try to repair and improve their functionality.
Remedies
Local Remedies:
o
Issues of local water problems must be resolved on local levels instead of taking the matter to
higher offices.
o
Municipality must be vigilant in effective water management by working on minor
infrastructure issue, sewage problems, water leakage issues and water supply issues to less
developed localities.
o
Prevention of water theft by controlling the development of secret canals from Punjab to
Sindh.
Political Remedies:
o
Resolving Inter-provincial conflict.
o
Addressing the issues of all provinces especially Sindh.
o
Federal and Provincial Governments must be on the same page to resolve water management
issues.
o
Viewing water crisis as a National issues instead of a provincial one.
o
Minimize international warfare on water by ensuring strong ties with Afghanistan, as Kabul
River is the only water source for Warsak Dam at KP and upper riparians. India has already
started funding Afghanistan for developments (KAMA hydroelectric power plant) which may
lead to future water disputes between Pakistan and Afghanistan. Therefore, a change in
strategy with Afghanistan might help. And Pakistan is already on its way to achieve it (Peace-
talks).
Role of Media:
o
Spreading awareness on importance of water via news channels, newspapers, billboards and
advertisements.
Dissect Projects:
o
Pakistan needs to divide water related projects with respect to time frame required for
completion.
o
This will help in completing short-term projects first and then moving on towards long-term
projects.
o
Projects can also be divided on the basis of Priority. The one that holds more importance
should be completed first.
Critical Analysis (use the Pros and Cons of IWT, Use Critical analysis of
global water crisis and use the Future trajectories and develop your own
narrative and final stance on this issue).
List of Water Supply Systems in
Pakistan
Headworks:
Name Province
Munda Headwork KP
Barrages:
Name Province
Baluchistan
Name Location/ Water Body Height Year of
nearest city completion
Under Base Dam Qila Saifullah Under Base River 50 ft. 1985
Gilgit-Baltistan
Name Location/ Water Body Height Year of completion
nearest city
Satpara Dam Skardu Satpara 128 ft. 2013
Islamabad Capital
Name Location/ Water Body Height Year of completion
nearest city
Rawal Dam Islamabad Capital Korang River 133.5 ft. 1962
Territory
Khyber Pakhtunkhwa
Name Location/ Water Body Height Year of
nearest city completion
Dandy Dam Miranshah 82 ft. 2011
Khan Khwar Besham, Shangla Khan Khwar River 151 ft. 2012
Duber Khwar Pattan, Kohistan Khan Khwar River 320.1 ft. 2013
Punjab
Name Location/ Water Body Height Year of completion
nearest city
Ghazi Barotha Dam Ghazi District Haripur, Indus River 2003
Pakistan
Gurab Dam
Jabbi Dam
Jamal Dam
Jammargal Dam
Jurash Dam
Kahuta Dam
Kanjoor Dam
Khasala Dam
Lehri Dam
Mailsi Dam
Mirwal Dam
Misriot Dam
Nirali Dam
Salial Dam
Shahpur Dam
Shakardara Dam
Dungi Dam
Bhugtal Dam
Chichali Dam
Sindh
Name Location/ Impounds Height Year of completion
nearest city
Darawat Dam Jamshoro District Nari Baran River 141 ft. 2014
Nai Gaj Dam Kirthar Mountains Nai Gaj river 194 ft. 2019
PAST PAPERS
PAK AFFAIRS
∙ 'The twentieth century witnessed the war for oil. The twenty-first century will witness the war
for water'. Examine the practical implications of this statement on situation of Pakistan.
(2013) (P.A)
∙ Critically analyze the key causes of delaying construction of dams in Pakistan. Give some
suggestions to revert this collateral loss. (2019) (P.A)
CURRENT AFFAIRS
∙ Evaluate the significance of water conflict between India and Pakistan in perspective of water
management projects in Indian held Kashmir. (2014) (C.A)
∙ Doyou believe that main cause of 2014 floods was Indian ‘water terrorism’ or it was due to
awful mismanagement of water resources in Pakistan? (2015) (C.A)
∙ What will be the reason of emerging water conflict between Pakistan and Afghanistan? (2019)
(C.A)
∙ What impact global climate change will have on the water resources of Pakistan? How will it
affect inter-provincial harmony? (2020) (C.A)
INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS
∙ Evaluate the significance of water conflict between India and Pakistan in perspective of Indus
Water Treaty. (2017) (I.R 2)
LINKS
http://www.indiandefencereview.com/news/water-availability-in-pakistan/
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_dams_and_reservoirs_in_Pakistan
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_barrages_and_headworks_in_Pakistan
http://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/251191548275645649/pdf/133964-WP-PUBLIC-ADD-SERIES-22-1-
2019- 18-56-25-W.pdf
https://www.globalcitizen.org/en/content/cape-town-water-crisis-day-zero-overflowing-dams/
https://dailytimes.com.pk/666539/water-crisis-a-bigger-threat-than-terrorism/
https://www.renewableenergymagazine.com/panorama/how-energyefficient-technologies-can-help-us-solve-20201013
https://www.worldpoliticsreview.com/articles/29072/in-iraq-water-crisis-deepens-threatening-the-country-s-future
https://transboundarywaters.science.oregonstate.edu/sites/transboundarywaters.science.oregonstate.edu/files/Publica
tions/Rees%2C%20G%202010%20-
%20The%20Role%20of%20Power%20and%20Institutions%20in%20Hydrodiplomacy.pdf
https://www.usip.org/sites/default/files/resources/SR261%20-%20Hydropolitics_in_Pakistan's%20_Indus_Basin.pdf
Videos
How a Dam Works
Hydropower 101