Leisure Travel and Business Travel: A Comparative Analysis: January 2008
Leisure Travel and Business Travel: A Comparative Analysis: January 2008
Leisure Travel and Business Travel: A Comparative Analysis: January 2008
net/publication/37359087
CITATIONS READS
2 1,860
3 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Mieke Witsel on 13 February 2020.
INTRODUCTION
Many persons, especially those who have studied tourism or who work in
travel and tourism industries, are aware of the broad difference between
leisure travel and business travel. However, as Mr Bert Van Walbeck recently
remarked to one of the co-authors of this paper, the comprehensive
difference between these two categories of travel or tourism seems to be an
unexplored topic. Bert’s experience as general manager of 5 star hotels, and
*Correspondence concerning this more recently as a consultant to developers and managers of luxury resort
article should be addressed to
Neil Leiper. Electronic mail hotels in various countries in Asia, would suggest that there are probably
may be sent via internet to many persons interested in travel and tourism unable to provide a detailed
[email protected]. analytical comparison of leisure travel and business travel.
The authors of this article were such persons when Bert raised the topic. His
challenge led to a decision to begin a small scale study aiming to compare
Copyright © 2008
Rex Publishing Co. business travel and leisure travel. A review of syllabi in a number of
university courses found that leisure travel/tourism and business travel/
tourism receive frequent mention but the differences between the two
categories are not considered in any depth.
The next step was a search of the research related activities and business-related activities.
literature. The search encompassed ‘travel’ and This refers to the practice of going on a trip
‘tourism’. Although there are interesting reasons when some time is spent on business and some
for distinguishing travel and tourism, many in diverse forms of recreation such as sightseeing,
researchers and institutions use these terms as shopping, relaxing in a resort or playing sport. So
synonyms. This article will follow that custom. far as is known, no wide-ranging statistical data
As expected, several publications were found on have been published on this phenomenon
aspects of business travel, such as Mason (2000), although Yesawich’s (2006) research, noted
Hankinson (2005), Harris and Uncles (2007) and earlier, is salient.
Tani (2005), and more were found that discussed
aspects of leisure travel: Ryan and Glendon On many trips, business travelers have no spare
(1998), Gladwell and Bedini (2004), Leiper (2004) time for leisure, while on many other trips they
and Moore, Cushman and Simmons (2005). have a few hours free after daily work
commitments. Many have a day or more free
Only two articles were found in the research after commitments are complete, before
literature that compared leisure travelers and returning to their homes in other cities. In
business travelers and neither attempted a generic contrast, the majority of travelers whose trips are
comparison, but focused instead on narrow, dominated by leisure – i.e. tourists on holidays,
albeit interesting, facets. Yavas and Babakus called ‘vacations’ by Americans - engage in no
(2005) investigated the criteria shaping choice of business activities excepting, for some
hotels in these two groups, by surveying a sample individuals, keeping in touch with work
of 500 guests in hotels in the USA. As might colleagues and work issues via phone or email.
have been anticipated, the two groups tended to
apply different criteria or, as the researchers Ten Possible Generic Differences
expressed it, “the congruence was weak” (p 359).
The second article (Yesawich 2006) reported on a In this section, certain differences between
study of affluent travelers and found that they business travel and leisure travel are reviewed.
prefer to separate business and leisure, that is, They can be expressed as ten questions: (i) what
affluent persons seldom go on trips for a mix of is the core difference between leisure and
business and leisure purposes. business? (ii) what types of experiences occur?
(iii) what are the focal points of the experiences?
Since there is no known research that provides an (iv) what is the mental process linking travelers
analytical comparison of business travel and and destinations? (v) what needs underlie
leisure travel as generic sets (i.e. in general, not in motivations for traveling? (vi) whose interests are
relation to a specific activity such as choosing served? (vii) who pays the costs and are there tax
hotels), the present article is a preliminary implications? (viii) what is the duration of trips?
attempt to fill this gap. Ten dimensions of (ix) what is the frequency of trips? and (x) who
possible differences between leisure travel and manages the trips?
business travel were identified. That approach is
used for structuring the first section of the (i) The core difference between leisure and business
discussion below. Before listing the ten
dimensions, mixed trips should be noted. For most individuals, most leisure and most
business occurs in their normal environments, in
Some Trips Mix Business and Leisure and near the city or town where they reside.
Relatively small proportions of leisure and
A characteristic of modern travel (or tourism) is business occur away from such places. The
that many trips involve a combination of leisure- discussion in this section is about leisure and
March 2008 2
NEIL LEIPER, MIEKE WITSEL AND J.S. PERRY HOBSON
business, not leisure travel and business travel. Business is different from leisure in several,
The core differences identified here carry over related ways. Business activity is normally
into the later sections where the focus is on travel regarded as obligatory, not optional. (Leisure
or tourism. does not normally have this attribute.) Business is
purposeful in particular ways: aimed at earning a
What is leisure? Summarizing a literature review living, and also aimed, in the minds of many
on the topic Leiper (2004) defined leisure as a individuals, at creating useful services, products
category of experiences with recreational and or facilities for society. (Many types of leisure
creative sub-categories, pursued with a relative activities are also purposeful, e.g. when persons
sense of freedom from obligations and regarded rest with the purpose of recovering from fatigue,
as personally pleasurable. According to but leisure is does not have the same purposes as
Dumazedier’s (1967) classic study of leisure, business.) Business normally occupies individuals
recreational leisure re-creates participants via for many hours of most days. (Leisure, in
experiences which restore, revive, or return them contrast, is mostly experienced in small chunks of
to their former condition, a recovery. Recreation time: an hour or two on working days, a day or
has three functions: rest, relaxation and two at weekends.) Business is something that
entertainment. Rest re-creates by allowing a individuals normally expect to practice for a large
person to recover from physical or mental portion of their adult lives. (Leisure is something
fatigue. Relaxation is recovery from tension. that begins in childhood and continues past
Entertainment re-creates by restoring a person's working life into retirement.) Classic research
attention and spirits when they are bored. Usually studies by Studs Turkel (1994) and Henry
when a person has a recreational experiences, two Mintzberg (1996) provide detailed insights into
or three of these functions occur together. When the nature of work in modern societies.
we are simultaneously rested, relaxed and
entertained, we are inclined to sense pleasure, we Although most leisure for most persons occurs in
are ‘having a good time’. small chunks of time (e.g. an hour or a day)
certain leisure occurs in large chunks. This is the
While recreational leisure restores, creative leisure leisure of tourism, when people go on vacations,
brings about something new, in some thing or away from business, work and obligations for a
somebody. For example leisure in craft and art few days or several weeks on end.
hobbies results in the production of useful or
beautiful things and educational activities in (ii) What types of experiences occur?
leisure should lead to participants gaining new
knowledge or understanding. Cultural tourism, The most common experiences of business travel
which properly pursued is creative leisure, is are meetings in various formats with other
described by Stebbins (1996:948) as “serious business persons of various sorts, i.e. other
leisure”. employees, managers, proprietors, directors,
officials. During such meetings, diverse business
Leisure, in either category - recreational or activities occur, such as negotiations and
creative, is not synonymous with spare time. Free exchange of information. Tani’s (2005) survey of
time can be frittered away, wasted, or can be international business travelers to and from
consumed in worthy non-leisure activities. Australia, based on a survey of 210 such persons,
Everyone uses a portion of their free time on found that “knowledge sharing is a very common
activities they regard as important but not as motivation to undertake a business trip while
leisure. This might include times spent caring for boosting sales is less common. Business trips are
a sick relative, doing household chores, going to mechanisms to access, develop and transfer
the dentist. knowledge” (p419). Another characteristic of the
March 2008 4
NEIL LEIPER, MIEKE WITSEL AND J.S. PERRY HOBSON
Table 1.
Twelve Categories of Needs Underlying Tourists’ Motivations
Sunlight Common among residents of certain places who lack sunlight in their normal routines
Self-evaluation Common among tourists, but few recognize it until after a trip
Self-esteem, prestige, confidence building Common; many tourists fail to recognize it in themselves but see it in other persons
Time in company with friends and relatives The basis of VFR tourism
might, for example, be a mix of needs for interest of the travelers or tourists personally and,
relaxation and regression. The same individual on in many cases, other members of families on
a future trip might be motivated by a different trips, or families and friends visited during trips.
mix of needs. The number of such needs is
infinite, depending on the degree of detail in the (vii) Who pays the expenses and are there tax
analysis. A summary is in Figure 1. It lists twelve implications?
categories of needs, and notes certain
characteristics of each category. Business travel expenses (i.e. for transport,
accommodation and so on) are normally paid by
Business travelers are different, for they go on the organization where the traveler is employed.
trips because they, or their work colleagues or In contrast, the expenses incurred on trips for
bosses, believe the interests of their organization leisure travel are usually paid from the personal
or industry will be served by the trip. The resources of the traveler or their family.
motivation of the travelers may be based in their However, some organizations provide employees
need to serve the business organization where with fully-paid or subsidized holidays. Sometimes
they are employed, or their need to obey this is done in the guise of convention or
directives of their superiors. conference travel.
(vi) Whose interests are being served? A sign of this is when delegates travel some
distance, perhaps half way around the world, to
The purpose of business travel is to serve the attend a conference but attend few if any of its
interests of business. Therefore business travelers official sessions; instead they spend virtually all of
are in effect instruments, servants or agents, to the time in leisure-related activities, such as
that end. In contrast, leisure travel serves the sightseeing or shopping, away from the
March 2008 6
NEIL LEIPER, MIEKE WITSEL AND J.S. PERRY HOBSON
have increased remarkably: the research was used or tour operator is used to take responsibility for
by Qantas for designing a frequent flyer scheme. the overall scheme of trip arrangement and
Fat long tails in the distribution curves of coordination. Only a minority of leisure travel
multiple trips were a key to the increasing trips involve travel agents and/or tour operators.
importance, for airlines, of frequent flyers in their This fact should be recognized in the context of
markets. Some years later, fat long tails in the all travel on trips away from home for at least
distribution patterns of purchase frequencies by one night, a context where the large majority of
buyers of many types of goods and services trips are within the traveler’s country of
became a widely discussed topic in marketing residence. In developed economies, the bulk of
management, a topic popularized by Anderson such trips use private vehicles for transport and
(2006). A research comment by Kosko (2006) is private homes of relatives or friends for
also noteworthy. accommodation. In these circumstances, there is
no need for travel agents or tour operators.
Trip frequency, does not seem to represent a
generic difference between leisure travel and This dimension does not represent a generic
business travel. Differences are circumstantial. difference between leisure travel and business
travel. Any differences are circumstantial, varying
(x) Who Manages Trips? case-by-case.
March 2008 8
NEIL LEIPER, MIEKE WITSEL AND J.S. PERRY HOBSON
these two categories can be compared. The two case study - Visiting students in Israeli
analytical approaches help fill a gap in the Universities. Journal of Travel Research, 42(1),
research literature which to date has lacked a 36 - 47.
detailed comparison of leisure travel and business Connell, J. (2004). The purest of human
travel. The result is academically interesting, and pleasures: characteristics and motivations of
might have potential for application in planning, garden visitors in Great Britain. Tourism
marketing and management. That potential can Management, 25(2), 229 - 247.
be explored in a later project. Dumazedier, J. (1967). Towards a society of
leisure. London: Collier Macmillan.
The topics of leisure travel and business travel Gladwell, N. & Bedini, L.A. (2004). In search of
are rather like the topics of tourism and tourism lost leisure: The impact of care-giving on
industries: everyone knows broadly what is leisure travel. Tourism Management, 25(6), 685 -
involved but relatively few persons, even among 693.
those who study in or teach courses on tourism, Hankinson, G. (2005). Destination brand
are able to set out definitions that will stand up to images: A business tourism perspective.
objective scrutiny. The evidence is the Journal of Services Marketing, 19(1), 24 - 32.
uncertainty about the exact nature of tourism and Harris, J. & Uncles, M. (2007). Modeling the
tourism industries apparent in many textbooks. repatronage behavior of business airline
Stear, Leiper and Maior (2005) criticized these travelers. Journal of Service Research,9(4), 297-
texts, saying that difficulties in defining a 311.
subject’s central concepts should not be lazily Herold, E., Garcia, R. & DeMoya, T. (2001).
relegated to a too-hard-basket and, noting that Female tourists and beach boys, romance or
many academics specializing in tourism do just sex tourism? Annals of Tourism Research, 28(4),
that, they identified an impediment for the 978 - 997.
development of knowledge in this field, a Kosko, B. (2006). Most bell curves have thick
syndrome that they called “DUDS - Definitional tails. World Question Center, 2006. Retrieved
Uncertainty Debilitating Syndrome”. October 15, 2007 from http://
www.edge.org/q2006/q06_11.html.
Perhaps this article on business travel and leisure Leiper, N. (1984). International travel by
travel will go a little way to remedying DUDS in Australians 1946-1983: Travel propensities &
relation to its theme. This article is not the result travel frequencies. in contemporary issues in
of extensive research. It is a preliminary Australian tourism, Barry O’Rourke (ed.), pp
investigation. Accordingly, the authors will 67-83. University of Sydney: Dept of
appreciate comments, especially critical ones, and Geography.
suggestions to guide future research. ____ (2004). Tourism Management, 3rd edition,
Sydney: Pearson Education.
Mason, K.J. (2000). The propensity of business
REFERENCES
travellers to use low cost airlines. Journal of
Transport Geography, 8(2), 107-119.
Anderson, C. (2006). The long tail: Why the Mintzberg, H. (1996). The manager’s job. in the
future of business is selling less of more. strategy process: Concepts, contexts, cases,
New York: Hyperion. 3rd ed. H. Mintzberg and J. B. Quinn eds., pp
Charters, S. and Ali-Knight, J. (2002). Who is the 19-34. NJ: Prentice-Hall.
wine tourist? Tourism Management, 23(3), 311- Moore, K., Cushman, G. & Simmons, D. (1995).
319. Behavioral conceptualization of tourism and
Cohen, E. H. (2003). Tourism and religion: A leisure. Annals of Tourism Research, 22(1), 67-85.
March 2008 10