Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews: Ji Rí Jaromír Kleme S, Yee Van Fan, Raymond R. Tan, Peng Jiang
Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews: Ji Rí Jaromír Kleme S, Yee Van Fan, Raymond R. Tan, Peng Jiang
Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews: Ji Rí Jaromír Kleme S, Yee Van Fan, Raymond R. Tan, Peng Jiang
Minimising the present and future plastic waste, energy and environmental
footprints related to COVID-19
Ji�rí Jaromír Kleme�s a, *, Yee Van Fan a, Raymond R. Tan b, Peng Jiang c
a
Sustainable Process Integration Laboratory – SPIL, NETME Centre, Faculty of Mechanical Engineering, Brno University of Technology - VUT Brno, Technick�
a 2896/2,
616 69, Brno, Czech Republic
b
Chemical Engineering Department, De La Salle University, 2401 Taft Avenue, 0922, Manila, Philippines
c
Department of Systems Science, Institute of High Performance Computing, A*STAR, Singapore, 138632, Singapore
A R T I C L E I N F O A B S T R A C T
Keywords: The COVID-19 pandemic has had growing environmental consequences related to plastic use and follow-up
Plastic waste footprint waste, but more urgent health issues have far overshadowed the potential impacts. This paper gives a pro
Dynamic waste management spective outlook on how the disruption caused by COVID-19 can act as a catalyst for short-term and long-term
Environmental footprints reduction
changes in plastic waste management practices throughout the world. The impact of the pandemic and epidemic
COVID-19 pandemic
following through the life cycles of various plastic products, particularly those needed for personal protection
and healthcare, is assessed. The energy and environmental footprints of these product systems have increased
rapidly in response to the surge in the number of COVID-19 cases worldwide, while critical hazardous waste
management issues are emerging due to the need to ensure destruction of residual pathogens in household and
medical waste. The concept of Plastic Waste Footprint (PWF) is proposed to capture the environmental footprint
of a plastic product throughout its entire life cycle. Emerging challenges in waste management during and after
the pandemic are discussed from the perspective of novel research and environmental policies. The sudden shift
in waste composition and quantity highlights the need for a dynamically reponsive waste management system.
Six future research directions are suggested to mitigate the potential impacts of the pandemic on waste man
agement systems.
* Corresponding author.
E-mail address: [email protected] (J.J. Kleme�s).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rser.2020.109883
Received 15 April 2020; Received in revised form 24 April 2020; Accepted 24 April 2020
Available online 27 April 2020
1364-0321/© 2020 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
J.J. Kleme�s et al. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 127 (2020) 109883
decision where new facilities should be built to handle the increased long-term changes in plastic waste management practices throughout
waste volume. The relevant aspects include economics, emissions, the world. The concept of Plastic Footprint (PF) [13] is introduced and
safety, regulatory issues, and public acceptance. However, at the onset then extended to Plastic Waste Footprint (PWF) [14] as a metric for
of the pandemic, it is too late for those thoughts. environmental burdens. The current pandemic introduced disruptive
Fig. 1 illustrates the matching of the supply of and demand for changes in production systems. The disruptions through a "butterfly
medical waste treatment during the pandemic. The expected amount of effect" can lead to negative and positive shifts that becoming more
waste far exceeds the available capacity for treatment of hazardous permanent features of post-COVID-19 economies.
medical waste since these systems were designed for waste quantities
generated during normal operations. If suppressions measure alone is 2. The impact of the pandemic on plastic waste
not sufficient, new facilities can be built, or mobile units used [7] to
ramp up capacity. A Pinch Point occurs where this expanded capacity The pandemic has led to major challenges in the handling of
meets the peak of the suppressed curve and ensuring that hazards from municipal solid waste (MSW) and hazardous medical waste. China has
pathogen-contaminated wastes are managed. It can be seen that a large the most data on this issue. According to the 11 March press releases of
surplus is treatment capacity would be left in place after the pandemic the State Council’s Joint Prevention and Control Mechanism in China
subsides. It is unlikely that these treatment facilities are to be in [15], the amount of MSW in large and medium cities was reduced by
cinerators with heat recovery, and that they can be repurposed for 30% during the disease outbreak. However, the generation of medical
municipal solid waste. waste increased sharply (þ370%) in Hubei Province, with a high pro
Given the technology options available for medical waste treatment, portion of plastics. From 20 January to 31 March, the accumulated
life cycle assessment (LCA) and related approaches can provide essential medical waste in all of China was estimated as 207 kt. In Wuhan,
guidance for identifying the most environmentally preferable alterna medical waste increased from the normal level of 40 t/d to about a peak
tive. Incineration of medical waste coupled with waste heat recovery is of 240 t/d, exceeding the maximum incineration capacity of 49 t/d [16].
an option that allows the chemical energy content of plastics to be The incineration cost of hazardous medical waste in China is estimated
recovered for useful purposes. An early LCA [8] with sensitivity analysis at 281.7–422.6 USD/t as compared to 14.1 USD/t for MSW [16]. Fig. 2
of heat recovery efficiency confirms that environmental impacts are shows the trends in waste flow compared to treatment capacity. Treat
minimised by maximising energy recovery. This is confirmed by more ment systems designed for waste quality and quantity under normal
recent LCA, even when non-thermal options as chemical disinfection are conditions have to cope with dramatic changes that force abnormal
considered [9]. However, there are obstacles to the widespread use of operations. Engineering analysis is essential to ensure that these systems
incineration with heat recovery. Public concerns about trace emissions are able to cope with the dynamic and evolving nature of the pandemic.
of dioxins and furans can become problematic [10]. Another complication is that much remains unknown about the virus
Social acceptability issues may not loom as large in the current itself, as it is still unclear what products and processes would be needed
pandemic since fears of contagion are likely to be greater than any to manage the pandemic.
concerns about environmental footprints, including GHG and pollutants. The COVID-19 crisis is highlighting the essential role of plastic in
A problematic issue is a mismatch between the supply of and demand for daily life. Management of the virus requires single-use plastic [17], even
the recovered heat. It can be both temporal and spatial. Some experts if disposability is largely seen as an environmental liability in most other
[11] expect the pandemic may peak in the second quarter of 2020 when applications. An effective assessment tool can summarise the key envi
the demand for heat in most of the Northern Hemisphere declines due to ronmental footprints of plastic products. Fig. 3 shows the plastic demand
warmer weather. Waste-to-energy facilities may not be conveniently by segment. Demand for medical products and packaging is increasing
located for energy recovery since priority is inevitably put on safe sharply during the COVID-19 pandemic.
disposal of contaminated waste. Xu et al. [12] show perspectives on Various mitigation or suppression measures being implemented in
balancing heat supply and demand to handle spatial and temporal im different countries are changing both the quantity and quality of plastic
balances. However, it remains uncertain if systems to be built on short waste. Single-use plastics are seen by consumers as a safe alternative for
notice or bring the mobile units to handle rapidly escalating volumes of many applications. Van Doremalen et al. [21], studied the survival of the
medical waste can be engineered for optimal energy recovery. virus on different surfaces, including plastics. Kampf et al. [22]
Sustainability of plastics has been under scrutiny even before the corroborated these results. Although plastics were shown to be no better
COVID-19 pandemic. This paper gives a prospective outlook on how the than other materials in terms of virus retention, disposability is regarded
disruption caused by COVID-19 can act as a catalyst for short-term and as an important advantage by consumers prioritising hygiene. This has
led to an increase in the use and disposal of plastic products, even for
non-medical applications. On the other hand, the plastic demand in the
Fig. 2. The expected trend of medical and MSW waste flow along with the
Fig. 1. Flattening the COVID-19 pandemic medical waste curve. epidemic/pandemic crisis.
2
J.J. Kleme�s et al. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 127 (2020) 109883
Table 1
The calorific value of plastic and the exhaust gas released by incinerating MSW,
hazardous waste and sewage sludge.
Type of Plastics LHV (MJ/kg) [30]a, [33]b
PE 42–45a
PVC 15–25a
PA 36.76b
PET 21.81b
PP 30.90–45a
PS 38.97–40a
Fines (12 mm mesh) 15a
Type Exhaust gas release (m3/kt) [30]
Fig. 4. The main waste handling approaches for contaminated waste during MSW 5.5
Hazardous waste 7.0
COVID-19. Double bagged [24], Holding time [25], treatment methods [26],
Sewage sludge 8.0
on-site, off-site and mobile facilities [27].
3
J.J. Kleme�s et al. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 127 (2020) 109883
Fig. 7. The embodied energy and value chain of plastic without considering the
supply chain (transporting).The % of energy recoveryc is estimated by the ef
ficiency of waste to energy. [40]a [33]b.
4
J.J. Kleme�s et al. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 127 (2020) 109883
� Further, optimise disaster waste management planning (com � Expanded development of advanced engineering and management
plementing each other): The planning can be on the regional scale (e. tools. As an example, these problems can be dealt with by new de
g., EU-neighbouring countries) instead of limiting to the local level. velopments of Pinch Analysis [44].
� Rethinking the strategies on minimising the impact of plastic yet
make use of its merits: The focus should not be targeted on plastics 5. Conclusion
(as being fundamentally bad) but society (appropriate utilisation)
and post-consumer plastic treatments. PWF can be used as a medium Among the many adverse consequences of the COVID-19 pandemic is
to assess sustainability compared to the alternatives (e.g. paper), by the sudden surge in the volume of plastic waste, particularly for products
considering GHG emissions and energy consumption. A dynamic used for personal protection and healthcare purposes. The environ
LCA approach is preferable. mental issues are related to the life cycles of products and are measur
� Incorporation of social factors and uncertainties: Although sustain able via metrics such as footprints (PF and PWF) highlighted in this
ability consists of three pillars, social factor is neglected in most of paper. The crucial priority is placed on the destruction of residual
the optimisation studies or assessment (e.g. techno-economic pathogens for the safe disposal of that waste. It is too early for
assessment). For future planning, either the sustainability of plastic comprehensive conclusions. However, they are some issues which can
or any other environmental footprint assessment, it is important to influence future environmental footprints: Would after the crises be
include the social factors as well as understanding the potential money and energy (oil and gas) cheaper, would developed countries
impacts to a selection. realise that ‘outsourcing’ to lower-cost bases is not always reliable, safe
� Amount control and fine-grid management: Although the surge in and or sustainable in the long-term? The collapse in crude oil prices to
the short term seems to be unavoidable [43], waste prevention negative values was reported in the USA recently. However, it is un
should be at the highest priority of waste management. With the certain if this price level will persist during the post-pandemic recovery
inspiration from the pandemic disease and the analytics of energy period. The impact on the price, the demand for plastics, waste treat
and environmental footprints, better trade-offs between medical/ ment and 6R initiatives have to be assessed. Although there have been
healthcare plastics and regular single-use plastics need to be per studies suggesting the reduction in environmental impacts (e.g. NOX
formed to control the total amount and elevate the flexibility for emissions) related to COVID 19, it is too early to gauge the long term net
future uncertainties. All categories of plastics can be managed in a environmental effects. There is uncertainty over the economic recovery
fine-grid manner according to the newly proposed Plastic 4R pro path, and there may be changes in consumer habits. Some issues have
grammes in Fig. 8 and circular economy strategies. been highlighted as priorities in this contribution both for scientific
research and for environmental policies. The emergency rush to rapidly
5
J.J. Kleme�s et al. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 127 (2020) 109883
build up capacities to cope with the crisis carries the risk that long-term [12] Xu ZY, Wang RZ, Yang C. Perspectives for low-temperature waste heat recovery.
Energy 2019;176:1037–43.
sustainability aspects may be less considered unless they are high
[13] Boucher J, Billard G. The challenges of measuring plastic pollution. Field Actions
lighted. The risks can be averted by bearing several key points in mind: Science Reports, SI19 2019:68–75. IUCN, Review of Plastic Footprint
Methodologies, portals.iucn.org/library/sites/library/files/documents/2019-0
i. The disruption of the COVID-19 pandemic can lead to large and 27-En.pdf. [Accessed 10 March 2020].
[14] Kleme�s JJ, Fan YV, Plastic replacements: win or loss? 2020, 5th international
persistent changes in economic structures; in a sense, the conference on smart and sustainable technologies, SpliTech 2020, plenary lecture,
outbreak presents a rare chance to shift modern product systems IEEE.
towards a more sustainable future trajectory. [15] Joint prevention and control mechanism of the state Council. 2020. www.gov.cn/
xinwen/gwylflkjz53/index.htm. [Accessed 7 April 2020].
ii. Metrics such as PF and PWF can become effective tools for [16] Tang W. The medical waste related to COVID-2019 is cleaned up every day—the
decision-making, policy creation, and public engagement. They medical waste treatment market needs to be standardised. 21st Century Business
provide an effective means of communicating abstract environ Herald; 2020. accessed 08.04.2020, www.21jingji.com/2020/3-12/xNMDEz
ODFfMTU0MjIxNQ.html.
mental burdens in numerical form for use by non-specialists. [17] Schlegel I. How the plastic industry is exploiting anxiety about COVID-19. 2020.
iii. Contingency plans to target the future of plastic and its waste www.greenpeace.org/usa/how-the-plastic-industry-is-exploiting-anxiety-about-co
management under various critical situations should be contin vid-19/. [Accessed 7 April 2020].
[18] PlasticsEurope. Plastics – the facts. www.plasticseurope.org/application/files/971
uously developed and adjusted. 5/7129/9584/FINAL_web_version_Plastics_the_facts2019_14102019.pdf.
[Accessed 10 March 2020].
This ’Expert Insights’ contribution is an attempt to raise awareness [19] WHO – World Health Organisation. Health-care waste. February 2018. www.who.
int/en/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/health-care-waste. [Accessed 10 March
about some issues, which would influence the future of environmental
2020].
concerns development. To work towards a safer and greener planet, [20] Statista, < www.statista.com/statistics/1107212/covid-19-food-delivery-frequenc
every single step considering the complexity of various issues becomes y-in-great-britain/>, accessed 14.03.2020.
an imperative goal of humankind. Future work should be directed by [21] van Doremalen N, Bushmaker T, Morris DH, Holbrook MG, Gamble A,
Williamson BN, Tamin A, Harcourt JL, Thornbury NJ, Gerber SI, Lloyd-Smith JO.
post-pandemic development and extend the concepts discussed in this Aerosol and surface stability of SARS-CoV-2 as compared with SARS-CoV-1. N Engl
contribution subject to country-specific conditions that may occur. J Med 2020. https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMc2004973.
[22] Kampf G, Todt D, Pfaender S, Steinmann E. Persistence of coronaviruses on
inanimate surfaces and its inactivation with biocidal agents. J Hosp Infect 2020;
Declaration of competing interests 104(3):246–51.
[23] Bourouiba L. Turbulent gas clouds and respiratory pathogen emissions. Potential
implications for reducing transmission of COVID-19. J Am Med Assoc 2020.
The authors declare that they have no known competing for financial https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.2020.4756.
interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence [24] Association of cities and regions for sustainable resource management. 2020.
accessed 30.03.2020, www.acrplus.org/en/municipal-waste-management-covid-
the work reported in this paper. 19.
[25] Public health england. www.gov.uk/government/publications/covid-19-deconta
Acknowledgements mination-in-non-healthcare-settings/covid-19-decontamination-in-non-healthca
re-settings. [Accessed 7 April 2020].
[26] Cdc - centers for disease control and prevention <www.cdc.gov/infectioncontrol/
This research has been supported by the project “Sustainable Process guidelines/environmental/background/medical-waste.html> accessed
Integration Laboratory – SPIL”, project No. CZ.02.1.01/0.0/0.0/ 07.04.2020.
[27] E&E news - the essential news for energy and environment�www.eenews.net/st
15_003/0000456 funded by EU “CZ Operational Programme Research, ories/1062690625> accessed 07.04.2020.
Development and Education”, Priority 1: Strengthening capacity for [28] WHO – World Health Organisation, Treatment and disposal technologies for
quality research under the collaboration agreement with De La Salle healthcare waste <www.who.int/water_sanitation_health/medicalwaste/077
to112.pdf> accessed 07.04.2020.
University, Manila, Philippines.
[29] The Hill, VA facility waste disposal measure could help limit the spread of
coronavirus <thehill.com/blogs/congress-blog/healthcare/486057-waste-
References disposal-measure-could-help-limit-the-spread-of�accessed 07.04.2020.
[30] Al-Salem SM. Energy production from plastic solid waste (PSW). In: Plastics to
energy. Amsterdam, Netherlands: William Andrew, Elsevier; 2019. p. 45–64.
[1] MacKenzie D. Covid-19 goes global. New Sci 2020;245(3271):7.
[31] Vanapalli KR, Samal B, Dubey BK, Bhattacharya J. Emissions and environmental
[2] Worldometer. COVID-19 Coronavirus pandemic. 2020. http://www.worldometers.
burdens associated with plastic solid waste management. Plastics to energy.
info/coronavirus/#countries%3C; accessed 08.04.
Amsterdam, Netherlands: William Andrew, Elsevier; 2019. p. 313–42.
[3] Rajmohan KVS, Ramya C, Viswanathan MR, Varjani S. Plastic pollutants: effective
[32] Mastellone ML. Technical description and performance evaluation of different
waste management for pollution control and abatement. Current Opinion in
packaging plastic waste management’s systems in a circular economy perspective.
Environmental Science & Health 2019;12:72–84.
Sci Total Environ 2020;718:137233.
[4] Windfeld ES, Brooks MS-L. Medical waste management – a review. J Environ
[33] Wasilewski R, Siudyga T. Energy recovery from waste plastics. CHEMIK 2013;67
Manag 2015;163:98–108.
(5):435–45.
[5] Liu HC, You JX, Lu C, Chen YZ. Evaluating healthcare waste treatment technologies
[34] RSC - Royal Society of Chemistry, Disposable cups information card <www.rsc.
using a hybrid multi-criteria decision-making model. Renew Sustain Energy Rev
org/education/teachers/resources/inspirational/resources/6.2.2.pdf#targetTe
2015;41:932–42.
xt¼In%20total%20about%2033%20g,polystyrene%20one%20about%201.5%20
[6] Yu H, Sun X, Solvang WD, Zhao X. Reverse logistics network design for effective
g>, accessed 10.03.2020.
management of medical waste in epidemic outbreaks: Insights from the
[35] Boustead Consulting and Associates. Final Report- LCA for three type of grocery
coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) outbreak in Wuhan (China). Int J Environ
bags <www.heartland.org/_template-assets/documents/publications/threetypeo
Res Publ Health 2020;17:1770.
fgrocerybags.pdf> accessed 30.03.2020.
[7] EVECO sro, EVECONT. accessed 07.04.2020, www.evecobrno.cz/en/aktivity/was
[36] PlasticsToday. Plastic more sustainable than paper, study shows. www.plastic
te-energy.
stoday.com/packaging/plastic-more-sustainable-paper-study-shows/2075183128
[8] Zhao W, Van Der Doet E, Huppes G, Zhang Y. Comparative life cycle assessments of
59524. [Accessed 30 March 2020].
incineration and non-incineration treatments for medical waste. Int J Life Cycle
[37] Eurostat, Packaging waste statistics <ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/
Assess 2009;14:114–21.
pdfscache/10547.pdf> accessed 30.03.2020.
[9] Hong J, Zhan S, Yu Z, Hong J, Qi C. Life-cycle environmental and economic
[38] Fan YV, Kleme�s JJ, Walmsley TG, Bert� ok B. Implementing Circular Economy in
assessment of medical waste treatment. J Clean Prod 2018;174:65–73.
municipal solid waste treatment system using P-graph. Sci Total Environ 2020;701:
[10] Makarichi L, Jutidamrongphan W, Techato K. The evolution of waste-to-energy
134652.
incineration: a review. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 2018;91:812–21.
[39] Zheng J, Suh S. Strategies to reduce the global carbon footprint of plastics. Nat
[11] Ferguson NM, Laydon D, Nedjati-Gilani G, Imai N, Ainslie K, Baguelin M, Bhatia S,
Clim Change 2019;9(5):374–8.
Boonyasiri A, Cucunub� a Z, Cuomo-Dannenburg G, Dighe A, Dorigatti I, Fu H,
[40] OpenEnergyMonitor, Plastics <learn.openenergymonitor.org/sustainable-ener
Gaythorpe K, Green W, Hamlet A, Hinsley W, Okell LC, van Elsland S, Thompson H,
gy/energy/industry-plastic> accessed 30.03.2020.
Verity R, Volz E, Wang H, Wang Y, Walker PGT, Walters C, Winskill P, Whittaker C,
[41] IEA, Put clean energy at the heart of stimulus plans to counter the coronavirus
Donnelly CA, Riley S, Ghani AC. Impact of non-pharmaceutical interventions
crisis <www.iea.org/commentaries/put-clean-energy-at-the-heart-of-stimulus-
(NPIs) to reduce COVID-19 mortality and healthcare demand. London, UK: Faculty
plans-to-counter-the-coronavirus-crisis> accessed 23.04.2020.
of Medicine, Imperial College; 2020. https://doi.org/10.25561/77482. COVID-19
Reports.
6
J.J. Kleme�s et al. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 127 (2020) 109883
[42] Barry J. This is what a real emergency looks like: what the response to Coronavirus [43] Jambeck JR, Geyer R, Wilcox C, Siegler TR, Perryman M, Andrady A, Narayan R,
can teach us about how we can and need to respond to the planetary emergency. Law KL. Plastic waste inputs from land into the ocean. Science 2015;347(6223):
accessed 23.04.2020, www.greenhousethinktank.org/uploads/4/8/3/2/48324 768–71.
387/this_is_what_a_real_emergency_looks_like_-_final_15-04-20.pdf. [44] Kleme�s JJ, Varbanov PS, Walmsley TG, Jia X. New directions in the
implementation of Pinch methodology (PM). Renew Sustain Energy Rev 2018;98:
439–68.