Drying Methods
Drying Methods
Drying Methods
Ahmad, A., Gungula, D.T., Tame V.T., Kapsiya J. and Kirawa, D. M. A. 944-100
Abstract
The main purpose of this research was to determine the effect of different drying methods on
physicochemical characteristics and sensory qualities of tomato powder in Yola, Adamawa State. The fruits
were harvested at fully matured and ripe. The harvested fruits
fruits were subjected to blanching prior to three
different drying methods. The three drying methods were shade drying, sun drying and oven drying which
represented the treatments. The experiment was arranged in a Completely Randomised Design (CRD) and
replicated
icated three times. Fresh and dried samples of tomato were analysed for their
physicochemical/functional properties, fresh had higher moisture content with 95.64 % followed by shade
dried with 5.90% while sun and oven dried had the least equal mean value of of 5.67%. The energy value was
higher in the sun dried sample with 317.9 k/cal though not significant difference (P>0.05)
(P 0.05) from the other
dried samples, all the dried samples were statistically difference at (P≤0.05)
(P≤0.05) from fresh sample with 11.0
k/cal and all these were as a result of high moisture content of the fresh sample. After drying, the
carbohydrate content of fruit increases and low carbohydrate of fresh fruits showed that they supply little
or no energy. Oven drying was found to be faster and efficient
efficient in moisture removal than sun and shade
drying methods. Therefore, pretreatment (blanching) prior to drying should be adopted for better quality
products.
Keywords: Tomato; Drying; Physicochemical Properties; Sensory Quality
94
Dutse Journal of Agriculture and Food Security (DUJAFS)
( ) Vol. 7 No. 1, June. 2020
Ahmad, A., Gungula, D.T., Tame V.T., Kapsiya J. and Kirawa, D. M. A. 94-100
95
Dutse Journal of Agriculture and Food Security (DUJAFS)
( Vol. 7 No. 1, June. 2020
Ahmad, A., Gungula, D.T., Tame V.T., Kapsiya J. and Kirawa, D. M. A. 944-100
Ash content indicated highly significant Lipid content showed highly significant
difference (P≤0.05)
≤0.05) between the dried samples difference (P≤0.05),
≤0.05), all the dried samples were
and fresh sample after drying. Shade dried found to be significantly difference from the
samples had the highest Ash content of 3.68% fresh sample after drying. Shade dried sample
while sun dried sample recorded the lowest value recorded the highest lipid content of 2.90% while
of 0.81%. The study has shown that at the different the least value (0.19%) wass obtained from fresh
drying method affect the ash content at sample. In terms of protein content, the result
processing. This is in line to the report of also indicated highly significant difference
McClement, (2003) who reported lower ash (P≤0.05)
≤0.05) between the dried samples and fresh
content of the sun-dried
dried products could be as a sample after drying. Shade dried sample was
result of dripping of moisture containing found to record the highest mean value of 3.12%
dissolved salts from thee pulp since minerals of protein
rotein content while the least value of 1.01%
essentially constitute ash. was obtained from fresh sample. This finding
Similarly, fibre content showed highly shows that the different method of drying had
significant difference (P≤0.05)
≤0.05) between the dried effect on protein content at processing. The
samples and fresh sample after drying. The result significantly higher protein content obtained in
showed that oven dried treatment recorded the shade-drying method could be attributed to
highest fibre content of (15.11%) but was not minimal effect of temperature exerted on the
statistically difference at (P>0.05) from sun and samples during storage. Furthermore, some
shade dried samples, while the least of value researchers reported that the significant
(1.05%) was obtained from the fresh sample. The differences on crude protein content between
result of the study has shown that the methods of fresh and dried samples and among the dried
drying did affect the fibre content both b at samples might be due to the denaturation of
processing and storage. The faster rate of drying protein cells caused by high temperatures from
in the oven compared to the solar dried could the oven during drying process leading to loss of
result in reduced fibre breakdown reflecting in protein thereby weakening the three
three-dimensional
the higher fibre content of the oven dried pulp. conformation of the protein cells (Danso (Danso-
The increase in the fibre content was in Boating, 2013). Similar observations were
agreement with the findings of Fagbohun et al., reported by Hassan et al.. (2007); Ukegbu and
(2010) who reported a decrease in the percentage Okereke (2013) on effect of drying method on
fibre content of sun-dried
dried plantain chips. protein content of vegetables. Elegbede (1998)
observed higher protein content in sun dried
96
Dutse Journal of Agriculture and Food Security (DUJAFS)
( ) Vol. 7 No. 1, June. 2020
Ahmad, A., Gungula, D.T., Tame V.T., Kapsiya J. and Kirawa, D. M. A. 94-100
vegetables than in solar dried samples may occur induce vitamin C losses.
sses. This result is also in
as a result of higher denaturation
denatur action of contrast with the report of earlier researchers that
protein cell due to high temperature of oven the higher temperature at which the samples were
drying and solar drying (700 ± 850C and 65 ± 5oC prepared is probably responsible for the loss of
respectively) than sun drying. This phenomenon ascorbic acid having been reported to be
was also supported by Idah et al. al (2010) who (Garangyo et al.,
corresponding to temperature (Garan
found a higher amount of protein content in 1992).
vegetables after drying in open sun as compared Table 2 shows the result of the effects of drying
to solar dried samples. methods on physical and sensory attributes of
Carbohydrates content indicated highly dried and fresh sample of tomato. Water
significant difference (P≤0.05)
≤0.05) between the dried absorption capacity indicated highly significant
samples and fresh sample after drying and sun- sun differences (P≤0.05)
≤0.05) among the drying methods
dried sample had the highest carbohydrate after drying. The oven dried tomato had the
content of 69.87% followed by oven dried highest water absorption capacity of (3.30
sample with (69.77%) while the least value v mg/100g), while this was not significantly
(1.30%) was obtained from fresh sample. The difference from the value (3.10 mg/100g), when
increase in carbohydrate content might be due to tomato was shade dried, it was significantly
low level of moisture with increased temperature. higher compared to the water absorption capacity
This result agrees with the findings of Oluwalana (2.67 mg/100g) when sun dried. The increased
and Oluwamukomi (2011) who observed that as water absorption capacity at higher temperature
the temperaturee of plantain flour blanched under is an indication that the tomato powder at this
three temperature regimes increased, their temperature is capable of absorbing water than
carbohydrate content also increased. This study the other samples within a short time (Itiola and
is also in agreement with the results obtained by Odeku, 2005).
005). This may be attributed to amylose
Ukegbu and Okereke (2013) who according to leaching (Etudaiye et al.,., 2009) while the low
them reported that “various vegetables
vegetable like water absorption capacity values may be
African spinach, fluted pumpkin and okra in their attributed to the formation of covalent bonds
fresh state have been noted to be poor sources of between hydroxyl groups (Jiang et al., 2015).
carbohydrates. However, after drying, the The high-water
water absorption capacity va values also
carbohydrate content of vegetables increased due have direct correlation with the gelatinization
to removal of moisture content (Kolawole et al., temperature (Falade and Okafor, 2013). The
2011). ability of oven to dry the sample efficiently
Calorific
alorific value indicated highly significant ensures the higher rate of water absorption
difference (P≤0.05)
≤0.05) between dried samples and capacity and this study is therefore, in
fresh sample after drying, sun dried recorded the conformity with the findfindings of Damirel and
highest of (317.9kj/cal) but was not statistically Turhan (2003) on dwarf cavendish and banana
difference from oven and shade dried samples slices.
while the least of 11.0
1.0 kj/cal was obtained from Bulk density showed that the effect of the drying
fresh sample. Vitamin C content showed highly method on bulk density was not significantly
significant difference (P≤0.05)
≤0.05) between the dried different (P>0.05) after drying. The results
and fresh samples after drying. The oven dried obtained is a confirmation of the earlier re
report by
sample recorded the highest vitamin C content Torgul and Pehlivan (2004) that bulk density of
(15.64 mg/100g) followed by shade dried
drie (14.26 flour from fruits increased as a result of heat
mg/100g) while the least was obtained from the treatment of the flour prior to drying.
fresh sample (6.73 mg/100g) after drying. The
slow drying process might be the probable reason Effect of Drying Methods on Sensory
for the higher content obtained in the oven-dried
oven Evaluation of Tomato Powder Soup
samples. This result is however in disagreement Colour indicated highly significant difference
with what at was reported by Damodaran et al. (P≤0.05)
≤0.05) between the fresh sample and dried
(2008) and Fellows (2000) who found out that samples after drying, fresh sample recorded the
higher temperatures of drying gave lower highest of 8.67 followed by oven dried with 7.33
vitamin C content and that the samples from the but oven dried was not statistically difference
oven dryer had lower vitamin C content than the (P>0.05) from shade and susun-dried samples. The
samples from the solar and sun dryer in i both response of panelists on appearance (colour)
storage periods. According to them these indicated that the oven dried tomato products
differences might be due sensitivity of vitamin C was highly preferred because the samples looked
to heat and oxidation. Vitamin C content brighter and retained much of the natural colour
decreases during cutting and drying. Hossain et than the sun and shade dried samples. The
al. (2010) also reported that water loss may also difference
rence in the appearance (colour) of the dried
97
Dutse Journal of Agriculture and Food Security (DUJAFS)
( Vol. 7 No. 1, June. 2020
Ahmad, A., Gungula, D.T., Tame V.T., Kapsiya J. and Kirawa, D. M. A. 944-100
Table 2: Effect drying methods on physical characteristics and sensory quality of Tomat
Tomato powder
Treatments H20 Bulk Colour Taste Aroma Consistency Overall
Absorption Density Acceptability
(mg/100g) (mg/100g)
Shade 3.10 0.61 7.00 6.67 6.67 7.00 7.00
Sun 2.67 0.61 7.00 6.33 6.67 7.33 7.00
Oven 3.30 0.61 7.33 7.00 7.00 7.33 7.00
Fresh 8.67 8.33 8.00 8.00 8.00
Tomato
P<F 0.003 0.790 0.004 0.009 0.140 0.050 0.247
LSD 0.220 0.030 0.745 0.942 0.745 0.666 1.290
The slow drying process of the sun and shade Otegbayo et al.. (2001) reported that boiled yam
drying methods might have caused the from Pona; a cultivar of D. rotundata was rated
objectionable colour of the tomato powder. This superior to other cultivars in cooking quality
result is however not in concordance with the attributes due to its sweet taste, softness and
work of other researchers who stated that sun mealy texture after cooking. There was no
dried method can produce excellent colour of significant difference (P>0.05) between the fresh
mango chips in maintaining its yellow colour sample and dried samples on overall
(Bertina, 2015). acceptability before and after storage.
Taste indicated highly significant
ficant difference
(P≤0.01)
≤0.01) between the fresh sample and the dried Conclusion
samples after drying, fresh sample had the In this study, the various drying methods used
highest of 8.33 followed by oven dried with 7.00 were capable of preserving the nutrients in the
while the least of 6.33 was obtained from sun dried samples of tomato without total loss of any
dried sample. Generally, there was variation in nutrient. Shade dried and oven dried samples
tastee among the treatment samples. Oven dried were found to retain most of the nutritional
tomato powder soup was the most accepted attributes of tomato powder after storage, On the
scoring. This result is however contrary to the other hand, oven and sun drying were faster than
findings of Kammerow, (1960). The low the shade drying method. Oven drying was more
temperature during sun drying process may have cost effective and gave the lowest moisture
enhanced the taste of the soup. Also, taste
ta may content in this study, proving lower moisture
be attributed to fat content in the mango chips. content and higher nutritive value, thus cconfers a
Research conducted by (Kammerow, 1960) and greater increase in shelf-life
life on the dried samples
(Aiyesanmi and Oguntokum1996) showed that and other sensory qualities.
fat contribute to energy and palatability of foods.
In terms of aroma, the result shows no significant References
difference (P>0.05) between the dried samples Adaskaveg, J. E., Forster, H., & Sommer, N. F.
and fresh sample after drying and amongst the (2002). Principles of post-harvest
dried samples. Consistency indicated significant pathology and management of decays of
difference (P≤0.05)
≤0.05) between the dried samples edible horticultural crops. P. 196-197.
and fresh sample after drying. The highest
consistency of 8.00 was obtained from fro fresh Agrios, G. N. (2005). Plant Pathology, 5th
sample but was not statistically difference Edition, Academic Press, New York, USA.
(P≤0.05) from both oven and sun-drieddried samples P: 58.
while the least of 7.00 was obtained from shade
dried sample. The consistency of the fresh Aiyesanmi, F. A., & Oguntokun, M. O. (1996).
samples over dried samples may possibly be as a Nutrient composition, mineral content and
result of little or no damage that was induced in solubility of the protein of palm weevil
fresh tomato resulting in an integrated but very (Rhynchoporus phoenicis f. Coleoptera:
thin cell wall. This thin cell wall had a poor Curculionidae). Journal of Zhejiang
ability to resist external forces, leading to University SCIENCE 8, 318
318-322.
reduced hardness compared with dried samples
(Jiang et al., 2015). Also, drying method
met had no Alamu, O. J., Nwaokocha, C. N
N., & Adunola, O.
effect on texture, which in this case consists of (2010). Design and construction of a
elasticity, consistency, stickiness and hardness. domestic passive solar food dryer,
98
Dutse Journal of Agriculture and Food Security (DUJAFS)
( ) Vol. 7 No. 1, June. 2020
Ahmad, A., Gungula, D.T., Tame V.T., Kapsiya J. and Kirawa, D. M. A. 94-100
Ames, B.M., Shigena, M.K., Hagen, T.M. Etudaiye,, H.A., Nwabueze, T.U. and Sanni, L.O.
(1993). Oxidants, antioxidants and the (2009). Quality of fufu processing from
Degenerative Diseases of Ageing. Journal cassava mosaic disease (CMD) resistant
of Health National academic Science. varieties. African Journal of Food Science
7915-7922. Vol. 3 (3), 61-67.
AOAC International (2007). Official methods of Eze, J. I., & Agbo, K. E. (2011). Comparative
analysis, 18th edition, Association of Studies of Sun and Solar Drying of Peeled
Analytical
alytical Chemists, International, and Unpeeled Ginger. American Journal of
Washington DC Scientific and Industrial Research
Research, 2(2):
136-143.
Ayandiji, A. O. R. & Adeniyi, O. D. (2011).
Determinant Post-harvest
harvest Losses among Fagbohun E .D., Abegunde O O. K, & David O. M.
Tomato Farmers in Imeko-Afon
Imeko Local (2010) Nutritionall and mycoflora changes
Government Area of Ogun State, Nigeria. during storage of plantain chips and the
Global Journal of Science Frontier health implications,, Journal of Agriculture
Research, 11(5), 22-28. and Biotechnology and Sustainable
Development., 2(4), 6161-65
Bala, B. K. & Janjai, S. (2009). Solar drying of
fruits, vegetables, spices, medicinal plants Falade, K. O. & Abbo, E. S. (2007). AirAir-drying
and fish: Developments and Potentials. and rehydration characteristics of date palm
International Solar Food Processing Phoenix dactylifera L.) fruits. Journal of
(Phoenix
Conference 14-16, January, 2009 India. Food Engineering 79, 724-730
Bertina, N. (2015). Quality of keitt mango chips Fellows, J. P. (2000). Food Processing
as affected by method of drying, Technology, Principles and Practice 2nd
packagingand storage periods.
periods A thesis Edition. CRC Press, Woodhead Publishing
submitted to the Department of Limited.
Horticulture, Kwame Nkrumah University
of Science and Technology in partial Hassan, S. W., Omar, R. A., Maishanu, H. N.,
fulfilment of the requirement for the degree Matuza, I. K., Faruk, U. Z. & Sani, A. A.
of Masters of Philosophy. (2007). Effect of drying method on
nutrients and non- nutrients composition of
Damodaran, A. (2008). Equity Risk Premiums leaves of Gynandropsis gynandra
(ERP): Determinants, Estimation and (Capparaceae). Asian Journal of
Implications. Stern School of Business Biochemistry.2, 349--353
Danso-Boating,
Boating, E. (2013). Effect of drying Hossain, M.E., Alam, M. J, Hakim, M. A.,
methods on nutrient quality of basil Amanullah, A.S.M. & Ahsanullah, A.S.M.
(Ocimum viride) leaves Cultivated in (2010). An assessment of physico
physico-chemical
Ghana. International Food Research properties
rties of some tomato genotypes and
Journal 20(4), 1569-1573.
1573. varieties grown at Rangpur. Bangladesh
Research Publication Journal 4(3), 135-
Demirel, D. & Turhan M. (2003). Air drying 243.
behavior
or of Dwarf Cavendish and gros
Michel banana slices. Journal of Food Garangyo, T., Thombiano, T., Werem, A.,
Engineering. 59, 1-11. Drawara, B. & Sawadogo, L. (1992). Etude
de impact du sechagesolare derent sur la
Elegbede J. A. (1998). Legumes. Nutritional teneuren vit C de la tomato. Science Tech.
Quality of Plant Foods. In: Post Harvest 20, 53-61.
Research Unit. Osagie AU, Eka, QU
(Eds). Ibitoye, D. O., Akin-Idowu,
Idowu, P. E. & Ademoyegu,
O. T. (2009). Agronomic and Lycopene
Emperatriz, P. D., Ronald, M., Elevina, P. & Evaluation in Tomato (Lycopersicon
Mily S. (2008). Production and lycopersicum
rsicum Mill.) As a Function of
characterization of unripe plantain (Musa
( Genotype. World Journal of Agricultural
99
Dutse Journal of Agriculture and Food Security (DUJAFS)
( Vol. 7 No. 1, June. 2020
Ahmad, A., Gungula, D.T., Tame V.T., Kapsiya J. and Kirawa, D. M. A. 944-100
100