Neonatal Ethics

Neonatal Ethics
Amy Allan, Holly Nolan, Blossum

Xiong
Neonatology
● Subspecialty of pediatrics
○ Specifically newborn infants (premature)
● 14 years of schooling required
○ 4 years of undergraduate school
○ 4 years of medical school
○ Pediatric residency
○ Neonatal fellowship
Neonatology ● Salary: $197,700 (mean)
○ Avg. retirement age: 63
● Pros: $, career satisfaction
● Cons: Years of schooling, schedule
not flexible
● Neonatal- first 28 days of life
Neonatal ● Special section of the hospital
○ Separate from healthy baby nursery
Intensive Care ○ Still close to mothers
Unit (NICU) ● For babies who need round the clock care
due to complications and problems like:
○ Assisted breathing
○ Underdeveloped body systems
(immune system, brain, etc…)
● Admitted from delivery room, newborn
nursery, or other hospital’s NICU
Who Needs Special ● Babies born under 37 weeks or
over 42 weeks
Care? ● Low birth weight (under 5.5 lbs)
● Medical condition
○ Heart problems
○ Infections
○ Birth defects
Beginning and Advancements
● Dr. Joseph DeLee ● Certification for neonatology

○ 1896 ○ 1975
○ First incubator ○ American Board of
○ Chicago, Illinois Pediatrics
● Treatment of PPHN
● First NICU
○ Persistent pulmonary
○ 1965
hypertension
○ First NICU in American
○ Government grant
hospitals
● Further treatment of NEC
○ New Haven, Connecticut
○ Necrotizing enterocolitis
○ Government grant
Where? Why?
● Globally ● Saving babies up to 22 - 23

○ United States weeks
○ Europe ○ 5,000 born annually in
○ Asia United States
● Factors ○ Slim chances with varying
○ Cost birth factors
○ Access/Location ○ 50/50 problems
○ Availability ● Giving newborns a fighting
chance
● Varies in different hospitals
Gestational vs. ● Gestational : last normal
menstrual period-birth
Fetal Age ○ Used to describe where a

baby is (devel.)
● Fetal : conception-birth
○ actual age of growing fetus
(approx. 2 weeks younger)
Age and ● Week 21-22: stomach able to
absorb nutrients (mostly
Development placenta), skin more opaque and

beginning of hair
● Week 23-29: brain cells,
movement, bowel movement,
eyes, active, sleep
● Week 30: gaining body weight,
most body functions developed
● Week 32: organs developed
(lungs)
● Week 31-38: growing, fetal
position, preparing for birth
Premature ● History:
○ Before a baby was considered
Criteria premature solely on a low

birth weight
● Modern times:
○ Anything before a full term
birth (38-42 wks.)
● Spectrum
○ Less than 28 weeks:
extremely preterm (<6%)
○ 28-31 weeks: very preterm
○ 32-36 weeks: moderately
preterm
Survival Rate?
● Before 28 weeks and
6 days
○ 80% survival
○ Down 10% for
every week
before 28
● Between 29 - 32
weeks and 6 days
○ 95%
○ Breathing
difficulties
● Above 33 weeks
○ 99% or more
The
Problem
Physicians vs. Parents- the decision
Ethical
● Who can receive this care? (LDC
vs MDC) ($$$)
● If it is experimental (not been tried
Questions ●
before) is it still okay?
Is a baby ever too far gone or too
sick?
The Law ● Gray area
○ Physician v. Parents- who
controls future of baby in
complicated situations
● Factors to consider:
○ Choice affects parents
■ They are long-term
caretakers
○ Child suffering
○ Chances of survival
● Stipulations/who is to blame?
Baby Doe #1 Baby Doe #2
● Born 1982 ● Born with severe

● Born with down syndrome and a meningomyelocele
tracheal-oseophageal fistula ○ What is meningomyelocele
○ What is a fistula? ● Parents and physician decided to
● Parents told surgeon not to fix not provide treatment
fistula ● Died of dehydration
● Died of starvation and
dehydration
Baby Doe amendment formed from

this case
● A federal law signed in 1984
Baby Doe ● Prevents “withholding of medically
Amendment
indicated treatment from disabled
infants with life-threatening
conditions.”
● “Does not include failure to
provide treatment…when…such
treatment would prolong dying, not
be effective…be futile in terms of
survival…be virtually futile…and
treatment itself…would be
inhumane.”
Moral Code ● Quality of life
○ Lifelong effects
○ Ties to abortion laws
○ Who gets to live and who
does not
Religious ● Most people in religious groups
are pro-life
Beliefs ○ Generalized idea, some may

disagree
○ Seen as murder
Societal Impact ●
●
Population statistics
Long term care with parents
& Future ● Medical - therapy,

treatments/medications
Implications ● Education - Where does the money
come from?
○ Teacher aids
○ Programs
● Adulthood
○ Occupation
○ Where to live
○ Support
Disability ● Correlation between earlier birth
and possible disabilities
Statistics ○ Developmental
○ Cognitive
Financial Costs ●
●
Average stay is 2 weeks
Admission to the NICU = $76,000
of NICU ●
○ What are admissions?
Charges = $280,000
○ What are charges?
● U.S. alone = $26.2 billion
● Look into possible coverage with
How to Cope your insurance

○ Add your child onto the
With Financial insurance if you have not
already done so
Costs ● Contact a social worker
○ Can help you find financial aid
for NICU costs
● Apply for financial aid
○ Medicaid
○ Supplemental Security
Income Program (SSI)
● Payment plans
○ Contact the hospital’s finance
department
Pros/Cons/ ● Pros: Scenario #1
○ Baby lives
Risks/ Possible ○ It would be as a result of the

parents’ decision
Outcomes ● Cons: Scenario #2

○ Birth defects
○ Mental disabilities
Scenario:
○ Costs
If the baby is in distress and in ○ Overall quality of life
between receiving care or dying
Preventative ● Early education and formation
Measures
Discussion ● What do you think about taking
extreme measures for premature
Questions babies?
○ Do you think that it is worth
the possible consequences?
○ Should laws define the final
decision or should they by
based off of case by case?
○ Why have laws not been
created regarding extremely
preterm births?
Any Questions?

Neonatal Ethics

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Neonatal Ethics

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Neonatal Ethics

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Neonatal Ethics

Amy Allan, Holly Nolan, Blossum

● Dr. Joseph DeLee ● Certiﬁcation for neonatology

● Globally ● Saving babies up to 22 - 23

Fetal Age ○ Used to describe where a

Development placenta), skin more opaque and

Criteria premature solely on a low

● Born 1982 ● Born with severe

Baby Doe amendment formed from

Baby Doe ● Prevents “withholding of medically

Beliefs ○ Generalized idea, some may

& Future ● Medical - therapy,

How to Cope your insurance

Risks/ Possible ○ It would be as a result of the

Outcomes ● Cons: Scenario #2

You might also like