AN4104 Forward Converter Type PC SMPS With FPS: Sangtae-Im PD Division
AN4104 Forward Converter Type PC SMPS With FPS: Sangtae-Im PD Division
AN4104 Forward Converter Type PC SMPS With FPS: Sangtae-Im PD Division
AN4104
Forward Converter Type PC SMPS with FPS
Sangtae-Im
PD division
Introduction
The purpose of this application note is to examine basic circuit characteristics, transformer and
secondary inductor design methods according to the circuit design, auxiliary power supply terminal
and optimum remote control circuit etc., based on the forward converter with FPS (Fairchild power
switch) as all related to the desk-top PC SMPS.
First of all, the basic concept of the FPS is to combine the existing MOSFET and its control IC,
which were previously separately configured, into 1 package and to include external circuits for
configuring existing, various protection features in the internal control IC to execute self-protection.
By doing this, the SMPS can be easily designed with few components, enhancing set reliability
and production and reducing field defects. These additional effects result in Total cost down, the
ultimate purpose to its development.
Various line-up of FPS supports everything from products for 5W auxiliary power supply product to
250W, large capacity SMPS, depending on the type of the internal MOSFET. Table 1 shows the
FPS product groups which can be applied to a 220V-input forward converter with different output
power.
Because the forward converter has high energy transfer efficiency as compared to the flyback
converter, it can obtain a large output using a relatively small transformer and has superior output
ripple noise characteristics. For these reasons, it is frequently used in above -150W PC SMPS.
Unlike the flyback-type, the forward converter operates with the ON-ON method immediately
delivering energy to the secondary side when the transformer primary main switch turns on.
The next section describes the basic circuit operation of this type of forward converter
Table 1.
Device Freq. Power
KA5H0165R 100kHz 10 ~ 20W
KA1M0680B
70kHz
KA1M0680RB
90 ~ 150W
KA1H0680B
100kHz
KA1H0680RFB
KA1L0880B 50kHz
KA1M0880B
KA1M0880BF 180 ~ 250W
70kHz
KA1M0880D
FS7M0880
1
RECT
C6 R3 R4 D5 L2
+12V
RT1 FUSE
R5 +
C4 C12 + C11 +
D2
C1
R6 +
C5 D4
+5V
R1
R2 R10
D3 C14 +
C13 +
D1 R7
R10
VCC Dranin
SPS
R8 R11
GND SS FB
C8 R12
C7 + C10 +
OP1
C9 C17
OP1
C15 C16 IC3
1. FORWARD CONVERTER
1.1 Basic Operation
Figure 2 shows the basic topology of the forward converter. The transformer in the forward con-
verter acts to eliminate the concept of energy storage and acts purely as an energy transfer media.
Therefore, the most ideal transformer in the forward converter would be one that has an infinite
magnetizing inductor value (Lm) making the circuit an open circuit, essentially. In actuality, how-
ever, this magnetizing inductor value is finite. Therefore, a circuit (Figure A) which completely
resets the stored energy in the magnetizing inductor before the beginning of the next switching
cycle when the switch turns on at every cycle is absolutely needed. Though there are various tech-
niques to form this type of a reset circuit, the transformer reset winding or the RCD clamping circuit
etc. is more widely used. It can be said that the forward converter operates basically the same as
that of the Buck converter (or also called the Step-down converter). It is just that the desired output
voltage can be obtained suitable for off-line by first using the transformer to down the hundreds of
DC volts to an appropriate tens of volts and then stepping down through, again, two manual
switches (Diode1,2) and the secondary inductor. At this time, D1 always switches the same as the
primary main switch (SW) and D2 switches opposite to D1.
2
The next section reviews the stages along with each waveform of the operation of this type of for-
ward converter.
D1
+ iLi
Lm Vm D2
−
VIN + sw
−
D3 isw
+
−
VC
A
N:1 Li
+
+ + VLi − +
ia
Lm Vm VS VO
− −
+
− iLm −
VIN isw
N:1 Li
+ + V − +
Li
Vm Lm VO
− −
VIN +
−
+
− VC
N:1 Li
+ + VLi − +
Vm Lm VO
− −
VIN +
−
t3 ~ t4
Cos
3
Vm
Vin
Sa Sa=Sb
(a)
Sb
Vc-Vi
iLM
ILp
(b)
VLi
Vs-Vo
Sc Sc=Sd
(c)
Sd
Vo
iLi
Ip Io
(d)
isw
Ip
N
ILp
(e)
Vsw
Vc
Vi
(f)
t1 t2 t3 t4 t5
t1~t2 Interval
Between t1~t2 when the primary side main switch (SW) turns on figure 2 and figure 2a becomes
equivalent and the state of each switching element, voltage and current of each terminal can be
expressed through the following equations.
4
ia = iLi / N
isw = iLm+ia = [(VIN / Lm)t] + [iLi / N]
VS = VIN / N
As revealed above, the current shape of the primary switch in the forward converter is determined
by the magnetizing inductance current, iLm, and the secondary inductor current, iLi.
Looking at figure 2a, voltage Vm equals VIN when the main switch (SW) is on and, in addition, the
secondary side voltage, VS, is applied in one direction, turning on D1. The current delivered
through the transformer supplies the output current (Io) through the secondary side inductor (Li). It
is stored in Li as magnetic energy until the main switch turns off and then it free wheels through D2
to supply the output current continuously.
t2~t3 Interval
When the primary main switch turns off, reverse voltage is applied to the Vs and D1 turns off. At
this time, the energy which was stored in Li during t1~t2 free wheels through D2 to supply output
current continuously and D2 turns on. As D3 turns on, the energy stored in the Lm forms the path
through which iLm can continuously flow. At this time, the voltage across Vm is applied with reverse
voltage of (Vc-VIN) based on Vc making iLm have a negative slope (Figure 3b) which slowly
reduces to become 0 at t3. Consequently, the energy stored in Lm completely resets. Once Vm
resets and becomes 0V, D3 turns off.
One item to note here is that the max duty of the forward converter is decided when designing
according to the value of Vc. This can be well understood through figure 3(a). As was mentioned
previously, D3 and Vc act to completely reset the energy, which was stored in Lm during the inter-
val the SW was on, before the next cycle. For example, if Vc is designed to be 2VIN, namely, when
the Vm reverse voltage is designed to become -VIN when the SW is off and max duty exceeds
50%, the energy stored in Lm does not reset completely before the next cycle and eventually the
transformer saturates and the max duty becomes limited to 50%. This is a very important design
point for a forward converter and should be especially, carefully considered during designing in
order to properly obtain the maximum output under minimum input voltage conditions. The state of
each switching element during this internal is as follows:
t3~t5 Interval
Once t3 is reached, the stored energy in Lm completely resets; Vm becomes 0V; D3 turns off. The
equivalent circuit is shown in figure 2c. The energy stored in the secondary inductor, Li, free
wheels through D2 with a slope -Vo / Li until the next main SW turns on and continues to supply
output current. [Refer to figures 3c, d]. In this interval, the output voltage determined below is the
same as the input/output condition of the Step-down converter
V O = D × V S [D: Duty]
= D × ( V IN ÷ N )
5
The voltage waveform of the primary main switch (SW) of the forward converter is a step waveform
as in figure 3f. During the interval between t3~t4, there is resonance between the transformer mag-
netizing inductor (Lm) and the parallel equivalent capacitor of the SW and its voltage decreases to
the input voltage.
iLm
iLm
iR
(a) (b)
As representative reset circuits, figures 4 (a) and (b) have the following characteristics.
The reverse voltage across Lm, which changes with duty, is a special feature of this type of a RCD
reset circuit. Even if the input voltage becomes low as the reverse voltage increases due to an
increase in duty, it still has beneficial features in normal operation.
When the diode connected in series to the reset winding in figure 4(b) turns on, the voltage across
the reset winding equals the input voltage (Vin). Furthermore, a reverse voltage based on the wind-
ing ratio of the two windings is applied across Lm and this reverse voltage completely resets the
energy. Unlike the concept associated with the above RCD circuit, which consumes the energy
stored in Lm, the reset method, which returns the stored energy in Lm to the input using the reset
winding, is more advantageous in terms of efficiency. However, if the input voltage decreases, the
reverse voltage across Lm decreases and, ultimately, the max duty becomes limited. Therefore,
where normal operation is required even at low input voltage, the reset circuit based on the above
RCD circuit can be advantageous.
6
1.3 Coupled Inductor Circuit
D5 Va
+12V
i2
Io2
+ VL2 −
−VLe+
Vb 12V
D4 Le
N:1
Vb
+5V
Va 5V
i1
L1
Io1 + VL1 −
The output of the forward converter applied in an actual PC SMPS is not simply one but multi-
outputs of 3.3V, 5V and ±12V, usually. Among these, the 5V and 12V outputs design the secondary
side inductor as a coupled inductor, which uses the same core, as shown in figure 5. The main
reason for using the coupled, 5V and 12V inductors is to raise the cross regulation between the
two voltages resulting from load fluctuations. If the turn ratio between the two windings and the turn
ratio of the transformer do not match when designing this type of coupled inductor, a ripple current
increases toward one of the two outputs (Figure 6b/c). This is described well in the equivalent
circuit in figure 5.1. If the turn ratio of the coupled inductor is designed well to be 5:12 when the
duty is 50%, the transformer turn ratio should be determined such that Va and Vb become 10V and
24V, respectively, for normal operation. However, a case where Vb was designed low such that it
only outputs 22V because the transformer turn ratio was not appropriate will be examined.
In such a case, the voltage across L1(VL1) becomes 5V and, accordingly, voltage across L2 (VL2)
becomes 12V based on the turn ratio. In addition, the voltage across the leakage inductor has a
reverse voltage of -2V and the current shape is such that the ripple voltage at the 5V terminal
becomes much larger, as shown by figure 6(c).In order to optimize the ripple current characteristics
at the two output terminals, the turn ratio should be determined such that turn ratio of transformer
at the two output terminals and the turn ratio of the inductor match. In an actual circuit, this type of
turn ratio matching is quite tricky. This is because the diode drop voltage varies according to the
amount of output current and because it is difficult to obtain a positive turn ratio.Therefore, an
actual design should consider these points such that the output voltage and turn ratio are best
matched.
7
i2
i2
Io2
Io2
i1 i1
Io1 Io1
i1+i2 i1+i2
a) When the winding ratio between the transformer inductor is well matched b) When the transformers 12V terminal is high
i2
Io2
i1
Io1
i1+i2
Slope Compensation
Sub-harmonic shows cyclic distortion at a frequency lower than the basic switching frequency and,
consequently, does not exceed the input power of 50% duty during normal operation. A subhar-
monic is generated when the duty is above 50% at continuous current mode (CCM) in the peak
current control mode. This sub-harmonic is created when the waveforms input to the two PWM
comparator inputs do not meet at the point where they are to supposed to coincide. This is
because the error amp output of the voltage loop phase lags behind the output voltage waveform.
8
OSC
Vfb +
ERR Ve S Q
Σ −
AMP Comp
Vref − R
+
Vc
Slope
Compensation T
Indutor
Current
T
Figure 8 shows current waveform distortions according to duty when controlled as an open loop
with an ∆Io error. In figure 8a, when the duty is less than 50%, ∆Io converges after few cycles have
passed but, in figure 8b, when duty is over 50%, ∆Io gradually gets larger as cycles pass and
results in the generation of sub-harmonic oscillation. On the other hand, in figure 8c, even when
duty is over 50%, with slope compensation applied at the error amp output, ∆Io converges after
few cycles as in figure 8a and, consequently, shows normal operation. Even if duty exceeds 50%
due to the lowering of the input voltage, normal output can be supplied without input power limita-
tion from subharmonics by applying slope compensation. Consequently, the desired hold up time
requirement can be satisfied even using a small input capacitor. The optimum compensation can
be obtained when using 1/2 the negative slope (M2) of the current waveform in figure 2 as the
slope, generally, for slope compensation.
M2
M1 M2
M1
∆IO
∆I1 Inductor ∆IO Inductor
D ∆I1
D
Ve
Compensating slope
M1 M2
∆IO
Inductor
D ∆I1
After having reviewed slope compensation for improving the subharmonic oscillation when control-
ling through the peak current mode, the application of slope compensation in a circuit with FPS will
Rev C, May 2002
9
be examined. With FPS, the application circuit for slope compensation can be formed more simply
than the existing 3842 series, as shown by Figure 9. It can be formed by using the voltage wave-
form of the VCC terminal winding of the transformer. A negative slope can be obtained when C1
discharges due to the negative voltage at the VCC terminal when the SW is on. This slope is deter-
mined by R1 and C1 time constants; the equation is presented below. C1 value should be ten
times the C2 value and R1 value can be calculated from equation 1. It can be then designed with
the desired slope.
SPS
FB
C2
R1
Ton Toff
Vs waveform + iC1
+
Vs C1
−
Vc1
R1 Linear slope
∆Vc
+
−
V + C1
Discharge
t
ton
—ton ⁄ R 1 C 1
∆V C 1 = V S ( e —1 )………1
Figure 10. Equivalent circuit of the interval when the SW is ON and FB terminal actual waveform
Figure 11 shows the flyback method auxiliary power supply circuit with KA5H0165R, controlled
through primary regulation. The next section reviews each stage of operation of this type of auxil-
iary power supply terminal.
10
L201
R101
C101
D201
R102
+ +
EC201 R201 EC202
D103 D102
C104
+
1: SOURCE
2: DRAIN 3 2
3: VCC
4: Feedback 1H0165R
ZD101
C103 + 1 4
R104
C105
R103
2.1 Start-up
Because the PC SMPS input terminal always uses the voltage doubler, it rectifies with the DC volt-
age of 220VAC even if 110VAC is input. Therefore, the start up condition for a auxiliary power sup-
ply can be calculated based on the 220V input power supply condition flyback design. The start up
current consumed in the internal UVLO block before the FPS starts-up is defined to be Max 450µA.
Furthermore, the start-up voltage to start internal blocks is 15V and the stop voltage to stop them is
10V.
Furthermore, an appropriate start-up resistance for the auxiliary power supply is calculated such
that current over 450µA needed at the start can be supplied to the IC even at the lowest DC input
conditions.
The time after the AC is input and before the auxiliary power supply starts is determined based on
the start-up resistance and capacitance (C103) connected in parallel to the VCC terminal.
D1 D2
R1
−
Cfb
R2 +
Ids
*R1 + R2 = 3kΩ
11
Figure 12 shows the block diagram of the FPS internal feedback terminal and the external applica-
tion circuit used for primary regulation.
When the feedback terminal in the figure is operating normally, Vfb voltage is set to always main-
tain a fixed VCC voltage and compared to the transformer inductor sensing current (Ids) to deter-
mine the PWM duty.
Furthermore, the secondary side output voltage, proportional to the primary side voltage, is based
on the transformer turn ratio. To increase the load regulation of the output voltage due to load vari-
ations, the coupling coefficient between the primary and secondary side should be designed high
when making the transformer and an appropriate dummy resistance attached to the load terminal.
The advantage of primary regulation is the cost down effect, but its disadvantage is that precise
output voltage regulation is difficult when the load variation is wide.
However, it is useful in a system where the load variation is comparatively stable after power has
been applied.
Table 2 shows the parts list of figure 11 needed to form the auxiliary power supply
The operation of this remote control can be understood through the FPS internal block in figure
13(b). As shown by the figure, the current source controls the FPS internal feedback terminal. Fur-
thermore, all three, internal diodes are on from 0~3V in the initial state and their voltages are
almost equal. Consequently, Vfb, VSS and VCO have the same potentials. Furthermore, if TRs of
the photocouplers connected to feedback and soft -start terminals completely saturate in Figure 13
12
(b), all the current from the current source discharges through the feedback terminal and S/S termi-
nal paths and eventually VCO becomes lower than 0.2V, the transistor saturation voltage. Because
the positive terminal of the comparator in figure 13 (b) has a 0.1V offset, the negative terminal of
the internal comparator (Comp1) always has a voltage less than the positive terminal if VCO is less
than 0.2V and, as a result, the comparator output becomes high state. If the comparator output
maintains the high state, the FPS cannot switch any further and cuts off the main power supply ter-
minal operation. Again, to start the main power supply operation, the TR in the secondary side is
turned off and OP1 and OP2, which were held back in the primary side, are released. Because the
VCC voltage is normal at this time, soft start operation starts like the before and the main power
source terminal switches normally. The reason for making the feedback terminal and soft start ter-
minal GND level simultaneously for the remote control is as follows:
First, even if OP2 was eliminated and OP1 in the feedback terminal saturated, VCO drops below
0.2V as mentioned before and the main power supply terminal stops switching and its operation
stops. However, VSS remains at 5V because the diode connected to the soft start terminal has
been cut-off and, therefore, it cannot execute FPS soft start when the main power terminal is
restarted. Therefore, to make the initial state or equal conditions to turn on/ off the main power sup-
ply terminal using the remote control, the soft start terminal must be “downed” to the GND level.
Furthermore, even when the soft start terminal OP2 is “downed” to the GND level and the feedback
terminal OP1 left as is, VCO drops below 0.2V and the main power supply terminal stops operating.
However, the problem that arises at this point is that Vfb gradually increases due to the 5µA current
supply source connected to the feedback terminal. When the feedback voltage reaches 7.5V, FPS
latches -up due to the internal protection circuit and, once latched-up, the latched-up state does
not release until VCC falls below 5V. Therefore, even if the main power supply terminal is turned on
by the remote control, the FPS remains latched-up and does not operate.
The feedback terminal potential is dropped to the GND level to prevent the feedback voltage from
rising to 7.5V by flowing 5µA through OP1.
Though the method of cutting off the FPS VCC power of the main power supply exists for remote
control of the main power supply besides the above method, dropping the soft-start and feedback
terminal voltages to GND level is simpler and effective in terms of circuitry for faster control based
on the remote control signal. Figure 14 shows the application circuit of the PC SMPS, which
require the auxiliary power supply, with FPS, above examined slope compensation and possible
remote-On/ Off control.
The auxiliary power supply terminal has the flyback configuration primary regulation method with
KA5H0165R and the main power supply terminal is designed to have the forward configuration
with KA1M0880D allowing 5V and 12V outputs. The auxiliary power supply VCC winding supplies
the DC input to the FPS VCC of the main power supply and, once the AC input power is supplied,
the auxiliary power supply always operate normally.
13
VCC
SPS
GND SS FB
+
OP2
+
OP1
OP1
(a)
5µA 1mA
VCO
Comp1
Feedback
−
Vfb +
OP1
+
SPS
OP2
(b)
Figure 13. Application circuit for remote control(a) and FPS internal block diagram(b)
14
C101 R101
R102
D101
D102
3 2
+ +
EC201 EC202
ZD101
1H0165R R201
C103 1 4
+
R104
C102
R103
DC input
C6 R3 R4 D5 L2
+12V
+
D2 D4
+5V
R9
+ +
C13 C14 R10
3 1 R12 R13
R11
2 1M0880
R8
+ 5 4
C7
OP1 OP2
+ C8
C10 D6
C9 TR1
OP2 IC3
OP1
C15 C16
Remote on / off
signal
15
3. KNOWN CAUTIONARY ITEMS WHEN DESIGNING TO APPLY THE FPS
Until now, the forward converter operation with FPS and FPS application circuit configuration
method according to the various, special conditions of the PC SMPS were examined. Next, the
known cautionary items when designing a circuit with FPS will be reviewed.
One of the main items for caution when laying out the SMPS PCB is always the separation of the
power GND and the Signal GND. The FPS package internally has a common GND so the power
GND and Signal GND must be separated at the shortest possible point from the lead frame GND-
Pin and the GND pattern length made shortest possible when laying out the PCB. (Refer to figure
15 )
Sense
FET
IC
DC link capacitor
(Refer to Figure 16) The sensing current noise can greatly affect the PCB pattern, but, by using
slope compensation as shown in Figure 16, the PCB could be designed more prudently. The
standard values of the components used for slope compensation are presented in Figure 16. The
above values is applicable to all flyback configured SMPS.
16
Vfb
isense (a) Ideal case
switching error
Slope
Compensation
(c) Slope Compensation
VCC
VCC
1H0165R
1H0165R
FB
FB
272
272
333 2.2k
Figure 16. Origin for switching oscillation at no load and slope compensation application
Referance
[1] Switch Mode Power Supply Handbook, Keith H. Billings, McGraw-Hill, Inc., 1989
[2] “Coupled Filter Inductors in Multiple Output Buck Regulators Provide Dramatic Performance
Improvement,” L. H. Dixon, Unitrode Seminar Manual SEM500
[3] “Modeling, Analysis and Compensation of the Current-Mode Converter”, Unitrode Application
Note(U-97), Unitrode Linear Integrated Circuits Data Book and Applications Handbook
Author
Sangtae, Im is an application engineer in Power Device Division, Fairchild Electronics Co., LTD.
Tel. 82-32-680-1275
Fax. 82-32-680-1317
E-mail. [email protected]
17