Leadership: Eneida O. Roldan and Joel Dickerman
Leadership: Eneida O. Roldan and Joel Dickerman
Leadership: Eneida O. Roldan and Joel Dickerman
8
Eneida O. Roldan and Joel Dickerman
“To be nobody but yourself in a world which is doing its best, night and day, to make you
like everybody else means to fight the hardest battle which any human being can fight; and
never stop fighting.” – E.E. Cummings, Poet
E. O. Roldan (*)
Florida International University Herbert Wertheim College of Medicine, Miami, FL, USA
e-mail: [email protected]
J. Dickerman
National Board of Osteopathic Medical Examiners, Inc., Chicago, IL, USA
Today’s health-care environment calls for a different type of leader with an ability to
stretch his or her comfortable patterns of leadership style. Physicians have multiple
skills and strengths by the nature of their long academic and training years required
to become a physician. Physicians are comfortable to face complexity that requires
difficult decision-making in diagnostics and patient care. They care about their
patients and, more importantly, have high ethical standards in how they practice. In
spite of these attributes, today’s physician faces challenges to evolve into a less
autonomous environment brought about by the fast-evolving health-care environ-
ment. Physician leadership once centered on heading a surgical or patient care team;
physicians now lead population-based management teams and serve on management
teams for complex health-care systems. New management styles are necessary to
combat the regulatory aspects of health care, such as knowledge of reimbursement,
health care reform, and other aspects that affect a population. However, management
and leadership are not the same. To acquire management skills is more of the how to
effectively complete tasks in an organization, whereas leadership is the why we do
what we do in an organization focused not only on tasks but also on people [1].
8 Leadership 91
Health care systems are highly susceptible to rapid changes through demographic
shifts, disease patterns, high impact technology, scientific innovation, public policy,
and processes that impact the financial viability and capabilities of health systems
to meet their mission. These challenges easily align with the VUCA teaching. The
term defines volatility, uncertainty, complexity, and ambiguity but more importantly
provides us with the opportunity to turn challenges into positive and reproducible
outcomes through a counter-balance of volatility with vision; uncertainty with
understanding; complexity with clarity; and ambiguity with agility [2]. In the world
of health care, the future is uncertain. This is not necessarily an unfavorable aspect
of the field, but rather implies the need for new types of leaders. The new health care
leader is not fearful or resistant in the face of change, but rather embraces change as
a means to innovate. The leader is able to apply leadership skills to all aspects of
health care, from education to delivery of care.
Leadership Theories
There are many leadership theories that have been studied throughout the centuries.
For the purpose of providing those most commonly used, we will focus on four
leadership theories: Transactional, Transformational, Situational, and the role of
Emotional Intelligence for the leader.
and emphasizes that people work more effectively if they have a sense of mission.
The transformational theory requires leaders to communicate their vision in a man-
ner that is meaningful, exciting, and creates unity and collective purpose; the man-
ager who is committed, has vision, and is able to empower others and is described
as a transformational leader. Transformational leaders are able to motivate perfor-
mance beyond expectations through their ability to influence attitudes [4].
Situational Leadership Dr. Paul Hersey and Ken Blanchard created situational
leadership. Situational leadership style is an adaptive style. The leader using this
style focuses on how best to get “buy-in” of its followers observing all existing
variables in the environment to reach its goal. It emphasizes leading your team
based on the following factors:
This type of style is very useful in crisis, when the leader needs to be vigilant
regarding resistance to change from the group. In this manner, the leader is an
observer and easily adapts its style of leadership to “bring in” the followers. If used
effectively, leaders will identify champions for change from the group [5].
1. Jeranil was elected as one of three chief residents of her psychiatry residency
program 2 weeks ago. Since the announcement, she has been approached by
several individuals with requests. An intern has asked her to enhance faculty
teaching efforts, a second year resident would like for her to advocate for depart-
mental adherence to resident work hours, and a senior faculty member has asked
for her to speak with residents about partaking in more research. Jeranil is feel-
ing overwhelmed by the multiple requests.
(a) Which leadership style(s) reflects Jeranil in this case and why?
(b) How can she be a more effective leader?
Discussion: Jernil feels overwhelmed by the requests of her peers and her fac-
ulty. This is common when employing a transactional approach to leadership –
trying to lead by attending to the self-interests of those you are trying to lead.
Focusing on a shared vision with her fellow residents (i.e. improving overall resi-
dent education) and recruiting them to participate in the development of an
action plan can create an environment that is energetic versus draining, collab-
orative versus self-centered, and innovative versus problem-oriented. She has an
opportunity to develop leadership skills in Communication and Relationship and
Management. Serving as a chief resident provides Jernil the opportunity to
develop leadership skills and perhaps continue a career in health-care
leadership.
2. Dwayne has been interviewing medical student applicants for the past 6 months;
which he finds personally and professionally gratifying. The Associate Dean of
Admissions has been impressed with his critique and write-ups of applicants and
has approached him about serving as the medical student representative on the
committee. Dwayne is excited because he has a number of ideas on how to
increase the number of applicants and matriculants from the surrounding inner-
city community and is eager to implement these changes.
(a) Which leadership style(s) reflects Dwayne in this case and why?
(b) How can he be a more effective leader?
Discussion: Dwayne is demonstrating an Emotional Intelligence approach to
leadership. He is self-aware of his own emotions and uses his emotions for posi-
tive thinking and problem solving. He is looking to promote diversity and is will-
ing to participate in the development of a plan to increase the number of
applicants in the surrounding inner-city. Dwayne has an opportunity to develop
transformational leadership skills by helping others to become mission-driven
and to develop skills in Facilitator/Vision and Professionalism.
3. Mikaela has just assumed the presidency of a medical student organization. Her
members are passionate and she has decided to email her members and ask for
suggestions for activities and projects for the year. Soon after sending the email,
she received two emails asking to speak at this month’s Board meeting about
organizing a sexuality workshop at a local college and a breast cancer fundrais-
ing walk the following month.
94 E. O. Roldan and J. Dickerman
(a) Which leadership style(s) reflects Mikaela in this case and why?
(b) How can she be a more effective leader?
Discussion: Mikaela is demonstrating a situational leadership approach to help
nurture the passion in her medical student organization. She adapts to the situa-
tion at hand to encourage others and bring out the best in her team. Her recogni-
tion of the passion and emotion of others may help her to develop skills in
Emotional Intelligence leadership. The requests of her team can provide Mikaela
an opportunity to develop skills in Business and Knowledge of the Health-Care
Environment.
There are a number of different assessment tools that may provide insight to leader-
ship styles and adaptability. These tools can help individuals to align a leadership
style with their own traits and strengths and may help one identify areas of weak-
ness and future development. We will cover three most common tools: the Myer–
Briggs type indicator, 360 assessments, and the StrengthsFinder Assessment.
360 Assessment This assessment first was originally used in the 1950s. By the
1990s, human resource departments were using this assessment as part of the organi-
zational feedback. The 360-degree feedback is a method of systematically collecting
opinions about an individual’s performance from a wide range of coworkers. This
includes peers, direct reports, the boss, and boss’ peers – along with people outside
the organization, such as customers. The benefit of collecting data of this kind is that
the person gets to see a panorama of perceptions rather than just self-perception,
which affords a more complete picture. Research clearly indicates that 360-degree
feedback systems give a much more accurate picture than self-assessment of what
executives really do and how executives actually behave [10–12].
identify areas where you have the greatest potential for building strength. It is mea-
suring your re-occurring patterns of thought, feeling, and behavior. Knowing this
information is a starting point, and where we come along side individuals, teams
and organizations to help leverage your talent, and turn it into sustainable strength
(Table 8.2).
Understanding one’s own personality styles along with understanding the con-
text in which leadership is needed in the health-care environment can help the indi-
vidual determine which leadership theory should be explored. This information can
help one pursue formal leadership training and identify leadership opportunities to
practice leadership skills.
Leaders in health care can take many forms. You are probably most familiar with
physicians serving as team leaders. For example, as you enter the operating room,
surgeons play a central role in leading anesthesia, nurses, scrub techs, and OR desk
staff. The following are examples of leadership roles in health care (Table 8.3).
Many medical students, residents, and faculty have gained an appreciation and
experience in serving as team, group, and organizational leaders. Developing lead-
ership skills provides you great opportunities to fill these higher roles as you prog-
ress through medical school, residency, and as a faculty member.
effect, negatively affects inclusion across professionals, and appears to be more con-
sequential among women [13, 14]. A lack of clarity for promotion and advancement
policies and procedures may also impede the inclusion of diverse individuals [14].
Leadership in academic medicine has often been viewed as hierarchical, tyrannical,
intimidating, abusive, malignant, and inflexible [15]. As we look to develop the future
leaders in health care, we should be mindful of these obstacles and cultures and pro-
mote diversity both in future leaders as one of the key skills of a health-care leader.
Serving as a leader in health care can provide you an opportunity to impact the health
and well-being of many more patients than a panel of patients assigned to your practice.
As you progress through your training, take advantage of the opportunities that present
themselves and consider a career in health-care leadership after graduation.
We have provided a roadmap to begin your journey in leadership. We also shared
our own journey. Remember, this is simply a roadmap built on our experiences as
physician leaders. The key is to be flexible and cognizant that each journey is indi-
vidual in nature. In general, leaders learn first to lead self then subsequently lead
others. To lead self, one needs to be aware of one’s own attitudes, behaviors, and
biases in order to continue to grow. Through growth, we are open to options and new
ideas and, more importantly, are not afraid to face challenges. Challenges, after all,
provide opportunities to improve ourselves and the community around us. Growth
enhances our ability to accept change and is not hindered by constraints. Until we
face who we are and why we act the way we do, it will not let us face a new world.
The development of leadership skills is vital to assuring the complex health-care
system in which we work is truly effective in improving the health of our patients.
Complex systems require the coordinated efforts of highly trained and diverse
workers. Leadership is the most effective means of coordinating the efforts of the
diverse teams needed to deliver health care in our current system.
If your actions inspire others to dream more, learn more, do more and become more, you
are a leader. – John Quincy Adams
References
1. Weiss DF, Tilin FJ, Morgan MJ. The interprofessional health care team, leadership and devel-
opment. Burlington: Jones & Bartlett Publishers; 2013.
2. Bennett N, Lemoine J. What VUCA really means for you. Harv Bus Rev. 2014:92 1/2. Available
at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2389563.
3. Nayar V. Three differences between Managers and Leaders. Harv Bus Rev. 2013/08. Available
at: https://hbr.org/2013/08/tests-of-a-leadership-transiti.
4. Bass B. From transactional to transformational leadership: learning to share the vision. Organ
Dyn. 1990;18(3):19–31.
8 Leadership 99
5. Shell R, Moussa M. The art of woo: strategic persuasion to sell your ideas. London: Penguin
Group; 2007.
6. Hersey P, Blanchard KH. Management of organizational behavior- utilizing human resources.
Englewood Cliffs: Prentice Hall; 1969.
7. Goleman D. Emotional intelligence. New York: Batman Books; 1995.
8. Dickerman J, Sánchez JP, Portela-Martinez M, Roldan E. Leadership and academic medi-
cine: preparing medical students and residents to be effective leaders for the 21st century.
MedEdPORTAL. 2018;14:10677. https://doi.org/10.15766/mep_2374-8265.10677.
9. Myers & Briggs Foundation. MBTI Basics. https://www.myersbriggs.org/my-mbti-personal-
ity-type/mbti-basics/. Accessed on July 21, 2017.
10. Hazucha JF, Hezlett SA, Schneider RJ. The impact of 360-degree feedback on management
skills development. Hum Resour Manag. 1993;32(2–3):325–51.
11. Kluger AN, DeNisi A. The effects of feedback interventions on performance: a histori-
cal review, a meta-analysis, and a preliminary feedback intervention theory. Psychol Bull.
1996;119(2):254–84.
12. Walker A, Smither JW. A five-year study of upward feedback: what managers do with their
results matters. Pers Psychol. 1999;52(2):393–423.
13. Conrad P, Carr P, Knight S, Renfrew MR, Dunn MB, Pololi L. Hierarchy as a barrier to advance-
ment for women in academic medicine. J Womens Health (Larchmt). 2010;19(4):799–805.
14. Morrissey CS, Schmidt ML. Fixing the system, not the women: an innovative approach to
faculty advancement. J Womens Health (Larchmt). 2008;17(8):1399–408.
15. Moutier C, et al. The culture of academic medicine: faculty behaviors impacting the learning
environment. Acad Psychiatry. 2016;40(6):912–8.
16. Stefl M. Common competencies for all healthcare managers: the healthcare leadership
alliance model. p. 360–374. http://www.healthcareleadershipalliance.org/Common%20
Competencies%20for%20All%20Healthcare%20Managers.pdf. Accessed on 25 Apr 2019.