BR No 469 Pier Design
BR No 469 Pier Design
BR No 469 Pier Design
TSLC :
0.460 1.200 2111.91 887.28 -11.29 DL + SIDL Below Bed block
0.460 1.200 2111.91 806.61 176.86 DL + SIDL + Water Below Bed block
0.460 1.200 2111.91 887.28 -11.29 DL + SIDL + Wind Below Bed block
0.460 1.200 2111.91 806.61 176.86 DL + SIDL + Water + Wind Below Bed block
0.460 1.200 3430.29 #REF! #REF! DL + SIDL + LL(TSLC) Below Bed block
0.460 1.200 3430.29 #REF! #REF! DL + SIDL+ Water + LL(TSLC) Below Bed block
0.460 1.200 3430.29 #REF! #REF! DL + SIDL+ Water + LL(TSLC) + Wind Below Bed block
Conclusion: PERMISSIBLE STRESSES IN CONCRE M25 8330kN/m2 (Bending compression) & 667kN/m2 (Tensile stress)
The stresses are within the permssible limits at all the sections of the pier
SKETCHES :
1.20 m
M 0.30
1.20 m 1.63
HFL 46.321
1.60 m
16.00
4.20
TRANSVERSE DIRECTION
8.00 m
48.41
46.32
5.83
8.529
42.12
PILE CAP
40.62
TRAFFIC DIRECTION
Dead Loads
Self Weight of Super structure = 2006.145 kN ( From RDSO drg 10271)
Live Loads
HORIZONTAL FORCES
= 1929 N/m2
= 1.929 kN/m2
From Cl. No. 2.11.2 of IRS Bridge Rules, Limiting wind pressure for LL to be present = 150
= 1.4715
Therefore,
Wind forces for the following two conditions are to be considered
= 38.632 m2
egory 1
Kg/m2
kN/m2
m2
m
DESIGN OF PIER
INTRODUCTION :
This note presents the stability analysis of pier for the proposed Railway Bridge No 469
between Guntur and Guntakal section.
The span arrangement of this bridge is 3 x 12.2 m PSC slab. PSC slabs are as per RDSO drg No 10271.
The calculations are made and presented in the following pages for the foundation of pier
Pile foundations are proposed and the depth of the pile is 15 m .
Piles are of RCC M 30 grade, bored, cast-in-situ, friction cum end bearing piles.
The pier is made of mass concrete gravity type and the grade of concrete is M 25
The permssible stress in concrete are 8330 kN/ sq m in compression and 833 kN/sq m in tension
REFERENCES :
DESIGN PARAMETERS
7 FSL RL 46.321 m
12 Span length between c/c of expn jts. 13.40 m Refer RDSO drg No 10271
23 Seismic Zone : II
24 Grade of concrete M- 25
At Top of Pier
Area 1.2X6.6
= = 7.920 m2
3.14x1.2x1.2/4 1.131
+ = m2
9.051 m2
Y
0.600
6.600
X X
Y
1.200
= 43.04727 m4
+ 3.14X1.2^4/64 = 0.10 m4
1.05 m4
1.05 x 2
Section Modulus ( Z yy) = = 1.75 m3
1.2
10.817 m2
Y
0.70
6.6
X X
Y
1.40
= 53.71126 m4
+ 3.14X1.4^4/64 = 0.19 m4
1.70 m4
15.655 m2
Y
0.965
X X
6.600
1.93
Y
= 86.53334 m4
+ 3.14X1.93^4/64 = 0.68 m4
4.63 m4
4.63 x 2
Section Modulus ( Z yy) = = 4.80 m3
1.93
SECTION PROPERTIES
Section Area in m2 ZXX in m3 ZYY in m3
1.63
8.00 1.40
5.83 4.20
8.53 1.929
PILE CAP
PILE CAP
c.g of pier @ Bed Level along traffic direction = ( 45.4974 x 2.9165 + 2.1264931 x 1.94
( 45.4974 + 2.1264931 )
= 2.873091 m
c.g of pier @ Bed Level ' ^ lar to traffic direction = ( 6.9996 x 2.9165 + 2.1264931 x 1.94
( 6.9996 + 2.1264931 )
= 2.690 m
LOADS
Dead Load
Super Structure = 2006.1 kN
Bed Block 8.00 x 1.200 x 0.45 x 24.00 = 103.68 kN
Self Weight of Pier Upto Bottom of Pier
Just Below the Bed block =( 9.051 + 0.000 ) x 0.01 x 23 = 2.082 kN
SIDL 804.00 kN
LIVE LOAD REACTION (SSLC) 1048.36 kN (with impact) 849.34 kN (w/o impact)
SSLC
TSLC
Force due to curvature of track 0x 25.58 = 0.00 kN
2
Additional reaction due to curvature of track 0 kN
= 3964.3 kN
= 4450.7 kN
At H F Level
Total vertical load in SSLC 2006.145 + 103.680 + 804.000 + 1048.358 + 0 + 373.132
= 4335.3 kN
= 4821.7 kN
= 5418 kN
= 5887 kN
MOMENTS IN SSLC
At top of pier
MYY
Moments due to eccentricity of live load reaction 1048.358 x 0.30 = 314.5
Moments due to longitudinal force 309.02 x ( 0+ 0.45 + 0.01 ) = 142.15
456.7 kN m
Mxx
Moments due to eccentricity Super structure reaction = 0 kN m
Moments due to eccentricity Live Load reaction = 1048.4 x 0.10 = 104.835846 kN m
Moment due to curvature of the track/ ohe 600.00 x 3.30 1980 kN m
= 2084.83585 kN m
At H F Level
MYY
Moments due to eccentricity of reaction 1048.358 x 0.300 = 314.5
Moments due to longitudinal force 309.015 x ( 0+ 0.45 + 1.634 ) = 643.98726
= 958.49 kN m
Mxx
Moments due to eccentricity Super structure reaction = 0 kN m
Moments due to eccentricity Live Load reaction = 1048.4 x 0.10 = 104.84 kN m
Moment due to curvature of the track = 600.0 x 3.30 = 1980.00 kN m
= 2084.84 kN m
At Bed level
MYY
MOMENTS IN TSLC
At top of pier
MYY
Moments due to eccentricity of live loadreaction 1534.766 x 0= 0.00
Moments due to longitudinal force 463.53 x( 0+ 0.46 ) = 213.22
Total moment 213.22 kN m
MXX
Moments due to eccentricity Super structure reaction = 0.00 kN m
Moments due to eccentricity Live Load reaction = 1534.8 x 0.10 = 153.48 kN m
Moment due to curvature of the track = 600.0 x 3.3 1980.00 kN m
= 2133.477 kN m
At H F Level
MYY
Moments due to eccentricity of LL reaction 1534.766 x 0= 0.00
Moments due to longitudinal force 463.53 x( 0+ 2.08 ) = 965.99
Total moment 965.99 kN m
MXX
MXX
1.63
HFL 8.08 1.40
4.20 4.20
8.529 1.929
to Bed level 2
At Bed level
Mxx
Due to Wind on Girder = 38.6322 x ( 0.961 + 6.283 )x 1.929 = 539.8 kN m
Sesimic Weights :-
δ = F Hp³ / 3EI
Ieff
= Effective Moment of inertial = 3.475371 M4 Long
75% of gross MI
Ieff
= Effective Moment of inertial = 64.90001 M4 Transverse
75% of gross MI
Longitudinal Direction :-
TRANSVERSE DIRECTION:-
50% Longitudinal Force is considered
Damping = 10%
TRANSVERSE DIRECTION
Hydrodynamic force :-
Fe = Ce x Ah x We
H /r Transverse = 4.353269
Ce Transverse = 0.73
Ce Longitudinal = 0.68
As the superstructure is very regid hence the time period is very less
hence Sa / g = = 2.5
Av = = 0.250
Since vertical sesimic acceleration coefficient is less than
0.50 no holding down device is required
LOAD COMBINATIONS :-
SEAT WIDTH :-
500+(2.5X19.80)+(10X7.033) 619.83 mm
Seismic Analysis
The location of the bridge falls in Seismic Zone III.
Seismic Zone = II
Design horizontal seismic coefficient, αh = Z/2 . I/R . Sa/g ( Cl 9.4.1 of IR Seismic code)
Z = Zone factor = 0.1 ( Table 1A of IR Seismic Code)
I = Importance factor = 1.5 ( Table 2 of IR Seismic Code)
R= Response reduction factor = 2 ( Table 3 of IR Seismic Code)
Sa/g = Average accelaration coefficient = 2.5 ( Fig 1 of IR Seismic Code)
αh (Longitudinal direction) = 0.1/ 2 x 1.5/2 x 2.5
= 0.09375 ###
ah = 0.09375
av = 0.5 x ah = 0.046875
We= weight of the water of the enveloping cylinder ( clause 10.3 of IR Seismic Code)
Diameter of the envoloping cylinder section at HFL = 8.08 m ( Refer Fig 3 under Cl 10.2 of IR Seismic code)
8.08
Radius at HFL R = = 4.041866 m
2
H 4.20
= = 1.01
R 4.15
W e = Õ R2 x H x 10
= 2275.4 kN
Lever arm , La = C4 H
H = = 4.199 m
4.199
C1 = = 1
4.199
Diameter of the envoloping cylinder section at HFL = 1.40 m ( Refer Fig 3 under Cl 10.2 of IR Seismic code)
W e = Õ R2 x H x 10
= 91.61 kN
C2 = 1 ; C3 = 1 ; C4 = 0.429
Moment = C3 F x La
La = C4 H
AT TOP OF PIER
Parallel to traffic
Design seismic force = weight of the component x αh
Moment @ Y - Y ,
Weight of the Design Seismic Lever Arm
S.No Description αh
component . kN Force m
kN-m
Total 369.15
L.Load ignored in case of parallel to traffic 1.12.6 B.R
Perpendicular traffic
Moment @ x - x ,
Weight of the Design Seismic Lever Arm
S.No Description αh
component . kN Force m
kN-m
1 Girder 2006.15 0.09 188.08 1.14 214.41
AT HFL
Parallel to traffic
Design seismic force = weight of the component x αh
Total 823.55
L.Load ignored in case of parallel to traffic 1.12.6 B.R
Perpendicular traffic
AT BED LEVEL
Parallel to traffic
Design seismic force = weight of the component x αh
428.28 2289.17
L.Load ignored in case of parallel to traffic 1.12.6 B.R
Perpendicular traffic
Weight of the Design Seismic Lever Arm Moment @ x - x ,
S.No Description αh
component . kN Force m kN-m
1 Girder 2006.15 0.09 188.08 6.573 1236.22
2 SIDL 804.00 0.09 75.375 7.534 567.88
3 Bed Block 103.68 0.09 9.72 5.758 55.97
AT TOP OF PIER
SSLC when the seismic force acting parallel to traffic
Dead load of girder = 2006.145 kN
SIDL = 804.00 kN
weight of Bed block = 103.68 kN
L.Load reaction = 1048.36 kN
Weight of pier = 2.08 kN
Less seismic force due to vertical accelaration = 0.00 kN
Total vertical load = 3964.27 kN
Moment about X - X axis
Due to water current = 0.00 kN m
Total = 0.00 kN m
Moment about Y - Y axis
Due to Longitudinal force = 142.147 kN m
Due to water current = 0.00 kN m
Due to Live Load = 314.51 kN m
Due to seismic force = 369.15 kN m
Due to hydrodynamic force = 0 kN m
Total = 825.81 kN m
Stresses ( S S L C) parallel to traffic = 3964.27 ± 0.0 ± 825.81
9.05 11.04 1.75
AT HFL
SSLC when the seismic force acting parallel to traffic
DL of girder = 2006.15 kN
SIDL = 804.00 kN
weight of Bed block = 103.68 kN
LL Reaction = 1534.77 kN
Weight of pier = 373.13 kN
Less seismic force in vertical direction = 0.00 kN
Total vertical load = 4821.7 kN
Moment about X - X axis
Due to water current = 0.00 kN m
Moment about Y - Y axis
Due to L.F = 213.22 kN m
Due to water current = 0.00 kN m
Due to seismic force = 823.55 tm
Due to hydrodynamic force = 0.00 kN m
Total = 1036.77 kN m
DL of girder = 2006.15 kN
SIDL = 804.00 kN
weight of Bed block = 103.68 kN
LL Reaction = 1534.77 kN
Weight of pier = 373.13 kN
Less seismic force in vertical direction = 0.00 kN
Total vertical load = 4821.7 kN
Moment about X - X axis
Due to water current = 0.00 kN m
Due to seismic force = (502.915 + 273.988 + 18.069 + 28.58 + 436.221 ) = 1259.77 kN m
Due to hydrodynamic force = 0 kN m
Total = 1259.77 kN m
Moment about Y - Y axis
Due to L.F = 965.99 kN m
Due to water current = 0.00 kN m
Total = 965.99 kN m
AT BED LEVEL
SSLC when the seismic force acting parallel to traffic
DL of girder = 2006.145 kN
SIDL = 804.00 kN
weight of Bed block = 103.68 kN
LL Reaction = 1534.77 kN
Weight of pier = 1654.46 kN
Less seismic force in vertical direction = 0.00 kN
Total vertical load = 6103.1 kN
Moment about X - X axis
Due to water current = 102.73 kN m
Moment about Y - Y axis
Due to L.F = 2912.33 kN m
Due to water current = 102.40 kN m
Due to seismic force = 2289.17 tm
Due to hydrodynamic force = 150.51 kN m
Total vertical load = 5454.40 kN m
DL of girder = 2006.15 kN
SIDL = 804.00 kN
weight of Bed block = 103.68 kN
LL Reaction = 1534.77 kN
Weight of pier = 1654.46 kN
Less seismic force in vertical direction = 0.00 kN
Total vertical load = 6103.1 kN
Moment about X - X axis
Due to water current = 102.73 kN m
Due to seismic force = (1236.224 + 567.875 + 55.968 + 429.101 + 716.724 ) = 3005.89 kN m
Due to hydrodynamic force = 11.28 kN m
Total = 3119.91 kN m
Moment about Y - Y axis
Due to L.F = 2912.33 kN m
Due to water current = 102.40 kN m
Total = 3014.73 kN m
Depth of section
from top of bed Section width Max pressure, Min pressure,
Vertical Load, kN Load case Remarks
block, m kN/m2 kN/m2
m
0.01 1.2 3964.27 908.90 -32.92 DL+ SIDL+ Wat + LL + Seismic // traffic Below Bed Block
0.01 1.2 3964.27 752.01 123.98 DL+ SIDL+ Wat + LL + Seismic ┴ traffic Below Bed Block
1.63 1.40 4335.32 929.52 -127.93 DL+ SIDL+ Wat + LL + Seismic // traffic @HFL
1.634 1.40 4335.32 880.22 -78.63 DL+ SIDL+ Wat + LL + Seismic ┴ traffic @HFL
5.83 1.93 5616.65 1350.17 -632.62 DL+ SIDL+ Wat + LL + Seismic // traffic @ BED LEVEL
5.83 1.93 5616.65 979.83 -262.29 DL+ SIDL+ Wat + LL + Seismic ┴ traffic @ BED LEVEL
TSLC
0.01 1.20 4450.67 823.83 159.64 DL+ SIDL+ Wat + LL + Seismic // traffic Below Bed Block
0.01 1.20 4450.67 676.29 307.18 DL+ SIDL+ Wat + LL + Seismic ┴ traffic Below Bed Block
1.634 1.40 4821.72 873.95 17.58 DL+ SIDL+ Wat + LL + Seismic // traffic @HFL
1.634 1.40 4821.72 938.58 -47.05 DL+ SIDL+ Wat + LL + Seismic ┴ traffic @HFL
5.833 1.93 6103.06 1530.28 -750.59 DL+ SIDL+ Wat + LL + Seismic // traffic @ BED LEVEL
5.833 1.93 6103.06 1171.14 -391.45 DL+ SIDL+ Wat + LL + Seismic ┴ traffic @ BED LEVEL
Horizontal load
along the traffic = 1.60 x428.277 = 685.24 kN
Perpendicular traffic = 0 kN
Horizontal load
along the traffic = 0 kN
Horizontal load
along the traffic = 1.60 x428.277 = 685.24 kN
Perpendicular traffic = 0 kN
Horizontal load
along the traffic = 0 kN
Load Combination 2. (1.25 DL + 2.0 X SIDL + 1.4x(LL+LF)+ 1.25EQ + 1.0 HY +1.0 X BO)
SSLC ( Seismic force parallel to traffic)
Horizontal l load
Along the traffic = 1.4 x 309.015+ 1.25x 428.277 + 1.0 x (182.897+83.631) = 1341.11 kN
Moment about the axis perpendicularl to traffi 1.40 x (1941.541 + 254.802) + 1.25x(2289.168)+1.0 x (102.398+150.509 = 6189.247 kN m
Horizontal l load
Along the traffic = 1.4 x 309.015+ 1.0 x182.897 = 615.518 kN
Moment about the axis parallel to traf= 1.25 x 2778.743+ 1.0 x(102.731+11.283) = 3587.44 kN m
Moment about the axis perpendicularl to traffic = 1.4 x (1941.541+ 254.802 )+ 1.0 x 102.398 = 3177.278 kN m
Vertical load = 1.25x( 2006.145+103.68+1654.464)+2.0 x804+ 1.4 x 1534.77) - 1.0 x81.783 = 8380.3 kN
Horizontal l load
Along the traffic = 1.4 x 463.525+ 1.25x 428.277 + 1.0 x (182.897+83.631) = 1450.81 kN
Horizontal l load
Along the traffic = 1.4 x 463.525+ 1.0 x182.897 = 831.8319 kN
Moment about the axis parallel to traf= 1.25 x 2778.743+ 1.0 x(102.731+11.283) = 3871.38 kN
Moment about the axis perpendicularl to traffic = 1.4 x2912.328+ 1.0 x 102.398 = 4179.656 kN m
DESIGN OF SUB STRUCTURE
Depth of pile = 16 m
No of piles = 6 No
3.6 3.6
3 4.5
1.2 m dia
8.7
DL + SIDL + LL
DL+SIDL+LL+WATER+WIND
DL + SIDL + LL
= 1478.29 kN Max
= 703.422 kN Min
= 1559.71 kN Max
= 622 kN Min
= 1640.53 kN Max
= 697.535 kN Min
= 1747.37 kN Max
= 590.696 kN Min
SEISMIC CONDITION
SINGLE SPAN LOADED CONDITION
= 1657.65 kN Max
= 590.403 kN Min
= 1580.33 kN Max
= 667.726 kN Min
= 1818.27 kN Max
= 591.917 kN Min
= 1756.73 kN Max
= 653.466 kN Min
2
Self weight of the pile = ∏ x 1.2 x 16 x 25 = 434.294 kN
4
Max Load at toe of the pile = 1747.37 + 434.2938 = 2181.66 kN
Summary of loads on piles
Seismic case
Single Span Loaded condtion
Seismic force acting parallel to traffic 1657.65 590.403
Seismic force acting perpendicular to traffic 1580.330 667.726
The maximum working load on pile is 1687 kN ( 172 t) . The safe load carrying capacity of the pile
calculated from the soil parameters given in the soil investigation report is 281 t.
However the safe load carrying capacity of the pile shall be ascertained from the load test as per IS 2911 Part IV.
STRUCTURAL DESIGN OF PILE
Depth of pile = 15 m
No of piles = 6 No
3.6 3.6
1.2 m dia
3 4.5
8.7
VERTICAL LOADS & MOMENTS AT TOP OF PILE CAP ( Limit state of collapse)
( The partial safety factors are taken from Table 12 of Concrete Bridge Code)
DL + SIDL + LL
Load Combination 2. (1.25 DL + 2.0 X SIDL + 1.4x(LL+LF)+ 1.25EQ + 1.00 HY +1.0X BO)
= 2698.66 kN Max
= 488.50 kN Min
= 2514.95 kN Max
= 573.12 kN Min
= 3121.79 kN Max
= 338.97 kN Min
= 3061.54 kN Max
= 245.41 kN Min
Load Combination 1
= 1694.09 kN Max
= 880.16 kN Min
= 1595.88 kN Max
= 978.38 kN Min
= 1627.090158 kN Max
= 813.16 kN Min
= 1600.24 kN Max
= 974.01 kN Min
Load Combination 2
= 2212.94 kN Max
= 823.29 kN Min
= 2147.53 kN Max
= 943.22 kN Min
= 1984.78 kN Max
= 1278.43 kN Min
= 2397.57 kN Max
= 931.07 kN Min
2
Self weight of the pile = ∏ x 1.2 x 0 x 25 = 407.15 kN
4
Max Load on the pile = 3121.8 + 407.1504 = 3528.94 kN
= 773.17 kN
= 216.49 kN
= 685.51 kN
2 2
MAX HORIZONTAL FORCE PER PILE = 216.49 + 685.51 = 119.81 kN
6
= 27386.13 N/mm2
T = 2843.327 mm = 2.84 m
L1 / T = 1.519
DESIGN OF PILE
Moment , M = 547.13 kN - m
= 202.5865 kN m
Provide steel reinforcemet equal to 0.80% of the cross sectional area of the column
= 9047.79 mm2
p / fck = 0.027
= 2332.8 kN m
(Mu / Muxy)αn = 0.3476 < 1 O.K
2 2
MAX HORIZONTAL FORCE PER PILE , Q = 0.00 + 685.24 = 114.21
6 kN
Load Combination (1.25 DL + 2.0 X SIDL + 1.4x(LL+LF)+ 1.25EQ + 1.0 HY +1.0X BO)
2 2
MAX HORIZONTAL FORCE PER PILE, Q = 831.83 + 745.60 = 186.18
6 kN
= 27386.128 N/mm2
T = (E I/ƞh)1/5 =
T = 3542.0208 mm = 3.542 m
L1 / T = 1.219
Load Combination 1
Moment in the pile = 0.9 x 114.21 x 12.11 = 622.45
{m x Q ( L1 + Lf)/2} 2 kN - m
Load Combination 2
Moment in the pile = 0.9 x 186.18 x 12.11 = ###
2 kN - m
Combination 1
Seismic force parallel to traffic : Max Vertical load on the pile , P 1694 kN
Moment , M = 622.4 kN - m
Seismic force perpendicular to traffic Max Vertical load on the pile , P 1600 kN
Moment , M = 622.4 kN - m
Combination 2
Seismic force parallel to traffic : Max Vertical load on the pile , P 2213 kN
Moment , M = 1014.7 kN - m
Seismic force perpendicular to traffic Max Vertical load on the pile , P 2398 kN
Moment , M = 1014.7 kN - m
Load Combination 1
= 173.56861 kN m
Provide steel reinforcemet equal to 1.00% of the cross sectional area of the column
= 11309.73 mm2
= 19154.6494481 kN
p / fck = 1 / 30 = 0.033
= 2073.6 kN m
Load Combination 2
= 245.64427 kN m
Provide steel reinforcemet equal to 1.00% of the cross sectional area of the column
= 11309.73 mm2
= 19154.6494481 kN
p / fck = 1 / 30 = 0.033
= 2332.8 kN m
= 526.78 mm
Assuming z = 0.94 xd
= 1330.1 mm
Actual z = (1-(1.1fyAst/fck*bd))d =
1357.433 mm OK
= 2158 mm2
SHEAR FORCE
Vc = 0.406 N / mm2
Vc x S = 0.308 < V
750 750
750 1307.5
Since the bed block is fully resting on the pier, there is no bending in the bed block.
Angle of internal friction at toe of pile, Ø = 35 deg (from soil investigation report)
Bore hole 2
Depth of pile = 14 m
Nc = 0
Ru = 7406.80 kN
qs1 = 0 kN
Ks = 1.5
Pi = 26.55 kN/m2
δ = 0
α = 0.4
C = 30 kN/m2
qs1 = 203.575 kN
Ks = 1.5
Pi = 30 kN/m2
δ = 32
α = 0.3
C = 0 kN/m2
qs1 = 28.119 kN
Ks = 1.5
Pi = 25.2 kN/m2
δ = 0
α = 0.3
C = 79.5 kN/m2 (avg value)
qs1 = 359.650 kN
Ks = 1.5
Pi 55.44 kN/m2
δ = 33
α = 0.3
C = 0 kN/m2
qs1 = 54.005 kN
Ks = 1.5
Pi = 22.05 kN/m2
δ = 10
α = 0.3
C = 110 kN/m2
qs1 = 441.257 kN
Ks = 1.5
Pi = 28.35 kN/m2
δ = 33
α = 0.3
C = 12 kN/m2
qs1 = 88.69 kN
Ks = 1.5
Pi = 78.75 kN/m2
δ = 34
α = 0.3
C = 0 kN/m2
qs1 = 79.68 kN
= 7406.798790531 + 1254.97
= 8661.769072065 kN
Factor of safety = 3
= 2887.26 kN 294.3177 t
INDEX
CONTENTS PAGE NO.
1 Introduction 1 to5
2 Stresses in Pier section ( Normal & wind loads) 6 to 13