Inveniaspartners The Evolving Heathcare C Suite
Inveniaspartners The Evolving Heathcare C Suite
Inveniaspartners The Evolving Heathcare C Suite
Healthcare C-Suite:
Copyright Statement
43 Conclusion
44 Resources
2
3
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
The healthcare C-Suite faces unprecedented change brought about by healthcare reform,
accountable care, increased consolidation and the economic realities of declining Medicare
reimbursement, deteriorated payer mix and pressures to contain costs.
Shifts in the healthcare landscape call for a new brand of healthcare leaders. Healthcare
organizations (HCOs), including hospitals, health systems, and payers, increasingly seek
out executives from industries as diverse as insurance, e-commerce, technology, retail and
consumer products.
There’s little doubt that healthcare C-Suites and boards will need skills, competencies and
knowledge as listed below:
4
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
Barry Ostrowsky, President and CEO, CEO, Baylor Scott & White Health, Louis, Missouri
Barnabas Health, West Orange, Dallas, Texas Victor V. Buzachero, Corporate
New Jersey John J. Finan, Jr. President and CEO, Senior Vice President for Innovation,
Deborah Proctor, President and CEO, St. Franciscan Missionaries of Our Lady Human Resources and Performance
Joseph Health, Irvine, California Health System, Baton Rouge, Louisiana Management, Scripps Health, San Diego,
Joel T. Allison, FACHE, President and and Board Member, Mercy Health, St. California
I would also like to thank the many Chicago, Illinois Ralph Muller, President & CEO,
others who provided insightful thoughts Jim Skogsbergh, President & CEO, University of Pennsylvania Health
and opinions for our report. They Advocate Health Care, Downers Grove, System, Philadelphia
include the following individuals: Illinois Lloyd Dean, President & CEO, Dignity
Mark Stauder, President & COO, Inova Health, San Francisco, California
Donna Katen-Bahensky, former Health System, Falls Church, Virginia Sam Moskowitz, Senior Vice President,
President & CEO, University of Steve Lipstein, President & CEO, BJC MedStar Health, Baltimore, Maryland
Wisconsin Hospital and Clinics, HealthCare, St. Louis, Missouri
Madison, Wisconsin Mitch Wasden, President & CEO,
Scott Serota, President & CEO, University of Missouri Health System,
Blue Cross Blue Shield Association, Columbia, Missouri
This report also offers predictions on the future of the C-Suite and guidance on how organizations,
executives and board members can prepare for healthcare’s bright but turbulent future.
We welcome your input on this report and look forward to providing you with ongoing insights on
healthcare executive and board search, assessment and talent management.
For more information on how InveniasPartners can help meet your healthcare executive search,
assessment and talent management needs, call Madeline Lazarz at 312-283-8184 or e-mail
Madeline Lazarz at [email protected]
Curt Lucas
Curt Lucas
President and CEO InveniasPartners
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
Economy and finance: While fewer uninsured patients will decrease the bad debt of
hospitals and health systems, volume is likely to remain weak.
Information technology and e-health: HCOs will continue to rely on data and data
analytics to deliver evidence-based care, manage population health and predict health
outcomes.
Insurance and coverage: While payers may continue to exclude higher cost hospitals,
payers are still willing to collaborate with hospitals interested in accepting lower
reimbursement.
Physicians: HCOs will continue to acquire physician practices at a rapid pace creating
enhanced management and financial challenges.
6
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
Quality and patient safety: HCOs will focus on care partnerships with patients,
competition based on value, realignment of services with payment systems and
individual accountability for improvement.
Workforce: The C-Suite will continue to build workforces that are capable
of meeting the requirements of new and emerging markets, using programs
like workplace wellness and prevention to reduce healthcare costs and boost
productivity.
Chief executive officers (CEOs) are feeling the pressure. “State and federal
governments that pay the majority of the bills are running out of money, while
the private sector is unable to absorb added cost shifting,” says John Finan,
President and CEO of Franciscan Missionaries of Our Lady Health System
(FMOLHS), Baton Rouge, Louisiana. “And everything is playing itself out through
a complex, troublesome piece of legislation that carries both benefits and
challenges.”
7
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
While the healthcare industry has always grappled with change, never before has
the change been so profound or broad based. Among the most challenging trends
witnessed by InveniasPartners in its work with hospitals, health systems and payer
organizations are the following:
8
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
Integration/Accountable Care
C-Suite executives and board members must decide if an HCO can emerge as an in-
tegrated delivery system (IDS) that would ultimately evolve into an accountable care
organization (ACO), according to Jay Eckersley, partner in the Salt Lake City, Utah
office of InveniasPartners. The strategy: Reap the rewards of market share growth
through covered lives, premiums and payments based on quality and outcomes.
Still, some hospitals and health systems are joining ACOs, helping to usher in the
prediction that more than 200 million Americans will be covered by ACOs by 2016,
says a report from ReportsonReports.com. Other hospitals and health systems are
seeking relationships with public and private payers for shared savings and bundled
payments, according to a 2014 report from ITG Market Research.
For example, DaVita HealthCare Partners has joined forces with Englewood,
Colorado-based Centura Health to create relationships that incorporate “financial
incentives to manage healthcare costs and quality, including accountable care and
capitation contracts,” according to Modern Healthcare. Meanwhile, Anthem Blue
Cross has created a health plan where seven rival hospitals, including Cedars-Sinai,
UCLA Health and MemorialCare Health System, will share in profits and losses.
ACO success is evident throughout the country. Neptune, New Jersey-based Me-
9
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
ridian Health System created an ACO through a partnership with Meridian hospitals,
partner companies, and more than 800 physicians and allied health professionals. The
ACO, which now serves some 50,000 patients, promotes evidence-based medicine,
patient engagement, and an infrastructure that allows providers to report on quality
and cost metrics.
Under CEO Joel Allison, FACHE, Baylor Scott & White Health, Dallas, Texas, has
advanced population health through an ACO called the Baylor Scott & White Quality
Alliance. Hospital admissions for the ACO’s 34,000 members have already declined
more than 4 percent, while 30-day readmissions are down 18 percent with a 7 percent
cost savings.
10
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
Consolidation
Just as troubling to C-Suite and board members is the surge in mergers and acquisitions, a
trend that will continue throughout 2015, according to a report from Moody’s Investors Service.
The implications and results of consolidation may vary by provider size.
Struggling smaller hospitals are likely to gain from being acquired by larger, stronger systems,
predicts Moody’s. However, hospital and health system consolidation may emerge as a “credit
negative” for acquirers due to “high financial leverage associated with acquisitions and the risks
that come with acquired assets.”
According to Curt Lucas, President and CEO, InveniasPartners, consolidation deals typically
involve the following:
Because loose affiliations often fall apart against managed care pressures, HCOs often
“merge up to avoid scrambling the egg,” says Eckersley. C-Suite search assignments typically
emerge immediately after a merger or before an HCO enters into its next merger discussion.
This is followed by pre and post-merger talent management in anticipation of a newly created
integrated delivery system and re-engineering of the C-Suite to include a specific number of
executives—often no more than 8–10.
Formed through the 2013 merger between Baylor Health Care System and Scott & White
Healthcare, Baylor Scott & White Health is now the largest not-for-profit health system in Texas
with 43 hospitals, some $9 billion in net revenue and a patient population larger than the state of
Virginia. The goal: Increase efficiency to combat shrinking margins brought about by healthcare
reform and the Affordable Care Act.
“Combining two systems offered us the opportunity to develop new models of care that
support individual patient care and population health management,” says Joel T. Allison,
FACHE, President and CEO, Baylor Scott & White Health. “By using our size and strength to
zero in on the health and well-being of patients, families and communities, we can continue
to offer high-quality care at an affordable cost.”
11
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
“Healthcare has always taken care of the sick, but the emerging measure of success
is how well HCOs can manage and ensure the health of a population,” says George
Popko, partner, InveniasPartners. “It’s no longer about how to run a hospital, but how
to engage physicians and sustain population health.”
Fortunately, population health management programs are already paying off, according
to a survey of healthcare executives by KPMG LLP. More than half expect to recoup
investments in three to four years and view population health management as a
strategy to reduce avoidable medical costs and care variability.
Population health demands that C-Suites and boards align or reposition every care
entity—from hospitals, nursing homes, and imaging centers, to pharmacies, labs and
physician practices—along the expanding continuum of care, according to Popko.
Equally important, C-Suites and boards must secure and control premium dollars to
keep people healthy and manage care delivery.
As President and CEO of Irvine, California-based St. Joseph Health, Deborah Proctor
illustrates the challenges of managing a complex health system of 16 hospitals,
physician organizations, home health agencies, hospice care, outpatient services,
skilled nursing facilities and community outreach programs in Northern and Southern
California, Texas and New Mexico.
“St. Joseph Health’s emerging approach to population health management will vary
by region,” says Proctor. Texas, for example will become an insurance partner, while
Southern California will house population management within a medical foundation.
The only commonality among regions: physician leadership of population health
management.
12
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
The definition of population is also shifting; Proctor, for example, recently formed a
partnership with a residential complex equipped with a grocery store, restaurant and
fitness club, in addition to a St. Joseph Wellness Center. Within the St. Joseph Health
Wellness Corner Village, residents have access to exercise equipment, as well as
personal coaching and health and medical services available through a St. Joseph
Health medical group. Wellness Corner Village has already offered triathlon training and
a more aggressive form of yoga, along with weekly consults with plastic surgeons and
sports medicine physicians.
The project is a winner for St. Joseph Health and the residential complex. Revenues
for the medical group will continue to climb as St. Joseph Health delivers its health
and wellness services through Wellness Corner Village. More specifically, St. Joseph
Health and the complex will share data on factors like resident age, income, education,
employment, activities and preferences for evening and weekend appointments.
13
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
“Ensuring that patients and consumers get the care they need means honing in on the
retail and consumer experience—specifically how people shop,” says Baylor, Scott &
White’s Joel Allison. “How, for example, can HCOs engage young invincibles in prevention
and wellness while taking on the retailers that just migrated into the healthcare space?”
The transition calls for a massive change in culture. “It may be a challenge to think
in terms of consumers and customers instead of patients,” says Allison. “Healthcare
executives and providers have devoted their lives to patients, so it’s not in our DNA to
carry on discussions about retail, shoppers and shopping. But we need to do it.”
The shift to consumers and a retail environment may also require HCOs to open their
doors to outsiders. “HCOs need to diversify their portfolio of outsiders and identify how
these professionals could contribute to the C-Suite,” says Allison. “Healthcare needs
people who will challenge traditional thinking, but still understand healthcare’s culture,
mission, vision and values.”
“HCOs must define what they hope to become and where they’ll fit, and then pinpoint
specific areas of expertise,” adds Allison. That, in turn, calls for leaders “to run a marathon
as well as a sprint” and meet consumers’ needs in an ever-changing environment.
“Executives must be as proactive as they are reactive, accepting that some ventures will
be home runs and others will be foul balls,” he says.
The healthcare C-Suite and board are especially concerned about the evolution of retail
clinics that have surfaced within supermarkets, chain drug stores and retailers like Wal-
Mart and Target. RAND Health counsels providers to track their answers to the following
questions:
14
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
The influence of retail is also being felt in Southern California where Deborah Proctor sees
value in a community wellness or customer engagement strategy that functions like a retail
business and relies on executives to take charge of wellness, accountable care, population
health and insurance. The focus: Manage at-risk lives through population health and deliver
care within an integrated system that addresses both wellness and acute patient care.
Proctor believes that HCOs must re-engineer how they interact and engage with patients,
consumers and members. While health systems may implement consistent approaches to
care delivery, she believes the way systems approach population health management can
vary by region, community, or patient population.
Proctor has already moved forward with a customer engagement digital strategy, reflecting
a nationwide trend to engage consumers, patients and families via digital media. Hospitals
already rely on digital media to acquire and retain patients, according to experts from
BerylHealth.
St. Joseph Health’s digital platform allows customers to become partners, even if they
never sought sick care or joined an insurance plan. Community residents obtain access
to a hub, which puts them in touch with St. Joseph’s digital platform. They can load their
health data into the hub, request that a hospital interact with a wellness center or allow a
physician to see their fitness data.
For example, residents who are expecting a baby can access specialized pregnancy
content, network with communities of mothers, parents and hospital-based labor and
delivery services or locate stores selling baby supplies.
Proctor believes that St. Joseph Health’s new digital platform will give consumers access
to health information and healthcare delivery in the way they want it, where they want and
when they want it. Going forward she believes that HCOs will need fewer customer service
professionals who staff call centers and will instead need more executives who can design
and implement multiple channels for community residents to engage with a health system.
15
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
“The trends of accountable care, consolidation, population heath management and retail
competition and the consumer suggest that C-Suite and board members must rethink
healthcare’s business model,” says FMOLHS’ Finan. Among his recommended questions:
16
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
George Popko,
InveniasPartners, Princeton, New Jersey
17
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
Step 1: Leadership assessment: C-Suite and/or board members may choose to partner
with an executive search, assessment and talent advisory firm to assess executive
needs and create position specifications consistent with culture and preferred executive
performance.
Step 2: Executive selection: Executives, board members and consultants explore how
the right talent will drive clinical, financial and operational performance. Consultants brief
hiring executives and board members on interview standards, best practices, process, and
anticipated results.
Step 3: Strategic onboarding and coaching: Consultants work with hiring executives and
board members to ensure fulfillment of the four Cs: compliance, clarification, culture and
connection, all of which prevent executive derailing and enhance executives’ contributions
to strategic goals.
Step 4: Executive engagement: Consultants work with C-Suite and board members to
reinforce the HCO’s value proposition, mission, values and culture. By promoting external
and internal involvement and participation, the C-Suite and board enhance executive
engagement, performance and retention.
18
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
Step 5: Executive development: Consultants join forces with C-Suite and board members
to create an enterprise-wide leadership development program. The goals: Identify and assess
high-potential leaders. Then educate executives on how they can champion and live HCO
values.
Step 6: Succession planning: Consultants help craft a succession plan complete with
roles, responsibilities, timeframes and resources that support C-Suite and board investment
in high-potential executives, clinicians, managers and other professionals. The process
includes developing objectives that come under review every six months. The goal: leadership
continuity.
Health systems continue to evolve from cultures based on hierarchy, fragmentation and
expert-centeredness to cultures rooted in integration, collaboration, teaming, matrix structure,
and patient/family centeredness. These changes demand leaders who think strategically,
embrace change, learn quickly, move with agility and manage horizontally throughout the
enterprise.
“One thing is sure: HCOs should avoid a do-it-yourself approach. Identifying the appropriate
mix of skill, knowledge and experience requires enterprise-wide assessment,” says Jay
Eckersley, partner, InveniasPartners.
“Search, assessment and talent management firms evaluate an HCO’s mission, vision, values,
strategy and culture to identify candidates who will fit within that culture and fulfill strategic
goals,” says Lucas. “Only then can board and C-Suite members think in terms of specific
positions or clusters of positions.”
This includes merging titles like chief incentive officer, chief experience officer, chief
engagement officer, chief safety officer, chief population health officer and chief technology
officer.
19
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
The best executive search, assessment and talent management firms challenge the
“specs” for positions—especially if a C-Suite and board identifies its ideal candidate
as a white male under the age of 40.
“The key,” says George Popko, “is motivating C-Suite and board members to examine
how candidates complement the HCO’s workforce, patient population and surrounding
community and service area.”
“All too often, employees, patients, families and clinicians can’t imagine how members
of a C-Suite or board could relate to their lifestyle, concerns and priorities,” counsels
Lucas. “If HCOs want to serve patients/consumers in an increasing diverse community
and nation, they must add diversity to their leadership team.”
Transitional and transformative: Recruit C-Suite and board leaders with the skill,
knowledge and experience to take on the transition to value-based accountable care,
population health management, collaborative care across the continuum and fulfillment
of meaningful use.
“C-Suite and board members sometimes chase after the best talent without seeking
skill sets that complement HCO strategy,” says Barry Ostrowsky, President and CEO,
Barnabas Health, West Orange, New Jersey. “But healthcare is less about managing
health services and more about the delivery of care, prevention and wellness in a
retail-based, consumer-oriented environment.”
Back-to-basics: Seek out C-Suite and board leaders who can focus on patient
satisfaction, quality improvement and financial performance, and who can reach past
the “bigger is better” merger and acquisition mania of past years. Lucas advises HCOs
to search for leaders who are willing to work with incentives that respond to long-term
financial, clinical and operational performance rather than quick fixes and fast wins.
Inspirational: The best executives understand how to forge bonds between C-Suite
20
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
People focus: “Seek C-Suite and board leaders who can implement enterprise-wide
human capital management and align employee performance with HCO strategy,”
counsels Popko.
Ostrowsky recommends that HCOs recruit a visionary chief human resources officer
(CHRO)—possibly someone from outside of healthcare. As a stop gap measure,
he advises HCOs to build a team of executive vice-presidents to oversee talent
management.
Openness: “Seek C-Suite leaders who won’t endlessly meet and collaborate but will
lead and act decisively,” advises Popko. Equally important, uncover leaders who are
willing to combat healthcare myopia and look for inspiration and ideas from outside
the industry.
Ostrowsky, for example, meets regularly with small groups of less experienced
professionals to discuss new and emerging trends, implications, strategies and “what
Barnabas needs to achieve success.” He also challenges professionals “not to wait for
me to explain something” but to master trends on their own.
Tech savvy: The best executives know how to leverage new and emerging
technologies. While information systems have allowed HCOs to use data more
effectively, Popko believes that it’s up to C-Suite and board members to transform
data into information, information into meaning, meaning into knowledge and
knowledge into wisdom, as first described in The Knowledge Pyramid.
Diversity: HCOs need executives who will bring diversity—in age, gender or
ethnicity—to the C-Suite and board room. “HCOs should ensure that newly developed
or recruited executives and board members complement the HCO’s patient population
and workforce,” says Lucas. “That, in turn, means working with executive search firms
that make diversity a priority.”
21
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
Eckersley recommends CEO, line and support staff leadership development for
hospitals, health plans and clinics. He envisions each system hospital being led by
a CEO, as well as a chief medical officer elected by medical staff and a chief nursing
officer. Each member of a C-Suite can share the same incentive-based goals linked to
the system’s strategic goals.
Eckersley recommends that hospitals and health systems develop multiple strategic
service lines around mission, vision and values. Physician and executive teams
can take charge of service lines that could include women and children, oncology,
neuroscience, cardiovascular, seniors, sports medicine and emergency, trauma and
burn care.
22
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
However, not all services may qualify as strategic service lines. To evaluate the prospects of
service lines, Eckersley suggests applying the following criteria:
“Hospitals and health systems increasingly abandon the belief that a physician will magically
morph into a manager and run a service line alone,” says Eckersley. “Instead, a physician
and manager should partner to build market share and assume insurance risk on a carve-
out if a contract demands it.”
Other organizations like Scripps Health have taken a different tack. When Scripps’ COO
moved up to become CEO some 14 years ago, he chose not to replace himself with
a traditional COO. Instead, COO roles and responsibilities are shared among several
executives, including the CEO, chief financial officer (CFO), and Victor Buzachero, who
handles workforce and talent management as Corporate Senior Vice-President for
Innovation, Human Resources and Performance Management. The executives also support
each other on board committees.
23
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
The executive team realized that Scripps had “grown up by picking up facilities,” says
Buzachero. What it lacked, however, was a consistent strategy for addressing the
needs of diverse functions like human resources, information technology, purchasing
and clinical care. Buzachero responded with a succession planning and benchmark
development program. The goal: Create horizontal operations leaders who assume
responsibilities across the organization that complement their vertical responsibilities.
“Our horizontal VPs are the best operations executives because they understand how
to collaborate with other operations executives,” says Buzachero. “Professionals who
might have defended their silos or turf are now committed members of a team.”
Managing across Scripps has already created the need for senior executive talent in
medical management, population health and business development. For example, a
senior vice-president of corporate development now promotes dialogue on potential
partnerships and affiliations.
24
25
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
HCA, for example, sponsors an executive development program “that ensures the
management pipeline necessary to ensure leadership today and in the future.”
Candidates can choose from two-to-three year programs focused on COO, CNO or
controller positions with promotion based on “individual development, leadership skill
assessments completed by (a) mentor and executive development leadership.”
Assessment: Who are the real leaders in this organization? What types of leaders
does FMOLHS need in terms of skill, experience, expertise and cultural fit?
Expectations: What are the behaviors required for success? FMOLHS focuses on
mission, quality, satisfaction (team member, patient, physician), and financial results.
What kind of performance is expected?
Goals and objectives: How do we create a clear line of sight from organizational
performance requirements to individual leader personal goals and contributions to
success?
Support: How can FMOLHS provide the resources—human, financial and structural—
that executives need to support performance excellence?
26
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
Scripps evaluates its executives based on outcomes, including employee morale, financial
performance, quality and patient satisfaction. By feeding performance data into an
algorithm, Buzachero can rank executives and executive performance from highest to
lowest.
Executives in the top quartile tend to perform well in every category: budget, turnover,
patient satisfaction and quality. However, executives in the lowest quartile miss on almost
every measure, while those in the middle quartile demonstrate mixed results. The actionable
data and intelligence allow Scripps to validate and invest in high-potential executives.
“Scripps no longer relies on performance reviews, just concrete statistics,” says Buzachero,
who compares the process to the narrative of the 2011 film “Money Ball.” By securing
data on how well executives perform under pressure in a variety of settings, Scripps can
formulate individualized plans for improvement. Or the system can transform the highest-
performing executives into mentors, coaches or heroes that up-and-coming executives
might want to emulate.
And what about executives who rank near the bottom? Buzachero and his colleagues work
to find these executives less complex, more realistic positions. However, if the executives
fail to perform after a period of three years, they invariably leave the organization.
Executives who rank in the middle typically qualify for coaching and possible placement
within Scripps.
Scripps always leaves the door open to new executives who might head up massive
development, construction or redesign projects. Buzachero already sees the need for an
executive who could re-engineer some of Scripps’ clinical areas. However, he insists that
the executive be someone “with a transformational mindset, lean experience and the talent
to teach Scripps new skill sets.”
27
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
Buzachero’s passion for executive development is shared by Allison of Baylor Scott &
White. Allison advises HCOs to pinpoint emerging leaders and perform regular assessments
of professionals who are likely to occupy executive positions in one-to-three years. For
example, Baylor requires each emerging executive to prepare a performance development
plan complete with goals for improvement.
“Developing leadership talent is the best way for an HCO to get ready for situations that
call for someone to step in to develop or run a program,” says Allison. “And the premium
strategy for doing that is to assess and develop talent faster than your competitors.”
Executive assessment and development are vital to succession planning and management,
according to Lucas. These programs typically start with a succession management plan that
delineates targeted roles and assessment and development of high-potential executives.
By relying on succession planning, HCOs can ensure leadership continuity and avoid
disruptions that come with crisis and turnover.
Experts agree. Succession planning ensures the survival of any business, according to a
2014 Harvard Business Review blog. The author recommends that C-Suites and boards
sustain their focus on succession planning—even when a CEO’s retirement is two-to-three
years out. Equally important: Observe how candidates interact with the outgoing CEO and
set clear expectations on the new CEO’s roles and responsibilities.
and ongoing assessment and talent management of c-suite executives and board
members. Just as vital, says InveniasPartners, is integration of fresh, diverse points of
view and creation of an environment that supports innovation and change.
28
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
HCO success hinges on the ability of C-Suite and board members to engage and align
clinicians, employees and managers with strategic objectives and goals, not on the
ability to recruit, hire and reward people for competency or tenure.
Adds Lucas: “We need to recognize executives who are willing to move the bar on
performance outcomes in measurable areas like patient satisfaction, quality, safety,
efficiency and cost, not just those who stick with the organization for years.”
Industry changes have sold Baylor, Scott and White’s Allison on the concept of team-
based care and a team-based C-Suite and board development. “Surround yourself
with people who can develop and execute on new ideas and sustain a spirit of
innovation and entrepreneurship that surges throughout the enterprise,” he says. “If
you’re committed to team-based collaboration, the last thing you want is a C-Suite or
board controlled by one or two executives.”
29
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
HCOs that commit to developing existing executives for higher, more expansive
roles may be less likely to conduct exhaustive searches of external candidates. The
answers will surface in research that evaluates the following:
Finan has introduced an assessment process to confirm the quality of existing talent
and identify executives who would participate in accelerated development programs
and then serve in expanded or emerging executive roles.
30
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
Adds Finan: “FMOLHS will go outside of healthcare or our organization if we have to,
but we believe that we build a stronger organization by promoting executives within
the organization. The key is developing a strong mix of executives who complement
each other’s strengths, while compensating for areas that need enhancement.”
31
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
“HCOs need professionals with the knowledge, skill and experience to envision the
next wave of innovation and forge a path to enterprise-wide transformation,” says
Lucas. As an alternative to quick termination and turnover, he advises C-Suite and
board members to work with search, assessment and talent management firms to
evaluate the performance of existing executives along with the HCO’s overarching
needs for fresh skill sets, knowledge, experience and competencies.
HCOs can then develop position specifications based on clinical, financial and
operational needs, including demographic needs, rather than on the popularity or
trendiness of a specific C-Suite position.
Equally important is revamping incentive programs. “While almost all HCOs now offer
incentive and bonus programs for senior executives, the programs often typically
aren’t strong enough to incentivize or differentiate between short or long term
leadership performance,” says Lucas.
Short-term incentives, which typically come in the form of an annual bonus, reward
executives for “moving the needle” on variables like patient satisfaction, reduced
morality or healthcare-associated infections. However, few programs hone in on the
clinical outcomes goals, strategic organizational priorities and long-term financial
performance.
FMOLHS’ Finan believes that many physicians falsely assume that completion of
an MBA program is a fast track to the C-Suite. He counsels physicians to consider
alternatives such as serving as examiners for the Baldrige program or attending
programs similar to those offered by the Harvard School of Public Health or the
American Association of Physician Leadership.
32
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
Ostrowsky’s approach also surfaces in his interactions with members of the medical
staff, who typically want an inside track on strategy, implementation, results, benefits
and roadblocks. Among the questions Ostrowsky prepares to answer: Where is
Barnabas headed? How can physicians participate? How can we better align
physicians with Barnabas’ strategic goals and objectives?
“Do everything you can to see that the C-Suite is an extension of the enterprise,” says
Ostrowsky. “It’s a mistake to connect the enterprise to a C-Suite that no longer fits the
HCO’s strategy.”
He believes reaching out embraces the recruitment of board members who are
prepared to enforce C-Suite accountability, represent or reflect other industries and
ensure clinical, financial and operational performance.
“C-Suite and executive team members also need to get out from behind their desks to
conduct rounds throughout the enterprise,” counsels Lucas. “They should listen and
seek answers to core questions: What’s working? What isn’t working? What should be
changed—now and in the short-term future? Which innovations should be introduced
and launched?”
“CEOs need a truthful evaluation of facts, opinions and implications of new and
emerging trends,” says Ostrowsky. He recommends using panels of experts to deliver
advice on diverse enterprise functions, including talent management and human
resources, as well as emerging healthcare trends.
33
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
“Network with C-Suite executives and board members within the provider, payer,
government and retail healthcare communities, but also reach for inspiration from
entertainment, sports, technology, retail and consumer products,” says Lucas. “If you
insist on staying in your own back yard, you may get fenced in.”
He recommends that C-Suite and board members move through these steps:
And what happens if an HCO responds to the call for accountable care and
integrates enough to assume insurance risk? It should at least consider going at risk
and sponsoring a health plan. “Providers need not allow insurance companies to do
what they could do themselves: wholesale or group contract services to self-insured
employers,” advises Popko.
HCOs should also select service lines to grow market share or covered lives. They
might, for example, market an at-risk product for orthopedics to employers or
insurance companies, or sell services such as vascular grafts for a specific price.
“The key,” says Eckersley, “is acting on the assumption that large employers will use
health plan products to improve quality and outcomes.”
34
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
“Innovation flourishes when clinicians, executives, managers and employees are aligned
and collaborate across the enterprise,” says Lucas. “Collaboration should reach beyond
the enterprise to embrace think tanks, associations, vendors, government and media.”
Hospitals and health systems are already involved in community-wide partnerships that
“bring a wide range of stakeholders—healthcare providers, educators, business leaders,
social service providers, community organizations, and clergy—together to promote
healthy behavior, improve access to primary and preventive care, and reduce health
disparities,” according to the Commonwealth Fund.
Funded by the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation (RWJF) and the Kresge Foundation,
the Hilltop Institute’s Community Benefit Programs foster collaboration between multiple
hospitals and local health agencies, according to Partnerships for Community Health.
Change also beckons executives and board members to broaden the concept of
engagement to include former competitors and diverse fields and disciplines like sports,
entertainment, politics, media and religion.
• St. Joseph Health teamed up with the Los Angeles Angels to mark Cancer
Survivorship Day, while recognizing community heroes through its St Joseph
Health Heroes campaign and Halo Moments Web site.
• Massachusetts General Hospital has partnered with the Boston Red Sox to
establish Home Base, a provider of healthcare services to deliver care for Iraq
and Afghanistan veterans who have combat or deployment-related stress or
traumatic brain injury (TBI). Home Base also provides counseling and support
for veteran’s families and those who are closest to the veteran.
35
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
Executives must also take a fresh look at former competitors that could easily morph
into partners. St. Joseph Health, which once competed with Hoag Memorial Hospital,
is now part of an alliance called St. Joseph Hoag Health. In 2014, St Joseph joined with
Children’s Hospital of Orange County (CHOC) to form an accountable care organization.
“As HCOs become larger and more complex, C-Suites and boards must also change,”
says Lucas. For example, one hospital CEO who managed 150 employees for five
years faced an organization that grew to 1,500 employees in just one year. While the
CEO struggled to maintain his existing C-Suite team, he eventually realized that he
needed a new team to meet changing requirements in human resources, marketing and
information systems.
“C-Suite executives often fall into a pattern of passivity and the mentality of don’t rock
the boat,” says Popko. “The search for collaboration can easily evolve into a relentless
pursuit of consensus. The CEO and members of the board and C-Suite must lead and
take ownership.”
36
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
Small independent hospitals may continue to falter without integration: Mergers and
acquisitions could lead to nothing more than a collection of hospitals that operate under
a single umbrella. “What’s needed,” says Lucas, “is integration and alignment driven by
C-Suite and board leaders who envision the HCO’s evolution over the next three-to-five
years and forge strategies around margin, revenue, quality of care and satisfaction.”
The future will hinge on care management, making physician and nurse leadership
indispensable, Healthcare’s future is about improving the management of care and the
best people to lead that change are often clinicians,” says Finan. “The CEO must view the
HCO through the lens of what is needed to provide complete care of the patient.”
That means the HCO must evaluate clinical process and improve care teams to deliver
predictable outcomes and costs. For example, one FMOLHS organization established
a joint program in which physicians, nurse leaders and team members redesigned
orthopedics processes that start with an office visit for knee pain and conclude with the
final visit following a surgical procedure and rehab.
37
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
Consumers will come into their own. Baylor Scott & White’s Allison is convinced
that healthcare will reach beyond conversations about patients to conversations about
consumers as the industry expands population health management and embraces
the evolving continuum of care. Authentic population health management will blend
prevention, wellness and patient management in the best, most appropriate settings
across the continuum, he predicts.
Innovation superstars will stay on HCOs’ radar. Healthcare C-Suites and boards
will likely search for colleagues with characteristics often found among increasingly
popular chief innovation officers (CINOs). Many organizations struggle to innovate
because they don’t know how to lead the process, according to Collective Genius: The
Art and Practice of Leading Innovation. Top-notch innovators can unleash and harness
the “collective genius” of everyone in the organization, says the book’s author.
38
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
Accountability will increase: “HCOs will increasingly insist on board performance and
accountability,” forecasts Popko. Board members, in turn, will hold C-Suites accountable,
insisting that executives adhere to strategic goals and priorities. The trend could mean
recruitment of board members with fresh, outside-the-industry perspectives and extensive
business experience.
Talent management will surge. HCOs will need internal and external performance
management expertise to evaluate and enhance leadership capabilities that improve care
processes. That, in turn, requires measuring how well clinicians, employees and executives
fulfill enterprise goals and objectives. Adds Eckersley; “Human capital management is
the selection, development, management and alignment of talent and human capital with
business and clinical strategies and tactics.”
C-Suite turnover and retooling will continue: “As healthcare shifts from fee-for-service
to accountable care, C-Suite turnover may be inevitable,” predicts Lucas. “Half of C-Suite
executives will need to re-learn healthcare, re-tool skills and operate within new and
emerging clinical and business models.” That could mean ongoing turnover within the
C-Suite as documented within American College of Healthcare Executives (ACHE) turnover
studies and the growing emphasis on investment in enterprise-wide assessment and talent
management.
New positions will surface on C-Suites and boards. Not every new and emerging C-Suite
position will survive or become commonplace. That being said, Lucas envisions growing
roles for population health managers within hospitals, health plans and medical groups,
as well as accountable care managers within hospitals and health plans. Also gaining in
popularity is the chief ambulatory care officer—especially within hospitals that rely on an
expanded care continuum for revenues.
39
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
Baylor Scott & White’s Allison envisions a healthcare C-Suite composed of physician and
nurse executives, along with chief officers devoted to population health, integration and
experience and physicians and nurse executives who lead clinical enterprises. Baylor’s
Office of Patient Centeredness, which aims to create positive experiences for providers,
patients and family members, relies on the expertise of a chief safety officer, chief
information officer and chief patient experience officer.
“The key,” says Allison, “is to embrace trends like consolidation, value-based payment and
population health while sustaining a focus on patient experience, engagement and care.”
St. Joseph Health’s Proctor envisions a strategy and business development executive with
customer engagement experience who could come from outside of healthcare. She’s already
staffed senior marketing positions with professionals from other industries, following the
lead of C-Suite and boards that increasingly recruit talent from hospitality, financial services
and other consumer-facing sectors.
40
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
Adds Proctor: “As we move from acute care to care across an ever-expanding continuum,
we need C-Suite executives who understand customers—who they are, how they behave,
why they get sick and what they’re willing to do to stay healthy.”
“The key,” she says, “is making the transition from selling sick healthcare to selling
partnerships in enhanced health and well-being” through “an open model where people can
go anywhere they want for a healthcare experience.”
Patient experience will grow as a C-Suite function. Fewer than 100 hospitals have chief
experience officers (CXOs), according to Catalyst Healthcare Research. However, analysts
like the Beryl Institute view the CXO as an emerging role “that encompasses and leads a
broad portfolio of resources and services fundamental to the patient and family experience—
from advocacy to service and, in some cases, broadening to lead or significantly influence
people, quality and safety issues.”
The next round of CEOs will likely be physician executives. Insurance companies that
employ physician executives have already set a precedent for recruiting executives to head
up healthcare systems that will either function like insurance companies or act in partnership
with insurance companies.
“Physicians understand hospital and health system culture and the intersection of clinical,
financial and operational strategy, along with population health, insurance and technology,”
says Eckersley. “With backgrounds in insurance and clinical care, they know how to manage
large groups, analyze data, strike premiums and manage costs.”
“HCOs will embrace physicians, nurses and other clinicians as future C-Suite and board
members,” predicts Lucas. “Candidates will include nurses who evolved into human
resources, technology or operational positions or became presidents of hospitals. Or, board
members will emerge from the ranks of physicians with specialized expertise in technology,
government, public policy, clinical management or insurance.”
41
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
“Physicians feel more confident and secure when they’re included in decisions that affect
them and have representation from physician leader,” says FMOLHS’ Finan. “Often a
physician leader can help physicians connect care decisions to quality, satisfaction, and cost
outcomes. It’s a different perspective and mindset that we need within C-Suites, boards and
throughout the enterprise.”
When FMOLHS launched its population health program, Finan found its leader in a pediatric
emergency physician who had been its chief medical information officer. When FMOLHS
created a clinical network to improve quality and assume financial risk, it turned to a
physician executive at its Baton Rouge hospital. Ultimately, the physician emerged as the
leader of a clinical network. A physician serving as FMOLHS’ Vice-President of Performance
Excellence and Technology was selected to unify multiple practices across the system.
42
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
Conclusion
Healthcare is changing. HCOs must act in the context of trends that include accountable
care, consolidation, population health management, retail competition and the burgeoning
role of consumers. The preferred approach is for C-Suite and board members to rely on
external expertise and a disciplined process to find and develop talent with the right mix of
knowledge, skill, experience and leadership insight. HCOs must also create structures that
ensure C-Suite and board success, including a process through which they can assess and
develop executives. HCOs can look forward to a future where C-Suite and board members
will need to demonstrate knowledge, skill and competence in diverse areas, including
innovation, accountable care, population health, consumer behavior, digital health, patient
engagement and experience, and predictive analytics.
43
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
Resources
Top Health Industry Issues of 2015: Outlines of a C-Suite Executives Share Early Challenges on
Market Emerge Healthcare Reform
http://www.pwc.com/en_US/us/health-industries/top- http://ir.medassets.com/releasedetail.
health-industry-issues/assets/pwc-hri-top-healthcare- cfm?ReleaseID=824866
issues-2015.pdf http://www.healthcareitnews.com/news/how-get-c-
suite-focus-security
Healthcare Delivery of the Future: How Digital
Technologies Can Bridge the Gap of Time and Evolution in the C-Suite and the Evolving Role of the
Distance between Clinicians and Consumers CMIO
http://www.pwc.com/us/technologyandinnovation http://www.healthcareitnews.com/news/how-get-c-
suite-focus-security
Healthcare Predictions for 2015
http://techcrunch.com/2014/12/27/top-5-healthcare- Developing Mindful Leaders for the C-Suite
predictions-for-2015/ http://blogs.hbr.org/2014/03/developing-mindful-
leaders-for-the-c-suite/
Grim Outlook for Healthcare, Hospital Sector in 2015:
Rating Agencies
http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/12/17/ Five Hospital C-Suite Trends: Who’s Making It to the
us-healthcare-nonprofit-ratings- Corner Office
idUSKBN0JV00R20141217 http://www.healthcareitnews.com/news/how-get-c-
suite-focus-security
Five Digital Health Trends You’ll See in 2015
http://mashable.com/2014/12/16/health-tech- The Wisdom Hierarchy: Representations of the DIKW
trends-2015/ Hierarchy
http://jis.sagepub.com/content/33/2/163.abstract
Consumers’ Influence on Health IT in 2015
http://www.ihealthbeat.org/perspectives/2014/ Poll Reveals C-Suite Focus on Clinical Operations
consumers-influence-on-health-it-in-2015 http://healthcareceoforum.com/news/healthcare-poll-
shows-c-suite-focus-on-clinical-operations
The Future 100: Trends and Changes in 2015
https://www.jwt.com/en/worldwide/thinking/ C-Suite Must Band Together to Rein in Healthcare
thefuture100trendsandchangetowatchin2015/ Costs
http://nbchnewsletter.blogspot.com/2014/09/c-suite-
Hospitals Elevate Patient Satisfaction to the C-Suite must-band-together-to-rein-in.html
http://www.informationweek.com/healthcare/
leadership/hospitals-elevate-patient-satisfaction-to-
the-c-suite/d/d-id/1127860
44
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
Voices from the C-Suite: Perspectives on Patient The C-Suite Is Expanding: Why it’s Worrisome
Experience http://www.beckershospitalreview.com/healthcare-
https://theberylinstitute.site-ym.com/store/ blog/the-c-suite-is-expanding-why-it-s-worrisome.
ViewProduct.aspx?id=1510539 html
Physicians in the C-Suite The Future of the Hospital C-Suite with Paul Keckley
http://www.kornferryinstitute.com/reports-insights/ http://www.dotmed.com/news/story/23922
physicians-c-suite
IBM Insights from the IBM Global C-Suite Study
How HR Can be the Healthcare C-Suite’s Secret http://www-935.ibm.com/services/us/en/c-suite/
Weapon csuitestudy2013/
http://www.healthleadersmedia.com/content/HR-
301587/How-HR-Can-Be-the-CSuites-Secret-Weapon IT Has Finally Cracked the C-Suite
http://www-935.ibm.com/services/us/en/c-suite/
Wanted: Hospital CEOs without Healthcare csuitestudy2013/
Experience
http://health.usnews.com/health-news/hospital-of- Don’t Stop Learning Once You Hit the C-Suite
tomorrow/articles/2014/01/28/wanted-hospital-ceos- http://hbr.org/tip/2014/08/27/dont-stop-learning-
without-health-care-experience once-you-hit-the-c-suite
Survey Reveals Priorities for the Healthcare C-Suite The Seven Skills You Need to Thrive in the C-Suite
http://www.aethon.com/survey-reveals-priorities- http://blogs.hbr.org/2014/03/the-seven-skills-you-
hospital-c-suite/ need-to-thrive-in-the-c-suite/
45
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
IBM: Top Five Lessons for CIOS from the C-Suite New Anthem Blue Cross Plan Takes on Kaiser
Report http://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-anthem-
http://www.forbes.com/sites/peterhigh/2014/06/24/ hospitals-deal-20140917-story.html#page=1
ibm-top-five-lessons-for-cios-from-c-suite-report/
Digital Patient Engagement & Hospital Marketing
Take a Look at How Market Forces Will Impact Health Strategies to Improve Patient Acquisition and
Care Retention
http://www.hhnmag.com/display/HHN-news- http://www.beckershospitalreview.com/healthcare-
article.dhtml?dcrPath=/templatedata/HF_Common/ information-technology/9-digital-patient-engagement-
NewsArticle/data/HHN/Magazine/2014/Sep/gate-aha- hospital-marketing-strategies-to-improve-patient-
environment-scan-2015 acquisition-and-retention.html
46
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
Foundation Medicine
http://www.foundationmedicine.com
Organizations
Barnabas Health
http://www.barnabashealth.org/
47
InveniasPartners: Delivering Leadership Excellence
InveniasPartners