Kachra Kahani
Kachra Kahani
Kachra Kahani
KAHANI
AKNOWLEDGEMENT
Our Special thanks to Ms. Hira Zuberi
for her constant support and guidance, to Orangi Pilot Project,
especially Mr. Ashraf for supporting and facilitating our research,
to Mr. Farhan Anwar, for advising us throughout the process, to
organizations including Trashit.pk, Gul bahao Trust and Anmol
Zindagi Trust for providing us with their time and knowledge on
this burgeoning environmental crisis. And finally, the wonderful
homemakers of Karachi without whom the content of this
booklet wouldn't have been possible.
INTRODUCTION
This interactive booklet provides a brief introduction to all the traditional waste
management practices, categorized under five major themes. Engaging the reader
with the content, the booklet contains concise guide scripts on how to adopt the
traditional practices in our everyday context. The reflection boxes are there for you
to scribble down your thoughts on the material and to maintain a personal waste
production log to write your own 'Kachra Kahani'.
SINDHI
Shamim aunty has lived in different parts of Sindh province and after marriage, she moved to
Karachi. With a profound knowledge on Sindhi and Urdu literature, she has taught as a
lecturer in many different universities in the province. Growing up, she lived in the experience
of Sindhi Goths (villages). She tells us that life was dramatically different than how it is today,
not just in terms of geography of a rural-urban landscape, but also in terms of how the overall
culture has changed in a short while. “My father used to teach us simplicity - to take only the
required amount of food on the plate, and to be mindful of what we wear and how we spend
our life”. Shamim shah takes pride in how her cultural roots has taught her well to manage
waste produced in households. To treat things with respect means to value what we have
used, and today’s consumerist culture, which she dubs as no-dolati daur i.e. “New Money
Culture” where people don’t even think about how they have taken things for granted.
To this day, Shamim wakes early and prepares healthy meals of almonds and honey for her
family. She strongly believes in a life lived with ideals of “etedaal” or “mayanaravi” which
translates as maintaining “balance” in our everyday life. Shamim points out that “waste” is
just not what you are throwing out in the dustbins, but waste is also the “junk food” that we
are putting inside our bodies. She told the diet she had in her village was purely organic and
packaged with a minimalist fashion. She recalls that milk, butter and lassi used to come from
Hyderabad and the butter would be packed in peepal tree leaves.
Even today, Shamim points out that her family’s use of plastic is minimal. “Think of how
unhealthy the food must get when you put it in a plastic container and warm it in the oven.
But who thinks about that?” she complained. “Now everything is plastic. Plates are getting
thinner and lighter like a papad. It is convenient but is just so bad for the environment and for
our own health” she continued.
Naushaba Ali, Junejo
Naushaba Junejo spent her childhood in a rural area of Sindh, after her marriage in 1982,
she moved to Karachi and went on to have six children. Hers’ was a love marriage,
something she had to fight for and hence, ended up spending very little time in her maternal
home with her beloved dadi and dada. “It was very difficult realizing I would not get to relish
the time I spent sitting with my dadi learning about various totkas and growing--most of which
I have forgotten completely.”
Naushaba aunty pointed out that when it comes to reusing items they purchased from the
market, they can hardly reuse it because of the low-quality packaging. As a child, in her
mother’s house, ghee (clarified butter) came only in tins. The Junejo household then utilized
the tins as makeshift dustbins and/ or buckets.
She said one change she has visibly noticed over the years is in the material of the utensils--
from terracotta, steel, copper utensils to plastic ones. Every month, we called for the man
who did Kalli that is to clean copper utensils with ash and some water using a jali. In the
short time, she lived in her village she learned how to do rilli work, and today she has
adopted that practice to stitch together leftover pieces of clothes and make beautiful wall
hangings and table runners.
Barni Glass Wala
These vendors in Sindhi villages would come door-to-door, with bags made out of date
palms and would collect old and worn out clothes, broken glass utensils, scrap metals, and
other non-reusable leftovers from houses and pay a small amount in exchange. This system
is similar to that of a Tin dabbay walay in urban areas of Sindh.
Najma aunty is born and raised in Karachi, alongside her two brothers. Like most memons
she was also married off at an early age and gave birth to her first child at the age of 20.
Najma begum’s in-laws lived in a joint-family system and at one time in her house food was
made for about 20+ relatives who used to come over for lunch every second day.
As a child, however, a normal day for her progressed from attending school to coming back
home, finishing her homework and going out to play with the neighbours or with her siblings.
Her mother had also hired a governess for them who used to come and teach them English.
Her entire childhood revolved around books or hand-stitched, cloth dolls by her
grandmother.
She remembered her mother stitched them 3-5 clothes for everyday use and about the same
number was kept to wear at occasions. Old clothes were never thrown away rather reused
by way of mix and match or additional stitching to make brand new clothes or given away in
charity. “Nowadays, I try to recycle plastic bottles and boxes, and pizza boxes for diy arts and
crafts.”
Najma aunty now has a habit of carrying cloth bags for vegetable and fruit shopping and
actively refused to accept plastic spoons provided with her takeaway or delivered food. “At
our home, we also have steel straws, one for each member. This is one thing you will always
find inside our car’s storage box and the handbags we carry.”
Afsheen Begum, Bombaywala Memon
Aged 48, Ms. Afsheen is a mother of two daughters and has lived her entire childhood in
Karachi’s North Nazimabad area. Afsheen Begum was born into a devoutly religious Memon
household, where religion was and still is central to the way the family members conduct
their daily lives. At one time in her house they stopped having chicken because of a “fatwa”
(a religious ruling) which proclaimed the chicken feed to be made out of non-halal
(impermissible) ingredients.
The importance of religion strongly reflected in Afsheen Begum’s thoughts regarding the
waste management situation of the city and the consumerist culture. In her words (translated
into English):“Islam is a guidebook on how to lead a minimally simplistic lifestyle. However, in
today’s time we ‘want’ more and more things--without even thinking twice if we need them or
not.”
Afsheen aunty fondly remembered what her father used to tell her as a child and the
practices he had made sure her mother stuck to regardless of whatever convenient
alternative was introduced in the market. Her father encouraged to purchase glass bottles of
syrups and glass feeders over the plastic ones. The choice of material was of course not
very safe in a house of 5 little children but it was nonetheless far more hygienic than plastic
feeder bottles for the little kids.
The fast pace world of today worries aunty a lot, especially because despite high regard for
the traditional and religiously guided practices she feels she was not able to transfer those
into her daughters. “We make food in the quantity that usually none of it is leftover but when
it does why do my daughters firstly think about throwing it away?”
Homemade shampoo and soap
Before shampoos became available in plastic bottles and before the soap quality improved, the
Memon community preferred using homemade soaps and shampoos over the khulla
(unpackaged) products. The soaps are a by-product of the charbi (animal fat), reused to
produce sufficient quantities of soap that could easily last a year. Shampoos, on the other hand,
were made using natural herbal products and was stored in glass bottles. This practice is
particularly important if we want to look at a world where plastic does not exist anywhere in
health and hygiene.
Riffat Jabbar was a born and raised Hyderabadi girl. After her marriage, she moved to a
village in Badin and soon after settled with her husband and then two-born kids in Karachi.
By profession, Riffat is a doctor and her focus on a healthy diet comes as a part and parcel
of it. Her diet included clarified butter, fresh vegetables from the farm and fresh milk. With an
organic food-intensive diet, the waste produced in her house was mostly offered to the cattle
or used to make beauty products such as orange peel mask.
Riffat recalls using chikkays (baskets made out of date palm leaves), then cloth tote bags
came into fashion and soon plastic bags tucked under mattresses or sofas became a
common sight. In her maternal home, Riffat had a huge garden from where she learned the
art of how to take care of plants. She uses the same techniques in managing her garden,
even pomegranate seeds find their way back into the soil.
Fond of tailoring, Riffat aunty remained concerned about the cloth wastage, the fashion
industry is producing in this day and age. “ In our time, even the tiniest piece of cloth was
brought to use: Use it as a cleaning rag or stitch a new piece of clothing.” Many of the clothes
she wears to new events today also are a mix and match of preloved clothes.
Sobia Basit, Sheikh Punjabi
Aunty Sobia lived her childhood in Faisalabad, where her father had a banking job. She has
two brothers and sisters and in her words, her family lived a rags-to-riches situation when her
uncle’s oil factory saw expansion. Soon after her matric, Sobia aunty was married off to a
businessman and went on to have three kids.
“The food made was made in the quantity, so that nothing is left behind. You see we did not
have the facility of a fridge back then.” Sobia aunty believes that the technology spurt and
innovation has buttressed the use of wasteful packaging. She also thinks that the shifting
cultural and social class connotations attached to the use of a particular material of utensil
plays a major role in our generation’s obsession with plastic cutlery. “Households in those
times used either steel or glass crockery. When I was in 6th or 7th grade, I saw this growing
craze for having plastic utensils when all the aunties used to talk about was how they
purchased a set of imported plastic crockery with beautiful-looking pattern all over it. Steel
which was locally produced was preferred over the import-quality plastic crockery.”
Despite the availability of various kinds of plastic boxes, she had her doubts on those that
claim to be microwave-friendly.
Some of the blame was to be shared by the capitalist economy too which replaced the 10 to
15 years old practice of storing steel or tin biscuit boxes for other use, with fit-for-purpose,
commercially available plastic containers. Aunty Sobia pointed out in those times, even the
plastic feeder bottles cost Rs.35 to 40, over the glass feeder bottles priced Rs. 100-150.
Being extremely fond of tea, sobia aunty misses the smell of the crushed tea leaves that
reached her nostrils as she flipped open a steel airtight lipton jar. She misses the time before
the plastic pouches filled the top shelves of the stores.
Hodi system
The Hodi system involved releasing grey water into a ditch dug either in a shared garden space or
inside the house. The pipes are linked such that the grey water from the kitchen makes its way
into the ditch. Through the pipes on the output then the plants are watered.
Homemade cornstarch
We are all aware of the fiber starch which is packaged and sold in plastic bottles. What did
people used to do before this? The Punjabis used boiled rice water as fiber starch instead of
straining it directly in the sink. Cotton clothes were soaked overnight in the fiber starch. It took
time but the results were nonetheless, effective.
BALOCH
Gulbahar is born and raised in Chitral. The culture in which she grew up is very different
from her urban culture in Karachi. Because of her studies, she has to live here with her
younger sister and her father. She said that the environment here is so polluted, which
wasn’t the case back in her village in Chitral. She feels that people in her village were very
close to nature, and connected with nature. She said that “I would run around with my friends
climbing trees and rocks and playing our cultural games... I can say that I was very close to
nature while growing up.”
Her favorite snacks included eating chips, biscuits and bubble gum but that was consumed at
a very rare basis, as most of the consumption included dairy products, meat and vegetables
available at homes. The packaging of these snacks was mostly plastic but at some instances
paper like plastic was used for biscuit packaging. Even the packaging of shampoo bottles
was plastic. However, some soaps used to have thick paper packaging.
She still remembers some everyday items that she used for reusing purposes such as the
paper boxes that come with shoes, to keep her books and comb. It was a practice that was
done by her mother as well to keep small things in the boxes so that she wouldn’t have to
search for them elsewhere. She also gave an insight that some of the people in her village
used to burn all these plastic and paper discards as ‘fuel’. “Like we don’t have gas in Chitral,
so it was natural to use plastic or paper to burn with wood.”She uses fruit peels like bananas
and orange as skin products. She has shared a totka that she has used involving orange
peels; “I once made a paste of Aloe Vera and orange peel to treat my pimples. Banana peel
can also be used for such purposes.”
She also mentioned that her village the leftovers of vegetables and fruits was used as fodder
for animals and sometimes was used to make organic fertilizer.
Wooden Utensils
Using wooden utensils in their everyday loves was a common practice in places in Chitral.
However, now the these utensils has been replaced by the plastic ones.
URDU SPEAKING
Sobia, 70 years old, grew up in Dhaka, Bangladesh and got married at the age of twenty.
Soon after, the 1971 war broke out and she migrated to Karachi, Pakistan. Although Dhaka
is predominantly an urban region, Sobia lived in the rural parts of the sprawl and hence her
lifestyle used to closely cling with traditional ways of life. Growing up, she had a great interest
in farming, and would often help her family members prepare rice fields in their subsistence
farms. She also recalls that unlike how children consume snacks today in elaborate
packaging, most of her snacks were either homemade or used to be sold wrapped in banana
leaves or newspapers.
Her adulthood in Karachi was dramatically different. With the aftermath of the war, her family
lost most of their possessions back in Bangladesh and they had to move to a much smaller
house and in a very poverty stricken life. Forced to live a frugal life, Sobia made sure that
every material in the house is completely utilized to its potential, and her knowledge of living
in a bihari household came in handy.
Today, even when her financial situation is good, she holds on to her frugal practices and is
very mindful of her consumption. Sobia comments that “Lawaazmaat”, which can be
expressed in english language is “extravagance” in today’s culture is the primary reason for
today's culture of wastefulness. She also posits that another reason for “overproduction” of
household waste is that people have forgotten what has been taught in religion, such as the
concepts of Taharat (the act of purification from uncleanliness) and Iman (faith) being
fundamentally based on having cleanliness and leading a simple, non-wasteful and
environmentally healthy life. “People have stopped prioritizing all this! There used to be a
discipline that was followed with waste production and maintenance but you do not see that
now, do you?”
Saima Amir, Dehliwala
Saima works at a tax consultant agency in Karachi and is also a homemaker with two kids.
She has spent a great portion of her childhood in the loving care of her nani, who had a
garden in her house. She fondly remembers and recalled how much time her nani use to
spend in the garden, caring for her plants. Her ‘plant care’ routine involved the use of organic
waste produced in the household for the nourishment of the plants. She narrates: “ My nani’s
house had a 6’ by 4’’ inch garha (ditch) dug at the back of the house, where us kids used to
dump the dry and wet waste...it was very smelly so we used to keep it covered.”
During the time she was growing up, she witnessed that most of the packaging they obtained
from outside was exhausted in its reusable capacity. “We knew the shampoo plastic bottles
kept without any label symbolized an oil bottle.” As a child, whenever Saima stayed at her
nani’s for her vacations, she provided her with some of her mother’s preloved clothes. She
recalled the pleasure which came with the sight of a wheatish bori (a sack) in which originally
the monthly stock of vegetables arrived and the feel of wearing the same clothes her amma
jaan (mother) wore once. Often she used to sneak in the store to get her hands on some
clothes for herself but to her dismay came across old copper utensils packed away in the
bori.
Copper utensils were preferred in her household and used by her nani so much so that even
meethai (sweets) brought home came in a thaali (silver tray) and wedding invitations too
went in a copper thaali (tray). “My nani had a copper katora (bowl) with a beautiful flower
pattern embossed on it. She used to drink every type of beverage, be it tea or rooh afza, in
that only. I have it kept as a decoration piece in my house now.”
Saima is very keen on instilling a similar sustainable way of living in her children so she has
separate plastic and dry and wet bins in her house. She told her mother does the same,
however whatever waste she collects she delivers it by the end of the week to Gul Bahao in
a bori.
Lemon peel dishwashing soap
In most households, lemon peels when squeezed are considered useless and thrown away. This
particular community adds the peel in the dishwashing soap bar bowl and uses the organic
waste for washing dishes. It offers a more cleaner and grease-free dish washing.
Shahista Hanif is a homemaker who has been a city-dweller since her childhood. Her
ancestors migrated from the modern-day area of Rajasthan towards Pakistan 10 years post-
partition in search of better employment opportunities. They settled in Old Karachi and later
moved to in the area of Johar. She got married at the age of 21 and now has four children.
She remembers the time the milkman used to arrive, cracking his typical bell and announcing
his arrivals. That was her cue to take the steel utensil to the door and purchase milk for the
day. During the time they were shifting, a lot of scrap material came with the boxes,
sometimes even thermapol. Shahista aunty cut and used the thermapols as makeshift
jewellery holders. In those times, she would recall “we had more time to indulge in these
activities.”
Now although, Shahista aunty doesn’t have the time but if you walk into her house you may
find elaborate pieces of artwork crafted out of waste material such as used shashlik sticks,
broken mirrors, and cardboard boxes. Instantly noticeable, however, will be the steel glasses
and utensils. Shahista aunty takes great pride in her ancestral style of living so she and her
entire household is not only keen on adopting the ancestral way of using steel crockery for
eating or drinnking but also, finds value in drinking or eating in them. As the traditional design
of the steel glasses allows for more volume of water to be stored.
Dry Ridge Gourd Scrub
The fancy name for these scrubs are ‘loofah’. We know about the several commercially-sold,
nicely-packaged (read: plastic-covered) scrubs, available in liquid form or a jaali but little is
known about the dried touri (ridge gourd) scrubs. The scrubs are made by peeling an unfresh
touri, which is then sun-dried to extract the jaal (scrub). These organic scrubs disintegrate with
use, leaving behind zero-plastic waste.
Zubaida is 45 years old, born and raised in Karachi. Her father was a Kathiavari-Gujrati and
her mother was a Kutchi. Both Kutch and Kathiavar are situated in Gujrat. However, both
Zubaida’s parents were born in Karachi. Though Zubaida had stayed spent all her life in
Karachi, she still was tied to her traditional roots because of her mother. Reflecting on her
childhood, she remembered how her financial conditions led her to live a simple, non-
extravagant life. We use to get just ek paisa as our pocket money, and I use to save them to
buy gola ganda. At that time, gola ganda was not packaged in a thermocol/plastic container,
but there were stick golas everywhere.
Also, there were no plastic shoppers that we used before. She remember sewing bags out of
cloth pieces, and then those were used whenever someone from the family goes out for
shopping. She also highlighted that how they used to fetch imli from the tree in their school,
and never use to buy imli.
Zubaida was married in a Kathiavari-Gujrati family, where they use to cook almost all the
sweets and snacks at home. She pointed out to a golden color machine, which were used to
make gathiyas (a type of a nimko) as snacks. She also highlighted that especially in winters,
they use to make kheer-ki-faqi and khoraki ladoo, traditional sweets to keep warmth.
Shanilla
Shanilla was born in India, in Sidhpur Gujarat. While she reflected on her past, she
mentioned that how she followed simple routine of going to school, coming back, playing with
friends and then going to religious education center. She remembers how the village where
they live was very poor, therefore whatever the waste was produced was mostly reused.
Even the cow dung was applied on walls and floors, used as technique to mend floors. After
marriage, Shanilla moved to Karachi with her family. Even then she lived a fairly simple
lifestyle. She was also fond of gardening, so she kept rose plants on the window sill of her
bedroom. Shanilla said, “our roses were beautiful and healthy from our neighbors, because I
used leftover tea for my roses.”
She also mentioned that this consumption of plastic shopper is pretty recent, as she
mentioned until a few years back I used to carry plastic bag, Challa, whenever I went to buy
vegetables. Even the pulses and spices were packed in newspaper or brown paper, and all
the liquid items were packaged in glass.
Shanilla also shared a secret for her long hairs during the interview. She mentioned that how
she sprayed onion water in her scalp twice a month, to have a healthy, long and shiny hairs.
Even now, Shanilla reuses all the containers to keep her jewelry and other stuff.
Pomegranate peel powder
Pomegranate peel powder is known for many health benefits. Some of the common health
benefit that Shanilla mentioned was using its powder to treat severe vomiting and diarrhea.
Hijaz is an Afghani refugee who lived in Badakhshan, and migrated to Pakistan in late 1990s.
Reflecting on his lifestyle their, he remembered that as a child he mostly had natural foods.
Nothing was packaged there, all we used were fruits, vegetables and meat. Beside that, they
used natural resources in their everyday lives. He remembers using wood as a fuel to cook
food and to keep themselves warm in cold weather.Hijaz remembered that all the household
items were made at the village, but at times, they also purchased it, like soap.
Hijaz also mentioned that he could not remember any packaged waste to be generated at all.
Also, the glass and plastic bootlegs that they got were always reused as containers for salt,
sugar and many other things. They were never discarded. He quoted that “No, but we usually
reused every object that could be reused, be that bottle or plastic bags.”
HUNZA
Our childhood was very different from here at Karachi. I remember coming home from school
and playing with the slingshot Gulail, to catch sparrows. We used to roam around in the
jungle to catch sparrows. Another child home game that Rashid reflected on was extracting
tyres from large cell batteries. He mentioned that how they use to remove chemicals it and
extract the circular objects from both sides. These were then attached to empty Ghee ka
dabba, and they play with it.
Reflecting back on those days, he also remember how the shoe boxes were reused for a lot
of purposes. Whenever we needed to send fruits to someone, we would quickly pack them in
the shoe boxes. As they grow their own fruits, it was the best way to reuse cardboard boxes.
Rashid also mentioned that he used to love freshly baked items, which were not packaged
as they are today. Also how packaging materials, such as shoe boxes and dalda tin boxes
were reused for everything. Even they use to store the stock of wheat from fields in these tin
boxes.
SHARED
PRACTICES
Two sided nipple glass feeder was common among many ethnicities.
Shopping Kits, such as tote bags with plastic boxes or plastic Challas were
commonly used.was common among many ethnicities.
Leftover food is used as Animal fodder in many places
Glass Packaging