Faculty of Pharmacy, Nursing and Health Professions
Faculty of Pharmacy, Nursing and Health Professions
Faculty of Pharmacy, Nursing and Health Professions
Abstract
An erythrocyte based drug delivery system have been extensively studied
for their capability as a carrier to prolong the drug’s action by its slow
release or as a biological device for targeted drug delivery to target organs,
also to enhance the bioavailability, pharmacokinetics and eliminates
toxicities of the drugs. The concept in this review is to investigate the
methods of drug encapsulation in erythrocytes with experimental details and
loading conditions. Focusing only on drugs loaded inside erythrocytes using
techniques such as hypotonic pre-swell dilution, endocytosis and by Normal
transportive mechanism, and reviewing some in vitro studies for drug
delivery of metformin as parenteral slow release depot formulation and
propranolol as bioadhesive system.
Page 2
Erythrocytes as a novel drug delivery system
Table of content
1. INTRODUCTION......................................................................................................................4
2. DRUG LOADING OF CARRIER RBCS.......................................................................................4
3. PREPARATION OF RESEALED ERYTHROCYTES.......................................................................5
3.1 ERYTHROCYTES ISOLATION..................................................................................................5
3.2 DRUG ENCAPSULATION..........................................................................................................5
3.3 ESSENTIALS FOR ENCAPSULATION........................................................................................5
4. OSMOSIS BASED METHODS......................................................................................................5
4.1 DILUTION METHOD................................................................................................................6
4.2 HYPOTONIC DIALYSIS.............................................................................................................6
4.3 PRE-SWELL DILUTION............................................................................................................7
4.4 ISOTONIC OSMOTIC LYSIS...................................................................................................7
5. ENTRAPMENT BY ENDOCYTOSIS.............................................................................................8
6. IN-VITRO CHARACTERIZATION OF RESEALED ERYTHROCYTES..........................................9
6.1 DRUG CONTENT QUANTIFICATION........................................................................................9
6.2 IN-VITRO DRUG RELEASE AND HEMOGLOBIN CONTENT STUDY..........................................9
6.3 PERCENT CELL RECOVERY AND MORPHOLOGICAL STUDY................................................9
6.4 OSMOTIC FRAGILITY AND OSMOTIC SHOCK STUDY............................................................9
6.5 TURBULENCE SHOCK STUDY...............................................................................................10
6.6 ERYTHROCYTE SEDIMENTATION RATE (ESR)..................................................................10
6.7 SHELF LIFE AND STABILITY AND CROSSLINKING OF RELEASED ERYTHROCYTES.........10
6.8 MECHANISM OF DRUG RELEASE FROM RESEALED ERYTHROCYTE................................10
6.9 STORAGE..............................................................................................................................11
7. ROUTE OF ADMINISTRATION.................................................................................................11
8. ERYTHROCYTES FOR TARGETED DRUG DELIVERY............................................................11
8.1 HUMAN ERYTHROCYTES AS CARRIER FOR METFORMIN...................................................11
8.1.1 COLLECTION OF ERYTHROCYTES................................................................................11
8.1.2 LOADING OF METFORMIN IN RBC..............................................................................11
8.1.3 METHOD OF ENDOCYTOSIS..........................................................................................12
8.1.4 NORMAL TRANSPORTIVE MECHANISM........................................................................12
8.1.5 CHARACTERIZATION OF METFORMIN LOADED RESEALED ERYTHROCYTES............12
8.1.6 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION..................................................................................14
8.2 ERYTHROCYTE BASED BIO ADHESIVE SYSTEM FOR NASAL DELIVERY OF PROPRANOLOL18
8.2.1 ERYTHROCYTE SEPARATION........................................................................................18
8.2.2 LOADING OF PROPRANOLOL HCI................................................................................18
8.2.3 BIOADHESION PREPARATION.......................................................................................18
8.2.4 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION............................................................................................19
9. CONCLUSION..........................................................................................................................20
10. REFERENCES......................................................................................................................21
Page 3
Erythrocytes as a novel drug delivery system
Page 4
Erythrocytes as a novel drug delivery system
Page 5
Figure 2 Schematic illustration of hypotonic hemolysis drugs loading
method. [7]
Erythrocytes as a novel drug delivery system
Page 6
Erythrocytes as a novel drug delivery system
Page 7
Erythrocytes as a novel drug delivery system
5. Entrapment by endocytosis
Page 8
Erythrocytes as a novel drug delivery system
Page 9
Erythrocytes as a novel drug delivery system
Page 10
Erythrocytes as a novel drug delivery system
the gel, followed by centrifugation and washed in White crystalline powder of metformin hydrochloride
HBSS before use. The benefits of storing in gel is the C4H11N5•HCl, USP have a MW of 165.62.
ease in dispersing after liquefaction and the Metformin hydrochloride 2.0 g is soluble in 20 mL of
prevention in clumping (a draw back in liquid water. The PKa of metformin is 12.4. The pH of a
media). To boost the cells circulation survival time 1% of metformin hydrochloride in aqueous solution
upon reinjection, purine nucleosides or calcium- is 6.68. It is freely soluble in water [19][25]
chelating agents are added.
The storage conditions and characteristics varies and
8.1.1 Collection of erythrocytes
depends on the type of preservatives used and the RBC was obtained from the Amrita Institute of
container for the finished product; the most common Medical Sciences blood bank, Kochi. The clinic has
utilized containers are plasticized polyvinyl chloride an identified approval from donators that their blood
bags (compatible and non-extractable in blood). usable for medical research. Using phosphate
Loaded erythrocyte should administered briefly after buffered saline (PBS) (pH 7.4) for RBCs washing to
production to skip storage-induced RBC degradation. get rid of the remains of heparin because it performs
Saline, adenine, glucose, and mannitol are the most as an analytic interferential in the study as the heparin
widely utilized preservatives solutions for resealed and metformin absorption maxima is 232 nm. The
erythrocytes. [21][9][22] [23] resilient buffer was excluded by aspiration then by
centrifugation to obtain packed volume cell. Care
was taken for using PBS 7.4 Instead of distilled water
for washing erythrocyte because distilled water is a
7. Route of administration haemolysing agent.[19]
The intravenous route is the most common rout of
administration next is subcutaneous, intranasal, oral
and intraperitoneal in which 25% of resealed cell
8.1.2 Loading of metformin in RBC
survived in circulation for 14 days.[24]
A set of metformin in water concentrations varying
from one to ten mg/ml was prepared. Then the
8. Erythrocytes for Targeted Drug
mixture added to the suspended RBC in PBS and
Delivery allowed to set for one hour. The supernatant liquid
This review focuses on the studies of tow potential was retreated, and percentage of hemolysis was
routs of administration of carrier erythrocytes; slow calculated for each metformin concentration. The
release depot parenteral and bio adhesive system for hemolysis percentage was determined
nasal delivery.[19] spectrophotometrically using the equation no.2.
Absorbance of sample−absorbance of blan
% hemolysis=
Absorbance of positive control
A positive control test of supernatant was
8.1 Human erythrocytes as carrier for prepared; in order to obtain the supernatant the
metformin addition of the nonionic detergent triton X to
Metformin is a biguanide class drug used as first-line erythrocyte suspension as positive control was
drug of choice for the treatment of type 2 diabetes used. 1% v/v triton X/water with a haemolysing
and in cases of polycystic ovary syndrome. The capacity of 100% (The rate of haemolysis
objective in this review is to slow down the release of elevated with the increase in detergent
metformin using carrier erythrocyte to achieve a slow concentration, by elevating membrane
release depot parenteral formulation.
permeability to KCL and colloid osmotic
The endocytosis method was used for metformin haemolysis).
encapsulation in carrier erythrocytes in order to retard The blank supernatant is prepared adding normal
release of the drug. saline to the erythrocyte suspension. By using
Page 11
Erythrocytes as a novel drug delivery system
ultraviolet (UV) spectrophotometrically the Data of the amount(µg) of metformin loaded in RBCs
absorbance determined at 540 nm. using endocytosis method versus normal transportive
The metformin concentration to be loaded to mechanism at four different concentrations is shown
erythrocytes were optimized by detecting the in table2. [19]
percentage haemolysis. Drug loading was
performed by the method of normal transportive
mechanism and endocytosis.[19][26] 8.1.5 Characterization of metformin
loaded resealed erythrocytes
Encapsulation efficiency
8.1.3 Method of endocytosis
To evaluate the drug content, packed loaded RBCs
One ml of the desired concentration of membrane are deproteinized with methanol after
metformin/water (range: 1-10 mg/ml) is added to five centrifugation at 3000 rpm for 15min ( mechanical
ml of buffer consisting of ATP 2.5 mmol, CaCl2 1 stress leading to RBCs lysis and release their
mmol and MgCl2 2.5 mmol. Followed by the content), 1 ml of clear supernatant liquid is pipetted
addition of erythrocytes 0.65 ml to the solution and out and analyzed using UV-visible spectrophotometer
incubation step for 15 min at 0˚C. The resealing step at 232 nm. For comparison, the evaluation carried out
was performed using sodium chloride 0.9% solution for both methods of encapsulation endocytosis and
at 37°C to obtain the required suspension. Then normal transportive mechanism. The blank
washing tow times using cold PBS to discard the supernatant is prepared by adding normal saline to
metformin bounded on surface membrane of RBCs, the erythrocyte suspension. The encapsulation
then final centrifugation for 15 min at 5000 rpm.[19] efficiency is calculated using the equation no3 below.
[27] [19]
Table 2 Data table of the amount of metformin(µg) loaded in RBCs using endocytosis method versus normal transportive mechanism at four different
concentrations.[19]
Encapsulated drug
Encapsulation efficiency= × 100
8.1.4 Normal transportive mechanism Total drug
This method involves the encapsulation of the drug
into erythrocyte by incubation without destruction the
erythrocyte membrane. In vitro drug release
One ml of the desired concentration of Using orbital shaking incubator(applied as
metformin/water (range: 1-10 mg/ml) is added to mechanical stress to induce drug release from RBCs),
five ml of PBS( pH7.4), which then added to withdraw one ml of the supernatant at different time
erythrocytes solution 0.65 ml and incubated for intervals followed by deprotenization by methanol
15min at 0˚C. The resealing step was performed and inserted through syringe filter 0.22 µm to clear
using equal volume of sodium chloride 0.9% solution the precipitated protein. Then determine the amount
at 37°C. . Then washing tow times, using cold PBS to of metformin released in every time interval at 232
obtain the required suspension then final nm using UV spectrophotometry, a plotting of the
centrifugation for 15 min at 5000 rpm to discard the obtained data in different kinetic models are done in
metformin bounded on surface membrane of RBCs. order to study the release kinetics. This study
Page 12
Erythrocytes as a novel drug delivery system
Page 13
Erythrocytes as a novel drug delivery system
Stability studies
There is not a specific guideline for the estimation of
resealed erythrocytes stability, in this study; the
storage of resealed erythrocytes must be in
lyophilized state. Lyophilized erythrocyte
formulation stability was evaluated by calculating the
hemolysis percentage following re-suspending the
formulation in PBS. [19]
indicates exclusively a fragile interaction among
metformin and hemoglobin. Docking results of
8.1.6 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Physical interaction of RBC with metformin
The study focused on physical interaction of
metformin with hemoglobin and metformin with
RBC, the metformin with RBC physical interaction
was evaluated by having FTIR spectra of lyophilized
RBC, metformin and physical combination of
lyophilized RBC and metformin stored for 7 days.
Docking human oxy hemoglobin chain (a) with
metformin is a process used to evaluate the physical
interaction of metformin with hemoglobin.
Docking is the molecular design method established Metformin with hemoglobin was viewed in Fig 8.
for the search of the ligand-binding site in the
objected protein movable site and the followed by
calculation of the amount, which permits the
evaluation protein-ligand binding free energy. [19] Characterization of metformin loaded
resealed erythrocytes
Encapsulation efficiency
Various concentrations of 1, 4, 7, 10 mg/ml of
metformin were applied for encapsulation. The load
of encapsulated in erythrocytes of these
concentrations of Metformin displayed in Fig. 9. The
chart indicates that when we used concentration of 10
mg/ml the load of metformin encapsulated is higher.
Physical interaction of metformin with The equivalent encapsulation efficiency of various
hemoglobin concentration of metformin was determined. Fig 10
displaying the encapsulation efficiency at four ranges
The docking study shows the existence of hydrogen of Metformin. Fig 11 displays a correlation between
bonding among the drug and amino acids LYS127 encapsulationFigure 10 the encapsulation
efficiency efficiency at loaded
of metformin four different
byconcentration by
the method of endocytosis. [19]
and ASP126. The binding score was −3.33, means normal transportive mechanism with endocytosis
the lack of other interactions such as pication method at different concentration.
interaction or cation-cation interaction, which
Page 15
Erythrocytes as a novel drug delivery system
metformin-loaded erythrocytes
Table 3 Effect of Glutaraldehyde concentration on the percentage
cumulative drug release within 12 days.[19]
(with the highest loading metformin
concentration 10mg/ml)
F0 F1 F2 F3 F4
Osmotic fragility Glutaraldehy 0.0% 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8
This test evaluates the ability RBCs to resist the de % % % %
destruction in hypotonic solutions. RBC are concentration
Figure 14 (a and b) Kinetic data modeling for F0 formulation. [19]
conferred to a solution of salt water (NaCl) with v/v
accelerating dilution. % cumulative 98.34 84.6 76.0 70.3 58.9
drug release % % % %
The preceding blood destruction occurs, the more %
within 12
easily to see breakage in quality of RBC by osmosis. days
Hypotonic (0.9% NaCl) leads to a RBCs burst. A
membrane break appears, in hypotonic conditions,
permitting (a portion of the oxygen hemoglobin to
leave the cells. By determining the concentration of
hemoglobin, the destruction percentage of blood at
various NaCl concentrations can be evaluated. Figure 15The osmotic fragility test of normal and loaded red blood
cell. Percentage hemolysis plotted against concentration of sodium
Usually hemolysis begins at 0.45-0.5% NaCl and chloride. Data are expressed as mean±standard deviation, 3
conclude at 0.3-0.33% NaCl. Osmotic fragility samples in each group n=three. [19]
Page 16
Erythrocytes as a novel drug delivery system
potential modifications in cell membrane (reliable MCV values suggest macrocytic (large RBC size
and average). The reference range for MCV in
acceptable human quality/integrity or completeness) Adult/elderly/child is 80-96 FL/red cell. The normal
and the cells resistance to osmotic pressure of the erythrocyte gave an MCV value of 93 FL and
medium. Applying Paired t-test (to determine metformin loaded erythrocytes gave an MCV value
whether the mean difference between two sets of of 95 FL expressing a normal average RBC size in
observations is zero), shows that that the variance in spite of the loading stress.[19]
osmotic fragility of both unloaded and loaded is not
statistically critical, and the unloaded erythrocyte has Stability studies
less osmotic fragility than the loaded erythrocyte. In
fig 15 percentage, hemolysis plotted versus To evaluate the resealed erythrocyte stability, they
concentration of sodium chloride. Data are have been stored in lyophilized state at 4°C. SEM
demonstrated as mean±standard deviation, three image showed a deformity in RBC shape and that F0
samples in every group n= 3.[19] formulas without Glutaraldehyde cross-linking were
Figure 16 Scanning electron micrograph image of normal erythrocytes. [19]
Page 17
Erythrocytes as a novel drug delivery system
Page 18
Erythrocytes as a novel drug delivery system
Page 19
Erythrocytes as a novel drug delivery system
Page 20
Erythrocytes as a novel drug delivery system
Erythrocytes : A Novel Drug Delivery,” vol. [22] J. A. K. M. D, “·: I,” Dis. Chest, vol. 47, no.
04, no. 17, pp. 119–130, 2016. 2, pp. 157–159.
[10] P. Selvamani, S. Latha, S. Monisha, and T. [23] B. E. Bax and Y. Godfrin, “Drug-loaded
Supassri, “A REVIEW ON RESEALED erythrocytes : on the road toward marketing
ERYTHROCYTE AS A NOVEL DRUG approval,” pp. 665–676, 2016.
DELIVERY SYSTEM,” vol. 8, no. 4, 2015. [24] B. K. Nanjwade, T. Life, S. Pvt, and T.
[11] A. V Gothoskar, “Resealed Erythrocytes : A Srichana, “Resealed Erythrocyte Based Drug
Review,” no. March, 2004. Delivery System,” no. June, 2017.
[12] M. Magnani and L. Rossi, “Approaches to [25] R. Id, “Reference ID: 4079203,” pp. 1–18.
erythrocyte- mediated drug delivery,” 2014. [26] J. Bielawski, “Two types of haemolytic
[13] C. H. B. Rao, “Erythrocytes as Carrier for activity of detergents,” vol. 1035, pp. 214–
Drugs , Enzymes and Peptides Erythrocytes as 217, 1990.
Carrier for Drugs , Enzymes and Peptides,” [27] J. Ross and S. U. V, “Energy Transfer from
no. April, 2012. Adenosine Triphosphate,” pp. 6987–6990,
[14] M. Hamidi, A. Zarrin, M. Foroozesh, and S. 2006.
Mohammadi-samani, “Applications of carrier [28] E. Briones, C. I. Colino, and J. M. Lanao,
erythrocytes in delivery of “Study of the factors influencing the
biopharmaceuticals,” vol. 118, pp. 145–160, encapsulation of zidovudine in rat
2007. erythrocytes,” Int. J. Pharm., vol. 401, no. 1–
[15] S. Biagiotti, M. F. Paoletti, A. Fraternale, L. 2, pp. 41–46, 2010.
Rossi, and M. Magnani, “Critical Review [29] P. Taylor and R. Greenwood, “Drug
Drug Delivery by Red Blood Cells,” vol. 63, Development and Industrial Pharmacy Human
no. August, pp. 621–631, 2011. Insulin Binding to Erythrocyte- Membrane,”
[16] P. D. Patel, N. Dand, R. S. Hirlekar, and V. J. no. August, 2015.
Kadam, “Drug Loaded Erythrocytes : As [30] P. Laboratories, “The encapsulation of insulin
Novel Drug Delivery System,” pp. 63–70, in erythrocytes,” no. 20 mM, pp. 246–247,
2008. 1983.
[17] V. L. Lew and U. Kingdom, “Mechanism of [31] “NII-Electronic Library Service.”
Spontaneous Inside-Out Vesiculation of Red
Cell Membranes,” vol. 106, no. June, 1988. [32] S. P. Vyas, N. Talwar, J. S. Karajgi, and N. K.
Jain, “An erythrocyte based bioadhesive
[18] X. Han, C. Wang, and Z. Liu, “Red Blood system for nasal delivery of propranolol,” vol.
Cells as Smart Delivery Systems,” 2018. 23, pp. 231–237, 1993.
[19] S. Aiswarya, S. Parvathy, A. Tp, and V. [33] M. Saleemuddin, U. Zimmermann, and F.
Viswanad, “DESIGN AND IN VITRO Schneeweiß, “Preparation of Human
CHARACTERIZATION OF METFORMIN Erythrocyte Ghosts in Isotonic Solution :
LOADED RESEALED ERYTHROCYTES,” Haemoglobin Content and Polypeptide
vol. 10, no. 4, 2017. Composition,” pp. 627–631, 1977.
[20] I. Migneault, C. Dartiguenave, M. J. Bertrand, [34] R. Greenwood, “Intraduodenal Administration
and K. C. Waldron, “Glutaraldehyde : of Biocarrier-Insulin Systems,” vol. 9045, no.
behavior in aqueous solution , reaction with April, 2016.
proteins , and application to enzyme
crosslinking,” vol. 37, no. 5, 2004.
[21] C. H. Villa, D. B. Cines, D. L. Siegel, and V.
Muzykan-, “PT NU SC,” Transfus. Med. Rev.,
2016.
Page 21
Erythrocytes as a novel drug delivery system
Page 22