Nasdaq Trader Manual
Nasdaq Trader Manual
Nasdaq Trader Manual
Trader Manual
THE INFORMATION CONTAINED HEREIN IS PROVIDED ONLY FOR THE PURPOSE OF PRO-
VIDING GENERAL GUIDANCE AS TO THE APPLICATION OF PARTICULAR NASD RULES.
ALL USERS, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO, MEMBERS, ASSOCIATED PERSONS AND
THEIR COUNSEL SHOULD CONSIDER THE NEED FOR FURTHER GUIDANCE AS TO THE
APPLICATION OF NASD RULES TO THEIR OWN UNIQUE CIRCUMSTANCES. NO STATE-
MENTS ARE INTENDED AS EXPRESS WARRANTIES.
© 1998, The Nasdaq Stock Market, Inc. All rights reserved. Nasdaq, Nasdaq National Market, OTC
Bulletin Board, and The Nasdaq Stock Market are registered service marks of The Nasdaq Stock Market,
Inc. ACT, CAES, Nasdaq Trader, SelectNet, SOES, and The Nasdaq SmallCap Market are service marks
of The Nasdaq Stock Market, Inc. Nasdaq Workstation II is a registered trademark of The Nasdaq Stock
Market, Inc. NASD is a registered service mark of the National Association of Securities Dealers, Inc.
NASDR and NASD Regulation are service marks of NASD Regulation, Inc.
Table of Contents
Nasdaq Trader Manual
Table of Contents x
Chapter 1
Revised January 2001
Once you register in a security, the rules require you to enter a quotation in that
security within five business day. If you do not enter a quotation within five
business days of the effective of your registration in that security, the system will
delete your registration in the issue on the sixth business day.
Before you can begin quoting any securities on Nasdaq, your firm must be
approved and authorized as a Nasdaq Market Maker. Your firm must meet
financial responsibility and other requirements. For more information or to
apply to become a Market Maker, please contact the Subscriber Services
Department at (800) 777-5606, or visit the “Trading Services” section on the
Nasdaq TraderSM website at nasdaqtrader.com.
Location Identifiers
When you trade a stock from a location other than your firm’s main trading
desk — such as from a different city, the foreign desk, the convertible bond desk
or arbitrage desk — you must use a fifth-character identifier at the end of your
Market Maker identification (MMID) to identify the location at which it is
being traded. The fifth-character identifier on the MMID notifies other traders
that they should call that location instead of your main Nasdaq trading desk.
When you register in the security, use the applicable character in the
“Loc./Desk” field of the Market Maker Quote Management window on the
Nasdaq Workstation. Please note that the letters (A,B,C, etc.) are not restricted
to the cities shown. However, the character, the location it stands for, and the
phone number should be identified in the Nasdaq Automated Directory. Call
Nasdaq Market Operations at (800) 219-4861 for more information or to
request a change in the listing.
Training
To arrange for training or to request training materials, please contact:
Nasdaq Subscriber Training (212) 858-4084
You may also complete the Subscriber Training request form located at the URL
below.
http://nasdaqtrader.com/asp/GetCustomerInfo.asp?2
The obligation to “keep quotes firm” means that Market Makers and
ECNs/ATSs must honor orders presented to them at their quoted prices and
sizes at all times during market hours and during the extended trading session
(4:00 p.m. to 6:30 p.m., ET) if a firm’s quotes are open during such time. The
exceptions to this firm quote requirement include when a Market Maker has
just executed an order and is in the process of updating its quote, and/or when
the Market Maker is updating its quote and has sent a quotation update into
Nasdaq. If, as a Market Maker, you are presented with an order at your posted
size and price, and you are not in the process of executing another order or
updating your quote, you must execute the incoming order. If you do not
execute the incoming order, you may be charged with “backing away” from your
quote. See discussion of “backing away” in Chapters 4 and 12.
Please note that when a Market Maker’s quote is executed against in the Small
Order Execution SystemSM (SOESSM), the system will decrement the quote by
the size of the execution in SOES. When the quote is decreased to a size of zero,
a Market Maker has five minutes to update its quote. If no action is taken
within five minutes, the Market Maker is “SOESed out” in that security for 20
business days. For more information on managing displayed quotes please refer
to the Nasdaq User Guide.
Locks/Crosses Prior To 9:20 a.m., ET: For locks/crosses that occur prior to 9:20
a.m., ET, any party to a lock/cross would have the right, but not the obligation,
to send, beginning at 9:20 a.m., a Trade-or-Move Message of any size to any
party to the lock/cross. Unlike locks/crosses that occur at or after 9:20 a.m., ET,
however, there is no requirement that the market participant initiating the
lock/cross send a specific number of shares to those being locked/crossed.
Withdrawal of Quotes
There are two types of quote withdrawals—temporary excused and unexcused.
As a Market Maker, you may withdraw a quote on a temporary basis for certain
reasons, without having to wait 20 business days to reregister, by contacting
Nasdaq Market Operations to effect a temporary or “excused” withdrawal. If you
would like to withdraw quotations (Nasdaq Marketplace Rule 4619) on a
temporary excused basis, you must first contact Nasdaq Market Operations at
(800) 219-4861 (see “Excused Withdrawals” below). In the case of excused
Excused Withdrawals
Following are the reasons why your temporary withdrawal from quoting a stock
may be excused:
If your compliance officer instructs you to “get out of a stock,” you should
contact Nasdaq Market Operations immediately. You will be advised whether
written documentation is necessary, and then Nasdaq will decide whether to
effect the withdrawal on an “excused” basis. If you withdraw your quote by
keyboard entry, without notifying Nasdaq Market Operations - even if the
reason is justified under the rules - you may have to wait 20 business days before
you can reregister in the stock. We advise you to call Nasdaq Market Operations
whenever you decide to cease making a market in a Nasdaq stock temporarily,
to ensure that you remain in compliance.
If one of your traders will be out of the office for a religious observance, it may
be possible to obtain an excused withdrawal for the issues traded by that
You may not, however, close your markets because of market volatility. Nasdaq
Marketplace Rule 4619 prohibits a withdrawal due to pending news or an influx
If you have received an excused withdrawal because you are on vacation, you
run the risk of losing that status if you execute orders as a Market Maker in
SelectNet during your scheduled vacation time. The use of SOES or SelectNet
as a Market Maker while you have excused withdrawal status can cause you to
lose your excused status and you may be considered to be in a state of voluntary
(unexcused) withdrawal, resulting in a 20-day penalty period.
Market
Maker
Quote
Montage
Appeal Procedure
If your request for an excused withdrawal is denied by Market Operations, you
may request an appeal. The Market Operations Review Committee has
jurisdiction over such appeals. If you wish to request an appeal, call Nasdaq
Market Operations at (800) 219-4861. By rule, your request must be made in
writing, but Nasdaq Market Operations will facilitate your hearing and act as
liaison between you and the appeal committee.
If your firm experiences system problems and you are not able to update your
quotes before the five-minute window elapses, you must contact Nasdaq Market
Operations to have your quotes temporarily withdrawn. Nasdaq Marketplace
Rule 4730 stipulates that if your ability to update quotations becomes impaired
due to equipment or communication problems, you must contact Nasdaq
Market Operations to have your market placed in a “closed” state. You are liable
for any executions until this is done and subject to the 20-day period if you are
“SOESed-out-of-the-box.” See Chapter 4 for information on responding to
SOES executions.
Even if your firm has reached its limit on reinstatements, under certain
circumstances a designated Nasdaq officer may grant a reinstatement if it is
believed that it is necessary to maintain a fair and orderly market. Such reasons
may include a documented system failure at the firm, lack of Market Makers in
Convertible Bonds
Convertible bonds are listed on Nasdaq and in many ways appear to be treated
as equities, but some of the Market Maker requirements, as explained below,
differ from equities. Convertible bonds do not have an “NM” or “N” symbol on
the NWII screen to denote National Market or SmallCap, respectively.
Quotations
Quotations in convertible bonds listed on Nasdaq are required to be firm,
continuous, and two-sided, as they are with Nasdaq equities; but, convertible
bonds are exempt from the quotation size requirements of Nasdaq equities.
Convertible bonds are not subject to SOES executions.
Unit of Trading
The generally accepted unit of trading for a convertible bond is 10 bonds, at a
face value of $1,000 each.
Although all securities listed on the Nasdaq National Market and the New York
and American Stock Exchanges are eligible for UTP trading by other markets or
exchanges, there is a limit to how many Nasdaq National Market securities an
exchange can trade at one time, pursuant to UTP rules. Currently, the limit is
Exchanges that trade Nasdaq stocks via UTP now have access to SelectNet.
Thus, NASD members and exchange specialists can now access each other’s
quotes. This is important in light of the SEC Order Handling Rules, because
quotes of UTP exchanges trading Nasdaq stocks are reflected in the Nasdaq
quote montage.
Primary Market Makers are exempt from the Short Sale Rule, thereby allowing
them to sell short at the bid on a down tick. At this time, any registered Market
Autoquoting
Autoquoting to keep your quote in a Nasdaq security away from the inside
market is not permitted. (UTP exchanges are, however, permitted by the rules
in their markets to do this type of autoquoting.) Autoquoting is generally
permitted when your firm is updating its quote following an execution.
Your firm may also autoquote to display customer limit orders that reside in an
internal execution system.
Phone Numbers
Nasdaq Office of General Counsel (202) 728-8294
Nasdaq Market Operations (800) 219-4861
Fax Number
Nasdaq Market Operations (203) 385-6380
Training
To arrange for training or to request training materials, please contact:
Nasdaq Subscriber Training (212) 858-4084
You may also complete the Subscriber Training request form located at the URL
below.
http://nasdaqtrader.com/asp/GetCustomerInfo.asp?2
Distribution Requirements
Initial Public Offerings—IPOs
Registration
Once an initial public offering (IPO) has been approved for listing, the symbol
is entered into the Nasdaq® system and is made available for registration.
Securities available for registration are included on the Nasdaq News frame,
which is accessed through the “InfoSvcs” menu located on the main menu bar
of Nasdaq Workstation II® (NWIITM), with the code “SR” indicated on the far
right. If you wish to register as a Market Maker for the next day, you may do so
through the "MarketMaking" menu on your NWII.
Nasdaq rules allow Market Makers to register on-line during the first five days
of quoting the new security. To register on-line on the day the issue is released
for trading, contact Nasdaq Market Operations at (800) 219-4861. See
“Registering for IPOs and Syndicates” in Chapter 1 for more information.
Release
To release an IPO on Nasdaq, if your firm is the underwriter, you must contact
Nasdaq Market Operations and provide the time and date of Securities and
Exchange Commission (SEC) effectiveness; confirm the final price and number
of shares offered; and confirm the settlement (closing) date of the offering and
the time the security is to be released for trading.
When the security is being released for trading, Nasdaq provides a 15-minute
window that allows all Market Makers registered to trade in the stock an
opportunity to enter and adjust quotes before the issue is released for trading. If
the market is locked or crossed at the end of the initial 15-minute window, an
additional 15-minute quotation-only period will be provided before trading may
begin. Information on this 15-minute window, including quotation and trading
release times, is available in the Nasdaq News frame.
Only Nasdaq securities that are the subject of firm commitment, fixed-price
offerings may be eligible for passive market making.
SEC Rule 103 (replacing Rule 10b-6A) permits passive market making on
Nasdaq during the restricted period of Rule 101, when market making by
distribution participants otherwise is prohibited. Rule 103 limits the price levels
of bids and purchases that you can make as a Nasdaq passive Market Maker.
The rule generally limits a passive Market Maker’s bid to the highest current
independent bid (i.e., the bid of a Nasdaq Market Maker that is not
participating in the distribution) during the restricted period.
It limits you to the amount of net purchases that you can make on any one day
to 30 percent of your Average Daily Trading Volume (ADTV). An initial
ADTV limit of 200 shares is set for less active Market Makers.
If you are the manager of the underwriting, you must forward a copy of the
completed Underwriting Activity Report to Nasdaq Market Operations—no
later than one business day before the commencement of the restricted period—
indicating those participants that will engage in passive market making or will
be excused, and the effective date(s) of the restricted period. If you are a
distribution participant, you may change your status voluntarily during the
restricted period by contacting Nasdaq Market Operations at (203) 375-9609.
Purchase Limitations
On each business day of the restricted period, your net purchases (purchases in
excess of sales) as a passive Market Maker may not equal or exceed 30 percent
of your ADTV in that security during the restricted period. Your ADTV is
derived from the NASD® Monthly Activity Report and is available from the
underwriting activity report issued by the NASD Regulation® Corporate
Financing Department.
If your net purchases equal or exceed 30 percent of your ADTV at any time
during the restricted period, you must withdraw your quotations from Nasdaq
immediately for the remainder of that day, regardless of any subsequent sales.
Prior to equaling or exceeding the ADTV you may purchase all of the shares
that are part of a single order that, when executed, results in your net purchase
limitation being equaled or exceeded. After that purchase is effected, you must
withdraw your quotations immediately.
Passive Market Makers must not purchase stock on a principal basis at a price
higher than the highest independent bid, which includes purchases through
electronic communications networks (ECNs)/alternative trading systems (ATSs).
At the open, you may not quote a bid higher than the highest independent bid.
During trading hours, you may not initiate a bid above the highest independent
bid, and in instances where only passive Market Makers are at the inside bid,
you may not raise your bid to join other passive Market Makers at the inside
bid. However, if you receive an unsolicited customer limit order, you must
display the quote in accordance with the Limit Order Display Rule.
When entering quotes on the first day of passive market making, make sure the
bid you display does not exceed your 30 percent ADTV net purchase limit.
Excused Withdrawal
If you meet or exceed your 30 percent ADTV net purchase limit, you must
withdraw your quotes from the NWII or execute a sale that would bring your
net position under the 30 percent ADTV limit. In either instance, you must
respond within 30 seconds of the executed trade. If you withdraw your quote,
you must contact Nasdaq Market Operations so they can place the quote in an
excused withdrawal state.
Stabilizing Bids
Underwriters or other designated Market Makers may enter stabilizing bids for
the purpose of maintaining the price of a security pursuant to SEC Rules 101
and 104 of Regulation M.
When you are in a stabilizing (one-sided market) condition, you are not eligible
to participate in the Small Order Execution SystemSM (SOESSM).
Penalty Bids
Penalty bids are entered to track sales in the market by syndicate members, and
for which selling concessions will be withheld by the underwriter. They are
governed by SEC Rules 101 and 104 of Regulation M.
Since a penalty bid cannot be entered through a Market Maker’s terminal, you
must notify Nasdaq Market Operations of your intentions. Nasdaq Marketplace
Rule 4623 requires written confirmation no later than the close of business on
the day that the penalty bid is imposed. Notice must include the name and
symbol of the security and the date of imposition of the penalty bid. Notice
must also be sent to the NASD Regulation Corporate Financing Department.
Only one penalty bid may be in effect for any security at one time. A penalty bid
will be identified with a modifier on the screen, at the option of the member.
Phone Numbers
Nasdaq Market Operations (800) 219-4861
NASD Regulation Corporate Finance (240) 386-4623
Overview of SOES
SOES is an automated trading system that lets SOES participants enter and
execute orders of limited size in active SOES-authorized Nasdaq securities.
Reports of these executions are sent to the Automated Confirmation
Transaction ServiceSM (ACTSM) as locked-in trades, then both sides of the
transaction are sent to the applicable clearing corporation(s) for clearance and
settlement, and the trade is reported to the tape.
Both The Nasdaq SmallCap MarketSM and Nasdaq National Market® securities
are eligible for trading through SOES. The stocks are separated into tiers
representing the largest order for a given stock that can be entered into SOES.
National Market securities are separated into tiers of 200, 500, and 1,000 shares,
depending on the trading characteristics of the stock. SmallCap securities are
separated into 100- or 500-share tiers.
All order-entry firms and Market Makers registered with Nasdaq have access to
SOES. Electronic communications network (ECN)/alternative trading system
(ATS) and unlisted trading privileges (UTP) participant quotes do not
participate in SOES.
Participation
SOES participation is mandatory for Market Makers in Nasdaq National Market
securities and voluntary for Market Makers in the SmallCap Market. All
National Association of Securities Dealers, Inc. (NASD®), member firms may
participate in SOES if they:
Types of Orders
SOES accepts market orders and marketable limit orders. All-or-none (AON);
fill-or-kill (FOK); good ’til canceled (GTC); and good ’til date (GT Date)
orders are not permitted in SOES.
SOES accepts orders that are either preferenced to a particular Market Maker or
unpreferenced. A preferenced order will be executed against the Market Maker
to which the order is directed, at the inside market price, and unpreferenced
orders will be executed against Market Makers in rotation, at the inside quote.
Market Makers may establish those order-entry firms from which they will
accept preferenced orders.
Nasdaq Market Makers in Nasdaq stocks may quote actual size when displaying
proprietary interest in all stocks listed in both the National Market and SmallCap
Market. A Market Maker’s minimum quotation size obligation will be no less than
100 shares (or one normal unit of trading) whether the firm is displaying a
proprietary interest or reflecting a customer limit order.
A Market Maker must update its quote when its size is exhausted—within five
minutes for a Nasdaq National Market security and by system close (6:30 p.m.,
ET) for a SmallCap security.
(2) Maintain displayed size and supplemental exposure, equal to or greater than
the SOES tier size. Your displayed size and supplemental size will decrement
following each SOES execution. If the displayed quote size is reduced to zero, but
you still have supplemental exposure size in that security, your quoted price will
remain the same; its size will be restored to the SOES tier size automatically; and
the quote will be re-ranked at the bottom of the montage at its price level. If both
the displayed quote size and supplemental exposure size are reduced to zero, you
may update your quote and size manually, or rely on the auto-refresh capability
described above. You must restore your supplemental exposure size manually—the
system will not automatically refresh your exposure size.
(3) Maintain displayed size and unlimited supplemental exposure size (e.g.,
999,999). Your displayed size will decrement following each SOES execution,
but your supplemental exposure size will not decrement. If your displayed quote
size is reduced to zero, your quote remains the same, but your displayed size will
be restored to the SOES tier size from the supplemental exposure size, and the
quote is re-ranked to the bottom of the quote montage at its price level.
(4) Maintain displayed size and select the “NO DEC” option (e.g., 999,998).
Your displayed size and supplemental exposure size will not decrement following
If you do not update your quote in a Nasdaq National Market security within five
minutes, your quote is placed in a “SOES suspended” state for 20 business days.
If your displayed size is reduced to zero in a Nasdaq SmallCap security, your quote is
placed in a “SOES closed” state, re-ranked at the end of the quotes displayed in the
quote montage, and withdrawn from the SOES rotation until you update your quote
and restore yourself to SOES. If you do not update your quote before 6:30 p.m., ET,
of the same trading day, Nasdaq will withdraw your quote for 20 business days.
If your displayed quote size is reduced to zero during the last five minutes of the
trading day (3:55 to 4:00 p.m., ET), your quote will show no size on the side of
the market that was decremented to zero. You have until 6:30 p.m., ET, on that
day to re-open your quote and re-establish your displayed size. If you fail to
restore your displayed size before the 6:30 p.m., ET, cutoff time, your firm will be
withdrawn from the security for 20 business days. This procedure applies to all
Nasdaq National Market and SmallCap securities.
SOES Size
Exhausted
Pop-Up
Window
The display of a “SOES Size Exhausted” pop-up window does not affect the
availability of all other Workstation functions. If another window is accessed
while the pop-up window is displayed, the pop-up window will move behind
the active window. If the size in another security is reduced to zero while the
pop-up is in the background, the pop-up will reappear and display a new
warning message.
In SmallCap, however, the SOES system will continue to execute against the
next available SOES Market Maker at the ECN/ATS or UTP price.
Orders that time out are not considered cancellations for the purposes of this
fee and, therefore, are not included in the fee calculation. The most up-to-date
fees for SOES are available in the “Trading Services” section on the Nasdaq
TraderSM Web site at www.nasdaqtrader.com, or by calling Nasdaq Subscriber
Services, at (800) 777-5606.
Overview of SelectNet
SelectNet offers traders the ability to automate the negotiation and execution
of trades. Orders of any size up to six digits can be entered into SelectNet.
Executions are automatically reported to ACT for public dissemination and
sent to clearing for comparison and settlement.
When an order is countered, negotiations begin and the two parties exchange
messages until they produce a full or partial execution, decline the transaction,
or the transaction times out.
Participation
All Nasdaq order-entry firms or Market Makers may participate in SelectNet if they:
Hours of Operation
Normal trading hours: 9:30 a.m. to 4:00 p.m., ET
Before- and after-hours trading: 9:00 to 9:30 a.m. and 4:00 to 6:30 p.m., ET
If you enter a broadcast order into SelectNet for display to all other Market
Makers and your order is priced better than your displayed Nasdaq quote, you
must change your Nasdaq quote to show the better price that you have
displayed through the SelectNet broadcast. However, you are not required to
change your quote if the order is preferenced to a single Market Maker or to an
eligible ECN/ATS.
SelectNet Cancellations
A market participant may not cancel or attempt to cancel a SelectNet order for
10 seconds after the order is entered into the system. This rule applies to orders
entered during all three sessions of the SelectNet operational hours (9:00 to
9:30 a.m., ET; 9:30 a.m. to 4:00 p.m., ET; and 4:00 to 5:15 p.m., ET).
This Incoming Liability Order pop-up window does not affect the availability
of all other workstation functions. If you want to access another window while
the pop-up window is displayed, the pop-up window will move behind the
active window. If another liability order is received while the pop-up is in the
background, the pop-up window will reappear and display a new alert.
Incoming
Liability
Order
Pop-Up
Window
The Incoming Liability Order pop-up window will disappear when the liability
order is either executed or times out. If there are multiple liability warnings in
the window, and one of the orders is executed or times out, the “Additional
Messages in Queue” number is reduced by one.
Backing Away
A “backing-away” occurs when a member firm is not complying with its
obligations under Rule 11Ac1-1(c) (SEC Firm Quote Rule), which requires a
Market Maker to execute an order “presented” to it at a price at least as
favorable as its published quotation, up to its published quotation size. As a
Market Maker, your obligation to fill an order begins at the time the order is
“presented” regardless of how the order is transmitted to you. This includes an
order presented to you through SelectNet. Backing away may also violate
Conduct Rule 3320 and Marketplace Rule 4613(b), which require a Market
Maker to trade at its quotation and up to its quotation size when presented with
an order.
Exceptions to the Firm Quote Rule exist for Market Makers only if: (1) you
revise your quoted price or size in Nasdaq prior to the order being presented; or
(2) you have effected or are in the process of effecting a transaction at the time
an order is presented and immediately upon completion of that transaction
communicate a revised quotation to Nasdaq (the trade-ahead exception).
(2) Failure to act on a preferenced SelectNet liability order. The fact that
preferenced SelectNet liability orders may have scrolled off the Nasdaq
Workstation screen is not an exception to Rule 11Ac1-1. If you are a Market
Maker, you should take whatever steps you deem necessary to ensure that your
preferenced liability orders received through SelectNet are monitored and
responded to immediately.
On July 16, 1997, the SEC sent a letter to the NASD and NASD Regulation,
Inc., providing guidance on a variety of firm-quote compliance issues. Based on
the guidance provided in the SEC’s letter, NASD RegulationSM will continue to
analyze the SOES/SelectNet “double-hit” issue on a facts-and-circumstances
basis and will continue to review firms that demonstrate a pattern of non-
responsiveness to SelectNet liability orders after presentment, and initiate
disciplinary action, if warranted. As stated in the SEC’s 21(a) Report, “the firm
quote rule is triggered when an order is ‘presented’ to the Market Maker.
Because all preferenced SelectNet orders are delivered electronically to a
particular Market Maker, the presentment of an order is readily ascertainable.”
Your other option is to contact the other firm to seek resolution of the trade. If
you contact the other side first, you will not be held to the five-minute
requirement of contacting the Market Regulation Department. However, you
must contact the other side within five minutes, and if there is no resolution,
you must contact the Market Regulation Department immediately after your
contact with the other firm.
The fees listed above are temporary and subject to change. The most up-to-date
fees for SelectNet are available in the “Trading Services” section on the Nasdaq
Trader Web site at www.nasdaqtrader.com, or by calling Nasdaq Subscriber
Services at (800) 777-5606.
The SEC has stated that ECNs/ATSs may charge non-customers for executions
occurring through SelectNet. Individual ECNs/ATSs have established charges
and any questions regarding these fees should be addressed to the ECNs/ATSs.
Trade Reporting
Classes of Securities Subject to Trade Reporting
Nasdaq National Market® —The top tier of Nasdaq® issues that satisfy the
highest level of listing qualifications on The Nasdaq Stock Market®.
The Nasdaq SmallCap MarketSM —The second tier of Nasdaq issues, generally
comprising companies with fewer assets than those on the Nasdaq National Market.
Contra Party
Market Non-Market
Member Transaction Maker Maker Customer Exchange
Principal Transactions
Market Maker buys from: No Yes Yes No
sells to: Yes Yes Yes No
Non-Market Maker buys from: No No Yes No
sells to: No Yes Yes No
Agency Transactions
Market Maker buys, as agent for customer, from: No Yes Yes No
sells, as agent for customer, to: Yes Yes Yes No
Non-Market Maker buys, as agent for customer, from: No No Yes No
sells, as agent for customer, to: No Yes Yes No
Riskless Transactions by
Non-Market Makers
Non-Market Makers buys from customer and sells to: No Yes Yes No
sells to customer and buys from: No No Yes No
(4) Transactions where the buyer and seller have agreed to trade at a
price substantially unrelated to the current market for the security
(for example, to enable the seller to make a gift).
Who/What Reports
Buy as principal Buy of 100 shares at 40
100 shares at 40 plus
1/8 markup
Sell as agent Sell of 100 shares at 40
100 shares at 40 plus
$12.50 commission
Buy as agent
100 shares at 40 plus
$12.50 commission
and Cross of 100 shares at 40
Sell as agent
100 shares at 40 plus
$12.50 commission
Member firms that have the operational capability to report transactions in foreign securities (excluding
1
Canadian Issues and ADRs) within 90 seconds of execution, between the hours of 8 a.m. and 5:15 p.m.,
ET, may do so at their option.
(1) one in which a member that is not a Market Maker in the security, after
receiving a customer’s order to buy, purchases the security as principal
from another member or customer to satisfy the order to buy, or
(2) after receiving a customer’s order to sell, the member sells the security as
principal to another member or customer to satisfy the sell.
Paper Form T
Now that the Automated Confirmation Transaction ServiceSM(ACTSM) window
is open for up to one year from trade date, it is no longer permissible to report
trades beyond T+1 by using a paper Form T, subject to certain limited
exceptions.
Trade Corrections
The Browse function in ACT, accessible through the “Utilities” menu located
on the main menu bar of Nasdaq Workstation II®, is used for trade scanning and
reconciliation of original T and T+n open and as-of trades. The Browse
function can be used by both order-entry firms and Market Makers. The Browse
function is used to:
Phone Numbers
MarketWatch
Trade Reporting Rules, Complaints (800) 211-4953
StockWatch Section (Trading Halts) (800) 537-3929
Trading Halts
The Nasdaq Stock Market® provides real-time surveillance of issuer activity on
Nasdaq® by reviewing press releases issued by Nasdaq-listed companies for
material news, and by monitoring price and volume activity in Nasdaq securities
using automated surveillance systems. In the course of on-line surveillance, the
Nasdaq StockWatch Department has the authority to implement temporary
trading halts to allow for even dissemination of material news.
Tracking the status of trading halts can also be done by accessing the Nasdaq
News frame. The schedule listed on the following page identifies the specific
codes that reflect the status of trading halts, suspensions, and cease trade orders
in Nasdaq and Consolidated Quotation System (CQS) securities.
Another source for tracking trading halts is on the Nasdaq TraderSM website,
nasdaqtrader.com. From the homepage, simply click on the “Trading Halts”
shortcut button. You can access a list of trading halts and resumptions for the
current day, a display of halted issues that have not resumed trading from
previous days, an archive of trading halts, and trading halt codes.
[MarketWatch Page]
T.2 [Halt-News Released] company symbol, name, and halt time. The news
has begun the dissemination process over a major wire service.
H.9 [Halt-Not Current] company symbol, name, and time of update. Trading is
halted because the company is not current in its required filings.
Any trading during a halt is a violation of NASD Conduct Rule 3340. Any
trades executed during a halt must be canceled as soon as possible before the
close of the trading day. If not, Nasdaq will cancel the trade.
Nasdaq will suspend trading in conjunction with all suspensions by the SEC,
regulatory suspensions, and Cease Trade Orders (CTOs) from other regulators.
When a trading halt has been implemented as a result of an SEC suspension,
the status of the halt is updated with an H.10 indication. A trading halt resulting
from a CTO or regulatory suspension is updated with an H.11 indication. The
date and time of the trading suspension, and the date and time the suspension
expires, will be displayed on the news frame. For example, the Nasdaq News
frame would display:
H.11 ABCD AB Company SEC Susp 7/20/00 9.30 am Exp 8/2/00 12.00 am
OTCBB Halts
Nasdaq will halt trading in OTC Bulletin Board®‚ (OTCBB) issues in the
following instances:
Another source for tracking OTCBB trading halts is on the OTCBB website,
www.otcbb.com. From the homepage, simply click on the “Trading Halts”
shortcut button. You can access a list of trading halts and resumptions for the
current day, a display of halted issues that have not resumed trading from
previous days, an archive of trading halts, and trading halt codes.
Currently, when the Dow Jones Industrial Average (DJIA) declines by levels of
10 percent, 20 percent, and 30 percent, circuit breaker trigger points are hit.
The actual numerical points are determined each calendar quarter (based on the
DJIA average for the final month of the quarter).
For current circuit breakers please consult the circuit breakers web page on the
Nasdaq Trader website at nasdaqtrader.com.
If the market closes for the day, trading in Nasdaq securities will recommence
at 9:30 a.m., ET, the following business day, with pre-open trading allowed at
8:00 a.m., ET. During the circuit breaker trading halts, NASD member firms
may not directly effect trades in Nasdaq- or exchange-listed securities on
Phone Numbers
StockWatch (800) 537-3929
Nasdaq Product Development (212) 858-4322
Market Watch
Trade Reporting Rules, Complaints (800) 211-4953
StockWatch Section (Trading Halts) (800) 537-3929
Firm Quote Compliance, Market Regulation (800) 925-8156
Training
To arrange for training or to request training materials, please contact:
Nasdaq Subscriber Training (212) 858-4084
You may also complete the Subscriber Training request form located at the URL
below.
http://nasdaqtrader.com/asp/GetCustomerInfo.asp?2
or send email to [email protected]
Limit Orders
Limit Orders
The National Association of Securities Dealers, Inc. (NASD®), Limit Order
Protection Interpretation eliminated the so-called “Manning safe harbor” that
previously allowed you, as a member firm, to trade ahead of your customers’
limit orders if you disclosed to your customers that trading ahead was your
firm’s practice. Limit Order Protection Rules are sometimes referred to as
Manning Rules.
A Market Maker is obligated to protect a limit order up to the size that it trades
ahead of the order. For example, if your firm holds a customer’s limit order to
Trades done in the Small Order Execution SystemSM (SOESSM) and SelectNet®
activate your responsibility to execute the limit orders you are protecting. Once
you have agreed to accept preferenced orders through SOES from another
member, you must also protect limit orders preferenced to you from that firm.
Keep in mind, the execution of a limit order pursuant to the interpretation does
not trigger an obligation to execute another limit order on the opposite side of
the market.
IM-2110-2 does not apply to a customer limit order if the limit order is
marketable at the time that it is received by a Market Maker. Although these
orders must be executed at their limit price or better, these orders are to be
treated as market orders for the purposes of determining execution priority. The
exclusion for marketable limit orders from the general application of IM-2110-2
is limited solely to customer limit orders that are marketable when received by a
Market Maker. If a customer limit order is not marketable when received by a
Market Maker, the limit order must be accorded the full protections of IM-2110-
2. Moreover, if the limit order was marketable when received and then becomes
non-marketable, it must, from that point in time until the order is executed,
canceled or modified, be accorded the full protections of IM-2110-2.
As the member firm imposing the terms and conditions on the limit order, you
must ensure that those terms and conditions are clearly communicated to the
customer. Any customer may place special conditions on the handling of a limit
order, and although you may not seek to negotiate special terms and conditions
with non-institutional customers, any customer may qualify or specify certain
conditions regarding the handling of a limit order. For example, a customer
placing a larger-sized limit order, such as 1,000 shares, may determine that he or
she is best served if the limit order is handled as an “all-or-none” (AON) order, or
is not subject to minimal partial fills as a Market Maker trades with smaller-sized
market orders at the same or inferior price as the limit order. The interpretation
With adequate disclosure, you may impose commissions, fees, or separate charges
for the handling of a limit order.
Price Improvement
As a Market Maker, you may give price improvement to an incoming orders. To
avoid violating the limit order protection rule when giving price improvement to
an incoming market order, the minimum amount of price improvement to the
market order must be 1/16, or one-half of the normal minimum quote increment
when the actual spread equals the minimum quote increment.
Priority of Execution
Your firm may choose any reasonable methodology for the way it executes the
multiple limit orders it holds, as long as it applies the methodology consistently.
You may not knowingly favor your own customers’ limit orders in determining
the priority of limit orders accepted by your firm from your own customers and
customers of other members.
For example, if your customer enters a limit order to purchase security ABCD,
with a request that the total costs not exceed $10 per share, and that customer is
If your firm informs a customer that it will protect an order at a price, it must
report the trade at that price. Firms that choose to use an internal sales credit as a
part of their calculation in determining the price for limit order protection
purposes have therefore chosen to make the sales credit part of the markup. Once
you have effected the markup calculation in this way, your firm must be
consistent in using the same calculation for other rules related to execution price
reports. Thus, your firm must treat the internal sales credit as part of the markup
for trade reporting and confirmation purposes.
Keep in mind, your firm may always provide the customer an execution at a more
favorable price.
If, however, your customer’s limit order is a de minimis size — that is, less than
or equal to 10 percent of your displayed quote size — you do not have to update
your quote to reflect the size of the limit order. The Display Rule requires that
you, as a Market Maker, update your quote to reflect your customer’s limit order
as soon as practicable, but no later than 30 seconds of receiving the order. The
For example, if you receive a customer limit order and send it to an ECN/ATS for
execution, and subsequently you receive a market order, the SEC has stated that
the market order must be given the improved price of the limit order. Your
obligation to protect the limit order and to improve the price of an incoming
market order does not end when the limit order is sent to another entity for
execution.
Phone Numbers
NASD Regulation®, Market Regulation (800) 925-8156
Nasdaq Office of General Counsel (202) 728-8294
The Erroneous Transaction Rule (Rule 11890 of the Uniform Practice Code)
says that:
“Officers of The Nasdaq Stock Market... have the authority to review any
transaction arising out of the operation of any automated quotation, execution,
or communication system owned or operated by Nasdaq... with a view toward
maintaining a fair and orderly market and the protection of investors and the
public interest.”
Under the rule, there must be an obvious error in the terms of the trade, such as
price, number of shares, the identity of the security, etc. For example, if you
entered an order into SelectNet to buy a stock at 10, but you entered the order
for 100 erroneously, you would be able to request a ruling on the grounds that
the price was clearly in error.
An erroneous complaint should identify the security, shares, price, and contra
broker as well as the Nasdaq system through which the transaction was
executed. In the case of SelectNet transactions, you may identify the
transactions by providing the SelectNet reference numbers. Nasdaq may reject a
request if the transaction cannot be readily identified from the filed complaint.
Also, your initial request or follow up documentation should explain the nature
of the error.
Nasdaq Market Operations will contact the contra party to the trade and offer
them the option of faxing any facts they feel are relevant.
The details of the transaction and related market activity will be presented to a
Nasdaq officer for consideration, along with the letter from your firm and the
contra party.
The officer has three options: (1) the officer may declare the trade “null and
void”; (2) the officer may modify one or more terms of the transaction; or (3)
the officer may decline to act on the request.
Nasdaq Market Operations staff will call both parties to the transaction and
advise them of the ruling. In addition, the officer will fax a written notice of the
ruling to both parties.
■ For transactions occurring between 9:30 a.m. and 10:00 a.m., Eastern
Time (ET), your written request must be received by 10:30 a.m., ET.
■ For transactions occurring prior to 9:30 a.m. or after 10:00 a.m., ET, your
written request must be received within 30 minutes of the transaction.
A. Although you can request a review, it may not be possible for the officer
to determine that the transaction was, in actuality, an error. Despite the
fact that you may have made a mistake, it is not an obvious error if the
trade was consistent with the market price and size at the time of the
transaction. If you executed 10,000 shares of a thinly traded stock, the
transaction might be viewed as an obvious error, being inconsistent with
the trading pattern of the issue.
Q. Can I ask for an erroneous trade ruling for a pre-opening SelectNet trade?
A. The rule requires that the member involved in the transaction shall
provide Nasdaq with any information that it requests.
A. Initially you must clearly identify the transaction(s) at issue and request
a determination. An additional 30 minutes is provided from the time
your faxed request is received for you to provide any additional
information. It is strongly recommended that you provide an explanation
of the circumstances surrounding the questioned transaction.
Phone Number
Nasdaq Market Operations (800) 219-4861
Fax Number
Nasdaq Market Operations (203) 385-6384
Short Sales
The NASD Short Sale Rule
National Association of Securities Dealers, Inc. (NASD®) Rule 3350, or NASD
Short Sale Rule, was approved by the Securities and Exchange Commission
(SEC) on a pilot basis through September 30, 2000.
In general, the rule prohibits NASD member firms from effecting short sales (for
customer or proprietary accounts) in Nasdaq National Market® (NNM)
securities at or below the current inside bid whenever that bid is lower than the
previous inside bid. (This is called the “Bid Test,” as opposed to the “Tick Test,”
which applies to exchange-listed securities under SEC Rule 10a-1, the SEC
Short Sale Rule.)
The rule does not apply to securities traded on The Nasdaq SmallCap MarketSM,
securities traded through other Nasdaq®-operated services like the OTC Bulletin
Board® (OTCBB). The rule is in effect during normal domestic market hours,
from 9:30 a.m. to 4:00 p.m., Eastern Time (ET). Unless eligible for one of the
rule’s exemptions described below, to effect a “legal” short sale on a down bid,
you must execute the sale: at a price at least 1/16 of a point above the current
inside bid, if the inside spread is 1/16 of a point or greater; or at a price equal to
or greater than the offer price if the inside spread is less than 1/16 point.
The Nasdaq Stock Market® calculates the inside bid and disseminates symbols to
denote whether the current inside bid is an “up bid” or a “down bid.”
Specifically, an up bid is denoted by a green “up” arrow and a down bid is
denoted by a red “down” arrow on Nasdaq Workstation II® (NWIITM). If a
security’s symbol has a green up-arrow next to it, you can effect short sales in
the security and not violate the rule (even if you do not qualify for a short-sale
exemption).
The NASD Short Sale Rule also contains a number of other exemptions.
Specifically, the rule has exemptions for registered warrant and options Market
Makers that hedge warrant or options positions established pursuant to bona
fide market-making activity. The rule incorporates exemptions contained in
SEC Rule 10a-1—the SEC Short Sale Rule—applicable to exchange-listed
securities. For a more complete discussion of these exemptions, please refer to
NASD Notice to Members (NTM) 94-68 and NTM 94-83.
Three interpretations (IMs) to the rule are contained in IM-3350, in the NASD
Manual, immediately following the rule language. You should read the
interpretations in IM-3350 carefully, as they contain information about what
constitutes bona fide market-making activity; the definition of a “legal” short
sale; and examples of what are considered to be manipulative acts and violations
of the rule.
1
Since the rule has been in effect, Nasdaq has used the current standard as well as two other standards to
determine whether a dealer is “qualified” and eligible for the short-sale exemption for Market Makers.
Nasdaq presently is developing a new test (for which it intends to seek SEC approval), under which only
Market Makers that meet certain quantitative criteria will be designated as primary Market Makers and
will qualify for this exemption.
For a full discussion of these issues, please refer to the following Nasdaq Head
Trader Alerts: Alert #1997-30 (March 13, 1997); Alert #1997-32 (April 2, 1997);
and Alert #1997-38 (April 18, 1997), which are located on the Nasdaq TraderSM
Web site at www.nasdaqtrader.com. Also refer to NTM 94-68 and NTM 94-83.
2
A seller shall be deemed to own a security if: (1) the seller or the seller’s agent has title to it; (2) the seller
has purchased, or has entered into an unconditional contract, binding on both parties to purchase it, but
has not yet received it; (3) the seller owns a security convertible into or exchangeable for it and has
tendered such security for conversion or exchange; (4) the seller has an option to purchase or acquire it
and has exercised such option; or (5) the seller has rights or warrants to subscribe to it and has exercised
such rights or warrants.
Trades executed through the Small Order Execution SystemSM (SOESSM) against
a Market Maker are not subject to the above ACT reporting requirements
because SOES is mandatory for all Nasdaq National Market securities and
Market Makers have no control over the timing of executions through SOES.
For a full discussion of these issues, please refer to Head Trader Alert #1997-34.
3
Market Makers can use the QuickReport function on the Dynamic Quote window of Nasdaq
Workstation II to enter exempt short sales (marked as “SX”) and non-exempt short sales (marked “SS”).
Buy-Ins
When a buy-in for a Nasdaq security is sent to a clearing corporation on behalf
of a customer who wants possession of his or her shares, the buy-in must be
executed for cash or guaranteed delivery, if the clearing corporation cannot
satisfy the share allocation.
Phone Numbers
Nasdaq Office of General Counsel (202) 728-8294
Nasdaq Market Operations (800) 219-4861
Chapter 10 ATSs/ECNs 1
(2) that does not: (i) set rules governing the conduct of subscribers other than
the conduct of such subscribers’ trading on the ATS; or (ii) discipline
subscribers other than by excluding them from trading on the ATS.
“any electronic system that widely disseminates to third parties orders entered
therein by an exchange Market Maker or OTC Market Maker, and permits
such orders to be executed against in whole or in part . . .”
The rule excludes electronic systems that cross orders at one or more specified
times at a single price set by the system (by algorithm or by any derivative pricing
mechanism) and do not allow orders to be crossed or executed directly by
participants outside of those specified times.
The rule also excludes any system operated by a Market Maker that executes
customer orders primarily against the Market Maker’s principal account.
This chapter will focus on ECNs since orders or quotes submitted to this type
ATS can affect a members ability to comply with the SEC’s Quote and Limit
Order Display (Rule 11Ac1-4) Rules. Together, these rules are referred to as “the
Order Handling Rules” because they dictate how Market Makers must display
their quotes and handle customer limit orders.
2 ATSs/ECNs Chapter 10
SEC Quote Rule
The SEC Quote Rule, among other things, requires Market Makers to provide
Nasdaq with any quote or customer limit order that a Market Maker submits to
an ECN, unless the ECN to which the order or limit order was submitted is
linked to Nasdaq.
Linked ECNs
Under both of these rules, a Market Maker’s obligation to handle a quote or
customer limit order in a certain manner will depend on whether the quote or
limit order has been delivered to an ECN that is linked with Nasdaq. To
summarize, a Market Maker that submits a quote or customer limit orders to a
non-linked ECN and does not also reflect that quote or limit orders in its Nasdaq
quote will have violated the SEC Quote Rule and/or the SEC Limit Order Display
Rule. In contrast, a Market Maker that submits such quote or limit orders to a
linked ECN will not have to change its quote in Nasdaq and will be in compliance
with the SEC Rules.
The linked ECNs currently include Archipelago (ARCA), ATTAIN (ATTN), Brass
Utility L.L.C., (BRUT), B-Trade Services(BTRD), Instinet (INCA), The Island
ECN, Inc. (ISLD), MarketXT (MKXT), Spear Leeds and Kellogg (REDI), and
NexTrade (NTRD). SelectNet‰ Broadcast is an ECN under the SEC’s definition,
but it is not a linked ECN because Broadcast orders are not included in the
Nasdaq quote montage and do not set the inside market. Accordingly, Market
Makers may not use the SelectNet Broadcast to satisfy the display alternative in
the SEC Rules.
Chapter 10 ATSs/ECNs 3
Linked ECNs—Participation in SuperSoes
Linked ECNs may choose how they accept orders in SuperSoesSM. An ECN can
participate either as a full participant ECN or as an order-entry ECN. Full
participant ECNs provide automatic execution for orders received through
SuperSoes, and likewise can send orders to Market Makers or other full
participant ECNs for automatic execution. Full participant ECNs are identified
by a fifth character “+” symbol in their Nasdaq MMID.
If the order in the ECN is not from an NASD member, the broker/dealer that
sponsors the ECN is obliged to take reasonable steps to avoid the lock or cross.
4 ATSs/ECNs Chapter 10
Currently, the ECN can do one of two things: (1) enter an order into SuperSoes
or SelectNet (as applicable) to take out the other quote; or (2) not display the
order in Nasdaq.
As to the second approach, the SEC Quote Rule only requires ECNs to display the
orders of specialists or Market Makers. If the order is from another entity, the
ECN does not have to provide that order to Nasdaq, and thus can avoid locking
or crossing the market. However, Regulation ATS requires certain ECNs to
provide Nasdaq with their best priced buy and sell orders from all types of
subscribers, not just specialists and Market Makers. The second option is not
available for ECNs subject to this requirement.
Disruption of Service
If an ECN’s link to Nasdaq is disrupted so that the ECN cannot correctly show its
prices on Nasdaq or if order-entry ECNs cannot accept SelectNet, the ECN
becomes a non-linked ECN until the problem is corrected. During the time that
the link is disrupted, Market Makers that use the ECN to enter customer or
proprietary orders must change their quotes in Nasdaq to reflect the
quotes/orders they are putting into the ECN/ATS.
The SEC allows linked ECNs to charge a service fee to anyone that accesses their
quotes through SelectNet or SuperSoes. Each ECN determines whether or not to
charge for such access, and how much the charge will be. If an ECN charges for
access, the ECN contacts each firm that accesses the ECN through SelectNet or
SuperSoes and bills that firm directly for that access.
Phone Numbers
Nasdaq Office of General Counsel (202) 728-8294
MarketWatch
Trade Reporting Rules, Complaints (800) 211-4953
StockWatch Section (Trading Halts) (800) 537-3929
Chapter 10 ATSs/ECNs 5
Chapter 11
Revised October 2000
Exchange-Listed Securities
National Association of Securities Dealers, Inc. (NASD®) member firms are
permitted to trade exchange-listed securities (Consolidated Quotation Service
[CQS] securities) as principal in certain circumstances, and The Nasdaq Stock
Market, Inc. provides quoting and execution services to accommodate Market
Makers and order-entry firms in Nasdaq InterMarketSM trading.
Each day the primary exchange opens a particular security for trading, you are
allowed to trade the security before the primary exchange does, but that action
precludes all CQS Market Makers from participating in the exchange’s pre-
opening indication. This pertains only to Intermarket Trading System (ITS)
eligible securities that send out pre-opening indications to Nasdaq.
Quotation Requirements
A CQS Market Maker must maintain continuous, two-sided quotes. Your
quotations are required to be firm up to their displayed size. The minimum
quote size for CQS securities is 100 shares (i.e., 1 x 1).
Autoquote Policy
NASD Rule 6330(d) explicitly permits the following uses of computer-generated
quote updates:
Trade Practices
If your firm trades CQS securities, you must abide and adhere to the following
conditions and requirements when trading CQS securities for your own account
or for your customers:
CAES
CAES is an order delivery and execution system that allows you to direct
agency orders in exchange-listed issues (CQS stocks) to Nasdaq Market Makers
for execution. CAES automatically does the following with each execution:
ITS
ITS provides the link between Nasdaq (the Nasdaq InterMarket) and other ITS
participant exchanges in exchange-listed issues. The ITS system allows for
either automatic execution or delivery of an ITS commitment.
■ Nasdaq (T)
Phone Numbers
CAES/ITS Service Desk (203) 385-6399
Nasdaq InterMarket Market Services (202) 974-2110
Nasdaq Subscriber Services (800) 777-5606
Nasdaq Office of General Counsel (202) 728-8294
Fax Number
CAES/ITS Service Desk (203) 385-6555
Regulatory Requirements
Prohibitions Against Anti-Competitive Behavior
The Nasdaq Stock Market, Inc. supports an open and equitable trading
environment for all market participants, and the National Association of
Securities Dealers, Inc. (NASD®) has established rules to foster fair practices and
prohibit anti-competitive behavior. Specifically, NASD Conduct Rule IM-2110-5
identifies certain conduct that is inconsistent with just and equitable principles
of trade. Neither your firm nor anyone associated with your firm should:
■ Your firm may set its own bid and ask in any Nasdaq security, the prices
at which it is willing to buy or sell any Nasdaq security, and the
quantity of shares of any Nasdaq security that it is willing to buy or sell.
■ You may set your own dealer spread, quote increment, or quantity of
shares for your quotations in any Nasdaq security. You may also set any
relationship between or among your dealer spread, inside spread, or the
size of any quote increment in any Nasdaq security.
■ Your firm may communicate its own bid or ask to explore the possibility
of a purchase or sale of that security, and to negotiate or agree to, that
purchase or sale.
■ You may communicate your firm’s own bid or ask for the purpose of
retaining an agent or subagent for your firm or for a customer of your
firm (or to be retained as an agent or subagent).
■ Your firm may engage in any underwriting (or any syndicate for the
underwriting) of securities to the extent permitted by the federal
securities laws.
■ You may take any unilateral action or make any unilateral decision
regarding the Market Makers with which your firm will trade and the
terms on which it will trade, unless such action is prohibited by the
interpretation.
■ You may deliver an order to another member for handling.
The SEC has stated that, as a general matter, the duty of best execution refers to
your duty to seek to execute your customer’s order in the best available market.
NASD Conduct Rule 2320 states that in any transaction with or for a customer,
a member and its associated persons must use reasonable diligence to ascertain
the best inter-dealer market for the security and buy or sell in such market so
that the price to the customer is as favorable as possible under prevailing market
conditions. Among the factors that will be considered in applying the standard
of reasonable diligence are as follows:
A. MMA must execute the market order at 10 1/4, the price of the
undisplayed limit order. MMA may execute the market order against the
limit order or against its own inventory. However, if it fills the market
order out of its own inventory, the Manning Rule requires that MMA
protect the limit order at its price (i.e., 10 1/4). The remaining 500 shares
of the limit order would continue to reside undisplayed on MMA’s book.
Q. System Orders:
The inside market on Nasdaq is 10 – 10 1/2, 10 x 10. Market Maker
A(MMA) holds a customer limit order to buy 1,500 shares at 10 1/4,
which the customer has requested not be displayed. MMA receives a
customer market order to sell 1,000 shares from another broker/dealer
through MMA’s automated order delivery and execution system. At what
price should the limit and market orders be executed?
A. Both the market order and the limit order must be executed at 10 1/4.
Even though the order is from another broker/dealer, the other firm has
routed its order with the understanding that MMA will provide
automated executions for that broker’s customer orders and thereby
provide best execution through MMA’s system. Therefore, MMA must
match (as principal or as agent, as explained in the above answer) the
1,000-share customer market order against 1,000 shares of the
undisplayed customer limit and execute at 10 1/4. The remaining 500
shares of the 10 1/4 limit order remain undisplayed on MMA’s files.
A. Both the market order and the limit order must be executed at 10 1/4.
Even though the order is from another broker/dealer, MMA must match
1,000 shares of BDB’s customer order against the undisclosed limit order
of 10 1/4, because MMA has an arrangement under which it has
implicitly or explicitly undertaken to provide best execution to BDB’s
customers’ orders
A. MMA may execute BDB’s market order to sell at MMA’s published quote
of 10. MMA does not owe a best execution obligation to a non-customer
where no understanding or expectation of treatment as a customer has
been reached by MMA and BDB. Broker/dealers are not considered
customers for purposes of this obligation. If MMA executes BDB’s order
at 10, MMA has traded through the customer limit order it holds,
however. Thus, under the Manning Rule, MMA must execute 1,000
shares of the limit order it holds.
A. MMA must execute the customer limit order and 2,000 shares of the
market order at 20 5/32, even though its displayed quote was rounded to
20 1/8. The execution must occur at the actual limit order price that
MMA held.
Q. Execution Price:
The inside market on Nasdaq is 10 – 10 1/2, 10 x 10. Market Maker A
(MMA) holds a customer limit order to buy at 10 1/4 for 1,500 shares
that the customer requests not be displayed. MMA receives a customer
limit order to sell 1,000 shares at 10 1/8. At what price(s) should the
limit orders be executed?
A. MMA should execute the sell limit order against the buy limit order at
10 1/4. In essence, the second limit order is a marketable limit order that
is the equivalent of a market order and should be treated as such under
the best execution principles discussed by the SEC.
A. MMA must execute the market order at a price at least 1/16 better than
the limit order price so as not to violate the NASD Limit Order
Protection Rule. However, when the actual quotation spread is the
minimum quotation increment, the minimum price improvement is one-
half of the normal minimum quote increment. For example, if the actual
A. Because MMA has been given discretion by its customer to work the
order, MMA does not owe the same best execution obligations to it and
to other crossing orders as it would if the order were a non-discretionary
market or limit order. Thus, where beneficial to the discretionary order,
MMA may trade at 10 1/16 or lower with incoming orders without
necessarily triggering a fill for the discretionary order it holds. Because
the discretionary order is not a priced order, there are no Manning
obligations to the order, nor is there a specific price at which an
incoming order can be matched.
A. MMA does not have to match the market order against the discretionary
order and MMA is able to buy from the market order at its bid of 10,
assuming that this handling benefits the discretionary order. The
discretionary order with a cap is not considered a limit order because the
firm is “working” the order and may be able to execute it at prices other
than the 10 3/16 cap price.
A. No. While MMA has a Manning obligation to execute the limit order,
MMA can execute the limit order at its stated price of 10 1/8. In
addition, MMA is not obligated to execute 1,000 shares of the 100,000-
share block at 10 1/8, assuming that MMA has clearly disclosed to the
institution that it intends to handle the order in this manner, and the
institution has agreed to this practice.
A. MMA must execute the net sell order at 20 by matching (as principal or
as agent) the limit order to buy at 20 against the net sell order first, and
then execute the remainder of the net order against its inventory.
Transactions executed based on knowledge of less than all of the terms of the
block transaction may still be considered frontrunning—that is, a prohibited
action—so long as there is knowledge that all of the material terms of the
transaction have been or will be agreed upon imminently.
The general prohibitions stated above do not apply to transactions that you
execute through automatic execution systems where you must accept the
automatic executions.
Under the interpretation, it is recommended (but not required) that your firm
develop and implement policies and procedures to establish effective internal
control systems, and procedures that would isolate specific information within
research and other relevant departments of the firm to prevent the trading
department from utilizing the advance knowledge of the issuance of a research
report. Firms that choose not to develop “Chinese Wall” procedures bear the
burden of demonstrating that the basis for changes in inventory positions in
advance of research reports was not purposeful.
If the OTCBB displays three firm quotations, you are not required to call the
three Market Makers to verify the firm quotations that are displayed on the
screen. Rather, you need only note on the order ticket, the identity of the
broker/dealers, and the firm quotations obtained from the OTCBB. You could
also print a copy of the screen and attach the copy to the order ticket.
If the OTCBB has fewer than three Market Makers listed, you must check the
“Pink Sheets” or any other quotation medium for additional Market Makers. A
Market Maker in these quotation mediums must be contacted to obtain its
current quotations. If three Market Makers cannot be found, then you need only
contact the one or two that you do find.
On occasion, the application of the Three Quote Rule may hinder your best
execution obligation due to time delays involved. Several market participants
have questioned the value of the Three Quote Rule, pointing in particular to
foreign securities traded on foreign exchanges, but not on U.S. exchanges. For
these foreign exchanges, taking the time to contact three dealers before
executing the transaction could hinder best execution. In such cases,
exemptions from the rule may be considered. For more details, please see NASD
NTM 97-88.
Phone Number
NASD Regulation, Inc., Market Regulation (301) 590-6410
Nasdaq Office of General Counsel (202) 728-8294
ACT Requirements
The Automated Confirmation Transaction ServiceSM (ACTSM) was developed
for National Association of Securities Dealers, Inc. (NASD®) members to use in
comparing trade information and submitting locked-in trades to the National
Securities Clearing Corporation (NSCC) for clearing. ACT also accommodates
all of Nasdaq® trade reporting. Nasdaq execution systems, such as the Small
Order Execution SystemSM (SOESSM) and SelectNet®, have an automated
interface with ACT and automatically route execution reports through ACT for
reporting and comparison.
Nasdaq Market Makers are required to submit trade reports through ACT,
within 90 seconds of execution (see Chapter 5 for additional information) for trade
reporting and clearing purposes. Similarly, order entry-firms are required to
submit details of the trade, or accept or decline the Market Maker’s entry, using
the ACT browse function on the Nasdaq Workstation II®(NWIITM) within 20
minutes of the trade. Participants may also use the browse function to change
the status of desired trades by entering a different code into the system.
The Market Maker trade correction (No/Was) function may also be used to
correct a previously entered original trade that is unanswered or declined by the
order-entry side or that was submitted for trade reporting purposes only.
Hours of Operation
ACT is open for trade report input daily from 8:00 a.m. to 6:30 p.m., Eastern
Time (ET). ACT also operates a service desk for small-sized firms with
infrequent transactions. To see if your firm qualifies for the ACT Service Desk,
contact the ACT Service Desk at (203) 378-0166.
T+N entries may be submitted until 6:30 p.m., ET, each business day. At the
end of daily matching, all declined trade entries will be purged from the ACT
As-Of trades will be included in ACT’s Risk Management calculations and will
be subject to Blockbuster and Sizable Trade Clearing Firm authorization when
limits have been exceeded.
The participant will need to reverse the side of the trade when submitting an
As-Of Trade Reversal into ACT. For example, if the subscriber wishes to cancel
a previously submitted sell trade, the subscriber must submit an As-Of Reversal
trade as a buy.
The subscriber will also have the ability to enter an As-Of Reversal function on
a net position basis. For example, if a subscriber entered a sell trade for 1,000
shares but the trade should have been for 800 shares, the subscriber may enter
an As-Of Trade Reversal for 200 shares as a buy to net the position to the
correct amount. This can be done in lieu of an As-Of Trade-Reversal buy for
1,000 shares and an As-Of trade sell for 800 shares.
A Step Out allows Broker A (executing broker) to “Step Out,” or allocate all or
part of the trade(s) to another broker/dealer(s) (Broker B). Broker A will submit
an ACT Market Maker (MM) entry that is flagged as a Step Out against Broker
B. In addition, Broker B will be required to acknowledge the trade by either
accepting the trade or submitting a matching order-entry (OE) firm entry that is
also flagged as a Step Out. Since the Step-Out flag will be a part of the
matching criteria, an omission of the flag by either side will cause the trade not
to match. Once the trade has matched, it will be submitted to the NSCC for
clearance and will include the Step-Out flag for identification purposes.
Give-Ups
“Give-Up” trades enable executing broker/dealers to submit trades to ACT
on behalf of a participant broker/dealer. The participant broker/dealer, in turn,
agrees to accept and honor all trades reported on its behalf, while the executing
broker/dealer adheres to the rules and provisions of ACT trade reporting. The
ACT Give-Up Automatic Lock-In function allows an introducing broker to
enter and lock-in a trade when it is responsible for both sides of the trade. This
QSR
A QSR (Qualified Special Representative) Agreement enables a special
representative, on behalf of the participant broker/dealer, to submit data
resulting from trade executions on the special representative’s automated system,
directly to NSCC for clearing. The participant broker/dealer agrees to accept
the terms of each trade that is reported in this manner. Members that have QSR
agreements with NSCC must still use ACT to submit trade reporting
information, but because of the QSR relationship, Nasdaq does not submit that
information to NSCC for clearing.
Training
To arrange for training or to request training materials, please contact:
Nasdaq Subscriber Training (212) 858-4084
You may also complete the Subscriber Training request form located at the URL
below.
http://nasdaqtrader.com/asp/GetCustomerInfo.asp?2
Training
The Nasdaq® Training Group is located in New York City at 33 Whitehall
Street. The staff offers comprehensive, on-site and phone training for member
firms on all aspects of Nasdaq Workstation II® (NWIITM), including workstation
set-up, and how to participate in the Small Order Execution SystemSM (SOESSM),
SelectNet®, and the Automated Confirmation Transaction ServiceSM (ACTSM).
For those firms located outside the New York City area, there may be charges
associated with having Nasdaq staff travel to your facility for on-site training.
Chapter 14 Training 1