White Paper Infotrends Harlequin Host Renderer SDK
White Paper Infotrends Harlequin Host Renderer SDK
White Paper Infotrends Harlequin Host Renderer SDK
May 2012
Service Areas
Prepared for
Comments or Questions?
Analysis Global Graphics Demonstrates Power with Latest Harlequin RIP
Table of Contents
Executive Summary.................................................................................................................... 4
Recommendations ................................................................................................................. 4
Introduction ................................................................................................................................ 5
Partnerships ..................................................................................................................... 17
List of Tables
Table 1: Key Strengths of the Harlequin Host Renderer Technology ..................................... 7
Table 2: RIP Test Computer Specification ................................................................................ 12
Table 3: RIP Speed Test File Categories ................................................................................... 13
Table 4: Required # of Harlequin RIP instances (or Servers) by Print Device ...................... 15
List of Figures
Figure 1: Exponential Rise in Continuous Feed Inkjet Printer Placements, North America
and Western Europe .................................................................................................................. 5
© InfoTrends 2012 2
Analysis Global Graphics Demonstrates Power with Latest Harlequin RIP
© InfoTrends 2012 3
Analysis Global Graphics Demonstrates Power with Latest Harlequin RIP
Executive Summary
Global Graphics, a long standing raster image processer (RIP) developer, has just
launched its Harlequin Host Renderer 3 (HHR3). This product is a highly-configurable
RIP that digital hardware equipment manufacturers can use in their digital front-ends
(DFEs) to drive their print equipment.
To demonstrate the power of the HHR3, Global Graphics asked RIT to do a speed test
and commissioned InfoTrends to write an analysis on its technology and the findings of
the speed test. The results show that a typical configuration of the Harlequin RIP can
easily drive most printers at a speed that is well in excess of the rated speed of the device.
When needed, the architecture is also scalable enough to get more performance by adding
additional RIPs.
Key Findings
The Harlequin product is based on an architecture that allows for efficient, parallel
rendering using multiple CPUs. Global Graphics has also developed technology that
automatically detects and optimizes variable data jobs, which increases performance
and removes the need for proprietary VDP languages.
With the PDF-playing field leveled because of PDF being an open standard now,
Global Graphics is well positioned to drive high-end PDF ripping and benefit from
the AFP/IPDS to PDF migration.
Recommendations
OEMs that develop mid-range or office type equipment will also benefit from
Harlequin technology. While the scope of this white paper is on the high-end (as
optimization plays a bigger role there), the product comes with flexible and cost-
effective licensing that make it a good fit for those markets, as well.
© InfoTrends 2012 4
Analysis Global Graphics Demonstrates Power with Latest Harlequin RIP
Introduction
Digital, continuous-feed color inkjet is the fastest growing segment in the printing
industry. High-speed printing, however, puts tremendous requirements on the DFE in
terms of data processing speed and throughput. With its long history and strong
background in high-speed ripping, Global Graphics is in a strong position to benefit from
this emerging high-speed printing opportunity. This whitepaper explores the strengths of
the Harlequin RIP technology and highlights the role Global Graphics plays in shaping
this changing print landscape. The paper also features an independent speed-test carried
out by the Rochester Institute of Technology (RIT) to demonstrate the performance of the
Harlequin technology.
15GB
per second is the amount of data
required to run an HP T400 Web
Press at rated speed (600 ft/min)
High-speed printing puts a big requirement on the DFE in terms of data processing speed
and throughput, especially when personalization or graphically-intense elements, such as
live transparencies, are involved. As the technological limits of inkjet printing in terms of
printing speed and width are still a long way from being achieved, we can expect the
requirements for faster data processing only to grow phenomenally in the decade to
come.
The Harlequin RIP is Global Graphics’ premier offering in the digital print production
space.
© InfoTrends 2012 5
Analysis Global Graphics Demonstrates Power with Latest Harlequin RIP
Harlequin Technology
The core of the Harlequin technology is a Raster Image Processor (RIP) that converts
incoming page description languages, such as PostScript or PDF, to a machine readable
output raster using a variety of screening techniques. The Figure below explains the four
key RIP phases.
The Harlequin RIP technology goes back to 1988 when it was first released as a PostScript
renderer under the name ScriptWorks, providing an alternative to Adobe’s Configurable
PostScript Interpreter (CPSI). Over the years, Harlequin was extended with the need to
support more data formats; multi-core CPU processing; and various in-RIP capabilities,
such as font emulation, color management, trapping, imposition, and more screening
options.
Harlequin has supported native PDF processing since 1997 and live transparencies since
2002, which is much earlier than other players in the market. As a result, the Harlequin
technology is generally considered to be a mature and a well-performing RIP solution.
A single DFE can contain multiple Harlequin Host Renderers, and each
host renderer benefits from multi-threading, multi-core CPU processing
and other speed-enhancements capabilities.
© InfoTrends 2012 6
Analysis Global Graphics Demonstrates Power with Latest Harlequin RIP
2. Embedded SDK
3. Server RIP
The Harlequin Server RIP is a flexible RIP server that OEMs or ISVs can
use as a RIP server with their own Graphical User Interface (GUI).
For inkjet or high-speed production print manufacturers looking for RIP technology to
power their products, the Harlequin Host Renderer is the component that is most suited.
© InfoTrends 2012 7
Analysis Global Graphics Demonstrates Power with Latest Harlequin RIP
© InfoTrends 2012 8
Analysis Global Graphics Demonstrates Power with Latest Harlequin RIP
Besides the normal PDF standard (ISO 32000-1), additional subsets have been defined.
The three most well-known subsets include:
PDF/X: Specialized exchange format for the printing and graphic arts industries that
has additional requirements, such as the embedding of fonts
PDF/VT: Specialized format for variable data jobs that comes with support for live
transparencies; ICC-color profiles; and efficient processing of repeating text, graphic,
or image content
The PDF subsets have been developed by committees of leading industry experts,
including hardware and software vendors as well as end users. Global Graphics has been
a member of those working group committees, and its CTO Martin Bailey is considered to
be the U.K.’s principal expert on ISO for PDF, PDF/A, and PDF/VT. Not surprisingly,
Harlequin technology supports all PDF file formats natively. Global Graphics is
committed to continue to influence the development of PDF in the future and especially
want to make it work well in high-volume environments.
© InfoTrends 2012 9
Analysis Global Graphics Demonstrates Power with Latest Harlequin RIP
125k
4.1%
4.1%
100,000 to 250,000
31.0%
N = 74 Respondents that work for a Database Marketing/Direct Mail Company, In-plant Data Center or a Data
Processing Printer/Service Bureau
As a result, more print service providers (PSPs) will invest in inkjet. There is also a need
to fill those machines, which will increasingly happen with a mix of applications. For
instance, service bureaus that primarily produce transactional documents are looking to
capture more POD work, while commercial printers are making steps in the transactional
or direct mail space.
From a data format perspective, InfoTrends firmly believes there is a place for AFP/IPDS
on the high-end (transactional only), but there are increasingly clear benefits for a PDF-
based workflow on the cross-over point, which tends to be more medium-sized providers:
© InfoTrends 2012 10
Analysis Global Graphics Demonstrates Power with Latest Harlequin RIP
PDF (including PDF/VT) enables PSPs to continue using their PDF-based workflows,
which includes preflighting, proofing, and imposition solutions
Very dissatisfied; we
Slightly dissatisfied; tried native PDF Don’t
native PDF rendering rendering, but found know/unfamiliar
did not perform as AFP/IPDS to be better 0.4% Can’t tell; we haven’t
expected, we will stay 1.9%
with AFP/IPDS tried native PDF
3.4% rendering for current
AFP/IPDS jobs
Not satisfied/not 6.8%
dissatisfied; each
technology has its
unique advantages
and disadvantages
9.0%
For Global Graphics, the move to PDF in high-volume environments is important as this
plays perfectly to the strength of their product offering. The speed test from RIT confirms
that the latest edition of Harlequin Host Renderer is well-suited to power this emerging
inkjet print opportunity.
The test file suite, developed by RIT, was composed of files in six different categories, see
Table 1. For each category, multiple test files were created with different page counts and
© InfoTrends 2012 11
Analysis Global Graphics Demonstrates Power with Latest Harlequin RIP
characteristics to reflect the variety in real-world production jobs. Each test file was
ripped twice using a server that consisted of ten RIP instances. The speeds recorded were
then averaged across the two experiments and the ten RIP instances. The average speed
per RIP for each job category is presented in Figure 6.
Test Hardware
The DFE was installed on an HP ProLiant Density Line server. This is a complete server
unit that does not share components (like power and cooling) with other servers. In this
sense, it is not different than a normal computer but it has the advantage that it can be
placed in a server rack and be easily scaled. While HP equipment was chosen for this test,
the Harlequin RIP can run equally well on hardware from other manufacturers.
At time of writing, the retail cost for the HP ProLiant DL 360 G7 unit is around $7,000
(€5,300 or £4,400). As the speed results will show Harlequin RIPs running on a single
server like this provide enough power to drive most of today’s available print devices on
the market. For certain demanding RIP applications, multiple servers are needed.
Manufacturer Hewlett-Packard
Model Proliant DL360 G7
Processors 2
Intel Xeon X5670 @ 2.93 GHz
Processor Model
(6-core)
Installed RAM 12 GB
Hard disk 280 GB
Operating System Windows Server 2008 R2 (64-bit)
RIP product Harlequin Host Renderer SDK 3
Test Suite
The RIP print test files were created using InDesign, QuarkXPress, XMPie, and GMC.
These software applications provide good representation of the standard production tools
used to create static and variable data pages for the six sample categories.
The obtained ripping speed is a function that involves many variables including how well
the document is designed, the image resolution used, level of transparency, coverage, and
the usage of variable content. The speed test in this analysis provides an average based on
© InfoTrends 2012 12
Analysis Global Graphics Demonstrates Power with Latest Harlequin RIP
real-world production jobs and should provide a good indication of how well the
Harlequin RIP behaves in practice.
Simple VDP
Transaction/TransPromo documents. Image
data in device CMYK color space and no live
5,000 transparency. Simple VDP documents have
8 considerable re-use of page elements.
10,000 (7x)
Reoccurring objects were placed in the same
location, scale, and rotation on the page
Commercial
General Office/Presentations, Proposals &
1 Reports, and Promotional Brochures.
2 Typically very few pages, from a single side
5 to a single 4/1 or 4/4 page with heavy
4 coverage. Generally half-folded, z-folded,
8 (2x) gate-folded, or can be a small saddle-stitched
booklet
Photo Book
The photo book test files have heavy image
coverage, typically with RGB images and
5 24 (5x) have live PDF transparency on approximately
5% of the pages.
Note that the difference between simple and complex VDP does not relate to the
complexity in designing the document or the sophistication of business rules, but to the
complexity that is found from a ripping perspective (e.g., level of coverage, variable
elements, or transparencies).
© InfoTrends 2012 13
Analysis Global Graphics Demonstrates Power with Latest Harlequin RIP
For VDP and labels, a single Harlequin RIP instance of our test server ripped, on average,
between 1,905 ppm and 3,269 ppm. Please note that the Harlequin VariData optimization
technology provides additional speed benefits here (See Table 1). Ripping speeds slow
down when heavy coverage and imagery is introduced, as those characteristics limit the
amount of optimization that can be applied. Nevertheless, even when large amounts of
calculation are required, the Harlequin Host Renderer 3 provides enough firepower to
drive most printers with a single server, certainly on the cut-sheet side. It is also
important to note that every page in the test file is unique. In real-world production,
publication and commercial applications especially have run lengths that are longer than
one which equates to faster speeds as the DFE can re-use those pages and does not need
to rip them again.
Labels 3,269
Publication 192
Commercial 121
Photo Book 82
Table 4 provides an overview of selected printer models and the number of Harlequin RIP
instances that are required to drive those machines based on the speed test results from
RIT. The first and second column states the model and speed of the machine in pages per
minute (U.S. Letter equivalent). For the label printing presses, we have calculated print
speed based on the linear speed of the device and the number of n-up pages that fit the
printing width (2-up landscape for the Xeikon and 1-up portrait for the Indigo).
We also multiplied the stated engine speed by 2.5 to account for the fact that jobs are not
always well-designed and some of those may impact performance. Assuming that the RIP
speeds as mentioned in column ‘PPM 2.5x’ would be able to drive a machine at rated
© InfoTrends 2012 14
Analysis Global Graphics Demonstrates Power with Latest Harlequin RIP
speed, we then provided for each application category the number of Harlequin instances
required, as well as the number of servers between brackets. The speeds shown below
each category description are results from RIT, see Figure 6.
It is important to note that the number of RIP instances and servers are theoretical
values based on measurements using average hardware. In practice, the number of
servers on the high-end can be reduced by using higher-spec hardware and the Harlequin
RIP can be further configured to the specific demands of each unique print category.
HP T410
162 258
Color Inkjet 5,000 12,500 1 (1) 3 (1) - 15 (2) 16 (2) -
(16) (26)
Web Press
Kodak
117 185
Prosper 3,600 9,000 1 (1) 2 (1) - 10 (1) 11 (1) -
(12) (19)
5000XL
Kodak
112
VersaMark 2,180 5,450 1 (1) 1 (1) - 6 (1) 7 (1) 70 (7) -
(11)
VX5000
Océ
52
ColorStream 1,010 2,525 1 (1) 1 (1) - 3 (1) 3 (1) 32 (3) -
(5)
3500
HP Indigo 12
240 600 1 (1) 1 (1) - 1 (1) 1 (1) 7 (1) 18 (2)
W7200 (1)
HP Indigo -
143 358 - 1 (1) - - - - -
WS6000
HP Indigo
120 300 1 (1) 1 (1) 1 (1) 1 (1) 1 (1) 3 (1) 6 (1) 9 (1)
7500
Xerox iGen4 110 275 1 (1) 1 (1) 1 (1) 1 (1) 1 (1) 3 (1) 5 (1) 8 (1)
Ricoh C901 90 225 1 (1) 1 (1) 1 (1) 1 (1) 1 (1) 2 (1) 4 (1) 6 (1)
Konica
Minolta 80 200 1 (1) 1 (1) 1 (1) 1 (1) 1 (1) 2 (1) 4 (1) 6 (1)
C8000
Canon
imagePRESS 70 175 1 (1) 1 (1) 1 (1) 1 (1) 1 (1) 2 (1) 3 (1) 5 (1)
C7000VP
* Based on an average run length of 75; ** - based on an average run length of 50; the number of RIPs
required depends on the average run length as well as the type of content (e.g. color vs. monochrome, raster
or vector data, etc.). The data here is just an indication. The italic values in dark grey represent options that
are not or hardly used in practice but they do demonstrate the ripping power that is required to drive the top
end of the market
© InfoTrends 2012 15
Analysis Global Graphics Demonstrates Power with Latest Harlequin RIP
This overview shows that the Harlequin Host Render 3 satisfies a very critical market
requirement to deliver pages to the printer at speeds in excess of the rated speed of the
print device and, where necessary, can scale up to offer a greater performance. By
delivering pages at over twice the performance of typical production printer, service
providers using the Harlequin RIP will be assured of running the print device at rated
speeds, which is a fundamental requirement in today’s competitive market and also often
cited by end-users as a barrier to digital high-end printing.
In addition to this overview, RIT reported that Harlequin rendered all files flawlessly and
performed efficiently across all files, even on the most complex documents. Further
information can be obtained by contacting Global Graphics.
InfoTrends’ Opinion
Global Graphics is well positioned to benefit from the growth in the high-production
inkjet market. Its high-quality RIP technology is mature, consistent in output, extremely
efficient, robust, and scalable. As the independent speed test has demonstrated, the
Harlequin Host Renderer 3 can deliver pages to printersat speeds that exceed the rated
speeds of the print devices.
As we are only at the beginning of the inkjet revolution, we can expect to see faster, wider
and more productive inkjet products coming onto the market in the next few years. High-
speed printing puts a big requirement on the DFE in terms of data processing speed and
throughput, especially when personalization or graphically-intense elements (such as live
transparencies) are involved. Companies that invest in inkjet printing should carefully
consider their RIP partner as speed requirements for RIPing tend to rise exponentially,
which may form an important cost to the overall printed product.
Hardware vendors that are looking for RIP technology to drive their digital print
equipment should include Global Graphics on their evaluation list. With 20 years of
experience, a very focused approach to engineering, and a range of high-performing
products, Global Graphics is a company that should not be overlooked.
© InfoTrends 2012 16
Analysis Global Graphics Demonstrates Power with Latest Harlequin RIP
Product Lines
The company is active with three major product lines:
Harlequin: A robust RIP on the market that can natively process PostScript, PDF,
and XPS. The Harlequin RIP is found in digital print DFEs, such as the HP
SmartStream Pro and Ultra, as well as in other solutions, such as workflow
management solutions marketed by Agfa.
Jaws: A native PostScript and PDF RIP kernel designed for integration with OEM
solutions, Jaws is extensively used in DFEs for the wide format market. It can also be
found in print-related software solutions that require on-the-fly interpreting or
rendering capabilities, such as VDP or Workflow Management systems.
Partnerships
Global Graphics sells to a wide variety of business partners ranging from digital or wide
format print manufacturers to workflow software or variable data printing providers.
Customers include Agfa, Canon, Compose, Corel, Delphax, FujiXerox, Hewlett-Packard,
Kodak, Presstek, Quark, Rampage, Ryobi, Onyx, Miyakoshi, Screen, and Showa
Information Systems.
This material is prepared specifically for clients of InfoTrends, Inc. The opinions expressed represent our interpretation
and analysis of information generally available to the public or released by responsible individuals in the subject
companies. We believe that the sources of information on which our material is based are reliable and we have applied
our best professional judgment to the data obtained
© InfoTrends 2012 17
Analysis Global Graphics Demonstrates Power with Latest Harlequin RIP
Kaspar Roos
Associate Director
[email protected]
+ 011 44 75 8550 6114
Follow me on Twitter
Kaspar Roos is an Associate Director for InfoTrends’ Production Workflow & Custom
Communications Solutions Services. Mr. Roos is responsible for conducting market
research, providing forecast analysis, consulting with clients, and creating editorial
content for product and market analysis reports. His primary focus area is on the graphic
communications industry and data processing markets.
Comments or Questions?
i The images do not reflect the actual files used for the RIP test. Images are sourced from:
Labels: Harkwell Labels, http://www.harkwell-labels.co.uk/
Simple VDP: DocPath, http://www.docpath.com
Complex VDP: Aztec Mailing Centre, http://aztecmailingcentre.co.uk
Commercial: Snell Vliet, http://www.snellevliet.nl
Photo Book: Bonus Print, http://www.bonusprint.co.uk
Publication: http://myzerowaste.com
© InfoTrends 2012 18