Gender Roles Socialization in Patriarchy Society
Gender Roles Socialization in Patriarchy Society
Gender Roles Socialization in Patriarchy Society
5.1: INTRODUCTION
Patriarchy literally means "rule of the father", today it is a term that refers to
social systems where power is concentrated in the hands of adult men. In this type of
system men hold authority over women, children and property, leading to female
subordination.
Traditional gender roles cast men as strong, decisive, rational and protective while
women are seen as emotional, irrational, weak, nurturing and submissive. These
gender roles are restrictive of both men and women as it is degrading for a man to
have some sort of female characteristic and unattractive for a woman to have some
Gender roles are a set of social and behavioral norms that, within a specific
specific sex. The perception of gender roles includes attitudes, actions and
personality traits associated with a particular gender within that culture. Gender
roles are predominantly considered within a family context as well as within society
261
in general and may collectively be referred to as gender stereotypes which are
friends, school etc. can effect on that as socializing factors. So, it is observed that
appropriate gender behaviours of women and men that are learned during
socialization process mostly are associated with gender stereotype beliefs which are
next generation.
thoughts in early years of 1970s in a book called “sexual Politics”. Kate Millet
objectivity, agency and structure. The term patriarchy has a long old history in
political science theories. The origin of this word is the word Patriarchs which means
tribe leader. This concept was used widely in political literature of 17th century for
In fact this word was used for explaining government in which the relation
between the king and people was like father and son. Millet borrowed this term from
politics and there are two reasons for this borrowing. First, according to Millet’s
opinion in a patriarchy system, all men have domination on women. Second, old men
261
are prior to younger and children. It seems that due to same reason Millet has
any way gradually this term extended between all feminists whom have now changed
a social and ideological construct which considers men (who are the patriarchs) as
social structures and practices, in which men dominate, oppress and exploit women”
hierarchal and unequal where men control women’s production, reproduction and
which strengthen the iniquitous power relations between men and women. Patriarchy
is not a constant and gender relations which are dynamic and complex have changed
over the periods of history. The nature of control and subjugation of women varies
from one society to the other as it differs due to the differences in class, caste,
nature, certain characteristics such as control over women’s sexuality and her
reproductive power cuts across class, caste, ethnicity, religions and regions and is
261
institutionalized and legitimized by several ideologies, social practices and
institutions such as family, religion, caste, education, media, law, state and society,
women's mobility and burdens them with the responsibilities to nurture and rear
children. The biological factor to bear children is linked to the social position of
The first lessons of patriarchy are learnt in the family where the head of the
family is a man/ father. Man is considered the head of the family and controls
hierarchal system as it not only mirrors the order in the state and educates its children
but also creates and constantly reinforces that order (Lerner, 1986: 127; also see
Bhasin, 1993: 10). Family is therefore important for socializing the next generation
in patriarchal values. The boys learn to be dominating and aggressive and girls learn
are not only social constructs but also have been internalized by both men and
women. While the pressure to earn and look after the family is more on the man, the
261
women are supposed to do the menial jobs and take care of their children and even
other members of the family. It is because of these gender stereotypes that women
rape, sexual harassment, sexual abuse, female feticide, infanticide, sati, dowry
self-sacrificing, self-effacing pure image of women and through ritual practice which
emphasized the dominant role of women as a faithful wife and devout mother (Desai
Laws of Manu insist that since women by their very nature are disloyal they
a God, which symbolized that man is a lord, master, owner, or provider and women
wife of her husband and as a widow of her son (Chakravarti,2006: 75). While in
266
ancient India (Vedic and Epic periods), women were by and large treated as equal to
men, the restrictions on women and patriarchal values regulating women’s sexuality
and mobility got strengthened in the post-Vedic periods (Brahmanical and Medieval
periods) with the rise of private property and establishment of class society.
and the laws and norms regarding family, marriage, divorce and inheritance are
linked to patriarchal control over property biased against women. A person’s legal
identity with regard to marriage, divorce and inheritance are determined by his or her
religion, which has laid down duties for men and women and their relationship. Most
religions endorse patriarchal values and all major religions have been interpreted and
controlled by men of upper caste and class. The imposition of parda, restrictions on
leaving the domestic space, separation between public and private are all gender
specific and men are not subjected to similar constraints. Thus the mobility of
women is controlled. They have no right to decide whether they want to be mothers,
when they want to be, the number of children they want to have, whether they can
use contraception or terminate a pregnancy and so on and so forth (also see Bhasin:
6).Male dominated institutions like church and state also lay down rules regarding
261
5.3: MORE DETAILED ANALYSES OF PATRIARCHAL BELIEFS IN THIS
STUDY
the acceptance rate of gender stereotypes, so the researcher has focused on the
acceptance rate of gender stereotypes variance. She has tested the relationship
between patriarchal beliefs and nationality, gender, marital status, study field, family
size, occupational status, living area variables which has shown in the following
tables:
Table-5.1
The T-test of the variables (table-5.1) shows the T value as 6.3 and 0.5 at a
significance level of (0.00 & 0.6) respectively for India and Iran. Thereby, it can be
said that the gender has affected the patriarchal beliefs in India but it has not affected
the patriarchal beliefs in Iran. The mean differences are significant in India regarding
261
Chart-5.1
Gender and Patriarchal Beliefs by intervention of the nationality
16
14
12
10
8
6
4 partiarchy
2
0
The chart-5.1 shows that the acceptance rate of gender stereotypes among
Indian male is more than Indian female but there is no significant difference between
Iranian male and female and also this chart indicates that the acceptance rate of
gender stereotypes among Indian male is more than Iranian male and the acceptance
rate of gender stereotypes among Indian female is less than Iranian female.
Table-5.2
ANOVA Test for Study Field and Patriarchal Beliefs by Intervention of the
Nationality
Nationality Sum of Mean F d.f. Sig
Square Square
261
The ANOVA test of the variables (table-5.2) shows the F value as 16.957 &
4.770 at a significance level of (0.00 & 0.009) respectively for India and Iran.
Thereby, it can be said that the study field and patriarchal beliefs is valid; therefore,
it is inferred that there is a significant difference between the study field of Indian
and Iranian students regarding patriarchal beliefs; so the result can be generalized to
the universe.
Table-5.3
TUKEY HSD Test for Study Field and Patriarchal Beliefs by intervention of the
nationality
TUKEY test shows the study field is influenced the patriarchal beliefs only
among Indian students, while the study field is not influenced the patriarchal beliefs
among Iranian students. The table-5.3 shows that among three study fields, there is a
significant relationship. It means that there is a significant difference between Art &
Social Science, Engineering & Technology and Science in India. But the above table
shows that there is only a significant difference between Engineering & Technology
211
Chart-5.2
Study Field and Patriarchal Beliefs by intervention of the nationality
16
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0 Series 1
The above chart indicates that the patriarchy beliefs among Indian students
of the Art & Social Science is more than the other study fields (Science and Eng-
tech) and also the patriarchy beliefs among Iranian students of the Science is more
Table-5.4
T Test for Living Area and Patriarchal Beliefs by Intervention of the
Nationality
Nationality N Mean Std.Deviation t d.f. Sig(2-
Living Area tailed)
India Urban 142 11.74 4.62 4.575 366 0.000
Rural 216 14.00 4.54
Iran Urban 243 12.72 5.17 1.594 267 0.1
Rural 26 14.38 3.96
212
The T-test of the variables (table-5.3) shows the T value as 4.575 at a
significance level of (p=0.00). Thereby, it can be said that the living area and
respondents ; therefore, T-test shows that mean of the patriarchal beliefs of Indian
the Indian students. But this is not significant for Iranian students.
Chart-5.3
Living Area and Patriarchal Beliefs by Intervention of the Nationality
15
10
5
0
patriarchy beliefs
The chart-5.3 shows that the patriarchal beliefs among Indian and Iranian
211
Table-5.5
The above table (5.4) reveals that there is a positive and weak correlation
between family Size and patriarchal beliefs (r=0.130, sig=0.01) among Indian
students and there is a positive correlation between family size and patriarchal beliefs
(r=0.119, sig=0.05) among Iranian students. Thus, it can be inferred that as the
number of family size of Indian and Iranian respondents increases, the patriarchal
beliefs increases. This result is significant and it can be generalized to the universe.
Since the mid-1980s, the term empowerment has become popular in the
as to what the term means among development actors. The concept of women's
211
movement, particularly by "third world" feminists. They clearly state that women's
women having less control over material assets and intellectual resources. Women
participate in their own oppression so they must first become aware of the ideology
The empowerment process starts from within but access to new ideas and
information will come from external agents. With new consciousness and the
strength of solidarity, women can assert their right to control resources and to
Empowerment is a process by which those who have been denied power gain
power, in particular the ability to make strategic life choices. For women, these could
children. For this power to come about, three interrelated dimensions are needed:
access to and control of resources; agency (the ability to use these resources to bring
about new opportunities); and achievements (the attainment of new social outcomes).
Women are empowered; does that mean that men have less power?
often poorly understood. The need to empower women responds to the growing
211
recognition that women in developing countries lacks control over resources and the
same time, the realization that women have an increasingly important role to play in
through various ways by equipping the right and power as so to enable to fight
against male hegemony. Apart from the Constitution which provides for the gender
equality and also to lessen the gap between two sexes, law can create empowerment
supporting, stimulating and monitoring the attitudinal and values change in society.
sanctions against certain types of behavior that violates the dignity and liberty of
them a share on matrimonial property or giving them a right to work and an equal
compensatory discrimination in their favour by reserving jobs and seats in local self-
governing institution. Lastly, by facilitating the exercise of liberty and freedom for
females.
211
In relation to empowerment of women through institutional infrastructure,
one of the most important strategies for their empowerment is to facilitate access to
grievance redresses and rights enforcing institution. Contrasting with the ancient
times when patriarchy was all supreme, the modern Indian and Iranian infrastructure
which includes the Family Court Act which was passed and which provides an
establishment of family court in the view of conciliation and securing the settlement
The movement to change public opinion and societal attitudes and values can
at the most catalyze by law. But such change cannot come merely through legal
prescriptions. The law can help by protecting the freedom of those people who
crusade for the change and by firmly preventing those who try to subvert. Gender
considered. Before the national legal instruments are discussed, it is better to know
first about the international legal instruments which give guarantee and protection for
women. They include the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 1948, the
on of All Forms of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW), 1979 and also the
216
With respect to the Indian and Iranian constitutional guarantee against
patriarchy, both Constitutions have provided many provisions to give guarantees and
safeguard women and also in order to raise the dignity and strengthening the
empowerment of women. First and foremost the preamble itself contains the goal of
equal status and opportunity for all citizens, either men or women. Further various
articles which include Articles which give guarantee on equality before the law and
equal protection of law, forbid discrimination on the ground of sex by the State,
educational institution.
others expect in reciprocal action with them. This process helps people to adapt with
the group (Doyle and Paluti, 1998:73). Values teaching process, attitudes formation
socialization. With realization of this process, individual would find identity or social
self. Socialization factors have important role in transferring gender roles and gender
fundamental parts: families, schools, media etc. In patriarchal society, these factors
usually make obedience, passive, emotional and dependent picture from women and
an independent, firm, deserve, capable and decisive picture of men. And choose toys
in two years old which are suitable for their gender. In the third birthday child can
211
classify people according to being men and women and have some social
expectations of both genders. In about five years old children start to learn
abstractive psychological related to the gender stereotypes. In their opinion boys are
adult, too noisy, aggressive, and capable and girls are little, silent, obedient and
patriarchal society.
Jefri Rubin and his coworkers in a research in 1974 found that parents
behave with their children based on their gender role traits. Several studies showed
that the way in which adults behave with their children is completely affected by
their classifying in boys and girls groups (Doyle and Paludi, 1998:74). According to
parents' stereotype expectations from sons and daughters often are shown that gender
roles socialization of children are simplified using toys and clichés clothes choice. In
another way, parents enhance gender roles of their children with choosing method of
children's overall participation in doing house work. For example girls are used for
works such as cleaning up, setting the table and washing and boys are used in objects
In another way, mass media such as books, magazines, radio, TV, internet,
cinema… have important role in socialization. In most Medias women should act in
amazing activities and active roles while girls are generally limited and act passive.
Usually in children stories, men perform amazing activities and active roles while
211
girls are generally limited and act passive. School and friends also directly and
indirectly produce and reproduce gender roles in children (Ibid: 79). Definitely
women gender behaviours are completely distinguishable and different from men
are represented which are the basis of gender identity of a person. People's thoughts
about themselves are never performed in the void but are formed in the interactions
(Wood, 1999:57). In the patriarchal cultures, women's roles are considered so much
lower than men's and this consideration is produced and reproduced through social
relations, therefore there is a mutual relation between patriarchal society and gender
role socialization. It means both patriarchal society and gender role socialization
In social role theory, men and women learn femininity and masculinity
through social conditions and even learn gender roles related to their biological
Surveys show that behavioral differences are mostly based on gender stereotype
beliefs and caused women act as feminine style and also men act men's fashion.
Gender role theory, is one of the most effective explanations for reasons of
Eagly believes that one of the reasons which men and women enhance
gender stereotype beliefs is the way of their performance based on social roles. Roles
which have been separated based on gender borders (Vogel, et al, 2003:1).so, men
211
and women act based on type of gender classification because roles which they play
need different skills and include different expectations. for example since women
have been seen in educational roles and roles combined with humans relations
traditionally, they are expected to look after children and olds of a family, While
men are expected to have instrumental and active roles . According to this theory,
men and women enhance gender stereotype beliefs because different roles that they
play and create different social demands for them and their roles.
Men need to learn more about women’s problems and find the way to use
their existing power and authority, to change the culture in a more equal direction,
workplace cultures Labor, child rearing and family-care have to be addressed. This
will necessitate further rethinking of men's roles in the child- and family-care arenas
A more gender equal society would be one that would leave men with more
options in terms of careers, life styles and general ways of being. This could not be
good for their emotional, physical and mental health. At the individual level they
would not have to prove their masculinity by dominating other men and women, by
211
Research on attitudes toward gender roles and gender equality reveals that
the majority of men, especially of young men support gender equality. Most
egalitarian attitudes are found among men from the educated middle classes…But
there is a huge gap between egalitarian attitudes and social practice. More and more
men express the wish to be involved actively in parenthood, not limiting fatherhood
to being the economic provider; But only two percent of fathers make use of the
especially the men from the educated classes who strictly vote to gender equality and
for wife- husband relations that are freed from a typical gender division of labor,
But in this study, the results show that male students more than female
students believed in the gender stereotypes and patriarchal beliefs. It means the male
There are some major events that paved the way to gender equality and
gave more arguments to the movement that supported it. Starting with the Vienna
of Action and Declaration became major program documents that fueled the struggle
for women’s rights and gender equality for many years on.
212
Gender equality has been and still is perceived in many societies as
women. Women are struggling for gender equality, what about men? Do they need
it? Will they allow it? Will they accept it? The stereotypes concerning both genders
are so deeply enshrined in our minds that sometimes even the strongest advocates for
gender equality are stepping back unconsciously and are paying tribute to their
stereotypical thinking. This is maybe the reason why the gender equality cause was
perceived only as a “women’s” cause and men were more or less isolated from this
process.
Studies have shown that in most societies, gender-based norms and practices
favor men over women in granting access to recourses, opportunities, rights, voices,
decision-making power at home and in the public spheres. There have been various
interpretations of the term gender equality in the past. The World Bank (2001)
defines gender equality in terms of rights, recourses and voices-equality under the
productive resource) and equality of rewards for work and equality of voice.
Millennium Project Task Force for Education and Gender (Grown et al-2005) adopted an
operational framework for understanding gender equality which has three main domains
(i) The capabilities domain which is referring to basic human abilities as measured by
education, health and nutrition; (ii) the access to resources and opportunity domain
which refers primarily to equality in the opportunity to use or apply basic capabilities
211
through access to economic assets(such as land, property) or infrastructure (such as
income and employment) as well as other political bodies, and (iii) the security domain
particularly targets at women and girls, and restrain them from reaching their potential.
The gender approach in the field of planning for sustained development shows
increasing public opportunities for the educated women's active role and social
participation in sustained development plans of any country are taken as necessary and
those indicators and criteria as well as increasing public opportunities for women's
social participation is a leap towards sustained development but it seems that household-
supporting women, as a part of the society, encounter numerous problems, so efforts are
necessary for recognition, removal or reduction of those problems. Therefore, one cannot
cease his or her efforts towards decline and weakening of the patriarchal beliefs in the
society, since paying attention to gender equality could have a significant effect on the
One of the most important criteria that show improvement in the gender
equality in the patriarchal societies (countries) is that women and men can equally
access to cultural, social, economic and political sources and they have equal
211
Today, improvement in the gender equality is the most important duty to of
Governments because the gender equality can be used to comment frequently on key
issues that have affected people and contributed to the public debate about how to
and enhanced gender equality, especially both men and women as two important
parts of the population. This kind of works can help the governments to take
necessary steps to increase the gender equality and attempt to promote it. Especially,
5.8: SUMMARY
related to gender stereotypes. The researcher has written briefly about socialization
and also improvement of gender equality. So the researcher has examined the
patriarchal beliefs with some variables of the research and found that there is a
significant relationship between patriarchal beliefs and gender (male more than
female), study field (respectively Art & Social science field more than Science field
and Science field more than Engineering- Technology field), family size (the number
of family size increases, the patriarchal beliefs increases), living area (rural area is
211
more than urban area). This chapter has also covered gender equality and
211
REFFERENCE
Alsop, R.A. Fitzsimons and K.Lennon (2002). "Theorizing gender". USA: Blackwell
publishers Inc.
Bhasin, Kamla. (1993)." What is Patriarchy?" Kali for Women. New Delhi.
Desai, Neera and Krishnaraj, Maithreyi. (2004). “An Overview od the Status of
Women in India” in Manoranjan Mohanty, (ed). Class, Caste, Gender.
Sage Publications, New Delhi.
Doyle, J. A. and M.A. Paludi. (1998). "Sex and gender, The human experience".
Boston: Mc Graw Hill.
http://www.un.org/womenwatch/daw/egm/men-boys2003/EP3-Marinova.pdf
216