Green Marketing: A Challenge or An Opportunity in The Global Environment
Green Marketing: A Challenge or An Opportunity in The Global Environment
Green Marketing: A Challenge or An Opportunity in The Global Environment
Research Online
University of Wollongong in Dubai - Papers University of Wollongong in Dubai
2009
Pradeep K. Khandelwal
Institute of Management Technology
Publication Details
Saxena, R. P. & Khandelwal, P. K. 2009, 'Green marketing: a challenge or an opportunity in the global environment', Global Studies
Journal, vol. 2, no. 3, pp. 59-73.
Abstract: The earlier perception of industry towards green marketing was that the pressure for making
business environment green and behaving in a more responsible manner especially comes from Gov-
ernment and its legislations. Now that old perception is changing throughout the globe as studies
performed on consumers reflect that in most countries consumers are becoming more aware and
willing to act on environmental concerns. There is a radical change in consumer preferences and life
styles. They prefer environment friendly products over the others and many times are ready to pay a
little extra price for such green products. Due to this shift from traditional marketing to green marketing,
companies these days are facing many new challenges. This can also be viewed as a source of new
opportunities to grow in today’s highly competitive global environment. A 2008 survey by the National
Geographic Society and GlobScan on consumer choice and the environment reported on current be-
havior in fourteen countries (including Canada, China, France, Germany, India, Mexico, Russia, the
UK and the US). The study found signs that consumer in all countries “feel empowered when it comes
to the environment and are taking some action in their daily lives to reduce consumption and waste.”
A global Synovate survey conducted in 2007 in association with Aegis, and repeated in 2008 in asso-
ciation with BBC World, also found that consumers in most countries are becoming more aware and
willing to act on environmental concerns. Most of such studies on green philosophy and green marketing
are done in developed countries but such studies however, remain conspicuously missing in the context
of developing economies like India. The present study discusses the concept of green marketing and
its interface with consumers in India. A field survey of consumers was conducted to understand their
perception towards green marketing and preference for green products. The data collected was analyzed
by using the T-test and One Way ANOVA. The results of the study are highly relevant in this challenging
era of liberalization and globalization and can be used by industries for exploring and exploiting new
opportunities. This study also provides future direction to researchers in the field of green marketing.
Keywords: Green Philosophy, Green Marketing, Green Companies, Green Brands, Green Consumers,
Sustainable Development, Competitive Advantage, Corporate Social Responsibility
Introduction
G
OING GREEN SEEMS to be the way to go these days. The book “Green Marketing
Manifesto” written by John grant states that “We are currently eating, sleeping and
breathing a new found religion of everything ‘green’. At the very heart of respons-
ibility is industry and commerce, everyone is now racing to create their ‘environ-
mental’ business strategy. In line with this awareness, there is much discussion about the
‘green marketing opportunity’ as a means of jumping on this bandwagon.”
“The Growth of Green Marketing” an article contributed by Smart blog to the special
section of the Reno News & Review , states that “Today’s consumers are increasingly socially
conscious, with a growing concern to know if companies honestly treat employees fairly
while doing their part to protect and save the environment. Brand values like social respons-
ibility, benefit to the community, and “being green” are at the top of more shopping lists
than ever. Not unsurprisingly, enthusiasts of technology are leading the way.”
Today’s “green marketing” offers a unique set of challenges; the least of which is a pre-
valent lack of standards for identifying what it actually means to be a “green” product or
company. In combination with the increase in consumer awareness, marketers are seeing a
growing demand for eco-labeling, “green” advertising and the overall importance of reporting
on sustainability and renewable energy oriented products and projects. This obviously has
created a glut of misguided opportunities to nearly everything to be positioned as being
“green”, from a minor packaging change to actual services and products that truly reduce
energy and waste.
“Green marketing” isn’t merely a catchphrase; it’s a marketing strategy that can help you
get more customers and make more money. As in any marketing effort — the challenge is
doing it right the first time. With a struggling economy forcing businesses and consumers
to cut back on spending, marketers are more hard pressed than ever to find new, innovative
ways to pitch their product or service.
60
RAVINDRA P. SAXENA, PRADEEP K. KHANDELWAL
offering better value to consumers in the form of green products to use and a green environ-
ment to live.
Energy conservation is one of the major areas IBM is focusing on by working on smart
energy solutions globally. They are working towards “A Smarter Planet” which is also the
name of their campaign for making the planet green. Similarly, Philips has decided to analyze
their environmental activities by participating in the “green electronics” campaign initiated
by Greenpeace, a global non-governmental organization. In 2007, Philips unveiled their
sustainability agenda, Eco Vision, which focuses on improving the energy efficiency of its
products. Recently, the company launched 91 green products and in 2008, 25 % of their total
sales were from the eco-friendly products. They intend to increase this number to 30 % by
2012. Also, to add to their environmental drive, Philips announced a recycling system in
several countries. With the help of their partners they intend to integrate environmental costs
with their product prices, which means cost reduction and a safer planet (Gulf News, Sunday,
May31’ 2009).
We may find hundreds of such examples from companies and brands who are making
headway in this difficult arena, such as Marks & Spencer, McDonald’s, Sky, Virgin, Toyota,
Tesco, O2 to realize the potential of green marketing and green philosophy that the future
needs to embrace. The recently published Forrester study titled “Making the Case for Envir-
onmentally and Socially Responsible Consumer Products” states the findings of a survey
conducted between April and May of 2008, including over 5,400 U.S. adults asking about
their purchasing habits. Surprisingly, 65% of these consumers confirmed that they are highly
concerned about the environment or issues of global warming (this trend is up nearly 23%
from a November’ 2007 study). Also findings of this study reveal that 53% of these consumers
were concerned about sustainability. In short, we can state that the businesses that understood
this unique opportunity of becoming green and have been quick to leverage this philosophy
with their products and value chain are more successful than others.
As one aspect of green marketing ensures lot of new opportunities for sustainable con-
sumption and sustainable development, the other aspect reflects numerous challenges to
corporate. Bill Roth says in his MSNBC column (Entrepreneur.com) that green marketing
is full of challenges including a lack of standards determining what it means to be a green
product or green company and total cost of entry into the market by practicing green philo-
sophy. According to a survey of marketing managers at Eloqua’s user conference, two of
top factors preventing organizations from taking a shot at green marketing are a lack of
awareness and costs. Though market entry may be a challenge, nearly 60% of respondents
said they believe green marketing can provide a competitive advantage and 90% think the
industry has a responsibility to become more environmentally friendly. According to a recent
review of S&P 100 companies, industries that were once under high levels of government
regulation and public scrutiny in the past tend to have the most effective sustainable growth.
“The bottom line is that from challenges comes opportunity”.
It is only since 1990’s that the researchers have started academically analyzing consumers
and industry’s attitude towards green marketing, and providing guidelines to industries to
save cost on resources, recycle waste, adapt sustainable technologies, practicing green
philosophy and transforming into a green company to gain competitive advantage and sus-
tainable growth. But, most of such studies are done in the context of developed countries
and such studies however, remain conspicuously missing in the context of developing nations
like India. This research is an attempt to fill some gap in this discipline in the developing
61
THE GLOBAL STUDIES JOURNAL
countries. The present exploratory research discusses the concept of green marketing and
its interface with consumers. The study is based on the data collected through a field survey
of consumers to understand their behavior towards green marketing and green products.
Review of Literature
During the last two decades the burgeoning environmental movement was named as the
“green movement”; environmentally aware consumers called the “green consumers”, product
designed to protect the environment called the “green products” and marketing that uses the
environmental claims called the “green marketing” (Peattie,1997). According to the authors
like Ottaman, (1993) and Ken Peattie, (1993) conventional marketing is out and Green
Marketing is in.
According to Hawken (Ecology of Commerce, 1995) business has three issues to face.
These are what it takes, what it makes and what it wastes. What it takes is materials from
the environment, (its ecosystem) through extracting, mining, cutting, hunting and other
means. What it makes is the products of commerce, goods and services that are derived from
the natural environment through the process of conversion and transformation. What it wastes
represents eco-costs arising from garbage, pollution and destruction of natural systems,
which are the consequences of taking and making processes. And these costs are not intern-
alized in most of the accounting systems so far.
The critical importance of industrial greening, in particular, is highlighted by a consider-
ation of the factors that contribute to large-scale environmental deterioration. Environmental
Impact equals a product of population (P), time’s affluence (A), time’s technology (T)
(Ehrlich and Ehrlich 1991).
I=PxAxT
P and A are socio-political phenomena and are beyond the control of an industry or business.
However, technology co-efficient is controllable. Technology applications reflect consumption
of resources in qualitative and quantitative terms, energy used and the efficiency level of
production & marketing and disposal of wastes. These are controllable technology decisions
that can increase or reduce eco-costs. The goal is to reduce the use of unsustainable techno-
logies and increase the use of clean technologies so that in the long run T is reduced to Zero
which theoretically means I (environmental impact) would be Zero at any quantity of P and
A.
It is predicted that the future markets would be directly linked to the development, transfer
and implementation of eco-friendly technologies, referred to as Environmental Technologies
(ET). All kinds of ET are available now. Also, technology has made available substitutes,
which are less resource intensive, for example, Copper has been substituted by fiber optic
cables in telecommunication industry, thus reducing the demand for copper as well impact
on environment associated with copper mining. IBM is in the process of developing ‘smart
grids’, which will bring into effect smart energy management, which is crucial for the reduc-
tion of greenhouse emissions. Additionally, it will provide reliable usage information to
consumers. The Beacon Institute in New York has collaborated with IBM to position floating
sensors in the Hudson River to monitor how the river reacts in different situations and thus
conserving water by using the optimized solution, an excellent example of CSR. In Germany,
62
RAVINDRA P. SAXENA, PRADEEP K. KHANDELWAL
an energy provider works with IBM to provide customers with pricing information, as it alters
during the day. This allows the customers to modify their consumption behavior in order to
utilize the least amount of power during peak hours. In addition to the customers saving
money, it reduces consumers billing complaints, a classic example of green marketing.
Greening product or market is viewed as the outcome of rational strategic choice. It may
thus involve the search for different types of competitive advantage (Gladwin, 1992a). As
a result of staggering pollution levels and the diversity of environmental concerns, a wide
range of pressures is coming to bear upon industry/firms from many sides. The intensity of
these pressures varies by country, sector, industry and firm. It is clear, however, that firms
need to respond in order to ensure further use of scarce resources, public and political legit-
imacy, profitability and financial assurance (Schot, Johan & Fisher, Kurt 1993). These green
pressure groups can be classified as follows, which poses challenges to industries :
Customers Pressure: Consumers are increasingly better informed and becoming aware
of the environmental impact of consumer products and are thus demanding that industry
improves the environmental performance of its products. Today consumers are more
enlightened and especially in developed countries, they even seek for sustainable devel-
opment for their children.
Government Pressure: The threat of tougher legislation and the rising costs of com-
plying with environmental regulations and penalties in case of noncompliance are
possible motivating factors for firms to incorporate environmental concerns in their
strategies (Banerjee 1998). In India the Governments enacted laws concerning pollution
control and environmental protection, including Environment (Protection) Act 1986,
the Air (Prevention & Control of Pollution) Act 1981 & the Water (Prevention &
Control of Pollution) Act 1974. While environmental legislation represents the main
pressure, increasing costs associated with managing emissions are also an important
factor. Legislation can lead to different degrees of corporate environmentalism, depend-
ing on the level of strategy in which the firm includes environmental concerns. At a
purely functional level, responses to legislative pressure can mean complying with ex-
isting regulations. At a higher corporate level of strategy, threat of environmental legis-
lation and liability could influence decision on new business opportunities.
63
THE GLOBAL STUDIES JOURNAL
Employees Pressure: The interests and aspiration of the work force of trade unions
represent potential pressure resulting in lies a strong interest in the environmental per-
formance and health and safety aspects of the plant.
64
RAVINDRA P. SAXENA, PRADEEP K. KHANDELWAL
the Marketing Intelligence Service (Consumer Reports, 1991), which tracks new product
introductions, reports that the percentage of new packaged products making some kind of
green claim more than doubled between 1989 and 1990, rising from 4.5% to 11.4% of the
total. During the same year, the number of green advertisements appearing on television and
in major print outlets more than quadrupled, according to an audit by the advertising agency
J. Walter Thompson (Consumer Reports, 1991).
It is a fact that most studies on green consumers and green marketing have been carried
out in developed countries and only a few of them originate from developing countries. Such
studies are conspicuously lacking in the Indian context. It is against this backdrop that a
survey of Indian Consumers was carried out to know their perception towards green market-
ing. Whether, the companies in developing countries like India could also gain competitive
advantage by following the philosophy of green marketing and practicing the green business
strategies.
Methodology
Premise of this study is based on four assumptions (hypothesis) based on the above literature
review, that these days consumers prefer green products over non-green (grey) products;
their awareness for environmental concerns is high; they feel in future more and more people
will prefer green products as their attitude for consumption is changing; and companies who
practice green philosophy will have better opportunities for sustainable growth.
Exploratory research design is used to set and test the above hypothesis. A structured
questionnaire was executed on 400 consumers and a five point balanced Likert Scale was
used for understanding consumer behavior towards green marketing and green brands.
Cronbach Alpha Index has been used for checking the validity and reliability of hypothesis
and corresponding questions in the questionnaire. It was found that the set four hypotheses
are reliable on the basis of their respective Cronbach alpha value. The internal consistency
of data has been very high as Cronbach alpha value for all the hypothesis was found on the
upper side. Non probability approach of sampling was adopted by the researchers, and a
combination of Judgment and convenience sampling was used for selecting the subjects to
ensure the heterogeneity in the sample i.e. to include the respondents of both genders and
their marital status, different age groups, education level, income level, occupation and
residing areas. Out of the total sample of 400 consumers, researchers found 321 responses
valid to include in the study. Collected data was analyzed by using Parametric Tests (inde-
pendent samples equal variance-T Test).
65
THE GLOBAL STUDIES JOURNAL
attitude towards green products and green marketing. To measure this variation Co-efficient
of variation can be calculated and compared to understand the difference in the attitude of
males and females, and similarly for married and unmarried. One way ANOVA can be applied
on different age groups, income levels, education levels and location categories to measure
the difference in attitude between the bands in each demographic variable. Profiling of re-
spondents is the future scope of our study, and is not performed in this study.
66
RAVINDRA P. SAXENA, PRADEEP K. KHANDELWAL
67
THE GLOBAL STUDIES JOURNAL
68
RAVINDRA P. SAXENA, PRADEEP K. KHANDELWAL
Results
Levene’s test for equality of variances (t-test) indicates that results are highly significant at
1% for all the four hypothesis. From the above statistics we will observe that for each hypo-
thesis p-value is 0.0 even less than 0.01, and t-calculated is much higher as compared to t
critical at 1% (2.326), hence in each case null hypothesis (H0) is rejected and alternate hy-
pothesis (H1) is supported.
69
THE GLOBAL STUDIES JOURNAL
The above results of the study provide strong evidence to conclude that these days’ con-
sumers prefer green products over non-green (grey) products (H1). Their awareness and
concern for environment protection is high (H2). They believe in future more and more
people will prefer green products (H3). Also, they feel that in future the companies who
practice green philosophy will have better opportunities for sustainable growth (H4).
Conclusion
In today’s global environment “green marketing” offers a unique set of challenges and ample
opportunities. It is quite evident from the above findings and discussions that consumers
these days are more aware and concerned about environmental protection and in general
their preferences are changing from non-green to green products. Also, they are of the
opinion that in future preference and consumption of green products will increase and com-
panies who follow the green philosophy will enjoy distinctive advantage in the market and
will register sustainable growth in today’s highly competitive global environment.
With the increase in consumer awareness about green revolution and their changing attitude
from non-green to green products, marketers are seeing a growing demand for eco-labeling,
green products, green advertising and the overall importance of energy conservation and
renewable energy oriented products and projects. These days, throughout the globe so many
new and old companies jump on the “green philosophy” bandwagon. We all know the success
story of McDonald’s whose growth worldwide continues due to its timely strategic changes
and adapting to changing customer needs. It faced severe challenges at different times, and
has evolved successfully with the health food revolution, launching dozens of new products
and moving toward environmentally-safe packaging and recyclable goods. GE’s “Ecomagin-
ation” campaign shown a spotlight on leading edge technologies, and in doing so, provided
tangible evidence to customers, investors, employees and other stakeholders that the GE is
making progress in a way that will help the environment and the bottom line. DuPont known
as America’s worst polluter in 20th century, is now transforming itself from a down-and-
dirty oil-and-chemicals business into a 21st century, eco-friendly life sciences firm. Dell’s
initiative of recycling computers and message to its customers states “Friendly to the envir-
onment. Friendly to your wallet”, it is another example of company’s efforts for sustainable
growth, generating profits while saving the planet. This new era of globalization, at one end
creates several challenges for industries but at the other end presents an array of opportunities,
where correct, appropriate and timely strategic decisions in practicing green philosophy may
lead a company towards sustainable growth.
70
RAVINDRA P. SAXENA, PRADEEP K. KHANDELWAL
countries. Also, studies can be performed to assess consumers’ price sensitivity in accepting
green products. Studies relating to measure the influence of green branding, green packaging,
green labeling and green advertising on consumer behavior can be performed in different
Nations. As of now, a very limited literature on such researches is available in developing
countries, being this concept relatively not much old in these nations; therefore authors feel
that there is immense scope for further research in this field on consumers and industries
across different sectors and segments.
References
Azzone, Giovanni and Raffaella, Manzini (1994). Measuring Strategic Environmental Performance.
Business Strategy and the Environment, Vol. 3, No. 1, pp1-14.
Buchholz, Rogene (1991).Corporate Responsibility and the Good Society: From Economies to Ecology.
Business Horizons, (July – August), pp 19 – 31.
Clarke, Geri (2004). Understanding Green Consumer Behaviour. Journal of Consumer Behaviour,
Vol. 4, pp. 73 – 79.
Coddington, Walter (1990). How to Green Up your Marketing Mix. Advertising Age, Vol. No. 61
(September 3), pp 30.
Crane, A. and Peattie, K.(1999). Has green marketing failed or was it never really tried? Business
Strategy and Environmental Conference Leeds. September 1999.
Crane, Andrew (2000). Facing the Blacklash: Green Marketing and Strategic reorientation In The
1990s. The Journal of Strategic marketing, Vol.8, pp277-296.
Crane, Andrew (2000). Marketing, Morality and the Natural Environment, London: Routledge Pub-
lishing.
Cravens, David W., Gerald E. Hills and Robert B. Woodruff (1987). Marketing Management, Home-
wood, Illinois, Irwin.
Cravens, David W., Piercy Nigel F. (2006). Strategic Marketing (8th Edition), Mc Graw Hill, Interna-
tional Edition
Crosby, Lawrence A, James D. Gill and James R. Taylor (1981). Consumer / Voter Behaviour in the
Passage of the Michigan Container Law, Journal of Marketing, Vol. No. 45 (Spring), pp 19
– 32.
Davis, Joel J (1991). A Blueprint for Green Marketing. Journal of Business Strategy, July/ Aug.
Davis, Joel J (1992). Ethics and Green Marketing. Journal of Business Ethics, Vol.11, No. 2, pp 81-
87.
Davis, John (1994). Green Business: Managing for Sustainable Development, London: Blackwell
Business.
Eco Consumer (2001a). CUTS-CSPAC. Green building, 8(2): May.
Eco Consumer (2001b). CUTS-CSPAC. Eco-fever among corporate, 8(2): May.
Eco Consumer. (2001c).CUTS-CSPAC. Eco-friendly practices could result in cost saving. 9(3): 9.
Econews (1988) CPREEC. Environment. 4 (2). http://cpreec.org/econcern.htm/
Ehrlich, Paul R., and Ehrlich, Anne H. (1991). Healing the Planet: Strategies For Resolving the Envir-
onmental Crisis. Addison-Wesley.
Eisenhart, Tom (1990). There is Gold in that Garbage. Business Marketing, (November), pp 24.
Elkington, J and Hailes, J (1988). The Green Consumer Guide, Victor Gollacez, London.
Fox, Karen F.A. and Philip Kotler (1980). The Marketing of Social Causes: The First Ten Years.
Journal of Marketing, Vol. No. 44 (Fall), pp 24 – 33.
Freeman, R.E.and J.Liedtka (1991). Corporate Social Responsibility: A Critical Approach. Business
Horizons, Vol. 34, No. 4, pp 92-98.
71
THE GLOBAL STUDIES JOURNAL
Gladwin, T.N (1992). The Meaning of Greening: A Plea for Organizational Theory, in Fischer, K. and
Schot, J., (ed.) in Environmental Strategies for Industry. International Perspectives on Re-
search Needs and Policy Implication, Washington D. C: Island Press.
Gladwin, Thomas N (1992), Building the Sustainable Corporation: Creating Environmental Sustainab-
ility and Corporate Advantage. Washington, D.C: National Wildlife Federation Corporate
Conservation Council.
Grant John (2008), “Green marketing Manifesto”, Wiley, john & sons, Inc (ISBN-13:9780470723241).
Hentze, Elizabeth A. (1991). What Is the Corporate Message? Academy of Marketing Science News,
12 (July), pp 12.
Keller, G.M.(1987).Industry and the Environment: Toward a New Philosophy. Vital Speeches Vol.
54, No. 5, pp 154-157.
Kotler, P (1999). Marketing Management: The Millennium Edition, New Delhi: Prentice Hall of India.
Kotler, Philip (1988). Marketing Management, Analysis Planning, Implementation and Control.
Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
Kotler, Philip and Gerald Zaltman (1971). Social Marketing: An Approach to Planned Social Change,
Journal of Marketing, Vol. No.35, (July), pp 3 – 12.
Lodge, George and Jeffrey Rayport (1991). Knee-Deep and Rising: America’s Recycling Crisis. Harvard
Business Review, (September – October), pp 128 – 139.
Love F. John (1995), McDonald’s: Behind the Arches, Bantam Books (ISBN-13:9780553347593).
McCarthy, E. Jerome and William D. Perreault (1984). Basic Marketing. Homewood, Illinois: Richard
D. Irwin, Inc.
McIntosh, Andrew (1990). The Impact of Environmental Issues on Marketing & Politics in the
1990s.Journal of the Marketing Research Society, Vol. 33, No.3, pp205-217.
National Association of Attorneys General (NAAG)(1990). The Green Report: Findings and Preliminary
Recommendations for Responsible Environmental Advertising. Washington, DC: NAAG.
Ottaman, J.A.(1992). Sometimes consumers will pay more to go green. Marketing News, July 6, pp16.
Ottaman, J.A. (1993).Green Marketing: Challenges and Opportunities. NTC: Lincolnwood.
Ottaman, J. A (1998). Green Marketing: Opportunities for Innovation, Illinois: NTC: Lincolnwood.
Pearce, David (1991). Environmentalism and Business, in The Greening of Business. Rhys A. David
(ed), Book field, VT: Growing Publishing Co. pp 1 – 10.
Peattie, K (1995). Environmental Marketing Management, Pitman Publishing, London.
Peattie, K. (1995) Green marketing. M and E Handbooks. London: Pitman Publishing.
Peattie, K. (2001). Golden Goose or Wild Goose? The Hunt for the Green Consumer, Business Strategy
and the Environment, Vol.10, pp187-199.
Porter, Michael E (1991). America’s Green Strategy, Scientific American, (April), pp 168.
Schwartz, Joe and Thomas Miller (1991). The Earth’s Best Friends. American Demographics, (Febru-
ary), pp 26 – 35.
Shearer, Jeffery W. (1990). Business and the New Environmental Imperatives. Business Quarterly,
Vol. 54, No.3, pp 48-52.
Smartblog (April 16, 2009), “The Growth of Green Marketing” (gsmp.ie.edu).
World Commission on Environment and Development (1987). Our Common Future, Oxford: Oxford
University Press.
Zimmer M.R., T.F. Stafford and M.R. Stafford (1994).Green Issues: Dimensions of Environmental
Concern. Journal of Business Research, 30 (1) pp 63-74.
72
RAVINDRA P. SAXENA, PRADEEP K. KHANDELWAL
73