2004 BIR - Ruling - DA 320 04 - 20180419 1159 Ho7dm4
2004 BIR - Ruling - DA 320 04 - 20180419 1159 Ho7dm4
2004 BIR - Ruling - DA 320 04 - 20180419 1159 Ho7dm4
Gentlemen :
This refers to your letter dated October 1, 2003 requesting for a clari cation as
to whether or not your processed Bangus are VAT-exempt.
It is represented that you are an owner/operator of a bangus sh pond in San
Fabian, Pangasinan; that the proliferation of sh pens and sh cages has severely
depressed the price of fresh bangus while the cost of feeds, electricity and labor has
increased and continues to increase; that you are registered as a non-vat taxpayer; and
that the following is a list of your processed bangus products:
1. Plain Deboned Bangus — the bangus is washed, gutted, deboned, soaked
in brine (water and salt) solution for 30 minutes, drip-dried, packed in
cellophane, vacuum packed then last frozen;
2. Smoked Deboned Bangus — The bangus sh is washed, gutted, deboned,
soaked in brine (water and salt) solution for 30 minutes, drip-dried,
smoked in a smoking chamber, packed in cellophane, vacuum packed
then blast frozen;
3. Marinated Deboned Bangus — The bangus sh is washed, gutted,
deboned, soaked in marinade (vinegar, salt, garlic and pepper)
solution for 30 minutes, drip-dried, packed in cellophane, vacuum
packed then blast frozen;
4. Bangus Belly — the bangus is washed, gutted, deboned, soaked in brine
(water and salt) solution for 30 minutes, drip-dried, cut out belly
section, packed in cellophane, vacuum packed and blast frozen;
5. Boneless Bangus Fillet — the scrap bangus meat leftover after cutting out
belly section is packed in cellophane, vacuum packed and blast
frozen; EcTDCI
In a related ruling, pursuant to the above provisions of law and regulations, this
O ce has the occasion to hold that "ground beef, chopped and frozen, quali es for
exemption from VAT" as agricultural food product in its original state. ( VAT Ruling No.
064-88). Verily, deboning is a simple process which does not alter the substance of the
thing, much less transform the meat into another distinct product altogether. What
would be outside of the scope of the term "simple process" is the kind of physical or
chemical process which would alter the exterior texture or form or inner substance of a
product in such a manner as to prepare it for special use to which it could not have
been put in its original form or condition.
In the light of the foregoing, this O ce is of the opinion and so holds that your
processed bangus products, namely Plain Deboned Bangus, Smoked Deboned Bangus,
Marinated Deboned Bangus, Bangus Belly, Boneless Bangus Fillet, Whole Gutted
Milk sh, Bangus Longaniza, and Bangus Spring Roll are within the purview of the
de nition of a food product in its original state, hence, exempt from the 10% Value
Added Tax.