Doi BLM and SLC Land Exchange Moa 5 2012
Doi BLM and SLC Land Exchange Moa 5 2012
Doi BLM and SLC Land Exchange Moa 5 2012
INTRODUCTION
This Memorandum of Agreement ("MOA") is between the United States Department of the
Interior ("DOl"), Bureau of Land Management ("BLM"), and the California State Lands
Commission ("CSLC") (collectively referred to as "Pat1ies", and each individually as a "Pat1y").
The purpose of this MOA is to facilitate the exchange of selected California School Lands under
the jurisdiction of the CSLC for selected federal lands under the jurisdiction of the DOl, BLM
consistent with each Party's land tenure objectives, including, but not limited to, consolidating
lands held by the State of California into contiguous parcels suitable for developing renewable
energy projects.
I. PARTIES
The following officials are executing this MOA as representatives of their respective agencies:
II. AUTHORITY
A. BLM's authority to enter into this MOA is section 307b of the Federal Land Policy and
Management Act of 1976 (FLPMA) (43 U.S.C. 1737). Exchanges contemplated in this
MOA would be completed under the authority of section 206 of the FLPMA (43 U.S.c.
1716) and/or section 707(a) of the California Desert Protection Act of 1994 (16 U.S.c.
4IOaaa-77).
B. California State Lands Commission: Chapter 2 of Division 7.7 of the Public Resources
Code.
JJJ. DEFINITIONS
"School Lands" means lands, or interests in lands, granted to the state of California by an Act of
Congress, March 3, 1853 (Ch. 145, 10 Stat. 244), for the specific purpose of providing support
for the public schools, and acts related thereto.
MEMORANDUM OF AGREEMENT RELATING TO LAND EXCHANGES TO CONSOLIDATE LAND PARCELS BETWEEN THE UNITED STATES
DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR, BUREAU OF LAND MANAGEMENT, AND THE CALIFORNIA STATE LANDS COMMISSION
PAGEIOF9
IV. BACKGROUND
In 1994, Congress passed the California Desert Protection Act of 1994 (Public Law 103-433)
(CDPA). The following sections of the CDPA direct the Secretary of the Interior to:
1. Section 702 (16 U.S.C. 410aaa-72): "In preparing land tenure adjustment
decisions with the California Desert Conservation Area, of the Bureau of Land
Management, the Secretary shall give priority to consolidating Federal ownership
within the national park units and wilderness areas designated by this Act."
2. Section 707(a) (16 U.S.C. 410aaa-77a): "Upon request of the California State
Lands Commission the Secretary shall enter into negotiations for an agreement to
exchange Federal lands or interests therein on the list referred to in subsection
(b)(2) of this section for California State School lands or interests therein which
are located within the boundaries of one or more of the wilderness areas or park
system units designated by this Act. The Secretary shall negotiate in good faith to
reach a land exchange agreement consistent with the requirements of section 206
of the Federal Land Policy and Management Act of 1976"
The Governor of the State of California issued Executive Order S-14-08 (November 17, 2008),
establishing a state policy goal of producing thirty-three percent of California's electrical needs
with renewable energy resources by 2020. In 2011, the California Legislature enacted and the
Governor signed legislation (SBX2-Simitian, Chapter I, Statutes of 20 I I) adopting the thirty-
three percent by 2020 standard. A substantial number of renewable energy projects are required
for California to meet this directive, as well as to achieve the state's climate change goals of
reducing greenhouse gases in the atmosphere.
The Secretary of the Interior's Secretary's Order 3285AI, amended February 22, 2010,
establishes a policy encouraging the production, development and delivery of renewable energy
as one of the Department's highest priorities. The Secretary directed agencies and bureaus
within the Department to work collaboratively with each other, and with other Federal agencies,
departments, states, local communities, and private landowners to encourage the timely and
reasonable development of renewable energy and associated transmission while protecting and
enhancing the nation's water, wildlife, and other natural resources. On January 27, 2012, the
Secretary of the Interior and the Governor of the State of California entered into a Memorandum
of Understanding which directs California agencies and Department of the Interior agencies to
take the necessary actions to further the implementation of Assembly Bill 32 and SBX2 and the
Secretary's Order 3285A I in a cooperative, collaborative, and timely manner.
Concurrent with the Governor's Executive Order S-14-08, The California Department of Fish
and Game ("CDFG") and the California Energy Commission ("CEC") created the Renewable
MEMORANDUM OF AGREEMENT RELATING TO LAND EXCHANGES TO CONSOLIDATE LAND PARCELS BETWEEN THE UNITED STATES
DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR. BUREAU OF LAND MANAGEMENT. AND THE CALIFORNIA STATE LANDS COMMISSION
PAGE 2 oF9
Energy Action Team ("REAT") through the "Memorandum of Understanding Between the
California Energy Commission and the California Department of Fish and Game Regarding the
Establishment of the Renewable Energy Action Team" (November 17, 2008). Additionally,
CDFG, CEC, BLM, and the United States Fish and Wildlife Service ("'USFWS") (collectively,
"REAT Agencies") have committed to a cooperative relationship to achieve shared energy policy
goals through the "Memorandum of Understanding Between the California Department of Fish
and Game, the California Energy Commission, the Bureau of Land Management, and the U.S,
Fish and Wildlife Service Regarding the Establishment of the California Renewable Energy
Action Team (November 17,2008). [n signing the second Memorandum of Understanding, the
state and federal agencies sought, among other things, to develop renewable energy projects in
an environmentally responsible manner within the Mojave and Colorado Desert Regions, and to
establish the Desert Renewable Energy Conservation Plan ("'DRECP"). The DRECP is
scheduled to be completed in 2013, and will guide renewable energy project siting in the DRECP
Planning Area to ensure the optimum development of renewable energy resources while
providing maximum protection of California's environment.
The CSLC has management jurisdiction of approximately 322,000 acres of School Lands within
the DRECP Planning Area; therefore, the CSLC's extensive holdings in the DRECP Planning
Area provide unique opportunities for the REAT Agencies to simplify land acquisitions for both
renewable energy projects, as well as mitigation efforts. Recognizing that the renewable energy
development and environmental protection goals of the REAT Agencies and the DRECP were
compatible with, and furthered the management objectives of the CSLC for School Lands within
the DRECP Planning Area, the CSLC signed a Memorandum of Understanding with the REAT
Agencies in September 2011 (Memorandum of Understanding Between the California
Department of Fish and Game, The California Energy Commission, The Bureau of Land
Management, The U,S. Fish and Wildlife Service, and The California State Lands Commission
Regarding Participation and Engagement in The California Renewable Energy Action Team and
The Desert Renewable Energy Conservation Plan).
[n October, 2011, the California Legislature enacted, and the Governor signed working
legislation (Ch. 485 Statutes of 20 I I, AB 982-Skinner (commencing with Public Resources
Code Section 8700». This legislation directs the CSLC to engage in a cooperative effort with the
DOl through the BLM to exchange fragmented School Lands with existing federal lands in the
state of California to consolidate School Land parcels into contiguous holdings suitable for the
development of renewable energy-related projects. The majority of the approximately 322,000
acres under the jurisdiction of the CSLC in the DRECP Planning Area are fragmented and
isolated such that the size of the individual parcels is insufficient for development of renewable
energy projects. In addition, a significant portion of these parcels are located within national
parks, preserves, monuments, and forests. Although such lands retain significant conservation
value, their location limits development potential.
MEMORANDUM OF AGREEMENT RELATING TO LAND EXCHANGES TO CONSOLIDATE LAND PARCELS BETWEEN THE UNITED STATES
DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR, BUREAU OF LAND MANAGEMENT. AND THE CALIroRNIA STATE LANDS COMMISSION
PAGE30F9
V. PURPOSE AND AGENCY OBJECTIVES
Generally, the CLSC's objective, as provided in AB 982, is to consolidate School Lands into
contiguous holdings suitable for renewable energy related projects. To accomplish this, the
CSLC desires to acquire federal lands which are suitable for siting large-scale renewable energy
projects, or suitable for mitigation efforts linked to large-scale renewable energy projects or
which otherwise have potential to generate revenue for the State Teachers' Retirement System.
In exchange for the federal lands described above, the CSLC general objective is to convey
School Lands which have limited potential to produce revenue.
The BLM's objective is to acquire School Lands within the national park units and wilderness
areas designated by the CDPA and within other designated areas identified for acquisition based
on BLM's approved land use plans and plan amendments. In exchange for the School Lands
described above, the BLM's general objective is to convey federal lands which are not
considered suitable for long term management as public lands.
In addition to using the exchange process described in this MOA, the Parties may also, at their
sole discretion, use their respective authority under state and federal law to process sales and
acquisitions to accomplish the land tenure objectives described above.
A. To work together to develop exchange proposals which meet each Party's respective
exchange objectives.
B. Either Party may develop and submit exchange proposals for further consideration.
C. That, generally, future conveyances under this agreement would include all of the
Parties' respective interests in the lands, including the mineral estates.
D. To make available for review and inspection any record relating to conditions which
may affect the value or desirability of lands to be exchanged. Such conditions
include, but are not limited to: mineral potential, hazardous materials or conditions,
MEMORANDUM OF AGREEMENT RELATING TO LAND EXCHANGES TO CONSOLIDATE LAND PARCELS BETWEEN THE UNITED STATES
DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR, BUREAU OF LAND MANAGEMENT, AND THE CALIFORNIA STATE LANDS COMMISSION
PAGE40F9
unexploded ordinance, and existing leases or other known encumbrances on lands to
be exchanged.
E. To cooperate to the highest degree practical to streamline the land exchange process
pursuant to this agreement. In so doing the Parties agree to share information
including, but not limited to School Land mapping, information concerning areas
with high conservation value, information concerning land with strong potential for
development of alternative energy projects. The Parties may also utilize existing data
promulgated by the REAT Agencies in connection with the DRECP where necessary
or useful for the purposes of this MOA.
F. The CSLC agrees to prepare and submit to the BLM, within 240 days of the
execution of this MOA, a proposal for one or more land exchanges consistent with
the objectives of this MOA and Chapter 2 of Division 7.7 of the Public Resources
Code, and that further the policies and directives of the CSLC. The BLM agrees to
give priority to this proposal and streamline the exchange process to the extent
practical and reasonable. The BLM, to the extent practical, will provide CSLC with a
list of federal lands (consistent with the list identified in 16 U.S.C. 410aaa-77(b))
under BLM's jurisdiction offered for exchange to facilitate the CSLC's proposal.
Such list may be populated with parcels selected by the BLM which may otherwise
further federal policies, directives, or similar agendas. Although the CSLC will not
be obligated to choose parcels only from such a list, it is understood and agreed the
purpose of such a list is to offer federal lands which BLM has made a preliminary
determination are suitable for exchange to the CSLC.
G. Although AB 982 directs the CLSC to propose acre-for-acre exchanges the BLM
currently has no legal authority to exchange lands on an acre-for-acre basis.
Therefore, the Parties agree to propose and process exchanges consistent with section
206 of the FLPMA (43 U.S.C. 1716), and, if applicable, consistent with section 707
of the CDPA (16 U.S.C. 410aaa-77(a)), unless future federal legislation allows
otherwise. BLM is required by section 206 ofFLPMA (43 U.S.C. l7l6(b) )to ensure
that: ".. values of the lands exchanged ... shall be equal, or if they are not equal, the
values shall be equalized by the payment of money .... so long as payment does not
exceed 25 per centum of the total value of the lands or interests transferred out of
Federal ownership. When appraising the values of the lands in any exchange, the
Parties shall comply with applicable state and federal appraisal standards, including
those found at 43 Code of Federal Regulations 2201.3. The Parties shall cooperate in
the preparation of appraisal instructions and review of contract appraisals. The
completion of any specific exchange is dependent on the Par1ies reaching an
MEMORANDUM OF AGREEMENT RELA TlNG TO LAND EXCHANGES TO CONSOLIDATE LAND PARCELS I3ETWEEN THE UNITED STATES
DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR, BUREAU OF LAND MANAGEMENT. AND THE CALIFORNIA STATE LANDS COMMISSION
PAGESOF9
agreement on the value of the lands to be exchanged based on appraisals of the lands
involved.
H. The Parties agree to use the DRECP and any other additional pertinent data sources
including other planning documents to identify federal lands suitable for exchange to
the CSLC.
A. If, after due consideration, the Parties mutually agree to proceed with a specific
exchange proposal, they shall enter into a nonbinding agreement to initiate a land
exchange, as required and described at 43 Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) 2201.1.
The agreement shall include a description of the lands being considered for exchange,
a description of the appurtenant rights, authorized uses, title defects or encumbrances,
a time schedule for completing the exchange, an assignment of responsibilities and
costs for processing the exchange, and a notice of any known hazardous substances
on the lands and any commitments for remedial actions. Exchanges which would
involve the acquisition of School Lands by the U.S. which are within an area under
the administrative jurisdiction of a federal agency other than the BLM (National Park
Service, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service or the U.S. Forest Service), would be
subject to the consent and agreement of the other federal agency.
B. Upon completion of all exchange processing steps, including but not limited to
envirorunental analyses, appraisals, and all other supporting studies and requirements
to determine if a proposed exchange is in the public interest and in compliance with
appl icable law and regulations, the Parties shall have full discretion to decide whether
to approve an exchange proposal. CSLC staff will present the proposed exchange,
along with the staffs recommendation, to the CSLC for its consideration at a properly
noticed public meeting. If BLM approves an exchange, a notice of the availability of
the decision approving the exchange must be published and distributed consistent
with 43 CFR 2201.7.
C. After the CSLC and BLM approve an exchange, the Parties may enter into a legally
binding exchange agreement as provided by 43 CFR 2201.7-2. The binding exchange
agreement shall include, but not be limited to the following items:
MEMORANDUM OF AGREEMENT RELATING TO LAND EXCHANGES TO CONSOLIDATE LAND PARCELS BETWEEN THE UNITED SlATES
DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR. BUREAU OF LAND MANAGEMENT, AND THE CALIFORNIA STATE LANDS COMMISSION
PAGE 6 OF 9
I. A description of the lands and interests to be exchanged and all reserved and
outstanding interests, the amount of any necessary cash equalization, and other tenns and
conditions of the exchange;
3. A description of the costs, if any, which the noncomplying party is liable in the
event of failure to perform or to comply with the terms of the exchange agreement; and
A. Nothing in this MOA is intended to, or shall be construed to limit or affect in any way
the authority or legal responsibilities of BLM or CSLC. Specifically, nothing in this
MOA shall imply that any signatory is in any way abrogating or ceding any
responsibility or authority inherent in its control or trusteeship over land or natural
resources. CSLC's approval authority or discretion over any proposal or
development affecting its School Lands shall not be limited by this MOA.
B. Nothing in this MOA binds BLM or CSLC to perform beyond their respective
authorities.
C. Nothing in this MOA requires BLM or CSLC to assume or expend any funds 111
D. The mission requirements, funding, personnel, and other priorities of BLM or CSLC
may affect their respective abilities to fully implement all of the provisions identified
in this MOA.
E. othing in this MOA is intended to or shall be construed to restrict BLM, or the State
of California, whether through CSLC or other agencies or departments, from
participating in similar activities or arrangements with other public or private
agencies, organizations, or individuals.
F. Any information furnished between the Parties under this MOA is potentially subject
to the Freedom of Information Act, 5 U.S.C § 552, el seq. ("FOlA") and the
California Public Records Act, Gov. Code §6250, el seq. ("CPRA"). The Parties
agree to consult one another prior to releasing potentially privileged or exempt
MEMORANDUM OF AGREEMENT RELATING TO LAND EXCHANGES TO CONSOLIDATE LAND PARCELS BETWEEN THE UNITED STATES
DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR, BUREAU OF LAND MANAGEMENT. AND THE CALIFORNIA STATE LANDS COMMISSION
PAGE 7 OF 9
documents and to cooperate in good faith to assert all such privileges and exemptions
permined by ForA and CPRA.
G. Each and every provision in this MOA is subject to the laws of the State of
California, the laws of the United States of America, and to the delegated authority
assigned in each instance.
H. All cooperative work under the provision s of the MOA will be accomplished without
discrimination against any employee because of race, sex, creed, color, or national
ongm.
J. This MOA shall become effective upon signature by the Parties. This MOA may be
executed in one or more counterparts, each of which will be considered an original
document. The effective date shall be the date of the last signature as shown below,
excepting subsequent amendments and addition of counterparts.
K. This MOA shall be in effect from the date of execution unti I terminated by one or
both of the Parties. If one of the Parties terminates the agreement, that Party shall
give the other Party at least 30 days advance written notice of termination. At any
time that the Parties determine that the purposes set forth in this MOA have been
satisfied, the MOA may be terminated. In the event either Party withdraws from the
MOA, such withdrawal will result in termination of the agreement.
L. This MOA is intended to facilitate cooperation among the Parties. It is not a contract
for acquisition of supplies or services; it is not legally enforceable; and it does not
create any legal obligation of or between any of the Parties or create any private right
or cause of action for by any person or entity.
M. othing in this MOA may be the basis of any third party challenges or appeals.
othing in this MOA creates any rights or causes of action in persons not parties to
this agreement.
This MOA supersedes and replaces in their entirety, the following, and only the following
agreements between the BLM and the CSLC executed following passage of the CDPA in 1994:
The primary points of contact for carrying out of the provisions of this MOA are:
x. APPROVALS
'1
UA'! , 2012
Curtis L. Fossum
Executive Officer
MEMORANDUM OF AGREEMENT RELATING TO LAND EXCHANGES TO CONSOLIDATE LAND PARCELS BETWEEN THE UNITED STATES
DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR, BUREAU OF LAND MANAGEMENT, AND THE CALIFORNIA 5TATE LANDS COMMISSION
PAGE90F9