2s Draft Gibson

Kathleen Gibson
MUED 376
Dr. V
Mayhew: The Effect of Initial Impressions on the Perception of Teaching Effectiveness in Choral
Music Student Teachers; takeaways
There are many influences behind a teacher’s effectiveness in the classroom, though they
differ in a choral setting. Teaching pre-service music educators how to be effective in a choral
rehearsal is important because of the difference in setting when compared to general music
education. In The Effect of Initial Impressions on the Perception of Teaching Effectiveness in
Choral Music Student Teachers, Paul Mayhew discusses the factors that play into a teachers
effectiveness in a choir setting, referencing multiple previous research studies that surveyed pre-
service and in-service music educators, along with teacher trainers on the importance of each
factor.
Mayhew outlines three characteristics of an effective music teacher in the beginning of
his essay: teacher intensity, conducting and nonverbal behaviors, and teaching patterns. A
teacher who is more intense has high-magnitude behaviors that include 1) maintaining eye
contact, 2) varying proximity to students during rehearsal, 3) using expressive conducting
gestures, 4) maintaining a rapid, exciting pace, 5) facial expressions that indicate a clear approval
and disapproval, and 6) varying the speed, pitch, and volume of speech (Yarbrough, 1975).
“High levels of intensity influence perceptions of teaching effectiveness more than accuracy of
instruction or student attentiveness,” Mayhew notes, after discussing a study where pre- and in-
service music educators labeled teaching excerpts as high- or low-intensity (p 19). When a high-
intensity teacher is effectively working with students, the students are more likely to have higher
respect for the conductor and remain engaged longer. This is why the six characteristics of
teacher intensity are important to understand and emulate in a rehearsal. Conducting and
nonverbal behaviors give students the opportunity to assess their conductor without the need to
physically engage. A student is able to see how confident, prepared, and excited a conductor is
before any musicking happens; however, they are also able to see how anxious or unprepared a
conductor can be. A student creates this impression of a conductor in the first moments of
interaction, so it is important for conductors to be conscious of all their behaviors. Eye-contact
and facial expression are two important ways a conductor can communicate their readiness,
creating a trusting environment where the students are engaged and understand the conductor’s
intension. Teaching patterns that are sequential are found to be the most effective for conductors
in order to relay understanding. There was an observable difference between the success of
different teaching patterns, however, Mayhew discovered that it was the skills and behaviors
viewed as important to students, pre-service and in-service teachers, and teacher trainers that
created the foundation effective music teaching. He looked at previous research that asked each
of those groups to identify these skills and characteristics, explaining the importance behind the
characteristics listed in these studies.
Mayhew reviewed multiple studies that investigate these skills and characteristics, paying
particular attention to Bergee’s 1992 survey that “identified three interpretable factors” that each
group studied (pre-service music teachers, in-service music teachers, and teacher trainers)
viewed as essential in rehearsal teaching patterns and effectiveness—conducting technique,
teacher-student rapport, and instructional skill (p 23). A conductor’s technique is an integral
factor in choral settings. It is important that the conductor practices the music before stepping up
to the stand and that they have full understanding of their gesture’s intensions. Preparedness is a
key factor for a conductor’s success, while also understanding that gestures will need to be edited
as a piece is being learned. This relates to how a conductor understands their choir, creating
rapport with the students individually and the ensemble as a whole. In Bergee’s study, they noted
ten sub-factors that relate to student-teacher rapport, including but not limited to: “demonstrates
the ability to motivate students, interprets accurately psychological mood of the group, [and]
provides for individual rates of learning,” (p 23). These three factors are most essential for a
conductor to understand and exhibit during rehearsals because they show that the conductor is
engaged, attentive, and understanding. A conductor’s ability to give instruction successfully can
be difficult but is molded throughout time and their strive to better themselves as a conductor.
Wordiness and lower-level vocabulary are two things that can make instructions difficult or
frustrating for students, so a conductor should plan out how they will give each instruction
during a rehearsal as to avoid these issues. These characteristics are important for a conductor to
understand and apply to their choir for a successful and effective rehearsal.
As a conductor gains more experience, they are able to see what works and what doesn’t
in a rehearsal. Mayhew explores Standley and Madsen’s 1991 demonstration, showing how
music teachers are able to recognize the qualities that show the effectiveness of a conductor, with
more effective teaching found in conductors with longer experience. They concluded that both
pre-service and in-service music teachers are able see the key characteristics in teaching
effectiveness, though they don’t always agree on assessments of teaching effectiveness.
Mayhew’s explanation and interpretation of these studies show us the characteristics and
skills that are most important for conductors to understand and apply when teaching. In order to
be a successful conductor there are many interwoven parts, making it essential for conductors to
consistently self-review and strive to live up to their potential as their career progresses.

2s Draft Gibson

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

2s Draft Gibson

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

2s Draft Gibson

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Kathleen Gibson

Music Student Teachers; takeaways

education. In The Effect of Initial Impressions on the Perception of Teaching Effectiveness in

Mayhew outlines three characteristics of an effective music teacher in the beginning of

contact, 2) varying proximity to students during rehearsal, 3) using expressive conducting

interaction, so it is important for conductors to be conscious of all their behaviors. Eye-contact

characteristics listed in these studies.

viewed as essential in rehearsal teaching patterns and effectiveness—conducting technique,

teacher-student rapport, and instructional skill (p 23). A conductor’s technique is an integral

effectiveness, though they don’t always agree on assessments of teaching effectiveness.

You might also like