Risk Assessment
Risk Assessment
Risk Assessment
1. 1 Introduction
provide general information about ML & TF risks related with or generated through the
products, services, delivery channels, and geographical presence;
assist MIDAS Financing Limited (MFL) to assess their ML&TF risks efficiently;
enable MFL in implementing an AML & CFT program appropriate to their business having
regard to the business size, nature and complexity;
provide a broad risk management framework based on high-level principles and procedures
that MFL may wish to consider when developing and implementing a risk-based approach
to identify, mitigate and manage the ML & TF risks;
enable MFL to understand how and to what extent, it is vulnerable to ML&TF risks; and
help MFL to allocate the resources efficiently to mitigate the Ml & TF risk.
Recommendation 1 of Financial Action Task Force (FATF), the international standard setter
on anti money laundering (AML) and combating terrorist financing (CTF) states that
countries should require financial institutions and designated non-financial businesses and
professions (DNFBPs) to identify, assess and take effective action to mitigate their money
laundering and terrorist financing risks. As per Rule 21 of MLP Rules 2013 MFL shall
conduct periodic risk assessment and forward the same to the Bangladesh Financial
Intelligence Unit (BFIU) for vetting.
MFL would take appropriate steps to identify and assess their money laundering and terrorist
financing risks arisen from or through customers, products or services and transactions or
delivery channels and geographical presence.
1
MIDAS FINANCING LIMITED
Risk can be defined as the combination of the probability of an event and its consequences. In
simple term, risks can be seen as a combination of the chance that something may happen and
the degree of damage or loss that may result if it does occur.
Risk management is a systematic process of recognizing risk and developing methods to both
minimize and manage the risk. This requires the development of a method to identify, assess,
treat (deal with), control and monitor risk exposures. In risk management, a process is
followed where the risks are assessed against the likelihood (chance) of them occurring and
the severity or amount of loss or damage (impact) which may result if they do happen.
For the AML & CTF aspects, MFL would take into account two main sources of ML & TF
risks i.e., ML & TF risk arises from or through doing their business and non-compliance of
regulatory requirements.
ML & TF risk that arises or generated in doing business is the risk that business may be used
for ML & TF. MFL must at least take into consideration the following segment of their
business in assessing ML & TF risk:
● customer risks, i.e. ML&TF risk arisen from or generated through customers
Regulatory risk is associated with not meeting all obligations of MFL under the Money
Laundering Prevention Act, 2012, Anti Terrorism Act, 2009 (including all amendments), the
respective Rules issued under these two Acts and instructions issued by BFIU. Examples of
regulatory obligations are failure to report STR/SAR, unable or inappropriately verification
of customers and lacking of AML&CFT program (how a business identifies and manages the
ML&TF risk it may face) etc.
2
MIDAS FINANCING LIMITED
2.1 Introduction
MFL will have flexibility to construct and tailor its risk management framework for the
purpose of developing risk-based systems and controls and mitigation strategies in a manner
that is most appropriate to its business structure (including financial resources and staff), its
products and/or the services it provide. Such risk-based systems and controls would be
proportionate to the ML&TF risk(s) MFL reasonably faces.
For effective risk management, MFL would at all levels follow the principles below:
Risk management is not a stand-alone activity that is separate from the main activities and
processes of MFL. Risk management is part of the responsibilities of management and an
integral part of all organizational processes, including strategic planning.
Risk management helps decision makers making informed choices, prioritize actions and
distinguish among alternative courses of action.
Risk management explicitly takes account of uncertainty, the nature of that uncertainty,
and how it can be addressed.
Risk management will be aligned with the MFL’s external and internal context and risk
profile.
Following the above mentioned principles MFL will develop and maintain logical,
comprehensive and systematic methods to address each of the components referred to in this
Guideline.
In assessing and mitigating ML & TF risk, MFL would consider a wide range of financial
products and services, which are associated with different ML & TF risks. These include:
Different deposit schemes: where MFL offer products and services directly to persons,
business customers, Corporate bodies, Government offices, NGOs, Clubs, societies such as
Term deposit scheme, Double money deposit scheme, Triple money deposit scheme, Monthly
deposit scheme as well as other savings products;
3
MIDAS FINANCING LIMITED
Corporate finance and investment services: where MFL would provide corporate finance
products such as lease finance, term loan, project finance, working capital finance, short-term
finance and investment services to corporations, large and medium size enterprises,
governments and institutions;
Consumer finance: where MFL finance their customers to purchase different consumer
products and services.
MFL would be mindful of those differences when assessing and mitigating the ML & TF risk
to which they are exposed.
(a) establishing the internal and external context within which the designated service is, or is
to be, provided. These may include:
-the jurisdictions MFL is exposed to, either through its own activities or the activities of
customers, especially jurisdictions with relatively higher levels of corruption or organized
crime, and/or deficient AML & CFT controls and listed by FATF;
-the distribution channels, including the extent to which MFL deals directly with the
customer or the extent to which it will rely (or is allowed to rely on) third parties to conduct
CDD and the use of technology;
-the volume and size of its transactions, considering the usual activity of MFL and the profile
of its customers.
(d) risk treatment (mitigating, managing, control, monitoring and periodic reviews).
4
MIDAS FINANCING LIMITED
Risk identification:
Risk assessment/evaluation:
MFL would identify sources of risk, areas of impacts, events (including changes in
circumstances) and their causes and their potential consequences. The aim of this step is to
generate a comprehensive list of risks based on those events that might create, enhance,
prevent, degrade, accelerate or delay the achievement of objectives.
Identification would include risks whether or not their source is under the control of the
organization, even though the risk source or cause may not be evident. Risk identification
would include examination of the knock-on effects of particular consequences, including
cascade and cumulative effects. It would also consider a wide range of consequences even if
the risk source or cause may not be evident. As well as identifying what might happen, it is
necessary to consider possible causes and scenarios that show what consequences can occur.
All significant causes and consequences should be considered.
MFL would apply risk identification tools and techniques that are suited to its objectives and
capabilities, and to the risks faced. Relevant and up-to-date information would be used in
identifying risks.
In identification of ML & TF risk MFL would consider at least the risk arisen doing its
business i.e. its customers, products or services, delivery channels or methods and jurisdiction
and risk of non-compliance.
MFL would consider the risk posed by any element or any combination of the elements listed
below:
● Customers
● Products and services
● Business practices/delivery methods or channels
● Countries it does business in/with (jurisdictions).
Under these four groups, individual risks to MFL can be determined. While not an exhaustive
list, some of these individual risks may include:
6
MIDAS FINANCING LIMITED
Customers:
Followings are some indicators (but not limited to) to identify ML & TF risk may arise from
customers of MFL.
a customer or a group of customers making lot of transactions and/or maintaining several
accounts in the same name or group.
a customer who has a business which involves large amounts of cash.
- significant and unexplained geographic distance between the institution and the location of
the customer.
a corporate customer whose ownership structure is unusual and excessively complex.
customers that are politically exposed persons (PEPs) or influential persons (IPs) or head of
international organizations and their family members and close associates.
customer opens account in the name of his/her family member who intends to credit large
amount of deposits not consistent with the known sources of legitimate family income.
a customer generally tries to convince for cash deposit but insists for financial instrument
while withdrawing the deposit.
7
MIDAS FINANCING LIMITED
Syndicate financing
anonymous transaction
Receivable financing
Term Loan
Term Deposit
Direct to the bank account of the customer or to the account of the supplier/vendor through
A/C payee cheque
online/internet
phone
8
MIDAS FINANCING LIMITED
fax
Country/jurisdiction:
any country which is identified by credible sources as having significant level of corruption
and criminal activity.
any country known to be a tax haven and identified by credible sources as providing
funding or support for terrorist activities or that have designated terrorist organizations
operating within their country.
any country identified by FATF or FSRBs as not having adequate AML&CFT system.
branch in any land port, sea port city or any border area.
Regulatory risk:
This risk is associated with not meeting the requirements of the Money laundering Prevention
Act, 2012, Anti Terrorism Act, 2009 (including all amendments) and instructions issued by
BFIU. Examples of some of these risks are:
For assessing risk, MFL will use, the Table -1, which is a simple & generic table with Risk
Score and Treatment. Risk Score can be found by blending likelihood and impact; Table -1 is
9
MIDAS FINANCING LIMITED
used, only the examples of customer risk assessment and developed phase by phase so that
user can have a good idea of risk assessment.
New customer
(example only)
Customer who
brings in large
amounts of used
notes and/or
small
denominations
(example only)
Customer
whose business
address and
registered office
are in different
geographic
locations
(example only)
A table similar to Table 1 shown above - Risk management worksheet - would be used for
each risk group in preparation for assessing and managing those risks: customers, products
and services, business practices/delivery methods, country/jurisdiction and the regulatory
risks. Compilation of all risk groups by following table-1 will be treated as risk register.
Having identified the risks involved, they would be assessed or measured in terms of the
chance (likelihood) they will occur and the severity or amount of loss or damage (impact)
which may result if they do occur. The risk associated with an event is a combination of the
chance (likelihood) that the event will occur and the seriousness of the damage (impact) it
may do.
10
MIDAS FINANCING LIMITED
To help assess the risks identified in the first stage of this process, MFL will apply the risk
rating scales for likelihood shown in Table 2 and impact shown in Table 3 and from these
MFL will get a level of risk or risk score using the risk matrix shown in Figure 2.
Likelihood scale
A likelihood scale refers to the potential of an ML&TF risk occurring in the business for the
particular risk being assessed. Three levels of risk are shown in Table 2. This likelihood will
be ascertained based on the available information, group consultation or by applying
subjective judgment. MFL shall engage all concerned and competent personnel in ML & TF
risk management process including ascertaining the likelihood scale.
Very likely Almost certain: it will probably occur several times a year
Impact scale
An impact scale refers to the seriousness of the damage (or otherwise) which could occur if
the event (risk) happen.
In assessing the possible impact or consequences, the assessment can be made from several
viewpoints. It does not cover everything and it is not prescriptive. Impact of an ML&TF risk
could, depending on MFL and its business circumstances, be rated or looked at from the point
of view of:
● how it may affect the business (if through not dealing with risks properly MFL suffers a
financial loss from either a crime or through fines from BFIU or regulator);
● the risk that a particular transaction may result in the loss of life or property through a
terrorist act;
● the risk that a particular transaction may be involved in funds generated from any of the
following crimes: corruption and bribery, counterfeiting currency, counterfeiting deeds and
documents, smuggling of goods/workers/immigrants, banking offences, narcotics offences,
psychotropic substance offences, illegal arms trading, kidnapping, terrorism, theft,
embezzlement, or fraud, forgery, extortion, smuggling of domestic and foreign currency,
black marketing, fraud etc.;
11
MIDAS FINANCING LIMITED
● reputational risk – how it may affect MFL if it is found to have (unknowingly) aided an
illegal act, which may mean BFIU or government sanctions and/or being shunned by the
community of customers;
● how it may affect the wider community of customers if it is found to have aided an illegal
act; the community may get a bad reputation as well as the business.
Legal risk- how it may affect MFL if it becomes a part of legal proceedings.
Risk matrix will be used to combine LIKELIHOOD and IMPACT to obtain a risk score. The
risk score may be used to aid decision making and help in deciding what action to be taken in
view of the overall risk. How the risk score is derived can be seen from the risk matrix
(Figure 2) and risk score table (Table 4) shown below. Four levels of risk score are shown in
Figure 2 and Table 4.
IMPACT
How serious is the risk?
12
MIDAS FINANCING LIMITED
Rating Description
Extreme Risk almost sure to happen and/or to have very serious consequences.
Response:
Do not allow transaction to occur without reducing the risk to acceptable
level- Follow EDD
High Risk likely to happen and/or to have major consequences.
Response:
Do not allow transaction until risk is reduced- Follow EDD
Medium Possible this could happen and/or have moderate consequences.
Response:
May go ahead but preferably reduce risk- Follow standard CDD
Low Unlikely to happen and/or have minor or negligible consequences.
Response:
Okay to go ahead.
As per above discussion, MFL would calculate risk score by blending likelihood and impact,
the risk matrix and risk score and can assess the risks of individual customer, product/service,
delivery channel and risks related to geographic region by using the simplified risk
management worksheet (Table-01). It would also fix up its necessary actions against the
particulars outcomes of risks. All the exercises done by MFL would be called together "Risk
Registrar".
Once threat levels and risk scores have been allocated MFL can be entered in the risk
management worksheet (Table 5) next to the risk.
13
MIDAS FINANCING LIMITED
This stage is about identifying and testing methods to manage the risks MFL may have
identified and assessed in the previous process. In doing this MFL will need to consider
putting into place strategies, policies and procedures to help reduce (or treat) the risk.
● process to place customers in different risk categories and apply different identification and
verification methods
14
MIDAS FINANCING LIMITED
Another way to reduce the risk is to use a combination of risk groups to modify the overall
risk of a transaction. MFL may choose to use a combination of customer, product/service and
country risk to modify an overall risk.
Keeping records and regular evaluation of the risk plan and AML & CFT program is
essential. The risk management plan and AML&CFT program cannot remain static as risks
change over time; for example, changes to customer base, products and services, business
practices and the law.
Once documented, MFL would develop a method to check regularly on whether AML &
CFT program is working correctly and effectively. If not, the FI needs to work out what
needs to be improved and put changes in place. This will help keep the program effective and
also meet the requirements of the AML & CFT Acts and respective Rules.
--------x-------
15