Implementation of MALDI-TOF MS in The Routine Clinical Laboratory
Implementation of MALDI-TOF MS in The Routine Clinical Laboratory
Implementation of MALDI-TOF MS in The Routine Clinical Laboratory
• Theresa Stanley
• Lars Westblade, Ph.D
• John Rogers, Eric Graves, Summer Interns
• Ankita DeSai, ID Fellow;
• Beverly Rogers, Chief
• Aurora Muhuza DB coordinator
• Maria Atuan-Lean, Six Sigma
• Jonelle McKey-Financial Analysis
Disclosure:
2010, Database development Bruker
Reagent support
Children’s by the Numbers
3 Hospitals
520 staffed beds
17 neighborhood locations, including:
Four Immediate Care Centers
One Primary Care Center
Marcus Autism Center
More than 7,500 employees
Access to more than 1,600 pediatric physicians
6,500 volunteers
2nd Largest pop. of pediatric CF patients in US
Objectives: MALDI-TOF
• Preanalytical
– Justification
– System selection
• Analytical
– How, What, Where, When, Why
• Postanalytical
– REPORTING
5
Doern, 2013 Clinical Microbiology Newsletter 35:69-78
Excellent Review
6
Clark et al., 2013 Clin Microbiol Rev 26:547-603
Pre-Analytical
Cost Justification:
Assessment of outcomes
Reimbursement
Cost-effectivenesss of switching to
MALDI-TOF MS for routine bacterial identification
Galliot O. e tal.JCM 2011. 49:4412
Estimated annual costs for the standard protocol and MALDI protocol
9
Tan et al., 2012 J Clin Microbiol 50:3,301-8
Impact of MALDI-TOF MS on Cost-Effectiveness
in the Microbiology Laboratory
12
Huang et al., 2013 Clin Infect Dis 57:1,237-45
Impact of MALDI-TOF MS Identification on Clinical Outcomes
13
Huang et al., 2013 Clin Infect Dis 57:1,237-45
Impact of MALDI-TOF MS Identification on Clinical Outcomes
• Gram-negative AST set up directly from positive blood cultures (BD Phoenix)
• Interventions:
- Gram stain result called to appropriate member of the patient care team 24/7
(same for preintervention and intervention groups)
14
Perez et al., 2013 Arch Pathol Lab Med 137:1,247-54
Pre-Analytical
• Selection of Instrument
Size/footprint
Electrical requirements
Data drops
Service contract
Connectivity
Workflow and volume
• Backup systems: plan for 3 days
Commercially Available Platforms:
VITEK MS IVD System (bioMérieux)
Instrument: VITEK MS
Preparation:
- Bacteria, direct transfer
- Yeast, on target extraction
Target: Disposable
16
Image: David Pincus/Marc van Nuenen, bioMérieux
Commercially Available Platforms:
VITEK MS RUO System (bioMérieux)
Instrument: VITEK MS
Preparation:
- Bacteria, direct transfer
- Yeast, on target extraction
Target: Disposable
17
Image: David Pincus/Marc van Nuenen, bioMérieux
Commercially Available Platforms:
VITEK MS IVD and RUO Systems Workflow
Patient samples
• Features:
Peaks
No spectra comparison
No spectra embedded in the commercial software,
only a matrix of bins and weights
Bins
• Default manufacturer’s confidence 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 ………………………….
value:
60.0% to 99.9% and a single identification: accept
identification (typically species level)
Peaks
bsence
Presence/A
Low discrimination identification: >1 but not more
++ + + + + + +
than 4 organisms displayed (typically genus level)
Unidentified organisms: >4 organisms 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Database (closed): v1
Preparation:
- Direct transfer on target extraction full extraction
- Direct transfer full extraction
20
Image: Markus Kostrzewa, Bruker Target: Non-disposable
Commercially Available Systems: RUO
MALDI Biotyper™ System (Bruker)
Instrument: Microflex LT
Databases (open):
- Main 5627
- Select agent v1
- Mycobacteria v2
- Fungi v1
Organisms contained:
- Main, 2,297 species (Gram-negative, Gram-positive, yeast,
filamentous fungi [few] and mycobacteria [few])
- Select agent, 11 species
- Mycobacteria, 131 species
- Filamentous fungi, 128 species
Preparation:
- Direct transfer on target extraction full extraction
- Direct transfer full extraction
22
Slide: Markus Kostrzewa, Bruker
• Pickolo-MI, Robotic sampling, TECAN (Morrisville, NC);
• Copan WASP (Murrietta,CA);
• Copan, MALDI-Trace (Murrietta, CA)
• Becton Dickinson(BD) Kiestra (Franklin Lakes, NJ)
- 0.000-1.699: No identification Slide (source): MALDI Biotyper 3.0 User Manual Revision 2
Be aware of differing versions when comparing data-current 3.1 !! 24
Optimizing Identification
• Gram positives: on plate formic acid >= 1.7
– (Patel- Mayo, Burnham-Wash U [JCM 51: 1421])
• Gram negative and non-fermenters >=1.9
– (Ford [JCM 51:1412])
• Yeast >=1.7
– (Jerris [ASM 2013])
• Rapidly Growing Mycobacteria >=1.7
– (Jerris [ASM 2014])
Can Different Databases Make a Difference?
• S. pneumoniae, 25; S. mitis, 34; S. oralis, 3 (62 isolates)
• Software:
- Visual inspection of spectra: FlexAnalysis 2.4
- Comparison and identification of spectra: Biotyper 3.0
- Database processing: ClinProTools 2.1 (perhaps not for the routine laboratory)
27
Ikryannikova et al., 2013 Clin Microbiol Infect 19:1,066-71
Analytical
MEDIA
• Culture condition environment (aerobic, anaerobic,
microaerophilic, microaerobic) , temperature, and
media have little effect on accuracy of identification
of organisms by MALDI-Tof MS.
• Organisms can be tested after storage:
5 days of storage at 35oC and 4o (McElvania, 2013).
our experience extends this to
10 days post routine incubation
(but not directly from the cold)
Preparation of Specimens: Direct Transfer
1. 2.
4. 3.
Air Dry
(~60s)
30
Image: David Pincus/Marc van Nuenen, bioMérieux
VITEK MS™ Target Slides
Disposable slides:
• Barcoded for traceability
• Three acquisition groups per
slide
• 1-16 samples per group
• Calibration spots embedded in
each acquisition group
• No cleaning
• Low cost/test
VITEK MS™ Prep Station – Integrating ID+AST
Target plate
assignment
for VITEK MS
Smart
Carrier
assignment
For VITEK2
VITEK MS™ Streamlined Workflow
• Flexibility:
– Multiple Benches (Urine, Stool, TB,….)
– Separate setup stations possible
– 1 – 4 slides analyzed per run.
• High Throughput:
– 4 x 48 spots = 192 samples/run
• Significant Time Savings
Three Steps for Microorganism Identification via MALDI
BioTyper
TARGET TOF
IDENTIFICATION
PREPARATION MEASUREMENT
Pick
Matrix
Inactivation of
pathogens
Formic acid, Analyze
dH2O Ethanol Ethanol
acetonitrile supernatant
10 min
1 ml
~20 min.
Mycobacteriology
Sample Preparation
Positive culture
75% Water
Water EtOH Water
50ul
95°C
30 min
2 ml
50ul
100% ACN + silica FA
EtOH beads, vortex 1 50ul
min.
5% sBAP,
3-5d, 35oC, 5-7% CO2
~60 min.
Intens. [a.u.] Effect of Bead-Beat on MALDI Spectrum
6000
4000
2000
0
Intens. [a.u.]
3000
2000
1000
0
5400 5600 5800 6000 6200 6400 6600 6800
m/z
Filamentous fungi – liquid culture
Intens. [a.u.]
6585,21
e.g. A.niger
6744,05
4000
6016,93
3000
2000
8049,55
1000
4536,96
9074,52
0
MALDI target
MALDI order assignment
LIS
ID/MIC results MALDI ID
No
Vitek MS RUO
Yes
Vitek MS IVD
Yes
Remarks
Facility of preparing smear Very easy Easy Easy For Vitek-MS systems, matrix
solution must be deposed each
Disposable targets Yes Yes Yes two spots
Reusable targets Yes No No
Software Easy to use Not easy to use Very easy to use
Time for 96 identifications
Time to prepare work list
<5 5–10 NDa
(min)
Time to load target and make
2 5
vacuum
Time for analysis (min) 40 55
Time for 16 identifications No ID before success of QC at end
ND ND 15
(min) of run (each 16 IDs)
Quality
IVD Yes No Yes
Need for validation before clinical
RUO Yes Yes No
reporting
Quality management Easy Easy Very easy
Costc
Device + NAb ++
Reactants +++ NA + Based on catalog prices
Maintenance ++ NA +++
Implementation
Noise Silent Noisy Noisy
Size Smaller Bulkier Bulkier
Connectivity Via LIS NA Via Myla 57
Capacity 1 × 96 4 × 48 4 × 48 Martiny, et al, JCM, 2012, 50
Post-Analytical
• Reporting is the deal
CHOA and friends
• Shigella is not identified by MALDI-TOF mass spectrometry. Organisms
identified as “Escherichia coli” should be examined for lactose
fermentation and subjected to spot indole test and, if negative, an identity
of Shigella species should be considered. An agglutination assay with
Shigella antisera Group D should be performed; colony morphology and
lactose fermentation should also be observed and taken into consideration
when making a species level identification. Serotyping in group D antisera
is needed to call Shigella sonnei. If the isolate does not serotype in Group
D antiserum, perform Microscan identification and discuss next steps with
supervisor.
B. caccae
B. eggerthii
B. finegoldii
B. fragilis
B. intestinalis
B. massililensis
B. nordii
B. ovatus
B. salyersiae
B. stercoris
B. thetaiotaomicron
B. uniformis
B. vulgatus
●87XXX1 Matrix
Assisted Laser
Desorption Ionization
Time of Flight
(MALDI-ToF)
extraction
http://clinmicro.asm.org 71