Mushroom Characterization: Part I - Illustrated Morphological Characteristics
Mushroom Characterization: Part I - Illustrated Morphological Characteristics
Mushroom Characterization: Part I - Illustrated Morphological Characteristics
www.creamjournal.org Article
Doi 10.5943/cream/8/5/3
Abstract
Conventional taxonomy of mushrooms is often not very easy for amateur taxonomists and
research scholars to initiate the research on taxonomy and diversity of mushrooms due to the
complex morphological characteristics that is often very difficult to comprehend. We illustrate the
external morphological characteristics of mushrooms through colorful photographs to facilitate the
taxonomic characterization of mushrooms and to promote the research on mushrooms. In addition,
a data sheet for morphological characteristics of agaric mushrooms is provided.
Introduction
It is an endeavor to simplify the morphological characteristics of mushrooms and to make
known to the amateur mycologists beyond a shadow of doubt for easy identification of mushrooms.
Although, several materials and field guides in the form of drawings are available for illustrating
the morphotaxonomy of mushrooms (Largent & Stuntz 1977, Singer 1986, Lodge et al. 2004), still
amateur mushroom taxonomists feel it tiresome to take up initial research on mushrooms due to an
array of mushroom characteristics to be recorded. Further, outsourcing as well as DNA extraction
followed by ITS sequences of mushrooms samples for molecular identification is very expensive.
In addition, the Institutes which provide identification services mostly prefer to sequence the pure
cultures of mushrooms rather than exsiccata since the latter often gets contaminated by other
microbes due to improper storage conditions. Isolation of pure cultures of mushrooms is also
cumbersome and there are stringent requirements for expertise. Further, obtaining pure cultures is
not possible for all the mushrooms. However, identification of mushrooms through conventional
taxonomy cannot be omitted. Mushroom characterization is complicated due to its vast
morphotaxonomic characters which cannot be simply understood. Therefore, we aimed to simplify
the morphological characteristics of mushrooms through color photographs taken in natural habitats
for their easy recognition. This manuscript deals exhaustively with the morphological
characteristics of agarics studied mainly from the Western Ghats, and other regions. Isolation and
Submitted 11 July 2018, Accepted 20 August 2018, Published 12 September 2018
Corresponding Author: Senthilarasu Gunasekaran – e-mail – [email protected] 501
long term preservation, microscopical characteristics, and identification of agarics will be discussed
in future publication.
Collection
Collections should be made between early morning to early or late afternoon to have enough
time for processing (morphological characteristics, spore print, isolation and dehydration) of the
mushrooms after collection. In the field, notes on the general type of habit, habitat, place and date
of collection, geographical coordinates, vegetation, and name of the host plant for ectomycorrhizal
fungi should be recorded in the field note book. Young to mature fruit bodies should be collected
for each species to measure the range of dimensions and color characteristics. Photographs should
be taken to show the mushrooms in their natural habitat. If photography is not possible in the field,
it should be taken either in the laboratory or nearby work station. It is essential to show the
mushroom pileal surface as well as gill views to record the characteristics like color, shape and
texture of the pileus, and type of attachment of the gills with the stipe (Fig. 1). The photographs
should illustrate almost all the external features of the mushrooms.
The samples should be collected in paper bags and brought to the laboratory or work station
for further processing of morphological characterization. Minimal number of species should be
collected to conserve the biodiversity of mushrooms as well as to avoid the wastages of
mushrooms. The perfect identification method should be in the following steps: 1) Collection,
2) Morphological Characterization, 3) Collection of Spore Print, 4) Isolation & Preservation of
502
Pure Cultures, 5) Dehydration and Herbarium Preparation, 6) Microscopical Characterization,
7) Morphotaxonomic Identification and 8) Molecular Characterization. For describing a new
species of mushroom, all the steps are mandatory for authentic identification and finding its
relationship with closely related species.
Size
The measurements of the pileus (generally diameter, and height if the shape is conic,
campanulate and parabolic), stipe (length, width at the widest point, width at the bulbous base, if
any), width of lamellae, thickness of pileal context and height of volva, if any, should be taken in
millimeter to avoid any decimal value when describing morphological characters.
Color
The color characters should be noted using any standard color charts (Kornerup & Wanscher
1978, Ridgway 1912) in natural light conditions for accurate notation of the color. If the color
charts are not available, the HSV Color Plates for Mycology (http://website.nbm-
mnb.ca/mycologywebpages/EssaysOnFungi/Collecting_mushrooms_for_scientific_study/Illustratio
ns/HSV_plates_for_mycology.pdf) may be used. The color of the pileal surface, fibrils or
squamules if any, gills, pileal context and stipe should be recorded. It is also important to note the
color variations of young to mature pileus (Fig. 2) and gills (Fig. 3), color changes of the surface of
the pileus, pileal context, gills or tubes (Fig. 4), surface of the stipe on bruising and hygrophanous
nature (Figs 7B, 16, 21) of the pileus, etc.
Pileus
Umbo
UMBONATE: A protrusion or a bump at the apex of the pileus is called an umbo. The pileus is called
umbonate if an umbo occurs at its apex.
BROADLY UMBONATE: If the protrusion is broadly rounded, it is termed broadly umbonate (Fig.
6C). A small umbo is called subumbonate (Fig. 20A, B).
ACUTELY UMBONATE: If the protrusion is sharp, the pileus is called acutely umbonate (Fig. 6D).
CUSPIDATE: The umbo is sharply demarcated, rounded and elongated, the condition is said to be
cuspidate (Fig. 6E).
503
MAMMILLATE/PAPILLATE: The breast shaped pileus is termed mammillate or papillate in which the
umbo is sharply demarcated but not elongated (Fig. 7A).
UMBLICATE: If an umbo occurs in the depression of the pileus, it is said to be umblicate (Fig. 7B).
Fig. 3 – Color of gills: A. Young basidiomes. B. Mature basidiomes with appendiculate pileus.
Depression
DEPRESSED: If the pileus has a depression at the disc, the condition is said to be depressed.
NARROWLY-SHALLOWLY DEPRESSED. If the depression is shallow with smaller diameter, the
condition is said to be narrowly-shallowly depressed (Fig. 8A).
NARROWLY-DEEPLY DEPRESSED: If the depression of the pileus is deep with smaller diameter, it is
termed narrowly-deeply depressed (Fig. 8B).
BROADLY-SHALLOWLY DEPRESSED: If the depression of the pileus is shallow, and the diameter of
the depression is broad, it is referred to as broadly-shallowly depressed (Fig. 9A).
BROADLY-DEEPLY DEPRESSED (INFUNDIBULIFORM): If the depression is so broad as well as deep,
the condition is said to be deeply-broadly depressed or infundibuliform. The shape of the
infundibuliform pileus resembles a funnel (Fig. 9B).
PERFORATED: Sometimes the depression continuous with the lumen of the stipe and forms an
opening at the disc (Figs 10, 16). The perforated pileus is mostly associated with a hollow stipe.
504
FLABELLIFORM: A fan-shaped pileus is termed flabelliform (Fig. 11B).
CONCHATE: If the pileus is oyster-shaped, the term conchate is used (Fig. 12A).
SPATHULATE: If the pileus is spoon shaped, it is termed spathulate (Fig. 12B).
PETALOID: A petal-shaped pileus is referred to as petaloid.
505
Fig. 5 – Shape of the pileus: A Convex. B Conic with decurved and eroded pileal margin.
C Uplifted with eroded margin. D Broadly convex. E Plane, orbicular and crisped margin.
506
Fig. 6 – Shape of the pileus: A Narrowly parabolic. B Broadly parabolic. C Broadly umbonate.
D Acutely umbonate. E Cuspidate. F Campanulate.
507
Fig. 7 – Shape of the pileus: A Mammillate umbo. B Umblicate with hygrophanous pileus.
508
Fig. 8 – Depression of the pileus: A Narrowly-shallowly depressed with ciliate margin.
B Narrowly-deeply depressed.
509
Fig. 9 – Depression of the pileus: A Broadly-shallowly depressed. B Broadly-deeply depressed
(Infundibuliform).
510
Fig. 10 – Depression of the pileus: Perforated.
Fig. 11 – Shape of the pileus on top view: A Dimidate with striate margin. B Flabelliform.
511
Surface of the margin
TRANSLUCENT-STRIATE (PELLUCID): If the pileal surface is transparent and the gills can be seen
through the wet pileus as lines, the condition is said to be translucent striate or pellucid (Fig. 16).
STRIATE: If definite lines are present as part of the cap itself, the margin is called striate (Fig. 11A).
PLICATE-STRIATE: If folds are present between the striae, the condition is referred to as plicate
striate (Fig. 17A).
TUBERCULATE-STRIATE: If small bumps occur on the striae, the term tuberculate-striate is applied
(Fig. 17B).
SULCATE: If the lines form definite grooves, the margin is said to be sulcate (Fig. 18).
512
Fig. 13 – Margin of the pileus: A Inrolled, B Rimose to lacinate with incurved margin.
513
SILKY (SERICEOUS): If the pileal surface appears to be made of silk like hairs, it is said to be silky or
sericeous (Fig. 15).
514
FIBRILLOSE: If the pileal surface is covered by visible filaments or fibrils it is said to be fibrillose.
The fibrils are composed of hyphae adhered with the pileal cuticle.
APPRESSED-FIBRILLOSE: If the fibrils are appressed on the pileal surface, it is termed appressed-
fibrillose (Fig. 15).
TOMENTOSE: If the fibrils are densely mated and wooly, like a woolen blanket on the pileal surface,
it is said to be tomentose.
VIRGATE: If the appressed fibrils appear as mere streaks, the surface is referred to as virgate.
515
Fig. 15 – Shininess of the pileus: Silky with appressed-fibrillose.
Fig. 16 – Striations of the wet, perforated pileus: Translucent striate with entire margin.
516
Fig. 17 – Striations of the pileus: A Plicate striate. B Tuberculate-striate.
517
DOWNY-FIBRILLOSE: When the fibrils form a downy layer, the pileal surface is said to be downy-
fibrillose.
FLOCCOSE: If the fibrils have the appearance of flattened cottony layer, the term floccose is used.
DOWNY-WOOLLY: Downy-woolly is a condition intermediate between downy-fibrillose and
tomentose i.e. densely matted and wooly fibrils (Fig. 25A).
MATTED-FIBRILLOSE: If the fibrils are matted and inter-woven, appearing like felt is said to be
matted-fibrillose (Fig. 25B).
VELUTINOSE: If the pileal surface is covered by compact, short, fine and soft hairs (velvety), it is
called velutinose.
Fig. 19 – Shininess of the pileus: A Shiny, smooth, glabrous. B Smooth, dull, dry.
518
Fig. 20 – Wetness of the pileus: A Moist, subumbonate. B Glutinous, subumbonate.
519
Fig. 21 – Hygrophanous pileus with glabrous stipe.
VILLOSE: If the hairs on the pileal surface are rather long and weak, it is termed villose (Figs 26,
27)
PUBESCENT: If the hairs are short, it is said to be pubescent.
HISPID: If the hairs retain a bit of flexibility resulting in a surface tending to be villose, the term
hispid is used (Fig. 28A)
STRIGOSE: Strigose is a condition where the pileal surface is having long and coarse, bristle-like
hairs.
SQUAMOSE: If cohesion of fibrils occurs at the tips of the hyphae as well as laterally, the tips stick
together to form scale like structure on the surface, and the scaly surface is called squamose.
SQUAMULOSE: If the pileal surface is covered by small scales it is called squamulose. The small
scales are called squamules.
520
FIBRILLOSE SQUAMULOSE: An intermediate condition between fibrillose and squamulose in which
the fibrils are joined at their tips but still retain the individual hyphae below the tips (Fig. 28B).
APPRESSED-SQUAMULOSE: If the scales are flattened or appressed to the pileus surface, it is said to
be appressed-squamulose (Fig. 29A).
RECURVED-SQUAMULOSE: If the tips of the scales are erect and turned backwards on the pileal
surface, the term recurved squamulose is used (Fig. 29B).
IMBRICATE-SCALY: The appressed squamules may sometimes overlap with one another, giving a
surface referred to as imbricate-scaly (Fig. 30).
SQUARROSE: If the scales are upright on the surface of the pileus particularly, at the disc of the
pileus, the term squarrose is applied (Fig. 31).
PUNCTUATE-SQUAMULOSE: If the surface of the pileus is dotted with minute scales or points, it is
called punctuate-squamulose.
521
SCABROUS: If the texture of the surface is rough to the touch due to the presence of large plate like
scales or points, it is said to be scabrous (Fig. 32).
Gills
522
Fig. 24 – Texture of the pileus: A Furfuraceous. B Granulose.
523
Fig. 25 – Texture of pileus: A Downy wooly. B Matted fibrillose.
524
Fig. 26 – Texture of the pileus: Villose.
525
Fig. 28 – Texture of the pileus: A Innate, hispid pileus. B Fibrillose squamulose.
526
Fig. 29 – Texture of pileus: A Appressed-squamulose. B Appressed- to recurved-squamulose.
527
Fig. 30 – Texture of pileus: Imbricate-scaly pileus.
528
Fig. 32 – Texture of the pileus: Scabrous.
529
Fig. 34 – Attachment of gills: A Free, crowded gills, centrally attached stipe with the pileus.
B Adnexed, crowded gills.
530
Fig. 35 – Attachment of gills: Sinuate, crowded gills.
Fig. 36 – Attachment of the gills: Adnate with distant gills alternating with lamellulae.
531
Fig. 37 – Attachment of gills: A Subdecurrent, smooth gills. B Decurrent.
532
Fig. 38 – Serrate gills alternating with lamellulae and attenuated stipe towards base.
533
Gill features
LAMELLULAE: Smaller form of gills which do not reach the stipe and occur in between gills (Figs
36, 38).
ANASTOMOSING: The lamellae and lamellulae are interconnected by lamellulae which makes the
entire gill area appear as veined. The gills are termed anastomosing gills and the branching pattern
is said to be intervenose or costate (Fig. 39)
COSTATE-RETICULATE: If the gills are interconnected by numerous veins and the hymenium appears
like a net, it is said to be costate-reticulate (Fig. 42).
FURCATE: If the gills divide into distinct branches between the pileal margin and stipe apex and the
branching is irregular and sporadic, the gills are called furcated (Fig. 43).
BIFURCATE: If the gills divide into just two branches, whether the branches are regular or not, it is
said to be bifurcate.
DICHOTOMOUS: If the gills are branched repeatedly and the branched gills are of equal length, the
gills are said to be dichotomous or dichotomously branched (Fig. 44).
534
Stipe
535
Fig. 43 – Gill features: Furcate.
536
Fig. 45 – Attachment of the pileus with the stipe: A Lateral. B Eccentric, scabrous stipe.
537
Attachment to the substrate and basal tomentum
BASAL TOMENTUM: The attachment of the stipe to the substrate is by mycelium arising from the
substrate and superficially running up on the surface at the base of the stipe is called the basal
tomentum (Fig. 46).
RHIZOIDS (RHIZOIDAL): If the hyphae are large and distinct from one another, the hyphae are called
rhizoids, and the basal tomentum is defined as rhizoidal (Fig. 46A).
RHIZOMORPHS: If the hyphae are cord-like and elastic in consistency, it is said to be rhizomorphs
(Fig. 46B)
STRIGOSE: If the hyphae are large and look like bristles at the base of the stipe, it is referred to as
strigose (Fig. 47A).
PSEUDORRHIZA (RADICATED): Stipe of some mushrooms continues as a root-like process called
pseudorrhiza. The stipe of such mushroom is said to be radicated (Figs 47B, 48).
538
INSERTED: When the stipe is completely devoid of any hyphae, rhizoids or rhizomorphs, where it
originates from the substrate the stipe is said to be inserted (Figs 53A, 54A).
CLAVATE: If the stipe base is enlarged and appears as a club, it is said to be clavate (Fig. 49D).
OBCLAVATE: If the stipe apex is enlarged and appears as an inverted clavate, it is called obclavate.
BULBOUS: If the base of the stipe is enlarged abruptly, the term bulbous is used (Fig. 50).
539
Fig. 49 – Shape of the stipe: A Terete, equal stipe. B Compressed. C Smooth stipe, attenuated
towards apex. D Clavate, scaly stipe.
540
Fig. 50 – Shape of the stipe: Bulbous, scaly stipe.
541
Fig. 51 – Surface of the stipe: Glabrous.
542
Partial veil (Annulus)
SUPERIOR: If the veil is located in the top half of the stipe, it is said to be superior (Fig. 56A).
CENTRAL: If the annulus is located approximately in the middle of the stipe, the term central is
applied (Fig. 56B).
INFERIOR: If the veil is located in the lower half of the stipe, it is called inferior.
ATTACHED: If the annulus is attached firmly to the stipe and do not fall out in mature specimen, it is
said to be attached (Fig. 56C).
FUGACIOUS: If the annulus is loosely or tightly attached in young specimens and fall out at
maturity, it is called fugacious (Fig. 56A).
DOUBLE ANNULUS: It may have cottony roll of tissue on the underside, in which case it is called a
double annulus (Figs 40, 56C).
SINGLE ANNULUS: If the undersurface is smooth, the annulus is termed single (Fig. 56A).
Universal veil/Volva
The cup like membranous structure present at the base of the stipe is called volva.
Free volvas
SACCATE: In this case, the volva is free from the stipe except at the extreme base (Fig. 57).
543
Adherent volvas
FLARING: The volva is attached at the stipe along its length except at the volval margin where it
flares out (Fig. 58A).
CIRCUMSESSILE: The adherent volva is similar to flaring, however; instead of flaring out at the
volval margin, it forms a tight rim around the stipe. It is called circumsessile (Fig. 58B).
ZONED: This type of volva is similar to circumsessile. However, in this case, the upper part of the
volva forms a ring or zone like structures just above the main part of the volva.
Growth habit
SOLITARY: The fruit body grows alone and apparently no other fruit bodies of same species grow
near its vicinity. Single fruit body present on the substratum (Fig. 59C).
GREGARIOUS: Fruit bodies grow close together as group in large numbers, but occur as individuals
and do not share a common base (Fig. 59A).
SCATTERED: The solitary or group of fruit bodies scattered apart one to two feet (Fig. 59B).
CAESPITOSE: Several fruit bodies grow in clusters and share a common base (Fig. 60A).
CONNATE: The stipes of two or more fruit bodies are joined together at the base (Fig. 60B).
544
Fig. 54 – Consistency of the stipe: A Cartilaginous, inserted stipe. B Woody, scabrous.
545
Fig. 55 – Consistency of the stipe: Solid.
546
Fig. 56 – Partial veil: A Single, superior, fugacious. B Central. C Attached, double annulus.
547
Fig 57 – Free volva: Saccate.
548
Fig. 59 – Growth habit: A Gregarious. B Scattered. C Solitary.
549
Fig. 60 – Growth habit: A Caespitose. B Connate.
550
Fig. 61 – Type of fruit body: Sessile.
551
Fig. 63 – Type of fruit body: A Imbricate. B Ungulate. C Effuso-reflexed. D Resupinate.
552
CHARACTER RECORDING CHART FOR AGARICS
Ref. No. Date of Collection
Thickness Consistency
Odor: Taste:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
LAMELLAE
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Color: Young Old Color changes on bruising
553
Margin: Entire Serrate Undulating
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
STIPE
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Size: Young Old
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ANNULUS
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Superior Inferior Central Attached Moveable Double Single
Fugacious
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
VOLVA
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Saccate Adherent Flaring Color
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
GROWTH HABIT
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Solitary Scattered Gregarious Caespitose Connate
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
FRUITING BODY ATTACHMENT
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Stipitate Sessile Effuso-reflexed Resupinate
Acknowledgements
This article is mostly based on the collections of authors. In addition to this, GS while
working for the project NFCCF at Agharkar Research Institute, Pune received several collections of
554
mushrooms and their photographs from different regions for identification. A few of the
photographs received for identification is also used in this article.
We dedicate this paper to the Indian mycologists, Dr. T.S. Suryanarayanan, Director,
VINSTROM and Dr. V. Muruganandam, (Rtd. Prof.), Ramakrishna Mission Vivekananda College,
Mylapore, Chennai, Tamil Nadu who impressed us to take research on Mycology and late Prof. K.
Natarajan, CAS in Botany, University of Madras, Chennai, Tamil Nadu who trained us in
taxonomy of mushrooms. GS thanks the Indian Government Funding Agencies such as Ministry of
Environments and Forests (MoEF), for the financial assistance provided under the project “All
India Co-ordinated Project on Taxonomy of Fungi (AICOPTAX)” during 2000-2004, Department
of Science & Technology (DST) for the financial assistance provided under the project “National
Facility for the Culture Collection of Fungi (NFCCF)” during 2008-2013 and Department of
Biotechnology (DBT) under the project “Developing a Mushroom Germplasm Bank for Western
Coast of India with Special Emphasis on Maharashtra and Goa to Commercialize their
Neutraceutical and Pharmaceutical Potential” for the period from 2016 to 2018. VK thanks UGC-
SERO (MRP-6365/16) for financial assistance for the project “Macrofungal Diversity of
Puducherry and their Sequence Based Molecular Systematics” that helped in contributing to this
article.
GS personally thanks Dr. Taiana Riviere, Mr. Santosh Swami, Mrs. Vimal Vaingankar, Mr.
Subash Gaikwad, Mr. Lalit Joshi, Mr. Prakash Joshi, Dr. Rasika Baghwat and Mr. Sushant Bornak
for their assistance during the field trips made to different regions of Western Ghats.
References
Kornerup A, Wanscher JH. 1978 – Methuen Handbook of Color. 3rd edn. London: Eyre Methuen,
243 p.
Largent DL, Stuntz DE. 1977 – How to Identify Mushrooms to Genus I: macroscopic features.
Indiana University, Mad River Press, 86 p.
Lodge DJ, Ammirati J, O’Dell TE, Mueller GM. 2004 – Collecting and Describing Macrofungi. In
Biodiversity of Fungi: Inventory and Monitoring Methods, Mueller, G.M., Bills, G.F., Foster,
M.S., Eds. New York, Academic Press, 128–158 p.
Ridgway R. 1912 – Color Standards and Color Nomenclature, Washington D. C.
Singer R. 1986 – The Agaricales in Modern Taxonomy. 4th edn. Sven Koeltz Scientific Books.
Koenigstein, Germany, 981 p.
555