Kaizene 2 Edite
Kaizene 2 Edite
Kaizene 2 Edite
TVET –Program Title: ITSM AND DATABASE ADMINISTRATION Level: IV & III Year: I
This module aims to provide the trainees with the knowledge, skills and right attitude required to participate in the planning
process and to contribute to the development of a strategic plan..
Leaning Objectives:
Learning outcomes:
Introduction
5S is amongst the first and fundamental steps implemented by an enterprise towards the path of implementing Total
Quality Management and continuous improvement at the operation level. 5S is a process designed to organize the
workplace, keep it clean, and maintain effective and standard conditions. It instills the discipline required to enable each
individual to achieve and maintain a world-class environment. The use of this tool was started in 1972 by Henry Ford
in the United States as the CANDO program: Cleaning up, Arranging, Neatness, Discipline and Ongoing improvement.
The technique was popularized as ‘Japanese 5S’ in 1980 by HiroyukiHirano.
Many enterprises have practiced the 5S and derived significant benefits from it. In particular, this technique has been
widely practiced in Japan. Most Japanese 5Spractitioners consider 5S useful not just for improving their physical
environment, but also for improving their thinking processes too. In Japan it is also called ‘ workplace management’.
5S will be needed if the workplace is messy and unorganized. It will also be needed if employees spend extra time in
searching tools, papers, information, etc.
What Is 5S?
5S is a method of creating a self-sustaining culture which perpetuates a neat, clean, efficient workplace; a
method for removing all excess materials and tools from the workplace and organizing the required items
such that they are easy to find, use, and maintain.
3. Shine (Seiso)
Deviations become visual by cleaning: “Cleaning = inspection; Cleaning with meaning”
4. Standardize (Seiketsu)
Visualize the 5S standards in the workplace: “Make the best way the easiest way”
5. Sustain (Shitsuke)
Everybody follows the standard until we have a better one:“Stick to it!”
Why do we practice the 5S?
The general concept of the 5S is that they are intended to eliminate waste. Working in disorder is neither
productive, nor safe. 5S is a simple and practical method to instill a quality culture at the work place. It is relatively
easy to undertake, and requires minimal additional resources. The first and small investment made in time and
effort pays off in a much bigger manner when the results are realized and maintained.
Among the main benefits of implementing 5S are:
The workplace becomes cleaner, safer, well-organized and more pleasant
Floor space utilization is improved
Workflow becomes smoother and more systematic and non-value added activities are reduced;
Time for searching tools, materials and document is minimized;
Machi ne breakdowns are reduced since clean and well-maintained equipment breaks down less frequently
and it also becomes easier to diagnose and repair before breakdowns occur, therefore extending equipment life;
Errors are minimized leading to making defect-free products;
Consumables and material wastage are minimized;
The morale and satisfaction of employees improves; and
The productivity of the organization improves together with the quality of products and services.
Introduction
A successful operation in the hospitality industry requires efficient management of personnel and cooperation between
many different skilled professionals. Working in this type of international setting can seem like a puzzle. To make it
work, you must not only be familiar with the job specifications for your colleagues, but you must also be very familiar
with your suppliers and customers. A job specification describes the knowledge, skills, education, abilities and
experience that are essential to a particular job. In short, a job specification describes the exact person that a company
requires for a particular role.
Institution Name Document No.
A piece of work, especially a specific task done as part of the routine of one's occupation or for an
agreed price.
A post of employment; full-time or part-time position
Anything a person is expected or obliged to do; duty; responsibility
An affair, matter, occurrence, or state of affairs.
The material, project, assignment, etc., being worked upon
The process or requirements, details, etc., of working.
The execution or performance of a task
The requirements for a job vary according to the nature of the job itself. However, a certain work ethic must be
cultivated to succeed in any job and this is fundamental to an individual’s sense of himself as a worker, as part of
production relations and a fundamental economic being. The basic requirements for a job remain the same no
matter what the job is, where it is located or what professional and educational qualifications are required for it.
These are as follows:
and certificates. However education is not limited to what is taught in colleges or vocational training courses. It is
the burning desire to learn more, to reach the depths of knowledge about a particular field of interest, to complete
the job and learn from it that marks the true enthusiast and the truly learned.
Soft Skills: Soft skills include those skills which ensure that a job is executed well, and the employee can carry
himself in the proper manner too. For example, good and smooth communication, computer skills, proficiency in
language if needed, presentable appearance, the ability to manage crises are all soft skills which are fundamentally
important in any job and which must be cultivated consciously.
Experience: The number of years of experience you have had in the role in which you desire to fill. A job
specification will detail the number of years of work experience a candidate needs in order to successfully fill
Institution Name Document No.
a position. Positions that require more complex and responsible duties, and supervisory and managerial roles,
will always require more work experience.
Overview of Job Duties: This is where the employer repeats the requirements and activities that the
prospective employee must undertake in the position.
Thus, the requirements of a job, though specific to it, cover also a general spectrum.
These make for better employees and better individuals.
1. Work Instruction
Information about the work
Describe what workers need to be able to do on the job
Work functions
Key activities of each work function
Performance indicators
Personal protective equipment include those prescribed under legislation/ regulations/codes of practice and
workplace policies and practices. Safe operating procedures include the conduct of operational risk assessment and
treatments associated with workplace organization. Emergency procedures include emergency shutdown and
stopping of equipment, extinguishing fires, enterprise first aid requirements and site evacuation.
Occupational safety and health (OSH) also commonly referred to as occupational health and safety (OHS) or
workplace health and safety (WHS) is an area concerned with the safety, health and welfare of people engaged in
work or employment. The goals of occupational safety and health programs include fostering a safe and healthy
work environment. OSH may also protect co-workers, family members, employers, customers, and many others
who might be affected by the workplace environment. In the United States the term occupational health and safety
is referred to as occupational health and occupational and non-occupational safety and includes safety for activities
outside work.
Occupational safety and health can be important for moral, legal, and financial reasons. In common-law
jurisdictions, employers have a common law duty (reflecting an underlying moral obligation) to take reasonable
care for the safety of their employees. Statute law may build upon this to impose additional general duties,
introduce specific duties and create government bodies with powers to regulate workplace safety issues: details of
this will vary from jurisdiction to jurisdiction. Good OSH practices can also reduce employee injury and illness
related costs, including medical care, sick leave and disability benefit costs.
As defined by the World Health Organization (WHO) "occupational health deals with all aspects of health and
safety in the workplace and has a strong focus on primary prevention of hazards." Health has been defined as "a
state of complete physical, mental and social well-being and not merely the absence of disease or infirmity.
Occupational health is a multidisciplinary field of healthcare concerned with enabling an individual to undertake
their occupation, in the way that causes least harm to their health. It contrasts, for example, with the promotion of
health and safety at work, which is concerned with preventing harm from any incidental hazards, arising in the
workplace.
Institution Name Document No.
Since 1950, the International Labor Organization (ILO) and the World Health Organization (WHO) have shared a
common definition of occupational health. It was
Adopted by the Joint ILO/WHO Committee on Occupational Health at its first session in 1950 and revised at its
twelfth session in 1995. The definition reads: "The main focus in occupational health is on three different
objectives: (i) the maintenance and promotion of workers’ health and working capacity; (ii) the improvement of
working environment and work to become conducive to safety and health and (iii) development of work
organizations and working cultures in a direction which supports health and safety at work and in doing so also
promotes a positive social climate and smooth operation and may enhance productivity of the undertakings.
Joint ILO/WHO Committee on Occupational Health: those in the field of occupational health come from a wide
range of disciplines and professions including medicine,
Psychology, epidemiology, physiotherapy and rehabilitation, occupational, occupational medicine, human
factors and ergonomics, and many others. Professionals advise on a
broad range of occupational health matters. These include how to avoid particular pre-existing conditions causing
a problem in the occupation, correct posture for the work, frequency of rest breaks, preventative action that can be
undertaken, and so forth.
"Occupational health should aim at: the promotion and maintenance of the highest degree of physical, mental and
social well-being of workers in all occupations; the prevention amongst workers of departures from health caused
by their working conditions; the protection of workers in their employment from risks resulting from factors
adverse to health; the placing and maintenance of the worker in an occupational environment adapted to his
physiological and psychological capabilities; and, to summarize, the adaptation of work to man and of each man to
his job.
While top management has the ultimate responsibility for the safety and health program in an enterprise, authority
for ensuring safe operation should be delegated to all management levels. Supervisors are obviously the key
individuals in such a program because they are in constant contact
Management commitment and resources
With the employees. As safety officers, they act in a staff capacity to help administer safety policy, to provide
technical information, to help with training and to supply program material.
Total commitment on the part of management to making safety and health a priority is essential to a successful OHS
program in the workplace. It is only when management plays a positive role that workers view such program as a
worthwhile and sustainable exercise. The boardroom has the influence, power and resources to take initiatives and to
set the pattern for a safe and healthy working environment.
Management commitment to occupational safety and health may be demonstrated in various us ways, such as:
Allocate sufficient resources (financial and human) for the proper functioning of the occupational
safety and health program;
Establishing organizational structures to support managers and employees in their OSH duties;
Designating a senior management representative to be responsible for overseeing the proper
functioning of OHS management.
Institution Name Document No.
The process of organizing and running an OSH system requires substantial capital investment.
To manage safety and health efficiently, adequate financial resources must be allocated within business units as part of
overall running costs. The local management team must understand the Value that corporate leaders place on
providing a safe place of work for employees.
There should be incentives for managers to ensure that resources are deployed for all aspects of safety and health. The
challenge is to institutionalize safety and health within the planning process. Once the program is under way,
concerted efforts must be made to guarantee its sustainability
Workplace hazards
Although work provides many economic and other benefits, a wide array of workplace hazards also present risks to the
health and safety of people at work. These include "chemicals, biological agents, physical factors, adverse ergonomic
conditions, allergens, a complex network of safety risks," and a broad range of psychosocial risk factors
Physical hazards are a common source of injuries in many industries. They are perhaps unavoidable in certain
industries, such as construction and mining, but over time people have developed safety methods and
procedures to manage the risks of physical danger in the workplace. Employment of children may pose special
problems. Falls are a common cause of occupational injuries and fatalities, especially in construction,
extraction, transportation, healthcare, and building cleaning and maintenance
The transportation sector bears many risks for the health of commercial drivers, too, for example from vibration,
long periods of sitting, work stress and exhaustion. These problems Occur in Europe but in other parts of the
world the situation is even worse. More drivers die in accidents due to security defects in vehicles. Long waiting
times at borders cause that drivers are away from home and family much longer and even increase the risk of HIV
infections.
Confined spaces also present a work hazard. The National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health defines
"confined space" as having limited openings for entry and exit and unfavorable natural ventilation, and which is not
intended for continuous employee occupancy. Spaces of this kind can include storage tanks, ship compartments,
sewers, and pipelines. Confined spaces can pose a hazard not just to workers, but also to people who try to rescue
them.
Noise also presents a fairly common workplace hazard: occupational hearing loss is the most common
work-related injury in the United States, with 22 million workers exposed to hazardous noise levels at work
and an estimated $242 million spent annually on worker's compensation for hearing loss disability. Noise is
not the only source of occupational hearing loss; exposure to chemicals such as aromatic solvents and
metals including lead, arsenic, and mercury can also cause hearing loss.
Institution Name Document No.
The Act
The Occupational Health and Safety Act 2004 (the Act) is the cornerstone of legislative and
administrative measures to improve occupational health and safety in Victoria. The Act sets out the key
principles, duties and rights in relation to occupational health and safety.
The Regulations
The Occupational Health and Safety Regulations 2007 are made under the Act. They specify the ways duties
imposed by the Act must be performed, or prescribe procedural or administrative matters to support the Act, such
as requiring licenses for specific activities, keeping records, or notifying certain matters.
Guidance
Effective OHS regulation requires that Work Safe provides clear, accessible advice and guidance about what
constitutes compliance with the Act and Regulations. This can be achieved through Compliance Codes, Work Safe
Positions and non-statutory guidance ("the OHS compliance framework"). For a detailed explanation of the OHS
compliance framework, see the Victorian Occupational Health and Safety Compliance Framework Handbook.
Policy
Not every term in the legislation is defined or explained in detail. Also, sometimes new circumstances arise
(like increases in non-standard forms of employment, such as casual, labour hire and contract work, or completely
new industries with new technologies which produce new hazards and risks) which could potentially impact on
the reach of the law, or its effective administration by Work Safe. Therefore, from time to time Work Safe
must make decisions about how it will interpret something that is referred to in legislation, or act on a particular
issue, to ensure clarity. In these circumstances, Work Safe will develop a policy. A policy is a statement of
what Work Safe understands something to mean, or what Work Safe will do in certain circumstances
Observing personnel protection
Overview of Protection
For every tool there is the right job, and for every job there is the right tool. Ensure that you are
familiar with the correct use of each tool and that the right tool is used for the current task.
This will reduce the chances of damage or injury. Skilled use of tools and software makes
the job less difficult and ensures that tasks are performed properly and safely. The Figure shows a
sample tool kit used to install, connect, remove, and repair PC components.
In addition to hardware tools, software tools are also available that help diagnose problems and
determine which computer device is not functioning correctly.
Identify Hardware Tools and Their Purpose
A tool kit should contain all the tools necessary to complete hardware repairs. Hardware tools are
grouped into the following four categories:
ESD tools
There are also devices that enable us to protect ESD. These devices include:
A. Anti- Anti-static wristband: these devices have a strap that you wrap around
your wrist or ankle on one end. The other end of the strap is attached
computer case to keep ground between the computer and you.
B. Anti-static mats: these are mats that you place on the work surface and on the
floor in front of work area. They make an excellent place to place your tools and
components when you work on a system.
Anti-static bags (pouches): they have special coating or filament that prevents ESD. They are used to store any sensitive
electronic device like cards, RAM, drives, etc when they are not installed in a computer.
Hand Tools
Most tools used in the computer assembly process are small hand tools. The list that
follows describes the small hand tools that you will most commonly use:
Torx screwdriver: Used to tighten or loosen screws that have a star-like depression on
the top, a feature that is mainly found on laptops.
Institution Name Document No.
Hex driver: Sometimes called a nut driver, this tool is used to tighten nuts in the same way that a
screwdriver tightens screws.
Needle-nose pliers: Used to hold small parts.
Wire cutters: Used to strip and cut wires.
Tweezers: Used to manipulate small parts.
Part retriever: Used to retrieve parts from locations that are too small for your hand to fit in.
Flashlight: Used to illuminate areas that you cannot see well.
Cleaning Tools
The appropriate cleaning tools are essential when maintaining or repairing computers. The list that follows
describes the cleaning tools that you will most commonly use:
Soft sloth: Used to clean different computer components without scratching or leaving debris.
Compressed air: Used to blow away dust and debris from different computer parts without
touching the components.
Cable ties: Used to bundle cables neatly inside and outside of a computer.
Parts organizer: Used to hold screws, jumpers, fasteners, and other small parts to prevent them from
getting mixed together
Diagnostic Tools
To test hardware, you will use the following diagnostic tools:
Digital multi meter: Used to test the integrity of circuits and the quality of electricity in
computer components.
Loopback adapter: Used to test the basic functionality of computer ports.
Institution Name Document No.
An inventory list is kept in every toolbox to be checked before and after each job or maintenance action, to ensure that all
tools are available to do your work, and to ensure that they are accounted for
4. Use Each Equipment Only For The Job It Was Designed To Do.
Each particular type of tool has a specific purpose. If you use the wrong tool when performing
maintenance or repairs, you may cause damage to the equipment you're working on or damage the
tool itself. Remember, improper use of tools results in improper maintenance. Improper maintenance
results in damage to equipment and possible injury or death to you or others.
Always avoid placing tools on or above machinery or an electrical apparatus. Never leave tools un
attended where Computers or Electrical equipments are running.
6. Identify Safety Procedures to Protect Equipment from Damage and Data from Loss
Static electricity is the buildup of an electric charge resting on a surface. This buildup and sudden release of
energy, called electrostatic discharge (ESD), can be destructive to the electronics in a computer system.
ESD can cause permanent damage to electrical components. Follow these recommendations to help prevent
ESD damage:
Keep all components in antistatic bags until you are ready to install them.
Use grounded mats on workbenches and on the work area floor.
Use antistatic wrist straps when working on computers.
Avoid working on carpeted areas if possible.
Climate also affects risks when working with computer equipment. Consider the following
recommendations:
If the environment temperature is too high, equipment can overheat.
If the humidity level is too low, the chance of ESD increases.
If the humidity level is too high, equipment can suffer from moisture
damage.
Preparing and using tools and equipment to implement 3S
Introduction
3S Principles are your reliable instruments to make a break-through in improving your work environment and staff
attending various types of jobs in your Project or Instituti on. This is not only a concept but also a set of actions
which have to be conducted systematically with the full participation of staff serving in the Project or Institution.
3S activities are practiced in a real participatory movement to improve the quality of both the work environment
and service contents delivered to your clients.
Sponges brooms
Brushes spades
vacuum cleaners waste baskets
dust bins gloves
dust masks detergents
containers oils
bolts screws
boots shoes Et
Institution Name Document No.
Samples of slogan
LO2: Standardize 3S
This learning guide is developed to provide you the necessary information regarding the
following content coverage and topics:
Preparing and following plan
Benefits of standardizing 3S
Preparing and implementing tools and techniques to standardize 3S.
Institution Name Document No.
Lead-time reduced
Changeover time reduced by streamlining operations.
Breakdowns and minor stops eliminated on production lines.
Defects reduced by mistake proofing.
Clear methods and standards are established.
In-process inventory is reduced.
Space usage is improved.
Customer complaints are reduced.
Keys to 5s Success
In order for the 5S system to be successful, the most important factor is the commitment, participation and
involvement of everyone and strong visible support from top management. Generally, 5S activities should be
carried out systematically as follows:
Visit 5S model companies for continual improvement.
Train everyone adequately on 5S Practices.
Promote 5S Campaign.
Plan systematic approach following the Plan-Do-Check-Act (P-D-C-A) Cycle.
Practice Performance Measurement and Reward System.
How to Initiate 5s Implementation
The 5S approach outlined in this guidebook is a simple and systematic methodology which can be
introduced and implemented in any size and type of organization. To start the 5S: Step-by-Step
Implementation, each phase must be thoroughly analyzed and addressed using the P-D-C-A Cycle and
5W1Happroach as follows:
PLAN
Preparation:
Provide training and education for everyone.
Form 5S Council.
Set-up 5S Zones.
Determine 5S objectives, goals and implementation phases.
Plan 5S action plan and 5S Launch.
DO
Sort:
Identify what is necessary
Set in Order:
Define what and how to arrange.
Shine:
Identify dirt sources.
Identify root causes.
Take action to eliminate dirt sources and root causes.
Standardize:
Who is responsible?
What actions to take to maintain the desired condition?
When must those actions be taken?
Where must they apply?
Institution Name Document No.
Ensure that all the three pillars are maintained in their fully implemented state.
Muda elimination
Quality improvements
Institution Name Document No.
Cost improvements
Process improvements
Institution Name Document No.
ወ/ሮ ስህን ቴክኒክና ሙያ ኮሌጅ OF/WSPC /263-01
W/RO SIHEEN TECHNICAL AND VOCATIONAL COLLEGE
Issue No. Page No.
Title:
2 Page 48 of
TTLM
48
Page 23 of 53
Institution Name Document No.
ወ/ሮ ስህን ቴክኒክና ሙያ ኮሌጅ OF/WSPC /263-01
W/RO SIHEEN TECHNICAL AND VOCATIONAL COLLEGE
Issue No. Page No.
Title:
2 Page 48 of
TTLM
48
'continuously," B for "daily (mornings)," C for "daily (evenings), " D for "weekly," E for "monthly" and F for
"occasionally." Each 5S job assignee can then use these charts as 5S Checklists. This particular example shows
clearly who is responsible for each job, which area, what to do, and when to do it
Visual 5S
The Visual 55 approach makes the level of five pillar conditions obvious at a glance. This is particularly helpful
in factories that handle a great variety and number of materials. The main point of Visual 5S is that anyone should
be able to distinguish between abnormal and normal conditions at a glance.
As a factory example, consider a drill-press process where Set in order has been applied so that the position and
amount of each finished work piece is clearly indicated. As an additional visual aid, the place where the last batch
item goes can be marked with a thick red line to indicate that it is time to stop and send the batch to the next
process.
Five- Minute 5S
When using the Visual 5S approach, instant visibility can act as a trigger for taking immediate three pillar
action(Sort, Set in Order, and Shine activities) against the discovered abnormalities (i.e., overproduction,
disorder, and contamination). We must also deal with the question of how ski llfully and efficiently these actions
are carried out. Instead of following two hours for removing all of the cutting shavings from the floor, we can
set up a half-hour or a one-hour Shine procedure that accomplishes the same task. The term "Five-Minute 5S" is
a loose one-the actual time can be three minutes, six minutes, or whatever is appropriate. The point is to make
the five pillar work brief, efficient, and habitual. In figure below shows a signboard that was made as part of a
Five-Minute 5 campaign.
Checklist on 3S Maintenance Level
After we have assigned the three pillar jobs and have incorporated the three pillar maintenance into the everyday
work routine, we need to evaluate how well the three pillars are being maintained. For this, we can use a
Standardization-level Checklist as shown in the figure below.
To evaluate the effectiveness of the maintenance activities, the evaluator ranks the Sort, Set in order, and Shine
levels on a scale of 1 to 5. Such checklists can be made for specific workshop and/or production processes. One
example is shown in the Figure below. 5S Checklists like the one in the figure are used to check five pillar levels
in the factory as a whole. When a company implements 5S Month of intensive activities, 5S Checklists should be
used to make weekly evaluation of five pillar conditions.
The 5 Whys and 1How (5W1H) Approach
We begin by asking "why?" until we identify the underlying causes - for every answer we gel we must ask "why"
again. Usually we ask "why" at least five times to get to the root of the problem. When we do find the underlying
cause, we ask "how" we call fix it. Accordingly, this method is called the "5W1H' approach.
When we ask "why" setting in order is breakable, we find that one answer is because people make mistakes in
putting things back. At this point, we need to identify what types of items are not being returned correctly. Once
we identify this, the question is how to achieve unbreakable setting in order by making it impossible to return
them to the wrong place. If we can somehow eliminate the need to return items at all, we can achieve unbreakable
setting in order.
Three techniques for doing this are:
Suspension Use elimination.
Incorporation
Suspension
In the Suspension technique, tools are literally suspended from above, just within reach of the user. Figure
above shows this method in practice. Here a weighted pulley device is used to suspend tools from an
overhead rack. When the operator finishes using the tool, he merely releases it and it automatically returns
to its proper storage place.
While this technique does not eliminate the need to return items to a specific place, it does effectively
Page 25 of 53
Institution Name Document No.
ወ/ሮ ስህን ቴክኒክና ሙያ ኮሌጅ OF/WSPC /263-01
W/RO SIHEEN TECHNICAL AND VOCATIONAL COLLEGE
Issue No. Page No.
Title:
2 Page 48 of
TTLM
48
eliminate the need for people to return them. People may make mistakes in returning things, but
suspension devices do not. This technique achieves unbreakable setting in Order.
Incorporation
Incorporation means creating a flow of goods or operations in a factory process in which (1) jigs, tools, and
measuring instruments are smoothly integrated into the process and (2) such devices are stored where they are
used and therefore do not have to be returned after use. The figure below shows an example where a measuring
gate has been incorporated into a cutting process for an automobile part. The measuring gate catches any pieces
that have not been machined to the correct height. This measuring procedure is an example of "mistake -
proofing’' (or poka-yoke). The incorporation of the measuring gate into the cutting process means that its storage
place is also its place of use. It is therefore used (for full-lot inspection) without having to be put back anywhere.
Use Elimination
Suspending or incorporating jigs, tools, or measuring instruments effectively eliminates the need to return
them after each use. However, these items are still being used. The question is whether there is some way
to serve the function of the tool without using the jig, tool or measuring instrument. A set in order
approach that eliminates the use of a particular jig, tool or measuring instrument is in fact unbreakable
setting in order.
There are three techniques for eliminating the use of certain tools:
Tool unification
Tool substitution
Method substitution
Tool unification
Tool unification means combining the functions of two or more tools into a si ngle tool. It is an approach that
usually reaches back to the design stage. For example, we can reduce the variety of die designs to unify dies or
make all fasteners that require a screw-driver conform to the same kind of screw-driver, flat-tip or Phillips.
Tool substitution
Tool substitution means using something other than a tool to serve the tool's function, thereby eliminating the tool. For
example, it is sometimes possible to replace wrench-turned bolt with hand-turned butterfly-grip bolts, thereby eliminating
the need for a wrench.
Method substitution
If we substitute ordinary wrench-turned bolts with hand-turned butterfly-grip bolts, we have eliminated the wrench, but
we have not eliminated the method (bolt fastening).Bolt fastening is just one way to fasten things. Fastening pins, clamps
Page 26 of 53
Institution Name Document No.
ወ/ሮ ስህን ቴክኒክና ሙያ ኮሌጅ OF/WSPC /263-01
W/RO SIHEEN TECHNICAL AND VOCATIONAL COLLEGE
Issue No. Page No.
Title:
2 Page 48 of
TTLM
48
and cylinders can also be used for this purpose. We may find we can improve efficiency even more by replacing one
method with another. This is "method substitution
Introduction
The continued employment of the 3S will ensure a high standard of workplace organization. Once the 3S are in
place, the next step is to concentrate on standardizing best practices. The plan must include the creation of
procedures and simple daily checklists which are to be visibly displayed at every workplace. The checklists must
serve as visual signpost to ensure that the daily3S requirements are carried out habitually as best practices in the
work area. Examples of checklists are:
Cleaning procedures.
Maintenance schedules.
Page 27 of 53
Institution Name Document No.
ወ/ሮ ስህን ቴክኒክና ሙያ ኮሌጅ OF/WSPC /263-01
W/RO SIHEEN TECHNICAL AND VOCATIONAL COLLEGE
Issue No. Page No.
Title:
2 Page 48 of
TTLM
48
5S Implementation Schedule:
(Target Area Example)
Notes: 1. Each S may take several months to implement but perfecting the process never ends
2. The 5S system will expand into other areas after the initial area is completed
Introduction
To enhance total participation at all levels of employees and develop a continuous improvement culture and best
performance spirit in the teams, the formation of 5s council is very important.5S implementation responsibilities are to be
distributed throughout the organization. Every member must know their own 5S responsibilities and perform accordingly.
5S Chairman:
5S Coordinator:
Communicates with everyone involved.
5S Facilitators:
Support 5S implementation. Ensure employee implementation plan.
Communicate with everyone involved. Monitor measurement systems.
Motivate work groups.
5S Leaders:
Participate in work group implementation Communicate with everyone involved.
process.
Monitor progress of group activities.
Employees’ responsibilities:
Participate in group activities with full commitment
Keeping the workplace to the standard.
Standardized cleanup
Standardize is the fourth step of the 5S method. It means "standardized cleanup". It derives from the one-time
Shine step which made the factory "shiny clean" and set the standard for cleanliness. Standardize makes it
possible and feasible to live up to that standard.
Standardize enables and ensures compliance to the new standards of cleanliness. The benefits include:
Page 29 of 53
Institution Name Document No.
ወ/ሮ ስህን ቴክኒክና ሙያ ኮሌጅ OF/WSPC /263-01
W/RO SIHEEN TECHNICAL AND VOCATIONAL COLLEGE
Issue No. Page No.
Title:
2 Page 48 of
TTLM
48
Maintaining the higher morale gained during Shine
Relapsing into dirty or messy conditions means that the Shine effort was wasted
Minimal investment in time: the goal is 5 minutes per worker per shift
From the shine step, we have the following information about the cleanup process, or we have begun to list
questions that require investigation:
Clean surfaces
How to clean and where to store the cleaning tools (and consumables, such as
detergents)
Sequence of tasks
Time required for each task
How often should this task be performed?
Daily, weekly or less frequently?
Where does the dirt come from?
Can the source be eliminated or re-directed?
Page 30 of 53
Institution Name Document No.
ወ/ሮ ስህን ቴክኒክና ሙያ ኮሌጅ OF/WSPC /263-01
W/RO SIHEEN TECHNICAL AND VOCATIONAL COLLEGE
Issue No. Page No.
Title:
2 Page 48 of
TTLM
48
Daily Cleaning Tasks
Each worker should have a set of daily cleanup tasks. These tasks may include:
Wipe or clean tools before storing them in their appropriate racks
Clean and inspect the machinery used during that shift
Clean one's own workbench
Dust or wipe down work surfaces
Store workbench items properly – put the lids back on jars, for example
Sweep a designated area of the floor
Turn off or unplug power tools as required
Visually check that everything is in place
This set of actions should not add more than about five minutes to each worker's set of routine daily tasks. One
key is that this becomes the routine. For management to enforce the standards, the standards need to be
documented. Since managers actively helped in the one-step Shine process, the photographs of the tidy workplace
should be sufficient.
Several successful repetitions are needed to make a change into a standardized habit. Daily and weekly tasks
quickly become routine. Because of the time which elapses between the infrequent cleanup tasks, it will take
longer to make them habitual and repeatable. Therefore it is vital to develop a system that works for your
organization. Management should make these infrequent cleaning tasks into deliverables and inspect the results
until satisfied that the change is habitual. You don't want to open a cabinet or move a machine and find a built -
up mess that should have been addressed regularly.
Support the sort and set in order initiatives: regular cleaning ensures that only useful
objects are kept, and tools are stored in their proper places
Page 31 of 53
Institution Name Document No.
ወ/ሮ ስህን ቴክኒክና ሙያ ኮሌጅ OF/WSPC /263-01
W/RO SIHEEN TECHNICAL AND VOCATIONAL COLLEGE
Issue No. Page No.
Title:
2 Page 48 of
TTLM
48
Maintains the morale boost from the one-time shiny-clean step: the effort was not wasted;
management really is committed; and everyone continues to work toward this common goal
Provides a daily visual inspection of equipment and facilities, so preventative
maintenance can be performed at the earliest possible time
Makes it easier to note that tools and materials are stored properly at the end of each shift
Reinforces the culture of tidiness, so workers are less likely to leave a mess
that they will just have to clean up later
The less frequent cleanups – weekly or even less often – also have benefits:
Reinforces the good first impression of cleanliness and tidiness, because the less-used
or less-visited areas are also well-maintained; there is no contrast between a showcase
work station and a messy storage closet
Reduces environmental health hazards – dust or pools of toxic liquids – for workers
Reduces wear on machinery, by cleaning the equipment and by reducing airborne grit
that can get into moving parts
The fourth phase, standardize, focuses on maintaining the clean and safe working environment. Prior to this
phase, all sorting and cleaning has been performed. This phase is there to set simple, visible guidance, how the
area should be kept on daily basis. Different organizations have different ways to measure the maintenance of 5S.
One of the most popular tools for standardizing is a 5S audit. These audits are kept after different time periods,
for example once a month. The audit has set standards that are evaluated during the audits. Afterwards the results
of the audit will be posted for everyone to see. This also helps to point out some problem areas and take actions to
these.
Standardizing activities
Standardization will lead equalization of activities. Standardization is useful for;
Everyone’s participation
Standardization itself:
Reduces training time: similar situations are documented in similar ways; basic tasks are performed in
each work group; and experience co -workers can explain things to newcomers
Reduces or eliminates confusion – each worker knows the tasks and responsibilities
Improves morale by reducing the friction between workers with different personal tolerances for
neatness, or different ways of storing tools
Contributes to consistent quality and productivity
Here are some of the problems that result when we do not
implement Standardization well:
Conditions go back to their previous and undesirable levels even after a companywide 5S implementation
campaign.
At the end of the day, piles of unneeded items are left from the day's production and lie scattered around the
production equipment.
Tool storage sites become disorganized and must be put back in order at the end of the day.
Cutting shavings constantly fall on the floor and must be swept up.
Page 33 of 53
Institution Name Document No.
ወ/ሮ ስህን ቴክኒክና ሙያ ኮሌጅ OF/WSPC /263-01
W/RO SIHEEN TECHNICAL AND VOCATIONAL COLLEGE
Issue No. Page No.
Title:
2 Page 48 of
TTLM
48
Even after implementing Sort and Set in order, it does not take long for office workers to start accumulating
more stationery supplies than they need.
These problems and others reveal backsliding in gains made from implementing Sort, Set in Order,
and Shine Activities. The basic purpose of the Standardize pillar is to prevent setbacks in the first
three pillars, to make implementing them a daily habit, and to make sure that all three pillars are
maintained in their fully implemented state.
Sort activity
Page 34 of 53
Institution Name Document No.
ወ/ሮ ስህን ቴክኒክና ሙያ ኮሌጅ OF/WSPC /263-01
W/RO SIHEEN TECHNICAL AND VOCATIONAL COLLEGE
Issue No. Page No.
Title:
2 Page 48 of
TTLM
48
LO3: Sustain 3S
Preparing and following plan
Introduction
Sustain means making a habit of properly maintaining correct procedures. Maintain and practice the first four S’s.
Be thorough in straightening up, putting things in order and cleaning.
Planning Stage
Steps for planning
1. 5S organization structure
2. Recognition of current condition
3. Deciding activity range
4. Goal setting
5. Planning stage
6. Budgeting
7. Kick-off :- The declaration of 5S activity
5S Organizational Structure
Page 35 of 53
Institution Name Document No.
ወ/ሮ ስህን ቴክኒክና ሙያ ኮሌጅ OF/WSPC /263-01
W/RO SIHEEN TECHNICAL AND VOCATIONAL COLLEGE
Issue No. Page No.
Title:
2 Page 48 of
TTLM
48
Fig. Organizational Structure
5S Promotion office duties
Organize Training
Recognition of current condition
by using 5S Checklist and
Planning stage: includes promotion, time frame and overall 5S activities plan.
Goal setting
Budgeting
It is necessary to prepare a budget for 5S activity because it costs money.
Page 36 of 53
Institution Name Document No.
ወ/ሮ ስህን ቴክኒክና ሙያ ኮሌጅ OF/WSPC /263-01
W/RO SIHEEN TECHNICAL AND VOCATIONAL COLLEGE
Issue No. Page No.
Title:
2 Page 48 of
TTLM
48
Kick-off: - is the declaration of 5S activity.
Discussing, preparing and implementing tools and
techniques to sustain 3S
We need to be continually motivated to improve the company and promote the 5 -S program.
Distribute a 5-S newsletter, 5-S posters, 5-S awards, 5-S motto, 5-S Day — always continuing to
inspire fresh, new enthusiasm
Team and Management Audits using Cleaning and Lubrication Standards and Visual
Work Instructions
Step 3 - Create motivation for 5-S
Page 37 of 53
Institution Name Document No.
ወ/ሮ ስህን ቴክኒክና ሙያ ኮሌጅ OF/WSPC /263-01
W/RO SIHEEN TECHNICAL AND VOCATIONAL COLLEGE
Issue No. Page No.
Title:
2 Page 48 of
TTLM
48
To what level has our company progressed in the 5-S program? What is our goal?
Promote the idea of how much more the 5-S level of the company as a whole needs to
improve to pass our competitors
Take video/pictures of our area every 6 months and compare to see improvements.
Inspecting workplace.
Inspection and Maintenance
Cleaning is not the only facet of Shine. The daily Shine ritual should also include inspection and routine
maintenance. As your employees are doing their daily cleaning routine, they should be inspecting tools and
machinery for damage as well. Include this in the daily checklist to make sure it gets done.
Periodic routine maintenance should also be done at this time. Some examples are checking the oil level in
machinery, tightening up belts, hoses, nuts, and bolts, or checking if tools need sharpening.
The goal for Shine is to keep everything in great working order so it lasts as long as possible and doesn’t
break down. Clean and properly maintained tools and machines also increase safety in the workplace.
Fewer injuries and less downtime equate to higher morale and higher productivity.
What if an employee sees a pool of oil that wasn’t there before or notices a safety hazard? If it’s a quick fix, put a
maintenance tag on it and notify your supervisor. If something needs further evaluation, there should be a
maintenance log you can fill out that will ensure further action. And don’t forget your computers and other office
equipment! They need to be defragmented (PCs) and air-dusted periodically to keep them in good condition.
Cleaning check list should be systematically used in every work venue. This is not a bid burden to respective
work team member to give mark just after conducting routine cleaning work before and after the work. Once the
check list is applied, relevant supervision should be conducted. For sustaining the check list utilization, the format
should not be too complicated. Also, the guidance should be done by the middle class managers under no blame
policy but under encouraging atmosphere.
Sustaining the gains
a. Top management Patrol Must
c. Mutual patrol
d. Self patrol
f. Camera patrol
Visibly highlight the problems and progress of the activity using photographs.
Cleaning up workplace.
Introduction
Developed in Japan, 5S is a system of organizing workplace for efficiency, effectiveness and safety. 5s is
important because the implementation is about empowering employees to control their work area and
create an environment where they want to work every day. It is a program that only works with grass roots
level engagement. With commitment to safety, we are equally committed to 5S to ensure a safe place to
work. It enabled us to indicate where waste was occurring and thus improve the work area sustainably.
We recognized real problems, found solutions and ultimately we were successful in our endeavors.
Perform the five minute shine:- cleaning should be practiced daily and should not require a lot time
Page 39 of 53
Institution Name Document No.
ወ/ሮ ስህን ቴክኒክና ሙያ ኮሌጅ OF/WSPC /263-01
W/RO SIHEEN TECHNICAL AND VOCATIONAL COLLEGE
Issue No. Page No.
Title:
2 Page 48 of
TTLM
48
Creating standards for shine procedure:- people’s needs to know what kinds of procedure to follow in
order to use their time efficiently; Otherwise, they are likely to spend most of their time getting ready
to clean
Sustaining cleaning activity (Sample applied on a given area)
Type of cleaning Time Frequency (timing)
2. No matter how well Set in Order is planned and implemented, tools and jigs do not get
returned to their designated place after use.
3. No matter how dirty equipment becomes, little or nothing is done to clean it.
4. Terms are left protruding into walkways, causing people to trip and get injured.
Page 40 of 53
Institution Name Document No.
ወ/ሮ ስህን ቴክኒክና ሙያ ኮሌጅ OF/WSPC /263-01
W/RO SIHEEN TECHNICAL AND VOCATIONAL COLLEGE
Issue No. Page No.
Title:
2 Page 48 of
TTLM
48
These 5S related problems and others are likely to occur in any factory or office that lacks a commitment to
sustain the five pillar gains over time.
For instance, going back to our exercise program example, how could you create conditions in your own life that
would encourage sustaining your plan to work out at a gym three time a week? You might:
Join a gym with a friend so you can work out together and encourage each other (see Figure above).
Make a plan with your spouse to eat dinner later three nights a we so you can go to the gym
after work.
Get extra sleep on the nights before you work out, so that you will not be too tired by the end of the
day to follow through with your exercise plan.
These conditions would make it easier for you to sustain your schedule for exercising at the gym three
times a week.
Similarly, you and your company can create conditions or structure that will help sustain to the five
pillars. The types of conditions that are most useful for this are:
Awareness. You and your coworkers need to understand what the five pillars are and how
important it is to sustain them.
Time. You need to have or make enough time in your work schedule to perform 5S
implementation.
Structure. You need to have a structure for how and when 5S activities will be implemented.
Support. You need to ha e support for your efforts from management in terms of
Acknowledgement, leadership, and resource
Satisfaction and Excitement. The implementation of the five pillars needs to be fun and satisfying for
you and the company. This excitement and satisfaction gets communicated from person to person,
allowing 5S implementation to build as it involves more people.
Page 41 of 53
Institution Name Document No.
ወ/ሮ ስህን ቴክኒክና ሙያ ኮሌጅ OF/WSPC /263-01
W/RO SIHEEN TECHNICAL AND VOCATIONAL COLLEGE
Issue No. Page No.
Title:
2 Page 48 of
TTLM
48
The primary objective of 5S is to create a clean, orderly environment- an environment where there is a place for
everything and everything is in its place. Beyond this, many companies begin their lean transformation with
5Sbecause it exposes some of the most visible examples of waste it also helps establish the framework and
discipline required to successfully pursue other continuous improvement initiatives.
5S Implementation in the Office
As a company holistic approach, 5s implementation in the office activities must fully support shop-floor
manufacturing operations to eliminate waste as a means to improve productivity. When developing a culture of
continuous improvement, 5S improvement steps mirrors our attitudes and behavioral patterns during the
transformation process. Although not manufacturing, you can consider the office as a paperwork factory. Like
manufacturing, adopting the 5S principles throughout the office and administrative functions increases efficiency.
The 5S management philosophy eliminates waste and improves office organization and standardization. 5S serves
as the foundation for continuous improvement activities and provides the base for applying other Lean
methodologies. It also supports the cornerstones of employee engagement. Although 5S concepts are simple and
easy to understand, many organizations fail in the implementation process. Companies mistake 5S as a spring
cleaning program. However, 5S, when applied correctly, continuously improves workplace organization and
improves productivity.
Have people who make a mess and another group of people cleans up.
Page 42 of 53
Institution Name Document No.
ወ/ሮ ስህን ቴክኒክና ሙያ ኮሌጅ OF/WSPC /263-01
W/RO SIHEEN TECHNICAL AND VOCATIONAL COLLEGE
Issue No. Page No.
Title:
2 Page 48 of
TTLM
48
A. 1st class workplace:
Have people who don’t make a mess and yet everyone cleans up.
5S Workplaces
Key components of the 5S philosophy are safety and good housekeeping practices. Safety is an integral part of the
sort, set in order and shine segment of any 5S project. Standardize and sustain refers to methods used to ensure
that safety and good housekeeping is maintained. Check sheets can be used to build good habits in these areas and
to ensure good housekeeping is maintained in all areas. Implementing the 5S method means cleaning up and
organizing the workplace in its existing configuration. It typically is the first lean method that organizations
implement. This lean method encourages workers to improve their working conditions (including safety and
ergonomics) and helps them to learn to reduce waste, eliminate unplanned downtime and conduct in-process
inventory.
The 5S methodology typically is implemented using a three-step process, which includes establishing a cross-
functional team (including employees who work in the associated areas), touring all areas associated with the
manufacturing processes under review and brainstorming ways to improve organization to reduce waste. For
example, factories usually have a great deal of waste associated with searching for items. It is not unusual for a 3
-hour changeover routine to include 30 minutes of searching. When attempting to reduce changeover time
radically (for example, going from 3 hours to 10 minutes), there clearly is no room for 30 minutes of searching
waste.
Page 43 of 53
Institution Name Document No.
ወ/ሮ ስህን ቴክኒክና ሙያ ኮሌጅ OF/WSPC /263-01
W/RO SIHEEN TECHNICAL AND VOCATIONAL COLLEGE
Issue No. Page No.
Title:
2 Page 48 of
TTLM
48
For example, team members might observe workers walking long distances to obtain needed parts, or spending
time reaching into bins on shelves to find parts. Or they may identify hardware, like nuts, bolts and screws that
are used in a certain area, but stored in a central storage facility far away from the point of use.
Audits can be conducted to review 5S progress in particular processes from level 1 (initial effort) to level 5
(habit). In the “Shine” category, for example, the goal is to have a system in which work area housekeeping is a
routine way of life and corrective action measures are in place to address cleanliness issues.
Safety also plays an important role in the 5S audit process. Standard works heats are developed for each
process to help make a factory more visual, highlighting safety precautions for each cell, in addition to
showing where all work in process should be located.
A clean, well-organized and safe work environment is, of course, an efficient and productive work environment.
A less obvious, but still important, aspect of lean is that it gets the employees involved throughout the process,
engaging and challenging best practices, encouraging the employees to have a real sense of involvement and to
work hard to maintain all the effort the team has invested.
Sustainability activities
Refresher training
Periodical evaluation of 5S activities with proper advices for continuation and further
improvements
Page 44 of 53
Institution Name Document No.
ወ/ሮ ስህን ቴክኒክና ሙያ ኮሌጅ OF/WSPC /263-01
W/RO SIHEEN TECHNICAL AND VOCATIONAL COLLEGE
Issue No. Page No.
Title:
2 Page 48 of
TTLM
48
Appreciation, recognition and awarding on good 5S activities
Page 45 of 53
Institution Name Document No.
ወ/ሮ ስህን ቴክኒክና ሙያ ኮሌጅ OF/WSPC /263-01
W/RO SIHEEN TECHNICAL AND VOCATIONAL COLLEGE
Issue No. Page No.
Title:
2 Page 48 of
TTLM
48
81-100: Excellent
61-80: Good
41-60: Fair
21-40: Poor
Upon receipt of the 5S audit check sheet, the leaders of the process are then able to determine if additional steps, tools or
methods are needed to sustain the production process.
Conclusion
Generating 5S practice in theory involves straightforward steps which lead to continuous improvements. 5S is a Lean
technique that involves activities designed to create and maintain a disciplined workplace. It helps create a better working
environment and can be implemented to eliminate waste and improve operational processes. The performance of 5S in a
workplace could be evaluated using a 5S Checklist, which is a tool that will help ensuring that 5S standards and workplace
organization are being met. It enables the observer to better address compliance gaps and provides an opportunity for
continuous improvement.
Page 47 of 53
Institution Name Document No.
ወ/ሮ ስህን ቴክኒክና ሙያ ኮሌጅ OF/WSPC /263-01
W/RO SIHEEN TECHNICAL AND VOCATIONAL COLLEGE
Issue No. Page No.
Title:
2 Page 48 of
TTLM
48
Sustain 3s Audit
Page 48 of 53
Institution Name Document No.
ወ/ሮ ስህን ቴክኒክና ሙያ ኮሌጅ OF/WSPC /263-01
W/RO SIHEEN TECHNICAL AND VOCATIONAL COLLEGE
Issue No. Page No.
Title:
2 Page 48 of
TTLM
48
Steps for planning
1. Kaizen Team organizational structure.
4. Goal setting
5. Planning stage
6. Budgeting
7. Kick-off
LO1 Self-Check -1
Answer all the questions listed below. Use the Answer : (5 pts each)
1. Which of the following is not included in the five steps of Japanese 5S?
B. Standardize D. None
2. Which of the following is not included in the main benefits of implementing 5s?
A. Floor space utilization is improved
Page 49 of 53
Institution Name Document No.
ወ/ሮ ስህን ቴክኒክና ሙያ ኮሌጅ OF/WSPC /263-01
W/RO SIHEEN TECHNICAL AND VOCATIONAL COLLEGE
Issue No. Page No.
Title:
2 Page 48 of
TTLM
48
B. Time for searching tools, materials and document is minimized
C. Errors are minimized leading to making defect-free products;
D. Consumables and material wastage are minimized;
E. None
3. A job specification describes the exact person that a company requires for a particular role.
(True/False)
4. Which of the following is Components of a Job Specification?
A. Experience B. Education
C. Required Skills, Knowledge and Characteristics D. All
5. Management commitment to occupational safety and health may not be demonstrated in:
A. Allocating sufficient resources B. Establishing organizational structures
B. Designating a senior management representative D.None
6. Occupational safety and health programs and policies must aim at both prevention and protection.
(True/False
Self-Check –LO2
1. Which of the following is not 5S?
2.In order for the 5S system to be successful, the most important factor is the commitment,
participation and involvement of EVERYONE. (True/False)
Page 50 of 53
Institution Name Document No.
ወ/ሮ ስህን ቴክኒክና ሙያ ኮሌጅ OF/WSPC /263-01
W/RO SIHEEN TECHNICAL AND VOCATIONAL COLLEGE
Issue No. Page No.
Title:
2 Page 48 of
TTLM
48
D. Delivery time improvements E. None
4. Ensure that all the three pillars are maintained in their fully implemented state.(True/False)
5. Which of the following is included in Red Tag Rules in preparing procedures for standardizing 3S
activities?
A. When to Red Tag B. How to Red Tag C. What’s go on the Red Tag D.All
6. . Which of the following are tools and techniques to standardize 3S?
5S Job Cycle Charts
Page 51 of 53
Institution Name Document No.
ወ/ሮ ስህን ቴክኒክና ሙያ ኮሌጅ OF/WSPC /263-01
W/RO SIHEEN TECHNICAL AND VOCATIONAL COLLEGE
Issue No. Page No.
Title:
2 Page 48 of
TTLM
48
E. All
Given necessary templates, tools and materials you are required to perform the following
tasks within 8 hour.
Task 1- Briefly describe steps in planning the sustain stage and apply the steps in sustaining
the 3pillars (3S) in your actual work shop
ASSIGMNTE (1)
Answer all the question listed below .Use the answer sheet
1. What is the job?
2. What is the job requirement?
3. List the requirement of job.
4. What is work?
5. Describe work instruction by your own words.
6. Describe the difference between procedure and work instruction?
7. What is OHS represents for
8. What is WHS represents for.
9. What are the goals of OHS?
10. List some examples of OHS requirements in your work areas.
11. Describe 3S
12. What is red tagging?
13. List steps in red tagging?
14. Describe steps to set in order.
15. List steps to shine activities.
16. Describe shine targets.
17. Describe steps in cleaning/inspection.
18. List types of patrolling system.
19. Why awarding is necessary in sustain implementation?
20. What are the activities performed during preparation of audit and during audit
Page 52 of 53
Institution Name Document No.
ወ/ሮ ስህን ቴክኒክና ሙያ ኮሌጅ OF/WSPC /263-01
W/RO SIHEEN TECHNICAL AND VOCATIONAL COLLEGE
Issue No. Page No.
Title:
2 Page 48 of
TTLM
48
ASSIGMNTE (2)
1. Define the fourth pillar of 5S? (2 point)
9. How the 5 whys and 1 how (5W1H) approach are used to sustain the 3S?
Page 53 of 53