Amercool - Basics of Air Cooled Heat Exchangers Rev1
Amercool - Basics of Air Cooled Heat Exchangers Rev1
Amercool - Basics of Air Cooled Heat Exchangers Rev1
of
Air Cooled
Heat Exchangers
Table of Contents
Finned Tubes 16
The Air-cooled heat exchanger is a device for rejecting heat from a fluid or gas directly to
ambient air. When cooling both fluids and gases, there are two sources readily available,
with a relatively low cost, to transfer heat to…..air and water.
The obvious advantage of an air cooler is that it does not require water, which means that
equipment requiring cooling need not be near a supply of cooling water. In addition, the
problems associated with treatment and disposal of water have become more costly with
government regulations and environmental concerns. The air-cooled heat exchanger
provides a means of transferring the heat from the fluid or gas into ambient air, without
environmental concerns, or without great ongoing cost.
An air-cooled heat exchanger can be as small as your car radiator or large enough to
cover several acres of land, as is the case on air coolers for large power plants where
water is not available.
The applications for air cooled heat exchangers cover a wide range of industries and
products, however generally they are used to cooler gases and liquids when the outlet
temperature required is greater than the surrounding ambient air temperature.
The only common thread among these users is the need to reject heat from a source into
the air. Some of these applications also use the discharge air from the air cooler to help
heat buildings or other equipment.
The basic heat transfer relationships that exist for shell and tube exchangers also apply to
the design of an air-cooled heat exchanger. However, there are more parameters to be
considered in the design of an air-cooled exchanger.
Since the air-cooled heat exchanger is exposed to changing climatic conditions, problems
of control of the air cooler become relevant. A decision must be made as to what the
actual ambient air temperature to be used for the design.
Some of the governing factors in the design of the air cooler are:
Tube diameter
Tube length
Fin height
Number of tube rows
Number of passes
Face area
Horsepower availability
Plot area
Since there are many variables, normally there many solutions, however the designer
attempts to find the optimum economic design given these factors.
Q = U * A * MTD
where
Normally, this equation is solved for the surface area or A, since the heat load is known,
and the over-all heat transfer coefficient and the MTD can be calculated, based on known
information.
To calculate the sensible heat load Q in Btu/hr, the following equation must be
followed:
Q = m * Cp * (Ti – To)
Where
The following formula can be used to calculate the lb/hr of a gas stream given in
MMSCFD and the lb/hr of a liquid given in GPM.
A correction factor is then added to the MTD to account for different row/pass
configurations.
where
U = 1/R
The effective outside film coefficient, in terms of tube surface, is the true air film
coefficient multiplied by the ratio of total surface to tube surface and by fin efficiency.
The inside film coefficient is depends on tube size, velocity of the liquid or gas in the
tubes and various physical properties of the fluid, such as the viscosity.
The inside fouling factor is dependent on the dirt or scale characteristics of the liquid or
gas in the tubes.
The outside fouling factor, based on tube surface, must be divided by the surface ratio,
(bare to finned) which results in a very small figure, negligible in most cases.
The thickness of the tube is normally small enough with sufficiently high conductivity
that this factor is almost negligible.
Vertical air cooled Heat exchangers, while shaped differently have the same
components as needed on the horizontal air cooler, as indicated in the diagram below:
Air Cooled Heat Exchangers can be built in several configurations, normally controlled
by the power available, the installation and customer preferences.
Diagrams of the various types of air coolers are indicated on the following pages. There
are many similar configurations by different manufacturers, however most of these are a
derivative of one of these types.
The most common type of air cooler is the horizontal coil with horizontal fan and vertical
air flow. This type is typically driven by an electric motor drive attached to the fan
through v-belts to allow for speed reduction between the motor and the fan. This model
can also be driven by hydraulic motors, air motors and even from an engine with special
right angle gear drive arrangements.
The normal application for these models are in plants or refineries where electric power is
available, and where the cooler is installed away from other equipment to allow adequate
air flow around the air cooler.
This model is built in both induced draft and forced draft configurations. Depending on
the application, and the installation site, there are advantages and disadvantages to both
models. Some of the advantages and disadvantages of each model are listing below:
Advantages Advantages
Disadvantages Disadvantages
1. Less uniform distribution of air over 1. Higher horsepower since fan is in outlet
the bundle. air stream.
2. Increased possibility of air recirculation. 2. Mechanical equipment subjected to
higher temperatures.
3. Low natural draft capability on fan 3. Fans are less accessible for maintenance.
failure.
4. Exposure of coils to sun, rain, etc. 4. Plenums must be removed to replace
bundles.
Another common configuration of air cooler is the vertical air cooler. This model typical
consists of bundles stacked vertically, with a vertical fan, and intake air flow from a
horizontal direction. Different models may have air flow turning to discharge vertically,
air flow horizontal, or bundles mounted at an angle to the fan.
This model was developed for applications where the fan was driven from an engine and
the cooler was skid mounted with other equipment. This is the typical application for
engine driven skid mounted gas compressors and generator sets. It is common for the
cooler to be utilized, not only as a radiator for the engine, but to include gas or air cooler
for the compressor.
Typically, these coolers are v-belt driven from a natural gas or diesel engine, however
most manufacturers also build this model with electric motor drivers.
Again, this configuration is available in both forced and induced draft, with both models
having advantages and disadvantages dependent on the application.
Advantages Advantages
Disadvantages Disadvantages
1. Less uniform distribution of air over 1. Higher horsepower since fan is in outlet
the bundle. air stream.
2. Accessibility of bundles for replacement 2. Lifting is difficult since all of the weight
is difficult is in the front of the cooler.
3. Discharge air is at a lower velocity, 3. Fans are less accessible for maintenance.
since it comes off of the coils.
4. Exposure of coils to sun, rain, due 4. More susceptible to hot air recirculation
to slope of bundles. due to lower intake air velocity.
In applications where power is not available, Natural draft coolers can be utilized for
some applications. This design is based on the air cooler bundle generating it’s own air
flow, either from natural crosswinds, or from the air flow created when the hot air rises
from the bundle, and the cooler air replaces it.
Natural draft coolers can be built in a variety of configurations, including models with
horizontal coils, vertical coils and units utilizing stacks to provide additional means of
generating air flow across the coils.
The tube bundle or coil is designed and manufactured as an assembly of tubes, headers,
tube supports, and side frames that assembled allowed the entry and exit of the fluid or
gas into a series of tubes for cooling purposes. Usually, the tube surface has aluminum
fins to added extended surface area to compensate for the low heat transfer rate of air at
atmospheric pressure.
A typical tube bundle is shown below with the different components shown:
The coil or bundle in the air-cooled heat exchanger is an assembly of tubes, headers, side
frames and tube supports as shown in the figure on the next page. Usually the tube
surface exposed to the passage of air has extended surface in the form of aluminum fins
to compensate for the low heat transfer rate of air.
The box header is normally fabricated from plate, and consists of a tube sheet, plug
sheet, top and bottom wrappers, and end plates. In a standard box header configuration,
holes must be drilled and tapped in the plug sheet opposite each tube to allow
maintenance of the tubes. A plug, normally a shoulder plug with a gasket, is threaded
into each hole to seal under pressure, but allow access when required.
Partitions, or pass plates are welded into the headers to establish the tube side flow
pattern. The tube side flow pattern is determined by maximizing the inside tube
velocities; within the pressure drop limits imposed. Pass plates can also be used as
structural stays of the tube and plug sheets, in some configurations.
Within practical limits, the longer the tubes and the greater the number of rows, the less
the surface area cost per square foot. One or more bundles can be combined on a
common structure, assuming all bundles have the same airside static pressure loss.
The bundles must be designed with at least one floating header to allow for thermal
expansion of the tubes. Failure to provide for thermal expansion, could result in
problems with the tube-to-tube sheet joint, since the thermal expansion will attempt to
push the tube into the header box, loosening the expanded tube-to-tube sheet joint.
Tubes are generally expanded into the holes in the tube sheet of the header box. The
expansion process can be done utilizing a grooved tube sheet hole or a smooth inside tube
sheet hole. In high pressure or high temperature applications, the grooved tube sheet hole
is preferred due to the additional strength provided. The expanded tube-to-tube sheet
joint has been utilized in services up to 15,000 psi design pressures. In some cases,
welded tube-to-tube sheet joints may be required.
Once installed in the bundle, the tubes must be supported to prohibit intermeshing of the
fins, and “bunching” of the tubes, which allows for openings in the tube that allow
channeling of the airflow. Several means of tube support are utilized dependent on
manufacture.
The most common tube support is provided by a “wiggle strip” that is place between each
row, and runs between each tube. This method allow for support of the tube from the fin
tip and is susceptible to movement in the bundle during transportation.
A third method is the scalloped channel. This method provides a strip, normally
fabricated from aluminum that cradles each tube and runs the entire width of the bundle.
The scalloped channel is formed to provide both supports from the fin tip, and to the tube
wall. Based on the configuration, it is not able to move after inserted, and also provides a
means of keeping the tubes spaced properly.
Tube support can also be provided by cast zinc collars. This method requires a zinc
collar to be poured at each support spot on the tube. This method, while providing
excellent support, is normally cost prohibitive.
The tubes are normally round and can be produced to almost any metal suitable for the
process. Tube material is selected based on the corrosion, pressure and temperature
limitations of the material in the process it is exposed.
Fins are normally helical wound aluminum fins. Aluminum material is used for reasons
of good thermal conductivity and economy of fabrication. The normal aluminum
material used is 1100-00 due to its relatively low cost and superior thermal conductivity.
Fins can be produced from other materials including copper, steel and stainless steel.
Copper is normally used in offshore or marine environments when the airside
environment is corrosive enough to justify the cost increase associated with copper
material. Steel and stainless steel is normally used for very high temperature
applications.
Fin Types
The most common fin type utilized in the air-cooled heat exchanger design is the L-
footed tension wound aluminum fin. The fin is produced by wrapping an aluminum strip,
that is footed at the base, around the tube. This process is done by holding tension on the
fin at all times. The ends of the fins are stapled to prohibit the aluminum fin from
unraveling, and loosing the contact between the fin foot and the tube. This contact is
critical to the operation of the air cooler, since the heat is transferred from the tube wall,
through the fin, to the surrounding ambient air.
Extruded
For applications where atmospheric corrosion is critical, the extruded fin tube provides
the best protection.
There are several other types of fin that are similar to the above fin types:
Again, this process is very similar to the L-footed tension wound fin, but utilizes knurling
wheels that actually knurl the fin foot into the tube. This allows for a tighter bond
between the tube and the fin, and reduces the likelihood of a corrosion film between the
two.
By cutting a slit into the fin, more air turbulence can be created, due to the interruption of
the air boundary layer. This in turn increases the airside heat transfer coefficient with a
modest increase in the airside pressure drop and the fan horsepower.
The air-cooled heat exchanger is controlled by two factors, the tube bundle size and
configuration, and the ability to move air across the surface area that the bundle provides.
Therefore, a major consideration of air cooler manufactures is not only the selection of
the proper fan, but also the design of plenums to force the air across the surface area.
The common means of moving air across the air cooler bundle is an axial flow, propeller
type fan that either pushes (forced draft) the air across the bundle or pulls (induced draft)
it across.
Even distribution of the air across the tube bundle is critical for uniform heat transfer.
this is normally achieved by adequate fan to bundle coverage and controlling the static
pressure loss across the bundle. A good design practice, and API661 requirement, is to
maintain a forty percent (40%) coverage of the face area of the tube bundle to the area of
the fan. Coverage’s of less than this will allow for lower airflows on the outer surfaces of
the tube bundle, and can result in poor performance.
In addition, the distance from the fan to the coil can be critical. Again, good design
practice requires an air dispersion angle of forty five percent (45%). The angle is
measured from the outlet side of the fan ring to the center of the depth of the coil.
This distance will allow the air to disperse, rather than channel directly through the
bundle in front of the fan.
In horizontal configurations, the face coverage and air dispersion angle control the
plenum size. On vertical configurations, many times the forty five percent dispersion
angle is more difficult, since the overall size of the cooler is affected. Therefore, the
designer must compensate for this design flaw by other means. This can be
accomplished by additional air flow from the fan, resulting is more air flow than required
directly in front of the fan, with the outside surfaces at the design velocity. It can also be
accomplished by adding additional surface area to the coils affected.
On vertical coolers with vertical air discharge, the designer also has to deal with the
problem of discharging the air from the cooler, without causing additional pressure losses
to the fan. Careful design of the size of the discharge plenum must be undertaken to
assure the air can discharge the cooler.
Fan ring design varies among manufacturers. The common configurations for fan rings
are indicated on the following page. Due to the cost of manufacture, the eased or taper
fan rings are generally not utilized in standard products, however are available when
required for special applications.
The tapered inlet and eased rings both allow for a more uniform exit of the air from the
fan ring. Most fan design programs will indicate slightly less horsepower required for
this configuration. In addition, these fan rings allow for better air dispersion since the air
is directed when it leaves the ring.
In most air-cooled heat exchangers, the cost of producing this configuration outweighs
the increased savings in horsepower, or in airflow efficiency.
These are the most common fan rings utilized by manufacturers. This ring is easily
produced, and provides good air movement if close tip clearance between the ring and the
fan are maintained. The depth of this ring will vary with the fan selected.
Fans can vary in size from 2 to 20 feet in diameter, and can have from 2 to 16 blades.
Common sizes are in one-foot increments, but can be supplied in any diameter desired.
Generally the blades are aluminum, but other materials are available, including steel,
fiberglass, reinforced plastic and wood.
Normally the blades of the air cooler have a profile that allows an even distribution of air
across the length of the blade. This can be accommodated for by a blade that has a wide
chord width at the tip, and tapers to a narrow chord at the tip. In addition, most blades
have a twist that compensates for the slower velocity at the portion of the blade closer to
the center of the fan. This helps produce a more uniform, efficient air velocity pressure.
The number of blades in a fan is not important, but the area of the total blade surface at
each radius is vital. Blade widths are generally limited by physical conditions in order to
keep the fan from becoming too deep.
Fans may have fixed or adjustable pitch blades. Normally smaller blades (four feet and
less) are provided with fixed pitch, while larger diameters are generally adjustable pitch.
Fan Laws
Horsepower
Horsepower of a given fan in a given installation, with increase or decrease in RPM, will
vary approximately as the cube of the RPM.
(a) The static pressure will increase as the square of the CFM.
(b) The velocity pressure will increase as the square of the CFM.
(c) Since the velocity pressure and static pressure are additive,
the total pressure increases as the square of the RPM.
(d) The volume will increase directly as the speed.
(e) As a result, the horsepower will increase as the cube of the speed,
the horsepower being the product of the CFM and the total pressure.
With changes in air density, horsepower for a given volume will increase or decrease in
direct proportion to the air density, provided that the static pressure also varies directly
with the air density, as is the case in most practical applications.
Environmental noise is becoming an increasing factor in the design and operation of air-
cooled heat exchangers. Due to this, the design of a noise efficient air-cooled heat
exchanger is a growing concern.
• Fans are the largest contributor to the overall noise levels in the air cooler. There
are many factors in the fan design and the selection of the proper fan for low noise
applications that affect the noise level, however the fan speed has the greatest
effect on the overall noise.
• The method of speed reduction is probably the second most significant source of
noise in the air cooler. Many methods of speed reduction are available, however
due to the constraints of the low noise requirements, many of these do not lend
themselves to low noise applications.
• The electric motor is generally much less of a factor in the overall noise than the
fan or the drive, however there are steps that can be taken to minimize the noise
source.
• Structural vibration and the effects of rotating equipment can have an effect on
the air cooler structure, including vibration in panels. A low-frequency noise can
be produced from this vibration in the panels, adding to the overall noise level of
the air cooler.
In the initial design of the equipment, it is possible to reduce noise in the air cooler and to
have an impact on the overall plant noise. Generally, the following are general rules to
use in the design of a noise efficient air cooler:
• Fans should be run at slow tip speeds, utilizing wide chord with blades to achieve
adequate airflow. Normally this will require reducing the static pressure through
the coils, due to the fact that most fans will not overcome high static pressures at
low tips speed.
• V-belts, not cog belts should be used to drive the air cooler. Normally v-belts will
add very little noise to the overall air cooler package. The use of newer “cog”
type belts, including HTD belts will add a significant factor to the noise level.
• The use of thicker panels, and elimination of any members interfering with the
inlet airflow should be carefully studied. These two factors, though minor, should
reduce low-frequency noise, usually generated by the air cooler structure.
2. A general rule of thumb for the airside face velocity through the coils is as
follows:
3 row coil 800 to 850 FPM
4 row coil 500 to 700 FPM
5 row coil 450 to 600 FPM
6 row coil 350 to 500 FPM
3. On new construction, good design practice would normally restrict the number of
tube rows to four. This allows for some modification, if need later, to allow for
higher heat load applications. Normally, on gas compressor applications, the air
is at such a high temperature after the four rows, that additional cooling from
additional rows in minimal.
5. Air dispersion angle of forty five percent should not be exceeded, without
compensating for this in the design.
6. Fans should be operated in the mid range of the fan performance, this should
be applied to tip speed, ability to handle the static pressure, and blade angle.