Absar Kazmi Rathin Evaluation

INDIAN INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY BOMBAY
Referee's Evaluation Report on Ph.D. Thesis
Name of the Candidate: Mr. Rathin Biswas

Department : Centre for Urban Science and Engineering
ICT Enabled Framework for Public & Community Sanitation : Governance &
Title of Thesis :
Implementation
Name of Referee & Address : Prof. Absar Ahmad Kazmi
Professor, Department of Civil Engineering, IIT Roorkee - 247667, Uttarakhand, India
SECTION A
(Referee's Overall Recommendation)
Recommendation of the Referee Mark (\/) ) in the

appropriate box
(a) The thesis be accepted.
(b) The thesis be accepted after clarification of the minor points listed in
my report, at the time of viva-voce.
(c) The thesis be accepted after minor modifications in the thesis, as

suggested in my report. The thesis need not be referred to an external
referee again.*
(d) The thesis requires major revisions. The nature of the revisions are
indicated in my report. It is recommended that the revised thesis be
examined again by an external referee.
(e) The thesis is rejected.
Section B (Referee's Detailed Comments) : Please provide the following as an attachment.

1. General comments on the thesis, including a critical survey and evaluation of the quality and quantity of the
work reported in thesis.
2. Points which require clarification, and suggested amendments or revisions (if any).
3. Questions to be asked at the time of the viva voce.
4. 4. If the thesis is recommended for an IIT-Bombay "Best Thesis Award", please provide suitable
justification . You may base your recommendation on a comparison with other thesis in a similar area, with
which you are familiar.
Date: ___________________ Referee's Signature: ______________________
SECTION B
(Referee's Detailed Comments)
Name of the Candidate : Mr. Rathin Biswas
Referee's Name : Prof. Absar Ahmad Kazmi

Detailed Comments :
Referee's Signature: ______________________

(Please provide your signature on each additional sheets)
Guidelines for referees

1. During the evaluation of the thesis by the referees, any communication regarding the
thesis between the referees and the supervisor/student is strongly discouraged.
2. IIT Bombay expects the thesis to be comparable to the standards expected of reputed
universities in the world . The thesis must contain original work and critical
interpretation which is worthy of publication.
3. A "Referee's Evaluation Report on Ph.D. Thesis" format is given to the examiner with
the thesis. The form consists of two sections, as follows:
Section A (Referee's Overall Recommendation)
Ticking the first or second box ('a' or 'b') implies that the scheduling of PhD viva voce
exam is recommended. Ticking the third box ('c'), on the other hand, implies that the
candidate will give a detailed response to the Internal examiner to comments provided
in Section B along with an action taken report. The fourth box ('d') implies that the
thesis needs to be revised, and the revised thesis should be reevaluated by an
external referee. The fifth box ('e') is self explanatory.
Section B (Referee's Detailed Comments)
Section B is expected to be detailed. The comments should draw attention to the
merits as well as the shortcomings of the thesis. In particular, if 'd' or 'e' are
recommended in Section A, detailed comments to support the recommendation are
requested.
4. In addition, if you strongly feel that this thesis is worthy of an award, you may
recommend the thesis for an IITBombay "Best Thesis Award" along with your
comments. You may base your recommendation on a comparison with other thesis
in a similar area, with which you are familiar.
5. The "Referee's Evaluation Report on Ph.D. Thesis" (both Sections A and B) should be
sent by email (in pdf format) to ([email protected]). If the hard copy of the thesis has
been sent to Examiner(s), they may retain the hard copy of the thesis, unless they
have marked corrections and would like to share these with the candidate/
supervisor(s). In this case, the thesis may be posted to the following address:
Assistant Registrar (Academic),
Academic Section,
IIT Bombay, Powai,
Mumbai, 400076, India.
भभारततीय पपररौदद्योगगिकती ससंस्थभान ममबसं ई
Academic Office
Sub.: Payment of Honorarium to the PhD Thesis Referee
Kindly arrange to make payment of honorarium due to me to my bank account.
1. Personal details of the Referee
Name ___________________________________________________
Address __________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________
Phone / Mob. No. __________________________________________________________
Email id __________________________________________________________
2. Bank details :
Account Number __________________________________________________________
PAN No. __________________________________________________________
IBAN /IFSC code __________________________________________________________
Swift code / BIC __________________________________________________________
Bank Name __________________________________________________________
Bank Address with Pin code __________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________
I, __________________________________ hereby confirm that the above mentioned personal and bank details
should be used to remit any payments due to me. I agree that IIT Bombay shall not be held responsible for non-
payment if details provided are not found to be correct.
Date : 18-6-2019 Signature of the Referee
For Academic Office Use

Submitted to the Dean (AP) for consideration and approval of payment of Rs.. 10000/- to the Referee for
evaluation of PhD Thesis of Mr. Rathin Biswas (Roll No: 144420002), Centre for Urban Science and Engineering
Assistant Registrar (Academic)

Dean (AP)
Forwarded to the Dy. Registrar (F&A) for necessary action.

Absar Kazmi Rathin Evaluation

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Absar Kazmi Rathin Evaluation

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Description:

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Absar Kazmi Rathin Evaluation

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

INDIAN INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY BOMBAY

Referee's Evaluation Report on Ph.D. Thesis

Name of the Candidate: Mr. Rathin Biswas

Recommendation of the Referee Mark (\/) ) in the

(a) The thesis be accepted.

(c) The thesis be accepted after minor modifications in the thesis, as

(e) The thesis is rejected.

Section B (Referee's Detailed Comments) : Please provide the following as an attachment.

Date: _ Referee's Signature: ____

Name of the Candidate : Mr. Rathin Biswas

Referee's Name : Prof. Absar Ahmad Kazmi

Referee's Signature: ______________________

Date : 18-6-2019 Signature of the Referee

For Academic Office Use

Assistant Registrar (Academic)

Forwarded to the Dy. Registrar (F&A) for necessary action.

You might also like