Susanne Bodach
Susanne Bodach
Susanne Bodach
Dissertation
Susanne Bodach
TECHNISCHE UNIVERSITÄT MÜNCHEN
Fakultät Architektur
Susanne Bodach
Vollständiger Abdruck der von der Fakultät Architektur der Technischen Universität
München zur Erlangung des akademischen Grades eines
Doktor-Ingenieurs
genehmigten Dissertation.
Die Folgen des Klimawandels und steigendes Umweltbewusstsein haben dazu geführt, dass
Energieeffizienz und klimagerechtes Bauen als Schlüsselfaktor für eine nachhaltige globale
Energiezukunft gesehen werden. Obwohl die Industrieländer schon einige Fortschritte in der
Umsetzung innovativer Strategien zur Reduzierung des Gebäudeenergiebedarfs gemacht
haben, beginnen die Entwicklungsländer erst langsam solche Einsparpotenziale zu
erschließen. Der globale Energiebedarf wird aufgrund des Bevölkerungswachstums, der
stetigen Urbanisierung und des zunehmenden Wohlstandes vor allen in Entwicklungsländern
steigen. Energie wird dabei mehr und mehr von Gebäuden in den schnell wachsenden
urbanen Zentren verbraucht. Wie andere Entwicklungsländer, kann Nepals schwache
Energieversorgung die wachsende Nachfrage nicht erfüllen, was zu regelmäßigen
Stromausfällen und Energielieferengpässen führt. Dies hat einen negativen Einfluss auf das
tägliche Leben und das Wirtschaftswachstum. Das Fehlen von Bestimmungen und
Standards für Energieeffizienz und das mangelnde Bewusstsein für diese Fragen werden
langfristig die Versorgungslücke verschlechtern. Auf der anderen Seite, ist die Wissensbasis
über wirksame Maßnahmen zu Reduzierung des Gebäudeenergieverbrauchs durch
klimagerechtes Bauen und effiziente Technologien sehr gering. Das Ziel dieser Doktorarbeit
ist es, mit der Entwicklung von technischen und regulativen Empfehlungen diese
Wissenslücke zu füllen. Mit dem Fokus auf traditionellem Wissen, Klimazonierung und
energieeffizientem Gebäudedesign legt diese Forschungsarbeit wichtige Grundlagen für die
Entwicklung von Standards und Vorschriften zur Energieeffizienz in Gebäuden im Kontext
des Entwicklungslandes Nepal.
Die Ergebnisse dieser Forschung zeigen, dass die traditionellen Bauweisen in Nepal sehr
gut an das lokale Klima angepasst sind. Traditionelle Häuser in der gleichen Klimazone
verwenden ähnliche passive Designkonzepte, die auf moderne Gebäude übertragen werden
könnten, um deren Energiebedarf für Raumklimatisierung zu senken. Die klimatische Vielfalt
innerhalb des Landes erforderte die Entwicklung einer bioklimatischen Zonierung für das
Bauen, die zur Einführung einer Energieeinsparbauverordnung unbedingt notwendig ist. Mit
Hilfe des bioklimatischen Ansatzes und der anschließenden Validierung durch thermische
Gebäudesimulation, wurden fünf Klimazonen nach topografischer Höhe vorgeschlagen. Eine
simulationsbasierte Studie zur Energieeffizienz in Hotelgebäuden ergab erhebliche Energie-
und Kosteneinsparpotenziale. Durch die Optimierung des Fensterflächenanteils, der
Ausrichtung, Verschattung und thermischen Masse können durchschnittlich 37% der Heiz-
und Kühlenergie gespart werden. Kosteneffektive Dämmmaßnahmen führen abhängig von
der Klimazone zu Energieeinsparungen zwischen 26% und 50%. Die Ergebnisse der
Simulationsstudie geben auch Aufschluss über die wichtigsten passiven Maßnahmen und die
optimalen Dämmwerte für jede Klimazone. Des Weiteren wurden Energieeffizienz-Szenarien
für den Wohngebäudesektor entwickelt. Die Umsetzung von Energieeffizienzmaßnahmen
könnten den steigenden Energieverbrauch für die Raumklimatisierung in 2040 um 23%
senken. Somit wurde aufgezeigt, dass die Verbesserung der Gebäudeeffizienz das
Wachstum des Energiebedarfs in Nepal verlangsamen kann. Zum Abschluss wurde ein
breiter Katalog von geeigneten Politikstrategien diskutiert und es wurden regulative
Maßnahmen zur Förderung der Energieeffizienz in Gebäuden erarbeitet. Deren Umsetzung
kann einen wesentlichen Beitrag zur ressourceneffizienten und nachhaltigen Entwicklung des
Landes leisten.
Table of contents
Acknowledgements I
Abstract III
List of figures IX
List of tables XI
Acronyms XIII
1 Introduction 1
1.1 Background and problem statement . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1
1.2 Research objectives . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2
1.3 Methodology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3
1.4 Structure of the thesis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
2 Results 7
2.1 Learning from the past . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7
2.2 Climate and design . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13
2.3 Energy-efficient design . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19
VII
Table of contents
References 71
Glossary 77
Appendices 81
A Publication I 83
B Publication II 101
VIII Climate responsive building design for low carbon development in Nepal
List of figures
IX
List of figures
E.1 Comparison of hourly dry bulb temperature from different climate data sets . . 144
E.2 Comparison of daily climate data from Biratnagar . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 144
E.3 Comparison of hourly climate data from Biratnagar . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 145
E.4 Comparison of daily climate data from Kathmandu . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 145
E.5 Comparison of hourly climate data from Kathmandu . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 146
E.6 Comparison of two climate data sets for Kathmandu . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 146
D.1 Assumptions for energy scenarios for space conditioning in hotels . . . . . . . 138
D.2 Energy demand projection of hotel buildings under different scenarios . . . . . 139
D.3 Assumptions for energy scenarios for space conditioning in residential buildings 140
D.4 Energy demand projection of residential buildings under different scenarios . . 141
XI
Acronyms
a Anually
ASHRAE American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning Engineers
CDD Cooling degree days
GIZ Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit GmbH
GWh Gigawatthour
HDD Heating degree days
HDI Human development index
HVAC Heating, ventilation and air conditioning
IEA International Energy Agency
IFC International Finance Corporation
kg Kilogram
km Kilometer
kWh Kilowatthours
LCC Life-cycle cost
LCCA Life-cycle cost analysis
LPG Liquefied petroleum gas
m Metre
m2 Square metre
masl Metres above sea level
Mio Million
mm Millimetre
NGO Non-governmental organisation
PF Projection factor
SHGC Solar heat gain coefficient
toe Tons of oil equivalent
TWh Terrawatthour
TMY Typical meteorological year
yr Year
UN-Habitat United Nations Human Settlements Programme
UNDP United Nations Development Programme
UNEP United Nations Environmental Programme
USD US-Dollar
W/m2 K Watt per square metre per degree Kelvin
WWR Window-to-wall ratio
XIII
Chapter 1
Introduction
Buildings are responsible for over one third of final energy consumption worldwide and are an
equally important source of carbon emissions [1]. New inefficient buildings being built today
will be in operation and will continue to consume energy for the next decades. In the business-
as-usual scenario, energy consumption in buildings will increase by 50% in 2050 compared
to 2010 [2]. Consequently, total carbon emissions will more than double and the average
global temperature is projected to rise by at least 6◦ C worsening the adverse effects of climate
change [2]. Most of the added demand is coming from developing countries due to the growth
of population, rapid urbanisation and rising living standards.
There is a widespread agreement that access to reliable and affordable energy sources
is fundamental for economic development [2–4]. However, the development model of the
industrialised countries, which is based on cheap fossil fuels and environmental degradation,
High
Industrialised countries
Energy consumption
Sustainable level
Developing countries
Low
Today Future
Time
Figure 1.1: Sustainable development model of contraction and convergence (adapted from
[3])
1
Introduction
cannot ensure a sustainable future for further generations. The most important strategy for
sustainable development is to decouple quality of life from consumption of natural resources
and carbon emissions [3]. Developing countries should switch to the low-carbon development
path while the industrialised countries have to reduce their resource and energy consumption
(Figure 1.1).
The energy consumption of buildings can be significantly reduced through
climate-responsive building design and energy efficiency. Building energy regulations and
standards can play a vital role to reduce the energy use in buildings [5]. By setting minimum
requirements, they enhance energy efficiency and contribute to a more sustainable
construction sector. However, it is essential to understand the local context in order to find the
most effective measures to transform the sector towards higher energy efficiency and, thus,
sustainability.
Almost all developed countries’ governments have introduced standards and regulations
to enhance energy efficiency in buildings. More and more developing countries are currently
introducing such legislation [6]. Unlike other Asian countries, Nepal has not developed
standards or regulations regarding energy efficiency in buildings. Beside few small NGO
initiated activities, the awareness about energy efficiency in general and particularly for
buildings among policy makers and all stakeholders of the construction sector is low.
Academic institutions have so far conducted little research on this topic. Consequently, there
is a lack of well-documented information about effective measures to drive the sector towards
higher energy efficiency.
Beside few studies on climate-responsive design for individual buildings in specific
locations, no data about passive and active strategies to reduce energy consumption in
buildings in Nepal is available. Due to the geographic and climatic diversity of the country,
there is the need to conduct a comprehensive study to identify regions with similar climate
design strategies. Furthermore, those strategies have to be evaluated in regards to its
importance and cost-effectiveness in order to develop effective building energy regulations
and policy measures.
Due to the fact that the state of research about climate-responsive building design and
energy efficiency in Nepal is at the starting point, this doctoral thesis is going to lay some
groundwork in this field. Therefore, a rather horizontal approach was used investigating few
selected important aspects. The overall objective of this study was to develop
recommendations for transforming the building sector towards higher energy efficiency.
Thus, this PhD research is focusing on three main areas:
1. Following the principles Learning from past experiences, the study aims to investigate
the passive design concepts used by vernacular architecture in Nepal.
2. The development of a bioclimatic zoning presents a required basis for building energy
conservation policies because of the climatic diversity within Nepal.
3. Finally, it is envisaged to analyse the effectiveness of passive design measures for each
climate zone and estimate energy saving potentials.
The consideration of climate-responsive design and energy efficiency strategies can slow
down the energy demand growth of Nepal’s fast growing building sector.
The hypothesis asserts that energy efficiency measures can achieve considerable energy
savings in buildings. Consequently, building energy regulation and energy conservation
measures can contribute to a resource-efficient and low-carbon development path for the
country to embark on.
1.3 Methodology
In order to achieve the objectives, this research was designed as illustrated in Figure 1.2.
Analysing the Nepalese building sector concerning energy efficiency was required to identify
the gaps and develop adequate strategies. Three focus areas were identified as crucial to
develop recommendations for driving the building sector towards more energy conservation:
3. Energy-efficient design.
Identifying gaps
Focus areas
Figure 1.3 illustrates problem statement, methods, scope and contribution of each focus
area. Although each focus area stands independently, a systematic learning effect was
induced. Investigating on vernacular architecture led to a large catalogue of passive design
measures for each climate. The geographic diversity of the country required a
comprehensive study of the climate conditions and its implications for passive design
resulting in the development of bioclimatic zoning for Nepal. The hotel sector was selected to
investigate the effectiveness of the design measures and quantify energy saving potentials
for heating and cooling. As a result, a catalogue of priority design strategies and
cost-effective insulation measures were developed for each bioclimatic zone.
Finally, the synthesis of the outcomes from the three focus areas led to the
comprehensive understanding of building design and energy efficiency in the context of
Nepal. As a result, design recommendations and policy actions are suggested to ensure the
low-carbon development for the building sector.
The thesis is organised into four chapters as follows. This chapter, Chapter 1 - Introduction
provides the background of the research, the problem statement, objectives, research design
and framework, and the structure of the thesis report.
I. Learning from the past II. Climate and design III. Energy-efficient design
Research problem
Chapter 2 - Results presents the findings of the three focus areas of this cumulative
dissertation. The first sub-chapter titled Learning from the past contains the study on
vernacular architecture of Nepal and how it follows climate-responsive design strategies
(published in [7]). The second sub-chapter Climate and design reveals the first proposal for a
bioclimatic zoning (published in [8]). The results of a quantitative analysis for energy saving
potentials in one building sub-sector lead to passive design strategies for each climate zone
that are summarised in the third sub-chapter Energy-efficient design (published in [9]).
In Chapter 3 - Design and policy recommendations the findings of chapter 2 are brought
together leading to a comprehensive catalogue of climate-responsive design strategies for the
different bioclimatic zones of Nepal. The bioclimatic zoning for Nepal is further developed
considering the results of the building simulation study. Furthermore, policy implications are
discussed in detail and required interventions are suggested.
Chapter 4 - Building energy conservation for low-carbon development highlights the
importance of the key findings of this PhD research to ensure a sustainable development
path for Nepal. Scenarios for the whole building sector estimate considerable energy saving
potentials during the next decades if proper policy strategies are implemented.
Results
Traditional building design is the result of hundreds of years of building optimisation through
trial and errors. Due to the absence of mechanical means, natural sources like the sun and
the wind and locally available materials are used for the buildings to create the most
comfortable indoor climate [10–13]. Passive techniques applied in vernacular houses are
often very effective in the local climatic context and do not rely on energy-intensive and
expensive active systems.
Through the modernisation of the construction sector, traditional knowledge of
climate-responsive building construction is disappearing slowly. In many regions of the world,
vernacular houses have been analysed thoroughly to understand the passive design
techniques [13–16]. In Nepal, there is a lack of proper documentation and analysis of this
In alpine climate
In cool temperate climate
Humla house In warm temperate climate
In subtropical climate
Tamang
house Name of vernacular house
Gurung
house
Tamang
house
Dangaru Tharu House
house in Salle
Hill house
Adobe house Dolakha Sherpa
Tharu house house
Newar
N Chitwan house
Limbu house
Kochila Tharu
0 50 100 200 house
Kilometers
Figure 2.1: Nepal map with the location of analysed vernacular houses
7
Results
%
%
50
90
80
70
60
0
10
AC %
V Natural ventilation 30
TM Thermal mass
15
TMV Thermal mass with night ventilation
EC Evaporative cooling TMV
AC Active cooling %
20
H Humidification
DH Dehumidifaction 10
CZ 10%
5
PSH TM
AH
H EC
0
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45
Dry bulb temperature (°C)
Figure 2.2: Bioclimatic chart for the four predominant climate zones of Nepal: the perimeter
was plotted based on monthly minimum and maximum mean outdoor air temperature and
relative humidity (adapted from [7])
Table 2.1: Characteristics of vernacular houses by climatie zone (adopted from [7])
9
Results
Table 2.2: Passive design strategies of vernacular houses in subtropical climate zone
(adapted from [7])
ventilation. These both passive design strategies are needed in this climate to keep the indoor
at a comfortable level. In the colder climate zones of the country, the building form is more
compact often with an almost square floor layout to reduce the surface of the exterior envelope
and, thus, the heat loss.
In subtropical climate, internal spaces are arranged horizontally. The floor plan has no or
very few internal division walls to enhance air flow within the buildings. In contrast, in Nepal’s
colder climate zones internal space arrangement is vertical to create buffer zones towards
the exterior and protect from the cold weather conditions. The main living area in traditional
houses in the coldest climate is located in the centre of the second floor enclosed by rooms of
secondary use. Animals are housed in the ground floor and storage rooms are located in the
third floor, creating an effective buffer zone.
Thermal mass of traditional houses increases the colder the climate conditions are. In
subtropical climate, buildings have walls and roofs made of lightweight material leading to
Table 2.3: Passive design strategies of vernacular houses in warm temperate climate zone
(adapted from [7])
Table 2.4: Passive design strategies of vernacular houses in cool temperate climate zone
(adapted from [7])
low thermal building mass as recommended for hot and humid climates. In the other climate
zones, buildings have a medium to high thermal mass using materials like natural stone, mud
and clay bricks.
Although window and door openings in vernacular houses in subtropical climates are
rather small, the permeable wall material allows the air to flow through the building envelope.
Window openings in warm temperate climate are of medium size as compared to small
openings in the colder climate zones. While medium sized windows can be effectively used
for natural ventilation in the hot season, small openings are better as they reduce heat loss
under cold conditions. Additional shutters applied in vernacular houses in the colder climate
zones, increase the tightness and insulation level of the envelope.
Shading is very important in hot climates. Therefore, openings in the envelope are shaded
by a large roof overhang of a balcony or veranda in subtropical and warm temperate climate.
Often, shaded semi-open spaces are provided by the building layout. In contrast, windows in
colder climate regions of Nepal have shutters and sunny semi-open spaces are provided in
form of a roof top terrace or a wind-protected small courtyards.
Concluding the analysis of vernacular architecture in different climate regions of Nepal,
it can be said that most of the passive design strategies are applied (Table 2.2, Table 2.3,
Table 2.5: Passive design strategies of vernacular houses in alpine climate zone (adapted
from [7])
Table 2.4, Table 2.5). The identified strategies for each climate zone can be used to design
modern climate-responsive buildings with low energy demand for active cooling and heating.
However, it is clear that even if a new building is designed accordingly, new lifestyles and
increased thermal comfort requirements might lead to the need of mechanical systems or
the need of modern low-energy building technologies like the application of better insulation
materials or double glazing windows.
Bioclimatic or climate-responsive building design is one of the major drivers to reduce energy
consumption and, thus, carbon emissions from the building sector [17]. Although buildings
in developing countries like Nepal are not yet as energy-intensive as in the developed world,
increasing thermal comfort requirements and changing lifestyles combined with population
growth and rapid urbanisation will lead to an increased energy demand in the building sector.
Low energy consumption in buildings can only be achieved if the local climate conditions
are considered during the early stage of the design. Therefore, many countries with large
climatic diversity have developed a bioclimatic zoning for building construction which is
necessary to introduce energy conservation standards and building energy codes [18–25].
Nepal has not yet developed any bioclimatic zoning nor has it established any standard with
regards to building energy conservation. The National Building Code is mainly concerned
about structural and earthquake safe design [26].
The lack of a climate classification for the building construction sector was identified as a
major gap towards more energy efficiency in buildings in Nepal. Therefore, a study analysing
the climate of Nepal was conducted with the objective to develop a bioclimatic zoning for Nepal.
Using the bioclimatic approach, this study is an important part of the PhD research (published
in [8], see also appendix Publication II on page 101).
Climate data being the most important input of this study has to be carefully chosen. A
typical meteorological year (TMY) is often used in climate-responsive building design for
analysing design strategies and conducting building energy simulation. The TMY is
generated based on weather observations over a longer period (at least 20 years) by the
national meteorological institutions of a country. The lack of TMY data sets for Nepal made it
necessary to generate such data sets by using the software tool Meteonorm [27]. Monthly
climate normals (temperature, precipitation) from 26 weather stations, either directly collected
from Department of Hydrology and Meteorology Nepal [28] or derived from United Nation’s
Food and Agriculture Organisation climate database [29], were imported into the software to
achieve more accurate results.
The comparison of the generated data sets with measured climate observations is needed
to check the plausibility of data. Therefore, weather observations (temperature and relative
humidity) from recently installed automated weather stations were analysed and compared
with the TMY data set. Figure 2.3 and Figure 2.4 illustrate the exemplary comparison for the
location Pokhara. The density of the data points for 2013, 2014 and 2015 is lower than for the
generated TMY data set because the weather station only records observations five times a
day. Nevertheless, it can be seen that both daily averages and hourly values are in a similar
range (see also appendix Comparison of climate data sets on page 143). Consequently, the
generated TMY data sets are used for the following analysis.
The climate data was plotted on the bioclimatic chart of [10] with the objective to identify
locations with similar passive design strategies. In this chart the comfort zone is defined
20
10
0
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
TMY: Typical meteorological year generated by Meteonorm software with monthly station data from 1981-2010
2013 2014 2015 : Oberserved data of 1 year from automated weather stations
SWERA: Climate data generated by SWERA project
Figure 2.3: Comparison of daily climate data from Pokhara (Data sources: [27–30])
%
%
50
70
90
80
60
10
15
20%
10
10%
5
-5 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45
Dry Bulb Temperature (°C)
Figure 2.4: Comparison of hourly climate data from Pokhara (Data sources: [27–30])
Jomsom
Thakparpha
Surkhet
Lumia
Janakpur Dharan
Biratnagar
0 50 100 200
Kilometers
Figure 2.5: First proposal of bioclimatic zoning for Nepal (adopted from [8]
at temperatures between 18◦ C and 29◦ C and at an absolute humidity between 4 g/kg and
17 g/kg according to the recommendation for developing countries [31]. The zones for passive
design strategies are defined by [32] for warm and humid climate (see also [8]). The analysis
of the climate data identified elevation as the main factor for climate design. Therefore, a
classification by elevation with a total of four bioclimatic zones was suggested (Figure 2.5).
Figure 2.7, Figure 2.8, Figure 2.9 and Figure 2.10 show the bioclimatic charts for the four
proposed climate zones. Each line on these charts was derived from the monthly minimum
and maximum mean outdoor temperature and relative humidity of all the weather stations in
one zone. Hourly temperature and humidity levels in one month move around this line. While
the blue lines represent the climate conditions during the winter months, the red lines stand
for the summer (monsoon period). The green lines show the conditions in pre- and post-
monsoon. Additionally, a blue, red and green perimeter line (cloud) was added representing
the area of hourly temperature and humidity values for each season.
According to the analysis of the bioclimatic charts, the temperate zone has the most
comfortable climate as the majority of line segments fall within the comfort zone. While heat
stress is the most important concern in warm temperate climate, cold stress is dominant in
the cold climate zone of the country. Natural ventilation, high thermal mass for cooling and
passive solar heating are the three predominant passive design strategies. Depending on the
season and the climate zone, it is recommended to apply one or more of these strategies
(Figure 2.6).
In warm temperate climate zone (above 500 masl) passive solar heating strategy can avoid
the use of active heating completely. However, some active cooling might be necessary in the
hot and humid monsoon season. Thermal mass for cooling is useful for the hot and dry
weather in spring and autumn.
Spring/autumn
Spring/autumn
Monsoon
Monsoon
Warm temperate Temperate
Winter
Winter
climate zone climate zone
(blow 501 masl) (501 - 1,500 masl)
Spring/autumn
Spring/autumn
Monsoon
Monsoon
Cool temperate Cold
Winter
Winter
climate zone climate zone
(1,501 - 2,500 masl) (above 2,500 masl)
Figure 2.6: Predominant passive design strategies for proposed bioclimatic zones by season
(adapted from [8]
In temperate climate zone (501 - 1,500 masl) cooling is not required if the building has a
high thermal mass and is optimised for natural ventilation cooling. Passive solar heating can
keep indoor temperature at a comfortable level in spring and autumn and has the potential to
reduce active heating in winter to almost zero.
Buildings in cool temperate zone (1,501 - 2,500 masl) should be designed to enhance
natural ventilation during the monsoon season. Passive solar heating is essential for spring
and autumn and can considerably reduce the need of active heating in winter. However, some
mechanical heating might always be required in winter.
Due to the low summer temperature, natural ventilation for cooling is not necessary in
Nepal’s cold climate (above 2,500 masl). However, passive solar heating is recommended
and useful throughout the year. It can replace the need of active heating in summer and
reduce it during the other seasons of the year.
The development of a bioclimatic zoning based on climate data has its limitations especially
in composite climates like Nepal. Therefore, the effectiveness of conflicting design strategies
can be only evaluated using thermal building simulation. Thus, the bioclimatic zoning was
further adjusted (see section Adaption of bioclimatic zoning for Nepal on page 25).
0%
%
%
%
90
80
70
60
50
10
Summer (monsoon)
Winter
Pre-/post-monsoon 20
V AC
%
CZ Comfort Zone
40
Potentials for specific passive design strategy:
CZ
10% 5
AH PSH H
-10 -5 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40
Dry bulb temperature (°C)
Figure 2.7: Bioclimatic chart for warm temperate climate zone (adopted from [8]
%
%
%
90
80
70
60
50
10
Summer (monsoon)
Winter
Pre-/post-monsoon
20
V AC
%
CZ Comfort Zone
40
TMV
PSH Passive solar heating
15
AH Active heating %
V Natural ventilation 30
TM Thermal mass
TMV Thermal mass with night ventilation
EC Evaporative cooling EC
AC Active cooling % 10
20
H Humidification
TM
CZ
10% 5
AH PSH H
-10 -5 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40
Dry bulb temperature (°C)
Figure 2.8: Bioclimatic chart for temperate climate zone (adopted from [8]
0%
%
%
%
90
80
70
60
50
10
Summer (monsoon)
Winter
Pre-/post-monsoon 20
V AC
%
CZ Comfort Zone
40
Potentials for specific passive design strategy:
AH CZ
10% 5
PSH H
-10 -5 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40
Dry bulb temperature (°C)
Figure 2.9: Bioclimatic chart for cool temperate climate zone (adopted from [8]
%
%
%
90
80
70
60
50
10
Summer (monsoon)
Winter
Pre-/post-monsoon
20
V AC
%
CZ Comfort Zone
40
TMV
PSH Passive solar heating
15
AH Active heating %
V Natural ventilation 30
TM Thermal mass
TMV Thermal mass with night ventilation
EC Evaporative cooling EC
AC Active cooling % 10
20
H Humidification
TM
AH CZ
10% 5
PSH H
-10 -5 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40
Dry bulb temperature (°C)
Figure 2.10: Bioclimatic chart for cold climate zone (adopted from [8]
By analysing nineteen vernacular houses in different climate regions of Nepal, various suitable
passive design strategies could be identified for each climate zone [7]. The study of the climate
data from 26 Nepalese weather stations resulted into the development of a bioclimatic zoning
with its main climate-responsive design strategies [8]. However, there is the need to evaluate
the importance of each strategy in order to develop effective passive design guidelines and
building energy regulations for the country.
Moreover, some identified design strategies are conflicting each other due to the composite
character of Nepal’s climate. For example, traditional buildings in subtropical climate of Nepal
have low thermal mass [7]. In contrast, high thermal for passive cooling was identified using
the bioclimatic chart [7]. Solely, hourly building energy simulation can help to evaluate the
effectiveness of the thermal mass strategy.
Therefore, a building energy simulation study for Nepal was conducted with the objective
to evaluate the effectiveness of different design strategies and to estimate energy saving
potentials (published in [9], see also appendix Publication III on page 111). It is the first
comprehensive study that assesses energy-efficient building design in Nepal.
The building sector is complex and there exist a large variety of building types. Thermal
comfort requirements of local people in Nepal are still very low and, thus energy-intensive
active heating and cooling systems are commonly not yet installed in residential buildings.
However, there is an increasing trend to install these systems in commercial buildings.
Therefore, hotels were selected for the simulation study as they are an important sub-sector
of commercial buildings.
The hospitality industry is one of the most important sectors for economic development
in Nepal. The number of tourists has almost grown by 400 percent in the last decade and
the travel and tourism industry corresponds to 8.2 percent of Nepal’s Gross Domestic Product
*A vertical section of the hotel building was modelled and side walls were assumed to be adiabatic.
(GDP) in 2013 [33]. From 2009 to 2013, the hotel and restaurant business experienced an
annual growth rate of over 6 percent per year [34]. The growing numbers of tourists and the
boom in the tourism sector have led to more hotels being built by investors. Furthermore,
there is an increasing trend to install mechanical heating and cooling systems to achieve the
thermal comfort requirements of international tourists.
Based on an extensive field study, reference models for typical hotel buildings ranging
from small-scale resort hotels to large-scale multi-storey hotels were developed (see
Figure 2.11). Using building energy simulation with parametric analysis, these reference
designs were optimised by varying different design parameters. For each climate zone and
hotel type, all design parameters were ranked in order to find the most important factor to
reduce energy demand for heating and cooling. Two sets of simulation runs were conducted
due to the huge number of design parameter combinations. The first set of runs (passive
design optimisation) focused on the optimisation of parameters like window-to-wall ratio,
thermal mass, orientation and shading devices. The objective of the second set of run
(insulation level optimisation) was to find the cost-effective insulation level for each
component of the building envelope.
The results of the passive design optimisation indicate that minimising solar gains by
keeping the window-wall-ratio small and using shading devices is the most important design
strategy in Nepal’s warm climate zone. In all other climate zones, high thermal mass has
priority because on the one side the passive cooling effect can reduce energy demand for
mechanical cooling. On the other side, thermal mass is necessary to store solar heat gains
Table 2.6: Passive design recommendations for hotel buildings in Nepal ([9])
Table 2.7: Recommendations for window performance of hotel buildings in Nepal (adapted
from [9])
and, thus, can reduce energy demand for mechanical heating (passive solar heating effect).
Large windows facing south are recommended for the moderate and moderate cold climate
to enhance passive solar heating. In the cold climate zone passive solar heating can be only
effective when the window area is moderate to balance heat losses in the cold season.
Table 2.6 summarises the recommendations for energy-efficient hotel design in Nepal.
The insulation level optimisation concluded that insulation measures can be cost-effective
in almost all climate zones over the building life time and are highly recommended
(Table 2.9). Depending on the climate zone U-Values between 0.25 and 1.6 W/m2 K are
recommended for exterior walls. The roof should have a thermal transmittance between 0.25
and 0.7 W/m2 K while the optimal ground floor insulation level is between 0.9 and
0.25 W/m2 K. The best insulation level of 0.25 W/m2 K is recommended for the whole exterior
envelope of hotel buildings in the cold climate. Minimum ground floor insulation is necessary
in warm, moderate warm and moderate climate.
Improving the performance of windows is not cost-effective in all climate zones when
considering current investment prices. However, switching from single to double glazing to
improve the building performance is recommended under most conditions (Table 2.7). It is
important to consider that double glazing is a new building technology in Nepal and,
therefore, very expensive. There are few suppliers with a limited range of double glazing
windows available in the market. Furthermore, the double glazing available in the Nepalese
market has a higher U-Value compared to European standards. According to the simulation
results, double glazing windows is not recommended in the moderate warm, moderate and
moderate cold climate zone from the cost-perspective when comfort requirements and
energy consumption are low. For all others zones and for higher comfort requirements (e.g.
hotels with international tourist) doubled-glazed windows with an U-Value of 3.2 W/m2 K are
cost-effective. Assuming that with the dissemination of double glazing in the country,
international production standards will be introduced, a window performance of less that
3.0 W/m2 K can be easily reached. In moderate cold and cold climate windows U-Values
Table 2.8: Energy saving potentials in hotel buildings through energy-efficient design by
climate zone (adapted from [9])
Table 2.9: Recommendations for opaque envelope insulation of hotel buildings in Nepal ([9])
Bioclimatic zone U-Value for Wall U-Value for Roof U-Value for Floor
Minimum Maximum Thickness Minimum Maximum Thickness Minimum Maximum Thickness
Comforta Comforta Insulation Comfort Comfort Insulation Comfort Comfort Insulation
W/m2 K W/m2 K mm W/m2 K W/m2 K mm W/m2 K W/m2 K mm
Warm 0.35 0.35 100 0.70 0.40 50-100 - 0.90 0-25
(<500m)
Moderate warm 1.60 0.60 50 0.70 0.40 50-100 - 0.90 0-25
(501-1000m)
Moderate 1.60 0.60 50 0.70 0.40 50-100 - 0.90 0-25
(1001-1500m)
Moderate cold 0.60 0.35 50-100 0.70 0.40 50-100 0.90 0.50 25-50
(1501-2500m)
Cold 0.25 0.25 150 0.25 0.25 150 0.50 0.25 50-100
(>2500m)
23
Results
4470
4264
4000 4024
USD/room
2935
2636
2036 1996
Figure 2.12: Comparison of life cycle costs for base case design and optimised passive design
for different typologies and locations (adopted from [9])
253
203
USD/room
179
133
122
76
58 56
Figure 2.13: Comparison of annual electricity costs for base case design and optimised
passive design for different typologies and locations (adopted from [9])
25
Design and policy recommendations
Passive solar design strategies for each bioclimatic zone were identified by using the
bioclimatic approach. The further energy simulation based analysis found an inconsistency of
priority passive design strategies within the temperate climate. Therefore, a further
differentiation of the temperate climate zone is necessary. As a result it is suggested to
improve the bioclimatic zoning leading to five elevation-based climate zones (see Figure 3.2):
Table 3.1 gives an overview about the climatic conditions in each bioclimatic zone by
indicating dry bulb temperatures in the different seasons, annual rainfall, cooling and heating
degree days as well as humidity conditions. It can be seen that the warm and moderate warm
climate zone have a considerable long period of hot and humid conditions.
The analysis of heating and cooling degree days for all assessed locations confirm a clear
relationship with regard to elevation (Figure 3.1). That means, the lower the elevation, the
higher the cooling degree days. In contrast, the higher the elevation, the higher the heating
degree days. Locations below 1,000 masl are dominated by cooling with more than 1100
cooling degree days (CDD18) while they have less than 400 heating degree days (HDD18).
Locations between 1,000 and 1,500 masl have a moderate amount of cooling degree days
2,500 5,000
2,000 4,000
1,500 3,000
1,000 2,000
500 1,000
0 0
0 1,000 2,000 3,000 4,000 0 1,000 2,000 3,000 4,000
Elevation (masl) Elevation (masl)
(a) CDD18 (b) HDD18
Figure 3.1: Relationship between elevation and cooling degree day (CDD18)a /heating degree
day (HDD18)b
a
Calculated at 18.3°C acording to ASHRAE-method[35]
b
Calculated at 18°C acording to EUROSTAT-method[36]
Mahendranagar Dunai
Design and policy recommendations
Thakparpha
Dhangadhi
Birendranagar
Beni
Gulariya Pokhara Besishahar
Dhunche
Nepalganj
Damauli Gorkha
Tansen
Kathmandu
Bharatpur Charikot
Kapilavastu Lalitpur Bhaktapur
Shidharthanagar Dhulikhel Salleri
Hetauda Taplejung
Okhaldhunga
Sindhulimadi Bhojpur
Birganj Dhankuta
Ilam
Gaur Janakpur
Siraha Bhadrapur
27
Design and policy recommendations
28
Design and policy recommendations
and heating degree days. All locations above 1,500 masl are dominated by heating with more
than 700 heating degree days; they have less than 500 cooling degree days.
Aiming to compare all bioclimatic zones, Figure 3.3 indicates the relative importance of
passive and active design strategies for each climate zone. It can be seen that natural
ventilation for cooling and solar control are the most important climate responsive design
strategies in Nepal’s warm and moderate warm climate. Passive solar heating has priority in
the moderate, moderate cold and cold climate to reduce the energy demand for heating. High
thermal mass is important in all climate zone except the warm climate. It can be noticed that
insulation of the building envelope is only slightly important in moderate warm and moderate
climate due to the moderate temperatures. Regarding the active design, fan-forced ventilation
plays an important role in warm, moderate warm and moderate climate. Dehumidification is
fairly important in the warm and moderate warm climate zone. While active cooling is very
important in the warm climate zone, active heating is very important in Nepal’s moderate cold
and cold climate. The predominant design strategies for each climate will be described in
detail below:
The warm climate zone (below 500 masl) has the hottest temperatures of the country
resulting into the highest energy demand for active cooling systems. Additionally,
dehumidification is very much required during the monsoon season due to the high humidity
levels. In the post-monsoon season more than 20% of the time thermal comfort can be
reached by dehumidification only. However, passive design can contribute to considerable
cooling energy savings. Natural ventilation strategy can be used as cooling strategy almost
one third of the year. Solar control is needed about 30% of the year. The demand for heating
is very low and can be reduced to zero if the building is optimised for passive solar heating for
the coldest period of the year. Thereby, thermal mass plays a secondary role and should not
Natural ventilation
Passive design
Solar control
Solar heating
High thermal mass
Insulation
Fan-forced ventilation
Active design
Dehumidification
Cooling
Heating
be too high to reduce the risk of overheating in the hot season. An appropriate solution for
the contradictory impact of thermal mass could be the application of massive floors, while
walls are light weighted and well insulated. Insulation of the building envelope will contribute
to reduce the need for cooling.
In the moderate warm climate zone (from 501 masl to 1,000 masl) both summer and
winter are mild and the need for heating and cooling is limited. According to the simulation
results of this research energy consumption for space conditioning is lowest compared to
other climate zones in Nepal. Natural ventilation cooling and solar control in the warm season
can reduce the need for active cooling considerably. Dehumidification is the most important
active measure for reaching thermal comfort in the warmer period. However, some cooling
will be needed during the hottest days of the year. For the cold season, the optimisation of
the design for passive solar heating combined with medium to high thermal mass can reduce
the need for heating to a minimum. Thermal mass is highly recommended for this climate
because it is effective as a heat sink for hot days and a heat storage for cold days. Using
thermal mass the high daily temperature can be balanced. According to the simulation
results of the hotel typologies, passive design (excluding insulation) can achieve energy
savings between 22% and 38%. Cost-optimum insulation levels at 0.35 W/m2 K lead to an
energy reduction between 35% to 47% [9]. Similar savings might be achieved in the
residential sector due to the fact that dwellings and hotels have a similar use pattern.
Nepal’s moderate climate (from 1,001 masl to 1,500 masl) has mild temperatures in
summer and winter resulting in the combined need for heating and cooling. However, the
need for cooling is much lower and the need for heating is higher than in the moderate warm
climate. The heating demand in this climate will be always higher than the cooling demand. If
natural ventilation cooling, solar control strategies and high thermal mass are applied in the
building design, the cooling demand can be reduced to a minimum. Similarly, insulation of the
envelope combined with high thermal mass and the design optimisation for passive solar
heating will reduce the demand for heating. Considering passive design features like thermal
mass, solar control and building orientation, energy savings of 39% to 50% can be reached.
The insulation of the building envelope to a cost-effective level of about 0.40 W/m2 K will lead
to energy savings of 37% to 40% [9].
The moderate cold climate zone (from 1,501 masl to 2,500 masl) is dominated by the
need for active heating during at least six month of the year (from October to March). In
contrast the cooling demand will be almost zero if the building openings are designed to have
moderate solar gains in the warmer summer period. Natural ventilation cooling will assure
thermal comfort during hot summer days. Passive solar heating and high thermal mass are
the most important strategies for the colder period. The simulation-based study of this thesis
indicates that passive design (excluding insulation) can lead to energy savings of between 28%
and 73% depending on the typology. Envelope insulation reaching a thermal transmittance of
0.35 W/m2 K is cost effective and results into savings of between 41% and 50% [9].
The cold climate zone of Nepal (above 2,500 masl) is a region where winters are harsh
and summer temperatures hardly reach the comfort zone level. In this climate there is no
need for cooling. In contrast, heating is necessary almost all year. Over 60% of the time
active heating is needed. In winter solar gains can cover some heating demand during the
day. According to the building energy simulation study conducted in the context of this thesis,
energy saving potentials through passive design (excluding insulation) are only between 9%
to 23%. Envelope insulation with an U-Value of 0.25 W/m2 K can bring savings between 38%
and 53% compared to an uninsulated building [9].
Figure 3.4 shows a representation of all bioclimatic zones using the psychrometric chart.
The perimeter line for each zone was created as the contour of monthly lines for mean
minimum and maximum temperatures and relative humidity of all weather stations which fall
into the zone. Consequently, it represents the monthly temperature and humidity levels of the
zone. The figure illustrates the climatic diversity within the Nepalese territory which implies
the need for specific passive design in each climate zone.
The following sections illustrates the characteristics of the five bioclimatic zones and the
recommended design strategies in detail aiming to be a practical guideline for architects,
engineers and home-builders in Nepal. According to the existing construction practises it is
assumed that the building can be naturally ventilated during the time when outdoor
temperatures are comfortable.
10 )
0%
%
%
y(
90
80
Moderate cold climate (1,501 - 2,500 masl)
dit
mi
Moderate climate (1,001-1,500 masl)
%
hu
30
70
ive
Moderate warm climate (501-1,000 masl)
lat
Re
Warm climate (below 500 masl)
%
60
ASHRAE-55 comfort zone for winter and summer 25
%
50
20
%
30
10
20%
5
10%
-10 -5 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40
Dry Bulb Temperature (°C)
Figure 3.4: Presentation of bioclimatic zones in the psychrometric chart: Perimeter line
based on monthly values for mean minimum/maximum temperature and relative humidity of
all weather stations in the zone
30
20
10
0
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
%)
Hourly climate data
0%
%
y(
90
80
10
dit
%
30
70
ive
lat
Re
%
60
25
%
50
20
%
40
15
%
30
10
20%
5
10%
-10 -5 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40
Dry Bulb Temperature (°C)
No or very small windows Small window area Elongated floor layout Glazing with low SHGC
East/West WWR 0-20% South/North WWR 20-30% with long east-west axis
Sun shading
Passive cooling
Insulation
30
20
10
0
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
%)
Hourly climate data
0%
%
y(
90
80
10
dit
%
30
70
ive
lat
Re
%
60
25
%
50
20
%
40
15
%
30
10
20%
5
10%
-10 -5 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40
Dry Bulb Temperature (°C)
Figure 3.7: Climate conditions of Pokhara representing moderate warm climate zone
No or very small window area Small window area Elongated floor layout Glazing with low SHGC
Eas/West WWR 0-20% South/North WWR 20-30% with long east-west axis
Sun shading
Passive cooling
Insulation
Figure 3.8: Passive design strategies for moderate warm climate of Nepal
30
20
10
0
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
%)
Hourly climate data
0%
%
y(
90
80
10
dit
%
30
70
ive
lat
Re
%
60
25
%
50
20
%
40
15
%
30
10
20%
5
10%
-10 -5 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40
Dry Bulb Temperature (°C)
Large window area High thermal mass for passive Glazing with high SHGC
South WWR 40-60% solar heating in winter
Sun shading
Passive cooling
Insulation
20
10
0
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
20
10
0
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
)
Hourly climate data
(%
0%
%
90
80
ty
10
idi
%
30
70
ive
lat
Re
%
60
25
%
50
20
%
40
15
%
30
10
20%
5
10%
-10 -5 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40
Dry Bulb Temperature (°C)
Figure 3.11: Climate conditions of Dhunche representing moderate cold climate zone
Insulation
Natural ventilation
Cross ventilation
for hot summer days
Figure 3.12: Passive design strategies for moderate cold climate of Nepal
20
10
-10
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
20
10
0
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
%)
Hourly climate data
0%
%
y(
90
80
10
dit
%
30
70
ive
lat
Re
%
60
25
%
50
20
%
40
15
%
30
10
20%
5
10%
-10 -5 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40
Dry Bulb Temperature (°C)
Insulation
The majority of the buildings in Nepal has neither a modern cooling nor heating system. On
the one hand thermal comfort requirements are still very low and people are very well adapted
to the local climate [37, 38]. On the other hand the country often suffers from supply shortage
of electricity and fuel which makes the running of space conditioning system extremely costly
and unreliable.
However, in urban centres new commercial buildings and residences of the upper middle
class are increasingly equipped with space conditioning systems. Most common are decentral
split systems and window air-conditioners for cooling as well as portable electric or gas heaters
for heating purposes. Often this space conditioning equipment is added later by the user
of the building because the building owner has no interest to invest in costly central space
conditioning systems.
Is the building owner and user the same person or organisation, which is often the case
for banks, hotels, or office buildings of big companies, the provision of a central HVAC system
might be considered. In this case, a conventional air-driven HVAC system is installed leading
often to oversizing of equipment due to the lack of know-how. Although the climate in the
hilly region of the country, where also the capital Kathmandu is located, require more space
heating than cooling, building owners and builders are more concerned about space cooling.
A reason for this might be the fact that new buildings are often designed with large unshaded
window areas resulting into overheating in the warm season.
The high solar radiation makes the application of solar energy technologies suitable for
Nepal. Solar thermal collectors are already a standard technology for water heating in
residential buildings in the urban centres. Photovoltaic systems were introduced and are still
subsidised for rural electrification in the remote areas of Nepal. Recently, photovoltaic
systems have reached commercial viability as electricity backup in the urban centres of the
country. Compared to photovoltaic systems, conventional diesel backup generators have
higher running costs and supply shortage of petroleum products leads often to unreliability of
these systems.
The increasing trend to install active heating and cooling systems in new buildings
demands for a catalogue of suitable solutions to assure energy-efficient provision of thermal
indoor comfort. In the following section, possible technology solutions are discussed aiming
to make suggestions for heating and cooling systems that are energy-efficient on one side
and can be easily combined with renewable energy supply systems on the other side.
Experiences from the developed countries have shown the negative impact of mechanical
ventilation systems such as the Sick Building Syndrome [39]. Naturally ventilated building are
often more accepted by the user. Consequently, there is a trend towards more user control.
Mechanical ventilation systems are also very energy-intensive and imply higher construction
costs. This has led to the development of more energy-efficient hybrid ventilation concepts
and the mixed mode operation of mechanical heating and cooling systems [40].
The building stock in Nepal is still very traditional and most buildings are naturally
ventilated. It is common practice to open all windows of the house during a cool summer
night and close them in the morning when temperature rises. In contrast, international
investors like big hotel chains are guided by the idea to built sealed envelopes which are fully
air-conditioned hoping to provide the best comfort to their clients.
Looking at the climate conditions in the country, temperature and humidity levels are
moderate for more than six months of the year except for the extreme mountain climate in the
upper Himalaya. Rather than switching towards energy-intensive sealed buildings with
mechanical ventilation systems, natural ventilation can be used to provide thermal comfort at
no cost.
However, when comfort requirements rise mechanical ventilation systems might become
necessary. Particularly, in the warm climate zone of Nepal mechanical ventilation will be
required when using radiant cooling systems due to the need of dehumidification. At noise
polluted sites mechanical ventilation is often the only solution to ensure thermal comfort
without neglecting the acoustic comfort.
area is not sufficient an air-source heat pump or a biomass boiler might be installed, becoming
a very suitable space conditioning system for Nepal’s heating dominated climate regions. For
a solely solar thermal driven system, a large hot water tank might become necessary for
buildings that are occupied for 24 hours.
Radiant floor heating and cooling provides space conditioning through the integration of water-
bearing pipe system into the floor. The floor materials must be heat conducting and preferably
of high to medium thermal mass. The system can be used for heating and cooling. However,
cooling capacity is low because the flow temperature during cooling mode should not be lower
than 18◦ C [41]. Therefore, the radiant floor heating and cooling systems are recommended
for climate conditions with moderate heating and low cooling needs. It is recommended for all
climate zones except warm climate.
The system can be easily powered by renewable energies like ground-source or water-
source heat pump as well as solar thermal collectors. Due to the fact that solar collectors are
often already foreseen for hot-water provision, the collector area could be expanded to power
the radiant floor heating system at very low cost. If the heating demand is higher an air-source
heat pump or biomass boiler can be installed.
The thermal activation of massive building components like concrete slabs or walls is one of
the most cost-effective solutions for moderate cooling and heating loads [42]. The thermal
mass of the building is used as radiant cooling and heating system by integrating a water-
flown pipe system into the concrete ceilings. Therefore, concrete slabs must be exposed.
Using the thermal lag of the building mass, night cooling can decrease the temperature inside
the building and reduce the need for cooling during day. TABS are very much suitable for office
buildings but can also reduce cooling energy in buildings that are occupied 24 hours.
In Nepal’s moderate warm and moderate climate TABS alone might provide sufficient
heating and cooling. However, in warm climate where more cooling is required, the
installation of a mechanical ventilation might be necessary to pre-cool and dehumidify the air.
The main advantage of TABS is the simple integration of renewable energy systems for heat
generation and refrigeration due to the low flow temperature. Ground-source or water-source
heat pumps might be used for heating and cooling: Solar thermal collectors can be used for
heating only.
The chilled beam technology is a central space conditioning system designed to heat and
cool large buildings. The primary advantage compared to conventional central air
conditioning systems is the lower energy consumption and, thus, operating costs. A chilled
beam is a convection system where the air is cooled or heated by passing through a water
driven heat exchanger (chilled beam) which is integrated into the suspended ceiling or
suspended in short distance from the ceiling. If the system needs to provide cooling and
heating a fan coil convector should be installed to ensure sufficient air circulation during the
heating period.
Chilled beam technology might become a technology option for large commercials building
with high thermal comfort needs. For buildings with low ventilation requirements and moderate
cooling load, the use of chilled beams with natural ventilation is possible [42]. However, the
installation of a mechanical ventilation system might be necessary to dehumidify the air during
the monsoon season, particularly in Nepal’s warm climate zone. In this case, heat recovery
is possible and pre-cooling by an earth tunnel or pre-heating by solar air collector could be
provided.
3.7.8 Summary
The previous section summarised some energy-efficient technology options for active heating
and cooling systems in Nepal. Depending on the heating and cooling demand, not all systems
might be suitable for all climate zones. Figure 3.15 and Table 3.2 concludes the applicability
of the space conditioning system by bioclimatic zone and building type, respectively. Table 3.3
summarises which renewable energy sources can be used to power the different systems.
The proposed list of technology options does not claim to be exhaustive. Depending on
the thermal comfort requirements, site conditions and building configuration other heating and
cooling concepts might be applied.
Split system
Hot-water convector
Figure 3.15: Suitability of active heating and cooling systems by climate zone
Table 3.2: Recommended heating and cooling systems by building type (based on [41, 42])
Table 3.3: Renewable energy integration for heating and cooling systems
Nepal’s energy consumption per capita is still very low in comparison to industrialised
countries. Access to reliable and affordable energy sources is fundamental for economic
development [3]. However, any new policy with regard to energy utilisation has to consider
the environmental impact on the one side and the sustainable economic growth on the other.
Policies that foster energy consumption are less likely to speed up economic development in
Nepal than to degrade the environment [43]. In contrast, policies strategies for energy
conservation and carbon emission reduction would not hamper the long-term economic
growth and are, therefore, the most appropriate policy option. Nepal’s policy makers should
focus on the enhancement of efficient energy use, particularly, under the scenario of the
unreliable power supply and the increasing dependency on fossil fuel imports [43].
The issue of energy efficiency has been incorporated into policy strategies like the draft of
the National Energy Strategy, the National Climate Change Policy and the National Urban
Development Strategy [44–46]. However, energy efficiency in buildings is not yet
incorporated into the regulatory framework for building construction. There is no building
energy conservation code in place and the national building code is mainly concerned about
the structural resistance, particularly, in regard to earthquake safety [26]. The building bye
laws set minimum requirements for access, open space, building area and height,
daylighting, and ventilation [47].
For this reason, it is highly recommended to develop and introduce a building energy
conservation code. International experience has shown that mandatory building energy
codes are a highly efficient policy measure to foster energy efficiency in buildings [6].
However, one of the main challenges regarding the implementation of energy-efficient
buildings in least developed countries is to cover the incremental cost [48]. Although the life
cycle cost study for hotel buildings in Nepal has shown that most energy efficiency measures
pay back the initial investment [7], building owners might not be able to afford the additional
investment costs. Therefore, it is important to focus on policy measures for the market
segment where the economic benefits are greatest, resulting into high probability of
enforcement, for example commercial buildings.
Electricity prices in Nepal are still very low. However, the scheduled electricity outages
caused by the power crisis has lead to the need of expensive diesel-driven backup systems.
Particularly in the commercial building sector and the larger scale residential building
developments electricity backup systems are essential to provide proper services. In this
market segment, the incremental cost of energy-efficient design can easily be recovered by
reduced investment and running costs for expensive backup systems. Properly designed,
these buildings might need a less powerful backup system or can provide the same services
without any which would, finally, reduce the incremental cost.
In the residential sector policies should concentrate on measures which do not increase
the investment costs of the building such as design strategies and optimal orientation,
shading, natural ventilation, locally available low-cost construction techniques and insulation
materials. This can be done by the adoption of design guidelines for energy efficient homes
according to the bioclimatic zones based on this research (see previous sections). The
Green Homes Project initiated by UN-Habitat has shown that municipalities are willing to
incorporate energy-efficient and sustainable building components in their regulations [49]. In
the long run such guidelines should lead to a national mandatory Green Building Code which
considers energy efficiency on the one hand but also other sustainability issues like water
efficiency, environmental impact of building materials and so on.
The Nepal Energy Efficiency Programme (NEEP), a Nepali-German cooperation
programme to promote energy efficiency, started to support the Nepali government in 2010 to
promote energy efficiency in various sectors with the technical support of the Deutsche
Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit (GIZ). The building sector, except energy
audits in few hotels, was not in the focus of the programme in the beginning. Since 2014,
NEEP is promoting the introduction of market based energy efficiency services for the private
and public sector. Furthermore, it supports the Nepali government to institutionalise an
energy efficiency entity which is envisaged to mainstream energy efficiency in the country
and to establish a regulatory framework. [50]
Many studies have identified that the lack of awareness and know-how is one of the major
barriers for the implementation of energy efficiency measures [51, 52]. Therefore, the
government has to take the lead and initiate pilot projects of energy-efficient public buildings
such as government offices, schools or low-cost housing to showcase the feasibility of
energy-efficient buildings. In the long term, energy efficiency has to be a key consideration in
government buildings. Consequently, the right signal will be given to push the construction
sector towards more energy efficiency.
Besides the building design, new regulations need to target energy consuming appliances
in buildings which are mostly imported from neighbouring countries. There is an urgent need to
adopt an energy labelling for such appliances to reduce the waste of energy through inefficient
household applicances. Due to the fact that the neighbouring countries India and China have
already such appliance standards in place, the official recognition of these standards might be
a fast way to introduce an appliance standard for such a small market place like Nepal.
The introduction of mandatory energy performance audits is recommended to foster
energy efficiency in large commercial and public buildings. Therefore, a mechanism for
certified energy auditors like in India could assure quality audits not only in industrial but also
in the building sector [53].
The state-owned utility Nepal Electricity Authority (NEA) can also play an active role in
promoting energy efficiency. Similar to the campaign for energy-efficient light bulbs (CFL),
NEA should conduct subsidy programmes for energy-efficient building technologies. In
countries like Brazil, utilities have conducted refurbishment programmes in informal
settlements resulting into the reduction of electricity theft [54].
To overcome financial barriers the development of specific grant and incentive schemes is
necessary. This could be done by the establishment of partnerships with international bodies,
for example through climate change adaptation programmes or similar. Furthermore, fiscal
instruments like import tax exemption on energy-efficient building technologies and the
reduction of building permit fees for energy-efficient designs can contribute to reduce the
incremental cost. Fiscal incentives for national industries to develop low-energy building
technologies (e.g. lightweight concrete blocks or insulation materials based on rice husk) can
strengthen the local economy and reduce the need to import.
Finally, extensive awareness raising and training programs are required to ensure the
implementation of energy efficiency policy measures. Thereby, all stakeholder of the building
value chain have to be targeted to assure regulation enforcement. In the long term energy
efficiency has to be incorporated into all educational institutes that train building
professionals. (see Table 3.4)
Energy consumption in developing countries like Nepal will increase with economic
development and rising living standards. The pace of growth depends strongly on how fast
modern consumption patterns are adopted. The comparison of energy use per capita and
human development index from 1990 and 2012 in Figure 4.1 illustrates the different
development paths in developing countries. Brazil could reach the same level of development
as China with only two third of per capita energy consumption. A major share of consumption
growth will be used in buildings for heating and cooling purpose.
In order to give an outlook on the impact of energy conservation in the future, energy
savings scenarios for the Nepalese building sector were developed. On the one hand, the
hotel building sector is selected for the scenario development representing an important growth
sector for economic development. On the other hand, future saving potentials are estimated
India
0.40
Nepal
0.20
0.00
0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500
Energy consumption (toe/capita)
Figure 4.1: Energy use and human development index (HDI) from 1990 to 2012 for selected
countries (Data from [55, 56])
63
Building energy conservation for low-carbon development
for the residential sector being the major contributor to energy consumption growth.
Projections for Nepal’s hotel buildings estimate that the annual energy demand for space
conditioning will grow from 10.2 GWh in 2016 to 189.5 GWh in 2040 (Figure 4.2a). Assuming
a moderate energy efficiency scenario (EE–2), energy savings of 39.2 GWh or 21% could
be achieved in 2040. In the high energy efficiency scenario (EE–5) energy savings of about
81.5 GWh or 43% are obtained. Assuming that the consumption share of electricity is going
to increase from 5% in 2016 to 29% in 2040, about 54.9 GWh of electricity will be used for
heating and cooling in hotels in 2040 under the Business-as-usual (BAU) scenario. In the
moderate (EE–2) and high (EE–5) energy efficiency scenario this amount will be reduced to
43.6 GWh and 31.3 GWh, respectively.
From country perspective the commercial sector including hotels has a share of only 3.4%
of total primary energy consumption. The largest amount of energy (80.4%) is consumed in
the residential sector corresponding to 84.0 TWh. About 12.1 TWh (14%) of this amount is
150
100
50
0
2020 2025 2030 2035 2040
(a) Energy demand
60 54.9
43.6
40
31.3
20 13.5 11.9
9.5
1.8 1.8 1.7
0
2020 2030 2040
Figure 4.2: Energy demand projection of hotel buildings in Nepal under different scenariosa
(BAU: Business-as-usual scenario, EE-2: Moderate energy efficiency scenario, EE-5: High
energy efficiency scenario)
a
Assumptions described in appendix Approach for energy saving scenarios
used for heating and cooling whereby 98% comes from traditional biomass. Electricity use for
space conditioning in residential buildings amounts to 218 GWh which correspond to 1.8% of
primary energy. About 28% of this amount is used for heating and 78% for cooling. Concerning
the whole power sector of Nepal, about 7% of all electricity is used for space conditioning in
residential buildings. [57]
Today traditional biomass for heating purposes is mainly used in the rural areas whereby
electricity for heating and cooling is used in the urban centres of the country. In the future,
further urbanisation and increasing living standards will lead to a substantial growth of
electricity use for space conditioning in Nepalese dwellings.
In a Business-as-usual (BAU) scenario which assumes no further energy efficiency
improvements, it is estimated that the residential energy consumption for heating and cooling
will rise from 12.1 TWh in 2011 to 90 TWh in 2040. Considering a slow dissemination of
energy efficient building design and technologies (Scenario EE–1) consumption would
increase to only 83.1 TWh. In the moderate energy efficiency scenario (EE–3) energy
consumption is estimated to rise only to 69.2 TWh in 2040. That means energy savings of
23% could be achieved under a moderate energy efficiency scenario (EE–3) in 2040.
The residential energy scenario assumes that the share of electricity use for heating and
cooling rises from 1.8% in 2011 to 30.8% in 2040. Consequently, in the BAU scenario
residential buildings will consume annually 27.7 TWh of electricity in 2040. In the slow (EE–1)
and moderate (EE–3) energy efficiency scenario electricity demand is predicted to rise to
only 25.6 TWh and 21.3 TWh, respectively.
According to the BAU scenario the amount of electricity consumed by building’s space
conditioning systems in 2040 will rise by a factor of more than hundred. This will increase the
need to expand the power supply side drastically. Having experienced the severe impact of
the current power crisis which is hampering the economic development in Nepal, demand side
management should be on the priority agenda of policy makers. Slowing down consumption
growth reduces the need for high investments in the construction of new hydro power plants.
The presented energy scenarios show that energy efficiency in buildings can considerably
slow down the growth of the energy consumption. Therefore, government regulations and
policy actions are indispensable to ensure a low carbon development path for the country.
80
60
40
20
0
2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040
(a) Energy demand
30 27.7
25.6
21.3
20
10.2 9.7
8.8
10
3.1 3.1 2.6
0
2020 2030 2040
(b) Electricity demand
Figure 4.3: Energy demand projection of residential buildings in Nepal under different
scenariosa (BAU: Business-as-usual scenario, EE-1: Slow energy efficiency scenario, EE-3:
Moderate energy efficiency scenario)
a
Assumptions described in appendix Approach for energy saving scenarios
The modernisation of the Nepalese building sector is going through a critical transition.
Economic development, population growth and fast urbanisation will lead to a substantial
increase of energy consumption in buildings and the change of technology used for heating
and cooling purposes. Figure 4.4a and Figure 4.4b illustrates the implication of switching
heating and cooling technologies regarding energy consumption in buildings.
Traditional biomass which is still used for space heating in the rural areas will be soon
replaced by modern heating technologies like liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) heaters and
electric heaters and later by split heat pumps and central heating systems (see Figure 4.4a).
The positive effect of switching to modern fuels is a reduction in energy intensity in the first
run. However, more LPG for space heating has to be imported which will widen the trade
deficit with India. Inefficient electric heaters will add substantial load to the power grid and
worsen the power deficit, if the further expansion of the electricity generation is not sufficient
to cover the additional demand. Modern split heat pumps can provide space heating at higher
High
Inefficient
Heating energy
building
Energy-efficient
building
Low
Traditional LPG Electric Split heat Central
biomass heater heater pump heating
High
Inefficient
buildings
Cooling energy
Energy-efficient
buildings
Low
Figure 4.4: Technology transition and building energy use for heating and cooling in Nepal
efficiency than electric heaters. Still they imply a growth of the electricity demand growth. At
a later stage central heating systems might be disseminated in the market due to higher
comfort needs. This transition can also be critical if such systems rely on imported fossils.
Currently, most buildings in Nepal are cooled by natural ventilation because thermal
comfort requirements are still very low compared to the developed world. However, there is a
trend to install modern cooling technologies like fans and window air conditioners in office
buildings. The dissemination of these technologies in the whole building sector will add
electricity load to the power grid and, consequently, will be critical for the reliability of the
power supply system. In the cooling dominated climate region central air conditioning system
might become a standard technology in the future to fulfil higher thermal comfort standards.
The transition to buildings with modern space conditioning technologies that are more
energy intensive will consequently lead to an substantial growth of energy consumption. In
particular, the use of so called modern fuels like electricity and fossil fuels will increase. The
consumption growth can only be slowed down by promoting energy-efficient building design
and the use of highly-efficient space conditioning systems. Building design should optimise the
use of natural resources for passive heating and cooling as well as natural ventilation. In the
heating dominated climate zone building envelope insulation is critical to reduce the energy
demand of mechanical heating systems. In the cooling dominated regions solar control is
required to avoid overheating and reduce the energy demand of active cooling systems.
Projections for Nepal’s energy sector indicate that the transition from traditional and fossil
fuels to electricity is imminent [58]. It is predicted that the electricity supply will continue to
be based on hydro power which is free of climate-damaging carbon emissions. Hence, the
switch to space conditioning systems that rely solely on electricity might become the most
environmentally friendly option. However, the current critical situation of the power supply is
casting doubts with regard to such a scenario being feasible. Therefore, the integration of
decentralised renewable energy systems into modern heating and cooling systems is highly
recommended.
This PhD research is the first comprehensive study on climate-responsive design and energy
efficiency in buildings conducted in the context of the developing country of Nepal.
Recognising the importance of traditional knowledge, a large number of vernacular houses in
different climate regions of the country were analysed to identify passive design strategies for
each climate.
Furthermore, the first bioclimatic zoning for Nepal was developed analysing a climate data
from all of the country. Due to the climatic diversity within the Nepalese territory, the
bioclimatic zoning for building design is essential to develop and introduce energy-efficient
design guidelines or an energy conservation building code.
Finally, the effectiveness of passive design strategies for each climate zone was evaluated
in a quantitative manner for one sub-sector (hotel buildings) and cost-effective insulation
levels for the building envelope are proposed. The quantification of energy savings and
cost-effectiveness of passive design strategies resulted in design guidelines for
energy-efficient hotel buildings in Nepal which can be used to develop an energy
conservation building code.
It was not in the scope of this research to cover all aspects and areas of energy efficiency
in buildings in Nepal. Few important issues were selected that have been identified as crucial
to set the foundation. Thereby, the focus was on the architectural design to reduce the
operational energy demand for space heating and cooling. Energy consumption for lighting
and appliances was not considered. Similarly, the topic of embodied energy that can amount
to a substantial share of the building’s life cycle energy demand was not in the scope of this
study.
Conducting research in developing countries like Nepal is facing the challenge of the lack
of reliable data, especially with regard to the building stock. Monitoring studies on energy
performance of buildings were not yet conducted. Climate data in form of a typical
meteorological year, which is the main input to conduct thermal energy simulation, is only
available for two locations in the whole country. Therefore, this doctoral research had either to
collect and generate the needed data or to make reasonable assumptions.
Future research in the field of energy efficiency in buildings in Nepal is needed to
consolidate the findings of this research. Surveys and measurement-based studies on the
energy use in buildings should be conducted for different building types and in the different
climate zone to fully understand the dimension of the growing energy consumption.
Recently, few Nepalese architects and building owners have started to implement energy-
efficient design strategies in newly constructed buildings. These pioneer designs should be
analysed and monitored to find out which design strategies are effective to provide thermal
comfort with minimum energy input.
Further simulation-based studies are needed to investigate which passive design
measures are effective in building typologies other than hotels. Consequently, building
sub-sectors can be identified where policy intervention is most needed, leading to substantial
energy savings. The focus on electricity savings will determine which actions are required to
slow down the electricity consumption growth in buildings and, thus, to reduce the
demand-supply gap in the power sector.
[1] WBCSB. Energy efficiency in buildings transforming the market. Tech. rep. Geneva:
World Business Council for Sustainable Development (WBCSD), 2009 (cited on
page 1).
[2] International Energy Agency. Transition to sustainable buildings - Strategies and
opportunities to 2050. 2013 (cited on page 1).
[3] P. Hennicke and S. Bodach. Energierevolution: Effizienzsteigerung und erneuerbare
Energien als globale Herausforderung. München: Oekom-Verlag, 2010 (cited on
pages 1, 2, 58).
[4] UNEP. Towards a Green Economy: Pathways to Sustainable Development and Poverty
Eradication. 2011 (cited on page 1).
[5] L. Pérez-Lombard, J. Ortiz, and C. Pout. “A review on buildings energy consumption
information”. In: Energy and Buildings 40.3 (2008), pp. 394–398 (cited on page 2).
[6] J. Iwaro and A. Mwasha. “A review of building energy regulation and policy for energy
conservation in developing countries”. In: Energy Policy 38.12 (2010), pp. 7744–7755
(cited on pages 2, 58).
[7] S. Bodach, W. Lang, and J. Hamhaber. “Climate responsive building design strategies
of vernacular architecture in Nepal”. In: Energy and Buildings 81 (2014), pp. 227–242
(cited on pages 5, 8–11, 19, 35, 43, 47, 51, 58, 83).
[8] S. Bodach. “Developing Bioclimatic Zones and Passive Solar Design Strategies for
Nepal”. In: The 30th PLEA Conference - Sustainable habitat for developing societies.
Ahmedabad, 2014 (cited on pages 5, 13, 15–19, 25, 101).
[9] S. Bodach, W. Lang, and T. Auer. “Design guidelines for energy-efficient hotels in Nepal”.
In: International Journal of Sustainable Built Environment (2016) (cited on pages 5,
19–24, 30, 31, 35, 39, 41, 43, 47, 51, 111).
[10] B. Givoni. Man, Climate and Architecture. Ed. by Henry J. Cowan. Amsterdam - London
- New York: Elsevier Publishing Company Limited, 1969 (cited on pages 7, 8, 13).
[11] O. H. Koenigsberger et al. Manual of Tropical Housing and Building: Climatic design.
Reprint. University Press (India). 2010. Longman, 1974 (cited on pages 7, 8).
71
References
[12] V. Olgyay. Design with the Climate. Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press,
1963, p. 190 (cited on page 7).
[13] R. Shanthi Priya et al. “Solar passive techniques in the vernacular buildings of coastal
regions in Nagapattinam, TamilNadu-India – a qualitative and quantitative analysis”. In:
Energy and Buildings 49 (June 2012), pp. 50–61 (cited on page 7).
[14] L. Borong et al. “Study on the thermal performance of the Chinese traditional vernacular
dwellings in Summer”. In: Energy and Buildings 36.1 (2004), pp. 73–79 (cited on page 7).
[15] A.S. Dili, M.A. Naseer, and T. Zacharia Varghese. “Passive control methods of Kerala
traditional architecture for a comfortable indoor environment: Comparative investigation
during various periods of rainy season”. In: Building and Environment 45.10 (2010),
pp. 2218–2230 (cited on page 7).
[16] A.S. Dili, M.A. Naseer, and T. Varghese Zacharia. “Passive control methods for a
comfortable indoor environment: Comparative investigation of traditional and modern
architecture of Kerala in summer”. In: Energy and Buildings 43.2-3 (2011), pp. 653–664
(cited on page 7).
[17] S.V. Szokolay. Introduction to architectural science: the basis of sustainable design.
Elsevier Architectural Press, 2008 (cited on page 13).
[18] Instituto Nacional de Normalización. Arquitectura y construcción - Zonificación
climático habitacional para Chile y recomendaciones para el diseño arquitectónico -
Norma Chilena Oficial. Chile, 1977. (Visited on 07/15/2014) (cited on page 13).
[19] N.K. Bansal and G. Minke. Climatic Zones and Rural Housing in India. Scientific. Jülich:
Kernforschungsanlage Jülich GmbH, 1988 (cited on page 13).
[20] Instituto Nacional de Normalización. Clasificación bioambiental de la República
Argentina IRAM 11603:1996. 1996 (cited on page 13).
[21] Associação Brasileira de Normas Técnicas. Desempenho térmico de edificações Parte
3: Zoneamento bioclimático brasileiro e diretrizes construtivas para habitações
unifamiliares de interesse social. Rio de Janeiro, 2003 (cited on page 13).
[22] J.C. Lam, L. Yang, and J. Liu. “Development of passive design zones in China using
bioclimatic approach”. In: Energy Conversion and Management 47.6 (2006),
pp. 746–762 (cited on page 13).
[23] ASHRAE. Standard 90.1-2007 Normative Appendix B – Building Envelope Climate
Criteria. 2007 (cited on page 13).
[24] L. Rosales. “Zonas climáticas para el diseño de edificaciones y diagramas
bioclimáticos para Venezuela”. In: Tecnologıa y Construcción 23.1 (2007), pp. 45–60
(cited on page 13).
[25] A. Mahmoud and A. Hassaan. “An analysis of bioclimatic zones and implications for
design of outdoor built environments in Egypt”. In: Building and Environment 46.3
(2011), pp. 605–620 (cited on page 13).
[56] The World Bank. World Development Indicators. 2015. URL: http://data.worldbank.
org/data-catalog/world-development-indicators (visited on 03/01/2016) (cited on
page 63).
[57] WECS. Energy Consumption Situation in Nepal 2012. Tech. rep. Government of Nepal,
Water and Energy Commission Secreatriat (WECS), 2014 (cited on pages 65, 137, 140).
[58] H.B. Rijal and A. M. Narkarmi. “Demand Side Management for Electricity in Nepal:
Need analysis using LEAP Modeling Framework”. In: Proceedings of IOE Graduate
Conference of Tribhuvan University Kathmandu. Tribhuvan University Kathmandu, 2015
(cited on page 68).
[59] ASHRAE. ANSI/ASHRAE Standard 55-2010 Thermal Environmental Conditions for
Human Occupancy. Atlanta: American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and
Air-Conditioning Engineers, Inc., 2010 (cited on page 80).
[60] WTTC. Travel & Tourism Economic Impact 2014 Nepal. Tech. rep. London: World Travel
& Tourism Council, 2014 (cited on page 138).
[61] CBS. Population Atlas of Nepal. Tech. rep. Kathmandu: Government of Nepal, Nationlal
Planning Commission Secretariat, Central Bureau of Statistsics (CBS). URL: http://
cbs.gov.np/atlas/ (visited on 04/10/2016) (cited on page 140).
[62] Ministry of Statistics and Programme Implementation. Housing conditions and
Amenities in India 2008-09. Tech. rep. New Delhi, India: Government of India, 2010
(cited on page 140).
[63] Christoph Schillings, Richard Meyer, and Franz Trieb. Solar and Wind Energy
Resource Assessment (SWERA). Tech. rep. October. DLR-Stuttgart submitted to
UNEP/GEF, 2004 (cited on pages 143–146).
Absolute humidity: Absolute humidity is the measure of moisture (water vapour) in the air,
regardless of temperature, and is expressed as grams of moisture per cubic meter or
kilogram of air.
Base case model: In thermal building simulation, the base case model refers to a reference
design of a building before starting to optimize the design to improve its thermal performance.
Bioclimatic design: Bioclimatic design considers the local climate conditions during the
process of designing a building aiming to provide the best thermal indoor comfort without the
need of mechanical means. Basic elements are passive systems which utilise natural
sources (for example, sun, air, wind, vegetation, water, soil, sky) for heating, cooling and
lighting.
Bioclimatic zoning: Bioclimatic zoning in the context of building design refers to a climate
classification which is developed for building design. Many countries whose territory extents
over several climate zones have developed such a zoning to establish standards and
regulations for energy efficient building design.
Cooling degree day: Cooling degree day (CDD) is a measure of how much (in degrees),
and for how long (in days), outside air temperature was higher than a specific base
temperature (comfortable indoor temperature). It reflects the amount of energy that is needed
to cool a building and is here calculated at a base temperature of 18.3°C according to
ASHRAE-method [35].
Cold stress: Cold stress refers to the condition that occurs when the human body do not feel
comfortable. A cold environment forces the body to work harder to maintain its core
temperature of 37°C. There are four factors which contribute to cold stress in buildings: low
indoor temperatures, increased and cold air movement and dampness. If a person
experiences cold stress depends also on personal factors such as clothing, metabolic heat,
state of health and acclimatisation.
Climate change: The term climate change is used to describe the phenomena of rising
global air temperatures and changing climate patterns which is mainly caused by human
activities. Since the start of the industrialisation, human activities have released large
amounts of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases into the atmosphere. The majority of
greenhouse gases come from burning fossil fuels to produce energy, although deforestation,
77
References
industrial processes, and some agricultural practices also emit gases into the atmosphere.
Energy saving scenario: Energy saving of energy efficiency scenarios provide a framework
for exploring future energy demand in buildings, under different conditions. The starting point
of the analysis is the business-as-usual (BAU) scenario which assumes that the level of
energy efficiency in buildings does not improve in the future. An energy savings scenario
explores how far the energy demand for buildings can be reduced if specific energy efficiency
measures are implemented.
Energy efficiency: Energy efficiency refers to the effort to reduce the energy demand of
buildings to provide thermal and visual comfort to its users. In short, energy efficiency means
using less energy to provide the same level of comfort. The energy use intensity in
kilowatt-hours per square meter is generally used to compare the levels of energy efficiency
between different buildings.
Heat stress: Heat stress is a form of overheating that the occupants of a building may
experience when the measures their body uses to regulate internal temperature begin to fail.
It is dependent on a range of environmental factors like air temperature, air velocity, radiant
temperature, relative humidity and the uniformity of conditions as well as personal factors
such as clothing, metabolic heat, state of health and acclimatisation.
Heating degree day: Heating degree day (HDD) is a measurement which was developed to
estimate the energy demand for heating a building. The heating requirements for a given
building in a specific climate are directly proportional to the number of HDD in this climate.
Heating degree days in this study are defined relative to the base temperature of 18°C
according to EUROSTAT-method [36].
Insulation: The term insulation refers to thermal building insulation which is one of the most
important measures to reduce the energy consumption of buildings. Insulation reduces heat
loss or heat gain through the building envelope and is a key factor to achieve thermal comfort
for its occupants.
Life cycle cost: The life cycle cost of a building includes all recurring and non-recurring costs
over the whole life span of the building. It includes acquisition and construction costs,
operating and maintenance costs as well as residual values. The life cycle cost analysis
(LCCA) is a method for assessing the cost-effectiveness of energy efficiency measures. For
example, with the help of LCCA it can be determined whether the incorporation of a
high-performance HVAC or glazing system, which may increase initial cost but result in
reduced operating and maintenance costs, is cost-effective or not.
Natural ventilation cooling: Natural ventilation cooling describes all design strategies that
enhances the air movement into and within the building to cool down the indoor environment
and increase the thermal comfort of the building user.
Passive cooling: Passive cooling includes all passive design strategies that reduce the need
for mechanical cooling while maintaining thermal comfort. The most important measures are
natural ventilation, thermal mass and orientation for cooling.
Passive design: Passive design concept uses natural resources instead of electricity or fuel
to provide the best indoor comfort for building users. These strategies include daylighting,
natural ventilation, and solar energy.
Passive solar heating: Passive solar heating includes all passive design strategies that
reduce the need for mechanical heating while maintaining thermal comfort. The building’s
design is optimised to increase the solar heat gains during the cold period of the year.
Projection factor: The projection factor (PF) is the ratio of the horizontal depth of the
external shading device (often overhang or fins) divided by the height of the fenestration.
Relative humidity: Relative humidity measures the moisture (water vapour) in the air relative
to the temperature of the air. It is expressed as the amount of moisture in the air as a
percentage of the total amount that could be held at its current temperature.
Solar heat gain coefficient: The solar heat gain coefficient (SHGC) refers to the solar
energy transmittance of a whole window system considering the glazing and frame material
as well as deviders and screens (if present).
Solar control: Solar control describes the process to design a building in such a way to
minimize solar heat gains and, thus, reduces the need for active cooling. This can be
achieved by measures like reducing the window area, optimising the building orientation or
through the shading of windows.
Solar gain: Solar gain, also called solar heat gain, refers to the heat energy from the sun
(solar radiation) which is collected by the building through windows, wall and roof raising the
building’s indoor temperature. The amount of solar gain increases with the ability of any
intervening material to transmit or resist the radiation.
Thermal comfort: Thermal comfort is defined as "that condition of mind which expresses
satisfaction with the thermal environment and is assessed by subjective evaluation." [59]. It
depends on the air temperature, humidity, radiant temperature, air velocity, metabolic rates,
clothing levels and acclimatisation. However, thermal comfort is highly subjective and difficult
to measure because it is highly subjective. Thermal mass is particularly beneficial in climates
with large diurnal temperature differences.
Thermal mass: Thermal mass is the ability of a material to absorb and store thermal energy.
Building materials like concrete, bricks require a lot of thermal energy to change the
temperature because of the high density. They are therefore said to have high thermal mass.
Lightweight materials such as timber have low thermal mass. Depending on the climate, the
appropriate application of thermal mass in buildings can be used to reduce the energy
demand for heating and cooling. For example, thermal mass can store solar energy during
the day and re-radiate it at night (see passive solar heating).
Traditional biomass: Traditional biomass includes firewood, charcoal, manure and crop
residues which plays still a vital role in meeting the energy needs of mostly rural people in
developing countries. In buildings, it is used for cooking and heating. Apart from being
energetically inefficient and time consuming, the use of traditional biomass is connected to
several severe health and environmental problems.
U-Value: The term U-Value, or thermal transmittance (see above), is the rate of heat
transferred through a building structure, divided by the difference in temperature across that
structure. U-values are measured in Watts per square metre per degree Kelvin (W/m²K). The
lower the U-value of a building component, the better it insulates. While a solid brick wall has
an U-value of about 2.0 W/m2 K, a cavity wall without insulation of 1.5 W/m2 K and a very
good insulated wall of 0.18 W/m2 K.
81
Appendix A
Publication I
Contribution:
I was a major contributor to this study. In close cooperation with the co-authors, I developed
the research design, collected the data and conducted several field visits. The analysis and
interpretation of the data was done mainly by me. All authors were involved into the critical
revision of the manuscript and the final approval of the version to be published.
83
Energy and Buildings 81 (2014) 227–242
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Vernacular architecture is the result of hundreds of years of optimization to provide a comfortable shelter
Received 11 January 2014 in a local climate using available materials and known construction technologies. Due to the absence of
Received in revised form 15 April 2014 mechanical means, traditional buildings use solar passive measures to achieve thermal comfort condi-
Accepted 14 June 2014
tions. In most developing countries it can be observed that with the modernization of the building sector
Available online 23 June 2014
this traditional knowledge of smart and climate responsive design is being lost. Instead the modern build-
ing design is dominated by universal architecture that neglects local climate conditions and traditional
Keywords:
construction techniques and materials. This paper reviews examples of vernacular architecture and its
Vernacular architecture
Nepal
building elements in Nepal and analyses in a qualitative manner which bioclimatic design strategies were
Bioclimatic design applied.
Climate responsive building design © 2014 Published by Elsevier B.V.
Developing country
Traditional building techniques
1. Introduction sun and wind [3–7]. Several studies have proven that better thermal
performance can be achieved by passive measures in vernacular
Worldwide around 40% of energy is consumed in buildings [1]. architecture [6–9]. The developing world’s construction practices
Due to population growth, increased urbanization and improve- until recently were basically grounded onto this knowledge of
ments of living standards most of energy consuming buildings traditional building techniques. However, modernization together
will be located in the urban centers of the developing world. The with the need of effective and fast provision of shelters for the
depletion of energy resources and the risk of climate change are increasing population has flooded the market with new building
demanding for a sustainable development path based on renew- designs, technologies and materials. These are rapidly accepted by
able energies and energy efficiency [2]. Climate responsive or solar users who demand for such designs and express increased ther-
passive building design can play a significant role in reducing the mal comfort expectations. The group of new building professionals
energy demand of buildings without compromising modern living does often apply new designs without considering local climate
standards. conditions.
The most important function of buildings is to provide shelter Consequently, traditional houses are disappearing and the
with appropriate thermal and visual indoor comfort for its occu- knowledge about its construction practices is slowly forgotten.
pants. The comfort level in a building depends upon the designs Therefore, the need to document this knowledge of traditional
in combination with the outdoor climate. Design irrespective to constructions practices is evident. Few studies [10–12] have ana-
climatic conditions means either to create uncomfortable indoor lyzed vernacular architecture from specific locations of Nepal
environments or to increase the need for maintaining thermal in regard to climate responsiveness. This research is the first
comfort through artificial means. As our ancestors had fewer tech- comprehensive study on solar passive design features of a large
nologies available for heating and cooling, vernacular houses are number of vernacular houses from all over the country. Fol-
mainly designed to optimize the use of natural resources like the lowing the principle “Learning from the past” [13], it might be
the groundwork to develop new and more sustainable design
strategies for the fast growing building sector that consider
∗ Corresponding author. Tel.: +49 32221782489. the local climatic conditions while aiming at the reduction
E-mail addresses: [email protected] (S. Bodach), [email protected] of energy-intensive and expensive artificial means to provide
(W. Lang), [email protected] (J. Hamhaber). comfort.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.enbuild.2014.06.022
0378-7788/© 2014 Published by Elsevier B.V.
228 S. Bodach et al. / Energy and Buildings 81 (2014) 227–242
Abundant: wood, thatch, daub, and the harsh climatic condition timber and other organic materials
other biogenic materials, mud, for building purposes are rather scarce.
biogenic materials
Nepal has large climatic variations from hot sub-tropical cli-
mate to cold tundra climate. Several geographical factors influence
sand, gravel
materials
and hot summers (Cwa), warm climate with dry winters and warm
Typical vegetation
summers (Cwb), snow climate with dry and cold winter and cool
Scarce vegetation
Sal forest
Sal forest
Nepal, local climate data from four typical locations of Nepal were
collected and analyzed. Tundra climate is not considered in the
analysis due to the fact that there are very few settlements above
Soil type
per month.
Kathmandu (27◦ 42 N, 85◦ 22 E) is representing the warm tem-
perate climate of Nepal that is mainly dominant in the Hilly
Region (Koeppen: Cwb). During summer outdoor conditions are
Altitudes (m)
2000–5000
2500–4000
200–1000
200–2000
>5000
average.
Dhunche (28◦ 48 N, 85◦ 18 E) situated in the Himalayan Moun-
10–35
20–50
10–50
5–30
40–60
20–70
10–60
5–50
Himalayan Valleys
Higher Himalaya
Inner and Trans
Fore Himalaya
Churia Hills or
Gangetic Plain
Hilly Region
(Mountain)
Region
Table 1
Table 2
Nepal’s climatic zone (after [24]).
Climatic zone Altitude Mean temperature Annual average precipitation Selected locations
Winter Summer
4. Climate-responsive design strategies for Nepal winter period. The protection of the building from heavy monsoon
rain is necessary according to the Mahoney Table (Table 3).
For the four representative locations the following design rec-
ommendations were identified by using Olgyay’s bioclimatic chart
[3], Givoni’s psychrometric chart [4] and Mahoney Table [5] as
described in the methodology above. Exemplarily, Givoni charts 4.2. Warm temperate climate
for four climates are shown in Fig. 3.
Temperature in Nepal’s warm temperate climate does not drop
down drastically during winter. Therefore, solar radiation com-
4.1. Sub-tropical climate bined with thermal mass of the building can keep the indoor
temperature at a comfortable level. Buildings should be oriented
The enhancement of air movement is essential for the sub- with the longer façade toward south and have medium sized open-
tropical climate of Nepal. It is recommended to allocate rooms ings; by this way solar penetration of the south façade could provide
single-banked and provide permanent provision for air movement, solar heat gains in winter (when the sun angle is low) and reduce
e.g. through cross or stack ventilation. According to the Mahoney overheating in summer. Shading devices for windows are needed
Table (Table 3) houses should be oriented north and south (long axis for the summer period. From December to January active solar or
east–west) to reduce solar heat gains, particularly during the hot conventional heating might be partly needed. The Mahoney Table
season. Openings should be of medium size (20–40% of outer wall recommends heavy external and internal walls and light but well
area) and exclude direct sunlight during summer months through insulated roofs. However, according to Givoni’s chart thermal mass
shading devices. High thermal mass with night ventilation might is only favorable during April and May to balance the internal tem-
provide thermal comfort, particularly during the hot and dry sum- perature swing (Fig. 3). In humid summer months air movement is
mer period. However, light building materials are recommended the essential bioclimatic design strategy for Nepal’s warm temper-
for the hot and humid monsoon season. Light, well insulated roofs ate climate. Therefore, single-banked room arrangement or other
are recommendable for this climate. Olgyay’s chart and Givoni’s means of natural ventilation are recommended (Table 3). Heavy
chart indicates that solar radiation in form of solar passive heat- rains during monsoon season claim for protection and adequate
ing can be sufficient to provide thermal comfort during the short rainwater drainage.
90 %
90 %
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
0
0
80
80
40
40
60
50
60
50
10
10
70
70
AH Active Heating 8
SPH Solar Passive Heating 7 25 25
CZ Comfort Zone
%
V Natural Ventilation
30
30
6
TM Thermal Mass V 20 V 7 20
9
TMV Thermal Mass with Night 5 6
DH DH
Ventilation 9
90 %
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
0
0
40
40
80
80
50
50
60
60
10
10
70
70
Location:Dhunche 1982 m Location:Thakmarpha 2566 m
28° 48' N, 85° 18' E 25 28° 45' N, 83° 42' E 25
%
%
30
30
V 20 V 20
8 DH DH
7
ABSOLUTE HUMIDITY (g/Kg)
Fig. 3. Givoni’s bioclimatic chart for four representative climate zones of Nepal.
In cool temperate climate the use of solar radiation for passive In contrast to the conditions within the cool temperate climate
heating is an effective design strategy during the longer winter zone, Nepal’s alpine climate is far colder and dryer. Protection
period from October to March. In contrast to warm temperate cli- from the cold is necessary from October to April (Table 3). There-
mate a compact building layout is recommended by the Mahoney fore, compact building layout and small openings (15–25% of outer
Table. During half of the year active solar or conventional heating is wall area) are recommended. According to the Mahoney Table
needed, particularly during night time. However, due to high solar room arrangement should be double-banked with temporary pro-
radiation in winter solar passive heating combined with thermal vision for air movement during summer days. Heavy external
mass (heavy walls and floors with thermal time-lag of more than and internal walls are dominant climate-responsive design strate-
8 h) can reduce the need for conventional heating considerably. The gies to enhance solar passive heating effect for large temperature
rest of the year passive solar heating solely can provide comfort dur- swing between day and night. In contrast to Nepal’s temperate
ing cool nights. From June to September natural ventilation of the climates heavy roofs with thermal lag of more than eight hours
building is needed to avoid over-heating during the day (Table 3). are desired. Active solar or artificial heating is required during
According to Mahoney Table openings should be medium sized and long winter periods. In summer nights comfort can be achieved
protection from heavy rains as well as adequate rainwater drainage if the building’s thermal mass can store enough heat that is gained
is necessary. from solar radiation during the day. Low precipitation amounts
Table 3
Recommended design strategies for each month in different climate zones of Nepal according to Mahoney Table.
Design strategy Subtropical climate Warm temperate climate Cool temperate climate Alpine climate
J FMAM J J A SON D J FMAMJ J ASOND J FMAM J J ASOND J FMAMJ J ASON D
H1: Air movement essential
H2: Air movement desirable
H3: Rain protection necessary
A1: Thermal capacity
A2: Outdoor sleeping
A3: Protection from cold
232 S. Bodach et al. / Energy and Buildings 81 (2014) 227–242
eliminate the need to protect the building from heavy rains or high 5.1.3. Building stories and internal space arrangement
humidity. Most vernacular houses in Tarai have only one single floor or,
like Rana Tharu houses, a ground floor with a mezzanine that is
5. Climate-responsive design in vernacular houses of used as storage [15]. They have high ceilings for enhancing per-
different climate regions manent ventilation that is strongly needed in this hot and humid
climate. However, due to increasing urbanization and higher settle-
A total number of 19 vernacular house are analyzed in the fol- ment density one of the Tharu studied houses in the Eastern Nepal
lowing according to the climate classification. The locations of the was found to be of two-story.
houses are shown on the map in Fig. 4. The spaces in the studied houses are organized more in a hor-
izontal manner. The internal space is almost undivided and, thus,
enhances a continuous natural circulation of cool air coming from
5.1. Sub-tropical climate the shaded area below the eaves [12]. The studied Longhouses have
only one division that does not reach the roof so that air can freely
The analysis of vernacular architecture in Nepal’s subtropical circulate (Fig. 5). In Rana Tharu houses big vessels, which store
climate refers to the following houses: Tharu houses in Chitwan grain, are used for dividing the space. In all Tharu houses semi-open
(field research), Traditional Tarai houses [12,27], Rana Tharu house spaces in form of a veranda are occupying a large part of the floor
in Kanchanpur district of Far-western region [15], Dangaura Tharu plan. The verandas are shaded by the roof overhang and provide
house in Dang district of Mid-western Region [15,16] and Eastern an additional comfortable space for daily activities (Fig. 6). Hav-
Kochila Tharu in Morang and Sunsari of Eastern Nepal [15]. ing two story houses, the Eastern Kochila Tharus use the second
Due to the dominating tropical monsoon climate houses have floor mainly as sleeping rooms and storage. One-third of the second
to protect from heat and heavy rainfall [27]. Local materials mainly floor plan consists of a veranda that provides a breezy semi-open
used are cane, timber and thatch [12]. They lead to the design of a sleeping space for hot and humid summer months [15].
comfortable ‘breathing’ house that means the building envelope is
rather permeable and enhance natural ventilation [15].
5.1.4. Walls
5.1.1. Settlement pattern The walls of traditional Tarai houses are rather light and mostly
The traditional settlement pattern in sub-tropical climate of made of wattle and daub [27]. The upper portion of the exterior
Nepal is rather loose than dense. Tharu houses are either loosely wall is observed to be of bamboo strips that are loosely woven into
situated along the road or they create clusters of semi-closed com- an open mesh which provide day lighting and permanent ventila-
pounds [15,16]. Rana Tharu houses are arranged around a courtyard tion. Unplastered walls of wood or reed have random gaps. External
that is open to at least one side so that breezy winds can flow walls might also be made of thin woven cane mats tied onto a
through the settlement. In the Dangaura Tharu village the long timber frame, rendered with mud plaster and white washed [12].
houses are arranged in one single row along the road with a wide
open yard in front of each house [12]. This facilitates easy penetra- 5.1.5. Roof
tion of air through the houses. Most traditional roofs in Nepal’s subtropical climate are made
of thatch in the form of a pitched roof [12,15,16]. The triangular
5.1.2. Building form and orientation opening at either end and the low windows ensures the perma-
The buildings have rectangular floor plans that are enclosed nent inflow of air from the shaded area below the eaves that leads to
with low walls, sometimes no higher than 75 cm [12]. Dangaura inside temperatures that are usually much lower than outside tem-
and Eastern Kochila Tharu houses are found to be typical Long- peratures [12] (Fig. 7). Dangaura and Kochila Tharu houses have also
houses while Rana Tharu houses have a more compact floor plan. light, well insulating thatch roofs. The wide roof overhang protects
The longer axis of Dangaura Tharu houses is more than twice of the walls from direct sun radiation. Verandas are formed by extending
shorter axis. The longer facade is typically oriented north–south the roofs and provide a comfortable place to work and even sleep
which reduces the exposure to the sun. at night [27].
S. Bodach et al. / Energy and Buildings 81 (2014) 227–242 233
Sleeping
Kitchen
Sleeping
5.1.7. Openings
Buildings have very few and low windows that together with an
opening in the roof enhance the air circulation to provide comfort
during hot and humid summer months [12]. Shading of the win-
Indoor dows is provided through roof overhangs and the planting of trees
Storage around the buildings [27].
Table 4
Characteristics of vernacular houses in subtropical climate of Nepal.
Tharu house in Chitwan Traditional Tarai houses Rana Tharu house Dangaura Tharu house Kochila Tharu house
Settlement pattern Scattered clusters Loose clusters of Loose pattern around open Loose, along the road side Loose building clusters
semi-enclosed compounds courtyard along road
Building form Rectangular Rectangular floor plan Compact layout Elongated Elongated
Building n.s. n.s. Longer façade north–south Longer side east–west Long facades east–west
orientation wards oriented
Building stories 1 1 1.5 1 2
Internal space Horizontal, few divisions Horizontal manner, almost Horizontal, mezzanine Horizontal, few division Mainly horizontal, 2nd
arrangement undivided open space used as storage floor includes open
veranda
Semi-open spaces Veranda Veranda Open courtyard, veranda Veranda Open courtyard, veranda in
second floor
Wall material Wattle and daub, straw Mud plastered woven cane Mud plastered Low walls of wood and Lumber on timber
and mud, timber, bamboo mat tied on timber frame timber/bamboo walls bamboo covered by mud structure
layer
Wall thickness Very thin Thin, permeable to air Thin Thin Thin, permeable to air
Roof material Thatch Thatch or tiles Tiles Bamboo lathes with thatch Thatch
covering
Roof type Pitched roof Hipped roofs Pitched roof Hipped roof Pitched roof
Roof overhang Wide Wide Wide Large Large
Foundation Plinth of stone and mud Stone plinth or wooden Earth/stone plinth Slightly raised platform Earth/stone plinth
piling
Floor Compacted earth with fine Compacted earth or clay n.s. Covered by mud layer n.s.
mud layer tiles made
Ceiling High High ceilings High ceiling High ceiling n.s.
Openings Very small Upper part of exterior wall n.s. Few and small openings Few and very small, doors
is made of loose bamboo are largest openings
strips
5.2.5. Roof oriented southwards. The side and the back wall have often no
The typical roof type applied in vernacular architecture in the openings except a small hole from the kitchen which is used as
warm temperate climate of Nepal is the pitched roof supported smoke outlet. In Newar houses the main living room has a big win-
by a timber structure and covered by locally available hatch, stone dow with decorative wood carvings that allows solar radiation of
slates or tiles. A large roof overhang of minimum 50 cm protects the lower angle to heat the room in winter [20] (Fig. 9). Many houses
walls from the heavy monsoon rain and avoids solar penetration of have grilled windows to protect from solar penetration in summer
the facade during summer [14,16]. In Central Nepal the roofs were [12]. Remarkable, in Limbu houses the main entry door and larger
typically covered by thatch that lasts properly maintained up to windows are placed on the shorter facade of the building that is
eight years [16]. In Dolakha’s Hill houses slate on timber structure faced southwards [16]. Although most authors describe hilly houses
is the main roofing material. The pitched roofs of Limbu and Gurung have small windows, compared with mountain houses they are of
houses are very steep and use thatch, straw or grass as roofing. medium size. The windows are almost always oriented southwards
Newar architecture has developed a water inclusive roof design aiming to enhance solar heat gains during winter. The openings are
of burnt clay tiles which are placed upon a mud layer of 4–10 cm often equipped with shutters that can be closed during cold nights
[14,32]. in summer and the cold season. In this way the envelope tightness
is increased and the heat losses are reduced.
All studied houses of Hilly Nepal use a large roof overhang to
5.2.6. Foundation, floors and ceiling
shade south facade and windows. In Indo-Nepalese houses the
Most houses in warm temperate climate of Nepal have a stone
veranda that is located in front of the longer facade has a thatch
foundation that protects from flooding during the monsoon sea-
covered timber roof structure to provide shading [16]. In the Limbu
son. The foundation of Newar houses is made of a 60–80 cm deep
houses an overhanging timber structure is used to form a veranda
stone plinth [14,20]. In Indo-Nepalese houses and those studied in
surrounding the house in the first floor [16]. The Gurung houses
Dolakha a 30–50 cm thick stone platform serves as foundation of
have deep overhanging eaves restrained by brackets [12]. The roof
the building. This platform is often extended about 1.50 m at either
overhang of Newar architecture is widely known because of his dec-
one or more sides of the exterior walls to create a veranda which
orative character, particularly, in temples and palaces where fine
is used as semi open working space. The ceilings are very low (not
wood carvings can be seen. Moreover, the roof overhang protects
more 1.80 m) to reduce the air volume that needs to be heated dur-
the walls from the heavy monsoon rain.
ing the cold season. In all studied houses a wooden framework of
pillars and beams is used to support the ceilings. It is covered by
lathwork and rough casting of 20 cm mud layer and a final layer of
5.2.8. Results
a mixture of clay and cow dung [16]. In other houses clay or earth is
It was observed that many building features of the different
used for flooring [32]. Wood was widely available in the hilly area
houses in warm temperate climate of Nepal are largely similar
and is, therefore, used as structural as well as covering material. The
(Table 5). Most vernacular houses have a rectangular floor plan.
additional use of clay and earth increases the thermal mass of the
The longer facade with the openings is often oriented southwards
floor and contribute to balance the diurnal temperature changes.
to enhance solar gains during winter. Due to the wide roof over-
hang the building facades and windows are shaded in summer. In
5.2.7. Openings the dense Newar settlements the smart arrangement of courtyards
The openings in houses of Hilly Nepal are rather small, but assures solar passive heating in winter and shading in summer.
larger than those in the mountain houses. The windows are mainly Generally, houses in this climate are of high thermal mass using
located in the longer facade that faces downhill and is mostly locally available materials. Particularly, during sunny winter days
236
Table 5
Characteristics of vernacular houses in warm temperate climate of Nepal.
Hill house in Dolakha House in Salle Newar house Indo-Nepalese house Adobe house Gurung house Limbu house
the thermal mass is favorable to store solar heat gains of the day
for cooler nights. The low ceiling height reduces the air volume to
be heated in the winter season. The vertical internal space arrange-
ment of Newar houses is optimized for the cold winter because it
creates buffer zones in the ground and the upper floor in order to
keep the main living and sleeping spaces comfortable.
In summary, it can be said that the vernacular houses in Nepal’s
warm temperate climate are very well adapted to the local climate
condition. They consider the most important climate-responsive
design strategies like enhancing solar heat gains during winter and
protecting from the strong solar radiation in summer.
Fig. 11. Floor plan and elevation of Sherpa house (after [17]).
238 S. Bodach et al. / Energy and Buildings 81 (2014) 227–242
Table 6
Characteristics of vernacular houses in cool temperate climate of Nepal.
semi-open space. These semi-open spaces provide another com- 5.3.8. Results
fortable place, e.g. in winter when the sun is shining. The previous analysis shows that traditional settlements in cool
temperate climate tend to be more compact than in the warmer
5.3.4. Walls climate zones (Table 6).
Walls are made of locally available stones with a thickness of up Locally available stones, which are used for walls and timber, are
to 1 m [17]. Stonework is made either dry or bound together with also the dominating material for floor, ceilings, interior cladding of
rudimentary mortar made of soft clayed earth. In Sherpa houses wall and roofing. Like in warm temperate climate the high thermal
mostly inner and especially outer walls are plastered with clayed mass of the building is favorable to store solar thermal gains during
earth and then painted because the plaster is also an excellent sunny winter days for the cooler nights. Due to the heavy precipita-
weatherproofing material. In Tamang houses the outer walls are tion during monsoon season roofs are pitched and mostly covered
made of dry stonework while the entry façade of the first floor is by wood slate and stones. Openings tend to be smaller than in warm
made of timber. Inner walls of main living spaces are often planked temperate climate that leads to the reduction of heat losses. Inter-
with timber lathes. nal spaces are arranged vertically creating a thermal buffer on the
upper and lower level for the main living area.
5.3.5. Roof In conclusion, the mountain houses in the cool temperate cli-
Due to the heavy rains pitched roofs are more frequently used in mate of Nepal are very well adapted to the local climate conditions.
the traditional architecture of the cool temperate mountain climate They fulfill the most important design strategy – compact building
[17]. Either in Sherpa and Tamang houses the roof rest on a wooden layout and orientation toward the Sun.
pillar and beam structure. Wood or slate (if available) is often used
as roofing material in the form of square or rectangular roofing tiles.
Heavy stones are placed on top to prevent them from being blown 5.4. Alpine climate
off by heavy monsoon winds.
Representing vernacular architecture of alpine climate, houses
5.3.6. Foundation, floor and ceiling and settlements from the following areas in far-western, mid-
The Sherpa houses in Khumbu village are built on a platform western, and western development region of Nepal were analyzed:
which is made of locally available stones. The double wooden ceil- Humla [12,33], Dolpo [16], Upper and Lower Mustang ([11,34],
ings of these houses are supported by a framework of timber pillars field visit 2010), Thak Khola villages in Mustang district [16] and
and beams. Carpets are often laid above the wooden floor in the Manang [12,16]. All these locations are part of the Himalayan
main living areas [17]. mountain range located on the northern stretch of Nepal between
Tamang houses are slightly elevated attached to each other 2500 and 4600 m.a.s.l. (Humla – 3500 m.a.s.l., Dolpo – above
forming a terrace structure. The interior structure including floors 4000 m.a.s.l., Upper Mustang – 2800–4600 m.a.s.l.; Lower Mustang
and ceiling are completely made of timber. Often the main entry – 2500–3800 m.a.s.l., Manang – 3500 m.a.s.l.). In contrast to cool
façade is also timber cladded. temperate climate, temperatures are lower and the amount of pre-
cipitation is very low throughout the whole year.
5.3.7. Openings
In Khumbu village doors and windows of the Sherpa houses are
faced to south-east direction for an effective exposure to the winter 5.4.1. Settlement pattern
Sun [17]. Also houses in Langtang village are observed to face south- The villages in such a harsh and cold climate are very compact
east. No openings are placed in the back side of the houses which (Fig. 12). The buildings are often attached to each other creating
are not sun-faced. In Sherpa houses wooden windows with finely small alleys that are protected from the cold wind and snow storms.
carved decoration and colorful paintings. In the main entry façade In Braga (Manang district) the houses are grouped closely together
of Tamang house one decorated small window is placed as opening. sharing one or more exterior walls. In Dolpo the houses are also
The actual opening of those windows is rather small. Often shutters attached to one other but each house has its own outer wall [12].
are used to close the openings completely during night and the cold Thakali villages are observed to be very compact although adjacent
winter season. walls are not common.
S. Bodach et al. / Energy and Buildings 81 (2014) 227–242 239
Fig. 12. Typical attached Tamang house with elevated ground floor.
Fig. 14. Compact building typologies of Thakali houses in Marpha, Lower Mustang (after [16]).
240 S. Bodach et al. / Energy and Buildings 81 (2014) 227–242
5.4.5. Roof
Due to the scarcity or even total absence of rainfall roofs of ver-
nacular houses in alpine climate are generally flat [12,16,27,34].
Using locally available material, the roofs are typically made of 2nd floor
stone and mud laid on a timber post and beam structure. Vernac-
ular architecture of this region has developed different techniques
to make the roof waterproof. For example, in Humla roofs consist of
Store Store Store
dried juniper branches laid over roughly cut timber boards with an Room
added layer of black mud and a final waterproof layer of fine white
mud [12]. This technique protects from the wet snow that typically
Room of Living
falls in the early winter months. Thakali and Manang people have Store
ancestors
also developed a roof finishing system that uses a fine mud layer to room
ensure waterproofing. Furthermore, wood is piled on the border of
roofs that provides protection from the strong wind [16]. In some
Store Kitchen
mountain houses a slight roof overhang can be seen for protecting Canopy Terrace
semi-closed spaces in front of the house [33].
5.4.7. Openings
Cattle shed
The studied vernacular houses have very small doors and win- Store
Canopy
dows made of wood [16,27,34]. Windows are often the most
expressive element of the house and have nice carvings with Bud-
dhist symbols [12]. In Upper Mustang villages look like fortified
towns due to the reduced window area of the outer walls (Fig. 15). Ground floor
Generally, shutters are used to reduce infiltration of cold air, par-
Fig. 15. Floor plan of Thakali house in Taglung (after [16]).
ticularly, during night time. The protection from heat losses is the
main bioclimatic strategy to maintain comfortable indoor climate
under very cold conditions (Fig. 16).
5.4.8. Results
Vernacular houses in Alpine climate have several more features
to protect from the coldness than houses in the other climates
of Nepal. Settlements and building volumes are compacter and
denser than in temperate climates. The houses have far smaller
and less openings in order to reduce heat losses. The internal space
arrangement is optimized to create thermal buffer zones. The use
of window shutters has the effect to increase the tightness of the
building.
Roofs are flat as far less rain is falling than in cool temperate
climate. The buildings have a high thermal mass that help to bal-
ance large diurnal temperature range between the season and in
summer. Semi-open spaces like the sunny flat roof top, wind pro-
tected veranda and courtyards play an important role to provide
comfortable areas for all kind of household activities during the
day.
Concluding, the vernacular house design is very much adapted
to the local climate conditions. The main objective is to reduce heat
losses during long and cold winter season (Table 7). Fig. 16. Typical small windows in building façade in Upper Mustang.
S. Bodach et al. / Energy and Buildings 81 (2014) 227–242 241
Table 7
Characteristics of vernacular houses in Alpine climate of Nepal.
Humla house Dolpo house House in Upper Mustang Thakali house Manang house
Location Far-western mountain Mid-western mountain Western mountain region Western mountain region Western mountain region
region region
Settlement pattern Densely scattered, partly Houses attached to one Dense housing cluster Compact settlements Dense, attached houses
attached houses other
Building form Almost square floor plan Rectangular Rectangular toward square Terraced houses Almost square surface
Building South n.s. toward sunny side of valley Southwards facing Facing south
orientation
Stories 3 2.5 2 3 3
Internal space Vertically and horizontally Vertical space use creates Vertical space arrangement Centrally and vertically Vertical space arrangement
arrangement use of buffer zones thermal buffer zones with thermal buffer zones with use of buffer zones by uses buffer zones
Semi-open space Roof top Courtyard, roof terrace Courtyard, roof terrace Courtyard, roof terrace Courtyard, roof terrace
Wall material Stone and mud mortar Lower wall: stones and Sun-dried bricks Flat natural stone masonry Stone assembled with
mortar, upper walls: coated with white and red earth
sundried bricks mud
Wall thickness 45 cm 40 cm 45 cm 50 cm Thick
Roof material Mud n.s. Mud filling over wooden Severe mud layers 10 cm mud layer on
structure wooden latter
Roof type Flat Flat Flat Flat Flat
Roof overhang 50 cm n.s. n.s. Yes Slight overhang
Foundation n.s. n.s. n.s. n.s. Stone, 30 cm deep, 60 cm
wide
Floor n.s. n.s. Mud covered n.s. n.s.
Ceiling Low ceilings Low ceilings Wooden beam and pillar Wooden structure Wooden beam and pillar
structure structure
Openings Small Very few and small Small openings in South, Small windows with Very small wooden
West or East facade shutters windows
Table 8
Climate-responsive design strategies in vernacular architecture of different climatic zones in Nepal.
cold in winter. Shaded semi-open spaces like verandas, balconies [5] O.H. Koenigsberger, Manual of Tropical Housing and Building: Climatic Design,
and courtyards provide a cooler spaces in summer. University, Longman, 1974.
[6] A.S. Dili, M.A. Naseer, T.Z. Varghese, Passive environment control system of Ker-
In the cool temperate climate, the building design should be ala vernacular residential architecture for a comfortable indoor environment: a
optimized for solar passive heating, protection from the cold in win- qualitative and quantitative analyses, Energy and Buildings 42 (2010) 917–927.
ter, compact settlement pattern and building layout, high thermal [7] R. Shanthi Priya, M.C. Sundarraja, S. Radhakrishnan, L. Vijayalakshmi, Solar
passive techniques in the vernacular buildings of coastal regions in Nagap-
mass of walls and floors but light well insulated roof and medium attinam, TamilNadu – India – a qualitative and quantitative analysis, Energy
sized. Most of these identified design strategies are applied in the and Buildings 49 (2012) 50–61.
vernacular houses. Heavy very thick stones walls protect the inha- [8] A.S. Dili, M.A. Naseer, T. Zacharia Varghese, Passive control methods for a
comfortable indoor environment: comparative investigation of traditional and
bitants from the cold and harsh climate in winter. The arrangement
modern architecture of Kerala in summer, Energy and Buildings 43 (2011)
of additional functions like livestock and storage above and below 653–664.
the main living space provides thermal buffer zones. Partly, studied [9] L. Borong, T. Gang, W. Peng, S. Ling, Z. Yingxin, Z. Guangkui, Study on the ther-
mal performance of the Chinese traditional vernacular dwellings in Summer,
buildings are oriented toward south to benefit from solar heat gains
Energy and Buildings 36 (2004) 73–79.
during the day that is stored in high thermal mass of the envelope [10] H.B. Rijal, H. Yoshida, N. Umemiya, Passive cooling effect of traditional ver-
for cooler night. nacular houses in the sub-tropical region of Nepal, in: PLEA 2005 – The 22nd
Houses in Alpine climate of Nepal need mainly protection from Conference on Passive and Low Energy Architecture, Beirut, 2005, p. 1.
[11] A.K. Upadhyay, H. Yoshida, H.B. Rijal, Climate responsive building design in
the cold and should enhance solar passive heating. Besides high the Kathmandu Valley, Journal of Asian Architecture and Building Engineering
thermal mass of the walls, floor and roof, a dense and compact (2006) 169–176.
settlement structure and building layout is recommended. It was [12] A. Gansach, I.A. Meir, Energy-culture across altitude, in: PLEA 2004 – The
21st Conference in Passive and Low Energy Architecture, Eindhoven, 2004, pp.
further elaborated that only small openings are suitable. The stud- 19–22.
ied examples of vernacular houses in this climate show few features [13] P. Supic, Vernacular architecture: a lesson of the past for the future, Energy and
that would enhance solar passive heating. Priority is given to the Buildings 5 (1982) 43–54.
[14] W. Korn, The traditional architecture of the Kathmandu Valley, Reprint: 2, Ratna
protection from the cold through thick heavy walls, very small Pustak Bhandar, 1977.
windows and a very dense settlement structure. Furthermore, the [15] H.O. Skar, Nepal: Tharu and Tarai Neighbours, EMR, Kathmandu, 1999.
vertical internal space arrangement keeps the main living area with [16] G. Toffin, Man and his House in the Himalayas: Ecology of Nepal, Sterling Pub-
lishers, New Delhi, 1991.
the open fire in the center of the building warm through thermal
[17] V. Sestina, E. Somigli, Sherpa Architecture, UNESCO, Geneva, 1978.
buffer rooms all around. The flat roof top terrace provides a sunny [18] S.R. Tiwari, H. Yoshida, H.B. Rijal, S. Hata, S. Hanaoka, Cultures in Development
and warm place for doing any kind of household activity during the Conservation of Vernacular Architecture, VAASTU 6 (2004).
[19] S.R. Tiwari, Sustainable urban development lessons from historical Asian cities,
day.
in: International Conference on Culture in Sustainability of Cities II, Kanazawa,
The results of this study show that traditional architecture in Japan, 2000.
Nepal is very well adapted to the local climate conditions. The ver- [20] G. Scheibler, Building Today in a Historical Context: Bhaktapur, Nepal, Ratna
nacular houses are designed in such a way to provide the most Pustak Bhandar, Kathmandu, 1982.
[21] N. Gutschow, B. Kölver, I. Shresthacarya, Newar Towns and Buildings: An Illus-
comfortable shelter with the building materials and technolo- trated Dictionary Newari-English, VGH Wissenschaftsverlag, Sankt Augustin,
gies that were available at that time. The architectural design is 1987.
optimized to use natural resources like solar radiation and wind [22] Z. John Zhai, J.M. Previtali, Ancient vernacular architecture: characteristics cate-
gorization and energy performance evaluation, Energy and Buildings 42 (2010)
efficiently. However, traditional building design and techniques 357–365.
cannot always meet modern living style. Nevertheless, traditional [23] M.K. Singh, S. Mahapatra, S.K. Atreya, Solar passive features in vernacular archi-
buildings constitute a rich knowledge base that should not be aban- tecture of North-East India, Solar Energy 85 (2011) 2011–2022.
[24] V.P. Shrestha, A Concise Geography of Nepal, Mandala Publications, Kath-
doned and totally replaced by modern universal energy-intensive mandu, 2007.
building practices. Instead vernacular design has to be translated [25] B. Upreti, An overview of the stratigraphy and tectonics of the Nepal Himalaya,
and adapted to modern living and comfort requirements. For exam- Journal of Asian Earth Sciences 17 (1999) 577–606.
[26] M. Kottek, J. Grieser, C. Beck, B. Rudolf, F. Rubel, World Map of the Köppen-
ple, the vertical space arrangement of Newar houses might be
Geiger climate classification updated, Meteorologische Zeitschrift 15 (2006)
inappropriate for modern lifestyle. However, the Newar courtyard 259–263.
settlement structure that is optimized for solar penetration in win- [27] J.M. Boch-Isaacson, D. Dobereiner, Architecture & Construction Management
in the Highland and Remote Areas of Nepal, Boch-Isaacson, Kathmandu, 1987.
ter and reduces solar heat gains in summer, can be used to create
[28] S. Hanaoka, H.B. Rijal, S. Hata, Changes and improvements to traditional ver-
dense and resource efficient residential areas of modern living. nacular houses in a mountain area of Nepal, in: 3rd International Conference
This study laid the groundwork in identifying the design strate- on Environmentally Sustainable Development, Pakistan, 2009, pp. 3–7.
gies used by vernacular architecture in Nepal. Further research is [29] A. Macfarlane, Resources and Population: A Study of the Gurungs of Nepal, 2nd
ed., Ratna Pustak Bhandar, Kathmandu, 2003.
needed to translate these traditional strategies into the modern [30] P. Sagant, Prêtres Limbu et catègories domestiques, Kailash – Journal of
context and come up with appropriate building techniques for the Himalayan Studies 1 (1973).
fast developing constructions sector of the country. [31] P. Oliver, Encyclopedia of Vernacular Architecture of the World, vol. 2,
Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1997.
[32] C. Bonapace, V. Sestini, Traditional Materials and Construction Technologies
References used in the Kathmandu Valley, 2003, pp. 180.
[33] R. Fuller, A. Zahnd, S. Thakuri, Improving comfort levels in a traditional high
[1] World Business Council for Sustainable Development, Energy Efficiency in altitude Nepali house, Building and Environment 44 (2009) 479–489.
Buildings Transforming the Market, WBCSD, Geneva, 2009. [34] NTNC, Sustainable Development Plan Mustang 2008–2013, 2008.
[2] P. Hennicke, S. Bodach, Energierevolution Effizienzsteigerung und erneuer- [35] H.B. Rijal, H. Yoshida, Winter thermal comfort of residents in the Himalaya
bare Energien als globale Herausforderung, Oekom-Verlag, München, Region of Nepal, in: Proceeding of International Conference on Comfort and
2010. Energy Use in Buildings – Getting Them Right (Windsor), Network for Comfort
[3] V. Olgyay, Design with the Climate, Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ, and Energy Use in Buildings, 2006, pp. 1–15.
1963. [38] ICIMOD, GIS Datasets of Nepal 1:250,000, 2013.
[4] B. Givoni, Man, Climate and Architecture, Elsevier Publishing Company Limited, [39] Department of Hydrology and Meteorology, Meteorological Data of Selected
Amsterdam/London/New York, 1969. Weather Stations Between 1969–2010, 2012.
Appendix B
Publication II
101
Developing Bioclimatic Zones and Passive
Solar Design Strategies for Nepal
ABSTRACT
Nepal displays a highly varying topography which is leading to a variety of climatic conditions. With the
introduction of modern construction technologies in the country, the building sector has adopted
uniform design and building techniques that often neglects local climate and rely on energy-intensive
mechanical means to provide thermal indoor comfort. The definition of a climate classifications for
building design can be an important decision making tool towards climate-responsive and energy-
efficient architecture. This paper represents the groundwork for developing bioclimatic zones for
building design in Nepal. Based on climatic maps areas of similar climatic conditions were identified.
Climate data of various locations within these zone were collected and analysed. A bioclimatic approach
was adopted using the psychrometric chart in order to identify passive design strategies for each
locations. Finally, an overview of appropriated design strategies for summer and winter for each zones
is developed.
INTRODUCTION
Climate-responsive design is considered to be one of the major requirements to drive the building
sector towards sustainable development (Szokolay, 2008). However, architects and building planners are
still guided by universal design style that is rather focusing on form language and neglecting the local
climate conditions (Liedl, Hausladen, & Saldanha, 2012). Climate classification for sustainable building
design can fill the gap and guide building professionals which design strategies are suitable in a certain
climate context. Many countries that have a variety of climates within their territory have developed a
climatic classification for building design - also called bioclimatic zoning. Climate maps for Nepal have
been developed based on physiological features and vegetation. However, no building design specific
climate zoning is available for the country. Few authors identified the climate-responsive design
strategies for specific locations in the country (Upadhyay, Yoshida, & Rijal, 2006). This research is the
first comprehensive study aiming to provide the groundwork for developing a bioclimatic zoning and the
appropriate design strategies for the whole territory of Nepal.
There are several approaches to define a climate classification for building design. Givoni (1969)
distinguishes between four main climate classes, namely hot, warm-temperate, cool-temperate and cold
climates; using sub classification he elaborated a total number of eleven climate types for the whole
planet. Koenigsberger (1974) developed six climate zones for building design in the tropics based on the
two climate factors, temperature and humidity; these factors dominantly influences thermal comfort.
Many countries with high climatic variations have developed their own climate zones for building design
Susanne Bodach is PhD candidate at the Institute of Energy Efficient and Sustainable Design and Building, Technische Universität
München, Munich, Germany
METHODS
Research region
Nepal expands from the Gangetric plain at an elevation of 60 m up to the high Himalaya Mountains
with the highest peak in the world the Mt. Everest at an elevation of 8,848 m. The highly diversified
The bioclimatic approach explores the opportunities to design according to the local climate
conditions. Olgyay (1963) developed the first bioclimatic chart based on outdoor climate conditions
aiming to identify mitigation measures like solar radiation, air movement or shading to achieve a
comfortable indoor climate. Givoni (1963) developed a bioclimatic chart based on indoor conditions
using the standard psychrometric chart. His chart has been widely used to identify passive design
strategies for different bioclimatic zones (Lam et al., 2006; Rakoto-Joseph, Garde, David, Adelard, &
Randriamanantany, 2009; Singh, Mahapatra, & Atreya, 2007). Some countries have used solely his chart
to define the climate classification for building design (ABNT, 2003).
The main challenge for developing a bioclimatic chart is the definition of the thermal comfort zone.
Thermal comfort is defined as a subjective response of a person in regard to satisfaction with the thermal
environment (ASHRAE, 2010). It is influenced by environmental factors, such as air temperature, air
movement, humidity, radiation, and personal factors like metabolic rate, clothing, state of health and
acclimatization (Szokolay, 2008). For naturally ventilated buildings ASHRAE Standard 55 proposes the
adaptive thermal comfort approach and defines a range of acceptable indoor temperature of 2.5 K above
and below optimum comfort temperature. Thereby, the comfort temperature is calculated by the outdoor
temperature using the equation (1).
However, some studies question the applicability of the adaptive model, particularly, in warm and
humid climates (Harimi, Ming, & Kumaresan, 2012). Two studies on thermal comfort in Nepal have
found that people feel comfortable at temperatures far below and above international comfort standards
(Rijal, Yoshida, & Umemiya, 2010). Comparing the optimum comfort temperature using equation (1)
and the actual comfort temperature found in the field, temperature differences between 0.2 and 9 K are
Table 2. Comparison of predicted comfort temperature and actual found in the field
Summer Winter
Location Altitude Tmean out Tc pred Tc field Tmean out Tc pred Tc field
Banke 150 m 31.4 27.5 30.0 15.2 22.5 16.2
Bhaktapur 1,350 m 22.2 24.7 25.6 10.6 21.1 15.2
Dhading 1,500 m 25.4 25.7 29.1 13.3 21.9 24.2
Kaski 1,700 m 18.8 23.6 23.4 8.9 20.6 18.0
Solukhumbu 2,600 m 13.1 21.9 21.1 4.0 19.0 13.4
Mustang 3,705 m n.s. n.s. n.s. 6.0 19.7 10.7
Tmean out Mean outdoor temperature (Rijal et al., 2010)
Tc pred Predited comfort indoor temperature (de Dear & Brager, 2002)
Tc field Comfort temperature according to field study (Rijal et al., 2010)
Updating his original research work, Givoni proposed an extended comfort zone for hot developing
countries that considers the acclimatization resulting from living in naturally ventilated buildings
(Givoni, 1992). It defines temperatures between 18°C and 29°C and humidity levels from 4g/kg up to
17g/kg as comfortable. Givoni's extended comfort zones is used in this study because it is evaluated the
most appropriate approach for the Nepalese context. Givoni did not define zones for passive design
strategies in his updated chart for hot developing countries. Therefore, this study uses the boundaries
defined by Gonzalez et al (1986) for warm and humid climates in developing countries. The upper limit
for ventilation is set to absolute humidity of 20.5 g/kg. The ventilation zone was extended to 100% of
relative humidity taking reference to several studies conducted in hot and humid climates that found out
that local people can cope with higher humidity by increasing ventilation (Gonzalez et al., 1986; Shastry,
Mani, & Tenorio, 2012). Solar passive heating zone is defined between 10.5°C and 20.0°C (outside
comfort zone). Mechanical heating is needed up to a temperature of 10.5°C. The upper boundary for
evaporative cooling is set at the wet bulb temperature line of 24°C. Humidification is needed below wet
bulb temperature of 10.6°C.
Nepal’s climatic diversity is mainly caused by the high variation in altitude. Therefore, elevation
was chosen as the main criteria for developing bioclimatic zones. Meteorological data (temperature,
precipitation) from 26 weather stations were collected either directly from Department of Hydrology and
Meteorology or derived from United Nation's Food and Agriculture Organisation (FAO) climate
database (FAO, 2014). The station data was used to generate a typical meteorological year (TMY) for
each location using the recognized software tool METEONORM (Meteotest, 2014). The TMY was then
analysed using the bioclimatic approach.
RESULTS
The plotting of the climate data of 26 locations on the psychrometric chart shows clearly that Nepal
has a composite climate that is strongly influenced by the monsoon. Composite means there is no
dominating climate for six following months. Instead there are four different seasons that are leading to
different design strategies: 1. Winter season (December to February); 2. Pre-Monsoon (March to May);
3. Monsoon or summer season (June to September); 4. Post-monsoon (October to November).
The analysis of the bioclimatic chart of 26 locations led to four different bioclimatic zones
(Figure 1): 1.Warm Temperate (below 500 m); 2. Temperate (500-1500 m); 3. Cool temperate (1501-
2500 m); 4. Cold (above 2500 m). Table 4 gives an overview about the climatic conditions in each zone.
The climate and design strategies for each zone are discussed in the following.
In the warm temperate climate daily temperature rises in pre-monsoon and monsoon season well
above the comfort zone reaching up to 35°C. While relative humidity is below 60 % in the pre-monsoon,
it increases up to 90 % in monsoon season. The winter month are warm with average temperatures above
10°C. Figure 2 shows that the main design strategies for warm temperate climate zone is natural
Figure 2 Bioclimatic chart for warm temperate (left) and temperate climate zone (right)
In the temperate climate zone average summer temperatures are more moderate, hardly exceeding
the comfort zone. During pre-monsoon mean temperatures and humidity is very much comfortable.
However, in some places day temperature can rise up to 35°C. In the monsoon season relative humidity
might increase above 80% in few locations. In winter temperatures fall below the lower comfort limit;
In the cool temperate climate day temperature in pre-monsoon and monsoon season are within the
comfort zone. During monsoon time temperatures are between 15-20°C and relative humidity rarely
rises above 80%. In winter average temperatures are clearly below comfort. Night temperatures can
down up to the freezing point. Passive solar heating is the most essential strategy used all over the year
(Figure 3). In summer thermal mass that store solar heat gain during the day might compensate night
temperatures that are often below the lower comfort limit. In winter solar heat gains might contribute to
reduce the heating demand by mechanical means. However, mechanical heating is necessary from
October to March.
In the cold climate temperature hardly reach the comfort zone (Figure 4). During summer, day time
temperature rarely rises above 18°C. During winter average temperature are around the freezing point. In
the cold climate of Nepal passive solar heating is the only design strategy that can be applied. It will
reduce the heating demand during the summer month. However, mechanical heating is required all over
the year.
DISCUSSION
The bioclimatic chart for the warm temperate climate indicates passive solar heating as main
CONCLUSION
This study developed the first bioclimatic zoning for Nepal. The main passive solar design
strategies for the four different bioclimatic zones were identified using the bioclimatic chart. This new
climate classification can help planners and architects to make general decisions at early design stage to
develop more climate-responsive and energy-efficient buildings. Furthermore, it might be useful for the
development of appropriate building energy regulations.
However, the qualitative approach of the bioclimatic chart has its limitations due to the fact that it
only considers two climate factors: temperature and humidity. The micro-climatic conditions can vary
and a detailed analysis of the site might be necessary to come up with site-specific solutions.
Due to the fact that the climate in Nepal is of composite character design strategies might
conflicting each other. Therefore, further research is needed to quantify the effectiveness of the passive
design strategies in each climate zones.
REFERENCES
Publication III
Contribution:
My contribution to this simulation study included concept development, acquisition of data,
several field visits and data analysis. The concept design was supported by the co-authors.
The modelling and simulation was conducted by me in close consultation with the co-authors.
The validation of the simulation results was mainly done by the co-authors. The article was
drafted by me and critically revised by the co-authors.
111
International Journal of Sustainable Built Environment (2016) xxx, xxx–xxx
H O S T E D BY
Gulf Organisation for Research and Development
Original Article/Research
Abstract
It is predicted that the major increase in energy consumption and, thus, carbon emissions, will happen in the developing world. How-
ever, in most developing countries the knowledge about energy efficiency, particularly in the building sector, is quite low. Strategies devel-
oped for industrialised countries might not be suitable or must be adapted for the very different context of developing countries. This
research aims to find energy-efficient and cost-effective building design options for the case of Nepal. Energy-efficient building design
is a non-trivial issue involving a number of interdependent design criteria. Particularly, in composite climates, passive design strategies
might conflict each other leading to an inefficient building design. This paper explores the energy conservation potential in hotel design
for all bioclimatic zones of Nepal using building energy simulation with parametric analysis. Based on extensive field studies, reference
models for typical hotel buildings ranging from small-scale resort hotels to large-scale multi-storey hotels were developed. These refer-
ence designs were optimised by varying design parameters such as window-to-wall ratio, glazing material, shading devices, glazing type
and insulation levels. During the design optimisation, energy demand as well as cost effectiveness were evaluated. Finally, recommenda-
tions for energy-efficient and cost-effective hotel design solutions were suggested. In addition, the bioclimatic zoning for Nepal was
consolidated leading to five elevation-based zones that can be used to introduce building energy regulations in the future.
Ó 2016 The Gulf Organisation for Research and Development. Production and hosting by Elsevier B.V.
Keywords: Energy efficiency; Hotel buildings; Passive design; Building energy simulation; Parametric study
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijsbe.2016.05.008
2212-6090/Ó 2016 The Gulf Organisation for Research and Development. Production and hosting by Elsevier B.V.
Please cite this article in press as: Bodach, S. et al. Design guidelines for energy-efficient hotels in Nepal. International Journal of Sustainable Built
Environment (2016), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijsbe.2016.05.008
2 S. Bodach et al. / International Journal of Sustainable Built Environment xxx (2016) xxx–xxx
Please cite this article in press as: Bodach, S. et al. Design guidelines for energy-efficient hotels in Nepal. International Journal of Sustainable Built
Environment (2016), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijsbe.2016.05.008
S. Bodach et al. / International Journal of Sustainable Built Environment xxx (2016) xxx–xxx 3
Table 2 environment for local people, they might not fulfil increas-
Locations for simulation. ing thermal comfort requirements for modern building use.
Bioclimatic zone Location Elevation HDD18a CDD18b The findings of Rijal et al. (2010) show that local people in
Warm temperate Biratnagar 72 m 68 2418 Nepal are satisfied with indoor temperatures that are out of
Rampur 256 m 210 2081 the average range of international comfort standards
Temperate Pokhara 827 m 289 1391 (Bodach et al., 2014). However, hotel buildings which
Kathmandu 1337 m 632 930
Cool temperate Dhulikhel 1552 m 932 491
mostly serve international tourists have to comply with
Dhunche 1982 m 1147 218 higher comfort standards that can only be reached using
Cold Thakmarpha 2566 m 2456 20 for example modern insulation materials as well as active
Namche 2254 m 5013 0 heating and cooling technology.
a
Heating degree days at 18 °C according to EUROSTAT-method Although Nepal’s building stock is still very traditional,
(EEA, 2015). new construction materials are emerging in the market
b
Cooling degree days at 18.3 °C (65 °F) according to ASHRAE-method because they allow faster construction and lead to a better
(ASHRAE, 2009).
finishing. Reinforced concrete frame construction is the
dominant structural system for hotels in urban centres as
roofing was also found in few hotels in the temperate cli- it is seen as the most earthquake safe building technique
mate zone. and also promoted by the national building code. Domi-
Although traditional building techniques are very well nating walling material is the full brick which is produced
adapted to the climate and provide a comfortable indoor in the country using a very old inefficient kiln technology
Fig. 2. Bioclimatic zoning map of Nepal with selected locations for energy simulation.
Please cite this article in press as: Bodach, S. et al. Design guidelines for energy-efficient hotels in Nepal. International Journal of Sustainable Built
Environment (2016), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijsbe.2016.05.008
4 S. Bodach et al. / International Journal of Sustainable Built Environment xxx (2016) xxx–xxx
that is also a major contributor to air pollution. A substi- multistorey single-banked typology assumes the linear
tute for walling is the concrete hollow block (CHB) which arrangement of guest rooms at one side of an elongated
is also manufactured locally and has less embodied energy. corridor, while the double-banked typology has guest
Corrugated galvanised iron (CGI) sheets are often used for rooms at both sides. The courtyard type has a square lay-
pitched roofs combined with tile or thatch roofing. out with an interior open courtyard whereas in the atrium
Another new material for lightweight construction is fibre typology the courtyard is covered by a roof.
cement board which is mostly imported from India or Tables 3 and 4 list the construction materials and insu-
Thailand. Windows have commonly single glazing. Win- lation levels that were considered for the optimisation.
dow frames were still made of timber in the last decade. The thermal transmittance of all considered opaque envel-
Due to wood scarcity and the rise in prices, wood is now ope components are shown in Table 5. Based on market
replaced by aluminium and PVC framing. research, six different window types, which are available
According to the findings of the field research, seven in Nepal, were selected for this study (see Table 6).
building typologies for hotels were developed and assigned In order to explore the influence of thermal mass, typical
to the relevant climate zone (Fig. 3). Single cottage, double construction practices of high, medium and low thermal
cottage and bungalow are small-scale typologies for resort mass were taken into account. The fact that walls of brick
hotels. They have one, two and four guest rooms, respec- or concrete hollow blocks are still not common in moun-
tively. The bungalow typology has a similar layout like tainous regions because of high transportation cost, led
the double cottage but is a small two-storey building. The to the conclusion that only stone and lightweight materials
were studied in the cold climate. The optimisation of pas-
sive design parameters considers only three uninsulated
base cases of low, medium, and high thermal to keep the
number of total solutions at a reasonable size and reduce
simulation time.
Table 3
Construction materials considered for optimisation.
Wall Roof Floor
Low mass Fibre cement board CGIa Fibre cement board
Medium mass Concrete hollow block Thatch on CGIa Screed on brick solids
High mass Full brick, Stoneb Tile on CGIa, RCCc slab Screed on brick solids
a
Corrugated galvanised iron.
b
Only for cold climate.
c
Reinforced concrete.
Table 4
Thermal insulation levels considered for optimisation.
Thickness and material of insulation layer
Wall Roof Floor
Reference case 0 uninsulated 0a uninsulated 0 uninsulated
Insulation level 1 0a 50 mm GWc/100 mm thatchd 25 mm XPSe
Insulation level 2 50 mm EPSb 100 mm GWc/150 mm thatchd 50 mm XPSe
Insulation level 3 100 mm EPSb 150 mm GWc/200 mm thatchd 75 mm XPSe
Insulation level 4 150 mm EPSb 200 mm GWc/200 mm thatch+50 mm GWd –
a
50 mm air gap.
b
Expanded polystyrene (EPS).
c
Glass wool (GW) for tile and metal roof.
d
For thatch roof.
e
Extruded polystyrene foam (XPS).
Please cite this article in press as: Bodach, S. et al. Design guidelines for energy-efficient hotels in Nepal. International Journal of Sustainable Built
Environment (2016), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijsbe.2016.05.008
S. Bodach et al. / International Journal of Sustainable Built Environment xxx (2016) xxx–xxx 5
Table 5
U-Values of building envelope components considered for optimisation.
Base Insulation Insulation Insulation Insulation
case level 1 level 2 level 3 level 4
²
(W/mK) (W/mK)² (W/mK)² (W/mK)² (W/mK)²
Exterior wall
Full brick 2.188 1.600 0.590 0.340 0.238
Concrete hollow block 1.988 1.264 0.537 0.321 0.229
Fibre cement board 1.677 0.819 0.600 0.343 0.240
Stonea 1.402 1.385 0.558 0.329 0.233
Roof
Clay tile 2.775 0.689 0.370 0.253 0.192
Thatch 2.775 0.564 0.402 0.321 0.233
CGIb 2.780 0.487 0.256 0.174 0.131
RCCc Slab 2.798 0.610 0.346 0.242 0.186
Ground floor
Screed on brick solids 4.166 0.858 0.478 0.254 –
Fibre cement board 6.115 0.918 0.496 0.259 –
Timbera 2.115 0.911 0.580 0.336 –
a
Only for cold climate.
b
Corrugated galvanised iron.
c
Reinforced concrete.
Please cite this article in press as: Bodach, S. et al. Design guidelines for energy-efficient hotels in Nepal. International Journal of Sustainable Built
Environment (2016), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijsbe.2016.05.008
6 S. Bodach et al. / International Journal of Sustainable Built Environment xxx (2016) xxx–xxx
Table 8
Design parameters for insulation level optimisation of single-banked typology.
Parameter Values
Wall material Full brick CHBa FCBb Stone
Roof material CGIc Thatch Concrete
Floor material Concrete FCBb Timber
Wall insulation none 50 mm air cavity 50 mm EPSd 100 mm EPS 150 mm EPS
Roof insulation none 50 mm GWe 100 mm GW 150 mm GW 200 mm GW
Floor insulation none 25 mm XPSf 50 mm XPS 100 mm XPS
a
Concrete hollow block.
b
Fibre cement board.
c
Corrugated galvanised iron.
d
Expanded polystyrene (EPS).
e
Glass wool (GW).
f
Extruded polystyrene foam (XPS).
Please cite this article in press as: Bodach, S. et al. Design guidelines for energy-efficient hotels in Nepal. International Journal of Sustainable Built
Environment (2016), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijsbe.2016.05.008
S. Bodach et al. / International Journal of Sustainable Built Environment xxx (2016) xxx–xxx 7
existing buildings. In order to validate the plausibility of In this research multivariate, regression analysis was
the results a comparison with existing data was conducted. used to analyse the influence of design parameters for
However, there is lack of measured data from Nepal. As a energy performance. The linear regression coefficient was
result, energy consumption surveys from other countries normalised into the standardised regression coefficient
were used. (SRC) to make comparison possible. The standardised
Energy consumption in hotel buildings might vary con- regression coefficient (SRC) is a tool to quantify the sensi-
siderably depending on the location, climate, hotel stan- tivity of heating and cooling loads as well as the total
dard (number of stars), facility size and additional energy demand with regard to the different design parame-
services provided (swimming pool, restaurants, laundry, ters (Hopfe, 2007). The ranking of the SRC shows the
etc.) as well as the occupancy rate and the efficiency of importance of each design parameter for heating, cooling
the equipment (Bohdanowicz and Martinac, 2007). A and total energy demand.
review of several surveys conducted all around the world For instance, the regression analysis for cooling electric-
concluded that the average energy use intensity of hotels ity (dependent variable) leads to a positive SRC for WWR
is between 69 and 689 kWh/m2 per year (Wang, 2012). South. That means, the higher the window area on the
The share of energy used for space conditioning ranges southern facade the higher the cooling electricity. It indi-
between 32% and 57% of total energy consumption cates that reducing the window-to-wall ratio (WWR) South
(Deng and Burnett, 2000; Shiming and Burnett, 2002; will reduce the need for active cooling.
Trung and Kumar, 2005; Chedwal et al., 2015). In order to include thermal mass and orientation into
The simulation results of this study show similar varia- the regression analysis, dummy variables had to be intro-
tion because of the climatic diversity of the country. duced into the model. The dummy variable for orientation
Assuming a share in energy demand for room conditioning has the lowest value of 0.1 for all design alternatives where
of 40%, the uninsulated reference hotel design would have the long building facades were facing exactly north- and
an energy intensity between 93 and 708 kWh/m2 per year southwards (north axis is 0°). The dummy variable was
depending on the location (Fig. 4). Therefore, the highest increased by 0.1 for every 30° that the model differs from
energy intensity is reached in the cold climate at 3354 m the optimum orientation. The dummy variable for thermal
elevation and the lowest in the temperate climate. Consid- mass had the value of 0.1, 0.2 and 0.3 for low, medium and
ering the geographical distribution of hotels (Central high thermal mass buildings, respectively.
Bureau of Statistics(CBS), 2004), an average energy use
intensity of 197 kWh/m2 per year was estimated. This value 3. Passive design optimisation
is comparable with the Indian benchmark of 260 kWh/m2
per year considering that the share of luxury hotels in India The following section investigates the importance of
is much higher than in Nepal (BEE, 2011). design parameters for reducing heating and cooling energy
demands in each bioclimatic zone. Building design param-
2.7. Regression analysis eters like window-to-wall-ratio (WWR), thermal mass, ori-
entation and shading (fins and overhang) were considered.
Regression analysis is widely used by building energy The impact of thermal insulation of roof, exterior walls and
simulators either to predict energy performance of build- ground floor is investigated in a separate section due to its
ings or to assess the influence of design parameters (Lam high relevance to achieve low-energy designs (see section
and Hui, 1996; Hopfe, 2007; Hygh et al., 2012; Daly ‘‘Thermal insulation optimisations” below).
et al., 2014). Regression analysis is a statistical method to
estimate relationships among different variables. Hygh 3.1. Warm temperate climate
et al. (2012) suggest that a linear regression model can help
to make early design decisions to reduce the energy For all locations below an elevation of 500 m (Biratna-
demand of buildings. gar and Rampur) the simulation results show that HVAC
energy consumption is dominated by cooling demand with
an average share between 80% and 95%.
Minimising solar gains is the most important passive
design strategy for all building typologies in this climate.
Therefore, the design parameters window-to-wall-ratio
(WWR), overhang and orientation have the highest abso-
lute Standardized Regression Coefficients (SRC). Fig. 5
illustrates the results of the regression analysis for the bun-
galow typology in Biratnagar. It shows on the top ranks:
WWR South (0.63), Overhang South ( 0.45), Orientation
(0.30), WWR East (0.24) and WWR West (0.23). All these
Fig. 4. Estimated energy use intensity for hotels in Nepal based on design parameters can reduce solar penetration of the
uninsulated reference model for different elevations. building.
Please cite this article in press as: Bodach, S. et al. Design guidelines for energy-efficient hotels in Nepal. International Journal of Sustainable Built
Environment (2016), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijsbe.2016.05.008
8 S. Bodach et al. / International Journal of Sustainable Built Environment xxx (2016) xxx–xxx
Fig. 5. Standardised regression coefficient (SRC) of design parameters for bungalow typology.
The positive SRC for the WWR South means that the
higher the window area, the higher the total HVAC energy
demand. Being on the top rank shows that reducing the
WWR South has the highest impact on energy reduction.
Similarly, the SRC for WWR East and West is positive
demonstrating that windows in these direction should be
also small or even avoided. In contrast, the SRC for the
overhang projection factor (PF), is negative. This negative
relation means that the larger the overhang, the lower the
energy consumption.
Consequently, best performers in this climate have a
WWR South and North of 20% and an overhang with a
projection factor (PF) between 0.4 and 0.6. Furthermore, Fig. 6. Comparison of non-conditioned thermal performance in summer
they have small or no windows facing East and West and of bungalow typology for Biratnagar.
have an optimum orientation which means that the long
facades are facing north and south.
A less important passive design strategy for energy
reductions in this climate is the thermal mass effect. The
regression analysis shows that higher thermal mass has a
positive impact on reducing the heating demand (negative
SRC) while it tends to slightly increase cooling demand
(positive SRC) due to the effect of overheating. The ther-
mal mass effect can be illustrated by the thermal perfor-
mance of a non-conditioned building.
During a warm summer day, the indoor temperature in
the low mass design increases more than in the high mass
building (Fig. 6). However, during night time the low mass
building can cool down faster and at a lower level than the
high mass design which reduces the need for cooling. The
fact that the hotel room is occupied and air-conditioned
less hours during the day than during the night time results
in a slight performance advantage for low mass buildings in
the warm temperate climate.
From Fig. 7 it can be seen that low mass buildings per-
form better than high mass designs in summer but worse in
winter. The combined effect leads to annual energy savings,
depending on the location. For example, a low mass design
of the bungalow typology results in marginal annual energy
savings of 1 kWh/m2 in Biratnagar compared to the high
mass design. However, the same low mass design in Ram- Fig. 7. Monthly HVAC energy demand of low mass and high mass
pur consumes 6 kWh/m2 more electricity than a high mass bungalow typology in warm temperate climate.
Please cite this article in press as: Bodach, S. et al. Design guidelines for energy-efficient hotels in Nepal. International Journal of Sustainable Built
Environment (2016), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijsbe.2016.05.008
S. Bodach et al. / International Journal of Sustainable Built Environment xxx (2016) xxx–xxx 9
Table 10
Cost saving potential for Double-banked typology in Biratnagar by reducing WWR from 60% to 20%.
Cost saving potential
Construction costs Annual electricity costs Life cycle costs
Thermal mass USD/m2 USD/room USD/m2 USD/room USD/m2 USD/room
High 11 313 2 49 25 727
Medium 13 380 2 51 27 799
Low 10 296 2 53 25 739
Average 11 330 2 51 26 755
Please cite this article in press as: Bodach, S. et al. Design guidelines for energy-efficient hotels in Nepal. International Journal of Sustainable Built
Environment (2016), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijsbe.2016.05.008
10 S. Bodach et al. / International Journal of Sustainable Built Environment xxx (2016) xxx–xxx
demand for air conditioning compared to all other climate illustrates the small but still negative SRC ( 0.092) for
regions. Depending on the building typology heating Overhang South. Instead, the SRC for Overhang South
demand has a share of between 15% and 35% of total ( 0.057) in Kathmandu is so small that the majority of
HVAC energy demand in Pokhara (827 m). In Kathmandu best performers have no overhang. Optionally, an over-
(1337 m), the share of heating amounts to between 35% hang with a projection factor (PF) of 0.2 can be foreseen
and 70%. for the south facades with a WWR of 40% and larger.
The regression analysis indicates that thermal mass is Alternatively, a more flexible shading device like external
the most influential passive design factor in this climate. blinds or shutters can be used in Kathmandu whenever
In contrast to locations in warm temperate climate, the overheating occurs.
SRC for thermal mass is negative for both heating and The cost analysis shows that annual electricity costs for
cooling demands (Fig. 9). In other words, the higher the room conditioning in high and medium mass hotel designs
thermal mass of the building the lower the energy demand are almost half compared to the low mass design (Fig. 10).
for heating and cooling. For example in Kathmandu, the high mass design of
The second most important passive design factor for double-banked typology with WWR North and South of
Pokhara is minimising the WWR South while it is optimis- 40% has annual HVAC electricity costs of 42 USD per
ing the orientation for Kathmandu. Due to the higher guest room while the same design using low mass materials
share of cooling demand in Pokhara as compared to Kath- needs 81 USD per guest room (Fig. 10). LCC cost savings
mandu, window areas, particularly those facing south, of the same design amount to 248 USD per guest room.
should be kept as small as possible in order to avoid over- This indicates a clear cost advantage for high and medium
heating. In contrast, in Kathmandu moderate window mass designs in this climate.
areas between 20% and 60% can be used for passive solar Energy cost savings are also considerably high when
heating during the colder month and, thus, reduce, heating optimising the WWR according to passive design. Fig. 11
demand. The results of some typologies for Pokhara show (a) indicates the cost optimum for annual electricity costs
that a moderate WWR South (20–40%) with an overhang at a WWR of 40%. However, LCC present value is lowest
(PF 0.4) leads to the optimum combination of passive solar for designs with a WWR of 20% due to the fact that the
heating in winter and protection from overheating in share of investment for additional window area is higher
summer. than the annual energy cost savings (Fig. 11(b)).
In Pokhara best performing design alternatives have an Likewise in warm temperate climate, optimising the ori-
overhang with a projection factor of 0.2 or 0.4. Fig. 9(a) entation of the hotel building results also in considerable
Fig. 9. Standardised regression coefficient (SRC) of design parameters for double-banked typology.
Please cite this article in press as: Bodach, S. et al. Design guidelines for energy-efficient hotels in Nepal. International Journal of Sustainable Built
Environment (2016), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijsbe.2016.05.008
S. Bodach et al. / International Journal of Sustainable Built Environment xxx (2016) xxx–xxx 11
Fig. 10. Cost analysis for double-banked typology in temperate climate by thermal mass.
Fig. 11. Cost analysis for double-banked typology with different WWRs in Pokhara.
Table 13 the same design amount to between 78 and 182 USD per
Cost saving potential for Double cottage typology in Pokhara by guest room. Although, building orientation might be influ-
optimising the building orientation. enced by other factors like site constraints or the panora-
Cost saving potential mic view, if possible, optimum orientation should be
Annual electricity costs Life cycle costs considered to prevent unnecessary high energy costs.
Compared to USD/m2 USD/room USD/m2 USD/room To illustrate the cost saving potentials of the most
important passive strategies, a step-by-step design optimi-
30° 0.40 10 3.57 89
30° 0.35 9 3.10 78 sation of the single-banked typology was conducted and
60° 0.81 20 7.28 182 the cost implication analysed (see Fig. 12). The base case
60° 0.79 20 7.08 177 is an inefficient design with large window areas of 60%
and the long building facade facing south-west (orientation
60°). The annual electricity cost for the base case design of
cost savings in Nepal’s temperate climate (Table 13). For 122 USD per guest room can be reduced to 58 USD per
instance, annual electricity costs for double cottage typol- guest room through optimal orientation (Design 1), reduc-
ogy with a WWR of 40% in Pokhara can be reduced ing the WWR North to 20% (Design 2) and WWR South
between 9 and 20 USD per guest room. LCC savings for to 40% (Design 3) and adding an overhang (Design 4).
Fig. 12. Cost analysis of optimised design for single-banked typology in Pokhara.
Please cite this article in press as: Bodach, S. et al. Design guidelines for energy-efficient hotels in Nepal. International Journal of Sustainable Built
Environment (2016), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijsbe.2016.05.008
12 S. Bodach et al. / International Journal of Sustainable Built Environment xxx (2016) xxx–xxx
To summarise, passive design optimisation can lead to Illustrating opposed passive design strategies, the regres-
annual electricity cost savings of more than 50% and life sion analysis for east and west facing WWR results in a
cycle cost savings of about 30%. negative SRC for heating and positive SRC for cooling
Concluding, the results of the passive design optimisa- (e.g. Fig. 13(a)). Simply put, larger openings might
tion running for the temperate climate zone shows that dif- decrease the heating demand but at the same time increase
ferent recommendations are needed for the two locations. the need for cooling. The regression with the annual
Although higher thermal mass is a critical passive design HVAC energy demand as dependent variable shows no
strategy for Pokhara and Kathmandu, the WWR South significant relation (p-value is greater than 0.05). This indi-
should be minimised in Pokhara while in Kathmandu a cates that both effects cancel each other out. Looking at
moderate WWR South is favourable. Furthermore, in best performing design alternatives in Dhulikhel, openings
Pokhara an overhang for the south facing window is towards east, west and north should be kept as small as
required, while flexible shading devices are recommended possible (10–20%). In Dhunche, east and west facing
for Kathmandu. The cost analysis shows that passive WWR can amount up to 30% while north facing windows
design optimisation in temperate climate results in consid- should be as small as possible or avoided.
erable energy cost and life cycle cost savings. Orientation and shading have also less importance for
passive design in this climate. Actually, orientation is only
3.3. Cool temperate climate relevant for elongated layouts: long facades should be
oriented south-east, south or south-west wards. The major-
The simulation results indicate that hotel buildings ity of the best performing design alternatives in this climate
in Nepal’s cool temperate climate conditions require have neither overhang nor fins. Consequently, overhang
considerably more heating than cooling. For the analysed and other shading devices are not required.
typologies in Dhulikhel (1552 m) the share of HVAC Having the highest impact on energy demand reduction,
demand is between 60% and 85% of total HVAC energy high thermal mass does also reduce energy and life cycle
demand while in Dhunche (1982 m) it rises to 99%. costs (LCC). Annual HVAC energy costs for single-
Likewise in temperate climate, increasing thermal mass banked typology in Dhulikhel with low mass materials
has the highest impact on HVAC energy reduction. amount to 73 USD per guest room while medium and high
Fig. 13 shows the SRC for thermal mass on the first rank. mass solutions have energy costs of only 26 and 23 USD
Therefore, the application of building materials with high per guest room, respectively (Fig. 14(a)). While high mass
thermal mass should be prioritised. solutions have lowest annual electricity costs, medium mass
In contrast to all lower locations, the SRC for WWR design performs best in life cycle costs due to the fact that
South in regard to total HVAC energy demand is negative the construction costs for walls made of concrete hollow
(Fig. 13). This illustrates that a larger window area facing blocks (medium mass) are lower than for full brick walls
south results in more reduction of heating demand in (high mass).
winter than it increases cooling demand in summer. In The cost analysis for different WWRs shows that
interpreting these findings, it has to be considered that increasing window area facing south and decreasing
cooling demand in cool temperate climate is much lower WWR North result in marginal energy savings (Fig. 15).
that in warm temperate and temperate climate. For higher For instance for the double-banked typology in Dhulikhel,
locations like Dhunche, cooling might even not be annual electricity cost savings amount up to 4 USD per
required. According to the simulation results, best per- guest room when WWR South is maximised, and up to 2
formers have a south facing window area between 40% USD per guest room when WWR North is minimised
and 80% to maximise passive solar heating. (Fig. 15(a)). Life cycle costs decrease slightly when WWR
Fig. 13. Standardised regression coefficient (SRC) of design parameters for courtyard typology.
Please cite this article in press as: Bodach, S. et al. Design guidelines for energy-efficient hotels in Nepal. International Journal of Sustainable Built
Environment (2016), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijsbe.2016.05.008
S. Bodach et al. / International Journal of Sustainable Built Environment xxx (2016) xxx–xxx 13
Fig. 14. Cost analysis for single-banked typology in cool temperate climate by thermal mass.
Fig. 15. Cost analysis for double-banked typology with different WWRs in Dhulikhel.
North is reduced but increases slightly when WWR South high thermal mass and large window areas facing south-
is increased (Fig. 15(b)). This means that in the long run wards. WWR North, East and West should be kept small.
reducing window area northwards leads to LCC net sav- Shading devices are not required. Envelope optimisation
ings due to reduced energy costs. The annual energy cost towards passive design results in moderate energy cost
savings due to passive solar heating cannot fully compen- savings in this climate.
sate the high investment costs for increased window area
facing South. 3.4. Cold climate
Passive design optimisation can lead to moderate energy
cost savings. Fig. 16 illustrates the annual HVAC energy HVAC energy demand of hotel buildings in locations
costs for the double-banked typology in Dhunche. It can above 2500 m are dominated by heating. Simulation results
be seen that passive design can lead to savings of up to for Thakmarpha (2566 m) indicate a share of heating
20 USD per guest room annually. Although total window between 98% and 100% of total HVAC energy demand.
area of the building has increased in the most energy- In Namche Bazar (3354 m) annual energy demand for
efficient design (Design 4), the life cycle costs have room conditioning is 100% based on heating.
decreased slightly. In other words, the energy cost savings Likewise in cool temperate climate, the regression anal-
pay back the initial investment for additional window area. ysis indicates that thermal mass has the highest impact on
To conclude, the most important design strategy for total HVAC energy demand (Fig. 17). On the one hand,
cool temperate climate is passive solar heating through due to elevation, temperatures are low in this climate. On
Fig. 16. Cost analysis of optimised designs for courtyard typology in Dhunche.
Please cite this article in press as: Bodach, S. et al. Design guidelines for energy-efficient hotels in Nepal. International Journal of Sustainable Built
Environment (2016), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijsbe.2016.05.008
14 S. Bodach et al. / International Journal of Sustainable Built Environment xxx (2016) xxx–xxx
Fig. 17. Standardised regression coefficient (SRC) of design parameters for double-banked typology.
Fig. 18. Standardised regression coefficient (SRC) of design parameters for atrium typology.
the other hand, solar radiation is high and can be used for facade with the largest WWR of the atrium and courtyard
passive heating which requires a high building mass. typologies is south-facing.
According to the low SRC, window-to-wall ratio The cost analysis shows that in Nepal’s cold climate pas-
(WWR) plays a secondary role for passive design optimisa- sive design can only lead to marginal energy cost savings.
tion (Fig. 18). Depending on the orientation of the open- Fig. 19 compares the annual HVAC electricity costs of dif-
ings, higher window area might reduce (negative SRC) or ferent hotel building typology by thermal mass. Compared
increase (positive SRC) total HVAC consumption. A pos- to the cool temperate and temperate climate absolute cost
itive SRC means that the heat loss through the openings is savings through the application of high mass materials
higher than the solar gains. A negative SRC indicates that amount to between 11 and 17 USD per guest room for
passive heating through window in this direction is effec- Thakmarpha and between 11 and 28 USD per guest room
tive. For example, the results of the atrium typology indi- for Namche. Relative savings are marginal at a level of 2%
cate that larger windows facing South and East reduce to 9% of annual HVAC energy costs.
energy demand while North and West facing windows Similar to the thermal mass strategy, the optimisation of
increase energy demand (Fig. 18). Best performing designs window areas can lead to modest energy cost savings. For
in this climate have a WWR South and East between 20% example, increasing the window area facing South and East
and 40% and a WWR North and West between 10% and of the atrium typology from 10% to 40% results in annual
20%. electricity cost savings of 5 USD per guest rooms (Fig. 20
The SRC for orientation in cold climate has a very low (a)). Equally low are cost savings for optimised design in
rank which means orientation does not have a strong Namche (see Fig. 21(a)). Due to the higher additional
impact on energy consumption. For some typologies, there investment cost for the increased window area, life cycle
is no significant relationship between orientation and costs of the optimised designs are slightly higher than the
HVAC energy consumption (p-value > 0.05). Best per- inefficient design (Figs. 20(b) and 21(b)).
formers of elongated layouts have the facade with the lar- Combining all passive design strategies for the cold
gest window area facing south-east or north-east to climate, Fig. 22 indicates that absolute energy cost
increase solar gains of the low-standing morning sun. The savings are at a similar level as in cool temperate
Please cite this article in press as: Bodach, S. et al. Design guidelines for energy-efficient hotels in Nepal. International Journal of Sustainable Built
Environment (2016), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijsbe.2016.05.008
S. Bodach et al. / International Journal of Sustainable Built Environment xxx (2016) xxx–xxx 15
Fig. 19. Annual electricity costs for different typologies by thermal mass in cold climate.
Fig. 20. Cost analysis for atrium typology with different WWRs in Thakmarpha.
Fig. 21. Cost analysis for atrium typology with different WWRs in Namche.
Fig. 22. Cost analysis of optimised designs for atrium typology in Thakmarpha.
Please cite this article in press as: Bodach, S. et al. Design guidelines for energy-efficient hotels in Nepal. International Journal of Sustainable Built
Environment (2016), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijsbe.2016.05.008
16 S. Bodach et al. / International Journal of Sustainable Built Environment xxx (2016) xxx–xxx
Table 14
International and regional standards for envelope insulation IEA (2013), Dicke et al. (2003), ICC (2014), MoHURD (2015) and BEE (2006).
Region Climate Wall Roof Floor Windows
U-Value U-Value U-Value U-Value SHGC
[W/m2K] [W/m2K] [W/m2K] [W/m2K]
IEA Global Hot 0.35 0.35 – 1.8 0.05–0.5
Cold 0.15 0.15 – 1.8 0.05–0.6
Europe Moderate 0.4–0.65 0.45–0.9 0.4–0.65 2.5–3.25 –
Cold & Temperate 0.15–0.4 0.22–0.45 0.15–0.4 1.25–2.5 –
USA Very cold 0.40 0.16 0.31 0.37 0.45
Warm & mixed-humid 0.59–0.7 0.18–0.22 0.43 0.45–0.60 0.25–0.40
very hot & hot 0.86 0.22–0.27 0.61–1.83 0.65 0.25
China HSWW 0.8–1.5 0.5–0.8 1.5 2.0–5.2 0.18–0.52
Temperate 0.8–1.5 0.5–0.8 – 2.0–5.2 0.24–0.48
Cold 0.45–0.50 0.40–0.45 1.00 1.4–3.0 0.35–0.52
India Warm-humid 0.35 0.26 3.18 0.25
Composite 0.35 0.26 3.18 0.25
Cold 0.37 0.26 – 4.09 0.51
climate. For instance in Thakmarpha, energy cost sav- Table 14 shows a summary of international and regional
ings for atrium typology amounts to up 24 USD per standards that are relevant for the climatic context of
guest room when all passive design strategies are consid- Nepal. It can be seen that standards are more stringent in
ered. However, the relative saving potential amounts to colder climates than in warmer climates. For instance, in
only 12% due to the fact that total energy costs are twice Sweden (Stockholm), cost-effective wall, roof and floor
as high in cold climate compared to cool temperate cli- insulation reaches U-Values of 0.20, 0.17 and 0.25 W/
mate. The most energy-efficient design (Design 4) has m2K, respectively (Boermans and Petersdorff, 2007). In
marginal higher life cycle costs like the base case design comparison, in southern Italy (Palermo), U-Values of
(Fig. 21(b)). 0.48 W/m2K for walls, 0.34 W/m2K for roofs and
To summarise, high thermal mass is very important for 1.44 W/m2K for floors are cost-efficient. Furthermore,
passive design optimisation in Nepal’s cold climate region. developed countries have higher thermal insulation stan-
North and west facing windows should be kept small while dards as compared to developing countries, probably
south and east facing windows can be moderate for opti- because they have a longer tradition of using thermal insu-
mising passive solar heating. Marginal energy cost savings lation. Developed countries also have higher requirements
can be achieved through passive design. for thermal comfort.
Without considering insulation measures, passive design Depending on the construction practices, countries dif-
strategies have the potential to reduce HVAC energy ferentiate their thermal performance standards according
demand between 9% and 23% in this climate. Compared to the thermal mass of the building. Therefore, lightweight
to all other climate zone the reduction potentials are construction has to comply much stricter requirements
moderate. Therefore, the next section analyses in detail than buildings with high thermal mass. This has to do with
the energy savings that can be achieved by insulating the the fact that buildings with high mass can benefit more
hotel buildings. from passive solar heating and cooling effects. For exam-
ple, in China, buildings with low thermal mass have to fulfil
4. Thermal insulation optimisation much lower requirement with regard to the U-Value than
high mass buildings (Shui et al., 2009). It is also common
4.1. International standards to set up thermal resistance of windows depending on the
window-to-wall-ratio following the principle - the higher
In order to keep the indoor environment comfortable, the window areas, the lower the U-Value. Some countries
envelope insulation is necessary to reduce heat loss during also allow trade-offs for low solar heat gain coefficient of
cold weather and keep out excess heat during hot weather. window system if shading devices are provided (BEE,
Finding the optimal insulation level for the building envel- 2006; ICC, 2014).
ope means maintaining a balance between the investment
cost in insulation material during the construction of the
building and the energy cost for mechanical room condi- 4.2. Minimum thermal comfort
tioning low during the operation of the building. Primary
factors for determining the optimal insulation thickness The results of the minimum comfort3 optimisation runs
are climate, cost of energy, cost of the insulation materials indicate that in locations above 500 m and below 2000 m
and the efficiency of the air conditioning system. Many increased insulation levels are almost not cost-effective.
countries have already established standards for optimal
insulation levels which can serve as reference. 3
As defined in methodology section.
Please cite this article in press as: Bodach, S. et al. Design guidelines for energy-efficient hotels in Nepal. International Journal of Sustainable Built
Environment (2016), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijsbe.2016.05.008
S. Bodach et al. / International Journal of Sustainable Built Environment xxx (2016) xxx–xxx 17
Table 15
Optimal insulation of building envelope for minimum thermal comfort.a
Location Wall Roof Ground Floor Window
W/m2K mm W/m2K mm W/m2K mm W/m2K SHGC
Biratnagar 72m 0.32 100 0.37 100 4.17 0 3.14 0.23
Rampur 256m 0.34 100 0.69 50 4.17 0 5.40 0.33
Pokhara 827m – – 0.69 50 4.17 0 5.40 0.33
Kathmandu 1337m – – 0.69 50 – – 5.38 0.68
Dhulikhel 1552m – – – – – – 5.38 0.68
Dhunche 1982m 0.59 50 0.69 50 – – 5.38 0.68
Thakmarpha 2566m 0.23 150 0.37 150 0.48 50 5.38 0.68
Namche 3354m 0.24 150 0.23 150 0.25 100 3.15 0.62
a
Minimum comfort as defined in methodology section.
Please cite this article in press as: Bodach, S. et al. Design guidelines for energy-efficient hotels in Nepal. International Journal of Sustainable Built
Environment (2016), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijsbe.2016.05.008
18 S. Bodach et al. / International Journal of Sustainable Built Environment xxx (2016) xxx–xxx
Fig. 25. Range of cost-effective insulation level for minimum comfort Fig. 26. Cost-effective insulation level of opaque envelope for maximum
(Minimum comfort as defined in methodology section) by envelope comfort by location (Maximum comfort as defined in methodology
component. section).
be noted that only insulated cases with life cycle net savings
are considered in this figure. While U-Values between 0.23
and 0.59 W/m2K are cost-effective for the exterior wall,
roof insulation with thermal transmittance between 0.23
and 0.69 W/m2K is optimal. Cost-effective design solutions
have windows with a thermal transmittance between 5.40
and 3.14 W/m2K, which corresponds to aluminium win-
dows with single glazing and double glazing, respectively.
Please cite this article in press as: Bodach, S. et al. Design guidelines for energy-efficient hotels in Nepal. International Journal of Sustainable Built
Environment (2016), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijsbe.2016.05.008
S. Bodach et al. / International Journal of Sustainable Built Environment xxx (2016) xxx–xxx 19
Table 16
Optimal insulation of building envelope for maximum thermal comfort.a
Location Wall Roof Ground Floor Window
W/m2K mm W/m2K mm W/m2K mm W/m2K SHGC
Biratnagar 72m 0.32 100 0.37 100 0.86 25 3.14 0.23
Rampur 256m 0.34 100 0.37 100 0.86 25 5.38 0.33
Pokhara 827m 0.54 50 0.69 50 0.86 25 5.38 0.33
Kathmandu 1337m 0.59 50 0.37 100 0.48 50 5.38 0.68
Dhulikhel 1552m 0.34 100 0.37 100 0.48 50 5.38 0.68
Dhunche 1982m 0.24 150 0.37 100 0.48 50 2.44 0.62
Thakmarpha 2566m 0.24 150 0.25 150 0.25 100 2.44 0.62
Namche 3354m 0.23 150 0.25 150 0.25 100 2.44 0.62
a
Maximum comfort as defined in methodology section.
Table 17
Energy saving potential through passive design by location and typology.
Building typology
Location Single cottage Double cottage Bungalow Single-banked Double-banked Courtyard Atrium
Biratnagar 72 m 22% 32% 29% 38% 36%
Rampur 256 m 22% 25% 29% 34% 29%
Pokhara 827 m 41% 39% 50% 47% 50% 44%
Kathmandu 1337 m 49% 48% 58% 64% 55% 50%
Dhulikhel 1552 m 49% 57% 73% 56% 49% 28%
Dhunche 1982 m 33% 54% 31% 53% 14%
Thakmarpha 2566 m 15% 13% 23% 15%
Namche 3354 m 13% 9% 23% 11%
Average 34% 39% 43% 42% 35% 40% 17%
Please cite this article in press as: Bodach, S. et al. Design guidelines for energy-efficient hotels in Nepal. International Journal of Sustainable Built
Environment (2016), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijsbe.2016.05.008
20 S. Bodach et al. / International Journal of Sustainable Built Environment xxx (2016) xxx–xxx
Please cite this article in press as: Bodach, S. et al. Design guidelines for energy-efficient hotels in Nepal. International Journal of Sustainable Built
Environment (2016), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijsbe.2016.05.008
S. Bodach et al. / International Journal of Sustainable Built Environment xxx (2016) xxx–xxx 21
energy savings in cool temperate climate. However, in cold While international and regional standards suggest to
climate orientation does not play a significant role. Similar apply more insulation on roofs than walls, the results of
to that of Florides et al. (2002), it can be concluded that, this study conclude a similar thickness for roof and wall.
particularly, elongated layouts should orient the long The reason for that might be the particular multi-storey
building facade towards south. building typology where the roof surface area is smaller
However, in hotel design the orientation of the building in percentage of total outer surface area than the wall. Fur-
and its openings is often influenced by other factors like the thermore, this research is based on the combined effect of
panoramic view or site constraints. Improving the thermal all insulation measures while most studies on cost-
properties of the window according to the passive design effective insulation thickness investigate each building ele-
strategies of the climate can still lead to an energy- ment separately.
efficient design. Two examples are explained below: There are two insulation measures that are not always
This research recommends that windows facing east and justified by economic feasibility: Firstly, floor insulation
west should be avoided in warm temperate and temperate and, secondly, double glazing. In warm temperate climate
climate. If this is not possible, vertical shading devices like the cool ground can be used as thermal sink to reduce
fins combined with low-e glazing should be applied to needs for active cooling. Additional floor insulation
reduce solar gains and prevent overheating in the morning reduces this natural cooling effect and, therefore, increases
and evening hours. Similarly, windows facing north should cooling demand. Regarding glazing it is noticed that, par-
be avoided in cool temperate and cold climate to protect ticularly, in temperate climate, the high additional invest-
from the cold. If this design strategies cannot be fulfilled ment for double glazing does not pay back over life time
due to other design priorities, a lower U-Value of the win- because absolute energy cost savings are very low.
dow (double glazing) and, thus, a better insulation might The market for double glazing is still in the early stage
compensate increased heat losses through additional win- and few companies are offering this product in Nepal. A
dow area. study on hotel design in neighbouring India with similar
It is uncontroversial that envelope insulation reduces market conditions concluded that glazing is one of the least
energy demand in many climates. Using dynamic energy cost-effective energy conservation measure with a simple
simulation and life cycle cost analysis Florides et al. payback period of 10.3 years (Chedwal et al., 2015).
(2002) showed that roof insulation is cost-effective for the Although this payback time is much less than the building’s
hot climate in Cyprus with a short payback period between life time, replacing single for double glazing is the most
3.5 and 5 years while wall insulation pays only back over a cost-intensive energy saving measure leading to a substan-
time period of 10 years. In Turkey, an optimised hotel tial increase of construction costs. Particularly, small and
design will have 37% less energy need than a standard medium scale hotel entrepreneurs with limited investment
design (Sozer, 2010). In India, hotels can save between capital might not be able to fund additional construction
33% and 50% by applying insulation measures (Chedwal costs.
et al., 2015). Floor insulation and double glazing windows might not
Determining which level of envelope insulation is cost- be justified by economic feasibility for some climate region
efficient depends on several factors and makes comparison in Nepal. However, they are necessary for other demands
difficult. In most regions, except Northern Europe, insula- like acoustic comfort, condensation issues or thermal com-
tion requirements of building regulations do not reach the fort (surface temperature). Therefore, these measures
economically justified level (IEA, 2013). The fact that should be considered to ensure a comfortable hotel design.
building energy demand is a major contributor to climate Finally, the results of the simulation runs led to different
change, performance goals should meet climate change design recommendations for the two locations in the tem-
action and not only economically feasible level. perate climate (from 501 to 1500 masl). A further differen-
Comparing the findings for cost-effective insulation for tiation of the temperate climate zone is needed and a
Nepal with international standards (Table 14) the follow- renaming of all zones proposed. The following consoli-
ing can be concluded: dated bioclimatic zoning for Nepal with five elevation-
based bioclimate zones is suggested:
Recommended cost-effective insulation for cold climate
reaches similar values as North-European standards. Warm climate (below 500 masl).
Cost-effective U-Values for temperate and cool temper- Moderate warm climate (from 501 to 1000 masl).
ate climate are comparable with standards of similar cli- Moderate climate (from 1001 to 1500 masl).
mates in the International Energy Conservation Code Moderate cold climate (from 1501 to 2500 masl) and
(ICC, 2014). Cold climate (above 2500 masl).
Results for warm temperate climate reaches thermal
resistance very close to Indian regulations (BEE, 2006). In conclusion, passive design strategies and minimum
Similar to standards in India and USA, a low SHGC of requirements for insulation levels are suggested for each
at least 0.25 is recommended for locations with high bioclimatic zone (see Tables 18–20). These energy efficiency
cooling load.
Please cite this article in press as: Bodach, S. et al. Design guidelines for energy-efficient hotels in Nepal. International Journal of Sustainable Built
Environment (2016), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijsbe.2016.05.008
22 S. Bodach et al. / International Journal of Sustainable Built Environment xxx (2016) xxx–xxx
Table 18
Passive design recommendations for hotel buildings in Nepal.
Bioclimatic Thermal WWR WWR WWR WWR Orientation Overhang Fins East &
zone mass South North East West South PF West PF
Warm low, medium, 20% a/ 20%a/ 0–20% 0–20% South 0.2–0.4 0.4–0.6
(<500 m) or high 30%b 30%b
Moderate warm high 20%a/ 20%a/ 0–20% 0–20% South 0.2–0.4 flexible shading
(501–1000 m) 30%b 30%b
c
Moderate high 40–60% 10–20% 10–20% 10–20% South 0.2 flexible shading
(1001–1500 m)
Moderate cold high 40–60% 10–20% 20–30% 20–30% South flexible shading
(1501–2500 m)
Cold high 20–40% 0–20% 0–20% 0–20% – – –
(>2500 m)
a
For small-scale hotels with low case depth.
b
For large-scale hotels with large case depth.
c
For WWR greater than 40.
Table 19
Recommendations for opaque envelope insulation of hotel buildings in Nepal.
Bioclimatic zone U-Value for Wall U-Value for Roof U-Value for Floor
Minimum Maximum Thickness Minimum Maximum Thickness Minimum Maximum Thickness
comforta comforta insulation comfort comfort insulation comfort comfort insulation
W/m2K W/m2K mm W/m2K W/m2K mm W/m2K W/m2K mm
Warm 0.35 0.35 100 0.70 0.40 50–100 – 0.90 0–25
(<500 m)
Moderate warm 1.60 0.60 50 0.70 0.40 50–100 – 0.90 0–25
(501–1000 m)
Moderate 1.60 0.60 50 0.70 0.40 50–100 – 0.90 0–25
(1001–1500 m)
Moderate cold 0.60 0.35 50–100 0.70 0.40 50–100 0.90 0.50 25–50
(1501–2500 m)
Cold 0.25 0.25 150 0.25 0.25 150 0.50 0.25 50–100
(>2500 m)
a
Minimum and maximum comfort as defined in the methodology section.
Table 20
Using building energy simulation as the main method,
Recommendations for window performance of hotel buildings in Nepal.
this research has its limitations. The results of the simula-
Bioclimatic zone U-Value SHGC
tion are calculated under predefined boundary conditions.
a b
Minimum Comfort Maximum Comfort However, those boundary conditions are based on assump-
W/m2K W/m2K
tions that might have a certain impreciseness. Absolute
Warm 3.20 3.20 60.25 energy demand in the real building might vary because of
(<500 m)
variation in thermal properties of building materials, con-
Moderate warm 5.40 3.20 60.3
(501–1000 m) struction quality and building use.
Moderate 5.40 3.20 P0.6 For the economic analysis, construction prices from
(1001–1500 m) Kathmandu in January 2015 were used to make a compar-
Moderate cold 5.40 2.50 P0.6 ison possible. However, prices in other locations of the
(1501–2500 m)
country might be higher or lower due to additional or less
Cold 3.20 2.50 P0.6
(>2500 m) transportation cost. Furthermore, construction prices are
a influenced by other factors like labour cost, fuel prices,
Minimum comfort as defined in the methodology section for small-
scale hotels. demand-supply gap etc.
b
Maximum comfort as defined in the methodology section for all other The focus of this study was on hotel buildings as an
hotels. example typology for commercial buildings. Seven different
typical hotel designs were used to conduct the analysis. If a
guidelines for hotel design are the first step towards a low- particular hotel design is significantly different to the
carbon development path of the fast growing accommoda- developed typologies, its thermal performance might also
tion sector in Nepal. vary. Nonetheless, the findings of this study are an effective
Please cite this article in press as: Bodach, S. et al. Design guidelines for energy-efficient hotels in Nepal. International Journal of Sustainable Built
Environment (2016), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijsbe.2016.05.008
S. Bodach et al. / International Journal of Sustainable Built Environment xxx (2016) xxx–xxx 23
Please cite this article in press as: Bodach, S. et al. Design guidelines for energy-efficient hotels in Nepal. International Journal of Sustainable Built
Environment (2016), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijsbe.2016.05.008
24 S. Bodach et al. / International Journal of Sustainable Built Environment xxx (2016) xxx–xxx
Dicke, N., Weber, C., Kjellsson, E., Despretz, H., 2003. Towards an IEA, 2013. Technology roadmap energy efficient building envelopes. Tech.
European building code. In: Tech. rep., IER, University of Stuttgart rep., International Energy Agency (IEA), Paris. URL <http://www.
ADEME, Sophia Antipolis ByFys. University of Lund. iea.org>.
Department of Energy (DOE), 2015. Building Technologies Office: Lam, J.C., Hui, S.C., 1996. Sensitivity analysis of energy performance of
EnergyPlus Energy Simulation Software. URL <https://energyplus. office buildings. Build. Environ. 31 (1), 27–39.
net/>. Meteotest, 2014. Meteonorm Software. URL <http://meteonorm.com/>.
Department of Energy (DOE), 2015. EnergyPlus – Testing and Validation MoHURD, 2015. Chinese Standard: GB 50189-2015. Public building
Report. URL <https://energyplus.net/testing>. energy efficiency design standards.
European Environment Agency (EEA), 2015. Heating degree days. URL NEA, 2014. Annual Report - Nepal Electricty Authority. URL <http://
<http://www.eea.europa.eu/data-and-maps/indicators/heating-degree- www.nea.org.np>.
days-1>. Rijal, H., Yoshida, H., Umemiya, N., 2010. Seasonal and regional
Fanger, P.O., 1970. Thermal Comfort: Analysis and Applications in differences in neutral temperatures in Nepalese traditional vernacular
Environmental Engineering. Danish Technical Press. houses. Build. Environ. 45 (12), 2743–2753.
Florides, G., Tassou, S., Kalogirou, S., Wrobel, L., 2002. Measures used Schiavon, S., Lee, K.H., 2013. Dynamic predictive clothing insulation
to lower building energy consumption and their cost effectiveness. models based on outdoor air and indoor operative temperatures.
Appl. Energy 73 (3–4), 299–328. Build. Environ. 59, 250–260.
Gasparella, A., Pernigotto, G., Cappelletti, F., Romagnoni, P., Baggio, P., Shiming, D., Burnett, J., 2002. Energy use and management in hotels in
Apr 2011. Analysis and modelling of window and glazing systems Hong Kong. Int. J. Hospitality Manage. 21 (4), 371–380.
energy performance for a well insulated residential building. Energy Shui, B., Evans, M., Lin, H., Jiang, W., Liu, B., Song, B., Somasundaram,
Build. 43 (4), 1030–1037. S., 2009. Country Report on Building Energy Codes in China. URL
GoN, 2014. Tourism Employment Survey 2014. Tech. rep., Government <http://www.pnl.gov/>.
of Nepal (GoN), Ministry of Culture, Tourism & Civil Aviation, Sozer, H., 2010. Improving energy efficiency through the design of the
Kathmandu. URL <http://www.tourism.gov.np>. building envelope. Build. Environ. 45 (12), 2581–2593.
Gratia, E., Herde, A.D., 2003. Design of low energy office buildings. Stevanović, S., 2013. Optimization of passive solar design strategies: a
Energy Build. 35 (5), 473–491. review. Renewable Sustainable Energy Rev. 25, 177–196.
Hachem, C., Athienitis, A., Fazio, P., 2011. Parametric investigation of Trung, D.N., Kumar, S., 2005. Resource use and waste management in
geometric form effects on solar potential of housing units. Solar Vietnam hotel industry. J. Cleaner Prod. 13 (2), 109–116.
Energy 85 (9), 1864–1877. Wang, J.C., 2012. A study on the energy performance of hotel buildings in
Hopfe, C., 2007. Uncertainty and sensitivity analysis for detailed design Taiwan. Energy Build. 49, 268–275.
support. Technische Universiteit Eindhoven, 1799–1804. URL WECS, 2010. Energy Sector Synopsis Report 2010. Tech. Rep. July,
<http://www.bwk.tue.nl/bps/hensen/team/past/Hopfe.pdf>. Government of Nepal, Water and Energy Comission Secretariat,
Hygh, J.S., DeCarolis, J.F., Hill, D.B., Ranji Ranjithan, S., 2012. Kathmandu. URL <http://www.wecs.gov.np/pdf/snyopsis.pdf>.
Multivariate regression as an energy assessment tool in early building WTTC, 2014. Travel & Tourism Economic Impact 2014 Nepal. Tech. rep.,
design. Build. Environ. 57, 165–175. World Travle & Tourism Council, London.
ICC, 2014. 2015 International Energy Conservation Code. Internation Zhang, Y., 2012. Use jEPlus as an efficient building design optimisation
Code Council. URL <http://codes.iccsafe.org/>. tool. In: CIBSE ASHRAE Technical Symposium. No. April. pp. 1–12.
Please cite this article in press as: Bodach, S. et al. Design guidelines for energy-efficient hotels in Nepal. International Journal of Sustainable Built
Environment (2016), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijsbe.2016.05.008
Appendix D
In order to give an outlook on the impact of energy conservation in the future, energy savings
scenarios for the Nepalese building sector were developed (see Energy saving scenarios for
the building sector on page 63). It was envisaged to create a simple model to estimate the
impact of the introduction of design concepts and technologies for more energy-efficient
buildings and compare the increase of energy consumption with the business-as-usual (BAU)
scenario. This study only considers energy consumed for heating and cooling purposes. Due
to the lack of data, reasonable assumptions were made for a number of variables illustrated
in Table D.1 and Table D.3.
For the energy demand projection in hotel buildings, 2016 was selected as baseline year
and the total number of hotel rooms was calculated from data of 2009 assuming a growth
rate of 6%. It was assumed that 20% of the hotel rooms are equipped with space condition
systems in 2016 and that this percentage increases by 3% every year. According to the
conducted energy simulation study the energy consumption of the inefficient reference room
and retrofitted energy efficient hotel room is 79 and 47 kWh/m2 a, respectively. Furthermore,
it was assumed that the share of electricity use for space conditioning is 5% in 2016 and will
grow by 1% every year.
For the energy scenarios of the residential sector the total floor area was estimated based
on the population, household size, number of households and floor area per household. The
year 2011 was used as baseline year with a household size of 4.9 persons and 20% of
residential floor area with energy consuming space conditioning. With rising development the
household size is assumed to decrease by 1% every year while 1% of air-conditioned floor
area is added. The energy consumption per floor area of the base case buildings were
calculated using statistical data of energy consumption for heating and cooling from [57] in
2011. Based on the results of the simulation study, it was assumed that energy-efficient
residential buildings will consume 42% less energy for heating and cooling than the inefficient
base case.
137
Approach for energy saving scenarios
Table D.1: Assumptions for energy scenarios for space conditioning in hotels of Nepal
Description Value
Hotel rooms
Total number in 2016 21,460a
Annual growth rate 6.0%b
Average size 30 m2c
Space conditioning
Share of air-conditioned rooms in 2016 20%
Annual growth rate 3%
Energy consumption
Base case buildings 79 kWh/m2 ad
Energy-efficient buildings 45 kWh/m2 ad
Electricity
Electricity share of consumption in 2016 5%
Annual growth rate 1%
Scenarios
Business-as-usual (BAU) All hotel buildings are inefficient base case
buildings
EE-2 Share of energy-efficent hotel rooms is
increased by 2% annually
EE-5 Share of energy-efficent hotel rooms is
increased by 5% annually
a Projections from data of 2009 [34] with annual growth rate of 6.0%
b Based on sector growth rate projection of 5% [60] and historical growth rate: 6.5% from 2009 to 2013 [34]
c Based on field research
d Based on own thermal building simulation
138 Climate responsive building design for low carbon development in Nepal
Table D.2: Energy demand projection of hotel buildings in Nepal under different scenarios
Share of electricity used for space conditioning (%) 5.0% 9.0% 14.0% 19.0% 24.0% 29.0%
Electricity consumption BAU (GWh) 0.5 1.8 5.7 13.5 28.4 54.9
EE-2 scenario
Share of energy-efficient air-conditioned rooms (%) 0.0% 8.0% 18.0% 28.0% 38.0% 48.0%
Number of ineffizient conditioned rooms 4,292 7,976 13,973 21,659 30,997 41,568
Number of energy-efficient air-conditioned rooms 0 694 3,067 8,423 18,998 38,370
Energy consumption EE-2 (GWh) 10.2 19.8 37.3 62.7 99.1 150.3
Electricity consumption EE-2 (GWh) 0.5 1.8 5.2 11.9 23.8 43.6
Energy saving potentials (GWh) 0.0 0.7 3.1 8.6 19.4 39.1
Energy saving potentials (%) 0.0% 3.4% 7.7% 12.1% 16.4% 20.7%
EE-5 scenario
Share of energy-efficient air-conditioned rooms (%) 0.0% 20.0% 45.0% 70.0% 95.0% 100.0%
Number of ineffizient conditioned rooms 4,292 6,936 9,372 9,024 2,500 0
Number of energy-efficient air-conditioned rooms 0 1,734 7,668 21,057 47,495 79,938
Energy consumption EE-5 (GWh) 10.2 18.8 32.6 49.8 70.0 107.9
Electricity consumption EE-5 (GWh) 0.5 1.7 4.6 9.5 16.8 31.3
139
Approach for energy saving scenarios
Table D.3: Assumptions for energy scenarios for space conditioning in residential buildings of
Nepal
Description Value
Demography
Population growth rate 1.35%a
Household size in 2011 4.9 persons%a
Annual growth rate of household size -1%
Floor area
Floor area per household in 2011 43.0 m2 b
140 Climate responsive building design for low carbon development in Nepal
Table D.4: Energy demand projection of residential buildings in Nepal under different scenarios
Energy consumption (TWh) 12.1 16.9 24.7 35.1 48.8 66.7 90.0
Share of consumption by electricity (%) 1.8% 5.8% 10.8% 15.8% 20.8% 25.8% 30.8%
Electricity consumption (TWh) 0.2 1.0 2.7 5.5 10.2 17.2 27.7
EE-1 scenario
Share of energy-efficient air-conditioned floor area (%) 0.0% 0.0% 4.0% 9.0% 14.0% 19.0% 24.0%
Ineffizient air-conditioned floor area million (m²) 60.9 85.2 119.8 161.3 211.8 272.6 345.0
Energy-efficient conditioned floor area million (m²) 0.0 0.0 5.0 15.9 34.5 63.9 109.0
Energy consumption EE-1 (TWh) 12.1 16.9 24.4 34.1 46.6 62.6 83.1
Electricity consumption (TWh) 0.2 1.0 2.6 5.4 9.7 16.2 25.6
Energy saving potentials (TWh) 0.0 0.0 0.3 1.0 2.2 4.1 6.9
Energy saving potentials (%) 0.0% 0.0% 1.3% 2.9% 4.5% 6.1% 7.7%
EE-3 scenario
Share of energy-efficient air-conditioned floor area (%) 0.0% 0.0% 12.0% 27.0% 42.0% 57.0% 72.0%
Ineffizient air-conditioned floor area million (m²) 60.9 85.2 109.8 129.4 142.8 144.7 127.1
Energy-efficient conditioned floor area million (m²) 0.0 0.0 15.0 47.8 103.4 191.8 326.9
Energy consumption EE-3 (TWh) 12.1 16.9 23.8 32.1 42.2 54.5 69.2
141
Appendix E
Climate data is the most important input for analysing bioclimatic design strategies and
conducting building energy simulation. Commonly a typical meteorological year (TMY) is
used for this purpose. A TMY is a combination of selected weather data for a specific
location, generated from observed weather data over several decades. It represent the
long-term average meteorological conditions of a place while having a realistic frequency
distributions and contains hourly values of all relevant meteorological elements.
The lack of TMY data sets for Nepal made is necessary to generate such data sets for
the different locations. This was done by using the software tool Meteonorm [27]. Monthly
climate normals (temperature, precipitation) from weather stations, either directly collected
from Department of Hydrology and Meteorology Nepal [28] or derived from United Nation’s
Food and Agriculture Organisation climate database [29], were imported into the software
with the aim to have more accurate results.
In order to check the plausibility of the generated data sets, it was compared with other
existing climate data (see also Climate and design on page 13). For the comparison study
measured climate observations from recently installed automated weather stations [30] and, if
available, hourly data sets from the SWERA project [63] were used.
The following figures illustrate the comparative analysis for the locations Biratnagar and
Kathmandu. The density of the data points for 2013, 2014 and 2015 is lower than for the
generated TMY data set either because the weather station does not on a hourly bases (but
every five hours) or data records are missing. The psychrometric chart shows also that hourly
temperatures of the measured data is only available as integer value. Nevertheless, it can be
seen that both daily averages and hourly values are in a similar range.
143
Comparison of climate data sets
30
20
10
0
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
30
20
10
0
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
20
10
0
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
TMY: Typical meteorological year generated by Meteonorm software with monthly station data from 1981-2010
2013 2014 2015 : Oberserved data of 1 year from automated weather stations
SWERA: Climate data generated by SWERA project
Figure E.1: Comparison of hourly dry bulb temperature from different climate data sets in
Biratnagar, Pokhara and Kathmandu (Data sources: [27–30, 63])
30
20
10
0
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
TMY: Typical meteorological year generated by Meteonorm software with monthly station data from 1981-2010
2013 2014 2015 : Oberserved data of 1 year from automated weather stations
SWERA: Climate data generated by SWERA project
Figure E.2: Comparison of daily climate data from Biratnagar (Data sources: [27–30])
144 Climate responsive building design for low carbon development in Nepal
Comparison of climate data sets
%
0%
%
%
50
70
90
80
60
10
Typical meteorological year (TMY)
generated by Meteonorm with monthly
%
40
station data from 1981-2010: 25
TMY
Observed data of 1 year from
automated weather stations:
%
2013 2014 2015
30
15
%
20
10
10%
5
-5 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45
Dry Bulb Temperature (°C)
Figure E.3: Comparison of hourly climate data from Biratnagar (Data sources: [27–30])
20
10
0
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
TMY: Typical meteorological year generated by Meteonorm software with monthly station data from 1981-2010
2013 2014 2015 : Oberserved data of 1 year from automated weather stations
SWERA: Climate data generated by SWERA project
Figure E.4: Comparison of daily climate data from Kathmandu (Data sources: [27–30, 63])
Climate responsive building design for low carbon development in Nepal 145
Comparison of climate data sets
%
0%
%
%
50
70
90
80
60
10
Typical meteorological year (TMY)
generated by Meteonorm with monthly
%
40
station data from 1981-2010: 25
TMY
Observed data of 1 year from
%
2013 2014 2015
30
15
%
20
10
10%
5
-5 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45
Dry Bulb Temperature (°C)
Figure E.5: Comparison of hourly climate data from Kathmandu (Data sources: [27–30])
%
%
50
70
90
80
60
10
20
%
SWERA
30
15
%
20
10
10%
5
-5 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45
Dry Bulb Temperature (°C)
Figure E.6: Comparison of two climate data sets for Kathmandu (Data sources: [27–29, 63])
146 Climate responsive building design for low carbon development in Nepal