Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 32 views

    Rhetoricalessay

    Uploaded by

    api-519837257
    The document provides an analysis of the music videos for the song "Hurt" by Nine Inch Nails and Johnny Cash's cover. It notes that while Trent Reznor's version from 1994 addresses public violence and war through black and white footage of its impacts, Johnny Cash's 2002 version tells a more personal story of inner violence through color footage of his life and career. Both appeal to emotions through symbolic imagery and leave room for interpretation, though Reznor's version targets a broad audience while Cash's is more introspective. Ultimately, both convey that violence and evil will amount to nothing.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Rhetoricalessay

    Uploaded by

    api-519837257
    32 views4 pages
    The document provides an analysis of the music videos for the song "Hurt" by Nine Inch Nails and Johnny Cash's cover. It notes that while Trent Reznor's version from 1994 addresses public violence and war through black and white footage of its impacts, Johnny Cash's 2002 version tells a more personal story of inner violence through color footage of his life and career. Both appeal to emotions through symbolic imagery and leave room for interpretation, though Reznor's version targets a broad audience while Cash's is more introspective. Ultimately, both convey that violence and evil will amount to nothing.

    Original Title

    rhetoricalessay

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    The document provides an analysis of the music videos for the song "Hurt" by Nine Inch Nails and Johnny Cash's cover. It notes that while Trent Reznor's version from 1994 addresses public violence and war through black and white footage of its impacts, Johnny Cash's 2002 version tells a more personal story of inner violence through color footage of his life and career. Both appeal to emotions through symbolic imagery and leave room for interpretation, though Reznor's version targets a broad audience while Cash's is more introspective. Ultimately, both convey that violence and evil will amount to nothing.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as docx, pdf, or txt
    32 views4 pages

    Rhetoricalessay

    Uploaded by

    api-519837257
    The document provides an analysis of the music videos for the song "Hurt" by Nine Inch Nails and Johnny Cash's cover. It notes that while Trent Reznor's version from 1994 addresses public violence and war through black and white footage of its impacts, Johnny Cash's 2002 version tells a more personal story of inner violence through color footage of his life and career. Both appeal to emotions through symbolic imagery and leave room for interpretation, though Reznor's version targets a broad audience while Cash's is more introspective. Ultimately, both convey that violence and evil will amount to nothing.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as docx, pdf, or txt
    of 4

    Vy Strong Strong 1

    Zach Gregory

    English 1201

    19 June 2020
    We all hurt in different ways
    There are some songs that speak to a generation while others may hold some

    significance for the individual person. Some songs are special enough that they can speak

    to many in different ways. These songs, transcend the testament of time and find new

    meaning to those that come across it. The introduction of a music video can significantly

    effect the meaning of a song. “Hurt” by Nine inch Nails was written in 1994, by Trent

    Reznor the band’s lead singer, and released in 1995 as part of the band’s second studio

    album. Johnny Cash released his version of the song seven years later in 2002. Reznor’s

    version of the song addressed all people about the pointlessness of violence. Cash’s

    version spoke about the pointless violence in his own life.

    The original video creates an ambiance of doom and gloom. A sweaty Reznor

    stands alone on a stage with images projected on a screen behind him. The whole video is

    shot in black and white while the background images flickered as if they were from a

    1950s silent film. There are snippets of men, women, and children all effected by the

    violence of war. A man can be seen to have been impacted by shrapnel to his face. A

    mother holds her child to her chest. Several animals are shown accelerated, decaying into

    the ground. There is an image of a snake and a chameleon. Towards the end, a bird

    captures a fish out of water and the crowd cheers.

    Cash’s version is shot in color and seems to tell more of a story than the original.

    The video still has a gloomy presence but has staged scenes which makes it somehow

    less raw than the version put out by Reznor. There are scenes from Cash’s life and career

    mixed in between shots of him in his home sitting around luxury. He plays the piano
    Vy Strong Strong 2

    Zach Gregory

    English 1201

    19 June 2020
    while the song climaxes. We see memorabilia and awards from his career. The video

    shows video reel from Cash visiting his childhood home along with reels of his wife and

    children. Cash is seen sitting alone at a table full of luxurious food and drink. There are

    also clips of video from a portrayal of the Crucifixion.

    Both videos use old footage to portray their viewpoints. Cash’s version shows old

    video throughout his career while Reznor’s version shows footage from events in the

    world. Both videos use these images to appeal to the viewers emotions. Feelings of dread

    and darkness are portrayed in both versions of this song. The lyrics from each remain

    similar if not exactly the same. A few words have been changed from the original version

    of the song written by Reznor. Both videos share a stance on violence, evil, and war.

    While Reznor’s version of the song targets a broad audience and speaks upon

    public violence, evil, and war; Cash’s version speaks only for the violence, evil, and war

    within oneself. This is evident, not only, in the images of each music video but the way

    the videos were shot. The original version was filmed using a real crowd during a

    concert. The later video is a recording of only Cash and his wife in their private home.

    Reznor stands in front of images of literal death and decay. You can tell the people that

    have been hurt in the video reel were effected by war due to uniforms and helmets

    shown. The video compares us to animals showing a snake and a chameleon. Metaphors

    for evil and those that hide right in front of our eyes.

    Although these two versions are years apart in the making, the messages remain

    similar. The original version targets people of the masses while the later version targets
    Vy Strong Strong 3

    Zach Gregory

    English 1201

    19 June 2020
    anyone that can see the monster within themselves. Both videos appeal to pathos and play

    on the emotions of the viewer. Symbolic images are shown in both versions leaving the

    viewer to decide how they interpret the meaning. Reznor uses his platform to inform the

    viewer of what is happening in their world. He opens the viewers eyes to a broader truth.

    The Cash version of this song takes an introvert view on the lyrics. Cash takes a look

    within himself and finds a narrow truth. Although they target separate audiences, both

    videos hold the same message. The messages in both videos are that we all die and the

    violence, destruction, and evil acts of this life will all be for nothing.
    Works Cited
    Cash, Johnny. “Hurt” YouTube, 13 September 2019, www.youtube.com/watch?

    v=8AHCfZTRGiI

    Reznor, Trent. “Hurt” YouTube, 16 March 2009, www.youtube.com/watch?

    v=dhh21crSohs&list=RDMMdhh21crSohs&start_radio=1

    You might also like