Dampers Bridges 01 2014 PDF
Dampers Bridges 01 2014 PDF
Dampers Bridges 01 2014 PDF
ASSESSMENT OF
CABLE BEHAVIOUR
DESIGN AND
FABRICATION
INSTALLATION
AND TUNING
RETROFITTING
VSL - SPECIALIST KNOW-HOW
FOR CABLE-STAYED STRUCTURES
Over 50 years of engineering
experience Vibration phenomena
VSL’s specialist construction systems have Various effects can lead to excitation of the cable and eventually to instability of the structure if the
been used throughout the world since 1956 vibrations are not controlled. Stay cables are generally excited by aerodynamic forces acting on the
and have earned an excellent reputation for cable, or by anchorage displacements caused by the action on the structure of dynamic forces such
quality and reliability. This has made VSL a as traffic. Wind excitations can be categorised in four families:
recognised leader in specialist construction
methods and associated engineering works.
A worldwide network
VSL provides solutions through its network of
locally-based subsidiaries who have access to
a strong common technical support structure.
Its clients work with a local partner while
benefiting from the constant development and
evolution of VSL’s technologies. VORTEX SHEDDING
Alternating asymmetrical vortex detachment induces a lift force perpendicular to the direction of the wind and
hence vibrations of the cable.
2 V S L D A M P I N G S Y S T E M S F O R S T AY C A B L E S
VSL SOLUTIONS
FOR VIBRATION CONTROL
Modelling of vibration effects Methods of controlling vibrations
Today’s recommendations for stay cables Modern cable-stayed structures have to VSL’s services:
issued by the various international bodies accommodate increased dynamic demands on • Stability risk analysis
require a project-specific assessment of the their cables. VSL’s response to this requirement • Proposal of mitigation measures,
dynamic effects. However, the mechanisms of includes use of the following devices: including provision of dampers
dynamic excitation are particularly complex • Estimation of the behaviour of the
phenomena and their reliable prediction is Helical ribs damper-equipped cables, taking into
difficult. VSL uses analytical tools that have The stay pipes of the VSL SSI 2000 cable are account excitation by aerodynamic effects
been developed in collaboration with supplied with helical ribs. Their shape and and structural coupling
internationally-renowned experts in the field. dimensions have been optimised and validated • Design, fabrication, workshop testing,
These tools simulate the cable’s response in wind tunnel tests for effective control of the supply and installation of a choice of two
under combined excitation effects while risk of rain-wind induced vibrations while different damping systems
applying different stability criteria that allow minimising the increase in wind drag. • Full integration of two different damper
estimation of the vibration risks and any types into the VSL SSI 2000 system either
additional damping required. Additional damping devices at the time of installation or for
VSL can therefore assist the designer in The most versatile means of controlling installation at a later stage (retrofitting)
assessing the risk of cable vibrations and can vibrations is to increase the structural • Retrofitting solutions for existing strand
propose suitable mitigation measures based damping ratio of the cable by installing and parallel wire cables
on a modular approach. additional damping devices. VSL offers two • Fine-tuning of damping devices after
types of dampers: the VSL Friction damper and installation to match the actual
the VSL VE damper. This permits selection of characteristics of cable and structure
the most appropriate damping behaviour to
suit the characteristics of each individual
cable. The VSL VE damper is further available number of moveable parts. The two dampers
in two grades, «Standard» and «High complement each other and allow
performance». implementation of the most appropriate
In addition to their high efficiency, the common solution, taking account of the characteristics
qualities of both damping systems are their of the stay cables, the types of critical
adaptability, their great durability and their low vibrations and the required performance. Both
maintenance costs, achieved by minimising the systems can be used on the same structure.
Simulation of cable amplitudes for an undamped cable
under parametric excitation
The required additional
damping ratio is
Testing defined for each
The behaviour of VSL Dampers and the structure on a case-by-
correlation of calculated and actual cable case basis and lies
oscillations have been verified in several typically below 1%.
full-scale tests. The effectiveness of the The achievable
damper can be assessed by measuring the damping ratio can be
cable acceleration over time and comparing defined as a function
the results with and without the damper. of x/L, where x is the
Validation of damper modelling position of the damper
in a laboratory test from the anchorage
relative to the cable
length L. The graph
above can be used to select the appropriate damper type depending on the achievable x/L.
The damper is typically located close to the deck anchorage for improved accessibility and
aesthetics. For special cases, an additional damper can be provided near the pylon anchorage.
V S L D A M P I N G S Y S T E M S F O R S T AY C A B L E S 3
VSL DAMPERS – COMMON FEATURES WI
Two systems cover the full range
of requirements VSL Friction
In general, VSL Friction dampers are more suitable for
damper
long cables, whereas VSL VE dampers are more
suitable for short and medium length cables.
The final selection of the most appropriate system is
made by VSL using analytical tools that have been
developed in collaboration with internationally-
renowned experts in the field.
Protective collar
The moving part of the damper connects
to the stay cable using a collar fitted with
a protective neoprene ring to ensure lasting
protection of the cable’s main tensile element.
4 V S L D A M P I N G S Y S T E M S F O R S T AY C A B L E S
TH COMPLEMENTARY CHARACTERISTICS
VSL VE
damper
V S L D A M P I N G S Y S T E M S F O R S T AY C A B L E S 5
THE VSL FRICTION DAMPER – HOW IT
Dissipating energy through friction Composite Oscillating
The VSL Friction damper applies the same
principles used in disc brakes, dissipating the
pad movement Sliding
energy through friction generated between two disc
friction partners. The first is a pair of sliding
discs which is connected via a collar to the Collar
tensile member of the stay. It is sandwiched by
the second partner, which consists of a
specially developed composite pad supported
by a pair of spring blades that are connected
to the external structure of the guide pipe.
High performance
and outstanding efficiency
The VSL Friction damper provides high
performance for critical cases or where the
damper has to be placed close to the deck
anchorage relative to the overall length
of the cable.
The required stiffness of the spring blades to Spring
generate the appropriate friction force depends
on the dynamic characteristics of the cable. blades
This allows easy adaptation to all cable sizes,
whether for a new installation or as part
of a retrofitting solution.
Unaffected by temperature
The damper’s insensitivity to temperature
changes results in friction characteristics that
are very stable throughout a wide temperature
range. The chosen materials ensure well-
controlled behaviour with no stick-slip effect at
the friction interface.
The force acting on the damper when it is This is a very efficient method for preventing
activated has initially to exceed the static excessive wear of the friction surfaces without
friction before the friction partners start affecting the damper’s performance.
moving relative to each other. Inspections of installed dampers after several
years of operation have clearly demonstrated
There is no movement of the damper arising this beneficial effect.
from the non-critical continuous vibration of
the cable with the small displacements that
traffic and other effects cause on every cable-
stayed structure.
Friction damper installed prior to covering
with anti-vandalism protection
6 V S L D A M P I N G S Y S T E M S F O R S T AY C A B L E S
WORKS
Perfectly tuned for critical vibrations comfort of the user at the same time as having Efficient at all vibration modes
Various theoretical approaches have been an Eigen frequency close to that of the First mode modal component
developed in an attempt to estimate the structure. This brings the risk of coupling
achievable damping of a stay cable equipped effects between the structure and cable, which
with a damper installed near one anchorage. could prove catastrophic.
One result that is widely acknowledged shows
the existence of a limitation, and can be Activated only when needed
expressed as (Kovacs 1982): In addition to this outstanding performance, the
damper’s characteristics are particularly suited
or to stay cables. The initial effect of static friction
prevents activation of the damper under small
The example shows the calculated modal response of a specific stay cable
susceptible to rain-wind induced vibrations resulting in instability over a
typical 10min period. The same cable equipped with a VSL Friction damper
does not experience instability over the same period.
V S L D A M P I N G S Y S T E M S F O R S T AY C A B L E S 7
THE VSL FRICTION DAMPER – HOW IT
Close to the anchorage:
The low x/L ratio required by the VSL Friction
damping ξmax=x/(2L)
Ratio to maximal theoretical
damper and its compact body mean that it can
be positioned close to the deck anchorage and VSL Friction Damper
easily integrated into the anti-vandalism
protection near deck level. The result is an ] Various viscous dampers
available in the market
1% Amplitude of vibration
expressed as a ratio
of the cable length
Based on the high performance measured during several full-scale tests, the VSL Friction
damper can be considered amongst the most efficient passive damping devices for mitigation
The damper is fully integrated into the anti-vandalism cover.
of stay cable vibration (Cable Dynamic Symposium Vienna 2007, proceedings, Behavior
Comparison of Cable Dampers by Full-Scale Experiment, S.S. Ahn, J.H. Park, S.H. Lee, C.M. Park).
Performances have surpassed 100% of the theoretical maximum damping that can be provided
by a passive damping system to a stay cable.
8 V S L D A M P I N G S Y S T E M S F O R S T AY C A B L E S
WORKS
Adjustable damping capacity
The contact force of the pads is controlled by
elastic deformation of the spring blades.
Varying the stiffness of the blades allows
adjustment of the damping characteristics for
each installation.
Indicative dimensions of the VSL Friction dampers, for each anchorage size in the VSL SSI 2000 stay cable system brochure
type L1 min DR* L1 min DS* L2** Ø1** Ø2 DR* Ø2 DS*
6-12 1500 900 200 430 219.1 x 6.3 177.8 x 4.5
6-19 1750 1200 200 450 267 x 6.3 219.1 x 6.3
6-22 1900 1350 220 470 298.5 x 6.3 219.1 x 6.3
6-31 2100 1550 220 505 323.9 x 6.3 244.5 x 6.3
6-37 2300 1750 250 545 355.6 x 6.3 273 x 6.3
6-43 2550 2000 250 585 406.4 x 8.8 323.9 x 7.1
6-55 2650 2050 250 610 419 x 10 323.9 x 7.1
6-61 2850 2250 280 630 419 x 10 355.6 x 8
6-73 3050 2450 300 650 508 x 11 406.4 x 8.8
6-85 3150 2600 300 680 508 x 11 406.4 x 8.8
6-91 3400 2800 300 700 559 x 12.5 457 x 10
6-109 3550 3000 400 730 559 x 12.5 457 x 10
6-127 3950 3350 400 740 610 x 12.5 508 x 11
Dimensions noted in millimetres. * DR refers to the use of adjustable anchorage at the damper location level, while DS refers to the use of fixed anchorage.
Other sizes available on request. ** These dimensions are given for indication only. They must be adapted according to specificities of the project.
For larger sizes please contact your local VSL representative.
V S L D A M P I N G S Y S T E M S F O R S T AY C A B L E S 9
THE VSL VE DAMPER – HOW IT WORKS
Shear deformation Oscillating
of high damping rubber
The heart of the VSL VE Damper is a high
movement
damping rubber material which dissipates the Moveable
kinetic energy of the vibration by shear
deformation of specially-designed pads. Each collar
damper consists of a series of pads mounted
between a moveable collar attached to the
tensile element of the stay cable and a fixed
support rigidly connected to the guide pipe.
The damper’s characteristics are adjusted for
each structure by varying the number of pads
and choosing between two pad types, «high
performance» and «standard». The HDR can
withstand large shear deformations and can
also cater for significant deformation under
tension or compression without affecting its
damping properties. This allows longitudinal
movements between the cable and support to
VE
be accommodated entirely within the HDR, pads
which avoids the need for additional hinged or
sliding interfaces that would affect the
damping ratio.
Fixed support
connected to
guide pipe
10 V S L D A M P I N G S Y S T E M S F O R S T AY C A B L E S
Independent of vibration mode Time-displacement curves as recorded during VSL VE damper testing
and amplitude
The behaviour of the VSL VE damper can be First mode of vibration
modelled as a combined device consisting of a
spring, a friction member and a viscous
element all contained in the HDR pad. This
makes the damping performance of the
VSL VE damper largely independent of the
vibration mode and the amplitude. The time-
displacement curves recorded from full-scale
tests clearly illustrate this behaviour.
V S L D A M P I N G S Y S T E M S F O R S T AY C A B L E S 11
THE VSL VE DAMPER – HOW IT WORKS
Full-scale test results
As well as laboratory testing, numerous full-
scale in-situ tests have been carried out to
assess the VSL VE damper’s performance and
the characteristics of the HDR component
under varying environmental conditions.
The pads have been subjected in laboratory
tests to fatigue loading where they had to
sustain 10Mio load cycles. To assess their
durability, accelerated ageing tests have been
carried out, from which a life expectancy has
been derived that is in excess of 60 years
without deterioration of the mechanical
properties.
The VE pad:
the heart of the VSL
VE damper
12 V S L D A M P I N G S Y S T E M S F O R S T AY C A B L E S
Highly deformable
The damper pads, including the interface
between the HDR and the mounting plates,
have been designed to accommodate large
deformations without damage. The dissipated
energy per shear cycle even increases with
increasing deformation. The maximum
permissible deformation is considerably in
excess of the actual movements occurring in
the damper. This results in very high durability Hysteresis of a VSL VE damper
«standard» pad under varying
and fatigue resistance. shear displacement
Indicative dimensions of the VSL VE dampers, for each anchorage size in the VSL SSI 2000 stay cable system brochure
type L1 min DR* L1 min DS* L2 Ø1** Ø2 DR* Ø2 DS*
6-12 1500 900 200 410 219.1 x 6.3 177.8 x 4.5
6-19 1750 1200 200 430 267 x 6.3 219.1 x 6.3
6-22 1900 1350 200 450 298.5 x 6.3 219.1 x 6.3
6-31 2100 1550 220 470 323.9 x 6.3 244.5 x 6.3
6-37 2300 1750 220 470 355.6 x 6.3 273 x 6.3
6-43 2550 2000 240 490 406.4 x 8.8 323.9 x 7.1
6-55 2650 2050 240 510 419 x 10 323.9 x 7.1
6-61 2850 2250 260 530 419 x 10 355.6 x 8
6-73 3050 2450 260 530 508 x 11 406.4 x 8.8
6-85 3150 2600 270 560 508 x 11 406.4 x 8.8
6-91 3400 2800 270 570 559 x 12.5 457 x 10
6-109 3550 3000 290 600 559 x 12.5 457 x 10
6-127 3950 3350 300 620 610 x 12.5 508 x 11
Dimensions noted in millimetres. * DR refers to the use of adjustable anchorage at the damper location level, while DS refers to the use of fixed anchorage.
Other sizes available on request. ** These dimensions are given for indication only. They must be adapted according to specificities of the project.
For larger sizes please contact your local VSL representative.
V S L D A M P I N G S Y S T E M S F O R S T AY C A B L E S 13
APPLICATIONS
Uddevalla Bridge, Sweden - 1998
Badajoz Bridge,
Spain - 1996
14 V S L D A M P I N G S Y S T E M S F O R S T AY C A B L E S
GROUND ENGINEERING
Offshore
structures
REPAIR, STRENGTHENING
& PRESERVATION
LNG & LPG
containments
36.25
Structural
3178.25
diagnostics
& Monitoring
Heavy lifting
Repair &
Strengthening
Formwork &
Creating sustainable solutions Equipment
www.vsl.com
V S L D A M P I N G S Y S T E M S F O R S T AY C A B L E S 15
VSL LOCATIONS
Headquarters
VSL International Ltd. Middle East /
Sägestrasse 76
CH-3098 Köniz SULTANATE OF OMAN MALAYSIA
Switzerland VSL Muscat LLC VSL Engineers (M) Sdn. Bhd.
MUSCAT KUALA LUMPUR
Phone: +41 58 456 30 00 Phone: +971 4 885 7225 Phone: +603 7981 47 42
[email protected] Africa / UNITED ARAB EMIRATES PHILIPPINES
VSL Middle East LLC VSL Philippines Inc.
EGYPT PORTUGAL MANDALUYONG CITY
VSL Sistemas Portugal SA DUBAI, UAE
VSL Egypt Phone: +971 4 885 0004 Phone: +632 722 1703
CAIRO PAÇO DE ARCOS
Phone: +351 21 445 83 10
Americas / Phone: +20 2 344 19 00 DOHA, QATAR
Phone: +974 44 052 444
SINGAPORE
VSL Singapore Pte. Ltd.
Delegação Norte
SOUTH AFRICA VILA NOVA DE GAIA SINGAPORE
ARGENTINA VSL Construction Solutions (Pty) Ltd Phone: +65 6559 12 22
VSL Sistemas Especiales de Phone: + 351 22 371 18 80
JOHANNESBURG
Construcción Argentina SA Phone: +010 492 1811 SPAIN
Asia / TAIWAN
BUENOS AIRES VSL Taiwan Ltd.
Phone: +54 11 5272 87 52 TUNISIA VSL Construction Systems SA
BARCELONA BRUNEI TAIPEI
VSL Tunisia VSL Systems (B) Sdn. Bhd. Phone: +886 2 2759 6819
BOLIVIA TUNIS Phone: +34 93 289 23 30
BRUNEI DARUSSALAM
Postensados de Bolivia Phone: +216 70 72 84 73 Phone: +673 2 380 153 / 381 827 THAILAND
SAN MIGUEL, LA PAZ
SWEDEN
Internordisk Spännarmering AB VSL (Thailand) Co. Ltd.
Phone: +591 2 27 70 338
VÄSTERHANINGE CHINA PRC BANGKOK
VSL Engineering Corp., Ltd.
BRAZIL Europe / Phone: +46 10 448 11 42
(China)
Phone: +66 2 679 76 15 - 19
VSL Brasil Construção e SWITZERLAND HEFEI VIETNAM
Recuperação Ltda AUSTRIA VSL (Switzerland) Ltd. Phone: +86 551 382 29 18 VSL Vietnam Ltd.
SÃO PAULO Grund-Pfahl- und Sonderbau HANOI
SUBINGEN
Phone: +55 113 521 7153/4 GmbH
Phone: +41 58 456 30 30 HONG KONG Phone: +84 4 3976 5088
HIMBERG VSL Hong Kong Ltd.
CANADA Phone: +43 2235 87 777 SAINT LEGIER CHAI WAN HO CHI MINH CITY
CTT Stronghold Canada Phone: +41 58 456 30 00 Phone: +852 2590 22 88 Phone: +84 8 810 6817
TORONTO CZECH REPUBLIC
Phone: +1 416 477 1042 VSL Systémy / CZ / s.r.o TURKEY INDIA
PRAGUE VSL India Private Ltd.
CHILE Phone: +420 2 51 09 16 80
Mega Yapi Construction &
Trade Co. Ltd CHENNAI Australia /
VSL Sistemas Especiales de ANKARA Phone: +91 44 4225 11 11
Construcción S.A. FRANCE Phone: +90 312 490 90 66 VSL Australia Pty. Ltd.
SANTIAGO VSL France S.A. (Bouygues TPRF) INDONESIA NEW SOUTH WALES
Phone: +56 2 2571 6700 LABÈGE UNITED KINGDOM PT VSL Indonesia Phone: +61 2 9484 5944
Phone: +33 5 33 65 96 59 VSL System (UK) Ltd. JAKARTA
LUTON Phone: +62 21 570 07 86 QUEENSLAND
COLOMBIA GERMANY Phone: +44 148 040 4401 Phone: +61 7 3327 0200
Sistemas Especiales de
Construcción S.A.S
VSL Systems GmbH JAPAN VICTORIA
BERLIN VSL Japan Corporation
BOGOTA Phone: +61 3 979 503 66
Phone: +41 58 456 30 30 TOKYO
Phone: +57 1 226 6230
Phone: +81 3 3346 8913 SOUTH AUSTRALIA
NETHERLANDS Phone: +61 8 8252 1900
MEXICO Heijmans Civiel b.v. KOREA
VSL Corporation Mexico S.A de C.V Span en Verplaatsingstechnieken VSL Korea Co. Ltd. TASMANIA
MEXICO SEOUL Phone: +61 3 6249 3044
ROSMALEN
Phone: +52 55 55 11 20 36 Phone: +82 2 553 8200
Phone: +31 73 543 6611
PERTH
PERU NORWAY Phone: +61 8 9419 1119
Sistemas Especiales de Construcción Spennarmering Norge AS
Peru S.A. RUD
LIMA Phone: +47 98 21 02 31
Phone: +51 1 349 38 38
POLAND
VSL Peru S.A.C VSL Polska Sp. Zo. o
LIMA WARSZAWA
Phone: +51 1 713 98 32 Phone: +48 22849 22 09 VSL Infrastructure Protection Ltd. Intrafor Hong Kong Ltd. FT Laboratories Ltd.
LONDON CHAI WAN, HONG KONG PING CHE, HONG KONG
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA Phone: +44 207 803 3614 Phone: +852 2836 31 12 Phone: +852 2758 48 61
VStructural LLC SINGAPORE DUBAI, UAE
BALTIMORE, MD Phone: +65 65 59 12 22 Phone: +971 4 885 7225
Phone: +1 410 850 7000 VSL Offshore Pte Ltd.
SYDNEY SINGAPORE
Phone: +61 2 94 84 5944 Phone: +65 65 59 13 05
The information set forth in this brochure including technical and engineering data is presented
for general information only. While every effort has been made to insure its accuracy, this
information should not be used or relied upon for any specific application without independent
professional examination and verification of its accuracy, suitability and applicability. Anyone
using this material assumes any and all liability resulting from such use. VSL disclaims any and
all express or implied warranties of merchantability fitness for any general or particular purpose
Printed on paper or freedom from infringement of any patent, trademark, or copyright in regard to the information
from sustainably or products contained or referred to herein. Nothing herein contained shall be construed as
managed forests. granting a license, express or implied under any patents.