Abstract - : Task-Based Learning (TBL) and Cognition
Abstract - : Task-Based Learning (TBL) and Cognition
Abstract - : Task-Based Learning (TBL) and Cognition
7 | 2016
Task-Based Learning (TBL) and Cognition
Abstract | Teaching in the 21st century is a huge challenge and every school has to cope with
all the changes that occur within society and be, at the same time, an enjoyable place for the
students to develop their skills to live and function in the 21 st century society. This paper shows
how Task-Based Learning (TBL) can be a valuable option in the foreign language classroom
nowadays enabling the students to be active, interact with each other, learn by doing and
develop their language knowledge through communicative tasks, replacing the traditional,
teacher-centred lessons. At the same time, this article aims to show how doing tasks has
advantages in terms of the cognitive development while learning a foreign language, how these
tasks also affect the human brain as well as discuss the importance of bringing neuroscience
and scientific evidence into the classroom context.
Key words | Task-Based Learning (TBL), tasks, foreign language learning, cognition, human
brain and neuroscience
Citation: Andreia Costa, “Task-Based Learning (TBL) and Cognition.” e-TEALS: An e-journal of Teacher
Education and Applied Language Studies 7 (2016): 108-124. ISSN 1647-712X
DOI: 10.1515/eteals-2016-0010
Unauthenticated
Download Date | 11/4/17 3:47 PM
e -TEALS no. 7 (2016): 108-124
Task-Based Learning (TLB) and Cognition | Andreia Costa
The classroom should not be about direct instruction. . . . Human beings should not be
passive. When they get together, they should be interacting with each other. They
should be solving problems, or they should be making things.
(Robinson 117)
Indeed, one of the most demotivating factors for learners is when they have to learn
something that they cannot see the point of because it has no seeming relevance
whatsoever to their lives.
(Dörnyei 63)
The lack of student motivation is one of the biggest problems many teachers face nowadays.
Of course, it can be due to many factors but one of the main reasons is that sometimes
students cannot see any relevance in what they learn and do not have an active involvement in
their learning process. These two quotations (Robinson 117 and Dörnyei 63) give a clear
overview of what happens nowadays and are a starting point to reflect on possible solutions to
these problems. Therefore, it seems obvious that the traditional teacher-centred lessons no
longer interest students because they do not get involved in the classroom and become
demotivated. Since motivating students is one of the main goals of a teacher it would be
worthwhile to understand the way students learn and work best in order to adapt planning and
strategies according to students’ interests, making the learning activities and lessons meaningful
to them. Task-Based Learning (TBL) seems a possible option for the foreign language
classroom nowadays in order to prepare students for the 21st century, enabling them to learn
the language and, at the same time, acquire the skills they need to live in society nowadays.
Recently, there has been much talk on project-based lessons and task-based learning in
teachers’ meetings, conferences and workshops which shows a general consensus that the
traditional teacher-centred lessons and direct instruction have to be replaced by student-centred
approaches as a way of getting the students to become active, involved and engaged in the
page 109
Unauthenticated
Download Date | 11/4/17 3:47 PM
e -TEALS no. 7 (2016): 108-124
Task-Based Learning (TLB) and Cognition | Andreia Costa
lesson. When talking about learning a foreign language it seems even more obvious that if
students learn a language, they should put that knowledge into practice, communicate outside
the classroom, in the real world. Although TBL appeared in the 1970s with the Communicative
Approach, a study was carried out to analyse how authenticity and real-world tasks can be
brought to the foreign language classroom nowadays through TBL (Costa). Not only did this
study prove that TBL can bring authenticity to the classroom and is appropriate for this day and
age but also led to further research to find scientific evidence for the benefits of TBL in terms of
the cognitive development and the learning process. In fact, bringing scientific findings related to
brain studies to the classroom context is essential in understanding how humans learn
(Masuhara). Furthermore, the affective dimension plays also an important role in student’s
learning (Immordino-Yang and Damasio).
page 110
Unauthenticated
Download Date | 11/4/17 3:47 PM
e -TEALS no. 7 (2016): 108-124
Task-Based Learning (TLB) and Cognition | Andreia Costa
The central focus of TBL is doing tasks. The aim of the task is to create a real purpose for language
use and provide a natural context for language study. Students prepare for the task, report back after
the task and then study the language that arises naturally out of the task cycle and its accompanying
materials. (Willis 1)
Task-based learning is a different way to learn languages. It can help the student by placing him/her
in a situation similar to the real world, a situation where oral communication is essential for
completing a specific task. Task-based learning has the advantage of getting the student to use
his/her skills at his/her current level to help develop language through its use. It has the
advantage of making the student focus on achieving a goal so that language becomes a tool,
making the use of language a necessity. (Methods 3)
page 111
Unauthenticated
Download Date | 11/4/17 3:47 PM
e -TEALS no. 7 (2016): 108-124
Task-Based Learning (TLB) and Cognition | Andreia Costa
TBL PPP
Figure 1 - Structure of TBL and PPP
PPP is related to the Audiolingualism (from the USA) and Situational Language
Teaching (from the UK) in the 20th century that defend the correct use of the grammatical
structures as a way of learning a language. There is a contextualised presentation of the
structures, repetitions, practice and production, limiting what students can learn to that which is
controlled by the teacher (Harmer). These characteristics are different from TBL since here
students play a central role and the teacher doesn’t control what the students learn. Although
some studies on PPP proved that it isn’t very efficient in terms of students’ proficiency when
they have to put the language knowledge into practice in different contexts, it is still used very
often nowadays for two main reasons: the control that the teacher has during the lesson and in
terms of assessment of learned structures which implies only a right or wrong answer (Skehan).
TBL has three stages: pre-task, task cycle and language focus. In the pre-task, the
theme is introduced through expressions, structures and vocabulary, activating previous
knowledge and the teacher explains the task and can present examples of similar tasks
performed by other people. In the task cycle, the students do the task in pairs or in small
groups. The teacher monitors students’ performance from a distance, enabling them to use their
page 112
Unauthenticated
Download Date | 11/4/17 3:47 PM
e -TEALS no. 7 (2016): 108-124
Task-Based Learning (TLB) and Cognition | Andreia Costa
own knowledge avoiding asking questions to the teacher all the time. After doing the task, the
students prepare and plan how they are going to present what they did, what they found out
and their main conclusions. This moment is important because the students prepare carefully
what they are going to present, paying attention to the language they use: formal structures,
vocabulary and content. This moment enables language development (Willis). In the report
stage, the teacher should praise all the positive aspects and encourage students to continue
working because students’ performance is not likely to be native speaker-like. In the last stage,
language focus, they discuss and analyse the linguistic aspects that came up during the task.
There is a focus on the form; students practise the linguistic structures that appeared within the
context and in a natural way (Willis).
As mentioned above, TBL implies students’ involvement and learning by doing.
Therefore, it is important to focus now on what happens when doing a task in terms of the
learning process (cognitive effects).
page 113
Unauthenticated
Download Date | 11/4/17 3:47 PM
e -TEALS no. 7 (2016): 108-124
Task-Based Learning (TLB) and Cognition | Andreia Costa
dendrites
cell body
axon
myelin sheath
axon terminal
The axon connects to the dendrites of other neurons and conducts information as
electrical stimulation and transports chemicals substances (Jensen). When a neuron is
stimulated, it fires an electrical impulse to other neurons. At the same time, when there is a
positive environment, the dendrites grow and branch out. The information circulates in each
neuron as electrical impulses and only goes to other neuron as chemicals impulses, known as
neurotransmitters, through the synaptic cleft, which is the meeting point between two neurons.
The electrical message is sent from the cell body to the axon releasing chemical signals
(Jensen). When there is the repetition of the same episode or information, the connections
between neurons become more efficient, leading to its memorisation; when the information is
new and stimulates the brain, it leads to new neuronal connections and creates enriched
neurons. The difference between an enriched and an impoverished neuron is clear: there are
more branches of the dendrites and more connections in an enriched neuron.
page 114
Unauthenticated
Download Date | 11/4/17 3:47 PM
e -TEALS no. 7 (2016): 108-124
Task-Based Learning (TLB) and Cognition | Andreia Costa
Impoverished neuron
Enriched neuron
Doing tasks and solving problems leads to brain development because there is a
release of noradrenaline, a neurotransmitter synthesised from dopamine which is involved in
stimulation, rewarding and humour mood (Wolfe) and enables dendritic growth.
According to the Information Processing Model (from the 1950s) the information that
arrives through the sensory receptors and arouses the interest of the sensory memory is sent to
the working memory so that it is worked and can be stored in the long-term memory. Situations
that imply the releasing of adrenaline and noradrenaline by the adrenal cortex are related to a
better memorisation; here emotional factors have a significant influence. Therefore, in the
classroom context, emotions should play an important role and the type of activities a teacher
chooses is also very important: experiences and activities that are related to learning by doing,
experimenting and trial and error because they are meaningful and increase the emotional
connections: “Neither learning nor recall happen in a purely rational domain, divorced from
emotion, even though some of our knowledge will eventually distil into a moderately rational,
unemotional form” (Immordino-Yang and Damasio 127).
In a positive environment the brain releases neurotransmitters related to pleasure:
endorphin and dopamine. The same happens in the classroom context when students are doing
tasks that raise their interest, which can also be in pairs or in groups (TBL).
page 115
Unauthenticated
Download Date | 11/4/17 3:47 PM
e -TEALS no. 7 (2016): 108-124
Task-Based Learning (TLB) and Cognition | Andreia Costa
This generation seeks out a sense of the practical in what it does, and prefers that what it learns can
be explored and applied. Because of this, its learning is closer to the model of “just in time” than that
of “just in case” that is typical of traditional education. This generation prefers to learn what is
applicable in the present, and not what may be usable in the future. (Prestes 2)
page 116
Unauthenticated
Download Date | 11/4/17 3:47 PM
e -TEALS no. 7 (2016): 108-124
Task-Based Learning (TLB) and Cognition | Andreia Costa
The main conclusions were: TBL increased students’ motivation and was efficient in terms of
vocabulary acquisition and memorisation due to the materials chosen and the activities done.
The students enjoyed the active role they had in the classroom and were involved doing the
tasks. There was an increase of interaction and communication among students and an
enjoyable classroom environment. The second Action Research (Pinto) was implemented in
Cape Verde for a month in three schools. The students did the tasks communicating and their
motivation and interaction also increased. At the same time, the focus on form happened in a
natural context with real communicative situations to express meaning.
Learning in the 21st century means enabling the students to be critical thinkers, not only
learning things by heart but questioning and interpreting facts and information, to have their own
opinions and points of view, which is something related to the type of tasks they do in a TBL
lesson. To help teachers check if their students are able to think critically there is a useful, well-
-documented, reference: A Taxonomy of Educational Objectives, also known as Bloom’s
Taxonomy, which was created by a group of investigators of different universities of the United
States of America led by Benjamin Bloom in 1956. In this taxonomy, usually represented in a
pyramid, there are different levels, from the simplest to the most complex ones. Students’ answers
and performance help teachers to check if they are critical thinkers, according to each cognitive
process that is mentioned for each level of the taxonomy. If students can do what is described at
the top of the pyramid it means he or she is able to think critically (from Lower-Order Thinking
Skills (LOTS) to Higher Order Thinking Skills (HOTS)).
TBL enables the students to communicate, express meaning, learn by doing and
experiment through trial and error to accomplish a final outcome as it happens in the real world
when people communicate with each other. These ideas are related to the characteristics of the
Communicative Approach: learning a language means learning to communicate and express
meaning; the language is produced through trial and error; there is comprehensible pronunciation
but not necessarily like a native speaker; the use of native language and translation can be used
if there is a benefit for the student (Finocchiaro and Brumfit in Richard and Rodgers). Learning
page 117
Unauthenticated
Download Date | 11/4/17 3:47 PM
e -TEALS no. 7 (2016): 108-124
Task-Based Learning (TLB) and Cognition | Andreia Costa
by doing, which is at the heart of TBL, is also related to Constructivism (Piaget) and to Social
Constructivism (and its principle advocate, Lev Vygotsky) social interaction is vitally important
for cognitive development. Cooperative learning and the Zone of Proximal Development (the
difference between what the student can do alone and what he can do with the help of a more
experienced person: a classmate or a teacher), are two concepts of Social Constructivism and
the teacher functions as a facilitator not giving the answers but helping the students to find
them, “scaffolding” (Bruner, 1967).
Despite all the constraints and pressures of teaching (the national programme to follow
as well as the adopted coursebook) the teacher has the autonomy to choose the strategies,
activities and materials appropriate to his/her class in order to promote students’ motivation and
learning. A teacher should, whenever possible, choose activities and lessons that are
meaningful to the students, according to their interests and motivation, this is likewise true in a
TBL lesson. They should make what learners learn ‘value added’ so that they have the
knowledge and skills to live in the 21st century society (Ellison).
We are living in an age where the content taught in schools and the skills needed in a rapidly
evolving world is a constant balancing act. If educators are to fulfil their role in society, they must
reflect on what and how they teach so that they help to equip children with the knowledge, skills and
understanding they need to be able to live and function in society. This does not mean that we have
to reinvent the wheel, it simply means that we have to make what we teach “value added”. That is,
make it more relevant, get more out of it. (Ellison 23)
Making the activities meaningful to the learners also means establishing aims that
include the 4Cs related to CLIL (a concept derived from Content and Language Integrated
Learning – CLIL – but now made use of more ‘generalist’ contexts): Content (contents and the
way they are taught), Communication (the language of, for and through learning), Culture (the
knowledge the student has of himself/herself and others and what he/she can learn alone or with
other classmates) and Cognition (aims that promote critical thinking) (Coyle, Hood and Marsh). By
page 118
Unauthenticated
Download Date | 11/4/17 3:47 PM
e -TEALS no. 7 (2016): 108-124
Task-Based Learning (TLB) and Cognition | Andreia Costa
doing this, learning becomes more meaningful because it integrates different areas of knowledge.
The language appears naturally and there is a communicative goal to achieve a final outcome.
As educators have long known, it is simply not enough for students to master knowledge and logical
reasoning skills in the traditional academic sense. They must be able to choose among and recruit
these skills and knowledge usefully outside of the structured context of a school or laboratory.
(Immordino-Yang and Damasio 128)
page 119
Unauthenticated
Download Date | 11/4/17 3:47 PM
e -TEALS no. 7 (2016): 108-124
Task-Based Learning (TLB) and Cognition | Andreia Costa
been done before. Therefore, it is recommended that the theme and the type of
activities are appropriate to students’ age and level.
Sharing personal experiences: the same happens in the real world when people
share stories and personal experiences. It promotes communication and fluency and
develops social skills;
Projects and creative tasks: these tasks enable the students to use tools, gadgets
and knowledge from other areas to be creative. Examples of these tasks are:
posters, portfolios, pamphlets, videos, websites, radio programmes, magazines and
newspapers. As digital natives, students learn the language using technology: upload
pictures, make videos and other tasks.
What makes these tasks examples of TBL is the fact that they are the centre of the
lesson and students have a final outcome to accomplish and present to the other students.
Conclusion
According to the characteristics of 21st century society and learners, TBL may be a valid option
for the foreign language classroom in an effort to replace the traditional teacher-centred lessons
that still dominate Portuguese classrooms. TBL can help to foster advantages in terms of the
cognitive development, and at the same time, it provides students with opportunities to be active
and engaged in the lesson, learning by doing, using ICT tools and gadgets. Through TBL
students may acquire the skills that have been identified as fundamental for 21st century society:
collaboration, creativity, communication and critical thinking. It may also be a way to overcome
and deal with students’ bad behaviour, lack of attention and low motivation. Learner-centred
lessons can be one of the possible ways to involve and engage students and prepare them for
the real-world. At the same time, it is also true that neuroscience and other areas are crucial for
page 120
Unauthenticated
Download Date | 11/4/17 3:47 PM
e -TEALS no. 7 (2016): 108-124
Task-Based Learning (TLB) and Cognition | Andreia Costa
understanding language learning process and provide teachers with scientific and biological
evidence to improve their work.
Note
This article is derived from work undertaken for the final report of a Masters’ in Teacher Education course offered by the Faculty
of Letters, Porto: Costa, Andreia. “O Potencial do Task-Based Learning (TBL) para Trazer a Autenticidade para a Sala de Aula
de Língua Estrangeira através das Tarefas Baseadas no Mundo Real.” Diss. [Master’s Degree in Education]. Faculdade de
Letras da Universidade do Porto, Porto, 2016.
page 121
Unauthenticated
Download Date | 11/4/17 3:47 PM
e -TEALS no. 7 (2016): 108-124
Task-Based Learning (TLB) and Cognition | Andreia Costa
Works Cited
Boschma, Jeroen, and Inez Groen. Generation Einstein: Smart, Social and Superfast,
Communicating with Young People in the 21st Century. Keesie Agency: Netherlands, 2006.
Conselho da Europa. Quadro Europeu Comum de Referência para as Línguas - Aprendizagem,
Ensino, Avaliação. Porto: Edições ASA, 2001.
Costa, Andreia. “O Potencial do Task-Based Learning (TBL) para Trazer a Autenticidade para a
Sala de Aula de Língua Estrangeira através das Tarefas Baseadas no Mundo Real”. Diss.
[Master’s Degree in Education]. Faculdade de Letras da Universidade do Porto, 2016.
Coyle, Do, Philip Hood, and David Marsh. CLIL: Content and Language Integrated Learning.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2010.
Ellison, Maria. “Make Them Think! Using Literature in the Primary English Language Classroom
to Develop Critical Thinking Skills.” E-F@bulations/E-F@bulações 7 (2010): 21-31.
European Commission. “Multilingualism: an Asset for Europe and a Shared Commitment”. Brussels:
European Commission, 2008.
---. “Study on the Contribution of Multilingualism to Creativity”. Brussels: European Commission, 2009.
Harmer, Jeremy. The Practice of English Language Learning. England: Longman, 2001.
Immordino-Yang, Mary Helen, and António Damásio. “We Feel, Therefore We Learn: The Relevance
of Affective and Social Neuroscience to Education.” LEARNing Landscapes 5.1 (2011): 183-98.
Jensen, Eric. O Cérebro, a Bioquímica e as Aprendizagens: um Guia para Pais e Educadores.
Porto: Edições Asa, 2002.
page 122
Unauthenticated
Download Date | 11/4/17 3:47 PM
e -TEALS no. 7 (2016): 108-124
Task-Based Learning (TLB) and Cognition | Andreia Costa
Krashen, Stephen, and Tracy Terrell. The Natural Approach: Language Acquisition in the
Classroom. Hemel Hempstead: Prentice Hall, 1983.
Lapa, Carlos, Lídia Mota, and Margarida Vilela. Programa de Alemão 10.º e 11.º anos. Ministério
da Educação, 2001.
Masuhara, Hitomi. “Brain Studies and Materials for Language Learning.” Second Language
Research and Materials Development for Language Learning. Ed. Brian Tomlinson. London:
Routledge, 2016. 23-32.
Methods. “Task-Based Learning”. Methods. Funded with Support from the European Commission,
2013.
Prestes, Roberto Balaguer. “21st Century Students and 21st Century Skills”. Pearson ELT.com.
2012. Web. <http://www.pearsonelt.com/professionaldevelopment/articles/21st%20Century%20
Students%20and%2021st%20Century%20Skills>
Richards, Jack C., and Theodore S. Rodgers. Approaches and Methods in Language Teaching.
United Kingdom: Cambridge University Press, 1986.
Robinson, Ken. Creative Schools: The Grassroots Revolution that’s Transforming Education.
New York: Penguin Books, 2015.
Ruso, Nazenin. “The Influence of Task Based Learning on EFL Classrooms”. Asian EFL Journal
18 (2007): n. pag. Web. <https://www.asian-efl-journal.com/1855/teaching-articles/ 2007/02/ the-
influence-of-task-based-learning-on-efl-classrooms/#squelch-taas-tab-content-0-3>
page 123
Unauthenticated
Download Date | 11/4/17 3:47 PM
e -TEALS no. 7 (2016): 108-124
Task-Based Learning (TLB) and Cognition | Andreia Costa
Skehan, Peter. A Cognitive Approach to Language Learning. New York: Oxford University Press,
1998.
Willis, Dave, and Jane Willis. Doing Task-Based Teaching. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2007.
Willis, Jane. A Framework for Task-Based Learning. Harlow: Longman, 1996.
Wolfe, Patricia. Compreender o Funcionamento do Cérebro e a sua Importância no Processo de
Aprendizagem. Porto: Porto Editora, 2004.
page 124
Unauthenticated
Download Date | 11/4/17 3:47 PM