PACKER, E. (2014) - Leitmotif in Star Wars
PACKER, E. (2014) - Leitmotif in Star Wars
PACKER, E. (2014) - Leitmotif in Star Wars
leitmotivs that repeat throughout the trilogy. In the manner of a Wagner opera, Williams repeats
and varies these musical ideas according to the dramatic situation at hand. In the essay I plan to
identify and analyze five of the major motives used by Williams throughout Episodes IV, V, and
VI. More particularly, I will discuss Williams’ variation techniques used with these leitmotivs as
According The New Groves Dictionary of Music and Musicians, a leitmotiv is “a theme,
or other coherent musical idea, clearly defined as to retain its identity if modified on subsequent
appearances, whose purpose is to represent or symbolize a person, object, place, idea, state of
mind, supernatural force, or any other ingredient in a dramatic work, usually operatic but also
vocal, choral, or instrumental.” The term was first used to describe the 1871 opera, Carl Maria
von Weber in seinen Werken, but Richard Wagner was the first to legitimize the technique as a
significant symphonic developmental device. The New Groves Dictionary of Music and
“With the weakening of the closed form of the da capo aria, greater importance began to
pass to other forms, such as arioso, recitative and scene; and the association of motifs
with characters and events began now to provide not only a useful system of illustration
but, gradually, by the means of applying formal control through quasi-symphonic
techniques.”
Richard Wagner, best known for his opera works, rose to fame from the mid to late
1800’s. With stage works like Tristan und Isolde, Siegfried, and Die Walküre, Each had their
own leitmotivs that united the opera. The Tristan und Isolde Overture (which premiered two
years before the opera), resonates a melody that is overly chromatic and sensual that is left
unresolved. This theme is repeated and altered throughout the entire work, creating a sense of
2
unresolved desire. The use of this leitmotiv creates a sense of dramatic tension on stage that the
audience would not see otherwise. In this case, the Tristan und Isolde motif represents a feeling
and is indirectly associated with the two protaganists. Wagner’s technique carried over into other
great composers such as Hector Berlioz, Franz Liszt, Karl von Weber, and Robert Schumann.
Further, the use of Wagnerian techniques and leitmotif continued to be the basis for a majority of
film music. Max Steiner once said, “If Wagner had lived in this century, he would have been the
With the development of silent films in the late 18 70’s, music in movies began to play
pivotal role in programmic music. Mervyn Cooke comments: “Music may initially have been
supplied at film screenings simply because it has always been an inevitable adjunct to almost all
forms of popular entertainment.” (4). In the beginning, music was played for aesthetic purposes.
It was not designed for the film or even played simultaneously with the film, but as the silent
film reached its peak (c. 1912), music began to hold a pivotal place in programmic music. The
earliest appearances of film music can actually be seen in animated shorts from the early 1890’s,
such as Emile Reynaud’s Pantomimes lumineuses. Kathryn Kalinak writes that: “Silent film
accompaniment, after all, was produced by live musicians whose presence lent credibility to the
images themselves. The sight of live performers actually producing music transferred to the
silent images a sense of here and now…’ (Kalinak, 1998, 44). Although, Thomas Edison and
other great minds worked to invent a way to combine sound and visuals as early as the pre-
recorder, synchronized, and visual enhancing tool that we recognize as film scoring would not be
The use of Wagnerian techniques and leitmotif continued to be the basis for a majority of
film music. Claudia Gorbman describes leitmotif in filmic music “like the caption, anchor the
3
image in meaning, throws a net around the floating visual signifier, assures the viewer of a safely
Cinema music is still patched together by means of leitmotifs. The ease with which they
are recalled provides definite clues for the listener, and they also are practical help to the
composer in his task of composition under pressure. He can quote where he otherwise
would have to invent… They have always been the most elementary means of
elucidation, the thread by which the musically inexperienced find their way about.
(Adrono and Eisler 1994, 4-6)
In this way, leitmotif makes listening and composition an easy and enjoyable process, but
Adrono and Eisler go on to say that a true form of the leitmotif process may not be possible for
film:
The reasons for this are first of all technical. The fundamental character f the leitmotif –
its salience and brevity – was related to the gigantic dimensions of the Wagnerian and
post-Wagnerian music dramas. Just because the leitmotif as such is musically
rudimentary, it requires a large musical canvas if it is to take on a structural meaning
beyond that of a signpost… This relation is entirely absent in the motion picture, which
requires continual interruption of one element by another rather than continuity…
Cinema music is so easily understood that it has no need of leitmotifs to serve as
signposts and its limited dimension does not permit of adequate expansion of the
leitmotif.
(Adrono and Eisler 1994, 6)
These two even go as far as to say that leitmotif in filmic music “leads to extreme poverty of
composition” (Adrono and Eisler 1994, 6). Cooke, who comments on in opposition to Adrono
There is nothing inherently wrong about providing a ‘thread by which the musically
inexperienced find their way about’ if it is recognized tht commercially succeful narrative
films have to be ‘based on the premise that they must be easily understood’; these is of
course a subtext at work here, shown by the authors’ comment that ‘Cinema music I o
easily understood that is has no need of leitmotifs’, which stems from their rigid belief
that such music should aspire towards a state of modernist origianlyty that is inherently
more difficult for the average movie-goer to comprehend.
(Cooke 2008, 82-83)
As music approached the twentieth century, common practice music became less
romantic and grandiose. At the same time, film approached a golden age. One composer, by the
4
name of John Williams, began to combine twentieth century techniques with the grandiose,
John Towner Williams is one of the most influential of the twentieth century film
composers. He was born on February 8, 1932 in Floral Park, NY. Son of a jazz percussionist, a
young John Williams fell in love with the music in his blood. When Williams entered high
school, his family moved to Los Angeles, California where he attended North Hollywood High
School. After high school, he attended the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA) where
he studied composition under Mario Castelnuovo-Tedesco. Shortly after college, Williams was
drafted into the U.S. Air Force, but instead of serving on the field, he served with his musical
talents. For three years, Williams arranged, composed, and conducted pieces for the U.S. Air
Force Band. After making a name for himself in jazz and band composition, Williams applied to
Julliard school of Music in New York where he completed his masters in composition. After
playing piano at a jazz bar to put himself through the rest of college, he quickly found a position
as one of the staff composers for 20-Century Fox. And thus his career as a TV and movie
composer began.
Williams is credited with fourty-one Oscar Nominations and five wins. In addition, he
has an extensive collection of awards, including Gold and Platinum Records, Emmys, Golden
Globes, Grammys, and many more. He composed music made for film for over sixty years and
at age 82, a collection of his scores go down in history as some of the most recognizable
melodies in today’s pop culture; JAWS, Close Encounters, Raiders of the Lost Ark, Harry Potter
By the time noted jazz musician Johnny Williams appeared on the feature film scene in
the early 1960’s, the full symphonic score was a rarity and the composer was usually
5
called upon for light but sophisticated comedies. By the time he composed the score for
The Reivers in 1969, “Johnny” had become “John” and a distinctive musical voice had
emerged. After winning his first Academy Award for adapting the Bock/Harnick score
for Fiddler on the Roof (1971), the Wagnerian technique became pronounced in
Williams’ music for The Cowboys (1972) and The Towering Inferno (1974). Its
effectiveness gained a new level of awareness when his music for JAWS drove crowd out
of the cinemas in 1975.
(Matessino 1997, 5-6)
According to The American Film Institue’s 25 greatest film scores (last updated in 2005),
E.T. ranks at number 14 and Jaws at number 6. And finally, at number one is Star Wars. George
Lucas first hired Williams for his pipe dream project after seeing his previous success with
movies like Jaws. Williams’ jumped on the project without the expectation of writing music for
another five Star Wars movies, but Star Wars is significantly different from the rest of his works.
Traditionally, Williams never reads the script or visits the set before composing, but in order to
write for such an “out of the world” concept he broke those rituals. He also looked to more
modern composers like Holst and Dvorak for his inspiration. George Lucas approached Star
Wars with the hope of creating a new universe, but incorporating enough humanistic qualities in
the world to make it familiar to the audience. Because of this, Williams decided that a 19th
century, Romantic and Wagnerian approach would help connect the audience to the universe
through familiarity, but he also realized that a full symphonic score for a Science-fiction film
was something that had never been attempted before. But by the end of recording on March 16th,
1977 and the movie’s premier on May 25th of the same year, it was clear that Williams had made
the right decision. This began a new era of film music that incorporated elements from a long
history of “classical” and modern music that helped the audience and the film. Matessino writes:
Hearing the complete score for Star Wars in the sequence of the film adds a unique,
organic dimension to the listening experience. Very few scores so vividly paint musical
pictures of such accessibility and precision that one becomes aware of the narrative
through the music alone. In any given moment there is no mistaking desert for detention
6
block or spaceport for sand-crawler. The plight of Princess Leia, the coming-of-age
odyssey of Like Skywalker, and the final quest of Obi-Wan Kenobi all exist as much in
the music as they do on the screen. John Williams weaves these various characters and
storylines into a unified musical whole through his use of specific moods and distinct
thematic material.
(Matessino 1997, 5)
As I did extensive research, I got to experience what Matessino wrote. Williams’ score
There are also important structural characteristic which bind Williams to the classical
model: the use of music to sustain unity; a high degree of correspondence between
narrative content and musical accompaniment; the use of music in the creation of mood,
emotion, and character; the privileging of music is moments of spectacle; a dependence
on expressive melody and the use of leitmotifs; and the careful placement of music in
relation to the dialogue.
(Kalinak 1992, 190)
With special attention to detail, one can even identify a repetitive triplet rhythm that appears in
almost every major theme. In order to examine Williams’ use of leitmotif in the Star Wars
trilogy, I have compiled a list of appearances of five of the major leitmotif including: Main
Theme, Binary Sunset, Leia’s Theme, Darth Vader’s Theme/Imperial March, and Yoda’s Theme
(see Tables 1-5). Images 1.1-5.1 are all simplified transcriptions of the melody from John
William’s Star Wars (Suite for Orchestra). While all the themes I wish to address do not appear
in each film, Williams’ makes great of use these leitmotifs and other Wagnerian techniques.
The first theme that I will address opens each of the films and is probably the most
recognizable melody from the trilogy. The Main Theme is always the first element of Star Wars
that the audience is introduced to. It accompanies the signature title roll which sets the scene for
the story ahead. The theme is characterized by an abrasive entrance from the horn section (which
act as melody and percussive elements), the repetitive, syncopated triplet rhythm, and an iconic
Perfect Fifth interval from tonic to the dominant (see Image 1.1). The Main Theme is easily
7
divided into two parts; Luke’s Theme (Image 1.1) and Rebel Fanfare (Image 1.2).Each of these
themes are included in Table 1 under Appearance of Main Theme. Matessino writes and quotes:
The first theme in Star Wars is the theme associated with Luke Skywalker. “When I
thought of a theme for Luke and his adventures,” Williams says, “I composed a melody
that reflected the brassy, bold, masculine, and noble qualities I saw in the character.
When the theme is played softly, I tended towards a softer brass sound. But I used
fanfarish horn for the more heraldic passages. This theme, in particular, brings out the
full glow of the glorious brass section of the London Symphony Orchestra.” This now-
classic Star Wars theme perfectly conveys the heroism at the heart of the saga with the
economy of its open fifth (reaching upward), descending triplet (gathering strength for
another try), and triumphant lift to an octave to the opening note (attainment of the goal).
The note is savored and then the last four notes are repeated (reassurance of
achievement). The phrase then rounds out simply and effectively (task completed).
(quoted from Matessino 1997, 11)
Image 1.1
Image 1.2
8
Table 1
The second major theme that appears in the film series is Imperial March or otherwise
One motif that is not reprised from Star Wars is the musical tag for Darth Vader, the
rebel’s archenemy, in his flowing black robes and Nazi stormtrooper headgear, Vader is
the embodiment of evil. With his amplified heavy breathing and distorted speed, Vader
unsettles aurally as well as visually Not surprisingly, his motif in Star Wars plays off
musical conventions for suspense: its short passage in chordal harmony accompanied by
various combinations of timpani, celli, trombones, bassoons and basses playing low in
their register. There is a hint of dissonance in the accompaniment which is a kind of
ostinato, a single repeated note in a rhythmic pattern driven by triplets with a distinctive
descending major third at the end of some phrases.
(Kalinak 1992, 193-194).
While there is no complete statement of this leitmotif in Episode IV, scholars like Matessino
have called the timpani and lower strings that accompany the Rebel Fanfare in Imperial Attack
an undeveloped statement of the Imperial Theme. This pattern is repeated throughout the film.
The theme was composed especially for Empire Strikes Back. Imperial March (see Image 2.1)
was strategically not introduced in Episode IV because Lucas wanted to keep the whole of the
Empire a secret. After Episode IV, there was much about the Empire was left in the dark.
Episode V was the sequel that was created to unveil those secrets and intimidate the audience.
The theme first appears in Imperial Probe, where the theme is partially stated by a solo piccolo
and again by a muted trumpet. As Imperial Probe continues, tensions rise (with the ample use of
dissonance and syncopation) until the brass section enters with a complete statement of the
March.
The structure of the melody and its accompaniment leads the listener to believe that it is
in a minor key, when in reality, Williams is actually outlining a major triad. This was to create
propaganda components of nationalism. Since the rise of the Empire was highly inspired by the
Nazi revolution, Williams used to technique to show that things are not always as they seem.
Image 2.1
Table 2
Thirdly, I’d like to address Princess Leia’s Theme. This leitmotif, like Main Theme, is
easily separated into multiple parts (see Image 3.1 and 3.2). While Williams uses more than these
two examples, I will not discuss every variation. Mattesino describes the theme as a:
…beautifully constructed work in which the graceful purity of the theme emerges in all
its fullness as it is played in turn by horn, flute, and violins, with wind interludes before
and after each verse. The final crescendo and solo violin perfectly express Leia’s inner
strength and yearning for the innocence of a time long past.
(Matessino 1997, 19)
Biologically, Leia is the daughter of Anakin Skywalker, the infamous Darth Vader, but she grew
up as daughter of Bail Organa - a member of the royal family of the planet Alderaan. From the
very beginning, the Organa family has secretly opposed the Empire and her rebel upbringing
shows through. Princess Leia leads the Rebel Alliance as a sort of “rebel princess”. Williams’
challenge with creating Leia’s Theme was combing elements of a pure fairytale princess and a
sensual rebel leader into one. The theme is easily identified by the lifting jazz inflections and
sweeping melodies.
12
Image 3.1
Image 3.2
Table 3
The fourth leitmotif that I will address has been called many different names including,
The Force, Ben Kenobi’s Theme, and Binary Susnet. Because of the discrepancy over the title, I
have decided to call it Binary Sunset because that is the first and most complete statement of the
leitmotif. Like Main Theme, Binary Sunset follows the same “reaching” and “trying again”
format (see Image 4.1). The first phrase reaches a C for a short sixteenth note before it falls (first
try). The second phrase reaches the dominant on the last note of the triplet before settling on C
(second try – this time closer to the goal and for a slightly longer duration). The third phrase uses
the dotted eighth/sixteenth pattern as the final leaps towards the G (third try – goal attained as
tonic is held for a full two beats at an octave higher). The third phrase elides into the fourth
phrase, but instead of going straight back to tonic like in Main Theme, Williams prolongs the
dominant for an entire measure as if it were one last attempt at the goal, but is now too exhausted
to push through. This creates an intense emotional reaction from the listener because through the
tension, they are all longing for tonic again. When G returns in the last measure, there is a
Image 4.1
Binary Sunset, although debatably the most important leitmotif from the entire film series, is one
of the last of the major themes to be introduced. Matessino quotes Williams saying:
“I think of Ben Kenobi’s theme as reflecting both him and also the Jedi Knights and the
Old Republic that he remembers,” comments Williams. “It also serves to represent the
Force, the spiritual-philosophical belief of the Jedi Knights, and the Old Republic. Like
the Princess’ theme, it has a fairy tale aspect rather than a futuristic aspect. There is a lot
of English horn in Ben’s theme, which is often heard under dialogue. At other times, the
melody becomes the heroic march of the Jedi Knights.”
(quoted from Matessino 1997, 12)
Ben Kenobi, or Obi-Wan Kenobi as he was originally called, is a first look at the Jedi Knights –
the order of peacemakers and warriors who clung to the will of the Force. As one of the sole
survivors of the Great Purge, “Old Ben” carries a tragic sense of nobleness in his character.
Likewise, Binary Sunset, is supposed to carry the romantic mysticism and valor of the Jedi
Knights. This leitmotif is most often used in sentimental scenes to create a sense of distant
fantasy, or romanticism. It serves to represent a time of peace that has since been lost. In other
appearances, it is used in contrast with Luke’s Theme from the Main Theme when Luke joins
with his primal connection to the Force. For example, it is used in scenes like the Battle of Yavin
when Luke decides to rely on the force instead of a computer to destroy the Death Star.
15
Table 2
have discussed, but still plays a pivotal role (especially in Episode V). Yoda’s theme is a short
16
playful melody that is usually identified by a pure and simple melody. This leitmotif is heavily
associated with Yoda’s character and Luke’s training. It is most often used in contrast to the
Imperial March to emphasize the battle between good and evil. Some scholars would even go as
far to as to say that this theme represents the light side of the Force.
Image 5.1
Table 5
Groves Dictionary for Music and Musicians, say that these themes are even more effective in
combination: “The leitmotif may be musically unaltered on its return, or altered in its rhythm,
17
intervallic structure, harmony, orchestration or accompaniment, and may also be combined with
other leitmotifs in order to suggest a new dramatic condition” (644). The combination of these
Burning Homestead is a particularly interesting piece from A New Hope that combines a
Burning Homestead begins with a sad solo trumpet and strings as Ben and Luke find the
slain bodies of the Jawas who sold C-3PO and R2-D2. The tempo quickens a Luke
realizes that his family is in jeopardy and bolts to his landspeeder. Ben’s theme is played
by the trombones as Luke returns home, with strings and French horn climbing to the
discovery of the remains of his aunt and uncle. The theme is played again by cello
leading once again to the Death Star motif. In the battle station’s detention block, Darth
Vader approaches Senator Organa’s cell with both character’s themes occurring in
succession.
(Matessino 1997, 16).
Like Matessino stated, the Burning Homestead cue begins as Ben and Luke hace discovered the
slaughter Jawas. In this instance, Binary Sunset is played resolutely and forcefully as Luke
makes his way back to the place he calls home, desperate to save his family. The theme is then
repeated by a section of melancholy cellos as he discovers his aunt and uncle’s body. The theme
stays suspended at the second phrase and the horns begin to play the Death Star motif (which
was not covered in this paper). This tells the audience that Luke is upset and he blames the
Empire for their deaths, but it also tells them that, internally, he has made a decision to do
something about it. After the Death Star motif is played, there’s a transition to the Death Star
where Darth Vader is about to torture Leia in hopes of uncovering the location of the rebel base.
Their themes are layered in a way that the audience knows exactly what is about to happen. With
the use of suspense elements, this portion of the piece makes the audience severely
uncomfortable as they worry about Leia’s safety and cower at Vader’s presence.
18
Williams’ use of leitmotif as a center structure point in his filmic score for Star Wars is
credited with taking Lucas’ pipe dream science-fiction to an entirely new level. Individually and
in combination, these leitmotifs have brought a universe from “a long time ago in a galaxy far,
far away” a little closer to home. The success of these box-office record breakers and family
classics can greatly be attributed to John Williams’ work on the music. Had it not been for
Williams use of leitmotif, a large portion of the series magic would have been lost, and our
beloved heroes could have possibly just been forgettable characters. Because of the impact
Williams made, leitmotif in filmic music became an absolute standard for movies in the future.
While other techniques are still employed, Wagnerian leitmotif reigns as the greatest storyteller
in film music.
19
Bibliography
Adorno, Theodor and Hanns Eisler, 1994 [1947]. Composing for the Films, with a new
Cooke, Mervyn. A history of film music. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2009.
Kalinak, Cathryn, 1992. Settling the Score: Music and the Classical Hollywood Film, Madison
“Leitmotif.” The Dictionary of Music and Musicians. 2nd ed. Edited by Stanly Sadie and John
Mattessino, Michael. Liner notes to A New Hope: Special Edition. Williams, John. The London
Mattessino, Michael. Liner notes to The Empire Strikes Back: Special Edition. Williams, John.
Mattessino, Michael. Liner notes to Return of the Jedi: Special Edition. Williams, John. The
Thomas, Tony, 1977. Music for the Movies, 2nd edn, Los Angeles: Silman-James Press
“Wagner, Richard.” The Dictionary of Music and Musicians. 2nd ed. Edited by Stanly Sadie and
Williams, John. A New Hope: Special Edition. Williams, John. The London Symphony
Williams, John. The Empire Strikes Back: Special Edition. Williams, John. The London
Williams, John. Return of the Jedi: Special Edition. Williams, John. The London Symphony
Williams, John. Star Wars (Suite for Orchestra). Warner Tamerlane Publishing Corp. 1997.