10 Diapers Report PDF
10 Diapers Report PDF
10 Diapers Report PDF
net/publication/336315903
CITATIONS READS
0 55
5 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Anurag Roy on 07 October 2019.
Abstract
The diaper industry caters to a huge customer base comprising babies, the elderly as well as adults with certain medical conditions. Driven
by ease of use, a majority of diapers manufactured nowadays are of the disposable kind. Now, despite the overall convenience to
customers, one major drawback of these one-time use disposable diapers is that all of them invariably end up in landfills. It is noteworthy
to mention here that each of them has an estimated decomposition time of about half of a millennium owing to the presence of synthetic
components. A disposable diaper typically contains a number of polymers such as polyethylene, polypropylene, polyesters and
polyacrylates. Of these constituents, the most recent addition to the disposable diaper is the superabsorbent polymer (SAP) sodium
polyacrylate, which is non-biodegradable and which is the primary agent for water absorption and retention located in the core of the
commodity product. Having thoroughly reviewed the composition, manufacturing, functionalities, and environmental impact of disposable
diapers, the primary objective of this report is to propose a biodegradable substitute for sodium polyacrylate which could serve as a SAP. In
light of this, two materials that have shown promise are Poly(γ-glutamic) Acid (PGA) crosslinked by L-lysine and Gellan gum with
Jeffamine 130. The report also quantitatively asserts why the proposed material is better than the current one based on parameters such as
% biodegradability, water absorptivity, and retention time while discussing the associated development and challenges.
1. Introduction water per gram of cellulose fluff pulp, SAP can absorb up to
1000 g of water per gram of the polymer [3]. Sodium
The global industry of baby and adult diaper was valued at polyacrylate SAPs, are manufactured by mixing polyacrylic
US$65 Billion in 2018 [1], with the majority of the market acid (containing a carboxyl group) with a neutralizing agent
attributed to disposable diapers due to their convenience and such as sodium hydroxide in presence of a UV photo initiator
comfort. The average baby will consume about 4,000 and a crosslinker. Once in solution stage, the hydrogen in the
disposable (single-use) diapers in his/her lifetime [2], making carboxyl group detaches and sodium ions replace it instead,
these consumer products one of the most prevalent in landfills. thereby neutralizing the negatively charged carboxyl in the
The basic construction of disposable diapers consists of an process. This is generally followed by irradiation with intense
absorbent pad, or “core,” sandwiched between two layers of UV light, thus creating sodium polyacrylate. Under the
non-woven fabric that guide moisture towards the hydrophilic influence of multi-functional cross-linking agents, it is
core of the diaper while keeping the skin of the baby ultimately converted into a gel through radical addition
comfortable. Once the moisture reaches the core it comes in polymerization. The gel is thereafter dried, crumbled, and
contact with a sodium polyacrylate powder, a semi-crystalline ground into a fine powder using ball milling and finally
superabsorbent polymer (SAP). As their name suggests, SAPs screened out to obtain specific particle sizes. The SAP powder
are characterized by their unique and remarkable ability to is commonly used in dry granular powder form as described in
absorb 100 - 1000 times their mass in deionized water [3]. the following sections.
Also, disposable diapers have comfort features, including an The diaper’s absorbent pad is a matrix made up of two
elastic band to prevent leakages and adhesive tape to keep the essential parts. Manufacturers have optimized the two
diaper in place at the hips. constituents to suit the purpose of maximum water retention.
The earliest disposable diapers were made with primarily The two constituents are as follows:
biodegradable components, a thick layer of absorbent cellulose a) A fine (hydrophilic) polymer powder i.e. sodium
and thin synthetic comfort layer. With the advent of SAPs, polyacrylate which behaves like a tiny sponge exhibiting large
modern diapers are typically composed of 43% fluff pulp, 27% water retention capacity. At the microscopic level, the polymer
SAP material, and 30% of other materials making up the non- molecules are long (rope-like) chains with many functional
woven sheets [4]. These components give the diaper a thin and side groups, some of which interact with the water molecules
flexible overall construction at the cost of reduced while others chemically cross-link with other polymer
biodegradability due to the high percentage of non- molecules. This cross-linking process aids in ensuring a gel
biodegradable SAP. In this report, we investigate alternative network formation that absorbs enormous quantities of water
absorbent polymers that could reduce the environmental instead of dissolving in it.
impact of diapers by enhancing the biodegradability of the b) A fibrous material, for example, wood pulp. These
synthetic components in diapers. We introduce several fibers play the role of tiny straws which draw water from the
performance metrics to quantitatively compare the potential inner portion of the diaper and distribute it throughout the
alternatives: liquid absorbance or swelling, moisture retention absorbent layer matrix, essentially avoiding a phenomenon
time, and degree of biodegradability. called gel blocking. Gel blocking occurs when the outermost
layer of the pad absorbs water very rapidly, forming a gel
2. Manufacturing of Diapers which prevents further water content from permeating the bulk
of the intermediate absorbent layer, severely debilitating the
Formerly made from only cellulose fluff pulp, modern- overall functioning of the diaper.
day diaper manufacturers prefer to add SAP powder in the Looking into the construction, the absorbent pad is
absorbent layers which are clean, dry and granular in texture. sandwiched between two sheets of nonwoven fabric, which
This powder, upon exposure to water, forms a slurry and provide a steady shape, conformity and prevent leakage from
gradually absorbs the water transforming into a soft rubbery the sides. The top sheet (polypropylene) is permeable so as to
gel. When compared to the absorptivity of dry fiber, 12g of absorb and transmit the body fluids to the adjacent absorbent
1
pad, while the bottom sheet (polyethylene) is impermeable to give strength to prevent gel blocking and reducing the number
ensure leakage prevention from the other side of the diaper. or strength of crosslinks that must be broken in the
The pad’s layered construction is conducive to a roll-based biodegradation process.
conveyor belt assembly that occurs inside a long forming
chamber. The chamber has various pressurized nozzles at the Biodegradability
top through which either fibrous material or polymer powder In this report, the level of biodegradability of a
can be dispersed onto the underlying conveyor belt. A vacuum polymer is compared using biochemical oxygen demand
underneath the belt flattens the sprayed fibers. It is only after (BOD) analysis. In a basic test, the BOD percentage is the
the bottom fibrous layer of the pad is formed that the nozzles difference in the amount of microbial oxygen consumption
begin spraying a mixture of fibers and SAP powder. The final between a control sample and the subject sample which
layer, also primarily composed of fibers, is levelled by a roller contains the polymer to be degraded, as in Eq. 2 below.
which also removes excess fiber and ensures necessary
thickness uniformity. As a result of this multi-layered 𝐵𝑂𝐷
deposition, the SAP component is positioned centrally between 𝑚0 20345#67803 9: 459;<27 − 𝑚01 20345#67803 9: 2037>0?
the fibrous layers preventing the possibility of gel blocking. = 1
𝑚60?:#<> 45947@32<
Once the three components (absorbent pad, top and (2)
bottom sheets of nonwoven fabric) have been formed
individually, they are assembled together by passing the
The percentage biodegradability or biodegradation is
absorbent pad through a conveyor belt with the pre-applied determined by correcting the BOD for the theoretical oxygen
bottom sheet. The top sheet is placed onto the stack and the
uptake (ThOD) of the medium calculated by theoretical
assembly is connected together by a series of gluing, heating
models. The percentage biodegradability is expressed as in Eq.
and ultrasonic merging steps. The completed long layered rolls
3 [6].
are lastly cut into single unit disposable diapers, packed, and
shipped. MNO
%𝐵𝑖𝑜𝑑𝑒𝑔𝑟𝑎𝑑𝑎𝑏𝑖𝑙𝑖𝑡𝑦 = PQNO (3)
2
compounds increased by 23% for the same reason. Overall,
there has been a reduction in water usage and air emissions due
to the introduction of SAP since 1987, improving not only the
performance of the diaper but the environmental impact on
most of the indicators measured [4]. The fact is that innovation
in materials, recycling, biodegradability and packaging is key Figure 3. Predicted structure of gellan gum-Jeffamine hydrogel
to further reducing environmental impact. after crosslinking, represented by gellan gum (blue), Jeffamine
Recyclability of diapers is possible but its cost and lack of (red), and zero-length EDC/NHS crosslinking points (yellow) [9].
market for reuse of the product makes it almost prohibitive.
Although progress has been made to recycle and upcycle The study found that liquid absorbance of the
soiled diapers if we can create materials that can degrade in hydrogel was affected both by the acyl forms of gellan gum
bacteria-rich soil we create a solution for processing waste and employed and the quantities of EDC/NHS crosslinker. Test
preventing landfill waste accumulation and incineration. samples with the highest liquid absorbance were prepared with
high-acyl gellan gum (GGHA) and lower quantities of
5. Proposed materials EDC/NHS. In other words, these test samples have less
crosslinking, which results in adequate water absorbance of
Option 1: Gellan gum and Jeffamine 130 + EDC/NHS 145 g/g. Furthermore, the samples demonstrated excellent
An international collaboration at the University of water-retention ability, capable of a 450-minute water retention
Michigan provided an alternative hydrogel for sodium period. Also, its inherent properties make this replacement
polyacrylate [9]. Researchers obtained a biodegradable SAP by hydrogel suitable for arid climate or long-term storage before
crosslinking gellan gum and Jeffamine 130 (O,O’ -bis(2- use. The authors claim that the polymer is biodegradable after
aminopropyl)-polyethylene glycol) with [1-ethyl-3-(3- its intended use of controlled water or chemical release in
dimethylaminopropyl) carbodiimide hydrochloride] (EDC) and agricultural applications but do not provide experimental
N-hydroxysuccinamide (NHS). Gellan gum can be obtained in evidence to support the claim. In a separate study, the
a high acyl or low acyl form, as shown in Figure 1. When biodegradability of gellan gum was shown to be highly
hydrated, high acyl gellan gum, its natural form, forms a soft dependent on the acyl percentage. High acyl percentages have
elastic hydrogel while the deacylated low acyl gum forms a a greater number of large acyl side groups which can partially
stiffer more robust hydrogel. The chemical structure of the inhibit the gelling process resulting in a weaker gel that can be
primary crosslinker Jeffamine is shown in Figure 2. EDC/NHS degraded more rapidly, when compared with the stiffer low
acts as a zero-length secondary crosslinker which joins the acyl form [10]. Another study showed a biodegradability
amine groups of Jeffamine with the carboxyl groups of the dependence on the EDC/NHS content of a collagen-based
gellan gum forming an amine bond. The predicted structure of material. Low EDC/NHS crosslinker concentration degraded at
gellan gum-Jeffamine is shown in Figure 3 [9]. The advantage a faster rate than high concentration. These studies suggest that
of EDC/NHS combination is that urea is the only by-product of the high absorptivity gellan gum-Jeffamine polymer may be
the reaction, and it is water soluble and non-toxic. Thus, the biodegradable if high acyl gellan gum is used and the
manufacturing process of the hydrogel produces minimal EDC/NHS content is carefully chosen to balance the stiffness
cytotoxic waste which is an important consideration when and absorptivity of the polymer with the biodegradability.
choosing an alternative to sodium polyacrylate [10].
Option 2: Poly(γ-glutamic) Acid
Perhaps a more promising alternative is a poly(γ-
glutamic) acid (PGA) based hydrogel synthetized from a
microbial source. The polymer structure of PGA is shown in
Figure 4. PGA is a ubiquitous amino acid used in the synthesis
of proteins, which facilitates in the industrial production using
a mutant Brevibacterium flavum, yielding roughly 40 g/L in 2
days [11]. Naturally, PGA occurs in organisms by the
condensation of glutamate and ammonia, as shown in Figure 5,
an essential role in the metabolism of nitrogen. In humans,
PGA facilitates natural processes in the intestines, regulates
acid-base balance in the kidneys, activates immune cells, and
feeds cancerous cells. Studies such as [12] by Kunioka show
that PGA hydrogels are efficient agents for the purification of
turbid water.
PGA is water-soluble and biodegradable linear
Figure 1. Chemical structure of high acyl and low acyl gellan molecule with a high molecular weight between 100,000 to
gum. 1,000,000 g/mol. The synthesis of cross linking PGA was
published in 2011 by Murakami et al., a collaboration between
Japanese researchers at the Kagawa Industrial Technology
Center and Keio University [13]. Murakami et al. noted that
the crosslinking agents that are commercially available are
derivatives of petroleum, substances that do not lend
Figure 2. Chemical structure of Jeffamine. themselves to “green” chemistry. Additionally, PGA is
3
typically self-crosslinked by special γ-irradiation equipment. A at 25°C and the findings are summarized in Table 1Similar to
green solution that forgoes γ-irradiation is crosslinking by L- the gellan gum-Jeffamine hydrogel, we note that the
lysine, a bio-based amino acid for arresting the spread of absorbance and biodegradability of the PGA with L-lysine gel
herpes. depends heavily on the degree of crosslinking, so optimization
of the polymer’s components would be necessary before
application in the diaper industry
Table 1. Comparison of properties between the current polymer (Sodium polyacrylate) and two “green” alternatives (Gellan gum with
Jeffamine, PGA with L-lysine).
4
7. Conclusion
5
"Evolution of disposable baby diapers in Europe: life cycle
assessment of environmental impacts and identification of
key areas of improvement," Journal of Cleaner
Production, vol. 95, pp. 322-331, 2015.
[8] EDANA (European Disposables and Nonwovens
Association), "Sustainability Report," EDANA, Brussels,
2019.
[9] R. C. Sabadini, M. M. Silva, A. Pawlicka and J. Kanicki,
"Gellan gum–O,O′-bis(2-aminopropyl)-polyethylene
glycol hydrogel for controlled fertilizer release," Journal of
Applied Polymer Science, vol. 135, no. 2, p. 45636, 2018.
[10] S. Fisher, H. Lee, M. S. Kallos and C. J. Hunter,
"Degradation and Mechanical Properties of Gellan Gum
for Musculoskeletal Tissue Engineering," in 57th Annual
Meeting of the Orthopaedic Research Society, Long Beach,
2011.
[11] K. Drauz, I. Grayson, A. Kleenmann, H.-P. Krimmer, W.
Leuchtenberger and C. Weckbecker, "Amino Acids,"
Ullmann's Encyclopedia of Industrial Chemistry, 2007.
[12] M. Kunioka, "Biodegradable water absorbent synthesized
from bacterial poly (amino acid)s," Macromolecular
bioscience, vol. 43, no. 3, pp. 324-329, 2004.
[13] S. Murakami, N. Aoki and S. Matsumura, " Bio-based
biodegradable hydrogels prepared by crosslinking of
microbial poly (γ-glutamic acid) with L-lysine in aqueous
solution," Polymer journal, vol. 43, no. 4, p. 414, 2011.
[14] K. Kosemund, H. Schlatter, J. L. Ochsenhirt, E. L. Krause,
D. S. Marsman and G. N. Erasala, "Safety evaluation of
superabsorbent baby diapers," Regulatory toxicology and
pharmacology, vol. 53, no. 2, pp. 81-89, 2009.
[15] Government of South Australia, "SA Health," SA Health,
2012. [Online]. Available:
https://www.sahealth.sa.gov.au/wps/wcm/connect/public+c
ontent/sa+health+internet/health+topics/health+conditions
+prevention+and+treatment/infectious+diseases/toxic+sho
ck+syndrome/toxic+shock+syndrome+tss+-
+including+symptoms+treatment+and+prevention.
[Accessed September 2019].
[16] K. P. Kathirvel and T. Ramachandran, "Development of
Antimicrobial Feminine Hygiene Products Using Bamboo
and Aloevera Fibers," Journal of natural fibers, vol. 11,
no. 3, pp. 242-255, 2014.
[17] M. Liu and G. Tianhua, "Preparation and swelling
properties of crosslinked sodium polyacrylate," Journal of
Applied Polymer Science, vol. 82, no. 6, pp. 1515-1520,
2001.
[18] EDANA (European Disposables and Nonwovens
Association), "Guidelines for the Testing of Baby
Diapers," EDANA, Brussels, 2016.
6
View publication stats