Challenges of e Learning in Developing C
Challenges of e Learning in Developing C
Challenges of e Learning in Developing C
discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: http://www.researchgate.net/publication/267926328
DOWNLOADS VIEWS
191 58
3 AUTHORS, INCLUDING:
Abstract
Uganda introduced universal primary education (UPE) in 1997 and the country witnessed a dramatic
increase in the enrolment in primary education countrywide which also increased the ratio of pupils-to-
teachers, classroom congestion and limited learning resources thereby forcing schools to teach in
sessions (morning and afternoon) for nearly all classes. Over time, this high enrolment with all its
problems were transferred to secondary schools prompting the government of Uganda to introduce
universal secondary education (USE), and several years later this effect reached the universities. To
overcome these challenges, the universities and higher learning institutions adopted the use of
information and communication technologies, also referred to as e-learning in their academic
environments to facilitate teaching, learning and collaboration. The adoption of and implementation of
e-learning was met with numerous challenges and constraints and this paper therefore investigates
the challenges faced as a result of large classes consequential from bulky enrolment and also
explores the measure in context to their academic environment that were adopted to overcome the
limitations.
Keywords: challenges, e-learning, ICT, developing countries, pedagogy, measure, context.
1 INTRODUCTION
Educational opportunities in Africa have grown considerably since the 1950s [1], especially with the
involvement of the private sector and is marked by the increased enrolment at all levels. This growth
was more evident in the 1990s when the whole world collectively agreed to implement and fund
education for all (EFA) initiative with the one goal to provide universal access to free, quality and
compulsory education by 2015 [2]. EFA which aimed at providing education to all people regardless of
age, gender but most especially to marginalized groups especially the girl child began to be discussed
and its goals were established in Jomtien (Thailand) in 1990 and reaffirmed in 2000 in Dakar
(Senegal) [2] grew into a reality with the support of interagency commission comprising of UNDP,
UNESCO, UNICEF and World Bank [3] became to be known as the Millennium Development Goals
(MDGs) and it started to be implemented in many developing countries in order to reduce the number
of uneducated youths in Africa [4]. The manifesto of the MDGs then set that “all children in the world
must complete primary school, boys and girls must have equal access to education at all levels by
2015 [5]. Many governments around the world have been busy implementing this goal and in the last
nearly two decades, numerous countries in the sub-Saharan Africa (SSA) including Uganda began to
institute policies aimed at achieving this goal, by introducing universal primary education (UPE) in
order to eliminate financial barriers to education by subsidizing it by 50% [1], increase access and
equality and the quality of education. UPE became viewed as the elimination of primary school fees in
government aided (public) schools. The elimination of fees in the public schools in the different SSA
countries was conducted differently and at different times, though Uganda was the first to introduce it
in Eastern Africa
Uganda, located in East Africa and along the equator, with an estimated population of 34million people
by 2012 [6] and 50.1% of the population are below 15years of age [7] and it is projected that about
86% of this population live in rural areas [8] and earn their living from subsistent agriculture leaving
only 14 % of the population as urban dwellers. Also, 31 % of this entire population live below the
international poverty line [8]. Uganda became one of the SSA countries that started UPE in January
1997 [5],[1], then immediately the country witnessed a tremendously high increase in enrolment at all
levels in primary schools countrywide, from nearly 3 million in 1996 to 5.3 in 1997 and a phenomenal
7.5 million in 2007 [9]. This shot in enrolment was somewhat a good sign of an effort in reducing the
level of poverty but along with it came other enormous challenges in the short run. These challenges
3536
several other initiatives undertaken by the government of Uganda nearly around the same period
included the Complementary Opportunities for Primary Education (COPE) [5] which is a program
targeting children who were unable to attend the formal primary education. Most of the children in this
category were orphans, children of poor peasants who could not afford fees and/or children from large
families.
All these programs and government initiatives paved way for the inauguration of UPE in Uganda in the
early 1990s and in January 1999, UPE was birthed in the Uganda, Pearl of Africa.
2.2 Collaboration
ICT was built with the facilities and capabilities that enhance collaboration between groups of
individuals located in different geographical areas. The birth of these new technologies for education
has given birth to new terms like social computing [18] which when employed for learning, it also gives
rise to other new terms such as collaborative learning, which refers to the methodologies and
environments in which learners engage in a common task in which each individual depends on and is
accountable to each other [19]. With the inter-connection of ICT tools, devices and equipment located
in different places, users can comfortably connect to one another and collaborate on unlimited tasks
using these technologies as a platform.
3537
2.3 Data Capture
ICTs has provided individuals and organizations with the facilities that enable a vast range of data to
be gathered from far and wide and stored on a central repository. For example, historical,
environmental, academic, political and business data has all been captured and stored in and using
these ICT facilities. The storage is centrally done, but access can be remotely and concurrently done
by any authorised persons. These systems that provide the capture and storage also provide security
and safety to the data as well as maintaining integrity of the data, for future retrieval.
3 E-LEARNING
The integration and utilization of ICT tools and services in education otherwise referred to as e-
learning, presents enormous opportunities to significantly facilitate the effectiveness of delivering the
learning contents and gaining access to immense pool of educational information if appropriately
utilized, and it has also gained global recognition as a method to improve the teaching and learning
processes aimed at creating an economy powered by technology and propelled by information and
knowledge [16]. E-learning in universities and institutions of higher learning has been used both by
students and staff in the process of exchanging information and gaining knowledge [20] as well as for
communication and access to educational information. There are other uses such as for conducting
online classes, whereby the teacher and the students are in remote places but are able to conduct
lessons in class with the help of these technological tools and services. The basic components of e-
learning includes sets of computers (clients) from where users access materials and another computer
(server) on which the learning materials and knowledge contents are centrally stored, for collaboration
among the students in their learning processes and among the teachers for research,
In general, e-learning technologies are used to deliver learning instructions to learners who are
located in remote areas from a central site using computers, mobile phones, over computer networks,
internet connections and other methods of connection at cheaper cost. It was also established that
these technologies helps in conducting course related research and facilitates timely feedback to the
instructors and administrators as well as providing timely information and statistics about learners’
studying habits such as frequency of login and access of learning content, progress on courses, and
scores in each course. Recent innovations in e-learning allows education to be individualized
(adaptive learning), it enhances learners interactions with each other (collaborative learning), and it
transforms the role of the teacher [21].
3538
4 CHALLENGES
While the e-learning integration has witnessed enormous success and there are several success
stories to prove this, it has as well presented great challenges in equal measures to these institutions
of higher learning in Uganda. It was noted that the challenges were basically the same in almost all
the institutions, some of the institutions experienced a specific and contextual challenges different
from others. It is therefore important to understand these challenges so as to mitigate its effect on the
quality of education services and as well to give an opportunity for any other institutions preparing to
adopt these technologies in their academic setting to understand the difficulties ahead and plan well in
preparation.
4.2 Equipment
First of all, in Africa the cost of acquisition of ICT equipment, for example computers remains high and
internet access is excessively expensive [24], and institutions usually do not have adequate funds to
obtain sufficient equipment to implement a sustainable e-learning system. At times they may be able
to acquire these equipment but sustaining a reliable system becomes an issue over time. Apart from
the high costs of equipment in developing countries, many times the technological market in Africa is
also flooded with counterfeit products which are sold expensively as well. It becomes difficult for the
technologically inadequate professionals in these countries to differentiate between original and
counterfeit equipment.
On the other hand, in most parts of Africa, technological equipment, devices and tools suffer the
effects of environment over time. For example, the accumulation of dust inside the computers renders
it functionless eventually and the heat during dry season causes over heating of equipment and
reduces its life-span and functioning since the many of the institutions, organizations and schools do
not install air conditioning in their computer rooms. Due to environmental factors especially high
temperatures and dusts and lack of routine service and maintenance, some computers were rendered
unusable in some of the institutions. For example at one institution, a systems administrator revealed
that about one quarter of their computers in the laboratory is inaccessible because of virus infections
and functionless processors resulting from accumulation of dusts. He went on to explain that the
situation worsened when the university failed to procure the tools for servicing and maintaining those
3539
computers and also because their antivirus had expired since it was a free one downloaded from the
internet.
4.4 Pedagogy
It is evident that ICT is a new subject field in non-western countries [25] as compared to other areas
such as social sciences and business studies, not all universities offer degree study programs in ICT
related studies and therefore there are not so many professionals in this field. In most cases, it is
studied as a short course and or integrated into another study program as a course usually teaches
only the basics and within a single semester. And in the past, numerous students were taking degree
programs in ICT or computer science studies in universities in Europe and other foreign countries
outside Africa. Therefore, it is clear that many people are not well familiarized in the use and
application of ICTs in day to day activities and hence their knowledge and skills in ICT related work is
low compared to those in developed countries. However, their skills come from the use of basic
applications and or game playing on the computer. There are a number of people who studied
certificate in computer applications but due to inaccessibility of computers, their skills have
degenerated and need to learn again. While a large number of people are so poor that they cannot
afford to take studies in computer since the tuition is much higher than any other study programs.
There are therefore many issues that affect the pedagogy of e-learning in a developing country like
Uganda. These have been identified to include background education, cultural and ethical
orientations, poverty levels and religious inclinations; which all together create a wide diversity in the
educational environment to deal with. Education in Uganda was introduced by the missionaries [11] in
the 1880’s and has ever since undergone several modifications [26]. At the same time, the system of
education also has a background of Islamic education Islam as a religion was introduced in Uganda in
1844 by Muslim Arabs [27] and started Quran schools where most Muslim parents take their children,
but it is not clear when a curriculum for Islamic education was introduced. These differences in the
religious educational background offer a great diversity to deal with in terms of an acceptable
pedagogical method.
3540
the universities and institutions therefore adopted a blended approach to e-learning implementation. In
this approach, both the traditional teaching methodologies (face to face) and technology - enhanced
(online) learning were both implemented concurrently [28]. Both the students and the tutors
communicate, receive and deliver learning materials and access information using the traditional
methods such as face-to-face discussions with tutors periodically as well as using the ICT tools and
services to access learning content from the central repository whenever they can.
For example, at the beginning of the semester, the students converge at the university for orientation
and to pick learning materials for the new semester and to meet their instructors, get their contacts
and know all the important dates (for assignments, tests, face-to-face and examination). And towards
the end of the semester, they again converge at the university for a face-to-face residential session
with all the tutors for all courses. During this session, the students interact with the lecturers to resolve
any learning difficulties faced during self-study periods and at the end of this session, they do a final
end of semester sit-down university examination and break for vacation
3541
6 CONCLUSION
This study has identified that the preparation for education for all in Uganda began earlier than the
quest to fulfil the MDGs as well as preparation for UPE in Uganda also began before the global push
for it.
It can then be concluded that, the universities and higher education institutions in Uganda have
identified the potentials that ICT presents to education, but the implementation of these new
technologies took them by surprise without adequate preparations.
The integration and utilization of these tools for education had no proper guideline or sets of rule for
implementation, each and every institution managed their own affair in the integration process and
therefore there was no uniformity in the process.
Insufficient funds and inadequate levels of skills in the use of these technologies is the centre of all
challenges in the implementation of this great educational endeavour. It was acknowledged that most
universities do not receive external funds but rely heavily on the tuition fees collection from students
therefore; most of it goes into the daily operations and staff wages. They therefore do not have
sufficient funds to undertake big projects like the implementation of e-learning effectively.
REFERENCES
[1] Frederick W. Juuko and Constance Kabonesa. (2007) Universal Primary Education (U.P.E) in
Contemporary Uganda: A Right or Privilege? Human Rights and Peace Centre, HURIPEC
Working Paper No. 8
[2] UNICEF, UNESCO. (2007) A Human Rights-Based Approach to Education for all
[3] Inter-Agency Commission, Final Report. World Conference on Education for All: Meeting basic
Learning Needs, Jomtien, Thailand
[4] United Nations. (2000) Millennium Development Goals. Millennium Summit of the United
Nations.
[5] Louise Grogan. (2006) Who Benefits from Universal Primary Education in Uganda?
[6] http://www.popsec.org/key_facts.php#population_size. Population Secretariat, Ministry of
Finance, Planning and Economic development (2012) The Republic of Uganda. Accessed on
15th February 2012
[7] http://www.nationmaster.com/country/ug-uganda/peo-people Nation Master, Facts and
th
Statistics. Ugandan People Data. Accessed on 15 February 2012
[8] http://www.farmafrica.org.uk/where-we-work/uganda Farm Africa, Uganda. Facts about Uganda.
th
(Accessed in 15 Feb 2012)
[9] Mikiko Nishimura, Keiichi Ogawa, Daniel N. Sifuna, Joseph Chimombo, Demis Kunje Joseph
Ghartey Ampiah, Albert Byamugisha, Nobuhide Sawamura and Shoko Yamada. (2009) A
Comprehensive Analysis of Universal Primary Education Policy in Ghana, Kenya, Malawi and
Uganda, Journal of International Cooperation in Education. Vol 12.
[10] Fred Kirungi. (2000) Uganda Tackling School Bottlenecks African Recovery
[11] Jessica Norah Aguti. (2002) Facing up the Challenges of Universal Primary Education, (UPE) in
Uganda Through Distance Teacher Eductaion rogrammes. PAN Commonwelath Forum on
Open Learning: Open Learning: Transforming Education for Development
[12] Evelyn Kigozi Kahiigi, Love Ekenberg, Henrik hanson, Mats Danielson and F. F Tusubira.
(2008) Explorative Study of E-learning in Developing Contries: A Case of Uganda Education
System. Proceeding at IADIS Internal Conference e-learning, 2008
[13] Uganda Ministry of Education and Sports. (1999) The Ugandan Experience of Universal
Primary Education. Government of the Republic of Uganda.
st
[14] Ron Oliver. (n.d.) The Role of ICT in Higher Education for the 21 Century: ICT as a Change
Agent for Education.
[15] Wadi D. Haddad and Sonia Juric (n.d.) ICT for Education: Potential and Potency
[16] Victoria L. Tinio (n.d.) ICT in Education
3542
[17] http://www.un-gaid.org/tabid/885/Default.aspx United Nations, Department of Economi and
th
Social Affairs. ICTs in Education. Global Alliance for ICT and Development. Accessed on 15
February 2012
[18] Kirsti Ala-Mutka, Yves Punie and Christine Redecker.(2008) ICT for Learning, Innovation and
Creativity. Policy Brief. JRC, European Commission. Institute for Prospective Technological
Skills
[19] http://sydney.edu.au/education_social_work/learning_teaching/ict/theory/collaborative_learning.
shtml Collaborative Learning. University of Sydney. Faculty of Education and Social Work.
th
Accessed on 15 Febraury
[20] A. S. Sife, E. T. Lwoga and C. Sanga. (2007) New Technologies for Teaching and Learning:
Challenges for Higher Insitutions in Developing Countries. International Journal of Education
and Development using Inforation and Communication Technologies (IJEDICT). 2007, Vol. 3,
Issue 2, pp. 57-67
[21] Jorge G. Ruiz, Michael J. Mintzer and Rosanne M. Leipzig. (2006) The Impact of E-Learning in
Medical Education. Publication in the Academic Medicine, Vol. 81, No. 3/2006
[22] http://in.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20090214023227AA7oZye Yahoo Answers.
th
Computer and Unemployment. Accessed 16 February 2012
[23] http://www.geek.com/articles/chips/writer-claims-robots-will-cause-massive-unemployment-
th
2003087/. geek.com. Writer Claims Robots will cause Massive Unemployment. Accessed 16
February 2012
[24] Peter G. Mwesige. (2003) Cyber Elites: A Survey of Internet Café Users in Uganda.
[25] Erkki Sutinen. (2006) Ethnocomputing in Tanzania: Design and Analysis of a Contextualized
ICT Course. A Publication in Research and Practice in Technology Enhanced Education. Vol. 1,
No. 3 (2006) 239-267
[26] Doris Kakuru Muhwezi. (2003) Gender sensitive Educational Policy and Practice: A Uganda
Case study.
[27] Fred Sheldon Mwesigwa. (2009) Historical Context of Religious Conflict and Religious
Education Curriculum.
[28] John Watson. (2008) Blended learning: The Convergence of Online and Face-to-Face
Education. The Promising Practices in Online Learning
3543