This document provides analyses of 13 propaganda and advertising posters from different historical periods and styles. For each poster, it describes key design elements like composition, focal points, visual flow, use of color and typography. It also evaluates whether the poster achieves a balanced visual hierarchy and rhythm. Brief opinions are provided on the effectiveness of each poster's design.
This document provides analyses of 13 propaganda and advertising posters from different historical periods and styles. For each poster, it describes key design elements like composition, focal points, visual flow, use of color and typography. It also evaluates whether the poster achieves a balanced visual hierarchy and rhythm. Brief opinions are provided on the effectiveness of each poster's design.
This document provides analyses of 13 propaganda and advertising posters from different historical periods and styles. For each poster, it describes key design elements like composition, focal points, visual flow, use of color and typography. It also evaluates whether the poster achieves a balanced visual hierarchy and rhythm. Brief opinions are provided on the effectiveness of each poster's design.
This document provides analyses of 13 propaganda and advertising posters from different historical periods and styles. For each poster, it describes key design elements like composition, focal points, visual flow, use of color and typography. It also evaluates whether the poster achieves a balanced visual hierarchy and rhythm. Brief opinions are provided on the effectiveness of each poster's design.
Asymmetric Spontaneous composition based on visual weight distribution.
Focal point seems to be the head of
the rooster due to the details and the colour catching interest. The larger lettering ‘cocorico’ is difficult to read but complements the style of the illustration. The information is placed in heirarchy based on size , colour and proximity. The signature of the painter at the top left has a considerable weight of its own and reduced the weight of the negative space. Visual flow and rhythm is good.
Opinion - I really like the poster.
However if the lettering of the body text could have been less untidy it would have worked for me better than it does currently. 2 Henri Privat-Livemont Art Nouveau / Balanced / Asymmetric Intuitive composition based on visual weights of elements. Focal point is the face with the intricate hair using warm colours. The circle around the head defines the form of the lettering, increasing the visual emphasis in the area. There is also a good visual flow between the text and the illustration due to this. The gaze and the flowline of the arm aids the transition to the glass which balances the focal point. Hence there is harmony in the triangle of visual elements in the upper region. The repeating organic elements in the lower portion balances out the weights above. There is a consistent visual language, contrast in the elements emphasises the necessary ones. Opinion - I liked the poster due to its intricate yet balanced language. 3 Adolfo Hohenstein Art Nouveau / Balanced / Asymmetric Spontaneous visual composition. Illustration holds 4 main visual focal points with others aiding them. Good visual flow. The faces of the man and the woman hold the maximum visual interest. other elements like the flow lines of the body gestures and the gaze of the peacock direct the eye to these two faces. The gaze of the man and the woman are directed to the child at the lower right side providing visual flow downwards. His gaze is in turn directed to the text which is then placed in heirarchy using weight, size and proximity. Lettering done is compact and dense. Blue negative space at the top and bottom balance out each other.
Opinion - I loved the poster for the
way it plays with eye movements due to its controlled rhythm. 4 Eugène Grasset Art Nouveau / Unbalanced / Asymmetric Visual weight of the face in the illustration defines the focal point. The warm colours and red of the hair increases the interest in the area.Visual flow defined by fowline of the right arm going down to the text. excess of visual clutter to the left is not balanced by the negative space to the right. Poster is dynamic due to the angle of the lettering and the flowline created by the body. The Hair and the background texture increases the motion associated with the poster. Visual language is consis- tent and intricate, highlighted by the blunt but jagged patterns in the background and the dress. Colour scheme is triadic.
Opinion - Ambivalent. I liked
the illustration style but the other visual elements do not blend harmoniously due to the layout. 5 Will H. Bradley Art Nouveau / Unbalanced / Asymmetric Barrage of inforrmation at the top of the poster. Although heirarchy used is visible (using size weight and colour) there is large amounts of visual disturbance. Visual flow is not harmonious. Red dominates the region below the optical centre, hence it is the region of maximum visual weight. The colour red is not well distributed, causing the contrast of the elements in the poster to seem unbalanced.
Uses dichromatic colour scheme.
Opinion - Ambivalent. I like the
simple illustration. The lettering of ‘Chap Book’ also complements the illustration. However the layout is top heavy. a better choice of colours , with less of contrast would have helped lessen the visual disturbance. 6 Joseph Binder Art Deco / Unbalanced / Asymmetric Spontaneous composition based on geometric shapes. Visual language is clean towards the top but gets cluttered at the bottom causing the rythmn to break.
The composition seems unbal-
anced. Angled flow lines of the text seem forced. Emphasis seems divided beween the bright yellow and white shapes and the text. the illustrated buildings to the left cause visual disturbance. Lettering is tight due to lack of leading adding to the unbalance.
Uses a triadic colour scheme.
Opinion - I liked the poster, but
parts of it steal too much attention. The lettering could have stood out more and should have been less dense and packed. 7 Max Hertwig Art Deco / Balanced / Asymmetric Simple grid system, but lettering and composition seems sponta- neous. Visual weight distribution decided intuitively. Good visual flow due to the simple layout, but it gives the poster a very flat visual language.
The illutration is simple with clean
lines. lettering at the top is large and less condensed compared to the condensed text at the bottom. Analogous colour scheme gives the poster a controlled and harmoni- ous look.
Opinion - Ambivalent. Poster could
have been more harmonious if the face and hands would have been painted as visual weight around the face would then have balanced the poster better. 8 Leo Marfurt Art Deco / Balanced / Asymmetric Good visual Heirarchy. Althought the face is a strong focal point due to the interest it generates, the ‘1940’ in red and the large red circle below the optical centre balance the weight around it. Visual direction provided by all the elements which give good flow to the poster with harmonious transition from one chunk to another. Visual contrast of the face is balanced by the simpler, more rational chunks around it. Text is limited to necessary information. Hence the condensed font works well. heirarchy of text determined by colour hence the dates are in red. Colour scheme is diadic.
Opinion - Yes, I really like the poster
due to its smooth rythmn. 9 Jean Carlu Art Deco / Balanced / Asymmetric A large portion of the poster is a mass of positive space including the illustration and the lettering. it is balanced by the chunk of negative space in the centre which forms a shape as part of the illustration.
Lettering is inconsistent, disrupting
the rhythm of the illustration. text box at the lower left helps balance out the asymmetric illutration.
The illustration is the heaviest of
the visual elements due to the interest factor and contrast. Colour scheme is triadic.
Opinion - Ambivalent. I really liked
the illustration but the lettering does not work for me. 10 A.M Cassandre Art Deco / Balanced / Symmetric Simple 3 column grid. the text is concentrated above the optical centre. Heirarchy is maintained by size and weights of the lettering done. The visual weight of the text at the top is balanced by the mass of black in the illustration with the focal point being the more detailed cap. This is also due to the brighter colours, which cause the cap to stand out visually. Its emphasis is moderated by the black mass. Visual language is playful due to the contrast in the detail of the cap which is more visually engaging, the slightly less intricate lettering and the plain illustration of the man.Uses a complementary colour scheme Opinion - I liked the poster to to its harmonious yet playful rythmn. 11 Ludwig Hohlwein Propoganda / Balanced / Symmetric 3 column grid. Visual weight distributed aong the centre. Weight of the text at the bottom is balanced by the rough texture of the highlights on the face near the optical centre. This causes the poster to be very aesthetically balanced.
Grid has been roughly made as per
the flag required in the back- ground.Colour scheme is chosen based on the flag. Lettering done is based off a regular geometric font. It seems to balance the visual weight of the illustration by not being too loud itself.
Opinion - Yes, I really like the
poster. The illustration really stands out 12 Unknown / USA Propoganda / Unbalanced / Asymmetric Spontaneous composition. 2 column grid like structure. Has an Unbalanced feel to it due to the heavy text at the bottom right and the displaced ‘its safer’ text. Negative space below ‘OR’ misleads the eye.
Colour scheme is derived from the
American national flag.
Opinion - I did not like the poster
much. It lacks the use of Guestalt in a few places. Illustration could have been simplified. 13 N. Vatolina & N. Denisov Propoganda / Unalanced / Asymmetric Unalanced due to the uneven Distribution of red above the optical centre and to either side of it. Poster is heavier on the left.
Colour Scheme derived from the
Russian national flag.
Spontaneous Manuscript grid style
composition.
Opinion - Ambivalent. Partially
because i do not understand the context entirely. But due to the simplicity of the design it sems to have become quite significant as a propoganda poster. 14 Michel Jacquot Propoganda / Balanced / Asymmetric Manuscript Grid with centre aligned text.
Visual weight is balanced between
the focal point of the text box “Communisme” and the rough texture of the illustration. The intricacy of the wolf head is heavier due to interest but is balanced by the red colour of the text.
Opinion - No I did not like the
poster. The style does not com- plement the lettering. The poster seems too dense. 15 Gustav Klutsis Russian Avante Garde / Balanced / Asymmetric Greater Visual Weight at the top of the poster, above optical centre. Large portraits draw the eye, increasing the interest in the area. it is balanced by the isolated text at the bottom. The use of photo- graphs gives the mass of the poster an intricate and detailed feel.
Angle of the text and the shapes
the images are cropped in give the poster dynamism. the ascending text on the left balances the descending text on the right. Colour scheme is warm. Con- densed font style goes well with the flow lines. Text is minimum but impactful.
Opinion - I really like the poster.
The use of photographs with a dense collage like effect and simple use of colour appeals to the eye. 16 Müller-Brockmann Modernist / Balanced / Asymmetric Rhythm created through Repetition of squares which confine to a grid. Strong use of Guestalt, Visual Focal point is the text box with bold text at the lower left corner. It is balanced by the red square near the optical centre.
Uses a 3 column grid and Triadic
Colour Scheme. Font - Standard CT
Dense chunk of text is balanced
out by the visually less dense illustration and isolated text at the top left.
Visual language is simple and
rational, with inorganic shapes. The grotesque san serif doesn’t let the poster feel too rigid.
Opinion - I liked the poster.
However i don’t understand the context in which the squares are used. 17 Müller-Brockmann Modernist / Balanced / Symmetric 3 column grid with most of the text concentrated in the middle creates symmetry.
Font - Standard CT
Focal Point “der Film” is a mass
of bold text in a large font size but light colour. it is balanced out by the red text box at the top of the poster and the negative space between them.
Overlapping text gives a simple yet
rational feel to the poster. Since it is light text surrounded by dark negative space, the visual style looks clean and stands out.
Opinion - Yes, i liked the poster.
The overlapping text really catches the eye. However the colours seem a little too dull. 18 Armin Hofmann Modernist / Balanced / Asymmetric 18 * 24 grid
“Die Gute Form” Heavy Geometric
text placed around the optical centre forms the focal point. it is heavier to the top but is balanced out by the text box at the lower left corner. A chunk of high density is balanced out by the negative space and the isolated text box at the bottom left using a Grotesque San Serif.
Opinion - Yes, I really like the
poster. However, the text was illegible at first. The colour goes well with the rational style used along with the geometric lettering. 19 Emil Ruder Modernist / Unbalanced / Asymmetric 3 column Grid
BERLIN Heavy Condensed text
placed above the optical centre forms the focal point. It looks heavier on the top right. A chunk of high density is balanced out by the negative space and the isolated text box at the bottom left.
Font - Standard CT Condensed
The condensed text gives a sense of rigidity and tightness to the poster. The grotesque san serif at the bottom left does not ease the visual contrast.
Opinion - Yes, I like the poster. It
is a simple yet aesthetic design, highlighting specific parts of the text. 20 Richard Paul Lohse Modernist / Balanced / Asymmetric Grid seems to be deconstructed 3 column grid. Most of the visual allignment is done with reference to ‘allianz’.
“allianz” dominates the poster,
though the text right above the optical centre catches the eye first ( Helmhaus Zurich ) due to its position and visual contrast.
The balance in the dark and light
colours creates high contrast but it is well balanced throughout the poster. Font used is Standard. 4 point sizes have been used ( approximately 5pt, 10pt, 16pt and 205pt)
Opinion - I liked the poster. the
colour scheme and contrast seems to balance out the composition. Information seems accessible and 21 Depero Fortunato Futurism / Balanced / Asymmetric 22 Ardengo Soffici Futurism / Balanced / Asymmetric 23 Carlo Carra Futurism / Unbalanced / Asymmetric 24 Filippo Marinetti Futurism / Unbalanced / Asymmetric 25 Kurt Schwitters Dada / Balanced / Asymmetric 26 Tristan Tzara Dada / Balanced / Asymmetric 27 Man Ray Dada / Unbalanced / Asymmetric