Psicoeducacion en Salud Mental PDF
Psicoeducacion en Salud Mental PDF
Psicoeducacion en Salud Mental PDF
WALLBOTT,H: G. (1980). The measurement of human expression. In W . von Raffler-Engel (bd.), Aspecis of
nonverbal communication (pp. 203-228). Lisse: Swets & Zeitlinger.
WALLBOTT,H. G. (l982a). Contributions of the German “Expression psychology” to nonverbal behavior
research. Part 111: Gait, gestures, and body movement. Journal of Nonverbal Behavior, 7. 20-32.
WALLBOTT,H. G. (l982b). Bewegungsstil und Bewegungsqualitiii. Weinheim: Beltz.
WAXER,P. H. (1974). Nonverbal cues for depression. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 83. 319-322.
WAXER,P. H. (1976). Nonverbal cues for depth of depression: Set vs. no set. Journal of Consulting and
Clinical Psychology, 44, 493.
WOLFF,C. (1951). The hand in psychological diagnosis. London: Methuen.
The past 15 years have witnessed the emergence of the view that psychological prac-
titioners and counselors should consider educational training as a therapeutic modality.
Patterson (1967) was among the first to suggest educational training as therapeutic treat-
ment and to advocate the efficacy of an increasingly explicit teacher role for the therapist.
Subsequently, psychoeducational programs have been based on the premise that any
effective treatment must be focused rapidly and efficiently on assisting the individual to
develop or to improve specific life skills (Authier, Gustafson, Guerney, & Kasdorf, 1975;
Gazda & Brooks, 1980). Fundamental to this approach is the identification of coping
skills and therapeutic strategies for increasing these skills in persons with psychological
or emotional difficulties.
The authors express appreciation to the professional staff of the Departments of Nursing, Chaplaincy,
Psychiatry, Psychology, Rehabilitation Medicine, Social Work and Dietetics of the Veterans Administration
Medical Center, Augusta, Georgia, for their support and contribution to this study.
Reprint requests should be addressed to Harold J. May, Department of Family Medicine, East Carolina
University School of Medicine, P.O. Box 1846, Greenville, North Carolina 27834.
360 Journal of Clinical Psychology, May 1985, Vol. 41, N o . 3
Gazda and Powell (198 1) state that any effective therapy or intervention performed
with dysfunctional individuals has as its ultimate goal to assist them to develop or to im-
prove their life coping skills. The more direct the intervention strategy, the more effective
and efficient it is likely to be. In an evaluation of a treatment program in a community
mental health center, Brown (1980) compared psychoeducational training based on self-
regulatory skills to a group-counseling condition. Patients who were receiving skill train-
ing rated themselves lower on measures of anxiety and fearfulness and higher on indices
of assertiveness than the control group immediately after treatment and at 3-month
follow-up. Furthermore, fewer skill training participants were hospitalized within 1 year
after participation than were control subjects. Bogdanow (1977) also found that when
major attention was given to increasing patients’ coping skills, the probability of relapse
and rehospitalization was decreased.
Although intervention strategies focused on the acquisition of coping skills are
generally shorter-term and more goal-directed than traditional therapeutic approaches,
target skills to be acquired have varied widely. Examples of coping behaviors included in
psychoeducational training are: Anxiety management (Suinn & Richardson, 1971),
assertion (Alberti & Emmons, 1974), personal effectiveness (Liberman, King, DeRisi, &
McCann, 1975), and interpersonal communication (Powell & Clayton, 1980). In propos-
ing a general theoretical position for psychoeducational training, Gazda (198 1) suggests
that these generic life skills may be categorized according to the various areas of human
development (psychosocial, moral, physical-sexual, cognitive ego, emotional, and
vocational).
Although psychoeducational training has focused largely on emotional and psy-
chosocial life skills, research that has related physical fitness to behavioral variables such
as improved mood, self-concept and anxiety suggests the psychological benefits of fitness
training (Folkins & Sim, 1981; Morgan & Horstman, 1976). Improvements in car-
diovascular functioning after physical training, for example, have been associated with
reports of an increased sense of well-being (Buffone, 1980) and with more effective
management of emotional stress (Chapman & Mitchell, 1965).
The present study was designed to investigate the effectiveness of a comprehensive
program of life skill training (cf. Gazda, 1981) based on a psychoeducational model with
a sample of hospitalized psychiatric patients. Specifically, three skill training areas were
included: (1) interpersonal communication; (2) purpose in life problem solving; and (3)
physical fitness. These coping skill components correspond to the psychosocial, moral,
and physical areas of human development, respectively. The experimental program was
compared to a verbal counseling intervention that emphasized the analysis and discus-
sion of personal concerns. Only the participants in the psychoeducational program
received direct skills training.
METHOD
Subjects
Subjects included 54 male psychiatric patients of a Veterans Administration
Medical Center in the southeastern United States. Subjects were drawn from two treat-
ment wards in one residential building of the hospital. Participation in the study was on a
voluntary basis, and subjects were given the right to refuse any aspects of treatment.
Twenty-eight subjects volunteered and completed life skill training. They ranged in
age from 20 to 59 years (M = 37.67, S D = 11.02) and completed 12.33 years of educa-
tion (SD = 1.42). The majority were Caucasian (N = 21); previous psychiatric
hospitalizations ranged from 0 to 20 admissions (M = 3.52, SD = 4.85). Distribution of
psychiatric diagnoses for subjects who were participating in life skill training fell into the
following categories: Depression (N = lo), Schizophrenia, chronic undifferentiated type
(N = 5), Personality disorder (N = 5 ) , Anxiety disorder (N = 3), Schizophrenia, other
types (N = 2), Schizoaffective disorder (N = l), Paranoia (N = 1).
Life Skill Training 36 I
Assessments of ward behavior of subjects, via the NOSIE-30, also were made both
pre- and posttreatment. Two trained raters made independent behavioral observations
on each subject. An interrater reliability of .99 was obtained on the nurse-rater obser-
vations.
Fifteen bipolar adjectives that related to perceived satisfaction with hospital treat-
ment were included in the semantic differential scale. The bipolar adjective pairs were
ordered randomly and randomly polarized in the scale. Test administration occurred
only during the posttreatment evaluation period.
Posttreatment evaluation of blood pressure, heart rate, and respiratory capacity
also occurred after the completion of patients’ respective intervention program.
Group Descriptions
Life skill training (LST). Three training modules were selected for inclusion in the
study: Interpersonal communication, purpose in life problem solving, and physical
fitness/health maintenance. Training in each module occurred concurrently during the 2-
week period of programmed treatment.
Interpersonal communication is designed to teach group members attending, listen-
ing and responding skills. Via role play, videotape recording and group demonstration,
subjects learn the communication skills of appropriate attending behavior (verbal and
nonverbal), responding to content and feelings, and responding in a facilitative manner to
others. The human relations model of Gazda et al. (1975) served as the format for skills
training. Groups met four times per week for 1Y2 hours.
Subjects in the purpose in life training group were taught problem solving skills that
focused on the behavioral dimensions of anxiety, loneliness, grief, loss of self-worth, and
depression (Fabry, 1981; Frankl, 1974). The training model of Crumbaugh (1971, 1972)
served as a foundation of this group. Six 1-hour sessions were conducted in which sub-
jects developed behavioral and cognitive strategies for each problem area previously
defined.
Training in physical fitness and health maintenance was designed to enable group
members to develop knowledge and skills of nutrition and weight control and to perform
proper exercise. Subjects received 10 hours of instruction in nutrition and diet selection,
monitoring eating patterns and vital signs; an exercise program that involved the use of
major muscle groups was initiated for each participant.
Psychiatric treatment control group. Subjects in this group received daily group
counseling and occupational therapy and participated in ward meetings relating to group
interaction. Foci of intervention were on the analysis and exploration of individual
problems and the resolution of personal conflicts. No direct skills training via group
sessions was provided nor were subjects given a skill-building rationale of treatment.
However, after completion of the study, it was discovered that several TC subjects sought
and received some training in physical fitness and health maintenance on an individual
basis.
RESULTS
Table 1 presents the means and standard deviations of pre- and posttest scores on
the dependent measures for Life Skill Training (LST) and treatment control (TC)
groups. The first major analysis compared the scores of LST and TC subjects on six of
the outcome measures used in the study. Because LST subjects were found to be younger,
better educated, and had fewer hospital admissions, analysis of covariance statistical
procedure was selected to adjust for possible pretreatment sampling differences between
the two subject groups.
After treatment intervention, significant differences between the two groups were
evident on the GS and PIL ratings. Subjects who received LST obtained significantly
Life Skill Training 363
Table I
Means and Standard Deviations of the Pre- and Posttreatment Scores on the Dependent
Measures for Experimental and Control Groups
Pretreatment Posttreatment
Index Group N. M SD M SD
GS LST (26) 1.45 .26 2.10 .42
TC (26) 1.47 .2 I I .48 .21
PIL LST (22) 78.41 28.01 99.86 22.23
TC (22) 92.32 19.34 93.68 20.94
BPb LST (20) 126.60 11.55 123.70 7.35
TC (20) 126.45 7.69 124.55 6.37
HR LST (19) 80.11 9.28 78.32 7.05
TC (19) 84.11 9.79 8 1.79 9.91
FVC LST (19) 42.26 7.84 43.58 1.67
TC (19) 39.84 6.49 4 I .47 6.40
NOSIE LST (25) 50.24 4.14 46.86 7.58
TC (25) 51.36 7.92 46.96 7.99
Sm Dif LST (19) - - 83.60 18.04
TC (19) - - 73.75 16.61
.Number in parentheses indicates the number of patients who completed pre- and posttests.
blndicates systolic blood pressure.
Measure Group t
LST and TC group members on measures of blood pressures, heart rate, or forced vital
capacity. Furthermore, no significant differences were found between groups on staff
observation of subject ward behavior or symptoms.
In order to evaluate intragroup changes from pre- to posttreatment, further
statistical analyses were performed. Intragroup differences were evaluated by use of the
correlated t statistic, and results of these analyses are presented in Table 2. This table
reveals several areas of improvement for both LST and TC subjects.
Subjects who received LST demonstrated significant pre-post gains in interpersonal
communication ( 2 = 7.62, p <.001), meaningful purpose in life ( t = 4.34, p <.01), and
forced vital capacity ( t = 2.09, p <.05); a significant decrease in psychopathological
behavior also was reported ( t = 3 . 1 2 , ~<.01). Although results failed to reach a signifi-
cant level of difference, a trend toward improvement on pre-post evaluation of blood
pressure ( t = 1 . 9 0 , ~<.lo) and heart rate ( t = - 1 . 9 2 , ~<.lo) was noted for LST sub-
jects. In addition, despite no demonstrated differences between groups on satisfaction
with treatment, a trend in favor of LST subjects was observed after completion of train-
ing.
Table 3
Follow-up Data on LST and TC Subjects
LST TC
~~
Rehospitalization
12 months 6 7
24 months 29 29
Employment (at 24 months)
Employed 22% 21%
Unemployed 78% 79%
Exercise pattern (at 24 months)
Little or none 22% 21%
Occasional 56% 50%
Regular (> 3 times/wk) 22% 29%
Exercise and diet plan maintained? (at 24 months)
Yes 56% 14%
No 44% 86%
Satisfied with treatment? (at 24 months)
No 0% 0%
Slightly 22% 0%
Moderately 33% 21%
Very 45% 79%
Current Method Health Treatment
Yes 89% 64%
No 11% 36%
Frequency
Weekly 0% 22%
Monthly 74% 77%
> Monthly 26% I I%
Medication 89% 43%
Lge Skill Training 365
Study findings in the area of physical fitness and health maintenance are more
equivocal than results of training in communication skills or purpose in life problem solv-
ing. LST participants improved their physical fitness, as reflected in increased
respiratory capacity, while TC subjects improved respiratory functioning and decreased
blood pressure and heart rate. These results are especially encouraging given the
relatively brief, 2-week duration of treatment. Although the LST group engaged in a
daily exercise program to improve physical conditioning and muscle tone and were in-
structed in vital sign monitoring, it is possible that the unstructured activities of recrea-
tion for the TC subjects may have approximated the planned exercise regimen of LST.
Also, the discovery that subjects in the TC group had requested and received instruction
in physical fitness and health maintenance on an individual basis suggests that
experimental-control group differences would be minimal. Finally, the dietary restric-
tions of a controlled hospital environment may have equalized gains for both groups.
This study has indicated that hospitalized subjects can improve their physical fitness
as measured by several physiologic indices. The issue of generalizability and continuation
of fitness levels, however, remains to be addressed by future research. Further
longitudinal studies are necessary to assess whether the motivational aspects of LST (i.e.,
education in exercise patterns, nutrition and diet selection, monitoring of eating patterns)
can facilitate continued improvement in fitness and health maintenance. It also may be
useful to appraise an individual’s attitudinal change toward exercise and fitness subse-
quent to a skill-based training approach, thereby broadening the base of outcome
measures to include both physiologic as well as psychologic variables.
Although pre- to posttreatment ratings by ward staff indicated significant decreases
in observed behavior pathology for both groups, results in favor of the LST group were
only mildly apparent. However, findings of the study provide further evidence that symp-
tomatic change may occur after brief, time-limited treatment. This result supports the
previous research of Glick, Hargreaves, Drues, Showstack, and Katzow (1977), which
found no reliable outcome differences between short-term and long-term hospitalization.
Limitations imposed by experimentally non-controlled variables, such as psy-
chopharmacologic treatment, should be recognized in interpreting the results of this
study. Despite attempts to equalize the amount of time spent in treatment for each
group, the effects of chemotherapy on subject improvement may hamper generalization
of outcome results.
Unfortunately, available follow-up data on rehospitalization rates, employment,
self-reported diet/exercise patterns, and patient satisfaction suggest that neither skill-
based training intervention nor traditional insight-oriented therapy emerged as superior
to the other on these measures. The limited number of subjects who were able to be con-
tacted on follow-up (32% of LST; 54% of TC) brings into question the representativeness
of this sample in comparison to the original study population. However, because
rehospitalization rates at 12 and 24 months were available for all of the original subjects,
these measures could be viewed as more useful for longitudinal comparison. Inspection
of these hospitalization rates reveals a pattern that is virtually identical between the two
groups at both review dates. Based on the available data, it remains to be determined
whether the acquisition of coping skills will become a valid and reliable predictor of im-
proved psychological adjustment for chronic psychiatric patients. However, at the pre-
sent time it appears that non-traditional, skill-based training was unable to alter
rehospitalization rates for these patients during the 2 years posttreatment.
In an age of growing cost accountability, the economic impact of short-term, skill-
based training in mental health facilities should be explored. Because the psy-
choeducational model of LST may result in rapid skill acquisition and decreased
behavior pathology in participants, the cost-benefits of this treatment regimen should be
addressed in follow-up studies. The economic advantage of shorter hospitalizations when
skill-based training is employed may become more apparent, particularly if further
research and evaluation support the efficacy of short-term psychoeducational training.
Life Skill Training 367
REFERENCES
ALBERTI,R., & EMMONS,M. (1974). Your perfect right. San Luis Obispo, CA: Impact Press.
AUTHIER,J., GUSTAFSON,K., GUERNEY, B., & KASDORF,J. (1975). The psychological practitioner as a
teacher: A theoretical-historical and practical review. Counseling Psychologist, 5, 3 1-50.
BOGDANOW, W. J. (1977). Predicting rehospitalization among mental patients. Dissertation Abstracts Inter-
national, 37, 7357.
BROWN,S . D. (1980). Coping skills training: An evaluation of a psychoeducational program in a community
mental health setting. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 27. 340-345.
BUFFONE,G. W. (1980). Exercise as therapy: A closer look. Journal of Counseling and Psychotherapy. 3,
101-1 15.
CARKHUFF, R. R. (1969). Helping and human relations (Vols. 1 & 2). New York: Holt, Rinehart, & Winston.
CHAPMAN, C. B., & MITCHELL,J. H. (1965). The physiology of exercise. Scientific American, 212, 88-96.
CRUMBAUGH, J. C. (1971). Frankl’s logotherapy: A new orientation in counseling. Journal of Religion and
Health, 10, 373-386.
CRUMBAUGH, J. C. (1972). Changes in Frankl’s existential vacuum as a measure of therapeutic outcome.
Newsletter for Research in Psychology, 14, 35-37.
CRUMBAUGH, J. C., & MAHOLICK, L. T. (1964). An experimental study in existentialism: The psychometric
approach to Frankl’s concept of noogenic neurosis. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 20. 200-207.
FABRY, J. (1981). Logotherapy in sharing groups. In G. M. Gazda (Ed.), Innovations togrouppsychotherapy
(2nd ed.). Springfield, IL: Charles C Thomas.
FOLKINS,D. H., & SIM,W. E. (1981). Physical fitness training and mental health. American Psychologist,
36, 373-389.
FRANKL,V. E. (1974). Man’s search for meaning. New York: Pocket Books.
GAZDA,G. M. (1981). Multiple impact training. In R. J. Corsini (Ed.), Innovative psychotherapies. New
York: John Wiley.
GAZDA,G. M., & BROOKS,D. K. (1980). Life-skills training: A comprehensive approach to developmental
intervention. Journal for Specialists in Group Work, 5. 120-126.
GAZDA,G. M., & POWELL,M. (1981). Multiple impact training: A model for teaching/training life skills. In
G. M. Gazda (Ed.), Innovations to group psychotherapy (2nd ed.). Springfield, IL: Charles C Thomas.
GAZDA,G. M., WALTERS,R., & CHILDERS,W. (1975). Human relations development: A manual for health
sciences. Boston: Allyn & Bacon.
GLICK,I. D., HARGREAVES, W. A., DRUES,J., SHOWSTACK, J. A., & KATZOW,J. E. (1977). Short VS. long
hospitalization: A prospective controlled study. Archives of General Psychiatry. 34, 3 14-3 17.
HONIGFELD, G. H., GILLIS,R., & KLETT,C. (1966). NOSIE-30: A treatment-sensitive ward behavior scale.
Psychological Reports, 19, 180-182.
LIBERMAN, R., KING, L., DERISI,W., & MCCANN,M. (1975). Personal efectiveness. Champaign, IL:
Research Press.
MORGAN, W. P., & HORSTMAN, D. H. (1976). Anxiety reduction following acute physical activity. Medicine
and Science in Sports, 8, 62.
PATTERSON, C. H. (1967). The selection of counselors. In J. M. Whitely (Ed.), Research in counseling.
Columbus, 0: Merrill.
POWELL,M. F., & CLAYTON,M. S. (1980). Efficacy of human relations training on selected coping behaviors
of veterans in a psychiatric hospital. Journal for Specialists in Group Work. 5 , 170-176.
SUINN,R., & RICHARDSON, F. (1971). Anxiety management training. Behavior Therapy, 2. 498-510.
VITALO,R. (1971). Teaching improved interpersonal functioning as a preferred mode of treatment. Journal
of Clinical Psychology, 27, 166-171.