Marine Losses

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 15

MARINE LOSSES

Marine losses may be classified as


follows:
Total loss
Actual
Presumed
Constructive

Partial loss
Particular Average
General Average
LAW _RGU revised 30/04/2015 1
Definitions
Actual Total Loss occurs when the subject
matter is destroyed, or is so damaged as to
cease to be a thing of the kind insured, or
when the assured is irretrievably deprived of
it.
Presumed Total Loss. When the ship
concerned in the adventure is missing her
total loss may, after the lapse of a reasonable
time, be presumed. Ordinarily, it will be
presumed that the loss arose from "peril of
the sea" which is an ordinary marine risk. But
if the ship was last known to have been in a
war-infested area then, in the absence of
other evidence, the presumption will be that
she was lost through war risk.
LAW _RGU revised 30/04/2015 2
Constructive Total Loss
This occurs when the subject-
matter is reasonably abandoned
on account of its actual total loss
appearing to be unavoidable, or
because it could not be preserved
from actual total loss without an
expenditure that would exceed its
value after the expenditure had
been incurred.
LAW _RGU revised 30/04/2015 3
Constructive Total Loss
In case of constructive total loss the
assured may either retain possession
and treat the loss as a 100% partial
loss, or abandon the subject-matter to
the underwriters and claim for total
loss. If he elects to abandon he must
serve notice of abandonment on the
underwriters, otherwise the loss can
be treated only as a partial loss.

LAW _RGU revised 30/04/2015 4


Constructive Total Loss
In ascertaining whether the Vessel is a
constructive total loss, the insured value
shall be taken as the repaired value and
nothing in respect of the damaged or break-
up value of the Vessel or wreck shall be
taken into account.
No claim for constructive total loss based
upon the cost of recovery and/or repair of the
vessel shall be recoverable hereunder unless
such cost would exceed the insured value. In
making this determination, only the cost
relating to a single accident or sequence of
damages arising from the same accident shall
be taken into account.

LAW _RGU revised 30/04/2015 5


Particular Average Loss
This is defined by the Marine Insurance Act
as a partial loss of the subject-matter insured
caused by a peril insured against which is not
a general average loss. It may, perhaps, be
more directly described as a partial loss
arising from any kind of accident. General
average sacrifices and expenditures,
particular charges, and salvage charges do
not arise by accident and, therefore, are not
included in particular average. A particular
average loss falls directly upon the party
interested in the subject-matter. In the case
of accidental or fortuitous damage to the ship
it is the shipowner or, to the extent that he is
insured against such loss, his underwriters
who must bear the loss.
Similarly, in the case of accidental damage to
cargo, the loss rests with the cargo owner or
his underwriters.LAW _RGU revised 30/04/2015 6
Egs
There are innumerable varieties of
particular average, including, such
things as:
straining of ship in bad weather,
loss of masts or spars through heavy
weather,
damage to hull, machinery, or cargo
due to heavy weather or fire,
damage to ship or cargo due to
collision or stranding

LAW _RGU revised 30/04/2015 7


Tender Clause
The "Tender Clause" of the
Institute Clauses usually attached
to a hull policy requires that, in
the event of any accident giving
rise to a claim, notice shall be
given to underwriters before
survey or, if the ship is abroad, to
the nearest Lloyd's agent so that
an underwriters' surveyor can be
appointed if desired.
LAW _RGU revised 30/04/2015 8
Tenders Clause
The Tenders Clause was introduced to give the
underwriters some control over the cost of repairs for
which they were liable. As a matter of good practice
the assured is expected to arrange for tenders to be
taken, but this might lead to some delay in carrying
out the repairs and hence loss of use of the vessel.
The clause empowers the underwriters to decide
which port and firm of repairers is to carry out the
repairs. They may take their own tenders, or they may
require further tenders to be taken for the repair of the
vessel. The clause provides for an allowance to be
claimed by the assured for the time lost between the
despatch of the invitations to tender initiated by the
underwriters, and the time of acceptance of a tender
approved by them, even though such tender was one
originally obtained by the assured. Such aIlowance is
reduced by amounts that the assured otherwise saves,
is allowed in general average or recovers from third
parties for detention.
Although rarely exercised, underwriters reserve the
right to deduct 15% from the claim if the assured does
not comply with the terms of this clause
LAW _RGU revised 30/04/2015 9
INSTITUTE CLAUSES
There are numerous sets of these
Institute clauses, so called because
they are framed and sanctioned by the
Technical and Clauses Committee of
the Institute of London Underwriters.
The current sets of clauses listed and
described here are for use only with
the new Marine Policy Form. Which
particular set will be attached in any
given case will depend upon the nature
of the subject-matter insured and what.
risks it is intended to cover.

LAW _RGU revised 30/04/2015 10


perils of the seas
The term "perils of' the seas" refers
only to fortuitous accidents or
casualties of the seas such as
stranding, collision and heavy weather.
It does not include the ordinary action
of the wind and waves. The object
of'the insurance is to indemnify the
assured against losses arising from
accidents that may happen, not in
respect of events which must happen.

LAW _RGU revised 30/04/2015 11


Barratry
"Barratry" includes every wrongful act
wilfully committed by the master or crew
to the prejudice of the owner or charterer.
For example, wilfully running the ship'
ashore with fraudulent intent; fraudulently
selling the ship, her equipment or cargo;
sailing in breach of an embargo; willfully
assisting illegal immigration; smuggling
without the owner's consent, are all acts
of barratry. Presumably the reason for
making this peril subject to the proviso of
due diligence by the owner is to allow the
underwriters to decline liability if they feel
that the owner has not been careful
enough in selecting his crew.
LAW _RGU revised 30/04/2015 12
DEVIATION
A voyage policy may enumerate ports
of call, or it may give leave to call at
"any ports or places whatsoever". This
expression, however, is very restricted
in its meaning and the liberty given is
only to call at the usual ports on the
particular voyage. If the ship deviates
without lawful excuse, the
underwriters are discharged from
liability from the time of the deviation,
and it is immaterial that the ship may
have regained her route before loss
occurs.
LAW _RGU revised 30/04/2015 13
Eg
There is a deviation whenever: –
(a) the route designated by the policy is
departed from;
(b) if no route is designated, the usual route is
departed from.
Where ports of discharge in a given area are
not named, or not mentioned in any special
order, the ship must go to them in strict
geographical order. Failure to do so amounts
to deviation.
An intention to deviate will not void the policy
if a loss occurs before the ship actually
deviates

LAW _RGU revised 30/04/2015 14


Permitted deviation(s)
Section 49 of the Marine Insurance Act 1906 provides that deviation
or delay in
prosecuting the voyage contemplated by the policy is excused: –
(a) where authorised by any special term in the policy; or
(b) where caused by circumstances beyond the control of the
master and his
employer; or
(c) where reasonably necessary in order to comply with an express
or
implied warranty; or
(d) where reasonably necessary for the safety of the ship or subject-
matter
insured; or
(e) for the purpose of saving human life, or aiding a ship in distress
where
human life may be in danger; or
(f) where reasonably necessary for the purpose of obtaining medical
or
surgical aid for any person on board the ship; or
(g) where caused by barratrous conduct of the master or crew, if
barratry be one of the perils insured against
LAW _RGU revised 30/04/2015 15

You might also like