Journal of Dairy, Veterinary & Animal Research

Research Article Open Access

Status of artificial insemination in tigray regional

state, “constraints and acceptability under field
condition”

Abstract Volume 3 Issue 1 - 2016

The study was conducted in Tigray Regional State, Northern Ethiopia; from September Gebregiorgis Ashebir,1 Alemselam Birhanu,2
2010 to August 2011.Tigray regional state is located in the northern part of Ethiopia. Eastern
and the South-eastern zone of Tigray is purposively selected because it is believed that these
Tadesse Gugsa3
Mekelle University, College of Veterinary Medicine, Ethiopia
1,2
areas are the one in which AI service is widely exercised. Retrospective study, employing 3
Regional Bureau of Agriculture & Rural Development
questionnaire survey to evaluate the status of AI service of dairy cattle was conducted (RBoARD), Ethiopia
in the region. In the retrospective study, data were collected from records of IA service
covering the period from 1992 to 2002EC. Artificial insemination records were obtained Correspondence: Gebregiorgis Ashebir, Mekelle University,
from AI certificates, from inseminator’s record books & regional Artificial insemination College of Veterinary Medicine, Ethiopia,
center. Out of the 51032 animals inseminated 28972 animals were pregnant (56%) and the Email [email protected]
calves born were 18852 (37%). Structured questionnaires were prepared to interview a total
of 423 farmers, attendants, managers, veterinarians and AI technicians to collect data on Received: January 27, 2016 | Published: April 06, 2016
the status of AI services and constraints associated with the service. This survey indicated
constraints that hinder the success of AI, heat detection problem (28%), lack of awareness
(18%), lack of infrastructures (16%), management problem (14%), low experience of AIT,
disease problems, lack of incentive to the technicians and owners are the major limitations
among others. As per the respondents from all the PAs of the study area most of the cow
and heifers did not come in heat during the dry season of the year. Based on the records of
the AIT and the questioner collected the conception rate for total insemination in the dray,
rainy and harvest time is 23.92, 35.63 and 55.51% respectively. Conception rate in artificial
insemination is affected by the skill of inseminator. The records collected from the farmers
(n=380) shows that majority of them (52.89%) came in heat during evening hours followed
by those (32.37%) in morning hours. A low number of cows (14.74%) commenced heat
during noon/afternoon hours and the rest respondents are not knowing the exact time of
the commencement of heat of their animals. The artificial insemination programme in the
study areas is greatly influenced by the status of the farmers cows presented for AI belonged
to small (51%), marginal (29.57%) and large farmers (19.89%) and this is because farms
posses their own bull. Semen samples were evaluated for their motility and livability, 10
straws from each center were used for the evaluation of progressive motility and their
livability. Although the lab facilities in same whereas were limited the results of percent
progressive motile spermatozoa and percent live spermatozoa obtained are in consistent
with the normal ranges of the frozen thawed bull semen.

Keywords: artificial insemination, status, constraints, questioner

Introduction In Tigray region AI service provision was started 19years back in

the capital - Mekelle & Adigrat, now the service is given by 70 AI
Cross breeding through artificial insemination is the most suitable Ts in 33 Werdas & the capital city, at 52 breeding units and one farm
economical and time tested breeding technique for generating higher (TDA farm). Liquid nitrogen and other consumables are distributed
genetically potential and productive animals. Cattle breeding are to these breeding units every month from a sub centre established in
mostly uncontrolled in Ethiopia making genetic improvement difficult 2001G.C. The sub centre has two liquid nitrogen producing plants
and an appropriate bull selection criteria have not yet been established, each with a production capacity of 10liters per hour. The breeds
applied and controlled. Although artificial insemination, the most used for cross breeding in the region at present are pure HF, Jersey,
commonly used and valuable biotechnology,1 has been in operation in Begait X HF cross (50%) and pure Begait. Despite the fact that
Ethiopia for over 35years, the efficiency and impact of the operation AI use in the region smallholder dairy sector has been minimal or
has not been well-documented. Reproductive problems related to non-existent, its potential to improve smallholder dairy productivity
crossbreed dairy cows under farmers’ conditions are immense.2 It cannot be overemphasized. Improvement in service provision, such
is widely believed that the AI service in the country has not been as AI centers within the vicinity of progressive dairy communities,
successful to improve reproductive performance of dairy industry.3 development of market structures and promotion of “value adding”
From the previous, little study AI service is weak and even declining to products such as fresh or fermented milk products and packaging
due to inconsistent service in the small holder livestock production can ensure a consistent flow of income to dairy farmer’s households.
systems of the Ethiopian highlands.

Submit Manuscript | http://medcraveonline.com J Dairy Vet Anim Res. 2016;3(3):91‒95. 91

© 2016 Ashebir et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which
permits unrestricted use, distribution, and build upon your work non-commercially.
 Copyright:
Status of artificial insemination in tigray regional state,“constraints and acceptability under field condition” ©2016 Ashebir et al. 92

The latter is obligatory in view of findings that excess milk during for pregnancy, pregnancy rate, sex of calf born and subsequent
the rainy season and fasting was discarded in the area of study due to services of cow/heifers and the time of insemination were collected
a lack of sufficient facilities to accommodate excess-presented milk. and analyzed. The questionnaire format was prepared for interview
This created a disincentive to continue, let alone attract new farmers to and discussion on selected districts (PAs) of the zone, and within
engage in dairying. In this paper an attempt has been made to discuss the district on selected kushets and then from these selected kushets
status of artificial insemination under field conditions in Tigray.4 15-20 livestock owners by simple random sampling method were
interviewed.
Materials and methods
Semen samples were evaluated for their motility and livability, 10
Description of study area straws from each center were used for the evaluation of progressive
motility and their livability Immediately following thawing of the
The study was conducted in Tigray Regional State, Northern
straws in water bath (35-37oC) and examined microscopically (for
Ethiopia, particularly the eastern and south-eastern zone of the region
individual motility and live/dead count of the spermatozoa) following
including Mekelle city from September 2010 to August 2011. Tigray
the recommended procedures5,6 by staining with Eosin and Nigrosin
regional state is located in the northern part of Ethiopia. Eastern and
stain and Individual motility by putting one drop of frozen thawed
the south-eastern zone of Tigray is purposively selected because it
semen and covering with cover slip and examining under low power
is believed that these areas are the one in which AI service is widely
microscope (x10 and x40).
exercised and constituted wide range of agro ecology. The back
ground information of the study area (Eastern and South- Eastern zone Questionnaire survey
of Tigray) is most drought affected area of the region with diversified
agro ecological area this is varies in altitude from 1200masl in the Retrospective study, employing questionnaire survey to evaluate
low lands to over 3000masl in the high lands. Most parts of Atsbi- the status of AI service of dairy cattle was conducted in the eastern
womberta and Ganta-afeshum district have rolling to hilly high zone of Tigray (Atsbi wenberta , Hawzen, Saesie tsaeda emba, Ganta-
plateaus.Mekelle, the capital city of Tigray regional state, is located afeshum & wukro, kilte-awlaelo district) and South-East zone (Samre
783km north of Addis Ababa, the capital of Ethiopia. seharti, Adigudom Enderta, including mekelle city). Structured
questionnaires were prepared to interview a total of 423 farmers,
The mean minimum and maximum annual rain fall is 300mm and attendants, managers, veterinarians and AI technicians to collect
927mm respectively. Rain fall of the study area have bimodal season data on the status of AI services and constraints associated with the
the long rain season starts from end of June to beginning of September service.7 The details of the questionnaire formats were prepared for
and short rain season stays from January to march. Agro climatically farmers, AI technicians and attendants. During the interview process
the study areas are divided in to two, high lands (dega) which every respondent included in the study was briefed about the objective
accounts for 85% and mid high land (Weyna dega) which covers 15% of the study before starting presenting the actual questions. Then the
of the area. Mixed crop and livestock farming system is the mode of questions were presented to the respondents some of the information
agriculture in the area. The major crops that are grown in the area collected through interview was supported by observation. In the
include sorghum, maize, wheat, teff, pea and bean. Livestock are main survey information on the developed questionnaires included address
components as main factors for the livelihood of the community to of the owner’s breed of animal’s category of animals, technique of
undertake agricultural activities. Cattle are the major live stock kept in service, time of commencement of heat, conception rate in different
the area. In the study area crop vegetation is dependent on livestock. seasons of the year and failure to conceive and constraints of AI
The population density in the area is relatively high and small units service. Employing questionnaire survey regarding the importance of
of land are extensively cultivated by subsistence farmers. The small AI for herd owners related to genetic improvement, milk production
undulating mountains in the high lands and surrounding the low land and information about general status of the AI practices in the area
part of the area are very steep and with low vegetation coverage. were also assessed. The questionnaire was designed to identify the
major constraints in the success of AI service in the study area.8
Study population
AI personnel in the zone Artificial insemination center, AI Data analysis
technicians, cattle owners and their dairy cattle in the zone and animal The data collected from the respondents was analyzed using
production professionals in the region, zone and district agriculture appropriate statistically package for the social science. All data were
and rural development offices represent the study population. The entered in to ms- excel after the completion of data collection work
study populations were cattle owners (n=380) their animals (n=2056), from the study areas. The data was summarized using descriptive
artificial insemination technicians (n=16) and other animal health statics (frequency & percentages).
and production professionals (n=27). Cattle owners were interviewed
using structured questionnaire format which was translated in Tigrigna Results
language and artificial inseminator technicians, animal production
and health professionals were also interviewed using structured Artificial insemination programme in the region
questionnaire. Crossbreeding was taken up in the region under the RAIC at
different times since 1985 and AI with frozen semen contributed
Study design
significantly to the cross breeding and upgrading of local cattle. A
In the retrospective study data were collected from the ten year satisfactory method of insemination is essential for obtaining optimum
service provision of the region, records of AIC covering the period conception rates (CR). In almost all AI centers, the inseminators
from 1992 to 2002EC. Artificial insemination records were obtained differ in their ability to obtain and maintain satisfactory conception
from AI certificates and from inseminators’ record book. Data on the rates, the difference in CR due to inseminations often range 5-10%.9
date of first service, number of services delivered, animals examined Imperfection in semen handling, thawing and inseminating techniques

Citation: Ashebir G, Birhanu A, Gugsa. Status of artificial insemination in tigray regional state, “constraints and acceptability under field condition” J Dairy Vet
Anim Res. 2016;3(3):91‒95. DOI: 10.15406/jdvar.2016.03.00078
 Copyright:
Status of artificial insemination in tigray regional state,“constraints and acceptability under field condition” ©2016 Ashebir et al. 93

have been shown to be negatively correlated with the results of AI. insemination records were obtained from AI certificates and from
The most important primary requisite to obtain high conception rate is inseminator’s record books & regional Artificial insemination center.
inseminating cows and heifers at the appropriate time.10 However, they have not full record book. Data on the date of first
service, pregnancy diagnosis, number of calves born and subsequent
In the retrospective study, data were collected from records of AI
service were collected and analyzed.
service covering the period from 1992 to 2002 EC (Table 1). Artificial

Table 1 Ten Years service provision of the regional AI center (1992-2002EC)

Activities 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 Total

Production ofLN2 (Lt.) 3240 4239 2191 6676 10534 13001 8452 7457 6979 7072 23442 93283

Semen doses 3216 2579 3346 5826 8897 11400 8340 9251 9400 9402 12228 83885

AI service 1618 2193 2304 2773 4176 6514 4348 4801 4180 7779 10346 51032

PD +V 675 845 811 1173 1684 2994 1965 2963 2784 5001 8077 28972

Calf’s born 552 604 637 725 1260 1860 1471 1903 1854 3424 4562 18852

No of AIC 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 40 50 60 60

No of AI T 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 65 65 76 76

Training 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 65 65 86 86

LN2, liquid nitrogen; AIT, artificial insemination technicians; AIC, ai centers, PD +V, pregnancy diagnosis positive; source, regional board (RAI center 2011)

The details of the AI programme of the region and the influence of AIT, disease problems, lack of incentive to the technicians and
of various factors which affect this programme have been presented owners are the major limitations among others.
and discussed below. Out of the 51032 animals inseminated 28972
25% of the cattle owners (small holders) who participated in the
animals were pregnant which around 56% is and the calves born were
questionnaire survey indicated that, they don’t get enough AI service
18852 (37%). Since the efficiency of AI is measured by not how many
and 60% of them explained the reasons for that as absence of service
animals are inseminated and pregnant but by how many calves are
on weekends and holiday. The study has clearly confirmed that 27.6%
born through this technology the efficiency of AI in the region seems
of small holders participated in the study areas showed dissatisfaction
satisfactory.
with the overall AI service Table 3. From the questioners and
The results of questionnaire survey in the present study indicated observations at field level only 16.15% of heifers were brought by
that there are many constraints in the success of artificial insemination the farmers for Artificial insemination, most of the farmers prefer to
in the study area (Table 2). As the result of the questionnaire inseminate cow artificially but for their heifers they prefer natural
survey indicated major constraints that hinder the success of AI are service the reason is heifers bred artificially are not conceived or have
heat detection problem (28%), lack of awareness (18%), lack of less conception rate than the cow.
infrastructures (16%), management problem (14%), low experience
Table 2 Response of the owners about the major constraints of AI

Constraints Frequency Percent(%)

Lack of infrastructure 62 16.32

Heat detection problem 105 27.63

Management problem 54 14.21

Disease problem 27 7.1

Lack of AIT experience 24 6.31

Lack of awareness 68 17.89

Lack of incentive 40 10.53

Citation: Ashebir G, Birhanu A, Gugsa. Status of artificial insemination in tigray regional state, “constraints and acceptability under field condition” J Dairy Vet
Anim Res. 2016;3(3):91‒95. DOI: 10.15406/jdvar.2016.03.00078
 Copyright:
Status of artificial insemination in tigray regional state,“constraints and acceptability under field condition” ©2016 Ashebir et al. 94

Table 3 Number of respondents and distribution of AI in the studied AI centers by animal category

Category of animals
Name of the AIC No. of farmers No. of AIT No. of other professionals
Cow Heifer Total

Adigrat 308 53 361 58 2 3

Edagahamus 109 22 131 25 1 1

Frewainy 73 13 86 20 1 2

Hawzen 131 21 152 28 1 2

Wukro 213 38 251 50 2 3

Atsbi-endaselassie 129 29 158 32 1 3

Haykmes’hal 104 8 112 18 1 0

Mekelle 373 79 452 60 3 6

Queha 107 26 133 32 1 2

Samre seharti 51 11 62 22 1 2

Adigudom 73 25 98 20 1 3

Hiwane 53 7 60 15 1 0

Total 1724 332 2056 380 16 27

Cow=83.85%; Heifer=16.15%

Farmers status vs artificial insemination Table 5 Conception rate in different season of the year 2002-2003 (from the
AIT record book and receipts)
Majority of cows crossbreed (over 80%) and local breeds (less
than 20%) in the urban and per urban areas belonged to different Season of insemination
%CR for first %CR for total
farmers category (Table 4) presented for AI belonged to small (51%), insemination insemination
marginal (29.57%) and large farmers (19.89%). The low pattern Dray season (“Bega”) 17.64 23.92
for less number of inseminations in cows (heifers) belonging to the
Rainy season (“Kiremt”) 30.12 35.63
large farmers shows that this category of farmers possess their own
bulls and they allow their animals to be naturally served instead of Harvest time (Autumn ) 48.47 55.51
taking a chance to send their animals at a distant place for artificial
Total 32.08 38.35
insemination. Such a practice may impose stress on cows/heifers,
resulting in low conception rates. Time of commencement of heat in rural bovine
Table 4 Farmers status and distribution of AI in the study area
The time of commencement of heat is a very important factor
determining the fate of the estrus for artificial insemination. The
Category of animals  
Farmers status records collected from the farmers (n=380) shows that majority of
Cow heifer averall them (52.89%) came in heat during evening hours followed by
those (32.37%) in morning hours. A low number of cows (14.74%)
Small farmers 828(48.03%) 211(63.55%) 1039(51%)
commenced heat during noon/afternoon hours and the rest respondents
Marginal farmers 510(29.58%) 98(29.52%) 608(29.57%) are not knowing the exact time of the commencement of heat of their
animals. Lowered environmental temperature (during morning and
Large farmers 386(22.39%) 23(6.93%) 409(19.89%) evening hours) which had a stimulatory effect on pituitary hormone
Total 1724 332 2056 for estrus cycle initiation might be the cause for more number of
animals showing estrus in this period Table 6.
As per the respondents from all the PAs of the study area most of
the cow and heifers did not come in heat during the dry season of the Table 6 The time of commencement of heat from 380 respondents
year. The limited grazing land and the non-availability of good quality
Seasons Number of respondents Percentage
feeds influence the reproductive performance of bovines. Majority of
cows remain anestrous during the long period of the year “bega”. A Morning 123 32.37
few may come in heat but this is of mainly silent heat which become Noon/afternoon 56 14.74
difficult to detect. Based on the records of the AIT and the questioner
collected the conception rate for total insemination in the dray, rainy Evening 201 52.89
and harvest time is 23.92, 35.63 and 55.51% respectively. Conception Night (10pm to 4am) 0 0
rate in artificial insemination is affected by the skill of inseminator
Total 380 100
(Table 5).

Citation: Ashebir G, Birhanu A, Gugsa. Status of artificial insemination in tigray regional state, “constraints and acceptability under field condition” J Dairy Vet
Anim Res. 2016;3(3):91‒95. DOI: 10.15406/jdvar.2016.03.00078
 Copyright:
Status of artificial insemination in tigray regional state,“constraints and acceptability under field condition” ©2016 Ashebir et al. 95

Physic-morphological characteristics of frozen thawed Recommendations

semen
i. Livestock owners should get educated and trained in modern
A total of 130  frozen thawed semen straws 10 from the RAIC profitable animal husbandry practices, especially feeding,
and 120 straws from the weredas AI centers were evaluated for their management and care of growing calves and heifers.
individual motility and livability before and after dispatching to the
ii. AIT should get regular training not only about AI techniques
centers. Although the lab facilities in same weredas were limited the
but also the cow, heifer and calf management practices.
results obtained are in consistent with the normal ranges of the frozen
thawed bull semen (Table 7). iii. AI center should be open throughout the day time and on
weekends as well.
Table 7 Physic morphological characteristics of frozen thawed semen
iv. Carrier structures should be established for the AITs.
Semen characteristics NAIC RAIC WAIC
v. Hardship and overtime allowances should be considered, this
%Motile spermatozoa 50-80(65.89%) 60.78% 54.75% may be helpful to reduce the high turnover of AIT.
%Live spermatozoa 50-90(72.55%) 71.56% 63.65% vi. No heat should be missed and insemination should be given
timely to achieve optimum pregnancy results.
NAIC, national ai center; RAIC, regional ai center; WAIC, wereda ai center
vii. As part of a long-term program farmers should breed their dairy
Discussion cattle by AI through the provision of these services by their
colleagues (qualified personnel and localized AI services) to
The artificial insemination programme in the study areas is greatly
enhance productivity (DIY).
influenced by the status of the farmers in relation to heat detection, their
awareness, AIT skill and willingness and availability of transportation Acknowledgements
and infrastructures. The inadequacies’ of the system such as use of
poor genetic quality bulls, interrupted liquid nitrogen supply, poor None.
delivery of AI services, lack of professionalism in providing services
and absence of co-ordination and control over the operations, lead Conflict of interest
to substandard semen quality, poor coverage and poor conception Author declares that there is no conflict of interest.
rates. Although the AI practice has been accepted by fairly a good
proportion of livestock owners, certain factors greatly influence References
acceptance of this practice by others. These factors are infrastructural
facilities, farmer’s awareness about AI and its merits, lack of farmer’s 1. Webb DW. Artificial Insemination in Cattle. Gainesville, Florida: IFAS
Extension; 2003:1‒4 p.
interest, lack of communication and also lack of incentives to farmers
and persons engaged in AI work at rural centers. Attempts to improve 2. Bekele T. Calf Sex Ratios in Artificially Inseminated and Natural Mated
the efficiency of AI should be based up on the understanding of most Female Crossbred Dairy Herd. In: Proceedings of the 13th annual
important causes for failure. According the respondents’ i.e the AI conference of the Ethiopian Society of Animal Production. Addis Ababa,
technicians the present survey indicates that the most common factors Ethiopia; 2005. p. 225‒230.
responsible for the failure of AI are: lack of infrastructure, lack of 3. Desalegn G, Medhin, Bekana M, et al. Status of artificial insemination
awareness regarding to AI, reduced conception and use of their own service in Ethiopia. A paper presented at the 17th Annual Conference of
bull were the main constraints encountered during service delivery. In the Ethiopian Society of Animal Production (ESAP), held at the Head
most of the cases the constraints of using AI service were described Quarters of the Ethiopian Institute of Agricultural Research (EIAR).
to have resulted from lack of awareness , having own bull , lack of Addis Ababa, Ethiopia; 2009. p. 87‒104.
infrastructure and low conception rate in the proportions of (33.3%), 4. Sinishaw W. Study on semen quality and field efficiency of AI bulls kept
(17.3%) , (30.6%) and (18.6%) respectively. The study confirmed at the National Artificial Insemination Center. Debre Zeit, Ethiopia;
that significant number of small holders participated in the study 2004.
areas showed dissatisfaction with the overall AI service and this is 5. Salisbury GW, Van Demark NL, Lodge JR. Physiology of reproduction
because of the AI service is not regular in weekends and holidays and artificial insemination of cattle. In: Freeman WH, editor. 2nd ed.
it is closed and the AI technicians are not responding for the calls San Francisco, USA; 1978. p. 385‒479.
from the farmers and farms. The AITs are also having their reason for
6. Hafez ESE. Reproduction in Farm Animals. In: Lea, Febiger, editors.
this ignorance because they are not gating any incentive. Livestock
6th ed. Philadelphia, USA: 1993. p. 405‒439.
owners do not allow their animals to be served naturally or artificially
even though these animals come in heat after a short period of calving 7. BoANRD (Bureau of Agriculture and Natural Resource Development).
with the misconception that there will be drop of milk production if Livestock census analysis results. Mekelle, Ethiopia; 1999. p. 230.
the animal conceives during their milking period. These actions result 8. Regional Artificial Insemination Center (RAIC). Annual report, Tigray,
in increase in the length of calving interval and reduce the number Mekelle, Ethiopia; 2010.
of calves from animals. Knowledge and awareness of proper animal
9. Roberts SJ. Veterinary Obstetrics and Genital Diseases, Theriogenology.
husbandry practices and traditional misconceptions could play an
2nd ed. India: CBS Publishers & Distributors; 1985. p. 604‒755.
important role in improving the reproductive efficiency of the cows.
The owners are not much aware as to when their animals should reach 10. Semen Production and Distribution Department. Semen production
puberty, and the growing animals do not have proper attention and and distribution accomplishment for 24years. NAIC, Addis Ababa,
are raised on dry fodder and grazing. Thus the age at puberty which Ethiopia; 2006.
should have been attained at 2 to 2.5years of age is attained as late as
4, 5 or 6years. In this way livestock owners miss at least one or two
calf crops.

Citation: Ashebir G, Birhanu A, Gugsa. Status of artificial insemination in tigray regional state, “constraints and acceptability under field condition” J Dairy Vet
Anim Res. 2016;3(3):91‒95. DOI: 10.15406/jdvar.2016.03.00078