Braz J Otorhinolaryngol.

2010;76(5):575-8.
ORIGINAL ARTICLE BJORL .org

Surgical simulator for temporal bone dissection training

Daniel Mochida Okada 1, Ana Maria Almeida de Sousa 2, Raul de Andrade Huertas 3, Fabio Akira Suzuki 4

Keywords: Abstract
surgery,
dissection, temporal
bone.
T emporal bone dissection plays an important role in the training of surgeons; however, they are
difficult to obtain.

Aim: To develop a synthetic replica of the temporal bone for dissection training.

Study Design: Experimental.

Materials and Methods: An acrylic synthetic resin replica was obtained from a human temporal
bone. For the evaluation of the method, we selected five ear surgeons to dissect the model in a
laboratory of experimental surgery. A questionnaire was filled, assessing external appearance, the
simulation of procedures (placement of ventilation tube, mastoidectomy, decompression of the
facial nerve and translabyrinthine access to the internal auditory canal) and their final conclusion.

Results: The evaluation indicated satisfaction in using the model (80%), being more evident
concerning the dissection of the mastoid segment of the facial nerve and translabyrinthine access
to the internal auditory canal. The placement of a ventilation tube was reasonable for 60% and
satisfactory for 40% of them. Mastoidectomy was satisfactory for 60% and fully satisfactory for 40%.

Conclusion: Dissection in this simulator does not replace otologic training in cadaveric temporal
bones. However, given the increasing difficulty in obtaining the latter, the development of new
teaching tools should be encouraged to continuously improve surgeons.

1
Clinical and surgical otology expert - UNIFESP, Assistant Physician - Otolaryngology Department - Hospital do Servidor Público Estadual - IAMSPE.
2
ENT Resident - Hospital do Servidor Público Estadual - IAMSPE.
3
Dental prosthesis technician - Colégio Bernardino de Campos, Sócio-proprietário J&R Laboratório de Próteses Dentárias.
4
PhD in Otolaryngology - UNIFESP, Coordinator of the Internship - Hospital do Servidor Público Estadual - IAMSPE.
Hospital do Servidor Público Estadual - Instuto de Assistência Médica ao Servidor Público Estadual Serviço de Otorrinolaringologia - Diretor Dr. Samir Cahali
Send correspondence to: Rua Dias de Toledo 261 apto 1301 Saúde 04143-030 São Paulo SP Brasil.
Paper submied to the BJORL-SGP (Publishing Management System – Brazilian Journal of Otorhinolaryngology) on September 16, 2009;
and accepted on December 16, 2009. cod. 6647

BRAZILIAN JOURNAL OF OTORHINOLARYNGOLOGY 76 (5) SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2010

http://www.bjorl.org / e-mail: [email protected]
575
 INTRODUCTION

The use of cadavers for medical education and

training started in 500 B.C. and its history evolved hand-
in-hand with the development we have today in Medici-
ne. For many years, this practice was prohibited because
of religious and ethical issues; however, it was after the
renascence that Leonardo da Vinci, Michelangelo and
Andreas Vesalius consolidated human anatomy and dis-
section methods1.
Study with cadavers is fundamental in schools of
medicine, nursing, physical therapy and other health-care
Figure 1. Human temporal bone after broad mastoidectomy.
disciplines. Training of surgical techniques in cadavers also
plays an important role in the education and enhancement
of surgeons. The current Brazilian legislation, by means
of law # 8,501 from November 30 of 1992, establishes
that only those cadavers which remain unclaimed for 30
days can be used for research and educational purposes2.
Training in temporal bone dissection laboratories
is already routinely carried out for the learning of surgical
anatomy and to train otolaryngologists, in accordance
with the theories from Fitts and Posner for the training of
motor skills3.
Thus, if on the one hand we have the legislative and
the difficulty in obtaining cadavers representing a major
limitation, on the other we have the need to develop new
teaching approaches such as simulators and training in
virtual environments.
The goal of this project was to develop a replica
of the temporal bone, with proper anatomical reliance in
order to train dissection in the laboratory.
Figure 2. Main module and tympano-ossicular system.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The project was analyzed and approved by the

Ethics in Research Committee, through protocol # 054/09.
As primary model we used a left side temporal bone
we acquired from the Coroner’s Office of the city of São
Paulo, through an official request # 18/2008.
After properly cleaning the specimen, we did a
broad mastoidectomy in order to identify the sigmoid
sinus, mastoid tegmen, vertical portion of the facial nerve
and lateral semi-circular canal. After drilling the posterior
wall of the auditory meatus we removed the tympanic
membrane and ossicular chain. (Fig. 1)
Using molding, high fidelity silicone and thermo-
curing acrylic (Reg. ANVISA 10234680006) we built three
modules (main, tympano-ossicular system and mastoid
complex) for later assemblage. The tympanic membrane
was built from vegetable parchment paper. We stress that
the technique used to build the mastoid complex was
changed in order to obtain a porous material, similar to
the pneumatization of the temporal bone region. (Figs.
2 and 3)
Figure 3. Mastoid complex module.

BRAZILIAN JOURNAL OF OTORHINOLARYNGOLOGY 76 (5) SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2010

http://www.bjorl.org / e-mail: [email protected]
576
 DISCUSSION

Before 1992 there were no laws regulating the use

of cadavers for educational purposes. Different problems
were faced by medical schools in attempting to find bodies
from indigents4. The already known ethical and religious
issues blocked the donation of unidentified cadavers5. Fi-
nancial aspects, such as the provision of funeral grant by
Social Security also made this process even more difficult5.
Law # 8.501 from November 30, 1992 rules the con-
ditions of cadaver destination for education and research.
The cadavers which are unidentified and unclaimed after
thirty days can then be sent to educational institutions.
Figure 4. Surgical simulator. Should the cadaver be identified; however, without infor-
mation from relatives or legal guardians, local authorities
Before assembling the three modules we painted should publish the information in the main newspapers of
some of the structures with acrylic paint, namely: (Figure 4) the city during at least ten days, as a public service. Bodies
- Blue: sigmoid sinus suspected of unnatural or criminal cause of death cannot
- Red: mastoid tegmen be used. Moreover, the law establishes that for recognition
- Yellow: mastoid portion of the facial nerve and purposes, the authority or institution in charge shall keep
internal acoustic meatus the following information regarding the deceased: general
In order to evaluate the simulator we selected five characteristics, photos, fingerprints and identification -
experienced ear surgeons skilled in experimental dissec- should there be any2.
tion to study the models and later fill out the questionnaire, Nonetheless, knowing that the cadaver is only
taking into account the external appearance, the simulation donated after thirty days and that often times it is not put
of procedures (ventilation tube insertion, mastoidectomy, into formaldehyde before 72 hours post-mortem, the de-
decompression of the mastoid portion of the facial ner- generation process makes its use impossible6. Moreover,
ve and translabyrinthine access to the internal acoustic we have seen the spread of medical and other health
meatus) and their final conclusion. The aforementioned care disciplines schools, which increases even further the
procedures were done in an experimental surgery lab, with demand for cadavers.
the equipment routinely used to dissect temporal bones. These factors, associated with the constant pressure
for better results have led educators and researchers to
RESULTS develop new tools to train surgeons7. Thus, synthetic simu-
lators and those based on virtual environments are being
The opinions of the surgeons are listed on the developed in order to make up for the lack of cadavers8,9.
following table. Each mark (*) represents the opinion of Fitts and Posner’s theory shows that learning is an
each surgeon. (Table 1)

Table 1.

Very similar, but More or less

Identical Very different Totally different
not identical alike
External appearance * ****
Totally satisfactory Satisfactory Reasonable Bad Very bad
Ventilation tube insertion ** ***
Mastoidectomy ** ***
Dissection of the mastoid segment
**** *
of the facial nerve
Translabyrinthine access to the
*****
internal acoustic meatus
Completely satisfied Satisfied Reasonable Bad Very bad
Final opinion * ****

BRAZILIAN JOURNAL OF OTORHINOLARYNGOLOGY 76 (5) SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2010

http://www.bjorl.org / e-mail: [email protected]
577
internal human process, and it depends on practice and CONCLUSION
it tends to be permanent. Such process happens in three
stages - cognitive, associative and autonomous - in which, Dissection in this otologic simulator does not repla-
as the individual progresses on his/her training, better are ce the actual dissection of temporal bones from cadavers;
the outcomes achieved, its consistency and less number of nonetheless, it is a promising alternative for the practical
mistakes, together with an increase in the person’s capacity teaching of otologic surgery. With the growing difficulty
to identify and correct problems3. in obtaining natural temporal bones, we must develop
Training in simulators, as well as conventional dis- new teaching tools for the continuous improvement of
section, can separate the acquisition of skills from medical surgeons.
practice10. In the field of otology, there is already a virtual
simulator of temporal bone dissection (VOXEL-MAN Tem- REFERENCES
posurg Simulator) which enables the three-dimensional 1. LYONS A.S.; PETRUCELLI R.J. Medicine: An Illustrated History. Harry
visualization of tissues and provides a sensitive answer N. Abrams; Revised edition. New York, 1997.
to the operator (resistance, directions, burr speed). Zirkle 2. Disponível em: http://www.planalto.gov.br/ccivil/leis/L8501.htm.
et al.11 believe that such equipment has the potential to Acesso em 22/05/2009.
3. FITTS P.M.; POSNER M.I. Human Performance. Belmont, CA. Brooks/
enhance the skills of ENT residents. Nonetheless, this Cole, 1967.
equipment does not allow the use of routine equipment 4. QUEIROZ, C.A.F. O uso de cadáveres humanos como instrumento
used in otologic surgery, such as a microscope, aspirator na construção de conhecimento a partir de uma visão bioética.
and micromotor. Moreover, its high cost makes it difficult Dissertação de mestrado, Universidade Católica de Goiás, Goiânia,
2005.
to spread its use. 5. ESPÍRITO SANTO, A.M.; THEOPHILO, F.V.; FONSECA, H.; PRATES,
The present study aims at showing that this simu- J.C.; ANDRADE, O.P.M.; FREIRE,P.S. Uso de cadáveres no estudo de
lator enables temporal bone dissection training in con- anatomia humana nas escolas da área da saúde. Rev Goiana Med.
ventional labs, for it bears proper anatomical reliance and 1981;27(1/2): 107-16
6. WATANABE, I. O Ensino da Anatomia Humana: o dilema da escassez
provides a realistic feeling during surgery. Nonetheless, de cadáveres. Jornal da USP, São Paulo; 1998. p. 2, 30
some problems have been raised, such as tympanic mem- 7. OSSOWSKI, K.L.; RHEE, D.C.; RUBISNTEIN, E.N.; FERGUSON, B.J.
brane stiffness, the greater resin density when compared Efficacy of Sinonasal Simulator in Teaching Endoscopic Nasal Skills.
to the temporal bone and the lack of a facial nerve, since Laryngoscope.2008; 118(8):1482-5
8. PRZYBYSZ, C.H.; SCOLIN, E. Disponível em: http://www.fap.com.
in this simulator the nerve was only painted there. Despite br/fapciencia/002/edicao_2008/010.pdf. Acesso em 23/05/2009.
these criticisms, which will serve to enhance the simulator, 9. OLSZEWSKI, R.; VILLAMIL, M.B.; TREVISAN, D.G.; NEDEL, L. P.;
dissection was deemed satisfactory by the surgeons who FREITAS, C.M.D.S.;REYCHLER, H.; MACQ, B. Towards an integrated
evaluated it. system for planning and assisting maxillofacial orthognathic surgery.
Computer Methods and Programs in Biomedicine.2008; 91:13-21
10. KOPTA, J.A.; The development of motor skills in orthopaedic edu-
cation. Clin Orthop. 1971; 75:80-5
11. ZIRKLE M.; ROBERSON D.W.; LEUWER R.; DUBROWSKI A. Using
a virtual reality temporal bone simulator to assess otolaryngology
trainees. Laryngoscope.2007; 117:258-63

BRAZILIAN JOURNAL OF OTORHINOLARYNGOLOGY 76 (5) SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2010

http://www.bjorl.org / e-mail: [email protected]
578