SURFACE J442

REV.
MAY2006
VEHICLE Issued 1952-01
STANDARD Revised 2006-05

Superseding J442 DEC2001

Test Strip, Holder, and Gage for Shot Peening

RATIONALE

NOTE: (T) for technical changes and (E) for editorial changes.

1. (T) Figure 1 – Test Strip Specifications

a. Recommendation: Replace “Edge Type: Number 1 round” with “Edge Type: Number 1 (does not apply to ends
of strip)

b. Rationale: edge type number one includes several variations, all of which are acceptable for the purpose of the
test strip. Although the “round” edge may have nicer appearance the use of square edge number one or other
variants does not affect the performance of the test strip. Relaxing this requirement will give the strip producers
more flexibility in procuring raw material and will not be detrimental to the performance of the test strip.

2. (T) Figure 1 – Test Strip Specifications

a. Recommend deleting tempering temperature of 371 °C (700 °F)

b. Rationale: This is not the correct tempering temperature for the desired hardness range. Since the objective is
to produce strips of certain hardness it should be left to the discretion of the producer to select the tempering
temperature, which could be influenced by carbon content or as-quenched hardness.

3. (E) Figure 1 – Test Strip Specifications

a. Recommend deleting “Flatness: Measured as the reading on the Almen gage for each strip type is as follows:”
and replacing with “Pre-bow:“ the arc height as measured by the Almen gage prior to peening. The maximum
allowed pre-bow for each type of strip is as follows:”

b. Rationale: Pre-bow is the arc height measured on the Almen gage prior to peening. The Almen gage does not
measure flatness per se.

4. (T) Figure 2 Assembled Test Strip and Holder

a. Recommendation: add sentence “One or two additional holes may be used to facilitate mounting the holder to a
fixture. The hole(s) may be threaded and shall not extend into the strip contact surface of the holder.”

b. Rationale: Several commercially available holders already accept the practice of mounting the holder by use of
extra threaded holes. This provides a convenient method of attaching the holder to a fixture. The addition of
such holes that do not degrade the performance of the holder should be allowed.

__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
SAE Technical Standards Board Rules provide that: “This report is published by SAE to advance the state of technical and engineering sciences. The use of this report is
entirely voluntary, and its applicability and suitability for any particular use, including any patent infringement arising therefrom, is the sole responsibility of the user.”
SAE reviews each technical report at least every five years at which time it may be reaffirmed, revised, or cancelled. SAE invites your written comments and suggestions.
Copyright © 2006 SAE International
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical,
photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without the prior written permission of SAE.
TO PLACE A DOCUMENT ORDER: Tel: 877-606-7323 (inside USA and Canada)
Tel: 724-776-4970 (outside USA)
Fax: 724-776-0790
Email: [email protected]
SAE WEB ADDRESS: http://www.sae.org
SAE J442 Revised MAY2006 -2-

5. (T) 6.4 Zero Block (Add)

a. Recommendation: “A zero block, approximately the size of an Almen strip in length and width or large enough
to contact the Almen gage 4-balls and indicator tip, with a minimum thickness of 5 mm shall be used to set the
zero datum of the Almen gage. Flatness of the zero blocks shall be within ±.001 mm. Lapping the surface to
achieve flatness is recommended.

b. Rationale: It is common industry practice to use a zero block similar to these dimensions but there has never
been dimension or tolerance criteria established in J442. However, SAE J443 Section 5 states: “General –
Prior to use, the zero position of the gage shall be checked with a flat calibration block (see SAE J442), and, if
necessary, adjusted.” Therefore, to be consistent with J443 we need to add the zero block to J442. The
flatness tolerance of ±0.001 mm can be easily met and inspected by standard commercial practices.

6. (T) Figure 3 Almen Gage

a. Recommendation: add a tolerance for distance between back post -0.5 to +2.0 mm.

b. Rationale: the absolute distance between the posts (i.e. the 20 mm span from centerline) is not critical. Only
the distance of the edges of the posts to the centers of the ball centerlines (1.69/1.49 mm) is critical. Some
older gages did not maintain the 20 mm ± 0.5 mm tolerance but they, nevertheless, still functioned
appropriately. Spacing the back posts 20 mm with a tolerance of +2.0 mm and -0.5 mm has no influence on
the accuracy of the strip reading. It would seem to be unnecessarily rigorous to disqualify a gage for this
reason.

7. (T) Section 6.3

a. Recommendation: Replace “Any visual signs of wear…” with “Visual signs of wear or flat spots on the ball
greater than 1.0 mm (.039 inch).“ Posts should be inspected for grooves that may interfere with proper seating
of the test strip on the 4-ball platform and, if necessary, replaced.

b. Rationale: Virtually any use of the gage will produce “visual signs of wear” thereby rendering the gage useless.
The present accept/reject criteria are entirely subjective leaving interpretation to auditors and inspectors.
Inspection for flat spot of 1.0 mm can be easily accomplished using 5x to 10x magnification and a simple scale
or calipers. This is the procedure used by several aerospace companies.

1. SCOPE

This SAE Standard defines requirements for equipment/supplies to be used in measuring shot peening intensity.
Guidelines for the use of these articles (test strip, holding fixture, and gage) are also included.

2. REFERENCES

2.1 Related Publications

The following publications are provided for information purposes only and are not a required part of this specification. The
latest issue of SAE publications shall apply.

2.1.1 SAE Publications

Available from SAE, 400 Commonwealth Drive, Warrendale, PA 15096-0001, Tel: 877-606-7323 (inside USA and
Canada) or 724-776-4970 (outside USA), www.sae.org.

SAE J443 Procedures for Using Standard Shot Peening Test Strip

SAE AMS-S-13165 Shot Peening of Metal Parts

SAE J442 Revised MAY2006 -3-

2.1.2 ASTM Publication

Available from ASTM, 100 Barr Harbor Drive, West Conshohocken, PA 19428-2959, Tel: 610-832-9585, www.astm.org.

ASTM E 18 Standard Test Method for Rockwell Hardness and Rockwell Superficial Hardness of Metallic Materials

3. OUTLINE OF METHOD OF CONTROL

The control of a peening machine operation is primarily a matter of the control of the properties of a stream of shot in
relation to the work being peened. The basis of measurement of these properties is as follows:

If a flat piece of steel (the test strip) is clamped to a solid block (the test strip holder) and then exposed to a stream of
shot, it will be curved upon removal from the block. The curvature is due to residual compressive stresses induced by the
shot impacts, causing the peened face to be convex. The curvature serves as a means of measuring the effect of the
shot stream. The degree of the curvature depends upon the properties of the shot stream, the properties and mounting of
the test strip, and the exposure condition.

3.1 Properties

3.1.1 Shot Stream

The properties of the shot stream are: shot material (includes chemical and physical characteristics), size, shape, velocity,
directional consistency, and shot flow rate.

3.1.2 Test Strip

The properties of the test strip are: material (includes chemical and physical properties), hardness, physical dimensions,
and the extent of any internal stresses. The properties of the test strip mounting are flatness, rigidity, and the location and
force of the holding means.

3.1.3 Exposure

The properties of exposure to the blast stream are length of time, angle of impact, and the degree of uniformity and
consistency of the geometric relationship between the shot stream and test strip.

3.2 Standards

Based on these principles, the SAE has adopted the following standards: test strips, holding block, and gage.
Specifications for these parts, the method of use, and a standard designation are presented herein.

4. SPECIFICATIONS OF INTENSITY MEASURING EQUIPMENT

4.1 Test Strips and Holding Fixture

Standard test strips, N, A, and C are shown in Figure 1 and test strip holder is shown in Figure 2. The approximate
relationships between readings of test strips N, A, and C (for conditions of identical blast and exposure) are as follows:

C strip reading x 3.5 = A strip reading

A strip reading x 3.0 = N strip reading
SAE J442 Revised MAY2006 -4-

4.2 Gage

The gage (Almen gage) for determining the curvature of the test strip must incorporate the elements shown in Figure 3.
Curvature of the test strip is determined by a measurement of the height of the combined longitudinal and transverse arc
across standard chords. This arc height is obtained by measuring the displacement of a central point on the nonpeened
surface from the plane of four balls forming the corners of a particular rectangle. To use this gage, the test strip is located
so that the indicator spindle bears against the center of the NONPEENED surface, one long edge of the strip bearing
against the two back stops. The test strip is then centered by placing the ends even with the edges of the base, or by
resting the ends against built-in end stop(s).

5. DESIGNATION STANDARD OF INTENSITY MEASUREMENT

5.1 Primary Standard

The standard designation of intensity measurement includes the gage reading and the test strip used. It may be
explained by the example shown in Figure 4.

5.2 Transition Standard

Gages utilizing the inch-pound system (English units) may be encountered during the period of transition to SI. The
designation of intensity measurement in this temporary alternate is explained in the example shown in Figure 5.

6. MAINTENANCE, CALIBRATION AND USE

6.1 Test Strips

After removal from the test strip holder, test strips should not be replaced, re-used, or shot peened for any additional time.

6.2 Holding Fixture

The test strip contact area of the holding fixture shall be checked for flatness on a periodic basis. Flatness of the test strip
contact area shall not exceed 0.1 mm. In addition to a dimensional check for flatness, holding fixtures shall be checked
visually for the following characteristics:

a. Burrs or raised material that can be caused by damage or excessive peening (particularly on the holding fixture end
faces).

b. Particles of shot or beads that could become trapped under the test strip during installation.

c. Damage to threads that may prevent one or more screws from adequately holding the test strip in place.

6.3 Gage

Locating balls and indicator tip shall be checked periodically for wear. Any visual signs of wear or flat spots on the ball
greater than 1.0 mm (.039 inch) shall be cause for repair of the gage such that new round surfaces are in contact with the
test strip. Posts should be inspected for grooves that may interfere with proper seating of the test strip on the 4-ball
platform and, if necessary, replaced. The indicator shall be calibrated periodically over the range used for measuring test
strips. The calibration tolerance for the indicator shall not exceed 0.005 mm. The use of calibration blocks, either flat,
curved, or equipped with steps, is recommended.

6.4 Zero Block

A zero block, approximately the size of an Almen strip in length and width or large enough to contact the Almen gage
4-balls and indicator tip, with a minimum thickness of 5 mm shall be used to set the zero datum of the Almen gage.
Flatness of the zero blocks shall be within ±.001 mm. Lapping the surface to achieve flatness is recommended.
SAE J442 Revised MAY2006 -5-

FIGURE 1 - TEST STRIP SPECIFICATIONS

SAE J442 Revised MAY2006 -6-

FIGURE 2 - ASSEMBLED TEST STRIP AND HOLDER

SAE J442 Revised MAY2006 -7-

FIGURE 3 -ALMEN GAGE

SAE J442 Revised MAY2006 -8-

FIGURE 4 - EXAMPLE OF STANDARD DESIGNATION OF INTENSITY MEASUREMENT

FIGURE 5 - EXAMPLE OF DESIGNATION OF INTENSITY MEASUREMENT IN TEMPORARY ALTERNATE

7. NOTES

7.1 Superseded Gage Designation

Two types of gages were formerly used to measure the arc height of test strips. The number 1 gage, which is obsolete,
employed two knife edges to support the test strip; the number 2 gage (developed in 1943) uses four balls to locate the
test strip in relation to the indicator stem. Some engineering criteria may continue to show the numeral “2” after the test
strip letter, designating the use of a number 2 gage. This designation (such as A2) is neither required nor recommended.
The gage defined by this SAE Standard uses the same locating scheme as the number 2 gage, and therefore will yield an
equivalent reading.

7.2 Superseded Intensity Designation

The prior “dimensionless” value relating to the number of graduations read on the dial indicator has been discontinued in
favor of direct reading in millimeters (inches).

7.3 Marginal Indicia

The change bar (l) located in the left margin is for the convenience of the user in locating areas where technical revisions
have been made to the previous issue of the report. An (R) symbol to the left of the document title indicates a complete
revision of the report.

PREPARED BY THE SAE SURFACE ENHANCEMENT DIVISION OF THE

SAE FATIGUE, DESIGN, AND EVALUATION COMMITTEE