Wail of A Valley
Wail of A Valley
Wail of A Valley
C o n te n ts
page
Contents......................................................................................................................................v
1 About the Book................................................................................................................1-2
2 About the Author .............................................................................................................2-3
3 Preface .............................................................................................................................3-4
4 Foreword..........................................................................................................................4-6
5 PART I - LAYING THE SCENE.....................................................................................5-9
6 Chapter 1 - SAYYID SHARAFU'D-DIN .......................................................................6-10
7 Chapter 2 - MIR ALI HAMADANI'S ROLE AS A PROSELYTISER ...........................7-11
7.1 Twenty Humiliating Conditions – Charter of Islam in Kashmir...............................7-12
7.2 Temple Demolitions and Mir Ali ............................................................................7-13
7.3 Conversion realised through Force..........................................................................7-14
7.4 Mir Ali as an author................................................................................................7-14
8 Chapter 3 - P.N. BAZAZ and P.N. BAMZAI AS MYTH-MAKERS..............................8-16
9 Chapter 4 - LALLESHWARI - A SHINING SYMBOL OF INDIANNESS ...................9-17
10 Chapter 5 - TRIKA PAVED THE WAY FOR ISLAM - ANOTHER MYTH ...........10-18
11 Chapter 6 - KASHMIR - NOT A TABULA RASA ..................................................11-20
12 Chapter 7 - WILLING AND PEACEFUL CONVERSION - A HALF TRUTH........12-21
13 Chapter 8 - EXTRA-IDEOLOGICAL METHODS...................................................13-22
14 Chapter 9 - COMPROMISE AS TACTICS ..............................................................14-23
15 Chapter 10 - SHIHAB-UD-DIN'S ANTI-HINDU MEASURES ...............................15-24
16 Chapter 11 - 'SUFI-FACE OF ISLAM' THESIS DEBUNKED.................................16-25
17 Chapter 12 - SULTAN SIKANDAR - A CRUEL CRUSADER ...............................17-26
18 Chapter 13 - MIR ALI HAMDANI'S ADVICE TO SULTAN SIKANDAR -...........18-28
19 Chapter 14 - RETURN OF SANITY ........................................................................19-29
20 Chapter 15 - NA BHATTO AHAM - A CRY IN AGONY .......................................20-30
21 Chapter 16 - CRUSADE RE-LAUNCHED - SHAMS-UD-DIN IRAQI ...................21-31
22 Chapter 17 - NIRMAL KANTH - A PILLAR OF RESISTANCE ............................22-33
23 Chapter 18 - INTER-FACE BETWEEN HINDUISM AND ISLAM - A
MISCONCEPTION .............................................................................................................23-35
24 Chapter 19 - REGENERATION OF KASHMIR UNDER THE SULTANS - A MERE
FABRICATION ..................................................................................................................24-37
25 Chapter 20 - MUGHAL ANNEXATION AT THE BEHEST OF MUSLIMS...........25-38
26 Chapter 21 - LEARNING NOT ENOUGH, WIELD A WEAPON-KRIPA RAM DUTTA
26-40
27 Chapter 22 - MUSLIMS INVITE AFGHANS ..........................................................27-41
27.1 Asad Khan - A Savage..........................................................................................27-42
27.2 Hazar Khan - A Fiend...........................................................................................27-42
27.3 Atta Mohammad Khan - A Psychopath.................................................................27-42
27.4 Haji Karim Dad Khan - A Looter..........................................................................27-42
28 Chapter 23 - BIRBAL DHAR AND SIKHS .............................................................28-43
29 Chapter 24 – LOOT OF 1931 ...................................................................................29-45
29.1 Qadeer - the Waiter ..............................................................................................29-47
29.2 M.J. Akbar on Qadeer...........................................................................................29-48
1 A b o u t the B o o k
Kashmir: Wail of a Valley is the heart rending tale of the people, popularly known as Kashmiri Pandits,
the natives of Kashmir who by brutal force were reduced to a minority during a few centuries of Muslim
rule.
Despite their immense contributions to all segments of human learning, they were persecuted, and
discrimination continued even in post-independence era. The Islamisation of the entire Kashmir polity
brought about by thousands of Madarsas cut at the very roots of Kashmiri ethos of liberalism and
humanism. The alien gun-culture transformed the paradise into a veritable hell on the earth. Thousands
were killed, butchered and tortured. Three lacks of them are in exile and Diaspora.
All this has been exposed in Kashmir: Wail of a Valley. It is the result of the hard labour of Prof. Mohan
Lal Koul who has presented the gruesome tragedy of a minority with irrefutable evidence.
This is the second book of the author, first being Kashmir Past and Present: Unravelling the
Mystique, which is now a reference book.
2 A b o u t the A u tho r
3 P r e fa c e
Kashmir known world over as "a garden of eternal beauty" is now a veritable hell-hole of violence,
intimidation and terrorism. The cult of the gun introduced by the Muslim fundamentalists of indigenous
vintage churned out from the madrasas and Quarnic schools has devastated the total fabric of Kashmir
that had tolerance, cathelocity of outlook and humanism as its dominant weaves.
True to their cult, the fanatic Islamists fed on the fare of destruction, and bigotry wrought havoc not only
on temples of learning and widely disseminated infrastructural base for human resource development but
also targetted the talented and peace-loving Kashmiri Pandits as a specific ethno-religious group for their
externment and subsequent Diaspora. Through their noxious and vile propaganda the Islamists rallied the
Muslim majority for a religious war on the minority religious group which was charged with betrayal and
called upon to justify itself.
While perpetrating murders on this religious minority the Muslim murderers have forged alibis and set
themselves up as tin-pot judges. A farrago of canards, half-truths, accusations and distortions was
concocted and set afloat against the miniscule minority with the sheer objective of effacing out the acts of
foul murder. Crimes of barbrism and vandalism as the intrumentalities of genocide were committed on the
members of the target group with a reckless abandon. The crimes were meticulously devised,
programmed and executed in cold blood with the objective of scuttling their defences and finishing them
off after bludgeoning and wounding them. The number of those who were mercilessly butchered loses
significnce but what assumes vital importance is the prior act of selection. The members of the religious
group harbouring a non-Islamic faith were singled out from those who are to be preserved, thus
eliminating a dissent, a difference with the sole motive of ensuring and preserving a homogenous unity.
The annihilation of the Kashmiri Pandit community has been a camouflaged operation conducted by the
Islamists convinced of the murderous crimes as the final condition for the emergence of a holy theocratic
state for the ghettoised Muslims.
The Kashmiri Pandits are the Tutsis of Rwanda and Jews of Germany. They are in absolute ruins and
ashes. Wherever they be, they are a horrendous prospect of pa-thetic people who are destructed not by
plagues but by bigotry and intolerance. The storms of (manipulative have been ignored as non-events
which did not happen because they do not suit) history. When massacred in groups, they have been
cremated and in some cases buried in all dishonour and ignominy. Their habitations that they had
assiduously built up are all in charred remnants. The places of their worship and cultural symbols
specifying their faith and spiritual yearnings are in shambles. As victims to cruel forces of pan-Islamism,
they are bereft of their territory, their material possessions, their roots and their identity as a distinct
historical and cultural group with a background setting of a gargantuan culture and civilisation. A well-
defined and co-ordinated aggression was launched against every characteristic of the indigenous group to
destroy it and impose on the last outpost of the community in the natural abode the pattern of the
oppressor.
As people externed from their natural abode, and milieu, the Kashmiri Pandits have been dumped as
refuse in camps and one-room tenements with the pre-thought intent of breaking their resistance and
facilitating their wholesale destruction investing it with the veneer of natural death. De-recognising their
identities as purposeful and creative individuals, they have been lumped together under a doomed and
dubious label of "migrants" which rubs salt into their bleeding wounds. The callous rulers and their
buddies without a goulp of shame are at pains to dish out theories to legitimise their expulsion and
diaspora with a view to managing the effect of genocide.
And now a word of indebtedness. I feel highly indebted to my colleagues and friends inside academe who
have appreciated my efforts to delineate and highlight the genocide of my small community which has
been forced to live an ugly life in squalid camps and rented slums.
I am extremely thankful to P.N. Kachru, Onkar Kachru, D.N.Dhar, B.L.Handoo, Prof. M.L.Raina,
S.K.Koul, Shyam Koul, Pitambar Singh Bali and C.L. Chrangoo for their assitance and precious
suggestions to put the genocide of a distinct ethno-religious community in proper perspective and focus.
I must express my sincere thanks to the bunch of dedicated workers of the Vir Bhawan, Raghunath Pora,
Jammu who provided me photographs and biographical sketches of the Kashmiri Pandits who have been
tortured and mercilessly killed and butchered. I have to offer special thanks to H.N. Revoo, my school
friend and play mate, who has culled lots of material relevant to the devastation that the minority
community of Kashmiri Pandits has suffered for its patriotism and positive thought.
My thanks are also due for Ramesh Haku who not only went through the whole mansuscript but also
prepared a computerised version of it.
I also thank my wife Mrs Mohini Koul who has been prodding me to write about the community that is in
ruins and while fleeing from the terror created by the Muslim terrorists she did not care two hoots for the
materials stuffed in our home but brought all my notes and jottings that I had made about the developing
situation. Those notes and jottings were profusely used in my first book, Kashmir: Past and Present -
Unravelling the Mystique, which was published in 1996, by Sehyog Prakashan, a Delhi based
coperative venture in publishing.
Last but not the least I must convey my sincere thanks to the Managing Director, the Gyan Sagar
Publications, Dariya Ganj, New Delhi for publishing the book.
20.3.1998
Mohan Lal Koul
Rented slum, a migrant
Jammu.
4 Fo re w o rd
by Dr. K. L. Chowdhary
(Professor of Medicine, Government Medical College, Srinagar and Political Director of the Apex
Committee of the Kashmiri Pandit Organisations)
There is a plethora of newspaper and pamphlet print about the travails faced by Kashmiri Pandits during
the acme of the ongoing militancy in Kashmir and subsequent to their mass exodus in 1989-90 but only a
couple of organised attempts to put it down in a book format. A lot of disinformation and canard spinning
on the genesis of the exodus has been whipped up by the very people who engineered it, reinforced in no
small measure by the militant and secessionist-friendly press and the prevarication and pussilanimity of
the state administration and the central government. Many distortions and misrepresentations are still rife
as to the causes of the uprising in Kashmir which led to the taking up of sophisticated and lethal weapons
of destruction by what were perceived to be docile and peace loving Muslims of the Kashmir about whom
it was believed that their worst indulgence in violence was to hurl the Kangris (fire-pot) on the adversary
or use one's head to band that of the opponent m the manner of fighting rams locking horns. Even more
flagrant defacement of truth is to paint the Kashmiri Pandit as the schemer, the snatcher and the tyrant
even while this community with an ample fund of historical and cultural contribution with 5000-year
habitation in the valley has been forced repeatedly to abandon its homeland in the face of brutal Violence
and religious persecution for the past six hundred years.
It is a historical truth that only eleven families of Pandits survived in the valley after the first major
exodus but that was during the despotic rule of Sultan Sikander, the iconoclast, who was driven by
extreme religious frenzy to convert, kill or drive away the Hindus. The fact that nearly ninety-nine per
cent of the Pandits have now been again driven into exile and remaining remnants are living a life of
mental and physical siege is a colossal tragedy and a living shame on humanity because we are talking of
the last decade of the 20th century, of secular, democratic Republic of India, of Naya Kashmir conceived
on the principles and ideals of equality and liberty and fed on the principles of religious harmony. The
present exodus assumes gargantuan proportions because the largest democracy in the world could not
rescue a small Hindu minority of Kashmir from ethnic cleansing, genocide and exodus. The greater
tragedy of the nation is that we don't find many academicians, historians, votaries of freedom and
champions of human rights losing sleep either trying to analyst the causes or grasping the portents of the
tragic developments in Kashmir. That Kashmir has turned into alchemist's laboratory for transmuting
peace-loving youth into gun-wielding militants cannot be denied. That it can be-come a role-model for
fundamentalist and religious bigots for ethnic cleansing of minorities in other regions of the sub-continent
is a warning which we can ill-afford to ignore. That the demon of terrorism and secession if not crushed
and defeated will threaten the very survival of India as a multi-religious, multi-lingual and multi-ethnic
republic is a bitter truth that Indians will have to grapple with in all seriousness.
A studio of tragic history of the Kashmiri Pandits could be one approach in trying to understand some
facts of the Kashmir problem. Towards this Mohan Lal Kaul's book "Kashmir - Wail of the Valley" is a
bold and sincere attempt which traces the turbulence right from the times Islam opened its history in
Kashmir. The author is well rooted in history and like all of us has gone through the harrowing
experiences of being at the receiving end of a craftily conceived and carefully orchestrated creed of
Muslim hegemony thriving on the elimination, deprivation and subjugation of Hindus in the valley of
Kashmir leading not only to the invisible exodus from the year 1947 onwards but also to spurts of
violence, loot and plunder (like Wanpuh and Luka Bawan in 1986) culminating in ethnic cleansing and
mass exodus of 1989-90. A single-minded pursuit in unravelling the contours of a Pan-Islamic crusade
with its epi-centre in Pakistan and its clinical laboratory in Kashmir. In the process he exposes the
fabrication of lies and canards let loose by Islamic zealots and pulls the veil off secularism from the
visages of some terrorist organizations and their apologists, many of whom masquerade as Human Rights
champions. He ridicules the fast growing clan of pseudo-secularists in India and compulsive Hindu
baiters who denigrate their own religion and distort their own glorious history with all impunity. He does
not spare the state administration for conniving with the insurgents nor does he spare the central
government for concealing and deriding the forced exodus and down-playing the atrocities perpetrated on
the Pandits.
In essence the book of Mr. M.L. Koul is a litany of human rights violations against Pandits and the
running theme is that of loot, plunder and persecution. He prepares the ground from the days of Bulbul
Shah and Mir Ali Hamadani, the ace proselytizer, to the tyrannical rule of Sultan Sikander, Chaks,
Mughals, Afghans et al right into the reign of Dogras when the Muslims after a brief interlude in history
reorganised themselves against Hindus dur-ing the hey-day of freedom movement in the Indian Sub-
continent and organised their wrath against them in the loot of 1931. He moves on in the laying process,
as he calls it, to the loot of landed properties by the popular government of Sheikh Abdullah (1947) to the
loot of a Pandit girl (1967) and the dress rehearsal of ethnic cleansing in the loot and plunder of 1986. The
narrative enters the phase of armed terrorism with intimate details of the massacre of Pandits, their
exodus, the loot, the arson and the forcible occupation and annexation of their left-over properties and the
desecration and destruction of their religious and cultural signs and symbols.
There is a brief mention of two twilight periods during the rule of Zaina-ul-Abidin and the Dogras in the
otherwise dark history of Pandits since the advent of Islam in Kashmir. Mr. Koul debunks the myth of
voluntary conver-sions perpetrated by some historians of his own community. He also has a dig at those
who extol the Sufi tradition and claims that it was mainly patterned for proselytization. While we are not
aware of forcible conversions in post-independence era in the valley, we cannot discount the subtle moral,
psychological and socio-economic pressures on the Pandits generated by the ruthless campaign of hatred
and discrimination in all State-owned and private institutions and loudly proclaimed and propagated from
the psychology of siege under which a Pandit took birth and grew up but also for some of what looked
like voluntary conversions. While I believe all Sufis were not proselytizers, we have the striking example
of the sage of Charar-i-Sharief, Nund Rishi. We cannot but agree that the forces of fanaticism and
fundamentalism did have a great sway in Kashmir all through the last five decades and always found easy
victims in Pandits. We all have faced genie of Muslim bigotry let loose from the corked bottle at one time
or the other and I still remember with horror the hail of stones on my car from a rampaging mob of the
fateful evening when Zia-ul-Haq met his nemesis in an air-crash back home in Pakistan, as if I was
responsible for the accident. All sanity, was thrown to the winds during real or imagined provocation to
the Muslim sentiments and the non-Muslims found themselves the butt of their ire in vio-lent
demonstration against alleged blasphemy in a book titled, "The Book of Knowledge". A foreign tourist
once found himself inadvertently in the eye of the storm of shouting hooligans who forced him to join
their slogan "Ban Book of Knowledge". In absolute frustration he shouted, "Ban All Knowledge".
Mr. Mohan Lal Koul deftly unwinds the conspiracy re-plete with details and backed up by references to
push the Pandits to the wall and throttle his efforts for an honourable survival wherein the ruling elite, the
political, the bureaucracy, the judiciary and the religious institutions made a concerted effort where "all
the norms were violated and normlessness was stuck to as a norm". This happened right since the popular
government induced and implemented the so-called land reforms followed up with the weaning away of
Pandits from important positions in administrative governance, denying them educational op-portunities
and discriminating them in recruitment and promotions. The loot continues even today through a
perfidious scheme to buy off the left-over properties of the harried, harassed and left-over Pandits.
The theory of proxy war by Pakistan as the primary event is again being questioned and it is argued that
the seeds of violence and hatred were sown right from 1931 and nursed in madrasas, maktahas and
mosques from where it mushroomed into other religious and secular institutions of the land. Pakistan was
also waiting in the wings for its chance to throw in support, material, moral and physical. It is a different
matter, an aberration to which all violent uprisings are condemned, that like the Frankenstein monster
they consume the very architects of violence. That is how the "The tidal wave of Jehad and religious
bigotry unleashed by the JKLF flowed at the cesspool of rape, murder, loot and plunder," and after
finishing the task of banishing Pandits into exile it barged into moderate Muslim sections of the valley for
whom yesterday's "Mujahids and heroes" became today's tormentors. This phenomenon has received
scant attention from Mr. M. L. Koul, as also the phenomenon of militants turned informers, turned pro-
India and anti-militant militants or 'renegade militants'. The process of recruiting these 'reformed'
militants into the security forces and getting them elected to the State Legislature is a unique experiment
the usefulness of which are hard to fathom as yet.
I bow to you my country
that a militant who took up arms against you
and gunned down innocent citizens
looted, arsoned, raped
is today taking the salute
for the Republic Day parade
while his victims
shiver in refugee camps.
Apart from putting the facts in their proper perspective which yet might seem as an eye-opener to a
common man as well as the conscientious intellectual in India. This book is bound to kindle the "race
memory" of persecution of the Kashmiri Pandits which may to a large extent shape the strategy to re-
claim their ancestral "Home Land" which they have lost.
5 P A R T I - L A Y IN G T H E S C E N E
Kashmiri Pandits, a euphemism for Kashmiri Hindus, have a harrowing and bone-chilling history of gore
and blood, torture and religious persecution, molestation and disquiet. Tragically, much like the harassed
and bloodied Jews, they have been harried, despoilt and laid waste and as victims to vile oppression and
abominable persecution, they have been fleeing every now and then from their home-land, splendorous
and sublime in beauty and natural endowments, where they through ages have built a massive edifice of
culture and civilisation with few comparable parallels, to sanctuaries outside the purlieux of Kashmir to
save their skin and faith from the hurricane of Muslim zealotry and fanaticism. In fact, as evidenced by
historical tomes and records, their unmitigated and unabated saga of trials and tribulations, woes and
miseries, death and destruction dates back to dark and dismal times when some proselytisers donning the
garb of sufis actually fleeing from the persecution of their native Muslim rulers found refuge and
patronage in the region of Kashmir, which was dubiously usurped by some rugged tribals (of foreign
vintage) converted to Islam.
Orthodox Islam with the characteristic ingredients of a Semitic religion was ruthlessly introduced in and
foisted upon Kashmir, which was proverbially known world over as the bastion of Hindu sciences,
religion, philosophy and aesthetics. Rinchin, a pagan from Ladakh, was converted to Islam and Qutub-ud-
Din, a Muslim ruler, was coerced into submission by prescriptions, fatwas and commands to rid him of
un-Islamic and heretical practices, customs and manners and Islamised thus contributed his mite to the
transformation campaign against the Hindu dress, culture and language as was unleashed by Mir Ali
Hamadani.
6 C ha pte r 1 - S A Y Y ID S H A R A F U ' D - D IN
As is well-known, Sayyid Sharafu'd-Din, popularly known as Bulbul Shah, said to be a Suhrawardi sufi,
entered Kashmir during the reign of Suhadev, who granted him full scale freedom to preach and
propagate his religious faith and credo. Fed on the fare of broad-mindedness, tolerance and generosity, the
Hindu ruler did not think of subjecting him to 'humiliating conditions', which could have inhibited and
crippled his movements and religious activities. But, essentially, a proselytiser of Turkish brand, he
converted Rinchin, a fugitive tribal prince from Ladakh, to Islam when Dev-Swami, a Shaivite scholar,
refused him entry into the fold of Hinduism and through him rose from obscurity to lime-light and saw
fruition of his mission for speedy and vigorous propagation of Islam and its precept. Rinchin as the first
Muslim ruler generated religious strife and turbulence in the region of Kashmir & resorted to conversions
by coercion and by sword. Rinchin not only granted the revenues of certain villages to Bulbul Shah for
his maintenance, but also built a Khanqah for him near his palace. He built the first mosque in Kashmir.
"Bulbul Shah, a Muslim proselytiser under persecution in his native land saw the fruition of his plans
while admitting Rinchin to the Islamic fold. Toeing the line of suns of all hues, he managed entry into and
proximity to the court of a Muslim ruler, who would be instrumental in launching upon the persecutionary
campaign against the die-hard Hindus, who, despite the preaching of his Islamic tenets, could not be
attracted to Islam. At the behest of Bulbul Shah, Rinchin as the first Muslim ruler of Hindu Kashmir
launched upon the vigorous campaign of converting the Hindus of Kashmir", writes Koul.
Records Bamzai, "Suffice it to say that with this first success of his mission, Bulbul Shah acquired great
influence in the valley and very soon he effected the conversion of Rinchin's brother-in-law and
Commander-in-Chief and several others to his creed."
7 C ha pte r 2 - M IR A L I H A M A D A N I' S R O L E A S A P R O S E L Y T IS E R
A major role for paving the way for launching upon a state-based campaign for proselytisation of the
Hindu Kashmir was played by a notable Sayyid, Mir Ali, said to be a Kubravi Sufi, who was a fugitive
from Hamadan where Timur enraged by his indulgence in political affairs had swayed his power against
the Alawi Sayyids. He cooled his heels in Kashmir, which had come under the rule and hegemony of
Muslims. As testified to and buttressed by his extant works, he in essentia can be characterised as a
formidable proselytiser and a fundamentalist theologian with a deep streak of interest in affairs mundane.
Capitalising on his position of authority and influence as a Sayyid, he issued fiats to the Muslim ruler,
Qutub-ud-Din, to Islamise his state by placing it on the foot-stool of Sharia (Islamic law) and also impose
'twenty humiliating conditions' on the Hindu Kafirs with the express intent of coercing them to get
converted to Islam at pain of death. Politically, socially and religiously coercive and awesome, the fiat (in
the form of an advice) was an unholy combine of gag-order and lynch-law meant for prompt compliance
and implementation by the Muslim ruler, whose temporary dithering and equivocation occasioned by
dynastic considerations and ground realities was seriously resented and vigorously opposed by the
Sayyid, who having sown the seeds of contradictions, religious fanaticism and polarisation for a social
and political rupture quit the scene in absolute anger and despair too.
Records Baharistan-i-Shahi, "Sultan Qutub-ud-Din failed to propagate Islam in accordance with the
wishes and aspirations of Amir Sayyid Ali Hamadani and as such the latter found himself reluctant to stay
on in Kashmir."
It was on the persistent proddings of Sayyid Ali that the Sultan gave up his participation in Hindu
festivals, fairs and ceremonies and forced the Muslims to adopt the same dress that was prevalent and in
vogue in Muslim countries with a view to establishing their separate identity from the Hindus, but linking
it up with the Muslim 'umma'. The ruler was exhorted to divorce one of the two uterine sisters whom he
had married as it was deemed un-Islamic in law and practice.
Over-awed by the Sayyid, the Muslim ruler, Qutub-ud-Din, oriented and regimented into the regime of
his religious duties gave in and succumbed to the baptisation in matters of dress codes and fundamentals
of Islamic law, but somehow pulled his punches from sponsoring an aggressive conversion campaign,
which, he felt, might jeopardise his position and stature as the ruler of a Hindu dominated region. As he
was not in haste, his clever strategy was to mark time till the thorough entrenchment of the Muslim rule.
But as against him, Sayyid Ali was in post-haste and was for strident and quick measures to dent the
bulwark of Hindu culture and civilisation and also harboured a lurking fear that the Hindus, though
politically subjugated, might re-group and fortify their ranks to overthrow the Muslim rule, thus defeating
his plans for converting Kashmir, a Hindu citadel, for which the Prophet as claimed by him had ordered
him to visit Kashmir.
Sultan Qutub-ud-Din, to Sayyid Ali, appeared tolerant and liberal unto the Hindus who as a measure of
expediency were permitted to be the government functionaries and being Kafirs were neither hounded out
nor persecuted and as such had failed to draw a leaf from his religiopolitical culture to divide his subjects
into the strait-jacket of Muslims and Kafirs granting them the rights and privileges that flowed from the
religions they espoused. Incensed at this, Sayyid Ali's relations with the Muslim ruler suffered a dip and
were bitter and rancorous and as a matter of result an internecine 'conflict arose between them because of
their differing attitudes about the Hindus'. As a strong believer in Kufra, he viewed political conquest as a
sure means of propagation of religion and its support-base.
As explicated in his two principal works, Risala-i-Maktubat and Zakhiratul-Muluk, Sayyid Ali's political
thought, an anathema to a sufi of real and genuine vintage, appears to cloud his sufi credentials and poses
and projects him as a political crusader, who is not only conscious of, but frantically eager to enlist and
harness the support of government apparatus to boost and push up the interests of Islam, its precept and
precedent. Force and authority as two coercive weapons of the state as he firmly held were not to be
spared in the enforcement of religious lawns His immediate and persistent efforts to mobilise the Muslim
ruler and the instrumentalities of his government for aggressive and forceful propagation of Islam and
annihilation of those outside the orbit of Islam, Kafirs in usual Muslim parlance, are sufficient pointers to
establish that he was more wedded to the narrow interests of Muslimisation campaign than the domain of
Sufism, which, to a lay Indian mind, connotes if it can a broad plexus of values and concerns of
humanism transcending myopic religious and political perceptions.
In sharp contrast to the Kashmiri mystics and quietists, ever in spiritual quest, the authorities on sufi
trends of thought have observed that the Kubravi subs much in the line of subs of various silsilas (orders)
were sappers and miners of Islamic crusade and surprisingly enough, were politics-oriented and more
than most avidly keen to find a niche in the courts of Sultans and nobles and enjoy positions of power and
panoply.
Comments Rafiqi, "Besides occupying positions such as that of Qazi and Shaik'ul Islam, some of them
(Sufis) held high positions in administration, including that of wazir and they also served as ambassadors.
They visited the royal courts, established matrimonial alliances with leading nobles and ruling houses.
They dabbled in politics and on many occasions were exiled from the country."
7.1 Twenty Humiliating Conditions – Charter of Islam in Kashmir
Mir Ali's Zakhiratul-Muluk containing twenty humiliating conditions couched in unpolished and
unsophisticated language is a testament of intolerance, hatred, distrust and hate-campaign against the
Hindus of Kashmir. The fiat in the form of an advice reads as under:
1. The Hindus will not construct any new places of worship or idol temples in the territory under the
control of a Muslim ruler.
2. They will not re-construct any existing place of worship or temple that may fall into ruin.
3. They will not prevent Muslim travellers from staying in their places of worship or temples.
4. They will receive any Muslim traveller into their houses and will provide him with hospitality for three
days.
5. They will not harbour any spies and will not act as spies themselves.
6. If any of their relations show any inclination to embrace Islam, they shall not prevent him from doing
so.
7. They will respect Muslims.
8. If they are holding a meeting and a Muslim happens to come there, he will be received respectfully by
them.
9. They will not dress like Muslims.
10. They will not adopt Muslim names.
11. They will not ride a saddled horse.
12. They will not carry swords or bows and arrows.
13. They will not wear rings with diamonds.
14. They will not openly sell or drink intoxicating liquor.
15. They will not abandon their traditional dress so that they may be distinguished from Muslims.
16. They will not openly practice their customs and usages among Muslims.
17. They will not build their houses in the neighbourhood of Muslims.
18. They will not cremate their dead.
19. They will not mourn their dead loudly.
20. They will not buy Muslim slaves.
The advice concludes with the note that if they (Hindus) infringe any of the twenty conditions, they are
not to be protected and Muslims may rightfully kill them and appropriate their property as if they were
Kafirs (idolaters i.e; Hindus) at war.
Observes Rafiqi, "In his Zakhiratul-Muluk (Pp 117-18), Saiyid Ali advises a Muslim ruler to impose
twenty humiliating conditions on his non-Muslim subjects and in return the non-Muslims are guaranteed
nothing 107-9".
He further states, "Saiyid Ali reserves every benefit of the state for the Muslims. Unlike al-Mawardi, he
does not explicitly mention any rights which non-Muslims could expect in return for obeying the above
twenty rules.
"Mir Ali Hamadani's Zakhiratul-Muluk set a new agenda for the persecution and massacre of the
Kashmirian Hindus if they did not succumb to the blind forces of Islam. The book in its contents is highly
subversive and set the ground for unleashing an orgy of violence, commotion, disorder and anarchy aimed
at corroding and dismantling a social and religious ethos, which had a humanistic base and was high
above religious bigotry and myopia," writes Koul.
The charter of conditions is shocking and stunning and ironically enough framed and conceived by a sufi,
whose role in Kashmir on religious grounds has been trumpeted beyond credible limits. As a prelude to
the policy of death and destruction against the native Hindus, it, in fact, contained seed ideas of Muslim
vintage for re-modelling of the Kashrniri society by forcibly transmuting its religious complexion and
colour by unjust and unkind means, thus causing a yawning hiatus by tearing it away from its historical
and socio-cultural moares. The fiats calling for blatant and naked interference by any incognito Muslim
traveller (with its extended import to cover all Muslims) legitimised to sponge on Hindu Kafirs and their
religious places for goods and services strangely in the name of hospitality were not only coercive and
persecutionary, but also reflective of a mind that could be anything but not sufistic in frame and
motivations. Despite pretensions of Justice, brotherhood and equality, the charter was manifesting a
psyche, narrow, intolerant and more than most highly coercive, and was issued out not as a matter of
theoretical assumption, but for practical application and if and when applied, it would flagrantly violate
and transgress all decent and civilised principles and modes of a cohesive and harmonious civil life and
prognosticate a political, religious and societal structure etched upon pillars of coercion, persecution and
inequity.
Brimming with the force and fury of a command, the catalogue of woeful conditions supposed to invoke
an instantaneous obedience of a Muslim ruler, if true to his religious grain, was designed to project the
Hindus as the 'other,' to finish them politically, socially and religiously, shorn of rights and privileges as
they were the exclusive preserve of Muslims in a Muslim state. If reacting to his captive state, any Hindu
spartacus flouting any of the medieval conditions, cruel and base, in protest or desperation was flared to
be massacred and his property looted and appropriated (for distribution as booty among the faithfuls).
First subjugated and humbled and then stigmatised as Dhimmis, the Hindu Kafirs if granted the status as
it was meant for Jews and Christians only (ahli-Kitab) would be reduced to the miserable state of the
denizens of a gulag and could be given a semblance of protection, though perpetually vulnerable, only
after they paid the hated Jazia (poll-tax) to the Muslim ruler.
7.2 Temple Demolitions and Mir Ali
Temple-breaking as the sordid practice and standard police of Muslims was given a new pace and
direction when the famous temple of Kalishree in the city of Srinagar was desecrated and demolished
with absolute vengeance and a mosque constructed at the site on its plinth. The operations against the
temple as a precious relic of Kashmiri culture were led by none other than Mir Ali himself. The holy
spring inside the temple littered over with the images and idols of gods and goddesses (still intact) was
covered with logs and planks, thus hidden from public view, forbidding the people to drink its sparkling
waters believed to be efficacious in curing diseases. Even though the temple was dismantled and grabbed,
the Kashmiri Hindus never abandoned their claims to and the practice of worshipping the temple from the
river side. The mosque as the inaugural of Muslim oppression in Kashmir has been a bone of discord
between the Hindus and the Muslims generating many a religious strife. In the Sikh times, Phula Singh
trained his guns on the mosque, which escaped demolition and destruction at the intervention of a Hindus
"Mir Ali Hamadani was the author of the iconoclastic chapter of Kashmir history." writes Parimoo.
Records Rafiqi, "It is said that when Saiyid Ali converted the Chief Brahman of Kali-Mandar at Srinagar
to Islam and turned the temple into a mosque, he ordered Saiyid Kabir to settle down there and preach the
truths of Islam to people."
Puts Baharistan-i-Shahi," That some of the time which the holy Amir spent in Kashmir, he lived in a Sarai
at Alaudipora. At the site where his Khanqah was built, there existed a temple which was demolished and
converted into an estrade on which he offered Namaz five times a day."
7.3 Conversion realised through Force
Mir Ali steeped in his religio-political culture and persuasion could not continue with and stick to the
peaceful propagation of Islam in Kashmir as his successes by way of luring converts to Islam were not
significant and encouraging. After a bitter feud with the Muslim ruler, he left Kashmir in absolute anger
and appointed Sayyid Kabir at the mosque to preach and propagate the canons of Islam to the people, but
in sheer despair, he shifted to another quarter in Srinagar for he was just ignored as a non-entity and
people evinced no interest in his preachings and sermons, if at all he were delivering any. There was not a
single neo-convert, who had the expertise of calling the faithfuls to prayers. Conversion to an alien
religion was considered atrocious. Any convert to Islam was ostracised and held in extreme hate and
contempt. Fearing public wrath, a neo-convert had clandestinely fled to Samarqand for refuge and
succour. Such was the initial response to the missionary and proselytising activities in Kashmir. It is
amazing to learn that Mir Ali in his subsequent visits converted 37000 Hindus to Islam though he had no
direct rapport with the people except through the externalities of the religion he harboured.
What was the magic formula that worked in Kashmir, which had a continuous and coherent history of
culture and civilization? Historians discounting and debunking 'the sufiface of Islam' thesis as a sheer
myth have found the answer in cruel, ruthless and indiscriminate use of force, coercion and persecution
launched against the Hindus by the proselytizers in tandem with the brutal state power.
7.4 Mir Ali as an author
No doubt, a prolific writer, narcissustically in love with his learning and scholarship, Mir Ali thirstily
craved for a plume of feathers and immense recognition (normally shunned by a Kashmiri mystic), if not
from the heretical world, at least from the Muslim world, for his achievements in the domains of learning
and spirituality. But, the tact that he was not accorded recognition almost dismayed him in his
commitments and spirits and as an act of self-satisfaction and rationalization he nursed a fond hope that a
century after his demise the coming generations would recognise him as a man of scholarship and
spiritual attainments. That the Muslim world failed to accord him recognition is both curious and
intriguing, but very significant.
Comments Rafiqi, "Devoid of originality as they were, his works did not receive the widespread
recognition which those of sufi scholars such as Qushairi, Ghazali, Shaikh Shihab-ud-Din Suhrawardi and
Ibn'-Arabi obtained."
Such a telling comment on Mir Ali's works which are mostly tautological and said to be inferior to the
doctrine that they claim to demonstrate knocks the bottom out of P.N.K. Bamzai's eulogy woven around
his works, thus breaking a new ground for an objective assessment of his role-profile in Kashmir.
With Rafiqi's comment as a valuational Judgment, it is perhaps fair and not unreasonable to stipulate that
Mir Ali's challenge and thrust in Kashmir could not be based on his tremendous levels of scholarship nor
on his extraordinary attainments in the supra-sensible realms. Kashmir per se as a formidable seat of
learning and spirituality could not have only met his challenge, if he had posed any, but also blunted his
edge and reduced him to redundance had he resorted to the much respectable and scholarly technique of
discussions and discourses for an interface of ideas with a view to settling the religio-philosophical
disputations and controversies. Kashmir in the past had the rare destination of having discomfited and
convinced Adi Shankaracharya, a philosopher of extra-ordinary faculties, apropos his positions on
immensely delicate issues of Advaitism and Shaiva positions on the same and as a result of such an inter-
action sharp changes wrought in his postulations got reflected in his 'Saundaryalahiri', a major work of
vital importance. But, discussions and discourses, historically speaking, are foreign to Muslims who not
only dishonour but crush dissent. While converting the Brahmin-priest of Kali-temple to Islam, MirAli
keeping himself out of the ring is said to have prompted and incited his disciple, who in turn resorted to
the much-spurned miracle method and sophistry, not the technique of discussions and discourses
convincing the adversary of his superior religio-philosophical positions and discursive faculties.
There is much of veracity in the statement that most of the Sayyids who poured into Kashmir were not
devout and genuine sufis as they seemed to be this worldly, and curiously took part in politics, which is
an unspiritual activity repugnant to a love-affair with God, instigated and indulged in forcible
conversions, manipulated and wormed their way to the seats of power, did not spurn comforts and
resorted to and set the precedents of ruthless demolition of temples. Some of them were morbidly anti-
Shia and raked religious strifes and turbulence of unprecedented scale and dimension. Following their
foot-prints, a stiff of local variety with doubtful bonafides had political advisers, who established contacts
with an emperor to dismantle the shia-led government.
The set of goals and issues they projected and transformed into the hub of their activities were
xenophobia, racist, misanthropic and sadistic absolutely alien to and leagues away from the powerful
heritage of Kashmir in terms of cultural and civilisational depth of values of tolerance and acceptance and
absorption of extreme religious dissent. The ills they sought to fight were imaginary and the cures mainly
in the form of conversions were crippling and destructive. A well orchestrated way of life, a tolerant and
vibrant faith and Hell articulated vision of man, world and God became the targets of their proselytising
zeal resulting in the decline of a metaphysics-epistemology -ethics continuum sought to be replaced by
stray and unrelated constructs to suit a pre-determined and ossified idea, in the death of a creative artist
sculpting amazing images of gods and goddesses of Hindu and Buddhist pantheon given the option of
carving out grave-stones, un-Islamic, soul-less and monotonous, in the abandoning of chanting of mantras
replete with mystical and esoteric content substituted by dull arid meaningless repetition of mere names,
in the flight of painters, not reconciling to the dubbing of creative activity as un-Islamic and heretical and
refusing to cognise non-figurative dull designs of borrowed variety as real art, in the decay of an ethos,
vibrant, assimilative and self-regenerative filling the vaccum by intolerance, dissensions and religious
strifes and in the loss of a mother-language, mature and perfect to the core, serving as a vehicle of
creativity and philosophical musings and disquisitions replaced by a language nuancing an alien ethos.
In the words of Coomaraswamy, "Conversion destroys and if it does not destroy, it is no conversion."
8 C ha pte r 3 - P . N . B A Z A Z a n d P . N . B A M Z A I A S M Y T H - M A K E R S
Prem Nath Bazaz known for his Royist commitments and pro-Pakistan politics fabricated a myth that
"Lalla held discussions with Shah Hamadan when he came to Kashmir with his followers and learned the
philosophy of Islam from that great spiritual teacher."
P.N. Bamzai committed himself to the same myth when he recorded that "he (Mir Ali) came in contact
with the popular Shaiva teacher Lalleshwari and the great sufi saint Sheikh Noor-ud-din and had long
discussions with them on spiritual and philosophic subjects."
Be it said that Lalla's associations with Mir Ali are based on frills of legend and do not have any historical
veracity and authenticity. Noor-ud-din's associations with Mir Ali as held by Bamzai are equally
fallacious as scholars generally hold that he was born on 10 Zu'l Hijja, 779/9th April,1378 and Mir Ali is
said to have died in 1385 A.D. So, Sheikh was 7-year old, a toddler, when such discussions and debates
are invented to have been held.
The statements, misleading as they are, raise a more important and pertinent question of the language
through which discussions and discourses could have been held between Lalla and Mir Ali. As amply
evidenced and buttressed by her verse-sayings, Lalla was initiated into the Shaiva scriptures and Shaiva
thought by a well-known scholar of Sanskrit, Siddha Sri Kanth, and was, therefore, versed in Sanskrit,
which equipped her with the word - hoard for the expression of her intensely-felt mystical moments even
though the medium for them is the local dialect, which Bilhan has named as 'Desh Bhasha'. But, Mir Ali
proficient in Persian and Arabic could not have established an intimate and direct rapport with the
'mystical lark', who had no discernible achievements, not even a smattering, in the foreign languages,
which had not gained much of circulation and currency at that point of time in Kashmir's history. As
Muslim apologists, both Bazaz and Bamzai, could have created waves in history or made a splash had
they mentioned that Mir Ali conversed in Kashmiri and was versed in Sanskrit and Lalla had mastery
over Persian and Arabic or discourses were conducted with the active aid of interpreters.
Both of them could have learnt from the global history of Islam that wherever it has made its thrust, it was
not through debates, discourses and polemics, but as per historians through sword and cruel use of force.
Debates and discourses as a media for an interface of ideas and thought processes grant a sanctified right
to the adversary to vigorously stick to his position and give it a detailed explication. But, Islam in terms of
history is a closed religion and 'has closed itself on itself'' and therefore does not allow dissent and that
was how Mansur fell a martyr to his concept 'I am God', a position in collision with Islamic belief and
precept. As held by scholars, Islam in its essentials is a proselytising and centralised religion and any
place or province it has set its foot, it has unfolded its roll of history not through thought, but through
proselytisation through force and coercion.
A proselytising religion spurns thought and hence debates and polemics are distrusted as exercises in
futility. That discourses and debates were held between Lalla and Mir Ali Hamadani as invented by them
is actually the sheer projection of their Hindu mind which is open to thought and ideas and lends
acceptance and credence even to the view-point of an adversary.
9 C h a p t e r 4 - L A L L E S H W A R I - A S H I N I N G S Y M B O L O F I N D I A N N E SS
Lalla's pristine personality and philosophical beliefs realised through yogic practices are thoroughly
reflected in her verse-sayings, which, if clinically scanned, do not in the least reflect the Islamic teachings
nor is there any blend of Islam and Shaivism. As correctly appraised by Sir Richard Temple, she was a
Shaiva Yogini neatly grounded in Shaivayoga practices, a self-recognised soul and a spiritualist of depth
and maturity. Scholars keen to find an artificial graft of Islam on Lalla's stem of personal cultivation and
ultimate flowering catch hold of the verse-saying "Idol is of stone and temple is of stone," not knowing
that it is suffused with the Shaivite thought and content, which does not accept adherence to and frankly
rejects any conformity to external forms of ritualistic worship based on duality. Idol worship as held by
Kashmir Shaivism and also by Tantric enunciations might be useful for an initiate under-taking a spiritual
journey for final absorption in the ultimate Reality, but as he goes on ascending step by step from lower
planes of consciousness to higher ones, it is abandoned as of no use and utility.
Motivated by their Semitic back-ground, Grierson and Temple baffled by Lall's profundity of thought and
intensitv of felt experiences were in assiduous search of traces of Islamic influence in her verse-sayings
and went into raptures to find the word 'Jin' which, to them is Arabic in origin and usage. But, to be sure,
the said-word, to their dismay, is sanskritic in origin and semantics denoting one 'who has conquered his
wayword senses' and Lalla has used it for the Buddha, though it is used for Mahavira also.
Temple with his known Semitic persuasions and Kausambi with all his erudition have indicated and held
out a ridiculous thesis that Lalla conceived the idea of 'one God reality' from her associations with
Muslim saints like Mir Ali Hamadani. But, these scholars, to the surprise of all, are and seem to be totally
oblivious of the fact that the Hindus in their congeries of queries and questionings have not only
conceived, but reflected a thorough consciousness of the idea and the same gets expressly revealed
through the Hindu works on religion. Though polytheistic-vedic hymns are permeated with polytheistic
conceptions about the forces of Nature, yet the concept of 'one reality' is not absent or missing, but is
prominently present and palpably existing. In the upanishads, the idea of 'one reality' is the nub of all
enquiry, which culminates in the thought-construct of Brahman as the ultimate ground and support of the
universe.
Lalla is the essence of Indianness, its luminous and indomitable spirit, its holistic world-view, and its
challenge to the forces of hatred and persecution, obliterating its heritage rooted in continuity. Her verse-
sayings, thoughtful, intense and esoteric in import, are 'statements of spiritual experiences, lived and felt,
and guides to that experience.' As the epitome of indigenous ethos, Lalla is all-embracing, coherent and
sweeping, never singing songs of despair and woe, despite a blood soaked catastrophe to which she was
said to be a witness, but persistently defiant of hate-mongers and violence-perpetrators through her
mystical voice, lofty and resonant, proclaiming that 'equality before God was as much a part of Hinduism
as of Islam' and monotheism was not what could have sent her into raptures.
Despite defeat and discomfiture of the native Hindus, Lalla personified their unflinching confidence and
deep sense of pride in their heritage and roots and provided them a distinct and unmistakable identity by
irrigating the fields of Rishi-ethos with its root systems bedrocked in the Vedic Age only to sharpen the
cleavage between a highly tolerant and incredibly eclectic and catholic weltanchauung and a proselytizing
and heresy hunting creed. She honed and fine-tuned her thought, lived and felt, when Muslims were
sharpening their swords. She as a counter crusader held aloft the pennant of humanism at a time when it
was under the process of being cruelly bruised and brutally trampled upon and as a prime mover
generated a new wave of humanism flowing from the perennial fountain of Indianness, ever flowing and
fresh in contents, defying all attempts by full-blown fundamentalist parochials to give it a hiatus and a
break. In sharp defiance of what was alien Lalla thought in her own terms, and mused 'productively, not
reproductively'.
10 C ha pte r 5 - T R IK A P A V E D T H E W A Y F O R IS L A M - A N O T H E R M Y TH
In his attempt to stipulate a philosophical basis for the spread of Islam in Kashmir, P.N.Bazaz toyed with
another idea, astounding and unfounded, that Trika paved the way for Islam in Kashmir. How? He has not
felt kindly to explain it in details. Ajit Battacharjee in his book ' Kashmir - the wounded Valley' has
uncritically and slavishly upheld and adopted the same mish-mash thesis, thus lending legitimacy to the
preposterous thesis of 'peaceful conversion' in the valley of Kashmir.
With no firm grounding in the realms of philosophy in general and Kashmir Shaivism in particular, Bazaz
commits the fallacy of equating monotheism with the Absolute in the Trika, which, to him and Bamzai
too, is the apt nomenclature for Kashmir philosophy of Shaiva non-dualism. It is extremely relevant to
point out that monotheism in essence is a syriac concept common to Judaism, Christianity and Islam and
hence has implicit in it a definite psyche and the syriac-Judaic cultural ring and ambience and contrary to
it, the thought of non-dualism, the same as monism, has full-fledged history in India and naturally in
Kashmir too. To his lay mind, it appears, though an absurdity, that the concept of Absolute propped upon
logically structured thought-constructs led to the acceptance of Islam in Kashmir as 'one God reality' is at
the centre of Islamic religion too. Unaware of finer nuances of philosophica1 structures, he seems to hold
that Param Shiva or Shiva as the absolute in Kashmir non-dualism is the same God as Gods in Judaism
and Islam are. Shiva is an absolute, not a God and an absolute the same way as Shuniya (Void) and
Vignyan (Consciousness) are in the Buddhist philosophies of Madyamika and Shunivanvad and Brahman
in Sankara's philosophy of Advaitism (non-dualism).
Had Bazaz extended the limits of his misconceived and preposterous thesis, he would have no qualms in
formulating that the Indians accepted Islam because of Sankara's philosophy of Advaitism with Brahman
as the coping stone of the whole facade. To him, Brahman, perhaps, is the same God as that of Islam.
Monotheism with its Semitic colour and sociological and ethnic background especially syriac and Judaic
came over to Islamic realms as a borrowed bequest and if introduced in Kashmir by Muslim proselytizers
led by Saiyid Ali Hamadani could not have worked wonders on the thinking plane as it had no halo of
being new, original or innovative and more than most there is hardly any region and area of religion or
abstract thought which the Hindus have not prolifically conceived and dilated upon with depth and
mellowness.
Writes Giri Lal Jain, "There is no human aspiration and experience which lies outside the range of
Hinduism."
Writes Rafiqi, "that the idea had long existed in Hinduism. Even as early as Rig Vedic hymns, we meet
the idea of 'one reality'. This also is the teaching of upanishads, that whatever is, is Brahman, it is the
source and end of all."
Monotheistic religion in sharp contrast to polytheism has its full accent on the idea of one God and
professes and assumes the execution of His work on earth. Man in such a religion is enunciated as being
highly indebted to God for all his material and tangible possessions in the world. As a sequential
corollary, man is required and fiated to repose full faith in God and has to be devoted to him in all
gratefulness. A monotheistic religion with the accretion of prophetism is not lost in mystical realms, but is
rooted in time and history and looks forward to the end of the world when Justice would be dispensed and
meted out. Its interest in the world is not only maximum but supreme as it Is God's gift to man.
Puts Krishna Chaitanya, "Polytheism sees the imprint of God's foot-steps in every manifestation of nature,
in river and forest, in sun and moon. But, it too frequently degenerates into animism. Monotheism may be
a higher concept, but then one God has been too frequently a jealous tribal deity.
Kashmir Shaiva non-dualism having no comparable parallels with Monotheism has an entirely different
root system and soil chemistry. It encompasses and is securely modelled on a world-view, which has no
meeting-ground with and not even a remote semblance to the monotheistic idea. To monotheistic
religions, creation is deistic, but in Kashmir Shaiva Monism, there is no creation, instead there is
perpetual manifestation or emanation and Shiva as the absolute reality is both transcendental and
immanent. To Monotheistic religions, man is not accountable for all what he does, good or bad, on the
earth. He becomes accountable and is subject to judgment only after he goes to the grave.
But, as per the Shaiva non-dual tenets, every individual is responsible for his actions, past and present, in
this world, which is caught up in the layers and meshes of duality and his prime objective in the world is
to recognise himself the same as self realisation, by treading upon the path of piety and spiritualism, of
course, under the inspiring guidance of a worthy preceptor (guru).
Man has to march through time and history, but his ultimate state is self-recognition, which is the
attainment and actualization of original Shiva-condition, pure and pristine, a condition beyond time and
history. To Kashmir Monism, world is real, yet it in its basics is a duality and a seeker, who is not an
atom in a collective herd, chooses by the exercise of his free will to journey through the zigzags of duality
to a state, which is non-dual untainted by the meshes of time and history. Self-recognition is a condition
of perfection, though a state attained in and through the world, yet in essence a state of transcendentalism
where a self-recognised soul dwells enjoying the beauteous bliss. He may choose to be in the world for
altruistic purposes but as a man having tasted the bliss of recognition is not stained by his actions in the
world. He is in absolute harmony with the world which though apparently external to him is in reality his
own reflection or emanation. Liberation though considered to be in the world, but in essence is beyond
the world, which means beyond time and history.
Needham, F.Carr, Paul Tillich and Kausambi have offered a thesis for the peculiar Indian tendency to
weave and formulate Absolutist philosophies and have found its deep rooted motivations in the Indian
belief in time and history. One may not agree to the formulations that they have offered in this regard, but
they have certainly spotlighted the Indian belief in time as cyclical or circular, but not linear or straight.
The Indian view-point about time, to Needham, is 'that world goes down the destruction one after
another'. Kausambi holds that the belief in four ages of mankind is rooted in the climatic conditions of
this land.
These scholars of eminence also hold that the Indians have yet to make history and that is why they have
not produced a single work on history detailing out 'a series of specific events in which men are
consciously involved and which they consciously influence.'
Though Kashmir has a scintillating and coherent tradition of history-writing, yet the historians have
harboured and nurtured the same notions about time and history and that is why terror, trauma and
tragedy the Hindus have suffered with the on-set of Muslims in Kashmir have been negated and have not
been vividly and graphically drawn and delineated. Fate, to them, is a factor that shapes historical forces
and processes, which in themselves are pointless and purposeless.
The above formulations delineating the Indian positions on religious and philosophical issues lead one to
postulate that Monotheism as a religious idea emerging from tribal social formations contains a view,
which is absolutely at variance with an absolutist philosophy. Where Bazaz has artificially perceived a
unity of thought and concept are mutually antagonistic and ideologically divergent with no scope for a
rendevouz. In fact he has jay-walked into the whole issue.
11 C ha pte r 6 - K A S H M IR - N O T A T A B U L A R A S A
A victim to his political commitments, P.N. Bazaz has failed to assess and evaluate the depth and
dimension of Kashmir's culture and civilisation and its share of contributions as a tributary to the
mainstream culture and civilisation of India and with this lacunas in his historical and intellectual
constructions he seems to uphold the idea that Mir Ali through his stray visits was filling in a cultural and
civilisational vacuum in Kashmir. In sharp contradiction to what he held and expounded, Muslim
experience was that Kashmir was not a tabula rasa and 'tabula' refused to be wiped out'. Despite political
hegemony, on cultural plane Islam was a failure in Kashmir as its frontal forces exhibiting extreme forms
of bigotry failed to provide an alternate culture-model in sharp contrast to the tremendous indigenous
developments. As values are the outcome and product of a long churning that societies undergo during
life shaping processes, Mir Ali resorted to cosmetic and artificial changes, but assiduously worked for the
involvement of a state-based apparatus burdened with the religious responsibility of spreading the
support-base of Islam by forcible conversions. The rest was done by Sayyids parading as sufis posted by
him at various centres of Hinduism, who drilled the new-converts into some mechanical codes, tethered
them loose from their heritage, taught them the only lessons of believers and non-believers, the blessed
and the damned and to cap it all, fed them on the 'narrowness of the spirit', a hall-mark of Islam and other
Semitic religions, thus modelling them into split personalities caught up in the chasm of the rejected past
and stillborn future.
12 C ha pte r 7 - W IL L IN G A N D P E A C E F U L C O N V E R S IO N - A H A L F
T RU T H
Had the Kashmiri Hindus accepted Islam willingly and peacefully, it would have been a unique example
in the history of Islam only to be rivalled by the history of Buddhism. Contrary to the claims of Bamzai
and Bazaz, the dark reality remains that the spread of Islam in Kashmir was as blood-soaked and
apocalyptic as it was in countries where Islam was introduced by force and coercion and at pain of death.
'Social and religious humanism, as projected by Sufi dervishes is a half-truth invented by Bamzai and
'religious humanism' is a pale repetition of the same half-truth by Bazaz. The sufi dervishes with rare
exceptions could not be designated even remotely as humanists as they were deeply steeped in hide-
bound Muslim orthodoxy and held fast to viciously sectarian notions and their psyche and each cell of
their existence was highly biased and prejudiced and presided over by the idea of 'Kufra' for the
extirpation of which they were uncompromising and absolutely ruthless. The first glimpse of their true
face and also mind-set was betrayed through the prism of 'twenty humiliating conditions' as enshrined in
the 'Zakhiratul-Muluk' which Bamzai and Bazaz were either not aware of or if at all were conversant with
them, have conveniently brushed them aside like proverbial ostriches. Having known dark facts and grisly
crimes committed in the name of Islam, they have deliberately concealed them or trimmed and tailored
them to suit the requirements of so-called secular ideology and Royist thesis.
13 C ha pte r 8 - E X T R A - ID E O L O G IC A L M E T H O D S
Much against the culture of disinterested and dispassionate historians, Bamzai, Bazaz and their tribe did
not scratch and probe deeper to know that willing conversions in societies are a possibility where converts
were mentally and intellectually backward and primitive and had registered no significant and worthwhile
advances in the realms of culture and civilization and had proved incapable of evolving a world-view of
their own to suit their cultural needs and yearnings or where they conspicuously felt and discernibly
realised a proximity to tile outlook they were accepting and adopting to graft it on to the tree of their
thought. As is widely known that Kashmir as a vital and distinctive strand of the Indian cultural mosaic
had a fully spelt-out world-view, a philosophy and a well-founded leviathan of culture and civilization.
Muslim religious tendencies including its Persian variant of prophetic mysticism is at variance with and
antithetical to the Indian world-view and failed to register any impact on it. That is why Islam found few
ready recruits in India and Kashmir and hence, it had to take resort to extra-ideological methods of
forcible conversions and whole sale spoliation and destruction of the relics of Kashmir culture and
civilization.
14 C ha pte r 9 - C O M P R O M IS E A S T A C T IC S
As evidenced by historical records, the Muslims usurped the seat of power by a coup d'etat and fully
aware of the Hindu personality of Kashmir, they trod the Kashmir soil very warily and cautiously lest
they should slip and meet disaster. Sanskrit was allowed as the language in government circles not
because it was a continuation of the past legacy, but because it at that locus of Kashmir history could not
be replaced by Persian which had yet to register any imprint and headway in the courts of Sultans.
Brahmans were tolerated in the rungs of services as a matter of tactics and compromise. The dominating
and essential concern of the Muslim rulers at the initial stages was to entrench their rule and also to break
the Hindu resistance as the first step towards forcible conversions. Shah Mir encouraged inter-marriages
to dent the wall of Hindu resistance and a vital step he undertook was to pattern and model his
administration and modes of governance after the system prevalent in Muslim countries. Damaras, fierce
and garrulous, as centres of Hindu resistance, were annihilated and Lavanyas and Tantrins as peasant
soldiers were disarmed and butchered.
The moment Muslims felt sanguine and sure that a final and decisive war could be waged against the
Hindus, it was carried out without dither and tergiversation. To stein, the conversion in Kashmir was
gradual and a matter of slow process but the dismal fact remains that a sudden conversion to Islam with
the fury of a crusade was effected by the troika of Mir Mohammad Hamadani, Sultan Sikandar and Ali
Shah through unholy means and cruel strategies. Conversion of large masses of Hindu population to
Islam during the latter half of the 14th Century is an accomplished tact for Stein, true but how the
conversions were effected anti realised did not draw his keen attention and deep concern.
15 C ha pte r 10 - S H IH A B - U D - D IN ' S A N T I- H IN D U M E A S U R E S
A scion of Zain-ul-Abidin's court and noted historian, Jonraj, has sung paces and poems about Shihab-ud-
Din as a ruler and conqueror, but in the process has missed his livid and lurid acts of bigotry against the
Hindus, whom he subjected to the saga of persecution and torture. The Hindus were barred from going to
temples as the bigots as a matter of deliberate design had set afloat a canard that the Hindus were hatching
plots to dislodge the Muslims from power. Taking it as sedition, Shihab-ud-Din ordered the loot, plunder
and demolition of temples and shrines
Hasan, a Muslim chronicler, records that at the behest of Shihab-ud-Din, "all the temples in Srinagar and
the famous temple of Bijbehara were subjected to a spree of loot and plunder".
17 C ha pte r 12 - S U L T A N S IK A N D A R - A C R U E L C R U S A D E R
Sultan Sikandar and Malik Saif-ud-Din working out the motivational inputs of Mir Mohammad
Hamadani waged a cruel crusade against the Hindus to realise their conversion to Islam. It was a sheer
holocaust for the Hindus. Declared and projected as Kafirs at war, they were massacred and smothered
out mercilessly. Their cultural achievements dotting the length and breadth of Kashmir were put to a
ruthless and wholesale ravage and destruction. Sultan Sikandar committed unpardonable crimes, brutal
and horrendous, against Hindus, shaming the cruellest of the cruel. Hindus were held out three options,
either to get converted to Islam or flee their land of genesis or face perishment. As an outcome of this
brutal government decree, thousands of Hindus buckled under pressure and accepted Islam, thousands
fled the land and thousands accepted death as an alternative to conversion.
Winning the sobriquet of 'but-shikan'- idol-breaker, Sultan Sikandar as a Muslim vandal desecrated,
ravaged and smashed into smithereens numerous temples, caityas, viharas, shrines, hermitages and other
holy places of the Hindus and Buddhists. As a boor, he banned dance, drama, music and iconography as
aesthetic activities of the Hindus and fiated them as heretical and un-Islamic. He forbade the Hindus to
apply a tilak mark on their fore-heads. He did not permit them to pray and worship, blow a conch and toll
a bell.
He stopped them from cremating their dead. A Hindu mother giving birth to twins was exacted. Infamous
Jazia (poll-tax) equal to 4 tolas of silver was imposed on the Hindus in the same manner as Muslims
imposed 'blood-tax' on the Bulgarians. The Hindus were first cruelly butchered and then their sacred
threads were collected and put to flames. They were detained and then hurled into the waters of the Dal
Lake and that particular quarter of the lake is still known as 'Bata Mazar', grave-yard of Hindus.
A despicable war was waged on books enshrining Hindu contributions to and achievements in the
variegated segments of human knowledge and learning. Patrol guards were posted on all exit-points lest
the Hindus should escape the fury with their bodies and faith intact. Army was harnessed and pressed into
service to convert the Hindus. The Hindus were deprived of the means of livelihood so as to coerce them
to accept Islam. They were fiated not to put their learners to any type of schools. Celebration of Hindu
fairs and festivals was banned. Islamic law was imposed on the Hindus.
Records Baharistan-i-Shahi, "Immediately after his (Mir Mohammad's) arrival, Sultan Sikandar, peace be
on him, submitted to his supremacy and proved his loyalty to him by translating his words into deeds. He
eradicated aberrant practices and infidelity. He also put an end to the various forbidden and unlawful
practices throughout his kingdom. Thus during the entire period of his rule, all traces of wines and
intoxicants and instruments of vice and corruption, like the cord of canticle, lyre and tamborin were wiped
out. The clamour of the drum and the trumpet, the shrill notes of the fife and the clarion no longer reached
people's ears, except in battles and assaults."
"Hindus were forcibly converted to Islam and were massacred in case they refused to be converted',"
writes Hasan, a Muslim chronicler. He further observes, "And Sikandarpora (a city laid out by Sultan
Sikandar) was laid out on the debris of the destroyed temples of the Hindus. In the neighbourhood of the
royal palaces in Sikandarpora, the Sultan destroyed the temples of Maha-Shri built by Praversena and
another by Tarapida. The material from these was used for constructing a 'Jami' mosque in the middle of
the city."
"Towards the fag end of his life, he (Sultan Sikandar) was infused with a zeal for demolishing idol-
houses, destroying the temples and idols of the infidels. He destroyed the massive temple at Beejbehara.
He had designs to destroy all the temples and put an end to the entire community of infidels," puts
Bharistan-i-Shahi.
In his second Rajtarangini, the historian Jonraj has recorded, "There was no city, no town, no village, no
wood, where the temples of the gods were unbroken. When Sureshavari, varaha and others were broken,
the world trembled, but not so the mind of the wicked king. He forgot his kingly duties and took delight
day and night in breaking images."
Writes Ajit Bhatracharjee, "Sikandar (1389-1413) equalled the most blood-thirsty and iconoclastic
Muslim conquerors anywhere in his zeal to obliterate all traces of the Hindu religion and convert its
followers to Islam on pain of death. Temples were levelled and some of the grandest monuments of old
damaged and disfigured………. thousands of Hindus escaped across the borders of Kashmir, others were
massacred."
He further records, "Hindu temples were felled to the ground and for one year a large establishment was
maintained for the demolition of the grand Martand temple. But when the massive masonry resisted all
efforts, fire was applied and the noble buildings cruelly defaced."
According to M.Mujeeb, Sikandar, the iconoclast of Kashmir, made forcible conversions a sustained
political policy.
To quote Firishta, "Many of the Brahmans rather than abandon their religion or their country poisoned
them selves, some emigrated from their homes while a few escaped the evil of banishment by becoming
Mohamadans."
Puts A.K. Mujumdar, "These Muslim immigrants (so called sufis) brought with them that fanatic
iconoclastic zeal which distinguished Islam in other parts of India, but from watch Kashmir was happily
free up to this time.
He further records, "Sikandar's reign was disgraced by a series of acts, inspired by religious bigotry and
iconoclastic zeal for which there is hardly any parallel in the annals of the Muslim rulers of India."
18 C ha pte r 13 - M IR A L I H A M D A N I' S A D V IC E T O S U L T A N S IK A N D A R
-
AN ATROCIOUS FALSEHOOD
As a bare fact of history, it is not unknown that Mir Mohammad Hamadani as a formidable proselytiser
was squarely responsible for the blatant use of force and sword against the Hindu masses of Kashmir. The
pages of history are teeming with the brutalities and savageries inflicted on them only to coerce them to
accept Islam. Sultan Sikandar proved their great tormentor and the Hindus ran helter and skelter to safer
zones and as per the living memory of Kashmiri Pandits only eleven families stayed back and rest of them
were either brutally massacred or converted to Islam. Mir Mohammad not only instigated Sultan Sikandar
for the war waged against the Hindus, but is also said to have quoted scriptures that the Hindu Kafirs were
enemies of Islam and could not be granted protection as Zhimmis and yet, to Bamzai, he is a sufi saint,
who looked upon the policy of his mentor with disfavour and disapproval.
In his zeal for being a Muslim apologist, he goes on to add that "Mir Ali Hamadani, the great sub Sayyid,
would not look with equanimity on this show of brute force against the Brahmans (Hindus of Kashmir)
and advised Sultan Sikandar to desist from this un-Islamic practice. The Brahmans were allowed to
pursue their religion and occupation on payment of poll-tax or Jaziya."
Be it said that what Bamzai has recorded is a sheer distortion of and violence on facts of history. Mir Ali
Hamadani as per authentic records had died in 1385 A.D. and was laid to rest at Khatlan and according to
Bamzai, Sultan Sikandar came to the throne of Kashmir exactly in 1389 A.D., that is four years after Mir
Ali's demise. As per hard facts, Mir Mohammad arrived in Kashmir in 796/ 1393 and soon after Sultan
Sikandar was regimented into bigotry and embarked upon the extirpation of infidelity from the belts of
Kashmir. How Sultan Sikandar was asked and advised to stop his genocidal war against the Hindus after
Mir Ali's demise by Mir Ali himself is understandable to Bamzai alone.
19 C ha pte r 14 - R E T U R N O F S A N IT Y
Sultan Zain-ul-abidin authored a new chapter of tolerance, mutual good-will and co-existence in the
history of Kashmir. He allowed peace and respite to the harried, harassed and bloodied Hindus, whom he
called back to their land of genesis where from they had fled in fear and terror to the mountainous regions
and plains of India. He permitted them to pursue their religious and aesthetic activities and pursuits much
to the chagrin of the Muslim bigots, who opposed him tooth and nail for calling back Hindus and
rehabilitating them and allowing them to acquire and pursue knowledge and also to earn their living
without subjecting them to crippling discrimination on religious grounds. To the Muslim fanatics, the
Sultan was a heretic as he exempted the Hindus from Jaziya and permitted them to celebrate their fairs
and festivals and cremate their dead.
Records Baharistan-i-Shahi, "Whereas the Sultan showed considerable favour and regard to the Muslim
nobles and learned men, he also undertook the re-construction of the monuments of the infidels and
communities of poly-theists. He popularised the practices of the infidels and the heretics and the customs
of idol-worshippers and the people ignorant of faith. All those temples and idol-houses of the infidels
which had been destroyed totally in the reign of Sultan Sikandar, may God bless his soul, were re-built
and rehabilitated by him. Most of the unbelievers and polytheists, who had fled to the lands of Jammu and
Kishtwar because of the overwhelming strength of Islam, were induced by him to return to Kashmir. The
sacred books of the infidels and the writings of the polytheists which had been taken out of this country
were brought back and thus the learning of the unbelievers and the customs of the polytheists were
revived by him. He helped the community of the misled idolaters to prosper. In every village and town,
blasphemous customs connected with springs or temples were revived. He ordered that in every town and
locality celebration of special feasts and festivals by infidels be revived in accordance with the customs
prevalent in the past.
It further records, "The only conspicuous defect and an over-all drawback of Zain-ul-abidin was that
idolatory and heresy, which had been stamped out in the reign of Sultan Sikandar, the iconoclast, and of
which there had remained no traces in the land of Kashmir were revived by him. The customs and
practices of the polytheists and the heretics received fresh impetus and were given renewed currency. He
ordered that particular days of festivity to be celebrated in every town and village in which innumerable
vices and corrupt practices were let loose. In more than one way, these had a deleterious influence on the
sharia and Islam brought by the Prophet. The community of the infidels and heretics called him the great
king because they flourished under his rule and he was known by the name throughout his kingdom
…….. It resulted in the gradual weakening of Islam and decay of its canons and postulates, idol worship
and corrupt and immoral practices thrived."
20 C ha pte r 15 - N A B H A T T O A H A M - A C R Y IN A G O N Y
In the wake of Zain-ul-Abdin's death, Kashmir was again hurled into the vortex of chaos, disorder and
unprecedented religious bigotry. Haider Shah (1470-72) lecherous and a rake, given to the company of
ravishing damsels and bouts of drinking proved wild and ferocious for the Hindus of Kashmir. Not only
that he harassed and persecuted them, but also killed them with all vengeance. Revolting against the
policy of liquidating them, the Hindus in sheer anger and desperation mobbed most of the mosques built
on the temple plinths with temple materials and set them afire. The Sayyid Ali mosque constructed on the
plinth of a ravaged and spoliated temple was the main target and was burnt to cinders. This incident when
broached to the Sultan touched his raw nerve and not taking it lying town, he issued an atrocious decree
of chopping off the noses, ears and arms of the Hindus through the length and breadth of Kashmir.
Consequent upon it, the Hindus were swooped and caught and subjected to the vile and bloody orgy of
flenching the body parts and limbs. Dragging Hindus out from their houses, a brutality in itself, many of
them were sawed and chopped into two halves, an atrocity unknown to ferocious savages. Terrorised
beyond limits, they flinched and wilted, fell and faltered and in pain and agony yelled out their lungs" Na
Bhatto Aham"(I am not a Bhatta, a Kashmiri Hindu) only to avoid the bloody orgy of mutilation of body
parts.
21 C ha pte r 16 - C R U S A D E R E - L A U N C H E D - S H A M S - U D - D IN IR A Q I
The chaks, rough and rugged, owing their descent to Dardistan, added new chapters to the history of gore
and blood that was being wantonly written in Kashmir. It was during their rule and hegemony that the
Kashmiri Hindus, who, having survived the first wave of fury unleashed by Sultan Sikandar, were again
hurled into the orgy of flashing swords and savage brutalities, thus terminating their short spell of
honeymoon with peace and respite during the reign of Zain-ul-abidin. During chak period of Kashmir
history, Muslim bigotry and intolerance touched a new crescendo and Hindus were brutalised, tortured
and killed on an unprecedented scale.
Shams-ud-Din Iraqi, a frightful crusader from Talish on the shores of Caspian sea, had two stints in
Kashmir, one in the times of Sultan Hasan Shah and the other during the reign of Mohammad Shah. His
stay in Kashmir was highly controversial as he clandestinely propagated the canons and credos of Shia
Sect of Islam, which the Sunni Muslims bitterly resented and opposed, thus setting the ground and pace
for Shia-Sunni strifes and feuds. Shams Iraqi's mission and role in Kashmir was the same stamping out
and extirpation of infidelity and he in his conversionery campaigns was extended all manner of support
and succour by the governments led by Musa Raina and Kaji Chak, who as principal converts to his faith
executed his fiats and played a second fiddle to him. Musa Raina gave gardens, orchards, ornaments,
costumes, horses, jewellery and gold to Shams Iraqi, who utilised the wealth, they say, for the
construction of a Khanqah at Zadibal on the outskirts of Srinagar. The chiselled stones and other materials
from ravaged temples are said to have been utilised in the construction of the Khanqah.
Kashmiri Hindus had already tasted the bitter fury of a crusade, but Shams Iraqi lent it a new ferocity of
pace and momentum and as an outcome history was repeated for the Hindus, who were tortured,
persecuted and killed to bring them to the fold of Shia-faith of Islam. Temples out of morbid intolerance
were again pillaged and destroyed and mosques built at their sites. The Hindus were terrorised and
converted at the point of sword. "Twenty-four thousand Hindu families were converted at one stroke to
the faith of Islam by force and compulsion (qahran and gabran),'' records Hasan. The lands belonging to
the Brahmans from ages were suddenly confiscated and as a measure of coercion men associated with the
maintenance and up-keep of temples were detained and arrested to break their allegiance to the Hindu
places of worship. In the role of a model vandaliser Shams Iraqi vengefully plundered and destroyed the
Vishnu temple, a marvel of Hindu architecture, at Buniyar in the district of Baramulla. He lavished
personal care and attention in getting all the temples of Srinagar city looted, plundered and destroyed.
"As many as eighteen big temples in the city of Srinagar and in the rural areas of the valley were
completely destroyed under the instructions and orders of Shams-ud-Din Iraqi and Malik Musa Raina,"
records Tohfatul Ahbab.
"At the behest of Shams Iraqi, Musa Raina had ordered 1500 to 2000 infidels to be brought to his door-
steps every day by his followers. They would remove their sacred threads, administer Kalima to them,
circumcise them and thrust lumps of beef into their mouths,'' mentions Tohfatul Ahbab.
Musa Raina, Prime Minister of Mohammad Shah, proved a scourge for the Hindus. His bigotry and anti-
Hindu animus and venom got reflected when his government raised and organised a brigade of ferocious
and hardened criminals and notorious scoundrels under the command of a chak brute, who looted and
killed Hindu families, destroyed and ravaged Hindu temples and pulled down Hindu schools and Hindu
institutions of learning.
Records Bharistan-i-Shahi,"During the government of Malik Musa Raina, all the depraved heretics of this
land had been converted to Islam.
It also records, "He (Zain-ul-abidin) had permitted idolators and polytheists to revive the practices of
infidelity and they had propagated heresy (kufr) and false religion (Din-i-batil), with the support of some
more kings, the infidels had flourished day after day. But, with the support and authority of Malik Musa
Raina, Amir Shams-ud-Din Mohammad under-took a wholesale destruction of all those idol-houses as
well as the ruination of the very foundation of infidelity and dis-belief. On the site of every idol-house he
destroyed he ordered the construction of a mosque for offering prayers after the Islamic manner. The
idolatory and heresy which had existed prior to his coming were effectively replaced by his preaching and
propagation of Islam, its laws and practices. He brought honour to all the infidels and heretics (Zandiqa)
of Kashmir by admitting them to the Islamic faith and bestowed upon them many kinds of rewards and
benefactions. It is publicly known that during his life time, with the virtuous efforts and elaborate
arrangements made by the fortunate Malik Musa Raina, twenty four thousand families of staunch infidels
and stubborn heretics were ennobled by being converted to Islam.
22 C ha pte r 17 - N IR M A L K A N T H - A P IL L A R O F R E S IS T A N C E
Shams-Iraqi had to quit Kashmir amidst bitter opposition and stormy protests from the Sunni Muslims,
who had not taken kindly to and savoured well his religious activities related to the proliferation of
support-base of Shia-sect of Islam. With the decline of Musa Raina, he lost patronage and protective
shield from his government and had no option but to buzz off Kashmir in utter haste and confusion. In the
wake of his departure, a daring Pandit, Nirmal Kanth, defying oppression and opposition, launched upon
a campaign to re-convert the Hindus who had succumbed to the sword of Islam. His successes in his
unique venture of reclaiming the lost were enormous and baffling, but also fraught with perils for him, the
re-converts and original Hindus. Amidst the tycoon of Muslim bigotry, Nirmal Kanth, became a rallying
point for the Pandits who were eager to organise themselves and weld their ranks to seek protection of
their faith and limb from the biased Muslim ruler. After hectic and prolonged confabulations, he drafted a
mild petition and submitted it to the Sultan, who was incompetent and apathetic to the affairs of the state
except to enjoy his position of pelf and panoply. In fact, defacto power was vested in and wielded by the
feuding Shia nobles, their proteges and ignoble government officers.
The internecine and bitter struggle for power between Musa Raina and Kaji Chak finally culminated in
the elimination of Musa Raina. Seizing the reins of government Kaji Chek was in a tearing haste to
harness its instrumentalities to perpetrate death and destruction on the Hindus. Shams Iraqi was in
doldrums in Khurasan where the Sultan, Hussian Mirza, had developed deep suspicions about his political
and religious activities and had ordered his immediate expulsion from the country. With the active aid and
support of his previous contacts, he managed to stage a come-back into Kashmir after a period of twelve
years. Kaji Chak came under the umbrella of his influence and ideology and eight hundred prominent
Hindus especially the re-converts including Nirmal Kanth were gruesomely massacred as they were given
the bad name of apostates, who had betrayed and defied Islam and had practise idolatory by placing their
haunches on the divine book.
Records Baharistan-i-Shahi, "With the help of some of the chiefs of this land, some of them had reverted
to the customs of the infidels and polytheists. These apostates had resumed idolatory. Some of the infidels
related that during the hours of offering prayers and worshipping of idols, they would place a copy of the
Quran under their haunches to make a seat to sit upon. Thus idol-worshipping proceeded even when they
sat on the divine book. When the news and details of these doings were brought to Amir Shamsud-Din
Iraqi he summoned Malik Kaji Chak to him. Accompanied by Malik Ali and Khwaja Ahmed, his two
counsellors and administrators, Malik Kaji Chak presented himself before the venerable Amir, who
declared to them.
'This community of idolators has after embracing and submitting to the Islamic faith, now gone back to
defiance and apostasy. If you find yourself unable to inflict punishment upon them in accordance with the
provisions of Sharia and take disciplinary action against them, it will become necessary and incumbent
upon me to proceed on self-imposed exile and in that case you shall not stand in my way at the time of my
departure.'
It further adds, "Kaji Chak consulted his counsellors and administrative officers and decided upon
carrying out a whole-sale massacre of the infidels. Their massacre was scheduled for the days of the
approaching 'Ashura'. Thus seven to eight hundred infidels were put to death."
Baharistan-i-Shahi also describes, "Those killed were the leading personalities of the community of
infidels at that time, men of substance and government functionaries. Each of them wielded influence and
sway over a hundred families of other infidels and heretics. Thus the entire community of infidels and
polytheists in Kashmir was coerced into conversion to Islam at the point of sword. This is one of the
major achievements of Malik Kaji Chak."
As models of brutal intolerance and tyranny the chaks re-imposed Jazia (poll tax) on the Hindus, who
were exempted from paying it during the benevolent rule of Sultan Zain-ul-abidin. They had in all
vengefulness ordered to kill one thousand cows every day with a view to injuring and offending the
religious susceptibilities of the Hindus. To coerce them to join the Islamic fold, the Hindus were blatantly
discriminated and deprived of the opportunities of earning their livelihood and thus stark deprivation and
poverty stared them in the face.
23 C ha pte r 18 - IN T E R - F A C E B E T W E E N H IN D U IS M A N D IS L A M - A
M IS C O N C E P T IO N
Bamzai and Bazaz have waxed eloquent on the positive aspects of the inter-action between Hinduism and
Islam in Kashmir. The analyses that they have offered to buttress their thesis are a pack of cliches and
platitudes, which conventional historians take a resort to in utter contravention of historical facts and
verities. Their thesis prima facie fails to hold out because of the fact that outside Muslims, so called
dervishes of Bamzai and religious humanists of Bazaz encountered a powerful, well-entrenched and
articulate religious and philosophical tradition and history in Kashmir, which they being intellectually too
lay never understood nor did they endeavour to comprehend and delve deep into it to facilitate their
proselytising campaigns and activities. Hindus, to them, appeared pinning their faith in all sorts of
incompatible maze of ideas and beliefs, thus doling out an impression of not one religion, but multiple
sects and religions harbouring the same name-tag. The varied strata and tenets of Hinduism were too
profound for them, which, they only denigrated and straightaway rejected in a sheer snarl of contempt and
indifference. The psychology of total decimation and demolition of material manifestations of Hindu
culture and civilisation was born of blind negation on part of Muslims.
Not only in the beginnings, but even after the entrenchment of Muslim domination in Kashmir, not a
single discernible attempt was made to discover Kashmir and its sum-total of heritage. Most of the
segments of human activity especially aesthetic in essence and nature were heretical and therefore
forbidden fields for the where they dared not tread and had no history, cultivation and capacity to tread.
The processes of inter-face get generated in discovering ideas and beliefs and their raison dinette, which,
when interpreted and debated, inter-mingle with diverse paradigms, approaches and premises giving rise
to a new pattern. In Kashmir the pattern never came into being because Islam globally has a history of
spurning and rejecting the roots of the countries where the citizens are unable and forbidden to own and
appreciate a pyramid, a Martand or a statue of Buddha in deep meditation. Muslims from outside Kashmir
lacking in the spirit of quest had very weak and infirm intellectual and cultural instrumentalities and
traditions and did not penetrate through query and quest the solid monolith of Hindu-Buddhist-
vaishnavite thought amalgam but brutally vandalised and demolished the whole baffling monolith. They
burnt and destroyed books but never wrote a single treatise on Hindu thought and its underlying
principles even from a highly critical point of view. How many of them learnt Sanskrit and interpreted
Sanskrit works on varied branches of learning and religion. Forced Conversion admittedly are not a
feature and cardinal principle of Christianity and that is why the Christian erudites assiduously learnt
Sanskrit as the idiom of Indian culture and thought process and probed to know and discover the past of
India to enable them to persuade, not force and coerce, the Hindus to accept Christianity with its allied
tenets and precepts with a view to humanising them as per their colonial parlance.
What has, in reality, misled Bamzai and Bazaz into sponsoring a thesis of inter-face between Hinduism
and Islam is the non-purge and retention of Hindu practices, attitudes and rituals by the Muslims even
after they were tortured and coerced to accept Islam. The neo-converts to Islam had miserably suffered
two defeats, one that they as Hindus were politically discomfited and even as converts to Islam were kept
away as untouchables and hatefuls from sharing and tasting the fruits and privileges of power on an equal
footing with the outside Muslim masters in corridors of power and secondly they were forcibly converted
to Islam and thus smarted under a deep sense of guilt and schizophrenia. The twin defeats forced them to
fall back upon and seek a re-affirmation of their identity which, though severely threatened and lost, could
be provided and reinforced only by sticking fast to the practices they were habituated and inured to and in
their quest of identity Lal Ded with her Indian thought and spirit grew and emerged into a symbol of that
identity and Nund Rishi despite his abominable conversionary activities as the perpetuator of the same
identity. It appears intriguing that Nund Rishi professing Islamic faith was not very enthusiastic about and
dragged his feet from accepting the spiritual superiority of a Sayyid and contributed to a large measure in
generating a psyche that led to a tremendous upsurge against the Sayyids, who had brutally spearheaded
and sponsored Islamisation of Kashmir and slaughter of Hindus. The Rishi-cult undoubtedly embedded in
the Hindu heritage of Kashmir in spite of its erratic deviations from the mainstream throve on the
preservation of the indigenous ethos of Kashmir, thus establishing that the Muslims conquered only the
body of India (Kashmir-mind) the soul of which is ever defiant and invincible.
Inter-action as such is a matter of two-way traffic and the Muslims with nothing to offer were never a
party to this inter-action. If Muslims in the words of Sir Walter Lawrence have not abandoned the Hindu
religion of Kashmir and Hindu practices that never denotes and connotes mutual traffic and inter-action. It
only signals failure of Islam in Kashmir as it was unable to provide and invest the neo-converts with an
alternate culture-model uncompromising Islamic tenets and precepts.
2 4 C h a p t e r 1 9 - R E G E N E R A T I O N O F K A S H M I R U N D E R T H E S U L T A NS
- A M E R E F A B R IC A T IO N
Invested with the superficial views serving his a priori model based on his instinct of identification with
the aggressor, P.N. Bazaz strongly feels that the Sultans gaining political power and hegemony in
Kashmir meant a qualitative change from that what was old to that what seemingly had a ring of being
new and novel and the change, to him, had a regenerative impact in Kashmir. Very recently the votaries
of secessionism in Kashmir have re-cycled the same idea and have characterized the advent of Islam in
the region of Kashmir as a ray that dispels darkness from all corners, thus establishing the obliteration of
the racial memory of the converts. What Bazaz has put and what, votaries of Islam have to say in this
behalf do not seem to stand the acid-test of history, which gives a thorough exposure to the verbiage that
has been lavishly utilised to invest a non-tact with the raiment of a fact.
Historically, Lalitaditya and Avantivarman built up and consolidated gargantuan empires with well laid-
out political and economic structures. These periods of Kashmir history are of great significance as there
was a tremendous economic and political regeneration in Kashmir with their impact and imprint on the
growth and development of arts and crafts, architecture and sculpture, aesthetics and to cap them all,
philosophy touching a new apogee. The achievements in their totality registered during the Hindu period
of history instilled cynical inferiority among the Muslims who brutally levelled and destroyed them and
the ravaged
ruins ever in their muteness relate the epochal saga of' grandeur and glory. To negate and belittle the past
of' Kashmir there has been a colonial tendency to attribute everything that Kashmir has to Zain-ul-abidin
and other Muslim rulers who might have introduced certain new arts and crabs of Persian origins in
Kashmir. But, Zain-ul-abidin and other Muslim monarchs were not ruling over Africa, which has
wallowed in absolute darkness in terms of' human history and civilization. That Kashmir was steeped in
the mire of backwardness and primitivty with no history and culture prior to the advent of Islam in
Kashmir and Islam civilised it is a pale and futile version of the Christian idea of' 'White-man's burden'.
That the Muslims like Shakespeare's Prospero in the Tempest had the magical powers to civilise and
humanise the calibans and Ariels is preposterous. Puts D.N Dhar, "The change of reign from Hindu kings
to Muslim Sultans has only a shift of the Kaleidoscope on the same scene from one colour to another. It
was only a change in nomenclature and not in essence.
Had Bazaz deeply and carefully studied the history of Kashmir, especially the, Muslim period, he would
not have fudged facts and unnecessarily waxed eloquent on the so called regeneration of Kashmir during
the Sultanate period.
When Fateh Shah was occupying the throne of Kashmir, his Minister, Usman, divided the entire kingdom
of Kashmir into three parts, one he kept for himself, and the other two parts were doled out to Shankar
Raina and Nusrat Raina, two neo-converts to Islam. During the reign of Nazuk Shah, Abdul Magrey, his
Minister, distributed huge tracts of land among his close relations. When Mohammad Shah was the ruler,
Kazi Chak divided the entire valley of Kashmir into three parts, he gave one part to Sayyid Ibrahim
Baihaqi to rule and kept the other part for himself and the third part he gave as a gift to the Sultan. Sultan
Sikandar had allotted lands and Jagirs to the Muslim proselytisers seeking refuge in Kashmir when they
were fleeing Persia due to Timur's persecution. The Sayyid nobles and their collaborators captured the
seat of power in Kashmir and shared the power pie and looted the people and public exchequer with all
vengeance and the neo-converts as entirely subservient to them were meted out the humiliating and
abysmal treatment and in the words of Srivar were regarded as low as dust. And, to Bazaz, it was
regeneration and great impact of Islam in Kashmir.
25 C ha pte r 20 - M U G H A L A N N E X A T IO N A T T H E B E H E S T O F
M U S L IM S
The Mughal annexation of Kashmir is said to be the direct outcome of the Shia-Sunni strife and
turbulence that had ravaged and seeped deep to the very roots of Kashmir polity causing chaos, disruption
and dismantling of societal and political structures. The Sunni Muslims as per their history in time
complained of severe and unsparing political and religious oppression and persecution, which touched its
culmination in the exile of Sheikh Hamza Maqdoom from the precincts of Srinagar city to Beerva village
in Badgam District for spear-heading an anti-Shia movement. The two political advisers of the Sheikh,
paradoxically designated as suns, repaired to the imperial court of Akbar faith the humble petition that the
Sunni Muslims had been reeling and groaning under severe religious and political repression and needed
an immediate retrieval and salvation from the chak rulers and their official machine. Yaqub Sarfi and
Baba Dawood Khaki known as inveterate Shia-foes were involved in a maze of conspiracies against the
chak regime. That they sought for the intervention of the Mughal Emperor to dismantle the Shia-led
regime was deemed as the only viable and acceptable course open to them.
Though being deliberately smoke-screened, yet there is clinching historical evidence available not only to
suggest, but also to establish the leading role of Yaqub Sarfi in coaxing and inviting the Mughals for
invasion of Kashmir. At the head of a Sunni delegation, he ostensibly apprised the Mughal Emperor of
the oppression perpetrated by Chak fanatics as deviants from Islam on the Sunni Muslims, but in reality,
he in his moves and motives was prompted by his sectarian and anti-Shia sentiments and prejudices. It is
said that he even spelt-out in detail some of the conditions, which the emperor was required to act upon in
the wake of the annexation of Kashmir to the vast Mughal empire. That the Muslims (Sunnis) would not
be reduced to the position of slaves, they would not be oppressed and harnessed for begar (Corvee) and
the treacherous Chak nobles would be kept away from the administrative management of Kashmir were
the prime conditions stipulated by the delegation led by Sarfi. Muslims of the Sunni brand alone were his
primary and over-riding concern. Not a word was said about the Kashmiri Pandits, who were marauded,
brutalised and massacred for the religion they espoused and harboured. They were hounded out and
obliged to roam about the mountainous regions and plains of India to save themselves from the hurricane
of Muslim bigotry and intolerance. It is within the realms of possibility that the Emperor had his covetous
eyes on the splendorous vale of Kashmir and even had prior plans to annexe Kashmir. But, the Sunni-
Muslim leadership after prolonged and concerted deliberations sent a mission to the Imperial court, thus
providing an alibi to the Emperor for an armed intervention in Kashmir. The front-line objective of the
Sunni-Muslims was only to turn turtle the apple-cart of the Shia-Muslims and destroy their hegemony
over Kashmir. It is said that Yaqub Sarfi and Baba Dawood Khaki cringed and crooned before the
Emperor for immediate despatch of troops to the valley and when troops were despatched, Sarfi
accompanied the Imperial army to be at its beck and call and also serve as its guide to facilitate the
conquest of Kashmir by Mughals.
It was at the persuasion of Sarfi that the recalcitrant Chiefs of Karnah (West of Kashmir) surrendered to
the Mughal army, which as a matter of strategy utilised that as a vital base for further forays and
incursions into the valley of Kashmir. The emperor possessed of ample fund of military experience made
his own assessments and calculations and virtually ignored and paid no heed to the boastful claims of
Sarfi about the unstirred support that he drew from the fractious nobles and grantees of Kashmir for the
Mughal annexation of the territory under the Chak sway and rule. The troops were despatched via Hirpur
route and in the battle that ensued at Hastivanj, Sarti was seriously wounded and was removed from the
battle-field by his friends in the arms.
The significant role played by the Sunni leadership operating under the direct guidance and patronage of
Sheikh Hamza Maqdoom is deliberately being played down and even rejected as untrue by the
formulators and sponsors of the theory that Kashmir lost its independence with the Mughals annexing it
to their empire ruled from Delhi and Agra in 1586 A.D.
Records M.J.Akbar, "Kashmir suddenly became part of a larger world and peace of this world of empire
would last for more than a century and a half, that was the extraordinary legacy of Akbar."
He further records, "A standard land revenue policy brought stability and growth to the largely
agricultural economy.
26 C ha pte r 21 - L E A R N IN G N O T E N O U G H , W IE L D A W E A P O N - K R IP A
RA M D U T T A
Aurangzeb, a bigot to the marrow of his bone, was a scourge for the Hindus and worked havoc on them
through forcible conversions to the Islamic faith. It was at his behest that the governor of Kashmir,
Iftikhar Khan (1671-75) equally a bigot, unsheathed the sword of Islam against the Kashmiri Pandits with
the objective of securing their conversion to Islam. At this moment of grave crisis, some Pandits, wise
and learned, under the leadership of Kripa Ram Dutta of Bhawan, District Anantnag, decided to repair to
the Amarnath cave, held as an abode of Shiva, to pray to the Lord and seek His guidance for the
resolution of crisis they were faced with.
At the holy cave, Kripa Ram, an ardent believer in Shiva's grace, had a dream in which Lord Shiva
introduced him to the address of Guru Tegh Bahadur and directed him to seek his guidance to meet the
challenge posed by the demon of bigotry and religious blindness. Acting upon the Lord's Counsel, Kripa
Ram at the head of a delegation of 500 Kashmiri Pandits crossed over the mountain ramparts to reach
Anandpur village in the Punjab to call on Guru Tegh Bahadur.
The Pandits in extreme agony and distress presented a petition to the Guru in which it was stated that they
were being subjected to religious persecution, the sacred threads that they were putting on as a mark of
religious initiation were being forcibly removed from their person and each day such threads weighing a
maund and a quarter were being snapped and burnt and cows without number were being mercilessly
slaughtered to inflict grave hurt on the Hindus. Finally they sought for his intercession and protection.
The Guru in great distress and anguish pondered for a while and informed the suppliant Brahmans that the
brutal atrocities on the Hindus could be stemmed only after a great sacrifice.
Tegh Bahadur's son, Gobind Rai, prescient and precocious, present on the scene fully realising the gravity
of the distressing situation and exhibiting exemplary courage and zeal urged his father to undertake the
sacrifice for the protection and preservation of Hindu faith, which was under a severe onslaught from the
Muslim fanaticism and bigotry.
Guru Tegh Bahadur advised the Kashmiri Pandits to go to Delhi and tell the bigot in the emperor that he
should first convert Tegh Bahadur to Islamic faith and then all of them would follow suit sans any
equivocation. The same was verbatim conveyed to the emperor. Losing his cool and flying into a spasm
of rage, he summoned the Guru to Delhi. The Guru accompanied by five of his trusted and faithful
disciples arrived in Delhi and Aurangzeb in all his fanatic fury and wrath asked him to embrace Islam or
show some miracle to establish and prove his credentials of guruship As a spiritualist of high order, the
Guru denied that he could perform a miracle and valiantly and without a quiver refused to join the fold of
Islam. Aurangzeb ordered his execution and it was thus that the guru attained martyrdom.
The martyrdom of Guru Tegh Bahadur proved a waterlog for the forces of intolerance, hate and religious
fanaticism. The Hindus throughout the country were aflame with a deep sense of revenge and in the end it
got forged and mobilised into a strong resistance movement led by Guru Gobind Singh, who formed the
'Khalsa Panth' with the avowed objective of fighting and defeating the Muslim bigotry and fanaticism. In
generating and organising the resistance movement, Kripa Ram Dutta played a remarkable role by
nurturing and teaching Guru Gobind Singh at the preparatory stage till he flowered as the guiding symbol
of the resistance movement against intolerance and fanatic orthodoxy. It was Kripa Ram, who is said to
have innovated the vital idea of combining Shastra (learning) with Shastra (Weapon) and infused the
same into the great Guru, who through his divine vision and prescience moulded the Sikhs into a patriotic
martial race. He taught the Guru Sanskrit and through it introduced him to the entire store-house of Hindu
lore and learning and as a follower of Sikh faith fell to the forces of bigotry in the battle of Chamkaur,
thus materialising his significant thesis into actual praxis.
27 C ha pte r 22 - M U S L IM S IN V IT E A F G H A N S
With the Mughal empire declining and in doldrums, two prominent Muslims Mir Muquim Kanth and
Khawaja Zahir Didamari repeated the role-model of Yaqub Sarfi and Baba Dawood Khaki by begging of
Ahmad Shah Abdali to aggress Kashmir with a view to annexing it to Kabul. It was an 'Islamic invitation'
extended to Abdali, who was deemed a saviour sans minding and evaluating the havoc he was wreaking
on north of India. Abdali was not so impolitic as to miss the opportunity and without prevarication and
dither despatched his troops under the command of Abdullah Khan Ishk Aqasi to capture Kashmir for
Kabul. After a fierce battle for a fortnight, Ishk Aqasi vanquished his opponent and marched into Kashmir
triumphantly and the entire Muslim population hailed him as a victor.
The Afghans in their essential traits and characteristics were tribals, ferocious, cruel and inhuman and it
did not take them long to reveal their visage of savagery and ferocity. According to Walter Lawrence,
"when we pass from the Mughal period to the period of Shahani Durani, we pass to a time of brutal
tyranny, unrelieved by good works, chivalry and honour". As they were wantonly cruel and insatiably
avaricious, the dreams and visions of Kashmiri Muslims punctured like a balloon when Ishk Aqasi in
complicity with Mir Muquim Kanth applied red-hot iron-bars to a Muslim business-man to extort a huge
sum of money from him. It virtually shell-shocked them and visas contrary to what they had expected.
The Afghans though Muslims did not spare them when they started on their looting bouts by the
imposition of enormous tax-burdens on the Kashmiri populace. So, the Muslims viscerally hated them
and nick-named all breeds of Afghans as Kakad Khans, foolish and low in intelligence, an epithet which
the Kashmiri Pandits had sarcastically coined for them. Had the Afghans directed and utilised all the
weapons in their arsenal of barbarity and brutality against the Pandits, that would have dizzied them into
an ecstasy and given them an unbounded satisfaction.
It is axiomatically known world over that the extirpation of Kufra (infidelity) is a divine mission with
every Muslim, original or convert, and the Afghan savages embarked upon the same mission. The
Kashmiri Pandits harbouring a non-Islamic faith were the declared enemies of Islam and as a matter of
religious duty and obligation were to be subjected to brute force and harsh coercion. The mix-deeds that
the Afghans indulged in and the tyrannies that they perpetrated have earned them the sobriquet of
'butchers'. The Pandits were looted, plundered and killed with impunity. They were mercilessly hurled
into the waters of Dal Lake to meet their watery grave. The obstreperous Bomba tribals and brigands were
hired to harass and brutalise them and coerce them to join the fold of Islam. They burnt them alive in their
own houses. They killed them and their butchered remnants, stinking and smelling, littered over the
streets of Srinagar for days on end with ravenous crows prying over them and the relatives of the
butchered Pandits shrieking and screaming with none to soothe them and alleviate their sufferings. The
Pandits known for their love of learning were not permitted to put their scholars to any form of schooling
and educative processes. They were divested of their jobs, and thus were deprived of their livelihood.
Their women-folk were subjected to all forms of dishonour and ignominy. Lifting them and exporting
them to Kabul was a usual occurrence. To protect them from such atrocities, the young budding beauties
were disfigured and defaced by the flecking and mutilation of their body-parts and were married off
before the onset of puberty.
The Kashmiri Pandits were subjected to cruel taxes, levies and punitive exactions. The hated Jazia (poll
tax) was imposed on them. A separate capitation tax to the tune of Rs.12,500 per annum had to be paid by
every Pandit to the ruler at Kabul. An amazing punitive tax known as Smoketax (Zari-Dood) was laid on
them. In case their failed to pay it, they were intimidated, tortured and put to flashing swords.
Records Tyndale Bisco, "It is said that during the Afghan rule in Kashmir (1752-1819) the Afghans were
in the habit of riding into the Kashmiri houses on their horse-back, stabling their horses in the lower
portion and occupying the rest for themselves. The Kashmiris were unable to check these outrages by
force. They devised therefore the plan of having so low doors that not only the intruder had to dismount,
but also to bow his head on entry. As the Afghans were haughty and no one of them was willing to make
obeisance to a local person, they were forced to remain outside."
Writes Walter Lawrence, "The Pandits, who formerly wore moustaches, were forced to grow beards,
turbans and shoes were forbidden and the tika or fore-head mark was interdicted."
He further records, "The Jazia or poll-tax on Hindus was revived and many Brahmans either fled the
country, were killed or were converted to Islam."
27.1 Asad Khan - A Savage
Asad Khan, a class oppressor, boasted that the savage Nadir Shah was his prototype. Walter Lawrence
records about his atrocities on Hindus "It was his practice to tie up the Pandits, two in grass sacks and
sink them in the Dal Lake. As an amusement, a pitcher filled with odure would be placed on a Pandit's
head and the Musalmans would pelt the pitcher with stones till it broke, the unfortunate Hindu being
blinded with filth.
According to Forster, "Asad Khan stands in the foremost rank of tyrants". Concurs Fergusson, "Asad
Khan gave an unchecked expression to his sadistic tendencies. The Hindu Pandits as Kafirs or infidels
were naturally the first objects of his persecution. The atrocities of Asad Khan included tying up Pandits
by their hands back to back and throwing them into the lake. The hated Jazia, a tax on Hindus, was re-
imposed and numerous disabilities were placed on the Pandits and their religion."
27.2 Hazar Khan - A Fiend
Puts Walter Lawrence, "Mir Hazar was another fiend who used leather bags instead of grass sacks for the
drowning of Brahmans. He drowned Shias and Brahmans indiscriminately."
27.3 Atta Mohammad Khan - A Psychopath
Fergusson records about Ata Mohammad Khan, "Women rather than torture were his reigning passion
and beautiful Hindu girls had their features defaced by their parents rather than that they should attract the
attention of the agents of this insatiable ruler,"
Puts Walter Lawrence, "Ata Mohammad Khan was a ferocious libertine and his agent, an old woman
Koshib, was the terror of the Brahman parents, who rather than allow the degradation of their daughters
destroyed their beauty by shaving their heads or cutting their nose."
27.4 Haji Karim Dad Khan - A Looter
Records P.N.K. Bamzai, "He purposely kept the tax gatherers Aslam and Babu, in hinding accusing the
Pandit community of their murder. He collected their leading members and keeping them in close
confinement, subjected them to suffocating fumes from cow dung. They implored, they importunated, but
the heartless Haji would not release them until they agreed to pay an annual tax (known as Zari Dood or
Smoke Tax) of 50,000 rupees."
Giving an estimate of the Afghan rule, Walter Lawrence pithily puts, "Pathan rulers are only remembered
for their brutality and cruelty and it is said that they thought no more of cutting heads than of plucking a
flower."
In the same vein, Forster laconically records, "They rarely issued an order without showing the side of
their hatchet, a common weapon of the Afghans."
28 C ha pte r 23 - B IR B A L D H A R A N D S IK H S
The Afghans littered the valley of Kashmir with images of gore and violence and as a fall-out of their
primeval and unbridled savagery and ferocity, the Kashmiri Pandits in streams buzzed off their homes and
hearths to sanctuaries across the mountain ramparts in the plains of India. As evidenced by records of
sufficient veracity, their numbers in the valley fell to a mere seven thousand, four thousand in the city of
Srinagar and three thousand in the hamlets and villages, near and distant. According to Moorcraft, the
unprecedented depletion of Kashmiri Pandit population was the direct outcome of ruthless persecution
that they were subjected to. Concurring with the views of Moorcraft, Cunningham states that the
ancestors of Kashmiri Brahmans now settled in Delhi, Lucknow and elsewhere in the plains of India were
refugees from Afghan oppression and cruelty.
Dismayed and shocked by the ruthless persecution of his co-religionists, Birbal Dhar, a notable noble of
Kashmir, suddenly disappeared from the landscape of Kashmir alongwith his son causing a gnashing
anxiety to the Afghan governor, Azim Khan, rapacious and brutal and with the active aid of Raja Dhyan
Singh, brother of Raja Gulab Singh, appeared in the glittering court of Maharaja Ranjit Singh in the
Punjab. It was after a lot of persuasion that Ranjit Singh nodded the despatch of his troops to Kashmir to
annexe it to his kingdom. The Afghan resistance petered out in face of the pitch and thrust of the Sikh
onslaught and the Hindu conquest of Kashmir was celebrated for full three days.
The Sikhs were highly shocked at the sight of havoc that had been wrought on the Kashmiri Pandits all
through the period the Muslims held sway over Kashmir. Their temples had been ravaged and levelled;
they were butchered and murdered; they were not permitted to worship their gods and goddesses and their
women-folk were abducted for export to Kabul. They were burdened with unjust and inequitous. taxes
and exactions to satiate the hunger of the Muslim rulers at Kabul.
Now it was the turn of the Muslims to suffer. A brick for brick and tooth for tooth policy was pursued. In
sheer retaliation the Sikhs closed Jama Masjid built on the ruins of a Hindu temple and a Buddhist Vihara
for prayers, stopped azaan to call the faithfuls to prayers, imposed levies and taxes on the Muslims,
banned cow-slaughter and declared Pather Masjid as property of the state. Phoola Singh, a Sikh General,
trained his guns at the Mir Ali Mosque on the plea that it was raised on the plinth of a temple that was
pillaged and destroyed. The said - mosque was saved only at the intervention of Birbal Dhar, who has
been showered with bouquets and brickbats for this act of his by a substantial number of writers on
Kashmir history.
About the Sikh phase of Kashmir conquest, a host of lies have been told and a number of half-truths have
been woven with a view to discrediting the improvements that the Sikhs registered in Kashmir economy
and politics and the relief that they brought to the oppressed people. The latest attempt in the vicious
propaganda launched against all shades of Hindus is Altaf Hussain's book 'Paradise wounded', which is
said to have been written by the votaries of secessionism in America and issued out in his name. But the
available historical evidences and notices belie all what is said in the book by way of aiding and abetting
the on-going terrorism in Kashmir.
Writes Fergusson, "The condition of Kashmir under the Sikhs was no doubt an improvement on that
under the Afghans. The Hindus to whom the Sikhs are in many ways very near benefited most and the
disabilities under which they had been unable to practice the rites of their religion were removed. It was
now the turn of the-Muslims to suffer. Mosques were closed, the call to prayer was forbidden and capital
punishment was awarded for the killing of a cow."
Walter Lawrence puts, "It must have been an intense relief to all classes in Kashmir to see the downfall of
the evil rule of the Pathans. I do not mean Sikh rule was benign and good, but it was at any rate better
than that of the Afghans. "
Records Baron von Hugel, "The dreadful cruelties perpetrated by their earlier rulers, who, for the smallest
offence, punished them with the loss of their noses and ears, make poor Kashmiris well satisfied with
their present comparatively mild government."
29 C ha pte r 24 – L O O T O F 1931
Despite being autocratic and recalcitrant, Maharaja Hari Singh in his address to the chamber of Princes in
London was unequivocal and unmistakable in his support of the growing demand for Indian independence
which generated alarm waves for the British imperialists ever keen to perpetuate their hegemony over
India and other Princely states. Plans were set afoot and conspiracies hatched to keep the Maharaja under
the heel of pressure so that he would not dare thwart and impede the British strategies to meet the
challenges posed to their vast sprawling empire by the Russian expansion in the belts of regions
contiguous to their territories. On the chess-board of British geo-political strategies, Kashmir had notched
up as a key-region and the bonafides of Maharaja harbouring patriotic sympathies for the Indian
independence became suspect and hence it was deemed strategic and highly expedient to pin him down in
the communal tension that was covertly and overtly fuelled and heightened by inciting the Muslim
majority against him as he was harbouring a faith that was not Islamic.
Sheikh Abdullah was spearheading a movement against the Maharaja through the Reading Room Party
and as such had engrossed focus and is said to have been picked up for the role of an agent and the same
is revealed and established by the bunch of letters which were shown to Pandit Nehru (who felt shocked)
by Rafi Ahmad Kidwai, the then Food Minister of India, when the stage was set for the Sheikh's dismissal
in the wake of his fiery and treacherous statements questioning the irrevocability of Kashmir's accession
to India.
The Reading Room Party as per its role-model in Kashmir politics was communal to the pulp, blood and
bone as its bias against the Kashmiri Pandits was so pronounced that it prepared the ground for the blatant
loot and murder of Kashmiri Pandits in July,1931. The battle-cry against them was set off by the
malicious and apochryphal propaganda of the typical Muslim brand that they had an absolute strangle-
hold of the state services. The fact, to the contrary, was that the state services though very limited in
number were domineered and monopolised by the Punjabi and Bengali Muslims and Hindus. Despite
impecceable academic credentials, the Kashmiri Pandits were reluctantly recruited to the lower rung
services for a mere pittance which was also stopped by the then powers that be in view of the mounting
pressures on the Maharaja.
Lacking in the discernment of a modern mind, Sheikh Abdullah nursed a personal grudge against the
Maharaja as he was refused a lecturership in an academic college, not out of religious bias, but because of
his low academic merit. His competitor said to be a Kashmiri Pandit had a much brighter record than that
of the tall Sheikh. Steeped in the culture of Aligarh Muslim University, the Sheikh with a mind fine de
siecle and thinking communal straightaway sans any hesitation leapt to the conclusion that he was
dropped because the Maharaja was a Hindu and his competitor too was a Hindu. It speaks volumes about
the low mind of Sheikh Abdullah, who invested all his prowess and energies to metamorphose the
Reading Room Party into a seminary of religious venom, hatred and animosity against the Pandits.
The Sheikh wanted the Maharaja to show him special consideration on grounds of educational and
economic backwardness of the community he belonged to. Myopic in his views and outlook, he could not
see and discover poverty, backwardness and deprivation prevailing in Kashmiri Pandits. His competitor
was also a man from a poor and backward family. Despite economic disabilities and other inhibiting
factors, the fact remains that the Kashmiri Pandits all through their chequered history and despite Muslim
oppression have not broken their tryst with learning and education while the Muslims as a converted lot
cultivating other priorities parted ways perhaps with no remorse with the tradition resulting in their
educational backwardness which was perpetuated by the self- seeking Mullahs harbouring repugnance to
liberal forms of education. Credit must be given to the Maharaja that he firmly stuck to the rules and
stipulations that were laid down for recruitment to the institutions of higher learning and did not relax,
bend and flout them (as Sheikh did when in office) only to introduce the virus of mediocrity into the
mainstream of Kashmir polity.
The Reading Room Party with Sheikh Abdullah as its moving spirit earned patronage and favours from
the Muslim landlords, shawl tycoons, parochial mullahs and Muslim educated elite in government
service. The landlords owing allegiance to the Maharaja patronised the Sheikh with a view to furthering
their self interests and increasing their clout with the ruler for more economic favours and concessions. It
will not be out of place to put that the Sheikh, at the behest of Muslim landlords, was harnessed to collect
funds for organising a grand reception in honour of the Maharaja when he returned in 1931 from Europe
where his wife had delivered a male child. In an attempt to make in-roads into the Muslim gentry he even
accepted the convenorship of the Muslim Jagirdar Committee without any prevarication and outrage. The
shawl tycoons were on the same wave-length and nurtured and pursued their interests by openly aligning
themselves and making a common cause with the Muslim Jagirdars. The mullahs with obscurantism and
intolerance as their guiding - star strained every nerve and fibre to keep the Muslim masses away from the
light of education. The Sheikh sought and accepted their support and patronage and the fact that all the
mullahs in the city of Srinagar lending their wholehearted support to the Reading Room Party which was
presided over by the demon of Muslim bigotry testifies to its role-profile of inciting communal passions
and awakening furies against their religious enemies. The Muslim elite in government service were
ambitious of grabbing higher positions not on the strength of their merit and achievements, but on the
basis of religion they espoused and held.
The Reading Room Party with mosque as its immediate extension emerged as a focal centre for execution
and fructification of the British intrigues against the Maharaja who for his anti-British stances was
pressured and cowed down to hand over the complete control of the Gilgit Agency to the Britishers for
their strategic ends. As per available evidences, Sheikh Abdullah who had started strutting the religio-
political scene of Kashmir through his faculty of reciting the Quranic verses in a mellifluous voice in and
outside the precincts of a mosque had forged clandestine linkages with the British Political Department
which in essence was a receptacle of the British and Indian spies recruited by the British imperialists for
garnering their political interests.
The plethora of letters that the Sheikh had written to the spies of the Political Department explicitly reveal
his direct and definite bonhomie with the British operatives planning and executing measures and
schemes to nurse and safeguard their vital interests in Kashmir. Sheikh Abdullah in the role of a British
agent was first highlighted and thoroughly exposed in a very significant article published by the 'Blitz' in
its issue of 24th April, 1965 and the same was reproduced verbatim by H.L. Saxena in his book 'The
Tragedy in Kashmir'. The details in the article are comprehensive and are fully substantiated by the letters
written by the Sheikh to his mentors whose patronage he sought and enjoyed at the threshold of his
religio-political career till he emerged as a formidable force for the Maharaja to reckon with.
The Sheikh motivated by and suffused with pan-Islamism of Dr. Iqbal and communalism of the brand of
Aligrah Muslim university has been openly charged with being in regular correspondence and contact
with B.J.Glancy, Col. C. W. Colvin and Lt. Col . L.E. Lang who had been deputed on a mission and had
earned notoriety for spying operations in the Punjab and Kashmir. The mission that was said to be
entrusted to the Sheikh and for which he was said to be roped in was to breed discontent and
disenchantment among the Muslims of Kashmir and alienate them from the Maharaja and his power
apparatus and also beat Kashmiri Pandits into submission for their vociferous and strident anti - British
views and expressions.
It was notoriously known that the Sheikh had pro -Ahmadiya persuasions and links though Muslims as a
flock detested them as deviants from Islam. It was through the British spies that the Sheikh was said to
have formed a close rapport with the Ahmadiyas who had a well - cemented organisation and were highly
rich and affluent. In their political positions the Ahmadiyas were known as British lackeys and footmen.
For being affiliated with the Britishers and also for the tonnes of money they spent in Kashmir for
furtherance of their mission and also for Muslim welfare by way of instituting scholarships for Muslim
boys the Sheikh established a tie - up with the Ahmadiyas operating in the Punjab where they were
equally suspected and abhorred by the orthodox Muslims. His bonhomie and nexus with the Ahmadiyas
was an open secret and there were lot many groups and individuals who not only resented, but bitterly
opposed his political and religious affinity and contacts with the Ahmadiyas. The Sheikh perhaps at the
bidding of his masters not only invited but paved the way for the Ahmadiya intervention in Kashmir.
Crafty as the British spies were, they doled out an impression to the Maharaja that the Ahmadiyas were
their stark enemies and warned him of their anti - state activities and designs, but aware of the nexus
between the Britishers and Ahmadiyas, Maharaja Hari Singh in doldrums, despite his brave face, dared
not devise and execute stern measures to thwart and put an end to the Ahmadiya intervention in Kashmir.
Ahrars with their progressive camouflage were on the same wave - length with the Ahmadiyas in their
anti -Maharaja and anti-Hindu threats and agitations. Apparently votaries of Hindu - Muslim amity, the
Ahrars through the despatch of their Jathas and groups into the State created conditions for loot and
murder of Hindus. Stridently anti - Maharaja and seemingly anti - British, the Ahrars objectively
contributed to the British design of fomenting and proliferating the communal conflicts and tensions to
de-stabilise the Maharaja to further the imperialist designs and machinations. Kashmir practically marked
a reversal of their policy of inter-communal peace and amity as they vigorously fanned and fuelled
Muslim communalism to incredible limits. Their commitment to the congress as a secular organisation
was so fake and tenuous that they deserted the congress ranks to join the Muslim League or formed their
own outfits in the wake of M.A. Jinnah's declaration of Pakistan as the separate home-land for Muslims.
The Reading Room Party was closely knit with Ahrars and basked in their patronage and was maintaining
a regular liaison with them for political and religious mischief. The Ahrars essentially were communal
though they externally donned secular robes. They had hatred for the Maharaja as he was a Hindu and had
Muslims as his subjects. Their vigorous programme of despatching groups (Jathas) into the state was also
perceived to counter-act the political hold that the Ahmadiyas were fast gaining in Kashmir through
lavish spending.
The Punjabi Muslim press under the lavish patronage of the British imperialists launched a propaganda
blitz against the Maharaja who was denounched as a heretic with no right to rule over Muslim masses.
The tone and tenor of the published material was blatantly sectarian and communal inciting the Muslims
to launch a crusade against the Hindu Maharaja and his Hindu administration. The Muslim outlook' and
'Inqalab' as the two front-ranking dailies published from the Punjab fabricated and disseminated wanton
lies and half - truths about Kashmir conveying the same theme - song of incitement to revolt against the
Hindu ruler and his administration. The dailies couched and soaked in the language of fire and brimstone
and more than most communal venom were extremely popular with the members of the Reading Room
Party which was committed to the working out of the assigned task of inciting the communal passions and
igniting the communal fires to pave way for direct British intervention in Kashmir affairs.
Puts M.K.Teng, "Journals and akhbars issued from Lahore and elsewhere taking up the cause of Muslims
were patronised by the British to browbeat the Maharaja."
29.1 Qadeer - the Waiter
The British-Ahmadiya-Ahrar-Reading Room Party nexus cumulatively generated forces, evil and vicious,
which perpetrated loot and murder on the Kashmiri Pandits in the wake of a seditious speech delivered by
one named Qadeer, a cook in the employ of an English Major, a non-local, non-entity, illiterate and puny,
at the Mir Ali Mosque where Muslims had mobilised in unprecedented numbers for a political act of
selecting their representatives for an interface and dialogue with the Maharaja.
Who was Qadeer? How did he suddenly appear on the scene to spit out his Anti-Hindu venom? Who had
planted him? Who had given him contents for his speech? Who had guided him during rehearsals before
the actual delivery of his speech?
Such as these pertinent and vital questions have been deliberately obfuscated and smoke-screened by the
Reading Room Party and its prime mover Sheikh Abdullah lest their role in the nefarious game of
inflicting loot and murder on the Kashmiri Pandits should get revealed and exposed. P.N.Bazaz as a
contemporary was politically pro-active and had a penchant for dwelling on the faillings and foibles of the
Sheikh, but he too had maintained an intriguing silence on the issue of dramatic appearance of Qadeer,
the waiter, on the scene of the mosque, a centre-stage of Muslim politics and Muslim communalism, and
without irradiating it has broadly contributed to putting the issue under a thick cloak of secrecy. P.N.
Bamzai while detailing out the events leading to the loot and murder of Pandits has stopped short of
scratching the surface to unveil the real identity of Qadeer and his mentors. D.N. Dhar hat hit the nail on
the head when he quotes G.H. Khan that Qadeer was brought on the scene by Ahmadiyas who were
British agents but has failed to establish and formulate the whole spectrum.
Be it put that Qadeer was an Ahmadiya plant and as is well-known Ahmadiyas with their net-work were
in the thick of Kashmir politics and in the pursuit of their mission were spending incredible sums to lure
and buy followers for their creed and more than most had the credential of being British agents and had
cultivated complete rapport and deep links with the Reading Room Party functioning under the emergent
leadership of Sheikh Abdullah who had his patrons from amongst the top-brass of Muslim society known
as 'Rayisan-i-Kashmir'. Molvi Yusuf Shah's admission that Qadeer was catapulted on the scene by
Ahmadiyas exposes the whole circuit that could be held responsible for loot and murder of Kashmiri
Pandits.
If anybody can, let him controvert the thesis that it was British-Ahmadiya-Sheikh Abdullah nexus that
conspired to catapult Qadeer on the scene of the Mir Ali Mosque to precipitate a crisis for the Maharaja
and Kashmiri Pandits as the sigmatised enemies of Islam. It is a common sense averment that Qadeer
alien to the social and political milieu prevailing in Kashmir could not have dramatically mounted the dies
sans connivance, abetment and consent of the Reading Room Party and its chief mentors. The view that a
Muslim flaunting as an educationist had no mean role in preparing the contents of Qadeer's speech and
also honing up of his oratorical skills cannot be dismissed as a cock and bull story.
Dilating on the basic character of the communal uprising of 13th July 1931, D.N.Dhar proclaims," It was
the combination of Maulvis, landed interests and the merchantile bourgeoisie which was leading the
people for their vested interests. They had aroused the fury of the masses in the city not on concrete
economic and political issues, but on religious frenzy which led to a catastrophe."
He further puts, "Serious allegations have been made that the movement in 1931 had British
encouragement (involvement) and in fact it was sponsored by them and part of the leadership (the entire
Muslim leadership) acted at their behest. It is believed that they wanted to punish Maharaja Hari Singh for
his role at the Round Table Conference and his confrontation with them."
29.2 M.J. Akbar on Qadeer
M.J. Akbar's views on the Qadeer episode are replete with a penchant for investing a non-entity with a
heroic hue and aura. Qadeer, to him, seemed to 'discover a new-identits when he was in Kashmir as 'a
cook in the retinue of a European'. What was the identity that he discovered in Kashmir which otherwise
in Peshawar he was lacking? How was it that he suddenly found a new identity in Kashmir? Akbar hails
Qadeer's oratory as 'more spicy than his cuisine'? But, dismaying as it is, M.J. Akbar with all his calibre
has viewed and assessed the entire episode in the light of oratory and cuisine and has missed import of the
episode as part of a bigger game that the British played in accompaniment with their agents who were
roped in and harnessed to fulfill and execute their geo-political objectives Had he inquisitively probed
deeper, he would have discovered a sinister intrigue hatched by the BritishAhmadiya-Abdullah nexus to
destabilise the Maharaja for his anti-British postures and in the process would have known that Qadeer
was only a pawn to get things to a crisis - point paving way for direct British take liver of the state by
dislodging the Maharaja. Qadeer's oratory was doctored, packed with communal poison and was
inflammatory. His arrest and trial let loose communal frenzy which was directed towards the Kashmiri
Pandits like an artillery barrage.
29.3 P.N. Bazaz’s Rhetoric on the Loot of 1931
P.N.Bazaz in his characteristic fashion has dragged his feet from exposing the Reading Room Party for its
conspiratorial role in the perpetration of loot and murder on the Kashmiri Pandits. In a low key tone he
accuses the Reading Room Party of 'haying failed to cope with the situation'. He records that 'the Muslim
upper classes and communalists had an effective voice in the movement,' but bails out the Muslim
communalists by digressing into 'the discontent among the rank and file of Muslims'. He also accuses
Hindus of their 'hostile and positively indiscriminate attitudes towards the nationalistic and communalistic
aspirations of the Muslims. The riots that followed as per him were 'the work of goondas'.
With the glasses of Royism ever on his eyes P.N. Bazaz has made light of the 13th July, 1931 riots that
were communal in orientation, content and thrust and has resorted to digressions designed to camoulage
and obviate the religion-oriented motivations of the Muslims to loot and murder the Hindu Kafirs. That
the Muslims were backward, illiterate and wallowing in dust and dirt was the result of their Muslim
legacy bequeathed to them through six hundred years of Muslim rule and could be in no way the
handiwork of Pandits, who certainly were an advanced and civilised section of the Kashmiri society by
virtue of their liberalism and catholicity to orient themselves without undue interference from priest or
temple to the impact of new trends of thought and education. Mullahs as the ombudsmen of religious
interpretations and more than most as the religious police obstructed Muslims from taking to liberal
education free from the virus of fanaticism and were, in reality, their enemies who through a new
renaissance had to be thwarted and put at bay and if recalcitrant deserved to be targeted for their parochial
and obscurantist orientation sanctioned by religious tenets. Instead all the Mullahs were unequivocal in
their support of the Reading Room Party which had no radical and innovative programmes on its agenda
for the Muslim up liftment except that of widening and deepening the sphere of communal conflict and
strife in fulfillment of the assigned task.
The basic reality that Bazaz has missed and might be that he has willfully connived at it is the British
intrigue hatched with the active aid of Muslim agents affiliated with the Reading Room Party for putting
the Maharaja in a strait- Jacket and simultaneously punishing the Pandits for their anti-British sentiments.
The sudden act of pulling out a rabbit (Qadeer) from the hat of intriguers on the mosque site should have
set Bazaz a thinking about the conspiracy that the Britishers in tandem with the local Muslim leadership
drawn into their dragnet were un-ravelling with a view to removing the Maharaja for the direct take over
of his state. Riots were not the handiwork of goondas, but were deliberately and warily engineered and
were a fall-out of a well co-ordinated, systematic and carefully crafted endeavour to destabilise the state
and also not the result of mass discontent as there were no concrete and well-defined political and
economic issues involved. If there was discontent among the Muslims, the Bengali and Punjabi Muslims
ruling roost in the state by holding key-slots in the state services could have been the targets of their fury.
But leaving them comfortable and unharmed in their ivory towers, the Kashmiri Pandits as a target group
since the advent of Islam were looted, marauded and murdered with ferocious vengeance.
The Muslim vested interests as represented by Khwaja Saduddin Shawl, Syed Hussian Jalali, Kwaja
Shahabuddin et al known as the Rayeesani Kashmir were not looted and marauded. Was it because they
were Muslims? Most of them as the drones and exploiters of Muslims hobnobbed with Maharaja and
lived off his crumbs and enjoyed his munificence and benevolence and owned huge landed properties and
had enormous wealth and riches. Sheikh Abdullah as buttressed by a panoply of evidence had struck
back-room deals with them and were his political patrons and allies and it was under their patronage and
guidance that he set up and perfected the precedent and practice of overlaying mundane politics with
religion for communal mobilizations and riots.
P. N. Bazaz has pandered the Muslim tactics of levelling accusations and floating canards against the
Pandits whenever Muslims are up for a revolt or insurgency or Jehad. Being in the thick of Kashmir
Politics he should have evaluated the pros and cons of Hindu-Muslim tension that had gripped Kashmir
way back in 1910. The petition that was submitted to Maharaja on 18th September, 1910 underscored the
general rumour that the valley Muslims had a malicious intention of plundering Hindus on the same
pattern as the Shias were looted and ravaged in 1872-73 in the wake of Maharaja's departure for Jammu.
The factors motivating Muslims to loot and plunder Hindus have been more religious than economic.
Summing up the communalism leading to the loot anti plunder of Kashmiri Pandits and other Hindus
U.K. Zutshi writes, "The primary task of the leaders of 1931 agitation including Sheikh Abdullah was to
seek the acceptance of the long standing Muslim demand of proportional representation in state services.
This was a communal demand and had to be necessarily sought from a sectional platform. The demand
was clearly informed by the communal ideology The nature of the demand and the ideology in which it
was clothed leads to the conclusion that the agitation in 1931 was communal in character. Since it was the
communal forces that mobilised the masses and invoked their support against the Maharaja's government
the mass political awakening came to be enveloped by a communal ideology and was inevitably
accompanied by communal discord."
Drawing an unadorned picture of the happenings of 13th July, 1931 loot and plunder of Hindus,
G.S.Raghvan writes, "From Bohrikadal to Ali-Kadal - a long stretch - the Hindu shops were raided. Other
localities such as Safakadal, Ganjikhud, and Nawakadal too formed the centres of loot. Bazar streets were
littered with property, books of accounts were burnt; the Hindu shop-keepers were molested, in short,
pandemonium prevailed. The Hindu merchants lost lakhs worth of goods."
He further writes, "The most extra-ordinary portion of the story was that, almost simultaneously with the
happenings at Srinagar, there was an uprising at a place named Vicharnag, some 5 to 6 miles away. It has
been stated that untold atrocities were committed there; men owning lakhs were reduced to indigence and
women were subjected to the worst possible cruelties and the most indecent assaults. A military force was
despatched to the place, but by the time the havoc had been completed. Elsewhere the Hindus were the
victims of ambuscade. Some lost their lives and many suffered physical injuries. Stray assaults continued
till long after."
He continues, " It is true that the unspeakable atrocities of July were visited on the Hindus, robbing
women of honour. subjecting children to assaults and reducing the wealthy to penury."
A report was carried by the Tribune about the loot and murder of Kashmiri Hindus in its issue date-lined
18th July, 1931. The report reads as under:
THE KASHMIR RIOT
Harrowing Scenes
SCHOOL BOYS HURLED INTO RIVER
(Special to the "Tribune")
Srinagar July 14
Kashmir had hardly recovered from the shock of the floods, when it witnessed an orgy of communal
riving, which was unprecedented in the modern history of Kashmir. The authorities had decided to
conduct the trial for sedition of Abdul Qadir, a cook of European, in the Central Jail, because owing to
mischievous propaganda disorder was feared. Accordingly all the Magistrates, including the Governor of
Kashmir, had gone over to the Jail and all the courts in the city were automatically closed.
29.4 Police Attacked
At noon about a thousand Muslims gathered outside the Central Jail and there in defiance of the law
arranged a meeting. The Police Superintendent ordered them to disperse but they refused. The
Superintendent next ordered his constables to disperse the unlawful assembly. He had hardly given these
orders when the mob which had swelled into thousands charged the small police force present with
brickbats. The mob, inspire of police resistance, broke open the Jail gate and set a barrack on fire. The
small prison guard fired and a few Mohammadans died. About ten deaths are reported. A short time later
cavalry Police and military force arrived. Alarm bugle was sounded.
29.5 Rioting in City
Wild rumours spread in the city. The Muslims had already been observing a complete hartal since the
morning but now the Hindu shops are closed. The mischief - mongers, realising that all the forces, were
centred round the Central Jail, a place 3 miles away from the city, decided upon raiding the houses and
shops of the Hindus in the city. There seemed to be a well- organised conspiracy behind all this. The
telephone and electric wires were cut off, and about six thousand Mohammadans raided Maharaja Gunj,
looting and plundering the Hindus of the vicinity. Then followed harrowing scenes of incendiarism. No
military or police aid reached those quarters for full two hours during which hundreds of Hindus had been
looted and hundreds of them were injured with lathis and stones and incalculable damage was caused to
Hindu property. Visitors were also not spared, they were severely belaboured, and every thing, even their
shoes and turbans, were removed from their persons. Cars and buses were stoned and smashed. When the
military and police force did arrive, it found the mob beyond control; and it was not before 7 in the
evening that the havoc abated. Children, while returning from their schools, are reported to have been
picked up and hurled in the river Jehlum. Hindu women were insulted and maltreated. The Magistrates,
military soldiers and police constables were stoned and many got wounded. State buses carrying the
soldiers were also stoned and drivers wounded. The police had to open fire at Maharaja Gunj also. A few
casualties are reported among Mohammadans. But inspire of all this the mob did not disperse and
continued looting and wandering.
29.6 Order Restored
At last order was restored by energetic action of the State forces. Among the 15 deaths reported so far due
to police firing almost all are Muslims. Many Hindus, including women are missing. In the night curfew
order and section 144 were promulgated. They are still in force in the city. Services of more military have
been requisitioned, The city is observing a complete hartal. Panic prevails. In Amerakadal the Hindu
shops are open. Military and police are patrolling the city. All business is at a stand still. Colleges,
schools, courts and offices remain closed. Except for the General Post-office all other post - offices are
also closed. About 150 arrests have been made so far. House searches are being made to recover looted
property. Unconfirmed reports of looting, plundering and belabouring of Hindus have also been received
from Vicharnag.
30 C ha pte r 25 - L O O T O F L A N D E D P R O P E R T IE S
The National Conference having risen from the debris of Reading Room Party and Muslim conference
continued with its Anti-Kashmiri Pandit campaign and thrust culminating in the loot of landed properties
which in most of the cases were purchased by the owners with the moneys raised from the sale of
ornaments and other precious possessions. A Land Reforms committee with a Hindu careerist as its
fulcrum, a mere matriculate, granted extension upon extension, to sanctify the loot, was appointed in
April, 1948 with the patent mandate of drafting a full-scale reforms programme for the transfer of land to
the tillers after the abolition of big landed estates. The land reforms considered as a means to the
betterment of the lot of peasantry could not be rationally opposed, but how shoddily they were scribbled,
much less drafted and hastily implemented betrayed bias and vengeance. The Land Reforms committee
was not membered and led by eminent experts and reputed economists who could have drawn a fool-
proof reforms programme in accordance with the principles of fairness and equity. The vision and
perspective of its members was so limited and circumscribed that all available contemporary models
perfected only after proper experimentation were neither studied nor cognised for effective guidance and
subsequent implementation. The Soviet-type co-operative and collective farms failed to inspire the
committee members though land reforms considered vital to the processes of socio-economic
transformation were upheld by the communists who had played a key-role in drafting the New Kashmir
document. The manner land reforms were executed convinced all and sundry that it was a virtual loot
lerpetrated on the Kashmiri Pandits.
The local National Conference leaders and activists, mostly political leaders, in unison with the
designated revenue authorities at district and village level worked out the pre-determined mala-fide
objective of dispossessing the Pandits of their meagre landed properties. Wrath and fury unprecedented in
scale was generated against them as they had been cunningly projected as the only section possessing
landed properties. The names of Hindu landlords who were only two in number were frequently projected
as the exploiters and blood-suckers to solidify the ranks of Muslims on religious grounds for nefarious
political objectives. Ahmad Mir and Musmat Ashraf Begum possessing 4,202 kanals of land and 3,915
kanals of land respectively were never projected on the public mindscape because of the religion they
espoused. Two Muslim shrines of Baba Reshi and Dastagir Sahib had a land grant of ten thousand kanals
which are said to have been partially snatched away perhaps again on religious considerations. Despite
the Hindu ruler, there was no Hindu shrine which had in its possession the same measure of land to
augment and supplement its resources. Land reforms at the grass-root level were craftily used as a ploy to
sharpen the cleavage between the Hindus and the Muslims.
Lands were looted and usurped by the Muslims when the Kashmiri Pandits were bereft of constitutional
guarantees and safeguards as the people of India had yet to draft and adopt a constitution with a list of
fundamental rights and duties. Even the state had yet to give a constitution unto itself with a view to
creating a state within the state. The Kashmiri Pandits were not aliens, but bonafide citizens of the state of
India and before a loot was perpetrated on them, they had every right to defend themselves against such a
cruel atrocity. Sheikh Abdullah as the head of an Emergency Administration and Interim government
drawing executive authority only from the ruler whom he detested the most hastily embarked upon the
infliction of the loot on the Pandits who as per Islamic tenets could not own land and were maligned for
owning even small holdings of land and hence spurred by the same motivation could not be spared from
the sharp scissors of the land reforms. At the behest of Britishers and communal elements operating from
Lahore and elsewhere he had waged a sectarian battle against the Maharaja ostensibly to install a
responsible government, which under clear cut enunciations underlines a government responsible to the
legislature comprising the elected members on the basis of adult franchise. Was there any legislature
when the processes of land grabbing were given a push up? Was there a supervening constitution
sanctified under a due democratic process that would have invested the citizens with justiciable rights
flowing from it? The state of Jammu and Kashmir despite its accession to the nascent dominion of India
had yet to constitute itself as an integral part of the union in accordance with the requirements of a
modern nation- state.
Sheikh Abdullah committed a fraud on the Hindus when he made open declarations about the impending
land reforms from the pulpit of National Conference much before the reforms were formulated and
enacted as law. The Muslim landlords taking the cue and already aware of the dates for the enactment of
land reforms, to be exact, tipped off in advance, entered into quick negotiations with their Muslim tenants
and showed the lands under self-cultivation or distributed the lands beyond the stipulated ceiling among
their family members. The Hindu landlords were at a definite disadvantage as they could not exploit the
religious sentiments the same way as Muslims could. It was construed as a deliberate move revealing a
design to save the Muslim landlords from the clutches of arbitrary land reforms, which were pushed
against the Pandits right from 1947. The arbitrariness of the act was sanctified in a vengeful and brazen
manner by adding a sub-clause to the Act when the constituent Assembly was constituted in 1951.
The Hindus for the fact that they were Hindus and Kafirs at war were not paid any compensation when
tracts of land were snatched away and grabbed from them despotically and arbitrarily. The Land
Compensation Committee was conceived and set up as an eye-wash and a hoax and in utter disregard of
material grounds and facts it upheld the arbitrary executive fiat and unjustly fortified the fraud that was
committed on the land -owners by the Interim Government in the name of so-called socio-economic
reconstruction. As per the report of the said-committee. "To support compensation to such persons will be
like telling the tillers that though they morally owned the land, they must buy it from those 'who did not
morally own it ". What does 'morally owned the land' mean? What does 'who did not morally own it'
mean? The National Conference was ethnically cleansing a community by snatching away its main
succour and sustenance without allowing and opening up other channels for its survival and rehabitation
and compensation committee was vying with morals and quoting scriptures when what it was sanctifying,
upholding and contributing to was stark violation of all norms of ethics and its genuine tenets.
To possess land in terms of law means to own land and as is amply known possession is three-fourths of
law. The land was in actual possession of landholders who after due processes of revenue settlement and
verification legitimately conducted from time to time were enlisted as assamis by W.R. Lawrence and
invested with ownership rights with powers to sell and mortgage by B.J. Glancy and therefore not only
deserved compensation but had to be compensated as dictated by law for the losses they were incurring
when lands were inthe processes of being snatched away for distribution among Muslims. But law was
perverted and subverted with all cussedness and it has been so in Kashmir since 1947.
The compensation committee has recorded in acknowledgement that there were some proprietors who
had purchased their tracts of land very recently, but despite it, they were not shown consideration and
mercy and were brushed off their purchased properties with the same prejudice and vengeance. The
committee has also recorded that they had made huge profits from the landed property which they had
purchased and hence in view of it they could not be paid compensation. What a logic? The committee
labouring under severe communal prejudice failed to learn from the basic principle of commerce that
properties are made held and purchased with a view to making profits. The committee virtually played the
proverbial wolf and lamb with the Pandits ownring small tracts of land known as 'Chaks'. The orchardists
were not dispossessed on one pretext or the other as the Pandits were nor were their orchards put to a
ceiling because they are mostly Muslims and they are known world over for having made profits worth
crores and having amassed amazing assets and properties.
Records R.K.Bharti, "The Land is taken without compensation when Hindus are involved.
When Muslim novo-rich (VIPs) are involved the Act has taken care of them by providing 'prevalent
market rates' under schedule-III Part B of the Act."
Intriguing as it is huge orchards owned by the Muslim rich have not been brought within the purview of
land reforms. The Agrarian Reforms Act of 1972 as a satanic act had exempted the orchards laid out
before 1971 from a ceiling limit, but had prescribed and stipulated for a ceiling limit for the orchards laid
out and cultivated after 1971 Why were orchards laid out prior to 1971 put beyond the purview of a
ceiling limit? Why were orchards laid out after 1971 put to a ceiling limit? There was apparently no
logical or even reasonable basis for the said-stipulations, but all these stipulations smacked of communal
considerations and motivations. The Muslims had already laid out orchards which needed protection and
legitimacy and the Act provided such protection and legitimacy by incorporating illogical and
meaningless provisions. And Mir Qasim was the architect of these reforms with brimming communal
content in them.
Sheikh Abdullah in the wake of his take-over in 1975 as Chief Minister of the state caused the Act to be
amended in post-haste with a view to putting the orchards beyond any prescribed limit thus affording
lavish patronage and leverage both political and economic to the apple-sheikhs whose orchards endlessly
sprawl over acres upon acres of land with no perceptible curbs to their proliferation. It is believed that the
Sheikh and his close relatives owning huge orchards in the valley have vitalised and fortified their
interests in land against any onslaught in the form of setting a ceiling limit to their proliferation.
The orchard syndrome in reality reflects the creation of 'Kulaks' who enjoy tremendous levels of opulence
and prosperity at the expense of that segment of rural poor who were left out and not considered with
seriousness for allotment of land the time lands were snatched away ostensibly for distribution among the
landless. As the apple-sheikhs are rolling in enormous riches, there is a proclivity fast proliferating to
convert the cultivable lands though illegal into orchards and governments of varied brands infiltrated and
throttled by the Kulaks have as a matter of design stifled any attempt to thwart the tendency of
formulating and undertaking legal measures and introducing a ceiling limit as a matter of prime
importance for orchards as well. Kashmiri Pandits as victims to Muslim-tyranny suffered the main thrust
of the so-called land reforms and thus have been illegally deprived of their landed properties by blocking
all channels of redressal. But, now, when it is the Muslim Kulak at the land site, the politicals of all hues
and shades communally motivated garner and perpetuate his interests and hence there is no necessity felt
to frame committees upon committees to formulate dubious plans to trim and clip his wings from further
forages into the agricultural lands.
Comments D.N.Dhar." that Sheikh Abdullah had a tendency towards the development of Kulak economy
in the rural side. It may be appropriate to mention here that during his tenure of office, there were no
leftist elements either in his ministry or in the organization. In tact, he had developed abhorrence for such
elements. He did not even refer too often to the New Kashmir programme and his commitment to it."
Had land reforms been conceived honestly without communal bias these should have benefited and
shown concern for that section of the ruralites which was landless and therefore economically bereft and
at bottom line and wallowing in absolute poverty and deprivation. As is well known the reforms as such
were no longer a boon for the landless poor who as per a random estimate are no fewer than 30,000 in
number and are obliged to migrate to the heat and dust of plains for earning a pittance.
Why was not surplus land acquired by the government of Sheikh Abdullah from the big landlords by the
abolition of their estates distributed among the landless labourers on a priority basis? How was it that
despite their abominable conditions and bottom-line penury they were totally ignored and shown
indifference and jibing contempt? Their as the real rural poor should have been the first to be the
beneficiaries of the reforms which the fact remains were executed without cogent planning and fixation of
primary priorities.
Records D.N. Dhar, "Despite the fact that land reforms had led to enormous disparities in incomes in the
rural side find had created a big void between-the rich and the poor, it had led to general prosperity and
affluence. The fruits of this prosperity could have been fairly enjoyed by all sections of the village
community, had not the creation of Kulaks led to the depriving of a large section of rural population from
sharing good proportion of the land thus taken away from the landlords.""
The Muslim novo-rich, ruling elite, M.L.As, M.Ps, Government Officers, Judges and Tehsildars et al
owning enormous landed properties are a new class of Kulaks who do not cultivate the land themselves as
full-time occupation, but employ cheap wage labour from Bihar and West Bengal. As per the Act the
essential condition for ownership of land presumably is that the proprietor in fulfilment of his title has to
till the land himself, but this new class of Kulaks having taken to multiform trades and varied jobs is
proliferating at a fast and furious rate and continues to own land in fact and law. Various Acts passed
under different shades of governments have straightaway left out the Muslim Kulaks as immune for the
fact that they are Muslims and their interests are supreme and as a matter of concerted state policy have to
be garnered and sate guarded.
Discriminatory as it is, as per the Agrarian Reforms Act of 1976 the Kashmiri Pandits though allowed
resumption of land for bonafide cultivation have been mischievously put to the rigorous condition of
proving their residence at the land site and are said to be required to personally take to tillage in the
villages where lands are sought to be resumed. There are a host of other inhibiting conditions which the
Pandits are required to fulfill before they are allowed actual resumption. But the Muslim Kulaks continue
to enjoy fair share of prosperity without any intervention from government sponsored stipulations and
measures.
The Land Reforms Committee, a puppet created under an executive fiat, fixed an individual as a unit of
cultivation, not a family. This fundamental absurdity and irrationality was not a freak, but a deliberate
piece of design to enable the Muslim tenants, who already had their own tracts of land, to have big estates
comparable to the ones possessed by Chakdars. The head of a family with five sons (Muslims have yet to
accept family planning) was entitled to own as much of land as was permitted within the ceiling limit and
his five sons could hold the same measure of land individually and thus the family could possess a
sizeable land holding. Then, again, the six members of the same family could possess and own exempted
lands again on an individual basis. It will not be off course to say that the deliberate act of presuming and
establishing an individual as a unit of cultivation led to the creation and proliferation of a class of peasants
who are prosperous and affluent at the expense of landless labour left uncared for and high and dry.
There are examples galore that pinpoint to the unscientific character and sheer worthlessnessof the entire
exercise of land reforms. Land belonging to a Hindu widow completely dependent on it for succour was
grabbed and given to an apple-sheikh. A Hindu land - owner who had retired and was living on a meagre
pension lost his lands to a Muslim millionaire. A land holder was a petty school teacher whose land was
snatched and transferred to a Muslim gazetted officer flaunting pomp and riches. The lands belonging to
the deaf and dumb, morons, mental degenerates, physically disabled, cripples and handicapped - all
Kashmiri Pandits, were grabbed and transferred to apple-sheikhs, businessmen and affluent sections of
Muslims with assets enormous and unlimited.
The Hindus and Sikhs were virtually put on the hit-list of the government and as a result of the hate
campaign unleashed against them the revenue authorities in collaboration with the National Conference
lumpens and communist ideologues subjected them to the worst brand of intimidation and tyranny much
before the enactment of land reforms as law. Revenue records which were kept and maintained flawlessly
were suddenly tampered with, manipulated, mutilated and erased. Frauds committed were unscrupulous
and base. Manipulationsdevised were shameless and communally motivated. Revenue authorities
expected to be just and objective became law unto themselves and working out behests from the powers
that be flouted legal procedures and practices in all vengefulness. Harassment and intimidation of a Pandit
or a Sikh was not a matter of aberration, but an over-riding rule. In fact, rule of law was replaced by the
rule of Jungle.
There was a startling precedent set by a Muslim Tehsildar in Baramulla who without rhyme or reason
yelled 'Hindu-Muslim-Itihad-Zindabad' and took up his blind pen and transferred the lands of a Sikh to a
Muslim sitting in his revenue court. Having learnt about the atrocity, the Sikh despite his fighting spirits
and bravado meekly and helplessly filed an appeal to the same maverick officer, who was never
reprimanded and disciplined for the despotic act he had committed, instead earned accolades and praises
Galore from the powers that be. There was vet another example signalling collapse of law set by the
Muslim hordes who intruded into the orchards of a Sikh residing at Badgam and chopped off all the fruit -
bearing trees in one go and had the audacity to claim the land under their tenancy and astonishingly the
revenue authorities without any gualms and queries registered the mutations in the name of Muslim
plunderers thereby legalising the entire brutality and encroachment. As the orchards are not subject to a
ceiling limit courtesy Sheikh Abdullah's Agrarian Reforms Act of 1976, the cultivators exploiting
religious sentiments and deeply conscious of the flight of law and its enforcement agencies transformed
agricultural lands into orchards and the revenue authorities, most Muslims, abetted and connived at the
blatant outrage and defiance of law.
.Mirza Afzal Beg who was the Revenue Minister and headed the Land Reforms Committee was a ruralite
and was believed to own large tracts of land, but people maintain that he along with his close kins enjoyed
absolute immunity from the scalpel of land reforms. Ghulam Hassan Malik, a relation of Afzal Beg and
one-time M.L.A. from Devasar, District Anantnag was a well-known landlord, but as per the statements
of the natives of his village he continued to lord over his huge estate as Afzal Beg in lieu of his switch
over to National Conference from Yusuf Shah's camp is said to have immunised him against the virus of
land reforms and its attendant damage by tipping him off m advance about the dates when land would be
grabbed from Hindus by an enactment. The family of Razdans residing at Salia, District Anantnag had out
of prudence or foresight distributed the lands under their possession among natural heirs much before loot
was perpetrated on the Pandits, but Afzal Beg with his known credentials bearing personal grudge and
animosity against the family was said to have caused the mutations cancelled albeit their registration by
competent revenue authorities under due process of law.
Mir Qasim whose studies at Aligarh Muslim University were financed by Hindu Communists had learnt
many a lesson in communal politics in his capacity as Private Secretary to Afzal Beg. Being vengeful and
communally motivated he did not rest content with the abolition of big landed estates, but engineered the
total erosion of the rural base of Kashmiri Pandits through the Agrarian Reforms Act of 1972 delineating
the most irrational and unjustprovisions for compensation to the landowners thereby ending their aeons-
old tryst with land which they legally owned. The categorization of land masses accordant with a number
of factors was not scientifically carried out and despite its shoddiness did not contribute to the fixation of
reasonable prices for the said - lands. A kanal of land categorised as the best in terms of productivity,
situation, and soil chemistry was priced at a mockingly low sum of one thousand rupees when its actual
existing market rate ranged from 5 to 10 lakhs. The other grades of land as per their quality, location and
irrigational network were priced for a trice. The tenant as per the black Act selling the same land could
sell it at existing market rates. As stipulated in the black Act, the compensation to be paid to the owner
was fixed in proportion to the share of produce that the owner was coerced to accept under tyrannical
regimes. The compensation for a measure of land if acquired by government in public interest was to be
paid not to the owner but to the tiller who is a Muslim. The plethora of measures as enunciated in the
black Act of 1972 were biased and communal in intent and substance and to the knowledge of all were
contrived to the sinister end of grabbing land from Pandits for transfer to the Muslims.
As per the provisions of the black Act, the Pandits were bereft of their share of produce and their tillers
were directed to deposit the said-share of produce with the revenue authorities designated for the purpose
who in turn would manage the transmission of it to the owner either in cash or in kind. It did not take
Pandits much time to sense the conspiracy that was hatched at governmental level to uproot them from
their rural ambience and end their age old love-affair with the lands that they had legally purchased.
Despite all forms of lawful protests including submission of representations and memoranda, the Mir
Qasim government with an open nexus with fundamentalist forces sponsored by Jamaat-i-Islami proved
apathetic and unresponsive and that was how Kashmiri Pandits formed village level committees to fight
back the provisions of the black Act conceived to ethnically cleanse them.
Trilochan Dutt, the then Revenue Minister, who had tremendous history in politics, failed to prove smart
and nifty to smell the communal tilt discernibly prominent in the black Act and despite pleadings and
plaints from the Pandits he prevaricated on an issue that was of prime importance for them as their fate in
their natural habitat was being sealed by the very Congress government he formed a part of. On his
official visit to Hanand Chawalgam, District Anantnag, he had to face an avalanche of fury unleashed by
Kashmiri Pandits determined to wage a do or die battle against the communal government of Mir Qasim.
Pandits in swarming numbers from the nearby and distant villages turned up to plead with the Minister for
annulment of the satanic Act as it had driven a last nail into their coffin. To the surprise of all, a Kashmiri
Pandit granny suddenly appeared on the scene and tearing through the thick crowds, she in all her fury
slapped the Minister in his face and weeping and wailing yelled that she had not eaten for the last four
days. In his utter consternation, sensing more trouble, the Minister beat a retreat into the Rest House and
chased by the violent mob he entered the bath-room for refuge where he was said to have suffered the
wrath of giant sized bees and drones and the police posse standing by for the security of the Minister
maintained cool otherwise a bullet if fired would have resulted in a blood-bath. The Minister buzzed off
the scene quietly. This was the first ever resistance that the Pandits registered against the so-called land
reforms.
The violent incident sent shock waves into the government circles and the family of Mir Qasim. As a
result the government already in the lap of communal forces proved stiffer than the stiff and continued
with its policy of landing the Pandits into dire straits. Sayyid Hussian, brother of Mir Qasim, propping
himself up on his cretches, yelled his lungs out to tell and exhort the Muslims to bury the Pandits alive if
they dared ask for their share of produce. Sayyid Hussain, a non-entity, who had entered politics courtesy
Mir Qasim, was taught by a Kashmiri Pandit languishing in poverty and deprivation. How could Mir
Qasim maintain silence when his brother had already thundered against the Pandits? He asked the native
Hindus to march out of Kashmir and 10-feet wide road was all open for them. Mir Qasim's fiat to the
Pandits was a pointer to the agenda that the ruthless Muslim bigotry in all vengeance had framed for them
through the "twenty humiliating conditions" stipulating their total and ruthless annihilation if they dare
flout any of the conditions imposed on them in a state ruled by Muslims.
30.1 Daniel Thorner on Land Reforms
Daniel Thorner, a die-hard French Communist, who paid a visit to Kashmir during the period land
reforms were implemented and enacted has the following remarks:
"From 1948 to 1950 propaganda warfare between pro and anti-Pakistan elements was acute. Faced with
what looked like an imminent plebiscite on the question of possible accession to Pakistan Sheikh
Abdullah was not wholly confident of support they could muster among the peasantry. To capture the
imagination of peasants, to take their minds off the external issue of Pakistan and redeem the National
Conference's old promises of far-reaching land reforms Sheikh Abdullah's regime in 1950 rushed through
the drastic Act."
He adds, "The basic machinery for enforcing the Act was to be the notorious crowd of Kashmir Revenue
Department dating back to the regime of Maharaja. The machinery was utilised because there was no
other in existence and because National Conference motivated by the special sense of urgency arising
from the plebiscite issue felt it lacked time in which to create an alternative enforcement agency. The
National Conference Government did not entrust enforcement solely to the officers of the Revenue
Department, but was associatedwith them at the village level some of the conference's own local political
leaders. The intention was for the latter to check on the acts of the former. In the actual process of
implementation, however, the two elements cooperated all too Bell with each other at the expense of
"actual tillers"
He further adds, "Land reforms in Kashmir has clearly done away with the Jagirs and has weakened the
position of all the great land-lords. It has distinctly benefited those individuals who at the village level
were already the more important and substantial people. It has done the least for petty tenants and landless
labourers, these two categories being the largest in the country side."
Taking the wind out of the sails of publicity given to land reforms Daniel Thorner writes, 'India's most
publicised land reforms cannot be said to have succeeded in improving the economic lot of the Kashmiri
peasant. Whether the legislation was well conceived for this purpose remains debatable."
Comments he, "In some areas it looked as though the ordinary peasant was confronted with a more
formidable combination than he had faced under the rather ramshackle regime of the Maharaja."
31 C ha pte r 26 - L O O T O F A K A S H M IR I P A N D IT G IR L
Kashmiri Pandits closed their ranks and fortified their fronts as one monolith to retrieve a Kashmiri
Pandit girl, Parmeshwari by name, from the clutches of a Muslim abductor who virtually looted her as a
prized booty forconversion and subsequent marriage. Despite plaints and pleadings, the government of
G.M. Sadiq trapped by the Muslim fundamentalists and Pakistani moles manning vital levers of power
brazenly flouted all canons of law and natural justice and treated the entire gamut of the issue in the
fashion as was expected of Muslims. The Muslim police officers were in the lead-role and far from
camouflaging their anti-Hindu prejudices they shifted the venue of investigations from the Police Station,
Rainwawari where an FIR was lodged by the widowed mother of the abducted girl to the Police Station,
Khanyar which has been a den of Muslim bigotry and reaction. When hard pressed by the public opinion,
tile girl was recovered from Wazapore, a seminary of Muslim secessionism, but as presaged was not
restored to the care of her natural guardian nor was the Muslim looter charged with abduction for
punishment as required and stipulated by law.
The Kashmiri Pandits with an unabated history of harassment and religious persecution rose in open
revolt against the rulers who refused to see reason and motivated by religious prejudices overtly showered
support and encouragement on the Muslim abductor earning total sympathies from the Muslim majority.
The Muslim rulers as a matter of design kept the Pandits at bay by not associating them with the
procedural complications which were deliberately created to feed and arouse the demon of Muslim
bigotry. What was infuriating that the aggrieved mother of the looted girl was permitted to meet her
daughter only under police surveillance. No Kashmiri Pandit respectables were granted permission to
meet the girl with a view to measuring her reactions to the situation in which she was trapped. The said-
demand on part of Pandits was blatantly rejected lest the abducted girl interned in the Police Station
should retract from the stand that she was doctored and coerced to take a resort to. The police officers, all
Muslims, assigning Judicial powers unto themselves permitted the Muslim malefactor to take away the
abducted girl ignoring the authenticity of the age-certificate issued by a competent authority establishing
her credentials as a minor. As the case was virtually settled by the Muslim police officers, the Kashmiri
Pandits were naturally pushed to the wall and launched a peaceful agitation against the questionable act of
the government which had approved the handing over of the abducted girl to the comma.
Despite the soft statements of the Chief- Minister, the government of the day cracked the whip of
barbarity against the Pandit community, which exhibited unique will and daring to put a stop to the
forcible abduction and conversion of Hindu women. The Pandits courted arrests, held dharnas and staged
peaceful demonstrations to ventilate their vigorous opposition to the beetle-chewing Chief Minister,
G.M.Sadiq, who had facilitated and given a pushup to the sneaking-in processes of anti-nationals and
Plebiscite fronters into the kelp organs of power structure.
Kashmir Police long infected of communal virus swooped on Pandits with the fury of a crusade.
Indiscriminate arrests were effected, teargas shells were burst, bullets were tired and lathis were wielded
to break the resisting force of Pandits. Searches without proper permissions were conducted prior to the
effecting of arrests. Moneys and ornaments during searches were pilfered and looted. Women on a mass
scale were humiliated, reviled and molested. Peaceful protectors were brutally hit on heads and other
sensitive body-parts killing them instantaneously. Acid was hurled on protesting women and children. On
25th of August, 1967 alone, two hundred and two Pandits were seriously injured when the policemen
brutally charged a massive Kashmiri Pandit demonstration though peaceful. Many of them died from their
bleeding wounds. The injured were denied medical treatment in the government-run hospitals. The
funeral procession of Maharaja Krishen Razdan and Lassa Koul Badam was stoned and was said to be the
handiwork of policemen in plain clothes and Muslim bigots operating in tandem with the government
agencies. Riots were engineered and business establishments and houses belonging to Pandits at Karan
Nagar and other localities were vengefully looted, damaged and put to flames. Two Pandits were
mercilessly beaten to death. A dead body retrieved from a stinking drain was buried without ascertaining
the identity of the person killed. As muslims had suddenly found a new brother in G.M. Sadiq, they let
loose a reign of terror against the Pandits. Two youngmen H.N. Mattoo and Avtar Kishen Khushoo were
cruelly stabbed to death. Gopi Nath Handoo was gashed in chest and head and was done to death. Nine
Kashmiri Pandits were killed by the frenzied Muslims or by Police bullets and hammers.
G.M. Sadiq, the then Chief Minister, proved an utter failure to meet the thrust and strength of the
Kashmiri Pandit agitation which earned tremendous support and deep sympathy from broad sections of
Indian populace. He as a last resort played the time-tested card of Muslim bigotry as a counter-feint to the
pressures mounted by the Pandits for handing over the abducted girl to a third party till the relevant
records including the age of the victim were thoroughly looked into. Money and liquor were generously
and plentifully distributed among Muslims for their mobilisation against the Pandits and in the
mobilisation campaign two ministers, Peer Qiasud-din and Noor Mohammad, and a close relative of the
Chief Minister were seen in the lead-role. With a view to neutralising and debilitating the Pandit thrust, a
massive Muslim demonstration was staged in Srinagar ostensibly against the utterances of Balraj Madhok
who had aired the same views on Kashmir as the Chief Minister himself would harp on day in and day
out. Pitting the violent Muslim bigotry against the Pandits though a micro-minority was only to silence
their protest against the loot of a girl which in the eyes of Muslims was a sanctified act.
The genie of Muslim bigotry and fanaticism when aroused and let loose from its corked bottle is destined
to search for its victims in Kashmiri Pandits and though the agitation was called off yet a Jehad was
launched against the Pandits. Rumour mill was lubricated and a violent disinformation campaign
launched to arouse the religious frenzy to an unprecedented pitch. Pandits were accused of burning a
mosque at Baramulla in complicity with the security forces. The pro-pale goons from S.P.College,
Srinagar pounced on the Kashmiri Pandit students demonstrating against Miss Mahmuda Ahmad Ali
Shah who was said to have hurled foul invective on the Hindu girls of her college and Kashmiri Pandit
professors on staff of the college As a part of the whole nefarious game against the Pandits fuelled by
Congress government, a copy of the religious text was found cast into a filthy pond of a particular school
in Srinagar and Pandits were squarely blamed for the misdeed. Kashmiri Pandit teachers, headmasters and
professors were reviled, humiliated, cursed and physically beaten. Some of them though not involved in
the fury of the agitation were detained and put in jails. Muslims inured to the loot and plunder of
Kashmiri Pandits subjected Hindu shops and houses at Ganpatyar and Habba Kadal localities of Srinagar
to a ruthless loot and plunderbefore setting them to flames. The dailies, weeklies and monthliespublished
by the Kashmiri Pandits and issued by the Kashmiri Pandit organizations focussing on the tidal deluge of
violence and loot sweeping the Pandits were banned in a Nazi fashion with a view to gagging the
community. Pandits were maligned for having received arms from Jan Sangh rabids. A memorandum
submitted to the then Home Minister, Y.B.Chavan, by the Muslim respectables, all sponsored by the
Congress bigots and Pakistani moles and saboteurs, accused the Kashmiri Pandits of stock-piling arms
and ammunition in their residential houses and temples with the purpose of waging a war on the Muslim
majority. Mosques as usual were converted into centres of disinformation campaign against the Pandits.
Prayer was diluted and replaced by disinformation for loot and plunder.
The then Home Minister, Y.B.Chavan, proved deft at prevarication and finally under severe pressure from
Public opinion in the country paid a visit to the valley perhaps for an on-the-spot assessment of the tense
communal situation that had assumed grave proportions by the Muslim intervention as was manipulated
by the communalists and Pakistani subversives donning congress robes. The minister must have felt
elated at the withdrawal of the peaceful agitation, but had lost everything to the stalwarts of bigotry
operating at the state level to the end of ouster of the Kashmiri Pandit minority from the soil of Kashmir.
The posters flaring the Pandits to quit Kashmir for its annexation to Pakistan signalled a triviality of no
political import for the Minister who carried two of them to Delhi and consigned them to the dust-bin.
Had he taken the cue and wrought a stitch, Kashmir would not have witnessed the euphoric rise of the
demon of Muslim fundamentalism and bigotry fed by the natives and abetted by the Umma.
Rajeshwar Rao with a scintillating history in Communists with a view to ingratiating themselves with the
Chief Minister and his cohorts proved no better in assessing the invidious role of disruptionists,
secessionists and communalists serving as the storm-troopers of the Muslims in corridors of power for
stifling the Hindu protest. Enjoying government hospitality on a lavish scale, he could not but ditto to the
dot the government version of the political and communal scenario that had in reality received a heavy
hammering by the pursuit of the same strategy as was devised to batter and frustrate the Roti Agitation
launched against the British conspiracy against the Pandits. In a statement in Srinagar he washed out what
was fed to him by the Chief Minister with whom he was enjoying a fairly good rapport. His use of critical
faculties which were expected to have tempered through the study of dialectical works of Marx should
have normally guided him to the Pandits harbouring a genuine grouse against the Muslim rulers in
particular and Muslims in general who suddenly lose rationality when a Hindu girl is lifted for conversion
and nuptial knot. Had he cross-checked with Pandits and known the facts of their story, he would learnt
that the Muslims manning the Police Stations initially refused to file an FIR which was lodged soon after
the Kashmiri Pandit girl was abducted and when under terrific public pressure, an FIR was filed and the
girl recovered, she was not handed over to her widowed mother, but to the Muslim abductor thus settling
the whole issue and in contrast a Muslim girl, major by all proven evidence, was recovered from the
clutches of her Hindu abductor and without any prevarication restored to the protective care of her natural
parents. Incensed at this, the Hindus were more than justified to launch a peaceful agitation against the
denial to them of the right of equality before law and also against the hamhanded treatment that was
meted out to them by the fundamentalised law-enforcing agencies.
Had he minded an inter-action with Pandits, Rajeshwar Rao with ample grains of earthiness in him would
have come to as to how the vicious processes of subverting rule of law and brazenly discriminating
Pandits purely on religious grounds were initiated at the state level by the Muslim rulers of all shades and
persuasions and continued unabated without any let up. He would surely have felt dismayed had he
known the sordid details as to how the rabid communal elements operating with unrestrained freedom
with the entire Congress government at the fuelling end repeated history for the Pandits subjecting them
to loot, murder and arson and also as to how historical reality in Kashmir was in the processes of being
tailored and re-shaped for the establishment of a Muslim ghetto at the behest of his Communist
sympathiser who was perceptibly seen as the prodigal having returned to the ranks of Muslim rebids. The
massive anti-Hindu demonstrations would have given him a jolt and a shock as the rabid Muslims
manning the vanguard, rearguard and flanks of such demonstrations yelled out their lungs for Jehad
against Hindu Kafirs for their extirpation and indulging in ruthless loot and arson of Pandit properties in
broad daylight hoarsely screamed that Sadiq was a Muslim brother and that was the message they had
received thus testifying to the pact that he had clandestinely formed with the Muslim bigotry, frenzied and
cruel, through the mediation of Plebiscite fronters and Jamaat rabids only to push the religious enemies
into an irretrievable limbo of oblivion.
As the Pandits had plunged head long into the peaceful struggle, they threw off the cloak of reticence and
were forthright and minced no words in drawing the attention of the Central authorities to their chequered
history and to the pile of grievances that had accumulated as a result of blatant discrimination and
marginalisation that the Muslim rulers feigning dubious secularism had subjected them to all through
post-independence era. The Home Minister was informed in crystal - clear language that the government
was assiduously pursuing the policy-path of establishing the Sunni Muslim precedence at the expense of
other ethnic groups which in ultimate analysis would surely push the state into a jeopardy with no means
to retrieve it. This stand of the Pandits was cunningly exploited and misrepresented to generate
resentment against them and were accused of having abandoned and betrayed the cause of the abducted
girl for seeking jobs. Slogans were raised and posters distributed at the instance of some individuals in
Jammu with patronage from Dr. Karan Singh in thick cohorts with the vested interests in corridors of
power and the mischievous and derisive content of the chauvinistic campaign was designed in all
malafide to drift away the tremendous Hindu support to the Pandit agitation which pointedly reflected the
deep-seated resentment against and disapproval of the Muslim hegemony in the state allowed to be
crafted as part of an over-all appeasement policy of anti-nationals artful in dubious politics.
Whether P.N. Bazaz was justified in his mordant opposition to the Kashmiri Pandit agitation or not, but
the fact remains that he despised though in a low key the glaring discrimination that was perpetrated on
Pandits by all shades of Muslim politicals motivated to perpetuate their Muslim credentials among the
Muslim populace, thus throwing to the winds the constitutional guarantees ensuring rights of. all
segments of population transcending perspectives of caste, creed, colour or religion. The Constitution of
India, to the surprise of all, has not been the political Bible of the Muslim rulers, but the Glancy
Commission set up as an off-shoot of British conspiracy buttressed in later years by the Plebiscite Front
Resolution has not only been the seminary of guide-lines for recruitments to public services, promotions
and selections to the professional trainings, but has been the Magna Carta for Muslims who have shown it
an unflinching adherence as an article of faith. The Glancy Commission capturing the texture of a time is
inviolable, sacrosanct and incontrovertible even now when Jammu and Kashmir state has the supervening
sovereignty of the Indian constitution with a well-defined list of Fundamental Rights. KashmiriPandits as
the religious "Other" have to be edged out, merit is to be scaled down, and Muslims are to be
accommodated on the support-plank of Glancy Commission and "population ratio" thesis of Plebiscite
Front, a secessionist outfit tothe core. Merit, academic impeccability and excellence, to the Muslims, are a
red rag to the bull.
Exposing the Muslim rulers who have pawned their souls to the stinking Glancy Commission and taking
the lid off the cruelties inflicted on the Pandits for ethnic cleansing, Bazaz writes :
"Whatever justification there may have been for giving preference to Muslim candidates of inferior merit
in recruitment and promotions in public services or in admission to technical and educational institutions
in the past. I was a strong advocate of this as member of Glancy Commission, the time has come when the
policy of discrimination should come to a stop. Those Muslim politicians who continue to insist upon its
maintenance are wittingly or unwittingly accentuating communal discord. It is amazing that those who
shout for complete freedom should in the same breath oppose the criterion of merit in recruitment to
public services. Mark the absurdity: Muslims are most progressive and backward at one and the same
time. Muslims should try to appreciate the feeling of those Pandits who are discriminated against.
Political expediency might have dictated to "appease" Muslims in the past, but that argument can no
longer assuage the wounded feelings of aggrieved Pandits."
32 C ha pte r 27 - L O O T a n d P L U N D E R O F 1986
The proponents of the horror drama of 1931 in their brazen attempts to justify the macabre happenings
presented the thesis of "political and economic oppression of the Muslims by the ruling class and their
henchmen". A social democrat keen to carve out a niche for himself in the communally polluted politics
of Muslims coined the laboured justification "of the struggle in 1931 being aggressively communal in
outward form, but in essence being the struggle of victimised and enslaved people against the despotic
rule". To camouflage the vicious role of local Muslim rebids, a researcher in his thesis has shifted the
theatre of bigotry and belligerence from Kashmir to the Punjab tracing the motivations of horror drama to
the "communal influences" emanating from the Punjabi Muslim dispensations pursuing anti-Hindu
pogrom. But the macabre drama that was enacted in Feb. 1986 in the theatre of Anantnag was shocking
and flabbergasting and not only flouted, but debunked all strained interpretations that were coined and
contrived about July, 1931 communal commotion ignoring the Muslim disposition of perennial lure to
loot, murder and arson.
"Despotic rule," "political and economic oppression" and "victimised and enslaved people" as formulaic
formulations plucked out from text-books are absolutely lacking in the potential to delineate the
pathological Muslim mind that has been in hot chase of Hindu victims and finds satiation and satisfaction
only afterperpetrating the atrocities of loot, murder and arson on them. There was no Hindu Maharaja
who could be held accused of oppressing and tyrannising the Muslims when 1986-loot was wantonly
committed on the Pandits. There were no so-called Hindu landlords who could again be held guilty of
blood-sucking and exploiting the Muslim masses when in the same spree of loot Hindu properties were
pillaged and put to leaping flames. There were no Pandits even at the lower rungs of government
apparatus who could be stigmatised and hatefully cried foul of as representatives of the dehumanised and
oppressive state machine. The limpid fact of history is that the governments of varied political formations
in the wake of 1947 assiduously devised and pursued the communal plans of marginalising, eliminating
and sealing the fate of Pandits in their native land and in the calendar year of 1986 Pandits stood pushed
out to the peripheries of political and economic scenario of Kashmir leaving them high and dry, bereft and
beleaguered. And yet an atrocious loot was inflicted on them.
The loot, pillage and arson of Feb. 1986 falls into a pattern of several such bouts of loot, plunder and
arson littered over the palimpsest of Kashmir history planned and executed by Muslim bigots motivated
and stuffed with the loaded lessons of bigotry and prejudice. The loot and arson that was conducted over a
vaster area was vengeful, frightening and awesome, cruel and barbarous, wild and ferocious, a scene from
a macabre drama, bone chilling and blood curdling. The sweep of the loot was so broad and extensive that
the horror and violence of 1931-variety paled into an inconsequential event. The Pandits for no fault of
theirs were the butts of target, Pandits not confined to one locality or one habitation, but Pandits
inhabiting the entire landscape of District Anantnag were ruthlessly looted, ravaged and arsoned by the
Muslim hordes in thick cohorts with the state power. The broad purlieux of the district were converted
into a horror chamber of brutal violence, storm and rage. Like asiatic elephants the Muslims breaking
loose from their tethers, violent and uproarious, marching in waves upon waves carrying incendiary
materials and sharp-edged weapons screaming Jehad cries and death to Pandits went berserk rampaging
and destructing houses and temples, sheds and shops, fields and crops.
The Muslim hordes looted and pillaged nearly five hundred Kashmiri Pandit houses and the booty
acquired after vengeful loot was either kept or put to sale in open bazars. Fifty houses were burnt to
cinders leaving hundreds of hapless Pandit families battered, tattered, shattered and reduced from
prosperity to indigence. Women were the main butts of target and were subjected to untold cruelties and
the most indecent molestations and assaults and even after the restoration of apparent peace, they fell
victims to ambuscade. The stormy waves of looters on rampage in every village or hamlet were brutally
clamouring for the loot of young teenage girls. Ten thousand strong horde of Muslims at Lok Bhawan, all
locals, bayed for the blood of a young pretty Kashmiri Pandit girl interned in the bath-room of her house
under strict instructions from her parents to immolate herself if and when their house was stormed for
loot, rape and assault. Only providence could save her. Hundreds of shops, big or small, owned by
Kashmiri Pandits were plundered and looted and the owners assaulted and their shoes, turbans and
blankets in the Muhta Khanian fashion removed and looted. All large scale business ventures and hotels
belonging to Pandits were destroyed and portable goods broken or looted as prized booty. It was an open
and unalloyed loot of the Kafirs.
Not living down their Islamic image, in fact, adding laurels to it, the Muslim storm-troopers wielding
lathis, shovels, rods and sharp-edged weapons pounced in all fury on temples and idol-houses and
desecrated and ravaged sixty temples and set ablaze forty temples at one go. Temple stones, pillars, bricks
and planks lying in piles of ruin were conveniently looted for utilisation in private constructions. Such
was the colossal collapse of government machinery. Idols of Shiva, Vishnu and various gods and
goddesses of Hindu pantheon were broken or dug out from their sanctum sanctora and hurled out in
visceral contempt into ditches, rivers and flowing streams. Trees intertwined with crimson red threads
worshipped with absolute devotion were cruelly felled to the absolute satisfaction of marauders. All old or
newly built dharamshallas attached with temples for the convenience of pilgrims were denuded of
utensils, gas cylinders, dharies and carpets and all nitty-gritty and then put to flames.
Lok Bhawan of the Rajatarangini fame was transformed into a ghastly and grisly scene when Muslims
converged on the site of the temple and vandalised and broke all the precious idols with axes and iron
rods. The complex had three temples and two dharamshallas which were burnt and pitilessly razed to the
ground. After capturing the site the entire horde of vandalisers said Namaz within the temple precincts
and in all exhilaration and exuberance went out parading the village paths and roads, abusing and cursing
the Pandits, lapidating their houses and breaking windows, and window-panes and to the astonishment of
goddess of sanity screaming and shouting in one chorus for the loot of Kashmiri Pandit women.
As an expression of extreme hatred fresh cut head of a bull dripping blood was placed on the Shiva Linga
of a temple in Bijbehera. It did not shock the secularists anywhere. Though it was reported through all
channels of media.
Muslims, in fact, were replicating the mix-deeds and frenzied acts of Muslim vandals of historical
ignominy and each Pandit sunk in his colossal tragedy witnessing the devilish drama of death and
destruction from the open fields where they had taken refuge and cover could not but think that they had
not left them so savage when they were coerced to join the ranks of neo-converts and the journey from the
temple to the mosque has been shockingly devastating and incredibly brutalising.
The demon of Muslim bigotry and hatred ruling with absoluteness over one stretch of land was battened
to an enormous size by spontaneous responses all over the vale of Kashmir. Revengeful acts of loot,
molestation and arson were inflicted on the Pandits wherever they had been. Temples and idol-houses
were torched and Pandit houses stoned and broken into, looted and plundered. Women folk were reviled
and humiliated. All the horror happenings had the same contours and the same operation. Sopore as the
vestibule and cesspit of Muslim bigotry and vengeflness was in the lead-role of extirpating infidelity from
the land of Kashmir.
The 1986-loot was sponsored and monitored by Muslims manning levers of power. The Chief Minister,
G.M. Shah and the members of his family were directly involved in the loot and plunder of Kashmiri
Pandits. The Jammaat-i-Islami pockets that had found nurture and sustenance from unexpected quarters
were abuzz with tremendous activity in organising and planning the parameters of loot. The hordes of
Muslim rabids parading in waves upon waves belonged to the villages and hamlets where Jammaat-i-
Islami cadres drenched in communal venom were in tremendous strength and wielded unrestrained sway.
The Congress-I and National Conference cadres as votaries of the same brand of religious fanaticism fell
in line and were as wild and ferocious as the Jammaat-i-Islami cadres could be. As was corroborated from
realities on ground three villages were completely ravaged, plundered and destroyed and twenty-four
villageswere partially effected and the broad impact of officially sponsored and generated loot and
plunder was sensed in 764 villages and hamlets throughout the valley. Except Lok Bhawan and Fatehpur
crowds on a looting and destroying spree came from outside The Muslim rebids hailing from Kaimoh,
Khudwani and Arwani villages as the key centres of Jammaat-i-Islami with tremendous support from all
politicals owing allegiance to secular parties were discenibly seen in lead-role to wreak havoc on
Kashmiri Pandits, who were psychologically devastated and realised that fear of death was deadlier than
actual death.
The Muslim frenzy was generated and mobilised by setting afloat an apochrypal and malicious rumour
that the Haj pilgrims and Muslims in Jammu were put to a wholesale massacre by the Hindus. That there
was a well organised effort invested to oil the rumour mill got established by the fact that every nook and
cranny of the valley was abuzz with and echoed the same malicious rumour. In reality, the loot and arson
was organised and executed through phone-calls to the quarters that mattered especially the law-enforcing
agencies. The administration not only harboured but appeared to harbour absolute sympathies with the
Muslim looters and arsonists. The violent incidents of far-reaching political import pregnant with the
potential to rupture peace and public order were not as a common Police practice reported at all. No
appraisals were made. No concern was shown. No responses were built and organised to meet the
devastating challenges from the hydra-headed monster of Muslim communalism signalling that peace and
amity was a nine days' wonder. The Divisional officers disappeared from the scene in a jiffy as a
deliberate act of connivance and collaboration with the looters on rampage. None would be seen visiting
the affected villages with a view to re-assuring the hapless victims to the Muslim orgy of loot and arson.
Lok Bhawan much before the horrendous loot had emerged as a flash-point when the rabid Muslims
operating under government patronage profferred their untenable and malicious claims to the areas of
land belonging to the shrine since ages. To maintain peace and order and prevent any attempt to further
widen the gulf between the contending communities, heavy deployment was made after careful appraisal
and assessment of the dimensions of the entire scenario by the top Police brass. But, strangely, the armed
deployment on the trouble-spot was suddenly withdrawn at the behest of the Muslim collaborators in key
positions thus granting a free rope to the marauders for perpetration of loot and destruction on the
disinherited Kashmiri Pandits. Some lathi-wielding policemen practically ineffective and of no
consequence to meet the highly volatile situation were seen on the spot where new records were being
added to the despicable book of Muslim bigotry and garrulousness
How was it that the villages which were directly responsible for inflicting loot on the Pandits had full
flow of electric supply and the villages put to the bouts of gruesome loot and arson were steeped in
darkness? Akura was steeped in total darkness. So were Fatehpur and other villages that were marauded.
When a brilliant Hindu officer pointed out the design behind it, lies were fabricated, alibis coined and
falsehoods dished out. It was sensed as a deliberate act of preplanning on part of divisional officers to
provide cover to the vengeful ghosts and apparitions to batter their way into the Hindu habitations for loot
and arson. Writes Koul, "The formidable Muslim combine forgetting their political persuasions and
sinking their differences started on a looting and burning spree ravaging village after village. Political
affiliations did not divide their ranks and what held them together as a solid mass for a unified action was
the faith of Islam sanctioning their war on infidels (Kafirs). The Kashmirian Hindus as hapless and
terrorised victims to loot, plunder and arson rang up police stations but there was no response. The entire
drama of destruction and loot was stage-managed by the Muslimised bureaucracy with police as its vital
cog. As a matter of design, the state authority disappeared from the scene in a jiffy and law-enforcing
agencies proved a party to the loot and plunder of the Hindus. It was a rehearsal of one act of the drama of
death and destruction conceived and scripted by the demon of Muslim bigotry presiding over the Muslim
psyche.
The Indian government pooh-poohed the developments. The Minister for Internal Security who belonged
to the Nehru dynasty had his own contributions to make to the destruction and dehumanization of Pandits.
The appraisal report submitted to him by L.K. Advani and Kedar Nath Sahni about the prognosis of the
malicious communal developments in Kashmir with their looming threat to the security of India could not
serve as his guide-lines with the result that the Kashmiri Pandits are on the cross-roads of history waiting
for extinction. What was ominous that the secular parties especially Congress-I made a common cause
with rabid Muslims for the loot, plunder and arson of the molecular minority of Kashmiri Pandits. Cases
against the looters and arsonists were not registered under the prevalent laws. Nor were they tried and
punished. Law was allowed to rust on the Statute Book and it has been so in Kashmir since 1947. The
Congress provincial Chief, Mufti Mohammad Sayyid, who was openly involved in the macabre events,
was not arraigned before a tribunal. He was neither arrested nor tried for punishment. Jameel Ahmad
Andrabi who played a rabid role in the loot of 1986-variety was not hooked and tried under provisions of
law.
The Communal aggression on the Kashmiri Pandit ethno-religious minority proved of serious dimensions.
It was not only a prelude to its ethnic cleansing but paved the way for the Pandit exodus to various parts
of the country. A Jammu official then posted in Anantnag made it amply clear to the Union Home
Minister that it was a sinister conspiracy to push out Pandits from the valley as they were deemed as
obstacles in the Islamisation process that had begun in 1947. The loot and arson of Pandit properties was
the boiling point of hate -Pandit campaign built up and directed by the secessionist forces drawing
sustenance and unmitigated support from all brands of Muslim politicals. The Hindustan Times date-lined
July 8th, 1985 reported:
"That there was a mass exodus of the members of minority community from the state of Jammu and
Kashmir to other parts of the country. This was a dangerous trend which should be stopped. There was
indeed a sinister conspiracy to throw out the non-Muslims from the valley so that the designs of complete
Islamisation were fulfilled."
The statement issued out to the press by the Anantnag Prabandhak Committee in the wake of the whole-
sale loot of Kashmiri Pandits reads as under :
This Maha Shivratri has come to us with a train of sufferings, setbacks and a sad story of hundreds of our
Hindu brethren rendered homeless in Vanpoh, Dhanove Bogund, Luk Bhavan and many other places,
with at least twenty of our sacred temples burnt, damaged and desecrated. The sanctity of our homes in
the listed towns and villages have been defiled by ruthless stoning and illegal trespass. This organised
communal violence was aimed at annihilating this tiny community from the surface of our birth-place,
Kashmir. The indifference and laxity of Administration was apparent. The manner in which this military-
like operation was carried out speaks to indicate that preparations for this exercise were made in advance
and then executed. The intelligence agencies reportedly had warned the government both Central and
State about the Plan of the militant, anti-national and communal organisations bent on destabilizing the
communal amity of the state to further their design of secession. Reportedly the Governor had informed
the Central Govt. of the dangers. It is unfortunate that New Delhi kept sleeping over the matter and the
inordinate delay on their part to act in time has resulted in this holocaust. To further our doubts
identification of some police and civil officials who let the situation get out of hand and even helped the
plunderous has been reportedly established by the Press and the Government. The indifference and apathy
of other sections of the people and their attitude of passive spectators and the deep slumber of our national
leaders has placed this peace-loving community on the cross-roads of history where their very Survival is
at stake. The number of secular and nationalist elements in major political parties has thinned to such a
low percentage that it has become an exception. However, the minority community cannot forget the
protection nationalist and secular role of some of our Muslim brothers who plunged themselves headlong
to save their Hindu brother's life and property. These true Muslims shall be remembered as the torch
bearer's of amity and peace. The shocking incidents the details of which follow have proved beyond doubt
that the minority community in Kashmir cannot take the pledges and promises of their safety and welfare
for granted.
1. Anantnag - 150 houses heavily stoned and damaged. Property of one house completely looted. One
hotel ransacked and damaged. One Eye clinic looted. One Medical shop looted. Main temple Devibal and
Naibasti temple damaged. Cremation shed demolished.
2. Gotamnag- One main temple - cum-Dharamshala completely burnt. Old Dharamshala damaged. Pujari
seriously injured.
3. Krangsu - Pelting of stones on houses.
4. Akura- Shivalla Temple ransacked. Whole Property looted. Idols looted and broken. One cow-shed
burnt. One shop looted.
5. Nanil - Two Medical shops looted.
6. Thanisher(Akura) - One house burnt.
7. Ramhall - One Cowshed burnt.
8. Brakpora - One Medical shop looted.
9. Achabal - The idols desecrated. The details cannot be printed.
10. Nowgam (Kuthar) - Temple completely burnt. Houses stoned.
11. Telwani - Temple burnt.
12. Akingam - Six shops looted. One house completely ransacked. Carpet centre looted.
13. Mohripora - One temple completely burnt. One shop looted.
14. Sagam - Twenty five houses stoned and one temple stoned. One person seriously injured.
15. Batapora (Dialgam)-One temple damaged and one house burnt.
16. Fatehpora - One temple burnt. Walling and gate ransacked and one house looted.
17. Ranbirpora Kareva - Two sheds burnt.
18. Ohpaisen - Idols desecrated.
19. Nandkisore - Idols broken and desecrated.
20. Vanpoh - Two main temples burnt. One samadhi damaged. Four shops burnt and looted. One house
burnt. Two rice mills damaged. Twenty -six houses completely looted.
21. Danav Bogund - Seven houses completely burnt along with their house - hold effects. Two temples
burnt. One Dharmshala and Library completely damaged. All the other houses but one completely looted.
22. Chowgam- One temple looted.
23. Luk Bhavan - Three temples completely burnt and mercilessly razed to the ground. Two
Dharamshalas completely burnt. One shop completely looted. One house completely burnt. Murties and
precious ancient idols broken into pieces.
24. Verinag- Idols of one temple in the main parikrama of spring Nilnag damaged and looted.
25. Chandian Pajjan - Temple damaged and houses stoned.
26. Sallar - Main temple in Sallar along with ancient precious Murties destroyed. Geeta Bhawan
destroyed.
27. Aishmuqam - One temple burnt.
28. Bijbehara - All the three temples looted. Idols and ancient and precious Murties broken and thrown
into river. Houses stoned.
29. Gund Jaffar - One temple damaged.
DISTRICT ANANTNAG/PULWAMA
30. Tral -1 Kali Temple burnt
31. Dragpura - 1 Temple burnt.
DISTRICT BARAMULLA
30. Baramulla - 2 temples stoned
33. Seer - 1 Temple attacked.
34. Kawpura - 2 Temples stoned.
35. Bandipur - 1 Temple attacked
36. Sopore - 2 Temples ransacked, mud thrown on idols and pictures in the temple torn.
DISTRICT SRINAGAR
37. Jawahar Nagar - Property of the temple burnt.
38. Karan Nagar -Temple ransackedand burnt. Some shops of Hindus were burnt in the Chotta Bazar,
Karan Nagar area.
39. Ganpatyar - Temple stoned and the wall of the temple demolished.
40. Dashnami Akhara Budshah Chowk (Srinagar) -Small temple burnt, seat of Mehantji gutted in fire.
Dharamshala and transport godown burnt to ashes.
41. Waskura - Property of the temple burnt.
42. Purshyar - Temple stoned.
43. Bhairav Mandir - stoned.
44. Nawgam (Badgam) - 1 Temple looted, 4 houses stoned.
45. Mazbome (Badgam) 1 House ransacked and burnt.
46. Gulgam (Kupwara ) - 1 Temple burnt.
NOTE: Districts of Badgam, Kupwara and Pulwama not yet Surveyed Fully.
The total loss of Anantnag district which is running into crores of rupees is being assessed properly. The
details of loss of other districts are coming.
The history has struck the hour when we have to come together to devise a plan of our survival with
dignity and honour. Kashmir has ceased to be a land of peace and amity. This community has to think
about their collective survival in the context of indignity and out-rage perpetrated on our members in
different towns and villages. The only solution that can sustain our community seems to point towards
migration from this valley. Thus mass exodus of Kashmiri Hindus appears to be the only way of
preserving our life and culture. This land has ceased to provide safety to our life and property and our
continued living in this part of the country is fraught with the prospect of our total extinction.
33 P A R T II - C ha pte r 1 – N E H R U ’ S A D V IC E T O T H E K A S H M IR I
P A N D IT S
Pandit Nehru as the top leader of Indian Independence movement exhorted and advised the Kashmiri
Pandits at a mammoth gathering at Sheetal-nath grounds to join, reinforce and strengthen the so-called
nationalist forces obviously for empowerment of a culture model with its of-betrayed perverse proclivity
of maligning, persecuting, converting and liquidating non-Muslim ethnic groups. India as an ancient-land
with its catholic ethos was not only a subject of discovery, but was a source material for authentic study
and guidance to resolve outstanding problems and issues left over from history for purposes of shaping
and mending the future political and demographical map of India with an overriding accent on its organic
unity. In Kashmir Nehru's attempt was to gain that raison detre which he had lost in the domain of Hindu-
Muslim relations. The Hindu-Muslim conflict as a sordid legacy from history with its sharpened face led
to a damaging cleavage when Muslims motivated by their culture model spurning broad demands of
nationalism opted for a separate homeland. What happened in Kashmir was the continuation of the same
conflict under a feigned secular facade till such time Muslims would fight out the Hindu remnants in their
practices and thinking contours for a fundamentalist orientation and undergo rapid economic and
educational regeneration from torpid poverty and illiteracy with lavish and generous Indian fundings
under a constitutionally crafted dispensation hegemonised over by Muslims deft in the art of black-
mailing and then opt out on the contrivance of the same thesis of Muslim majority complexion of the state
with threats from the Hindu majority of India. That Nehru had thoroughly evaluated the religious
persecution carried out to the limits of genocide in Kashmir is not buttressed by his advice to the Pandits
to join the forces of treacherous nationalism which had a besmeared face of communalism and religious
antagonism.
34 C ha pte r 2 - P A N - IS L A M IC D E S IG N
The pre-dominating design of Muslim terrorism in Kashmir with its enormous contours is to snap the
political and constitutional linkages with the Indian political and constitutional organisation for a tie-up
with a theocratic state which has shot up into prominence as a front-line Muslim state with a
fundamentalist ideology and agenda. The severance of Kashmir from the country of infidels is perceived
to rectify the wrong that was committed in 1947. The Islamisation of the politico-economic structures and
substructures of the state and doggedly pursued from 1947 with a crusading zeal have ultimately touched
their apogee in violence and terrorism. The central governments of various political hues have played the
proverbial ostriches or nodded tacit approval of the sinister developments in the field of separatism and
fundamentalism coupled with monolithic political culture. The constitutional frame-work harbouring such
provisos as weakened the grip over Kashmir sundered the state apart from to mainstream national and
political life. With the depletion of the central authority the ruling elite and subversives in the state
apparatus harnessed the levers of power in a manner inimical to the broader interests of the nation-state
and created conditions in which Pak-intervention became inevitable.
The terrorist movement with all its overt and covert preparations was let loose only to snow-ball into
awesome dimensions after the defeat and fiasco of Soviets in Afghanistan. It came to be seen as an
inalienable part of the militarised Pan-Islamic movement chasing the goal of Muslim expansion into new
belts of territory for the establishment and consolidation of a new Muslim world for a hegemonic role.
Pakistan beaming in its aura of victory in Afghanistan diverted its mobilisations from Afghanistan to the
state of Jammu and Kashmir for its dismemberment from the Indian union for annexation to its domain to
complete the much publicised unfinished agenda of partition and in its hot pursuit of Pan-Islamic agenda
is zealously keen to fill in the vacuum in the Central Asian countries caused by the Soviet withdrawal and
with that prime objective in view it is not only seeking to expanding its borders for such a role-model in
Central Asia, but is bent upon making fresh inroads into the South Asian region to cobble up a defence
confederacy of the Muslim countries from Middle East to South East Asia.
The fundamentalist regimes that have come to power in most of the Muslim countries have lined up in
their relentless support of the terrorist movement in Kashmir. They have been funding, providing strategic
guidance and launching large-scale propaganda and disinformation campaign to boost up the spirits of the
terrorists. They are unanimous in looking at the Kashmir conflict as an Islamic issue which needs
immediate resolution by its annexation to a Muslim fundamentalist regime determined by its Muslim
majority character. The organisation of Islamic countries though internally riven has been meddling to
fuel the blazing fires of insurgency by keeping Kashmir on its active agenda. Organisations and varied
Islamic outfits have mushroomed in Muslim countries which not only collect huge sums in support of the
Muslim terrorism, but also have launched recruitment drives for training in anus and weapons. After
arming the recruits and indoctrinating them they are exported to Kashmir to feed insurgency and Jehad.
Fully cognisant of the role that Pakistan has been playing in Kashmir two front-ranking Muslim countries,
Saudi Arabia and Iran, in flagrant violation of international covenants have come out in open support of
Muslim terrorism aided and buttressed by Pakistan, in particular ISI wing of its army.
The terrorist movement in Kashmir soaked in parochialism and medieval brutalities set upon the Kashmiri
Pandits as the prime target with a view to smoothening the road to balkanisation of India as its primary
destination. The destruction of Pandits was perceived as a vital imperative if the bridge that connects
Kashmir with India was to be torpedoed. The Pandits in themselves reflected and symbolised the broad
spectrum of Indian value-system and therefore had to be dealt out a death-blow for giving a burial to all
that was deemed Indian to materialist the emergence of Kashmir as the undiluted land of Muslims. A
systematic campaign for their liquidation was initiated and whipped up. They were put on hit-lists issued
out from ,mosques which had emerged as the pivotal centres of terrorism. Threatening letters were written
to them to add to their fear-psychosis and to scare them away and more than big-sized posters purporting
the Pandits to quit or get killed were pasted on the doors of their residential houses and gates of temples.
The terrorists blared out open threats to the Hindu Kafirs to clear the land of Kashmir as the star of Islam
had blazed up in the skies of Kashmir. Selective killings were resorted to which ultimately turned the
current and tide against the Pandits. The State governnent not only abdicated, but was discernibly seen
collaborating with the killers. With the increase in the frequency and tempo of killings, the Kashmiri
Pandits as in the past so now were left with two options of either conversion to Islam or march out of the
purlieux of Kashmir for sanctuary in safer zones. The Hindu segment of Kashmiri population who formed
a very stable support structure of India in Kashmir was put to killings, torture, hangings from trees,
dismemberment of live bodies and gang rapes.
With the elimination of Kashmiri Pandits front the soil of Kashmir the terrorists laced with deadly
weapons and equipped with training in the use of such weapons declared war against the Indian security
forces who were holding on not withstanding the deliberate crumbling of the state security structures. The
role of Kashmiri Pandits in such a warlike situation was already delineated and envisioned by Sheikh
Abdullah who in unequivocal terms had dubbed the Pandits as the Indian agents. Sheikh's son, Farooq
Abdullah, given to harangues against Pandits, labelled them as "unpaid agents of India." Their
perceptions about the Kashmiri Pandits when translated in terms of war resulted in their death and
destruction as they were deemed to form a vital and more than most dependable conduit in the
communication channel providing vital clues and background information to the organs of government
fighting the undeclared war launched by Pakistan in absolute collaboration with vast sections of Muslim
population. The Kashmiri Pandits connected with intelligence agencies and telecommunication systems
were brutally massacred and tortured with a view to herding them out to block the channels of
communication. The entire vernacular press not only bent, but genuflected to kow-tow the terrorist
disinformation against the Mukhbirs, the Indian agents and security forces with a view to heightening
their thrust against the Indian presence in Kashmir.
Maximising the advantage accruing from the Indian failure in Kashmir, Pakistan came to hold the handle
of the "Master key" in letting loose the spate of terrorist violence and mayhem. It has been responsible for
the determination of the scale, goals and strategies of the on-going terrorist movement. It has set up a
massive network of training camps for the infiltrating Muslim youth to equip and brace them up with
capabilities to use and handle arms and ammunition besides indoctrination. The key persons from the
Pakistan army have been drafted to impart training to the Kashmiri Muslim youth in the use of lethal and
sophisticated weaponry. The trained Muslim youth have been offered cover to re-infiltrate into the Indian
positions for operation. The war being fought in the theatre of Kashmir is led by the local Muslim
terrorists whose flanks have been supported and reinforced by the quick induction of hard-core foreign
mercenaries from Muslim countries. Pakistan has launched upon a world-wide campaign through its hired
lobbyists to isolate India on the Kashmir conflict especially on human rights violations and in such an
endeavour it is being lent moral, political and diplomatic support by the Islamic countries pursuing the
same ends of militarised Islam. The Operation Topaic given high level publicity by the Indian defence
experts to cover the Indian failure in Kashmir had spelt out doom of the Hindu minorities by the strategy
of killing one to frighten away hundreds.
The terrorist violence in Kashmir with its calculated thrust against the Hindu minorities has been
inextricably linked with and owes its allegiance to the Islamic agenda of establishing a transnational
Muslim front spawning from the Mediterranean to the Malacca straits. India dominantly a land of the
Hindus and hence abjectly detested is perceived to put spokes in wheels of the formation and fashioning
of such a front which with nuclear capabilities is deemed to pose a challenge to the supremacy of the
unipolar world order. Israel hated as the arch enemy of the Muslim world has been under a constant threat
and aggression of the Muslim states which have not allowed it peace and stability for religious reasons.
Since partition in 1947 India has faced Islamic onslaught by the infliction of three wars with a view to
destabilising it for fragmentation, chaos and anarchy. More so, the devastation of India as a nation-state
which has been the leitmotif of Pakistan strategy came into sharp focus when the Sikh separatist terrorism
was abetted and reinforced by the provision of modern weaponry and strategic and logistic guidance. The
security scenario in the north eastern states has nose-dived and is amply vitiated by the abetment and
intervention of ISI saboteurs who have been training and arming the malcontents from the states in camps
operating within Bangladesh. By heightening the separatist conflict and turmoil in the Punjab Islamists
have been aiming at the destruction of northern borders for their relocation in the heartland of India.
35 C ha pte r 3 - S P O N S O R E D T E R R O R IS M
A canard of "sponsored terrorism" has been set afloat and given widest possible currency by some
defence experts earning tremendous support from Government of India with a view to concealing and
confusing the hard realities in Kashmir. As per the canard, the Muslim discontent actually born out of
religious hatred and fanaticism culminating in total revolt against the Indian presence in Kashmir is to be
attributed to Pakistan and its manoeuvres. The theory as it stands practically spells out a ruse to
obfuscating the Indian failures in Kashmir and absolving the internal saboteurs wherever they be
operating under varied nomenclatures dubious in intent and content. The fact remains that Pakistan
militarised the Muslim revolt against India, but there were internal forces both religious and political
which were to a large measure directly responsible for brewing and fermenting the revolt. It can be safely
averred that violence tinged communal was not generated and unleashed because of intervention from
Pakistan. It, in reality, is and remains a part and parcel of the rubric of Islamic ethos and cultural model.
There is a massive network of the Muslim organisations and outfits operating under religious cover to
indoctrinate and communalise the Muslim mind for establishment of a Muslim state cleansed of non-
conformist religious groups. A plethora of religious schools operating under government patronage and
funded by oil-rich gulf states have been igniting and fanning religious discord and hatred with a view to
establishing an exclusivist culture of Islam steeped in intolerance and distrust. Right from 1947 all shades
of governments not known for their vision and initiative but harbouring commitments to parochialism and
myopia have initiated the process of Islamisation which have concomitantly bred and promoted violence
and unleashed the forces of separatism and extra-territorial forays and flights. It is Islamisation only that
has poisoned and sharply cut at the roots of tolerance and mutual amity and accentuated and widened the
Hindu-Muslim divide and generated violence which ultimately paved the way for ethnic cleansing.
Violence as an offshoot and expression of Muslim fanaticism, brutality and intolerance has been holding
an absolute sway over the religious and political milieu of Kashmir for long and what Pakistan did was to
brace up and sharpen the teeth of the violence perpetrators operating without any check or restraint in the
name of Islam by lacing them with lethal arms and sophisticated weaponry. Islamisation as seen in the
context of Kashmir came to broaden its horizons and sight new destinations and perspectives by
establishing a linkage with the forces of religious bigotry and militarised fundamentalism in Pakistan and
other Muslim countries. Religious violence vitiating and poisoning the entire scenario preceded the
intervention from Pakistan and other Islamic countries. It will not be wide off the mark if it be put that
insurgency in Kashmir has foreign content with an ample amount of indigenous blend.
The brutal violence perpetrated on the Kashmiri Pandit minorities in the holocaust of 1986 by the
"lawless lizards" perpetually clamouring the same refrain of Islam in danger was the culmination of the
entire spectrum of Islamisation which had set its sights on waging a bigger battle for redempting Kashmir
from the so-called Indian yoke and annexing it to the transnational Muslim front with commitments to a
new perceived role. Violence was hurled on the minuscule minority when Zia-ul-Haq nicknamed as Zia
the whip in Kashmir, suddenly died in a plane crash in his own Country. Al Aqsa Mosque was reportedly
desecrated and damaged somewhere in Palestine as a result of the perennial religious discord and
animosity between the Jews and the Muslims and the happening proved highly expensive for the Hindu
minorities in blood and treasure. A book brought into Kashmir by a European missionary allegedly
containing an imaginary photograph of the Prophet was suddenly discovered on the dusty shelves of a
library and Muslims parting ways with the demands and requirements of sanity targeted the Kashmiri
Hindus by hurting, maiming and cursing them and stoning their entire habitations. Pakistan lost a match
or won a match and Hindus in both circumstances had to face violence, privation and suffering. Mast
Gull, a Pakistani awash-buckler, hailed and applauded by the locals as their saviour and a guest from
Pakistan was responsible for putting the Chrar mausoleum to flames and Muslims established startling
records as the ruthless marauders when the Hindu habitations with their left-behind properties were burnt
and razed to the ground. Violence as an ingredient of Muslim pathology was only aggravated and
harnessed to the hilt by Pakistan which has not reconciled to the historical reality of Jammu and Kashmir
as a part of the Indian state.
Loot, arson and vandalism were an accepted ethos of Kashmir prior to the declaration of proxy war and
the state governments have played an actively collaborative role to nourish and cultivate the religious
forces of bigotry and prejudice working cumulatively to quench dissent, liquidate the pluralistic fabric of
Kashmiri society and more than most to establish the absolute sway of Muslims over politics and
economy of the state. Under the secular garb Islam has been installed as the state religion and that is how
the Muslim onslaught on Hindu religious places has been fine-tuned into a state policy to establish
ascendancy of Islam. Islamic fundamentalism has been initiated and nurtured at the state level. So has
been secessionism coupled with subversion.
The twin forces of religious bigotry and separatism have been on the same wavelength and operating in
tandem adding immeasurably to the steam-roller image of Islam. The state apparatus infested with die-
hard subversives and moles transformed Kashmir into Nazi dominated Germany doling out the same
treatment to the native Kashmiri Pandits as Jews were meted out in Germany, persecuted and liquidated.
Assault upon their persons, their inherent freedoms, their constitutional guarantees and their cultural
heritage was installed as a centre-stage of political and religious strategy. The cultural authoritarianism
that goes with Muslim precedence, monolithic political culture and separatism has patently ordained that
anything that cannot be Islamised cannot be tolerated. The state policy as devised and determined by the
dominant Sunni Muslim politics has been predominantly suffused with anti-Pandit venom and animosity
and resonant with decibels for threats and sword-rattling against them without any visible let up. Farooq
Abdullah the maverick yelled, "Your bodies will be lying in Srinagar and your tattered clothes will reach
Delhi" and he was giving last touches to the hatched Muslim conspiracy to herd out Pandits from their
home-land to live the plight of refugees in their own country.
The secessionists having lost political power in 1953 not only hobnobbed with Pakistan, but were said to
be in receipt of hefty sums of money from that country to feed subversion and political instability and to
patronise terror groups that had been sprouting from time to time at the behest of Pakistan. Whether in or
outside the corridors of power the Muslim political leadership as a matter of calculated strategy has been
maintaining overt or covert contact with the ruling circles in Pakistan through Kashmiris and other
contacts settled in that country who have been frequently visiting Kashmir on crucial junctures and to
state the obvious has been responsible for mysterious fires and thefts, umpteen acts of subversion and
sabotage designed to mobilise and garner maximum support for separatist cause. Secessionism was fed by
the top leaders of the Plebiscite Front for twenty years and when rehabilitated and handed over political
power for purposes of political expediency and convenience through senseless accords and alliances, they
lent credibility and sanctity to the politics of secessionism and anti-national acts and added new
dimensions to it by founding a Muslim state practically outside the pale of India. It was made amply clear
that their options are either independence or Pakistan and if they forego the choices, their only
outstanding option is to be outside the constitutional and political organisation of India, and this is the
summum bonum of greater autonomy.
The Central Governments have not only turned a Nelson's eye to the militarised fundamentalist
developments in Kashmir, but allowed them to grow and expand in recognition of the Muslim majority
complexion of the stated Compromises with the chronic Muslim secessionists and arch-votaries of
independence with known links with and allegiance to the Jammu and Kashmir Liberation Front were
stitched out for short-term political gains and goals. Print media not lagging behind made incessant
projections about the Islamist forces working through Madrasas and mosques fast veering round a
struggle that had Pan-Islamic motivations and character and extra-territorial dimension. The movement
unleashed by Al-Jehad had been propagating and giving wide currency to the concept of "Islamic
revolution" as the only path to wrest away Kashmir from the grip of the Indian Kafirs. The dominant
Muslim population despite deep-seated religious rivalries and schisms could be visibly seen aflush with
the Khomeini brand of Islamic revolution and the Jammu and Kashmir Liberation Front, Mahaz-i-Azadi,
the Liberation League and other separatist outfits made their debut in the political skies of Kashmir as
direct off-shoot of the Islamic radicalisation and communalisation. Pakistan proved prompt and deft at
constantly monitoring political developments, broadened its perspectives and set its sights on bigger
goals. Where India lost Pakistan gained a tremendous political mileage. No tab was maintained on anti-
India forces maintaining stranglehold of the government apparatus and the principal political formation
within the state. Nor were poetical developments of far-reaching import carefully monitored. When
signals were loud and clear about the growing menace of terrorism, it was flip-flopped and given a short
shrift. The governor on the scene faxed "Today is late, tomorrow will be too late", but the Prime Minister
immured in his ivory tower, pampered and flattered by the whiz kids surrounding him, not bitten by
ground realities, consigned it to the waste-paper basket refusing to heed the signals presenting an altered
scenario.
36 C ha pte r 4 - K A S H M IR I P A N D IT S - S O F T T A R G E T S
Thousands of Muslim terrorists owing unflinching loyalty to multiform political and religious
organisations including the ruling National Conference were primarily responsible for the introduction of
"gun culture" in Kashmir thereby militarising the Muslim ethos already infected of communal canker.
Frenzied and wild, they launched upon a systematic campaign for wiping out Kashmiri Pandits to
establish an absolute Muslim sway with Islamic destinations in view. The foul statements and venomous
and uncalled for comments about the Pandits maliciously etching them on the Muslim mindscape as the
agents of India were a precursor to the storm that was imminent to engulf them. The trend was set when
they were put to sporadic killings and their properties torched and looted. The government authorities
overtaken by communal motivations and prejudices pooh-poohed the stygian and murky developments
with the result that the state as per the premeditated design lurched into an abysmal disaster and
destruction.
A sadhu clad in saffron living in a temple in north of Kashmir was chopped into pieces with an axe and
the sack containing his hacked body was recovered from a ditch. The grue-some killing did not cause an
alarm to the deracinated rulers enjoying carnival of power and pelf. Though they were in know of the
developments yet dismissed it as a stray case of mysterious murder. The Mahant of the Vicharnag shrine
on the outskirts of Srinagar was brutally murdered by a constable in the employ of J&K Government
when he dared spurn the offer of conversion to Islam as an alternative to his murder. The powers that be
did not pretend to be shaken and were in high voltage jubilation as events were unfolding as per the
delineated blue-print. A Pandit lady travelling in a bus in Pulwama was blatantly molested by the Muslim
passengers thus pointering to the all-time low dip in Muslim rationality. The incident though highlighted
at many a forum did not send shock waves in the ranks of ruling mandarins. A Kashmiri Pandit lady in
thirties serving as a staff-nurse in a government hospital was whisked away and stripped stark naked and
pushed out on the highway for every passer-by to witness her humiliation and dismaying as it is the
incident that did not cause horror to the guardians of law and order. A bullet was shot at a Kashmiri
Pandit lady killing her on the spot and in the ensuing whirlwind of confusion most of the Pandit ladies
crossing the Habbakadal bridge were ruthlessly mauled and molested. It caused no tremors and law
enforcing agencies completely infected and polarised felt no impetus to act to checkmate and blot out the
forces that were unleashing brutalities reminiscent of medievalism. A Kashmiri Pandit in budding youth
was killed by a Muslim killer in broad daylight and the authorities hush-hushed the whole case and posed
the killer as an insane despite his confession that he was paid money to kill any Pandit who came his way.
A notorious brigand acting as a muscleman of the powers that be killed a Pandit by forcibly barging into
his house and striking his head with a brick and the police prevaricated for long before an FIR could be
registered. And the progeny of the person murdered were forced to withdraw the case.
The properties of Kashmiri Pandits were being plundered and set afire and the ruling elite as part of the
whole design never moved in the direction of undertaking preemptive measure. A residential house
belonging to a Kashmiri Pandit at Saraibal in Kashmir was burnt to ashes and the government appeared
sunk in a pathetic state of inactivity. The shop of a Pandit situated on the ever-busy court-road in Srinagar
was looted in daylight and the police posse present on the scene disappeared in a jiffy. Most of the Hindu
shops in Ganda Singh Building in Srinagar were savagely looted by the Muslim looters and the
government authorities were in deep comas All liquor shops belonging to Pandits were brutally looted
and the government of the day never bothered to act to rein the frenzied Muslims, thus posing itself as a
model of inertia and inaction. The non-Kashmir Hindus who are bonafidestate Subjects and have a history
of residence in the valley were suddenly looted by the Muslim marauders on the untenable plea that they
are outsiders with no inherent rights to reside and carry on businesses in Kashmir. Yet the government
under the strangle-hold of Muslim fanatics did not feel obliged to act with force to disfigure the monster
of Muslim intolerance. Strikes were flared and demonstrations held against Darwin as his scientific theory
conflicted with the Islamic concept of creation. The government failed to smell the rat. The institutions
founded and run by the Kashmiri Pandit minority were put to bomb blasts and cruel flames of fired and
the senseless violence that was being perpetrated on the minuscule minority did not invite a vigorous
intervention from the government agencies which in reality shared deep commitments to ethnic cleansing.
The supine negligence on part of the government coupled with its incredible imperviousness to the sharp
and precipitous decline in communal and political scenario was deliberate to allow the proliferation and
consolidation of anti-India and anti-minority sentiment and thrust to materialise the ultimate objective of
disengaging Kashmir from the Indian union. The terrorists with training in arms and minds stuck in cages
were operating with policy, purpose and direction and the National Conference-Congress cornbine led by
Farooq Abdullah had commitments to withdrawal from the scene at an opportune moment leaving the
field open for the terrorists to establish their full sway and writ.
37 C ha pte r 5 - J K L F - A N O U T F IT O F K IL L E R S
The advocates of secular character of the Jammu and Kashmir Liberation Front have missed as
inconsequential the Jammat-i-Islami background and orientation of the terroristsaffiliated with the outfit.
As finished products from the Jamaat-i-Islami-manned front organizations including Islamic Students
League and Jamiat-e-Tulba they are in full agreement with the Jamaat-cadres on issues of launching
Jehad, fundamentalistation of Islam and its militarisation and inveterate opposition of pluralism, dissent
and secular ideology. Zia-ul-Haq and Ayatollah Khomeini harbouring fundamentalist views were
proclaimed as the heroes of Islam with visions of revitalizing and restructuring the Islamic movement for
a dominating role in the world with its main thrust against the religious enemies. The duo as the
proclaimed heroes of Islam were never the protagonistsof any brand of secularism. One Islamised
Pakistan and the other preached Islamic revolution with fundamentalist agenda as its guiding beacon.
Pakistan and Iran to the terrorists of JKLF were the model states which could be emulated with a view to
re-shaping and re-structuring Jammu and Kashmir accordant with the Islamic law and precedent.
Rustum ji and Ved Marwah have floated and publicised the unfounded thesis about the secular character
of the Jammu and Kashmir Liberation Front. George Fernandes in his talk and discussion at the centre for
International Affairs at Harvard university asserted the same fallacy that the JKLF was committed to the
maintenance of communal harmony and secular order in the state. Balraj Puri has found reflections of
fraudulent Kashmiriyat in the JKLF. To the disquiet of all supporters of the phoney thesis it was Yossef
Bodansky who as a putative expert on international terrorism in a seminar in New Delhi spotlighted and
exposed the communal substance and motivations of JKLF and its links with rabid organizations globally.
It is amply known that the terrorists operating under the umbrella of JKLF have been wedded to the
agenda of liberating Kashmir from the so-called servitude of India and declaring it as an independent state
under an overarching suzerainty of Islamic state of Pakistan. In its conceptual frame and ideology the
outfit is no different from the Jamaat-i-Islami which is fundamentalist and parochial with deep
commitments to Kashmir's annexation with Pakistan as a Muslim state. There is no denying the fact that
the JKLF has no well-defined ideological contours which could have set its parameters of differentiation
from diverse outfits operating the same fundamentalist agenda. It has been generally observed that the
terrorists connected with groupings having rabidly communal orientation and programme have found
refuge and patronage in the JKLF and have operated under its aegis. What brings the JKLF terrorists at
par with other terrorist groupings is the fundamentalist agenda of Pan-Islamic vintage with its sharp thrust
against non-Muslim religio-ethnic minorities. The communal orientation of the JKLF got revealed when
its cadres went berserk in putting the Kashmiri Pandits to indiscriminate killings obviously to cleanse
Kashmir of infidels who could not be tolerated in the republic that was deemed to be Islamic in form and
content. And the treatment that was meted out to the Hindu minority as an acid test exposed its
commitments to secularism as fake, false and mere presence.
Yossef Bodansky world-famous expert on Islamic fundamentalism snubbed the former security advisor to
the Governor of J&K state pleading for soft-pedalling with JKLF by reminding him that it was JKLF
which had initiated and organised killing of Pandits leading to their forced exodus.
Sheikh Abdullah and Mirza Afzal Beg sponsored and floated the Plebiscite Front that upheld and pursued
the secessionist programme with its emphasis on right of self-determination. With a view to adding
stridency to the secessionist movement an unholy alliance was forged with the Jamaat-i-Islami cadres to
break fresh ground for an armed struggle against the Indian sovereignty over the state of Jammu and
Kashmir and as an upshot a terrorist outfit Al Fateh surfaced which indulged in destruction and sabotage
on a large scale. The Jammu and Kashmir Liberation Front not only inherited and resurrected the
ideological content of Al Fateh but invested it with a new facelift in terms of impetus and orientation. It is
a common observation that after 1975-Accord with Mrs. Gandhi, the subversives with a heavy crime
record were showered lavish patronage and installed in key positions in government apparatus and
National Conference. With the outbreak of insurgency these subversives served the support-plank for the
JKLF which established its broad sweep and range with the government falling in line as a matter of sheer
connivance.
The drive against liquor shops, beauty and video parlours, cinema halls and other expressions of modern
civilisation was carried to the hilt by Allah Tigers which was operating under the cover of JKLF. The
outfit continued to Operate independently to kill and torture the Kashmiri Pandits, but its witch-priest, Air
Marshal Noor Khan, Joined the ranks of JKLF and propagated extreme strictness in religion and morals
for the reformation and purification of the Muslim society. The stance of JKLF vis-a-vis
fundamentalisation of Muslim society was the same as that of rabid Jamaat-i-Islami and other outfits
which are vociferously communal and brazenly sectarian.
The Jammu and Kashmir Liberation Front upholding; independence as an option in opposition to the first
two options of nexus of Kashmir with India or Pakistan has trapped a number of wiseacres who
pontificates as a mere assumption or concoction that third option is nationalistic in content with
commitments to secularism. But the said organisation despite its sham commitments to third option has
not at any point of time in its history negated or expressed its opposition to the establishment of Kashmir
as a Muslim State with Nizam-e-Mustafa as its ultimate destination establishing Muslim ascendancy and
authoritarianism, and brutal discrimination against non-Muslim religioethnic minorities. Pakistan and
Bangladesh as avowedly Muslim states have liquidated, converted or herded out the Hindu minorities and
have suppressed non-conformity, axed tolerance and accommodation and resorted to an unabated policy
of persecution. The expulsion of lakhs of Kashmiri Pandits from their home-land in Kashmir has put the
secular ideology in deep freeze and the Indian secularists despite its portents have evaded the
consequences ensuing from the Muslim refusal to co-exist with the Hindus even though a small minority.
And minus the Indian ostriches the world knows that the expulsion of non-Muslim ethnic minorities was
the handiwork of JKLF and its affiliates.
The terrorists of the JKLF brand were the first to wage war on the Kashmiri Pandits. The first hit-lists
were prepared, issued and updated by its cadres operating from the precincts of mosques and the first
killings were resorted to by the hounds of the same outfit. Tika Lal Taploo, B.K. Gangoo, Navin Sapru,
Ashok Kumar Qazi, Prem Nath Bhat, Sarwanand Koul Premi, T.K.Razadan, Nila Kanth Ganjoo et al
were brutally massacred by the cadres of JKLF, who took pride in fixing JKLF tags on their bodies,
bleeding and writhing in excruciating pain and agony and sadistically footing dances in extreme glee and
joy shared by hordes of Muslims present on the scene. The brutal killing of Sarla Bhat who was a nurse
on the staff of the Institute of Medical Sciences, Srinagar was also the handiwork of JKLF. The thigh of a
Hindu lady chopped off from the main body was branded JKLF. Noor Khan, Sher Khan, Bita Karate,
Showkat Bakshi, Yasin Malik, Dr. Abdul Ahad Guru, Hamid Sheikh, Javed Mir and Ashfaq Majid Wani-
all owing allegiance to JKI F-have oiled their hands with the blood of Kashmiri Pandits and their women-
folk. Bita Karate in his T.V. Interview shamelessly confessed the massacre of forty Kashmiri Pandits. The
total exodus of Kashmiri Pandits from the valley was near complete by October, 1990 and it was brought
about by the armed and unarmed activists of Jammu and Kashmir Liberation Front through ruthless
killings, torture and fear psychosis and yet it is secular.
The JKLF in the wake of dastardly killing of the religious minority of Pandits was asked to clarify its
position with respect to them and brazenly made it known through the 'Kashmir Times' issued from
Jammu that they must play a constructive role in the emergence of Kashmir as an independent state and if
they are keen to preserve their cultural heritage, entity and physical existence, they must lend support in
full to the JKLF. It sounded funny when Pandits were conveyed that they must prevail upon New Delhi to
implement the U.N. Resolutions on Kashmir without any further delay and dither as they are heard in
Delhi and have access to the corridors of power. H.N. Jattu broached the subject of Pandit killings with
Mufti Bahu-ud-din, Ex-Chief Justice, an ideologue of JKLF and Dr. Abdul Ahad Guru, a Pakistani
saboteur planted in the Institute of Medical Sciences, Srinagar who had set the pace for Pandit migration
through his war on M.L. Bhat, ex-Chief Engineer, posted in the Institute as chief engineer. Though
rebuffed, Jattu continued to contact them for stopping the killing of Pandits which was fast gaining pace
and momentum. He was asked if the JKLF stand vis-a-vis Kashmiri Pandits was clarified to him when
Ashok Kumar Qazi who was the organising secretary of his organisation was mercilessly tortured to
death.
The secular cloak of Jammu and Kashmir Liberation Front was torn to shreds when mosques that had
mushroomed all over the valley on an uprecedented scale were put to the unholy use of spewing out
venom against the infidels dubbing them as agents of India and flaring them to quit and buzz off the so-
called land of Muslims. They were threatened and cursed in the classical Muslim fashion. The mammoth
crowds of Muslims flitting about the streets rent the skies with stinking and lousy slogans and suffused
the environs with communal poison and hatred indicating the collapse of their will to resist the Frankstein
of terrorism. That the war waged by the JKLF terrorists was Islamic in content and spirit was established
by the fact of mosques having emerged as the focal centres of their struggle. Do secular movements
commence with volatile slogans tinted Islamic? Do secular movements target ethno-religious minorities
for the religion that they harbour? From its seminal beginnings the JKLF distanced itself away from the
ideological concept of a democratic state based on rational modernity. It did not hold aloft the banner of
religious tolerance and human fraternity. In its immediate political behaviour it rejected the involvement
of all segments of Kashmiri population and the spree of killings and orgy of loot that the JKLF let loose
typical in its Islamic frenzy were seen more as a conspiracy than a rational movement. Its calculation and
arithmetic were devised in absolute collaboration with the first generation Muslim learners who lacking in
dynamics of rational analysis exaggerated the support structures of America, Islamic countries and more
than most Pakistan which failed to wage a war on India as per its pledge. Had JKLF been secular it would
not have allowed religious bigotry to shade its political calculations and strategies. Resilience of the
Indian state with its commitments to secularism was not taken note of in factorial analysis.
The Jammu and Kashmir Students Liberation Front (JKSLF) operated as an Islamist organisation
nomenclaturing itself as Ikhwan-ul-Muslimeen (Muslim Brothers). Its front ranking leader, Hilal Baig,
has unequivocally projected and championed the "Islamicisation of Kashmir" as the dominating objective
of the current struggle in Kashmir. He also commands the armed wing of the organisation which has set
new records in terrorism and destruction.
The tidal wave of Jehad and religious bigotry that was generated and unleashed by the JKLF flowed into
the cesspool of rape and murder, loot and plunder and to the surprise of the admirers of Jehad and Azadi,
the Mujjahids of yesterday and hordes of V-flaunting Muslim supporters are seen taking holy dips and in
the process commitments to the "Independent Kashmir" have completely thinned and washed out. The
tribal Jehad as per the historical tomes launched in 1947 was lost in the rape of the bazzars of
Muzzfarabad and the Jehad of 1989-variety launched with the same gusto and contours has been lost in
the habitations of Kashmiri Pandits. The rape of Muzzfarabad was complete in three days and the
Pakistani army officer setting the goal and direction of the Jehad could rally them back for more ravishing
booties but the rape of the Pandit habitations has unceasingly gone on for seven years and no self-styled
champion of Islam has re-grouped them for a renewed Jehad as they are all submerged and lost under the
ocean of booties and loot of moneys pouring in from various sources.
The Jammu and Kashmir Liberation front ushering in a tornado of terrorism was backed up by a
gendarme of propagandists mostly drawn from National Conference activists at grass-root level. The
operations that the outfit evolved and executed were meticulously planned and schemed with a view to
drumming up euphoric support for its atrocious killing of Kashmiri Pandits. It banked upon a massive
network of propagandists, treacherous and wily, who in the fabrication of lies and their dissemination
outstripped and to a large measure excelled even the Nazi propaganda machine. The gory and dastardly
killings of innocent Pandits could not be explained even by Muslims and to quench dissent and doubt, the
Muslim propagandists hatefully castigated them and commanded that their had been killed after due
verification of their anti-Muslim activities and credentials and a stage came with the broadening of their
reach and sweep that Muslims fell in line and came to believe that Mujjahids could do no wrong and
much against the demands and requirements of sanity they joined the ranks of marauders and killers
pledged to wiping out the whole race of Hindu Kafirs. The exodus of Kashmiri Pandits emmassefrom
their native abode was maliciously attributed to the then governor, Jagmohan, by the same brand of
canard-spinners and to the amazement of everybody Muslims without a difference parroted the same tune
and song.
Despite the insidious and spiteful role in the expulsion of Kashmiri Pandits, the JKLF propagandists
never contributed to the belief that Pandits had started a new chapter of their life as hapless refugees in
tattered tentages and ramshackle hutments. Fearing nation-wide backlash the media perhaps at the behest
of powers that be played the migration extremely cool, yet there were patriotic agencies which in sheer
defiance of government policy of curbs and distortions splashed the Pandit migration supported by
harrowing photographs inside and outside the country. The JKLF supporters connected with media took it
yet another canard and mischief innovated by Government of India which in Kashmir passes for an
incarnation of Satan. To confirm the truth of camps having come up in the desert lands of Jammu and see
the reality for themselves, a group of ardent supporters of JKLF flaunting "V" signs, with a few of them
connected with media agencies, paid a visit to the camps at Muthi in the company of a Kashmiri Pandit,
whom they found pliant and obliging and had sought his assistance.
Peeping into the first tent etched on one side of the road running through the Jungle of tentages, they were
shell-shocked to see a young Kashmiri Pandit lady, wan, sallow and broken initiating her two children in
learning how to read and write English alphabets and were wondering with gaping mouths that the tents
had not broken their tryst with education and learning. After they were reluctantly received into the tent
they again felt shocked that the limited space within the tent was maintained spic and span. On enquiry
the lady all soaked in tears informed them that her husband in twenties was killed by the JKLF terrorists
and now as a widow at 27 she was maintaining her family on the meagre dole that the government paid
her and back home her family had enormous landed assets.
After traversing some distance they through the good offices of the Pandit accompanying them entered
another tent and found the inmates sitting on a printed blue sheet of cloth with two pillows decently
placed perhaps for the guests who might be paying them a visit off and on. The family was presided over
by a lady in sixties who, when asked, informed the visitors not only drawing but appeared to be drawing
pathological comfort from their plight that her husband was atrociously killed in his own orchard by the
gun-wielding Muslim neighbours who did not permit them to perform his last rites and since then they
have been grieving over his death in the tent that was allotted to them after a rigorous battle.
One of them truculently told her that Muslims had also lost their near and dear ones, but Kashmiri Pandits
never protested and maintained silence. Tears rolling down her sunken eyes the lady meekly told the
Muslim wearing a well-cut beard that if two families suffered deaths, each would mourn separately and
grieve over its own losses in terms of human life.
A school-going boy sitting by the side of his grandmother could be seen intently listening to the
conversation between the Muslim visitors and his grandma. The same person shot him a question if he
would like to return to his school in the native village. With all confidence the boy made a telling reply as
tohe could return to the same school because his class-mates mostly Muslims had guns to wield and
pistols to fire and had punctuated the whole area with hundreds of blasts.
On enquiry the boy again informed them that he was preparing for 10 + 2 examination and would be
joining an engineering college in Maharashtra. It was again a shock to them as it did not fit in the scheme
of things that they had planned for the Kashmiri Pandit learners. Though living in blighted conditions
they had not joined the ranks of waifs and strays. This is what left them dismayed and disappointed.
The group of Muslims had planned to see all the tents and have an interaction with the exiled Pandits for
reasons best known to them. But some Kashmiri Pandits who out of sheer curiosity had collected on the
scene politely informed them that they were welcome, but their sons and daughters were busily preparing
for examinations and hence it was improper and unwise to disturb them at this juncture. If they could
choose to pay a visit some other time, they would certainly talk to them at least about the conspiracy that
"V" flaunting monsters of hate had hatched to herd them out of their native places to transform Kashmir
into a Muslim inferno.
The Muslims linked with various media agencies pretended to be shocked and took it as a jolt to the
newly coined diabolical concept of Kashmiriyat and promised the Pandit who had accompanied them and
led them to the camps at Muthi that they would certainly highlight the miserable plight of Pandits living
in squalid camps. But, to the shock and dismay of the Pandit, yet not convinced of Muslim diabolerie,
they never wrote about it. How could they? This is the destiny that the Muslims perhaps with few
exceptions had warily planned in stealth for the Pandits who are stigmatised as Kafirs in Muslim parlance.
38 C ha pte r 6 - J A M M A A T - I- IS L A M I - A N O U T F IT O F P A R O C H IA L S
The Jammaat-i-Islami responsible for paving the way for inaugural of a destructive insurgency in 1988
inchoated in 1942 as a separate chapter from the Jammaat-i-Islami Hind and forging an open-ended
affiliation with the Pakistani brand of the outfit doggedly pursued the secessionist agenda and worst form
of communalism with its principal opposition to the core principles forming the cornerstone of Indian
democratic polity. That it would broaden the sweep and range of its appeal to such an extent that it would
emerge as a determining factor of Kashmir politics was practically beyond comprehension. The rigidities
of its adherence to the basics of Islam and its practices were not in sync with the pervasive shrine tradition
which the Kashmiri Muslims stuck to and could not abandon as an inherited religious practice and
behaviour. As is abundantly known the Jammaat-i-Islami as an organisation was held in utter contempt
for the abhorrence that it harboured against the shrine worship and the practices smacking of Hinduism.
In the seminal stages of its growth and development its appeal and influence were confined to its
committed cadres who did not form a spectacular number.
After the deposition of Sheikh Abdullah as the Chief Minister in 1953 the Jammaat-i-Islami as the rabid
fundamentalist organization proliferated at an enormous rate under the patronage of politicals who
manned the structures of political power in the state. Bakshi Ghulam Mohammad in his efforts to combat
Sheikh Abdullah hobnobbed with the rabid outfit and made resources to the ton of seventy-five thousand
available for the expansion of its roots among the Kashmiri Muslims. Moneys were fed to the
organization for establishing Islamic schools and teachers on staff of these seminaries of venom and hate
were paid from the Muslim Auqaf (trust) which has been aiding the Islamisation processes quite
generously. The Muslims with pro-Jammaat leanings and affiliations were granted out-of-turn
promotions, lucrative postings and also appointments in government services. Bakshi persuaded and
goaded a number of Muslims in government services to give up their jobs and devote themselves
assiduously to the expansion of the organization at grass-root level. The accusation was made by G.M.
Sadiq against Bakshi Ghulam Mohammad in 1957 on the floor of the House.
Jamaat-i-Islami upholding the secessionist agenda could not but forge links with the Plebiscite Front as an
organisation pledged to the secessionist agenda. Many of its front-ranking leaders worked hand in glove
with the Plebiscite Front which fact came to lime-light when they courted arrests along with the ardent
supporters of the Plebiscite Front. That they were unflinching in their positions became manifest when the
Jammaat-i-Islami representative attending the People's convention organised by Sheikh Abdullah
vehemently opposed the move for dialogue and reconciliation with the central government. The jammaat
rebids in their concerted bid to isolate Sheikh Abdullah and to impair his public image gave widest
possible currency to the theme-song of his betrayal in 1947 for having opted for India to the detriment and
demise of broad Muslim interests. The campaign had such vehemence that Sheikh Abdullah wilted and
flinched against its vigorous pressure and resorted to numerous postures that smacked of parochialism and
communalism much in conflict with his secular pretensions.
The Jamaat-i-Islami entrenched its roots deep in Muslim society and had its hey day during the notorious
congress rule of Ghulam Mohammad Sadiq and Mir Qusim who showered concessions and privileges
galore on the organisation and its sympathisers. The Islamic schools were patronised and financed to
proliferate and expand without fear or fetter. Key slots in government apparatus were not only offered but
specially reserved for the Jammaat-oriented Muslims. Government services were made available on
priority basis in relaxation of rules and norms to the sons and daughters of Mullahs who owed allegiance
to and had long associations with the outfit. The Backward Classes Association with Saif-ud Din Soz,
now a central Minister, as its secretary was Jamaat-innovated and Jamaat-led and was patronised to
scuttle the supreme court judgments which had pushed the Sadiq government into the vortex of a grim
crisis. The schools run by government were allowed to be transformed into battle-fields to organise war
on the senior-most Kashmiri Pandit teachers who had fought against religious discrimination and were
pressing for implementation of Supreme Court judgments in view of the government fiddling &
prevarication. To unleash Muslim bigotry and beat Kashmiri Pandits into submission clandestine pacts
were forged with the Jammaat-i-Islami rebids who were in the vanguard of anti-Pandit demonstrations
yelling out war-cries against them during Kashmiri Pandit Agitation of 1967. It was under the severe
pressure of Jamaati-Islami politicals and government officers with pro-Jamaat tilt and tendency that Mir
Qasim, the treacherous, rushed through the Land Reforms Bill of 1972 divesting the Kashmiri pandits of
small chunks of land which were left in their possession after the tyrannical Land reforms Bill of 1952.
The said-Bill replete with Communal poison and bias conveyed the signals that Pandits had to be pushed
out through economic squeeze to meet the ends of ethnic cleansing. The political and religious clout and
credibility of the Jammaat touched a crescendo when it won seven Assembly seats in perfidious
collaboration with Sadiq and Qasim as the congress rulers.
There does not seem much of-pith and substance in the assessment that Sheikh Abdullah was a prime
factor in thwarting and stone-walling the growth and expansion of the Jammaat-i-Islami in Kashmir. If his
utterances are a credible guide, it can be said that he was never averse to and at war with the Jammaat-i-
Islami and whatever opposition he demonstrated unto the outfit it did not flow from and was not rooted in
his ideology and conviction. There were clear indications that he wanted the outfit to carry out his dictates
& operate under the wings of his parsonage. When there were ample signals from the ground that the
Jammaat was gaining a distinctive political personality of its own away from the pale of his person posing
a threat to his crown and sceptre, he had no qualms to swoop on it through loot and plunder of its cadres
only to give it a jolt but not a death-blow. And ultimately he made a truce with the rabid organisation and
that was how the Jamaatists stuffed the innards of his organisation and cabinet. Saif-ud-Din Soz,
Mohammad Shafi, Abdual Gani Lone, to name a few, with tremendous Jammaat-i-Islami back-ground
and orientation were very close to the Sheikh and the latter two feathered his cabinet. It was Mohammad
Shafi who is said to have stopped the Sheikh in his tracks when he was on the point of issuing orders to
ban the organisation especially its Islamic Schools and it was Abdul Gani Lone who stuffed the
educational institutions with Jammaat commandos and brain-washed Muslims. The Sheikh's fulminations
against Jamaat were fake and meaningless. His tirades and innuendoes against it were hollow and
pointless. In reality, he had lots of empathies and ideological affinities with the outfit as his secessionist
proclivities found a new nourishment at the hands of the organisation which upheld and pursued the
secessionist goals with much greater vigour and virulence.
The Jammaat-i-Islami subscribing to blatant communalism and militarised Islamic fundamentalism led to
the absolute destruction of an ethos that was rooted in 5000 year old history of Kashmir. The fanatic pro-
Pakistan cadres of the outfit wallowing in mental backwardness and religious bigotry not only preached
and propagated secession with vehemence but fundamentalised the Muslim society and infrastructure of
governance through a large-scale campaign of fundamentalism and indoctrination leaving a pernicious
impact on the Muslim youth and nascent class of mediocre professionals. Parochial and destructive the
Jammaat-i-Islami worked over-time to uproot and decimate the values of tolerance, non-violence and
humanism as weaves of the fabric of Kashmiri society and hammered the Muslims out of the indigenous
cultural model contemptuously labelled as un-Islamic and Brahmanical. The Islamisation campaign
invested with a pointed thrust against catholicity of outlook, eclecticism and syncretism wreaked havoc
on Kashmiri Muslim society which under absolute brutalization and dehumanization not only indulged in
loot, arson and murder of the native Kashmiri Pandits as acts of piety in tune with religious injections, but
failed to throw up even a solitary individual or a body of individuals who dared condemn it as
retrogression and sheer savagery. The destructive war against the indigenous ethos of non-violence,
tolerance and humanism was carried on without a relent by Jammaat-i-Islami net-work of 11,000 urdu
and Arabic schools led by Mullahs as commandos and its nodal organizations like Islamic Students
League, Islamic students organization, Jamaat-e-Tulaba et al. The Muslim killers leading various terrorist
outfits straining every nerve to destruct the deep-rooted unique identity and authenticity of culture groups
subscribing to a world view in sharp contrast to the value-less value structure planted on intolerance and
religious myopia has had their grooming and churning in the Islamic schools as sanctuaries of rabid hate
and prejudice. The Islamisation campaign unleashed with the fury of a hurricane and the state apparatus
falling in line targeted and bruised the indigenous milieu embedded in the Vedic Age and the same was
given a fillip by the extension of invitations to the religious Mullahs from inside and outside the country.
The Jammaat as the pioneer of Islamisation campaign held an International Conference at Srinager in full
knowledge of the powers that be and invited the Imam of Mecca to boost up its religious credibility with a
view to mustering support for the launch of a frontal attack on the Indian presence in Kashmir.
A deal of understanding was struck between Sheikh Abdullah and Jammaat-i-Islami through the good
offices of the sister of the Saudi Arabian King when she paid a visit to Kashmir. In 1981-82 the Saudi
Arabian intelligence chief came to Kashmir twice with a view to adding new stridency and strength to the
secessionist movement which was in the processes of being fed by the Sheikh and Jamaati-Islami who
were never at different points on the wavelength. Rector of Madina university also paid a visit to Kashmir
to boost up the political fortune of the AntiHindu and anti-India forces in Kashmir. It has been of stated
that the state power and Jammaat-i-Islami have worked in tandem to Islamise and indoctrinate the
Kashmiri polity for the launch of Jehad against the infidels. Chasing the twin objectives of secession and
Islamisation the Jammaat emerged as the magnetic pole that gravitated the secessionist forces to itself
with the state power actively sharing the lead-role of the rabid outfit.
The Jammaat-i-Islami in Kashmir has launched a consistently virulent battle against the concept of
secularism which envisages a society sane and rational, pluralistic and accommodative. Contributing to
myopic communalism and fanaticism it upholds an Islamic society placed on the pedestal of Shariat,
Islamic precept and tradition as the ultimate destination of Muslims. Essentially parochial and leagues
away from modernity and rational democratic temper it has expressed its visceral hatred against a system
that is pluralistic and liberal contributing to composite culture patterns. As Islam has always thrived and
expanded under state patronage and protection the Jammaat does not subscribe to the separation of
religion from state power and that is why it has made an inveterate misuse of mosques as vehicles of
genocide, terror, scare and communal tension and mosques in Kashmir as is well known have proliferated
in the post-1947 era with Arab moneys. The formidable net-work of 600 study centres, units, thousands of
Islamic schools, libraries and mosque committees have sown arid scattered the seeds of bigotry and
religious indoctrination with a view to destroying secularism as a wall of life and posing the Islamic
society regulated by Islamic laws as an alternate model. The socio-political programmes as projected by
the rabid outfit are deep-dyed in the Islamic colour and Jehad is posed as a weapon for the establishment
of a socio-political destination as conceived in Nizam-e-Mustafa. The lone Jamaat M.L.A. in a press
conference in 1980 said that secular and socialist forces were a severe threat to the Kashmir Muslims.
The Jammaat-i-Islami with its vast array of brainwashed and regimented cadres from all walks of life with
urban and rural setting has acted as an arm of Pakistan on the soil of Kashmir. It has not only exported its
cadres to the training camps in Pak-occupied Kashmir, Afghanistan and Iran for arms training but ensured
Muslim intervention through Pakistan to add more doses of lethal violence to the Kashmiri Muslim ethos
already soaked in violence and fanaticism. The Dukhtaran-i-Milat (Daughters of Muslim community) as
the women's wing of the outfit has also exported thousands of Muslim girls to the same camps that are
manned by Sudanese, Saudi Arabian and Afghan desperadoes. Drawing main sustenance from Pakistan in
terms of fundings, strategies and political patronage, the Jammaat has been in thick contacts with the
Islamic countries that are chasing the goals of fundamentalist Islam. The war though low in intensity was
initially unleashed by the local Muslim terrorists affiliated to the Jammu and Kashmir Liberation Front,
but was in no time as a matter of strategy taken over under the instructions of mentors across the borders
by the Hizbul Mujahidecn which is the fierce fundamentalist armed wing of the Jammaat-i-Islami
butchers. On the plane of ideology the Jammaat is the votary of the Khomeini brand of revolution and
poses the Islamic Republic of Pakistan though a tailed state as the model of Nizam-e-Mustafa. It owes
ideological allegiance to and is directly a party to the crusading forces of militarised fundamentalist Islam
that have been operating on twin fronts of Kashmir and Tajkistan with a view to overrunning India and
Central Asia.
With a view to ethnically cleansing Kashmir the rabid Jammaat-i-Islami through its armed wing of Hizbul
Mujahideen has waged war on the native Pandits in close complicity with multiform Muslim terrorist
formations pursuing the same end. The terrorists of the outfit with a terrific religious background and
indoctrination have added bone-chilling and horrendous crimes to the despicable book of medieval
savageries and brutalities. Before putting the Pandits to a barrage of bullets they in servile obedience to
their religious training in the cesspools of Islamic schools inflicted torture and pain on them by way of
chopping off their tongues and peeling off their skin, gouging out their eyes and ripping open their bellies.
The infliction of pain and agony, death and destruction on the Kafirs reveals their new dynamics as
fanatics, mad men, psycopaths and mentally abnormal. The merchants of crime stuffing the outfit have
not been hired to assassinate the Pandits but they have been consciously and wilfully pursuing the path of
extermination of Pandits to work out the Islamic goals of realising an exclusivist social and political order
smacking of fascism. As was configurated by the Jammaat and its hateful leaders the willful assassins
have barged into the houses of Pandits, committed rape and plunder and squirted bullets on them. It has
been a plain murder of Pandits for the reason that they have refused to join the ranks of rebellious
Muslims and have withstood the pressures exerted on them through the state power manned by Jammaat-
oriented Muslims and men of their ilk. The killing of Pandits by the Muslim terrorist outfit of HM awash
with Islamic bigotry and hate has not only destabilised the Pandit minority but has also symbolised a
wanton onslaught on the historical identity of Kashmir founded on the plank of composite culture and
syncretism.
The Jammant-Islami with its known linkages with the politicals and rabid fundamentalists of Pakistan and
other Islamic countries has minced no words in repudiating and rejecting the accession of the J&K State
to the Indian Union. Despite its participation in a number of elections as required under a democratic
dispensation its fundamental stance has been that of stiff and uncompromising opposition to the State's
accession to India. As is widely known the Indian Independence Act of 1947 had empowered the
Maharaja of the state to exercise his options of acceding to either of the two dominions of India and
Pakistan and the Maharaja exercised his options which subsequently were ratified by the constituent
assembly of the J&K State constituted under due process of law. The Jammaat-i-Islami as a
fundamentalist organisation has not swallowed the reason and logic of the whole historical reality and
taking to the plank of two-nation theory it has been propagating for the state's accession to Pakistan on the
basis of Muslim majority character of the state. With a view to hiving off the state from the Indian Union
the Jamaat has launched not only a secessionist campaign through its Mullah-dominated mosque
committees but has also sponsored a terrorist outfit of Hizbul Mujahidden which is armed to the teeth and
has inflicted brutal violence and persecution with its comparable parallels to the history of Nazis on a
segment of population that has reposed no faith in the absurd formulations of two-nation theory and
Islamic society inspired by Islamic law and precept. Steeped in tribalism and narrow perspectives the
Jammaat has been instrumental in propagating codes and fiats lacking in relevance to the contemporary
techno-cultural and civilisational developments. In its sharp opposition to the clubs, video-parlours,
cinema houses, pubs and bars, the organisation as a combination of stereo-typed Mullahs, ignorant,
fanatic and backward, has made them as the basis of its political and religious opposition to India which
has been a gargantuan culture and civilization with a deep streak of liberalism and Catholicism running
through it.
In May, 1973 the hard-core Jammaat-i-Islami followers Ut1leashed massive religious frenzy in Srinagar
and Anantnag against a volume titled as Book of Knowledge authored by a European. The book was
already banned yet the Muslim fundamentalists accused Government of India of importing books replete
with anti-Islamic materials. Tulba as the students wing of the organization launched a virile campaign
against the university authorities to withdraw books from the university library which included outline of
history by H.G. Wells, Divine Comedy by Dante, Encyclopaedia Brittanica, Volumes 5 and 9 and all
works on history by Toynbee.
39 C ha pte r 7 - A F G H A N S A G A IN IN V IT E D - P A R A D O X IC A L
They say that public memory is short-lived, but there are stupendous disasters which cannot be easily
forgotten. As per the consensual estimate of historians, the Afghan tenure of rule in Kashmir was a total
disaster and all hues of people especially the Muslim majority rued the day when two Muslim leaders had
invited the Afghans to annex Kashmir to Kabul. They are said to have groaned and smarted under the
barbarous rule of Afghans and yearned for the times when they would be redempted from their oppression
and ferocity. Despite the experience being bitter and awesome, the Muslims by and large bloomed with
elation when a new nexus with the Afghans though for a different ball game was forged by the Muslim
outfits operating under dubious nomenclatures with open-ended patronage from ISI of Pakistan that has
been feeding and funding terrorism in Punjab and Kashmir. It is after due deliberations that the strategists
across the borders inducted and are inducting the Afghans said to be war-hardened into the secessionist
ranks. The twin motives behind this move are to add more teeth to the on-going terrorism and assure the
Kashmiri Muslims that they are not alone in the crusade against India and Kashmiri Pandits. The nexus
though evolved in stealth is an open secret known to all levels and shades of Muslim opinion.
If history is a guide, there should have been a strong resistance to the move, but there was no protest, loud
or subdued, not even a murmur of resentment. Instead all cells of Muslim intellectuals operating in every
house and office, factory and field, hospital and school endorsed the correctness of the measure as it was
deemed to quicken the processes of redemption from the Indian hegemony. What is surprising that the
historical wrongs and indignities that the Afghans had perpetrated on 'the garden of eternal beauty' and
the populace inhabiting it were conveniently bypassed and forgotten. That they had reduced them to
dismal poverty and abysmal illiteracy and had launched wanton assaults on their moral fibre were not
considered for due thought and deliberations. What cements their bonds with the Afghans is the war that
they have launched against Pandits as the branded enemies of Islam and political linkages with India
though voluntarily forged.
The change in perception was brought about by the protracted war that the Afghans fought against Soviet
Russia which was maligned for spearheading the godless philosophy of communism. The war that had all
the ingredients of crusade was blatantly fuelled and fed by the lethal weapons and bags of money
funnelled by America through Pakistan. The final discomfiture and fall of Soviet structure was hailed and
celebrated as an enormous victory for Islam. The Khomeini brand of revolution plus the Soviet collapse
inflamed the fundamentalist Muslims and their crowds of supporters with pride and passion. The Islamic
organisations that have proliferated and mush-roomed like vicious weeds with lavish patronage through
tonnes of money from a number of Muslim countries have widely set afloat and disseminated the thesis of
restoration of caliphate (though consigned to the dustbin of history) from Kashmir and central Asia to the
shores of ATLANTIC OCEAN. The thesis as such dyed in deep green appeared mesmerising, viable and
within the realms of possibility with the sudden, cracking and crumbling of political and administrative
edifice in Kashmir and hounding our of the entire native tribe of Kashmiri Pandits deemed as a vital
support -plank for the Indian presence in Kashmir.
The Afghans have been perceived through the prism of the same thesis of re-emergence and re-
vitalisation of Islam regaining its old glory. For the Muslim masses with few exceptions who do not make
a summer, they have ceased to be the hated people tagged as butchers, kakad khans-foolish and low in
understanding, sodomites and rapists and in actual estimation their stock has incredibly notched up. They
are now warmly and Jubilantly hailed as the soldiers of Islam, Mujjahids and Ghazis fighting and battling
for the holy cause of Islamic religion and extirpating infidelity and as operatives on Kashmir soil working
to the end of redempting and freeing Muslim millions frown the imaginary tyrannies of infidels and
heathens and materialising the dream of independence, annexation to Pakistan and Nizam-e-Mustafa. A
real big task in the service of Islam by all standards.
With this remarkable change in perception the Afghans have been harboured and welcomed with open
arms. They are free to intrude upon the privacy of men and women. They are fed on beef and other
protein rich foods. The Kashmiris present on the scene are said to have added startling records to the
domain of hospitality by not closing their doors at the fall of dark nights. The houses as fortresses with
doors and windows shut and barred is a bygone tale. The Afghan Mujjahids are accompanied by other
brands of Mujjahids hailing from Yemen, Saudi Arbia, Sudan, Libya and Algeria. Poems of praise and
appreciation have been sung and woven around them. Akbar Bhai, Jamal Bhai and Bomber Khan et
alhave resorted to large scale letchery (please consult their rape records) and are objects of extreme
veneration as they arc deemed to liberate Kashmir from the clutches of Indian security forces and
ushering in a new era for Islam and if and when killed in encounters or hide-outs, their burials are largely
attended. People opine that it could be out of moral obligation. But it could not be for guys who have
cruelly flouted and trampled upon common place text-book morals and other acceptable canons allied to
them. For the votaries of Kashmiriat, all brands of Muslims with whatever credentials, stock and hue even
though they vitiate the very spirit of it are acceptable no matter what the price be. After all it has the
sanction of the mullah and the mosque.
The Afghans and other Muslim mercenaries drawn from various Muslim countries where they are
considered as sources of great nuisance and trouble and are outcasts have been invited and inducted into
Kashmir and to everybody's sorrow and dismay have found their unstinted and volatile supporters, who
have succeeded in creating a climate of opinion m their favour by extolling their virtues as soldiers of
Islam and their unmitigated devotion to the cause of Jehad. What is missed that they only camouflage as
crusaders, but actually are in hot pursuit of letchery, sodomy and rape.
There is the standing testimony of a surrendered hardcore terrorist Tariq Hussain alias Turkey who has
unambiguously revealed that the most alluring factor for the Afghan and Pakistani militants to sneak into
Kashmir was the lust for beautiful girls. He named a Pakistani terrorist who violated the chastity of 19-
year old Zarina and made off with her to Pakistan as a prime catch. He disclosed that dishonouring of
Kashmiri women was the essential cause for the local terrorists to drift away from foreign militants.
But Turkey who had pawned his soul to the demon of Muslim bigotry has concealed the abominable
treatment meted out to Kashmiri Pandit women by the terrorists of local variety. Girija, a poor lab-
assistant in a school, was gang-raped and chopped into two halves on a sawing-machine, a barbarity that
can cause a shiver to class savages. In reality, the terrorists of local brand and of Afghan and Pakistani
make are on the same wavelength and own descent to the same tradition and inheritance of acquired
barbarity They have out-heroded one another in the perpetration of brutalities and cruelties on the
innocent victims harbouring a diverse faith and in the process have notched up amazing records. Every
time when crusade with its bag full of cruelties and atrocities is launched against the Kashmiri Pandits,
the likes of Turkey are in the lead role. In 1931, the crusades against the Maharaja ended in the blatant
loot and murder of Pandits and 1931 had its own quota of Turkeys. The crusade of 1947 was lost in the
pools and puddles of loot, murder, arson and rape and the local Turkeys did not lag behind. The crusade
of 1989 variety unleashed with the hurricane fury in the name of Independence and annexation to
Pakistan with Nizam-e-Mustafa as its lone-star was led by Turkeys who have put up a sign inscribed with
loot, murder, arson and rape of Kashmiri Hindus mesmerising all to rally and to the knowledge of all, all
have rallied for the unholy-holy task.
Extremely tired of militancy, yet persevering, in his heart of hearts convinced of its futility, yet
duplicitous, a JKLF activist, said to be an ideologue, camouflaging his identity under a thickly grown
beard, sat quietly sipping a drink in the company of his comrades at a bar in Jammu. Suddenly leaving his
seat with the brimming glass in his hand, he stridently headed towards a Kashmiri Pandit, perhaps his old
acquaintance, also busily boozing and insisted on him to join him at the table. The Pandit grew suspicious
and equivocated for a while, but somehow out of courtesy, a hall-mark of a Pandit, accompanied him to
the table. Quite knowledgeable about Kashmir affairs, the Pandit broke the ice by asking him the latest
about Kashmir and its future. The activist resorting to fanfaronade, a trait Muslims have honed into a skill
with the on-set of terrorism, shot straight that Kashmir is lost to Pandits and India.
Despite being in exile for 7 years, it was hard for the Pandit to swallow it. Fiddling with his glass, he first
asked as to how it was lost when the gun-wielding Mujahids have not captured an inch of Kashmir soil
for 'Independent-Kashmir'. With four larges in his tummy, the activist fully pepped up informed the
Pandit in all exuberance that the Afghans have taken over the crusade against India and he should know
that they put up a valiant battle against Soviet Russia and forced its withdrawal from the Muslim soil of
Afghanistan and India by all standards a weak, poor and internally riven state is unable to withstand the
thrust and fury of Afghan onslaught.
The activist did not stop there. Forgetting that he was carousing in a bar, he flusteringly stood up and
painted an Afghan as a war-steeled soldier with Allah on his lips, two deadly Klashnikovs in his two
hands, and a brick in his bag dangling from his shoulder.
What is this brick in his bag for? Asked the Pandit in absolute astonishment.
The JKLF activist now lost as he was gulping at a furious rate explained to the Pandit, "With the brick
under his head, he sleeps in the open."
The Pandit felt his condition and satisfied the Afghan in the activist by telling him that war is won and
liberation is achieved.
40 C ha pte r 8 - M A S S A C R E O F K A S H M IR I P A N D IT S
The Muslim terrorists operating under multiple forms of incarnations like Jammu and Kashmir Liberation
Front, Muslim Janbaz Force, Ul Umur, Al Burq, Hizbul Mujahideen, Al Jehad, Ikhwan-ul-Muslim et al
sharing visceral hatred against Kashmiri Pandits subjected them to intimidation, panic, rape, murder and
sexual assault with a view to exterminating them from the soil of Kashmir. In sheer violation of
universally accepted charter of rights and law as couched in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights
and other international covenants the terrorists debased, dehumanised and brutalised the cultured and
moderate community of Kashmiri Pandits by destructing and killing them in a punitive war. In heaping
death and destruction on them, the terrorists pursue the objective of dismemberment of the state from the
Indian liberal democratic order for a new political alignment based on religion. Terror was created and
violence propagated to obliterate dissent and opposition to the formulated goals of the terrorists. The
elements that were deemed inimical to the terrorist campaign have been liquidated with impunity and
subjected to an untold orgy of Nazi-type torture and persecution. Waves of communalism have been
fanned and fuelled thereby polarising the Kashmiri society for furtherance of political ends. The Kashmiri
Pandits as a distinct ethno-religious group have been under a conspiracy targetted, maimed and butchered
in groups and put to detestable forms of violence and brutality to destruct the Indian support planks to
materialist the secessionist goal thus flagrantly violating and transgressing their inherent political rights
and freedoms.
As an indoctrinated breed churned out from the Muslim seminaries of hate, fanaticism and religious
bigotry the Muslim terrorists launched an all-out religious crusade against the non-Muslim ethnic groups
directed to the end product of establishing an Islamic state placed on the foot stool of Shariat (Islamic
Law) which reduces the ethnic and religious minorities to the exiles of a gulag deprived of human rights
and human dignity. They through the dynamics of a religious war are in the quest of pan-Islamic theme
and vision of ascendancy of Islam and the sociopolitical system bearing its seal and sanction at the
expense of religion and faith espoused by minority groups and subgroups. The militarized Islam is not
chasing political goals alone but is rivetting its sights on religious objectives too. The forcible imposition
of a particular religion along with its socio-political order on an ethnic minority harbouring its own set of
beliefs and forms of worship is violative of human rights and essential freedoms that flow from them.
With the shared ideology and agenda of thrusting a second partition on India and transforming the state of
Jammu and Kashmir into an Islamic state, the Muslim terrorists have lost no time in spotting their
political and religious enemies in the Hindu minorities especially the Kashmiri Pandits. Politically the
Kashmiri Pandits repose full faith in and are unflinching supporters of the secular polity of India and as
such do not subscribe to any trend of thought and wave of movement aiming at snapping the historical,
cultural and political ties of the state with indict. It is pertinent to put that they have made no mean
contributions to the dynamics of growth, development and consolidation of democratic and secular order
and political and economic humanism allied with it and as a patriotic force have bitterly opposed the
constitutional barriers which have generated the vicious and baneful forces of separatism and
fundamentalism in Kashmir. In matters of religion the Pandits with the chequered history of torture and
persecution at the hands of Muslims have rejected the antediluvian tendencies breeding religious
perversion and paranoia and are wedded to the Indian discourse of allowance for tolerance and non-
conformity and stand for full flow of freedom for every individual to preach and practice his religion.
They have not only mocked at but held in utter contempt the Islamic police enforcing codes and fatwas
(religious decrees).
The Kashmiri Pandits have vigorously fought the secessionist forces seeking the placement of Jammu and
Kashmir outside the political and constitutional umbrella of India. They fought the Plebiscite Front which
as an organisaistion strove for and was pledged to the secession of the state for its emergence as the
personal fiefdom of the Sheikh dynasty. After the Plebiscite Front as a result of political developments
was deemed to have lost its political relevance and was disbanded, the condemnation of Pandits and
hateful thrust against them did not come to end and as always they were maligned and projected as the
enemies of the Muslim secessionist goals and ambitions. They were abhorred and projected as the "sworn
enemies" and concerted efforts were set afoot to marginalise them for the fact that they stood for the fuller
merger and integration of the state with the Union of India. The Muslim identity of Kashmir to the
exclusion of diverse ethno-religious minorities as an essential cog in the processes of total Islamisation
pursued at state level was exposed to the shreds by the Pandit minority. That is why they have been
branded as the inveterate enemies of Muslim identity which is being perceived under constant threat from
India harbouring a Muslim population equivalent to that of Pakistan.
With their well-known positions on politics and religion the Kashmiri Pandits as such have been opposed
to any movement for Kashmir's annexation with Pakistan and are equally inimical to the retrograde
Muslim programme of pushing the state into the lap of rabid fundamentalism and they, therefore, as a
resisting force were mercilessly massacred and eliminated in hundreds. Some of the killed were engineers
while some held positions in administrative setup. Some victims of genocide were teachers with
remarkable achievements in the domain of learning and creative thinking while some pursued legal
profession. A Hindu scientist who was brutalised to death had a number of research papers to his credit
while another was a highbrow intellectual with enormous studies in the realms of philosophy. Some of the
killed ran groceries while others held ordinary jobs hardly making two ends meet. Even a mad person was
not spared. Most of the victims to the Muslim massacre were innocent and peace-loving people who had
lived in penury and had been denied opportunities under the policy of discrimination which was
institutionalised by a system dominated by the Muslims.
As a weak and unarmed religio-ethnic group the Muslim terrorists put them to a mass massacre and had
their not been prompted by their "race-memory", a repertoire of past history of their persecution, to buzz
off their natural habitat, the terrorists, wildly frenzied and bent upon their destruction and decimation,
would have finished them off as a species.
Terror was created through threats, bomb-blasts, rumours and apochryphal allegations and the terror
machine was so endemic that every man, woman and child became vulnerable. No Pandit felt safe from
the penumbra of violence and terror. Kashmir for the hapless Hindus was reduced to a killing field which
was prowled about by communal and terrorist hyenas.
It was not only in violation of the canons of ethics and morality that Kashmiri Pandits as a miniscule
minority were cruelly killed and tortured but also in utter disregard of decent and civilised political
deporment recognised by the Charter of Human Rights Declaration and several other international
agreements. The killings were monstrous and barbaric paling the killings of Jews by the Nazis into a
triviality. The Pandits were abducted front homes, work-places or streets and tortured and killed to the
brutal ecstasy of their tormentors. The terrorists butchered them even in their homes in the presence of
their defenceless and hapless inmates. Labelling them as "informers" and "agents of India", they were
killed in large numbers without any considerations of age, vocation and political commitments. It is a
genocide of Hindus for the political commitments that they harboured and the religion that they espoused.
As members of a community with a tremendous history in time they have been bodily and mentally
harmed and injured and conditions have been created to bring about their death and destruction. The
terrorists have not concealed their first resolve to destroy the Kashmiri Pandits not only as political
opponents but also as religious enemies. They have generated tremendous mass support for the genocide
of Pandits through the Mosque Committees, plethora of Islamic organizations and Quranic Schools run by
the Jamaat-i-lslami.
The horrendous torture deaths brought about by a resort to barbaric methods will cause a shiver down the
spine of the worst Hitlerites. Burning cigarettes were applied to the naked bodies of Kashmiri Pandits.
Boiling wax was poured on highly sensitive parts of their bodies. Nails were driven into their foreheads.
Their eye-balls were gouged out and tongues chopped off. Male genitals were cut off. Private parts and
breasts of women were hewn open. Women were ripped into two equal parts on a wood-slicing machine.
Gangrapes were resorted to. Bellies were ripped open for entrails to spill out. Hairs from the heads were
plucked out. They were hanged and bullets pumped into their bodies. Kidneys were extracted from the
victims and offered to their parents to chew them at pain of death. Brains were hammered. All barbaric.
Torture deaths have been brought about by the following cruel and savage practices:
1. Hanging
2. Burning alive
3. Strangulation by steel wires
4. Draining of blood in hospitals
5. Drowning alive
6. Beating to death
7. Dragging to death
8. Breaking of body parts
9. Dismemberment of body
10. Slicing
11. Fleecing
12. Gouging of eye balls
13. Branding with red-hot iron bars
14. Impaling
15. Slaughter
In absence of government computations about the killings of Kashmiri Pandits, Sikhs and other Hindus,
private agencies and non-government organizations have put the number of Hindus of all shades who
have been killed at 2,500 out of which Kashmiri Pandits stand out with a figure of eighteen hundred and
odd. The Report submitted to the National Human Rights Commission by PKM has put the figures of
killed Pandits at 319 till October, 1990. B.N. Nissar, editor of the Kashyapvani, has issued out a list of
765 Kashmiri Pandits who were brutally massacred. As per him twenty two ladies were raped and killed,
sixty-six males were kidnapped and released which included Vijay Koul, director of the Regional Institute
of Science and Technology and Dr. A.K. Dhar, director of the Regional Research Laboratory, eighteen
were hanged to death, twenty-five ladies were raped and let off, eight were strangulated, hundred twenty-
four were kidnapped and killed and sixty were critically wounded and died for want of media laid. No
fewer than fifty seven sikhs have been killed. It is said that many a mass massacre of Kashmiri Pandits of
Sangrampora dimension was suppressed and not leaked to the press under the instuructions of the then
Home Minister of India.
The following persons belonging to the minority community of Hindus especially the Kashmiri Pandits as
infidels have been tortured and killed by the methods mentioned above :
him", said the killers. The treatment that was meted out to the father and his son can shame even the worst
Muslim tyrants. The spot where Premi would put his tilak mark was nailed. He was tortured by burning
bits of cigarettes. The limbs of his body were broken. His eyes were gouged out. He was hanged from a
tree and bullets were fired on him. His son was put to the same orgy of torture and death.
Bansi Lal Sapru
The Muslim assassins entered the school where he was teaching a class and forcibly took him out from
the back door of the school and sprayed him over with bullets. He was said to be massacred by the JKLF
murderers.
Ashwani Kumar Garyali
Date of Assassination:
Residence: Baghi Sunder Balla Chattabal
Survived by wife and seven daughters (19,16,13,11,7,5,3)
.He was in his thirties whenhe was shot dead by the Muslim terrorists. He was a petty shop-keeper
dealing in groceries. He was accused of being an informer and an agent of India. As the father of seven
daughters he should have been spared and shown compassion. But the terrorists emptied of such human
empathies and values and thus reduced to the level of barbarity killed him in cold blood The poor and
miserable wife of the deceased asked the Muslim killers to massacre the whole family as their breadearner
had been snatched from them. She was told that they were spared to weep and wail and atone for the sins
of having carried Kashmir to the fold of India.
Attar Singh
Name: Attar Singh
Father's Name: Fateh Singh
Date of Birth: 11.4.1929
Date of Assassination: 26.7.1990
Residence: Saimnoo, Kulagam
Survived by sons (36,30,20), daughters (28,26)
He was an ex-serviceman. He was suspected of being an informer. He was employed at the branch office
of the Hindustan Petroleum in Pulwama. After his duty hours he was returning home and the armed
Muslim gangsters shot him dead. No Sikh-Muslim terrorist pact could save him. When informed of the
killing, Samranjit Singh Mann was said to have felt sorry for the failure of the unholy pact that he had
forged with the Muslim killers.
Maheshwar Nath Bhat
Name: Maheshwar Nath Bhat
Father's Name: Zana Bhat
Date of Birth: 20.6.1921
Date of Assassination: 15.10.1990
Residence: Hazuri Bagh, Srinagar
Survived by wife (65), son (35), daughters (30,27,24)
It was exactly at 8 in the morning that the Muslim killers numbering three forcibly barged into his house
and started making enquiries about his son-in-law, an officer in the Department of Forests. They were told
that he had migrated to Jammu much earlier and the fact of the matter was that he had returned to join his
office on promotion as ACF at the behest and on the assurances of his Muslim colleagues with whom he
had maintained close contacts. During the period of enquiries his son-in-law hid himself in a bath-room
which he had bolted. Frustrated at not getting the prize catch the Muslim killers opened a volley of fire
killing Maheshwar Nath on the spot, injuring his old and ailing wife who in a state of unconsciousness
was hospitalised at Badami Bagh where she was given treatment and shifted to Jammu under security
cover. His relation was also admitted to the same hospital where he succumbed to his bullet wounds.
Shiban Kishen Koul
Name: Shiban Kishen Koul
Fathers Name: Radha Krishen Koul
Date of Birth: 13.5.1953
Date of Assassination: 15/16.7.1990
Residence: Ashmuji, Kulgam, Anantnag
He was in his twenties and was posted at Karnah as a Postal Assistant in the Postal Department. He came
to his native town on a holiday. His having left for Baramulla was conveyed through their accomplices to
the Muslim killers who were waiting for his arrival. In fact one of the killers was said to be following him
from Karnah itself. When he reached home, a killer called at his house and carried him along for a cup of
tea at a tea-shop in the heart of Baramulla town. Unsuspecting Manmohan accompanied his Muslim
friend with whom he had frisked and frolicked in his boyhood days. When he entered the tea shop, other
killers waiting for him hit him with bullets. He died then and there only. It is a classical case of treachery
practiced by the Muslim.
Veer Ji Bhat
He was a professor of Physics, a good teacher, cool, calm and soft spoken. But as ill-luck would have it
he was lost to sanity. As he would be raving and loitering about, the Muslim killers pumped bullets into
him killing him instantaneously. The militarised Muslim bigotry did not spare even an insane for the fact
of his being a kafir and threat to Islam.
Girija Kumari Tiku
Name: Girija Kumari Tiku
Husband's Name: Kanya Lal Tiku
Date of Birth: 15.2.1969
Date of Asassination: 11.6.1990
Residence: Arigam, Bandipora, Baramulla
Survived by mother (60), husband (25), son and daughter (4 and 2)
She was a laboratory assistant posted at Government High School, Trehgam. She had gone to the school
to collect her salary. After collecting her salary, she called on her Muslim colleague in the same village.
Her movements were watched by the Muslim terrorists who kidnapped her from the house of her Muslim
friend. None protested as she was a Hindu Kafir the possession of whose body was halal (lawful). She
was stripped, gangraped, placed on a mechanical saw and chopped into two equal halves. The frenzied
Muslim terrorists committed the grisly crime to establish a political order as conceived in their Nizam-e-
Mustafa. It was a monstrous and barbarous killing.
All brands of human rights activists with blinkers on their eyes failed to notice the gory murder of Girija
Tickoo. But, Salman Khurshid in his book "Beyond Terrorism" had the grace not to conceal the barbarous
murder of the Hindu lady by her Muslim killers who have revived the history of Muslim tyrants.
Writes he, "Girija Tickoo of Bandipora worked as a laboratory assistant at the Girls High School in
Trehgam, Kupwara. She was abducted in June, 1990 gangraped for several days and then shred into
pieces on a bar and saw mill."
Usha Kumari Koul
She was employed as a workman in the Watch Factory at Zainakot. On the fateful day she started her
daily chores at 7 in the morning. Suddenly she found her husband drenched in blood while he was coming
down the stairs She cried and screamed when she noticed the gun-totting Muslim killers leaving the
portals of her house. They returned from the gate and pumped bullets into her killing her m no time. The
Muslim murderers had entered her house stealthily and gone straight to the room of her husband and
sprayed him over with bullets. The couple was murdered in cold blood.
Sarla Bhat
Name: Nila Kanth Raina, M.A (History), M.A. (Economies), M.A. (political Science), B.Ed.
Father's Name: J.N. Raina
Date of Birth: 7.8.1924
Date of Assassination: 30.6.1990
Residence: Khankai Sokhta, Srinagar
Survived by wife (64), sons (40,36,30,28), daughter (26)
He was a veteran teacher with an enviable record of academics. The Muslim killers killed him in the early
hours of morning when he alongwith his family was boarding a truck to buzz off his native place. The
terrorists were none other than his students whom he had initiated to drive away the brute in them, but
despite his initiation the brute remained to take his toll. A full exercise was undertaken by the Muslim
killers prior to his killing. All Muslims in the neighbourhood complied with the commands of the
terrorists to keep their doors and windows open so that after the gruesome murder they would melt away
into their residences. Nobody reported the preparations for his killing to the nearby police station though
that would be a mere formality. Raina was shot at neck and chest and fell down writhing in pain and
agony. Nobody said a word about his cold-blooded murder. Instead the death was celebrated as a victory
for Islam and its militarised Jehad.
In his capacity as a celebrated teacher he entered hundreds of Muslim homes to teachand humanise the
wards of Muslim parents who did not shed a single tear on his death or even offer condolences.
Jawahar Lal Ganjoo
He was a class-IV employee of the Postal Department. He was kidnapped and killed by strangulation near
New Nirhama Bridge, Damhal Hanjipora. He was postmortemed at the Damhal Hanjipora hospital. An
FIR was lodged at the local police station, but was not registered by the station House Officer,
Mohammad Yousuf, who is alleged to be involved in the killing of the hapless Pandit living in sheer
poverty. It was only after lots of pressure by the surviving members of the killed that an FIR was finally
registered bearing No. 42/90 dated 7.8.90
Brij Nath Shah
Name: Brij Nath Shah
Father's Name: Shridhar Shah
Date of Birth: 8.12.1938
Date of Assassination: 27.4.1990
Residence: Ashram Sadhu Ganga, Kandikhas, Handwara
He was an unassuming recluse living on tenter-hooks within the premises of the hermitage(ashram)
popularly known as Saadha Malun which had lots of land attached to it. Prior to his killing many an
attack was launched upon the hermitage by Muslim intolerants with a view to grabbing the shrine. But
Brij Nath everytime frustrated their moves. Once he is said to have repulsed such an attack by thousands
of Muslims by smearing his body with red oxide thereby posing himself as a fearful apparition. The mob
was said to have been led by a local Mullah who through such an attack on the Hindu shrine was paving
his road to heaven. With the rise in terrorist spate Shah was kidnapped and tortured. Shah had his name
tattooed on his fore-arm The flesh at the spot was peeled off. His mouth had been stitched and he was
strangulated to death. The rope round this neck could be visibly seen when his body was recovered.
Chaman Lal Pandita
promised full protection. But when he cried for help, nobody came forward. His killing was a victory for
Islam.
Vasudev Pandita
neighbour's residence who had assured him full safely. On the fateful night ten masked Muslim killers
forced their entry into the house where he was seen just going to bed. They dragged him out, took him to
his own farm and pumped multiple bullets into him. His family searched for him and were shocked to see
him wallowing in his own pool of blood. He was cremated under police protection and his family
members were shifted to a hotel in Srinagar where from they were sent to Jammu under security cover.
The neighbour was in league with his killers. How fake the assurance was?
D.N. Chowdhary
not see and talk to his parents whom he served dutifully. His brutal assassination sent shock-waves not
only into the government circles but also into the Kashmiri Pandit minority. The pace of exodus got
accelerated which had begun the day Pandits perceived a nexus between the terrorists and government of
the day. The Union Home Minister and Information and Broadcasting Minister flew to Srinagar to offer
their condolences to the bereaved family. Shoukat Bakshi of the JKLF is said to be his killer who during
interrogation revealed that Koul was eliminated at the behest of Aman Ullah Khan based in Pakistan.
The Doordarshan Kendra, Srinagar is alleged to be infested with the accomplices and collaborators of the
Muslim terrorists. The file replete with the sinister details regarding some officials of the centre and its
over-all functioning has been moving from one Prime Minister to another but amazingly none has acted to
cleanse the centre of the gross anti-national elements.
Ashok Kumar Qazi
Name: Ashok Kumar Qazi
Father's name: S.N Qazi
Date of Birth:
Date of Assassination: 24.12.1990
Residence: Sheshyar, Habbakadal Srinagar
Survived by:
He was a well known social activist and had wide contacts with people of varied shades. He possessed
tremendous organizational skills and that was how he had emerged as the organising secretary of the
organization led by H N Jattu. With a spurt in the killings of Kashmiri Pandits Jattu had established
contacts with the kingpins of the murderous campaign asking them to explain their attitude unto Pandits
and he was silenced by the brutal killings of Ashok Kumar Qazi.
Qazi was surrounded by a pack of Muslim hounds when he was found in the local market doing some
shopping. He was shot in his knees, fell down in utter agonising state and started screaming for help from
all present on the scene. He was thoroughly known to all the Muslim shopkeepers who never felt kindly
to intervene with a view to saving him from the Muslim butchers. They tenaciously held that his killers
were fighting for Islam which meant death for the Kafirs. The Muslim killers led by Bitta Karate drew
pathological pleasure from Qazi's agonies and in sheer glee started singing and dancing. They plucked out
his hair, slapped him incessantly in the face and spat at him out of absolute contempt. One of the Muslim
brutes opened his trousers, flaunted his genitals and pissed over him. Meanwhile the siren of a police jeep
could be heard from a distance and the killers pierced him with a barrage of bullets. They melted away as
victors in the Muslim dominated locality and Qazi's bullet-riddled body was lying for hours together on
the road covered with blood-stained snow.
Dilip Singh
He was the son of a poor school teacher, who lived in absolute indigence but continued with the inherited
tradition of imparting education to his progeny. He was employed in Jammu and Kashmir Bank. He was
led to the trap of death laid for him by a Muslim friend, who is a cowherd boy. While talking to him the
Muslim boy led him to a lane of the locality where the Muslim killers were waiting for him. When he
came very close to them, he divas fired upon killing him instantaneously. With a view to instilling fear in
the Kashmiri Pandits his body was thrown on a crossing surrounded by the Pandit houses.
Autar Krishen Pandita
Name: Autar Krishen Pandita
Father's Name: Maheshwar Nath Pandita
Date of Birth: 4.3.1967
Date of Assassination: 12.8.1990
Residence: Rohama, Sopore Baramulla
Survived by father (63), mother (57), brothers (28,18) sister (25)
He was said to be employed at Police Station Khanabal, Anantnag. He was kidnapped while on duty. He
was taken to Chankhan, Sopore and put to untold torture. It is reported that people heard his screams
when he was beaten with iron rods. He was trampled upon and burning cigarette ends were applied to his
body. Despite his cries and screams nobody came to retrieve him from the clutches of the Muslim
butchers. He was bitten and flesh peeled off his body. Bullets were pumped into him. After he was dead
he was hurled into the Jehlum. A decomposed body was recovered from the river which could not be
identified. The Police Station at Khanabal is said to have declared him missing and was deliberately put
on leave. His disappearance and subsequent killing have not been looked into by any of the human rights
groups.
towards the road and was rescued by BSF Jawans. His body bore cigarette burns and deep - cut wounds
inflicted by sharp edged weapons.
Durga Nath Rafiz
fateful day of July 2 he left his homeat about 10 in the morning for his daily routine. He did not return
home till late hours in the night. He failed to turn up even on the next day. His family smelt a rat and
began wailing and moaning. Ultimately the disappearance of Bhushan Lal was reported to the concerned
Police Station at Kral Khud. The Station House officer was brutal in his behaviour and lauded the Muslim
terrorists for the role they were playing for ushering in a new era for Kashmir and unequivocally said that
in the process many people were bound to die. At the gate of the Police Station a constable asked the
relatives of Bhushan Lal to leave for Jammu as there was every likelihood that he might have been killed
by the Mujjahids. His dead body was finally found lying on a road. He was straightaway butchered by the
Muslim butchers. He carried three bullet wounds. He was cremated under security cover and his
dependents were shifted to Jammu. His brother is reported to have written to the Home Ministry about the
cold-blooded murder of Bushan Lal, but not a word of consolation was heard from that quarter. Such has
been the de-humanised face of Government of India.
M.L. Bhan
Name: M.L.Bhan
Father's Name: Not known
Date of Birth: Not known
Date of Assassination: 15.1.1990
Residence: Ompora, Badgam
Survived by: Not known
He boarded the bus bound for Srinagar. He was accompanied by his 12 year old son. His two killers also
boarded the same bus. When the bus started plying, they stood up from their seats and found a room close
by the side of Bhan and his son. In the flash of a moment one killer shot him at his temples. He died in no
time. His son sitting by the side of his father was shell-shocked and clung to his father whom he felt still
warm. He cried and screamed for help and sympathy. But none of the passengers who were all Muslims
cared to listen to him. Nor did they try to console the little boy. Instead they abused him and jeered at
him. The terrorists in full command of the situation ordered the driver to stop the bus. As he stopped the
bus, they threw away the dead body on the road-side and pushed the little boy out of the bus. At last a
vehicle of the security forces sailed by. The Jawans lifted his body and also picked up his son. The
Muslims who had thronged on the road-side exhibited their absolute hostility towards the miserable little
boy and the dead body of his father.
Ashok Suri
Name: Ashok Suri
Father's Name: Not known
Date of Birth: Not known
Date of Assassination: Not known
Residence: Kralpora, Badgam
Survived by: Not known
He was a driver who used to carry newspapers to the Western News Stand in Lal Chowk, Srinagar. On
the fateful day he was kidnapped by the terrorists when he was on way to Srinagar. He was severely
tortured. His body bore multiple burn marks. When half-dead he was told that they had to kill his brother
and he was caught by mistake. So he was let off. Somehow he reached his home and narrated the woeful
saga to his brother and begged of him to flee as his life was in imminent danger. But his brother did not
oblige him. It was in the mid-night that the Muslim terrorists again gate-crashed into his house, attacked
him with a sharp-edged weapon, chopped off his neck and left him to meet an agonising death.
B. L. Raina
open the door. Even on the persuasion of his wife he did not ring up the police station. Meanwhile the
killers made an opening to intrude into the house and searched every nook and cranny of the house and
failed to get hold of their victim who had hidden himself in a drum meant for rice. The tw o killers were
laced with a Klashnikov and a pistol. They left the house disgusted and when at the gate of the house a
Muslim neighbour of Ganju signalled them to go to the top storey of the house. They hastily went up and
found him hiding in the rice drum. Both the hounds emptied their breast of bullets on him and killed him
on the spot. His wailing widow begged of them to kill all the family as after his death they had little
meaning in life. The brutal killers said, "who will cry over his body, if we kill you" ?
Dr. (Mrs) Soni
Name: Dr. (Mrs) Soni
Father's /Husband's Name: Ved Lal Sumbli
Date of Birth: 8.11.1912
Date of Assassination: 18.7.1990
Residence: Karan Nagar Srinagar
Survived by none
She had lived all her life in Srinagar and was a very popular nurse and was taken for a doctor. After the
outbreak of Muslim insurgency she had stayed on in Srinagar and had not migrated even for a short
period of time. The Muslim terrorists harboured absolute abhorrence for her as it was within the
knowledge of all that she carried out abortions on unmarried Muslim girls who had been raped by them.
After the fall of evening Muslim gangsters carrying lethal weapons forcibly entered her house, hurled
invective on her, beat her with shoes and rods and tied her to the bed with a rope. Soni was 78-year old.
She was not shown any mercy though she pleaded for it. She wept and wailed and none of the terrorists
was moved. As an act of absolute cruelty the Muslim hounds sprinkled petrol over the room and set it
ablaze. Dr. Soni who had served the Muslims throughout her life screamed to rend the sky. Her screams
could be heard by all her neighbours who never turned up to save her from the clutches of the hounds
fighting For Jehad. She was burnt to death.
Anil Bhan
He was a bright youth with an enviable academic record. Having earned a masters degree in the subject of
Agriculture he sat for a competitive examination and through his sheer abilities and achievements won an
appointment as Agricultural Technical Officer in the United Commercial Bank. Intelligent and committed
to his profession he rose to be the Assistant Branch Manager of the said Bank. The Muslim terrorists with
the chalked-out plans of eliminating all bright Kashmiri Pandit young men assassinated him when he was
on his way to his office at Badshah Chowk, Srinagar, They squirted bullets on him when he took a turn
near Reshi Mohalla. He fell down with blood oozing out from the numerous wounds caused by bullets.
His killing generated a lot of fear and panic among Kashmiri pandits. The locality of Kannikadal where
Anil lived was reduced to a desert land as all the Pandits inhabiting the area boarded the next available
bus carrying them to safer zones for refuge from the Muslim hounds. Nobody was convinced when the
Muslim killers said that it was a case of mistaken identity. His brutal slaughter spread like wild fire
throughout the valley through the screeching lines in the local dailies strengthening the impression that
Muslim killers operating from the mosques had to massacre all youngmen belonging to the Pandit
community thus leading to their exodus from the killing field of Kashmir.
Do the Indian ostriches know it? Does Kuldip Nayar capping them all know it?
Bansi Lal Misri
Name: Bansi Lal Misri
Father's Name: Jia Lal Misri
Date of Birth: 8.9.1960
Date of Assassination: 27.3.1990
Residence: Hyderpora, Badgam
Survived by wife (27), son (1 year old)
He was a handsome youngman with many miles to go. Unlike Pandit youngmen he had taken up business
as his career and was doing extremely well. He had shifted to Jammu in the wake of terrorist deluge
enveloping the valley. But he chose to return to his home-land in connection with his business which he
had deftly expanded. He stayed with his brother at Hyderpora where he had constructed a house. The
Muslim killers three in number knocked at the door of the house. His brother jumped off the wall and ran
off to save his skin. Bansi informed them that he was not home. The killers immediately changed their
mind and decided to kill him. One killer would chase him, the other would guard the inner door of the
house and the third killer would position himself at the outer gate fringing the lane. The first killer chased
him and Bansi ran up the stairs of the house and jumped off the window into the compound. He could not
stand up as he broke his legs. The second killer arrived on the scene and put him to bullets. The third
killer too joined them and emptied his whole breast on him killing him instantly. Many bullets had struck
his head and his brains thus hammered out were seen hanging on one side. The local police as part of the
fundamentalist intrigue did not arrive on the spot. The CRPF personnel evacuated the family of his
brother to Jammu under security cover. He might have been cremated or given a burial as none of his
family attended his last rites.
Ramesh Bhat is a fireman. He was on duty in the fire-station Damhal-Hanjipora. It was exactly in the
night of 31st May, 1990 that the terrorists as per their pre-drawn blue-print entered his room where he
was playing cards with his colleagues, two Muslims and a Sikh. Being a Kashmiri Pandit he was picked
up and whisked away in the taxi of Gula Dar of the same village. There were nearly twenty firemen of
different ranks in the building of firebrigade but none came to intercede with a view to saving him from
the clutches of the killers.
Having reached Garo village the killers accused him of being a spy and asked him to hand over the
wireless set through which he was transmitting messages to his Indian masters. As he failed to produce a
wireless set the Muslim tormentors beat him with the pistol butts and fractured his head. He was carried
to Nehama where he was stabbed in his back and two sides. A dagger was pierced into his spleen and he
fell like a felled tree. Riding on his body he was trampled upon, crushed and left as dead. After two hours
the Muslim hounds returned to the same spot and beat him black and blue and installed a tag on his body
claiming responsibility for his murder.
Meanwhile a fire-van sailed by and fire-men taking him as dead lifted him and admitted him in the
Kulagam hospital where he was given first aid. Therefrom he was shifted to Bijbehara hospital by BSF
and CRPF personnel. As he was in deep pain the doctors advised the security men to get him admitted in
SMHS Hospital where he was operated upon and his spleen was removed.
The armed Muslim terrorists came to the hospital to kill him but they failed in their sinister design
because of security men guarding his body. After getting discharged Ramesh stayed at Avantipora Group
Centre for two months. His family was shifted to Jammu soon after Ramesh was stabbed. Presently he is
living in a rented slum in Jammu. He has a wrap round his waist. He walks with great difficulty and is
weak and emaciated.
Chamam Lal Koul
Gripped by fear and panic Chaman Lal called his neighbour, Som Nath, a young man of 32 years who had
stayed back to serve his invalid mother. Chaman Lal and Som Nath together accompanied the caller who
was known even to the latter.
Both of them were whisked away and nothing was known about them for full four days. Som Nath's
ailing and invalid mother wailed and screamed in agony but that would not melt the hearts of the Muslim
killers. Chaman Lal and Som Nath were hacked into pieces and were stuffed into two gunny bags which
were found lying on the Alijan Road. The police took the hacked bodies to the cremation ground for last
rites. The ashes of Som Nath were handed over to his old invalid mother who was shifted to Jammu under
security cover. The ashes of Chaman Lal were handed over to his old father at Jammu.
Daya Ram Koul
Name: Daya Ram Koul
Father's Name: Sona Koul
Date of Birth 2.4.1916
Date of Assassination: 13.6.1990
Residence: Chitragam, Shopian
Survived by: Wife (75), sons (40,30), daughter (5)
Daya Ram Koul had not fled his native hamlet as he alongwith his family was assured of safety by his
neighoours and family friends. It was an influential family which owned a large business establishment in
Chitragam. Daya Ram in the evening of his life was reluctant to abandon his birth-place and was keen to
breathe his last in his own native village.
When Daya Ram was younger in years he had taken an oath at the Shrine of Nand Rishi alongwith his
twelve Muslim friends that they would live and die together and partake of joys and sorrows of life in the
company of one another He alone remembered the pledge and rest of his twelve Muslim friends had clean
forgotten it and it cost his life.
The family lived comfortably and without fear and trepidation till 12th June, 1990. On the ugly day of
13th June 1990 a band of Muslim terrorists laced with sophisticated weapons entered his house and asked
Daya Ram's eldest son to accompany them for a word. The mother begged of them for mercy and cleverly
pushed them out of the house and bolted the door from inside. Her son managed to flee the scene.
Meanwhile she sent for the Muslim neighbour who had assured them of protection. He failed to turn up
pretending illness. Sensing trouble she alongwith her family fled her house and cried for help but nobody
came to their rescue. Terrorists fled the scene and did not strike that time.
41 C ha pte r 9 - L O O T , G R A B A N D A R S O N K A S H M IR I P A N D IT
P R O P E R T IE S
In their crusade launched with utmost fire and fury to establish a radical theocratic system, cleansing the
land of Pandit infidels, the Muslim terrorists uncritically accepted as Mujjahids by the Muslim population
went whole-hog to buttress up and fine-tune the record of gory traditions of their ancestors who roasted
people alive and ripped open the foetuses of pregnant women and resorted to loot, plunder and massacre
for whole-sale conversion thereby adding horrendous chapters to the despicable book of barbarity.
Unflinching in their obedience to the tradition of tyrants, tile new brand of Muslim terrorists concealing
their identities under resounding and high-flown Islamic names could not be found wanting in
perpetuating the memory of vandals and consummating the holy task assigned to them by cesspits of
Madrasas as the creation of Islamic fanatics. let them goes the credit of performing the sacred rites of loot
and pillage, rape and arson.
Once the Kashmiri Pandits have been forced to flee their homes and hearths to uncharted destinations,
Nemesis started her dreadful operations. Having looted and ransacked their living abodes, the terrorists
and their large mass of Muslim collaborators displayed their fiendishness by torching off the Pandit
houses built with the sweat and blood of their life-time earnings. As tribals in 1947 had been lured to the
loot and rape of bazars in Srinagar, the Muslims lending unmitigated support to the surge of armed
insurgency were promised loot, plunder, rape and unbridled appropriation of Pandit properties.
41.1 Loot and Plunder
The loot and pillage of Pandit houses was carried out under a well calibrated plan and strategy. As a first
step they were marked red to stand them out from the mixed populations for purposes of loot, rapacious
appropriation and arson. For looting operations areas were assigned to the gangs of looters working in
cohesion with mosque committees and experts churned out from Madrasas. A lightning operation for
stealing rubber shoes from Pandit houses was conducted by the same elements with mosques as pivotal
centres and to the knowledge of all mosques had mushroomed at a quick pace in strategic areas with the
massive aid of petro-dollars pouring in from channels abroad through local conduits. After the launch of
insurgency the waves of looters replicating their history in time tanned out in various directions to get lost
into the Pandit habitations and returned gage with immense booty to the precincts of mosques for
distribution leaving a chunk for mosque committees led by hard-core Mullahs fanged with bigotry and
separatism. The frenzied looters reflecting the apachi culture that has long been the essential ethos of
Kashmir are said not to be the traditional thieves and anti-socials, but well-off and prosperous guys
suffused with ferocious vengeance and anti-Pandit venom. Overpowered by predatory and confiscatory
persuasions, acquired and instinctive, assiduously nurtured and cultivated in the Quranic schools, the
Muslim looters broke open the doors and windows or bored burrow-like openings like predatory animals
for access into the houses for loot and plunder. It will be a miracle if any Kashmiri Pandit house has
escaped the looting sprees. The entire Pandit habitations scattered over the fertile valley have suffered not
one bout of loot and plunder, but several such spells of depredations and ravages.
To the shame of the shameless, the Islamic looters set up bazars where the looted property was openly put
to sale. The markets picked up for the purpose were not confined to the towns in the valley, but the looted
goods were pushed into the national market from Jammu to Delhi to Bombay to Calcutta. Brass utensils
spirited away from the kitchens of Pandit houses were pulverised into bits, stuffed into bags and sent
across the border as proof of their true Islamic orientation which had faked and lost its sheen by an
overlaying of Brahmanic culture. Gas cylinders stolen in spells of loot from the ravaged houses were kept
without any twinge of conscience and when their numbers swelled beyond any count, they were openly
sold as if slaves were being sold to the Muslim buyers in the slave-market of Turkistan. The shawls of
various varieties maintained as the prized possessions looted from the abodes of expelled natives are said
to be sold to the sophisticates throughout the national market especially the Bengali market where
patronage is lavishly showered on pedlars of loot. Radio-sets, Television sets, wall clocks, sewing
machines, newly sewn suits and dresses, saris of prominent delicacy et al acquired through organised loot
and legitimised as booty are kept to swell the stocks of those either in business or venture to float new
businesses The merciless looters engaged in "wiping out" operations against the religious enemies have
not spared their mattings and beddings thereby beefing up the quantum of their material properties
considered a value in desert cultures. With the looted properties from Pandit houses businesses have been
diversified or rendered a specialised touch. There are looters who are said to peddle in all sorts of
electronic goods and gadgets acquired through loot. There are others who have set up antique shops
dealing in rare objects dart and artefacts looted from Kashmiri Pandit sophisticates and plucked out from
temples.
With incalculable wealth of petro-dollars pouring in, Pakistan pumping millions to sustain and proliferate
terrorism and India in response not lagging behind to quench the blazing fires of insurgency by allowing
loot of public moneys or through huge packages and booty in kitties, the sole beneficiary, they say, is the
Kashmiri Muslim who has visibly scaled new levels of prosperity and affluence incomparable to what he
enjoyed prior to 1988 bench-mark. As a sure manifestation and indicator of newly acquired opulence and
prosperity, there is an unprecedented construction boom in the valley. New structures are pompously built
and old ones are dismantled and re-built more often than not with doors and windows, inner ceilings and
G.I.E sheets and other building materials uprooted, plucked out and stripped from the houses of infidels.
Those of their eviscerated houses which are yet standing and waiting for the date fixed for their blaze
have a saga to relate and a statement to make. They carry grisly scars and gaping wounds as the
marauders in their cycles of plunder and sack have looted away the house-hold effects that invested them
with the throb and feel of pulsating abodes. Their doors and windows have been pitilessly removed. They
are shorn of stones, bricks and other materials vitally placed to render monolithic wholeness to the
edifices. Inside houses the same loot and plunder has been affected. Almirahs, ward-robes, electric
fittings, water connections, switches, lamp shades, wash-basins and more than most toys of children and
their wooden cradles have been looted away with savagery. There are houses galore with no roots to
protect them form rains and snows as the ruthless looters in blitzkrieg operations have sadistically
dismantled and removed them for installation in their own constructions. There are open spaces which
once were sites of throbbing human settlements and piles of blackened ruins covering them now tell a
cruel tale of pillage and plunder.
At Naqashpora, Sathu Barbarshah, Srinagar there were Kouls living, a cultured and prosperous family
owning four houses which have been razed to the ground said to be the handiwork of near and distant
neighbours. In the brutal operation sixteen houses belonging to Pandits were levelled storey by storey,
wall by wall and brick by brick and the materials are said to have disappeared into the houses of apachies.
As reported to a humanistic organisation working for human rights violations three houses belonging to
Maharaja Krishen Bhat, Bhasker Nath Bhat and Kanth Ram of village Malmoh, Tehsil Pattan, District
Baramulla were stripped off the G.I.E. sheets serving as roofs of the houses on 15th Dec., 1996 by
Muslim looters. The said-village as a Kashmiri Pandit settlement had already suffered orgies of loot and
plunder at the hands of tribal looters enjoying autonomy of destructing the religious foes.
Writes Bali, "Those of the houses that have been untorched have the structure of dilapidated walls only
with gaping holes for doors and windows are shorn of all fittings, including electric and water taps. As per
house-hold and personal effects, these are conspicuously absent. Audio and video tapes alongwith TVs,
Video and audio tape recorders, music systems, stereos, kitchen ranges and kitchen gadgets, all have been
pilfered. Recording details of this rampage and loot will be ludicrous, bizarre and emotionally painful."
Writes Dr. R.L. Shant, "They have been reduced to a people condemned to suffer bearing tales of arson
and plunder of their belongings left back by them in cities and villages from the very neighbours who
leave no stone unturned in propagating through terrorist - friendly media in India that they are the
custodians of minorities in Kashmir."
Majboor, a poet and literatteur, already in exile, was completely wiped out by a frenzied mob of thirty
thousand Muslims in the wake of Mast Gul, a Pakistani vandal and brutal lout putting the highly revered
shrine of Nanda Rishi to flames.
The two families of Pandits staying back in the village were not spared or shown any mercy. Their houses
were first ransacked and then set on fire. Muslims hailed Mast Gul by crying hoarse, "Chrar bani hani
hani, Mast Gul kati bani- Chrar will be re-built slowly, but Mast Gul is a rare find" and their hurricane
fury as usual fell on Pandits and the paper general and his cortege went on watching the orgy of death and
destruction befalling Pandits who have not caused portals of governance any anxiety or concern.
Languishing in tattered tents, one-room hutments and rented slums, beleaguered Pandits to their shock
and dismay have lost their houses in Malayar, Kralakhud, Ganpatyar, Gundahlmar, Brayikujan, Zaindar
Mohalla, Jawahar Nagar, Fateh Kadal, Saffakadal and Karan Nagar. Malayar in the city of Srinagar was a
huge sprawling cluster of Pandit houses and it has been burnt down in blazing fires. The houses in
Ganpatyar locality standing along roadside have been vengefully torched off. Jawahar Nagar having come
up as a posh colony with a modern look and planning presents a scenario of a city sacked by the
prototypes of Nadir Shah. Houses of Pandits in Zaindar Mohalla and Karan Nagar have met the same fate
at the hands of marauders. Babapora with its interior depths touching the shores of Sheel-teng is a horror
scene of war-ravaged waste land. Narparistan sunk in a maze of narrow lanes and bye-lanes has been
licking its wounds as destruction is wrought on the Pandit houses which are now a pile of charred ruins.
The Jehadists as per their delineated plans have not confined their acrid war against the native Pandits to
the purlieux of Srinagar, but the hurricane fury of their Jehad in its broad sweep has engulfed their
settlements dotting the broad terrain of the valley. Poolie contiguous to the spring of Verinag as a village
of Pandit concentration has been obliterated with vengeance. Anantnag with its tremendous Hindu past
has lost most of its edifices which were sublime in their heights evoking awe and admiration. Verinag
with its pristine waters has been a witness to the gruesome fires which Islamists lit in the Pandit houses
for their decimation. The Islamic gun-totters have blazed the houses of Pandits in hamlets surrounding
Kokernag which has gone gory with the blood of Pandits. The Muslim arsonists have burnt down Pandit
settlements in Kupwara, Baramulla, Safapora, Chingund, Ratnipora, Wahibugh, Tahab, Tengapunna,
Wachi, Zablipora, Krandigam, Salar, Tral et al.
The twenty eight residential houses of Pandits in Chingund falling in Tehsil Duroo were burnt to ashes by
Muslim marauders. Even cowsheds, kothars and other structures were not spared. In the FIR filed by the
village chowkidar it is clearly stated that a violent Muslim mob attacked and burnt down all the houses,
cowsheds and kothars of Hindus of the village in the wake of Babri Masjid episode.
"It is shocking to learn that the wrath against the Kashmiri Pandits has assumed such proportions that
those houses, which had already been burnt down and their skeleton structures only stood there, were
either again set ablaze or were demolished or razed to the ground," writes Arvind Razdan.
The grand old residential house of Pandit Madhav Koul in Anantnag when put to flames was
smouldering, smoking and burning for a month's time. It was a massive edifice built in stone, brick and
deodar, a real monument speaking volumes for past glory and hence an eye-sore to the Muslim fanatics.
The huge building of Pandit Siri Koul had the same style, grandeur and wood-work and when set ablaze it
continued burning for days on end till it was said to have been pulled down by looting away its chiseled
logs sustaining the weight of the structure. The house of late Nila Kanth Jad was equally a magnificent
structure that had been the target of Muslims since Islamic resurgence in Kashmir and finally Muslim
cyclone took a toll of it. The house of late Shridhar Joo Kachru at Babapora in Srinagar when set ablaze
continued burning and smoking for ten days and the same is confirmed by Muslim witnesses who have
oiled and soiled their hands with the loot of the house.
Records K.N. Pandita, "Indeed these mute and lifeless objects are dangerous because they embody in
their lifeless souls the story of a great civilisation that has been allowed to be systematically destroyed by
those very elements in building whose civilisation and identity Kashmiri Pandits made the largest
contribution."
have been grabbed by Musluns who share the proceeds in partership with the terrorist outfits and
conniving authorities. There are a number of such localities where Muslim hordes vengefully felled the
orchards from one end to the other thereby inflicting immense losses on the Pandit owners. The walnut
trees generally cultivated within the precincts of Pandit houses have been cruelly felled and wood of the
felled trees was kept or disposed of in the markets fetching a lucrative price to the marauders.
41.5 JKLF Warning
The Jammu and Kashmir Liberation Front, a banned terrorist outfit, in a bid to establish its so-called
secular credentials, has issued a number of warnings to the illegal occupants of shops, business
establishments and landed properties belonging to the Pandits and such warnings are a standing and over-
arching testimony to the fact of their illegal usurpation by none other than Muslims.
41.6 Farooqi's Statement
In a statement to the press in Jammu, M. Farooqi, leader of the Communist Party of India, suggested that
all the left behind properties in Kashmir valley belonging to Kashmir Panda migrants should be declared
as 'custodian properties' with a view to rehabilitating them in their native homes and hearths as and when
they return to the valley. Appreciative of the government move to take the refugees back to the valley,
Farooqi made it amply clear that it could be possible only when their houses are protected (from Muslim
marauders) and maintained bit the government In his meeting with the Chief Minister and Finance
Minister of the state, Farooqi is said to have broached the subject of the forcible grab of the shop
belonging to Janki Dass in Akhara building, Maisuma by a protege of Dr. Karan Singh under the very
nose of paramilitary picket which was asked to shift its position through correspondence with B.S.F.
authorities by the dejure owner who was keen to re-start his business. To the suggestion to declare
Kashmiri Pandit properties as "Custodian properties", the Chief Minister and his Finance Minister to the
surprise of Farooqi were said to be in the first instance non-committal and ambivalent.
41.7 The Migrant Immovable Property Act, 1997
The Migrant Immovable Property Act, 1997 as passed by the State Legislature establishes that the
Kashmiri Pandit properties have been ravaged, destructed, arsoned and grabbed by the Muslim majority
and the owners of such properties who have been reduced to absolute penury during the eight-year period
of exile are forced to dispose of their left-behind assets in the form of denuded houses and cultivable
lands and orchards. The Act also establishes the failure of the State and Central Governments in
protecting their properties from the practicing marauders who have inherited as bequest a history of
rapacity and plunder. The governments could have protected the properties from the Muslim vandals
without the formulation of such an Act as there are laws galore which could have been invoked to
establish rule of law. It is absolutely shameful that the state which forms a part of Indian territory had to
formulate a distinctive Act for the protection of Pandit properties despite citizenship rights that stand
sanctified by the sovereign constitution. The governments should have immediately provided protection
to the Kashmiri Pandit properties when the Pandits fell victim to the militarised Islam. Now when each
habitation has been decimated and landed assets are grabbed the government as an eye-wash has rushed
through the legislation without consulting the Kashmiri Pandits. The reality is that the Pandits are m
distress and are constrained to sell off the properties to eke out an existence in camps and rented slums.
The government should have come out with liberal loans on softer terms thereby enabling the Pandits to
tide over the hardships that they are faced with during the period of wretched and unhappy exile.
The Act does not stipulate to put the predators and usurpers on trial for offences that they have committed
thereby reducing a av~ltsed society to the bottom level of barbarism and expelling even the feeblest ray of
modernism and rationality.
41.8 A Report about vandalisation of Kashmiri Pandit Properties
A report in Kashmir Sentinel date-lined Dec. 15,1995 puts:
"After the vandalisation, destruction and forcible occupation of Kashmiri Pandit houses, it is now a land
grab spree in Kashmir. The lands involved are those of displaced Kashmiri Pandit agriculturists and
orchardists who had fled the valley four years back to escape the torture and tyranny of the terrorists.
Reports from different parts of the valley say that land holdings of hundreds of displaced KP families
have so far been illegally taken over by the local Muslims who manage to get these lands mutated and
indications are that hardly any agriculturist will be left with any land in his nan1e in months to come.
The fraudulent transfers are being done and legalised by the officials of the State Revenue Department in
return for alternative bribes. The method usually adopted by the land grabbers in connivance with
Revenue officials, especially the Patwaris, is to get some local villagers as witnesses to testify that the
land holdings in question had been sold or transferred by the owners to the concerned villagers.
Recently a number of fraudulent land deals came to light when the displaced Kashmiri Pandit
agriculturists made enquiries about the fate of their land holdings back in the valley.
In one case in Baramulla district a village bully backed by a local terrorist group had not only grabbed the
agricultural lands of a KP family, but also had laid his hands on the family's orchard. In another case in
the same district the land owned by a Pandit family had been shown as belonging to the state by
tampering with Revenue records.
Those who had grabbed the land had been entered in the records as rightful owners."
The report further adds, "scores of orchards owned by displaced Kashmiri Pandits had fallen into the
hands of unscrupulous Muslim villagers who made huge profits which they shared with the local terrorist
groups. The land grabbing phenomenon has attained such alarming dimensions now that the State
Government has issued a circular to check the fraudulent deeds."
The Daily Uqab Srinagar date-lined Nov.27, 1994 reports: -
"A large area of land and houses belonging to Kashmiri Pandits near Mohalla Faqir Wani in Baramulla
have been taken over by some people and distributed among themselves. There are standing pear, apple
and walnut trees in this land. The income from the produce of these trees is pocketed by these people. The
police have not registered any case in this respect so far."
41.9 Representation To The National Human Rights Commission
A humanistic organisation dedicated to the restoration of peace in the valley has taken up the case of
Abdul Karim vs Brij Lal Tamiri with National Human Rights Commission. Abdul Karim S/o Mohammad
Sultan Sheikh, an employee of Military Engineering Service, has illegally occupied the house of Brij Lal
Tamiri at Shivapora, Srinagar which has remained vacant after the family fled away from their house in
early 1990. After contacting DIG, Kashmir Range, the owner of the house was informed through an
ordinary letter dated: 22nd May, 1996 that the illegal occupant had approached the court of city Munsif,
Srinagar directing the parties to maintain status quo, thus allowing the illegal occupation of Brij Lal
Tamiri's house by Abdul Karim.
After a thorough study of the case, the secretary of the NGO, Friends of Kashmir International, submitted
a petition dated: 7th July 1996 to Hon'ble Chairman, NHRC, New Delhi which reads as under:
"I have been directed by my NGO to seek your Lordships indulgence in a serious matter of violation of
human rights of the internally displaced persons from Kashmir valley living in refugee camps in Jammu,
Udhampur and other parts of the country since 1990.
It has come to the notice of our organisation that there are cases of forcible occupation by the locals of
vacant residential houses, shops, cowsheds or hutments of displaced persons from the valley. These
occupations are all illegal and unauthorised.
In order to regularise forcible and illegal occupation of these places, the entrepreneurs have contrived
forged documents and filed suits in courts of law seeking ex-partedecisions to legitimise their forcible
occupation. A fraudulent mechanism has been evolved of issuing court summons to the owners. The
Honourable courts knowing fully well that respondents being a threatened minority community would not
be able to attend its call. What is more, even the summons are invariably not received by the respondents
as these do not bear the correct addresses of the displaced persons, or get lost in the ordinary mail. Even
the notices issued in local vernacular papers do not reach the displaced persons. Taking undue advantage
of the forced absence of the displaced persons far away from their native land for last seven years, their
inability to protect their property in absence, their inability to present themselves before any court of law
in the valley even if a summon is received by them and lastly unwillingness on the part of state authorities
to enforce civil order these illegal occupants move the local courts swiftly to process ex-partedecrees
against the displaced persons seeking to dispossess or disinherit them of their properties.
In all fairness the local courts should not at all entertain such applications as involve the properties of
displaced persons only if justice is to be done. But, somehow, in an unusual situation prevailing in the
valley at present even the Honourable Judges would like not to be anything but accommodative even at
the cost of Justice.
Your Lordship may kindly note that forcible occupation of the vacant houses or shelters of the displaced
persons is violation of human rights (the right to property, and shelter) and admission of any case in this
regard by a local court in which case an ex-parte decision would be the procedural result is further
violation of human rights because it denies the persons involved the chance to be heard owing to
circumstances beyond control. Evidently the state government has the responsibility to protect the
property of the citizens (that being the constitutional right of all Citizens of India) and if it fails in
discharging that duty the displaced persons should not suffer on that count. They are already fouled and it
should mean their re-foulment which is not only unjust but also inhuman. As if sending them into forced
exile is too small a punishment which must be upgraded to forcible occupation of their property.
In the light of what has been submitted our organisation approaches the Hon'ble NHRC with the request
that appropriate steps commensurate with the lay.: and charter of human rights be taken at its earliest
convenience to stop occupation of the vacant houses and immovable properties of the internally displaced
persons from Kashmir either through muscle power or through fraudulent and illegal documentation. We
would like to submit that proper steps be taken to give a fair chance to the displaced persons to follow
legal proceedings wherever necessary in such cases only in Jammu and not in Srinagar. The threat to life
by the armed militants prevents the internally displaced persons from presenting themselves before any
court of law in the valley. The government could set up special tribunals in Jammu proper where such
cases could be filed and heard. The state Judiciary is expected to demonstrate its responsibility in
prevailing extra-ordinary conditions and spare the suffering displaced persons the travail of unnecessary
litigation for which they are neither mentally nor financially prepared."
In another communication dated September 30,1996 to the Hon'ble Chairman, National Human Rights
Commission, New Delhi the Secretary of Friends of Kashmir (India) conveys as under:
"We are grateful to the Hon'ble Commission for informing us vice their letter No. 9/73/96-LD of August
1,1996 that the matter of illegal occupation of Pandit houses in Kashmir valley submitted by us on 7th
June, 96 has been taken up by the Hon'ble Commisssion with the concerned authorities in the J&K State.
However, till date no state authority has contacted us nor do we know what action they would be
contemplating to take in the matter.
Through our sources we learn that there is a spate in forcible and illegal occupation of Kashmiri internally
displaced persons, left behind property by the locals in valley with tacit connivance of sections of
administrative and judicial authorities. Fake documents are produced and accepted to claim proprietary
rights over their houses, shops and immovable property. Physical absence of the owners from the scene
and their continued inability to challenge false claims in a court of law encourages blatant irregalarities.
What is more, reluctance of authorities to devise practical and collective safeguards against such
lawlessness leading to a state of loot is deplorable.
Before we proceed to cite a few more cases, we would like to high-light the methodology employed to
legalise false. ownership based on the sample study of the forcible and illegal occupation of the
residential house of one Brij Lal Tamiri (case already submitted to the Hon'ble Commission on June
7,1996). These are as under:
i) Obtaining stay orders from a court of law even without any proof of the sale of property.
ii) when the victim comes to know of fraudulent ownership, the stay order and appeals for transfer of case
to Jammu (for security reason), the opposition to the same is voiced on the plea that since the property is
located in Kashmir valley it should not be heard by the Hon'ble Court in Jammu.
iii) a fictitious name is shown as one of the defendants He may be shown as intermediary for selling and
described as a known person, relative or a friend. This serves the purpose of prolonging the case and
would at the same time break the resolve of the victim. Then the victim could be forced to agree to
distress sale of his rightfully owned property.
iv) entire strategy of this litigation revolves round prolonging the case on one pretext or the other, slow
down the legal procedure and oppose the case of transfer to Jammu.
v) Knowing that occupation of the house of internally displaced persons is illegal, under the grab of sta!
order, the occupants resort to a large scale damaging of the house besides looting the left-over goods of
the displaced victims.
Your lordship, in case of Brij Lal Tamiri, one Maharaj Krishen Watloo has been shown as a dependent,
though no person of this name and address exists. No attorney has been given by the owner to anybody
for sale of the house or for putting it on tenancy. But the Court has issued stay orders without any proof of
purchase by the illegal occupant. This has forestalled the eviction by the police. In the meanwhile the
occupant has resorted to a large scale damaging of the construction as the accompanying FIR indicates.
Your Lordship, we may be permitted to submit two more cases of forcible and illegal occupation of the
left behind houses of internally displaced persons from the valley. In one case, a local English daily
named Northlines of 24th August, 1996 has reported that one fruit merchant of district Pulwama in
Kashmir contrived fraudulent sale deed of the residential house of Mrs P.G. (name withheld by the
newspaper) an internally-displaced person originally residing in Hyderpora, Srinagar.
In another case, one Lassa Nath Bhat resident of Gouripora-Rawalpora tehsil and district Badgam in
Kashmir valley issued a public notice in Kashmir Times of September 1, 1996 saying that somebody had
produced fake documents and claimed the ownership of his left-behind residential house.
In view of the seriousness of the violation of human rights, especially the right to property, we are
concerned h the matter and approach the Hon'ble Commission could besides holding an independent
proble, advise the Government of J&K State to issue orders for :
a) Stopping sale of any kind of immovable property of the internally displaced persons from the valley
until the time they resume normal life in places of their origin.
b) appointing an independent tribunal headed by a High Court Judge based in Jammu. All cases of
internally displaced persons' property could be referred to this Tribunal for speedy and summary disposal.
c) holding the forcible occupants responsible for damaging the house and looting of immovable property
in it. Without a strong legal action this violation of human rights may not be stopped.
Many internally displaced persons are lodging FIRs with the police in Jammu stating that their
houses/shops/orchards/lands have been fraudulently grabbed by musclemen with the connivance of
authorities. As such, the Hon'ble Commission should supervene and stop violation of the rights to
property of the displaced persons. As and when more cases come to our notice, we shall submit these to
your Lordship for proper disposal."
41.10 Grab of the Shop of M.K. Dass
M.K. Dass and Mrs Sheila Dass were in regular tenancy of a shop in the Akhara building, Maisuma. The
shop as alleged is broken open, all medical goods and medicines ham been spirited away and a Muslim is
said to have grabbed the shop with the connivance of one Puran Shal1 who manages and overlords the
Akhara properties. M.IC. Dass has approached all concerned authorities for the restoration of the shop,
but as alleged he is not heard. He coven met the Chief Minister who promised him redressal, but nothing
concrete has emerged. His correspondence with authorities makes a curious reading.
That the tenant of the shop was in regular tenancy is perhaps substantiated by the letter that the BSF
authority wrote to the Divisional Commissioner. The letter reads:
No. 311/16/OPS/15BN/96/730
HQ Srinagar Frontier
Border Security Force
Srinagar (Kmr)
09 Sept. 96
To
The Divisional Commissioner,
J&K Government
Srinagar.
Sub:- Removal of Bunker/Payment of compensation in favour of Shri M.K. Dass Prop. M/s Jank Dass
and Co. Budshah Chowk, Srinagar.
Sir,
Please refer to an application submitted by M.K.Dass, Prop. M/s Janki Dass and Co. Budshah Chowk,
Srinagar (Copy enclosed for ready reference).
1. In this context, it is to inform you that the matter has been got enquired into depth through concerned
Sector DIG/Unit Comdt and reveals following:
a) During the year 1992, Security Forces were deployed in Kashmir valley and one bunker was
constructed by security forces during that time to deal with militancy in the area in front of AKHARA
BUILDING gate. This bunker is strategically covering MAISUMA road as well as dominate Akhara
Chowk and adjoining areas. This bunker also provides Security to Akhara building and checks the
entry/exist of visitors to Akhara building.
b) Since, Maisuma is the backbone of militancy and all sorts of demonstrations/ processions, grenade
throwing are planned and conducted by public in Lal Chowk area, therefore presence of this bunker is
essential to monitor the movement of the militants/public in the area.
2. The bunker in question is sited at appropriate place and tactically deployed. This bunker of course has
obstructed the entrance to M/s Janki Dass and Co. but for Security reasons it is not possible for us to
remove the said bunker.
Therefore, it is recommended that necessary compensation may be provided to the owner of the Shop, if
deemed fit.
Yours faithfully
sd/-(S.Chanhan)
Addl. Deputy Inspector Genl
(Operations )
The Inspector General of Police, Kashmir Zone, Srinagar wrote to M.K. Dass which reads as under:
Zonal Police Headquarters Kashmir Srinagar
No. Crime/Misc/97/1550
Dated: 3.3.1997.
M.K. Dass House No.01, Sector No.10 Nanak Nagar Jammu.
Please refer your application regarding shop breaking/replacing the shop locks by Puran Shah, Manager,
Dashnami Akhara Trust with the assistance of local gundas and looting the medicines from the shop
known as Janki Dass and Co. Chemists 16 Akhara building Rudshah Chowk Srinagar.
Report called from concerned SP is enclosed.
8. That in response to the point mentioning that the firm did not pay any rent to the Management is all
false and baseless. The fact is that no such default in payment of the rent has been ever committed either
by late Pt. Janki Nath Dass or his predecessors. The firm has paid the rent up-to-date. The last receipt
being of 15.11.89, then again a draft of Rs. 10,000/ - on account was sent through a registered draft No.
04183 State Bank of India aft. 27.12.1996 addressed to Secretary Mahadev Giri, Dashnama Akhra Trust,
Budshah Chowk, Srinagar but the same was deliberately returned back and avoided without furnishing
any reasons by Akhra Management. I again sent the draft to the concerned but it met the same fate with
the remarks that the addressee had left the place without leaving any address here which was all fraud and
fabricated. As the draft was addressed in the name of Secretary Dashnami Akhara Trust for which a
routine office is functioning there was no question that the addressee had left the place. It transpires that
Akhara Management in connivance with BSF authorities of the said post/bunker concocted a story
of"Emitting foul smell" and wanted to remove the expired medicines from the shop as the chemical could
be dangerous in case of any explosion caused near the bunker is only to interfere and induct Manzoor
Ahmed Narwari into the said premises as a trespasser and in this deal Puran Shah, Manager of the Trust,
the BSF Personnel of the post/bunker and Manzoor Ahmed are party and therefore they are to be
criminally prosecuted.
It is stated that because of my filing of an FIR they have not succeeded in dispossessing me, but if they
are not dealt properly they can succeed in their nefarious designs. It is also stated what business had the
Management of the Akhara Trust to break open the lock of my shop and then take out the
medicines/goods valued about Rs.4.00 to 5.00 lacs. It is a clear case of trespass and theft.
I sincerely feel that the culprits are arrested and immediately punished.
Thanking you,
Yours sincerely,
sd/- (M.K.Dass)
sd/- (Sheela Dass)
parties without following the process of law or without sending proper notices to the bona fide allottees of
the said-shops.
e) We have reasons to believe that the papers of allotment have been prepared illegally in a clandestine
manner by the Executive Officer of Srinagar Municipality, Mr. Ganai. In certain cases he has also forged
the signatures of the earlier Administrator of Srinagar Municipality for illegally allotting the shops to
others.
f) The shops have been re-allotted at a premium of only Rs.30,000 per shop while the current market
value of the shops is around Rs.7 lakhs each. We have authentic information to believe that Mr.Ganai has
reportedly accepted Rs.2.00 lakhs per shop as illegal gratification from the illegal allottees of the said-
shops.
g) In case the shops that were not gutted in fire, the locks were broken open and goods worth lakhs stolen
by the said official before allotting the shops to some other person.
h) While none of the tenants of the shops of the said complex including those who have been running
their business from these shops for all these years has been paying rent to the Srinagar Municipality due
to the troubled conditions in the valley. Only the migrants who have at least paid partial rent have been
singled out for this treatment.
i) In view of the foregoing it will be clear to your goodself that certain officials of Srinagar Municipality
have tried to tarnish the image of the administration by acting in a manner contrary to the declared policy
statements of the J&K Government as well as the Government of India. While the Union Ministers and
bureaucrats belonging to both the Union Government and the State Government have time and again been
voicing the resolve of the government regarding return of the Kashmiri migrants to the valley soon, these
officials of the Municipality, just in order to make a quick buck, have been working against this policy by
making all efforts to ensure that the migrants do not return to the valley.
Their action of re-allotment of the migrant shops is one step in this direction.
We, therefore, request your goodself to please use your good offices to ensure that the culprits in this case
of blatant misuse of power and corruption are brought to book and the shops are restored to the original
owners of the said-shops after making good the loss caused to them.
41.12 Dr. Kashi Nath Ticku's House Grabbed by the Government Department
Dr. Kashi Nath Ticku now an octogenarian has been in banishment for the last eight years. It is reliably
learnt that he has been spending the evening of his life in Gujrat. He is pained and anguished to learn that
his posh house at Jawahar Nagar in Srinagar city has been grabbed. After making thorough enquiries
about the grab he learns that it is not a Muslim who has broken open his house and spirited away all the
goods from his house but it is a Government Department that has occupied his house in his absence in
exile. The Department in the hands of frauds, fanatics and unscrupulous elements has been in occupation
of his house for purposes of running a school. Dr. Ticku has been on jaunts to Srinagar to get his house
vacated and has been meeting the officers of the Department of Education to ensure the vacation of his
house. It was after a long struggle that the officers of the Department agreed to pay him rent since the
time the house has been under its occupation. But no rent has been paid to him so far. Every tin1e he flies
to Srinagar he has to re-open his case as the officers suffused with communal venom feign ignorance
about the illegal occupation.
Dr. Kashi Nath Ticku is a doctor be profession and has been vitally linked with the so-called nationalist
movement led by Sheikh Abdullah. What his contributions have been to the movement can be learnt from
the galaxy of freedom fighters who wore honestly motivated for heralding a new era of democracy,
liberalism and religious Catholicism.
41.13 Felling of Poplars from a Kashmiri Pandit House and Hakim Ghulam Hassan
Hakim Ghulam Hassan is said to be a retired judge from the state judiciary. His house near Polytechnic,
Gogjibagh, Srinagar is fringed by the house of a Kashmiri Pandit hailing from a respectable family of
Mattoos from Rainawari. The house of the Pandit was deserted by the inmates when the Muslim killers
started the murder of Kashmiri Pandits as they were labelled as the agents of India and anti-Muslim.
It was after a year or so that Hakim Ghulam Hassan is said to have informed his Kashmiri Pandit
neighbour that he had sold the poplars growing within the premises of his house for a sum of Rs. 10,000
which he would be remitting to him very soon. The Pandit took Hakim Ghulam Hassan for his word and
believed that the money would come to him sooner or later. Rut the hopes of the Pandit were belied.
Money never came to him.
The Kashmiri Pandit in absolute despair is said to have gone on writing to his Muslim neighbour about
the despatch of money. Ghulam Hassan is said to have proved callous and discourteous in not writing
back to his Pandit neighbour Ultimately the Kashmiri Pandit is said to have phoned him from Jammu and
asked his immediate neighbour to send him the money that had accrued from the sale of poplars. Hakim
Ghulam Hassan reportedly informed him that he had deposited the money in the treasury. The Pandit put
the word "treasury" to an incisive analysis but could not come to any satisfying rational conclusion.
Hakim Ghulam Hassan perhaps meant that the money was deposited in the coffers of Muslim killers who
are said to have earned full-scale support and succour from men of his breed.
42 C ha pte r 10 - D E S T R U C T IO N A N D D E S E C R A T IO N O F T E M P L E S
With the transformation of political power in Kashmir 1339 A.D. the temples and cultural symbols of
Hindu style came under severe Muslim onslaught. The Muslim rulers steeped in Islamic orientation with
commitments to the forcible expansion of Islam desecrated, plundered and despoiled the temples and
shrines manifesting the character of Hindu faith and thought. As amply supported by historical evidences
Kashmir with its protracted history dating back to antiquity has been a Buddhist, Vaishnavite and Shaivite
seat and as such has witnessed amazing levels of cultural growth and flowering with their visible imprint
on viharas, caityas and temples dotting every inch of Kashmir soil. As has been the common practice with
Muslims a concerted campaign of bigotry was generated with the state apparatus in the lead role to defile
and destroy temples and other cultural expressions of Hindus fascistically declaring them as un-Islamic
thereby sealing any intellectual effort to probe their aesthetics and cultural value. The destructive
campaign as a result of religious Repossessions and paranoia has continued with no relent with a priori
objective of dismantling and annihilating a cultural ethos suffused with the ingredients of tolerance,
assimilation and wider vision of understanding. With narrow perspectives in view and hate syndrome as a
motivating factor no efforts have been spared to scatter the bacilli of iconoclasm to establish Muslim
cultural domination coupled with obscurantism giving rise to an ethos antithetical to the ideals of
harmony, coexistence and peace.
It will be in the fitness of things to put that the total history of Muslims in Kashmir spans over a period of
six hundred years and it has been a period of crusade chasing the twin objectives of conversion and
inconoclasm which are two faces of the same operation. Jonraj as an historian of eminence was a witness
to the forcible conversion of the Hindus of Kashmir and the desecration and demolition of the Hindu
temples and cultural signs and symbols akin to the faith. The iconoclastic character of Islam was well
within the range of his observation and experience when he with the bold flourish of his pen dilated on
the desecration and destruction of Hindu temples wrought by Muslims who in obedience to their religious
promptings flashed the naked weapon of force to expand the Islamic base with a view to earning the
promised religious compensation. Jehad or holy war has been the instrument to desecrate and level
massive stone structures of temples and to convert the Hindus to the faith of Islam. The Sayyids, the
Chaks, the Mughals and the Afghans harnessed and pressed into service their political power and
authority to realise the conversion and with a view to achieving the objective it became imperative to
decimate and obliterate the colossal religious and cultural symbols of Hindus especially their temples and
shrines.
The first bacilli of iconoclasm were sown the day when the Muslim rulers under obligation to a fiat issued
by a proselytizer masquerading as a Sufi resorted to the tyrannical measure of stopping the Hindus from
fresh constructions of temples and shrines for idol-worship and disallowing them to execute repairs to the
existing ones lying in a state of collapse and ruin.50 Startling records were set in the destruction of
temples and other symbols of Hindu culture. The materials from the destructed temples were looted and
wantonly utilised to build mosques and hospices and in most of the cases plinths were not ravaged but
kept intact and mosques built and imposed on the temple sites. The Muslim iconoclasm did not spare the
sculptural treasures amazingly creative and superb in conception and execution and reflective of an
intolerant culture model it Divas pursued with religious zeal to hasten Islamisation with a view to
reducing Kashmir to a Muslim ghetto.
Art connoisseurs throughout the world will feel shocked to learn that gun power as a hardware of war was
harnessed by Muslims to destruct and despoil the temples which religion and art wise are the churches of
the Hindus. When destruction could not be achieved through the blasting material, the Jungles in the
proximity of the temples were felled to use them as fuel for setting the gigantic structures ablaze. The
tremendous heat generated through the burning of logs of wood split the chiselled stones and set them
violently asunder with the result the massive structures fell and crumbled in a pile of ruins. The brutality
was not inflicted on one temple but was heaped without an exception on the giant temples studding the
gem of the valley. The ruins of Martand, Avantipur, Tapar, Parihaspur, et al are mute witnesses to the
depredations and ravages wrought by Muslims.
The Muslim iconoclasts, ignorant, puerile and pervert, harboured no sense of guilt when they destroyed
the sparkling specimens of Kashmirian architecture signalling a new apogee through a blend of
indigenous style with the Greek and Roman styles. The lofty pyramidal roofs were dismantled. The
trefoiled doorways covered by pyramidal pediments were broken with hammers. Colonnades fashioned
after the Greek model were removed. The said-materials were either sadistically destroyed or used in
mosques where their artistic loftiness and grandeur were lost. The losses thus rendered to the mosaic of
world culture were colossal and incredible.
The Temple of Martand built on a plateau amidst cnthralling natural ambience is a unique marvel in stone
symbolising through its distinctive style a celebrated classical order comparable to the architectural orders
that have flowered as mile-stones during the whole course of evolution. Shocking as it is the same stone
temple, solid and enduring, was put to the orgy of devastation through gun power and when sufficient
quantities of it were not readily available, its foundations were dug deep and chiselled and skilfully
carved stones removed filling the gaping wounds with logs of wood and putting them afire. Prior to the
destructive process huge hammers were cruelly used for one full year to destroy and vandalise its wealth
of masterly sculptural works of immense artistic merit and value. The same destruction was wrought Oil
the massive stone temple at Bijbehara which was famed as the city of temples. It was pillaged and
destroyed and its well carved - out stones with engraved figurines of gods and goddesses of Hindu
pantheon were utilised for the construction of a hospice which is not a patch on the original temple. The
temples were so massive in size and dimension that it was difficult to believe that they could be the
handiwork of human endeavour.
Remarks Sir Walter Lawrence, "While the old Hindu buildings defy time and weather, the Musahnan
shrines and mosques crumble away. Other foreign travellers have recorded that Hindu temples were built
to endure for all time. Their solidity of construction and their gigantic size strike one with wonder that
puny men could have built them. They often gazed upon them with amazement and lamented bigoted
Muslim fanatics who laid them to ruins with tremendous effort."
The temples at Tapar (Pratap-pur) that were built by the queen of a Hindu ruler, Pratapaditya, were
amazing marvels of Hindu architecture. The ruthless Muslims destroyed them with vengefulness and are
novel in a dilapidated condition. What is astonishing that a Muslim ruler, Zain-ul-Abidin (1420-70) A.D.
who withdrew the despicable levies on Pandits and re-settled them in Kashmir after they were forcibly
expelled from Kashmir thus earning kudos for his exemplary tolerance, utilised the huge temple stones
and Hindu idols to build a bund from Naidkhai to Sopore. If figurative meaning of his visit to Sharda, a
centre of Hindu pilgrimage now in Pakistan, is drawn from what Jonraj writes about it, it can be averred
that he was responsible for the desecration, breakage and destruction of the wooden idol of ancient origins
at the highly revered place of worship.
The Mughal emperors who were enamoured of the beauty of Kashmir valley have been extolled for their
tolerant credentials, but on the basis of available authentic evidences it can be said that they were the
same fanatic in matters of dismantling and devastating the religious places of Hindus. It is surprising to
learn that Jehangir in his religious fury dismantled the flight of steps linking the Temple of
Shankaracharya to the river Jehlum near the Temple of goddess Tripursundary. Nurjohan as his
celebrated queen utilised the same chiselled and sculptured stones to erect a massive mosque known as
Pathar Masjid. The Muslims never used the mosque for prayers not for the fact that it was built with
looted materials from a temple but because it was constructed at the instance of a woman who was a Shia-
Muslim by faith and creed. The same mosque was declared as property of the state by the Sikh
commander, Phula Singh, on the genuine plea that it was built with the materials dismantled and looted
from a temple. The Muslims raised a hue and cry as the mosque continued to be locked in Dogra times
and it was under a British conspiracy that the mosque was returned to the Muslims who trumpeted its
occupation by the state as a great symbol of tyranny.
The Narparistan Temple built by a Hindu ruler was forcibly occupied and turned into a Muslim shrine by
the installation of a grave (to sanctify the grab) in the sanctum sanctorum of the temple. The Kashmiri
Pandits not taking the brutality lying down locked horms with the Muslim rebids and recovered its
possession from the unlawful occupants. But Muslims mobilised their ranks, screamed Jehad to grab it
away from the Pandits and installed a new grave to maintain and fortify the forcible occupation. The
famous temple at Skand Bhawan at the head of a spring was desecrated and the spring of oozing waters
blocked by hurling of huge stones and boulders and re-christened as the shrine of Pir Mohammad Basur.
The Dedamar Temple was also levellcd and demolished and was forcibly converted into the Tomb of
Malik Sahib. The temples at Amrita Bhawan were laid waste and the site was occupied and converted into
shrines and burial grounds.
It was Praversena II, the founder of the city of Srinagar, who had constructed a country residence for a
reputed Hindu saint on the north-eastern corner of the legal Lake Bernier who accompanied Aurangzeb in
his visit to Kashmir has exposed the iconoclastic activities of Shah Jehan, a famous Mughal emperor. In
his travelogue Bernier records that the doors and pillars carved out of stone that were used in the Shalimar
garden built on the same area of villa were looted from some temples which were demolished by Shan
Jehan. And Bernier comments that their artistic grandeur and value was beyond estimate.
The famous Temple of Shiva Pravareshwar was de,nolished and with its looted materials was built the
shrine of Baha-ud-Din Sahib.60 The grave-yard that surrounds the shrine is a repository of many ancient
remains that have been used in walls and tombs. The ruins of a gate-way lying at one corner of the grave-
yard are still existing and the stone blocks of which the gate-way is built are of exceptional dimensions.
As the Muslims have no strong tradition in erecting shrines with stone blocks, it is authenticity held that
they are the materials of Shiva Pravareshwar Temple.
The Jamia Mosque situated in the vicinity of the shrine of Baha-ud-Din is surrounded by numerous
temple stones and massive pillars lending strong credence to the belief that it was built on the site of a
Vishnu temple which was worshipped and adored by Kashmiri Pandits. It has been the site of a Buddhist
Vihara as well which must have stood close by it. The Buddhists from the region of Ladakh still bow at
the site with a deep sense of veneration.
The temple of Vishnu Ranaswamin which as per the noted historian Kalhana was erected by Ranaditya
was subjected to the Muslim fury of desecration and destruction and ultimately suffered the orgy of its
conversion into the shrine of Pir Haji Mohammad. The Muslim shrines situated at Zakura (Juskapur) are
built out of the materials from temples that were destructed. Again the shrine of Farrukzad Sahib is
constructed at the site where there stood a massive temple dedicated to Amareshwar, and contains the
remains of the destructed shards of temple. There were temples built on an inlet of Anchar Lake which
were demolished and their looted materials utilised in the construction of tombs and shrines. The shrine of
Khawaja Khizar is built with the ruins looted from a temple.
The temple of Vishnu-Padamaswamin of considerable fame at Pampore was plundered and levelled and
its delicately chiselled columns and ornamented slabs were utilised in the erection of the shrine of Mir
Mohammad Hamadani and other Muslim shrines standing in the same locality.
The ancient site of Parihaspur on the plateau of Paraspur was vandalised and destroyed by the Muslim
vandals. As is historically established the site was littered over with Hindu temples and Buddhist Viharas
and caityas. The places of worship consecrated to gods and goddesses of Hindu and Buddhist religions
were built by the great conqueror Lalitaditya who is also credited with the completion of the Martand
Temple of considerable repute. The same saga of destruction is connected with the temples and shrines
dotting the Hariparbat Hillock which were demolished grabbed and converted into shrines and mosques.
The temple grab and destruction as the rallying point of Muslim Jehad failed to abate in its tidal wave
even under the rule of the Dogras who professed Hhldu faith and belief. The Islamic forces having a
distinct narrow and communal stream continued their onslaught on temples and Hindu-style cultural
symbols. Brute force was let loose to forcibly occupy the temple at Sahyar in the capital city of Srinagar.
Blatant attempts were made to grab the Bhairav Nath Temple at Chattabal but in face of Kashmiri Pandit
resistance the Muslim Communal forces had to beat a temporary retreat. The bigoted elements in the
police force came down heavy on the Pandits who were vigorously vociferous in their demand for
handing over the Laleeshwari Temple back to them as it was unlawfully grabbed and occupied by the
Muslims. The Glancy commission constituted by Maharaja Hari Singh in 1931 unjustifiably rejected the
Pandit demand for the restoration of the possession of Hariparbat and Shankaracharya Hillocks to the
Kashmiri Pandits on the flimsy and untenable ground of the consistence of some graves on their foot-
hills. The Buddhist sites with established historical background were not returned to the care the
possession of Pandits who had to be punished for their anti-British stances and sentiments.
The momentous event of Jammu and Kashmir acceding to the Union of India in 1947 did not bring
spectacular cheer and relief to the native Kashmiri Pandits. Instead a new storm of destruction gathered
for them leaving them bereft and beleaguered. As hapless victims to a tyrannical order the state
governments of all political hues vigorously worked out the single-point programme of marginalising and
edging them out of their natural habitat for ethnic cleansing. Besides political and economic oppression
and elimination they had to face governments under tight leash of the Muslims who contrived aided and
abetted the bigoted arts of laying claims to the temples and their properties. The temple lands cremation
grounds and holy springs reinforced by relevant documents as properties of Pandits faced immediate
onslaught and were first held in dispute by resorting to tampering of records and other fraudulent methods
and subsequently usurped by whipping up religious frenzy with a view to expanding Islam and its
reigning sway. In 1978 various SROs issued by the government not only fortified and strengthened the
Muslim Auqaf Act but also Fated the Muslims to grab the temple lands without check and constraint for
their transmission to Muslim Trusts. Not fewer than 70 temples and lands attached with them were cruelly
confiscated from the possession of the Pandits who proffered their claims supported by relevant revenue
records but were arbitrarily dismissed and rejected. The temples of historical importance were aggressed
and huge portions from them sliced away to be offered to the Muslims as booty in a platter. The Spot of
Vethavothur as the source of Vitasta worshipped by the Kashmiri Pandits as manifestation of Siva's grace
was pushed into a dispute and encroached upon through generation of mass frenzy. Lok Bhawan with its
mention in Rajtarangini was turned into a hot spot by grabbing the lands attached with the Temple from
hoary ages. The holy spring at Anantnag was wantonly aggressed and huge chunks of land attached with
it were fascistically sliced away for transfer to the Muslims. Lands measuring 55 kanals belonging to the
Durganath Temple as the precious property were straightaway grabbed only to beef up the landed wealth
of the Muslim Auqaf Trust. The lands attached with the Hariparbat Hillock were never offered protection
by various governments from the concerted Muslim onslaught and were subsequently grabbed and
confiscated from the helpless Pandits. The path for Parikrama around the Hillock which is central to the
theme of Kashmir's birth and its cultural history was dug out and the earth carried to fill the Muslim
Auqaf lands.
The Dewan Shiva Temple of Fateh Kadal has borne infinite scars stabbed on it by noisy mobs of Muslim
intolerants. Its outer walls facing the road-side have been felled and damaged umpteen times. Whenever
there is a volcanic eruption of violence mostly on superficial grounds, the said temple emerges as the
prime target of desecration, demolition and arson. On 26th of January 1989 the minority community of
Kashmiri Pandits was held in a total grip of fear and panic when a thousand strong mob of Muslims
wielding weapons desecrated and damaged the Dewan Shiva Temple. The strong door of the temple
refused to give way and the Muslim mob indulging in vandalism removed the idols in the open worship
enclosure quite adjacent to the main temple and hurled them into the running gutter. All attempts were
made to put the temple on fire. The government playing its tune to the unison of Muslim storm-troopers
had advance information about threat to peace on this day, but no arrangements, stiff or lenient, were
made to provide protection to the minority community and its culture symbols. The attack on the temple
was led and organised by the pro-Pakistan cadres of people's League, Kashmir Liberation Front, Muslim
Students Federation and Islamic Students League thriving under tremendous patronage from the
government headed by Farooq Abdullah and his cohorts.
The Hanuman Temple at Hari Singh Street, Srinagar attracting large crowds of Hindu, for worship has
been subjected to the worst forms of desecration and plunder at the hands of Muslim marauders. It is not
once but numberless times that the presiding idols in the temple have been desecrated, lifted and hurled
into the Jehlum at the shores of which the temple is situate. The latest brand of violence inflicted on the
temple was when the Muslims and the Sikhs forging an alliance at the behest of two secessionist leaders,
one from the Punjab and the other from Kashmir, organised a massive procession against the Kashmiri
Pandits. Starting from the Gurudwara in Lal Chowk, Srinagar the procession was immediately joined by
the Muslims as per the pre-meditated plans and crossing the old Amira Kadal Bridge it ran amok and
desecrated, looted and plundered the Hanuman Temple. Replicating the history of vandalism the main
idol visas plucked out from the sanctum sanctorum and thrown despicably into the flowing waters of the
Jehlum. The procession yelling "Muslims and Sikhs are brothers. Where from have Pandits come? "
forged ahead towards Hazuri Bagh and put the Arya Samaj Mandir to flames. And ultimately the Muslims
and the Sikhs in a joint operation burnt down the Nirankari Bhawan. Be it put that the Nirankaris are bete
noire of the Sikhs.
The Temple at Ganpatyar in Srinagar consecrated to the god Ganpati with its history embedded in the
misty past has a woeful saga to relate as it has suffered scares of defilement and demolition at the hands
of so-called rational nationalists and sinister communal elements day in and day out. Zulfikar Ali Bhutto
as a result of the eratic political rivalries in Pakistan was brutally hanged and Muslims of Srinagar with a
deep streak of pathology in their collective personality lost their shirt and pelted stones at the Ganpatyar
Temple as a tactic to keep the Pandits on tenterhooks. The Arabs lost a war to the Jews and with a view to
boosting the morale of the fleeing soldiers the Muslims took out a massive procession yelling out
trenchant anti-Jew slogans. While passing by the side of the said emple standing calm and tranquil, they
ran berserk, pelted the temple, damaged its gates and walls with all the Islamic vigour. Desecration to
some pages of the Muslim Holy Book manipulated by some political miscreants to arouse public wrath
sparked off demonstrations massive in size and scale, and the Ganpatyar Temple fell a victim to the
Muslim fury. Farooq Abdullah won an election and his Muslim supporters frantically celebrating his
victory by flaunting V-signs pelted the entire Hindu habitation including the temple.
The Muslim marauders, violent and highly aggressive, supporting the agitation that was unleashed at the
behest of Srinagar Bar Association in thick contacts with the powers that be burnt the entire shopping
complex of the Somvar Temple of Habbakadal. The shop-keepers suffered enormous losses and also lost
their source of livelihood. The government of Farooq Abdullah discernibly in cahoots with the swelling
tide of Muslim insurgency did not bat an eye-lid at their plight as the victims involved were all Kashmiri
Pandits who had been scored off its slate of policy and planning to meet the ends of ethnic cleansing. A
reign of terror was let loose against the Bandit community. Their houses were set ablaze. The temple at
Sathu Barbarshah was torched. The Pandits protested, demonstrated and clamoured for security and
pleaded for justice, butt all in vain. A mammoth public meeting of Kashmiri Pandits held within the
temple precincts to lodge a protest against the outrage was stoned by the Muslim rabids. Scores of
protectors were injured and the police posse failed to act. All the Kashmiri Pandit fora sensing the
holocaust that was in store for them forged a joint front to fight the government discrimination and apathy
towards the community. Peaceful protests were organised, dharnas held and representations shot. But
nothing concrete could emerge.
In its editorial date-lined 20th Nov. 1987 the Martand as the official organ of the Kashmiri Pandit ethno-
religious minority has recorded, "The community had not fully recovered from the shock of Shri
A.K.Ganjoo at Sathu Barbarshah on Tuesday, the 10th of November, when we had to suffer the burning
of minority shops in Habbakadal and a temple at Barbarshah on Tuesday the 17th of November, in the
wake of the second day of the bandh sponsored by the Srinagar Bar Association. The terror and vandalism
let loose on Tuesday resulting in the total destruction of property worth lakhs of rupees and burning of
one temple at Sathu Barbarshah speaks well of the organisation and tenancity of mischievous elements
trying to stir up communal tension in the valley. The violent mobs who held the city as hostage for the
whole day were ably supported by police indifference and apathy. These mobs were so to say freely
allowed to damage and destroy whatever came their way. It appeared that the entire civil administration
was not only drowsy and inactive but in total disrepair.
We have often referred to the tact that whenever leaders of various political parties are at loggerheads
with one another or whenever they have to cover up their inadequacies or incompetence they find it
convenient to turn to this tiny minority and make them scapegoats for their own misdeeds. We are
constrained to say that the system which surrounds us is totally rigged against the minority community.
We cannot be happy at the frequent eruption of violence in the state and the minority is the main victim in
majority of cases whenever such violence breaks out. We have often cited concrete instances of loot
murder burning of property of the minority community and of governments inability to bring the culprits
to book in such instances.
We are not certain whether we should call the attitude of the government towards the agitation sponsored
by the Srinagar Bar Association as political amateurism or sheer complicity. During the ten days of the
Srinagar Bar's boycott of courts in support of the government s Barber Move order of October 7, the state
government never cared to issue an appeal to the Srinagar bar to call off their boycott.
The captain crews of Pro-Pakistan forces operating under a religious veneer never relented in their
unmitigated campaign to capture and devastate the temples and shrines with their origins in the ancient
past of Kashmir. The sacred shrine of Muran in Pulwama fell victim to the Muslim bigotry and three
sacred springs of this historical shrine of ancient origins were filled with stones and boulders and captured
and occupied with maximum support from broad sections of Muslim populace. The government of the
day already in the lap of fundamentalist forces did not bother to act and respond though protests were
lodged and petitions submitted.
Swami Nandlalji as a spiritualist of great standing with acceptability among large sections of Muslims
had established an ashram (hermitage) at Tikar in north of Kashmir. The Muslim storm-troopers burnt it
to ashes with absolute vengeance. The total assets of the hermitage were lost in the devastating fire. The
law-enforcing agencies allowed law to be torn to tatters and shreds. The arsonists with established records
in loot, murder and arson were never chased captured and put on trial.
The loot plunder and destruction of temples and shrines was not the handiwork of thieves and burglars but
as borne out by irrefutable facts had the connivance and complicity of various brands of politicals chasing
the secessionist agenda which seemed to have state sponsorship and patronage. A gangster was caught
red-handed witl1 incendiary material on his person at the highly venerated shrine of Chakreshwar on the
Hariparbat Hillock. The police posse mounting vigil on the shrine did not report the incident to the
relevant quarters. On getting the wind of it the devotees at the shrine raised hue and cry contacted the
government authorities and impressed on them the dire necessity of curbing the looters and arsonists.
However some arrests were made though reluctantly and persons involved were charged with theft
burglary and violation of Arms Act. It came as a rude shock to the Kashmiri Pandits when politicals
strained their every nerve to secure their sate release. The vandals were none other than the Muslim youth
operating under political patronage to undermine communal peace and amity with a view to expelling the
Pandits from their native land. It is pertinent to put that the Al-Jehad activists pledged to the mission of
destruction of Pandits and their properties were the front-rank workers of National conference with its
dominant membership from the Plebiscite fronters.
The Muslim rabids in their relentless and untiring campaign for the grab of the Hindu shrines suddenly
generated Muslim frenzy for constructing a mosque on the strip of land that legally belonged to the
Papaharan shrine. The government authorities were contacted and apprised of the sinister plans of the
Muslim fanatics who harbour least respect for law of the land. They perhaps had given them go-ahead
signals became apparent when the rabids were not stopped in their tracks of building a mosque on the
land-area attached with the shrine and encroachment, already made, was not cleared. The Superintendent
of Police and Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Anantnag who were forced through the intervention of a Hindu
Minister to arrive on the trouble-spot were shown and given the copies of the revenue records relevant to
the case thereby debunking the Muslim claims. Being Muslims of the treacherous stock they declared to
the Muslims that revenue records had neither relevance nor sanctity. Such a declaration on part of the two
government officers expected to be fair and equitous boosted the morale of the law-breakers who
conceived and coined every coercive measure to stop the Pandits from fencing the land area with the
result that it was left open to trespass and grab. A land area of 15 kanals and 10 marlas as was buttressed
and reinforced by revenue records was attached with the shrines
The Additional Secretary of Farooq Abdullah said to be a pimp or a tout was found feting, wining and
dining in the company of a Muslim girl in a particular house at Anantnag. The Muslims got the wind of it
and felt extremely enraged. Their wrath should have visited on the persons involved in lechery, but in
their rabid hate they targeted a temple which was desecrated, pillaged and looted. Its glass-panes were
pelted and broken. The photographs of gods and goddesses worshipped by Kashmir Pandits were
destructed in Islamic fashion. The assets of the temple were looted as booty. The formality of contacting
the police was carefully observed and as usual no notice was taken of the acts of vandalism indulged in by
the vicious Muslim elements. Prior to this vandalism the Nandkeshwar shrine at Wanpoh was desecrated
and plundered and a temple at Danois village in Kulagam Tehsil was ransacked and looted in similar
fashion.
The Martand date-lined 26th July, 1985 carried an article by P.N. Bhat who had observed, "Kashmiri
Pandit community stand on cross-road of historic with all evil forces poised against it. Not a single day
passes without report from some village, town or mohalla in the city regarding an assault here or theft of
an idol there. Land grab of the community has become the order of the day. During the last three months
historical holly shrines of Kashmiri Pandits in Vetesta verinag, Tehsil Guru, Siligam Shivala, a shrine in
Tehsil Pahalgam and Lok Bhawan in Duru Tehsil have been desecrated. There is a planned conspiracy to
harass this unfortunate community by patronised anti-social elements who have, it seems, earned the
anticipatory clemency of ruling parties since 1947. It has been established beyond any shadow of doubt
that in this orgailised assault, be it Vetesta, Siligam, Lok Bhawan or Tral, all the political parties,
Jammaat-i-Islami, National Conference (F), National Conference (K) and Congress (I) join hands and
have not even a word of condemnation against these encroachments, abuses and attacks on the members
of the minority community. It is a matter of police and intelligence record that all important leaders of
National Conference (F) and Congress (I) have given their tacit approval and active support to these
lawless lizards for belabouring the minority community at Siligam and Lok Bhawan. The local
administration is directed on telephone not to execute the warrants against the known miscreants and
pressure is mounted on them to exact concessions from the minority community. This community is
being asked to surrender even what is left behind by the encroachers at the point of gun."
Gautam Nag associated with the highly revered name of Gautam Rishi has been sacred to the Kashmiri
Pandits and other Hindus who take a dip in its holy waters before they resume their march to the cave of
Amar Nath in the mountainous region. Motivated by the same hate syndrome Qazi Nissar, the Mirwaiz of
South Kashmir, with deep pledges to the Muslim secessionist politics based on sheer bigotry operating
under the protective wings of Mufti Mohammed Sayyid, the then Congress Chief, added a new chapter to
the Islamisation campaign and communal tension which he ably and tenaciously orchestrated and
heightened by issuance of Friday calls to capture Gautam Nag shrine. He rose like a meteor in the skies of
communal politics in Kashmir when he himself cut a ram on a day sacred to the Hindus and issued Friday
calls to the Muslims purporting to aggress the Hindu shrine for grab and occupation. Not only did he coin
a new etymology of Gautam Nag but also concocted a story that a Muslim saint, a neo-convert to Islam,
used to sit at the site for peace and rest. The Muslim Auqaf declaring that all Muslim properties were
under its protective care and management had no impact on Qazi Nissar who through his rude deportment
and fanatic rabble-rousing came to be seen as the pale version of Sikandar, the iconoclast.
Qazi Nissar said to have risen from rags to riches went on giving Friday calls to the Muslims to fortify
their ranks for aggression on the shrine. The process continued with no relent with a view to keeping the
communal cauldron on non-stop simmer. On every Friday call as could be observed droves of Muslims
got collected in unprecedented numbers, fretting and fuming, bespattering and inveighing, ready on a nod
to maraud, plunder and capture the shrine. To deter the Pandits from building a response they were
reviled and humiliated and their residential quarters were pelted and they were subjected to physical
assaults. The government of the day sunk in pathetic negligence and inertia appeared at the fuelling end
and had given ample signals that it had a common cause with terrorism. Ultimatclv the Gautam Nag
shrine was aggressed, its dharamshallas were burnt to cinders and the Mahant living within the premises
of the shrine was cruelly beaten and spat at.
The government under the helmsmanship of Farooq Abdullah declared the shrine as disputed and
appointed a petty Assistant Commissioner for adjudication of the title.
The Kashmiri Pandits not only in Anantnag but throughout the length and breath of the valley were
deeply anguished and shocked and immediately opened up channels of communication with the
government authorities inside and outside the state. The relevant and authoritative records and documents
were culled and gleaned and submitted for perusal. Qazi Nissar acting in tandem with the government
authorities did not relent in his vicious campaign for adding momentum to communal discord and tension,
strife and disorder. The lawless elements under patronage of the political class were in the process of
proliferating their base on ground for hiving Kashmir from the political organisation of India.
The Anantnag Prabandhak Committee in its emergency session on 21st of February 1989 was
unequivocal and forthright in its condemnation of the wave of commtulalism unleashed by Qazi Nissar
and rejected his utterances about the Gautam Nag shrine as false and spurious. The committee also
resolved to apprise the Chief Minister of the state and the Central govermnent about the strengthening of
communal forces as a result of thinning of securalist ranks. The deluge of resolutions passed and issued
out by the Kashmiri Pandit organizations and tore expressed their explicit intent to contact the Sadhu
Samaj at Allahabad that is committed in word and deed to the safe-guarding of Hindu interests all over
the country.
The communal politics with its pointed thrust against the molecular minority of Pandits was highlighted
by the Martand, date-lined 24th of March, 1989 under the caption "will Qazi Nissar-Farooq Abdullah
collusion set Kashmir ablaze"? The government was openly charged with a conspiratorial nexus with the
monsters of rabid hate who were doggedly working to the nefarious end of disseminating inter-
community hatred and disaffection. The mullahs of varied brands that were imported into Kashmir Acre
preaching Jehad for the achievement of political objectifies with their sharp thrust against Kashmiri
Pandits. The armed battle between the Iranian Hajis and the Saudi security forces and the explosion at
Faizabad ammunition dump provided grist to the mill of Muslim violence against the religious enemies.
The communal propaganda that Was politically motivated and officially regulated was invested with
vigour and stridency to realise the goal of denuding Kashmir of Hindu culture symbols with the implicit
underpinning that Kashmir had ceased to be a cup of tea for the Pandits.
The Muslim onslaught on temples and Hindu culture symbols touched a new water-mark in the wake of
Muslim terrorism sweeping the valley. Heinous crimes were committed in grabbing, desecrating,
demolishing and setting ablaze the Hindu places of worship. Alarm bells were tolled when hundreds of
temples and shrines in the district of Anantnag were razed to the ground, their properties looted and
pillaged. Despite the disinformation campaigns launched by B.G. Vergese and Harvinder Baweja through
the columns of "India Today" the fact remains that the Muslin insurgency holding aloft the banner of
Muslim Jehad against the miniscule minority of Pandits has destructed and plundered temples and shrines
of historical importance with a view to exterminating infidelity from the soil of Kashmir. There is hardly
a village or a town where temples and shrines have not been destructed, desecrated and demolished. Some
temples desecrated and damaged in Kashmir from 1990 onwards are under:
1. Dashnami Akhara, Srinagar
The temple in the Akara has been a chronic eye-sore to the Muslim fanatics. There was a park laid out
within its premises. There were dharamshallas for the sadhus and hermits for their short sojourn and a
residence for the mahant who looks after the entire shopping-cum-office complex. It has not been
attacked once but has a history of attacks at the hands of Muslim rabids. Dashnami Akhara is the place
where-from the pilgrimage for Amar Nath starts every year with religious rites and zeal. The same
Akhara was put to flames by the frenzied Muslim mobs causing tremendous damage and destruction to
the temple and the material properties attached with it. The Akhara is managed by the Dharmarth Trust
which perhaps did not deem it apt to lodge a protest with the government authorities on the desecration
and damage of the temple.
2. Ganpatyar Temple
Ganpatyar Temple has been the butt of attache whenever Muslims in their volcanic fury erupt on streets
to show down jews, to mourn the death of Zia-ul-Haq, to burn the copies of Satanic verses written by a
Muslim or to show down India if her team has defeated Pakistan. With the launch of Muslim terrorism the
said-temple has been bombed umpteen times and subjected to rocket attacks t. twice to say the least.
3. Shiva Temple, Jawahir Nagar, Srinagar
The property of the temple that was stuffed in the dharamshalla was brought out alongwith some idols of
the temple. Some utility items were looted as usual and other items considered inconsequential were put
on fire. The idols were hurled away in absolute disrespect and contumely.
4. Raghu Nath Mandir, Anantnag
It was put to bomb blasts at least nine times. The same has been confirmed by the Mahant of the temple.
5. Gautam Nag Temple, Anantnag
The temple having two storeys was burnt to ashes even though the Homeguards were placed on duty there
to save it from the Muslim marauders. A plethora of Sanskrit menu scripts in Sharda script were lost in
the devastating fire. The orchard attached with the temple was mercilessly felled.
6. Three temples of Lok Bhawan, Anantnag
The temples had suffered Muslim wrath in 1986. The then governor, Jagmohan, had got them repaired.
They were again put to an orgy of fire in the wake of terrorist avalanche menacing the valley. The
dharamshalla was burnt. The temples were damaged and destructed.
7. Shailputri Temple, Baramulla
The temple has been completely burnt. The main idol of the Shailputri riding on an ox was attacked and
its arms and legs axed. The whole complex is devastated. The walls surrounding the area have been
damaged. The idol of Shailputri in its mutilated form is in the protective custody of B.S.F. personnel. The
propaganda launched from various media agencies about the execution of repairs to the devasted temple
complex with the aid of locals has been only a lie among many lies told about the secular polity of
Kashmir lying in a shambles.
8. Wanpoh Mandir, Anantnag
The temple was repaired and face-lifted after it suffered desecration and demolition in 1986 as a result of
Muslim bigotry. The Muslim marauders have again publicly desecrated it on 21st of February, 1992.
9. Bhairavnath Mandir, Baramulla
It was desecrated and damaged in 1990. The scars inflicted on the temple can be visibly seen.
10. Rupabhawani Mandir, Vaskura
The temple consecrated to the saint poetess, Rupabhawani, was subjected to the worst brand of
desecration. The idols inside the temple have been removed and utility goods as part of assets of the
temple have been looted by the Muslim looters. Night soil was littered over the steps of tile temple not
once but ten times in the beginning of the calendar year of 1990. Some Pandits staying back in the hamlet
despite their status of hostages strongly protested against the desecration of the revered temple. They were
terrorised and mercilessly beaten. One of them was said to have cried," If the steps of a mosque were
littered over with night-soil, you would have risen in revolt, cried that Islam was in danger and roasted
Pandits alive."
11. Bhairav Nath Temple, Sopore
The temple was desecrated and damaged. The idols were broken and looted. The doors and windows of
the temple have been looted and the walls around the temple levelled and the materials looted by the
Islamic looters.
12. Khirbhawani Mandir, Ganderbal
The origins of the temple can be traced to epic times. It was subjected to a rocket attack on 4th April 1991
in which outer gate of the temple was severely damaged. It was again subjected to an attack on 4th of
May, 1991. The outer structures still bear the bullet scars. According to B.G. Verghese the temple
attracted attacks because of the presence of security forces guarding the temple. But he had not a word to
say about hundreds of temples which were desecrated, damaged and destroyed by the Muslims and had
no security forces to mount vigil on them.
13. Mattan Temple, Anantnag
A Muslim mob yelling in extreme fury and indignation entered the sacred premises of the temple and said
Namaz and declared to the world that it was a Muslim shrine.
14. Gautam Nag Hermitage
The state administration replaced the CRPF personnel guarding the hermitage by the local armed police
personnel who visibly harboured hate for the shrine and the Mahant looking after its management affairs.
The Muslims targetted the hermitage and burnt most of the construction within its premises on 19th of
Ocotber, 1990. The Mahant, Sukh Ram, had personally met the Home Minister who despite his promises
to defend the shrine allowed the Muslim bigotry to take a toll of the sacred site of the Hindus.
15. Vilagam
There were three temples at Vilagam All the three are desecrated by the Muslim marauders. Walls
enclosing the temples have been dismantled and materials looted. Idols have been either broken or
removed.
16. Shoolara
The temple has been desecrated. The original idol has been removed from the sanctum sanctorum.
17. Gushi
The structure of the temple is standing, but there is no idol which has been broken or stolen by the
Muslim bigots.
18. Kaloosa
The temple has been desecrated and its main idol broken or stolen.
19. Sadamalun
It is a hermitage with lots of land attached with it which are said to have been grabbed by the Muslims.
The mahant was hacked to pieces.
20. Pattan ruins
The temples at Pattan which were ravaged and destroyed by the infamous Sikandar, the iconoclast, have
been further devastated by the modern-day iconoclasts. That is how the ruins have dwarfed. The huge
slabs that were still standing giving it the look of temples belonging to the hoary past have been removed
and broken into heaps of pebbles.
21. Kanimoja Gantamulla
The huge stone held in great reverence at Gantamulla has been broken with hammers. Its half is missing
and half is still standing. There were three hooves of the sacred cow at the same place and Kashmiri
Pandits would throng the place on a particular day and date to have their "darshan". One hoof has been
maliciously destroyed.
22. Hanumat Kund, Kupwara
The Hanumat Kund at the place of Halmatpora was a spring of oozing waters. It was held in reverence
even by Muslims. Gujjar Muslims are said to have desecrated the spring by offering it meat and since
then it is said to have dried up and it has now been filled up with stones and boulders.
23. Raja Ram Mountains
These mountains lie between Tangadar and Teetwal. The idol of Ram has been desecrated, broken or
looted.
24. Khoj Bagh Temple, Baramulla
It was a Shiva Temple and has been burnt.
25. Hanjivera Temple, Pattan, Baramulla
The Samadhi of an unknown saint within the temple premises has been demolished.
26. Venkara Temple, Baramulla
It has been burnt.
27. Palhalan Temple Baramulla
It stands burnt to ashes.
28. Bhairav Nath Temple, Baramulla
It had 10 kanals of land attached with it. It is burnt.
29. Ragnya Temple, Zainpora, Kulagam
The temple suffered the Muslim wrath when Mast Gul and his local Muslim collaborators burnt the chrar
mausoleumof Nund Rishi. It was a temple after the pattern of Khsirbhawani Temple at Tulamulla. It was
desecrated, looted and destroyed by the Muslim Vandals.
30. Brari-Angan Shrine, Anantnag
It has been a centre of pilgrimage for the Kashmiri Pandits since ages. It had an ancient temple made of
wood with dhooni (holy fire) burning perennially. Even the Afghan tyrants could not put it out. But the
modern day frenzied Muslims have desecrated and decimated the whole complex with impunity. Swami
Swayamanand had built a new complex at the site after the pattern of Khsirbhawani Temple. The
Dharmashallas with three storeys each have not been spared either. The assets of the temple have been
looted by the Muslim vandals.
The Shiva Temple standing by the road-side is burnt. Another temple built by the Dogra Rajputs has also
been set ablaze.
35. Temples Arrh
The temple standing opposite to the Boys High Schools, Arrh is burnt to ashes. Another Shiva Temple
standing in the midst of the habitation has met the same fate. The foundations of another temple had been
laid. The plinth that was laid out has been dug out and materials looted by the Islamic looters.
36. Temple Batsargam
It was a replica of the Kulavaghishwari Temple of Kulagam. The wall around the temple has been
dismantled and materials looted. G.I.E. sheets are also looted. The two storeyed Dharamshalla is burnt
and destroyed. Chinars and walnut trees growing within the temple lands measuring 9-1/2 kanals have
been felled and looted. The assets of the temple are also looted. The Muslim government of Krishna Rao
proved shameless bysanctioning an ex-gratia grant of Rs. 3000/- which has been refused outright in view
of the enormous losses suffered by the Kashmiri Pandits.
37. Katyayani Temple, Kulagam
It has been totally razed to the ground. The icons of Shiva Parvati and Katyayani have been desecrated
and broken into pieces. Dharmashalla is burnt. Materials of the temple are looted as booty. The fencing
around the temple area measuring three kanals has been removed and destroyed.
38. Vaishakhi Temple, Kharbrari, Kulgam
It has a spring with ancient Shiva Lingas studding its sides. The trees and poplars growing within the
temple have been felled and looted. The wall around the temple has been dismantled.
39. Temple, Bugam, Kulagam
It is completely burnt. Its shiva and Ganesh idols have been desecrated and destroyed. It is standing on the
Maw Kuliya, a part of Vishoka (veshaw).
40. Temple, Dhanav, Bogund, Kulagam
It was the seat of Muslim loot of 1986. The temple which was looted and destroyed in 1986 was repaired
and now has again been looted and burnt by the same brand of Muslim destroyers.
41. Temple, Wanpoh, Anatnag
The two Shiva Temples on the Nandi Kulya have been burnt and destroyed. They were destroyed in 1986
loot as well.
42. Temple, Ashmuji, Kulagam
The temple with an area of 3 kanals has been burnt.
43. Temple, Divasar
It is an ancient temple site. It is burnt and its assets have been looted by the insatiable looters.
44. Temple, Khanbarni, Kulagam
The temple owes its origins to ancient past. Its area spawns over 1-1/2 kilometres up into the forests. It is
a replica of Khsirbhawani temple. It has been burnt to ashes. The pine trees considered sacred and
worshipped have been felled and burnt. It is essentially known as the seat of Mother Goddess
Tripursundary.
45. Nari Bharan Temple, Shopian
It was a small temple built after the tradition that \vas set by the Hindu rulers. The Muslims could not but
burn it too.
46. Thakur Dwar Temple Shopian
It was standing on the shores of river Rambiara. It was built by Rajputs with lots of investment. The
Muslim arsonists burnt it with vengeance. A Dharmashalla for pilgrims was also burnt by sprinkling
kerosene over it.
The Shiva Temple in the premises of vaital Bhairav in the Dal Lake has been surrounded by public
latrines built by Muslims who are sheer spiteful boors. The iron fencing of the temple is said to be
damaged and removed.
60. Balak Pathshahi Temple, Srinagar
It was a small temple located near Food Control Department, J&K Government. The Idol of Shiva is
desecrated and broken. The Srinagar Development Authority is said to have closed the gate of the temple
by constructing a wall illegally on that side. The Supervisor appointed by the Dharamarth Trust was
warned of dire consequences by the local Muslims if he entered the temple premises for inspection and
assessment of losses.
61. Ram Temple, Khankhai Sokta, Safakadal, Srinagar
The idols of Ram and Sita are destroyed. A separate Shiva temple in the same complex has suffered the
same fate. The Shiva Lmga is hurled into the Jehlum. The Dharamshalla having two storeys is burnt to
cinders.
62. Ropa Bhawani Asthapan, Khankhai Sokta, Srinagar
It is destroyed and burnt. The G.I.E. sheets are looted. The walls around the temple are dismantled and
materials looted.
63. Temple, Purushyar, Srinagar
The temple situated on the shores of the Jehlum was ravaged and desecrated. The Dharamshalla was put
afire by the Muslim arsonists.
64. Katleshwar Temple, Srinagar
There are no idols in the sanctum sanctorum of the temple. The doors and windows of the temple are
removed and looted. The walls of the temple have been scratched and razed. Shiva Linga thrown out of
the temple is damaged. Chain is hanging and bell has been looted. All types of slang and obscenities are
scribbled over the damaged walls of the temple. Dharamshalla is razed to the ground. Pandit houses
around the temple premises are burnt and destroyed.
65. Raghu Nath Temple, Fateh Kadal, Srinagar
The structure of the temple has been pulled down. The idols studding the parikrama are missing. The
idols of Ram, Sita and Hanuman are missing from the temple. Chain is hanging, but bell has been looted
by the frenzied looters. The inner walls of the sanctum sanctorum are scratched. All sorts of dirt including
shit is littered over the temple premises. All sorts of obscenities with genitals as the main theme are
scribbled over the temple walls with charcoal. While going to the river-side there was a temple structure
which has been destroyed. Steps leading to the main temple have been dug out.
The team of Kashmiri Pandits who paid a visit to the temple in the wake of the Sangrampora massacre
was shocked to find obscenities of the worst brand scribbled over the temple walls.
66. Swami Gopi Nath Ashram, Kharyar, Srinagar
The main gate of the ashram has been levelled. The dirt and rubble littered over the compound of the
ashram is thrown inside it by the secular Muslims. The temple 'sousing the Ganapati idol has been stoned
and damaged. The trunk is chopped off. The mahl ashram is blocked by planks of wood after putting it to
a bout of loot.
67. Temple, Payar
It is a piece of monument marking a specific development in the Hindu architecture. The same temple has
been desecrated. The Muslim boors have built huge public latrines around it thus polluting the environs of
the temple. The temple stones engraved with the figurines of Hindu deities are used as doorsteps to
denigrate the Hindu faith.
68. Temples, Malmoh, Badgam
The temples situated on the Nallah Ferozpore have been looted. The walls around them are demolished.
Trees standing in their midst have been felled and looted. The icon of Ganapati in the temple of
Bhagishwar Bhairav was broken allegedly by one Mohammad Ashraf S/o Abdul Aziz who was never
caught and tried for the heinous crime.
69. Temple, Shalla Kadal, Kanikadal, Srinagar
The temple built by the family of Tickoos has been occupied by a Muslim and is said to have turned it
into his residence. He has painted the whole temple structure green and has hurled the Shiva idol into a
gutter.
70. Pokhribal Temple, Kathidarwaza, Srinagar
It is situated on the shores of the Nageen Lake. It has been savagely looted and plundered. The musical
instruments within the Dharamshallas have been looted. The utensils, pots, pans and cups worth lakhs of
rupees have been removed from the temple premises by the Islamic crusaders. The Sikhs inhabiting the
neighbourhood of the temple could not save the temple from the vandals.
43 C ha pte r 11 - L O O T A N D B U R N IN G O F B O O K S
Kashmir as a nursery of learning and religion has to its credit multi-dimensional and multi-faceted
contributions to the mainstream culture and civilisation of India. There is no segment of human learning
and abstract thought which intellectuals and thinkers of Kashmir have not nourished and enriched with
loftiness of their thought and sublimity of their expression. The prolific faculties that they were endowed
with have found remarkable expression in the annals of philosophy, aesthetics, poetics, sculpture and
architecture and more than most in mathematics, astronomy and astrology. Kashmir as is universally
recognised vitas a pivotal centre of Sanskrit learning and erudition and as such had been a locus of
attraction for a galaxy of scholars and savants with urges to satiate their thirst for knowledge and up-date
their learning levels and scales. Kalhan, Jonraj, Srivar, Abhinavgupta, Somanand, Utpaldev, Somdev,
Kshemendra et al transformed Kashmir into an intellectual centre of tremendous reputation through their
scholarly attainments and this was how on the basis of trendsetting contributions to the total canvas of
learning and scholarship Kashmir earned the honoured appellation of "Sharda Peeth", a hallowed centre
of learning.
Islam tumbling like an avalanche upon Kashmir was ruthless in the destruction of "Sharda Peeth", its
heritage, value-structure and usages. The Muslim anxiety religious in nature to destruct and root out the
past of Kashmir (and as is well - known past lies buried in books) generated an unabated fury to tear,
mutilate and burn the treasure-trove of books that reflected like a mirror the 5000-year old cultural and
civilisational history from the seminal promptings to the stages of full flowering. As the ruling cliques of
Muslims sharing their ethos of intolerance, strife and disorder with their co-religionists inhabiting various
regions and belts of territory were in pursuit of the malignant objective of genocide of Kashmiri Pandits,
it would have remained an unfinished task of a set agenda had they not burnt their books on a stunning
scale. As is amply testified by historical evidences the Buddhist, Shaivite and Vaishnavite places of
worship littering over the land of Kashmir were not only cultural and religious symbols but receptacles of
learning and centres of golden light of enlightenment dispelling mental obscurities and intellectual
cobwebs through rare books and tomes orchestrating an ethos that surmounted the crude and un-seemly
antagonism and strife generated in the name of religion. The destruction of books and libraries involved
the same parameters of religious zeal and fanaticism with which destructive proselytisation was pursued
and realised.
The genocide of Kashmiri Pandits owing its perception and motivation to the Sayyids was translated into
actual praxis by Sikander, the book burner, who executed interalia the deliberate plan of destruction and
decimation of Hindu knowledge and learning with the objective of promoting the Islamic brand of
theology and learning with alien origins. As a psychopath with theo-fascist traits and proclivities he added
new chapters to the Muslim history that is replete with instances of burning of books and libraries. The
books as cultural objects dilating on Hindu learning, philosophy and theology were savagely fed to the
kitchen fires and bath-room boilers of Sayyids who have been acclaimed as the harbingers of Islamic faith
in Kashmir. The libraries which were set on fire with impunity went on burning and smouldering for
months on end. Not only did the psycopath impose punitive levies and cesses on the Pandits but also
destructed their faith and its reflections and explanations in books with the vicious objective of causing a
hiatus in the history of culture and civilisation that the Pandits of Kashmir had actively shaped and were a
heir to.
Records Srivar, "Sikander under the inspiration of yavanas (Muslims) burnt books, (saklan pustakan) the
same way as fire burns hay."
Being an erudite scholar of Sanskrit Srivar has deliberately taken to the plank of wrong grammar to focus,
stress and disseminate Sikander's heinous crime of destructing books on an unimaginable scale.
Again he records, "All the scintillating works faced destruction in the same manner that lotus flowers face
with the onset of frosty winter."
As an inveterate enemy of human knowlege and learning Sikander replicated the Muslim history of
burning libraries that were bedecked with precious books on all segments of human learning and creative
impulses. The Kashmiri Pandits vexed and mortified at whole-sale despoliation of their precious heritage
and cultural objects fled with a portion of their book-treasure to the mountainous regions and inaccessible
forest areas where they could be safe and secure from the Muslim philistines. Some Pandits extra-keen to
save their tomes and manuscripts from the Muslim destructionists crossed the mountain ramparts girting
the valley to the plains of India.
Writes Srivar, "The erudites of that period witnessing the en masse destruction of books by Muslims fled
their land with some books through mountain routes."
Sikander harnessed state machinery to get the houses of Pandits ransacked and looted and the choicest
books thus got were consigned to the flowing currents of rivers, oozing waters of lakes and wells and
hurled into deep ditches and ravines.
Records Walter Lawrence, " All books of Hindu Learning which he (Sikander) could find were sunk in
the legal lake and after some time Sikander flattered himself that he had extirpated Hinduism from the
valley."
A Muslim historian Hassan also writes, " All the Hindu books of learning were collected and thrown into
Dal Lake and were buried beneath stones and earth."
On the total destruction of treasure-trove of books in the times of Muslim vandals led by Sikander, Jia Lal
Kilam records, "Even in their miserable plight they (Pandits) did not forget their rich treasures which
linked them with their past. They felt that they were custodians of their past cultural heritage-the
illuminating treatises on the stupendous Shaiva philosophy and other great works on literature, art, music,
grammar, and medicine-works which have excited the wonder of an admiring world and wherever they
went they carried these treasures with themselves. Judging from the depth of thought displayed in these
works that have been preserved, their high literary merit, their insight into the depth of nature, their
poetical flights, their emotional Devour coupled with an incisive logical treatment of the subjects dealt
with in them, one can easily imagine the colossal loss the world has been subjected to by the acts of
vandalism which resulted in the destruction of hundreds of works which contained the labours of more
than two thousand years."
The destruction of books as leitmotifs of Hindu worldview, Hindu philosophical probes into supra-
sensible realms, Hindu historiography, Hindu aesthetics did not diminish in its fury even in the
comparatively peaceful times of Zain-ul-Abidin popularly known as Budshah. It is surprising that before
his conversion to Shriya Bhat he is said to have constructed a cause-way from Naidkhai to Sopore with
the temple stones and pillars along with invaluable stock of books that were looted from the temples,
libraries and Pandit houses. He is the same king that rehabilitated the Pandits after their first forcible and
massive exodus from their natural homes to unknown destinations.
The prolific and high calibre Kashmiri pandit scholars and intellectuals having scaled heights in creative
drinking based on an all-embracing outlook and psychical diversity w ere reviled, humiliated and tortured
to death. Bhuvaneshwar who had tremendous reputation all over the country for his amazing levels of
scholarship in Vedic lore and learning was harassed and put to an orgy of plunder and loot (lotri-dand).
Ultimately under motivations of infinite bigotry he was butchered in a merciless Muslim manner. His
severed head smeared with tilak as a caste-mark was hurled away on a road-side with a view to instilling
fear and trepidation among the intellectuals who had not renounced their religion and continued
contributing to the indigenous expressions of learning and scholarship. All the Brahmans who were
learned and had mastery over theology were exterminated. The fanatical intolerance and inveterate hatred
that was exhibited against Hindu lore and learning and especially scholars irrigating them led to the
demise of an ethos that had fostered plenitude and plenteousness of scholarship and learning.
Nona Dev, Jaya and Bhima Brahman with their depth of knowledge and breadth of vision were forced to
commit suicide by leaping into the rivers. The Kashmiri Pandit scholars who were highly venerated for
their varied contributions to learning and aesthetics were subjected to the mutilation of body-parts and
gruesome killings. Nirmal Kanth who had mobilised resistance against Muslim holocaust was physically
eliminated not for encouraging apostasy but for his attainments in the annals of learning and scholarship.
Men of letters were put to a whole-sale massacre and the books which they had authored were looted, torn
and burnt.
Records Shuka, "Khwaja Mir Mohammad on the other hand induced Kak Chakra (Kaji Chak) who was
alarmed at the work of Nirmal Kanth and others to give him permission to act against them, and actuated
by malice caused them to be killed."
Sukha again laments, "O Brah,nans, where in this Kali Yug are your Brahmanical spirit and practice? It
was for want of these that the sorrowful and the affrighted Nirmal Kanth and others were killed. The
oppression of the Mausalas (Muslims) which began in the times of Saidas (Sayyids) was perfected by
Kaka Chakra (Kaji Chak)."
To push out Sanskrit from the Muslim courts and relegate it into an oblivion Persian was introduced and
patronised by Muslims strutting the corridors of power. It was a big conspiracy to wean the Pandits away
from Sanskrit language which had been the fountain-head of their lore and learning and was spoken even
by women. The position of Kashmir in the domain of Sanskrit was so preeminent that it came to be
regarded not only as the abode of Goddess of Learning, Shardapeeth, but also as the Sarvajnapith (abode
of all forms of learning). Without being prolific on the significance of Sanskrit it can be said that Sanskrit
is even now the foundation of the Kashmiri cultural heritage. Banishment of Sanskrit and its replacement
by an alien language was an onslaught on the essence of Kashmiri identity. What would accrue from the
language policy of the Muslim rulers was to deprive the Pandits of their sustenance by keeping them
away from the administrative apparatus. But, to the shock and dismay of the fanatics, Kashmiri Pandits
with an ardour for learning and scholarship took to the learning of Persian and made amazing and breath-
taking contributions to the realms of Persian poesy and prose. But, Hazar Khan, the Pathan surrogate, did
not take it lying down and issued orders banning the learning of Persian by the Pandits. If a Pandit flouted
the flat, he as always was straightaway to be butchered.
Comments Jia Lal Kilam, "The Pandits were strictly forbidden to read Persian and the penalty for the
infringement was certain death. The degrading and unwholesome consequences of this order can well be
understood when we bear in mind that the Persian was then the court language and the affairs of the state
were conducted in this language. It is a known fact that the Kashmiri Pandits' mastery over the Persian
language was second only to the Persians. The result was that they secured an entrance into the
administration of the country. But Mir Hazar wanted them to be ousted for all time from the
administrative machinery and this he could achieve with ease if no Persian knowing Pandit was
available."
The fundamentalist forces in Kashmir that were in the processes of spreading their tentacles opened their
agenda with the declaration of war on books that were not of Islamic brand and hue. Darwin was the first
target as his Theory of Evolution does not conform to the Islamic tenets. The Jammaat-i-Islami as the
rabid fundamentalist organisation launched a campaign to ransack libraries in the educational institutions
and flared ban on books which did not correspond to their fake knowledge about man, world and God.
The Kashmir university funded by the University Grants Commission and headed by the Governor of the
state was denuded of two thousand books including the works of Milton, G.B. Shaw, Shakespeare, H.G.
Wells and tomes on Hindu Philosphy in a Nazi style. The book-shop vending works of Marx, Engels,
Lenin, Morris Cornforth, Winwood Read et al was looted in broad daylight at Batamaloo, Srinagar. The
library of the Information Centre run by Government of India was looted by the progeny of Halaku Khan
and set on fire. The book titled as "Pachan" authored by a Kashmiri literattuer was torn and burnt on the
streets of Baramulla and the author was imprisoned for no fault of his for months on end. A Muslim
progressive accused of heresy for having books of Marx, Lenin, Stalin, Mao et al was harassed by
instituting cases against him and with the onset of Muslim terrorism he was cruelly squirted with bullets
and killed.
As is well-known the Muslim insurgency backed up by the militarised Islamic forces opened its ruinous
agenda in 1988 and touched a crescendo in 1989. The Muslim marauders could not but suppress their
innate urge and proclivity to loot, plunder and arson the properties and estates left behind by the fleeing
Pandits. They desecrated and destructed their temples, harvested their crops and annexed their lands and
to cap it all looted and burnt their books as repositories of learning and knowledge. Targetting each
Kashmiri Pandit house for loot and ravage as per the delineated plans the ruthless marauders acting in the
name of Islam destroyed paintings in oils or in water colours and sketches of inestimable value and
images of gods and goddesses and human figures sculpted out of bronze and other materials to quench
their savage thirst for the annihilation of their religious foes. The Muslim destructionists chasing the
grand plan of ethnic cleansing have been following to a dot the objective of uprooting and destructing the
indigenous patterns of culture which are embedded and enshrined in books in the native language. Books
in the words of Jean Paul Sartre are "Culture objects" replete with value-based conceptualizations about
the inter-action that humanity in general had between itself and the surrounding milieu. Books are a sure
key to self-discovery and also provide a safe corridor to the past. Books establish the continuity and
coherence of a civilization. As the Muslim revanchists in their designs are out to destroy the community
of Pandits, numerically a minority, they are destroying their books to give a hiatus to their 5000-year old
cultural and civilisational process and also break their un-interrupted tryst with the goddess of learning.
There is much of pith in the statement "If you want to destroy a community, burn its books."
Man can beget sons but he cannot beget books. As a commonsense stuff it can be understood that a man
impelled by his natural instincts and drives can procreate but he is absolutely incapable of procreating a
book symbolising his culture as an accumulated store-house of values, traditions, customs and mental
patterns. A book invests a man with self-articulation. It gives him a definition and invests him with a high
sense of pride. The Muslim marauders with five hundred years of history in Kashmir have been chasing
Islamisation with a view to rendering the Kashmiri Pandits as "Cultural destitutes" by destroying their
"Cultural autonomy" which they presume is the prelude to their deculturation, assimilation and final
decimation without any resistance. With the motive of destroying Sanskrit learning and its vestiges in
Kashmir the invaluable treasure of Sanskrit manuscripts in Sharda script that was preserved in the
Research Library, Srinagar was shifted to the Department of Central Asian Studies where it is said to have
been dumped in gunny bags left to the care of hostile moths. The manuscripts are a veritable treasuretrove
dilating on mind-body disciplines, recondite philosophical doctrines, arcane fortune telling systems,
integrated theoretical systems from aesthetics to rhetoric and complexities of language nuances.
The books looted from Pandit clusters prior to their total decimation have been contemptuously torn,
mutilated and scattered over the interiors of the houses. There are marauders who have collected
numerous books on varied subjects, and have been selling them by weight. There is a special class of
Muslim marauders who have dumped a huge stock of invaluable books in their residential quarters and
have been selling them to retailers who in turn tear them page by page and convert them into cones and
other geometrical shapes to vend off their retail items like tea, sugar, salt, spices et al. There are Muslim
fanatics of the Jammaat-i-Islami breed who make a pile of the looted books in the isolated corner of a lane
and set it afire chanting "death to Pandit Kaisers." A few more cunning among them harness the services
of Kashmiri Pandit hostages staffing back in the valley and despatch them to Jammu and other
metropolises to mobilise the sale of old manuscripts in Shardascript at a lucrative price. The horoscopes
looted from Kashmiri Pandit houses are also a saleable item with the looters.
An officer in the state government, a literattucr by all standards, at the time of "office move" from Jammu
to Srinagar way back in 1992, was shocked and dismayed to learn about the sale of the looted books at a
particular shop in a down-town locality. Camouflaging his real identity he made a foray into the Muslim
den and succeeded in locating the shop. While accosting to the Muslim shopkeeper putting on a well-cut
beard he was plainly informed that he had been selling books looted from the houses of Pandit Kafirs who
had fled the land thus rendering a damage to the on-going movement. On enquiry he was told that he
himself had been looting books from the Pandit houses and then he had contacts who have been pursuing
it as a profession at the behest of respectable Muslims. "Who are the persons at whose behest they pursue
it as a profession?" asked the officer. "That I cannot tell", was the reply. Ultimately the officer was led
into the interior of the shop where he purchased 5 kgs of books for fifty rupees. When back home he was
surprised and vexed to find that the books he had purchased included Stein's Rajtarangini and two
volumes of Nilmat Puran. On perusal he discovered that all the books he had fetched home bore the
signatures of the Pandits who had purchased them with the moneys that they had earned with the sweat of
their brow. For the officer it was a shock, but for the Muslim looter it vas a religious act as he was
vending off booty legitimised by the Textual injunctions.
Amritsar as sources say has emerged very lately as the active disposal market of loot from the Kashmiri
Pandit houses. Old hand-written manuscripts in Sharda studded with miniature paintings on their margins
and books on varied segments of human learning are said to be openly being marketed. One such looted
manuscript has been acquired by an Institute pursuing research in the culture of Kashmir at Delhi. Gangs
of cloth and textile peddlers mostly from the Punjab and Delhi have been thronging the city of Srinagar
and have been operating as conduits for the disposal of knowledge and culture looted from the Kashmiri
Pandits houses.
There is a definite and pin-pointed information about some Muslims who have piled up incredible stocks
of looted books and manuscripts and other antiques in their houses and have been desperately searching
for touts throughout the country to dispose of their booty for hefty sums. Some such touts have already
made their presence felt in Jammu. People interested in the history of Kashmir are fully aware of the fact
that a cause-way in the Anchar Lake was built with the books of Hindu lore and learning, but they will
have to up-date their knowledge by the Muslim act of setting up a business in the area of looted books and
manuscripts.
The Muslim insurgents with religious motivations have ethnically cleansed Kashmir of its original natives
and there is a consistent drive to destroy their cultural and religious heritage thereby robbing them of the
characteristics of a religious minority with a deep-seated consciousness of its distinctive identity. Books
as a vehicle and source of heritage have been under the Muslim onslaught and this is what prompted the
author to probe the grievous losses by way of books that the Kashmiri Pandits have suffered. Ten
prominent Kashmiri Pandit artists, twenty professors, thirty-five teachers, ten political workers of long
standing and eighteen farmers were contacted and their book losses recorded. Some cases are highlighted
to focus on the cultural genocide of the Kashmiri Pandits in their native lanc1 which political myopics
still consider a tranquil secular oasis.
P.N. Kachru an Artist
P. N. Kachru is a graduate from the Punjab University. He kept terms in Post-graduation in English
Literature, 1945-46, in the same university. He earned a Diploma in Fine Arts (Painting) in 1944. He has
been the founder member of the National Cultural Front established in November, 1947 to combat the
tribal storm-troopers who invaded Kashmir in October, 1947. He has also been the founder member of
Progressive Artists Association, The National Cultural Congress, J&K State Cultural Congress, the J&K
Artists Association and the visionaries. He has held numerous exhibitions of his paintings at various art
centres in Delhi, Bombay, Lucknow and Srinagar. He has also participated in numerous national
exhibitions held by Lalit Kala Academy, New Delhi, Hyderabad Art Society, Academy of Fine Arts,
Calcutta, Bombay Art Sociery et al.
He shot up in the art scenario of the country when he earned a number of awards from Hyderabad Art
Societal and Academy of Art, Culture and Languages, J&K State. In 1988 he was invested with "the
Veteran Artists" Award by AIFACS, New Delhi.
Kachru had no fewer than four thousand books which have been looted by the Islamic looters. In fact, his
house was the first to be looted when the loot, plunder find arson of Pandit houses gained the fury of a
campaign. The looters were gage with the enormous booty that they got from the house. His writings and
his treasure of paintings as his life-time achievements have also been looted. The losses are inestimable
not only to the person of Kachru but to the entire cultural history of India.
The books he had and stand looted are as under:
f) A rare collection of art books which included a) Gupta Art by Harley b) Gupta Art by Jonathan
Williams c) Gandhara Art in Pakistan by Ingolt d) History of Indian Art by Hutchinson e) Art in Central
Asia by Rowlinson
g) He had procured a catalogue of Pehsawar Museum from Dacca in Bangladesh
h) Bronzes of Kashmir by P. Paul
i) Art and Architecture of Kashmir by P. Paul
j) Ancient Monuments of Kashmir by R.C. Kak
k) Early Sculpture of Art of Kashmir By Paul
l) A Handbook of Sri Partap Museum by R.C. Kak
m) His daughter, a medical doctor, had more than one hundred books on various topics of medical science
which also have been looted.
Pandit Dina Nath Muju
"I have lived my life. What even if they kill me and what will they gain by killing me?" These are the
words of a saintly son of Saraswati, Pt. Dina Nath Multi, who was robbed of his life at mid-night by the
Muslim killers. Was this eighty-year old man really a threat to their plans of establishing an Islamic state?
The day he was ruthlessly killed the Pakistan media blared out that a patron of Indian informers was
exterminated. And the progeny of so-called Rishis believed in what was drummed into their ears.
Pandit Dina Nath was a real Pandit. He would be busy reading and writing with his back erect till late in
the midnight. His study stacked and stuffed with books on variegated branches of learning, from historic
to philosophy, from J. Krishnamurti to Vivekanand, from Socrates to Democritus conveyed all about the
man. He has written innumerable articles which are mostly un-published and his son, Dr. G.K. Muju, is
collecting them to give them a book form. He had a distinct style of his own and his exposition was lucid
and expressive. His essay on "Spanda" (what it means) has won him acclaim from the American scholars
working on Kashmir Shaivism. "Shine ever more llrightlv" is his essay which he starts, "Today all of us
have electric light in our houses. The light in our room shines through a bulb. If there is no bulb there is
no light and the light cannot shine without the bulb. But the bulb itself cannot give us the light. There
must be current of light flowing into it."
Pt. Dina Nath Muju had nearly five thousand books which the Muslim looters have looted. His treasure of
books included
a ) Valuable manuscripts in Sharda (pothies)
b) All works and lectures of J. Krishnamurti
c) All studies on J. Krishnamurti
d) "Song of Life" as a rare collection of poems by J. Krishnamurti
e) Complete file of "Theosophist"
f) Theosophist literature
g) Nearly two dozen old Kashmiri Paintings
h) All works on Kashmir Shaivism from Vasugupta to Abhinavgupta
i) All studies on Kashmir Shaivism
j) Rare works on Indian Philosophy especially Vendanta
k) His own writings on various topics are lost
l) A 200-paged book "Kashmiri Language and Grammar" in Devnagri script was authored by him and
was ready for publication. If it is retrieved or was looted as booty is yet to be confirmed.
Pt. Anand Ji Razdan
Bandit Anand Ji Razdan of chowgam Noms a saintly person. A reputed saint, Divakak Ji lived at his
place for a considerable period of time. It was at his initiation that Anand Ji chose and vowed to be a
celibate. He would spend most of his time in worship and finally took to meditation. His fame as a saint
spread througth most of the villages wherefrom devotees would throng his house for blessings. He was in
close contact with Gasha Kak Ji and Sarwanand Ji who were acknowledged as reputed saints with
achievements in mystical realms.
Pandit Anand Ji had lots of books mostly devotional in contents which he had stuffed in fifteen wooden
boxes. He had some original manuscripts on Kashmiri Shaiva saints including Siddha Sri Kanth who was
the celebrated preceptor of Lal Ded the mystical lark of Kashmir. He was a poet and wrote religious
hymns. Some of them were printed also and were made available to his devotees. He in his ecstasy would
sing the hymns he himself had written.
All his poems, books and manuscripts are looted by the Muslim looters.
Kanya Lal Pandita - a lawyer
Kanya Lal Pandita is law graduate from the University of Kashmir. He has been a practicing lawyer and
in the wake of Muslim terrorism he like majority of his co-religionists tied his native land to a secure zone
in Jammu. He owned three houses which have been burnt by the Muslim arsonists. He had a well-
equipped library of law-books and reporters which catered to his requirements as a practitioner of lava.
The books that he had gone in for with his hard earned money were either looted or fed to the fire. With
the grievous loss of his books he belt crippled as a lawyer and had to refurbish his library with new tomes.
The losses he has suffered are:
a) All India Reporter 1950 (12 parts )
b) All India Reporter 1951 (full set)
c) All India Reporter (full sets) 1952 to 1961
d) Civil Procedure Code (3 Vols)
e) All India Service Reporter (1950 to 1989),
f) Service Law
g) Law of Writs
h) Chandigarh Law Reporter (1970 to 1989)
i) Mitra Limitation Act
j ) Medical Jurisprudence
k) Six versions of Quran in English gifted to him by a Muslim separatist now abroad namely Mohammad
Ayub Thakur
l) Kashmiri Version of Bhagavatgita written by Pt. Tara Chand, a scholarly person
m) History of Kashmiri Pandits after 1947 in manuscript form written by Prakash Ram Pandita
n) Bible and Guru Granth Sahib
Prof. M.L. Kokiloo
Prof. M.L. Kokiloo is a scholar of Sanskrit and an expert on Kashmir Shaivism. He has personal
achievements both in the fields of learning and spirituality. He belongs to the legendary family of
Kokiloos who have made positive contributions to the culture and tradition of Kashmiri Pandits. His
house at Banamohalla is burnt by Muslim marauders. He had nearly three thousand books including some
rare manuscripts of immense cultural value which have been looted and burnt. He regrets the loss of a
book " Shivaratri Puja Padati" which dilated on the worship of lord Shiva on the festival of Shiva-ratri.
He equally mourns the loss of "Jwala Puja Padati" which as a manuscript was written by an unmarried
daughter of the family with a deep spiritual bent. The Kokiloos have been an epi-centre of the Kashmiri
Pandit learning and scholarship. An ancestor of the family has authored a work on Sanskrit grammar
which even stein has made a mention of. He possessed rare manuscripts of the works of Kashmir
Shaivism and all versions of Rajtaranginis.
Badri Nath Nissar
Badri Nath Nissar is a reputed poet, author and journJlist. He is the president of All India Sahitaya Sadan
(Regd) J&K, Gehwara-e-Adab (Read) Haryana and "Sapan Mala" Memorial Committee, Jammu. He is
the patron of Panjabi Adbi Sangam (Regd), J&K and Farawani-e-Adab, Hissar, Haryana. He is also the
life-member of Bazm-i-Bekhud (Regd) Delhi and Kashmiri Pandit Sabha (Regd) Jammu. He is the editor
of the Kashyapvani, Jammu.
About the books which he has lost and valued them more than gold he writes:
"A portion of collection of books, besides my own authored ones, Urdu, Hindi, Sanskrit, Arabic and
Panjabi, was learnt to have been looted and burnt in Srinagar from my ancestral house at Purushayar,
Habbakadal, II Bridge much before our house was set ablaze on 11.6.1996 by the Kashmiri
fundamentalists, extremists and Muslim neighbours. Some detail of books is as under:
Kumar Sambhava by Kalidas
Malvikagni-mitra by Kalidas
Bhagvatgeeta with Urdu translation in verse and explanation Ganesh Stotra (75-year old)
Bhawani Sahastranam with Hindu/Urdu translation and "Namavali" - (100 year old)
Bible, an old manuscript in English
Zaboor (Urdu)
Yuhana Ki Anjeel (Urdu)
Quran (3 Nos)-(different sizes and shades)
Quran-i-Hakeem 16"x12" (Brail)
Amrit Varsha (4 series) Hindi
Shakuntala by Kalidas
Satyarth Prakash (Hindi)
Galib Panjabi Libas Vich (Panjabi)
Tarian Bhare Angarey (Panjabi)
Farhang-i-Amra (70 year old)
Farhang-i-Amra (Jadeed)
Karim-ul -Lughat
Feroz-ul -Lughat
Jehangiri Farhang
Hindi-Urdu-English Dictionary (4 Nos)
Poetry and Prose-Self Publications
Aij az-i-Islam, Guldastani- i -Islam
Sukhan wari, Asasa, Ashkbari
Mukhzan-i-Asrar-i-Nav ( Prose )
Dakhl-i-Maikada (do)
Kitabat (-do-)
Khatoot-ki-Baat (-do-)
Other Collections
Rum Jum Kul Kul Masnavi Zahar-i-Ishk
Sheereen Khusroo Masnavi Khanjar-i-Ishk
Makhzan-i-Asrar Masnavi Qatil-i-Ishk
Masnavi Gulzari Naseen (Majaz Licknavi)
letters of Sardar Patel and Churchill's volumes on Second World War also adored my tiny but beautiful
library. When I would be in my study with books near line and books on the shelves to look at I felt that I
had all the riches and wealth of the world. I have no agony on account of the loss of my movable property
but I feel terrible cheated by Providence which did not allow me a chance to bundle these books
alongwith me to lend me support and succour in my prolonged exile. It is the greatest misfortune that
could have befallen me. I sadly learn that many of these books have been torn into pieces and many arc
sold as scrap. The Muslim looters did not only rob us of what we had by way of material goods but they
robbed us of books which are the objects of culture and value systems."
Hriday Nath Vishan
H.N. Vishan is a retired lecturer in History. He served the State Department of Education for nearly
thirty-six Years with zeal and dedication. History was his special subject. He had collected lot many
books with savings from his petty incomes. About his losses by way of books he puts as under :
"I owe inheritance to a family that was dedicated to Education Department with the exception of my
father who had found a job in the Revenue Department. My uncle known as Master Subhershan Vishan
was a contemporary of two famous teacher-scholars Pt. Zinda Total and Pt. Shocker Pandit. He worked as
a teacher in the Mission School established by Tyndal Biscoe way back in 1888. He was a complete man
with high and lofty ideals. A trained graduate of those days he had earned tremendous reputation not only
as a teacher but also as a voracious reader. Unfortunately he died prematurely and that was the reason he
could not hold the same status in the scholarly circles as Master Ice and Shanker Pandit held. It was me
uncle who inspired me to read books and collect books. As I had a special taste for history I took to
reading books on history. I joined the Department of Education as a teacher in 1956 and whatever savings
I had I would go in for books that met my intellectual and spiritual yearnings.
I had collected a small library of six hundred books on different subjects. This habit of mine continued
with me till I was forced to abandon my sweet home as a result of militarised Islam. The fate of my house
at Banamohalla cannot be in any way different from the houses of my co-religionists. It is looted,
plundered and nearly destroyed. The books as I learn have been looted, burnt and some sold to retailers as
scrap. Those who could burn the library in Alexandria could not spare my tiny collection of books.
The books I had included the following:
1. Great Men of India.
2. Nehru-the Lotus Eater of Kashmir by D.F. Kraka
3. Daughters of Vitasta by P.N. Bazaz
4. My years with Nehru by B.M. Malik
5. A Study of Nehru by Rafiquc Zakaria
6. Neta Ji Subash Chander Bose by Chaman Lal Razaz
7. Curzon to Nehru by Druga Dass
8. Mission to Lahsa by Younghusband
9. Sardar Patel correspondence Vol I to X by Durga Dass
10. Gulab Singh-the founder of J&K State by K.M. Panikar
11. Raj Tarangini-Vol. I, II, III by M.A. Stein
12. Rajtarangini by Ranjit Pandit
13. Birds of Kashmir by Ruthbrook
14. The History of Kashmiri Pandit by Jia Lal Kilam,
15. A History of Kashmir by P.N. Bazaz
16. Roses in December by M.C. Chagla
17. Ancient Monuments of Kashmir bv R.C. Kak
and my books, journals, encyclopaedias and reference manuals. Yes, we left behind books on art and
craft, literature and language, science and religion, psychology and philosophy, classics and some rare
manuscripts, books in English, Urdu, Hindi, Kashmiri, Sanskrit and Persian and translations of great
works of art from one language into another. I don't know the exact count but the whole collection would
not be fewer than five thousand. All that I carried with me was the Bhagvat-Gita, Gitanjali, complete
works of shakespeare, Glimpses of world History by Nehru, the Rubayaat of Omerkhayaam and the latest
text-book of Medicine by Harrison. I wish I had carried more and stuffed them into the suit-case which I
carried along in place of the clothes I retrieved in haste.
I left behind a 50-year collection of my father's law books and library at his house at Barbarshah-SP
College Lane Srinagar-spanning his professional career from 1935 to 1988 which included all the All
India Reporters, books on constitutional and criminal law, other law manuals and reference books on
legal procedure and civil law-all told nearly a thousand books. He had willed to donate the whole
collection to the High Court Library of Srinagar and though I got lucrative offers for the lot I would not
betray my father's command. Various people who occupied the house from time to time without my
permission but within my knowledge offered to safe-keep the books but I hear that the collection is
slowly dissolving and all that is left now is in a bad shape.
The library at my house in Indira Nagar, Srinagar included the following:
1. Text Medical books on various disciplines of Medicine, viz; general medicine, neurology, cardiology,
psychiatry, nephrology, tropical medicine, gynaecology and obstetrics etc.
2. Medicinal journals spanning our career from 1967 in Medicine
a) Indian Heart Journal - Year 1978 to 1990
b) Neurology India - Year 1974 to 1990
c) Journal of Indian Medicinal Association - Year 1968 to 1990
d) Journal, Association Physicians of India. - Year 1968 to 1990
e) British Medical Journal - Year 1972 to 1982
f) Annals of Internal Medicine - Year 1976 to 1984
g) Indian Journal of obstetrics and gynaecology. - Year 1969 to 1990
3. Periodical (non-medicals)
a) National Geographic - Year 1980 to 1990
b) Readers Digest - Year 1940 to 1990
c) Condensed Readers Digest - Year 1962 to 1978
4. English literature
Classics, drama, Novels, Poetry by all time greats in English language representing the various continents
where the language is spoken - numbering nearly 1500 books."
5. Hindi Books
On religion, novels, short-stories and the great epics, nearly 250.
6. Urdu Books
Including poetry by great urdu poets, Nearly 50.
7. Kashmiri and Persian books at least 10 including some old manuscripts.
Besides these were a number of Atlases, books of general information, three English dictionaries, one
dictionary each in Hindi and Urdu and numerous other common journals like the Illustrated Weekly of
India, India Today, Time Magazine, Sarita etc. for which we were regular subscribers for more than three
decades.
What I miss most in exile is the company of the great men and women who have immortalized
themselves through their written works. I feel intellectually crippled. The books call me to my homeland
as much as the roots and the history of 5,000 years."
44 C ha pte r 12 - K A S H M IR I P A N D IT S A S M IG R A N T S
The peace-loving and patriotic ethno-religious minority of Kashmiri Pandits has been languishing in
humiliating and debasing exile for the last eight years as a fall-out of terrorist tyranny generated and
unleashed by the armed Muslim secessionists seeking Islamisation of Kashmir and its perpetuation by
annexation with Pakistan. The entire community is faced with a grim tragedy and has been obliged to
battle for survival at each step and end. The cruel rulers living in sealed ivory towers enjoying carnival of
power and pelf bereft of human empathies have not only politicised the sombre tragedy but have also
taken a resort to dubious formulations justifying the label that they have tagged onto the victims of
terrorism. Attempts are to drown this community in the intrigues of terrorism, Islamic bigotry and
secessionism and the impression is solidly reinforced and strengthened by the ruinous neglect and sadistic
apathy that have been displayed towards it. The gnawing concerns, immediate and beyond, of this
beleaguered community in exile have not been addressed. The members of this community as victims to
the storm of communalism and fanaticism are refugees in their own country suffering pangs of insecurity
and deprivation, torments of neglect and insensitivity.
What is astonishing that Govt. of India despite loud signals from the ground did not mind them and
continued to be sunk in a state of passivity and dismaying as it is failed in its constitutional obligations of
providing security at least of life and limb to the members of this indigenous community. How is it that
Govt. of India through its insouciance and insensitivity appears to be on the same wave-length with the
secession-seeking fundamentalist Islamic groups drawn from the local populace in cohorts with the Pan-
Islamic forces to push this hapless community into a state of extinction? The community which has been
a lustrous column of Hindu edifice of culture and civilization and pulsating model of what is Indian in
Kashmir has been dumped like garbage in tentages, one-room colonies and rented slums and has been
losing fast its stamina, resilience and a whole spectrum of inner resources. For the effete Govt. of India
they are not refugees while Bangladesh intruders are and that is why they are nomenclatured as
"migrants", not even the displaced persons on the basis of a deceitfully contrived thesis that "The
complainants are appropriately styled as migrants as they have migrated on their own from areas in the
valley to Jammu or other areas of the country. Their claim to designate them as internally displaced
persons is not acceptable to the government of India on the ground that displacement has been
sell:imposed".
The same thesis has been fairly fed and broadly doled out to the Indian media which was 'unable to
conceal the facts to its readership and have tried to minimise and ideologically cleanse the news by
calling the refugees "migrants" by blaming them for communal friction in Jammu where many of them
live in refugee camps'.
The politicals of the Indian brand given to chicanery and trickstry and more than most intrigue have not
fumed concern about and refused to project the blighted condition of the Kashmiri Pandit refugees who
have been forced at gun-point to abandon their native homes and hearths. The fact remains that the
Kashmiri Pandits have not crossed international borders and taken refuge in an alien land and that is
supposed to militate against their entitlement to tile status of refugees under established international law.
But what is highly significant and as such cannot be lost sight of is that this hundred percent literate
community cognised as such all over the world was cruelly thrown out of its home-land by the armed
Muslim fundamentalists when there was a total collapse of constitutional machinery and the government
of the day perceptibly worked in tandem with the Islamic secessionists allowing them support and
succour and time space to fan out and proliferate their base and appeal. It smacked of an intrigue on part
of the degenerate political culture in the country to concoct and figment a theory that Kashmiri Pandit
exodus unprecedented in the history of independent India was sponsored or self-willed thereby effacing
out the fundamental cause of fundamentalist insurgency leading to the cataclysmic event of forced
migration and dispersal. The Kashmiri Pandit compulsion to buzz off their land of genesis leaving behind
their houses and assets assumes clarity if and when the full-scale background scenario of fundamentalist
developments within Kashmir Is not put under wraps and is given unbiased projection in its broad
contours. The Kashmiri Pandits as a natural sequence of the fundamentalist proliferation were targeted for
killings, rape, torture and destruction thereby generating a volatile and lethal situation in which it was
extremely difficult, nay impossible, to live a civilised life of honour and dignity. A conspiracy was
hatched in the crucible of mosque to purge Kashmir of infidels and reclaim the lost land for Islam. What
happened on 19/20th January, 1990 was the climax of the whole process which was in actuality
commenced and given a push up by the Sayyids m 14th century and effacingly pursued by the communal
revanchists masquerading as nationalists. The Muslim crowds, merciless, coarse and savagely cruel,
squalling war cries and flitting about the lanes and bye-lanes of the valley traumatised Kashmiri Pandit
denizens of a concentration camp suffering suffocation, torture and persecution. The exodus was a
miracle worked by Pandits to escape the inferno of violence echoing medieval and base barbarity to the
freedom across the Bannihal tunnel.
With a view to putting the whole scenario in a proper perspective it needs be said that the fundamental
cause necessitating the exodus of Kashmiri Pandits is the Muslim bigotry. The 1989- 90 variety of exodus
of Pandits is the sixth in the series of their exoduses from their land of birth. As revealed by the telling
facts of history the first major exodus dates back to the barbarous times of Sikander Butshikan (1389-
1413) who unleashed a reign of terror for conversion of Hindu Kashmir to the Islamic religion. The
exodus was so massive in its scale and dimension that only eleven Kashmiri Pandit families stayed back
in their home-land.92 The processes of conversion continued without a let up at various stages of Muslim
rule. The basic and glaring cause of the exoduses in the past was Muslim bigotry and the cause has
remained unchanged and immutable. Even in secular and democratic India that is pledged to a
constitution with fundamental guarantees for its citizens the Kashmiri Pandits have been pushed out lock,
stock and-barrel with the patent aim of capturing Kashmir to establish a theo-fascist state thereby
exploding the myth of composite culture and farce of pluralism.
As per the deceptive formulations of the official class of political elite the Kashmiri Pandits in absence of
a refugee law in the country are migrants, not refugees or displaced persons. Fitting in the scheme of
things as devised by the said political class the word "migrant" camouflages Muslim revolt communal and
sectarian in content and motivation and carries within its ambit an element of voluntariness, self-will or
self-motivation to the exclusion of an external force or factor which is none other than Muslim frenzy for
Shad based on bigotry. The violent and impetuous conflict swamping the length and breadth of the valley
brought to a flash-point by the armed insurgency launched by the bigoted terrorists proved a catalyst in
transforming the whole political scenario in Kashmir. It is only an ostrich-like audacity to deny the fact
that the entire thrust of Muslim insurgency from seminal stages to its climax was
and continues to be against the patriotic community of Kashmiri Pandits. In fact, the evil forces of Jehad
as in the past so now opened their agenda by rape, torture and carnage of Kashmiri Pandits who were
catapulted to the eye of a storm by denouncing them as "informers", "fifth column" and "unpaid agents of
India" and such other depreciatory labels.
Violent strife and conflict and unendurable living conditions are the key factors that have caused the mass
exodus of Kashmiri Pandits from their native land. The Government of India in its response to the
International Commission of Jurists based in Geneva has acknowledged killings of Kashmiri Pandits and
perpetration of morbid violence on them and also collapse of rule of law as cardinal factors leading to
their mass exodus. This position of Government of India as shaped by political mandarins governed by
the unprincipled principle of political expediency is not only at variance with but in violent contradiction
to the stance it has taken in the National Human Rights Commission. The vivid dichotomy between the
two positions is not only duplicitous but open exhibition of fraud played on the hapless refugees who
have suffered enormous losses in terms of life and assets.
The response reads, "Most of the Kashmiri Hindu Community fled from the valley in early 1990. The
assassination of a number of leading Hindus and threats of violence by the militants were enough to
persuade the Hindu Community to flee."
The response further reads," The targeted killing of members of Hindu Community which has led to the
exodus of 2,50,000 members of the community resulting in a change in the very demographic profile of
the area and blatant religious cleansing."
The response also comments, "The instability in the region has led to the displacement of a large number
of Hindus or Kashmiri Pandits. On 1989-90 some 90,000 Pandits left the valley for fear of attacks on their
safety. To date 2,50,000 out of 3,00,000 are estimated to have left. A number of these displaced persons
are now in camps in Jammu and Delhi."
The above mentioned factors of strife and intolerable living conditions are the specific factors that have
led to the refugee movements all over the world. There are authentic reports to suggest that 15 million
refugees are in Diaspora all over the world and they are properly covered by a legal commission operating
under the aegis of United Nations Organisation. But the internally displaced persons outnumber the
refugees and as of now they are 30 million in actual numbers and are in Diaspora within their native
countries. Their status and position as internally displaced persons has been by and large recognised by
their respective governments or by the internationally recognised organisations under various linkages
and covenants to which the governments are a party. But the Government of India despite forced
migrations from the Punjab, Kashmir and North Eastern states has not deliberately framed a refugee law
to tackle with the humanitarian problem of internally displaced persons, but has chosen to be ruthlessly
arbitrary and callous and tackle the problem on administrative level. And this arbitrartiness determined by
extraneous considerations has settled the nomenclature of the Kashmiri Pandits as 'migrants' in
contravention of their status as refugees or internally displaced persons.
The Kashmiri Pandits as an exiled community stand deprived of the original territory that they ancestrally
belonged to and called their own in terms of history, identity and culture. Though a component of the
state of Jammu and Kashmir they as a spill-over effect of ethnic purge and in face of altered ground
realities have been forced for existential reasons to dwell in camps and rented slums in Jammu and its
adjoining districts. It is a matter of gnawing concern that they have lost the care and protection of their
own state of which they are and continue to be historically, culturally and legally an inalienable part and
component.
The dubious word "migrant" is closely akin to and firmly buttresses the state thesis that in view of their
voluntary choice of being in self-exile they do not for any cogent reason deserve and must, therefore
suffer the loss of the protective umbrella which could serve them in good stead in their state of indigence
and destitution. The enormous amount of hostility and harassment that they have been subjected to even
during the Presidential rule confirms that they are no longer the citizens covered under constitutional
frame-work. The position remains qualitatively unchanged even though popular rule much bruited about
has been resuscitated in the state.
The Governor, K.V. Krishna Rao, as an appointee of President of India, cynically and superciliously is
said to have disowned Kashmiri Pandits by telling a delegation that had called on him for an inter-face on
the formulated demands of the refugee community that they were not his concern nor were they on his
agenda. Did he have such a constitutional mandate as Governor of the state to disinherit a segment of the
native populace which is "pushed out" by the Muslim marauders and prima facie stands wronged and
more than most cruelly deprived of its native abode en masse? That the Pandits are not on his agenda is a
frank admission of the connivance and complicity of the state which he rules with all the executive
powers with the Islamic agenda of genocide of an ethno-religious minority. The animosity of the state
with Girish Saxena as the Governor of the state assumed a shrill stridency and a sharper edge when the
slots in the governing apparatus held by members of the minority community were fraudulently filled up
in their absence in exile thereby divesting them of their fundamental right of being an integral part of the
governing apparatus.
They are not considered and factually are rejected as a part of the state is testified by the blatant denial
and sealing of employment opportunities for the minority both at the state and central levels. The "herded
out" employees and the entire student community harbouring Hindu faith have been victims of crass
discrimination and worst brand of apartheid and Government of India is a front-rank fighter against
apartheid in Africa and elsewhere but perpetuates it in the state of Jammu and Kashmir. The policies of
the two governors with their source in Delhi have contributed their fair share of wisdom to the
Islamisation of the state apparatus which is deemed a stepping stone to the ultimate goal of secession
from the democratic polity of India.
The installation of popular rule has equally belied the hopes of the exiled community for a fair deal and
equalitarian treatment. They are meted out the treatment of aliens by the state of which they are
undeniably and inextricably a part and parcel. The government of Farooq Abdullah said to be infested
with pro-Pakistan moles and ISI agents has refused to be objective and non-sectarian too. The utterances
of the Chief Minister, Farooq Abdullah, inside and outside the state legislature, have added to the
insecurity and destabilization of the exiled community. There was a mass massacre of Kashmiri pandits at
Sangrampora by the local Muslim killers. The three brights of the community were selected for brutal
slaughter at Gool in the hills of Jammu and the administration proved so callous as not to feel morally
obliged to share the shock and grief with the bereaved families deprived of their near and dear ones.
Harassment of the displaced employees continues unabated. None of their pressing problems have been
addressed, much less solved. No tattered tent has been replaced. Sanitary conditions in camps are the
same abject. The few who have found employment on the recommendations of a Muslimised board
operating under a Kashmiri Pandit renegade do not stand benefited for administrative hurdles in their
postings and other trumped up hassles. The Pandits though very few in numbers drawing doles from the
government agencies are accused of retarding the pace of farcical development forgetting the terrorist-
bureaucratic nexus for siphoning off and looting the major share of the development funds.
The hounded out community which is in a state of traumatic exile and Diaspora has been forced to inhabit
the camps and rented slums in different states of the country.. If objectivity is a guide, it can be said
without fear or favour that the displaced Kashmiri Pandits are not treated with the same hostility,
contempt and vengefulness that their counter parts are faced with in parts of their own state. Yet it is no
consolation to the Pandits and does not in any manner compensate the traumatic loss of the home turf and
context that they historically and legally are aligned with but as of now are wallowing in pangs of exile
through the machinations of Muslim revanchists. As bona fide citizens of their own state they have been
coerced to dwell on the lands of other states in Delhi, Punjab, UP, Bombay and Madhya Pradesh and
depend on the care and protection of those states of which they do not form a part and parcel in political
and legal contexts.
The loss of ancestral territory and dependence on the hospitality of other states are the two fundamental
factors determining the status of displace refugees. Barbara-Harrel-Bond as an expert on refugees is forth-
right in her views in nomenclaturing those persons as refugees who "have lost the protection of their own
state and must rely!
on the willingness of others to observe humanitarian norms." Prior to their forced exodus the Kashmiri
Pandits were rooted, had their own dwellings, small or big, lived a normal life of civilised individuals
with grace and aplomb and procreated and bred their families for a decent and productive societal role.
But in sharp contrast to it they now in tents and slums are a waste material, bereft of opportunities, prone
to diseases and afflictions and reduced to energy-sapping indigent conditions of life and living. More than
most, they live in conditions which can be termed as "refugee- like" and prowl about in conditions which
again are "refugee like". The plight of the Kashmiri Pandits in the camps, one - room tenements and
rented slums resembles and is qualitatively the same as that of the refugees who have crossed
international borders for refuge and protection.
The Government of India has played the Hindu refugees from Kashmir foul. It has failed to evolve a
comprehensive and organic policy with respect to them. The community of Pandits despite its steeling
through the oppressive rule of Muslims has come to a crisis and a breaking-point wherefrom it might be
unable to re-coup and recover. The powers that be in Delhi have never felt concerned about the fate of
hundreds of thousands of Kashmiri Pandit refugees languishing in poverty, squalor and debasing
degradation in the refugee camps. They have been hybernating in exile for the last eight years sundered
apart from mainstream. The stamping out of Pandits was mapped by the local Islamic fundamentalists
with a specific purpose and it followed a well laid- out plan and strategy.
The craftily coined appellation of "Migrant" defining the nature of Kashmiri Pandit exodus from the
valley might be concealing an effort or a tendency to accord a formal recognition, say under severe
pressure, to the Muslim character of the state as is being expounded by the foreign intriguers and their
local proxies. The Kashmiri Pandits as aboriginals from the valley are deemed a problem who normally
under international covenants and laws cannot be deprived of their inherent right to inhabit the valley.
With a view to diluting their claims in such an eventuality what is needed is to rebuff the hapless refugees
that they had migrated on their own and had chosen to be in self-exile.
The complete Islamisation of the state as pursued by the wily secessionists without check or restraint from
the Government of India has purged the ethno-religious minority members from their native abodes to
transform Kashmir into a Muslim haven. The Tibetan and Sinkiangese Muslims way back in Nehru's time
were accepted on the soil of Kashmir on the basis of their Islamic colour and religion.
The Muslims coming in hordes from West Bengal, UP, Bihar et al getting married to the local Muslim
girls are reported to be fast gaining the status of State subjects in contravention of laws on the Statute
Book. But the genuine refugees, Hindus and Sikhs, from West Pakistan are denied state-hood lest it
should tilt the population profile of the state. That is a conspiracy afoot to purge the Pandits even from the
Jammu soil. Bogeys are created to build walls of dissensions between them and the local Hindu
population. Farooq Abdullah's incitement to the people of Jammu meets the same end. If ideological and
constitutional foundations of the Indian state are to be kept in place, what is needed is the resolution of the
political and ideological situation emerging from the forced expulsion of Kashmiri Pandits. In concrete
terms be it put that the crux of the problem is that the only Muslim majority state in India has refused
outright to co-exist with a minuscule Hindu minority.
The Kashmiri Pandits in exile have not been burdened with the label of refugees or displaced persons
perhaps for the fact that the Government of India refuses to own and is in no way committed to the
responsibility of re-settling the displaced persons or refugees in their native abodes with political and
economic rights and guarantees that they were bereft of even prior to their brutal externment. It is pithily
suggested by the Kashmiri Pandit watchers that the word "migrant" allows an escape route to legitimise
the vicious developments on Kashmir front by a weak, emaciated, fractured and lack-lustre government in
power.
For the Goverornent of India which failed to protect the pro-India minorities in Kashmir Kashmiri Pandits
on home front are migrants as they are perceived to have voluntarily marched out and therefore have lost
the rights and privileges of statehood but for international consumption the same human cattle dumped in
camps and slums are 'displaced persons' as they were targetted for killings and put to severe threats. It is
not only dichotomous but sounds scandalous and exposes the inhuman face of the Government of India
cursed with double-speak.
The misery of Kashmiri Pandit refugees wasting like worms in drains is delineated for the general
readers.
44.1 Gole Pulli Camp, Talab Tillo, Jammu
This was the first camp that was set up by the government in the wake of massive exodus of Kashmiri
Pandits from their natural habitat. The camp is inhabited by six hundred Pandits hailing from various
areas in the valley. It is a model of inhuman and shameless treatment meted out to a cultured community
reduced to the abominable status of refugees by the rulers who have battened on the marrow of the poor
and bereft and inhabit posh houses glittering with stuffed ill-gotten wealth. The refugees have been
dumped in the camp and left to their care. No person of any consequence has visited the camp so that he
could get a feel of the camp conditions and move in the direction of suggesting measures for their
improvement. The tents are torn to shreds and their replacement is out of question for the fact that it is a
farm house for the human cattle. The sun and rains are great tormentors for the inhabitants. The proposals
to shift the camp to Mishriwalla could not fructify for long as the government deep sunk in paralysis must
enjoy and draw vicarious pleasure from the blighted condition of the Pandits who have "injured the
psyche of Muslims." The camp is worse than a slum. Heaps of dirt and garbage are seen strewn around. It
is the foul and stinking smell that reigns supreme over the environs. The latrines are abominably dirty and
over-flowing and there are no arrangements to clean them on a regular basis. In some tents more than one
family could be seen huddled together. If a family chooses to move out of the tent to a rented
accommodation, the Relief Agencies score it off their registers and stop their meagre dole on which most
of them eke out an existence.
As the camp is a death-hole, the dwellers afflicted with varied diseases and ailments as a result of foul
surroundings have been falling fast into it.. Many young men and women kissed death prematurely and
could not be saved for want of proper medical treatment. Some have fallen prey to sun-strokes while
many more died from snake bites.
As a humanitarian act, the government after a long persuasion set up a dispensary. But dismaying as it is
no medicines were made available to it. The camp dwellers have fallen to physical and psychological
diseases and for treatment they are forced to depend on private doctors. The dispensary is of no use to
them. The camp is dwelt by 230 scholars who are at various levels of educational career. How can there
be a school for them? Long back Mubta Khan blazed the trail of denying schools to the Kashmiri Pandits.
The government under the tight leash of Muslims has taken a vow to follow the blazed trail. There are
schools run by government in the area but under the impact of racist policies the Kashmiri Pandit scholars
are not allowed admission in such schools. Despite this apartheid Pandit scholars manage their education
by traversing long distances despite inconvenience and discomfort.
The educated young men and women have been denied jobs both in the Central and State services. The
Kashmiri Pandits were declared a creamy layer right in 1947 when Mandal was in oblivion. So the
employables are in agony and distress as there is no glittering future for them. The retired people whose
numbers are increasing are facing economic indigence. They Eve on their meagre pensions and the
government based on ostentatious Nehru-Gandhi model has not come to their aid. Those still in service
are victims to apartheid. They have not been adjusted and therefore are vegetating & atrophying. Their
promotion avenues are blocked. Even if the crafty government promotes them, they are fiated to join their
posts in Kashmir where they were declared enemies of Islam and theocratic state of Pakistan.
44.2 Transport Nagar Camp, Jammu
The camp is so sunk in filth and foul smell that it mirrors the government apathy, indifference and
intransigence unto the hapless refugees. Representations were shot and pleas made to the concerned
authorities about the unlivable conditions in the camp but they have not stirred a throbbing heart. The
camp situate on the outskirts of Jammu city is as old as exodus itself. There are 125 families living in the
camp consisting of a building with four storeys.
There are no arrangements for water supply except that the pitiless government headed by a callous
Governor has harnessed a tanker that supplies water to the entire population in the camp once in a day.
With the loud noise of the horn women rush down from all the storeys to collect water and exigency has
taught them to form queues otherwise the driver of the tanker will shower a ridiculous taunt on them
which they detest. For women inhabiting the fourth storey of the house it has been a great hazard and
some of them lost their lives as a result of excessive strain on their hearts.
There is a spacious hall in each floor of the building where twenty-five families have been huddled
together. Their great predicament is loss of privacy.
Heaps of dirt and garbage emitting out foul smell lie scattered over the stairs of the building. There are no
arrangements for clearance of the dirt to keep the environs clean and healthy. The surrounding ambience
is stinking disseminating infections and diseases. Premature deaths are on an increase. As many as fifteen
persons died unexpectedly and could not be saved because of serious infections they had caught. Latrines
present a filthy spectacle and are a source of dirt and infection.
The government as an eye wash has opened a dispensary in the camp. But it is a farce. There are no
medicines available as could have saved the ill and aged from expenditure on them out of their meagre
doles. There are no arrangements for shifting the patients to the city hospitals at odd hours. The inmates
genuinely complain of government apathy.
There is no school for the scholars in the camp. There are no fewer than 160 learners at various stages of
their educational career. There is no primary school for the scholars who are at a preparatory stage. But
education is the most valued article of a Pandit. The scholars despite the scorching sun walk distances to
the schools at Satwari and Shastri Nagar. The condition of the schools for the "migrants" is distressing
and hateful.
44.3 Nagrota camp, Jammu
The total ambience of Nagrota camp accommodating five thousand Kashmiri Pandit men, women and
children is pathetic and awful and this camp in reality symbolises the contempt and apathy of the powers
that be unto the community punished for its undiluted patriotism and unflinching faith in the unity and
integrity of India. What the condition of inmates m the camp is exposes to the last shreds the trumpeted
claims of the government authorities that the uprooted refugees have been comfortably placed and their
problems mitigated to a larger extent.
The dwellers in the camp, frustrated and anguished, have been relentless in their pleadings with the
authorities for improvement of the camp conditions, but have been dismayed at the persistent government
apathy and negligence. Nothing concrete has been done to provide relief to the inmates who fire now
sullen and cynical and have lost faith in the government that can make tall promises but never fulfills
them.
The government following the precedent c f other camps has established a dispensary in the camp but has
never bothered to equip it in terms of medicine and necessary equipment. It is an eye-wash only to show
in papers that a dispensary has been set up in the camp and caters to the health needs of nine hundred
refugees. As the camp is a good distance away from the city proper, there should have been an ambulance
at the beck and call of the camp dwellers who are ill and afflicted because of hard and penurious life they
have been living at a stretch of land which is desert-like and turns into an inferno in the blazing sun. The
inhabitants of the camp are so poor and bereft that they hate lost their ailing kith and kin for want of
medicines. The meagre dole of Rs.1800/- for a family of five members cannot suffice their basic
necessities. The families comprising ten members are practically famished and starving. Who listens to
their woes? They are the Hindu refugees and must suffer for their refusal to accept the Islamic faith.
There are no arrangements for water supply to the helpless refugees. The hand-pumps that have been
installed are not working and need repairs. Petitions were made for their repair so that they serve a utility
but nothing solid was done at least for full ten months. Some of the handpumps which as good luck would
have it were working but failed to meet the demands of five thousand people who have to bathe, drink,
cook and do other chores. Long queues of women around the working, hand seen wearing frustration and
anger.
The authorities lacking even in low level common sense have set up these pumps close to the latrines with
the result the water that is drawn out is infectious and polluted and causes and disseminates diseases.
Nearly thirty people have fallen prey to various infectious ailments.
Mounds of garbage can be seen littered over the camp premises. Foul and stinking smell reigns supreme.
There are no well organised efforts to keep the camp free from the foul smell of rotting waste materials
with the result germs breed at a faster rate and spread diseases.
The camp has a population of 2800 school going scholars who have no arrangements for schooling within
the camp premises. At the prodding of parents they foot long distances to attend schools close to the city
or in the nearby areas. The new budding scholars are at a disadvantage as there are no schools to admit
them and they are not expected to walk over long distances to join a school whatever its quality is.
The government has shifted some camp dwellers to one room tenements which despite fanfare are virtual
hovels and hell-holes. The construction of these hovels is flimsy. They turn leaky in rains. The members
of the families living in them feel cramped, dull and miserable as they are huddled together like cattle and
lack privacy. The camp dwellers have named them as pigeon-holes constructed by the government that
vies with socialism and equality for all.
Most of the employables are graduates and post-graduates. The two Governors have been relentless in the
onerous task of Muslim appeasement and as per government policy Pandits could not be given jobs for
the fact that they left the valley on their own and had lost state protection. How absured it is! The jobless
youth yell that jobs are given to the Muslim killers who have destroyed Kashmir and patriots are left
bereft and beleaguered.
44.4 Polytechnic Camp, Jammu
The Polytechnic camp inhabited by uprooted Pandits was originally set up in May 1990. If any person
keen to learn what refugee life is like must pay a visit to this camp where stinking and foul smell rules the
roost. The Pandits for their cardinal sin of being patriots were pushed out by the Muslim marauders who
earned government protection then and continue to earn it nova and were dumped in a camp like the one
at polytechnic campus. Thirty-seven families are living here and could not be accommodated at some
other camp where some amenities were available. There is a capacious hall measuring 22x11 feet which
is accommodating no fewer than twenty-six families. They are huddled like cattle in the hall and at a
glance one can feel the tragedy and pathos of their lives. The other eleven families are left to fend for
themselves. They have lived and slept in the open for years together and as a result of self-efforts have
built kennels for themselves with gunny sheets and rags. The sun when it blazes maximum has rendered
them half-dead, merely wailing and panting. The cold and chilly winds in winters numb their bones. But
the government has not bothered a jot to provide them some relief from the wretched life they have been
forced to live.
The Relief Commissioner who was contacted on many occasions did not care a hoot as he is instructed to
create as many hurdles as he can and impose as much suffering as he can. He is the model of what his
government is and the Government of India is mute and cannot open its mouth for a relief to a segment of
population which is Hindu and if it dares do it, it will get scarred with the stain of anti-secular. Bereft of a
thing like conscience he had not even the courtesy to depute some officer who could at least console these
hapless Hindus.
Proliferating heaps of dirt and garbage at the very entrance of the cattle-farm is nauseating and stands
testimony to the sadistic treatment meted out to the refugees who were forced to quit by the cruel
Islamists. No Government authority feels interested in providing the dwellers the bare minimum level of
sanitation so that they do not fall prey to the agonies of disease and ill health. Latrines have not been
cleaned even once during the last five years. They are overflowing and are seminaries of all sorts of
disease germs. What is worst the latrines during rains start flowing out dirt into the self-made kennels
causing extreme misery and pain. The stinking seminaries of dirt and filth emit out foul smell that has
caused numberless diseases especially chest and throat ailments so chronic that they refuse to be
suppressed even by costly life-saving drugs.
There are no medical facilities available for the cattle of this farm-house. Despite pleadings, the
government without a conscience has not just cared. A dispensary even as an eye-wash has not been set
up.
There are not facilities of water supply to the worms in the camp. They are not humans. So they have not
to wash, eat, drink and bathe. A syntax tank with low capacity was installed in the camp as a matter of
great humanitarian act and that too is not serviceable. The women-folk as the worst sufferers of exile have
to bear the agony of fetching water from a public post.
That there is no relief counter for disbursement of relief is another hassle that the camp dwellers are faced
with. For the petty dole all and sundry in the camp including the ill and the aged have to go to the
exhibition grounds and have to wait there for hours on end in scorching sun and drenching rain.
The camp situated in the campus of the Polytechnic is in the neighbourhood of the hostel for boys. As
adolescents they misbehave with the young and budding girls in the camp. It is something intolerable for
the Kashmiri Pandit respectables. There have been so many quarrels, but the menace has not ended.
44.5 Purkhoo Camp, Jammu
The Purkhoo camp is situated on the Jammu-Poonch national highway accommodating four thousand
human cattle in tents and another bunch of two hundred cattle in oneroom pigeon-holes, a visible stain on
the Indian rulers, blunt and shameless. The tents do not speak but these tents do speak and vociferously
convey the litany of miseries and sorrows that the human cattle have been suffering inside their cramped
spaces. The tents as every on-looker can discernibly see are weather-beaten and have outlived their utility
and therefore are incapable of sheltering the human animals from the rigours of the sun and chill cold
of winter months. The tents, tattered and battered, arc overflowing to capacity and house eight persons
instead of its normal capacity for four. In summer they heat up and torment the dwellers who are ducks of
the lake and in rains they leak to the limit that inmates within them are little distinguishable from the
pools of mud and slush in which they wallow. The one-room tenements are suffocating ovens in summer
months and turn leaky in rains. The structures have fractured prematurely and are about to collapse and
the government claims that it has incurred 37,000 in each of these flimsy structures. And refugees can roll
out real figures about the constructions and corruption involved in them.
Most of the employables who are a staggering figure of thirteen hundred with degrees upto post-
graduation have been made to waste away and vegetate. There have been special employment drives for
the Muslims who have taken to guns for a fundamentalist agenda but there have been no drives for the
Kashmiri Pandit patriots who have stood the fury of Muslim hurricane. The state government has well-
known antipathy unto all shades of Hindus and is out to quench them out. What is surprising that the
Central government if it can be called a government has also fallen in line at the persistent prodding of the
Kashmiri Muslim politicians with anti-Pandit venom brimming their fangs. In absence of Jobs and other
employment avenues the young men and women are frustrated and depressed and live a life of absolute
penury and indigence.
The camp dwellers have not only to weather the horrors of weather vagaries but have also fallen prey to
sun-strokes and snake-bites. Dozens have lost lives due to heat strokes as the camp dwellers living a
starkly penurious life cannot afford gadgets to beat the heat and its baneful effects. Dozens have fallen a
victim to the snake-bites. With few exceptions most of the victims lost their lives for want of quick
treatment and timely assistance. As the victims to Muslim holocaust the camp dwellers are so poor and
bereft that they cannot afford beds and sleep on ground and that is why they fall prey to the snake-bites
and the entire area where the camp has come up is snake infested.
The camp in its totality is a living spectacle of dirt, filth and insanitary conditions. There are no latrines.
There are no bath-rooms. The authorities view the humans as two-footed animals and hence have dumped
them in the animal farm-house which the camp in substance is. The authorities never felt the necessity for
a drainage system. The refugees are forced to depend on the canal which flows by. They drink its water,
bathe in its water and do other chores with the canal water. The canal has smothered the lives of many
and its unclean water has caused many a disease resulting in numerous serious ailments.
The camp does not have any medical facility available. A medical team some time back was deputed to
the camp site but it could not become functional for want of accommodation. There are no facilities
available for shifting the seriously ailing persons to the city hospitals and for the purpose there should
have been an ambulance available at least during odd hours. "But the human bipeds do not need
medicate" argue men in corridors of power.
The camp dwellers have maintained the top record of 100% literacy level. There is a school that has been
set up by the government at the persistent demand of Pandits to meet the educational needs of their
learners. But the school is in a deplorable state and does not look like a school. It is without a chalk and
without a black-board. The school has a regular attendance of twelve hundred learners who are to be
accommodated in five tents supplied by the government. In all weathers, fair or foul, they have to receive
their lessons in the open. There are no fans made available to the school. The scholars do not have a fully
equipped laboratory for experiments. There is no library with a view to expanding the mental horizons of
learners. The worst is that there is no arrangement for drinking water. The scholars have to depend on the
infectious and unclean water of the canal. There is a tank that could be seen broken and the educational
authorities pushing the operation black-board have not thought it wise to equip the school for the progeny
of human bipeds.
The one-room tenements are not worthy of habitation. The room is so cramped and small that one cannot
sleep in it with one's legs stretched out. There is no ventilation. Materials used in the structures are sub-
standard. The camp dwellers authentically believe that two thousand is the maximum amount invested in
such flimsy and shaky structures.
Pran Nath Bhat, a refugee in the camp, hapless and poor was not provided a tent or a pigeon-hole to eke
out his existence. It was for a full period of twenty days that the human animal was forced to live in the
open under the blue canopy. No authorities were moved and paid any heed. Ultimately the Kashmir
Times published Pran Nath's tale of woe and neglect buttressing it with a photograph. The Relief
Commissioner along with his staff who is said to have battened at the distress of the refugees ultimately
moved in the direction of providing him a leaky tent. It is not the case of Pran Nath only. Every refugee is
a Pran Nath, a human biped, who has been harassed, humiliated and insulted at every step and end and the
country is going to celebrate the 50 years of independence. Hip-hip hurrah for the morbid Indian rulers!
44.6 A Report on Camps
"' Kashmiri migrants' camps are a shanty township of pucca houses, tin sheds and tattered tents which
house impoverished Kashmiri Pandit families. That it mocks at the plight of these families with a large
number of women and children does not seem to revolt the senses of any one in authority."
These words are from Mahendra Ved who paid a visit to the camps at Mishriwalla, Muthi and other
locations and felt moved at the pitiable condition of Kashmiri Pandit refugees. He records:
"Even accepting that trying to make 27,000 families comfortable away from their homes and hearths in
the sylvan valley is a thankless job, the state administration has fallen far short of even the minimum
standards. A peep into some of the camps showed that they are no more than organised slums. The future
holds no hope for them, if reports of their house-holds being sold with the help of fake documents and a
conniving bureaucracy at the lower level are any indication … at Purkhoo camp near here 200 have died
since the camp was set up …. Refugees say there is no relief, no compensation for their houses lost or
burnt down by the terrorists way back in 1990. They say their service records have been mutilated or
destroyed. The government should supply them with duplicate so that they could make their claims He
(Chief Secretary) admits that pucca houses built four years ago have leaking roofs but adds new lot of
houses are better than the first ones.
"We had thought it was a short term problem but unfortunately it has stretched so long," he says. An
embarrassing minister remarks, "It was wrong to have assumed that this would be a short term
problem…… By all means give Rs.15 crore to our butchers in Char-e-sharief. We too grieve at the
burning down of the shrine of our Nand Rishi. But how much is being spent to restore the temples that
have been burnt down? Are not all communities to be treated equally under the constitution?"
The tents sheltering thousands of Kashmiri Pandit refugees reveal a saga of untold woe and misery. Their
tops have given way under the lashing rains, gusty winds and scorching rays of the blazing sun. They
have gaping holes through which rain and wind directly enter the tents causing extreme pain and agony to
the human animals living in them. The flaps of the tents are worn-out and shredded and the canvas that
they are made of is weather-beaten, torn loose and thinned out.
A report in the Kashmir Sentinel mentions, "They (tents) tell the tale of the woes of their inmates whose
hopes and dreams are in shreds too. These homeless inmates from the land of chinars, ice-cool waters and
golden meadows are a wronged people, forced to live at wrong places. Living in arid, rocky and
depressed surroundings, they are not only at the mercy of the generally unfriendly weather, but still more
unfriendly government, which is outrightly callous.
On a visit to a family in the camp a KS reporter puts:
"Back home they had a cosy and comfortable home in a South Kashmir village where the music of
gurgling waters of a stream, flowing by the side of the house lulled them to sleep at night and lilted them
to wakefulness at dawn. The old lady presided over a Joint family that owned paddly lands a small
orchard and a small business in the village. The girl now rubbing the kickenware that has outlived the
utility was a blithesome little lassie studying in the local school. It was indeed a life of comfort and
contentment. Today the family, like hundreds of other displaced Kashmiri Pandit families, lives in the
arid surroundings of a dreary tented camp on the outskirts of Jammu. It ekes out its existence on a pitiable
government dole and some small time jobs that the male members manage to get now and then. The
education of the children has been badly hit by this life of homelessness, want and penury ..... Pain is writ
large on their faces, their expressions, their actions, their behaviour, in fact their entire existence."
45 C ha pte r 13 - C O N V E R S IO N S A S M U S L IM M A L A IS E
There is hardly any conceivable excess and atrocity which the Kashmiri Pandits as a characteristic
religious group have not been subjected to by the Muslim marauders. Apart from the pogrom having no
semblance of a human face that was perpetrated on them the devastating catastrophe that could befall
them was the forcible conversion to an alien religion of Islam. History is a pulsating witness to the brutal
conversions that were realised by Muslim monarchs whether of Sunni or Shia brand through spilling of
blood, hacking of flesh and splintering of body limbs for transforming religious complexion of Kashmir.
Sikander, Ali Shah, Malik Saif-ud-din, Kaji Chak, Aurangzeb and Afghan surrogates as medieval despots
were at pains to devise all instruments of coercion and repression with the ominous motive of
proliferating the support-base of Islam which in Kashmir at the initial stages was near negligible. With the
loss of political power to the Sikhs the raging fury of proselytisation campaigns came to a sudden halt but
the deep and crippling scar of conversion was already inflicted on the religious personality of Kashmir.
Some of the neo-converts who were traumatised by the forcible conversion to Islam harked back to their
birth religion. Had the process found support from the power structures it would have turned into a
roaring tide.
With the decay of Sikh state the reins of power in Kashmir were handed over to the Dogras by the British
masters and with the speed of lightning a consistent campaign of calumny virulent hatred was unleashed
by the Punjab based violent and fanatic Muslim groups urging the Kashmir Muslims to dismantle the
Dogra rule spoke by spoke. Demands were yelled that the rulers who were dubbed as staunch Hindus
should cease to create hurdles in the holy task of conversions from other faiths and should desist from
interference in the launch of straightforward hate campaigns against the religious enemies.
In the murderous loot of 1931 the seven Kashmiri Pandits belonging to a single family of the village of
Kanikoot near yusmarg were offered conversion as an alternate choice to escape slaughter. In 1932 when
riots were triggered off in Mirpur the Hindus were massacred, arsoned and coerced to accept Islamic
faith. Forty-one Hindus were forcibly converted to Islam in the Kotli Police Station area. In the Seri
Police Station area four hundred and thirty-five Hindus from ten villages were coerced to join the Islamic
ranks. In Kotli Tehsil five Hindus were slaughtered- who reportedly rejected the offer of conversion to
Islam. A Maulvi, combative and violent, from Kashmir was responsible for the riots in Rajouri with their
quick impact in all the adjoining areas.
"Islam is in danger" (and ironically it is always deemed in danger) is the standard Muslim tactics of
generating Muslim paranoia against Hindus and mobilising the Muslim hordes for unleashing wild frenzy
for Jehad. In the ensuing tidal wave of chaos and mayhem the Hindu minority for one reason or the other
is charged with betrayal and sacrilege to Islam and struck with fear psychosis generated in ample measure
by the yelling and howling Muslim crowds many succumb to the sword of Islam. Pt. Hargopal, a poet and
historian, known as the Lion of Kashmir, along with Janki Nath and Sham Narain was accused of having
used abusive language against Islam over a trifling issue of trespass which, his neighbour, a Moulvi,
refused to remove despite numerous requests and entreaties. Hargopal was put under detention to quell
the mob fiery. His licence as a practicing lawyer was cancelled. Despite court acquittal the Muslims as a
combination of brute force and harsh coercion never felt satisfied with the quantum of punishment
awarded to him. Ultimately all the three were exiled from their native homes.
The tribal raid of 1947 had all the contours of Muslim Jehad and primeval savagery. Thousands of
Hindus, men, women and children whose staggering numbers were never divulged were mercilessly
butchered and conversions as a Muslim malaise resorted to on a large scale. Till the adjoining areas of
Baramulla and the town itself were under the deluge of tribals Kahmiri Pandits who were unable to move
to the safer zones in the city of Srinagar were not only looted and killed but also converted to the Islamic
religion by the secular progeny of humanists drummed about as Islamic sufis. After the territories under
the avalanche of the barbarous raiders were cleared by the valiant soldiers of India, prominent Kashmiri
Pandits like Pt. Kashyap Bandhu, Pt. Shamboo Nath Ogra, Pt. Sham Lal Shalla alongwith Rameshwari
Nehru toured the villages and hamlets where Muslim marauders having planted banners of crescent had
effected forcible conversions. The neo-converts despite threats and verbal invectives from the Muslim
bigots were re-christened and restored to their birth religion.
The Muslim fundamentalist movement of 1989-variety targeting the Kashmiri Pandits as enemies of
Islam and agents of Brahmanical imperialism realised their massive exodus to the Siberia of Indian plains.
History has been repeating for them. They were slaughtered and their hefty properties looted, grabbed or
destroyed as per the religious ordinances and fatwas that have been relentlessly and immutably in vogue.
Buzzing off to safer zones despite heavy losses in terms of life and limb, what satisfied them the most was
that they preserved their ideological and religious personality which they had acquired through
civilisational processes of growth and flowering and had not renounced even in the worst.times of
Muslim holocaust. Yet there are a few thousand of their co-religionists who chose to stay back for their
own reasons despite polarisation on communal lines and religious cleansing. Their presence in the valley
though confined to the high security zone has been blown out to authenticate and propagate the dubious
theory of Muslim secular sense, tolerant ethos and intellectual acceptance of composite culture. As is
buttressed by the authentic reports their numbers are believed not to exceed a bare two thousand. But the
vested interests in cohorts with unscrupulous elements in the corridors of central government inflated
their figures to a whopping twenty thousand only to secularist the troubled times and to establish that the
Pandits' perception of deadly threat from the Muslim majority was only a ploy to be in self-exile.
The Kashmiri Pandits who have chosen to stay back as subservient to Muslim identity and
majoritatianism are to all intents and purposes hostages to the Muslim majority and have been victims to
Muslim fundamentalist terror attacks and Qrgies of carnage. The fate of Sohan Lal Braroo, his wife and
his innocent daughter has blackened the countenance of Muslim rationality and exposed the Muslim
pretensions of allegiance to Sufi Islam and caused shivers in the corridors of Geneva, the seat of Human
Rights Commission. T.N. Bhat who had stayed back and was a poor guy eking out existence from the
scarce earnings from a few temples. The inhuman terrorists earning tremendous favours and sympathies
from the Muslim masses robbed him of his earnings at the Shrine of Zeshta Devi, tied him to a three
wheeler, wounding him brutally and fatally and hurled him in an unconscious state into the Dal Lake for
final burial. But the humiliating disability and torture that they have been subjected to is the forcible
conversion to Islam and adoption of Muslim dress codes, language nuances and other outer appearances
that stand out a Muslim.
The Report of a team of the Gandhi Peace Foundation which visited Kashmir very recently reveals,
"Those Kashmiri Pandits who have stayed back with their families have made adjustments with the
overwhelming majority of Muslims. Their women do not wear sari, do not put on a bindi or wear
'dejohur'. They have no outward sign of being married."
Since the volcanic eruption of fundamentalist insurgency till June, 1994 a good number of Kashmiri
Pandits and their daughters under duress have been forcibly converted to Islam at the hands of rabid
Muslims owing allegiance to multiple armed outfits.82 The Pandit girls who were abducted from their
house-holds and work - places were forcibly converted and married to Muslims after meting out to them
the treatment prescribed for the looted women of Kafirs. In the hateful conversion campaigns the
Jammaati-Islami has been in the active vanguard and has drawn unstinted and unqualified support from a
Muslim fanatic, Qazi Nissar, and some Janata Dal turn-coat politicals with a dubious track-record in
politics. The pages of "Kashmiriayat" as the official organ of umat-e-Islami have showered a litany of
plaudits and praises on Qazi Nissar impelled by the Islamic concept of Kufra for the initiation and
direction of the conversion campaign. The hapless victims to the brutality of conversion generally belong
to the villages of Anantnag, Pulwama and Tangmarg.
In Tral (District Pulwama) a Pandit family with a teenage daughter clinging to its habitat like a limpet was
coerced to accept Islam by the rabid Jammaat activists.84 Since its conversion the brutalised family has
been shifted from its ancestral house to the house of a Muslim in the same locality. Attempts galore have
been made to abduct the teenage girl by the lecherous elements held in high esteem as the saviours of
Islam. The Pandit family is under close watch lest it should slip off to the safer zones for retrieval from
the atrocity and as is reliably reported has been under lessons of initiation in Islamic precepts and
practices by some rabid Mullahs who have been howling along with dogs since 19/20th January 1990 as
generalismos of Islamic army of marauders.
Another Kashmiri pandit girl from Safapora was made off as a prize catch by a Muslim in broad daylight.
She was converted under the shadow of a gun and married to her Muslim abductor. The parents of the girl
living in absolutely hostile environs meekly protested against the atrocity but were threatened with dire
consequences if they did not shut up their traps and maintain stoic silence. The mother of the girl under a
terrific shock developed serious ailments and her spouse floated a humiliating application in the dailies
for permission from the brutal terrorists to shift his wife to Srinagar for proper medical;aid. The family
somehow managed to flee to Jammu and thus was able to save another teenage daughter from the similar
fate awaiting her.
In Tangmarg a Kashmiri Pandit lady married with children was said to have been lifted and forcibly
married to a Muslim who is said to be a driver. Her husband tried to report the abduction to the nearby
police station but was threatened with dire consequences by the hostile Muslims in the area. In the same
area another girl with Hindu origins was said to have been converted and married to a Muslim under
duress.
Again in Tral (District Pulwama) a Kashmiri Pandit girl living with her parents was abducted by the
Islamic terrorists who rule the roost despite government claims of normalcy. She was converted to Islam
under gun-point and married by a terrorist affiliated to a particular brand of terrorist formation. Another
terrorist of a different brand did not take kindly to the marriage and after an incessant chase were able to
spot the terrorist and his bride and without mincing words commanded him to hand over the girl to him
for marriage. Losing his cool and in utter rage the terrorist pounced on his rival and in the ensuing bloody
duel he fell to a bullet. The rival made off with his catch to the privacy of a den leaving behind no clues
for tracing him out.
In the health resort of Pahalgam a Kashmiri Pandit boy possessed of Dutch courage reportedly married a
Muslim girl from the same area. The Muslim terrorists alongwith their Muslim supporters were shell-
shocked by such a marriage as it was deemed to score off the history that they were writing in Kashmir.
They were dead set after the two lovers for their annihilation. Ultimately after a hunt the couple was
traced, abducted and mercilessly beheaded with a blunt axe. Their bodies with severed heads were
recovered from a field. How could a space be allowed to those who are deviants from the grammar of
Islam?
Scores of Sikh girls have been abducted and brutally converted to the Islamic religion. The abduction and
subsequent conversion of Satinder Kour D/o Bhupender Singh R/o Khawaja Bagh, Barmulla and Surinder
Kour D/o Dalip Singh R/o Alucha Bagh, Srinagar have been splashed in the media. Appeals to the Sikh
separatist leader Simranjit Singh Mann who had informed the valley Sikhs that he had ensured their safety
through a pact with the Kashmiri terrorists failed to secure their release from the clutches of the Islamic
crusaders. The Sikh organizations of varied hues from the Punjab have also issued numerous appeals for
the redemption of the Sikh girls but to no avail. The chief of the Dukhtaran-i-Milat, Aisha Indrabi, has
been assiduously working to the nefarious end of realising the conversion of many a Sikh and Pandit girl.
In the villages of Sopore, Tral, Mattan, Anantnag et al the Pandit families that have been atrociously
converted to Islam are allowed to retain the pictures of Hindu gods and goddesses only to mislead the
anti-terrorist operators and maintain the effectiveness of the den.
Som Deva reports, "Since the eruption of the fundamentalist insurgency till June, 1994 nearly a hundred
Pandit and many Sikh girls have suffered this fate at the hands of Jamaat-i-Islami and Its armed outfit
Hizbul Mujahideen. Later on they were married to Muslim boys."
He continues, " In July, 1993 two Pandit girls at the historic village Omanagri (Anantnag) and another
one at Safapore were forcibly converted to Islam by Jammaat activists. The attempts by their families
which subsequently migrated to Jammu to seek the help of official agencies for retrieving their daughters
evoked no response."
46 C ha pte r 14 - K A S H M IR I P A N D IT S A N D C O M M U N IS T B E T R A Y A L
Despite shattering disintegration of Soviet state, there is no denying the fact that the Russian Revolution
with the Marxist thought and ideology as its driving force was a momentous event with international
impact and ramifications. The system as ushered in Soviet Russia divergent from and in sharp
contradiction to the capitalist system with neck-break competition as its cardinal principle generated a
new wave of optimism and blazed a futuristic hope for redemption from an exploitative imperialist yoke.
The capitalist countries with booties from their colonies doling out lots of comforts even to the working
classes suffered a shock when Marxian thought shot up in public estimation and came to be seen
potentially viable to replace the decadent capitalist order. The communist parties in developed and
developing countries gained amazing popularity and what was of tremendous significance was the
magnetic attraction that the thinkers, theoreticians and scholars felt for the Marxist ideology and soviet
experimentation in a system different from capitalist path.
The communist party of India owing its genesis to the impact of Russian Revolution functioned under the
Soviet patronage and came to be seen as the propaganda machine of the Russians and their projected
strategies. As India had been groaning and writhing under the ruthless British blood - sucking, the Indian
National Congress had already spearheaded a struggle for liberation from the British hegemony and the
communist party of India with its feeble political base had no option but to append itself to the congress
on the assumption that the anti-imperialist struggle had to be strengthened and fortified by the broad
mobilisation of patriotic forces. The communist party failed to take deep roots in India for the fact that it
had no feel and appreciation of the enormous heritage of India and that was how its evaluation and
perception of the Indian reality never harmonised and had no compatibility with the depths and
psychology of India, more than most with its leviathan of culture and civilization. The same theme-song
of "proletarian. Revolution" and "class struggle" with hatred as its cosmic principle were plucked out of
the Marxian Book to shape the Indian reality for a revolution and crude attempts were harnessed to
explicate the shaping processes of Indian history in the light of Marxist tenets distilling ersatz of the
Indian substance anomalous to its tone and temper.
With the specific objective of expanding the base of communist ideology, a branch of communist party
was also established in Kashmir under the leadership of Dr. N.N. Raina, who was the rallying point for all
shades of communists and progressives. In Kashmir, the communist party had a negligible base and drew
its support and sustenance mainly from Kashmiri Pandit intellectuals who had a strong tradition of
education enabling them to measure new ideological trends and waves shaping out on international arena.
The potent and only factor that impeded and nearly stifled the steady growth of communist ideology in
Kashmir was the hide-bound Muslim mind indoctrinated and deeply steeped in "Kufra" and "narrowness
of the spirit" shaping out into an absolute abhorrence to everything that is not Islamic. As the communists
in India had set a precedent, the Kashmiri Pandit communists also functioned as a pressure group within
National Conference, which had the same ideological goals and moorings as that of the Muslim
Conference. The pre-1947 and post-1947 history of National Conference testifies to the fact of pursuing
an anti-Kashmir) Pandit thrust and agcuda with the same overt and covert communal vigour as that of the
Reading Room Party which finally incarnated into the Muslim Conference.
Sheikh Abdullah in his psychological dynamics had no love lost for Kashmiri Pandits but found their
efficacy in thwarting the dominant role of Jammu Muslims whom he feared for their advancement in the
field of education and also their articulation of politics through the clarity of language. The stark reality of
Muslim backwardness coupled with parochialism had amply dawned on him at the Muslim conference
convention at Jammu where the whole show was stolen by the Jammu Muslims. Though the Pandits had
been the butts of his cynical malign and open hatred, yet he craftily used them to invest his anti-Maharaja
campaign with a veneer of secularism and liberal political content. His superficial cries for Hindu-Muslim
unity not flowing from his ideological moorings and convictions and his deep roots in the Aligrah Muslim
University culture duped Nehru and the advanced sections from the Pandit Community. With the Sheikh's
ascendancy in power the Pandits found him as no harbinger of the dividends of peace and amity and
social solidarity and cohesion.
Much in the line of Ahmadiyas and Ahrars, the Muslim communists from Lahore and elsewhere
descended upon Kashmir to add vigour to the communist ideology by ropmg In and forming contacts
with the leaders of National Conference. The study circles where they flaunted their learning of the
Marxist texts and the tactical line pursued by the Communist Party were largely attended by the Kashmiri
Pandit converts to Marxism. As the Muslim League with its agenda of Pakistan as the destiny of Muslims
had emerged on the political scene of India, communally besmeared Ideological content was provided to
the National Conference to fight out the Maharja as representing the decadent feudal system, but not a
word was said about the Muslim League as representing the same feudal and parochial interests. The
strategy and socio-political framings as chalked out by the Muslim communists from the Punjab for
political action was not the people of Jammu and Kashmir versus British Imperialism but the people of
Kashmir versus Maharaja Hari Singh. Fazal Illahi Qurban and Abdullah Safdar pursued the same strategy
in Kashmir with trappings of fixation as they felt satisfied that the ends of revolution were better served
by pitting the Muslims against the Hindu Maharja in particular and Hindus in general.
Of immense political significance was the arrival of B.P.L. Bedi and his European wife, Freda Bedi in
Kashmir. They as communists from the Punjab pioneered a new communist Manifesto for Kashmir in the
form of New Kashmir document, a pious statement of Marxist cliches, supposed to concretise the goals
chat were sought to be achieved through the force of a struggle against the Maharaja. The role of two
prominent Kashmiri Pandit communists Dr. N.N. Raina and late Moti Lal Misri was highly laudable in
drafting the document, but was diluted and never recognised for their Hindu credentials by the National
Conference which was principally a Muslim organisation preserving and battling for the Muslim interests
at the expense of other ethnic and religious groups. The document of New Kashmir apparently egalitarian
with an accent on minority rights was supposed to pave way for and establish a rational democratic order
and with that end in view the communists organised and held study circles to acquaint the lumpens with
the social and political content of the document and to their dismay the Sheikh swooped on them, de-
legitimised them, got the study circles stopped on the plea chat they were propagating communism among
the Muslim youth though the fact was that the Muslims by and large detested and shunned communism
for its atheistic approach and premise.
The Kashmiri Pandit communists glued to the pursuit of guidelines issued out by party bosses deft in
doling out cliches and off-ground phantasies were absolutely lacking in Hindu lore and orientation and
passed for extreme liberals which trait of theirs was mix-understood, never swallowed and appreciated by
orthodox Muslims mired in illiteracy and obscurantism. Liberalism as a cornerstone of Hinduism flaunted
in an extremely backward society propped upon the tenets of bigotry encouraged an elusive mutual
concourse weakening the resisting barriers that could have saved the Pandits from the Muslim onslaught.
The rapport that developed thick and fast in the wake of Nehru's intervention dizzied the Muslims from an
oblivion into an identity which till then was a missing quantum. The Pandit communists and many
Pandits in National Conference without any commitment to the community, thus rootless, surrendered the
will of the community to the Muslim majority and also through their closer inter-face with Muslims
appeared to have contributed to the growth of pernicious trends which compromised and diluted the
Hindu position of Pandits. As borne out by history, Hindus have perpetually-been the butts of Muslim
onslaught and this fact of history was completely overlooked as nought and much to the chagrin of
general Hindu opinion, such onslaughts and any piquant situation of communal dimension were brushed
off in ambivalent and lack-lustre fashion and positions were taken as could be characterised
capitulationary and uncouth defences were put up for the Muslim demeanour that has been absurd and
irrational.
The Hindu communists bright people by all standards got a life-time shock, when few Muslim
communists subscribing to the 'instinctive tilt of Muslim psyche for Pakistan' theory denounced them as
reactionary Brahmans and anti-Muslim and made a concerted bid to capture the Communist Party though
the Pandits as a matter of fact formed a bulk of its membership. They were beaten and thrashed, moneys
on them snatched and looted, humiliated and put to crass contumely. The Muslim communists and hired
goons in a joint operation looted and captured the Party run Book-shop at Lal Chowk, Srinagar and they
say that the whole operation was the brain-child of Mohinddin Qarra, the oriole of Kashmir, in
accompaniment with Pir Abdul Ahad, who in post-1947 scenario in his disgruntlement with Sheikh
Abdullah broke away from National Conference and without any contrition formed Political conference
with pro-Pakistan politics as its pivotal agenda. As expected the communist Party suffered a dip and a
split on communal lines and dismaying as it is, the Pandit communists alert as they should have been
failed to learn from the brash communalization of communist politics and continued with their
unflinching loyalty to National Conference which their party bosses had regimented them to believe that
Kashmir with its so-called radical programmes would lead to a communist revolution in India with waves
flowing in from Red China.
Pandit Jia Lal Kilam, a signatory to the National Demand, had the grace and independence to lodge
appealing protest against Sheikh Abdullah's utterances against the religion of Hindus and raised the issue
in the working committee of National Conference and offered his resignation when the Sheikh
unexpectedly thundered that he was first a Muslim and last a Muslim. The National Conference would
have sundered apart had not Pandit Nehru intervened for a patch-up to save the ship from sinking. But the
Pandit communists as per their history in Kashmir have maintained stony silence on issues of vital
concern to the community though the fact was that they were taken for Kashmiri Pandits and if the rag
came off, it was firmly suck back and when the state power moved against the Pandits wholehog, they
were not left out for special treatment or even consideration and were mandalised and discriminated and
met out a raw deal the same wise as the mass of Kashmiri Pandits were.
Pandit Jia Lal Taimiri, a veteran politician without a blemish, cultured and soft-spoken-was highly
detested for the eye he had on scams and kitties of N.C.Ministers. Nothing deterred him from setting a
brilliant and inimitable precedent when he openly confronted and opposed Sheikh Abdullah for the
appointment of Mohammad Sultan at the expcuse of P.N. Ganju on religious grounds and considerations.
A Gandhian to the core, Taimiri tailed to digest the injustice and staged a dharna at the National
Conference Headquarters demanding the withdrawal of unjust orders by the Sheikh who as a doyen of
secularism and nationalism lost no time in axing and weeding out Pandits thus paving way for ethnic
cleansing. Not emulating the example of Taimiri the Pandit communists not only maintained intriguing
silence, but also formed a part of National Conference gendarme in the execution of a policy of blatant
communalism by the State with Sheikh Abdullah telling the Pandit young men though competent and
qualified to go to greener pastures available for them in rest of India. The minorities were put on the hit-
list of the government, were harassed and tyrannised and driven into dire straits. Had the Pandit
communists followed to the dot the Taimiri precedent, it would never have been in conflict with the
Marxist dicta and doctrine.
The Pandit Communists and also the Pandits drawn into the dragnet of National Conference after
dissolving their parent body might not have been conversant with persecutionary history of how the
Muslim intolerants with their prejudices subjected them to a pogrom which had no semblance of a human
face, how a genocide was triggered off to transmute the religious complexion of Kashmir and how the
Hindus had been forced to march out of their native abode five times to say the least. The dispensation
incarnated from the forces with a fanatic and sectarian visage could not on a sudden vie with catholicity
of outlook and secular demeanour. How was it that the loot of 1931 and again the loot of 1932 were
totally ignored and blotted out of focus? How was it that the dismal and gory drama of 1947 with all the
ingredients of a crusade was painted rosy despite its murkiness?
The Pandit Communists following the behests of the Communist Party of India played a vigorous role in
laying bare Sheikh Abdullah's hobnobbing with the Americans who been deeply aware of the strategic
importance of Kashmir in the Himalayan water-shed and hence a focus of their not too benign attention.
In their unstinted support to the new dispensation led by Bakshi Ghulam Mohammad, the Communists
created the fronts and fortified the forces to put up an ideological battle against the instrumentalities of
destabilization and national insecurity Kashmir as an official organ of the Communists in Kashmir
published editorials and lead-articles that highlighted and put forth a reasonable analysis of the game-plan
of Imperialist powers to wrest Kashmir from the Constitutional organization of India to establish its
independence as a requirement of cold war politics of Dullesian vintage. Over the years with changes
taking place in Kashmir politics the Communist Party in keen earnestness to craft its politics to the needs
of the scenario back-tracked from the Central Committee resolution on Sheikh Abdullah who in all clarity
of language was accused of having fallen into the Imperialist dragnet. Jyoti Basu as the Chief Minister of
West Bengal in his address to an audience at College of Education, Srinagar declared that the dismissal of
the Sheikh's government in 1953 was illegal and unwarranted forgetting that he was a party to the whole
contents of the resolution as a Central Committee member. It was an act of opportunism and Communists
are essentially opportunists pursuing the same politics of the art of possible for a toe-hold here and a foot-
hold there through a flaunt of phoney and artificial slogans to perpetuate their rule in some burrows.
Sheikh Abdullah with a deep Streak of vengeance and vindictiveness in his personality wits in no mood to
forgive the Pandit Communists for their so-called betrayal in 1953. But aware of their political fertility
and acumen as Pandits, he invited a brilliant thinker of the stature of late Moti Lal Misri to participate in
the people's Convention hastily organised as a political gimmick to smoothen his highway for a
somersault ensuring his ascendancy to the seat of power and also to dole out fake and false impression
that he was convinced of the absurdity of the Plebiscite Front politics of which he was the pioneer and
innovator too. Despite opposition from many quarters the Sheikh was hastily and even impolitically under
a quaint arrangement installed as the leader of Congress Legislature party and in the wake of quirks and
heaves of history he entrenched himself as the elected Chief Minister of the State and the weapon used
was to feign illness to invoke public sympathy. And dismaying as it is, he launched a diatribe against the
Pandits by labelling them as 'Fifth Column', a Muslim calumny and canard motivated by his antipathy
towards the Pandit Communists formulating his distasteful role in the formulaic phrase of 'unconscious
votary of imperialism'.
Flaunting the credentials of a progressive, G.M. Sadiq maintained a close rapport with the Pandit
Communists whom he used at will as a support-plank to foment and perpetuate his self-promotion and
self-aggrandisement in pre-1953 and post -1953 political scenario. With no mass appeal, but still wielding
political power under all dispensations, he as a matter of first choice dictated by religious culture
embarked upon an antediluvian policy-path of formalising the wanton discrimination against the Pandits
by the issuance of a satanic government decree purporting religion-based quotas in recruitment and
admissions to the study programmes. Superseding the orders brazenly and clandestinely issued and
implemented, the said-order practically reserving the whole pie for the Muslims proved the first
convoluted exercise in generating Islamic paranoia about the Pandits who as the branded enemies of
Islam had to be expelled to the Siberia of the Indian plains.
Writes Koul, "The order proved a land-mark in the history of discrimination and relentless elimination of
the Kashmirian-Hindus. Violative of the Constitutional provisions, the orders were outrageously
communal making religion as a determining factor for entry into services and admissions in professional
colleges. What was shocking that such orders were issued at the behest of G.M. Sadiq who had
pretensions to secular and progressive credentials.
Harkrishen Singh Surjeet once known as an Akali Communist and now as a dubious power broker has
been overseeing the functioning of his Party unit in Kashmir and directing its affairs prior to the split of
the Communist Party and continued with the over-lordship even after the Party floundered into groups
and sub-groups. His Jaunts between Delhi and Kashmir undertaken with the objective of proliferating and
strengthening the base of C.P.I (M) unit in Kashmir and his successes and failures in this behalf are
within the knowledge of people interested in political affairs. As is common knowledge, his sphere of
activities in Kashmir has been limited to a house in Khanyar, Srinagar, which is owned by Yusuf Zargar,
a Muslim activist, but a comrade in Communist parlance. It was at the same house situated within the
tangle of narrow lanes and byelarlcs of the locality that Comrade Surjeet dilating on the political scenario
of Kashmir was said to have expressed his shirking doubts about the relevance and efficacy of Art. 370
and was said to have advocated its repeal. The meeting though not largely attended was suddenly wound
up when hundreds of Muslims lying in wait surrounded the house and lapidated it and let loose a barrage
of abuse and curse against the owner of the house and filthily denounced Surjeet, his Party and the
atheistic philosophy of Marx in so loud tones as to rend the sky.
The Scene was set for manhandling the Comtrades. But, before Comrade Surjeet could be bashed and
thrashed in the native Muslim fashion, his partyrmen, pale and panting, led him out of the house through
the back-yard door merging into the labrynthine of lanes and drains to the house of a Kashmiri Pandit,
late J.L. Dhar, not a comrade, where he cooled his heels and felt safe and secure and reassured. Invested
with an exceptional capacity of mind and intelligence, Surjeet should have promptly measured the trend
of ominous events shaping in the secular skies of Kashmir and despairing as it is he without touching the
hornet's nest maintained wooden silence and thought it highly prudent and sagacious not to broach the
subject with the powers that be then at the Central capital and perhaps fearing loss of face concealed the
incident fraught with nefarious designs of ominous proportions even from ills own party circles to which
he was responsible if responsibility is a principle informing the Communist politics. The Muslims who
had surrounded the house as the venue of Communist activists and had virtually bayed for their blood
were the same fanatic brigands churned out from the Madrasas functioning as the seminaries of
fanaticism and bigotry and upholding the agenda of converting the valley into a haven of Islam through
its annexation with Pakistan.
Aware as every cawing crow is of the tact that Kashmiri Pandits as a distinctive religious minority have
been expelled from their native birth-place lock, stock and barrel by the armed Muslim killers earning not
covert but overt support and collaboration from large sections of Muslim majority, but comrade Surjeet
set on the trail of faceless opportunist refuses to identify and cognise the stark reality and call a spade a
spade. If he does, the apple-cart of hollow secularism as conceived and practised in the country will turn
turtle and that is why he and his party as votaries of the same phoney secularism have not polically
necessary and expedient to issue out a single statement on the cruel expulsion of the entire Hindu
minority from the Muslim Kashmir. He can be unflinching in his support to the creation of Mallapuram, a
citadel of Islamic Sevak Sangh, but he cannot afford pay even lip-service to the cause of the three lakh
Hindu refugees wallowing in dust and dirt lest it should taint his secular image which in fact is nothing
more than a mask to conceal his anti-Hindu motivations.
Writes R.Venugopal, "How many of them (Communists) remember that in the mid-forties EMS led
processions of Muslims in Kerala along with the late A.K.Gopalan shouting 'Pakistan Zindabad' and
'Moplistan Zindabad'. A few will know now how he got the revered Gandhian, Kaliappan, arrested for
trying to re-build a temple just because the Muslims objected to it. It was he who distorted the Mopla
rebellion in 1921 into an agriculturists' fight against landowners.
EMS had the honour of equating communism with anti-Hinduism which was taken up by all other leftists
and so called progressives of our country."
47 C ha pte r 15 - H O M E L A N D D E M A N D R A IS E D
The terrorist violence launched through violence and carnage has been ravaging the State of Jammu and
Kashmir without any visible let up as the culmination of secessionist movement pursued with resilience
since 1947. Despite all campaigns of canard and disinformation inside and outside the country the world
opinion is now thoroughly convinced that the terrorism in Kashmir in its fundamental motivations and
inputs is a Muslim crusade and that is how Kashmiri Pandits as the first victims have been hounded out of
their ancestral abode and hurled into a crisis situation of exodus and exile. Beset with pangs of
destabilization and agonies of stupendous losses of assets and human life the entire community is on
cross-roads and stands absolutely brutalised and disfigured, alienated and isolated. It is disrobed of its
characteristic identity as an ethnic and religious minority and is equally bereft of its culture personality
and existence rooted in the history and culture of Kashmir. The community as a debris of shattered
illusions is not only sunk in the quagmire of trials and travails but is virtually frozen in time and space.
Uprooted from its cultural and civilisational ethos it seems to have lost purpose and direction and can be
compared to a rudderless boat adrift on the stormy and perilous waves. It was hunted and hounded and
continues to be pounded and bludgeoned. It was on the run all the time and continues to be in the same
oppressed state. Engaged in a grim battle for survival it is losing its nerve in face of harsh vagaries of
climate, an apathetic populace and extremely cruel and inimical administration. The members of the
community that have a proud record of decent and cultured life despite all manner of persecution and
economic squeeze are reduced to penury, want and deprivation.
The greatest tragedy is that they have become exiles in their own country and aliens in their own land.
Under the grip of an agonising and frustrating situation the community having no vote-bank clout is
deemed as disposable Junk by the governments under the tight leash of unscrupulous and corrupt
politicians who have made shameless attempts to conceal the genocide and hush up the plight and woes of
the community and tag it with labels and pejoratives as an excuse to leave it in lurch. The absolute
hostility of the Muslim government of the state being given, the central governments of varied shades
have been classical in their postures of neglect, callousness and apathy unto the community in exile and
Diaspora.
Kufra as a dominating factor of Muslim mental apparatus anti-Kashmiri Pandit hysteria was generated
and whipped up to weld Muslim ranks to realise their externment and exile flaunted as a tangible
achievement to cement the cracks in the secessionist movement. What was Hindu has been vengefully
erased and dismantled whole hog. Rational argument deemed as inimical to the terrorist-cum-secessionist
movement has been crucified to enforce uniformity through violent and ruthless methods. Rhythms of
religion have been geared to reinforce and stimulate frightful orgies of strife and disorder, rape and
masssacre. Untold physical sufferings have been perpetrated on the community and in the name of
religion its dignity has been fatally wounded and Nizam-e-Mustafa is held out to the battling ranks of
Muslim violents as a new dawn of promise and hope on the debris of hewn flesh of Kashmiri Pandits and
spilt blood of their womenfolk and children. To achieve the ends of crusade said to be historically
infamous the Kashmiri Pandits as Kafirs have been tortured, hanged, massacred, dismembered, tied with
grenades and blasted, lynched and sawed into two halves and burnt alive into cinders thereby putting into
shade the cruel pogroms of tyrants who have been tried and punished for their inhuman crimes under
international law.
As a response to the formidable challenges that have plagued and staggered the Kashmiri Pandit
community at large the demand for homeland has been voiced and articulated as a cogent and decisive
remedy to mitigate the social, political and economic strangulation and existential plight of the
community in forced galut and Diaspora caused by the Muslim crusaders motivated with the idea-force of
revanchism.
It is not for the first time that the homeland demand has been orchestrated and projected as a viable
alternative to the subjection that the Kashmiri Pandit community has been reduced to by the Muslim
rulers owing allegiance to the Islamic guide-lines not to the democratic and secular constitution of the
republic. The Kashmiri Pandits gave currency to and agitated the homeland demand in the wake of
murderous and despicable loot of 1931 when they were scathed, looted and murdered by the hateful
communal elements in league with British imperialists ensuring a raw deal for them by callous and
arbitrary rejection of their reasonable and legitimate demands and concerns. Hard pressed by the
communal scenario the Kashmiri Pandits with a discerning mind reiterated the demand for home. land
with its echoes in 1890 in which they would feel safe and secure from the brutal Muslim aggression and
implaccable enemies of civil society holding rights and values in contempt and to ransom through the
construction of their own state. In the wake of Bread Movement the demand snow - balled into a new
perspective and dimension when the Muslim majority was incited and harnessed to throttle the political
right to dissent and protest and stonewall the Kashmiri Pandit mobilisation to champion their economic
demands through generation of obscurantist and communal scenario. Now that the community as a whole
has been expelled and externed by the forces of militarized Islam flaunting bigotry and myopic
perspectives homeland demand is the apt response that hews close to the cause. As per the situation
obtaining homeland demand is neither a dream nor a fall-back option; in reality it is the first choice, an
effective political initiative and is to be pursued for hundred years with firm resolve and forceful vigour.
Homeland demand is the crystal ball in which KPs are gazing the ruptures and continuities between their
past and future.
In the post-independence era that began with Nehru's "tryst with destiny" the Kashmiri Pandits as a matter
of policy and communal vengeance were put on the hit-list of the governments of all shades and hues.
Blatant communal policies and measures were conceived and executed to sideline them from decision-
making bodies and governance structures. Communal quotas were fixed in education to rob them of
educational opportunities and attainments. Employment, postings and promotions were communalized to
incredible limits. Quality, brilliance and academic affluence were cruelly sacrificed at the altar of
quantity, gross mediocrity and academic poverty. The Muslim pre-eminence in all sectors of
administrative governance was rapidly achieved through blatant violation and transgression of the
legitimate rights and privileges of ethnic and religious groups not subscribing to the faith of Islam. To
achieve the sinister objective of undiluted Muslim sway and precedence fraudulent manipulations were
effected, irrational measures devised, communal directives issued and sectarian preferences unabashedly
flaunted. All norms were violated and normlessness thus created was stuck to as a norm. To cap it all,
posh Muslim localities abuzz with glitz and glamour were arbitrarily categorized as backward and
stinking slums inhabited by Pandits as posh and developed areas to deprive them of a tap or a good paved
- lane and other educational benefits. Remorseless and relentless purge of Kashmiri Pandits as the state
policy many brilliant sons of the soil seeking jobs and admissions in government sponsored study
programmes on the firm footing of merit and achievements were brazenly conveyed the whisper that they
could shift to greener pastures outside Kashmir in India leaving Kashmir to Muslims. This policy-path
was blazed by no less a person than Sheikh Abdullah, who was a prisoner of ghettoised mentality.
On the false and misconceived paradigm of backwardness and poverty blatant communalism was
practiced to ease out contenders with remarkable academic records and achievements. To Islamise the
services an unheard of practice was taken a resort to. Two seniority lists on the model of two-nation
theory, one for Muslims and the other for Hindus, were prepared and duly recognised and considered for
promotions. Not satisfied even with this cruel communal practice leading to the extreme polarization of
the two communities what the rulers did was to destroy records, tamper and manipulate them. Restless to
grab all levers of power for a bigger game-plan of secession the Muslim rulers declared as redundant the
entrenched principle of upward mobility through normal processes and established channels for the
Muslims, and devised and designed all means and methods of artifice, deceit and cunning to destabilise
and marginalise the Pandits who as kafirs at war were to be reduced to the hewers of wood and drawers of
water. The democratic and secular character of the state apparatus was metamorphosed into an Islamic
mould to cater to and foster the Muslim interests. The measure of labelling 90% Muslim population of the
valley as backward and poor and 10% population of Kashmiri Pandits, Sikhs, other Hindus even of Dogra
origin as creamy layer caused surprise at all levels of Judiciary. A particular justice of the Apex Court
was said to have remarked that it would have been better for the state government to declare 10% Hindus
also as backward and poor. A backward class organisation with Saif-ud-din Soz as its kingpin was formed
to coerce the Kashmiri Pandits not to pester for the implementation of Supreme Court orders which had
quashed all promotions on the absurd rationale of backwardness and poverty.
Since 1947 when the messiahs of responsible government came to power rule of law as pillar of justice
was sung out with the last requiem. It was banished for good from the land of Kashmir and shown
absolute contempt and derision and was never allowed to prevail with its full sway and sovereignty. As a
matter of result a new era of subjection and subjugation, denial and deprivation, fear and insecurity,
persecution and oppression began for the Kashmiri Pandits as a minority.
The "New Kashmir Manifesto" as an egalitarian and secular document was maliciously distorted to
restructure and reorganise the entire state into a political system which openly betrayed a bias and
partiality for the Muslims. The package of concessions and privileges followed by incessant flow of such
packages showered on Muslims as a special breed of people have not flowed from the sources in
constitution but from the religion that they harboured. Under the guise of communal amity, equality and
opening up of opportunities for the under-dogs the governments from time to time in complete disregard
of the constitutional principles of right to equality before law and safe-guard against discrimination on
religious grounds promoted the cause of Muslims leaving diverse ethnic and religious communities high
and dry, neglected and detested.304
Land reforms implemented with vengefulness against the Kashmiri Pandits proved as a prelude to their
death and destruction. They were not effected to usher in an egalitarian socio-economic dispensation with
the objective of founding a rational, sane and democratic society. As a weapon of destabilization
thousands of Kashmiri Pandits were forced to migrate to various parts of India for a pittance as a result of
economic squeeze and denial of rehabilitation opportunities. The National Conference rulers with ample
resources of cunning and fraud figmented the idea of the appeasement of Muslim peasantry especially the
richer sections through land reforms so that they belt wooed and enticed, nay bribed, to vote for National
Conference in case a plebiscite under a foreign agency was held. The land reforms shabbily implemented
with least ideological commitments to the restructuring of the entire politico-economic system on radical
lines led to the creation and spawning of a class of Muslim kulaks who have emerged as the bastions of
Muslim reaction and secession and as the mainstay of the detestable ideology and politics of Jammaat-i-
Islami. In the form of a protracted war waged on the Pandits the said-reforms injected communal venom
and virus into the average sections of Muslim peasantry. The 1989 - fundamentalist insurgency has drawn
maximum recruits and vigorous support from the Muslim novo-rich of the rural areas who were offered
land in a platter without paying a pie.
Conspiracies were hatched at governmental level to dispossess the Hindus of the industries which they
had established through the mobilization of their capital and entrepreneurial resources. The Muslim
workers in such industries were provoked for strikes and lock-outs thereby providing a handle to the
plotters to interfere for fruitification of their designs. The match factory in Baramulla as an enterprise of a
Hindu was grabbed when the Muslim labourers in the factory disrupted the productive processes through
strikes and lock-outs at the behest of their Muslim masters. The Woollen Mills in Srinagar again as
venture of a Hindu was put to the same orgy of labour trouble, throttling and lock-outs. The owner Divas
coerced to hand over the factory to the government for a trice. The Pandits thick in the silk trade owned
many a silk-weaving unit and under the guide-lines of the same conspiracy were ejected out of the
industry through generation of communal rivalries, withdraw al of government patronage and starvation
of raw-materials.
As a matter of reality all political regimes under the tight -leash of fundamentalist Muslims not only
stoked and fostered Muslim communalism but pioneered measures and devices to snuff out the Kashmiri
Pandit minority. It was subjected to unprecedented black-mail and intimidation. It was not only
disenfranchised but its population figures were clandestinely manipulated and consciously suppressed.
The constituencies where the community could assert and exercise its unfettered political rights were
fragmented and Jerrymandered thereby divesting it of the right to elect a single legislator to reflect its
yearnings and aspirations, grouses and grievances. As an essential part of Islamisation campaign the
names of six hundred towns and villages rooted in the Hindu stream of culture were slated off through the
imposition of unrelated Arabic and Persian names. Unable to transcend the narrow confines of Muslim
conference politics and sunk in picayune and orthodox views Sheikh Abdullah launched frontal attacks on
Pandits as his bete noir in 1978 and 1982 for the fact that he deemed in them a potential impediment to
the Islamisation as part of total game-plan of pan-Islamism which he had been feeding and directing since
his take-over in 1975. He set the trend for and reinforced the Muslim model of elimination of Pandits
when he fascistically commanded his Hindu Minister from Jammu region not to recruit them in state level
services and with a view to blotting out the community he mobilised and garnered the campaign for
marginalisation of the Pandits from Central services on the twin planks of religion and population ratio
and the same campaign was picked up by his minions and proxies who carried it to a logical end.
The Kashmiri Pandits thus disinherited by the Muslim politicals in their land of birth were assaulted and
their residential and business premises invariabley looted and plundered mostly on days connected with
events in the Muslim world especially Pakistan. The religious places of Pandits were the main targets and
therefore ravaged and arsoned. A storm of hatred and vengeance was unleashed against them blaming and
holding them responsible for a sell-out of Kashmir to India. The 1986 Muslim aggression on the minority,
planned and pre-meditated, marked the tail-end of the total destabilization campaign and strategy.
The protection and safe-guards meant for ethnic and religious minorities as a meaningful practice pursued
all over the world has no lessons for the Kashmiri brand of Muslim rulers who sadistically usurped the
democratic rights and privileges of the Pandit minority. In India which is broadly wedded to democracy
and secularism there is a duly constituted Minority Commission monitoring the rights and grievances of
Muslims in particular even though the Muslims in fulfilment of their demand had their chunk of land at
the time of partition. But in the state of Jammu and Kashmir where under the facade of secular
constitution a Muslim state has been created with fundings from Government of India. There have been
no safeguards and protective umbrellas for the minority and what has been astounding that all protections
and safeguards have been culled and harnessed to fortify the Muslim interests by throwing secular ideals,
democratic values and constitutional tenets to winds. Nor are there any operative channels that could
envisage and ensure the full participation of the minority in over-all functioning of the politico-economic
system and nation-building activities and processes. The Hindu minorities curiously dubbed as
"amaanat"- trust, not valued as citizens with the same democratic rights and guarantees that have been
enshrined in the Republican Constitution were squeezed, harassed, intimidated and finally liquidated
grabbing not only the political and economic cake to feed the insatiable Muslim dianasaur but also their
lands, properties and houses.
After the legal accession of the state to the Indian union was formalised Sheikh Abdullah vigorously and
assertively sought for special status on the grounds of Muslim majority character of the state thereby
protecting and subserving the Muslim interests of hegemonism and majoritarianism. But the congress
leadership under the siege of Pt. Jawaharlal Nehru bartered away the vital concerns and interests of
minority groups by placing them at the whims and tender mercies of Muslim majority which under no
circumstances can ward off the pull of Islamic ethos of persecuting and oppressing the minorities not
pinning their faith in Islam. In absence of political and constitutional guarantees with a heightened
emphasis on the right to live and live with safety and an effective mechanism for their implementation
Kashmiri Pandits were pushed out to the peripheries of the political and economic scenario, oppressed
and persecuted, bereft and deprived, hounded and hunted.
How wrong was Pt. Prem Nath Bazaz when he in his communication to Pt. Jawaharlal Nehru wrote that
the native Pandits should not press for political and constitutional guarantees and safety valves as an
effective shield against Muslim aggression and blatant trespass on and into their rights and privileges. In
his response to Pt. Bazaz Nehru with the political sagacity of a Fabian socialist dittoed to the dot what
Bazaz had communicated to him apropos political and economic safeguards and guarantees ignoring
Muslim cultural model brazen in its contempt of a liberal frame allowing and ensuring the blooming of
hundred flowers. Both Nehru and Bazaz despite tremendous signals from the changed political scenario in
the wake of 1953-developments could not envision a moment in history when Kashmiri Pandits rooted in
their commitments to the national unity, integrity and security would emerge as targets of gun and
grenade for the Muslim majority for not committing themselves to the consorting with the Muslim
majority for the agenda set by Islam heading towards militarization. Both of them were not perceptive in
their historical evaluation of Islam with the result that they anchored their unflinching faith in the view
that the Muslim majority despite the Hinduised Islam would perennially harbour goodwill and
accommodation unto the Kashmiri Pandit minority and there would be no distortions and aberrations in
the over-all ethos when ephemeral idealism in face of Islamic imperatives would get dimmed and
quenched out. That Rule of Law was the frame upon which Justice hangs as the only guarantee against
Muslim onslaught would be undermined and given a hamhanded and cosmetic treatment was not
visualised by the brightest literatti of the period.
Despite persecution and discrimination Kashmiri Pandits played indisputably a frontal role in
modernization of Kashmir and harnessed their mental and intellectual resources and initiatives to
reconstruct the infrastructural foundations for a vibrant democratic order as part of mainstream politics.
To dispel the darkness of illiteracy and backwardness as inhibiting factors forestalling any significant
social change they invested their honest endeavours and resourceful energies to expand the network of
universal education by encompassing the broad sections of Muslim society that had maintained distance
from the light of education. Modernity and rationalism were what they disseminated for the establishment
of a sane society, dynamic and buoyant comprising of the individuals cast in the mould of higher values
adding charm and meaning to human life. Though the Muslim vested interests in tandem with religious
lobbies had etched them as Muslim foes on the Muslim mindscape yet they reposed full faith in and were
never repugnant to the democratic order and its sanctified institutions supposed to guarantee their
maximum participation in the nation-building processes.
But unfortunately the carefully nurtured Muslimisation of total layers of state apparatus leading to the
erosion of secular ideals and democratic principles shattered their cherished dream of basic freedoms,
fundamental rights, unfettered opportunities for flowering and more than most security of life and assets
from all manner of religion inspired vandalism and barbarity. They have been betrayed by the Muslims
who were thick in the conspiracy that was brewed in the mosques and madrasas for their extermination
and are harbouring genuine feelings of hurt, disillusionment and disenchantment. With the inaugural of
Muslim terrorism the Kashmiri Pandits were reviled, humiliated, brutalised and slaughtered and to their
utter shock and dismay Muslims suffered a total failure in sanity and rationality and were swayed by the
waves of bigotry and hatred which emanated from the mushrooming mosques when in a typical boatman
s fashion loud drums about the inaugural of insurgency were fiercely beaten threatening the kafirs to quit
and vacate the land of Kashmir for an immediate Muslim take-over and consolidation.
The state government under the helmsmanship of Farooq Abdullah, traitorously simulating paralysis as an
act of complicity failed to rise to the occasion to meet the challenges posed by the devastating forces of
terrorism through flexing the powerful muscles of state power. The Kashmiri Pandits undergoing carnage
and horror were first betrayed by his government which abdicated its moral and constitutional obligation
to provide security to the victims under siege of Muslims gone berserk and added to their saga of disaster
by virtual perishment from the scene. The undeniable fact is that his government was in the warm lap of
Muslim conspirators and was fiddling when Rome was burning. The central Government is equally a
culprit and cannot divest itself of the fair share of responsibility that it had in the brutalization and
elimination processes that were wreaked on the Kashmiri Pandit minority. The trials and travails of the
patriotic community that had assumed menacing proportions since 1975-Accord with Sheikh Abdullah
were not monitored and measured and taken as ominous signals Wintering to an impending disaster with
far-reaching consequences for the national security. To the consternation of nationalistic and patriotic
forces the central government with a Muslim Home Minister having lubricated and stained his hands with
the blood of Hindu minority in a panic reaction to douse the fires of insurgency absorbed Muslims in
droves in Central Government institutions through extra-constitutional channels by flouting and effacing
norms and stipulations thereby completing the unholy task of Muslimisation of the valley.
As a cover up operation for the communal and fundamentalist character of the so-called freedom struggle
a virile campaign of disinformation was launched against the Kashmiri Pandits not only to malign them
but paint them in the blackest hues. The canard that their exodus was touted by Jagmohan, the then
Governor of J&K State, was floated, given widest possible currency inside and outside the country to
conceal the forced exodus and communal carnage of the Hindu minority. The web of malicious canards as
an instant product included the strands that Kashmiri Pandits as artful people had cornered and usurped
maximum state and central government jobs which as a source of anger and irritation had impelled the
Muslim youth to cross the borders and take to the gun culture and the Pandits through their merit and
achievements, cunning and manipulation would usurp all trades, professions, educational institutions and
government jobs in Jammu and elsewhere"'. As a spill-over effect of the villainous campaign the forced-
out employees were not suitably adjusted, the scholars of the community who had abandoned portals of
their educational institutions under severe terrorist threat were not enrolled in regular colleges in Jammu
and elsewhere, the unemployeds were denied employment and the professionals belonging to varied fields
made to vegetate and lose their acquired skills through dis-use. The strategy was to keep the cross-section
of Kashmiri Pandit refugee population in panic, stress and on tenter-hooks lest they should organise and
consolidate their numbers for a political act of demolishing and dismantling the decadent and moribund
political culture of the country immured to drown and annihilate the patriotic people for the appeasement
and pampering of Muslim rebels against national integrity and solidarity.
In galut and Diaspora the Kashmiri Pandits in a bird's eye view of themselves and their chequered history
of persecution and massacre have come to realise the prime importance of asserting their political rights
to a homeland in Kashmir where they will be free to conceive and construct a socio-political structure in
tune with their cherished goals and lofty ideals with least interference and interruption from Muslim
schizophrenia, backwardness and parochialism. The active political opinion that has emerged out of
protracted deliberations, debates and polemics was crytallised in the Homeland Resolution adopted by
Panun Kashmir in the Margdarshan convention held in December, 1991.
The Homeland Resolution Interalia demands:
a) The establishment of a homeland for the Kashmiri Hindus in Kashmir valley comprising the regions of
the valley to the east and north of river Jhelum.
b) That the constitution of India be made applicable in letter and spirit in this "Homeland" in order to
ensure right to life, liberty, freedom of expression and faith, equality and rule of law.
c) That the homeland be placed under Central administration with a Union Territory status so that. it
evolves its own economic and political infrastructure.
d) That all the seven lakh Kashmiri Hindus which include those who have been driven out of Kashmir in
the past and yearn to return to their homeland and those who were forced to leave on account of the
terrorist violence in Kashmir be settled in the homeland on equitable basis with dignity and honour.
Kashmiri Pandits through the concept and content of Homeland Resolution underscored the crying
realities that they have been deprived of a homeland and their generations are facing a precarious and
perilous future and the double-edged sword of Islamic communalism and Diaspora has exposed their
community to degenerating experiences of deprivation, insecurity, depression and estrangement. The
historic Resolution clinically analyses their prevailing position of insignificance and non-entity to which
they have been reduced and are bartered as sacrificial goats and disposable commodity and more than
most are on cross-roads and have ceased to be the citizens of their own state and the country as they have
lost the protective shield of fundamental rights and other constitutional guarantees which virtually
sustained them through the post-independence era of denial, discrimination, subjugation and blatant
religious persecution. The 1989-exodus grave in nature and formidable in scale has shaken them to roots
as it was a reenactment of their tryst with Muslim ferocity and bigotry in contemporary Kashmir which
political managers claim to be a part and parcel of India wedded to democracy and governed by a
sovereign constitution.
The political scenario in Kashmir has undergone a seachange by the replacement of normal political
culture even though tainted by unhealthy Muslim domination and precedence by a new breed of Muslim
terrorists who are avowedly for the elimination and decimation of the Kashmiri Pandit minority through
the ushering in of Islamic sociopolitical structures envisaging imposition of Jazia (poll-tax) and
disenfranchisement as its well-defined stipulations for the non-Muslim minorities. Terrorism has not only
led to their exodus from their birth-land but has also diminished and nearly sealed their chances for a safe
return to their native homes which have been brutally destructed and disfigured through acts of abysmal
vandalism. A minuscule minority scattered all over the valley where their cultural presence too has been
effaced out does not see any cogency and logic in living the same fashion in their scattered clusters as
they lived prior to their exodus and that is how they are face to face with a grim reality and cannot like
ostriches go on pinning faith in the shattered myths of secularism and coexistence. The only star that they
gaze at is a homeland where they can unify and galvanise into a force of resistance against the terrorist
onslaught and brutalities.
Catholic and modernistic in outlook, upwardly mobile and defiant of communal curbs, Kashmiri Pandits
refuse to live in a socio-political dispensation, which has been the creation of politicians who are self-
servers and in face of their political failures they wield the stick of Islam and to upgrade their popularity
graph they resort to rabble-rousing for plebiscite and myth of autonomy and swayed by whims of
vacillation and dreams of sultanate they spurt out venomous sputum against Kashmiri Pandits and back in
the seat of power they initiate subversion and swear allegiance to the forces of insurgency and in honest
confessions they nonchalantly spill the beans that they had dispatched National Conference activists
across the borders for arms training and strategic guidance. The Kashmiri Pandits abhor and detest the
socio-political order dominated by such dishonest and dubious politicians who are deft and artful in
double-speak and hypocrisy and can stoop to abysmal depths of moral eclipse in diverting the Muslim
frenzy against the minority by blaming them for the ills they are responsible for and for the failures in
nation-building processes they have pooh-poohed and never viewed from angles positive. Kashmiri
Pandits refuse to chain themselves to a system which is alienated and isolated from the currents and cross-
currents in the country through building of political barriers to cater to their needs of bigotry,
parochialism and religious schism. They uphold and subscribe to a world - view and work-culture which
do not cage and stifle their faculties and creative impulses in the straitjacket of cosmic hatred and
obscurantism and are votaries of healthy and wholesome trajectory of growth and development for
stupendous successes and glittering attainments. Nizam-e-Mustafa projected as the Islamic destination as
replacement of the sovereignty of Indian Constitution is an anathema to Kashmiri Pandits who are
wedded to liberalism, fairness, equity and egalitarian societal structures and feel, therefore, forced to
carve out a niche for themselves.
The Kashmiri Pandits refuse to tether themselves to a system which is wallowing in the shades of
medieval darkness and is shamelessly devoted to the Muslim commune' interests and in the process bares
its fangs of bigotry and communalism and as a part of Muslim conspiracy suddenly collapses to a heap of
mangled material under the weight of propaganda shit blurred out by Pakistan and avidly lapped by the
Muslims. It is a system which has lost its human face and where wise counsels failed to prevail, harmony
and co-existence could not bloom and good-will and tolerance were a far cry.
Kashmiri Pandits as an educated and cultured community and by all parameters poor but civilised section
of Kashmiri society have been for a vibrant and democratic society which they helped to take birth and
shape out in its broad features and contours through the spread of literacy levels for temper formation and
value enhancement. By introducing the Muslims to the language primers and initiating them in 3 R's the
Kashmiri Pandits despite religious differences and world-view variations humanised and aculturised them
for a new constructive role in world and life drama and equipped them with new cultivated ideas and
ingenuities, perceptions and awakened creativities. But tragically the advance that they had registered on
their intellectual slates previously not so unclean and medieval for leading an emancipated life on a higher
plane of values, surely not Islamic, was reversed and rubbed off by swashbucklers and dot-busters who
dressed their destructive plans under religious garb and religious terminology resulting in their eclipse and
death on 19th/20th January,
1990. Common sense took an immediate retreat. Rationality developed a tumour. Hallucination was at its
high noon. That what was taught to them by their detestable teachers as nebulous appeared shaping into
the form of reasonable credibility. New hopes even though dim and amorphous made them frenetically
feverish and hysterical. With loss of discretion "Azadi" and "annexation with Pakistan" started twinkling
like twinkling stars and what was worse they lent their vociferous support to the barbarous acts and
ignominous lechery which startled if not the world but the Pandits on the scene. It was a culture shock to
Pandits who failed to reconcile to the enveloping darkness and marched out to establish their own claims
and rights to an El Dorado in the valley which they have lovingly nomenclatured as 'homeland' stipulated
to be free and liberal in theme and concept excluding those myopics, parochials and fanatics responsible
for death of reason and crucifixion of an ethos. Azadi-seeking and Pakistan-dreaming Muslims have
fortified the Kashmiri Pandit determination and resolve to establish their prior rights to their ancestral
homeland which will be a scintillating model of liberalism, democracy, humanism and culture suffused
with the vitalising spirit of Indian Constitution.
The Kashmiri Pandits are justifiably apprehensive of the Constitutional changes that are sought to fortify
the state agamst the currents and cross-currents of the mainstream life of the country. The pre-1953 status
of the state in theory and praxis keeps the state outside the purview and pale of the Indian Constitution.
The constitutional provisos of the fundamental rights, citizenship rights, jurisdiction of the Supreme
Court, Directive Principles of the state policy et al were not applicable to the state on the plea that these
were not listed in the Instrument of Accession. The incorporation of Art. 370 misnomer as an enabling
provision but actually as an article of limitations constitutionally cognised the Muslim character of the
state thereby rendering diverse ethnic and religious groups to the status of subjugation and servility in a
Muslim state. It is an indisputable fact that Art. 370 has generated and unleashed the negative alchemy for
separatism, divisive forces, parochial trends and Muslim majoritarianism and has limited the sovereignty
of the Indian constitution thereby facilitating the push-over of the state into the vortex of terrorism and
insurgency. The cunning politicals inside and outside the corridors of power have exploited the said-
Article to the hilt as an instrument of black-mail to which the central power in the capital has been
constantly succumbing through its reiteration of continued support despite it being a weapon of Muslim
reaction and fundamentalism. In its basics the Homeland Resolution is bitter in its opposition to the
Article 370 which is primarily responsible for the banishment and uprooting of Kashmiri Pandits. The
homeland as envisaged by the Pandits will be unflinching in its faithfulness and fealty to the country and
its fundamental concerns and will emerge as an oasis of democracy and humanism in the desert of
Muslim insurgency and terrorism. It will have full flow of Indian constitution and will not be put to
limitations and mutilations, restrictions and trimmings to feed Muslim insularity based on religious bias.
The Homeland Resolution is the product of the failure of the secular experiment in the valley. Despite
attempts to camouflage the ground realities in Kashmir the facts speak that Kashmir has degraded into a
wild Muslim ghetto, it is being governed by the Muslim terrorists and their cohorts through their writs
and fatwas and it is the Islamic law that is enjoying precedence and supremacy and more than most
Kashmir has emerged as a theocratic state which is being funded and guarded on its frontiers by
Government of India. The people of India who appear to have been manipulated through propaganda
engineering have belatedly come to realise the secular experiment meeting its disaster in Kashmir. Even
Nehru himself was sceptical about the success of his experiment which had floundered on the Indian
plane but was giving it another trial in Kashmir. In his letter to P.N. Bazaz he writes," The real problem in
Kashmir is whether it continues as a secular state as the rest of India or not. This affects the whole of
India because secularism in India also has not got such a firm foundation as I would like it to have.
Anything happening in Kashmir will undoubtedly affect the rest of India with its vast Muslim
population." In such an uncertain and menacing situation when Kashmir is already in the Jaws of Muslim
communalists the Kashmiri Pandits have asserted their rights and claims to the homeland in valley
wherein democracy and catholicity with thrive and flower for the deviants to emulate. If Melapuram in
Kerala was carved out for Muslims to thrive and expand, why can't homeland in Kashmir be carved out
for Kashmiri Hindus to thrive and expand? Homeland emerges as an imperative to retain as much of area
as is possible with a view to consolidating all humanistic and democratic forces who are willing to settle
in it for patriotic considerations and demands. Homeland will emerge as a pocket of stiff resistance, not as
a pocket of compromise and acquiescence, against the Muslim frenzy that has been let loose to realise
another partition.
The Homeland Resolution envisages in unequivocal terms that the Kashmiri Pandits with their firm
commitments to the doctrine of live and let live and social unity cannot accept to live in a state which is
governed by Muslim preceptors openly preaching and propagating intolerance and religious hegemony.
As bitter enemies of religious fanaticism and myopic perspectives they abhor the Muslim majoritarianism
which fetters freedoms and shackles opportunities for growth and development on religious grounds.
They detest that state which is riddled with fanatics and enemy agents at every step of the total structure
assigned the role-model of decimating the remnants of the land of learning and wisdom that Kashmir once
was long ago. Kashmir is not Kashmir if it is denuded of Kashmiri Pandits who are a vital link between
the past and present of Kashmir. The opinion that has been floated by the Mushm vested interests and
picked up at many levels that Kashmiri Pandits can be sacrificed and murdered to retain Kashmir is
lacking in political sanity and prudence. Kashmir without Kashmiri Pandits is virtual acceptance of its
status as a Muslim state and another partition of the country with a deferred date.
The Homeland Resolution sums up:
They (Kashmiri Pandits) have not reacted to Muslim communalism, instead they have faced the rigours of
Muslim dominance with the fervent hope that the thrust on universal education and the scientific progress
in the state would pave way for the full flow of democratic thought, recognition of human rights, the
genuine urges and aspirations of Kashmiri Hindu minorities, religious tolerance, equity and justice. This
hope is now shattered. Neither his Muslim brethren in Kashmir nor the Indian Government which swears
by secularism came to the rescue of Kashmiri Hindus at the time when they were butchered and hounded
out of their homes and hearths, nor at this moment when they have been uprooted and thrown into
wilderness to face a life and death struggle for survival. All the constitutional guarantees for the
protection of their limb, life, property, their status and dignity have been trampled with impunity
Kashmiri Pandits have as much right to live in Kashmir as any other religious group.
The Kashmiri Pandits faced with the Muslim tyrannical order were neglected and hurled into the
backwaters of Kashmir political scenario which fact is conceded by a highly partisan writer like Gautam
Navlakha. He writes, "It goes without saying that the absence of a clearcut policy towards non-Muslims is
a shortcoming of the political leadership in Kashmir. It has seldom bothered to go beyond the generalities,
which only assuage the insecurity felt by Kashmiri Pandits."
As a result of intensified vilification campaign against Kashmiri Pandits and politically sponsored blatant
communal aggression launched upon them, a Jewish anthoropoligist Isaac Shamoun was obliged to
remark:
"This community is suppressed to the extent that its dignity as human beings is disfigured and its
personality debased making the community its worst enemy. Only such a community deserves to be lifted
upto the level of proud and dignified human beings.
As a response to the banishment and externment of the entire community the Homeland demand puts,
"Because of their equal rights to the land of their birth they stake their claim to be an equal partner to any
future deliberations in the process of normalization and ultimate solution of the problems."
48 C ha pte r 16 - S A N G R A M P O R A M A S S A C R E
As evidenced by the Sangrampora carnage it can be justifiably asserted that the naked dance of death and
destruction unleashed against the Kashmiri Pandits continues unabated and with impunity. The tall but
unbelievable claims made by rulers wielding political power and authority that terrorism ravaging the
state has been vanquished and stamped out stand debunked and put to rest. The occurrences of daily
encounters and increasing number of killings deflate the sails of propaganda and disinformation spree
floated and hyped by the Chief Minister and his charts. The valley is yet to be retrieved from the brutal
clutches of the Muslim terrorists and Doda continues to be reeling under the heels of gun-totting
desperadoes and the infiltration of waves of trained and armed terrorists has been stepped up in the border
districts of Poonch and Rajouri, thus lending new pitch and volume to the ongoing terrorism.
The cold-blooded slaughter of seven Kashmiri pandits inhabiting a tiny but distant hamlet of
Sangrampora in the District Badgam by the treacherous Kashmiri-speaking terrorists gone crazy in the
chase of Islamic goals sent shock waves into the Kashmiri Pandit refugees in distress and Diaspora. The
crime that they had committed was that they had not joined the ranks of fleeing refugees to escape the
Muslim brutalities and had chosen to stay back in a hostile society firmly glued to the Islamic agenda. Yet
they were put to a grisly carnage which had frightening range and contours. The Kashmiri Bandits in the
beginnings of insurgence and mayhem were tortured and killed in ones and two throughout the valley
thereby cleansing Kashmir of infidels. But the Sangrampora massacre was a holocaust that was
perpetrated on the Kashmiri Pandits in general and beleaguered Pandits in the valley in particular.
The dastardly and inhuman massacre did not earn full-throated condemnation on part of politicals who act
as hostages to their Muslims majoritarian identity based on the cocoon of insularity and deliberately
refuse to perceive beyond the eyelids of its set parameters. Under the motivations of Islamic
fundamentalism the mortgaged mentality of the Muslim politicals assumes extremely hostile and inimical
postures unto the religious minorities which is manifested through a relentless campaign of calumny and
vilification against them. Tolerance as an accepted canon has ceased to be and secularism necessitating
even-handed treatment of diverse religious groups is rejected thereby stabilizing the parochial politics
with communal under-pinnings. Shackled by such thinking and attitudinal changes, clitches and
compulsive words of sympathy were doled out with some insincere references to composite culture and
beaten-out secularism. There are Kashmiri pandits perhaps a siezable section among them who firmly
hold on to the view that they cannot and should not expect a fair deal from the political dispensation that
has come to power. The same dispensation betrayed them at the critical juncture of 1989- exodus and the
same formation is at the helm when the Sangrampora massacre was perpetrated with all its brutal
savagery. The prejudices, outmoded notions and malafide pulls remain and have not been dispensed with
for smoothening of relations between the majority and the minority for the achievement of desirable goals
of economic development and strengthening of democratic apparatus.
Despite tall claims of normalcy, the Sangrampora massacre establishes beyond any shadow of doubt that
the terrorists have not been marginalised and are still calling shots and Kashmiri pandits who Still dot
some localities and hamlets are not let off the hook and remain targets for killing besides canards and
disinformation to meet the strategic goals and political imperatives. The savagery that was let loose on
the. beleaguered Pandits incontrovertibly lays bare the Muslim motivations of liquidating and ethnically
cleansing the left-over elements of the religious enemies who have a saga of persecution and harassment
to relate. In fact, the Sangrampora massacre in the culmination of the entire process of exclusion,
decimation and ethnic cleansing which had started way back in 1947 under the dubious cover of socio-
economic reconstruction and regeneration. The security of Kashmiri Pandits in the valley in the totally
Islamised social, political and economic order cannot he ensured and guaranteed as the very presence of
Pandits is deemed to dismantle the Islamic state that is under the shaping out processes.
The hopless Pandits, budding and old, were brutally murdered to disperse the message that Kashmir as a
Muslim state purged of the vestiges of Hindu Kafirs remains paramount and cannot be compromised
with. The trumpet that was beaten about the return of natives was silenced through the gory and macabre
killing of persons, who had been left to their fate and fortune and were not provided a protective shield, a
fool proof security cover, even-though perpetually vulnerable. The desire on part of Pandits to return to
their natural abode in Kashmir was smothered and the same had suddenly burgeoned with a government
coming to saddle.
With the perpetration of death and destruction on the defenceless targets Muslim killers of the indigenous
brand which fact is testified to by the survivors of the victims made good their escape into safe havens
and have eluded arrest so far. It can be stated without fear or dither that they succeed to escape the noose
only with the connivance and tacit support of the perfidious elements that infest various levels of
governance. The staying back Pandits after the mass stampeding of their co-religionists had tied their lot
with the Muslim majority, submitted to its tyranny and accepted the status of servility in the hope that
they would be spared from the atrocity of being hounded Out and thus earn a reprieve. Little did they
know that the Muslim terrorists with tremendous support from Pakistan and emboldened by the
insensitivities and visceral hatred of the state government unto them were hatching conspiracies and
executing game-plans to drown them in a bloody holocaust through which they proved their high
potential to strike at will and exposed the falseness of the much-touted claims of Farooq Abdullah that
normalcy though elusive had already dawned and what was needed was to reinforce it zenith the return of
the exiled Pandits. But objectively normalcy is a self-created illusion on part of rulers who refuse to
realise that the ground realities are in conflict with their illusory perceptions. The nagging worry
obsessing the anti-insurgency operators and their command structures is that war waged by Kashmiri
Muslims has vet to exhibit convincing symptoms of diminishing and vanishmg levels of abatement.
The Sangrampora massacre has a telling message that the exiled Pandits who are accused as the betrayers
of the terrorist movement cannot return to their land of genesis even after the Muslims out of fatigue and
frustration decide upon normalizing conditions and investing them with a look of stability. It also puts the
fate of beleaguered Pandits in the valley in doldrums bringing it amply home to them that they can be
gobbled up any time by the Muslim hounds to satiate their ravenous thirst for the much-coveted blood of
Kafirs and cannot save their bacon. The two-pronged strategy that was achieved through the gory
massacre of Sangrampora was to stone-wall the return of natives and obliterate the last traces of Hindus in
Kashmir.
Without probing the entire gamut of the problem in depth and preparing a transparent blue-print some
futile and inconsequential shrill yells about the return of displaced Pandits proved a catalyst in the
Sangrampora massacre which re-affirmed the implaccable hatred of revival of socio-cultural milieu
informed of catholicity and resurrection of inter and intra-community trust and goodwill. The very idea of
transplantation of Kashmiri Pandits back into their original ambience is deemed as inimical to the Muslim
separatist instinct and separatist movement in the larger objective context. As part of a long range strategy
the Sangrampora carnage setting new records of mass massacre was enacted not only to reverse but abort
the measures though cosmetic and half-hearted to restore them in their habitations which Muslims have
wiped out and decimated. The discourse and agenda-setting Muslim think tank destructive in approach
and premis has amply made it known that Bud Shah in any case will neither be re-enacted nor resurrected
to fritter away the unprecedented gains to Islam in Kashmir with the cleansing of Hindus and their
heretical practices. The deep scars and concussion implanted on the ideological and cultural personality of
Kashmir are valued as Islamic gains which at all costs have to be consolidated and entrenched.
More than most the harrowing blood-bath at the distant outpost of Sangrampora has blasted the dubious
myth of Muslim tolerance as a vital ingredient of hazily defined Kashmiriyat which has been trumpeted
and glorified by Balraj Puri and men of his ilk. It has equally deflated the balloon of a sham that
Jagmohan as the State Governor conspired the migration of Kashmiri Pandits and armed conflict, internal
strife, violation of human rights and other hateful forms of violence were not the keel factors in inspiring
their mass exodus. What transports Balraj Puri into rapturous joy is that the All Parties Hurriyat
Conference has also condemned the killings at Sangrampora ignoring that the said-organisation as a
conglomerate of despicable, murderous and fanatic groups with communal fangs has initiated the doom
and destruction of Kashmir in general and Kashmiri Pandits in particular through export of Muslim youth
to the camps in POK, Afghanistan and Iran for arms training and indoctrination.
48.1 Kashmiri Pandit Protest
On 25th March, 1997 the Kashmiri Pandits in utter shock and anguish converged on the Rajendra Park in
Jammu and were vociferous in condemning the mass massacre of innocent Hindus who were presented to
the media inside and outside the country as models of defiance. A procession of twenty-five thousand
Kashmiri Pandits protesting against the wanton killings passed peacefully through the city thorough-fares
leading to the civil secretariat where as per plans a memorandum was to be presented to the Nero of
Kashmir whose father had dreamt of the state as his personal fiefdom. The demonstrators who were angry
and indignant raised anti-Farooq Abdullah slogans who as per his bistro Kashmir has been instrumental in
whipping up anti-Pandit hysteria through his frivolous and unsavoury statements and has been Justifiably
accused of shirking responsibility for protecting the unarmed patriotic citizens from the terrorist
onslaught. They raised anti-ISI and anti-Pakistan slogans as well. The demonstrators led by their sane
leaders had to face unprecedented columns of' police troops who resisted and thwarted their onward
march to the Civil Secretariat. Before negotiations could be concluded between the Hindu community
leaders and the police troops the latter pounced on the demonstrators in Nazi style fury and rage perhaps
at the behest of Nero himself. All demonstrators, men, women and children, were mercilessly beaten at
the Shalimar Crossing and Indira Chowk with lathis and rifle butts. Smoke-shells without number were
rained on the demonstrators with the intention to kill them. Some demonstrators, passers-by and scholars
returning from schools got trapped inside the Rameshwar Temple. The policemen under the orders of a
Muslim Officer gate-crashed into the Temple and kicked, beat & inflicted grievous injuries on the trapped
people. More than hundred rounds were fired in air and three hundred smoke-shells hurled on the
peaceful demonstrators. One hundred and fifty people including women were fatally wounded and eighty-
three of them bore severe head injuries. All the injured demonstrators were admitted to the Emergency
ward of the Medical College, Jammu for treatment. Scores of women injured in the brutal police action
included Kirti Kalla, Vice-President of ASKPC and Shyama Jee, an activist of Vishwa Hindu Parishad. A
young man was shifted to the Medical Institute in Chandigarh in an unconscious and critical state as he
was grievously wounded in the head.
The deputy commissioner on duty, an IAS officer, added a new feather to the Farooq Abdullah
Government when he in full public view was visibly seen hurling stones and shells on the demonstrating
mob of Kashmiri refugees.
On 26th March, 1997 the BJP issued a call for Jarmmu Bandh to register protest against the police action
on peaceful demonstrators in front of Civil Secretariat. The bandh-call vitas supported by all the Kashmiri
Pandit outfits and Jammu Organisations. Roopnagar, Janipur and Tope Sherkhan areas in Jammu emerged
as flash-points when bearded policemen and Kashmiri Pandits Were seen locking horns in ding-don"
battles lasting for hours togetllcr. The Muslim employees and their women-folk flanked be police troops
provoked the demonstrating Kashmiri Pandits for retaliatory acts. An SRTC bus used for transporting the
Muslim employees to the secretariat was said to hive been set on fire. There were some violent incidents
at Janipur said to be the aftermath of police provocation. The government quarters at Tope Sherkhan were
pelted at when Muslim women-folk yelled pro-Azadi and pro-Pakistan slogans. Some shops belonging to
the Kashmiri Muslims were put to flames when Muslim police desecrated a Temple. The residences of
Kashmiri Pandits were broken into, inmates kicked and beaten with lathis and rifle butts. Scores of
Pandits were fatally wounded. A retired INCAS officer was not spared either and was left with profusely
bleeding wounds. A budding boy was chased to the rooftop where he was caught, given merciless beating
and hurled down the roof leaving him with his legs broken. The Kashmiri Pandits, mostly students, who
were taken into custody were mercilessly beaten and let off reportedly after paying off huge sums of
money.
Without commenting upon the innards of the statement a UP legislator, Hans Raj Dogra, asked as to who
w as spilling the red blood of Muslims. Pat came the reply, "OUTSIDERS." "Outsides" is duplicitous in
intent and content, pregnant with double meaning which required to be divined and intuited.
At a function in the Central Hall of legislature the Chief Minister vented out his morbid wrath against tile
Kashmiri migrants (not displaced persons as per his statement in Bombay) for unleashing disinformation
against his plans (which he has none) for their return to the valley. He veiled his lungs out, "I am afraid
only of God arid not Kashmiri Pandits. I am not going to be scared about their processions and rallies.
Farooq Abdullah will do float is the demand of the situation."
A man in the gallery was heard whispering, "And demand of the situation is not to dispossess the grabbers
and looters of their landed estates and residential houses but to perpetuate the loot, grab and appropriation
of their left-behind properties and carry them not to their homes but to transit camps."
Farooq Abdullah sounded very secular with commitments to the restoration and revival of an ethos which
virtually is eroded and decimated when he dilated on the imperative of the return of Pandits so that bells
at KhirBhawani and Hari Parbhat were heard again.
Commenting upon his statement an elderly lawyer with tremendous political history and commitment to
secular ideology aptly put "it were better for the Chief Minister to institute a judicial probe into his own
contributions to the erosion and decimation of Kashmiri ethos which he feigns to lament and he should
answer as to why the bells of Bhairav Nath Temple in Srinagar have remained unrolled and unrung for the
last 30 years despite court directions and verdicts and if Pandits were vital to the Kashmiri ethos, why
were they labelled as Kafirs, targeted for rape and massacre and forced to flee the valley?".
48.4 Kashmiri Pandits decry the Chief Minister's Statement
The leaders of the Kashmiri Pandit organizations accused the Chief Minister of declaring war on the
minorities of the state. Terming his statement in the Legislative Assembly as superfluous and absurd, they
made it amply clear that their protests against the lapse of the government leading to the blood-bath at
Sangrampora had nothing to do with the dilution of the Muslim character of the state and what was
expected of the Chief Minister was that he should respect and perpetuate the healthy principles that
inform and regulate a participatory democracy leaving aside parochial views and devise and execute
measures to ameliorate the lot of displaced Pandits. Hitting the nail on the head they termed the brutal
slaughter of Kashmiri Pandits as a well-planned conspiracy to eject out the vestiges of Kashmiri Pandits
from the valley.
48.5 Kedar Nath Sahni's Statement
The eminent leader of Bhartiya Janata Party and in-charge Jammu and Kashmir affairs Kedar Nath Sahni
lashed out at Farooq Abdullah for making irresponsible statements about Jammu and Kashmir thus
adding complicacies to an already complex problem and tensions to an already tense political situation. In
a vigorous statement at Jammu he expressed his contempt at the communally tinted statement of the chief
minister that Jammu and Kashmir will always remain a Muslim majority state. He tailed to understand the
motivation that impelled him to issue such statements. He made it known that no fewer than ten
organisations had complained that there were moves afoot to metamorphose the population complexion of
Jammu.
The BJP leader having made his mark as a sagacious and astute politician spared no words in condemning
the brutal lathi charge on Kashmiri refugees and violent incidents at Top Sherkhan government quarters.
He saw a big conspiracy behind both the incidents and demanded a judicial probe to unravel it. He
castigated the government for its sheer failure in appreciating the psyche and problems of Kashmiri
Pandits and described the lathi charge as barbaric and inhuman.
He was astonished to learn about the Dcputv Commissioner on duty pelting stones on peaceful
demonstrators.
Exposing the canard that the Chief Minister was figmenting and disseminating about the unwillingness of
the Kashmiri Pandits to return to their native homes the BJP leader made it explicitly clear that they
would return only after safe and conducive conditions were created through the elimination of terrorist
menace ravaging Kashmir. He saw a sinister game-plan in the Sangrampora carnage which was to thwart
and pre-empt the return of the natives.
48.6 Fresh Exodus
The canard about the normalcy having been restored in Kashmir valley was tattered to shreds when scores
of Kashmiri Pandit families that had weathered the terrorist avalanche were forced to flee their native
homes and hearths for the woeful life as camp dwellers. The Sangrampora massacre opened a new
chapter of the exodus of Kashmiri Pandits which commenced in the wake of 1989 killings and warnings
to quit.
A number of causes with their cumulative effect can be attributed to the mass killings of Kashmiri Pandits
and subsequent wave of fresh exodus from the valley. There are observers who attribute it to the
irresponsible and worthless utterances of Farooq Abdullah about the displaced employees losing their
jobs and getting scored off the government registers in case they fail to join their duties back in the valley.
The hard and stark reality is that the landed properties, houses and even jobs on which they could have
joined have been arbitrarily, and illegally usurped and grabbed by the Muslims with absolute compliance
from the powers that be. There are many others who attribute the massacre and subsequent developments
to the rabid frustrations and desperation caused among pro-Pakistan terrorists who stand in a large
measure marginalised or eliminated through pro-India operatives. The commoners in general believe that
Farooq Abdullah through his vacillatory postures has not been able to put up a stiff resistance to the
terrorists who were encouraged and advised to cross borders for arms training by him only More so, he
has been dabbling in frivolous issues like " greater autonomy " and "pre-1953 status" there-by missing the
wood for the trees. There is a solid opinion that holds the Government of India responsible for the
massacre as it as a matter of policy has been attributing all killings of Kashmiri Pandits to ISI and
Pakistan thereby providing a shield to the local killers who arc responsible for the Sangrampora massacre.
Faronq Abdullah employed the same tactic when he held foreign mercenaries responsible for the blood-
bath.
The Hurriyat Conference leaders, better call them killers, as their hands are sullied with the blood of
Hindu Kafirs are not only suspicious of but opposed to the dialogue that India and Pakistan have initiated
at secretary level. With a view to frustrating the dialogue the unscrupulous Hurriyat leaders could have
master-minded the Sangrampora killings. As a matter of strategy the Hurriyat leaders do not want the
dialogue to fructify through the resolution of the entire spectrum of problems that have assumed a wider
dimension at the behest of a foreign U1trudcr that has its own geo-political game up its sleeves.
The residents of Sangrampora village even though the! were devastated through the mass Massacre had
no intentions of shifting to Jammu or elsewhere but had decided to stay on despite government neglect
and insensitivity. Inlet they could not stay on because of communal tension that was fuelled up and
aroused by the communal utterances of the Chief Minister. The Muslim neighbours nacho had earned
praises galore for tolerance and accommodation bluntly fated them to quit and before they abandoned
their natural habitat, they had to face social boycott. The terror that engulfed Sangrampora and adjoining
villages led to the exodus of twelve Kashmiri Pandit families residing in Lalgam village in the same
district. They have a saga of woes to relate.
48.7 RSS Chief's Statement in Jammu
The RSS Chief, Prof. Rajinder Singh, felt sect and shocked at the brutal treatment that was meted out to
Kashmiri Hindus languishing and wasting away in tooted colonies and other slums. He declared that
Kashmiri Hindus were not alone in their bitter struggle against terrorism but the entire nation was behind
them. In his address to the RSS cadres he bluntly asked as to how there could be communal harmony in a
country where three lakh Hindus were forced to buzz off their native houses to seek refuge in their own
state. He dilated upon the need to full protection and facilities to the migrants who had taken up refugee-
like life at Jammu.
48.8 Hizb Maligns Sagar
In sharp contradiction to the statement of Farooq Abdullah, Ali Mohammad Sagar, the Minister of State
for Home, held Hizbul Mujahideen responsible for the slaughter of Sangrampora Pandits. As per the
statement of the Hizbul Mujahideen, the fierce armed Muslim outfit, denied its involvement in the
incident and added that "malgning Hizbul Mujahideen in the tragic incident was sheer desperation on part
of Sagar. Sager attributing the killings to the Hizb was only disseminating lies and his history in politics
was that of a hooligan and rabble rouser" the statement added.
The Hizbul Mujahidden statement said that the government and the security agencies have been at cross-
purposes making contradictory statements with respect to the involvement of the Muslim militants in the
incident. The security agencies laid the blame on the Hizb by making a reference to the wireless message
that was intercepted by them. But the army held Lashkar-e-Toiba responsible for the mass massacre and
again the foreign militants gunned down in an encounter at Badgam were said to have been involved in
the gruesome killings.
Holding the government agencies responsible for the killings, the Hizb statement claimed that it did not
believe in killing innocent and unarmed civilians as it was engaged in a holy (unholy) war where there is
no place for killing innocents .
48.9 Officials Hate Pandits
A five-member team visited Srinagar and Budgam districts to probe into the gruesome massacre of
Kashmiri Pandits by the Muslim terrorists battling for secession and total Islamisation of Kashmir. The
members of the team in a press conference stated that bureaucratic militancy areas the biggest hurdle in
the normalization processes in Kashmir and the senior officers wielding levers of power not only
harboured bitter and despicable feelings against the Kashmiri Bandits but in fact were out to torpedo any
attempt by the Government or any section of Kashmiri society to encourage the return of the natives.
They could not meet the Deputy Commissioner of Srinagar to know from him about the plight of the
staying-back Pandits as he refused to give them an audience. They claimed that National Conference
workers though their numbers had considerably depleted were operating in league with militants. They
also blamed the government for concealing facts about the security scenario in Kashmir and said that
seven Kashmiri Pandits were butchered by Hizbul Mujahideen terrorists and not by foreign mercenaries
as was being claimed and given out by the government in power.
49 R E F E R E N C E S a n d N O T E S
1. Jonraj, Rajtarangini
2. A.Q. Rafiqui (Dr), Sufism-in Kashmir, Bhartiva Publishing House, New Delhi P.17, P.N.K Bamzai,
History of Kashmir, Delhi, P.317
3. M. L.Koul, Kashmir, Past and Present, unravelling the mystique, Sehyog Prakashan, New Delhi, 1994,
P.8
4. P.N.K. Bamzai, History of Kashmir, P 525
5. Bahristan-i-Shahi, trans. by K.N. Pandita (Dr. ), Firma Kandm, Calcutta, P.36
6. P.N.K Bamzai, History of Kashmir, P 527
7. A.Q. Rafiqui (Dr), Sufism in Kashmir, P 34
8. ibid, P. 77
9. ibid, P 39
10. Ibid, P 75, 80-1
11. ibid, P 209-10
12. M.L. Koul, Kashmir, Past and Present, uravelling the mystique, P 10
13. A. Q. Rafiqui (Dr), Sufism in Kashmir, P 82
14. Ibid, P 39
15. Ibid, P 82
16. M.L. Koul, Kashmir, Past and Present, unravelling the mystique P 11
17. P.N.K. Bazai, Historv of Kashmir, P 611
18. R.K. Parimu (Dr.), Musldn Rule in Kashmir, People's Publishing House, P.112
19. A.Q. Rafiqi (Dr), Sufism in Kashmir, P 88
20. Baharistan-i-Shahi, trans. by K.N. Pandita (Dr.), P.36
21. A. Q. Rafiqui (Dr.) Sufism in Kashmir, P 88
22. Ibid ,P 88
23. Ibid, P 84
24. Ibid, P 85
25. P.N.K. Bamzai, History of Kashmir, P 526
26. A.Q. Rafiqui, (Dr), Sufism in Kashmir, P 37
27. PN.K. Bamzai, History of Kashmir, P 528
28. P.N. Bazaz, History of the struggle for freedom in Kashmir P 83-86
29. P.N.K. Bamzai, History of Kashmir, P 527
30. A.Q. Rafiqui, Sufism in Kashmir, P 137
31. Ibid, P 39.
32. Bilhan, Vikramankdeva Charitam, Canto 18.
33. Girl Lal Jain, Hindu Phenomenon, P 64
34. A.Q. Rafiqui (Dr) Sufism in Kashmir, P 238
35. Girl Lal Jain, Hindu Phenomenon, P 5
36. P.N. Bazaz, History of the struggle for freedom in Kashmir, P 203
37. Pratap Chander, Hindu Mind, P 59 Quoted from Arnlod Toyenbee, A Study of Historv
38. Girl Lal Jain, Hindu Phenomenon, P 5
159. Ibid
160. Ibid
161. Kohli Commission Report suppressed by the Government was never placed on the table of the
House.
162. P.N. Bazaz, Kashmiri Pandit Agitation
163. Wail of the Vale, issued by Hindu Action Committee, 1967
164. Ibid
165. Ibid
166. P.N. Bazaz, Kashmiri Pandit Agitation, 1967
167. Ibid
168. P.L. Koul, Crisis in Kashmir,
169. A Memorandum of Respectable (Muslim) citizens of Kashmir submitted to the Home Minister of
India, Y.B. Chavan
170. Ibid
171. Interview with Amar Nath Vaishnavi, President All State Kashmiri Pandit Sabha
172. P.N. Bazaz, Kashmiri Pandit Agitation,1967
173. Pir Giyasudin, Main Trends of History of Kashmir Freedom Struggle
174. P.N. Bazaz, The History of the struggle for Freedom in Kashmir, P.154
175. R.K. Koul, Quest for Responsible Government
176. M.L. Koul, Kashmir, Past and Present, unravelling the mystique P.149, P.L. Koul, Crisis in Kashmir,
P.260, Narendra Sehgal, 149 Dharmantarit Kashmir, P.244
177. Ibid
178. Interview with locals
179. Anantnag Prabandak Committee Resolution
180. Kashmir Ki Vedana (Hind)); Genocide in Kashmir
181. Interview with locals
182. P.N. Bhat, Truth Foretold, P.72
183. Kashmir, Past and Present, unravelling the mystique, P.148