2nd International Conference on Electronic & Mechanical Engineering and Information Technology (EMEIT-2012)

Based on the MIDAS GEN frame structure joints is just domain of values
elastic-plastic static analysis
L. H. Yang 1,a, F. MA 1,b, J.Z. HOU1,c
1
Department of Civil Engineering, Taiyuan University of Technology
79, Yingzexi Street, Taiyuan, 030024, China
a
[email protected], [email protected] , [email protected]

Keywords: strong earthquake, frame structure and plasticity analysis, plastic hinge, just domain,
the seismic performance

Abstract. In this paper, the finite element analysis software MIDAS GEN structure, take give frame
structure joints place just threshold method, the frame structures in the action of the rarely met
earthquake elasto-plastic static analysis. Through comparing the different just domain length (not
just domain, standard calculation just domain, the whole just domain) value of the structure under
cycle, displacement, performance point, layer, layer between shear displacement between Angle
and so on, is put forward based on the theory of plastic hinge under strong overall performance
evaluation system structure. The results of the study show that: give frame structure joints of
different just threshold, it will directly affect the structure of internal force and deformation of the
structure seismic performance also has greater effect.

The Preface
In the practical calculation, the framework structure mechanics model according to the form of
beam-column usually heart line simplified to a one dimension line unit, and when components
section size relative its span is bigger, can form in the intersection beam-column relative rigid node
area, and call it just domain. Just domain means that no quality, its own not only stiffness
deformation, but can happen and the displacement of the rigid body displacement must be attached
to the component is a idealized component. In practical projects, when considering just domain, the
inevitable to structure of the internal force and deformation produce certain effect, and just domain
length different values, will affect the structure of the seismic performance is good. Concrete
structures of tall building technology procedures (JGJ3-2010) the first article 5.3.4 given clear just
domain calculation formula of length. This paper consider beam-column joints place just domain
length to the actual engineering as an example, the application of MIDAS software the
elastic-plastic static analysis of frame construction under the effects of earthquake damage
mechanism research, and through the change of joints place just domain length, discuss in Abraham
under severe earthquake, Beam-column just domain length selection on concrete frame structure
failure mechanism of influence.

Engineering example
A building project, a total of five layer, layer are 3600 mm, frame beams cross section are 300
x700 (mm), the second beam section are 250 x500 (mm), concrete strength grade are C30,
Beam-column advocate muscle HRB400 reinforced all use level, seismic fortification intensity of 7
degrees (0.10 g), the seismic grade for level 3, the category of Ⅲ, design for the second group
earthquake group. Figure 1 and figure 2 for the plan of the office building, respectively with
section.

Published by Atlantis Press, Paris, France.

© the authors
0423
 2nd International Conference on Electronic & Mechanical Engineering and Information Technology (EMEIT-2012)

Figure 1 Figure 2

Calculation and Analysis

In this paper, the frame beam-column joints were considered in three different sets of just
threshold, respectively is: (1) according to technical specification for concrete structures of tall
buildings (JGJ3-2010) the first article 5.3.4 calculation of just threshold (2) all joints is considered
just domain (3) in the joints don't consider just domain
Structure elastic analysis
The structures elastic analysis, comparative under earthquake effect to the parameters of the X,
Y, see the table below:
X to the earthquake effect Y to the earthquake effect
categor
No just Standard value All just No just Standard value All just domain
ies
domain just domain domain domain just domain
T1 0.9877 T1 0.8992 T1 0.8098 T1 0.9877 T1 0.8992 T1 0.8098
period
T2 0.9588 T2 0.8767 T2 0.7949 T2 0.9588 T2 0.8767 T2 0.7949
(s)
T3 0.9106 T3 0.8292 T3 0.7471 T3 0.9106 T3 0.8292 T3 0.7471
Displa F1 1/908 F1 1/936 F1 1/972 F1 1/913 F1 1/947 F1 1/994
ce- F2 1/637 F2 1/713 F2 1/803 F2 1/628 F2 1/709 F2 1/811
ment F3 1/722 F3 1/815 F3 1/930 F3 1/697 F3 1/792 F3 1/912
(rad) F4 1/988 F4 1/1117 F4 1/1275 F4 1/925 F4 1/1044 F4 1/1188
F5 1/1784 F5 1/2006 F5 1/2281 F5 1/1575 F5 1/1744 F5 1/1940
F1 5137 F1 5554 F1 6050 F1 4995 F1 5416 F1 5930
F2 4759 F2 5133 F2 5576 F2 4630 F2 5009 F2 5470
shear
F3 3976 F3 4276 F3 4629 F3 3879 F3 4187 F3 4560
(kN)
F4 2849 F4 3047 F4 3280 F4 2797 F4 3004 F4 3257
F5 1401 F5 1483 F5 1578 F5 1391 F5 1478 F5 1586
Note: T1, T2 and T3 said the first three respectively structure modes, F1, F2, F3, F4 and F5 says floor 1, 2, 3, 4,
and 5 layers.
Analysis of the above data can be concluded that the three just thresholds next: no just domain in
when X, Y to natural vibration period, displacement were the biggest, floor horizontal seismic shear
minimum, show that the minimum structure stiffness. Just when the fields on natural vibration
period, displacement are minimal, floor horizontal seismic shear is the largest, show that structure
stiffness is the largest. Standard value just domain cycle, displacement, stiffness size is located in
between. Each floor will meet the displacement of the seismic design of building codes
(GB50011-2010) 5.5.1 function of elastic layers displacement Angle 1/550 of the limit.
Structure elasto-plastic analysis
In this article, the MIDAS/Gen set the girder ends of the length of just domain method, the
elastoplastic static whole structure analysis. In the X, Y respectively to exert horizontal earthquake
effect, lateral force using modal loading PUSHOVER analysis way, the contrast in the
elastic-plastic stage structure, three just domain of various performance parameters under length.
Performance point

Published by Atlantis Press, Paris, France.

© the authors
0424
 2nd International Conference on Electronic & Mechanical Engineering and Information Technology (EMEIT-2012)

From the analysis of the software to see, in all the conditions are capacity spectrum curve can
and demand spectrum curve intersection get performance point that structure with good seismic
performance, and the ability of the spectrum curve relatively smooth, in under the shock of elastic
or a few basic for the hinge, and under the conditions of the earthquake has entered into the plastic.
The performance of the point the parameters see table 1:
Just domain length Sa Sd Vb（KN） Un（m）
X to
No just domain 0.1615 0.06386 12050 0.0875
Performance
point Standard value just domain 0.173 0.0587 12950 0.08
All just domain 0.1836 0.05062 13800 0.0688
X to No just domain 0.1498 0.06406 11370 0.086
Performance Standard value just domain 0.1614 0.06015 12240 0.08
point All just domain 0.1714 0.0539 12980 0.07
From the above analysis, we can see that take X to point the vertices of the largest performance
displacement UN = 0.0875m < 1/50×18 = 0. 36 m (1/50 is seismic code provisions of elastic-plastic
layer displacement between Angle limitation), therefore, to meet the vertex displacement X plastic
limit requirements. Point to take Y performance the biggest UN = 0.086 m < 1/50×18 = 0.36 m
(1/50 is seismic code provisions of elastic-plastic layer displacement between Angle limitation), so,
Y to also meet the vertex displacement plastic limit requirements. And in the performance of the
state to point X and Y to the maximum displacement between floors Angle see table 1:
Loading Just domain PUSH-DX PUSH-DY
method numerical (X to the maximum displacement (Y to the maximum displacement
between floors Angle) between floors Angle)
No just domain 1/117 1/138
modal Standard value just domain 1/122 1/141
All just domain 1/132 1/145
From the above analysis view of structure in the earthquake, layer displacement Angle between
will meet the standard seismatic design architecture (GB50011-2010) table 5.5.5 requirements of
the elastic-plastic layer displacement Angle between 1/50 of the limits that structure has better
seismic performance.
Plastic hinge
In the analysis, the MIDAS/Gen finite element program is through the plastic hinge to realize the
structure of the material nonlinearity, the plastic hinge on pole of elastic-plastic model to represent
component performance, this paper applied "yield force and the yield displacement" normalization
method, define beam hinge (moment, shear hinge), column hinge (PMM hinge) "generalized
force-generalized displacement" curve. Through the PUSHOVER analysis, it is concluded that the
proportion of plastic hinge, see table 1:
The proportion of plastic hinge (%)
Just domain PUSH-DX（PP） PUSH-DY（PP）
length LS-C LS-C C,D-
B-I0 I0-LS CP-C,D C,D-E B-I0 I0-LS CP-C,D
P P E
No just domain 4.9% — — — — 4.2% 1.9% — — —
Standard value
4.4% 1.1% — — — 4.6% 2.2% — — —
just domain
All just domain 4.6% 1.4% — — — 3.7% 1.8% — — —
Note: said did not appear plastic hinge, the data in the table is the presence of the rod of the plastic hinge with a
total stem a percentage of the structure
From the graph can see, three cases, structure component performance in most of the hinge IO ~
LS stage, the results show that the structure component has entered the yield at stage, and the
structure of components for moderate damage, there is a clear cracks in the component. Among
them, not just domain cases, structure in the X direction component performance hinge in B ~ IO
stage, show that this time just entered the plastic components, plastic degree is shallow. Standard
value just domain, the Y direction plastic hinge for the biggest proportion, all just domain, X
direction plastic hinge for the biggest proportion.
Published by Atlantis Press, Paris, France.
© the authors
0425
 2nd International Conference on Electronic & Mechanical Engineering and Information Technology (EMEIT-2012)

Layer shear-the displacement curve

The frame structure of the first layer for shear layer-the displacement curve, 2 layer displacement
curve and shear-first floor close, three layer from the whole layer shear displacement curve-to see,
is about to enter elastic-plastic stage, and four, five layer is in elastic stage. Due to the limited
length, the only one on the list of shear-the displacement curve.

From above to see, X direction structure in the first place into the elastic-plastic stage turning
point, along with the pushover increasing, the structure in the second turning point place into the
plastic deformation stage, then the shear layer are less growth, and displacement between floors but
change is larger, but were not beyond standard allowed scope. From the graph still can see,
interlayer shear displacement curve is increasing basic linear, curve set displacement in range does
not appear for fall, show that in the resistance there is great room for collapsed ability.
Y direction in the first place into the structure turning point elastic-plastic stage, along with the
pushover increasing, the structure in the second turning point in the inelastic phase, the shear layer
are less growth, and displacement between floors but change is larger, but were not beyond standard
allowed scope. At the same time, in the curve ends, appear significantly reduced section, from the
overall structure of the deformation to see, in Beam-column Joints all just domain cases,
displacement between floors to 48 mm, on the first floor column in the deep plastic hinge, show that
this time structure has lost bearing capacity. According to the standard Beam-column Joints
structure in the field just value, the displacement between floors to 54 mm, on the first floor column
in the deep plastic hinge, structure in Beam-column Joints no just domain cases, displacement
between floors to 58 mm, on the first floor column in the deep plastic hinge. Through the above
analysis shows that structural damage, all the just domain of the structure under minimum
displacement between the layers, its ductility is the worst.
To sum up, in under the action of the rarely met earthquake, when Beam-column Joints consider
all just domain, shear layer than the other two kinds of circumstances is the largest, explain the
structure of pushover, the domain of the structure under the earthquake had the greatest influence,
also more serious damage. When Beam-column Joints don't consider just domain, shear layer than
other two kinds of circumstances minimum, when the same beam-column point specification
requirements according to consider just threshold, the shear layer in between.

Epilogue
In this paper the MIDAS finite element analysis, in the framework structure joints of the place
just domain length (not just domain, standard value just domain, all just domain) problems in study,
studies show that node length of different domain to just the level of structure seismic shear force
and displacement, cycle all affect, and to structure the elastoplastic static analysis, beam-column
joints area just domain length between layers of different shear effect is particularly significant, and
with the length of the field just increase, and between shear layer in increase gradually, this means
that structure of the earthquake action in also gradually increase, so the structure in the earthquake
damage degree gradually was also intensified. The analysis and calculation of the standard in China
are just domain length method, the structure in the earthquake damage degree between the just
domain and no just between domains, and considering the size of their own section beam-column
just domain the influence of length, is a reasonable setting method, meanwhile, frame beam-column

Published by Atlantis Press, Paris, France.

© the authors
0426
 2nd International Conference on Electronic & Mechanical Engineering and Information Technology (EMEIT-2012)

joints area due consideration of just domain can effectively prevent the damage degree of quake on
the structure.

References
[1] GB50011-2010 (2010 edition) building seismic design specification [S]. (China architecture
&building press, Beijing, 2010)
[2] High-rise building reinforced concrete structure design concept, hubei party China (mechanical
industry press, Beijing, 2007)
[3] MIDAS/Gen application example tutorial and troubleshooting C.X Wang editor (China
architecture &building press, Beijing, 2010)
[4] Complex high-rise building structure seismic theory and application for the X.L lv (science
press, Beijing, 2007)
[5] Node just domain of reinforced concrete frame structure seismic influence on the performance
of the Z.F Zhang (hefei university journal 2010)

Published by Atlantis Press, Paris, France.

© the authors
0427