Otitis Exter Na: Jennifer Wipperman
Otitis Exter Na: Jennifer Wipperman
Otitis Exter Na: Jennifer Wipperman
KEYWORDS
Acute otitis externa Chronic otitis externa Antibiotics Topical steroids
KEY POINTS
Acute otitis externa most often is infectious in origin, and can be easily treated with a
com-bination of topical antibiotic and steroid preparations.
Systemic antibiotics are rarely needed for acute otitis externa.
Chronic otitis externa can be more difficult to treat, but if an underlying cause can be
iden-tified this condition can often be successfully managed.
In both acute and chronic otitis externa, prevention is fundamental. If patients are able to
avoid precipitating factors, future episodes can often be averted.
Otitis externa is a common problem seen in the primary care office, and most cases are
managed by primary care providers.1 Otitis externa is an inflammatory condition of the
external ear canal, with or without infection. Inflammation may be localized to the ear
canal, or include portions of the outer ear, such as the pinna or tragus. Acute otitis externa
(AOE) is defined as lasting less than 6 weeks, and chronic otitis externa (COE) as lasting
3 months or longer. AOE, also known as swimmer’s ear, is usually an infectious condition,
whereas COE more often has a noninfectious, allergic cause.
Diagnosis
AOE is a clinical diagnosis, the criteria of which are listed in Box 1. Diagnosis requires
a history of rapid onset (within the last 48 hours) occurring in the last 3 weeks with
signs and symptoms of ear canal inflammation. 2 Symptoms include otalgia, itching,
or fullness, with or without hearing loss. Signs include tenderness of the outer ear or
diffuse ear-canal edema or erythema with or without otorrhea, regional
lymphadenop-athy, tympanic membrane erythema, or surrounding cellulitis. Several
other conditions can mimic AOE, and should be differentiated (Table 1).
In uncomplicated cases, obtaining cultures of otorrhea is not necessary. However,
bacterial and fungal cultures may be helpful in resistant or recurrent cases in patients
with a history of frequent topical antibiotic use or the immunocompromised. If malig-
nant (necrotizing) otitis externa is suspected, cultures should always be obtained.
Pneumatic otoscopy and tympanometry are useful in differentiating AOE from acute
otitis media (AOM). This distinction is important because otitis media would require
Otitis Externa 3
Box 1
Diagnostic criteria for acute otitis externa
Data from Rosenfeld RM, Brown L, Cannon CR, et al. Clinical practice guideline: acute otitis ex-
terna. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 2006;134(Suppl 4):S4–23.
Table 1
Differential diagnosis of acute otitis externa
Treatment
The mainstays of treatment for AOE include pain control, treatment of infection, and
avoiding precipitating factors. These goals are most often accomplished with aural
toilet, a topical antibiotic and topical steroid, and over-the-counter oral pain medica-
tion if needed. Oral antibiotics are rarely indicated.
Topical antibiotics are effective for most cases. Most often, an aminoglycoside or
fluoroquinolone antibiotic is used, as they include coverage of Pseudomonas and
Staphylococcus spp. An aminoglycoside preparation, as found in Cortisporin Otic, should
be avoided if the tympanic membrane is perforated or if the patient has a his-tory of
contact sensitivity to neomycin. Up to 15% of the population has contact sensi-
tivity to neomycin, which increases to 30% among those with chronic or eczematous
otitis externa.8,9 Aminoglycosides are ototoxic, and can lead to hearing loss and ver-tigo if
they reach the inner ear.10 Both aminoglycoside and fluoroquinolone antibiotics have a
70% to 90% clinical response rate.11 Because topical acetic acid preparations (VoSol)
have anti-infective activity and drying action, they exhibit clinical cure rates
similar to those of topical antibiotics for AOE.11 However, acetic acid preparations
may be less effective if needed for a longer than 1 week. 12
A 2010 Cochrane review found no difference in efficacy between classes of antibi-
otics.11 Therefore, choice of antibiotic should be based on factors such as risk of
ototoxicity, contact sensitivity, availability, cost, dosing schedules, and patient compli-ance
(Table 2). Because topical antibiotics reach a high concentration in the ear canal,
even bacterial strains considered resistant to systemic antibiotics (ie, methicillin-
resistant Staphylococcus aureus) are susceptible to topical antibiotic preparations. 2 The
addition of a topical steroid results in reduced canal edema and otorrhea, and has-
tens pain relief.11,13 Many topical antibiotic preparations include a steroid component. In
general, patients should be treated for 7 to 10 days. 2 Practically, patients may be advised
to use drops for 1 week. If symptoms are not resolved they may continue to use drops
until a few days after symptoms resolve, up to 1 additional week. If symptoms still persist
at day 14, this should be considered a treatment failure.
Proper use of topical antibiotics is important, and misunderstanding of technique
can lead to treatment failure. For this reason, placement of drops should be taught
in the office. Up to 40% of patients do not self-administer drops correctly.14 Having
someone else administer topical preparations is therefore usually more effective. Pa-
tients should lie on their side with the affected ear up. Drops should be placed to run
along the side of the ear canal until it is filled, gently moving the pinna to and fro to
elim-inate air trapping and ensure filling. Patients should remain in this position for at
least 3 to 5 minutes.
For topical antibiotics to be effective, they must contact the epithelial lining. There-
fore, in patients with a significant amount of debris or otorrhea, aural toilet may be
necessary. In general, debris can be cleared using gentle suction, irrigation, or dry
mopping with cotton. Impacted cerumen and foreign bodies should be removed.
Gentle irrigation should be used only if the tympanic membrane is intact, and should
Otitis Externa 5
Table 2
Common topical antimicrobial preparations for acute otitis externa
Brand Cost of Generic
Component Name (Brand) Dosage Comments
Acetic acid 2% VoSol $30 for 15 mL 3–5 drops Avoid if tympanic
($36 for 15 mL) every 4–6 h membrane
ruptured. May
cause local
irritation
Acetic acid 2%/ VoSol HC $50 for 10 mL 3–5 drops As above
hydrocortisone ($50 for 10 mL) every 4–6 h
Neomycin/ Cortisporin $18 for 10 mL 3–4 drops —
polymyxin B/ ($100 for 10 mL) every 6–8 h
hydrocortisone
Ciprofloxacin/ Cipro HC Not available 3–4 drops 7-Day course
hydrocortisone ($190 for 10 mL) every 12 h adequate
Ciprofloxacin/ Ciprodex Not available 3–4 drops As above
dexamethasone ($160 for 7.5 mL) every 12 h
Ofloxacin Floxin Otic $20 for 5 mL 10 drops once 7-Day course
($80 for 5 mL) daily adequate
Data from GoodRX. Available at: www.goodrx.com. Accessed November 20, 2013.
Monitoring
Most patients with AOE will experience significant improvement within 24 hours. 16 If
patients do not improve within 48 to 72 hours, they should be reevaluated. Clinical
failure may be due to nonadherence, inadequate drug delivery, canal obstruction, or
misdiagnosis. Although most patients can be treated by their primary care provider,
referral is indicated in cases of suspected malignant otitis externa, lack of improve-
ment, or an inability to remove obstructing debris or a foreign body.
Prevention
Patients with AOE should prevent future episodes by limiting predisposing factors.
Moisture retention in the ear canal should be minimized, and a healthy skin barrier
maintained. Excessive moisture can be avoided in several situations. Swimmers may
use well-fitting ear plugs while swimming to prevent water retention in the ear canal.
After water exposure, the head should be tilted and the ear gently pulled to empty
any residual water. A hair dryer on the lowest heat setting may be used to help dry
the ear. In addition, acidifying drops, such as acetic acid 2% (VoSol otic so-lution)
may be placed in the ear after water exposure to dry the ear canal.
Sources of ear trauma should also be avoided. Patients should be instructed to
stop frequent ear cleaning, especially with cotton-tipped applicators. Hearing aids
should be examined to ensure that they fit well. Underlying dermatologic conditions
should be adequately treated.
Complications
In AOE, infection may spread from the ear canal itself to surrounding structures,
leading to auricular or facial cellulitis, perichondritis, or chondritis. 4 Ongoing chronic
infection may result in canal stenosis and hearing loss. 19
Malignant (necrotizing) otitis externa is a severe life-threatening complication of
AOE.20 It may occur in untreated cases where infection extends to the temporal
bone, causing osteomyelitis and systemic toxicity. Pseudomonas is most often impli-
cated. Malignant otitis externa is most common among adult patients, including
the elderly, those with diabetes mellitus, and the immunocompromised. 15 Nearly
90% to 100% of patients with malignant otitis externa have diabetes mellitus. 20
Further complications include meningitis, dural sinus thrombosis, cranial abscess,
and cranial nerve palsies. Facial nerve paralysis may be seen early during infection.
Malignant otitis externa should be suspected in patients with signs of systemic toxicity,
such as fever, or failure to improve with topical antibiotics. In addition to symptoms of
severe AOE, patients may also complain of headache, temporal mandib-ular joint pain,
and trismus. On examination, in addition to severe canal edema, ery-thema, and otorrhea,
granulation tissue is often present on the floor of the canal, especially at the bony-
cartilaginous junction. Diagnosis is confirmed by imaging with computed tomography or
magnetic resonance imaging. Patients will often have an elevated sedimentation rate, and
cultures of otorrhea should always be ob-tained. Treatment requires initial empiric
intravenous antibiotics that cover Pseudo-monas. In severe or resistant cases, surgical
debridement may be necessary.
In contrast to AOE, chronic otitis externa (COE) is more often attributed to allergic or
autoimmune causes than infectious etiology. Less than 5% of otitis externa is
chronic.2 However, COE is often a disturbing and sometimes disabling condition for
the 3% to 5% of the population affected by it.21 COE represents a common pathway
Otitis Externa 7
for several different disease states. It may be caused by allergic contact dermatitis,
autoimmune disorders, chronic dermatologic conditions such as psoriasis, or chronic
infection from fungi or bacteria.4,19
Clinical Presentation
Patients with COE present with itching of the ear, clear or mucoid otorrhea, and aural
fullness. Ear pain or discomfort and hearing loss may be present if the ear canal is
acutely inflamed and swollen. Many patients experience a waxing and waning course
over years with intermittent exacerbations.2 In at least half of patients, both ears are
affected. At times patients may also experience AOE. 19
Physical Examination
Physical examination findings in COE often vary depending on the cause. For
example, patients with contact dermatitis may exhibit a maculopapular rash with
excoriations on the skin of the conchal bowel and ear canal. Patients with chronic
dermatologic conditions such as psoriasis and atopic dermatitis may show eczema-
tous changes, hyperkeratosis, and lichenification of the ear canal epithelium. The ear
canal may be weepy, erythematous, and tender as well. Seborrheic dermatitis may
result in a lack of cerumen and dry, flaky, erythematous skin in the canal, with or
without clear otorrhea. COE has also resulted from chronic otitis media with tym-
panic membrane perforation. Purulent middle-ear drainage can enter the ear canal
and lead to an eczematous dermatitis. Finally, the ear canal in patients with fungal
infection (otomycosis) may show fluffy, cotton-like debris. Sprouting hyphae or dots
of black debris and thick otorrhea of various colors may also be observed.
Diagnosis
Diagnosis of COE is made clinically in patients with typical signs and symptoms of at least
3 months’ duration.19 Culture for bacteria and fungi is often prudent if chronic infection is
suspected. Patients with possible contact dermatitis should be thoroughly questioned
about the use of various agents such as neomycin, shampoos, detergents, hairsprays,
and hearing-aid molds. Skin-patch testing in cases of contact dermatitis may be useful to
elucidate the cause.17 Chronic dermatologic disorders such as pso-riasis should be
suspected when a typical exanthem is visualized elsewhere on the skin. Finally, patients
may have COE resulting from systemic autoimmune disorders already identified, such as
Wegener granulomatosis and sarcoidosis.22,23
Treatment
Treatment of COE is aimed at identifying the underlying cause and managing
accord-ingly. All patients should have aural toilet if needed, and be given preventive
precau-tions as for AOE. For patients with contact dermatitis, avoidance of any
potential irritants is paramount. Topical steroid therapy with medium-potency
(triamcinolone 0.1% cream) and high-potency (desoximetasone 0.05% cream)
agents is often effec-tive for patients with contact dermatitis or chronic dermatologic
conditions.17,19 Cream preparations are preferred, and a small amount can be
applied to the skin at the meatus twice daily. At times, higher-potency topical steroids
or a short course of oral steroids may be necessary. Topical tacrolimus has also
been used with suc-cess in noninfectious COE.24
Patients with chronic bacterial infection should be treated with topical antibiotics,
as for AOE. In cases of fungal otitis externa, antifungal creams such as clotrimazole
1% may be used.25 Acidifying topical agents are also beneficial. Gentian violet is an
antifungal and drying agent that can be applied in the office.19 It is painted on the
8 Wipperman
ear canal using a home-made Q-tip (ie, a toothpick wrapped in cotton). Recalcitrant
or severe cases, such as those involving Aspergillus, may require oral itraconazole.4
Complications
Patients with COE are predisposed to AOE because of the breakdown in epithelial
lining resulting from excessive moisture, trauma, itching, and accumulation of debris.
Fungal infection may result in perforation of tympanic membrane. 26 A major complica-tion
of COE is fibrosis of the medial canal. 27 After long-standing inflammation, a thick, fibrous
scar can form at the medial end of the ear canal. The tympanic membrane may appear to
be oriented laterally and have fibrotic changes, with absence of typical land-
marks. Eventually a fibrotic plug may become obstructive, resulting in a blind-ending
canal associated with conductive hearing loss.19
SUMMARY
Otitis externa is a common condition seen by primary care clinicians, who should be
familiar with its diagnosis and management. AOE most often is infectious in origin,
and can be easily treated with a combination of topical antibiotic and steroid prepara-
tions. Systemic antibiotics are rarely needed. COE can be more difficult to treat, but if
an underlying cause can be identified this condition can often be successfully
managed. In both AOE and COE, prevention is fundamental. If patients are able to
avoid precipitating factors, future episodes can often be averted.
REFERENCES
12. van Balen FA, Smit WM, Zuithoff NP, et al. Clinical efficacy of three common
treat-ments in acute otitis externa in primary care: randomised controlled trial.
BMJ 2003;327(7425):1201–5.
13. Mosges R, Schroder T, Baues CM, et al. Dexamethasone phosphate in antibiotic
ear drops for the treatment of acute bacterial otitis externa. Curr Med Res Opin
2008;24(8):2339–47.
14. England RJ, Homer JJ, Jasser P, et al. Accuracy of patient self-medication with
topical eardrops. J Laryngol Otol 2000;114(1):24–5.
15. Rubin Grandis J, Branstetter BF, Yu VL. The changing face of malignant (necrot-
ising) external otitis: clinical, radiological, and anatomic correlations. Lancet
Infect Dis 2004;4(1):34–9.
16. Schaefer P, Baugh RF. Acute otitis externa: an update. Am Fam Physician 2012;
86(11):1055–61.
17. Sood S, Strachan DR, Tsikoudas A, et al. Allergic otitis externa. Clin Otolaryngol
Allied Sci 2002;27(4):233–6.
18. Collier SA, Hlavsa MC, Piercefield EW, et al. Antimicrobial and analgesic pre-
scribing patterns for acute otitis externa, 2004-2010. Otolaryngol Head Neck
Surg 2013;148(1):128–34.
19. Kesser BW. Assessment and management of chronic otitis externa. Curr Opin
Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 2011;19(5):341–7.
20. Hollis S, Evans K. Management of malignant (necrotising) otitis externa.
J Laryngol Otol 2011;125(12):1212–7.
21. Ali R, Burns P, Donnelly M. Otitis externa: quality of life assessment. Ir J Med
Sci 2008;177(3):221–3.
22. Illum P, Thorling K. Otological manifestations of Wegener’s granulomatosis.
Laryngoscope 1982;92(7 Pt 1):801–4.
23. Lang EE, el Zaruk J, Colreavy MP, et al. An unusual case of external ear inflam-
mation caused by sarcoidosis. Ear Nose Throat J 2003;82(12):942–5.
24. Caffier PP, Harth W, Mayelzadeh B, et al. Tacrolimus: a new option in therapy-
resistant chronic external otitis. Laryngoscope 2007;117(6):1046–52.
25. Vennewald I, Klemm E. Otomycosis: diagnosis and treatment. Clin Dermatol
2010;28(2):202–11.
26. Viswanatha B, Sumatha D, Vijayashree MS. Otomycosis in immunocompetent
and immunocompromised patients: comparative study and literature review. Ear
Nose Throat J 2012;91(3):114–21.
27. Luong A, Roland PS. Acquired external auditory canal stenosis: assessment and
management. Curr Opin Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 2005;13(5):273–6.