Bkal 3063 Integrated Case Study 3
Bkal 3063 Integrated Case Study 3
Bkal 3063 Integrated Case Study 3
(GROUP D)
PREPARED BY:
NO NAME MATRIC NUMBER
1. AISYAH ARIANNA BINTI ABDUL AZIZ 248345
2. MUHAMMAD ADHZIM BIN ZULKEFLE 248392
3. SHAMSUL ARIF BIN ZULKIFLEE 248454
4. SHAHMIRA NAJWA BINTI NORDIN 248455
5. DURSHANTHINI A/P MANIVAIL 251111
PREPARED FOR:
DR. NORAZA BT MAT UDIN
SUBMISSION DATE:
14 OCTOBER 2019
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1
1.0 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
GEZ Bhd is a Malaysia's largest oil company that has run two major businesses
which are the fuel business and convenience store business. As part of the fuel business, the
petrol stations sold Petrol Ron 95 (R95), Petrol Ron 97 (R97) and Diesel with sales of 200
million liters of petrol and 150 million liters of diesel every month. Meanwhile, the
convenience stores, the Selesa Mart, sold food, snacks, beverages, cigarettes and
confectionery. Mr. Aiman is in charge and responsible for managing the sales activities of
over twenty petrol stations in the northern region of Malaysia as an Area Manager.
Referring to the case of GEZ Petrol Station, it is clearly shown that problems has
started to arise when they are having a difficulty to sustain in the business even though they are
in the stable business segment and consistent in the long run. Mr. Aiman claimed that the
knowledge of cost accounting should be accessible to dealers and their related workers because
To overcome these issues, GEZ Bhd should send the employees to attend training for
finance and costing to enhance their knowledge and expertise. Besides, GEZ Bhd should
reduce the credit card usage and they also need to consult with specialist oil and gas regarding
2
2.0 STATEMENT OF THE PROBLEM
2.1 GEZ PETROL STATION’S DIFFICULTY IN SUSTAINABILITY
THE BUSINESS
GEZ Bhd, a major oil company in Malaysia, in 2010, Mr Aiman was responsible for
directing the sales activities of more than twenty petrol stations in the northern
region of Malaysia (Ku Ismail & Wan Hussin, 2015). While being a stable business
with a steady increase in vehicles petrol station operators still encountered the
difficulty of maintaining the business leading to the end of the dealership license.
This issue will give negative impact toward GEZ Bhd to sustain in business. GEZ
The termination of the dealership license will make GEZ Bhd difficult to sustain in
business. Termination of dealership license will give negative impact toward GEZ
Bhd in future. The important reasons why GEZ Bhd need to overcome this issue is
to stay sustain in business. GEZ petrol station conducted two main businesses the
fuel business and the convenience store business, known as Selesa Mart. Under the
fuel business, the petrol stations sold Petrol Ron 95 (R95), Petrol Ron 97 (R97), and
Diesel, with sales of 200 million litres of petrol and 150 million litres of diesel
monthly. The stores sold, among others, groceries, snacks, drinks, confectionery,
GEZ Bhd should have knowledge regarding finance and costing because it is very
merely being knowledgeable on financial matters to the ability to make use of such
literacy on day to day financial decisions (Yong, Yew, & Wee, 2018). The
knowledge related to financial can make GEZ Bhd able to make use of such literacy
3
on day to day financial decisions. After GEZ Bhd understand the knowledge to
manage finance, GEZ Bhd able to use knowledge to manage company financial.
GEZ Bhd had a very low profit margin in the fuel business. It was important that
operators managed their cash collection very well. In 2010, the cost of fuel was
about 94% of the sale price (Ku Ismail & Wan Hussin, 2015). The causes of low
profit margin are product loss due to evaporation of fuel during filling and the
increasing cost of credit card fees paid to banks. Gross profit is what is left after the
cost of goods sold have been subtracted from net sales. Cost of goods sold, also
called “cost of sales,” is the price paid by your company for the products it sold
during the period you are considering. It is the price of the goods, including
inventory or raw materials and labour used in production, but it does not include
the earning power of your company from its current operations. If the operating
income of your business is not enough to produce the money you need to continue to
operate, you need to find other sources of revenue. Profit margin is important in
business to know the future profit that company will receive (Chen & Segal, 2019).
Profit margin is one of the profitability measures that is widely used to calculate the
percentage of sales that has become earnings. Simply put, the percentage figure
shows how many cents of gain for each dollar of revenue the company has made.
4
3.0 CAUSES OF THE PROBLEM
3.1 LACK OF KNOWLEDGE IN FINANCE AND COSTING
GEZ Bhd faces difficulty in sustaining the business due to the lack of knowledge in
finance and costing (ISMAIL). It is important for every business to understand the
use knowledge and skills to manage one's financial resources effectively for lifetime
unable to optimize business welfare, especially when the stakes are high or to exert
the type of competitive pressure necessary for market efficiency. Above all, cost
accounting is one of the domain things that internal management should understand
in every business. According to Mr.Aiman, the dealers and staffs do not have
total cost of production by assessing the variable costs of each step of production as
well as fixed costs, such as a lease expense (TUOVILA, 2019). It is used internally
accounting is not required to adhere to set standards and can be flexible to meet the
needs of management. Cost accounting considers all input costs associated with
To GEZ Bhd’s knowledge, there are many types of costs involved in cost accounting
but the relevant cost to the business is fixed cost and variable cost. Fixed costs are
5
costs that do not vary depending on the level of production. An increase or decrease
in production levels would cause no change in these costs. For example, the fixed
cost involved in GEZ Bhd is petrol station rental, equipment fee and salary of staffs.
Variable costs are costs tied to a company's level of production. For example,
helps in identifying the effect of sales volume and product cost on the operating
profit of a business. Cost Volume Profit analysis is also known as Break Even
Analysis. The aim of GEZ Bhd is to earn profit and profit depends upon a large
number of factors, most notable among them are the volume of fuel sales. The
volume of fuel sales is dependent upon production volume which in turn is related to
costs which are affected by volume of production and internal efficiency of the
business. CVP analysis helps management in finding out the relationship between
cost and revenue to generate profit. CVP analysis also helps in determining the level
at which all relevant cost is recovered and there is no profit or loss which is also
called the breakeven point. The application of this analysis did not learned by the
6
3.2 PRODUCT LOSS DUE TO EVAPORATION OF FUEL DURING
FILLING
The fuel business had a very low profit margin mainly due to the product loss from
the evaporation of fuel during filling. The tolerable product loss was 0.3% for diesel
and 0.5% for petrol for GEZ Bhd. Profit margin is one of the commonly
activity makes money. It represents what percentage of sales has turned into profits.
When there is product loss, the sales volume will decrease therefore it will reflect in
cardholders who carry balances month to month on their accounts will be charged
interest. A business’s profit margin provides an indication of the overall health and
activities not related to the core operations of a business. Taxes and interest are the
most common types of such expenses. In this case, GEZ Bhd faces increase in cost
of credit card fees paid to banks. These expenses are deducted from operating profit
to yield net profit or net income. Non-operating expenses directly reduce whatever
profit is left after deducting operating expenses. Due to increase in cost of credit
7
4.0 FINANCIAL STATEMENT AND COST-VOLUME-PROFIT
ANALYSIS
Stationeries 2,400
Total Fixed Costs 170,811 4,324 41,081 216,216 91,668 312,204
OPERATING
664,403 12,518 58,263 735,183 117,154 848,018
PROFIT
8
4.3 COST-VOLUME-PROFIT ANALYSIS (GRAPH)
R95
20,000,000
15,000,000
RM
10,000,000
5,000,000
-
0 2,000,000 4,000,000 6,000,000 8,000,000 10,000,000
Unit
R97
500,000
400,000
300,000
RM
200,000
100,000
0
0 40,000 80,000 120,000 160,000 200,000
Unit
Diesel
5,000,000
4,000,000
3,000,000
RM
2,000,000
1,000,000
0
0 500,000 1,000,000 1,500,000 2,000,000 2,500,000
Litre
9
5.0 DECISION CRITERIA AND ALTERNATIVE SOLUTIONS
Decision criteria in a business setting are variables or characteristics that are important to
the organization in the making of decision (Cox, 2015). The decision criteria are a formal
approach in helping to explore decision, by helping decision makers organize and unite
such information in a way which leads to confident about making a decision (Valerie
stability. Lacks in financial knowledge may lead to making a poor financial decision
has poor accounting practices, she or he might enter the wrong transactions thus
turn, will increase their confidence in making the decision. For example, if they're
unable to differentiate the variable expenses and fixed expenses might slow the
Besides that, untrained employees are likely to be less productive because they are
unable to perform the job thus will lead to miss the important deadlines or slow
job completion. For example, the budget company must be prepared before the
fiscal year begins, if the annual budgets are prepared after the fiscal year begins or
during the fiscal year, it difficult to plan for the future project growth.
10
The advantage of sending employees for attending an accounting course will
increase the efficiencies in processes which will result in financial gain for the
company. The disadvantages are the cost of the process because sending it to a
conference is in another location, this also will be a substantial cost for the
company.
Accounts are the most important for a company to oversee whether the company
handle the transactions for day-to-day operations, besides that accounting firm
also will give financial advice for the company because accounting firm is run by
First and foremost, hiring an accounting firm will save a lot of time and reduce the
work burden, since GEZ conducted two main business which is the fuel business
and the convenience store, which involved with a lot of transaction and to prepare
the financial statement might take a lot of things thus this will increase the burden
to employee in order to prepare the annual financial reporting. Besides that, with
lot of transactions GEZ might not aware with the rules and regulation that is
important, an accounting firm will ensure that company activities and transaction
The pros of hiring an accounting firm are they will manage everything for
company accounts, they will keep things on track and maintain the punctuality of
financial reporting. While the cons of hiring an accounting firm will be costly for
11
the company to pay its services because the accountant rates are vary based on
what is involved.
Low profit margin means products sell are very close to the price that it costs the
company. However, to generate high profit margin are not ideal for all industries,
some industries might generate low profit margin such as oil and gas, software
publishers, beverage manufacturing and others (Biery, 2017) Sine GEZ operate
petrol station, it’s hard to increase the profit margin. But are several ways that GEZ
This era of technological advancement, a consumer who usually pays using cash
will swiftly move towards a new era of the cashless payment methods. Bank
transfers, debit cards, credit cards, e-wallets are the top payment methods and it is
essential for a business to offer a range of payment methods for their customer. In
order to fulfill customer needs, GEZ also provides other alternative payment
A consumer the using of credit card more convenience and it takes only a few
seconds to slot in the card into the machine without the need to go to the counter
to pay the bills. But in business, the disadvantage of accepting credit card payment
from the customer may be costly because GEZ will have to bear the services
GEX can set a minimum purchase requirement, for example, customer should
spend at least RM50 for each fuel fill. By setting a minimum spending
requirement, it will help to boost the company’s sale. For example, for the
12
customer who usually refuels RM30 using the credit card, will have to fill up the
petrol up to RM50 in order to use the credit card. However, impose the minimum
The main business of GEZ Bhd is fuel business, but all products were loss due to
evaporation of fuel during filing and this may lead to low profit and it also will be
bring wastage and loss to the company. As GEZ Bhd mentioned about the product
loss, they didn’t state how the evaporation exactly happen that causing to the
product loss. By that, GEZ need to conduct thoroughly with the expertise but the
Currently GEZ conducted a two main business which is fuel business and
convenience store business, with the growing number of vehicles and the demand
fuel kept increasing, GEZ can grab this opportunity by conduct a new business
such as car wash. By providing car wash business beside the fuel station, GEZ can
generate more income by providing this service. Besides that, it is very convenient
to the customer to wash their vehicle as it is near with the petrol station.
Conducting this new business eventually will lead to some shortage to the
company such as the business location will be congested by many vehicles as they
want to wash their car and fuel their tank. Other than that, by conducting this
business in need of huge amount of capital to renovate the space and buying the
13
6.0 RECOMMENDED SOLUTION, IMPLEMENTATION AND
JUSTIFICATION
In this section, we will recommend the solutions for GEZ Bhd to overcome their
problem. According to the case study, we had identified that several issue in CEZ Bhd.
The first issue is lack of knowledge in finance, accounting and the second issue is related
to the low of profit margin that contributed to business failures. This will cause GEZ fail
to growth the business and facing the problem because accounting knowledge is very
various internal or external users which is intended to be used in decision making proses.
Business accounting help in making several short term and long-term business decisions
which helps an enterprise to grow as well as penetrate in the (EduPristine, 2018). Refer
to the Gartenstein (2019), accounting help the owner understand what's going on with
your business financially and it will help to more understand your business’s financial
workings, and able to keep operations profitable. Accurate of bookkeeping, can easily
detect the area that spending too much money in an area such as materials or payroll.
Related to the first issue, we suggest that GEZ bhd. providing training for their
employee. GEZ can sent their staff to class or seminar that related to the accounting.
Employee with the strong knowledge in accounting and finance can be an asset for the
company and will help company to growth the business. Besides, the financial statement
of the business will become more accurate and fulfil the qualitative characteristic of
financial statement. According to Steven Bragg (2018), there are several qualitative
comparability.
14
Understandability means the information must be readily understandable to users of the
financial statements. This means that information must be clearly presented, with
information must be relevant to the needs of the users, which is the case when the
information influences the economic decisions of users. This may involve reporting
GEZ financial statement will lead to irrelevance financial statement and decision can’t be
Reliability means the information must be free of material error and bias, and not
misleading. Thus, the information should faithfully represent transactions and other
events, reflect the underlying substance of events, and prudently represent estimates and
employees will be cause of accounting error. When GEZ facing the complex transaction
it will be high risk to accounting error arise. Financial statement with accounting error
will bring to the inaccurate financial figure and decision had been made will be less
presented for other accounting periods, so that users can identify trends in the
performance and financial position of the reporting entity. Compare from the previous
financial year will be the key to measure the performance in GEZ business.
Beside accounting use to monitor the performance of business, accounting also will
determine the sustainable of business. Accountant will save the world (Bakker, 2013).
15
To deliver on this vision, accountants will need a greater awareness of how they can
support stronger and more sustainable organizations.. To bring this vision closer to
reality, this briefing clarifies the important role accountants can, and must, play in
embracing sustainability to ensure that the organizations they serve are resilient. It does
organizations and highlighting the key elements of developing a sustainable strategy and
challenges in their diverse roles. It also provides information on the many resources and
tools available to help accountants develop the knowledge and skillset necessary to meet
(2018), the adoption of accounting in the public shareholding companies with a high
Related to the second issue, GEZ faces problem with the profit margin. Petrol Pump
businesses are very low margin businesses. The net profit percentages can vary between
0.5% to around 1% depending on how one manages employee salaries, expenses for
current/power consumption, credit to bulk buyers such as truck and bus owners, and
According to Cost Volume Profit (CVP) Analysis, it shows that the margin profit of GEZ
is very low. GEZ conduct two different business, petrol pump and convenience store. In
2010, revenue for petrol pump and convenience store are RM 19,251,898 and
RM1,430,292 respectively. The total revenue for that year is RM 20,682,190. According
16
to CVP analysis, the break-even point for the business is at RM 19,834,172 and the profit
for the company only RM 848,018 or only 4.1% from total revenue. Refer to the CVP
analysis, contribution margin from pump oil should be RM 1,112,419. The margin had
been reduced to RM 951,399 causes of credit card fee and product loss RM 77,008 and
RM 84,012 respectively.
In order to increase business profit, GEZ should develop the policy related to the credit
card use. CVP analysis shows the amount that been impose on credit card fees to GEZ is
RM 77,008 in 2010. GEZ’s customers that paid using credit card will reduce by charge
the credit card fees on customers. It will make customer more prefer using cash or debit
card. GEZ will reduce the credit card fees and increase their profit.
Other than credit card fees, GEZ management team should consider about product loss
due to evaporation of fuel during filling. According to H Onsa (2009), transportation and
handling of gasoline involves many distinct operations each of which represents potential
source of evaporation loss. The first operation is the transportation of gasoline from
refinery to the main strategic and bulk storage terminal. Then from these terminals to the
end fuel consumers sites or distribution services stations. It is final destination is motor
vehicle gasoline tank. GEZ management need to consult with specialist oil and gas
regarding the product loss and how to reduce that lost. Nowadays, technology will keep
upgrade to deal with the current issue. The specialist in oil and gas will able to provide
GEZ management team can take several actions to monitor emission control. First, check
condition of existing seals and replace vapor mounted primary seal with liquid mounted
seal. Install secondary rim seal and vapor recovery system. A future method for
controlling evaporative losses is to adapt a vapor recovery system (H Onsa, 2009). The
17
cost of this method is quite high because it needs special equipment to convert
hydrocarbon vapor to liquid before liquid fuel is sent back to the storage tank. Product
loss for GEZ business in 2010 amounted RM 84,012 or 0.5% from petrol revenue. This
product loss is very related with the sales, increase in sales also with increase in product
loss. GEZ should invest their money to reduce this product loss and it will be an efficient
18
REFERENCES
Bakker, P. (2013). Accountants Will Save the World. Retrieved from Harvard Business
Review: https://hbr.org/2013/03/accountants-will-save-the-worl
Bashatweh, A. M. (2018). Conclusion and Recommendations. Accounting Theory and Its
Impact on Adoption of Suntainability Dimensions, 97.
Biery, M. E. (24 September , 2017). Forbes . Retrieved from these-industries-generate-the-
lowest-profit-margins: https://www.forbes.com/sites/sageworks/2017/09/24/these-
industries-generate-the-lowest-profit-margins/#6f9d8adff49d
Bragg, S. (2018). The qualitative characteristics of financial statements. Retrieved from
Accountingtools: https://www.accountingtools.com/articles/what-are-the-qualitative-
characteristics-of-financial-statem.html
Chen, J., & Segal, T. (2019). Profit Margin. Retrieved from Investopedia:
https://www.investopedia.com/terms/p/profitmargin.asp
Cox, A. (23 June, 2015). netmind.net/choose-the-right-decision-criteria/. Retrieved from
netmind: https://netmind.net/choose-the-right-decision-criteria/
EduPristine. (2018). Importance of Business Accounting for enterprises. Retrieved from
https://www.edupristine.com/blog/importance-of-accounting-for-businesses
Gartenstein, D. (2019). Principles and Importance of Accounting for a Business. Retrieved
from Chron: https://smallbusiness.chron.com/principles-importance-accounting-
business-703.html
H Onsa, M. (2009). INTRODUCTION & EMISSIONS CONTROL. MANAGEMENT OF
EVAPORATION LOSSES OF GASOLINE'S STORAGE TANKS, 43.
International Federation of Accountants. (2015). Accounting for Sustainability.
ISMAIL, K. N. (n.d.). GEZ PETROL STATION: USING COST-VOLUME-PROFIT
ANALYSIS.
Ku Ismail, K., & Wan Hussin, W. (2015). repo.uum.edu.my. Retrieved from uum.edu.my:
http://repo.uum.edu.my/23470/1/NCSC%202015%201%207.pdf
Sood, P. (2018). How does the petrol pump business work? What is the profit margin for a
pump owner? Is it the same with private and govt companies? Retrieved from Quora:
https://www.quora.com/How-does-the-petrol-pump-business-work-What-is-the-
profit-margin-for-a-pump-owner-Is-it-the-same-with-private-and-govt-companies
19
TUOVILA, A. (30 September, 2019). Cost Accounting. Retrieved 10 October, 2019, from
Corporate Finance & Accounting: https://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/cost-
accounting.asp
Valerie Belton, T. J. (2002). Multiple Criteria Decision Analysis. Netherlands: Kluwer
Aacademic Publisers Group.
Yong, C.-C., Yew, S.-Y., & Wee, C.-K. (2018). Financial Knowledge, Attitude and.
Institutions and Economies .
20